ANDERSON. ATKINS.
BATES.
BELL.
BERRYHILL. BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG HUESO.
JACKSON.
LADA.
LEYVA.
MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
MONNING.
MORE LOCKED.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NELSON.
PAN.
PORTANTINO SKINNER.
STERN.
DON'T.
BUT ACT.
BY KATHY.
WIENER.
WILK.
A QUORUM IS PRESENT WITH THE
MEMBERS AND OUR GUEST BEYOND THE
RAIL AND IN THE GALLERY PLEASE
RISE WILL BE LEAD IN PRAYER THIS
MORNING BY. CHAPLAIN SISTER
MICHELLE GORMAN AFTER WHICH
PLEASE REMAIN STANDING. OUR
PLEDGE WILL BE LED BY SENATOR
MCGUIRE.
LET US REMEMBER THIS WE ARE IN
GODS PRESENCE.
MARGARET J. WHEATLEY SAYS
THERE IS NO POWER GREATER THAN A
COMMUNITY DISCOVERING WHAT IT
CARES ABOUT.
ASK WHAT'S POSSIBLE.
NOT WHAT'S WRONG.
AND KEEP ASKING.
NOTICE WHAT YOU CARE ABOUT.
AND ASSUME THAT MANY OTHERS
SHARE YOUR DREAMS.
LOVING AND MERCIFUL GODS
YOU HAVE GIVEN US THE COURAGE
AND DETERMINATION. TO ENGAGE IN
CONVERSATIONS THAT MATTER.
TO FORGE CREATIVE SOLUTIONS THAT
WILL AFFECT MANY INTO THE FUTURE.
WE CONTINUE TO TRUST IN THE
OUTPOURING OF YOUR SPIRITS.
IN NEW AND SURPRISING WAYS.
AS WE RELY ON THE GENEROSITY AND
HUMAN GOODNESS OF EACH OTHER.
WE MAKE OUR PRAYER IN YOUR NAME
AMEN.
MEMBERS.
JOINED TOGETHER. I PLEDGE
ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG. OF THE
UNITED STATES.
ZERO.
NATION.
INDIVISIBLE NCROWD.
MEMBERS WITHOUT OBJECTION THE
PROVISION OF SENATE RULE FORTY
FOR PROVIDING FOR VOTE ADD ONS
WILL BE AFFORDED TO THE
CONFERENCE COMMITTEE CONFEREES.
MESSAGES FROM THE GOVERNOR WILL
BE DEEMED READ. MESSAGES FROM
THE ASSEMBLY WILL BE DEEMED READ.
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES WILL BE
DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
ADOPTED. MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
AND NOTICES.
THE THE BE THE APPROPRIATE TIME
TO TAKE UP ANY WORSE OR BILLS
FROM THE INACTIVE FILE.
SEEING NONE WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
TO CONSIDERATION OF THE DAILY
FILE.
SECOND READING MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE RESOLUTION ONE TWELVE.
THE SECOND READING WILL BE
DEEMED READ GOVERNOR'S
APPOINTMENTS.
WE WILL START WITH MADAME PRO
TEM AND FILE ITEM NUMBER FIVE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
NUMBER FIVE IS THE CONFIRMATION
OF CHRISTOPHER CHASE TO THE
BOARD STATE BOARD OF FORESTRY-AND FIRE PROTECTION. MISTER
CHASE IS A TIMBERLAND MANAGER
FOR THE MICHIGAN CALIFORNIA
TIMBER COMPANY HE WAS APPROVED
BY THE RULES COMMITTEE ON MAY
SIXTEENTH IN A UNANIMOUS VOTE I
WOULD ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER ATKINS MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
BY CANNELLA.
BY.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
BY HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
HILL.
I HUESO.
JACKSON.
LA ISLA.
LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I KNOW SON.
BY PAN.
I.
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH. AYE SKINNER.
I STERN.
BY STONE.
FIVE BIDAK.
HI Y. KATHY.
BY WINNER.
BY WILK.
CENTER MOVES A CALL.
CENTER ATKINS FILE ITEM NUMBER
SIX PLEASE.
THANK YOU FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX
IS THE CONFIRMATION OF SUSAN IS
SORRY TO THE STATE BOARD OF
FORESTRY AND FIRE PROTECTION.
MISS WHO SORRY PREVIOUSLY SERVED
AS A REGIONAL MANAGER FOR THE U.
S. NATIONAL PARK SERVICE.
HE WAS APPROVED BY THE RULES
COMMITTEE ON MAY SIXTEENTH ON A
UNANIMOUS FIVE ZERO VOTE I ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER ATKINS MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I. BERRYHILL.
I.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I.
DALY OWN.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
I HILL. BY.
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA. BY MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LARK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
BY SKINNER.
BY STERN.
BY STONE.
NO.
BYE JACK. KNOW WHY COUNTY.
I WINNER. AYE WILK.
I.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN SENATOR
ATKINS THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
FOLLOW ITEM NUMBER SEVEN IS THE
CONFIRMATION OF RICHARD WADE TO
THE STATE BOARD OF FORESTRY AND
FIRE PROTECTION MISTER WADE IS
THE DISTRICT MANAGER FOR SIERRA
PACIFIC INDUSTRIES. HE WAS
APPROVED BY THE RULES COMMITTEE
ON MAY SIXTEENTH ON A FIVE ZERO
VOTE I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE
THEY DO CENTER ATKINS MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO. BELL.
I BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG AYE HILL.
I HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
I LET AYE. AYE LEYVA AYE AYE
MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN AYE STONE.
NO.
BIDAK.
NO WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER.
WILK.
BY.
CENTER ATKINS MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM NUMBER FOUR GOVERNOR'S
APPOINTMENTS SENATOR CANNELLA.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT OF
THIS IS FOR US.
THANK YOU PLEASE PROCEED ON
BOOZE TO RENEWED AND TODD
TROTTER TO THE CALIFORNIA
VETERANS BOARD. VETERANS BOARD
WORKS TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS AND
BENEFITS OF CALIFORNIA VETERANS
AND THEIR DEPENDENTS MISTER
BRUCE RUDE AND MISTER TROTTER
ARE BOTH VETERANS OF THE US ARMY.
BOTH APPOINTEES WERE PROVEN
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE HEARING
ON MAY SIXTEENTH ON UNANIMOUS
FIVE ZERO VOTE* RIVAL.
THANK YOU SENATOR CANNELLA
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
HURRY IN SEEING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
BY BATES.
I.
BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
BY BRADFORD.
BY. AYE DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
BY GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
BY LARA.
I LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE. AYE MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LOCK.
MARLA.
I AM A REAL.
BY NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
BY SKINNER.
I STERN AYE STONE.
I'VE IDEC.
AYE WIECKOWSKI.
AYE WIENER AYE WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
DE LEóN HILL AYE.
MITCHELL.
I THIRTY SEVEN KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE OF THE APPOINTMENT IS
CONFIRMED MEMBERS WE ARE GOING
TO MOVE BACK TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
FIVE AND LIFT THE CALL.
MISTER SECRETARY.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN. AYE ANDERSON.
ARE.
I BATES.
I.
BERRYHILL.
BY.
DELEON.
FULLER.
I GAINES.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG. AYE GAINES AYE
HUESO.
I NADA.
I MITCHELL.
MORRELL.
I WILL.
BY.
I SERVICE SEVEN KNOWS ZERO THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED MEMBERS
WE ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER SIX AND WE'RE GOING TO
LIFT THE CALL. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY ON.
GAINES.
HERNANDEZ.
I.
MITCHELL.
I.
GAINES NO.
AYES TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS TEND THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED FILE
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
I.
DELEON.
HERNANDEZ.
I MITCHELL.
I WIENER.
WIENER WINNER I.
EYES TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS TEND THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED.
MEMBERS WE ARE NOW MOVING TO
SENATE THIRD READING WE'RE
STARTING WITH FILE ITEM ONE ZERO
SIX SENATOR BRADFORD ARE YOU
PREPARED. FOR.
YOU ONE OF HEALTH ON FILE OKAY
VERY GOOD FILE ITEM. NUMBER ONE
ELEVEN.
EXCUSE ME FILE ITEMS SIXTY.
SENATOR MITCHELL.
WELL.
I ONLY WANT TO DO TO.
AND AND WE'VE HAD GIVEN.
ON FILE.
PASS SOME FILE FILE ITEM SIXTY
FOUR SENATOR MITCHELL
.
BY PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM EIGHTY
ONE AND FILE ITEM ONE ELEVEN.
ONE ELEVEN.
MEMBERS WE ARE ON FILE ITEM ONE
ELEVEN.
SENATOR MITCHELL OR MR SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN FORTY THREE
BY SENATOR MITCHELL AN ACT
RELATING TO EMPLOYMENT.
SENATOR MITCHELL.
OKAY.
I THOUGHT WE ONE WOULD HARDLY
ANY THREATS BY THIS IS FINE OKAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MADAM PRESIDENT.
COLLEAGUES TODAY I RISE TO
PRESENT THE SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
FORTY THREE WHICH REQUIRES THAT
EMPLOYERS WITH FIVE OR MORE
EMPLOYEES PROVIDE TRAINING ON
SEXUAL HARASSMENT PREVENTION. TO
NON SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES
THE WAY THE NON SUPERVISORY
EMPLOYEES ARE CURRENTLY INFORMED
ABOUT SEXUAL HARASSMENT
PREVENTION POLICIES AND
PROCEDURES ITS TO A POSTER. BUT
THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT TO
PROVIDE TRAINING TO NON
SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES. WE ARE
SENSITIVE TO THE DELICATE
BALANCE BETWEEN BUSINESS COSTS
EMPLOYERS AND EMPLOYEES SAFETY
IN THE WORKPLACE WE'RE WORKING
COLLABORATIVELY WITH
STAKEHOLDERS TO ENSURE THAT THIS
REQUIREMENT IS BOTH ACCESSIBLE.
AND COST EFFICIENT WHILE ALSO
DELIVERING THE IMPORTANT
INFORMATION THAT EMPLOYEES NEED
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE. BIG YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR BATES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND I
WON I THINK ARE I THE AUTHOR FOR
THE WORK ON THIS BILL. I AM
SUPPORTIVE OF THE MEASURE TODAY
BUT IS OUR UNDERSTANDING THAT
THE MTA HAS OFFERED AMENDMENTS
ON THE BILL.
OPPOSED AMENDMENTS REQUIRE ONE
HOUR OF TRAINING FOR NON
SUPERVISORIAL EMPLOYEES
CLARIFYING THAT TRAINING CAN BE
INCORPORATED INTO EXISTING
PROCEDURES. AND ESTABLISH A
MECHANISM TO CONFIRM COMPLETION
AND COMPREHENSION OF THE ONLINE
TRADING PROCESS I LIKE TO ASK
THE AUTHOR IT TO ADDRESS THE
CENTER CLOSE IS THERE ANY
POSSIBILITY. OF THE AMENDMENTS
BEING TAKEN AS THE BILL MOVES
FORWARD THANK YOU.
SENATOR BATES I THINK DUMB
CENTER MITCHELL MAY NOT OF HEARD
THAT LAST IVORY POLLOCK I
THROUGH DEBATE YOU MY REPEATING
YOUR POINT OUT IN THE IN THE
QUESTION IS AND YOU CAN ADDRESS
THAT IN YOUR CLOTHES AUTUMN. THE
AMENDMENTS OUGHT TO TAKE THE
MEMBERS THAT REQUIRE ONE HOUR OF
TRAINING FOR NON SUPERVISORIAL
EMPLOYEES CLARIFY THAT TRAINING
CAN BE INCORPORATED INTO
EXISTING PROCEDURES ALL YES AND
ESTABLISH A MECHANISM TO CONFIRM
COMPLETION. AND COMPREHENSION OF
THE ONLINE TRAINING PROCESS SO.
YEAH BIG YOU SENATOR BATES
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN SENATE
MITCHELL WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT AND YES.
TO MY COLLEAGUE WHEN I MADE THE
STATEMENT THAT WERE WORKING
COLLABORATIVE COLLABORATIVELY
WITH STAKEHOLDERS ADMITS
STAKEHOLDERS ACROSS THE BOARD
AND YES THAT IS AN ISSUE THAT
HAS COME UP AND WE'RE GOING TO
CONTINUE TO WORK ON TO TRY TO.
INCORPORATE AN ASPECT OF THAT
LANGUAGE OUT COMMIT TO THAT ON
AS THE BILL MOVES TO THE PROCESS
IF YOU'LL SUPPORTED GOING
FORWARD NOW I'D GREATLY
APPRECIATE I ASK FOR I VOTED S.
B. THIRTEEN FORTY THREE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
I ATKINS AYE BATES.
BY BILL.
BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA. AYE
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
ISLA.
BY LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE. AYE
MITCHELL.
BY MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL. BY NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE BIDAK.
BARBARA COUNTY AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
I.
WELL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. BELL.
I.
DELEON.
GAINES.
ARE.
EYES THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WERE
GONNA MOVE BACK TO FILE ITEM
EIGHTY ONE SENATOR MITCHELL
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN EIGHTY THREE BY
SENATOR MITCHELL AND ACKLINGTON
CHILD WELFARE SENATOR MITCHELL
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SP TEN
EIGHTY THREE OF THE MEASURE THAT
WILL STRENGTHEN THE INTENT. OF
THE CCR THE CONTINUUM OF CARE
REFORM INITIATIVE BY ADDRESSING
IMPLEMENTATION HURDLES IN THE
RESOURCE FAMILY APPROVAL PROCESS.
CURRENTLY THE RFP PROCESS TAKES
FAR LONGER THAN THE ORIGINALLY
ESTIMATED NINETY DAYS TO
COMPLETE.
FOR EXAMPLE AS OF THIS PAST
DECEMBER ABOUT FORTY PERCENT OF
RESEARCH RESOURCE FAMILY
APPLICATIONS TOOK LONGER THAN
NINETY DAYS TO COMPLETE.
THAT MEANS THAT FAMILIES ARE
GOING MONTHS BEFORE BEING
APPROVED AS A RESOURCE FAMILY
AND THEREFORE NOT RECEIVING ANY
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR TAKING
THE CHILD. COLLEAGUES THAT
REMIND YOU THESE ARE FOSTER CARE
PROVIDERS WHO ARE STEPPING UP TO
THE PLATE GOING THROUGH THE
PROCESS OF BEING LICENSE TO
BECOMING. A FOSTER PARENT AND
ARE NOT RECEIVING REIMBURSEMENT
FOR THE JOBS THEY ARE DOING.
THE LINK THE PROCESSES THAT
DETRIMENTAL TO THE RELATIVES AND
EXTENDED FAMILY WHO ACCEPT A
CHALLENGE TO THEIR HOMES PRIOR
TO BE APPROVED AS AN OFFICIAL
RESOURCE FAMILY.
THIS BILL IS AN IMPORTANT STEP
TOWARD FULFILLING THE INTENT OF
CCR BY SUPPORTING FAMILIES IN
MAKING SURE THAT UNINTENTIONAL
DELAYS DID NOT RESULT IN
HARDSHIP FOR CHILDREN WHO ARE
RECOVERING. FROM A BIG EDNA
BICU SIEVE AND NEGLECTFUL
ENVIRONMENT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE THOUGH.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE.
I'S THIRTY EIGHT KNOW ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS AT THIS TIME I WOULD
LIKE TO ASK OUR CONFEREES IF
THEY WOULD LIKE TO BRING UP IN
THE OF THEIR BILLS.
SENATOR SKINNER ZABLE LOOKS LIKE
SENATOR ROTH IS ALREADY UP AND
RUNNING SO WE'RE GONNA GO CENTER
ROTH SOONER RATHER MAY NEED A
LITTLE HELP IF YOU COULD LET ME
KNOW EITHER THE FILE ITEM OR THE
BILL.
I THINK YOU WILL START WITH FILE
ITEM EIGHTY TWO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN EIGHTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR ROTH AN ACT RELATING TO
THE PROPERTY SS CLEAN ENERGY
PROGRAM.
SENATOR ROTH.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES THIS BILL MAKES US
SEVERAL IMPORTANT CLEANUP
CHANGES TO WHAT IS KNOWN AS THE
PACE PROGRAM.
I'LL HIGHLIGHT THE MOST
IMPORTANT OF THEM THREE OF THEM
FOR YOU FIRST THE BILL REQUIRES
UNDERWRITING EARLY ENOUGH IN THE
PROCESS TO ENSURE THAT NO
HOMEOWNER. OBLIGATES HIMSELF OR
HERSELF ON A HOME IMPROVEMENT
CONTRACT.
BEFORE ACTUALLY LEARNING HOW
MUCH THE PACE FINANCING IS THAT
THEY QUALIFY FOR.
SECOND THE BILL INSURERS
TRANSPARENCY REGARDING
CORRECTIVE ACTIONS THAT THE
DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS OVERSIGHT.
DIRECTS PAY SOLICITORS AND PAY
SOLICITOR AGENTS TO TAKE AND
GIVES THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS TO HELP
PROTECT THEMSELVES FROM BAD
ACTORS.
AND THREE THE BILL GIVES THE
DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS OVERSIGHT
THE ABILITY TO STEP IN. AND TAKE
IMMEDIATE DISCIPLINARY ACTION IF
THEY LEARNED THE TO PAY
SOLICITOR OR PAY SOLICITOR AGENT.
IS SELLING PAYS FINANCING IN A
MANNER THAT IS HARMING
HOMEOWNERS.
THE BILL CONTAINS A NUMBER OF
OTHER CLEANUP CLARIFICATIONS AND
WITH THAT I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER ROTH MEMBERS IS
THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATE MORE TALK ON THIS ISSUE.
ARE THESE PROCEED THANK YOU.
CALLING SAYS SACRAMENTO SHOULD
HAVE NEVER.
NEVER.
AUTHORIZED THE USE OF.
PROPERTY S. FAST CLEAN ENERGY.
PACE.
AS A FORMER TREASURER TAX
COLLECTOR FOR A DOZEN YEARS.
I WILL TELL YOU THAT PACE IS A
FINANCING NIGHTMARE.
WE SHOULD ACTUALLY PUT PACE OUT
OF ITS EXISTENCE.
RECENT LOS ANGELES TIMES
ARTICLES.
WE'LL CONVENTION OF THIS.
STORIES ARE RATHER.
STERBEN.
S. BEAT ONE OH EIGHT SEVEN MAYBE
A GOOD STEP IN THE MEANTIME.
IF THOSE PROPAGATING PACE LOANS
ARE AGAINST THIS BILL.
THEN I'M BEGRUDGINGLY FOR IT.
SO I WILL VOTE FOR THIS BILL BUT
I'D RATHER VOTE FOR CHEMOTHERAPY
AND REMOVE THIS CANCER FROM THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. BUT I WANNA
THANK YASSER FOR HIS BILL THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
THINK.
THANK YOU CENTER MORLOCK MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING TO FILE ITEM EIGHTY FIVE
SENATOR ROTH. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN TWELVE A
SENATOR ROTH AND ACTING TO
LICENSE PLATES SOONER ROTH THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AGAIN
COLLEAGUES SO.
REMOVING THE LICENSE PLATES.
AND SUPPORTIVE SERVICES FOR
THOSE EXPERIENCING CHRONIC
HOMELESSNESS PERENNIAL PROBLEM
HERE IN THE STATE.
THIS BILL WOULD FIND SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES FOR THOSE EXPERIENCING
CHRONIC HOMELESSNESS IN
RECEIVING ASSISTANCE.
THROUGH THE HOUSING FOR HEALTHY
CALIFORNIA PROGRAM IT WOULD DO
SO BY AUTHORIZING THE INCLUSION.
OF THE HASH TAG SYMBOL ON
CALIFORNIA DRIVER'S LICENSE
PLATES.
THE FEE FROM THIS SPECIALIZED
PLATE WILL CREATE AN ONGOING
FUNDING SOURCE TO PROVIDE
DESPERATELY NEEDED SERVICES
DESIGNED TO HELP THE CHRONICALLY
HOMELESS.
RECEIVE MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT
AND COUNSELING. OVERCOME
SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND RECEIVED JOB
TRAINING ALLWHILE SAVING THE
STATE MONEY BY DECREASING MEDI
CAL COSTS.
IN ARE INTERCONNECTED WORLD.
A POWERFUL HASH TAG EMPOWERS
PEOPLE TO BOTH CREATE AN
INDIVIDUAL BRAND. AND BAND
TOGETHER.
DR MOVEMENTS TRY SAYING THAT
FAST.
AS WE HAVE RECENTLY SEEN WITH
THE HASHTAG ME TO.
THIS BILL WILL ALLOW
CALIFORNIA'S TO TAKE HIS POWER
ON THE ROAD WHILE SUPPORTING OUR
MOST VULNERABLE POPULATIONS AND
I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER ROTH MEMBERS IS
THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE. IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS BEFORE WE
GO TO OUR OTHER CONFEREES WE'RE
GOING TO GO BACK TO FILE ITEM
ONE OF SIX.
SENATOR BRADFORD MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
THE BILL TWELVE SEVEN I'M A
SENATOR BRADFORD AND ACT CLING
TO SOMETHING.
SENATOR BRADFORD GAVE ME LIFE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I.
.
I'M EXCITED TO PRESENT SP TWELVE
SEVENTY NINE A BILL THAT HELPS
SIMPLIFY CALIFORNIA'S COMPLEX
SENTENCING LAW AND RESTORE
GREATER PROPORTIONALITY. TO OUR
JUSTICE SYSTEM UNDER EXISTING
LAW OUR STATE HAS WON THE MOST
CONVOLUTED. SENTENCING
STRUCTURES IN THE WORLD YOU
LITERALLY NEED TO BE A
MATHEMATICIAN TO FIGURE OUT HOW
MUCH TIME ONE WILL GET BASED ON
ALL OF THE DIFFERENT MATRIX SIX
THAT YOU LOOK AT TO CALCULATE
SENTENCING. THIS BILL SIMPLY
REFINES CALIFORNIA'S.
PANTS AND COMPLEX SENTENCING LAW
IMPROVES BALANCE IN SENTENCING
AND UNDERLYING FELONIES BY
SIMPLY ENSURING THAT A FULL TERM
OF IMPRISONMENT DOES NOT EXCEED
PLACED A NUMBER OF YEARS FOR THE
BASE TERM I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE.
THINK YOU CENTER BRADFORD
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
THUNDERSTONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT OF THE
SITE CONTINUES THE TREND IN IN
CALIFORNIA AND RELEASING
DANGEROUS CRIMINALS AND AND. AND
BASICALLY.
TAKING AWAY FROM JUDGES THE
ABILITY TO PROVIDE ENHANCEMENTS.
IF YOU ARE GUILTY OF A OF A
ROBBERY YOU KNOW YOU'RE
BASICALLY CAN GET THREE FIVE
SEVEN YEARS AND. IMPRISONED SO
UNDER.
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM LOS
ANGELES IS BILL THEY CAN GET NO
MORE THAN TWICE THE BASE TERM SO
THEY GOT THREE YEARS FOR THE
FIRST TIME. OF BEING IN AN ARMED
ROBBERY THEY WOULD GET SIX YEARS.
BUT IF YOU HAVE SOME OF THIS
BEEN.
ACCUSED AND CONVICTED.
OF MULTIPLE ARMED ROBBERIES
THERE WOULD BE NO SENTENCE
ENHANCEMENTS FOR THESE VERY
DANGEROUS INDIVIDUALS.
THAT GO BACK INTO THE COMMUNITY
AND MAYBE NEXT TIME WHEN THEY DO
AN ARMED ROBBERY IS NOT GOING TO
DISARM ROBBERY BUT IT'S GOING TO
BE MURDER.
SO ONCE AGAIN. I ASK MY
COLLEAGUES.
DO YOU REALLY BELIEVE THE
PASSING THIS BILL IS GOING TO
MAKE OUR COMMUNITIES SAFER OR
LESS SAFE.
IF YOU BELIEVE THEY'RE GOING TO
MAKE IT SAFER THAN I RICHARD YOU
TO VOTE FOR S. B. TWELVE SEVENTY
NINE. IF YOU BELIEVE LIKE I DO
THIS CAN MAKE OUR COMMUNITY IS
MUCH MORE DANGEROUS I URGE YOU
TO OPPOSE S. B. TWELVE SEVENTY
NINE. THANK YOU MEMBERS OF.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE SENATOR
NELSON.
BUT A PRESIDENT LADIES DOWN THE
SENATE I I AGAIN WILL BREAK THE
SIMILAR ARGUMENTS THAT I
CONTINUE TO.
ON THIS
DASTARDLY.
CHANGING IN SENTENCING IN
CALIFORNIA.
THE PRIVATE THE CITIZENS WHO.
ARE VICTIMIZED.
HAVE A JUST.
RIGHT.
THE JUST RIGHT TO JUST TOUCH.
FOR VICTIMS.
THERE'S NO CLOSURE.
SOME SAY GET OVER IT.
WELL FOR MANY OF THESE CRIMES.
THERE'S NO GETTING OVER IT.
SIMPLE CARJACKING NO PROBLEM.
THE WHOLE IDEA.
OF ENHANCEMENT.
THEN IT GOES WAY BACK TO
NINETEEN SEVENTY SEVEN THE
DETERMINATE SENTENCE LAW.
WHEREBY.
CONSERVATIVES AND LIBERALS BOTH
REPORTED THAT.
FOR THE WRONG REASONS BOTH LIVED
TO REGRET IT.
BUT SINCE SOLUTION TO THAT FOLLY.
IN PART WORTHY ENHANCEMENTS.
FOR AGGRAVATING FACTORS.
RELATED THE CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR.
WATER AGGRAVATING FACTORS.
USING A GUN.
REPEAT BEHAVIOR.
CONTINUING TO DO FELONIES
AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN.
THAT INDICATES A PATTERN.
OF REPETITIOUS AN ESCALATING
BEHAVIOR.
AND FOR CRIMINALS.
GETTING AWAY WITH IT.
FOR GETTING OFF EASIER IS NOT A
SIGNAL TO THEM.
THE STOP DOING.
IT IS RATHER AN INVITATION.
I KEEP DOING IT.
AND TO BE EMBOLDENED.
TO INCREASE YOUR.
CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR THE
SERIOUSNESS.
OF THAT.
BEHAVIOR.
AND WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SERIOUS.
BEHAVIOR HERE.
CITIZENS THE WE REPRESENT.
HARM.
THEY'LL COME THE DAY OF
RECKONING FOR THIS NEW CRIMINAL
JUSTICE PROGRAM IN CALIFORNIA.
AND THE TIDE WILL TURN.
THEN I TELL PEOPLE.
THAT.
THAT WILL HAPPEN AND THEY SAID
HOW DO YOU KNOW.
AND I SA BECAUSE OUR PEOPLE OUT
CAMPAIGNING.
BURKE POSITION I TAKE.
WHO'S CAMPAIGNING.
THE CRIMINALS TWENTY FOUR SEVEN.
OR OUT ON OUR STREETS.
VICTIMIZING OUR CITIZENS.
I SAY ENOUGH.
I RECOMMEND A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR NIELSEN
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE CENTER
BRADFORD WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
YES THINK ABOUT A PRESIDENT AND
I AM JUST SOMEWHAT. AMAZED AT
THE.
DESCRIPTION THAT IS BEING MADE
BY MY COLLEAGUE FROM THE OTHER
SIDE I DON'T KNOW WHAT BILL
THEY'RE. REFERRING TO BUT THIS
BILL HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH.
HEINOUS CRIMINALS VIOLENT CRIME
IT CLEARLY STATES THAT THOSE
INDIVIDUALS. WHO WERE SENTENCED
FOR CRIME WHEELS RECEIVE NO MORE
THAN TWICE THE BASE OUT OUR
SENTENCING THAT'S A LONG TERM
THOUGH WHETHER IT'S SEVEN YEARS
YOU WILL DO FOURTEEN YEARS WE'RE
NOT TALKING ABOUT LETTING?
RAPISTS ARE MURDERERS OUT IT'S
NOT A SINGLE PERSON ON THIS
FLOOR WHO WOULD SUPPORT THAT SO
TO CONTINUE TO PUT THE BOOGIE
MAN IN EVERYTHING WERE TRYING TO
DO TO MAKE. JUSTICE.
BEAR
WORDS NOT JUST POTS JUST BLACK
AND BROWN PEOPLE AND THE
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM THAT'S
WHAT WE'RE STRIVING FOR ITS TRY
STRIVING FOR BALANCE MAKES YOUR
POOR PEOPLE HAVE A CHANCE TO
TURN THEIR LIVES AROUND. BUT NOT
SPIN THE REST THEIR LIVES IN
PRISON SIMPLY BECAUSE OF A
CONVOLUTED ENHANCEMENTS THAT WE
CLEARLY KNOW. DO NOT WORK WE'VE
HIT TWENTY FIVE YEARS OF
EXAMPLES OF THESE ENHANCEMENTS
HAVE NOT THE TO OR NOT ANY CRIME
OR YOU WOULDN'T BE COSTLY MAKING
ARGUMENT.
I'M AS INCREASE YOU CAN'T HAVE
IT BOTH WAYS YOU CAN'T STATE
THAT THE ENHANCEMENTS ARE GONNA
DETERRING CRIME BUT CRIME IS ON
THE RISE I THINK THIS IS
COMMONSENSE MEASURE. THIS DOES
NOTHING TO ELIMINATE
ENHANCEMENTS AND IT DOESN'T
PRECLUDE OF THE JUDGES FROM.
GIVING A HARSH SENTENCE IF HE
SEES FIT BIG JUST GIVE THEM.
DISCRETION IT DOESN'T LET OUT
ANYBODY VIOLENT OR SEXUAL IN
NATURE AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
CENTER BRADFORD MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
NO DALY OWN.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
NO.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I MORE LOCKED.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I STERN.
STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO WHAT KATHY. I WINNER. I WILL.
KNOW.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DELEON.
MCGUIRE.
I.
NEWMAN.
I.
PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
STERN.
BY EYES TWENTY TWO KNOWS FOURTEEN
THE MEASURE PASSES. MEMBERS WE
ARE GOING TO MOVE TO CONCRETE
NIELSEN AND I THINK YOU WANT TO
TAKE UP FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY.
YES
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN THIRTEEN BY
SENATOR NELSON AND ACT GOING TO
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT
MAKING PROBATION THEREFORE.
CENTER NIELSEN AYE TO PRESENT
LADIES GEMS SENATE THIS GIVES.
BOB.
CALPERS.
A NEW OPTION.
IT DID HELP OUR EMPLOYEES.
IT PROVIDES CALPERS THE
AUTHORITY TO ESTABLISH IRISH
SANCTIONS.
TRUST.
THESE CALIFORNIA STATE EMPLOYEES
THEN.
PIMPRI FUND THEIR FUTURE ANNUAL
PENSION CONTRIBUTIONS.
THEY EMPLOYERS WOULD HAVE THE
OPTION OF PAYING DOWN THE
UNFUNDED LIABILITY.
TO.
A DEFINED BENEFIT PLAN.
AVAILABLE.
IT IS A SIMILAR TO THE CALPERS
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS RETIREMENT
BENEFITS TRUST.
IT'S CURRENTLY LIMITED TO PRE
FUNDING EMPLOYEES.
EXCUSE ME EMPLOYERS OTHER POST
EMPLOYMENT BENEFIT LIABILITIES
BUT EXCLUDES PENSIONS.
WITH THIS BILL WE'RE GOING TO
INCLUDE PENSIONS.
TRUSTS ARE AVAILABLE IN THE
PRIVATE MARKET.
TO CUT COSTS TO THE PUBLICATION
SEE WOULD BE LAST.
IF THESE TRUST WERE OFFERED LIKE
CALPERS.
IT WOULD BE MORE COST EFFECTIVE
USE.
OF THOSE INVESTMENTS.
IT WOULD BE A SIGNIFICANT TOOL
FOR PUBLIC SERVICE AGENCIES.
TO RESPONSIBLY MANAGE
PENSION OBLIGATIONS.
AT FOR EMPLOYEES.
A PREPAY.
I WOULD URGE.
THEN I VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
NIELSEN MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA MOVE
TO FILE ITEM OR ONE FOURTEEN.
SENATOR LARA MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN ANYONE BY
SENATOR LOTT A AN ACT GOING TO
JUVENILES.
SENATOR LARA THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS S. B. THIRTEEN
NINETY ONE. PROHIBITS CHILDREN
AGES FOURTEEN AND FIFTEEN FROM
BEING TRIED AS ADULTS IN
CRIMINAL COURT AND SUBSEQUENTLY
SENT TO ADULT PRISON. CURRENTLY
IN CALIFORNIA YOUNG AGES OF
FOURTEEN AND FIFTEEN WHO COMMIT
CRIMES CAN BE TRIED AS ADULTS
AND SENTENCED TO THE ADULT
PRISON. THIS PRACTICE WAS
STARTED IN THE NINETIES A TIME
IN CALIFORNIA'S HISTORY WHAT THE
STATE WAS SUPPOSEDLY GETTING
TOUGH ON CRIME. BUT NOT SMART ON
CRIME BACK THEN SOCIETY BELIEVE
THAT YOUNG PEOPLE WERE FULLY
DEVELOPED AT AROUND THE AGE OF
FOURTEEN. NOW THIS RESEARCH HAS
CLEARLY BEEN DEBUNKED.
A COGNITIVE SCIENCE HAS SHOWN
THAT CHILDREN AND YOUTH WHO
COMMIT CRIMES ARE CAPABLE OF
CHANGE AND ARE REDEEMABLE.
HOWEVER FOURTEEN TO FIFTEEN YEAR
OLDS ARE ESPECIALLY VULNERABLE
TO MAKE POOR DECISIONS.
ABOUT ONE IN FOUR YOUTH UNDER
THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN HAVE MENTAL
HEALTH CHALLENGES AND MANY YOUTH
INVOLVED IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE
SYSTEM HAVE ACTUALLY EXPERIENCED
OUR OWN TRAUMA AND ABUSE. THAT
IMPACT OUR ABILITY TO MAKE GOOD
DECISIONS.
JUST OVER THE PAST TEN YEARS
MEMBERS FIFTY PERCENT OF LATINO
YOUTH AND SIXTY PERCENT OF BLACK
YOUTH WERE SENT TO ADULT COURT.
AFTER A TRANSFER HEARING
COMPARED TO ONLY TEN PERCENT OF
THEIR WHITE COUNTERPARTS FOR
SIMILAR CRIMES.
SOME YOUTH SENTENCED TO ADULT
PRISON HAVE COMMITTED VERY
SERIOUS CRIMES HOWEVER THEY ARE
NOT THE MAJORITY ABOUT SEVENTY
TWO PERCENT OF YOUNG OF OUR
YOUTH UNDER THE AGE OF SIXTEEN
WERE SENT TO ADULT COURT. FOR
CRIMES SUCH AS BURGLARY ROBBERY
AND ASSAULT. THE YOUNG IF TEENS
IN OUR SYSTEM NEED TO BE HELD
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS
BUT THEY'RE ALSO REQUIRED AGE
APPROPRIATE SERVICES AND
PROGRAMS TO REHABILITATE AND
GROWING TO HEALTHY MATURE ADULTS.
KEEPING OUR YOUTH IN THE
JUVENILE SYSTEM A DOES THAT MEAN
THEY GET OFF WITH A SLAP ON THE
WRIST SOME OF THESE YOU. MAY
HAVE COMMITTED VERY SERIOUS
CRIMES AND THEY WILL BE PUNISHED
TO INCARCERATION AT THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUVENILE JUSTICE
THIS IS STILL PRESENT. TONY
DIFFERENCES THEY HAVE AGE
APPROPRIATE REHABILITATIVE
SERVICES FOR THESE YOUNG
OFFENDERS. THIS IS STILL.
A PRISON MEMBERS.
WE CANNOT CONTINUE TO STAND ARE
YOU TO THE ADULT PRISON WHERE
THEY WILL NOT RECEIVE THE
APPROPRIATE SERVICES. TO HELP
THEM GROW INTO HEALTHY MATURE
ADULTS WE MUST REJECT THE LAWS
OF THE NINETIES THAT HELP
PERPETUATE NEGATIVE RACIAL BIAS
TOWARDS ARE BLACK AND BROWN YOU.
ALLOWED SAYS THAT CHILDREN ARE
REDEEMABLE AND SHOULD NOT BE
JUDGED BY THEIR WORST ACT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
STONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
.
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE I STAND
TODAY IN OPPOSITION S. B.
THIRTEEN NINETY ONE. NO ONE
WANTS TO SEE A FOURTEEN OR
FIFTEEN YEAR OLD BE JUDGES AN
ADULT.
AND I KNOW I DID NOT BUT
UNFORTUNATELY THE WORLD WE LIVE
IN HAS SEEN THAT THERE ARE SOME
YOUNG INDIVIDUALS WHO EXHIBIT A
HIGH LEVEL OF VIOLENCE.
AND MALICIOUS BEHAVIOR.
IT'S IMPORTANT TO KEEP THE
JUDICIAL DISCRETION OF THE
COURTS IN THESE CASES TO
SEPARATE THE YOUTHFUL MISTAKES.
FROM THE SERIOUS AND DANGEROUS
ACTIONS OF THE FEW.
LET US EXAMINE WHAT CRITERIA
CONSIDERED BY THE COURT LOOKS
LIKE.
DEGREE OF CRIMINAL
SOPHISTICATION EXHIBITED BY THE
MINOR.
WHAT THE MINOR CAN BE
REHABILITATED PRIOR TO THE
EXPIRATION OF THE JUVENILES
COURT JURISDICTION?
THE MINERS PREVIOUS DELINQUENT
HISTORY.
EXCESSIVE PREVIOUS ATTEMPTS BY
THE JUVENILE COURT TO
REHABILITATE THE MINOR.
AND THE CIRCUMSTANCES AND
GRAVITY OF THE OFFENSE ALLEGE IN
THE PETITION TO HAVE BEEN
COMMITTED. BY THE MINOR.
THESE CRITERIA ALLOW THE COURT
TO EXAMINE ALL SAME CONCERNS
THAT MY COLLEAGUE HAS SHARED.
A MAJORITY OF MINERS WHO FACE
COURT DISCRETION. WILL AND DO
FALL INEVITABLY IN THE JUVENILE
COURT SYSTEM.
BUT THIS DISCRETION IS THERE TO
CATCH A FEW. WHO INEVITABLY HAVE
DISPLAYED THE CARE STRICTEST
CHARACTERISTICS?
NEEDING A HIGHER LEVEL OF
REHABILITATION AND
ACCOUNTABILITY. FOR THOSE
REASONS I URGE A NO VOTE IN S.
B. THIRTEEN ANYONE. THANK YOU
CENTER STONE SENATOR NIELSEN.
THAT A PRESENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THE SAID I WILL BE
BRIEF.
I WILL JUST.
REITERATE SOME OF THE ARGUMENTS
OF MY COLLEAGUE.
IT ALSO NOTE THAT.
SADLY LADIES AND GENTLEMAN.
THERE ARE SOME OF OUR YOUTH.
THERE ARE VICIOUS.
AND WILL NOT REHABILITATE.
THANK A LOOK AT OUR GAINES.
THE YOUTH GANGS.
THE VICIOUSNESS OF THE BEHAVIOR
THAT THEY COMMIT.
I WON'T EVEN NAME ALL OF THE
GAMES.
BUT I'VE COULD TELL YOU THAT
THEY HAVE BEEN RAMPANT.
FOR DECADES.
EVEN VERY TINY SH COMMUNITY SUCH
AS HAMILTON CITY.
THE TINY TOWN ON THE SACRAMENTO
RIVER.
AND GLENN COUNTY.
TWENTY YEARS AGO GOT TAKEN OVER.
BY YOUTH GANGS.
THERE ARE INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE WORTHY.
OF THE.
ADULT COURT.
CONSIDERATION
OF THEIR BEHAVIOR.
AND SELDOM IS THIS COMMITMENT OR
THIS PART.
THE POSSIBILITY.
BE TRIED.
IN ADULT COURT.
IS NOT THE RESULT.
THE FIRST TIME BEHAVIOR.
OF THAT PERSON.
MOST ALWAYS IT IS RESULT.
OF A SUSTAIN PATTERN.
OF THAT ESCALATING BEHAVE RIFLE
CAN OF.
YES.
THEY NEED.
TO BE JUDGED.
FOR THE BEHAVIOR.
NOT ALWAYS
THE RAGE.
THANK YOU SENATOR NIELSEN
SENATOR MITCHELL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT EVO
QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
THE REAL ARE WE TO QUESTION.
PLEASE REFERITS SEEDS SENATOR
MITCHELL DID I DO SOME I'M
CURIOUS BASED ON SOME OF THE
COMMENTS OF OUR COLLEAGUES MADE
BY IT I WOULD OF.
LOVE TO HAVE HEARD ALL THE GAINS.
LISTED BUT I'M CURIOUS.
WILL A COMMENT WAS MADE ABOUT.
ON AN ASSUMPTION ABOUT THE
NUMBERS OF THE YOUNG PEOPLE THAT
THIS BILL IS INTENDED TO ADDRESS.
WHO ARE HAVE INDEED COMMITTED?
VIOLENT CRIMES AIR QUOTES BICU
DO YOU HAVE ANY REAL CITIZENS
WHO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
WE ARE CLEAR ABOUT THE
POPULATION.
BASED ON THE FACT THAT YOU THIS
BILLS ATTEMPTED TO ADDRESS THE
DO YOU CAN YOU TELL US HOW MANY
FALL INTO THAT CATEGORY SO WHAT
WE DO KNOW IS THAT SEVENTY TWO
PERCENT OF THE YOUTH. UNDER THE
AGE OF SIXTEEN HAVE SENT ARE WHO
HAVE BEEN SENT TO THE ADULT
COURT.
HAVE BEEN FOR A NON VIOLENT
CRIMES COOPER AGREE ROBBERY AND
ASSAULT.
AND ALSO THE DIVISION OF
JUVENILE JUSTICE.
AGAIN MEMBERS IS STILL PRESENT.
LET'S NOT FORGET.
THIS IS NOT SOME SORT OF SUMMER
CAMP.
THEY'RE STILL GONNA DO THEIR
TIME WE JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY HAVE THE APPROPRIATE
REHABILITATIVE SERVICES AND WERE
NOT THROUGH THE DAY THAT CLEARLY
STATES.
THAT OVER SEVENTY TWO PERCENT OF
OUR YOUTH ARE BEING SENT.
THE PUSH ONLY AFRICAN AMERICAN
AND LATINO YOUTH ARE BEING SENT
TO THE ADULT SYSTEM FOR NON
VIOLENT CRIMES.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING HEARING NONE CENTER OR
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THANK
YOU THANK YOU.
MEMBERS FOR THAT DEBATE LUCK
WE'VE ALWAYS SOME OF THE STAND
UP HERE AND SAY THAT YOU KNOW
THE FATHER AS AN UNCLE AS A
GRANDFATHER. YOU KNOW WE DON'T
KNOW WHAT THE CIRCUMSTANCES ARE
OF OUR CHILDREN OUR NIECES OR
NEPHEWS BUT WE DO KNOW IN OUR
HEARTS THAT. THESE ARE CHILDREN.
THAT COMMITTEES CRIMES HAVE BEEN
VICTIMIZED THEMSELVES.
OFTEN AT THE HANDS OF AN ADULT.
AND WE ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT THIS
RESEARCH AND DATA DEMONSTRATES
THAT PEOPLE ARE REDEEMABLE
CHILDREN ARE REDEEMABLE AND THAT
FOURTEEN FIFTEEN YEAR OLDS.
CAN CHANGE.
THIS WASN'T ALWAYS THE CASE.
THIS STARTED IN THE NINETIES.
AND SO WE'RE TRYING TO RIVER
BACK TO A A.
A TIME IN WHICH WE WOULD
CASTIGATE FOLKS.
WITHOUT ANY TYPE OF
REHABILITATION AND THE IRONY AS
IF WE SENT THESE FOURTEEN YEAR
OLD AND FIFTEEN ROLLED. TO THE
ADULT SYSTEM. GUEST ONE. BUT I
SHE GONNA BECOME THOSE GANG
MEMBERS THAT THE GOOD SENATOR
FROM TO HIM OF TALKS ABOUT.
WHERE THERE'S NO REHABILITATIVE
SERVICES WHATSOEVER?
AND THERE WERE IN WITH HARDENED
CRIMINALS.
SO YOU CAN AGAIN LIKE MY
COLLEAGUE FROM. BALLOTS UNDER
THE SAID YOU CAN'T HAVE IT BOTH
WAYS.
AND YOU CANNOT JUST GET UP HERE
AND TALK ABOUT ALTERNATIVE FOX.
BUT DATA IT'S CLEAR. THAT PEOPLE
THAT CHILDREN ARE REDEEMABLE
WE'VE SEEN THAT OURSELVES. AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL. AYE BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
NO.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
PILOT AYE. AYE LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
I MONEY. BY MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NO.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
I STERN.
STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO WHY COUNTY.
I WINNER.
I WILL.
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DELEON.
GLAZER.
NO.
MORE LOCK.
NO NEWMAN.
WHEN.
NO.
ROTH STIR.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY OWN.
NEWMAN.
ROTH.
STERN.
CENTER MOVES A CALL MEMBERS WE
ARE NOW MOVING TO CONFEREE
SKINNER AND WE ARE GOING TO DO A
NUMBER OF HER BILLS STARTING
WITH FILE ITEM FIFTY FOUR.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE TWENTY SIX
WESTERNERS SKINNER AND ACT CLING
TO PUBLIC SOCIAL SERVICES.
CENTER SKINNER THANK YOU.
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SP NINE
TWENTY SIX PROTECTS OUR CAL
WORKS AND CAL FRESH.
PARTICIPANTS WHO IS YOU KNOW ARE
REQUIRED TO HAVE.
BE EMPLOYEE TEMP WORK HOURS
WHAT IT DOES IS PROTECT THEM
THAT IF DALY QUIT THEIR JOB.
DO YOU TO WORKPLACE HARASSMENT
OR IN OTHER.
CIRCUMSTANCE FOR WHICH THERE IS
A LEGAL EMPLOYEE RIGHTS AGAINST
THAT THEY WOULD NOT HAVE THEIR
BENEFITS SUSPENDED. SERVICE
SPECIFICALLY IT PRESERVES THEIR
BENEFITS FOR THREE MONTHS
GIVING THEM TIME TO BE ABLE TO
FIND ANOTHER JOB. WHERE THEY
WOULD NOT ENCOUNTER THE
CIRCUMSTANCE THEY ENCOUNTERED ON
THE JOB THEY LEFT?
AND IT ALSO REQUIRES ARE
COUNTIES TO INFORM THESE
PARTICIPANTS OF THEIR EMPLOYEE
RIGHTS AND REMEDIES
I THINK MOST OF US REALIZE MANY
LOW WAGE WORKERS DO NOT REALIZE.
SOME OF THE PROTECTIONS WE HAVE
LEGAL LEAVE. TO.
.
AGAINST SEXUAL HARASSMENT FOR
EXAMPLE AGAINST DISCRIMINATION
SO THIS HELPS INFORM THOSE
EMPLOYEES AND MAKE SURE THAT
THEIR BENEFITS FOR AT LEAST
THREE MONTHS OR NOT SUSPENDED IF
THEY LEAVE A JOB. FOR THAT
REASON THE AMENDMENTS THAT WE
TOOK IN THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS HAS REMOVED ALL
OPPOSITION I ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN. NO ATKINS.
ANDERSON NOTA AYE ATKINS AYE
BATES.
NO.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG. AYE HILL. AYE
HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
I LADA.
LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
BY MONEY.
I MORE LOCK.
NO MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I.
NIELSEN.
NO PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN. AYE STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
DELEON.
GALGIANI.
I.
LOTTE.
I SWINGS SEVEN THOSE TEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE
GONNA NOW MOVED TO FILE ITEM
SIXTY FIVE. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE EIGHTY FOUR BY
SENATOR SKINNER AND ACT GOING TO
STATE GOVERNMENT CENTER SKINNER.
THANK YOU AND META PRESIDENT
MEMBERS SB NINE EIGHTY FOUR WILL
HELP PUT CALIFORNIA AT THE LEAD
OF ENSURING THAT THERE IS.
GENDER DIVERSITY AND GENDER
REPRESENTATION ON OUR STATE
APPOINTED BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS
AS WE KNOW. WOMEN MAKEUP HALF
THE POPULATION OF CALIFORNIA AND
YET WE ARE STILL UNDER
REPRESENTED ON PUBLIC AND
PRIVATE BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS
AND OF COURSE HERE IN THE
LEGISLATURE BUT.
THAT'S A SIDE OF THE BILL DOES
NOT COVER THE MAKEUP OF THE
LEGISLATURE.
BUT WHAT IT DOES IS.
IT REQUIRES THE COMPOSITION OF
EACH OF OUR STATE APPOINTED
BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS TO BE THE
FOLLOWING.
THAT IF THERE ARE SIX OR MORE
MEMBERS ON THAT BOARD OR
COMMISSION FORTY PERCENT WOULD
BE WOMEN.
AND IF THERE'S FIVE MEMBERS A
MINIMUM OF TWO AND IF THERE ARE
FOR LESS MEMBERS A MINIMUM OF
ONE.
AND WITH THAT I ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE. BIGGEST UNDER SKINNER
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
CENTER GLAZER.
I THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I WANNA EXPRESSED MY
APPRECIATION TO THE AUTHOR FOR
MOVING THIS IMPORTANT BILL
FORWARD AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT
I CAN SUPPORT TODAY. BUT THE
REASON I'M SPEAKING ON IT IS
BECAUSE OUT LATER TODAY FOR
MAYBE TOMORROW.
WE'RE GONNA DEAL WITH ANOTHER
BILL WITH SUCH A SIMILAR GOOD
PURPOSES.
IDEALLY WITH PRIVATE COMPANIES
I HEAR IN THE CASE OF THIS BILL
I THESE ARE PUBLIC COMMISSIONS
THINGS IN WHICH WE HAVE SOME
CONTROL OVER AND I THINK THIS
BILL. THAT'S IMPORTANT GOALS AND
STANDARDS THAT WE SHOULD HEAR TO
IN TERMS OF.
DIVERSITY ARE.
THE BELL OVER HERE IN A FEW
MINUTES HAS SIMILAR GOALS AND
DESIRES BUT YET IT'S IN.
PLACING THAT OBLIGATION ON A
PRIVATE COMPANY IT'S SOMETHING
THAT I THINK IS THAT MATERIAL
DIFFERENCE AND I WANTED TOCALL
IT OUT. AT THE SAME TIME IN
VIRGINIA A YES VOTE ON THIS
MEASURE.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER MEMBERS
ANY OTHER FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE THING THAT CENTER SKINNER
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
BUT BASS FEAR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
BY BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
BY CANNELLA.
NO DAILY ON.
DODD.
I.
FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
I HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LOVE ACT.
I LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
I MONNING I MORE LOCK.
NO MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NELSON.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER. AYE STERN. AYE STONE.
NOVI DAK
NO WIECKOWSKI.
I WIENER. AYE WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES.
DELEON.
FULLER.
GALGIANI.
I.
HUESO. I.
NGUYEN.
I.
I SWINGS SEVEN KNOWS NINE THE
MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO
FILE ITEM SEVENTY ONE.
SENATOR SKINNER MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN OH EIGHT BY
SENATOR SKINNER AND ACT WILLING
TO DENTAL SERVICES.
SENATOR SKINNER.
THANK YOU MADAM.
PRESIDENT A MEMBERS SP.
ONE ZERO ZERO EIGHT.
ENABLES OUR. CONSUMERS TO HAVE
ACCESS TO INFORMATION ABOUT
THEIR DENTAL PLANS.
IN A COMPARABLE FASHION TO WHAT
WE REQUIRE FOR HEALTH INSURANCE
PLANS
SO WHAT IT DOES IS PROVIDE. THAT
DENTAL INSURERS HAVE A UNIFORM
SUMMARY. OF THEIR BENEFITS
SO THAT YOU CAN COMPARE ONE PLAN
FROM ANOTHER.
AND PROVIDING YOU STRAIGHT
FORWARD INFORMATION. IT ALSO
GIVES YOU THE INFORMATION ABOUT.
IF YOU CHOOSE TO USE OUT OF
NETWORK PROVIDERS.
WHAT TREATMENTS WOULD BE COVERED
AND WHAT COST IT WOULD BE TO YOU
SO THAT ALLOWS THE CONSUMER TO
MAKE AN INFORMED DECISION?
WE TOOK AMENDMENTS THAT ADDRESS
THE DENTAL PLANS MAJOR CONCERNS
WE REMOVED DENTAL DISCOUNT PLANS.
AND WE I KNOW THAT SOME DENTAL
PLANS REMAIN OPPOSED BUT WE ARE
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THEM AND
DID TAKE A NUMBER OF AMENDMENTS.
SO WHAT I SP TEN THOUSAND ONE
THOUSAND IN.
ONE ZERO ZERO EIGHT DOES IS
IMPROVE TRANSPARENCY AND PROVIDE
CONSUMERS INFORMATION TO BE ABLE
TO COMPARE INCH DENTAL INSURANCE
PLANS WHEN THEY BEFORE THEY
CHOOSE TO BUY. WITHOUT
IONOSPHERE AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I ATKINS AYE BATES.
BELL.
BY BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA. AYE DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
BY HILL.
BY HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
BY LARA.
I LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
BY MONEY.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
BY SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
I BIDAK.
NO WHY KATHY I WINNER BY WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES.
NO.
DELEON.
MORE LOCK.
NGUYEN.
BY.
I STUDY ONE NO SIX THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO
FILE ITEM NINETY SIX
THE.
PASS ON ZERO ITEM ONE TWENTY TWO
ABSOLUTELY MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO
FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY TWO. MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE BY
SENATOR SKINNER AND HALF WILLING
TO PEACE OFFICER RECORDS.
SENATOR SKINNER.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS SP FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE.
WOULD ALLOW PUBLIC ACCESS TO THE
INVESTIGATION RECORDS RELATED TO
A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS USE
OF DEADLY FORCE.
DISCHARGE OF A FIREARM.
BONTA JOB SEXUAL ASSAULT OR WORK
RELATED DISHONESTY.
SO THIS IS A NARROW SET.
OF.
ISSUES.
THAT WE WOULD GIVE PUBLIC ACCESS
TO THERE HAVE BEEN PREVIOUS
SPILLS THAT WERE FAR BROADER.
NOW THE REALITY IS THAT
CALIFORNIA IS ONE OF THE MOST
SECRETIVE STATES IN THE NATION
WHEN IT COMES TO THE ABILITY OF
EACH AND EVERYONE OF US.
TO ACCESS LAW ENFORCEMENT
RECORDS
THERE ARE TWELVE STATES
INCLUDING ALABAMA ARIZONA
GEORGIA FLORIDA.
OHIO AND UTAH.
THAT HAVE FAR MORE EXTENSIVE
DISCLOSURE THEN WHAT IS PROPOSED
IN SP FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE.
ADDITIONALLY THERE ARE FIFTEEN
STATES
THAT HAVE DISCLOSURES VERY
COMPARABLE TO WHAT IS PROPOSED
IN MY BILL FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE.
AND NO STATES INCLUDE TEXAS
OKLAHOMA ARKANSAS TENNESSEE WEST
VIRGINIA AND KENTUCKY.
CALIFORNIA IS AN OUT LIAR IN
THIS REGARD.
BUT WHAT I THINK IS MOST
IMPORTANT FOR US TO TAKE NOTE OF.
IS THAT.
UNTIL TWO THOUSAND AND SIX.
THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC HAD ACCESS
TO ALMOST ALL INVESTIGATORY
RECORDS AROUND OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT CONDUCT FALL.
AND THE CHANGE FOR CREATING THIS
IN EFFECT.
A DARK HOLE OF LACK OF ACCESS TO
RECORDS CAME ABOUT. AFTER TWO
THOUSAND AND SIX
NOW THIS BILL DOES NOT RETURN
CALIFORNIA TO PRE TWO THOUSAND
AND SIX LEVELS.
IT'S A MORE LIMITED ACCESS THE
NAN.
STRIKING A BALANCE BETWEEN
PRIVACY PRIVACY AND PUBLIC RIGHT
TO KNOW.
AMENDMENTS WERE TAKEN.
IN THE PROBES COMMITTEE.
SO THAT NOW THE CALIFORNIA DA
ASSOCIATION IS NEUTRAL.
I MEAN I CAN DETAIL THOSE IF
NEEDED.
NIGHT.
SPECS WE ASK YOUR AYE VOTE ON
FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE. BIG YOU
CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF SB FOURTEEN
TWENTY ONE.
I WAS ALSO A CO AUTHOR FOR
SENATE BILL TWELVE EIGHTY SIX BY.
SENATOR LENO BACK IN TWENTY
SIXTEEN.
WE NEED TO.
WE NEED MORE DISCLOSURE
COLLEAGUES.
HAVING SERVED AS A SUPERVISOR
FOR COUNTY LARGE COUNTY THIS
CODE OF SILENCE.
HAS GONE ON A LITTLE TOO LONG.
THIS YEAR WE WERE INTRODUCED TO
JOSEPH JAMES TO ANGELO.
HE HS MONIKERS LIKE EAST AREA
RAPIST GOLDEN STATE KILLER.
AND HE WAS A FORMER POLICE
OFFICER.
HIS SHOPLIFTING ARRESTS
SHOULD HAVE BEEN DISCLOSED YEARS
AGO WHEN YOU ANALYZE.
THE REVIEWS BY JOURNALISTS AS TO
WHY.
HE WAS NOT CAUGHT SOONER.
COLLEAGUES.
WITH SP TWELVE EIGHTY SIX TO
YEARS TO GROW AGO IT WAS A GOOD
BILL AND THE SENATOR FROM
BERKELEY HAS MADE IT. A BETTER
BILL.
IT HAS AN INCREDIBLE LIST OF
ENDORSERS SINCE SUPPORTERS AND
IT DESERVES YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
THINKING SENATOR MORLOCK SENATOR
WIENER.
FIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT I RISE IN SUPPORT OF
SB FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE AND I
REALLY JUST WANT TO TIP MY HAT
TO THE SENATOR FROM BERKELEY.
AFTER TAKING AN ISSUE THAT HAS I
STRUGGLED IN THE LEGISLATURE FOR
MANY YEARS AND FINDING A PATH
FORWARD WORKING WITH THE
STAKEHOLDERS I'M COMING UP WITH
WHAT I THINK IS A VERY STRONG
BILL. AYE IT IS FOCUSED ON.
DE TRULY SERIOUS USES OF
PROMOTE ASSUME ALL USES OF FORCE
ARE SERIOUS BUT THE MOST.
SERIOUS USES OF FORCE ODD LIKE
SHOOTING OB TIME.
TO THE HEAD.
USES OF FORCE THAT ARE THE MOST
LIKELY TO CAUSE SERIOUS BODILY
INJURY OR DEATH IN SITUATIONS
WHERE AN OFFICER IS FOUND OUGHT
TO HAVE BEEN AT FAULT. THAT IT
WAS AN INAPPROPRIATE USE OF
FORCE AND IN THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES
THE INVESTIGATORY FILE.
WITH SOME EXCEPTIONS WOULD BE
MADE PUBLIC.
THIS KIND OF TRANSPARENCY IS
VERY IMPORTANT OPTIC EARLY FOR
THESE MOST SERIOUS KINDS OF USE
OF FORCE. ALREADY OFFICERS FOUND
THAT FALL IT IS CRITICALLY
IMPORTANT FOR THE PUBLIC TO KNOW.
WHAT HAPPENS?
AND SO THIS IS A GOOD STEP
FORWARD AND AGAIN I WANT TO
THANK MY COLLEAGUE FROM BERKELEY
FOR HER EXTRAORDINARY WORK.
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER CENTER
ROTH.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I WANT
TO THANK MY COLLEAGUE FOR
PURSUING THIS MATTER OF.
I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT FRANKLY
I HAVE NO OBJECTION TO.
OF THIS DISCLOSURE OF THE
RECORDS. INDICATED UNDER THE
NARROW CIRCUMSTANCES
SCRIBED.
A BUT I DO HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
THE DISCLSURE OF THE SPECIFIC
IDENTITY.
OF THE OFFICER OR OFFICERS
INVOLVED IN OTHER WORDS THEIR
NAMES.
ABSENT SOME.
STAND SHE HATED MISCONDUCT OR
SOME INITIATION OF SOME SORT OF
LEGAL PROCEEDING US CIVIL OR
CRIMINAL WHERE THE NAMES WOULD.
WOULD HAVE TO COME OUT FRANKLY I
DON'T SEE THE PURPOSE.
I'M OBVIOUSLY.
ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH THE
DISCLOSURE OF MISCONDUCT IN ONE
DEPARTMENT TO ANOTHER DEPARTMENT
DURING THE CONDUCT OF A. ROUTINE
PEACE OFFICER BACKROUND
INVESTIGATION I THINK CAN BE
DEALT WITH IN A NUMBER OF.
DIFFERENT WAYS OTHER WAYS OTHER
THAN DISCLOSURE OF THE
INDIVIDUAL NAMES OF THE OFFICERS
INVOLVED.
BUT.
I WILL SAY THIS WITH THE
AUTHORS COMMITMENT.
TO ADDRESS THIS IDENTITY ISSUE
AS THIS.
IS TIED UP RIGHT NOW BUT AS THIS
BILL MOVES FORWARD FROM THIS
HOUSE TO THE ASSEMBLY I WILL BE
SUPPORTING.
OF THE BILL TODAY WITH THAT
AUTHORS COMMITMENT THAT I KNOW I
HAVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU SENATOR ROTH
CENTER NIELSEN.
WE USE ARGUE CENTER STONE SORRY
PLEASE GO RIGHT AHEAD ARCHER YES.
THAT YOU A META PRESIDENT AND I
APPRECIATE THAT THE AUTHOR IS
WORKING WITH.
PUBLIC SAFETY AGENCIES ON.
THEIR CONCERNS.
BUT THE WAY IT IS AMENDED AND
WRITTEN AT THIS POINT I'M STILL
OPPOSED S. B. FOURTEEN TWENTY
ONE.
THE LONG STANDING PROTECTIONS
FOR PC PEACE OFFICER PERSONNEL%
FILES ARE BASED ON. OFFICERS
UNIQUE JOB RESPONSIBILITIES
UNLIKE ANY OTHER PROFESSION
PEACE OFFICER'S DUTIES INCLUDE.
USING PHYSICAL FORCE.
AGAINST OTHERS ENGAGING AND
DAILY CONFRONTATIONS WITH
CRIMINALS.
GENERATE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES
ACCUSED OF MISCONDUCT ARE
ENTITLED TO CLOSED HEARINGS.
AND EMPLOYEES PERSONAL RECORDS
ARE PRESUMED TO BE CONFIDENTIAL
REQUIRE A JUDICIAL WING OF THE
PUBLIC INTEREST.
BEFORE THEY ARE RELEASED.
THIS BILL WOULD PROVIDE
UNWARRANTED NEW EXCEPTIONS TO
THIS PRIVACY DEPRIVING OFFICERS
OF PRIVACY RIGHTS.
ACCORDED TO OTHER PROFESSIONS.
THIS WILL ULTIMATELY ONLY LEAD
TO UNNECESSARY ACCUSATIONS
ATTACKS.
POTENTIALLY ON POLICE OFFICERS
AND A GENERAL DEGRADATION OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT RESPONSE
THE CRIMINAL ACTIVITY FOR THOSE
CONCERNS I RESPECTFULLY. URGE A
NO VOTE IN S. B. FOURTEEN TWENTY
ONE AT THIS TIME.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE.
SENATOR NELSON DID YOU WISH TO
SPEAK ON THIS ISSUE.
SCARES THE DELAY I WAS TRYING TO
GET THE ACTUAL BILL LANGUAGE
MADAM PRESIDENT LEDGE JOHN
SENATE.
I WILL OF ASK FOR A NO VOTE. ON
THIS.
OFFICERS WHO.
PROTECT THE PUBLIC.
A WELL TRAINED.
THEY DO HAVE DISCIPLINARY.
PROCEEDINGS.
MY CONCERN ABOUT BILLS LIKE THIS.
IS.
WE'RE GONNA TRY.
THIS INDIVIDUAL.
IN THE PUBLIC.
BEFORE THEY EVEN GET A CHANCE.
THAT NEW PROCESS.
WITH SUCH DANGERS CAMERAS NOW
AND.
EVERYBODY'S GOT ONE.
AND THEY TAKE PICTURES.
OF A GIVEN INSTANT.
BUT THEY DO NOT.
HAVE ANY IDEA.
NOR DOES.
ANYONE PRESENT THE ENTIRETY OF
THE ACTIVITY. THAT RESULTED IN
THIS MOMENT.
IF YOU WILL ABUSIVE FORCE.
A BLEEDING BODY.
IN A STORE.
WHILE THE OFFICERS SAW THE
INDIVIDUAL COMMIT THAT CRIME AND
THEN RUN OUT.
THE OFFICER PURSUES.
FORCE ENSUES.
THAT'S THAT'S NOT PART OF THE
DEAL.
THAT'S ALL OVER THE EVENING NEWS.
THEN INDEED THAT OFFICER ISN'T
IDENTIFIED.
AND BRANDED.
IT'S KIND OF IRONIC THAT WE'RE
SO CONCERNED NOW ABOUT THE
TOTALITY OF THE HISTORY OF A
OFFICER A LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICER.
BUT FOR.
BONA FIDE CRIMINALS FELONS O. NO
WE DON'T WANT TO CONSIDER
ANYTHING THEY PREVIOUSLY DID.
NO THAT DOESN'T COUNT.
BUT FOR A LAW ENFORCEMENT
PROFESSIONAL.
YES IT DOES.
NOBODY AVIATION WHAT NEUTRAL AND.
SO BE IT.
SOMETIMES THEY JUST GET TIRED OF.
PUTTING UP WITH THE.
PRESSURE THAT COMES UPON THEM
AND.
THEY SUCCUMB.
THAT PRESSURE.
BUT I BELIEVE THAT WE NEED TO
PROTECT ARE LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS TO THE HIGHEST DEGREE
THAT WE CAN. THEY UNIQUELY PUT
THEIR LIVES AT STAKE.
AND IF THEY DO THINGS WRONG.
THEY ARE CAUGHT.
I URGE A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN CENTER
RURAL.
PRESIDENT MEMBERS THANK YOU.
VERY MUCH THIS SEASON SEEMS TO
BE A BILL I.
THINGS TO BE A SEASON WERE
PROTECTING CRIMINALS IN MACON
POLICE WORK MUCH HARDER AND SO.
I WILL BE A NO ON THIS VOTE
BECAUSE THE DUTY OF. I THINK THE
LEGISLATURE'S EARLY PROTECT THE
INNOCENT AS WELL AS.
TO PRACTICABLE LAW ABIDING
CITIZENS AND I WISH WE HAD BILLS
ON THAT. VERSES BILLS THROUGH A
RELEASE MORE CRIMINALS INTO OUR
STREET AND AGAIN. MAKE OUR UP
POLICE OFFICERS WORK MUCH MORE
HARDER AND DIFFICULT THEN THAN
IT IS NOW SELF AGAIN I URGE A NO
VOTE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU HUNTER MORALE. CENTER
BRADFORD.
THANK YOU MADAM PROTEOME I RISE
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF SP FOURTEEN
TWENTY ONE.
AND I'VE LISTENED TO THE
COMMENTS OF THOSE FOLKS BOTH AND
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION.
AND I AM AMAZED AT.
EVERYONE SHOULD WALL LAW
ENFORCEMENT SHOULD BE ENTITLED
TO. DUE PROCESS THEY SHOULD BE
CONSIDERED INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN
GUILTY WELL THAT'S WHAT SHOULD
APPLY TO EVERYBODY.
BUT AGAIN.
IT DOESN'T HAPPEN. ATHLETE
ALWAYS PLAY THIS CAR BUT IF
YOU'RE BLACK AND BROWN IN THIS
COUNTRY IT DOESN'T HAPPEN.
AND THE DEGRADATION OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT IN THIS COUNTRY IS
DUE TO A HUNDRED TO YEARS OF
ABUSE.
BOB ABUSE THAT SHOULD BE EXPOSED
AND IF YOU'RE A BAD ACTOR
WHETHER YOU ARE ELECTED OFFICIAL
WHETHER YOU'RE A TEACHER WITH
YOUR LAWYER WHAT YOU'RE LAW
ENFORCEMENT. IT SHOULD BE
EXPOSED AND THAT'S ALL WE'RE
ASKING FOR IS TO RECOGNIZE.
THOSE BAD ACTORS AND JUST
BECAUSE YOU PUT A.
UNIFORM ON AND PUT A BAD JOHN
DOES NOT MAKE YOU PERFECT
BLESSED IN ONE PERCENT OF ANY
OFFICER IS EVER.
CHARGED WITH ANY CRIME LET ALONE
CONVICTED.
I WISH WE OUGHT TO GET IT RIGHT
THAT OFTEN BUT IT DOESN'T HAPPEN
FOR SOME REASON THERE IS A
DOUBLE STANDARD THERE IS A BLOOM
COLD. THAT DOESN'T EXIST FOR ANY
OTHER PROFESSION OTHER THAN LAW
ENFORCEMENT THIS IS A TOUGH JOB.
MEAN IN PUBLIC SAFETY NOT BE THE
FIRST ONE TO RECOGNIZE THAT.
BUT.
AT SOME POINT OF WE BELIEVE IN
COMMUNITY BASED POLICING IT MUST
START WITH TRUST.
AND THERE IS GREAT DISTRUST
IN THIS STATE AND IN THIS
COUNTRY AS IT RELATES TO LAW
ENFORCEMENT AND NOT UNTIL WE
OPEN OURSELVES UP. COULD REMOVE
THE BLINDERS OF OUR BIASES AND
REALIZE THAT THEY'RE HUMAN
BEINGS AND THEY SHOULD BE HELD
TO THE SAME ACCOUNTABILITY AS
EVERYBODY ELSE.
WILL WE EVER REALLY MAKE OUR
COMMUNITIES FOR SO I STRONGLY
SUPPORT IT OUT TRY VOTE ON.
FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE.
THANK YOU CENTER BRADFORD
SENATOR MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT.
YOU AS A LEGISLATIVE BODY WE
HOLD OURSELVES TO A HIGH
STANDARD A HIGH STANDARD OF
TRANSPARENCY IT'S WHAT'S
APPROPRIATE IT'S WHAT THOSE WHO
ELECT US.
BACK TO BASS.
HOW DO WE DO THAT WE TELEVISE
OUR HEARINGS?
WE QUANTIFY OUR VOTES.
WE FILE CAMPAIGN REPORT WE SPEAK
WITH CONSTITUENTS WE REPRESENT.
AS LAWMAKERS WE STRIVE TO MAKE
SURE THE PUBLIC UNDERSTANDS HOW
WE OPERATE.
AS LAW ENFORCERS WHY SHOULD WE
EXPECT ANYTHING LESS.
IT IS TIME.
AND IT IS IMPORTANT.
AND THAT WE HAVE A MEANINGFUL.
HONEST.
DIRECT PUBLIC POLICY DISCUSSION.
ABOUT THE TRANSPARENCY THAT WE
SHOULD EXPECT.
FROM OUR INSTITUTIONS WHO WE
UNDER THE COLOR OF AUTHORITY.
ARE GIVEN THE POWER TO PROTECT
AND SERVE.
AND PARTICULARLY IN INSTANCES
WHERE. EXPLICIT OR IMPLICIT BIAS
MAY BE ASSUMED OR INFERRED.
WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS.
WHETHER THEY ARE BLACK OR WHITE
DEMOCRAT A REPUBLICAN RICHARD
POOR.
MALE OR FEMALE.
HAVE.
FAILURE PROTECTION.
UNDER THE COLOR MATURITY. AND
THIS BILL SIMPLY TRIES TO MAKE
THAT PROCESS MORE TRANSPARENT.
FOR EVERYONE.
I'M PROUD TO BE A CO AUTHOR AND
WILL BE VOTING IN SUPPORT OF
FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
CENTER GLAZER.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS AT LIKE AT MANY ON THE
FLOOR HAD BEEN VISITED MY OFFICE
BY POLICE SHEETS.
SHARES AND OTHERS THE AND THE
LAW ENFORCEMENT COMMUNITY WHO
EXPRESSED.
A CONCERN ABOUT THIS MEASURE.
ABA WHAT I TOLD THEM THEN AND I
SAY TODAY IS THAT. OUR
GOVERNMENT TRANSPARENCY IS A
PILLAR OF ANY FUNCTIONING
DEMOCRACY.
AND THAT WHEN STATE LAW PREVENTS
DEPARTMENTS FROM RELEASING ANY
INFORMATION ABOUT OFFICERS
EVEN THOSE WHO BEEN FOUND GUILTY
OF SERIOUS. JOB RELATED
DISHONESTY.
PUBLIC TRUST IS ERODED.
AND THE INTEGRITY OF OUR JUSTICE
SYSTEM IS TAINTED.
THE VAST MAJORITY OF OUR LAW
OFFICERS CONDUCT THEMSELVES WITH
THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF INTEGRITY.
BUT WE SHOULDN'T LET OUR JUSTICE
SYSTEM BE DRAGGED DOWN BY A FEW
BAD APPLES.
TRANSPARENCY IS CRITICAL TO
PROTECT CALIFORNIANS
IT'S TIME TO HOLD ALL THOSE
ACCOUNTABLE.
WHO HAVE A HISTORY OF OF PROVEN
MISCONDUCT IN WITHOUT I'M ASKING
FOR A YES VOTE ON THIS GOOD
MEASURE TODAY?
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NNE CENTER SKINNER
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
THANK YOU AYE MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I REALLY APPRECIATE.
THE DISCUSSION SO FAR BY MY
COLLEAGUES
AND THE THE REAL HEARTFELT
EXPRESSIONS.
I.
WE KNOW THAT OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS.
TAKE THEIR LIFE IN THEIR HANDS
EACH AND EVERY DAY WHEN THEY
WALK OUT THAT DOOR. AND NEVER
WAS IT MADE.
SO VISCERAL TO ME BUT WHEN MY
VERY FIRST YEAR IN THE STATE
ASSEMBLY THREE THOUSAND NINE.
WHEN FOR OAKLAND OFFICERS
WERE AMBUSHED.
AMBUSHED AND ALL DIED.
IN PURSUIT
OF A PARTICULAR CRIMINAL.
AND TO SEE. THOSE OFFICERS PORN
FROM THEIR FAMILIES AND TORN
FROM.
THE CITY OF OAKLAND'S FORCE.
IT STILL BREAKS MY HEART EVEN
THINKING ABOUT IT.
WE KNOW TODAY. THAT OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS UP AND
DOWN THE STATE ARE BETTER
TRAINED BETTER EDUCATED THAN
EVER BEFORE.
THERE'S ALSO INTERESTINGLY
ENOUGH A LOWER RATE OF USE OF
FORCE.
AND YET THERE'S A HUGE GULF
BETWEEN. BIG MANY OF OUR
COMMUNITIES VIEW. OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT.
AND WHAT WE NO ISRAEL AROUND THE
BEHAVIOR OF OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICIALS.
AND CERTAINLY WHILE I THINK WE
WELCOME THE FACT THAT THERE IS
BODY CAMERAS IN VIDEO.
IT ALSO WHEN WE SEE THOSE
DEPICTIONS.
AND VERY OFTEN I WILL SEE A
KID HOW COULD THEY POSSIBLY HAVE
USED FORCE BUT I ALSO KNEW HIM
ONLY SEEN. A VERY NARROW WINDOW
IN THOSE VIDEOS.
WHAT THE BENEFIT OF TRANSPARENCY
WHICH THIS BILL DOES?
ALLOWS IS THAT.
WOULDN'T. OCCURS.
LET ME BACK UP WE HAVE MANY IN
THE COMMUNITY WHO FEEL. THAT THE
INVESTIGATIONS FOR EXAMPLE OF
USE OF FORCE ARE SHIA.
THAT NO ONE IS REALLY
INTERVIEWED THAT THERE'S NO REAL.
TRYING TO GET AT WHETHER THAT
USE OF FORCE WAS.
UNDER THE RULES OR LEGITIMATE.
AND WITH THAT DISTRESSED
WE THEN HAVE DISC GULF BETWEEN
OUR COMMUNITIES AND OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT.
AND YET WE KNOW THAT COMMUNITY
TRUST IS ESSENTIAL FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO DO THEIR JOB.
NOW WILL BE ACCESS TO THESE
RECORDS OVERNIGHT BILL DISTRUST
NO. BUT HOPEFULLY IT WILL OVER
TIME.
BUT CERTAINLY KEEPING EVERYTHING
SECRET DOES NOTHING TO BUILD
TRUST.
AND AS MY COLLEAGUE FROM
RIVERSIDE SAID I WILL CONTINUE
TO WORK WITH OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICIALS. TO ADDRESS CONCERNS
THEY HAVE INCLUDING WHETHER WE
SHOULD.
REMOVE THE ACTUAL RELEASE SEVEN
NAME.
THOSE ARE AMENDMENTS THAT I'M
CONSIDERING AS WE MOVE FORWARD.
AND AS I MENTIONED IN MY OPENING
THE AMENDMENTS THAT I'VE TAKEN
SO FAR HAVE ARE CALIFORNIA DA
ASSOCIATION NOW REMOVED THEIR
OPPOSITION THERE NO NEUTRAL ON
THE BILL.
AND I THINK THAT THIS IS A VERY
IMPORTANT STEP FORWARD.
AND WITH THAT. I ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER. MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
BY LADA.
LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL. AYE
MONNING.
BY MORE LOCK.
BY. MORRELL.
NO.
NEWMAN.
I.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER. AYE STERN.
I STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO WIECKOWSKI.
I WINNER.
I WILL.
NO.
EYES TWENTY FOUR KNOWS TEN.
SORRY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THINK YOU.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
FULLER.
NO.
GALGIANI.
LOTTE.
I.
EYES TWENTY FIVE KNOWS ELEVEN
THE MEASURE PASSES OKAY MEMBERS
BEFORE WE MOVE TO OUR REGULAR
SENATE THIRD READING I WOULD
JUST LIKE TO DO A LITTLE
HOUSEKEEPING WE'RE GOING TO
BREAK TODAY FROM TWELVE TO
TWELVE THIRTY FOR LUNCH. SO PUT
THAT IN YOUR QUEUE BUT RIGHT NOW
WE'RE GOING TO START WITH FILE
ITEM FIFTEEN.
WHICH IS SENATOR WILK ARE YOU
PREPARED CENTER WILK.
PASS ON FILE.
FILE ITEM SIXTEEN SENATOR
MCGUIRE PALS ON FILE.
FILE ITEM SEVENTEEN SENATOR
HUESO.
PASS SOME FILE SIZE OF FILE ITEM
EIGHTEEN SENATOR MONNING NOT AT
HIS DESK.
FILE ITEM NINETEEN SENATOR
GLAZER NOT AT HIS DESK
FILE ITEM TWENTY SENATOR
MITCHELL MOTOR HER DESK FILE
ITEM TWENTY ONE SENATOR GALGIANI.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM TWENTY
TWO SENATOR BERRYHILL.
NOT OF HIS DESK FILE ITEM TWENTY
THREE SENATOR BRADFORD.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM TWENTY
FOUR SENATOR LARA.
PASS ON VINYL FILE ITEM TWENTY
FIVE SENATOR CANNELLA.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM TWENTY
SIX SENATOR JACKSON.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM TWENTY
SEVEN SENATOR HERNANDEZ IS READY
TO ROLL.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FIFTY TWO BY
SENATOR HERNANDEZ AND ACT CLING
TO PUBLIC HEALTH THUNDER
HERNANDEZ.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS OUT WERE ALL AWARE OF
THE GROWING HOMELESS CRISIS WE
HAVE HERE IN THIS STATE. THIS
BILL IS TRYING TO TACKLE JUST
ONE ASPECT OF THEIR PROBLEM WHAT
HAPPENS TO HOMELESS PATIENTS
AFTER DISCHARGE FROM THE
HOSPITAL.
I WANT TO BE CLEAR THE HOSPITALS
ARE NOT THE CAUSE OF THE PROBLEM.
AND IN MANY CASES HAVE BEEN
GOING ABOVE AND BEYOND THE HELP
HOMELESS PATIENTS.
BUT THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF
HIGH PROFILE CASES WHERE
PATIENTS HAVE BEEN DISCHARGED IN
AN UNSAFE MANNER.
FEEDBACK FROM HOMELESS SHELTERS
MAKES IT CLEAR THAT WE NEED
BETTER COORDINATION BETWEEN
HOSPITALS AND HOMELESS SERVICE
PROVIDERS.
IN RESPONSE TO CONCERNS FROM THE
HOSPITAL MANY AYE MEN THAT THIS
BILL LAST WEEK TO ADDRESS MOST
OF THE CONCERNS INCLUDING THE
FOLLOWING. MAJOR CONCESSIONS.
I DELETED THE REQUIREMENT THAT
HOSPITAL KEEP PATIENT UNTIL
DAYLIGHT HOURS OR DURING.
INCLEMENT WEATHER HOSPITALS
WOULD NOW BE FREE TO DISCHARGE
AS SOON AS AS CARES WAS
COMPLETED.
SECOND WAS I DELETED THE CHARGES
THE CHANGES TO THE COMMUNITY
BENEFIT LAW. AND I ALSO
CLARIFIED THAT HOSPITALS COULD
REFER PATIENTS WHO NEED
PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT TO COUNTY
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AGENCIES OR
OTHER PROVIDERS. AND WERE NOT
REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE
TREATMENT THEMSELVES.
SOME OBVIOUSLY TRYING TO WORK
WITH THE OPPOSITION BECAUSE I
THINK THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT'S
VERY VERY IMPORTANT WE HAVE TO
DEAL WITH THE MOST VULNERABLE
POPULATIONS.
WITH THESE CHANGES I BELIEVE
WE'RE IN A MUCH BETTER POSITION
WITH A HOSPITAL AND PHYSICIAN
CAMINO THOUGH AS ALWAYS WE WILL
CONTINUE TO GO NEGOTIATE IN GOOD
FAITH.
AND WITH THAT MEASURE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERNANDEZ
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR BATES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
AGREE WITH A GOOD SENATOR ARE
THAT IT IS A VERY IMPORTANT
ISSUE HOWEVER. I IN ITS CURRENT
FORM OF THIS BILL WILL REQUIRE
HOSPITALS IN MANY CASES TO KEEP
A HOMELESS PATIENT. LONGER THAN
THEY MIGHT OTHERWISE SAY AS A
pRESULT HOSPITALS WILL INCUR
COSTS RELATED TO HAVING TO KEEP.
PATIENTS LONGER IN SOME
INSTANCES THE PATIENT WILL HAVE
BEEN ADMITTED TO THE HOSPITAL IN
WILL BE IN A HOSPITAL BED LONGER
THAN MEDICALLY NECESSARY.
DESPITE TO THESE FISCAL
IMPLICATIONS THE BILL WAS TWENTY
EIGHT AIDED OUT OF SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
REPORTING MY OWN FISCAL COST
WITHOUT. ASSESSING THE CARS TO
OUR OF MEDICARE PROGRAM IN
PARTICULAR I URGE THAT THE BILL
BE ADDRESSED. IN THE ASSEMBLY
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE FORCE
COST IMPACT AS WE GO FORWARD IN
THE BUDGET AND I UNDERSTAND
YOU'RE CONTINUING TO WORK. ON
THAT ISSUE BUT UNTIL THE ACTUAL
pCOST OF THE BILL IS ADDRESSED I
WILL NOT BE SUPPORTING IT TODAY
AND ASK FOR A NO VOTE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR BATES CENTER
MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT YOU
DON'T A GREAT JOB THANK YOU.
COLLEAGUES.
I APPLAUD THE INTENT OF.
THE AUTHOR ARE AND WHAT THIS
BILL IS TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FIFTY TWO
HOWEVER PUTS MORE OF THE ONUS ON
THE HOSPITAL'S.
IN ORANGE COUNTY WE HAD A
WONDERFUL NONPROFIT STEP UP AND
BRING IT A FEW APARTMENTS.
ACTUALLY A IN A IN AN APARTMENT
COMPLEX IN PROVIDED A.
PLACE FOR HOSPITALS TO DISCHARGE
MAKE EVEN HAD STAFFING AND IT
WAS A WONDERFUL MODEL.
I SEE.
I SEE THE NEED I SEEN IT IN
PRACTICE.
I BUT I'M JUST NOT SURE THAT THE
HOSPITAL SHOULD HAVE THE ONUS. I
BELIEVE THAT WE SHOULD CHANGE
THE BURDEN TO THAT COUNTIES.
THE COUNTY SHOULD STEP UP AND
PROVIDE ASSISTANCE TO THE
HOSPITAL'S IN ORANGE COUNTY WE
HAVE A HOMELESS COORDINATOR.
BUT THE HOSPITAL SHOULD
COORDINATE WITH THE COUNTY NOT
OTHER HOSPITALS TO SAFETY NET
PROVIDERS I THINK THE BURDEN IS
PLACED IN THE WRONG.
AREA BUT I.
I COMPLETELY AGREE WITH THE
INTENT OF THIS BILL BUT I I
WOULD URGE A REWRITE.
THANK YOU MS BAKER MADAM
PRESIDENT THANK YOU CENTER MORE
LOCKED CENTER NIELSEN.
THE MEASURE PRESENTLY CHEN THE
SENATE.
I WITH THE AGREE WITH MY
COLLEAGUE FROM ORANGE COUNTY HAD
NOBLE INTENT OF THE BILL.
AND.
THERE IS A NEED FOR SURE.
OF A MANAGEMENT PLANNER.
I DON'T KNOW IF YOU CALL IT IS
LIKE AN I EP FOR SCHOOL STUDENTS
AN INDIVIDUAL.
REHABILITATION PLAN MAVEN IRP.
BUT I'M JUST NOT. VERY CONFIDENT.
THAT THE HOSPITALS OF THE PLACE
TO DO IT.
THEY ARE ALREADY BURDENED.
BY MANY MENTALLY DISTURBED
INDIVIDUALS.
SHOWING UP IN THE ER.
IN THE E. ARE THEY DO NOT HAVE.
THE PERSONNEL AND THE RESOURCES
TO DEAL WITH THIS.
I'VE HAD MANY COMPLAINTS AND
EVEN HAVE INTERVENED ON OCCASION
WHERE.
ARE.
PRISON INSTITUTIONS AB DELIVERED.
MENTALLY ILL INMATES.
TO THE ER.
AS THEIR PAROLE PLACEMENT.
NOW THESE E. OURS DO NOT HAVE
THAT CAPABILITY.
BRIGGS APPLE.
AN INDIVIDUAL.
LOU.
HAS NOT TAKEN THE METS.
BECOME AN UNSTABLE.
ACT OUT.
OR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE.
CRAZED WITH METHAMPHETAMINE.
SHOW UP IN THE ER.
THEY ARE DANGERS.
THE PERSONNEL WORKING IN THE ER.
THERE ARE DANGERS.
THE PATIENTS.
THEY'RE IN.
I SUPPORTED A BILL LAST YEAR
THAT HERETOFORE NEVER WOULD
SUPPORT.
ALLOWING E. OUR DOCTORS TO
IMPOSE A FIFTY ONE FIFTY HOLE.
THAT IS AN INDIVIDUAL OF OF
MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE.
THAT WOULD BE HELD IN.
CUSTODY AND TREATMENT.
WE ARE NOT CAPABLE OF DEALING
WITH THAT KIND OF PERSON REALLY.
AND THE OUR DOCTORS I WOULD NOT
THINK OF THE RIGHT INDIVIDUALS
TO IMPOSE FIFTY ONE FIFTY HOLES.
BUT KNOWING THE CIRCUMSTANCES
THAT THEY SUFFER UNDER I VOTED
FOR THE BILL.
KIND OF IN DESPERATION I GUESS.
BECAUSE A THE REALIZATION THE
MAGNITUDE OF THE PROBLEM.
THE HOMELESS POPULATION
INDIVIDUALS.
THEN I HAVE BEEN OUT.
NOT IN THE SHELTERS.
THAT ON THE STREETS.
ON THE RIVERSIDE.
BUT LAW ENFORCEMENT WHO ARE
TRYING TO INTERVENE.
IN NON PUNITIVE WAYS.
AT DIRECT THESE INDIVIDUALS INTO
WHAT TREATMENTS ARE AVAILABLE.
I'M NOT SAYING THAT THEY HAVE
ANY MORE CAPABILITY THAN.
THE PEOPLE IN THE E. R..
BUT AT LEAST IN ONE OF THE
CITIES I REPRESENT.
THAT'S REASONABLY WORKING.
THE BEST IDEA I BELIEVE THAT WE
CAN HAVE. FOR THE HOMELESS
POPULATION.
IT'S SOME AUTHORITY TO BE ABLE
TO.
DIVINE.
I REALLY. XIN AND THE SECURITY.
REGIMENT PROGRAM.
FOR THESE INDIVIDUALS.
BUT IT WOULD ALSO IN SOME MANNER
HAVE TO BE SUPERVISED.
AND IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE.
I JUST DON'T THINK.
THE HOSPITAL WE ARE TO THE RIGHT
PLACE.
I COMMEND THE AUTHOR IF ANYBODY
COULD MAKE THIS WORK.
IT IS A SENATOR.
FROM LOS ANGELES.
THEN I KNOW HE'LL WORK IN GOOD
FAITH AND.
MIGHT COME BACK AND CONCURRENT
SHOULD BE HAPPY TO SUPPORT.
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEN SENATOR
HERNANDEZ WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE. MADAM.
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS.
WE ALL KNOW AND WE HEAR FROM
OUR COMMUNITIES ABOUT THE
INCREASED NUMBER OF HOMELESS
PEOPLE WE HAVE IN OUR STREETS.
WHETHER IT'S SUBSTANCE ABUSE
WHETHER IT'S
MENTAL ILLNESS AND IT'S A
PROBLEM.
BUT IT'S ALSO A PROBLEM WITH
THESE INDIVIDUALS HAVE TO
UTILIZE OUR HEALTHCARE SYSTEM
HOSPITAL IN PARTICULAR.
AND THERE'S MANY INSTANCES THAT
THEY'RE JUST LAUGHED.
WITH OPEN WOUNDS THEY'RE LEFT
WITH THEIR HOSPITAL GOWNS.
IN THESE OF THE MOST VULNERABLE
PEOPLE IN THIS STATE.
AND THAT'S NOT WHO WE ARE AS
HUMAN BEINGS.
SO I MEAN THE ARGUMENT WAS MADE
THAT WE SHOULD HAVE THE COUNTY'S
DEAL WITH IT WELL THIS IS THE
STARTING POINT FOR ME FOR ME IS
I BELIEVE WE HAVE TO LOOK AT IT
FROM A STATES ISSUE. AND THE
HOSPITAL IS A LAST ENTITY THAT'S
GOING TO BE DEALING WITH THESE
PATIENTS AND IT'S A REAL SIMPLE
BARREN SENSE AND I'VE WORKED
WITH A HOSPICE ASSOCIATION.
TO TRY TO REMOVE A LOT OF THEIR
OPPOSITION WHICH WE HAVE BUT
THERE'S STILL SOME OUTSTANDING
ISSUES.
IT'S PRETTY BASIC THAT THE
HOSPITALS HAVE TO FIND A PLACE
TO PLACE THEM.
IN THE COMMUNITY WHETHER IT'S A
COMMUNITY HEALTH SENATOR SAM
WHETHER IT'S A HOME SOME TYPE OF
FACILITY.
AND THEY CAN'T JUST LET LEAVE
THEM WITHOUT SOME BASIC
NECESSITIES LIKE FOOD.
PROPER CLOTHING.
WATER MEDICATIONS JUST SOME VERY
COMMON SENSE STUFF YOU KNOW SO
FOR ME IT'S IT'S ABOUT HOW WE'RE
GOING TO TREAT THE MOST
VULNERABLE AND WITH THAT MEMBERS
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NAY VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERNANDEZ
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BAKES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL. NO. BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
I DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
I HILL. AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LAWLER.
I LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE RIGHT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
HUESO.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NO.
PORTANTINO.
ROUGH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
WILK.
NO.
CENTER HERNANDEZ MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM TWENTY EIGHT SENATOR STERN.
PASSED SOME FILE FILE ITEM
TWENTY NINE SENATOR WIENER.
PLUS TEMPORARILY FILE ITEM
THIRTY SENATOR LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE FIFTY SEVEN BY SENATOR
LADA AND ACT WILLING TO VEHICLES.
SENATOR LARA THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS BETWEEN TWENTY
TEN AND TWENTY FIFTEEN THE
NUMBER OF SUPER COMMUTERS WHO
DRIVE NINETY MINUTES. OR MORE TO
WORK GREW BY MORE THAN FORTY
PERCENT. ZEV EQUITY ACT
ESTABLISHES A PATHWAY FOR
CALIFORNIAN HOUSEHOLDS THAT MAKE
ABOUT. FIFTY AT FIFTY THOUSAND
DOLLARS OR LESS A YEAR TO APPLY
FOR A CLEAN STICKER.
CLEAN CAR STICKER WHEN THE
PURCHASE A USED ZERO EMISSION
VEHICLE EXISTING LAW DOES NOT
ALLOW A SECOND STICKER FOUR ZERO
EMISSION CARS WHICH PREVIOUSLY.
RECEIVED ONE WHICH BASICALLY
ELIMINATES A USED WAS THAT
OPTION.
AND IF YOU ARE AND IF YOU CAN
GET ONLY AND IF COUNTY GET THIS
INCENTIVE WOULD NEW NEW CARS.
HOW CAN THEN LOW INCOME?
CALIFORNIANS HAVE ACCESS TO
THESE CLEAN VEHICLES WE WORKED
WITH THE SENATE TRANSPORTATION
COMMITTEE WANT TO THANK SENATOR
ABOUT FOR HIS WORK. I MEASURE TO
AYE THAT TWENTY TWENTY THREE
SUNSET TO ALLOW US TO ASSESS.
THE IMPACT OF THIS PROGRAM ON
THE ADOPTION OF ZERO EMISSION
VEHICLES AND ON THE IMPACT TO
OUR HOV LANES ARE DIRECTLY AFTER
I VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEE.
SENATOR ANDERSON.
MEMBERS I I I THINK THE AUTHOR
MADE SOME EXCELLENT POINTS I I
DO THINK THAT THAT'S ONE THE
FLAWS IN THE SYSTEM THAT. THAT
TO A PEOPLE WHO ARE.
HAVING TO PURCHASE SOME
SECONDARY MARKET ARE NOT MISSING
OUT ON THAT OPPORTUNITY.
HOWEVER IF YOU'RE A MEMBER LIKE
I HAVE I HAVE NEVER SUPPORTED
SPECIAL PRIVILEGES TO THOSE. WHO
DON'T PAY ANY?
GAS TAX
SO THAT REASON I WILL BE
OPPOSING THIS BUT THE ARGUMENT
IN FAVOR CERTAINLY MAKES SENSE
IF YOU THINK.
THAT IF YOU HAVE AN ELECTRIC CAR
YOU DESERVE SPECIAL TREATMENT.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE.
SENATOR LARA JUDGE CLOSE.
THANK YOU MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR A VOTE THANK YOU MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
I.
BILL.
I. BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. AYE DELEON.
I DODD.
I FULLER.
NO.
GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONNING.
MORE LUCK.
NO MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
I.
BY DAK.
I WIECKOWSKI.
WIENER.
I WILK. AYE.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM THIRTY
TWO SENATOR GLAZER
.
MEMBERS WE GO WITH THE CALL ON
FILE ITEM THIRTY THAT WAS OF AND
WE JUST DID.
MISTER SECRETARY WHEN YOU'RE
READY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
HERNANDEZ.
I MITCHELL.
MONNING.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
WHY COUNTY?
EYES TWENTY NINE KNOWS FIVE THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM THIRTY ONE SORRY FILE ITEM
THIRTY TWO SENATOR GLAZER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TWELVE TWENTY FIVE A
SENATOR GLAZER AND ACT ON
EDUCATION FINANCE AND CLINGER
THROUGH UP TO TAKE EFFECT
IMMEDIATELY. CENTER GLAZER THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I
KNOW A NUMBER OF US SIR WEARING
THESE KEYS THAT TODAY IN HONOR
OF OUR CALIFORNIA STATE
UNIVERSITY IS THE KEY TO
CALIFORNIA'S FUTURE IT'S
APPROPRIATE ON A DAY LIKE TODAY
THAT.
I PRESENT THIS BILL TO YOU WHICH
WOULD AUTHORIZE.
FOUR BILLION DOLLARS FOR
FACILITIES FOR THE CALIFORNIA
STATE UNIVERSITY AND THE
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. THIS
BILL MOVED OUT OF BOTH OF OUR
POLICY COMMITTEES WITH
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
AND IF APPROVED BY THE GOVERNOR
OF COURSE THE SENATE IN THE
ASSEMBLY IT BE REPLACED BEFORE
VOTERS IN THE TWO THOUSAND
EIGHTEEN GENERAL ELECTION.
AFTER TWO LONG WE ALLOWED OUR
CLASSROOMS ARE LIBRARIES ARE
RESEARCH LABS IN OUR CAMPUSES TO
FALL INTO DISREPAIR. THIS BOND
WILL PROVIDE A MUCH NEEDED
INVESTMENT IN OUR HIGHER
EDUCATION INFRASTRUCTURE.
WE HAVEN'T PASSED THAT SPECIFIC
HIGHER EDUCATION BOND FOR MANY
MANY YEARS.
ACCORDING TO BOTH SYSTEMS THEY
HAVE CAPITAL NEEDS A EXCEEDING
SIXTEEN BILLION DOLLARS.
THEY CAN PROVIDE SOME OF THAT
HELP THROUGH OUR. SYSTEM WIDE
REVENUE BONDS BUT THE REST OF IT
HAS TO COME FROM EITHER THE THAT
TUITION ON OUR STUDENTS AND
THEIR FAMILIES ARE FROM THE.
GENERAL FUND THREW UP ON
PAVEMENTS WHICH IS BEING
PROPOSED IN THIS BILL.
THIS MEASURE PROVIDES IMPORTANT
FINANCIAL BACK BACKING FOR THESE
CRITICAL UPGRADES. TO OUR
COLLEGES I THINK THE VOTERS
SHOULD BE GIVEN A CHANCE.
BUT TO CONTINUE THE PROUD LEGACY
OF SUPPORTING OUR UNIVERSITIES
AND COLLEGES AND I WOULD ASK
YOUR AYE THOUGH TODAY.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
NIELSEN.
MADAM PRESIDENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN OF THE SENATE.
FOR OUR.
INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
IT IS TIME.
MY. GOOD COLLEAGUE FROM ORINDA
HAS NOTED JUST BEEN A LONG TIME
SINCE WE HAD A HIGHER AT BOND.
AND A HISTORY.
QUITE OFTEN WE DID HAVE THESE
BONDS.
THEY'VE BECOME MORE PROBLEMATIC
IS ARE BOND INDEBTEDNESS IS
INCREASED AND THE KIND OF THINGS
THAT WE. LET BONDS FOR AS.
MAGNIFIED.
BUT I'LL ARGUE THAT THIS ONE IS
WORTHY AND IS IMPORTANT.
I'VE REPRESENTED.
EITHER OF THE PHYSICAL CAMPUS
OVER THE SERVICE CAMPUS OF.
CHICO STATE.
THE NUMBER STATE.
SACRAMENTO STATE.
THEN I WANT TO FRESNO STATE.
I'M VERY FAMILIAR.
WITH ALL OF THOSE CAMPUSES.
MOST OF THEM.
HAVE VERY OLD.
BUILDINGS.
THERE HAVEN'T BEEN MANY NEW
BUILDINGS.
I REMEMBER.
WORKING TO GET MONEY IN THE
BUDGET FOR WHAT BECAME MEYER
HALL UC DAVIS.
ANOTHER INSTITUTION THAT I'VE
REPRESENTED.
AND I WAS TOLD BY THE CHANCELLOR.
THAT OUR DINNER ONE NIGHT THAT
THAT WOULD BEEN THE FIRST
CAPITAL OUTLAY.
FOR UC'S. IN TEN YEARS.
NOW THAT'S A WHILE BACK.
BUT MUCH CAN BE SAID.
THE SAME SITUATION.
AN EVEN GREATER MAGNITUDE TODAY.
THESE UNIVERSITIES LADIES AND
GENTLEMAN.
DO NEED SOME HELP.
FOR THE CAPITAL OUTLAY NEEDS.
THIS WILL PROVIDE IT.
I URGE THAT I VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN.
THIRD HERTZBERG.
THANK YOU.
MADAM PRESIDENT.
YOU KNOW WE WE FACE THESE ISSUES
AS TO WHETHER OR NOT.
APPROPRIATE TO ASK THE VOTERS TO
BORROW.
SOMETIME SO WE'VE DONE UNDER
CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE THE STATE
HAS BEEN.
TOO HEAVILY IN DEBT.
AND AS WE ANALYZE THE MANAGEMENT
OF THE STATE THE FISCAL
RESPONSIBILITY THE STATE THAT
RATIO OF DEBT IS QUITE IMPORTANT.
AND WHERE THE MONEY GOES IS
QUITE IMPORTANT.
AND THE REALITY IS THAT IF YOU
LOOK AT THE PAYMENT PAY DOWN OF
THE TRIPLE FLIP BONDS THE%
FIFTEEN BILLION DOLLAR. BONDS
THAT WE PAY DOWN AFTER A
SCHWARZENEGGER PUT THOSE IN.
IF YOU LOOK AT THE PAY DOWN OF
THE DEBT THE WALL OF DEBT THE
GOVERNOR BROWN TALKS ABOUT THAT
MOST OF WHICH WAS THE MAIDENS
FACTOR UNDER PROP NINETY EIGHT.
THAT WORD PRETTY GOOD SHAPE.
THE QUESTION WE ASK THEN THIS IF
WE ARE GROWING. WHAT DO WE
BORROW FOR AND HOW MUCH SHOULD
WE BORROW?
THERE IS NOTHING MORE IMPORTANT
IN MY JUDGMENT THAN HIGHER
EDUCATION AS IT RELATES TO THE
ECONOMIC BACKBONE OF CALIFORNIA.
WE AT IN FACT IF HAD SIGNIFICANT
INVESTMENTS IN THE UNIVERSITIES
IN NINETY EIGHT WE GET ABOUT A.
EIGHT NINE BILLION DOLLAR BOND
BY SENATOR CARD AT SP FIFTY IN
TWO THOUSAND AND TWO THOUSAND
AND TWO WE DO THE TWENTY FIVE
POINT NINE BILLION DOLLARS IN
BONDS.
BUT THOSE BONDS TRANSCENDED FROM
K. THROUGH TWELVE COMMUNITY
COLLEGES STATE UNIVERSITIES AND
THE UC SYSTEMS OF COURSE
HASTINGS WHERE I GRADUATED FROM
THAT'S INCLUDED IN THIS BOND.
BUT IF YOU LOOK AT WHAT THIS
BANDAS OF THE FOUR BILLION
DOLLARS SO WE HAVE INVESTED WE
HAVE BUILT A TREMENDOUS NUMBER
OF BUILDINGS THROUGHOUT THE
SYSTEM. BUT THE VOTERS PASSED A
BOND JUST RECENTLY FOUR K.
THROUGH TWELVE AND IT WAS THE
HIGHER EDUCATION WAS INCLUDED.
BECAUSE OF THE ARCHITECTURE AND
STRUCTURE OF HOW THE FINANCING
WORKED AND WHY IT WAS SO
IMPORTANT FOR DEVELOPERS WITH
RESPECT TO DEVELOPMENT FEES.
TO HIGHER ED WAS LEFT OUT.
SO THE QUESTION HERE IS SHOULD
WE DO IT.
THE ANSWER BUT IT SHOULD BE
DOING A BECAUSE THE STATE CAN
AFFORD IT AND YOU WANT TO INVEST
SOMETIMES EACH OF US WHEN YOU
BUY A HOUSE TO PUT A MORTGAGE ON
YOUR HOUSE. TO INVEST FOR THE
FUTURE THAT THE ANSWER THAT
QUESTION IS A RESOUNDING YES IS
THE INVESTMENT A WISE INVESTMENT
THE ANSWER TO THAT QUESTION IS A
RESOUNDING YES. THERE'S NOTHING
MORE IMPORTANT IN HIGHER
EDUCATION IN TERMS OF MOVING
PEOPLE INTO THE MIDDLE CLASS
MOVING PEOPLE UP. IN THE SYSTEM
IT IS EXPENSIVE THE WORLD HAS
CHANGED HOW WE HOW THESE SYSTEMS
WORK WHAT THEY COST TO OPERATE
UNIVERSITIES IT IS AN
INTELLIGENT AND THOUGHTFUL
INVESTMENT. AND I STAND HERE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
SOONER MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT IDEA.
JUST WANTED.
AB COUNTERPOINT.
YOU KNOW THAT.
ITS GETS A NICE THAT WE CAN
BORROW MONEY TO.
IMPROVE OUR SCHOOLS ARE COLLEGES.
BETTY COMES WITH A COST WE HAVE
TO PAY THOSE BONDS BACK.
SO WE'RE LOOKING AT A BOND ON
THE JUNE BALLOT TO ENABLE ISSUE
FOUR BILLION IN DEBT BUT WILL
PROBABLY COST. EIGHT BILLION.
AT THE END OF THE DAY WHICH WE
PAID OVER FORTY YEARS WHICH IS
PAID BY OUR KIDS. AND OUR
GRANDKIDS. BUT I'M JUST SAYING.
FROM FISCAL PERSPECTIVE WE NEED
TO. TAKE A HARD LOOK.
AND THE AMOUNT OF BALLOT
MEASURES WE ARE. GIVING TO OUR
VOTERS BECAUSE I DON'T THINK
THEY APPRECIATE WHAT HAPPENS TO
OUR BALANCE SHEET.
AND OUR GOVERNOR DOES HE.
HE HASNOT BEEN DISTRIBUTING A
REASSURING.
BONDS FOR THE SCHOOL BOND THAT
WE HAVE WAS APPROVED IN NOVEMBER
OF TWENTY SIXTEEN TO LOOK AT THE
BUDGET HE'S BEEN PARSING IT OUT.
VERY SLOWLY Y. BECAUSE HE'S
CONCERNED ABOUT PAYING IT BACK.
IT'S PAID OUT OF THE GENERAL
FUND NOT OUT OF PROP NINETY
EIGHT POUNDS AND HE SHOULD BE
CONCERNED.
ESPECIALLY WITH ALL THE THINGS
COMING UP ON THE HORIZON THAT WE
ARE.
FULLY AWARE OF PENSION PLAN
COUNTRIES IS GOING UP. THE
RETIREE MEDICAL LIABILITY OF
NINETY ONE AND A HALF BILLION
DOLLARS WILL BE PUT ON THE
BALANCHINE AS OF THE END OF NEXT
MONTHIT WILL SHOW UP IN YOUR
CAP FOR YOUR COMPREHENSIVE.
ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT COME
MARJORIE PEARL NEXT YEAR WE HAVE
THE MINIMUM WAGE GOING UP
WHICH'LL IMPACT. AYE HHS AYE IN
HOME SUPPORT JIMMY AYE AYE H. S.
AS IN HOME SUPPORT SERVICES.
.
WAGES THAT WE HAVE A LOT COMING
UP ON THE HORIZON SO WE NEED TO
BE CONCERNED ABOUT THAT. WE HAVE
THE JUNE BALLOT MEASURE WORK
WERE ALREADY LOOKING AT ANOTHER
BALLOT MEASURE IN NOVEMBER WITH
THAT WITH THAT A BOND OF FOUR
BILLION.
SO WITH THAT COLLEAGUES JUST ONE
REMIND YOU THAT OF ALL FIFTY
STATES.
CALIFORNIA HAS THE LARGEST
UNRESTRICTED NET DEFICIT.
THE LARGEST UNRESTRICTED NET
DEFICIT IN THE NATION WERE NEVER
FIFTY.
NOW IF WE TAKE A PER CAPITA WE
MOVE UP THE.
TO THE FORTY SECOND PLACE BUT
IT'S NOT BECAUSE WERE DOING
BETTER IT'S BECAUSE STATES LIKE
HAWAII. AND RHODE ISLANDER
POPPING UP BECAUSE OF THEIR
PENSION LIABILITIES AND WE'RE
MOVING UP BY SITTING STILL. SO
WITH THAT COLLEAGUES WE ALSO
LOOK AT THE CREDIT RATINGS.
OF OF THE STATE'S IN YOUR STAFF
REPORTS WERE IN THE BOTTOM THREE
STATES.
SO I AM JUST WANNA JUST.
REITERATE THAT WE'VE GOT TO BE
CAREFUL FOR THOSE THAT FOLLOW.
ABOUT ADDING THAT TO OUR BALANCE
SHEET AND I OPPOSE I POSES
MEASURE AND URGENT NO VOTE ON S.
B. ONE TWO TWO FIVE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT THANK YOU CENTER
MORLOCK CENTER FULLER.
WELL MOST OF YOU KNOW I DON'T
SPEND MONEY VERY OFTEN.
BUT THIS ACTUALLY WILL CREATE
WEALTH. FOR OUR CALIFORNIANS OF
THE NEXT GENERATION BRING
REVENUE TO S..
I AM AN EXAMPLE OF SOMEONE WHO
WOULDN'T BE HERE. WITHOUT HAVING
ATTENDED PUBLIC UNIVERSITY.
BOTH THE COMMUNITY COLLEGE THE
CSU AND EVENTUALLY THE UC.
I KNOW THAT YOU CAN USE
EDUCATION TO CLIMB OUT OF
POVERTY.
AND I THINK THAT IT'S THE THING
THAT WE ALL CAN DO.
AT LEAST GIVE PARENTS A CHOICE.
ON THE BALLOT.
AND YES IT COSTS MONEY BUT THIS
IS BASIC SERVICE.
AND ONLY THE STATE CAN PROVIDE.
AND SO THEREFORE I'LL BE
SUPPORTING IT TODAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR FULLER
THUNDERSTONE.
THEY COMMITTED PRESIDENT DID YOU
KNOW.
YOU THAT A WE NEED THESE
FACILITIES I HAVE.
EXTENSIONS OF YOU SEE ARE AND.
CAL STATE SAN BERNARDINO IN THE
COACHELLA VALLEY AND.
YES THEY CERTAINLY COULD USE
THIS MONEY FOR THE EXPANSION WE
CERTAINLY WANT TO PROVIDE A
WORLD CLASS EDUCATION.
FOR ARE KIDS TO LIKE THE AUTHOR
SAID TO.
PROPEL THEM FROM POVERTY TO THE
MIDDLE CLASS SIR.
OR HIGHER.
BUT I WANT TO CONCUR WITH MY
GREAT.
COLLEAGUE FROM ORANGE COUNTY.
AND TALK ABOUT OUR BONDED
INDEBTEDNESS AND TALK ABOUT OUR.
PENSION INDEBTEDNESS THAT.
COLLECTIVELY APPROACHES A
TRILLION DOLLARS.
FOR THE ENTIRE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
AND.
WE'RE IN THE PROCESS NOW WE HAVE
A STATUTORY DEADLINE OF JUNE THE
FIFTEENTH PASS A BUDGET.
WE HAVE THE HIGHEST BUDGET.
THE STATE CALIFORNIA HAS EVER
SEEN.
WE HAVE NINE BILLION DOLLARS
MORE THAN WE ANTICIPATED WE'RE
GOING TO BE COMING INTO OUR
COFFERS.
AND ONE THING THAT WE ALL
UNDERSTAND TWO THINGS.
IN THE LEGISLATURE.
THAT.
YOU THE DEMOCRATS CONTROL THE
SPENDING AND THE BUDGET.
AND THE BUDGET IS NOTHING MORE
THAN SETTING PRIORITIES FOR THIS
STATE.
SO IF YOU AGREE.
WITH ME THE HIGHER EDUCATION IS
A TOP PRIORITY IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AMONGST OTHER THINGS.
WHAT WE SHOULD DO IS USE OUR
BUDGET SURPLUS?
AND SAVE THE FOUR HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR THAT'S
GOING TO DEBT SERVICE AND LET'S
TAKE THAT FOUR HUNDRED MILLION
AN EQUALLY DIVIDED BETWEEN THE
UC'S THE CAL STATES. IN
PERPETUITY WHILE THE REVENUE IS
COMING INTO THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THAT OTHERWISE WOULD
BE SPENT ON.
DEBT SERVICE FOR THE NEXT FORTY
YEARS I KNOW OUR OUR OUR
UNIVERSITIES COULD USE IT USE
THAT FUNDS THOSE FUNDS FOR NOT
ONLY FOR BUILDING BUT ENHANCING.
CLASSES.
EXPANDING CLASSES WE HAVE A
HIGHER DEMAND FOR A MOMENT THAT
WE HAVE THE CAPACITY TO PROVIDE
THIS COULD GO TO AND ENHANCING
THAT CAPACITY. BUT LET'S NOT ADD
TO OUR STATE INDEBTEDNESS THAT
IS GOING TO MAKE OUR. OUR
RATINGS ON WALLSTREET EVEN LOWER
WHICH COST THE CALIFORNIA EVEN
MORE IN INTEREST RATES BECAUSE
THEY CONSIDER US THE HIGHER RISK
THAN MOST OTHER STATES IN THE
UNION. SO.
I SUPPORT THE EXPANSION OF.
OF THE FACILITIES I JUST
DISAGREE WITH THE WAY THEY WERE
GOING TO PAY FOR THEM WE SHOULD
BE USING SOME OF OUR BUDGET.
PROCEEDS.
OUR ENHANCEMENTS OF REVENUE
EXCEEDING OUR EXPECTATIONS AND
PAY CASH.
BUT THESE
FACILITIES AND NOT A DEAD ARE
CHILDREN AGAINST GRANDCHILDREN.
FOR FORTY YEARS INTO THE FUTURE
WE HAVE TO START LOWERING OUR.
OUR OUR OVERALL DEBT IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA BECAUSE ONE
DAY. WHEN OUR ECONOMY IS NOT AS
ROSY TO REFINING IT NOW THOSE
DEBTS STILL LIVE ON THEY DON'T
GO AWAY. AND WE'RE GOING TO BE
BACK HERE CUTTING THAT.
VERY IMPORTANT SERVICES TO
EDUCATION TO SOCIAL PROGRAMS
THAT MANY OF YOU TAKE GREAT
PRIDE IN. INCLUDING MYSELF.
SO LET'S PAY CASH LET'S NOT
BORROW.
VERSION OF WHAT IT IS BE TWELVE
TWENTY FIVE. THANK YOU CENTER
STONE CENTER GLAZER WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR
THE THOUGHTFUL CONVERSATION.
I THIS MORNING THANK YOU TO THE
SENATOR FROM BAKERSFIELD SENATOR
FROM TAMAR.
BUT THE SENATE OF THE SAN
FERNANDO VALLEY FOR YOUR ALL
YOUR THOUGHTFUL COMMENTS IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL AND I THINK.
I'M I'M REALLY PLEASED THAT IT
HAS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. I'VE THE
MEASURE THAT'S BEFORE YOU TODAY
CERTAINLY THANK YOU TO MY JOINT
AUTHORED FROM SANTA MONICA.
THE GOOD SENATOR CHAIR OF OUR
EDUCATION COMMITTEE FOR JOIN
WITH ME ON ON THIS BILL. BUT TO
SPEAK THE SPECIFICALLY TO SOME
OF THE COMMENTS HAVE BEEN MADE
BY THE SENATOR FROM TO MACULA
ORANGE COUNTY I WOULD SAY THAT'S.
I SHARE YOUR CONCERN ABOUT OUR
OUR.
.
OUR LONG TERM OBLIGATIONS I
THINK YOU'VE HEARD ME SPEAK ON
THIS ISSUE AND COMMITTEE ON THE
FLOOR ON MANY OCCASIONS.
BUT HEAR OUR CHOICES WE CAN
HAVE OUR OUR STUDENTS AND THEIR
FAMILIES THROUGH HIGHER TUITION
PAY THE COSTS OF THEIR LIBRARIES
IN CLASSROOMS.
OR WE CAN DO WHAT HAS CREATED
OUR GREAT SYSTEM OF OF. OF THE
HIGHER EDUCATION WHICH IS TO
HAVE ALL OF US SHARE IN THAT.
THAT IMPORTANT INVESTMENT ARE
OURS ARE CALIFORNIA STATE
UNIVERSITIES IN OUR UNIVERSE YOU
CALIFORNIA ALL THOSE CAMPUSES
WERE BUILT. OVER DECADES BY OUR
PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS WHO
KNEW WAS IMPORTANT TO INVEST.
THIS BOND IS GOING TO CREATE
CLASSROOMS AND LIBRARIES THEY'RE
GONNA LAST FOR THIRTY FORTY
FIFTY YEARS.
AND I THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE WE
TALK ABOUT THAT AND WHO PAYS IT
AND YES. OUR CHILDREN GONNA HAVE
THAT OBLIGATION AS WELL.
BUT IT'S GOING TO BE SOMETHING
THAT THEY'RE GOING TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF IS NOT SOMETHING
THAT WE'RE GONNA USE UP AND SPIT
OUT ANY YEAR TO.
IT'S GOING TO BE THE FACILITIES
AS GOING TO ALLOW US TO GRADUATE
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
GRADUATES.
TO BUILD OUR BUSINESSES TO FUEL
OUR ECONOMY IN CALIFORNIA TO PAY
TAXES.
AND I THINK IT'S A WORTHY
INVESTMENT THAT OUR GRANDPARENTS
MADE OUR PARENTS MADE AND WE
SHOULD MAKE FOR THE BENEFIT OF
OUR KIDS AND WITH THAT MEMBERS.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK
YOU SENATOR GLAZER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
I DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ. AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
ISLETA.
LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORLOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
BY PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO.
BIDAK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I'VE WINNER.
BUT I WILK AYE.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
HUESO.
LADA.
I.
WITH SO I.
MITCHELL.
NEWMAN.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
EYES THIRTY TWO KNOWS FIVE ON
THE URGENCY AYE AYES THIRTY TWO
KNOWS FIVE THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE ARE NOW GOING TO
BREAK FOR LUNCH.
WE WILL BE COMING BACK AND
GAMBLING DOWN AT PROMPTLY TWELVE
THIRTY SO GET SOMETHING TO EAT
AND BE READY TO GO AT TWELVE
THIRTY
MEMBERS THE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS
HAS ENDED AND WE ARE READY TO
GET STARTED. WE HAVE SO FAR
TAKEN UP FOURTEEN BILLS TODAY SO
WE HAVE A LOT OF WORK BEFORE US
I HOPE YOU ALL HAVE SOME LUNCH.
INNER FEELING FORTIFIED AND
READY TO GO SENATOR WIENER IF
YOU ARE NEARBY WE WOULD LIKE TO
GO TO FILE ITEM TWENTY NINE.
SENATOR WIENER FILE ITEM TWENTY
NINE THAT MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL EIGHT
TWENTY TWO BY SENATOR WINNER AND
ACT INTO COMMUNICATIONS.
SENATOR WIENER.
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT OUR COLLEAGUES SP
EIGHT TWENTY TWO COMPREHENSIVELY
PRETAX.
NET NEUTRALITY IN CALIFORNIA.
IT ENSURES THAT OPEN INTERNET
PER INDIVIDUALS FOR BUSINESSES
NONPROFITS.
ADVOCATES AND ANYONE ELSE WHO
RELIES ON THE INTERNET.
S. B. EIGHT TWENTY TWO INSURERS.
THAT WE GET TO THE SIDE WHERE WE
GO ON THE INTERNET. AND WHAT
SERVICES WE USE.
AS OPPOSED TO INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS MAKING THAT DECISION
FOR US.
OR MANIPULATING US INTO DOING
WHAT THEY WANT US TO DO.
S. B. EIGHT TWENTY TWO PROHIBITS
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS.
FROM BLOCKING OR THROTTLING
WEBSITES.
IT PROHIBITS THEM FROM CREATING
FAST LANES AND SLOW LANES
DEPENDING ON WHO PAYS FOR
GREATER SPEEDS IN OTHER WORDS NO
PAID PRIORITIZATION. BOTH WERE
CONTENT IS DELIVERED TO
CONSUMERS.
AND AT THE POINT OF
INTERCONNECTION.
AND IT PROHIBITS ISPS FROM
ENGAGING IN ANTI COMPETITIVE.
MONOPOLISTIC. NOT MONOPOLISTIC
PRACTICES BUT STIFLE INNOVATION
UNDERMINE SMALLER BUSINESSES.
AND HARM CONSUMERS BY RAISING
PRICES IN REDUCING CHOICE.
WHICH THREATENS THE INTERNET
STATUS AS AN OPEN FORUM FOR OUR
DEMOCRACY.
AND CONTRARY TO THE CLAIMS OF
SOME OF THE BILL'S OPPONENTS.
I'D VIS NET NEUTRALITY
VIOLATIONS ABSOLUTELY HAVE
HAPPENS.
THERE IS A LONG DOCUMENTED
HISTORY OF OF NET NEUTRALITY
VIOLATIONS IN THIS COUNTRY.
AND ELSEWHERE INCLUDING AN ISP
UP BLOCKING THE ORGANIZING
WEBSITE OF ITS WORKERS WHO WERE
TRYING TO ORGANIZE A LABOR UNION.
OF COURSE WE ALL AGREE THAT
IDEALLY NOW NEUTRALITY WOULD BE
GOVERNED BY ONE UNIFORM AND
ROBUST NATIONAL PROTECTIVE
STANDARD.
SADLY HOWEVER AFTER DECADES OF
INVOLVING FCC NET NEUTRALITY
RULES.
CULMINATING IN PRESIDENT OBAMA'S
FCC'S TWENTY FIFTEEN NET
NEUTRALITY ORDER.
A COALITION OF TELECOM AND CABLE
COMPANIES PERSUADED OUR NEW
PRESIDENT. DONALD TRUMP TO
ELIMINATE NOT JUST THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN OBAMA NET NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS BUT ESSENTIALLY ALL
FEDERAL NET NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS.
AS A RESULT OF THE TELECOM AND
CABLE COMPANIES ADVOCACY.
AND THE RESULTING DECISION BY
TRUMP'S FCC.
THERE WILL ESSENTIALLY BE NO
FEDERAL NET NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS. AS OF JUNE ELEVENTH
SO IT'S A COUPLE OF WEEKS FROM
NOW.
OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS MY
STAFF AND I HAVE WORKED
EXHAUSTIVELY WITH ACADEMICS.
WITH BUSINESS LEADERS AB SEE
CITY COMMISSIONERS. LABOR UNIONS
AND ADVOCATES TO CRAFT A BILL
THAT PROTECTS AN OPEN INTERNET.
AS A RESULT OF THIS WORK ON THIS
BILL SP EIGHT TWENTY TWO.
WE BELIEVE WILL WITHSTAND LEGAL
CHALLENGE.
AND WILL PROTECT AN OPEN
INTERNET IN CALIFORNIA.
S. B. TWENTY TWO IS SUPPORTED BY
A BROAD COALITION REFLECTING THE
REALITY THE CALIFORNIANS OF BOTH
PARTIES OVERWHELMINGLY SUPPORT
NET NEUTRALITY.
ONE OF OUR STRONGEST SUPPORTERS
FOR THIS BILL IS NOT OTHER THAN
TOM WHEELER PRESIDENT OBAMA'S
FCC CHAIRMAN AND THE AUTHOR OF
PRESIDENT OBAMA'S TWENTY FIFTEEN
NET NEUTRALITY RULES.
S. B. TWENTY TWO IS ALSO
SUPPORTED BY OUR ATTORNEY
GENERAL HAVEA BUT SARAH. BY THE
MAYORS OF LOS ANGELES SACRAMENTO
SAN FRANCISCO OAKLAND SAN JOSE
AND ELSEWHERE.
A LONG LIST OF BUSINESSES HAVE
ENDORSED THE BILL.
BUSINESSES THAT HAVE YOU HAVE
BEEN VICTIMIZED BY NET
NEUTRALITY VIOLATIONS OR ARE AT
RISK OF BEING VICTIMIZED.
THE BILL IS SUPPORTED BY A BROAD
LABOR COALITION INCLUDING THE
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION. STI
YOU TEAMSTERS UFCW UNITED HERE
UNITED AUTO WORKERS AND THE
WRITERS GUILD OF AMERICA.
AND A HUGE LIST OF ADVOCACY
ORGANIZATIONS THAT PROTECT
CONSUMERS. INCLUDING THE ACLU
THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
POVERTY.
THE LOS ANGELES DEMOCRATIC PARTY
THE CALIFORNIA CONSUMER
FEDERATION AND MANY OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS.
I COLLEAGUES TODAY WE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO STAND UP. FOR AN
OPEN INTERNET AND FOR THE TENS
OF MILLIONS OF CALIFORNIANS WHO
RELY ON THE INTERNET FOR AN
INCREASING ARRAY OF CRITICAL
NEEDS.
FOR THE BUSINESSES WHETHER LARGE
COMPANIES OR START UPS WERE
BROKEN MORTARS SMALL BUSINESSES
THAT CANNOT FUNCTION WITHOUT
FAIR INTERNET ACCESS.
PRETTY ADVOCATES WHO HOLD US
ACCOUNTABLE EMPLACEMENTS IN A
CENTRAL ROLE IN OUR DEMOCRACY.
FOR THE LABOR UNIONS WHO WORK TO
MAKE LIFE BETTER FOR WORKING
PEOPLE.
FOR THE SERVICE PROVIDERS WHO
CARE FOR OUR MOST VULNERABLE
RESIDENTS.
AND FOR HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS
WHO INCREASINGLY RELY ON THE
INTERNET TO DELIVER CARE.
OUR ECONOMY OUR DEMOCRACY AND
OUR DAILY LIVES DEPENDS ON THE
INTERNET.
THIS ISN'T ABOUT ATTACKING
TELECOM AND CABLE COMPANIES.
LIKE MANY OF YOU I WORK WITH
THEM ON A REGULAR BASIS THEY ARE
KEY. PLAYERS IN OUR ECONOMY.
BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT WE
SHOULD JUST HAVE THE HONOR
SYSTEM. WHEN IT COMES TO
KNOWLEDGE RALLY THAT WE SHOULD
JUST TAKE THEIR WORD FOR IT.
THAT THEY'RE NOT GOING TO ENGAGE
IN THESE PRACTICES.
WE KNOW THAT NET NEUTRALITY
VIOLATIONS HAPPEN.
AND WE KNOW THAT AFTER FEDERAL
NET NEUTRALITY PROTECTIONS
EXPIRE ON JUNE ELEVENTH. THERE'S
ESSENTIALLY NOTHING.
TO STOP INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS FROM ENGAGING IN ANTI
COMPETITIVE ANTI CONSUMER ANTI
DEMOCRATIC PRACTICES AND US
PICKING WINNERS AND LOSERS ON
THE INTERNET.
COLLEAGUES LET'S MAKE SURE THAT
DOES NOT HAPPEN. I RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
BATES.
THANK YOU ON MEMBERS OF IN A
MEMBERS AND NOT LET ME BEGIN MY
COMMENTS WITH A APPRECIATION TO
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM SAN
FRANCISCO ON. THE WORK HE'S THEN
OVER A NUMBER OF MONTHS ON THIS
ISSUE HOWEVER IT STILL HAS SOME
SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS. A DESPITE
THE RHETORIC THE TRUTH IS S. B.
EIGHT TWENTY TO UNDERMINE. OUR
STATE'S OWN CONSUMER SAN
INVESTMENTS ON OUR OWN
INFRASTRUCTURE IN OUR ECONOMY.
THE BILL GOES MUCH FURTHER THAN
FCC'S TWENTY FIFTEEN OPEN
INTERNET ORDER AND DOES SO IN
WAYS THAT WOULD HARM CONSUMERS
FIRST.
BOB THE BILL WOULD SHIFT
INFRASTRUCTURE IN OPERATION
COSTS TO CONSUMERS BY PREVENTING
INTERCONNECTION AGREEMENTS
BETWEEN INTERNET PROVIDERS AND
OTHER BUSINESSES A FREE RIDE.
THIS MEANS MULTIBILLION DOLLAR
COMPANIES PAY LESS WHILE
CONSUMERS PAY MORE.
SECOND THE BILL PROHIBITS MOST
ZERO RATING SERVICES WHICH
CURRENTLY SAVE CONSUMERS MONEY
BY ALLOWING THEM TO STREAM TV.
AND MOVIES WITHOUT USING THEIR
MOBILE. DATA THIS MEANS OF SB
EIGHT TWENTY TWO WHERE DID
BECOME LAW CONSUMERS AND OTHER
STATES WOULD CONTINUE TO BENEFIT
FROM ZERO RATING SERVICES WHILE
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS WOULD BE
LEFT WITHOUT THESE POPULAR
SERVICES.
THE BILL FUNDAMENTALLY
UNDERMINES INVESTMENT IN
INNOVATION IN CALIFORNIA
BROADBAND TO THE FOUNDATION OF
OUR STATES INTERNET ECONOMY.
THE DEBATE OVER NET NEUTRALITY
GIVES AN IMPORTANT ONE BUT IT
SHOULD BE HAPPENING AT THE
FEDERAL LEVEL. THE BILL IS NOT
NEEDED INTERNET PROVIDERS ARE
ALREADY HELD LEGALLY ACCOUNTABLE
BY THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY
GENERAL AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
ULTIMATELY ALL THIS BILL WILL
SUCCEED IN DOING IS OPENING UP
OUR STATE TO LEGAL CHALLENGES
AND COSTLY LITIGATION. WHICH WE
KNOW IS COMING.
IF THE BILL IS PASSED
REGARDLESS OF HOW EACH OF US
FEELS ABOUT OUR PRESIDENT IT
WOULD BE RECKLESS FOR THIS BODY.
TO SUPPORT LEGISLATION THAT
THREATENS THE CORE OF
CALIFORNIA'S VERY ECONOMY
PRESUMING TO FIX IN THE INTERNET
THAT IS NOT BROKEN. I URGE MY
COLLEAGUES TO VOTE NO ON S. B.
EIGHT TWENTY TWO AND CONSIDER
THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF HAVING EACH
OF US TO HAVE. MULTIPLE
CELLPHONES AS WE TRAVEL AMONGST
THE STATE'S OF WE HAVE A
PATCHWORK OF INTERNET OUT
REQUIREMENTS MY ANSWER I URGE A
NO VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
CENTER BATES CENTER HERTZBERG.
THANK YOU A.
MADAM PRESIDENT.
YOU KNOW.
THIS BILL.
PRESENTS.
ONE OF THE KINDS OF DILEMMAS
THAT INFORMS SO MUCH OF WHAT WE
DO AROUND HERE.
THE POLICY.
IS INTELLIGENT.
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
THERE'S COMPETITION GIVEN THE
CHANGING CIRCUMSTANCES AND
TECHNOLOGIES THE INTERNET.
WORLD HAS CHANGED IN DRAMATIC
WAYS AND THAT NEUTRALITY IS THE
WAY OF THE FUTURE.
THE ABILITY OF COMPANIES TO
DISCRIMINATE ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR
THAT IMPACTS.
INNOVATION AND NEW PEOPLE ALONG
THE PROCESS IS NOTHING LESS THAN
EXTRAORDINARY.
BUT THIS IS AS WAS MENTIONED A
FEDERAL ISSUE.
AND THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT SCREW
THIS THING UP.
IT IS WHEN YOU READ THE CASES
AND.
THE AUTHOR OF THIS MEASURE AND
HIS TRUSTY STAFF OF PUT ME TO
WORK.
SPENDING HOURS AND HOURS AND
HOURS READING THE LAW.
AND SO THE POINT I WONDER MAY
MAKE HERE WHAT SO CHALLENGES ON
THE ONE HAND.
NEITHER CAO IS THE RIGHT THING
TO DO.
TWO WHO DOES IT THIRTY STATES I
BELIEVE NOW HAVE ENGAGED IN PUT
BILLS UP. TO TALK ABOUT THIS
ISSUE WHY BECAUSE IT'S SO
IMPORTANT TO THE MARKET IS SO
IMPORTANT CONSUMERS YET THE
TRUTH OF THE MATTER IS.
THIS FIGHT THAT WE'RE FACING IS
HOW DO WE DRAFT THIS HW DO WE
WRITE THIS CAN WE. NARROWLY
CRAFTED ENOUGH TO MAKE IT
CONSTITUTIONALLY PERMISSIBLE
BECAUSE AS WAS INDICATED WE KNOW
THAT THE SECOND THIS THING
PASSES AND I THINK THAT IT WILL.
THAT THE THEY. ALL THE VARIOUS
PLAYERS WHO ARE COMING AROUND
AND TELLING US DON'T VOTE FOR
THIS THEY'RE NOT SUPPORTING IT.
AND THEY'RE GONNA LITIGATED.
AND THE ONLY THINK THAT
FRUSTRATES ME IN THIS FIGHT AS
SOMEONE WHO'S PUT IN SO MUCH BUT
TIME ON READING THE CASES IS IF
WE'RE GONNA PUT THIS BILL
FORWARD. AND WE'RE GONNA STAND
TALL FOR NET NEUTRALITY LET'S DO
IT IN HARMONY WITH THE CASE THAT
WE CAN WIN.
NOW THAT MAY NOT WORK AS
BRILLIANTLY THAT WE WHAT WE WALL
WANT TO TALK ABOUT NET
NEUTRALITY BUT I BELIEVE THAT
THERE'S A PATH HERE TO WIN IN
THE COURTS.
I BELIEVE THERE'S A PATH
AND I BELIEVE THAT WE SHOULD BE
GUIDED IN EVERY SENTENCE IT'S
WRITTEN IN THIS STATUTE SHOULD
BE BACKED UP BY A COURT CASE.
SO THAT WHEN THE OTHER SIDE GOES
TO COURT AND LITIGATE THIS THING
WE'RE PREPARED.
WE WENT BACK INTO THIS BILL AND
THAT IS IT AS BRILLIANT AS THE
AUTHOR ISN'T OF THE.
BRILLIANT AS A STAFF IS YOU KNOW
I JUST THINK WE'VE GONE RULE TOO
FAR.
THAT BEING SAID I CAN'T.
VOTE AGAINST THIS BILL.
BECAUSE THE PRINCIPAL IS SO
IMPORTANT.
THE PRINCIPLE IS SO IMPORTANT.
AND FOLKS THAT WE'VE ALL SEEN
THIS IN OUR JOBS IN THE
LEGISLATURE THAT WE VOTE ON
TOUGH BILLS AND THEIR MANIFESTED
IN THE PUBLIC PURVIEW IN ONE WAY.
AND INSIDE THE DETAILS OF WHAT
WE DO OUR JOB IN ANOTHER.
AND SO THIS IS ONE OF THOSE
CLOSE CALLS.
BUT I'M GONNA VOTE FOR BECAUSE
THAT NEUTRALITY IS THE RIGHT
THING TO DO.
I'M HOPING IT JUST GOES TO THE
PROCESS GETS WRITTEN IN A MANNER
THAT'S IT MAKES THAT ENHANCE ITS
ABILITY TO PASS.
SO I'M VOTE FOR IT UP BUT I I
ONLY WANTED TO EXPRESS THIS IS I
THINK THAT THERE'S BEEN SO MUCH
DISCUSSION ABOUT THIS ISSUE. SO
MUCH PUBLIC ATTENTION ABOUT THIS
ISSUE I THOUGHT IN THE CHAMBERS
LIKE THIS THAT ARE JOB IS TO IS
TO EXPOSE THESE IDEAS TO DEBATE
THEM TO THINK ABOUT THEM. AND I
WANTED TO EXPRESS WHAT I THINK
IS THE GREAT CHALLENGE THAT WE
FACE AND THAT THE LET DILEMMA
WERE IN THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
SENATOR MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MADAM PRESIDENT.
I'D LIKE TO ECHO SOME OF THE
COMMENTS MADE BY MY COLLEAGUE IN
IN IN RECOGNIZING IN REVIEWING
THE NUMEROUS LETTERS THAT A MY
OFFICE RECEIVE YOU KNOW THERE
WAS A GENERAL COMMON THREAD THIS
NOTION THAT GENERALLY MOST
PEOPLE SUPPORT NET NEUTRALITY IN
AN OPEN INTERNET.
AGAIN SOME FELT THAT THIS
LEGISLATION GOES TOO FAR AND THE
ONE I THINK COMIN.
.
ISSUE RAISED IN THAT CONTEXT AT
LEAST OF THE LETTERS THAT WERE
DIRECTED TOWARD ME INTERESTINGLY
ENOUGH WAS THE QUESTION ABOUT
WHETHER. BILL THE SPECIFICS IN
THIS LEGISLATION WHAT IF WHAT IN
EFFECT BANNED FREE INTERNET DATA
PLANS.
FOR THOSE WHO ARE MOST
VULNERABLE AND MOST NEED THAT
EXTRA ACCESS AND SO IF I MAY
THROUGH THE PRESIDENT QUESTION
OF THE AUTHOR.
SENATE WINNER WILL YOU TAKE A
QUESTION.
PLEASE PROCEED WITH SENATOR
MITCHELL ANSEL CENTER WINNER IF
YOU COULD JUST ADDRESS FROM YOUR
PERSPECTIVE I THINK IT WOULD
HELP ME AND HELP OTHERS.
FIGHT I KNOW THIS WOULD BE AN
ISSUE I WOULD HOPE THIS WOULD BE
THAT YOU WOULD BE SENSITIVE TO
BE. MY EXPERIENCE WORKING WITH
YOU THEY WOULD BE BUT IF YOU
COULD SPECIFICALLY TALK ABOUT
WHETHER FROM YOUR PERSPECTIVE.
BUT IF THIS WOULD BAN FREE
INTERNET ON AND AND IN EFFECT
LIMIT ACCESS TO A LARGE SEGMENT
OF OUR POPULATION.
ARE THANK YOU. MANAGER WHO MAY.
RUN PRESIDENT NOTHING'S PROCEED
OUR OUR THANK YOU TO SENATOR
FROM LOS ANGELES AFTER THAT
QUESTION I AND I BELIEVE THAT
THE QUESTION IS REFERRING TO THE
PRACTICE KNOWN AS ZERO RATING
YES SIR YES. I AND.
AYE THIS BILL WILL INCREASE
ACCESS TO THE INTERNET
PARTICULARLY FOR LOW INCOME.
CONSUMERS AND I WANTED TO SAY
THAT I.
ZERO RATING WHICH IS WHY I
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER SAYS.
YOU GET FREE DATA WHETHER IT'S
FOR PARTICULAR APPLICATION OR
PARTICULAR TIME OF DAY.
THAT THAT IS NOT CATEGORICALLY
BANDS BY THE BILL THE BILL OUR
BANDS. ZERO RATING THAT.
IS ANTI CONSUMER
ANTICOMPETITIVE THERE ARE OTHER
FORMS ZERO RATING THEY'RE NOT
PAN. OUT FOR EXAMPLE IF A.
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS SAYS
YOU DON'T HAVE TO USE YOU KNOW
ROCKETS ARE YOU ANY DATA DURING
CERTAIN TIMES OF THE DAY FOR
EXAMPLE THAT'S NOT BANNED. WHAT
IS VAN IS ONE INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS USED ZERO RATING?
AS A WAY TO MANIPULATE CONSUMERS
INTO USING FAVOR PRODUCTS
OFTEN THEIR OWN PRODUCTS THAT
CAN BE MORE EXPENSIVE.
AND THAT ARE VERY LIMITING IN
TERMS OF CONDUCT CONSUMER CHOICE.
SO THIS PLAYS OUT OFTEN IN TWO
WAYS ONE IS WE KNOW THAT
INTERNET ACCESS IS NOT THE SAME
KIND OF GROWTH INDUSTRY AS IT
USED TO BE. SO INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS ARE BRANCHING INTO
MORE AND MORE LINES OF BUSINESS
AND SO THEY'RE COMPETING AGAINST
THEIR OWN CUSTOMERS. SO AN
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER IN
EIGHTEEN TO YOUR COMCAST WILL
SAY IF USE MY PRODUCT.
YOU WERE NOT GONNA CHARGES DATA
IF YOU USE MY COMPETITOR'S
PRODUCT WHICH MAY BE CHEAPER.
WERE GONNA CHARGE YOU DATA.
THEY CAN ALSO PLAY OUT THAT YOU
HAD SAY A LARGE COMPANY PAYS THE
ISP. A BUNCH OF MONEY AND BECOME
ZERO RATED SO THAT NOW BECOMES
NO DATA. BUT THE SMALLER
COMPANIES THAT MAY HAVE A BETTER
SERVICE OR CHEAPER SERVICE BUT
CAN'T AFFORD TO PAY A BIG FEET.
THEIR NAZIRA RATED AND SO PEOPLE
THAN ARE MANIPULATED INTO USING
ONLY A LIMITED NUMBER OF
PRODUCTS
I AND IT MIGHT NOT ACTUALLY BE
THE BEST PRODUCT FOR THEM.
OR THE CHEAPEST OP PRODUCT.
I WHAT WE ALSO KNOW AND THIS WE
HAVE SEEN THIS ON THEIR EXAMPLES
OF THIS.
WHEN YOU HAVE ZERO RATING AND
LOOK TO BE VERY CLEAR WE TALK OF
FREE DATA NOTHING IS FREE.
THESE IP THEY'RE NOT GIVEN AWAY
YOU KNOW FREE DATA OUT OF THE
GOODNESS OF THEIR HEARTS ARE
DOING IT BECAUSE THEY MAKE MONEY
OFF OF IT.
WHEN YOU HAVE ZERO RATING WHAT
THAT MEANS AS FOR THE ZERO
RATING TO BE VALUABLE.
I S. P.'S PUSH DOWN BETA COPS.
AND A MAKE UNLIMITED DATA PLANS
MORE EXPENSIVE OTHERWISE IF YOU
MAKE IT EASIER AND CHEAPER
PEOPLE TO GO UNLIMITED DATA
PLANS. ZERO RATING HAS NO VALUE
WHATSOEVER.
SO THEY HAVE AN INCENTIVE TO
MAKE IT EXPENSIVE TO HAVE
UNLIMITED DATA. AND TO PUSH DOWN
DATA COPS.
AND SO FOR LOWER INCOME PEOPLE
REMAIN CAN'T AFFORD AN UNLIMITED
PLAN.
THEY ARE ABOUT ZERO RATING COMES
VERY VALUABLE AND THEY GET
MANIPULATED IN A WAY THAT THOSE
OF US WHO CAN AFFORD A HIGHER
PLAN OR NOT. INTO USING ONLY
SPECIFIC. SERVICES.
IN COUNTRIES THAT HAVE BANDS OR
RESTRICTED ZERO RATING LIKE IN
EUROPE BY INDIA IT. IS ANOTHER
ONE WHAT HAPPENED WAS IN AND
TWENTY SIXTEEN.
INDIA.
BAND ZERO RATING.
I IN JUST ONE YEAR. IDEA PRICES
FELL BY MORE THAN FIFTY PERCENT.
DATA CONSUMPTION PER CAPITA
INCREASED.
AND MARKET COMPETITION INCREASE.
WHEN NETHERLANDS BAND ZERO
RATING.
MONTHLY DATA COPS NEARLY DOUBLED
AND THE PRICE OF THE UNLIMITED
PLANS DECREASED SIGNIFICANTLY.
AND SO WHAT WE SEE IS THAT WHEN
YOU DON'T HAVE ZERO RATING.
CONSUMERS GOT MORE DATA MORE
CHEAPLY AND THE ZERO RATING
DOESN'T MATTER AND THEY GET TO
PICK FOR THEMSELVES.
BUT YOU DON'T HAVE TO BELIEVE ME.
ARE YOU OUR COLORS ELICITED
RECEIVED A COLLEAGUE OF A LETTER
FROM THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW
AND POVERTY. OTHER DESCRIBES IN
DETAIL Y. ZERO RATING IS BAD FOR
LOW INCOME PEOPLE.
BOB THERE WAS ALSO IN A
COALITION LETTER FROM A
COALITION OF CIVIL RIGHTS
ORGANIZATIONS TO THE FCC. ASKING
FOR IS YOUR RATING BAD EXACTLY
WHAT WE'RE DOING TODAY.
DIED.
SAYS VERY VERY SPECIFICALLY
THAT ZERO RATING HARMS LOW
INCOME PEOPLE.
AND COMMUNITIES OF COLOR.
AND WE HAVE A LOT OF DIFFERENT
GROUPS THAT ADVOCATE FOR LOW
INCOME CONSUMERS. ODD THAT HAVE
BEEN CATEGORICALLY OPPOSE ZERO
RATING AND ADVOCATED FOR EXACTLY
WHAT WE'RE DOING HERE TODAY.
SO I.
ON ITS SURFACE ZERO RATING
SOUNDS GREAT AND PRACTICE IT IS
ANTI COMPETITIVE.
AND IT IS ANTI CONSUMER.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER SENATOR
STERN.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
I'VE I'VE SEEN AS BILLING
COMMITTEE.
THROUGH NUMEROUS HEARINGS AND I
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S.
DILIGENCE AND HARD WORK ON THE
SUBSTANCE HERE.
I'LL BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
TODAY AS I HAVE BEEN IN BOTH THE
PREVIOUS COMMITTEES.
BUT I WANTED TO ADDRESS THIS
ISSUE OF.
FREE VERSE IS OPEN.
YES WE WANT THE INTERNET TO BE
OPEN.
I WANT EVERYONE TO HAVE ACCESS
TO IT.
AND WE DON'T WANT THOSE WHO
MANAGES TO MANAGE IT IN AN
UNREASONABLE MANNER THAT'S ANTI
COMPETITIVE.
BUT NOTHING IS FREE.
AS THE AUTHOR HIMSELF JUST SAID.
THERE'S NOTHING FREE ABOUT THE
INTERNET TRULY SOMEONE'S GOING
TO PAY FOR SOMETHING IT SOMETIME.
LIKE ANY PIECE OF INFRASTRUCTURE.
IT TAKES UP KEEP.
TAKES MAINTENANCE.
AND THAT DATA THAT GETS
DELIVERED AROUND THIS COUNTRY AT
LIGHT SPEED IS STILL A SHIPMENT
OF SOME KIND OF SOMETHING.
IT'S NOT JUST MAGICAL THE
NETFLIX GETS TO YOUR HOUSE
AND STREAM SMOOTHLY.
THERE IS A HIGHWAY THAT BRINGS
THAT TO YOU.
AND SO I WOULD JUST URGE IS THE
BILL MOVES FORWARD.
THAT THE COMPANIES OUT THERE
PUTTING MASS AMOUNTS OF DATA ON
THE WEB. LIKE OUR FRIENDS AT
NETFLIX
OR LIKE THOSE EDGE PROVIDERS OUT
THERE WHO ARE USING THE INTERNET
CURRENTLY FOR FREE.
MORE LEAST WANTED TO BE.
AND THAT NOW VENTURE THESE NEW
INTERCONNECTION AGREEMENTS.
OR TRYING TO FIND NEW PRODUCTS
THROUGH ZERO RATING.
THAT THEY STEP OUT OF THE
WOODWORK AND ACTUALLY. LET US
KNOW HOW THEY FEEL ABOUT THIS
BILL I THINK THERE'S BEEN.
.
I SILENCE ON THIS SIDE. OF THE
EDGE PROVIDERS THAT I. THAT
WASN'T THERE IN CONGRESS AND
THEY'RE DEBATING THIS NOW
THEY'LL TELL YOU THEY DON'T WANT
TO STATE BY STATE SOLUTION.
BUT IF WE'RE GOING TO GO SAVE
NETFLIX A BILLION DOLLARS HERE.
WE OUGHT TO KNOW THAT.
SO MY UNDERSTANDING FROM THE
BILL RIGHT NOW IS THAT IN
CURRENT FORM IT WOULD LIKELY
SEVER. FOR INSTANCE THAT.
VERY LARGE INTERCONNECTION
AGREEMENT BETWEEN NETFLIX AND
COMCAST.
AS THIS BILL MOVES FOR I HOPE
WE CAN BEGIN TO ILLUMINATE.
THE TRUE NATURE OF WHO WILL PAY.
BECAUSE IT'S CLEAR THAT.
THE CABLE INDUSTRY THE INTERNET
SERVICE PROVIDERS THOSE BRINGING
THE INTERNET TO YOU THEY ARE
PAYING.
AND THEY'RE GOING TO PAY MORE.
BUT THE.
THE CAUTIONARY NOTE IS.
THAT THOSE WITH MULTI BILLION
DOLLAR MARKET CAPS OUT THERE WHO
MAY WANT THAT PRODUCT TO BE FREE
THEMSELVES JUST LIKE A CONSUMER
DOES.
OUGHT NOT HAVE JUST A FREE PASS
THERE SO WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO
FIND THAT BALANCE BUT I WILL
TELL YOU. THIS AUTHOR.
HAS WORKED.
INCREDIBLY DILIGENTLY. CONTINUES
TO ME OVER AND OVER WITH THE
STAKEHOLDERS AND RECOGNIZES THAT
WE ARE AN UNCOMFORTABLE POSITION
HERE.
AS THE STATE STEPPING INTO WHAT
OUGHT TO BE A FEDERAL ISSUE.
AND WE DON'T HAVE A REGULATORS
LIKE THE FCC.
ORIGINALLY PROPOSED THE P. YOU
SEE WOULD COME AND DO THAT JOB
THAT WAS STRIPPED OUT IN
COMMITTEE.
SO NOW WERE GOING AT THIS FROM A
VERY DIFFERENT APPROACH WHERE
WE'RE TRYING TO REBUILD THE SAME
ARCHITECTURE THAT THE FCC SHOULD
HAVE IN PLACE NOW.
BUT WE HAVE TO COBBLE THAT
TOGETHER AS A MATTER STATE LAW.
SO I GET THAT IT'S SOMEWHAT OF
AN AWKWARD FIT.
I STILL THINK.
BED IT COUNSELS TOWARDS AN AYE
VOTE TODAY.
BECAUSE WE DO NEED TO SEND A
SIGNAL TO WASHINGTON THAT IF
THEY DON'T GET IT TOGETHER.
WE'RE GONNA.
BUT.
.
THE UNIT HAS TO WORK.
YOU DON'T HAVE TO WORK AND IT IS
NOT MAGIC IN ETHEREAL EVEN
THOUGH THAT THAT CELLPHONE YOURS
FEELS LIKE YOU TO JUST COMES OUT.
OUT FROM THE SKY IT COMES FROM
SOMEWHERE SO.
I'LL BE VOTING AYE TODAY AND
APPRECIATE THE ENGAGEMENT THE
AUTHOR GOING FORWARD.
THANK YOU CENTER STERN SENATOR
GAINES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS AND I.
JUST HAS SOME PROBLEMS OF WITH
THIS.
.
JUST CLEARLY FROM A
JURISDICTIONAL.
PERSPECTIVE AND THIS COMING
FROM VALUE ELSE U. S. TELL CALM.
MAD READ.
I'M SO SORRY PLEASE PROVIDE A
READ A QUOTE I IF I COULD FROM
US TELECOM.
AND I QUOTE THE INTERNET IS AN
INHERENTLY.
INTERSTATE AND INTERNATIONAL
SERVICE THERE'S ALWAYS BEEN
VIEWED AS SUCH BY THE FCC AND
THE COURTS.
SEPARATE CALIFORNIA LAWS
ATTEMPTING TO REGULATE.
THE SAME CONDUCT THROUGH
DIFFERENT AVENUES INTERPRETED BY
DIFFERENT STATE BODIES AND
PUBLIC AGENCY PURCHASING
ENTITIES WOULD CREATE AN
OVERLAPPING.
PATCHWORK EVEN WITHIN THE STATE.
AND THEN WE ALSO HAVE A UNQUOTE
AND THEN WE HAVE THE.
PREEMPTED ASPECT OF.
THE FCC ORDER SEVENTEEN DASH ONE
SIX SIX WHICH CLEARLY STATES
THAT BROADBAND INTERNET ACCESS
SERVICE SHOULD BE GOVERNED BY
UNIFIED. SET OF FEDERAL
REGULATIONS AND NOT A PATCHWORK
OF STATE AND LOCAL REQUIREMENTS
SO. I SEE AN INHERENT CONFLICT
WITH THE LEGISLATION.
BECAUSE THIS IS SOMETHING IS
REGULATED BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT NOT BY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
I WOULD URGE A NO VOTE THANK YOU
THANK YOU SENATOR GAINES CENTER
WINNER WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
SENATOR WINNER WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FUN CHECK ACOG THANK YOU FOR THE
THOUGHTFUL DISCUSSION I I JUST
WANT TO ADDRESS A VERY BRIEFLY A
FEW THINGS. I'VE TO THE.
MY STEAM COLLEAGUE THAT
MINORITY LEADER.
I AGREED THEY SHOULD BE.
THOUGHT NO MATTER WHAT THE
REALITY IS THAT THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT HAS ABDICATED.
AND IF THE ONE THAT CHANGES IN
THE FUTURE AND I HOPE THAT IT
DOES AND WE CAN REVISIT THIS BUT
IF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. IS
GOING TO ABDICATE ITS
RESPONSIBILITY TO PROTECT THE
INTERNET DOES THROW AWAY NEARLY
TWO DECADES OF WORK I'VE BEEN I
THINK WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY.
IN CALIFORNIA TO PROTECT OUR
RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES.
BUT THERE HAS BEEN THIS
NARRATIVE THAT WITH NET
NEUTRALITY PROTECTIONS THE ICE
PEAS ARE NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO
MAKE MONEY THEY'RE NOT GONNA BE
ABLE TO INVEST IN THEIR SYSTEM.
AND WITH ALL RESPECT TO THE
ISP'S THAT IS JUST FALSE BOTTOM
DURING THE SEVERAL YEARS THAT
THE OBAMA ORDER WAS AN ATTACK
THESE COMPANIES MADE A HUGE
AMOUNT OF MONEY. I MADE HUGE
INVESTMENTS IN INFRASTRUCTURE
BUT IT'S JUST NOT ADVOCATES. ON
YOU KNOW AND AND TERMS OF AYE
NETFLIX YES NETFLIX IS WHAT IT
IS BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT THIS IS
ABOUT AYE THIS IS ABOUT YOU SEE
THE HUGE COALITION OF ADVOCACY.
LABOR CONSUMER ORGANIZATIONS
THAT WANT THIS BILL THIS MATTERS
FOR AN OPEN INTERNET AND
COLLEAGUES I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR I DON'T. THINK YOU CENTER
WIENER MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
I DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
AYE. AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE
BY MITCHELL.
I MONEY.
BY MORE LARK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
SKINNER STERN.
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO WHY KATHY.
I.
WIENER.
I WILK NO. PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN.
I.
BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
HUESO.
I.
NEWMAN.
WHEN.
PAN PORTANTINO. BY. ROTH.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL. MEMBERS WE
ARE NOW MOVING TO FILE ITEM ONE
TWENTY SEVEN SENATOR HILL.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FORTY EIGHT
BY SENATOR HILL AN ACCOLADE
HEALING ARTS SENATOR HILL. THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SP FOURTEEN
FORTY EIGHT IS THE PATIENT'S
RIGHT TO KNOW ACT OF TWENTY
EIGHTEEN.
MEMBERS ALSO THIRTY SIX OF YOU
THIRTY SIX OF YOU VOTED FOR A
BROADER VERSION OF THIS BILL
LAST YEAR. THIS BILL HAS BEEN
SCALED BACK CONSIDERABLY.
ALSO A FEW WEEKS AGO ON THIS
FLOOR WE HONORED FORMER
OLYMPIANS WHOSE BRAVERY HELPED
BRING A SEXUAL PREDATOR. TO
JUSTICE
AND THESE SAME OLYMPIANS HAVE
BEEN VERY SUPPORTIVE OF ACTIVE
WITH THIS BILL.
THE BILL REQUIRES THAT
PHYSICIANS DISCIPLINED BY THE
REGULATORY BOARD FOR THE
FOLLOWING OFFENSES WILL HAVE TO
NOTIFY. THEIR PATIENCE PRIOR TO
THEIR VISIT.
ONE SEXUAL MISCONDUCT WITH A
PATIENT.
TO.
DRUG ABUSE THAT CAN HARM
PATIENTS.
CRIMINAL CONVICTION INVOLVING
HARM TO PATIENTS.
INAPPROPRIATE PRESCRIBING
RESULTING IN HARM TO PATIENTS.
THESE CATEGORIES INCLUDE THE
MOST EGREGIOUS PROBATION CASES.
THE BILL HAS BEEN AMENDED TO
EXCLUDE LESS SERIOUS.
OFFENDERS CURRENTLY DOCTORS HAVE
TO NOTIFY THEIR INSURER AND
THEIR HOSPITAL OR CLINIC ABOUT
THEIR PROBATION STATUS BUT
PATIENTS RECEIVE NO NOTICE.
THEY ARE LEFT IN THE DARK AND
SUSCEPTIBLE TO FUTURE ABUSE.
THIS IS MY THIRD YEAR CARRYING
THIS BILL AND THIS IS THE MOST
SCALED BACK VERSION YET.
MANY OF MEANT A.
MANY OF YOU HAVE PROBABLY BEEN
APPROACHED BY OUR GOOD FRIENDS
AT THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION.
AND THEY'VE SAID THAT A DEAL HAD
BEEN COMPLETED AND CONCLUDED. A
DEAL REGARDING THIS BILL.
UNFORTUNATELY I HAVE BEEN NO
PART OF THE CONVERSATION NOR
HAVE I BEEN IN DISCUSSIONS WITH
ANYONE REGARDING A DEAL
REGARDING THIS BILL.
AND THAT PART THOUGH THAT'S
IMPORTANT IS MUCH OF THE
CONCERNS
AND THE ISSUES THAT THE CMA HAS
AGREED TO WITH THEIR DISCUSSIONS.
ARE IN THIS BILL THIS BILL HAS
THE LANGUAGE.
THAT THEY WANTED EXCEPT FOR
THREE AREAS.
THREE AREAS THAT WE HAVE TWEAKED
SLIGHTLY IN ORDER TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY'RE CLEAR. MAKE SURE
THAT THEY COVER THOSE
APPROPRIATE OFFENSES AND MAKE
SURE THAT THERE ARE NO LOOPHOLES
IN THOSE AND LET ME. THAT ME
TELL YOU WHAT THOSE THREE
CHANGES ARE THE MINOR CHANGES
ONE. IS WE ARE CLARIFYING SEXUAL
MISCONDUCT DEFINITION SO ALL
SEXUAL MISCONDUCT SCENARIOS WILL
REQUIRE NOTIFICATION TO PATIENTS.
PLEDGE COUNCIL SAID THE CMA
LANGUAGE MIGHT NOT INCLUDES
CERTAIN SCENARIOS WHICH SEXUAL
MISCONDUCT OCCURRED BUT THERE
WASN'T PHYSICAL CONTACT.
THE SECOND AREA OF MODIFICATION
IS THE CONVICTION SHOULD BE
CRIMINAL INSTEAD OF JUST A
FELONY.
EVEN WITH A MISDEMEANOR
CONVICTION THE LANGUAGE.
STILL REQUIRES IT STILL REQUIRES
PATIENT HARM.
ALL OF THESE AREAS MEMBERS
REQUIRE PATIENT HARM FOR ANY
NOTIFICATION THE THIRD AREA. IS
ON THE INAPPROPRIATE PRESCRIBING
CATEGORY. WE'RE CLARIFYING THAT
THE PROBATION TERM IS FIVE OR
MORE YEARS SINCE MANY OF THE
FIVE YEAR PROBATION PEOPLE. IN
THIS CATEGORY ARE SERIOUS
OFFENDERS IT STILL HAS TO RELATE
TO PATIENT HARM.
MEMBERS WE.
LOOK AT THIS AND TAKE IT.
IT'S SO MANY TIMES WE TAKE
EVERYTHING FOR GRANTED IN THIS
CHAMBER.
BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
CHALLENGES FACED BY THOSE WHO GO
TO A DOCTOR.
AND AS WE TRUST THOSE PHYSICIANS
ON AN ONGOING REGULAR BASIS AND
WE SHOULD.
BECAUSE THEY HOLD OUR LIVES IN
THEIR HANDS.
BUT THERE ARE TIMES IN A VERY
SMALL NUMBER.
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT OUT OF ONE
HUNDRED AND FORTY THOUSAND
LICENSE PHYSICIANS IN CALIFORNIA.
THERE ARE ABOUT SIX HUNDRED ON
PROBATION AT ANY ONE TIME.
IN THE LIST WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
BRINGS THAT DOWN TO THOSE WHO
ARE GOING ON PROBATION.
TO LESS THAN A HUNDRED PROBABLY
LESS THAN SEVENTY.
CURRENT YEAR WOULD HAVE TO
NOTIFY THEIR PATIENTS.
BUT WHEN YOU LOOK IT'S THE
CONDITIONS IN THE TERMS OF
PROBATION THAT ARE NECESSARY. IN
SOME CASES.
THE TERMS OF PROBATION FOR THOSE
WHO HAVE BEEN INVOLVED WITH
SEXUAL MISCONDUCT.
THAT TERM REQUIRES THAT THEY NOT
TO PRACTICE ALONE WITH A PATIENT
THAT THEY HAVE TO BE CHAPERONED.
WHEN THEY SEE A PATIENT.
BUT THERE'S NO ONE PRESENT.
TO MAKE SURE. IT THAT CHAPERONE
IS THERE IN THAT THAT POSITION
IS NOT SEEN THAT PATIENT ALONE.
ESPECIALLY.
BASED ON THE FACT THAT THIRTY
PERCENT OF THESE DOCTORS RE
OFFEND.
MEMBERS WE WANT TO PROTECT THOSE
IN SOCIETY WHO ARE VULNERABLE.
AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
THERE'S TRANSPARENCY AND
INFORMATION AVAILABLE SO THAT
THOSE WHO ARE SEEN A PHYSICIAN
KNOW. THAT THEY CAN TRUST THAT
DOCTOR AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY
HAVE THAT INFORMATION NECESSARY
I ASK YOUR AYE VOTE MEMBERS
THANK YOU SENATOR HILL CENTER
MONNING.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
BRIEFLY I STAND IN SUPPORT OF
SB FOURTEEN FORTY EIGHT.
I KNOW THE AUTHOR HAS.
TAKEN A LOT OF AMENDMENTS TO
IMPROVE AND NARROW THE FOCUS OF
THIS.
BUT TO REMEMBER.
PRIMARY PURPOSE OF THIS IS
PATIENT PROTECTION
PATIENT RIGHT TO KNOW YOU READ
THE HEADLINES COMING OUT OF U.
S. SCENE.
APPARENTLY ALLEGE TO YEARS OF
ABUSE
ARM THIS IS A GUIDELINE.
TO PROTECT PATIENTS.
AND I WANT TO APPLAUD THE
AUTHOR ON THE WORK HE HAS DONE.
TAYLOR IT.
INTO NARROW IT TO THOSE
PROBATIONARY.
.
PROBATIONARY PERIODS FOR
PHYSICIANS THAT HAVE INVOLVED
DIRECT.
MISCONDUCT WITH THE PATIENT.
I THINK IT'S.
A CONSUMER RIGHT TO KNOW A
PATIENT RIGHT TO KNOW AYE URGING
AYE VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
CENTER MONNING CENTER HILL WHICH
I TO CLOSE A FEW VERY MUCH
MOVEMENT PRESIDENT I WANT TO
THANK. MY GOOD FRIEND THE
SENATOR FROM MONTEREY HE'S
ABSOLUTELY CORRECT.
pPART OF THIS BILL THE PART THAT
REQUIRES NOTIFICATION IT'S ONLY.
ONLY THOSE PHYSICIANS.
THAT ARE ON PROBATION WHERE THEY
HAVE CAUSED PATIENT HARM.
BUT DO YOU AYE THAT THEY MAY GET.
IT DOESN'T AND IS NOT INVOLVED
IN PITCHING ARM THAT'S NOT
INCLUDED.
ONLY WHEN PATIENT HARM IS
DIRECTLY RELATED AYE ASTRAEA AYE
VOTE MEMBERS THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR HELMS FOR
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
BY CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
I DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
BY HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
BY LARA.
BY LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
BY MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
BY.
NEWMAN.
I'VE NGUYEN.
NELSON.
PAN.
PORTANTINO I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
BY STONE.
BUT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
I. WIENER. AYE WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
FULLER.
MCGUIRE.
I MORLOCK.
NGUYEN.
I.
NIELSEN.
PAN
BY TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS THREE THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
GOING TO LIFT THE CALL ON FILE
ITEM TWENTY NINE. S. B. EIGHT
TWENTY TWO. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
PAN.
ROTH.
RATHER.
I WAS TWENTY ONE DOES.
YES PLEASE THANK YOU BRADFORD
AYE.
I SWING TO KNOWS TWELVE THE
MEASURE PASSES OKAY MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM.
YES OKAY THANK YOU I APOLOGIZE I
DID NOT HEAR THAT.
EYES TWENTY THREE KNOWS TWELVE
THE MEASURE PASSES.
WE'RE MOVING TO FILE ITEM THIRTY
THREE.
SENATOR GALGIANI MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TWELVE FORTY NINE BY
SENATOR GALGIANI AND EXPLAINED
ANIMAL TESTING.
SENATOR GALGIANI THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS SP TWELVE
FORTY NINE PROHIBITS THE SALE OR
PROMOTIONAL GIVEAWAY OF ANY
COSMETIC PRODUCT IN CALIFORNIA
THAT HAS BEEN TESTED ON AN
ANIMAL AFTER JANUARY FIRST.
TWENTY TWENTY WITH TWO LIMITED
EXCEPTIONS
FIRST IN THE EVENT THAT THE
FEDERAL DRUG ADMINISTRATION OR
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL.
REQUIRES TESTING AND THERE ARE
NO ALTERNATIVES AVAILABLE AND
SECOND THE SECOND EXEMPTION
WOULD ALLOW ANIMAL TESTING TO
COMPLY WITH THE FORMAL REQUEST
OF A FOREIGN REGULATORY
AUTHORITY. HOWEVER THIS
EXEMPTION WILL SON SAT AS OF
JANUARY FIRST TWENTY TWENTY
THREE.
AND AFTER JANUARY FIRST TWENTY
TWENTY THREE CALIFORNIA
CONSUMERS CAN WITH GREAT
CONFIDENCE BE SURE THAT THE
COSMETIC PRODUCTS THAT THEY
PURCHASE WERE NOT UNNECESSARILY
TESTED ON ANIMALS. SAVING
THOUSANDS OF ANIMALS FROM
CERTAIN DEATH FOLLOWING PAINFUL
TESTS ON THEIR EYES AND SKIN.
S. B. TWELVE FORTY NINE SIMPLY
BRINGS CALIFORNIA WHO MAIN
STANDARDS IN LINE WITH THE%
WORLD'S HIGHEST STANDARDS. AND
THE YEAR TWO THOUSAND CALIFORNIA
WAS THE FIRST STATE TO BAN THE
PRACTICE OF USING ANIMALS FOR
TESTING COSMETICS. HOWEVER THE
LAW AT THAT TIME STAYED SILENT
ABOUT THE IMPORTATION AND SALE
COSMETICS.
THAT WERE TESTED ON ANIMALS.
AT LEAST THIRTY FIVE COUNTRIES
THROUGHOUT THE WORLD HAVE
ALREADY BANNED THE SALE OF
COSMETIC PRODUCTS TESTED ON
ANIMALS.
THERE ARE MANY COSMETIC
COMPANIES THAT ARE CURRENTLY
THRIVING WITHOUT TESTING THEIR
PRODUCTS ON ANIMALS IN FACT A
COALITION OF OVER EIGHTY
COSMETIC COMPANIES.
SUPPORT THIS BILL THE EUROPEAN
UNION JUST PASSED A RESOLUTION
CALLING FOR THE PHASE OUT OF ALL
ANIMAL TESTING FOR COSMETICS
EVERYWHERE IN THE WORLD BY
TWENTY TWENTY THREE. EXACTLY THE
TIME FRAME IN WHICH THIS BILL
WILL PHASE OUT THE FOREIGN
REGULATORY BODY TESTING
EXEMPTION. LASTLY THERE
CURRENTLY THOUSANDS OF COSMETICS
ON THE MARKET THATWILL ALWAYS
BE AVAILABLE TO CONSUMERS SP
TWELVE FORTY NINE GRANDFATHER'S
EN ALL INGREDIENTS THAT HAVE
BEEN TESTED ON ANIMALS UP UNTIL
TWENTY TWENTY. AND AGAIN THAT
ALLOWS FOR EXCEPTIONS WHERE
TESTING IS REQUIRED BY LAW AND
NO ALTERNATIVES ARE AVAILABLE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE. BIG YOU CENTER GALGIANI
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE.
SEEING NONE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO. BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
BYE DOT.
FULLER.
NO GAINES
NO GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
HUESO.
JACKSON.
BY LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
PAN PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
I.
STERN.
BY STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO.
MY COUNTY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DODD.
GLAZER.
HILL.
HUESO.
MCGUIRE.
I SO.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
NELSON.
PAN.
ROTH.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS WE
ARE GOING TO LIFT THE CALL ON
FILE ITEM ONE FOURTEEN SB
THIRTEEN NINETY ONE. MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
DELEON. AYE.
NEWMAN.
ROTH.
BY.
STERN.
I.
WE WENT.
I WAS TWENTY THREE KNOWS FIFTEEN
THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM EIGHTY SIX SENATOR DODD.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN TWENTY ONE BY
SENATOR DODD AND ACT CLING TO
PERSONAL INFORMATION.
SENATOR DODD.
THAT A PRESIDENT MEMBERS S. B.
ELEVEN TWENTY ONE IS A COMMON%
SENSE MEASURE TO HELP PROTECT
CONSUMERS. FROM FUTURE DATA
BREACHES INCENTIVIZE.
COMPANIES TO INVEST IN DATA
SECURITY.
THE EQUIFAX BREACH AFFECTED A
HUNDRED AND FORTY EIGHT MILLION
U. S. CONSUMERS THAT'S FIFTEEN
FIFTY NINE PERCENT. OF THE U. S.
POPULATION
MAKING IT THE LARGEST THEFT OF
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBERS. IN THE
HISTORY.
UNDER CURRENT LAW CONSUMERS IT
IN EFFECT HAVE NO RECOURSE
AGAINST EQUIFAX
OR OTHER CORPORATIONS THAT
NEGLECT.
CHECKING OUR PERSONAL
INFORMATION.
WITH MORE AND MORE BREACHES OF
PERSONAL INFORMATION AVAILABLE
ON THE DARK WEB. ESTABLISHING
THE DIRECT CONNECTION BETWEEN
THE TWO IS INCREASINGLY
DIFFICULT. IF NOT IMPOSSIBLE.
IF YOUR IDENTITY GET STOLEN HOW
CAN YOU POSSIBLY KNOW WHETHER
THE DATA CAME FROM EQUIFAX
BREACH OR ANOTHER PARTY
ALTOGETHER.
SB ELEVEN TWENTY ONE WILL UPDATE
CALIFORNIA'S DATA BREACH LAWS
GIVING CONSUMERS RECOURSE.
SO THEY'LL BE FINALLY AN
INCENTIVE FOR COMPANIES TO TAKE
REASONABLE.
PURITY MEASURES TO PROTECT THEIR
DATA.
THIS BILL CLARIFIES THE
CONSUMERS COVERED BY DATA BREACH
PROTECTIONS NOT JUST A CUSTOMER.
THE EQUIFAX BREACH DEMONSTRATED
THE CONSUMERS CANNOT ALWAYS BE
DEFINED AS CUSTOMERS.
IT ALLIANCE THE INFORMATION
PRACTICES ACT WITH THE
CONFIDENTIALLY CONFIDENTIALITY
OF MEDICAL INFORMATION ACT BY
ADDING DAMAGES OF BETWEEN TWO
HUNDRED AND ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS
FOR FAILURE TO TAKE. REASONABLE
SECURITY MEASURES AND FAILURE TO
NOTIFY CONSUMERS THAT'S
DISCOURAGING BREACHES BY ADDING
TEETH TO THE LAW.
THIS ALSO HOLDS COMPANIES
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THE HARM THEY
BECAUSE AS A RESULT OF THE DATA
BREACH.
APPROPRIATIONS AMENDMENTS
DRASTICALLY LIMIT THE BILL. TO%
APPLY ONLY TO BUSINESSES THAT DO
NOT ENCRYPT.
OR REDACTED ADA. AND
KEEP A CONSUMER'S NAME AND
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER DRIVER'S
LICENSE OR FINANCIAL ACCOUNT
NUMBERS. THIS BILL NO LONGER
APPLIES TO USERNAMES AND
PASSWORDS.
EQUIFAX HOLDS US ALL OF US
CONSUMERS TO THE HIGHEST
STANDARDS DEAN YOUR CREDIT
SCORES.
IT'S TIME WE HOLD THEM IN OTHER
BUSINESSES ACCOUNTABLE FOR
KEEPING DATA SAFE I RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD.
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATOR STONE'S.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT DENIES
CERTAINLY WANT TO.
APPLAUD MY MY COLLEAGUE FROM
NAPA.
THAT WANTS TO.
STRENGTHENED TO ENSURE THAT.
WE DON'T HAVE COMPANIES THAT ARE
BEING HACKED IN VITAL
INFORMATION BEING SHARED NOT
ONLY THROUGHOUT THE UNITED
STATES BUT THROUGHOUT THE WORLD
BUT. I THINK HE'S DIRECTING HIS.
HIS FRUSTRATION AND ANGER. AT.
THE VERY COMPANIES THAT.
HAVE BEEN THE VICTIMS OF
CRIMINALITY.
THERE ARE SOPHISTICATED.
ENTITIES INCLUDING BROKE
COUNTRIES THAT DO NOTHING BUT
SPEND FULL TIME TRYING TO HACK.
THE PRIVATE SECTOR IN THE PUBLIC
SECTOR EVEN THE UNITED STATES
GOVERNMENT'S BEEN HACKED.
I'M SOME PRIVACY RVERS IT'D BEEN
HACKED IN THE GOVERNMENT AS WELL.
I REGRET REGRETFULLY MUST OPPOSE
S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY ONE CENTS
WILL UNDULY CREATE MASSIVE
LIABILITY TO BUSINESSES AND
NONPROFITS FOR DATA BREACHES.
EVEN WHEN NO CUSTOMER HAS BEEN
HARMED.
WELL THE INTENT
TO PREVENT DATA BREACHES THAT
HAVE BEEN IN THE PAST EXPOSE
CONSUMER INFORMATION IS ONE THAT
I COMMEND.
S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY ONE WOULD
DRASTICALLY EXPAND THE CIVIL
LIABILITY OF COMPANIES.
PROVIDING GOODS AND SERVICES.
AND CALIFORNIA.
WITHOUT ANY CORRESPONDING.
BENEFIT TO CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS.
MY FRIENDS.
WE ARE WITNESSING.
A TREMENDOUS FLIGHT.
OF BUSINESSES OUT OF THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA.
OVER THE PAST DECADE.
IN A PASADENA STAR.
ARTICLE AUGUST TWO THOUSAND
SEVENTEEN.
BETWEEN TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT
AND TWO THOUSAND AND FIFTEEN.
OVER TEN THOUSAND BUSINESSES
HAVE LEFT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
DECREASE OUR OPERATIONS.
OR CURTAILED PLANS TO LOCATE
DIVERSE OUR STATE.
YOU CAN LOOK AT BIG COMPANIES
LIKE HONDA.
YOU CAN LOOK A KUBOTA TRACTOR.
THAT LEFT TORRANCE CALIFORNIA.
FOR GREAT.
VINE TAXES.
HINES
BUT LEFT CHATSWORTH.
TO GO TO MASON.
OHIO.
VISITING.
THAT HAD SEAMSTRESSES YOU ALL OF
OUR COSTUMES FOR ALL OTHER
CHARACTERS THAT LEFT FULLERTON
CALIFORNIA.
FOR ORLANDO.
THE BOTTOM LINE IS THAT OUR
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT IS.
IN BAD SHAPE.
THIS BILL.
IS GOING TO PLACE A NON ENORMOUS
BURDEN.
I NOT ONLY LARGE BUSINESS BUT
SMALL BUSINESSES THAT REALLY ARE
THE FABRIC.
OF WHAT'S LEFT OF THE ECONOMY.
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
DISCOUNTING GAG.
HOLLYWOOD. AND SILICON VALLEY.
BY WIDELY EXPANDING THE SCOPE BY
WHICH A CONSUMER CONSUMER
COMPANIES THIS BILL SIMPLY IS
GOING TO BE LINING THE COP
POCKETS OF CONSUMER CLASS ACTION
ATTORNEYS.
ESPECIALLY SINCE THE CONSUMER
DOESN'T EVEN HAVE TO SHOW THAT
THEIR DATA HAS BEEN BREACHED LET
ALONE. ANY DAMAGE.
I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT.
THAT THE VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA
HAVE APPROVED PROP SIXTY FOUR
WHICH LIMITS SHAKEDOWN LAWSUITS.
BUT MAINLY RESULT IN LIEU. WHEN
FALLS.
FOR UNSCRUPULOUS LAWYERS.
AND HIGHER PRICES WHICH ARE
ULTIMATELY PASSED DOWN TO OUR
CONSUMERS.
BECAUSE OF THE HIGHER.
FRIVOLOUS LITIGATION COSTS.
CURRENT LAW ALREADY REQUIRES
COMPANIES THAT HAVE BEEN
BREACHED.
TO HELP CONSUMERS TAKE SEX
ACTION BY MANDATING THAT THEY
PROVIDE FREE IDENTITY THEFT IN
MITIGATION MEASURES.
LIKE EXPERIENCE HAD TO DO.
LIKE CREDIT REPORTING SERVICES
FOR AT LEAST ONE YEAR.
UNDER THE CURRENT LAW COMPANIES
ALWAYS HAVE AN INCENTIVE TO ACT
QUICKLY AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.
THE NOTIFY CONSUMERS AND DO AS
MUCH.
POSSIBLE TO MITIGATE THEIR HARM.
S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY ONE
DIMINISHES THIS INCENTIVE
BECAUSE.
IF THIS BILL IS ADOPTED.
A COMPANY THAT ACTS AGGRESSIVELY
TOOL LEMONADE INJURY TO
CUSTOMERS WILL BE EXPOSED TO THE
SAME HIGH ABILITY. AS A COMPANY
THAT THE LAYS ANNOUNCING A DATA
BREACH AND FAILS TO OFFER ANY
MITIGATION MEASURES.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN OF THE
SENATE.
THIS IS A HORRIFIC BILL. FOR
BUSINESS IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THAT INAPPROPRIATELY.
CRIMINALIZES.
AND PENALIZES.
BUSINESSES AND INVEST MILLIONS
OF DOLLARS TO PROTECT THE DATA.
FOR MONTHS SCRUPULOUS.
WORLDWIDE CRIMINALS AT SEEK TO
TAP THAT INFORMATION LET'S NOT.
CONTINUALLY IMPACT AND PENALIZE
THE BUSINESS IS THE STATE
CALIFORNIA LET'S BE UNITED IN
STAND FOR BUSINESSES. AND HELP
THEM DO WHAT WE CAN TO
STRENGTHEN THEIR DATA.
TO PREVENT IT FROM GOING TO
ROGUE. COUNTRIES INTO ROGUE
INDIVIDUALS THAT LOOK TO EXPLOIT.
THE CUSTOMERS TAKE THEIR MONEY
AND TAKE THEIR PRIVACY AWAY.
AGAIN LET'S NOT CRIMINALIZE OUR
BUSINESSES LET'S GO AFTER THE
ROAD CRIMINALS THAT ARE CAUSING
THE DAMAGE.
I URGE YOU PLEASE.
IN THE INTEREST A BUSINESS IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA PLEASE
VOTE NO ON S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY
ONE.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE SENATOR
ROTH.
THEY BETTER PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES
THIS A BILL COVERS.
A VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE IT'S
IMPORTANT ALL OF US IT'S
IMPORTANT TO THE LEGISLATURE.
IT'S IMPORTANT TO EACH AND
EVERYONE OF OUR CONSTITUENTS.
BUT.
.
SINCE WE'RE IN THE PROCESS OF
AUTHORIZING IN ESSENCE A LEGAL
CLAIM.
FOUR A VIOLATION OF WHAT WE'RE
ABOUT TO VOTE ON.
I THINK WE NEED TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE PROPERLY DEFINE WHAT
CONSTITUTES A BREACH.
AND MAKE SURE THAT A BREACH AS
DEFINED ULTIMATELY IN THIS
LEGISLATION IS ACTUALLY LIMITED
TO. SITUATIONS WHERE PERSONAL
DATA IS ACTUALLY EXCESS.
NOW I'LL BE SUPPORTING THE
MEASURE TODAY.
I KNOW I HAVE THE COMMITMENT OF
THE AUTHOR.
TO WORK ON THIS ISSUE AND I LOOK
FORWARD TO SEEING SOME LANGUAGE
IN THE BILL. COVERING THE POINT
THAT I JUST MADE WHEN IT RETURNS
TO THIS HOUSE FROM THE OTHER
SIDE SO.
BOB B. SUPPORTING THE BILL WITH
MY AYE VOTE TODAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR ROTH SENATOR
ALAN.
THANK YOU MEMBERS OWN A BILL OF
IT ON THE COMMENTS BY THE
SENATOR FROM RIVERSIDE AND AN
*.
I THROUGH THE CHAIR A QUESTION
OF THE AUTHOR.
WELL I THINK THAT THE WITH WITH
WITH PERMISSION.
I ARE YOU GONNA COMMENT FIRST OR
ELSE QUESTION.
IF THE COMMENT IN QUESTION.
FELL IS WILL THE AUTHOR TAKE A
QUESTION. ONLY A COMMENT A
QUESTION HAD TO DO IT WE'RE GOOD
SHAPE CENTER ALLEN PLEASE
PROCEED SO I APPRECIATE OUR
CONVERSATIONS.
SENATOR AND AND AND I THINK THE
KEY ISSUE THAT HAS BEEN MS
REALLY.
TROUBLED ME ON THIS BILL.
IS THIS CORE QUESTION OF.
OF MAKING SURE THAT THAT.
THE BUSINESSES DON'T END UP IN A
PLACE WHERE THEY'RE LIABLE TO
ALL OF THE SORTS OF.
EXCESSES
I THAT HAVE BEEN DESCRIBED BY
THE SENATOR FROM TO MACULA.
FROM FOLKS ON THE ON THE
PLAINTIFFS BAR AND. YOU KNOW ONE
OF THE QUESTIONS THAT CAME UP IN
FACT I THINK THERE WAS SOMEONE.
WHO WAS SPEAKING IN FAVOR OF
YOUR BILL AND COMMITTEE? WHO
SAID WELL IF THE BUSINESS HERE
SIMPLY DOWNLOADS NORTON?
ANTIVIRUS SOFTWARE THOUGH BILL
BE FINE SO THE QUESTION IS.
IS THERE SOME SORT OF A WHAT
GOOD CAN YOU WORK WITH WHAT
WOULD YOU KNOW ARE DO YOU HAVE A
FIRM COMMITMENT TO WORK.
WITH THE FOLKS RAISED CONCERNS
ABOUT THIS BILL.
TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S SOME
SORT OF.
PASSENGERS SAFE HARBOR THAT
BUSINESSES NO OKAY IF I TAKE THE
STEPS TO PROTECT.
CONSUMERS DATA I WILL BE FINE I
OR I WILL BE I WILL BE SICK
PROTECTED FROM A FRIVOLOUS
LAWSUIT UNDER THE SPELL.
YET I HAD.
TO THE SENATOR FROM BY SANTA
MONICA APPRECIATE THOSE COMMENTS
CONTENTS THAT'S A DIFFERENT I
MEAN OBVIOUSLY. THAT IS BEEN.
TOPIC OF DISCUSSION FROM THE
COMMITTEES.
DISCUSSION THAT WE HAD THROUGH
TODAY. AND I WOULD BE.
APPRECIATIVE OF BEING ABLE TO
WORK I WITH MY FELLOW SENATORS
ON.
THOSE TYPE OF AMENDMENTS
THAT WOULD BE ABLE TO.
MAKE SURE THAT THOSE.
COMPANIES DO AB A SAFE HARBOR.
THAT DO INSTITUTE REASONABLE
MEASURES.
TO PROTECT CONSUMERS.
CREDIT PROFILES.
YEAH THE APPRECIATE APPRECIATE
AN ANSWER GREAT DEAL IT'S MY
SENSE THAT WE DO NEED TO PROVIDE.
A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF.
OF SPECIFICITY OR OR OR GUIDANCE
TO BUSINESSES SO THAT THEY KNOW
IF I FOLLOW THESE REASONABLE
PROCEDURES.
I'LL BE OKAY I I SEE WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO I APPRECIATE
WHICH FRIEND DO I SUPPORT WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO. AND THAT IS
MAKE SURE THAT.
WHEN PEOPLE ENTER INTO THE
MARKETPLACE ONLINE THAT THEY'RE
NOT PUTTING ALL OF THEIR DATA
AND PRIVACY AT RISK JUST BECAUSE
THEY WANT TO PURCHASE SOMETHING
WHERE THEY WERE JUST BECAUSE
THEY WANT TO ENGAGE IN. IN IN.
MODERN LIFE WORK WHICH REQUIRES
ONLINE ACTIVITY.
AND YET. I DID IS IMPORTANT AND
I I KNOW YOU AGREE WITH ME ON
THIS IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE PUT
IN PLACE REASONABLE PROTECTIONS
FOR BUSINESSES. SO THAT THEY'RE
NOT JUST GONNA BE SUBJECT*
NILLY TO.
TO TO LAWSUITS.
THAT THAT ARE OUT THERE IS
ESSENTIALLY FISHING EXPEDITIONS.
THANK YOU.
SENATOR HILL.
THE PRESIDENT AND I I RISE TO TO
SUPPORT THIS LEGISLATION AND A
AND I KNOW IN TALKING WITH THE
OF THE GOOD AUTHOR FROM FROM
NAPA. THAT THE ISSUES THAT HAVE
BEEN RAISED BY.
OUR COLLEAGUES AND CERTAINLY
SOME OF THE QUESTIONS THAT I
HAVE THAT THE REASONABLENESS IN
THAT THE. THE ISSUES OF UP THE
FRIVOLOUS LAWSUIT PROBLEM THAT
COULD COME UP IN THE ISSUE THAT
THE FACT THAT THERE. ARE AREAS
WHERE BUSINESSES MAY BE
VULNERABLE TO TO SHOOT WHEN NOT
WHEN THEY SHOULDN'T BE.
THAT THE AUTHOR HAS TO REALLY I
THINK MADE A COMMITMENT A STRONG
COMMITMENT THAT HE WILL WORK ON
THAT IN THE SECOND HOUSE AND AND
RESOLVE THOSE ISSUES SO ARE. YOU
HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY
THANK YOU CENTER HILL SENATOR
GAINES.
THAT THANK YOU.
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SIGN.
VERY CONCERNED.
ABOUT THE LOW.
THE LEGISLATION TERMS WHAT
IMPACT WOULD BE ON SMALL
BUSINESS.
.
VIGGO AUTHORS.
DOING SOMETHING VERY LAUDABLE
TRYING TO RESOLVE.
THIS ISSUE WHICH CLEARLY IS A
PROBLEM IN TERMS OF DATA BREACH
BUT. WE TAKE A LOOK AT THE
DETAIL OF UP TO A THOUSAND
DOLLAR.
FINER.
.
DAMAGE PER PERSON.
YOU COULD HAVE A SMALL BUSINESS
WITH A THOUSAND CUSTOMERS.
AND IBM MILLION DOLLARS.
CIVIL LIABILITY OF THE SMALL
BUSINESS OF A DAY BASICALLY
BANKRUPTED.
AND WITH THE BALLOT INITIATIVE.
IF THAT IS ADOPTED.
THAT MY ABILITY WITH. THE
INCREASE FROM A MILLION TO TWO
MILLION.
SO.
I CANNOT SUPPORT THE BILL IN
ITS. CURRENT FASHION AND MY HOPE
WOULD BE THAT THE AUTHOR WOULD A
PLEASE TAKE A LOOK AT THE IMPACT
WE DON'T WANT TO PUT BUSINESSES
OUT OF BUSINESS.
WE WANT TO TRY TO STOP THE
BREACHES FROM OCCURRING SO.
AT THIS POINT I AM OPPOSE THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR GAINES CENTER
HERTZBERG.
JUST VERY BRIEFLY I CAME TO THE
FLOOR TODAY UNDECIDED ABOUT WHAT
I WAS GONNA VOTE ON THIS BILL.
AT BUT I A GIVEN THE A
QUESTIONS THE A COMMENTING
QUESTION AS AS SUPPORTED BY THE
OTHER SENATORS ON WITH A.
SUPPORTED TODAY ON THE GOOD
FAITH THAT AND INTEGRITY OF THE
AUTHOR WHO IS IT A GREAT
GENTLEMAN AND I THINK THAT HE
UNDERSTANDS THE SENSITIVITY TO
THE. LARGER LIABILITY ISSUE AND
SO I WILL BE VOTING AT TODAY
WITH THAT ASSURANCE LIKE SO MUCH.
THANK YOU SENATOR HERTZBERG
CENTER DAHLE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
YES.
MEMBERS.
IN CLOSING.
.
I I AM A BUSINESSMAN MOVES RAN A
BIT OF A BUSINESS FOR OVER
TWENTY FIVE YEARS.
I AND I WOULD AS THIS BILL IS
BEING CRAFTED WE WANTED TO MAKE
SURE THAT SMALL BUSINESSES WERE
NOT CAUGHT UP.
IN THE END IN THIS LEGISLATION.
AND IT MOST SMALL BUSINESSES USE
OFF THE SHELF SOFTWARE ANY THOSE
TYPE OF PATCHES. THEY
DEMONSTRATE THAT THOSE PATCHES
WERE INSTALLED THEY'RE EXEMPT
FROM THIS BILL BUT I'VE
COMMITTED ALREADY IN THE SESSION
JUST THE A MOMENT AGO. THAT I
WILL WORK OUT WITH THE OTHER
SENATORS ANYBODY THAT WANTS TO
COMMENT ON FURTHER UP PROVISIONS
THAT WEAKEN A MAN. TO MAKE SURE
THAT.
THIS DOESN'T BECOME A MECCA FOR
LAWSUITS OVER NO HARM THAT'S
BEING DONE SO I APPRECIATE THE
COMMENTS I RESPECTFULLY ASK RIBA.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
NO. DAILY ON.
I DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE
HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONNING.
BY MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
PAN.
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO AYE KATHY. AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. ATKINS BY.
BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ONE MORE TIME.
BRADFORD.
I.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
CENTER MOVES A CALL MEMBERS IF I
CAN HAVE YOUR ATTENTION FOR JUST
A MOMENT BEFORE WE MOVE TO OUR
NEXT BILL I JUST WANNA LET YOU
KNOW THAT WE HAVE DISPENSED WITH
SIXTEEN BILLS TODAY. AND IT IS
ONE FORTY FOUR AND OUR GOAL IS
ONE HUNDRED SO I THINK WE SHOULD
DIG IN AND GET READY TO SPEND
SOME TIME TOGETHER WE'RE NOW
GOING TO MOVE TO FILE ITEM FIFTY
EIGHT. SENATOR HERTZBERG MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE FORTY FOUR BY
SENATOR HERTZBERG AND ACTUALLY
COMMUNITY PARA MEDICINE. CENTER
HERTZBERG THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT ONE OF THE GREAT ONE
OF THE MANY CHALLENGES WE FACE.
IN THE DELIVERY OF HEALTHCARE IS
THAT FIRST INSTANCE WHEN NINE
ONE ONE IS CALLED. AND THE FIRE
TRUCK OR AN AMBULANCE SHOWS UP
TO TAKE A PATIENT TO THE E. R.
THEY'RE REQUIRED TO TAKE THEM TO
THE E. R.. AND OFTEN WE SEE
REPEATED PATTERNS WERE SOMEBODY
MAY HAVE CERTAIN ISSUES THAT ARE
COMMON TO THOSE PARTICULAR
FIREFIGHTERS THEY COULD TAKE
THEM TO SOBER CENTER OR TO OTHER
TYPES OF. OF FACILITIES AND SO
WHAT YOU HAVE BEFORE HERE TODAY
IT S. B. NINE FORTY FOUR IS A
COMMITTEE COMMUNITY PER MEDICINE
ACT OF TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN.
THAT BASICALLY IN A VERY BROAD
WAY GIVES AUTHORITY TO LOCALS
SET SUB PROTOCOL IT SETS UP A
COMMISSION.
WITH A BROAD ARRAY OF OF OF
PROFESSIONALS TO SET UP
PROTOCOLS WITH RESPECT TO THOSE
CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH YOU
TAKE YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO DIVERT.
A FIREFIGHTER OR A AMBULANCE
PROVIDER WOULD BE ABLE TO DIVERT
SOMEBODY TO AN ALTERNATIVE PLACE
ALL WITHIN VERY STRICT PROTOCOLS
NOW. THIS THIS IS A GREAT A LOT
OF THE ISSUES WITH RESPECT TO.
FIREFIGHTERS AND OTHER HEALTH
CARE PROVIDERS AND WE HAVE BEEN
ENGAGED IN VERY SERIOUS AND
THOUGHTFUL AND MEANING FULL AND
HONEST CONVERSATIONS SPINOSUM
MEMBERS OF THIS HOUSE OF COME TO
ME WITH SOME CONCERNS. WHICH IF
THIS MEASURE GETS OUT I HAVE
MADE THE PERSONAL COMMITMENT TO
CONTINUE TO DEAL WITH BECAUSE AT
THE END OF THE DAY EVERYBODY
HERE CARES ABOUT THE SAME THING.
TAKING CARE OF PATIENTS MAKING
SURE PATIENTS HAVE THE HIGHEST
QUALITY OF CARE I ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE ON THIS MEASURE. BIG CENTER
HERTZBERG MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
BATES.
NOBEL.
BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LARA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
NO.
NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY STONE NOVI TACK.
BY.
BUT COUNTY.
I WINNER. BY WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ATKINS.
BY.
BELL.
BRADFORD.
I.
DELEON FULLER.
NO GALGIANI AYE.
HUESO.
I MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NELSON.
ROUGH.
SKINNER.
WILK.
BY.
BY TWENTY FOUR KNOWS SEVENTH THE
MEASURE PASSES.
EXCUSE ME TWENTY FIVE SEVEN
KNOWS MAJOR STILL PASSES.
FILE ITEM THIRTY SIX SENATOR
GLAZER.
UPS ACCUSE ME.
THIRTY SEVEN SENATOR ALAN.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE
A SENATOR ALAN AN ACCOLADE THE
SOLID WASTE
SENATOR ALLEN THAT YOU SO MUCH
MEMBERS MADAM PRESIDENT ABD ESKI
THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE IS A MUCH
NARROWER BILL THAN THE MEASURE
THAT. CAME UP BEFORE. I THIS
BILL IS FOCUSED ON REDUCING
WASTE FROM TAKE OUT FOOD
CONTAINERS AT STATE RUN
FACILITIES.
THAT CANNOT BE RECYCLED OR
COMPOSTED.
THE BILL REQUIRES THAT BY TWENTY
TWENTY ONE FOOD PROVIDES ITS
STATE PARKS.
BEACHES AND OTHER FACILITIES USE
ONLY SUSTAINABLE PACKAGING AND
CALLS ON THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
TO SET AN EXAMPLE FOR ALL.
FOOD SERVICE PROVIDERS IN THE
STATE AND GLOBALLY NOW RUN OUR
STATE OVER A HUNDRED FIFTEEN
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS HAVE ALREADY
PASSED. SOME FORM OF LOCAL
MEASURE AIMED AT REDUCING WASTE
FROM THE FOOD SECTOR.
HAVING THE STATE ALSO TAKE
ACTION WILL SPUR THE MARKET FOR
ALTERNATE PACKAGING AND DRIVE
DOWN.
THE COST FOR EVERYONE SINGLE
FOOD A SINGLE USE FOOD
CONTAINERS ARE A MAJOR COMPONENT
OF URBAN LETTER. AND THEY OFTEN
WIND UP IN WATERWAYS CLOGGING
MUNICIPAL STORM DRAINS POLLUTING
BAYS EVENTUALLY ENDING UP ON THE
OCEAN. WHERE THEY LEACH TOXINS
INTO THE WATER THIS LETTER IS
COSTING LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN CLEANUP
COSTS? EVERY YEAR A LOT OF MY
CITIES ARE FACED WITH THE
SITUATION IN ONE STUDY FOUND THE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACROSS
CALIFORNIA SPEND. FOUR HUNDRED
TWENTY EIGHT MILLION DOLLARS A
YEAR TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO PREVENT
LITTER IN STREETS AND STORM
DRAINS.
IT'S TIME TO TAKE THIS NEXT STEP
TO REDUCING LITTER AND WASTE
THIS IS A MODEST STEP BUT IT'S A
STEP THE CAN HELP TO MOVE THE
NEEDLE ON THIS ISSUE. AND ALLOWS
THE CITY CALIFORNIA SET THE
EXAMPLE AND ASK FOR YOUR I'VE ON
THIS MEAURE THANK YOU SENATOR
ALLEN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE HEARING AND SEEING NONE
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
BY BERRYHILL. NO BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
NO DAILY ON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
HE'LL.
I. HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
MORE LOCK.
MONEY I.
MORRELL.
NO.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
PAN.
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER THERE.
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT. NO MY COUNTY. AYE
WIENER AYE WILK.
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BRADFORD.
DELEON.
GALGIANI.
HERTZBERG.
I.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
CENTER MOVES A CALL.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM SEVENTY FOUR.
SENATOR ALLEN. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN SEVENTEEN BY
SENATOR ALAN AND ACT GOING TO
FISHERIES.
THANK YOU MARILYN THAT YOU'RE
GONNA PRESENT MEMBERS ASSESS
PRETENCE OF ANTI WILL
INCENTIVIZE CALIFORNIA'S.
SWORDFISH FISHING INDUSTRY TO
TRANSITION AWAY FROM HARMFUL
DRIFT GILL NETS.
THE MORE SUSTAINABLE GEAR TYPES
SUCH AS DEEP SAID DOING HERE
SYSTEMS BY ESTABLISHING A
VOLUNTARY PROGRAM TO BUY BACK
STATE. DRIFT ON THAT PERMITS A
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE FUNDS.
FISHERMEN WHO CHOOSE NOT TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE BUY BACK
PROGRAM.
WILL BE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO
USE TRIPPED ON A CURE FOR THE
NEXT FIVE YEARS.
THESE NATS CAPTURE AND KILL
DOLPHINS WHALES SEA TURTLES AND
SO MANY MORE THREATEN ENDANGERED
SPECIES.
CALIFORNIA'S ONLY STAY IN THE
COUNTRY TO ALLOW THE SECURE
STILL AND EVEN UNITED NATIONS
HAS BEEN THEM ON INTERNATIONAL
WATERS.
WE'RE USING THE LEADER ON THESE
KINDS OF ISSUES IT'S TIME THAT
WE WERE THE LAST ONES.
THIS IS THIS TIME WE'RE ACTUALLY
THE LAST ONES USING IS OUTDATED
DEAR IT'S TIME TO CHANGE THAT
IT'S A BALANCE REASONABLE
APPROACH. TO ENCOURAGE INDUSTRY
TO TRANSITION TO MORE
SUSTAINABLE GEAR THAT'S
AVAILABLE THAT WORKS. AND I ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN SENATOR
GAINES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS IF I COULD ASK A
QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
THEATER ELOISE TAKE A QUESTION
SALUTE PLEASE PROCEED CENTER
GAMES FAQ R. DUH. DISLIKE GET
CLARIFICATION IN TERMS OF THE.
.
TED CHILL LA.
DOLLAR CREDITS A COULD BE
AVAILABLE.
TO COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN FOR
CHANGING THEIR NETS.
AND I GUESS MY CONCERN IS I WANT
TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TRANSITION INTO THE.
.
A NET THAT CREATES.
LESS LOSS OF FAR.
I SEE LIFE AND.
MAYBE YOU COULD JUST EXPAND ON
THAT A LITTLE BIT AND DATA
PROVIDE COMFORT BECAUSE.
MY CONCERN IS YOU'VE GOT
FISHERMEN THAT.
BETTER MAKING A LIVING CURRENTLY.
AND YET.
.
IF FOR TRANSITIONING THEM OUT
ONE TO MAKE SURE THEY'RE ABLE TO
TRANSITION TO THE NEW TECHNOLOGY.
YEAH.
PLEASE PROCEED TO THE CHAIR VERY
MUCH APPRECIATE THE QUESTIONS BY
FROM MY MY FRIEND. I SO THE THE
IDEA IDEA OF THIS BILL IS TO
BASICALLY HAVE A BUY OUT PROGRAM
WHERE WE BUY OUT THE PERMITS.
AND THAT WITH WITH THE MONEY IF
FOLKS WANT TO CONTINUE IN
FISHING THEY CAN AND SURFACED
FISHING THEY CAN TRANSITION OVER
TO THE DEEP TABOO HERE OR OTHER
TYPES OF. OF GEAR IF THEY WANT
TO YOU ARE THE PEW.
FOLKS HAVE ACTUALLY STUDIED THIS
FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS AND THEY
ACTUALLY COME OUT WITH A STUDY
THAT SHOWS THAT THE DEEP SAID
BOO GEAR. IS MORE PROFITABLE
THAN THE DRIFT GILL NETS AND THE
REASON FOR THAT IS. THAT THE.
THE THE FISH THEY GET CAUGHT IN
THE DEEP THAT BOOING HERE ARE
MUCH LESS LIKELY TO BE DAMAGED.
THE THE DRIFT GILL NETS
ILLEGALLY THESE MILE LONG THAT'S
THAT TRAWL THE THE OCEAN AND AND
IT CATCHING A LOT OF MARINE LIFE
PARTNER IS MY WERE SO CONCERNED
ABOUT TRYING TO PHASE OUT THIS
TECHNOLOGIES BECAUSE.
TONS OF TURTLES AND WHALES AND
DOLPHINS GETS STUCK IN THESE
NIGHTS BUT THE FISH THEMSELVES
THE SWORDFISH END UP GETTING
CAUGHT AND DAMAGE IN THE PROCESS
TO USE WITH LOWER. QUALITY.
AND SO THE PEW FOLKS HAVE
ACTUALLY FOUND THAT THE DEEP THE
BILL YEARS MORE PROFITABLE. ARE
AND THE IDEA IS THAT WE'RE GONNA
BE PUTTING UP MONEY TO ALLOW
THEM TO MAKE THIS TRANSITION.
THAN YOU KNOW WE'VE GOT SOME
SOME PHILANTHROPIES AND
FOUNDATIONS THERE'S ALSO GOING
TO BE. YET IT WOULD BE TALKING
THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE SOME SORT
OF OF OF STATE CONTRIBUTIONS
WELL TO PROVIDE A POT OF MONEY
TO REALLY MAKE SURE THAT THEM
FISHERMEN ULTIMATELY MADE WHOLE.
THAT THEY'RE ABLE TO MAKE THE
TRANSITION AWAY FROM THIS MORE
DAMAGING GEAR. AND THAT THEY'LL
BE COMPENATED FOR IT.
GREAT IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING OF
THE FIFTY PERCENT.
LESS LOSS OF.
MARINE LIFE WHETHER IT'S.
DOLPH INNER.
I WAY LATERITE ETERNAL OR
SOMETHING OF THAT NATURE THAT'S
EXACTLY RIGHT VERY GOOD ON I'M
GOING TO SUPPORT THE LEGISLATION
AND IF YOU COULD JUST.
STAY IN COMMUNICATION AND
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH A
COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN.
FOR THAT OPPORTUNITY FOR
TRANSITION APPRECIATE THAT YOU
SENATOR GREAT YOU THINK YOU
CENTER GAINES CENTER JACKSON.
THIS VERY BRIEFLY I WANT TO.
COMMEND THE AUTHOR FOR WORKING
SO DILIGENTLY TO TRY TO ADDRESS
THE THE CONCERNS AS ARTICULATED
BY OUR COLLEAGUE GO PREVIOUSLY
AND DOC. A WITH THE COMMITMENT
THAT WE WILL CONTINUE WORKING
WITH THOSE WHO ARE GOING TO BE
IMPACTED BY THIS THERE ARE
PARTICULARLY. A NUMBER OF
FISHERMEN IN IN MY DISTRICT TO
HAVE BEEN GOOD STEWARDS OF THE
OCEAN. OF WHO ARE GOING TO BE
AFFECTED.
WE WANT THEM TO CONTINUE
FISHING BECAUSE THEY HAVE THAT
SENSE OF RESPONSIBILITY AND
HISTORY WITH THE OCEAN AND OUR
MARINE. A LIFE THAT IS THE KIND
OF SUSTAINABLE APPROACH.
OF THAT IS SO CRITICALLY
IMPORTANT AS WE GO FORWARD THEY
ARE GOING TO BE IMPACTED AND.
WITH THE COMMITMENT ALL OF THE
AUTHOR THAT WE WILL TRY TO
ENGAGED AND HAVE CONVERSATION
WITH THEM SO THAT THEY CAN.
GO FORWARD THAT THEY CAN BE
PROPERLY COMPENSATED AND
CONTINUE WITH THEIR CAREERS I
WILL LAW. ARE ALSO WERE CHIN
IPHONE.
THANK YOU SENATOR JACKSON'S
SENATOR MCGUIRE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH A MATTER
PRESIDENT MEMBERS.
FEW ITEMS A INCLUDING OF WHAT
THE COULD CENTER FOR SANTA
BARBARA AS WELL SENATORS EL
DORADO I'D. JUST MENTIONED IN
NUMBER ONE.
APPRECIATE.
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM SANTA
MONICA OUT WORKING ON THIS ISSUE
BY NOW THAT IT'S EXTREMELY
DIFFICULT. OM AND YOU ARE
WAITING INTO A BATTLE THAT'S
BEEN ADDED FOR QUITE SOMETIME IN
GRATEFUL I THAT YOU HAVE BEEN
DOING THIS IN A VERY SINCERE
MANNER.
JUST A FEW ITEMS AND HAD THE
ABILITY TO THEIR TOP OF THE
SENATOR PRYOR OUGHT TO THESE
WORDS NUMBER ONE. THEY DO WE
GEAR IS STILL BEING TESTED AYE
AND THOUGHT THE SUCCESS RATE OF
THAT BUT WE GEAR. IT'S CANDIDLY
STILL EXPERIMENTAL THAT SAID ARE
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM SANTA
MONICA HAS SAID. THAT HE'S GOING
TO CONTINUE TO WORKING WITH
FISHERMEN AND THE REASON WHY
THAT IS SO IMPORTANT.
IS THAT THESE COMMERCIAL
FISHERMEN THIS IS ALL THEY'VE
EVER KNOWN.
EVERYTHING THEY'VE INVESTED IN
THEIR BOAT IN THEIR OPERATION IS
WHAT THEIR RETIREMENT IT'S GOING
TO BE. AND HOW THEIR KIDS ARE
GONNA BE SUPPORTED LONG TERM.
AND WHILE THERE HAS BEEN
PROGRESS MADE AND I'M GRATEFUL
TO THE SENATOR FOR STICKING WITH
HIS COMMITMENT.
NOW AMENDED IN THE BILL IS.
BURBAGE HIS HAS UPON
APPROPRIATION OF THE LEGISLATURE.
OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO HELP FIND
SOME TYPE OF SETTLEMENT INDOOR
THAT CDF W. CAPITA HARTMAN
OFFICIAL WILDLIFE WHO NEEDS TO
WORK. OUT WITH PRIVATE
ENTERPRISES MAYBE JUST LIKE YOU
OUGHT TO BE ABLE TO HELP FIND
SOME TYPE OF SETTLEMENT.
THEY'RE STILL NEEDS TO BE WORK
THAT HAS TO BE COMPLETED AND
THAT'S THE ONE AREA THAT.
AS DISAGREED CENTER FROM SANTA
BARBARA JUST MENTION MAKING SURE
THAT THERE IS A COMMITMENT AS WE
MOVE FORWARD THAT THERE'S A
COMMITMENT. I ON BEHALF OF THE
FLEET IF THEY'RE GOING TO BE
ABLE TRANSITION WITH GRACE.
I THINK THAT'S THE MOST
IMPORTANT PART OF ALL OF THIS I
THINK THAT'S THE MOST IMPORTANT
PART FLEET.
MY LAST FINAL SAY MADAM
PRESIDENT IS I ALSO KNOW THAT
THE SENATOR HAS BEEN. TRYING TO
BE ABLE TO GET FOLKS AT THE
TABLE THIS IS A VERY CHALLENGING
SUBJECT KNOW THAT THERE'S BEEN
SOME HESITANCY ON OTHERS I TO BE
TO COME TO THE TABLE BUT IT'S
BECAUSE.
THEY'RE FEARFUL THEY'RE FEARFUL
THAT THEIR ENTIRE LIFE MAY BE
GOING AWAY WITH THIS AYE AND
KNOW THAT THE CENTER IS GOING TO
CONTINUE TO WORK AND GRATEFUL
FOR THAT. IN HAPPY IN YOUR
CLOSING TO BE HERE ANY COMMENTS
YOU MAY HAVE THANK YOU IN PRISON.
THANK YOU SENATOR MCGUIRE
SENATOR ANDERSON. AS A SENATORS
I RISE IN SUPPORT IDEA.
I THINK THIS IS A THOUGHTFUL
BALANCED.
.
SPORTS FISHERMEN VERSUS
COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN.
AND I LIKE THE IDEA THAT'S A
PRIVATE PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP YOU
KNOW IN CEO COUNTY WE HAVE A LOT
OF SPORTS FISHERMEN IN THIS IS
VERY IMPORTANT TO US.
BUT WE ALSO USED TO HAVE A TUNA
INDUSTRY THAT THAT.
LEFT THE U. S..
AND TOOK ONLINE OTHER COUNTRIES
FLAGS TO CONTINUE THEIR
OPERATION.
BECAUSE THERE WAS NOBODY OUT
THERE THAT WAS WORKING FOR A
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP.
TO REPLACE WHAT THEY NEEDED TO
DO IN ORDER TO SURVIVE HEARING
IN CALIFORNIA AND I THINK THIS
BILL. ARE IN THINK YOU TO THE
AUTHOR FOR BEING THOUGHTFULNESS
APPROACH.
DOES THAT PAYMENTS ALLOWS THEM
TO CONTINUE. THEIR LIFELONG
CAREER AND ALLOWS THEM A A
FUTURE. ANTECEDENT TIME IT
BALANCES SPORTS FISHERMEN AND
THEIR NEEDS.
IT'S RARE THAT WE HAVE A BILL ON
THIS FLOOR THAT.
REACHES THAT BALANCE AND I
ALWAYS THINK IT'S
TOUGH WHEN YOU WADE INTO THE
DEEP WATER.
TO COME OUT A SURVIVOR AND.
MY COMPLIMENTS TO THE AUTHOR.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON
THUNDERSTONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
.
AS THE VICE CHAIR OF A NATURAL
RESOURCES IN WATER I REMEMBER
THIS HEARING VERY WELL.
IN HAVING A NUMBER OF.
SMALLER FISHER MEN AND WOMEN.
THAT HAVE SUCCESSFULLY USED TO
DRIFT GILL NET. THAT CLAIMED
THAT.
SHOULD WE MAKE THE CHANGES THAT
ARE. ARTICULATED IN THIS BILL
THAT WOULD PUT GENERATIONS OF
FAMILIES OUT OF BUSINESS AND THE
AUTHOR DURING THAT HEARING. TOLD
US THAT HE WAS GOING TO BE
REACHING OUT TO THOSE SMALLER
FISHER.
ENTITIES FOR FISHERMEN FISHER
WOMAN ENTITIES TO AUSSIE IF
THERE'S SOME TYPE OF COMPROMISES
THAT CAN BE MADE TO ENSURE THEIR.
CONTINUED DOT COMMERCE IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND IF I.
MADAM PRESIDENT I MAY ASK THE
AUTHOR WHAT IS PROGRESS HAS BEEN
AND AND WORKING WITH THE SMALLER
FISHER.
MEN WOMEN ENTITIES SET TO ENSURE
THEIR.
VIABILITY IN THE FUTURE IF THIS
WERE TO ME THOROUGHLY TAKE A
QUESTION OF SALUTE PLEASE
PROCEED SO THEY GET SENATOR FROM
THE NORTH COAST ALLUDED TO THIS.
I ACTUALLY CALLED.
A LONG LIST OF FISHERMEN HAD
VERY POSITIVE CONVERSATIONS.
I AND AND AND A WHOLE NUMBER OF
THEM HAD AGREED TO COME TO A
MEETING THAT WE HAD SCHEDULED.
FOR A COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO AND
THEN I TWO DAYS BEFORE.
THEY PULLED OUT.
AND WE DIDN'T REALLY KNOW WHY.
WERE STILL VERY COMMITTED TO
HAVING THAT OPPORTUNITY FOR TYPE
OF ONE SIT DOWN.
YOU KNOW AND WE'VE MADE IT VERY
CLEAR OVER AND OVER AND OVER
AGAIN THAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT
MAKING AN EFFECTIVE TRANSITION
THAT WILL. YOU KNOW.
THAT IT WILL ACTUALLY ALLOW
PEOPLE TO CAN STAY ON THEIR FEET.
KEEP DOING THEIR WORK OR MOVE
OUT OF THE BUSINESS IF THEY WANT
TO BE COMPENSATED FOR IT.
OUR BUT IT BUT YOU KNOW THIS IS
WHAT THE SENATOR WAS ALLUDING TO
WHEN HE TALKED ABOUT HOW
CHALLENGING IS I'M VERY
COMMITTED TO. YOU KNOW TED
CONTINUE THAT CONVERSATION AND
REACHING OUT TO THEM IN ENGAGING
WITH THEM AND.
AND AND GETTING TO A PLACE WHERE
WE CAN ALL COME TO AN AGREEMENT.
THANK ON MY OWN TIME PLEASE
PLEASE PROCEED THINK ABOUT A
PRESIDENT I WANT TO COMPLIMENT
TO MY COLLEAGUE FROM LOSANGELES
AND REACHING OUT TO THOSE A
SMALL FISHING ENTITIES.
AND.
.
I HAVE TO ADMIT THAT I DON'T
HAVE A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF
COASTLINE IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
THANKS ORANGE COUNTY.
AND.
WE DO BORDER MY DISTRICT AS
BOARD OF THE COLORADO RIVER
WHICH IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT
ENTITY IN ITSELF.
I'M GONNA REACH OUT TO THOSE
SMALLFISHERMEN AND BY THE WAY I
DON'T FISH RECREATIONALLY. I
DON'T FISH IN THE SPORTING. WAY
I'M JUST NOT A FISHERMAN.
AND I'M CERTAINLY NOT GOING TO
CARRY WATER FOR PEOPLE THAT ARE
WILLING TO MEET WITH YOU AND
SHARE THEIR CONCERNS.
SO TODAY EMILY OFF YOUR BILL IF
THEY DON'T STEP UP TO THE PLATE
AND EXPRESS THEIR CONTINUE
CONCERNS TO YOU.
THEN I WILL BE SUPPORTING YOUR
BILL THAT IF IT COMES BACK WITH
ANY AMENDMENTS
SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR EFFORTS.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE CENTER
MONNING THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT.
.
I APPRECIATE THE TIME THAT
PEOPLE DEVOTED TO THIS I KNOW.
IN THE INTEREST OF TIME WE DO
NEED TO MOVE FORWARD. BUT I
REPRESENT A BROAD CONSTITUENCY
THAT'S
HAS A KEEN INTEREST IN THIS BILL
BOTH THE FISHING COMMUNITY. AND
THOSE WHO ARE WORKING.
TOWARD SUSTAINABLE FISHERIES IN
MY DISTRICT AND I'VE HAD A
CHANCE TO ENGAGE WITH THE AUTHOR
I WANT TO THANK HIM FOR HIS
OUTREACH TO.
THE FISHING COMMUNITY IN MY
DISTRICT TEN I'LL BE SUPPORTIVE
TODAY I DO LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUE DIALOGUE AS THIS BILL
MOVES TO THE ASSEMBLY. AND.
WOULD HOPE THAT ALL
STAKEHOLDERS TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
OF AN OPEN TRANSPARENT PROCESS
HERE IN THE STATE LEGISLATURE.
TO MAKE SURE THEIR INTERESTS ARE
HEARD AND A TO THE EXTENT
POSSIBLE I KNOW THE AUTHORS
COMMITTED.
TO THOSE STAKEHOLDERS SIN FAMILY
BUSINESSES ARE THAT HAVE BEEN
THERE FOR A LONG TIME SO THANK
YOU AYE URGENT AYE VOTE. BIGGEST
UNDERMINING SENATOR BATES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENTE I
ACTUALLY HAVE THE.
WHEN HE'S VERY DIFFICULT
POSITIONS I HAVE A SPLIT AYE
REPRESENTING ALSO. A SENATOR
FROM ORANGE COUNTY INDIANA POINT
HARBOR MANY MANY SPORT FISHERMAN.
AFFICHER FAMILIES INCLUDING MY
OWN WE OWN A BOAT AND WE DO
OCCASIONAL SPORTFISHING AND ALSO
I REPRESENT A NUMBER OF THE
COMMERCIAL ON SMALLER I FAMILIES
THAT ARE INVOLVED IN THERE SO. I
THINK TODAY I WILL LAY OFF THE
BILL IN IN.
IN HOPES THAT THE CONVERSATIONS
GOING FORWARD AND I UNDERSTAND
THERE ARE ONLY SEVENTEEN. BIO A
COMPANIES OR INDIVIDUALS THAT
HAVE THESE FEDERAL LICENSES THAT
SEEMS TO BE A SMALL UNIVERSE.
THAT I SHOULD BE VERY MUCH A
PART OF THE CONVERSATION ARE I'M
NOT UNDERSTANDING WHY THAT CAN'T
BE GRANDFATHERED IN IN TERMS OF
AN EXCEPTION. TO THOSE WHO
CURRENTLY HA HAVE THOSE LICENSES
THEIR CONCERN IS ONE THAT THEY
WILL BE PROHIBITED. OFF FROM
FISHING IN THE.
MATTER THAT THEY HAVE FOR YEARS
AND YEARS AND THOSE FROM FOREIGN
COURTS WILL BE ABLE TO APPLY OUR
FEDERAL WATERS SANTA ACTUALLY
TAKE OVER. THE FISHING INDUSTRY
AND PUTTING ALL OF THESE
INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR FAMILIES
BY IN THE PRESENT AND THE FUTURE
OUT OF BUSINESS THAT'S OF GREAT
CONCERN I THINK TO ALL OF US.
ARE NO MATTER WHAT SIDE OF THE
ISSUE WE'RE ON HERE SO IT'S MY
HOPE IN YOUR DISCUSSIONS INCLUDE.
ALL OF THOSE AT THE AT THE SAME
TABLE SO THERE CAN BE SOME.
COMPROMISE AND CONSENSUS TO
PROTECT OUR BOTH OUR OF. FRIENDS
IN THE OCEAN AND THOSE WHO DO I
DO THAT IT'S A LIVELIHOOD SCHOOL
I WISH YOU THE BEST IN DOING
THAT I'D LIKE TO BE PART OF THAT
DISCUSSION. HIGH AT THE
APPROPRIATE TIME BUT TODAY I
WILL LAY OFF THE BILL I VOTED NO
ON A PROBES. FOR THE NOT THE
POLICY BUT CERTAINLY ARE THE OF
FINANCIAL ISSUES ARE THERE'S A
HUGE POLICY ISSUE HERE THAT
NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED. ARE IN
THOSE ROUNDTABLES
SO OUT TODAY I WILL LAY OFF IN
HOPE GOING FORWARD WE WILL FIND
OUT. A SPECIAL SPOT THAT PLEASES
BOTH SIDES.
THANK YOU SENATOR BATES FULLER
ALLEN PLEASE CLOSE. THANK YOU
MEMBERS FOR THE THOUGHTFUL
DISCUSSION JUST TO FOLLOW UP ON-MADAM MY MINORITY LEADER'S
COMMENTS.
WERE WHERE ABSOLUTELY COMMITTED
TO TEND TO HAVE CONTINUE
THOUGHTFUL DISCUSSION WITH.
WITH THAT WITH THE FOLKS FROM
YOU KNOW FROM BOTH SIDES OF THIS
DEBATE.
THIS IS VERY MUCH SUPPORTED BY
THIS THE SPORTS FISHERMEN.
.
AND YOU KNOW I I THINK THEY WERE
YOU KNOW WE'LL GET WE'LL BE ABLE
TO GET TO A PLACE AYE I REALLY
DO HOPE WE'LL GET TO A PLACE
WHERE. WHERE PEOPLE DO FEEL AS
THOUGH THEY'RE MADE HOLES SO I
WITH THAT I RESPECT YESTERDAY
VOTE? THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I.
ATKINS.
BY BATES.
BILL.
BY BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. AYE DELEON.
BYE DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I.
GLAZER.
BY.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
BY HILL AYE HUESO. AYE JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORLOCK.
MORRELL.
BY NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
NELSON.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY STONE.
RIGHT ACT.
BY KATHY.
BY WINNER.
BY WILK. AYE.
LET'S GO THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES.
FULLER.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
WHEN.
NELSON.
ROTH.
SKINNER RIGHT.
EYES TWENTY NINE KNOWS ZEROTH
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
ARE GOING TO GO TO FILE ITEM
THIRTY SEVEN AND LIFT THE CALL.
SB THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE. MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
DELEON.
I.
GALGIANI.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ONE MORE TIME. BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
ARE NOW MOVING TO FILE ITEM ONE
HUNDRED SENATOR DE LEóN.
I PREPARED TO TAKE THAT UP.
NO.
OKAY SCRATCH IT GOT IT.
EXCELLENT.
A VERY.
MEMBERS.
GOOD AFTERNOON.
WE'RE GOING TO ALLOW THE
PRESIDING OFFICER THINNER LEYVA
TO BE A TO TAKE UP. FIVE BILLS
HERE TODAY.
WE ARE THEN GOING TO GET BACK TO
OUR NORMAL FILE ORDER.
AFTER.
SENATOR LEYVA TAKES UP FILE ITEM
SIXTY ONE SEVENTY NINE EIGHTY
SEVEN NINETY ONE ONE TWENTY
EIGHT. WILL BE STARTING BACK AT
FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR.
WILL THEN PROCEED WITH THAT
WHILE WATER. OUT FOR THE
REMAINDER OF THE DAY IN WERE
VERY VRY GRATEFUL FOR YOUR
PATIENCE HERE TODAY.
SO CENTER LEYVA IS PREPARED TO
BE TO TAKE UP FILE ORDER NUMBER
SIXTY ONE.
SHE SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE SIXTY BEST
ENTERED LEYVA AND ACT GOING TO
CORRECTIONS
THERE LIMON THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS
LAST YEAR THE STATE AUDITOR
CONDUCTED AN AUDIT UPON MY
REQUEST. TO INVESTIGATE THE
GROWING INMATE SUICIDE RATES IN
OUR STATE PRISONS
DURING HER ANALYSIS THE AUDITOR
DETAILED SEVERAL DEFICIENCIES
WITH CD R. CD SEE OURS PROTOCOL
FOR RESPONDING TO AND PREVENTING
SUICIDES.
THE REPORT REPORT NOTED THAT
SEVERAL STATE PRISONS FAILED TO
COMPLETE REQUIRED SUICIDE RISK
EVALUATIONS AND TREATMENT PLANS.
IN ADDITION PRISON STAFF DID NOT
PROPERLY MONITOR AT RISK INMATES
INCOMPLETE REQUIRED TRAININGS
RELAYED TO SUICIDE PREVENTION
AND RESPONSE.
FOCUSING ON THE AUDITOR'S
RECOMMENDATIONS S. B. NINE SIXTY
REQUIRES CDC ARE TO REPORT
ANNUALLY TO THE LEGISLATURE ON
ITS PLANS AND EFFORTS TO ADDRESS
FOUND DEFICIENCIES.
IN ADDITION THIS MEASURE
REQUIRES PRISON OFFICIALS TO
NOTIFY FAMILY MEMBERS AND LOVED
ONES WITHIN TWENTY FOUR HOURS
WHEN AN INMATE HAS HAS HAD A
SERIOUS INJURY. ILLNESS ATTEMPT
SUICIDE OR DIES WHILE IN CUSTODY.
S. B. NINE SIXTY IS BURKE
VITALLY IMPORTANT TO ENSURE THAT
INMATES ARE TREATED HUMANELY.
AND THAT THEY RECEIVE THE
SUPPORT AND CARE THAT THEY NEED
A RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR SENATORS
WE HAVE ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THE FLOOR ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR.
SEE NO.
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ON THIS ITEM.
SEE NO OBJECTION EYES THIRTY
FIVE NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WERE NOW GOING TO SKIP
FORWARD TO ITEM SEVENTY NINE.
SENATOR LATEST PREPARE TO TAKE
UP MISTER SECTOR CAN YOU PLEASE
READ. SENATE BILL TEN THIRTY
EIGHT BY SENATOR LEYVA AND ACT
REALLY INTO EMPLOYMENT. MADAM
CENTER.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT THANK
YOU MEMBERS S. B. TEN THIRTY
EIGHT WILL ENSURE THAT
INDIVIDUALS CAN BE HELD
PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR
RETALIATING AGAINST A PERSON FOR
EXERCISING THEIR RIGHTS. UNDER
THE FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING
ACT FEE HA UNDER CURRENT LAW A
PERSON MAY ALREADY BE HELD
PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR HARASSMENT
CLAIMS UNDER FEE HA. HOWEVER
INDIVIDUALS MAY NOT BE HELD
PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR
RETALIATION DUE TO
INTERPRETATION BY THE CALIFORNIA
SUPREME COURT WHICH RENDERED THE
ISSUE UNCLEAR.
IF THERE'S NO INDIVIDUAL
LIABILITY FOR RETALIATION YOU
MAY END UP INCENTIVIZING THE
HARASSER TO JUST GET RID OF THE
PERSON WHO WAS HARASSED.
IN THE END THE HARASSER MIGHT
EVEN AVOID LIABILITY FOR THE
HARASSMENT IF THEY SUCCESSFULLY
SILENCE THE VICTIM.
S. B. TEN THIRTY EIGHT WAS
AMENDED TO CLARIFY THAT THIS
BILL DOES NOT PLACE SOLE
LIABILITY ON MEET EITHER THE
INDIVIDUAL NOR THE EMPLOYER. IT
MERELY CREATES A JOINT AND
SEVERAL LIABILITY IT ALSO MAKES
IT EXPLICITLY CLEAR THAT THERE
MUST BE INTENT
TO RETALIATE.
AS WE HAVE SEEN IN THE ME TOO
AND WE SAID ENOUGH MOVEMENTS
THREATS OF RETALIATION OR ONE OF
THE BIGGEST BARRIERS FOR WOMEN
AND MEN WHO WISH TO SPEAK OUT OR
FILE SEXUAL HARASSMENT
COMPLAINTS.
THESE FEARS ARE CERTAINLY VALID
AND WELL FOUNDED.
WHEN REPORTS COME OUT THAT
SOMEONE HAS BEEN HARASSED IN THE
WORKPLACE ONE OF THE MOST COMMON
QUESTIONS THAT ARISES IS. WHY
DIDN'T SHE SAY ANYTHING
ACCORDING TO A TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN STUDY BY THE U. S. EQUAL
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY
COMMISSION? SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT
OF EMPLOYEES WHO SPOKE OUT
AGAINST WORKPLACE MISTREATMENT
FACE SOME FORM OF RETALIATION
SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT.
INDIVIDUALS NEED TO UNDERSTAND
THAT THERE WOULD THEY WILL BE
HELD ACCOUNTABLE IF THEY TRY TO
INTERFERE WITH THREATEN OR
OTHERWISE RETALIATE AGAINST
SOMEONE WHO'S MADE A SEXUAL
HARASSMENT CLAIM. WE MUST NEVER
ALLOW VICTIMS TO BE SILENCED
AGAIN I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE.
MEMBERS TO ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR.
SEE NINE MISTER SECRETARY CAN
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
NO DALY OWN.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON AYE LARA.
I LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LUCK
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT KNOW WHY CASKEY.
WIENER.
I WILK.
NO.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS.
BRADFORD. BY.
DALY OWN.
GAINES.
NO.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
NEWMAN.
NELSON ROTH.
SKINNER.
BY KATHY.
FEDERAL LEYVA MUSICAL.
MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM EIGHTY SEVEN.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN TWENTY FOUR
BY SENATOR LEYVA AND ACTUALLY
THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT
WELCOME BACK CENTER LEYVA.
THANK YOU SENATE'S BUT THE
SENATE MCGUIRE AND MEMBERS S. B.
ELEVEN TWENTY FOUR PROTECTS THE
RETIREMENT BENEFITS OF CALPERS
MEMBERS BY MAKING SURE THAT ANY
COLLECTIVELY BARGAINED
COMPENSATION. TOWARDS RETIREMENT
CANNOT BE FORCED TO BE PAID BACK
DUE TO INCORRECTLY REPORTED
INFORMATION BY THEIR EMPLOYERS
THIS MEASURE RESPONSE TO
INSTANCES WHERE THE COMPENSATION
INFORMATION OF RETIRED EMPLOYEES
WAS MISCALCULATED OR INCORRECTLY
REPORTED TO CALPERS. BY THEIR
EMPLOYERS IN THESE INSTANCES THE
RETIRED EMPLOYEES ARE FORCED TO
PAY BACK THE OVERPAID AMOUNT AND
EVEN SUFFER FUTURE REDUCTIONS IN
THEIR PENSION.
THESE RETIRED EMPLOYEES
SOMETIMES RELY ON FIXED INCOMES
AND SHOULD NOT HAVE TO TAKE
UNEXPECTED CUTS NO BENEFITS.
S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY FOUR GIVES
RETIREES THE PEACE OF MIND THAT
THEY WILL NOT BE FORCED TO PAY
MONEY BACK OR HAVE REDUCTIONS TO
THEIR FUTURE PAYMENTS BECAUSE OF
THEIR EMPLOYERS. ACCOUNTING OR
REPORTING ERRORS THIS BILL HAS
NO OPPOSITION AND IS SUPPORTED
BY THE CALIFORNIA PROFESSIONAL
FIREFIGHTERS PEACE OFFICERS
RESEARCH ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA AND THE RIVERSIDE
SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
MEMBERS TO ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR.
SEE NINE MISTER SECRETARY CAN
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. AYE ATKINS.
BATES.
I BILL.
BY BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER. AYE GAINES.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
ISLA.
I LEYVA.
I AM A CHOIR. BY MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK BY MERRELL.
BY NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
BY.
SKINNER.
I STERN.
STONE.
I'VE BIDAK BY WIECKOWSKI.
I WINNER.
I WILL.
I.
MR CENTER CAN YOU PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ATKINS.
BERRYHILL.
DALY OWN.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I.
HUESO.
BY MITCHELL.
I NIELSEN.
STERN.
EYES THIRTY THREE NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA BE MOVING ON
TO FILE ITEM NINETY ONE SENATOR
LEYVA MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FIFTY SIX BY
SENATOR LEYVA AND ACTING TO
HEALTH CARE SERVICE PLANS THE
FLOOR IS YOURS BEEN CENTER.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
AFTERNOON AGAIN MEMBERS S. B.
ELEVEN FIFTY SIX SETS
REQUIREMENTS FOR A PERSON OR
COMPANY THAT PURCHASES HEALTH
INSURANCE ON BEHALF OF SOMEONE
ELSE. IF THE PURCHASER STANDS TO
BENEFIT FINANCIALLY FROM THAT
POLICY THESE COMMONSENSE
REQUIREMENTS INCLUDE DISCLOSING
THE INTENTION TO PAY PREMIUMS ON
BEHALF OF A CONSUMER TO
REGULATORS. AGREEING NOT TO
STEER PATIENTS INTO OR AWAY FROM
A SPECIFIC COVERAGE OPTION
PROVIDING ASSISTANCE SOLELY ON
THE BASIS OF FINANCIAL ME.
REQUIRING THE THIRD PARTY TO PAY
PREMIUMS FOR THE ENTIRE PLAN
YEAR EVEN IF THE PATIENT STOPS
TREATMENT THAT BENEFIT PROVIDER.
THAT BENEFIT THE PROVIDER. IF
THE THIRD PARTY PAYER DOES NOT
MEET THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH
IN THE BILL THE ONLY
REPERCUSSION CONTAINED IN S. B.
ELEVEN FIFTY SIX IS THAT THE
FINANCIALLY INTERESTED PROVIDER
WOULD RECEIVE THE MEDICARE
REIMBURSEMENT RATES SERVICES.
FOR THE SERVICES PROVIDED TO
THAT PATIENT.
THIS BILL PROTECTS LEGITIMATE
THIRD PARTY PAYMENT MECHANISMS
REMOVES THE INCENTIVE FOR
PROVIDERS TO GAME THE SYSTEM AND
ESTABLISHES SAFEGUARDS TO HOLD
PATIENTS. WHO MAY HAVE
INADVERTENTLY BEEN CAUGHT UP IN
ONE OF THESE PAYMENT SCHEMES
HARMLESS ARE RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THIS BILL HAS
RECEIVED NO NO VOTES? AND HAS
RECEIVED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SENATOR.
MEMBERS TO ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR OF ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR.
THREE NINE MISTER SECRETARY CAN
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
I HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
I.
MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I AM MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL.
NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE AYE DECK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WINNER. AYE WILK.
BY.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ANDERSON
NO.
ATKINS.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
BERRYHILL AYE.
DELEON.
GAINES.
GLAZER.
AYE HUESO. AYE MORRELL.
NIELSEN.
ROUGH.
BROTHER.
EYES THIRTY TWO KNOWS ONE THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS ETCETERA LEYVA HAS ONE
FINAL BILL SHE'LL BE PRESENTING
TODAY.
WE ARE THEN GOING TO BE LIFTING
THE CALL AYE HERE MOMENTARILY.
ON FIVE BILLS WE'RE GONNA ASK
THAT ALL MEMBERS PLEASE STAY ON
THE FLOOR IN THE COMING MINUTES
ALL MEMBERS PLEASE STAND THE
FLOOR AS WE'RE GONNA BE LIFTING
THE CALL ON. NOW SIX BILLS ARE
HERE MOMENTARILY CENTER LEYVA IS
PREPARED TO PRESENT ON FILE ITEM
ONE TWENTY EIGHT.
YOUR SECTOR CAN YOU PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FORTY NINE
BY SENATOR LEYVA AND ACRYLATE
EVIDENCE.
CENTER LEYVA THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS.
THE CORE OF SP FOURTEEN FORTY
NINE IS ACTUALLY VERY SIMPLE AND
STRAIGHTFORWARD. BUT IT WILL
HAVE A TREMENDOUS IMPACT ON THE
LIVES OF SURVIVORS AND HELP TO
PUT RAPISTS BEHIND BARS.
THIS MEASURE SIMPLY CHANGES ONE
WORD IN EXISTING LAW BY SAYING
THAT LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES
AND FORENSIC LABORATORIES.
SHALL FOLLOW INSTEAD OF SHOULD
FOLLOW AS IT CURRENTLY STATES
LISTED TIME FRAMES FOR
SUBMITTING AND ANALYZING RAPE
KIT EVIDENCE.
MEMBERS MANY OF YOU KNOW THE
JUST TWO YEARS AGO GOVERNOR
BROWN SIGNED MY SB EIGHT
THIRTEEN WHICH ELIMINATED THE
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ON RATE
WHICH MANY OF YOU VOTED ON. ON
THIS FLOOR.
BUT KNOW THAT WAS CERTAINLY A
HUGE VICTORY THE ROAD TO JUSTICE
FOR SURVIVORS OF RAPE AND SEXUAL
ASSAULT WILL BE INCOMPLETE IF
THE RAPE KITS ARE NEVER TESTED.
ALL RAPE SURVIVORS DESERVE TO
HAVE THEIR RATE KIDS TESTED
WITHIN THE SPECIFIED TIME FRAME
WHICH CAN IN TURN HELP TO ENSURE
JUSTICE FOR SURVIVORS.
IDENTIFIES SERIAL PERPETRATORS
AND EVEN EXONERATES THE
WRONGFULLY CONVICTED I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
MEMBERS TO ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR. WE DO
SENATOR STONE CENTER HERTZBERG
SENATOR STONE.
THANK YOU. MISTER PRESIDENT AND
I WANT TO A RISE IN SUPPORT AND
THANK THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
CHINO.
IT'S ABOUT TIME.
ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT ROLES
OF GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE TO
ENSURE JUSTICE.
WHILE SERVING ON A THE BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY
WE ACTUALLY HAVE A.
SEXUAL ASSAULT RESPONSE TEAM
THAT WAS DYSFUNCTIONAL NOT
OPERATING.
THAT WAS ALLOWING BASICALLY NOT.
FORENSICS EXAMS ON VICTIMS OF
SEXUAL ASSAULT NOT TO BE DONE.
AS ABOARD SUPERVISOR INCOMING.
THE FIRST THING I DID WAS
FUNDED THAT PROGRAM.
AND THE START EXAMS MY FRIENDS
ARE NOT CHEAP.
YOU HAVE TO HAVE A FORENSIC
NURSE.
ACOSTA COUNTIES RANGES ANYWHERE
FROM EIGHT HUNDRED TO A THOUSAND
DOLLARS A TEST.
AND WHY DO THE TEST.
IF WE'RE NOT VETO.
SENATE TEST AND FOR.
ANALYSIS THEIR THOUSANDS OF KITS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THAT CAN IDENTIFY
MURDERS AND. AND AND RAPISTS.
FAR TOO LONG THESE VICTIMS OF
HEINOUS CRIMES HAVE BEEN BY
JUSTICE BECAUSE OF UNTESTED RATE
GETS THEM.
ALL BECAUSE CURRENT LAW ONLY
ENCOURAGES INSTEAD OF REQUIRES
AS THIS LAW WILL CHANGE.
TO ME THE FORMER LANGUAGE WAS
UNCONSCIOUS NOBLE.
S. B. FOURTEEN FORTY NINE WOULD
REQUIRE ALL RICKETS.
THAT MUST BE SUBMITTED WITHIN
TWENTY DAYS UNTESTED NO MORE
THAN A HUNDRED TWENTY DAYS.
THIS WILL PREVENT THE
DEVELOPMENT OF RAPE KIT BACKLOGS
IN EVIDENCE ROOMS OR
LABORATORIES THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIA THAT WE. WITNESSED
TODAY.
NOT ONLY COULD WE POSSIBLY SOLVE
MORE CRIMES AND GET MARIE PISS
OFF THE STREET BUT WE CAN ALSO
EXONERATE.
THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN WRONGFULLY
IDENTIFIED AND. OF SEXUAL CRIMES.
WE ONLY HAVE TO LOOK TO LAST
MONTH.
TO SEE HOW DNA EVIDENCE WAS USED
TO CATCH THE GOLDEN STATE KILLER.
HOW MANY MORE RAPISTS AND
MURDERERS CAN WE CATCH?
IF WE JUST CAST THE RAPE KITS.
IN OUR BACKLOG WHICH I HOPETHIS
YEAR'S BUDGET AND THROUGH BILLS
THAT WE'VE SEEN COME TO FRUITION.
FOR THESE REASONS AND MORE I
APPLAUD THE AUTHOR FOR THIS BILL
IN NINE THROUGH C. ASK LEE URGE
AN AYE VOTE ON SP FOURTEEN FORTY
NINE.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE.
SENATOR HERTZBERG GOOD AFTERNOON.
THANK YOU.
ALL OF THE RAPE KITS.
FOR THE LA COUNTY SHERIFF.
AND THE LOS ANGELES POLICE
DEPARTMENT.
OUR TEST CAL STATE LOS ANGELES.
AT THE HERTZBERG DAVIS FORENSIC
SCIENCE CENTER AND I AM PROUD TO
REPORT THAT THEY HAVE NO
BACKLOGS OF RAPE KITS THERE IN
LA COUNTY ZERO.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG.
MEMBERS WE HAVE ANY ADDITIONAL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ANY
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THE FLOOR.
SENATE LABOR WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT THANK
YOU.
YOUR SECRETARY CAN PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
BY BERRYHILL.
BY BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
I.
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LARA. AYE LEYVA. AYE.
MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
BY MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
FIVE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE IDEC IA CATHY.
I WINNER.
I.
WILK.
BY MISTER SECTOR CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS THREE
TIMES.
DELEON.
NO SENT.
THEY LEóN.
NIELSEN.
DELEON.
NIELSEN.
AYES THIRTY SEVEN NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS IF YOU CAN GIVE US JUST
A FEW MOMENTS.
WE'RE GOING TO ORGANIZE THE
BILL'S THAT WE'RE GONNA BE
LIFTING THE CALL ON. WHERE
SENATOR CONFEREES HAVE ANOTHER
MEETING COMING UP SO WE'D LIKE
TO BE ABLE TO HAVE EACH OF OUR
CONFEREES ADD ON TO THESE? ARE
SIX THESE FIVE BILLS AND WE ALSO
KNOW THAT SENATOR SKINNER HAS A
BILL THAT SHE'S GOING TO NEED TO
BE ABLE TO PRESENT IS WELDING
DISCOVERS A FEW MOMENTS WE'LL BE
RIGHT BACK WITH YOU
MEMBERS WHO. AGAIN WE'RE
GRATEFUL FOR YOUR PATIENCE.
SENATE SKINNER IS GOING TO BE
TAKING UP FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY
FOUR.
WE'RE THEN GOING TO LIFT THE
CALL.
AND THEN WE'RE GOING TO GO BACK
TO FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR IN WORK
THE FILE.
SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE READ
FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY FOUR.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR SKINNER AN
ACRONYM MURDER.
GOOD AFTERNOON SENATOR SKINNER.
THANKS SO MUCH.
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS.
LAST YEAR.
WE HAD A RESOLUTION BEFORE US
WHICH TALKED ABOUT THIS.
OLD ENGLISH COMMON LAW PRACTICE
OF FELONY MURDER RULE. WHICH HAS
IN.
CAN VERY BROUGHT BE VERY BROADLY
APPLIED.
TO SWEEP UP
ANYONE WHO IS THAT OR AROUND.
THE COMMITTING OF A FELONY THAT
RESULTS IN THE DEATH.
THEY CAN BE SWEPT UP.
AND CHARGED WITH FELONY MURDER.
AND IN THAT RESOLUTION. WE
ADDRESSED THE DIFFERENT COURT
CASES THAT HAVE DECRIED THE FACT
THAT VARIOUS OF OUR STATES
INCLUDING CALIFORNIA. HAVE NOT
APPROPRIATE LEAD DEFINED OUR
MURDER STATUTE SO THIS BROAD.
FROM SWEEPING DOES NOT OCCUR.
THAT RESOLUTION HAD OVER THIRTY
SENATORS VOTING IN SUPPORT.
WHAT I BRING BEFORE YOU TODAY
WITH SP FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN?
IS.
THE ABILITY TO REFINE OUR MURDER
STATUTE.
SO THAT IT CAN.
APPROPRIATELY FIT.
CRIME THAT IS COMMITTED.
.
AND IT WOULD A LINE CALIFORNIA.
WITH STATES
LIKE ARKANSAS. KENTUCKY MICHIGAN
OHIO. THAT HAVE ALSO.
RE WRITTEN THEIR MURDER STATUTES.
TO REFLECT
THIS APPLICATION.
NOW.
SP FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN DOES
NOT LET MURDERERS OFF THE HOOK.
IT RETAINS LIABILITY FOR ANYONE
WHO.
ACTUALLY COMMITTED A MURDER.
WHO AIDED THE KILLING?
WHO PLAN TO KILLING?
OR EVEN ACTED WITH RECKLESSNESS
DURING THE CRIME.
WHAT S. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN
IS DESIGNED TO DO?
IT IS TO PROTECT.
WOMAN. WHO IS NOW SERVING?
A LIFE SENTENCE.
IN CALIFORNIA'S
STATE PRISON.
HER INITIALS ARE VJ.
AN I WILL RELATE TO YOU THE
CIRCUMSTANCES
OF THE OF.
HER SENTENCE
AND HER CHARGE.
VJ.
WAS RENTING TO SOMEONE.
A ROOM IN THE BACK OF HER HOUSE.
THAT RENTER.
HAD A ONGOING ARGUMENT WITH
THEIR MUTUAL NEIGHBOR.
THE RENTER.
REPEATEDLY THREATENED TO HARM
VGA.
AND HER ELDERLY FATHER WHO LIVED
WITH HER. IF SHE WOULD NOT
INFORM HIM OR IF SHE DID NOT
INFORM HIM WHEN THE NEIGHBOR
RETURNED HOME.
FEARING FOR HER AND HER FATHER
VJ INFORMS THE RENTER THAT THE
NEIGHBOR HAD RETURNED HOME.
AS CITY SHE HEARD THE FIGHTING
THAT THEN ENSUED
BETWEEN HER RENTER AND THE
NEIGHBOR.
SHE RUSHED OUT WENT TO THE AID
OF THE NEIGHBOR EVEN DROVE THE
NEIGHBOR TO THE HOSPITAL.
UNFORTUNATELY THAT NEIGHBOR DID
NOT SURVIVE.
VJ DID NOT KNOW THAT THE RENTER
INTENDED.
TO COMMIT THAT ACTION OF HARM
AGAINST THE NEIGHBOR.
SHE DID HER BEST
TO INTERVENE AND TO SAVE HIS
LIFE.
AND YET.
SHE WAS CHARGED UNDER THE FELONY
MURDER RULE AND WAS SENTENCED
TWENTY FIVE YEARS TO LIFE.
NOW IN ADDITION.
TO.
APPROPRIATELY FIXING OUR NEW
ORDER MURDER STATUTE
SO THAT IT WOULD NOT APPLYING
CASES SUCH AS THAT.
IT ALSO ESTABLISHES FOURTEEN
THIRTY SEVEN A PROCESS FOR RE
SENTENCING.
AND I'VE TAKEN AMENDMENTS FROM
OUR CALIFORNIA DA'S ASSOCIATION.
ON A NUMBER OF POINTS.
SPECIALLY ON THE RE SENTENCING
PORTION TO ADDRESS THEIR
CONCERNS.
AND WITH THAT.
I ASKED FOR YOUR AYE VOTE ON SB
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER TO ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATOR STONE.
THEY WERE GONNA TURN OVER TO
SENATOR WIENER AND THEN SENATOR
ANDERSON.
CENTER STONE.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT AND I
KNOW THAT THE CALIFORNIA
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
IS STILL IN OPPOSITION I'M NOT
SURE IF THEY STILL ARE WITH THE
MOMENTS I HOPE THAT THE AUTHOR
WILL. RAISE THAT ISSUE IN HER
CLOSING STATEMENT BUT. BASED ON
WHAT I DO KNOW.
I'M RISING IN OPPOSITION SP
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN WHILE I
CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND THE
AUTHOR'S INTENT I FEEL THIS BILL
GOES. A BIT TOO FAR AND RAISES
SOME SERIOUS QUESTIONS.
BECAUSE THE BILL CAN BE APPLIED
RETROACTIVELY.
THERE WILL BE A NUMBER OF
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES.
WHAT IF A MURDER CONVICTION
COMES NT FROM A JURY BUT AS A
RESULT OF A PLEA BARGAIN?
AS THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS RIGHTFULLY POINT OUT.
UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
MEASURE A RE SENTENCING HEARING
WILL BE NECESSARILY REQUIRED.
WITH A FULL COURT RECORD
INCLUDING TRANSCRIPTS AND
EXHIBITS.
DETERMINE THE EXACT LEVEL OF
PARTICIPATION IN THE CRIME IN
ORDER TO DETERMINE WHETHER A
PARTICULAR DEFENDANT IS IN FACT.
ENTITLED TO RELIEF.
IN CASES THAT ARE RESOLVED
THROUGH A NEGOTIATED PLEA.
NO SUCH RECORD EXISTS.
AND VIRTUALLY ALL PARTICIPANTS
AND MURDER.
MAY QUALIFY FOR RELIEF TO WHICH
THEY MAY NOT BE ENTITLED.
ADDITIONALLY.
THIS BILL REQUIRES THE
PROSECUTION TO PROVE BEYOND A
REASONABLE DOUBT.
THAT THE CRIMINAL FALLS INTO ONE
OF THE CATEGORIES THAT PRECLUDES.
RE SENTENCING.
ONCE AGAIN A CASES THAT ARE
RESOLVED THROUGH A NEGOTIATED
PLEA DEAL OF THE ABSENCE OF A
FULL COURT RECORD WILL
NECESSARILY PREVENT THE PEOPLE.
FROM ESTABLISHING BEYOND A
REASONABLE DOUBT WHETHER THE
PETITIONER. IS EXCLUDED.
THIS GOOD MAN THAT JUST ABOUT
ANY CRIMINAL WHO PETITIONS EVEN
THOSE WHO WERE MAJOR
PARTICIPANTS IN A CRIME WHICH
RESULTED IN DEATH.
COULD BE ENTITLED TO RESET
SAYING AND THE ELIMINATION.
OTHER SENSE MEMBERS THIS BILL
GOES.
WAY TOO FAR AND I THINK THAT'S A
VERY DANGEROUS PRESIDENT FOR
THOSE REASONS I WOULD URGE YOU
TO VOTE NO ON SB FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE CENTER
WIENER.
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH AS THE
PRESIDENT I RISE IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF SB FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN OF THIS BILL IS LONG
OVERDUE THE FELONY MURDER RULE.
IS DRAMATICALLY TOO BROAD BY AND
IT IS SWEEPING UP PEOPLE WHO MAY
HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME.
BY THEY SHOULD NOT BE GUILTY OF
MURDER IT'S RUINING PEOPLE'S
LIVES. ARE RATHER THAN
REHABILITATING THEM.
AND.
WE SHOULD DEFINITELY PASS THIS
BILL AND I WANT TO THANK THE
SENATOR FROM BERKELEY OFFERING A
FORWARD.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON THEIR
GOING TO GO TO SENATOR NIELSEN
CENTER ANDERSON.
I CENTERS ARAB LOOK.
WE'VE ALL HEARD OR READ THE CASE
WHERE SOMEBODY.
GOES WITH BUDDIES TO SEVEN
ELEVEN.
AND.
SO HE RUNS INTO GET SLURPEES
FOR VERY IN THE CAR.
AND THEN THERE'S A GUNSHOT
SOMEONE DIES.
AND THEY'RE ALL CHARGED WITH
PULLING THE TRIGGER.
BUT THE DRIVER IN THE FRIENDS IN
THE CAR HAD NO IDEA THAT THE
CRIME WAS GOING TO OCCUR.
BUT THERE ADDRESSED UNDER THIS
LAW. IN WE KNOW THAT TO BE WRONG
IT'S NOT FAIR EVEN IF THEY KNEW
AND THEY THOUGHT.
THAT THEY WERE GONNA BE
SHOPLIFTING BUT NEVER UNDERSTOOD
THAT A WEAPON WHICH CAN BE TAKEN
AND AND USE HER DISCHARGED.
HA.
TAKING SOMEONE'S LIFE.
BUT THEIR CHARGE AND IS IF THEY
HAD PULLED THE TRIGGER.
ON THE FLIP SIDE WE'VE ALSO READ
IN LEARNED THAT SOME PEOPLE.
CLARK
IN COLD BLOOD.
IF THEY'RE GONNA GO TO SEVEN
ELEVEN THEY'RE GONNA KILL THE
WITNESSES AND THEY'RE GONNA
STEAL.
AND THEY SHOULD BE CHARGED.
BUT THEY'RE ALL LUMPED TOGETHER.
THIS BILL.
SETS OUT TO SEPARATE THE TWO.
TO GIVE REAL JUSTICE TO THOSE
WHO WEREN'T ACTIVE PARTICIPANTS
IN THE MURDER OF ANOTHER.
NOW HAVING SAID THAT.
OUR AYE I'M SUPPORTING THE BILL.
BUT WHEN I HEARD THE TESTIMONY
IN PUBLIC SAFETY.
AND IT WAS RIVETING.
THEY TALKED ABOUT WILL THIS IS
RETROACTIVE IN SOME PEOPLE PLEAD
BARGAIN. AND THERE WOULDN'T BE.
EVIDENCE BECAUSE IT WAS NEVER
WENT TO TRIAL.
SO HARD WE DETERMINE THEIR.
WELL.
MAY ASK QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
CENTER SKINNER WOULD YOU ACCEPT
THE QUESTION FROM SENATOR
ANDERSON YES I WILL FINANCING
PLEASE PROCEED SO SCARCE.
SO ARE.
MERE MARTYR.
YOU ARE I AM.
YOU WERE PRESENTED WITH THIS
ISSUE.
AND I I KNOW I SPOKE TO
AFTERWARDS THAT THIS WAS A MAJOR
ISSUED WAS NOT INTENDED.
IN I KNOW YOU'VE TAKEN
AMENDMENTS CAN YOU EXPLAIN THOSE
AMENDMENTS AND HOW THAT
ADDRESSES THIS SPECIFIC ISSUE.
YES THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION
SO THERE WERE. A NUMBER OF
AMENDMENTS THAT WE TOOK IN THE
PROBES COMMITTEE MOST OF THEM WE
TOOK.
AS RESULT OF OUR DISCUSSIONS
WITH THE LEGISLATIVE COMMITTEE
OF THE CALIFORNIA DE A
ASSOCIATION.
SPECIFICALLY NO YOUR TIME
QUESTION REGARDING RECENT SING
BUT LET ME DESCRIBE THE THREE
AMENDMENTS TO OF WHICH HAVE TO
DO A THREE SENTENCING.
THE FIRST AMENDMENT I WOULD
DESCRIBE WHICH DOES NOT HAVE TO
DO WITH THREE SENTENCING.
CLARIFIES.
THERE IS WE STILL HAVE ON THE
BOOKS.
EXCESS READ A MURDER ACCOMPLICE
TO MURDER.
BUT THERE ARE THOSE
CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE. IN AIDING
AND ABETTING.
DEPENDING ON THE NATURE OF IT.
SHOULD STILL ALLOW FOR A FIRST
DEGREE OR SECOND DEGREE MURDER
CHARGE.
AND THE BILL IS ORIGINALLY
DRAFTED.
WAS PERHAPS TOO NARROW.
SO WE.
ACCEPTED AN AMENDMENT. THAT
BROADENS THE PROVISIONS TO
ENSURE THAT ANYONE WHO AIDED OR
ABETTED A MURDER WOULD STILL BE
ELIGIBLE. FOR A FIRST OR SECOND
DEGREE MURDER CHARGE.
NOW ON THE RE SENTENCING PORTION.
THESE ARE THE THINGS WE DID.
WE CLARIFIED THAT CERTAIN PEOPLE
WOULD BE INELIGIBLE FOR THE RE
SENTENCING PORTION OF THE BILL.
DUE TO BEING A OF FOR EXAMPLE AN
OLDER PERSON DIRECTING A YOUNGER
PERSON IN THE CRIME WERE
MASTERMINDING THE CRIME OR SOME
AT PROVISIONS LIKE THAT.
WE SECONDARILY FLIPPED THE
BURDEN OF PROOF
SO THAT THE PETITIONER WOULD
HAVE TO PROVE Y. THEY WERE
ELIGIBLE. UNDER THIS BILL
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN FOR RE
SENSING RATHER THAN THE
PROSECUTION SO THE BURDEN HAS TO
BE ON THE PETITIONER. AND IT
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS OF OUR
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS THAT THE
ORIGINAL BILL PLACE THE BURDEN
ON THE DA'S.
TO SHOW THAT THE PETITIONER WAS
INELIGIBLE SO WE FLIPPED THAT
BURDEN OF PROOF. AND THOSE ARE
THE AMENDMENTS WE ARE TAKING AND
WE ARE STILL WORKING VERY
CLOSELY WITH THAT LEDGE
COMMITTEE. ON WE WERE HOPEFUL
FOR A A SUPPORT POSITION.
BUT THERE WITH THERE'S A FEW
THINGS WE MAY STILL HAVE TO
ADDRESS BUT WE ARE VERY CLOSE.
THANK YOU ON MY OWN TIME PLEASE.
CENTERS SO IN THE CASE OF THE
PERSON WHO SIMPLY.
ARE GOING TO THE LOCALS ARE.
QUICKIE MART.
FIRST SLURPEE.
WHO'S DRIVING
THIS WOULD ALLOW THEM TO BE
APPROPRIATELY SENTENCE BECAUSE
THEY HAD NO KNOWLEDGE OF THE
CRIME.
YET ON THE FLIPSIDE IF THEY WERE
PART OF.
PLANNING AND THEY HAD KNOWLEDGE
THAT THAT THERE WERE GOING IN
WITH THE INTENT I'M KILLING
SOMEBODY OR HAD THE POTENTIAL
KILLING SOMEBODY THEY STILL
COULD BE CHARGED.
WITH MURDER WHAT NUMBER TWO.
I THINK THIS STRIKE THAT BALANCE.
IN THE CASE OF RETROACTIVE IT'S
UP TO THE INCARCERATED PERSON.
TOOK TO MAKE THE CASE ON WHY
THEY SHOULD BE UNDER CONSIDER
AND CONSIDERATION.
NOW ONE THE CONCERNS I HAD WAS
WELL.
THEY PLEAD BARGAINED.
SO NEVER WENT TO TRIAL.
WELL THERE'S STILL A RECORD OF
EVIDENCE.
IT'S ALL IN THE POLICE DOCUMENTS.
IN THE CHARGING DOCUMENTS WHEN
THEY WENT TO MY NATIONALLY IN
SAID. WE'RE GONNA CHARGE YOU
WITH THIS BECAUSE WE BELIEVE
THAT YOU'RE GUILTY.
THAT EVIDENCE IS STILL THERE
THAT EVIDENCES STILL PERMIT SO
THAT. PERSON WHO IS INCARCERATED
WILL HAVE TO OVERCOME THAT
BURDEN.
IN ORDER TO BE CONSIDERED.
IT IT IS A HEAVY BURDEN THAT THE
AFTER OVERCOME.
SO I I'M I'M CONFIDENT THERE ARE
SOME MINOR. ADJUSTMENTS THAT
STILL NEED TO COME OUR WAY. BUT
I'M CONFIDENT THAT THE UP.
AUTHOR.
IN.
I'M A JOINT AUTHORED THIS BILL
TOM VERY CONFIDENT WITH MY JOINT
AUTHORED. THE ACT IT WILL BE
ADDRESSED.
MOVING FORWARD BUT THE MAJOR
ISSUES THE MAJOR REPORT FACT
THAT WAS SUCH A PROBLEM THAT
THAT HAD THIS BILL IN SUCH
UPHEAVAL.
JERRY WOULD YOU LIKE TO SAY
SOMETHING ON KNOW YOU ACT NOW
STUFF DE OF SOME THE HIDE.
SO.
.
I BELIEVE THAT WE'VE OVERCOME A
LOT.
IAN I IN I THINK THIS BILL IS
WORTHY OF SUPPORT ARE TONIGHT
VOTE.
THANK YOU MISTER SENATOR.
THE DEAN OF THE SENATE CENTER
NIELSEN.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT LADY
GEM OF THE SENATE.
WHAT THIS DOESN'T OVERCOME?
IS A CRIME.
OF MURDER.
SOMEONE OR PEOPLE.
MANY'S.
OUR DEBT.
AS A RESULT.
NO THIS BEHAVIOR.
THEY'RE ALREADY HAD IS A
CRITERIA.
THE INDIVIDUAL HAD TO KNOW THE
PERPETRATOR.
THEN DO THAT HE INTENDED.
TO COMMIT SUCH CRIMES.
AND BY THEIR WORDS OF THE
CONDUCT.
THEY WOULD OBVIOUSLY HAVE
KNOWLEDGE OF BEING APART.
IT ISN'T JUST BECAUSE YOU IT
JUST HAPPENED TO BE RIDING ALONG
IN THE CAR.
THE GUY JUST JUMPED OUT AND
STARTED SHOOTING AND KILLED
SOMEBODY.
IS A LOT MORE THAN THAT THAT
TEST IN THAT BARS HIGH.
NO RESPECT THE DA'S.
THEN I THOUGH THAT THEY'VE RUN
REAL LOT OF PRESSURE TO.
LOOK AT THINGS DIFFERENTLY THESE
DAYS.
BUT THIS IS ALSO A PART OF THE
THAT DEPLETE BARGAIN IS AN ISSUE.
PRE BARGAIN MEANS.
THEY PLAYED DISRUPTING.
LESSER.
THEN COULD HAVE BEEN CHARGED.
THAT HAPPENS.
WILL REGULATE REGULARITY AND ONE
OF THE MOST DISTURBING ASPECTS
OF THIS THICKLY REGARDING THE
RETROACTIVITY.
IS FACTS BUT NOW BEING EVER
NUMBER OF YEARS. LATER OR EVEN
AT THE TIME.
FOR THE RE SENTENCING PORTION OF
THIS.
FAX NOW CONSIDERED THAT WERE NOT
LITIGATED AT THE TIME.
NOW WHAT IN PART DOES THAT MEAN.
THE TRIAL THE VICTIMS HAVE
STANDING.
AND FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS OVER
RECENT YEARS THE STANDING OF THE
VICTIMS OF HEINOUS ATROCIOUS
CRIMES.
AB THE LESSER STANDING.
IN THESE PROCEEDINGS.
AS WELL AS AND PAROLE.
PROCEEDINGS.
I DARE THIS BILL DOES NOT SAY
THAT THE VICTIMS COULD COME BACK
AT THIS SO CALLED RE SENTENCING.
I WOULD HOPE IT DOES.
MAYBE THAT WOULD BE ONE OF THE
AMENDMENTS THAT CAN BE IN THE
FUTURE TAKEN.
I RESPECT THE AUTHOR TO.
AND I COMMEND THE INTENT.
THE WORK WITH THE OPPOSITION.
I WILL ONLY SAY BECAUSE OF THE
NATURE OF THE SERIOUSNESS OF
THIS BEHAVIOR.
I DO BELIEVE.
WE OUGHT NOT TAKE.
ANOTHER STEP FIRE GENOVA.
THANK YOU SENATOR CENTER MORLOCK
GOOD AFTERNOON SIR.
GOOD AFTERNOON MR PRESIDENT.
SOMETIMES YOU SORT OF WISH YOU
HAD THE WISDOM OF SOLOMON SOME
OF THESE BILLS TODAY ON. DEALING
WITH.
ISSUES OF SEVERITY.
BUT TASK SOMETIMES YOU HAVE TO
SEPARATE THE WHEAT FROM THE
CHAFF WHEN PEOPLE ARE. CHARGED
WITH A CRIME.
AND YOU CAN'T HAVE EVERYBODY
COTTON THE GILL NET.
WELL WE.
BE.
.
THE SUFFERING SERIOUS PENALTIES
SO MISTER MISTER PRESIDENT I
THINK WE NEED TO PROVIDE JUDGES
WITH.
FLEXIBILITY.
AND ON THE ISSUE OF
RETROACTIVITY OF COURSE YOU
PROVIDE RETROACTIVITY.
BECAUSE ONCE YOU'VE MODIFIED.
YOU SHOULD GIVE THAT BENEFIT TO
THOSE BEFORE SO I URGE AN AYE
VOTE MISTER PRESIDENT THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH CENTER.
MEMBERS WOULD LIKE ME TO SEE IF
THERE'S ANY ADDITIONAL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR ANY DIGITAL DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR.
BOTTOM SENATOR WOULD YOU LIKE
CLOSE PLEASE THANK YOU I MISTER
PRESIDENT I THINK WE HAD A GOOD
DISCUSSION AND NOW IS JUST TO.
CLOSE SAID. I REMIND YOU THAT
IT S. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN
DOES NOT ABOLISH THE FELONY
MURDER RULE. AND IT RETAINS A
LIABILITY FOR ANYONE WHO KILLED
IT AT THE KILLING PLANNED THE
KILLING OR EVEN ACTED WITH
RECKLESSNESS DURING THE CRIME.
AND I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THE HUMANITARIAN SIR SECRETARY
CAN YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
BY ATKINS.
BY BATES.
NO. BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DALY ON.
BYE DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG. AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE. AYE
MITCHELL.
BY MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK I'M A REAL.
NO. NEWMAN.
NO.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO WHY COUNTY. AYE WIENER.
BY WILK.
NO.
THANK YOU CAN YOU PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
I.
HUESO.
I PORTANTINO.
STERN.
I.
ICE TWENTY SIX
KNOWS ELEVEN. THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS.
IN ABOUT SIXTY SECONDS WE'RE
GOING TO LIFT THE CALL.
ON FIVE BILLS.
WE'RE GONNA START FROM THE BACK
IN THE GO TO THE FRONT.
WE'RE GONNA START WITH FILE ITEM
SEVENTY NINE.
THEN WE'RE GONNA GO TO ITEM
TWENTY SEVEN.
THIRTY THREE.
EIGHTY SIX AND THIRTY SEVEN.
PLEASE GIVE US SIXTY SECONDS
WE'LL BE RIGHT BACK WITH YOU
.
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA LIFT THE
CALL ON ITEM SEVENTY NINE.
ITEM SEVENTY NINE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ATKINS.
I.
DELEON.
I.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
I.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
NO. ROTH.
SKINNER.
BUT
SKINNER AYE.
WACHOWSKI.
IS YOU SURGERY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
NEWMAN.
ROTH.
WHY COUNTY?
I TWENTY ONE KNOWS THIRTEEN.
THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WERE NOW MOVING A FILE
ITEM TWENTY SEVEN FILE ITEM
TWENTY SEVEN MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
HUESO.
MITCHELL.
PORTANTINO
MITCHELL I.
PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
BY.
STERN.
STERN AYE ROTH AYE.
HUESO I.
IT'S JUST ARE TAKING PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. PORTANTINO.
I.
ICE TWENTY SIX KNOWS THIRTEEN
THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON A FILE
ITEM THIRTY THREE FILE ITEM
THIRTY THREE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DODD.
GLAZER.
HILL.
HUESO.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
NO.
PAN.
ROUGH CENTER GALGIANI MOVES THE CALL.
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON A FILE
ITEM EIGHTY SIX EIGHTY SIX.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NO.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
NO.
PAN.
ROTH.
I.
SKINNER.
I I.
I TWENTY ONE.
NOS THIRTEEN. THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS OUR FINAL ITEM ON CALL
FILE ITEM THIRTY SEVEN.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
GALGIANI.
MITCHELL.
I.
MORE LOCK.
NO.
NIELSEN.
NO. PAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I.
YEARS AGO.
ANDERSON WE HAVE IS NO.
EYES TWENTY TWO KNOWS THIRTEEN
THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBER THAT LEAVES US WITH ONE
BILL STILL ON CALL FILE ITEM
THIRTY THREE GOING TO TURN IT
BACK OVER TO CENTER LEYVA.
SENATOR PARRY PREPARED TO
PRESENT FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR
PASS ON FILE. FILE ITEM THIRTY
FIVE SENATOR MCGUIRE.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN NO NINE BY
SENATOR MCGUIRE AND TACKLING THE
FISHING.
SENATE MCGUIRE.
BENNETT PRESIDENT MEMBERS THE
GREAT STATE OF CALIFORNIA
PROVIDES AMERICA WITH FRESH
HEALTHY WHILE CAUGHT SEAFOOD.
CALIFORNIA'S FISHING INDUSTRIES
AMONG THE TOP SEAFOOD PRODUCING
STATES IN THE GREAT UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA. THE JOINT
COMMITTEES ON FISHERIES AND
AQUACULTURE WORKS WITH THE TENS
OF THOUSANDS OF HARD WORKING MEN
AND WOMEN OF THE GOLDEN STATE'S
COMMERCIAL AND RECREATIONAL
FISHING INDUSTRIES WORTH NOW
NINE BILLION DOLLARS. IN ADVANCE
IS AN OMNIBUS BILL EVERY FEW
YEARS TO REMEDY ISSUES AND
CHALLENGES LARGE AND SMALL.
S. B. THIRTEEN OH NINE ADDRESSES
VARIOUS ISSUES INCLUDING
REQUIRING THE DEPARTMENT OF FISH
AND WILDLIFE TO DEVELOP
REGULATIONS FOR THE RETRIEVAL OF
LOS OR ABANDON COMMERCIAL CRAP
TRAPS. AND EXCEEDING THE REPEAL
DATES AT THE EXISTING STATUTES.
AUTHORIZING THE FISH AND GAME
COMMISSION TO CONSIDER REQUEST
TO TRANSFER A HALIBUT PERMIT. TO
ANOTHER VESSEL OR EQUAL OF EQUAL
OR LESS CAPACITY.
EXITING THE COMMERCIAL SALMON
STAMP PROGRAM A CLARIFYING ANGEL
BE TAKE LAW IN HUMBLE BAY TO
LIVE THE REST OF CALIFORNIA. AND
THIS BILL COMPLIANCE AT COMPILES
ISSUES
THAT AFFECT FISHING RESOURCES
PROTECTION IN ONE SINGLE BILL.
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR IN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER MCGUIRE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM THIRTY
SIX SENATOR GLAZER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN SIXTEEN BY
SENATOR GLAZER AND ACT GOING TO
PARKS AND RECREATION. CENTER
GLAZER. THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS SAID THIS IS A
DISTRICT BILL THAT I'VE.
PARTNERED WITH MY REPUBLICAN
COLLEAGUES IN THE ASSEMBLY I
CATHARINE BAKER.
THAT DEALS WITH A UP PRICKLYPIECE OF PROPERTY. AYE THAT IT'S
IN OUR AREA THAT'S A PROPOSED TO
BE USES AN OFF HIGHWAY MOTOR
VEHICLE PARK.
SO THIS LEGISLATION WOULD
EMPOWER NOT REQUIRE IN POWER.
THE DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND
RECREATION TO DECIDE THE FUTURE
OF THIS PROPOSED EXPANSION AREA.
KNOWN AS THE ALAMEDA TESLA
EXPANSION.
THANK YOU MEMBERS IN NINETEEN
NINETY THE DEPARTMENT OF PARKS
AND REC PURCHASE THIS PIECE OF
LAND.
AT FOR ABOUT NINE MILLION
DOLLARS IN ITS BEEN MIRED IN
CONTROVERSY EVER SINCE.
THE BILL THAT'S IN FRONT OF YOU
TODAY TO IS NOT MANDATE ANYTHING
IT DOES NOT SPEAK TO THE
ACTIVITY OF OFF ROAD RIDING.
IT DOES NOT TAKE AWAY THE
CURRENT OFF HIGHWAY. VEHICLE
PARK THAT IS NEXT DOOR IT SIMPLY
GIVES THE PARKS DEPARTMENT THE
OPTION TO SELL THIS PROPOSED
EXPANSION AREA IF THEY DECIDE.
IT'S IN THE PUBLIC'S INTEREST.
AND BY DOING SO RETURNING ALL
THE MONEY.
THAT THE. LAND VALUE WAS WORTH
BACK TO THE OFF HIGHWAY VEHICLE
FUND FOR WHICH IT ORIGINATED FOR
THOSE CONTINUED PURPOSES.
THE ONLY CONDITION IN THE BILL
IS THAT THAT IF THEY ARE GOING
TO.
I SELL THE LAND BACK IT MUST BE
PERMANENTLY PRESERVE FOR
CONSERVATION PURPOSES.
THIS BILL IS SUPPORTED BY TWENTY
FIVE LOCAL AND STATEWIDE OUGHT
PRESERVATION ENVIRONMENTAL
COMMUNITY IN NATIVE AMERICAN
ORGANIZATIONS AS WELL SIX.
LOCAL PUBLIC AGENCIES AND FOR
THOSE REASONS BUT I WOULD ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE TODAY.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER.
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR ANDERSON ADAM SENATOR
SORRY.
.
MANY OF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH
THIS BILL WE HAVE A GREEN
STICKER FEE EVERYBODY WHO'S AN
OFF ROAD USER HAS TO BUY A
LICENSE
IT'S A GREEN STICKER THAT GOES
INTO A TRUST FUND HERE WITH THE
STATE.
AND IT'S
MEANT TO BE USED FOR TWO
PURPOSES
WARDEN TO MAINTAIN CURRENT LANDS
THAT THEY HAVE. SO THAT THAT
THEY'RE NOT HAVING A NEGATIVE
IMPACT ON THE ENVIRONMENT AND
THE SECOND REASON IS TO ACQUIRE
NEW LANDS BECAUSE FREQUENTLY
THEY LOSE LANCE.
CHIU THE ISSUES THAT I HAVE A
PROBLEM WITH WITH THIS BILL AND
ARE PERHAPS THE AUTHOR COULD
HEAR.
SPEAK TO THIS IN AS CLOSE AS ONE.
THE ACT THIS BILL AUTHORIZES THE
FEEL OF THE LAND FOR LESS THAN
MARKET VALUE.
THAT MEANS THAT THOSE SCREEN
STICKERS.
ALL THAT MONEY THAT THEY A CRUDE
AND PUT TOGETHER ARE NOT CAN GET
THEIR MONEY BACK IT'S NOT GONNA
GO BACK TO THE TRUST OF THE SAME
AMOUNT. THAT THEY SPENT IT INTO
IT FURTHER LIMITS THEIR ABILITY.
TO RECREATE WITH THEIR FAMILIES
KNOW IF YOU EVER GO OUT TO THE
DESERT IF YOU'RE GONNA TO ANY
USE RECREATION CENTERS. YOU'LL
SEE FAMILIES OUT THERE LARGE
FAMILIES HAVING A WONDERFUL TIME
TOGETHER IS FAMILY BUILDING. I
THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT WE
SUPPORT THOSE FAMILIES AND ALLOW
THEM TO CONTINUE DIRECT CREATE.
HOW IN THESE PLACES WHERE THEY
HAVE?
PURCHASE THE LAYER AND WITH
THEIR TRUST MONEY.
AND THEY HAVE MAINTAINED IT AND
IT'S NOT BEEN ON THE BACKS OF
TAXPAYERS BUT RATHER ON THE
BACKS OF THE GREEN STICKER FEES.
SO FOR THAT REASON I'M NOT
SUPPORTING IT BUT.
I'M OPEN TO HEARING THE RESPONSE.
IN YOUR CLOTHES I BECAUSE I DO
THINK THOUGH.
.
THERE YOU'RE YOU'RE DOING THIS
THINK THE BILL'S FALLING SHORT
OF TAKING CARE OF THOSE WHO PAY
INTO GREEN STICKER FEES.
THINKING SENATOR ANDERSON
SENATOR STONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT YOU
KNOW FOR YEARS WHEN I WAS A
YOUNG KID. MY PARENTS SCRAPED UP
ABOUT FIFTY BUCKS AND BOUGHT ME
A LITTLE MANY BY GOING TO PLACE
CULTURE BECAUSE CANYON WHICH I
THINK IS AN.
MY GOOD FRIEND FROM ORANGE
COUNTY'S DISTRICT TODAY BUT
TODAY IT'S.
WERE A MULTIMILLION DOLLAR
HOMES ARE AND I UNDERSTAND THAT
THIS AREA THAT.
THE SENATOR IS TRYING TO
PRESERVE UP IN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA.
A LOT OF HIS A CONSTITUENTS
REALLY DON'T WANT TO SEE THE
EXPANSION OF AN OHP PARK THAT IS
ADJACENT TO IT.
SO AS MY GOOD FRIEND FROM.
SAN DIEGO MENTIONS THAT.
YOU KNOW WE'VE ONLY GOT LIKE
EIGHT OR NINE OF THESE PARKS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AND IF WE DON'T
PROVIDE AN APPROPRIATE PLACE FOR
PEOPLE TO RECREATION. THEY'RE
GONNA GO ON PLACES WE DON'T WANT
THEM TO RECREATION NAMELY PLACES
THAT HAVE SENSITIVE HABITAT.
SO I WOULD LIKE TO SUPPORT THIS
BILL BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT IT
COULD BE A. A WAY IN WHICH
A.
SELLER.
ACTUALLY SELL IT TO A
MUNICIPALITY FOR LESS THAN
MARKET VALUE THAT CAN THEN TURN
IT OVER TO EVIRONMENTAL.
IDENTITY AND THAT PRESERVE THE
LAND AGAIN TO THE DISADVANTAGE
OF THOSE THAT HAVE PAID FOR
THOSE STICKERS FOR YEARS TO
ENSURE THEY HAVE AN APPROPRIATE
PLACE. TO WRECK READ WITH THEIR
OFF ROAD VEHICLES.
SO IF I COULD PLEASE ASK THE
AUTHOR A QUESTION.
WITHOUT OBJECTION CENTER GLAZER.
COURSE PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU
SENATOR YA IF YOU WOULD BE SO
INCLINED TO AMEND YOUR BILL. TO
ENSURE THAT THE LAND IS SOLD AT
FAIR MARKET VALUE NO MATTER TO
WHOM IT SOLD.
I WOULD BE DELIGHTED TO SUPPORT
YOUR BILL TODAY.
OR IS THAT THE QUESTION THAT IS
THE QUESTION THANK YOU CENTER
GLAZER AYE THANK YOU ARE MADAM
PRESIDENT THAT.
WE'RE FOLLOWING CURRENT STAY
ALIVE THE DISPOSITION OF UP. OF
LANDS FOR PUBLIC USE IT SO. THIS
BILL IS CONSISTENT WITH HOW WE
HANDLE THIS MATTER FOR DECADES
IN NOT AND THAT'S WHY IT'S NOT
WRITTEN. ACCORDINGLY.
I'D APPRECIATE IT. THE QUESTION
FROM THE SENATOR FROM TO MACULAR
BUT THAT SOMEHOW THE BILL HAS
BEEN CRAFTED ON MY OWN TIME AND
CARE THINGS FIRST OF THE THE
ANSWER THEN WAS NO AND THE
ANSWER IS NO BECAUSE I BELIEVE
THAT THERE ARE MOTIONS IN PLACE
NOW TO TAKE THAT EXPENSE OF. THE
LAND AND GIVE IT TO A NOTHER.
MUNICIPALITY SO THAT THEY CAN
HAND IT OVER TO AN ENVIRONMENTAL
AGENCY WHICH WILL CHEAT.
THOUSANDS OF NOT TENS OF
THOUSANDS OF YOUNGSTERS AND A
YOUNG OLDER ADULTS AT LOVE TO
RIDE OFF ROAD VEHICLES.
WERE TAKING MONEY AWAY FROM
THEM THAT THEY HAVE PAID THE
STICKERS FOR FOR MANY MANY YEARS
THIS IS UPBEAT.
AYE UNDERHANDED WAY OF GETTING
LAND INTO ENVIRONMENTAL HANDS
WITHOUT. RETURNING THE MONEY
THAT PAID FOR. AND SO FOR THOSE
REASONS LET'S NOT CHEAT THE O. A
TWO YEARS AT A PAY THE STICKER
FEES THAT I. HAVE AN IMPORTANT.
INDICATE MORE VERY IMPORTANT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT TOOL IN BY
MY FRIEND FROM IMPERIAL COUNTY
AND RIVERSIDE COUNTY WE'VE GOT
SOME PARTS TO GENERATE A LOT OF
MONEY A LOT OF HOTELS.
A LOT OF GASOLINE GET SOLD.
A LOT OF OFF ROAD VEHICLES THE
PROBABILITY DOLLAR INDUSTRY IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THIS IS
GONNA HAVE AN IMPACT ON WHERE
THESE THESE PEOPLE CAN GO SO
LET'S AT LEAST IF WE'RE GONNA
SUPPLE AND THUS GET MARKET VALUE
FOR ITS RETURN TO THE WHICH HE
FUND SO THEY CAN BUY IT LANDED
LESSEN. THEM IN MORE. THAN AREAS
THAT ARE NOT AS SENSITIVE AS
THIS ONE. AND SO WE CAN ALLOW
FOR THIS INDUSTRY THRIVE IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR THOSE
REASONS I RECOMMEND NO VOTE IN
SB THIRTEEN SIXTEEN.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE SENATOR
GAINES.
YEAH THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I HAVE ISSUES WITH THIS
BILL ALSO SEEMS TO ME THAT THAT
OUGHT TO BE DONE.
IF THE LAND IS SOLD.
DONE AT FAIR MARKET VALUE AND
IF IT'S NOT IT IT'S REALLY A
TAKING.
AND I UNDERSTAND WHAT THE STATE
PROCESS IS.
BUT I DO UNDERSTAND WHAT
EMINENT DOMAIN AS.
AND. IT EMINENT DOMAIN SITUATION
THAT WOULD BE AT MARKET VALUE SO.
.
I WOULD DIE ASK THE AUTHOR WOULD
RECONSIDER THE VALUATION THAT
PROPERTY UPON ITS SALE.
AND A IN ADDITION TO THAT WE
OUGHT TO BE LOOKING AT ANOTHER
LOCATION.
FOR AN ADDITIONAL HP PARK IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
THERE'D BEEN CONTINUED ATTEMPTS
TO.
EITHER REDUCE ABOUT THE SPACE
OF POETRY PARKS ARE NOT ALLOW
NEW PARKS TO BE BUILT.
IN THE STATE AND.
IN THIS PARTICULAR SITUATION
WE'RE GIVING UP ACREAGE.
AND THERE OUGHT TO BE.
EQUAL ACREAGE AVAILABLE AT
ANOTHER LOCATION IN THE STATE.
AND ARE THE CLARITY THAT THAT
WILL IN FACT HAPPEN WITH A DATE
CERTAIN.
SO UNTIL I SEE THOSE SORTS OF
PROVISIONS IN THE BILL I CANNOT
SUPPORT IT THANK YOU.
I THINK YOU CENTER GAIN CENTER
WIECKOWSKI PRESIDENT I'M I RISE%
IN SUPPORT THIS MATTER I'M A CO
AUTHOR THIS IS IN OUR AREA THIS
IS PUBLICLY OWNED LAND WITH THIS
BILL SIMPLY DOES IS. ESTABLISHES
A PROCESS
THERE'S NO CONTRACT BEING SIGNED
NOTHING BEATS BEING TRANSFERRED
WE WERE IT'S THERE IS AN OPTION
TO SELL THE LAND BUT IT IS
PUBLICLY OWNED LAND AYE URGENT
AYE VOTE ON THIS MATTER. TO LET
THE PROCESS GO FORWARD. BIG
CENTER RIGHT HEALTHY SENATOR
NIELSEN BUT. THANK YOU. ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING NONE CENTER GLAZER PLEASE
CLOSE.
THAT THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
THANK YOU. TO MY COLLEAGUE NEXT
DOOR ALAMEDA COUNTY FOR HIS.
WORDS OF SUPPORT AND THANK YOU
FOR THE INQUIRIES FROM THOSE WHO
ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE BILL THE
MUNICH A COUPLE THINGS CLEAR.
THIS PROPERTY HAS A I WAS
ACQUIRED. AND IS IT MIRED IN
CONTROVERSY LAWSUIT AFTER
LAWSUIT AFTER LAWSUIT THERE IS
NO PROSPECT.
OTHER OFF HIGHWAY VEHICLE PARKED
BEING CONSTRUCTED FOR THOSE
PURPOSES IN THE NEAR FUTURE ARE
YEARS INTO THE FUTURE. AND SO
HERE YOU HAVE A SITUATION OF AYE
AND THE SENATOR FROM NORTH
SENIOR COUNTY IS RIGHT WE'VE
PAID INTO THIS FUND.
AND THAT MONEY IS SET. SITTING
THERE NOT GOING FOR ANY GOOD USE
TO ADVANCE THE SPORT ANYWHERE
BECAUSE IT STUCK IN THIS
LITIGATION MORASS.
AND SO THE OPTIONS ARE BUT LET
THAT PROCESS GO ON FOR YEARS AND
YEARS AND MAYBE NOTHING COMES OF
IT WHICH IS WHAT THE VIEW OF THE
LOCALS FROM THE AREA. BOTH SIDES
OF THE AISLE OR GIVE THE
DEPARTMENT THE OPTION AND THESE
ARE THIS IS THE DEPARTMENTS IS
THE COMMISSION OF OFF HIGHWAY.
VEHICLE BUT MEMBERS WHO ARE
COMPASSIONATE COMMITTED TO THE
SPORT.
LET THEM MAKE A JUDGMENT THAT
HEY.
WE DON'T HAVE A THIS IS A DEAD
ENDS AND WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS
GIVEN AN OPTION THAT THEY DON'T
HAVE TODAY. THAT IF THEY DECIDE
THAT IT IS A DEAD AND. THAT THEY
CAN GET TRY TO GET AS MUCH OF
THAT MONEY BACK AS POSSIBLE SO
WE CAN GO TO THE ACQUISITION FOR
THOSE WHO WANT TO ENGAGE IN THE
SPORTS ACTIVITY.
SO THOSE ARE THE CHOICES BEFORE
US.
ALL THAT THIS IS A PROCESS GO
FORWARD INTO A DEAD END WITH NO
CHOICES OR GIVE THEM A CHOICE
OUT OF THAT DEBT AND WHERE THEY
CAN GET. A LOT OF THAT MONEY
BACK AND HAVE IT BE USED FOR
GOOD PURPOSE.
THAT'S WHAT THE BILL DOES IT
PROVIDES AN OPTION ONLY.
WHICH DOESN'T EXIST TODAY AND
WITH THAT MEMBERS I'D ASK YOUR
RIVAL.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
DODD.
I.
FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NOW GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL. AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
PILOTA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE. AYE
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK.
NO MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO BIDAK
NO I COUNTY.
AYE WIENER AYE WILK.
NOW. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS DAILY ON.
HUESO.
I MITCHELL.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
EYES TWENTY TWO NO'S THIRTEEN
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM THIRTY
EIGHT SENATOR NEWMAN.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ FOR
ABOUT THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR BY
SENATOR NEWMAN AND ACCOLADES
ELECTIONS.
START PASSED ON PASS ON FILE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FILE ITEM
THIRTY NINE SENATOR MCGUIRE
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FIFTY THREE
BY SENATOR MCGUIRE AND ACT
WILLING TO CIVIL ACTIONS.
SENATOR MCGUIRE GOOD AFTERNOON
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS ILLEGAL
TIMBERLANE CONVERSION.
VIOLATIONS HAVE JUMPED OVER TWO
HUNDRED PERCENT SINCE THE
PASSAGE OF THE MEDICAL MARIJUANA
REGULATION IN SAFETY ACT BACK IN
TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN.
FROM THIRTY CASES IN FIFTEEN TO
NINETY NINE IN SEVENTEEN.
OVER THE LAST TWO DECADES TENS
OF THOUSANDS OF ACRES
OF CALIFORNIA'S PRISTINE FOREST
MILLION HAVE BEEN ILLEGALLY
CONVERTED TO ILLEGAL CANNABIS
GROSS.
IT'S REPREHENSIBLE ACTION IS
POLLUTED PRISTINE WATERSHEDS
THREATEN DRINKING WATER SUPPLIES
KILLED COUNTLESS IT WILDLIFE AND
IT'S PUSHING THE RARE BEAR LIKE
MAMMAL THE FISHER TO EXTINCTION.
DUE TO THE ILLEGAL ROAD INTO
SIDES USED IN SEVERAL THESE GROW
SITES.
IN ORDER FOR CAO FIRED TO
THOROUGHLY INVESTIGATE ROAD
CANNABIS GROWS.
S. B. FOURTEEN FIFTY THREE
EXTENDS THE STATUTE OF
LIMITATIONS FOR A LEGAL FOR SLAM
CONVERSIONS
WHICH DECIMATED OUR FORCE.
FROM ONE YEAR TO THREE.
THE BILL ALSO ALLOWS THE CAUSE
OF ACTION TO CREW UPON DISCOVERY
THE VIOLATION PURSES THAT CAN
THE CONVERSION TAKES.
PURSES WHEN THE CONVERSION TAKES
PLACE A CRITICAL CHANGE THAT
WILL ASSIST IN PROSECUTING THESE
OFFENSES IN ADDITION IT EXTENDS
A STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR
ILLEGAL FORSTMANN CONVERSIONS.
MEMBERS
WE ARE DESPERATE FOR YEARS
DISTANCE IN RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MCGUIRE
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING THEN.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD
BY CANNELLA AYE DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LOCK.
I AM A REAL.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY STONE.
I'VE IDEC.
BY WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER AYE
WILK AYE PHYSICALLY ABSENT
MEMBERS.
BELA.
DELEON.
GAINES.
NO CARES KNOW AND IS NOW GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I MITCHELL.
MORRELL.
NO.
NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
NO ROTH.
SKINNER.
BUT AS THIRTY ONE KNOWS FOR THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY
SENATOR LARA.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM FORTY ONE
SENATOR JACKSON HAVE SOME FILE
FILE ITEM FORTY TWO SENATOR
WIENER MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SINOPOLI TWENTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR WIENER AND ACTUALLY THE
LAND USE.
CENTER WIENER AYE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR UNDER PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES ARE AS WE ALL KNOW WE
ARE AND.
THE DEPTHS OF A TERRIBLE
HOUSING CRISIS HERE IN
CALIFORNIA.
OUR STATE HAS A HOUSING DEFICIT
OF. NEARLY FOUR MILLION HOMES
CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING DEFICIT IS
EQUAL TO THE OTHER FORTY NINE
STATES HOUSING DEFICITS COMBINED.
AYE IT IS REALLY DOING SEVERE
DAMAGE.
TO SO MUCH OF WHAT CALIFORNIA
IS A BALLOT IN TERMS OF OUR
DIVERSITY YOUNG FAMILIES BEING
ABLE TO MAKE LIVES FOR
THEMSELVES HERE. IT IS CAUSING A
SPIKE IN HOMELESSNESS ARE WE
HAVE TO ADDRESS IT. ODD THIS
BILL WILL REFORM.
ONE ASPECT OF THAT CRISIS AND
THAT IS HOW WE SAID HOUSING
GOALS FOR CITIES.
THROUGH THE REGIONAL HOUSING
NEEDS ASSESSMENT OR REENA REENA
CAN BE AND SHOULD BE A POWERFUL
TOOL OFFER THE STATE TO ENFORCE
OUR HOUSING LAWS. AND
SPECIFICALLY OUR FAIR SHARE
PRINCIPLES TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL
COMMUNITIES ARE CONTRIBUTING.
OUGHT TO OUR HOUSING SOLUTION.
I SB TWENTY EIGHT STRENGTHENS.
THE SATE'S.
OR STRENGTHENS RINA BY MAKING
IT MORE DATA DRIVEN UNLESS
POLITICAL.
RIGHT NOW WE HAVE A PROCESS
WHERE THE STATE PROVIDES EACH
REGION OR COUNCIL OF GOVERNMENTS.
WITH IT OVERALL REGIONAL
HOUSING GOAL AND THEN THE REEDS
AND DISTRIBUTES THAT HOUSING
GOALS.
AMONG THE CITIES AND THE REASON.
IT IS A HIGHLY POLITICIZED
PROCESS THAT LEADS TO VERY
INEQUITABLE OUR RESULTS WITH
SIMILARLY SITUATED CITIES HAVING.
RADICALLY DIFFERENT RENO GOALS.
WITH SOME CITIES BEING ABLE TO
ALMOST ENTIRELY AVOID HOUSING
GOALS.
SOME CITIES HAVING AN E. YOUR
HOUSING GOAL OF TWO OR THREE
UNITS IT JUST DOESN'T MAKE SENSE
IT'S NOT SUSTAINABLE. SP TWENTY.
ADDRESSES SEVERAL DIFFERENT
AREAS BOB FIRST.
REGARDING.
HOUSING DEFICITS WERE
COMMUNITIES ARE NOT MEETING
THEIR HOUSING GOALS. I GIVE
SPECIFIC GUIDANCE TO THE HOUSING
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT ONE HOW TO CALCULATE
THE BACKLOG OF EXISTING HOUSING
NEED BY READS.
DURING A HOUSING COSTS BURDENS.
I'D ALSO REQUIRES COMMUNITIES.
WHEN PLANNING FOR FUTURE
HOUSING ZONE FOR A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY FIVE PERCENT OF THEIR
ALLOCATION RATHER THAN A HUNDRED
PERCENT.
I'D ALSO FOCUSES ON
CONCENTRATING GROWTH WHERE IT'S
MOST SUSTAINABLE. I WANT TO
THANK THE COALITION SUPPORTING
THIS BILL AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AIBO. THANK YOU SENATOR
WIENER MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
NO FALCONS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
I.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
NO HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
HUESO AYE JACKSON.
LOTTE.
BY LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
BY.
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN STONE.
BUT ACT.
BY WHY COUNTY BY WINNER. AYE
WILK.
NO.
LOTTE I TO KNOW PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
BRADFORD.
DELEON.
JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
I.
NEWMAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE I.
COOLEY AS MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
ALLEN.
BRADFORD.
DELEON.
JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
NEWMAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL. MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY
THREE SENATOR DODD.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT THIRTY BY
SENATOR DOT AND ACT WENDY PEOPLE
INSTRUCTION.
SENATE ON.
BETTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS TODAY
AND PRESENTING S. B. EIGHT
THIRTY PERTAINING THE MEDIA
LITERACY EDUCATION.
THE RISE OF FAKING MISLEADING
NEWS IS DEEPLY CONCERNING EVEN
MORE CONCERNING IS A LACK OF
EDUCATION PROVIDED. TO ENSURE
PEOPLE CAN DISTINGUISH WHAT'S
FACT AND WHAT'S NOT.
A RECENT STANFORD STUDY FOUND
THAT EIGHTY TWO PERCENT OF
MIDDLE SCHOOL STUDENTS
STRUGGLE TO DISTINGUISH
ADVERTISEMENTS FROM REAL NEWS
STORIES.
WHILE WE HAVE CRITICAL THINKING
REQUIREMENTS ARE CURRICULUM THEY
HAVEN'T KEPT UP WITH THE DIGITAL
AGE.
BY GIVING STUDENTS THE PROPER
TOOLS TO ANALYZE THE MEDIA THEY
CONSUME WE CAN EMPOWER THEM TO
MAKE INFORMED DECISIONS.
S. B. THIRTY REQUIRES A STATE
BOARD OF EDUCATION TO DEVELOP
ADOPTED MEDIA LITERACY MODEL.
MODEL CURRICULUM IT PROVIDED ON
ITS WEBSITE A LIST OF MEDIA
LITERACY RESOURCES MATERIALS AND
TRAINING OPPORTUNITIES FOR
TEACHERS.
THIS BILL HAS HAD NO OPPOSITION
IS SUPPORTED BY A COALITION OF
EDUCATION AND CHILDREN'S
ADVOCACY GROUPS RESPECTFULLY ASK
RIBA. THANK YOU SENATOR DODD
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE SENATOR
NIELSEN.
MADAM PRESIDENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THE SENATE I.
DON'T HAVE A BIGGER SUBJECTION.
BUT I FIND IT.
KIND OF AMUSING AMUSING ENOUGH
THAT ALL VOTE NO.
AMUSING IS THAT. IN CALIFORNIA.
OUR STUDENTS.
GRADUATE.
OKAY TWELVE.
EFFICIENT IN READING AND MATH
SKILLS.
THEY THEN GO ON TO THE
UNIVERSITIES AND FOR DECADES.
THOSE REMEDIAL MATH.
REMEDIAL ENGLISH.
FOR THOSE STUDENTS COMING INTO
COLLEGE.
WELL.
CSU NEWS YOU DON'T WANT TO
BOTHER WITH THOSE STUDENTS
ANYMORE.
SO THEY'VE ABOLISHED IT.
THERE'S SOME SORT OF A
CONVOLUTED PROCESS I'VE BEEN
INFORMED OF.
BUT I THINK IT'S.
CONVOLUTED AVOIDANCE.
SO WE'VE DONE A DISSERVICE TO
OUR CHILDREN IN K. TWELVE.
WE LET THEM GO ON MATRICULATED
THROUGH COLLEGE AND UNIVERSITY.
DEFICIENT INTO SKILLS ESSENTIAL.
THE BE SUCCESSFUL IN LIFE.
BUT WE'RE GONNA TAKE CARE THEIR
DIGITAL NEEDS.
AND IT USUALLY WORD IN OUR
ANALYSIS IT MAY NOT BE IN THE
BILL THAT SAYS DIGITAL
CITIZENSHIP.
I DO NOT KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS.
BECAUSE IT APPEARS IN AMERICA WE
DON'T PUT MUCH
STOCKTON CITIZENSHIP ANYMORE
EITHER.
BUT I THINK WE SHOULD FOCUS MORE
ON HAVING OUR YOUTH.
A YOUNG. COLLEGE STUDENTS.
LEARN.
AND BE CAPABLE IN READING.
WRITING.
AND MATH.
THEN LET'S GET ON TO DIGITAL
STUFF.
THINK YOU CENTER NIELSEN SENATOR
DODD WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
YES.
MADAM PRESIDENT GLAD I CAN GIVE
THE SENATOR FROM GERBER A CHANCE
TO CHUCKLE TODAY BECAUSE THERE
HAVE BEEN A LOT TO CHUCKLE ABOUT.
BUT THIS ONE IN PARTICULAR THIS
BILL IN PARTICULAR.
MADAM PRESIDENT IS.
.
NOT A NEW CURRICULUM FROM THE
STANDPOINT OF NEW COURSE WORK.
AGAIN AS I SAID.
WE HAVE COURTS WORK ALREADY
BEEN HASN'T KEPT UP WITH THE
DIGITAL AGE. THIS WILL GO INTO
THE SOCIAL STUDIES CURRICULUM.
AND.
WE'VE BEEN FROM A FIRST GRADE
THROUGH TWELFTH GRADE THESE
IMPORTANT CURRICULUM SKILLS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR RIBA.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DAILY ON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI AYE GLAZER. AYE
HERNANDEZ. AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON AYE LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCK NO MORALE. NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NOTE NO SON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO.
BUT ACT NO AYE KATHY. AYE WINNER.
I WILL. NO. LEGALLY ABSENT
MEMBERS DAILY ON. MITCHELL ROTH.
SKINNER.
I SWIM TWO KNOWS THIRTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FORTY FOUR SENATOR WHITE
HOUSE THE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT THIRTY ONE BY
SENATOR WHITE HOUSE HE AND
ACKERLEY LAND USE CENTER RIGHT
HEALTHY MEN PRESIDENT MEMBERS
THIS IS THE SPORTS SUPPORT.
BILLITON ANOTHER ONE OF MY LINE
OF EXCESS RETOOLING UNITS EIGHTY
USE POINT PASSED THE FIRST BILL
SP TEN SIXTY NINE.
IN TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN WE SAW
A MAJOR INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF
PERMITS I BELIEVE SANTA. BARBARA
FOR INSTANCE INCREASED THEIR UP
PERMITS BY THREE HUNDRED
FOURTEEN PERCENT LOS ANGELES WAS
ALMOST TWO THOUSAND HOWEVER A
RECENT REPORT CAME OUT TO SHOWS
THAT NEARLY THREE HUNDRED
THOUSAND. THREE HUNDRED THOUSAND
ON PERMITTED HOUSING UNITS ARE
EXISTS IN THE GREATER LOS
ANGELES AREA AND MOST OF THESE
ARE EIGHTY YEARS.
THE NUMBER OF. AYE UNCOMMITTED
EIGHTY USE IS DIRECTLY
CORRELATED TO THE IMPACT SAID
THAT AS CITIES AND COUNTIES ARE
CHARGING. IN SANTA CRUZ COUNTY
WHICH I'VE USES MY.
THE THE LEADER IN EXCESS
RETOOLING UNITS SIXTY ONE
PERCENT OF THE EIGHTY USE AND
THAT COUNTY AND THAT CITY ARE ON
PERMITTED SO WHAT WE DO HERE IN
S. B. EIGHT THREE ONE. WE TRY TO
ADDRESS SOME OF THESE.
LIMITATIONS WOULD PROHIBIT WE
LIMIT THE IMPACT FEES WE WE TOOK
AN AMENDMENT TO ALLOW SCHOOL
DISTRICTS TO GET UP TO THREE
THOUSAND DOLLARS WOULD PROHIBIT.
OWNER OCCUPANCY WE REDUCE THE
TIME FRAME FOR APPROVING A
PERMITS AND ALSO CREATES AN
AMNESTY PROGRAM WITH THESE
PROBABLY FOUR HUNDRED THOUSAND
UNITS IN THE OUT IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WE SAID. A PROCESS OF
PEOPLE BECOME COMMANDED DART
MAKES HAVE THESE BOOTLEG UNITS
BECOME LEGAL AND WITH THAT IT'S
VERY IMPORTANT AND NECESSARY
STEP NURTURED AYE VOTE. PEGGY
CENTER WHITE HOUSE KEY
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE SENATOR
HERTZBERG.
THEY RESPECT MADAM PRESIDENT WE
SPEND A LOT OF TIME IN A LOT OF
MONEY AND PASS A LOT OF BILLS
THAT A LOT OF DISCUSSION ON THE
ISSUE OF HOUSING. WHICH IS VERY
URGENT.
ARM AND THIS ACCESSORY DWELLING
UNITS OF MEASURE WE WORKED ON IT
MANY YEARS AGO AT WITH A NUMBER
OF OTHER FOLKS THROUGHOUT THE
YEARS IS SO IMPORTANT I JUST
TELL YOU. THAT WE PUT AN
APPLICATION IN FOR THE STRATEGIC
GROWTH COUNCIL NORTHEAST LOS
ANGELES. AND PART OF IT REQUIRED
A HOUSING COMPONENT AND
BASICALLY THE ONLY WAY WE COULD
BECAUSE IT TAKES ABOUT SIX
CENTURIES TO GET ANYTHING BUILT
IN LOS ANGELES. THE ONLY WAY WE
COULD MEET THAT HOUSING
REQUIREMENT IS TO USE THE
ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT APPROACH
WHICH THE COMMUNITY IN NORTHEAST
LOS ANGELES FOUND COMPLETELY.
CULTURALLY APPROPRIATE WORKED
EXTREMELY WELL THAT WAS A FAST
WAY TO GET THERE AND AT ITS A
WAVE OF PEOPLE AKE MONEY IT'S
SMART AT A HUNDRED LEVELS. I
KNOW THERE'S OF THE COMPLEXION A
COMPLEXITIES WITH RESPECT TO
OTHER INTERESTING GOVERNMENT BUT
WILL PUSH SERIOUS ABOUT. OF THE
ISSUE OF HOUSING THIS IS A GREAT
WAY TO BE ABLE TO CREATE SOME
UNITS FOR FOLKS ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE.
BECAUSE IN HERTZBERG CENTER
WIECKOWSKI RESIDE CLOSE ORIGINAL
VOTE THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
EXCUSE ME MEMBERS IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SEEING IT THERE IS PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
BY ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BELL. AYE BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
I. GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
NO.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG. AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
LADA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK AYE MORRELL. AYE
NEWMAN. AYE NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE.
FIVE I TACK.
I LIKE KELSEY.
AYE WIENER. AYE WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN.
BERRYHILL.
I.
DELEON.
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
PORTANTINO.
ROTH THERE.
I THIRTY KNOWS ONE THE MEASURE
PASSES MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY
FIVE SENATOR JACKSON.
PAT.
THANK YOU FILE ITEM FORTY SIX
SENATOR WIN NOT AT HER DESK FILE
ITEM FORTY SEVEN SENATOR MCGUIRE
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT NINETY SIX
PRESIDENT A MCGUIRE AND AKRON
ARSON. SENATE MCGUIRE.
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS THERE IS NO DOUBT.
CALIFORNIA'S FACING A NEW
REALITY WHEN IT COMES TO OUR
CLIMATE.
THE SIZE AND SCOPE OF WILDLAND
FIRE EVENTS IN THIS GREAT STATE
ARE GETTING WORSE.
S. B. A NINETY SIX WILL EXTEND
THE SUNSET DATE HONOR STATES
AGGRAVATED ARSON STATUTES. UNTIL
JANUARY FIRST OF TWENTY TWENTY
FOUR. AND INCREASE THE THRESHOLD
AMOUNT ON PROPERTY DAMAGE FROM
SEVEN MILLION TO EIGHT POINT
THREE MILLION.
AGAIN THIS PENALTY IS RESERVED
FOR THE WORST OF THE WORST.
ARSONISTS WHO EXHIBIT SPECIFIC
INTENT TO INFLICT DAMAGE TO
THEIR COMMUNITIES OR WHO ARE A
CONTINUING THREAT TO SOCIETY.
THIS BILL IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN
EVER IT WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE BIGGIE CENTER
MCGUIRE MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING HEARING NONE MEMBERS IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN EYES
THIRTY FIVE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM FORTY EIGHT SENATOR
WIENER NOT AT HIS DESK FILE ITEM
FORTY NINE SENATOR WIENER.
DID YOU WANT TO FORTY EIGHT
FORTY NINE FORTY EIGHT PLEASE.
MISS SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE HUNDRED BY
SENATOR WIENER AND ACTING TO
PUBLIC SOCIAL SERVICES. CENTER
WIENER.
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH JOB MADAM
PRESIDENT.
SP NINE HUNDRED I IS A
BIPARTISAN BICAMERAL BILL.
THAT SEEKS TO HELP LOW INCOME
FAMILIES.
USE THEIR CALPERS BENEFITS AND
MAXIMIZE THEM TO ACCESS FRESH
FRUITS AND VEGETABLES.
WISELY NINE HUNDRED SABA SAYS
THE CALIFORNIA FRUIT AND
VEGETABLES EBT PILOT PROGRAM
WHICH REQUIRES THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES.
AND CONSULTATION.
WHAT THE DEPARTMENT OF FOOD AND
AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY
STAKEHOLDERS?
TO CREATE A MECHANISM WITHIN THE
ELECTRONIC BENEFIT TRANSFER EBT
SYSTEM. THAT WILL ALLOW
RECIPIENTS TO RECEIVE A DOLLAR
FOR DOLLAR CREDIT ONTO DIRECTLY
ONTO THEIR EBT CARDS WHEN THEY
BUY CALIFORNIA GROWN FRESH
FRUITS AND VEGETABLES WITH THEIR
CALPERS BENEFITS.
THE PILOT IS INSPIRED BY LOCAL
HEALTHY FOOD INCENTIVE PROGRAMS
THAT ARE OPERATING IN FARMERS
MARKETS AND GROCERY STORES AND
COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
ARE CURRENTLY.
ONE PEOPLE ACCESS DIS INCENTIVE
PROGRAMS THE USER CALPERS
BENEFITS TO BUY FRESH FRUITS AND
VEGETABLES THEY HAVE TO USE.
PAPER CERTIFICATE IT'S ON WE'LL
BE.
THIS BILL WILL I REQUIRE THAT
THAT BE LOADED ONTO THE EBT CARD
I WILL CREATE A PILOT PROGRAM.
CALPERS RECIPIENTS WILL BE ABLE
TO EAT AND ACCESS HEALTHIER
FOODS AND WILL HELP CALIFORNIA
FARMERS SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER WHERE MEMBERS
IS ARE IN DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
ANY OBJECTION TO USE A UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
THE.
THING IN HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES SENATOR WIENER TO JOIN
TAKE UP.
FORTY NINE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE OH FIVE BY
SENATOR WIENER IN AKRON
ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES SENATOR
WIENER. AYE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I SP NINE
TO FIVE IS A BILL THAT IS MAKING
A RETURN TRIP. BY THE CALIFORNIA
LEGISLATURE IT IS A LOCAL
CONTROL BILL.
SO THAT COMMUNITIES WILL BE
ABLE TO DECIDE FOR THEMSELVES OF
WHETHER TO STICK WITH.
THE CURRENT.
STATEWIDE TO A. M. ALCOHOL CUT
OFF OR GOOD FOR A M. OF FOR
THEIR NIGHT LIGHTS A PURE LOCAL
CONTROL ISSUE.
I ASK YOU NOT A FIVE UNLIKE LAST
YEAR INSTEAD OF APPLYING TO THE
ENTIRE STATE.
LAST NIGHT OF FIVE WILL CREATE A
FIVE YEAR PILOT PROGRAM IN SEVEN
CITIES THESE OF THE SEVEN CITIES.
WHOSE MAYORS AND CITY COUNCILS
HAVE REQUESTED.
HAVES EXTRA SUPPORT OPERA THE
IDEA OF LOCAL FLEXIBILITY TO GO
PAST TWO A. M..
THE CITIES ARE OAKLAND SAN
FRANCISCO SACRAMENTO LOS ANGELES
WEST HOLLYWOOD LONG BEACH AND
PALM SPRINGS. AT THE CONCLUSION
OF THE FIVE YEAR PILOT PROGRAM
THE LEGISLATURE WILL BE ABLE TO
STUDY THE RESULTS AND THE TERM
AND WHETHER TO EXTEND THAT.
THIS BILL IDEAS ALLOWS BUT DOES
NOT REQUIRE.
CITIES ARE TO MAKE THEIR OWN
LOCAL DECISION NOT TO GO PAST
TWO AM TO FOUR AM FOR THEIR BARS
AND NIGHTCLUBS.
IT DOES NOT INCLUDE LIQUOR
STORES BARS NIGHTCLUBS AS WELL
AS RESTAURANTS.
NO COMMUNITY WILL BE REQUIRED TO
GO PAST.
TO I AM THIS WILL BE A CURE
LOCAL DECISION.
IN ADDITION AND OTHER BILL
REQUIRES THAT IF THE CITY IS
CONTEMPLATING GOING PAST TWO AM.
I WILL HAVE TO GO THROUGH A
COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDER PROCESS IT
WILL HAVE TO FORMULATE A A
PUBLIC SAFETY AND TRANSPORTATION
PLAN.
DOT PLAN WILL HAVE TO BE AFTER
BEING APPROVED BY THE CITY
COUNCIL WILL HAVE TO BE
SUBMITTED OUGHT TO THE ABC TO
MAKE SURE THAT IT COMPLIES. WITH
THE LAW.
AND THEN OF COURSE EACH
INDIVIDUAL NIGHT AUG LIQUOR
LICENSE EXTENSION WILL HAVE TO
GO THROUGH THE A. B. C. PROCESS
WE WORKED EXTENSIVELY WITH ABC
AND OTHER STAKEHOLDERS. IN
FORMULATING THE SPELL COLLEAGUES
NIGHT LIFE IS A MAJOR ECONOMIC
DRIVER IN CALIFORNIA GENERATING
BILLIONS AND BILLIONS AND
CONSUMER SPENDING EMPLOYING A
HUGE NUMBER OF RESIDENTS OF OUR
STATE. AND GOOD JOBS MIDDLE
CLASS I JOBS BY RIGHT NOW
CALIFORNIA'S DESTINATION CITIES
ARE AT A DISADVANTAGE COMPARED
TO THE OTHER STATES AND CITIES
AROUND THE COUNTRY. AND AROUND
THE WORLD.
THAT DO NOT HAVE AN ARTIFICIAL
TO A. M. CUT OFF TIME AYE
COLLEAGUE AYE REESE COLLEAGUES I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER.
MEMBERS IF I CAN ASK YOU ALL TO
GIVE YOUR ATTENTION TO EVER IS
SPEAKING AND AT THE BACK OF
CHAMBERS ALSO IF YOU COULD PAY
ATTENTION TO WHO'S SPEAKING IT
WOULD BE MUCH APPRECIATED SO
HARD HERE APPEAR. THUNDERSTONE.
THINK ABOUT A PRESIDENT AND I
WANNA THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
INCLUDING.
A CITY THAT I REPRESENT PALM
SPRINGS.
TO GIVE YOU SOME STATISTICS
PALM SPRINGS HAS ABOUT FORTY
EIGHT THOUSAND PEOPLE LIVING AT
CITY IN HAS OVER A MILLION
VISITORS A YEAR.
ESPECIALLY DURING THE.
THE WINTER MONTHS IN THE FALL
MONTHS
WE CAN SEE THE POPULATION RISE
IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY BY FORTY
PERCENT BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE
TRYING TO ESCAPE THE. THE SNOW
IN CANADA AND NORTHERN UNITED
STATES INCOMING TO THE BEAUTIFUL
COACHELLA VALLEY.
AND THIS IS GOING TO PROVIDE
MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR PEOPLE
DIRECTORY EATEN.
AND THE PALM SPRINGS AREA IT
HAS THE.
CODIFICATION OF THE CITY
COUNCIL THERE.
AT A TIME WHEN WE HAVE YOU KNOW
TAXIS UBERS AND LET'S TO MAKE
SURE THAT PEOPLE ARE SAFELY
DRINKING AND SAFELY DRIVING. AND.
I WANT SOMEONE SUPPORT MY CITY
OF PALM SPRINGS A MONSTER
COURAGE.
MORE COMMERCE IN THEIR CITY AND
RECREATION IN A RESPONSIBLE WAY
AND FOR THOSE REASONS I'VE
STRONGLY.
A SUPPORT A SB NINE TO FIVE
PRETTY MY FRIEND FROM SAN
FRANCISCO INCLUDING PALM SPRINGS
ENERGY RIGHT OUT.
I THINK YOU CENTER STONE FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING NONE
SENATOR WE KNOW WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
I'VE. AYE CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG. AYE HILL AYE
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
LOTTE.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL.
NO.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE.
BYE BYE JACK.
NO AYE KATHY AYE WINNER.
I WILK.
NO LEGALLY ABSENT MEMBERS DAILY
ON. JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
ROTH.
HUESO I DON'T KNOW.
SKINNER.
STERN.
EYES TWENTY FOUR KNOWS NINE THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY
SENATOR BELL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE OF SIX BY
SENATOR BILL AND EQUANIMITY CAO
CENTER BELL.
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SO THIS
BILL S. B. NINE OH SIX.
ESTABLISHES A CERTIFICATION
PROGRAM FOR PURE SUPPORT
SPECIALIST.
THIS IS A PERSON WHO HAS LIVED
EXPERIENCE WITH MENTAL ILLNESS
OR SUBSTANCE ABUSE DISORDER
WOULD DRAWS ON THAT EXPERIENCE
ALONG WITH SKILLS. LEARNED IN A
A CERTIFIED TRAINING PROGRAM.
TO PROVIDE CRITICAL SUPPORT FOR
CLIENTS AND TREATMENT PROGRAMS.
ACROSS THE NATION PEER SUPPORT
PROGRAMS HAVE EMERGED AS AN
EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE. WITH
PRUDENT PROVEN BENEFITS TO BOTH
PEERS AND THE CLIENTS THEY
ASSESS.
NOW CALIFORNIA HAS A PHONE
BEHIND THE REST OF THE NATION ON
THIS ISSUE.
IT'S TIME WE GET ON TRACK MORE
THAN FORTY STATES
HAVE ALREADY ADOPTED THESE PEER
CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS.
MEDICAID RIVER REIMBURSES FIFTY
PERCENT. OF THE COST APPEARS
SERVICES IN STATES
WHITNEY CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS
THAT CALIFORNIA HAS NOT ACTED.
THIS WILL MAKE SURE APPEARS GET
TRAINING THEY NEED TO DO THE
BEST WORK.
AND SURE THEY GET PAID FOR THEIR
WORK AND HELP GROW OR MENTAL
HEALTH. WORKFORCE AND RESULT IN
BETTER CARE AYE URGENT AYE VOTE
ON THIS.
THANK YOU SENATOR BELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
HEARING AND SEEING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
HEARING AND SEEING NONE EYES
THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY ONE
SENATOR BELL MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE TWELVE BUT
SENATOR BELL AND ACTING HOUSING
CENTERVILLE.
MADAM MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS.
SP NINE TWELVE.
ON BEHALF OF CENTER SKINNER
MYSELF.
WHICH MODELS THE SENATE SO FIVE
BILLION HOMELESSNESS AND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SOLUTION
BUDGET PROPOSAL. THAT WAS
UNVEILED ON MAY SIXTEENTH THE
BILL WAS THIS BILL WAS AMENDED
IN THE SENATE JOB.
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEES TO
MAKE IT CONSISTENT WITH THE
SENATE BUDGET PROPOSAL.
WE HAVE HEARD ALL THE STARLING
NUMBERS CALIFORNIA'S HOME TO A
QUARTER OF THE NATION'S HOMELESS
POPULATION UNLIKE.
OTHER JURISDICTIONS ACROSS THE
COUNTRY ARE NUMBERS ARE
INCREASING.
LAST YEAR A HUNDRED THIRTY FIVE
THOUSAND MEN WOMEN AND CHILDREN
LIVED IN CALIFORNIA STREETS.
WHICH WAS.
OF FOURTEEN PERCENT INCREASE
SINCE THE YEAR BEFORE.
THE SENATE HOMELESS AND HOW
AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUDGET
PROPOSAL BUILDS ON INVESTMENTS
PROPOSED. IN THE GOVERNOR'S MAY
REVISE TO PROVIDE A HOLISTIC
INVESTMENT.
IN ADDRESSING THE HOMELESSNESS
CRISIS AS WELL AS INVESTING IN
CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE. TO
PREVENT HOMELESSNESS FROM
OCCURRING.
BROADLY SPEAKING THE SENATE
PROPOSES OF.
THE FIVE BILLION DOLLARS OVER
FOUR YEARS IN THREE TARGETED
AREAS.
THE THREE TARGETED AREAS ARE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CONSTRUCTION.
TO CREATE A HOUSING FOR HARD
WORKING FAMILIES.
AND PREVENTING THEM FROM FALLING
INTO HOMELESSNESS.
SECONDLY LONG TERM HOMELESSNESS
SOLUTIONS.
TO PREVENT HOMELESSNESS AND.
HE PEOPLE HOUSE.
AND AND THIRDLY IMMEDIATE SHORT
TERM HOMELESS SOLUTIONS
TO QUICKLY MOVE PEOPLE FROM THE
STREETS IN THE HOUSING.
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
PARTNERSHIP.
ESTIMATES CONSTRUCTION FUNDS.
WILL CREATE DATA THIRTY FOUR
THOUSAND.
NEW AND REHABILITATED AFFORDABLE
HOMES.
NINETY FOUR THOUSAND JOBS.
SIXTEEN BILLION DOLLARS IN
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
SEVEN HUNDRED MILLION AN
ADDITIONAL LOCAL AND STATE TAXES
AND FEE REVENUES.
BUT THIS PROPOSAL STRIKES THE
APPROPRIATE BALANCE.
IT PROVIDES SUBSTANTIAL
INVESTMENT IN SHORT TERM
SOLUTIONS.
LA AS WELL AS LONG TERM
SOLUTIONS TO CREATE HOUSING.
FOR HOMELESS
AND.
IT ALSO PREVENTS LE. THE LONG
TERM PROBLEM BY PROVIDING A
AFFORDABLE INCREASING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING.
WE CANNOT LISTS LET OUR FAMILIES
LANGUISH ON THE STREETS.
WELL THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
CONTEMPLATES FUNDING CUTS TO
WORKING FAMILIES ONE STEP AWAY
FROM HOMELESSNESS I REQUEST AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR BELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE
HEARING AND SEEING THEM MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
IDEALLY OWN.
DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER. AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
I HUESO.
BY JACKSON. AYE LARA AYE LEYVA
AYE MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONEY.
HI MORE LOCK BY MERRELL.
AYE. AYE NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
BY JACK.
I WIECKOWSKI. AYE WIENER.
BY WILK AYE.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ANDERSON AYE.
BATES.
I.
DELEON.
FULLER.
GAINES.
MITCHELL. ROTH
SKINNER STONE.
I STARTED TO NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY TWO
SENATOR WIENER. MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL NINE
EIGHTEEN BY SENATOR WINNER AND
HECKLING TO HOMELESS YOUTH
SENATOR WIENER AYE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT ARE. VERY
APPROPRIATE.
THAT THIS ODD BILL FOLLOWS I
SENATORS BELL AND. I SKINNER'S
BILL.
S. UNITED TEAM.
WILL.
IS ARE HOMELESS YOUTH ACT OF
TWENTY EIGHTEEN.
THE BILL WILL CREATE.
NEW GRANT PROGRAM.
TO AWARD.
FUNDS TO NONPROFIT OR CONTINUE
OF CARE ADMINISTRATIVE ENTITIES
THAT PROVIDE YOU SPECIFIC
HOMELESSNESS OUGHT SUPPORT.
AND AND THE BILL WILL FINALLY
CRIED MORE BOOKS ADMINISTRATIVE
CONCENTRATION WITHIN OUR STATE
GOVERNMENT.
THE STATE DOES NOT DO ENOUGH OF
FOR OUR HOMELESS KIDS.
BUT THE NUMBERS ARE STARK.
WE HAD. MORE THAN FIFTEEN
THOUSAND USE LIVING ON OUR
STREETS AND CALIFORNIA.
THIS DOES NOT INCLUDE YOUNG
PEOPLE WHO ARE LIVING HOMELESS
WITH THEIR PARENTS USER. MORE
THAN FIFTEEN THOUSAND
UNACCOMPANIED HOMELESS YOU.
I'M MORE THAN ONE THIRD OF THE
NATION'S HOMELESS YOUTH LIVING
CALIFORNIA.
ABOUT ONE IN NINE HOMELESS
PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA.
IS A YOUTH AND THAT IS UNDER THE
AGE OF TWENTY FOUR.
A STUDY BY THE UNIVERSITY OF
CHICAGO LAST FALL. FOUND THAT
NATIONALLY ONE IN TEN. YOUNG
PEOPLE AGED EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY
FOUR WILL EXPERIENCE
HOMELESSNESS OVER THE COURSE OF
A YEAR AND ONE IN THIRTY KIDS
AGED THIRTEEN TO SEVENTEEN. WILL
DO SO ONE IN TEN CSU STUDENTS
EXPERIENCES HOMELESSNESS.
ARE THE NUMBERS ARE GROWING AND
IT IS A MORAL STAIN ON
CALIFORNIA.
APPROXIMATELY FORTY PERCENT OF
THESE HOMELESS YOUTH IDENTIFY AS
LGBT.
YOUTH OF COLOR YOUTH INVOLVED
WITH THE JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM
AND FORMER FOSTER YOU ARE-INCREASED RISK FOR HOMELESSNESS.
ONE STUDY OF FORMER FOSTER YOU
FOUND THAT UP TO FORTY PERCENT.
THE FORTY SIX PERCENT.
A FORMER FOSTER YOU HAD BEEN
HOMELESS AT LEAST ONCE.
BY THE AGE OF TWENTY SIX.
THESE YOUNG PEOPLE ARE SLEEPING
IN WAREHOUSES IN FIELDS BEHIND
BUSINESSES ALONG RIVER BEDS IN
THEIR CARS.
IN BETTER STAYING IN PLACES
WHERE WE DO NOT WANT PEOPLE TO
BE LIVING AND WE NEED TO HELP
THEM.
WE KNOW THAT THESE YOUNG PEOPLE
ARE AT SIGNIFICANT RISK OF
VICTIMIZATION. I AND THE DAY ARE
SAYS TRULY VULNERABLE.
BOB.
STATE. UNTIL A FEW YEARS AGO
SPENT ABOUT A MILLION DOLLARS A
YEAR.
ON YOUTH HOMELESSNESS FOR THE
WHOLE STATE THAT NUMBER HAS
INCREASED THANKS TO THE WORK OF
OUR BUDGET CHAIR AND OTHERS THAT
I WANT TO THANK THEM FOR THEIR
WORK.
BUT WE NEED TO DO A LOT MORE
WE'RE WORKING IN THE BUDGET THIS
YEAR AND I WANT TO THANK THE
SENATE LEADERSHIP FOR ITS STRONG
PROPOSAL IN FUNDING YOUTH
HOMELESS PROGRAMS. S. B. NINE A
TEAM WILL CREATE THE
ADMINISTRATIVE STRUCTURE.
SO THAT WE CAN HAVE A TRULY
FOCUSED APPROACH AND REDUCING
AND ULTIMATELY ELIMINATING I USE
HOMELESSNESS WHEN TO GET THESE
KIDS OFF THE STREETS. AND THE
SERVICES BACK ON TRACK SO THAT
THEY CAN LEAVE THE GREAT LIVES
THAT I KNOW THEY'RE CAPABLE OF
LEADING COLLEAGUES I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NIVEAU.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I ATKINS AYE BATES AYE BELL. AYE
BERRYHILL AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA.
I DE LEóN. DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
I HUESO.
BUT I JACKSON.
I LARA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NELSON.
BY PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE.
FIVE AYE DECK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
BY WINNER. AYE WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
DAILY ON.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
I MORALE.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY.
I SAID BEFORE NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM FIFTY THREE SENATOR
WIENER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE TWENTY THREE BY
SENATOR WINNER AND AQUINNAH
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE. SENATOR
WIENER. AYE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MADAM PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES.
ALMOST NOTHING WE DO IS A STATE
GOVERNMENT.
HAS THE POWER TO NEGATIVELY
IMPACT AN INDIVIDUAL THEIR
FAMILY AND THE ENTIRE COMMUNITY.
THEN WRONGFULLY CONVICTING
SOMEONE PUTTING SOMEONE AWAY WHO
DID NOT COMMIT THE CRIME.
S. B. NINE TWENTY THREE IS A
LONG OVERDUE REFORM OF HOW WE DO
EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATIONS IN
CALIFORNIA.
TO MAKE SURE THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
GOING TO JAIL ARE GUILTY AND
PEOPLE WHO ARE IN A SENSE ARE
REMAIN FREE.
I NOT ONLY DOES A WRONGFUL
CONVICTION REPRESENT THE HEIGHT
OF INJUSTICE.
BUT ONE INNOCENT PERSON IS
CONVICTED OF THE REAL
PERPETRATOR REMAINS UNDETECTED
AND COULD DO SIGNIFICANT HARM TO
OTHER PEOPLE.
IN CALIFORNIA I WIN THIS
MISIDENTIFICATION AKA HAS
CONTRIBUTED TO SIXTY SIX KNOWN
WRONGFUL CONVICTIONS JUST THAT
WERE AWARE OF.
I INCLUDING TWELVE OUT OF THE
THIRTEEN.
BASED ON DNA EXONERATIONS.
EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATION
MISIDENTIFICATION IS THE LEADING
CONTRIBUTOR TO WRONGFUL
CONVICTIONS APPROVAL WITH DNA
EVIDENCE NATIONALLY.
I IN ORDER TO ADDRESS THESE
ISSUES ó CALIFORNIA MUST
IMPLEMENT EVIDENCE BASED
PROCEDURES FOR EYEWITNESS
IDENTIFICATION. A TO IMPROVE THE
RELIABILITY OF VALID I WITNESS
ID'S.
I THESE EVIDENCE BASED BEST
PRACTICES CONTAINED IN S. B.
NINE TWENTY THREE. I HAVE BEEN
ENDORSED BY THE NATIONAL ACADEMY
OF SCIENCES. THE US DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE.
THE AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION THE
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
CHIEFS OF POLICE.
AND IN TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT
WERE RECOMMENDED BY OUR OWN%
CALIFORNIA COMMISSION ON THE
FAIR ADMINISTRATION. OF JUSTICE
CURRENTLY IN CALIFORNIA THERE IS
NO STATEWIDE STANDARD ARE
REQUIRING LAW ENFORCEMENT TO USE
BEST PRACTICES AROUND AYE
WITNESS'S IDENTIFICATION
EYEWITNESS IDENTIFICATIONS. SOME
COUNTIES HAVE IMPLEMENTED. BEST
PRACTICES BUT MOST HAVE NOT.
NATIONALLY NINETEEN STATES HAVE
ADOPTED.
STATE REQUIREMENTS FRYE WITNESS
IDENTIFICATION PROCEDURES
INCLUDING GEORGIA NEBRASKA NORTH
CAROLINA OHIO TEXAS IN WEST
VIRGINIA. CALIFORNIA SHOULD
FOLLOW SUIT.
S. B. NINE TWENTY THREE SETS OUT
MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR THESE
AYE WITNESS ID PROCEDURES. IT
REQUIRES A BLIND OR BLINDED
ADMINISTRATION PROCEDURE TO
PREVENT SUGGESTED THAT'S.
IN A BLIND LINE UP BE OFFICER
ADMINISTERING.
THEY LINE UP DOES NOT KNOW WHO
IS THE SUSPECT SO THE OFFICER
CAN I I'M INTENTIONALLY.
SUGGESTS TO THE WITNESS WHO THE
SUSPECT IS.
IF THAT IS NOT PRACTICAL A SO
CALLED BLINDED TECHNIQUE CAN BE
USED SUCH AS THE FOLDER SHUFFLE
METHOD.
SECOND BOB BEFORE THE PROCEDURE
THE EYEWITNESS SHOULD BE
INSTRUCTED THAT THE PERPETRATOR
MAY OR MAY NOT BE IN THE LINEUP.
SO AS NOT TO SUGGEST THAT YOU
HAVE TO PICK OUT SOMEONE.
THIRD THE PROPER USE OF FILLERS
NINE SUSPECT FILLERS USED IN THE
LINEUP SHOULD MATCH THE
WITNESSES DESCRIPTION OF THE
PERPETRATOR. SO THAT THE SUSPECT
IS NOT STICK OUT LIKE A SORE
THUMB.
AND FOURTH I COMPETENCY MEN'S
IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE LINE
OUT ASKING THE WITNESS HAL
CONFIDENT.
HE OR SHE IS VERY CONFIDENT
SOMEWHAT CONFIDENT AND SO FORTH.
AND FINALLY RECORDING THE ENTIRE
IDENTIFICATION PROCESS LAWSUIT
COULD BE SCRUTINIZED LATER.
BOB WE'VE TAKEN SIGNIFICANT
AMENDMENTS INCLUDING COST
REDUCTIONS WE ARE SENSITIVE THAT
ESPECIALLY SMALLER POLICE
DEPARTMENTS.
HAVE COST PRESSURES AND WE TOOK
AMENDMENTS TO TRY TO REDUCE
THOSE PRESSURES. ARE BUT THIS
ARE FUNDAMENTALLY IS ABOUT THE
FAIR ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE I
THIS IS A GOOD BILL IT IS LONG
OVERDUE IN CALIFORNIA AND I ASK
DERIVABLE.
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I EXTENDS.
I BATES.
BILL.
I BERRYHILL AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA AYE DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN.
BY PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE.
NO.
BY JACK.
NO.
BY COUNTY.
I WIENER. AYE WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES.
NO.
DELEON. FULLER.
GAINES.
MITCHELL. MORLOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NO.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN I TWENTY FOUR KNOWS EIGHT THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY
FIVE SENATOR HERTZBERG.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE THIRTY BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG AND ACT WILLING TO
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS.
SENATOR HERTZBERG THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR.
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM THE COUNTY
OF CINEMA TELLS ME.
THAT IN THE COMMUNITIES HE
REPRESENTS
IN THE NORTHERN PART OF THE
STATE. THERE'S NEAR TWO BILLION
DOLLARS BURIED IN BARRELS
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA TWO BILLION DOLLARS
INTERNATIONAL RINI.
THE GENTLEMAN CAME IN A MILE
OFFICES SAID HE'S GOT A TRACTOR
TRAILER WITH FORTY MILLION
DOLLARS IN IT I SHOULD YOU CAN
PARK IT MY DRIVEWAY.
WHY IS THAT WHY IS THAT BECAUSE
WE HAVE A DISCONNECT BETWEEN THE
FEDERAL LAW IN THE STATE LAW THE
VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA BY A WIDE
MARGIN? SAID THE CANNABIS
INDUSTRY IS LEGAL BUT THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT'S BANKING
SYSTEM SAYS IT'S ILLEGAL A
SCHEDULE ONE DRUG SO YOU CAN'T
USE OUR BANK SO WHAT DO WE DO.
LAW ENFORCEMENT SAYS WHAT DO WE
DO WITH ALL THIS CASH LOCAL
GOVERNMENT SO WORRIED ABOUT THE
CASH OUR GOVERNMENTS ARE ASKING
FOR BUDGET CHANGE PROPOSES ALL
OVER THE PLACE TO PUT A BULLET
PROOF GLASS. AND ALL KINDS OF
NEW SECURITY MEASURES IS TAKING
DAYS TO COUNT THE MONEY THAT HAS
TO BE COUNTED THREE TIMES A DAY
IN. THE EMPLOYMENT DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT OTHER PARTS OF OUR
GOVERNMENT THE STATE AND LOCAL
GOVERNMENT SO OF WHAT THE V. DO.
BUT THE V. DO.
THERE HAS BEEN A DISCUSSION TO
CREATE A STATE BANK.
I THINK THAT BY THE TIME
GOVERNMENT GETS AROUND PUT
TOGETHER REGULATIONS TO WAS
STATE BANK.
IT'S THAT THE WHOLE ISSUE'S
GOING TO BE OVER WITH AND WE'RE
GONNA HAVE THE FEDERAL LAW
CHANGED.
IN THE INTERIM WHAT THIS BILL
DOES IS CREATE THE ABILITY FOR
WHAT'S CALLED A CLOSED LOOP.
PRIVATE INVESTOR BANK WHAT DOES
THAT MEAN.
WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS TO
BASICALLY AND IT QUICKLY TO BOLT
ONTO THE EXISTING BANKING
STRUCTURE A NEW LIMITED CHARTER
BANK? OR CREDIT UNION THERE'S
ABOUT A HUNDRED AND TWENTY EIGHT
BANKS AND A HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE
CREDIT USE IN CALIFORNIA. AND
BASICALLY PRETTY SPECIAL CLASS
WITHIN THE BANKING DEPARTMENT
ALL THE REGULATIONS THAT
CURRENTLY EXISTS WE DON'T HAVE
TO CREATE NEW REGULATIONS AND
REINVENT THE WHEEL WHAT THE
RIGHT RESPONSIBILITY OF
DIRECTORS ARE WHAT
CAPITALIZATION REQUIREMENTS ARE
ALL THE SAME. IT JUST HAS FOR
LIMITED PURPOSES IT'S NOT
PERFECT SOLUTION BUT IT BEGINS
TO START TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM
THAT WE'RE FACED WITH ONE YOU
CAN PAY GOVERNMENT FEES IN YOUR
TAXES IN THE LOCAL FEES WITH A
CHECK ESPECIALLY MARK CHECK
COMING FROM THESE BANKS.
ELIMINATES THE CASH MANAGEMENT
SECURITY PROBLEM AND AS FIONA
MOM WHO IS THE SPONSOR OF THIS
MEASURE TALKS ABOUT. ALLOWS US
TO CREATE AUDIT TRAILS TO BE
ABLE TO BETTER MANAGE OUR TECH
BUT MANAGE THE MONEY. SECOND YOU
CAN PAY YOUR RENT YOUR LANDLORD
YOU GOT IT IN THE LAND OR COULD
TAKE A CHECK RATHER THAN PICKING
UP THE CASH THREE YOU CAN PAY
YOUR VENDORS OF SOMEONE'S A
PLUMBER FOR EXAMPLE. AND DOES A
LOT OF PLUMBING SERVICES FOR FOR
STUFF YOU CAN FIX THAT AND
LASTLY YOU COULD INVEST IN BONDS
IN CALIFORNIA BECAUSE THE MONEY
STAYS LOCAL. THE NOTION BEHIND A
CLOSED LOOP BANK IS THAT WE'RE
NOT USING THE FEDERAL SYSTEM
WE'RE NOT USING THE FEDERAL WIRE
THERE'S ONE OTHER LOOPER THAT
YOU GOT TO JUMP THROUGH AND
THAT'S THE FDIC. RIGHT NOW BANKS
ARE THE BAR ARE INSURED BY THE
FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE
CORPORATION A NUMBER OF THESE
VARIOUS A.
WHICH IN COLLEGE THAT THE BANKS
CREDIT UNIONS HAVE PRIVATE
INSURANCE AND UNDER THE CURRENT
LAW. THE BANKING COMMISSIONER
HAS ABILITY USE PRIVATE
INSURANCE SO THIS IS A SHORT
TERM CREATIVE APPROACH TO DEAL
WITH THIS EXTRAORDINARY PROBLEM.
PUBLIC SAFETY PROBLEM CASH
MANAGEMENT PROBLEM AND ALLOWS
FOLKS TO PUT TO GO OUT AND PUT
THESE BANKS TOGETHER THERE'S
ABOUT NINE HUNDRED EIGHTY FIVE
BANK BRANCHES AROUND CALIFORNIA
THAT WILL BE CLOSED.
SO IF WE CAN GET THESE BANKS
OPEN LITERALLY PEOPLE THAT WANT
TO PUT THE MONEY UP INVEST CAN
GO IN AND RENT THESE BRANCHES
THERE'S PLENTY OF VAULTS AROUND
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. TO
IMMEDIATELY PUT THE
INFRASTRUCTURE IN PLACE AND
ULTIMATELY WHAT'S GOING TO
HAPPEN IN THIS INDUSTRY IS
EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED WITH THE
REAL ESTATE BUSINESS IN THE
EIGHTIES.
THESE BANKS ARE GOING TO OPEN
AND WHEN IT BECOMES LEGAL ALL
THE SMALL BANKS BECAUSE WE CAN
HAVE GREAT DEPOSITORS AND GREAT
RELATIONSHIPS ALL IN CASH
THEY'RE GONNA BE ABLE TO GO OUT
AND ROLL THEM UP AND BE SOLD. TO
THE BIG BANKS WHICH IS WHAT
GENERALLY HAPPENS SO THIS IS A
BRIDGE.
SHORT TERM BRIDGE UNTIL THE
FEDERAL LAW CHANGES THE WAY TO
DEAL WITH PUBLIC SAFETY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THE STATE.
AND THE COLLECT REVENUES I THINK
IS PRETTY CREATIVE WHICH GOT A
LOT OF BROAD BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
AND ASK YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS
MEASURE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY BUT.
THUNDER MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SAID I
WANT TO.
.
AFFIRM THE SENATOR. FOR HIS BILL
SP NINE THIRTY.
DURING OUR RESEARCH HAS HE HAS
LOOKS LIKE THE FDIC MAY ALLOW
BANKS TO. HANDLE.
FUNDING IF THEY SO CHOOSE BUT
THEY THEN HAVE THE LIABILITY
EXPOSURE SO WHAT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA DOES DONE. IS THEY'VE
PROVIDED INSURANCE.
POLICY THAT WOULD.
REIMBURSE THESE BANKS SHOULD
THEY HAVE A BIG RUN IN WITH THE.
WITH THE FEDERAL RESERVE. SO
WE'RE GETTING CLOSER I LIKE THIS
IDEA GOVERNMENTS CAN DO BANKS
I'VE LEARNED THAT.
THE FUN WAY WHEN I WAS
TREASURER THE COUNTY OF ORANGE
AND I URGE AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT.
THANK YOU CENTER MORE LIKE ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATOR HERTZBERG WOULD LIKE TO
CLOSE.
S. RIVAL THANK YOU THANK YOU
SENATOR MISTER US SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
AYE BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA.
I DE LEóN. DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
YEAH I.
GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
I HUESO.
I JACKSON.
ISLA.
BY LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
MONNING.
AYE MORLOCK AYE MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY STONE.
BYE BYE DECK PILOT KATHY.
BY WIENER. AYE WILK.
BY. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS DE LEóN.
MITCHELL. ROCK.
SKINNER.
EYES TWENTY NINE NO SIX THE
MEASURE PASSES
FILE ITEM FIFTY SIX SENATOR
ALLEN NODDED YOU READY. VERY
GOOD MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL NINE THIRTY THREE BY
SENATOR ALLEN AND ACKLINGTON
VISUAL AND PERFORMING ARTS
EDUCATION.
SENATOR ALLEN VISION AND PRESENT
MEMBERS I SP NINE THIRTY THREE
ESTABLISHES THE ARTS FOR EVERY
STUDENT ACT WHICH IS INTENDED TO
CLOSE THE GAP IN ACCESS TO
VISUAL PERFORMING ARTS.
EDUCATION FOR CALIFORNIA
STUDENTS
THE ACT WHICH IS CONTINGENT UPON
FUNDING IN THE BUDGET CREATES AN
INCENTIVE GRANT PROGRAM FOR
SCHOOLS.
TO CREATE NEW PROGRAMS AND BUILD
UPON EXISTING PROGRAMS TO EXPAND
OPPORTUNITIES FOR STUDENTS
ACROSS THE STATE.
ARTS EDUCATIONS IN CHINA IMPROVE
CRITICAL THINKING PROBLEM
SOLVING SKILLS FOR CELTIC CROSS
CULTURE UNDERSTANDING SUPPORT
CIVIC ENGAGEMENT IT ALSO CAN BE
THE CRITICAL THING IN IN
IMPACTING WHETHER IT. STUDENT
DROPS OUT OF SCHOOL OR NOT
BECAUSE IT CONNECTS TO A STUDENT
IN THE WAY THAT THE TRADITIONAL
CURRICULUM DOESN'T.
I RESPECT FASTER AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA AYE DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON AYE LARA.
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE. AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
BYE BYE DECK IA CATHY.
I WINNER.
BY WILK.
I. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ANDERSON AYE.
DELEON. MITCHELL MORLOCK.
MORRELL.
I.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
BY CITY FOR NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM FFTY SEVEN
SENATOR WIENER MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE THIRTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR WINNER AND ACTUALLY NO
CLIMATE.
SENATOR WIENER THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
JOINT AUTHORS HAVE ON THIS BILL
OUR COLLEAGUES SB NINE THIRTY
SEVEN.
WILL.
BRING HELP BRING OUR WORKPLACES
INTO THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY BY
REQUIRING ALL EMPLOYERS TO MAKE
LACTATION ACCOMMODATIONS OFFER
PARENTS RETURNING TO THE
WORKPLACE AFTER CHILDBIRTH. OUR
CURRENT LAW.
REQUIRES FLEXIBLE BREAK TIME.
AND REQUIRES DIED.
LIKE TITIAN HAPPEN SOMEWHERE
OTHER THAN SITTING ON A TOILET.
WELL THAT'S GREAT.
TO SELL YOU GET COLLECTED
SOMEWHERE OTHER THAN SITTING ON
A TOILET IT'S NOT GOOD ENOUGH.
WE NEED.
TO MAKE SURE THAT.
WHEN.
WOMEN HAVE.
NEW BABY DIED THEY CAN RETURN
TO WORK I NOT HAVE TO CHOOSE
BETWEEN WORKING.
AND.
LACTATING AND BREAST FEEDING.
ABA DIED UNFORTUNATELY IS ALL
TOO OFTEN THE CHOICE.
THAT WOMEN FACE AFTER THEY HAVE
A CHILD AND WE SEE WOMEN WHO
DON'T RETURN TO WORK. OR WOMEN
WHO ARE FORCED TO BUY BABY
FORMULA WHICH IS VERY EXPENSIVE.
WHO WERE NOT ABLE TO BONDS?
WITH THEIR CHILD APPROPRIATELY.
AND WE KNOW THAT BREASTFEEDING
IS HEALTHY OPERATES CHILD WE
WANT WOMEN TO BE ABLE TO RETURN
TO WORK. WHEN THEY DECIDE IT'S
APPROPRIATE TO RETURN TO WORK.
AND NOT.
HAVE TO GIVE UP ON IT BY
BREASTFEEDING IN ORDER TO DO SO.
ODD DE LACK OF LACTATION
FACILITIES PARTICULARLY IMPACTS
LOW INCOME BY WORKING MOTHERS I
AM WE REALLY NEED TO MAKE SURE
THAT OUR PEOPLE ARE ABLE TO
LACKEY.
AS WELL AS RETURNING TO WORK BY
THE BILL.
SETS STANDARDS OF FOR EMPLOYERS
IN TERMS OF THE SPACE THAT NEEDS
TO BE PROVIDED.
TO A LACTATING MOTHER OF THE
BILL ALSO.
CREATES OR REQUIRES THE
CREATION OF BUILDING STANDARDS
ON TERMS OF INCLUSION A
LACTATION SPACE IN NEW
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT AYE WE'RE
WORKING WITH A BROAD GROUP OF
STAKEHOLDERS.
AND I WANT TO THANK BOTH THE
SUPPORTERS.
AND THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY OFFER
WORKING WITH US ON THIS BILL I
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON AYE ATKINS.
BY BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
BY CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LADA.
LEYVA AYE AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK
NO. MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NELSON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
BIDAK.
NO I COUNTY.
BY WIENER. AYE WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
FULLER.
GAINES GALGIANI I.
ANDERSON I KNOW.
GLAZER.
LOTTE.
I.
MITCHELL.
NGUYEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STONE.
WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
FULLER GAINES.
GLAZER.
MITCHELL.
NGUYEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
STONE.
WILK.
BUT AS WE ONE KNOWS FIVE THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY
NINE SENATOR JACKSON'S.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE FORTY SEVEN BY SENATOR
JACKSON ENACT WENDY PEOPLE
INSTRUCTION.
SENATE JACKSON THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES S. B. NINE
FORTY SEVEN CREATES A PROCESS BY
STAKEHOLDERS
OTHERS WILL COLLABORATE WITH THE
STATE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION TO
PROVIDE TOOLS AND GUIDANCE FOR
INSTRUCTION ABOUT DIGITAL
CITIZENSHIP. MEDIA LITERACY AND
THE SAFE USE OF TECHNOLOGY.
TEENAGERS SPEND AN AVERAGE OF
FIFTY HOURS A WEEK ONLINE.
THE NUMBER FOR TWEENS.
IS EVEN HIGHER.
CURRENTLY THERE ARE NO
COMPREHENSIVE STANDARDS FOR
TEACHING STUDENTS ABOUT THE MORE
CRITICAL ASPECTS OF DIGITAL
CITIZENSHIP. THINGS LIKE SEXTING
CYBERBULLYING.
PRIVACY AND FAKE NEWS.
EDUCATORS ARE FACED WITH THE
OFTEN OVERWHELMING CHALLENGES
PRESENTED BY TECHNOLOGY USAGE BY
STUDENTS AND STUDENTS STRUGGLE.
TO MAKE SENSE OF AN EVER
CHANGING DIGITAL LANDSCAPE.
S. B. NINE FORTY SEVEN WOULD
ESTABLISH AN ADVISORY PANEL
COMPRISED OF EDUCATIONAL EXPERTS
WORKING IN TANDEM WITH THE STATE
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION ACCUSED
ME STATE DEPARTMENT. OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTION TO DEVELOP BEST
PRACTICES.
AND STRATEGIES THAT SUPPORT
SCHOOL DISTRICTS INCLUDING
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT FOR
EDUCATORS AND ADMINISTRATORS
PACIFIC PLAY THE BILL REQUIRES
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTION. IN CONSULTATION
WITH THE STATE BOARD OF
EDUCATION AND A PANEL
STAKEHOLDERS TO IDENTIFY BEST
PRACTICES IN MEDIA LITERACY IN
DIGITAL CITIZENSHIP. AND THEN TO
REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE ON THE
STRATEGIES THEY THEY HAVE
DEVELOPED TO IMPLEMENT THOSE
PRACTICES.
AS STUDENTS IN CALIFORNIA USED
THE IMMENSE POWER OF TECHNOLOGY
AND DIGITAL MEDIA TO EXPLORE
CONNECT CREATED LEARNED IN WAYS
NEVER PRVIOUSLY IMAGINED THEY
FACE INCREDIBLE OPPORTUNITIES AS
WELL AS POTENTIAL PITFALLS. AND
BY CREATING A PATHWAY TO
INCORPORATE INSTRUCTION ON DISC
DIGITAL CITIZENSHIP INTERNET
SAFETY AND MEDIA LITERACY INTO
CALIFORNIA'S PUBLIC SCHOOLS THIS
MEASURE WILL HELP OUR STUDENTS
ARE KIDS. LEARN HOW TO SAFELY
RESPONSIBLY AND EFFECTIVELY UC
EXTRAORDINARY POWER AND TOOLS OF
MEDIA AND TECHNOLOGY AVAILABLE
TO THEM WITHOUT I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY AK FEAR I. THINK
YOU SENATOR JACKSON DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SENATOR ANDERSON.
SARAH'S ARIA RISE TO OPPOSE THIS
BILL BECAUSE IT DIVERTS PROP
NINETY EIGHT MONEY EITHER
CLASSROOMS.
YEAH AND WE ALL KNOW THAT. LEAST
IN MY DISTRICTS MANY OF THEM ARE
STRUGGLING HAVE ARTS PROGRAMS
AND I DON'T I CAN'T AFFORD TO
LOSE THOSE ARE PROGRAMS.
BIG.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON.
SENATOR JACKSON WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE IS THANK YOU ARE I SEE
NO INDICATION THAT ART PROGRAMS
ARE GOING TO SUFFER FROM THIS.
OUR YOUNG PEOPLE TODAY AS WE ALL
KNOW SPEND ENORMOUS TIME ON THE
INTERNET. THEY STUDY ON THE
INTERNET THEY INQUIRE ON THE
INTERNET IT PROVIDES THEM WITH
INFORMATION COMMUNICATIONS IT IS
THE TOOL OF THE PRESENT AND THE
FUTURE. IF THESE YOUNG PEOPLE
DON'T LEARN HOW TO USE IT
EFFECTIVELY ARE THEY WILL SUFFER
DRAMATICALLY OF NOT ONLY IN
THEIR EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE BUT
ALSO IN THE SOCIAL. OUR
EXPERIENCES THAT ARE THEIR
FUTURE AND WITH THAT I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
BIG CENTER JACKSON MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
DOT.
AYE FULLER. KNOW GAINES.
NO GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
JACKSON AYE ISLA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
MONNING.
BY MORE LOCK NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO VIBE ACT NO AYE KATHY.
I WINNER AYE WILK
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ANDERSON NO.
DALY. HUESO AYE.
MITCHELL.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
EYES TWENTY TWO NOS THIRTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING TO FILE
ITEM SIXTY TWO SENATOR PAN
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE SIXTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR PAN AND ACT GOING TO
PUBLIC POST SECONDARY EDUCATION.
SENATE MAN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATORS SP NINE SIXTY
EIGHT REQUIRES THE COMMUNITY
COLLEGES A STATE COLLEGES.
CALIFORNIA TO MEET THE RATIO OF
ONE MENTAL HEALTH COUNSELOR TO
EVERY ONE THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED
STUDENTS UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA'S
ENCOURAGED TO MEET SAME RATIO.
SB NINE SIXTY EIGHT HOPES TO
REMEDY THE GENERAL LACK OF
CONSISTENT REPORTING THROUGHOUT
SYSTEM MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS.
I ALSO REQUIRE EACH PUT CAMPUS
REPORT THE LEGISLATURE EVERY
THREE YEARS THROUGH TH USE OF A
SURVEY AND TO REPORT ANNUAL
ATTEMPTED SUICIDE DATA. THERE'S
A GROWING NEED FOR MENTAL HEALTH
SERVICES ANA CAMPUSES IN SP NINE
SIXTY EIGHT ADDRESSES THE MENTAL
HEALTH CRISIS FACING
CALIFORNIA'S PUBLIC HIGHER
EDUCATION SYSTEM WHILE ALSO
GIVING US THE INFORMATION.
WE NEED TO CONTINUE TO PROVIDE
THE CARE THEIR STUDENTS DESERVE
TO BE NICE SIXTY EIGHT HAS NO
FORMAL OPPOSITION EXPECT WE ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
CENTER PAN MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN EYES
THIRTY FIVE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM SIXTY THREE SENATOR
LARA MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL NINE SEVENTY FOUR BY
SENATOR LOTT A AND HECKLING TO
MAKEOUT. CENTER LARA THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS. MEMBERS
BEING ABLE TO GO SEE A DOCTOR
AYE SOMETHING THAT SOME OF US
TAKE.
PROGRAM ESPECIALLY AS WE GET
OLDER S. B. NINE SEVENTY FOUR
ALLOWS ALL CALIFORNIANS AGE
SIXTY FIVE OR OVER WHO MEET. THE
INCOME AND RESIDENCY
REQUIREMENTS TO RECEIVE FULL
MEDICAL COVERAGE.
WE HAVE A SYSTEM CURRENTLY THAT
IS UNFAIR AND CRUEL AS MANY AS
THREE THIRTY THOUSAND CALIFORNIA
RESIDENTS WHO ARE AGED EIGHT
SIXTY FIVE OR OVER DON'T HAVE.
ACCESS TO A REGULAR DOCTOR THEY
CAN'T.
GET PREVENTIVE SCREENINGS FOR
CANCER OR HEART CONDITIONS ARE
HEALTHCARE SYSTEM IS STRONGER
AND MORE COST EFFECTIVE AND
EFFICIENT WHEN WE DETECT AND
TREAT PREVENTABLE CONDITIONS
EARLY. RATHER THAN FORCE
PATIENTS TO RESORT TO OUR
EMERGENCY ROOM CARE STUDIES SHOW
EMERGENCY ROOM CARE COSTS THREE
TIMES MORE THAN PRIMARY CARE AND
THAT. AND THAT PEOPLE CAN PUT
OFF CARE UNTIL THEY ARE VERY
VERY ILL. THAT IS A NOT A WAY TO
TREAT PEOPLE WHO HAVE WORKED
THEIR WHOLE LIES RAISE FAMILIES
AND PAY THEIR FAIR SHARE OF
TAXES. OUR ELDERS ARE STILL
WORKING MOST HAVE A CHILDREN AND
SPOUSES WHO ARE YOU WITH
CITIZENS AND RESIDENTS SOME OF
OUR ELDERS HAVE BEEN. WAITING
MORE THAN THIRTY YEARS FOR A
SOLUTION FROM WASHINGTON TO.
REFORM OUR IMMIGRATION SYSTEM
MANY ARE HELPING TO RAISE THE
NEXT GENERATION OF CALIFORNIANS.
WASHINGTON POLITICS SHOULD NOT
DECIDE WHO GETS HEALTHCARE IN
CALIFORNIA WE ARE MUCH BETTER
THAN THAT. AS WE TWO YEARS AGO
IN CALIFORNIA STARTED COVERING
ALL CHILDREN.
TODAY NEARLY TWO HUNDRED AND
FIFTY THOUSAND CHILDREN HAVE
ACCESS TO PRIMARY CARE THIS IS A
GREAT WORK THAT WE'VE ACTUALLY
ACCOMPLISHED HERE IN THE SENATE
MEMBERS.
SO.
AGAIN I KNOW ELDER SHOULD SUFFER
OR DIE FROM A TREATABLE
CONDITION BECAUSE WHAT OF WHERE
THEY WERE BORN AND THEIR LACK OF
ACCESS TO CARE ESPECIALLY THE
MOST POWERFUL STATE. IN THE
UNION I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON. NO ATKINS AYE BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DOT.
FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ. AYE HERTZBERG.
HILL.
HUESO.
BUT I JACKSON.
AYE LARA. AYE LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCKED
NO MORALE.
NEWMAN.
MORRELL NO.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NOPE Y. CASKEY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
GLAZER.
HERTZBERG.
HILL.
I.
MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
CENTER MOVES A CALL.
FILE ITEM SIXTY FOUR SENATOR
MITCHELL NOT HER DESK FILE ITEM
SIXTY SIX SENATOR WIENER. MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NYE NINETY BY
SENATOR WINNER AND ACT WHEN
INMATES.
SENATOR WIENER AYE THANK THANK
YOU VERY MUCH TRYING A PRESIDENT
I COLLEAGUES. SP NINE NINE THE.
IS A CIVIL RIGHTS BILL TO
ENSURE I'D THAT.
TRANSGENDER PRISONERS WHETHER
IN STATE PRISON ON COUNTY JAIL
ARE TREATED US FAIRLY AND
EQUITABLY.
WITH DIGNITY.
GIVEN AN OPPORTUNITY.
TO BE REHABILITATED I
SPECIFICALLY.
SP NINE NINE THE AYE REQUIRES
THAT TRANSGENDER.
INCARCERATED INDIVIDUALS.
BE GIVEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO
AFFIRM THEIR GENDER IDENTITY
THEIR PREFERRED PRONOUNS NAME
AND SO FORTH.
AND THAT THE INSTITUTIONS
RESPECT.
THOSE AFFIRMATIONS IN ADDITION
AND VERY SIGNIFICANTLY.
THE BILL.
REQUIRES THAT INDIVIDUALS WHO
ARE PLACED IN SOLITARY
CONFINEMENT I'VE NOT DUE TO ANY
MISCONDUCT BUT RATHER FOR THEIR
OWN SAFETY. BY THE DAY HAVE FAIR
ACCESS OUGHT TO.
SERVICES.
EYES WHETHER IT'S EDUCATIONAL.
OR HEALTH SERVICES.
AND OTHER RESOURCES ARE RIGHT
NOW I LGBT INCARCERATED
INDIVIDUALS AND PARTICULARLY BY
TRANSGENDER WOMEN.
AYE TIMES OR A PLACE IN THE
SOLITARY BECAUSE THEY ARE AT
INCREASED RISK OR CAN BE AT
INCREASED RISK OF FOR ASSAULT.
INCLUDING SEXUAL ASSAULT ODD
BECAUSE I CALIFORNIA FRANKLY IS
BEHIND IN TERMS OF APPROPRIATELY
HOUSING.
TRANSGENDER INCARCERATED
INDIVIDUALS WHO SHOULD BE.
ANKLE A HOUSE ACCORDING TO
THEIR GENDER OF BETTER TIMES AND
FREQUENTLY THEY ARE NOT.
AND SO THEY ARE.
TIMES AT RISK OF VICTIMIZATION
PLACED IN SOLITARY CONFINEMENT.
AND THEN LOSE ACCESS OUGHT TO.
THESE CRITICAL SERVICES.
SO THIS IS I THINK AN IMPORTANT
BILL ON A GOOD STEP FORWARD TO
HAVING A MORE EQUITABLE.
SYSTEM IN CALIFORNIA AND I
RESPECTFULLY HOUSE WHEN I GO.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE.
HEARING AND SEEING THEM MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
I BATES.
BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA.
IDEALLY OWN.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ.
I HEARD HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO. AYE JACKSON.
BY LARA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
IF I WIN.
NELSON.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
FIGHT BACK.
BUT KATHY.
I WINNER.
BY WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN.
I BATES.
DALY ON.
FULLER.
GAINES.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
WHEN.
NIELSEN SKINNER.
STONE.
PRODUCT.
I.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PSSES FILE ITEM SIXTY
SEVEN SENATOR HERNANDEZ MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE ANY TWO BY
SENATOR HERNANDEZ AND ACT
WILLING TO ALCOHOL AND DRUG
PROGRAMS CENTER HERNANDEZ THINK
AMANDA PRESIDENT MEMBERS ON
COLLEAGUES.
WE'VE BEEN HEARING ABOUT ON
SOME TROUBLING PRACTICES
HAPPENING WITHIN THE SUBSTANCE
ABUSE TREATMENT INDUSTRY. WHILE
THE MAJORITY OF TREATMENT
SYSTEMS OPERATE WITHIN THE LAW
THERE ARE BAD ACTORS OUT THERE.
AND WE NEED TO PROTECT
INDIVIDUALS WITH SUBSTANCE USE
DISORDERS WHO NEED A RANGE OF
SERVICES.
PEOPLE OF SUBSTANCE ABUSE
DISORDERS DESERVE ACCESS TO
COMPREHENSIVE.
QUALITY CARE IN THE SAME WAY
THAT THOSE WITH PHYSICAL HEALTH
AILMENTS HAVE ACCESS.
THIS BILL STRENGTHENS OVERSIGHTS
OF LICENSE AND CERTIFY TREATMENT
PROGRAMS.
BY REQUIRING THEM TO DISCLOSE
CERTAIN BUSINESS RELATIONSHIPS.
INCLUDING THOSE WITH UNLICENSED
SOBER LIVING HOMES.
THIS BILL ALSO TIGHTENS CURRENT
LAW IMPROVE TREATMENT SERVICES.
AND PROVIDE THE AGENCY S. MORE
OVERSIGHT AUTHORITY OVER
RESIDENTIAL TREATMENT FACILITIES
MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FROM
IOWA.
THANK YOU CENTER HERNANDEZ
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE AYE AYES
THIRTY FOUR KNOW ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM SIXTY
EIGHT SENATOR MORALE.
PASS TEMPORARILY FILE ITEM SIXTY
NINE SENATOR LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ONE THOUSAND BY
SENATOR LADA AND ACT WILLING TO
TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION.
SENATOR LARA THANK YOU MEMBERS
AS THE ONE THOUSAND PROMOTES
ACCESS TO SPEED IN OUR
COMMUNITIES BY INCLUDING
PROXIMITY TO FAST. CHARGING
STATIONS AS PART OF THE CRITERIA
IN A PUBLIC INVESTMENTS THIS
BILL WILL HELP PREVENT THE
SCENARIO WHERE SOME COMMUNITIES
IN OUR STATE HAVE ACCESS. TO
VERY FAST CHARGING STATIONS
WHILE OTHERS GET LEFT BEHIND
ALSO SB ONE THOUSAND INSURERS
ACCESS TO ALL TYPES OF E. VIS
WHEN WE MAKE PUBLIC INVESTMENTS
IN EVEY INFRASTRUCTURE. BETTER
THAT THEIR COMPONENT OF THIS
BILL IS TO ADDRESS THE BARRIERS
TO HEAVY DUTY FLEETS AND PROMOTE
STRATEGIC CHARGING WHILE ARE
CHARGING FOR THE HEAVY DUTY.
FACTOR WE NEED TO DEMOCRATIZE
FAST CHARGERS WITH OUR PUBLIC
INVESTMENTS MEMBERS ALL ALSO
WERE EXPANDING ACCESS TO EVERY
COMMUNITY I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
I. THINK YOU CENTER LARA.
IS THERE ANY MEMBERS A
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
I. ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
BY BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LARA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I.
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK.
MORALE.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE AYE DECK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
WIENER.
I WILK. AYE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
I.
DELEON.
MITCHELL. MORE LOCK WHEN.
I KNOW SAN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
WHY COUNTY?
I.
EYES THIRTY THREE NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON THE
FILE ITEM SEVENTY SENATOR WIENER
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TUNNEL FOR A SENATOR
WIENER AND ACT GOING TO MENTAL
HEALTH SENATOR WIENER I'VE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SP ONE
THOUSAND FOUR. FIVE SIX TO
STANDARDIZE AND STRENGTH AND.
PREVENTION EARLY INTERVENTION
TREATMENT ACROSS CALIFORNIA.
BY ESTABLISHING STRATEGIC
PRIORITIES FOR COUNTY MHSAA OR
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES ACT
FUNDED PROGRAMS THIS IS THE FROM
THE MILLIONAIRES TAX OF THE
VOTERS PASSED AWHILE BACK. THESE
PRIORITIES INCLUDE EARLY
PSYCHOSIS AND MOOD DISORDERS
ACTION INTERVENTION ACROSS THE
LIFESPAN. BY OUR REGION
ENGAGEMENT THE TARGETS.
TRANSITION AID YOU. WITH A
PRIORITY ON COLLEGE PARTNERSHIPS
AND CHILDHOOD TRAUMA PREVENTION
AND EARLY INTERVENTION.
I SB ONE THOUSAND FOUR REQUIRES
THE MHSAAOVERSIGHT AND
ACCOUNTABILITY COMMISSION OUGHT
TO CREATE STATEWIDE REPORTING
METRICS FOR TRACKING THE
OUTCOMES. AND EFFECTIVENESS OF
COUNTY PREVENTION EARLY
INTERVENTION PROGRAMS AND TASKS
THE COMMISSION WITH PROVIDING
COUNTIES PROGRAMMATIC SUPPORT
AND TECHNICAL. ASSISTANCE.
WE KNOW.
DIED OF THE APPROXIMATELY HALF
A BILLION DOLLARS OF PREVENTION
AND EARLY INTERVENTION FUNDING
FROM THE MHS AYE SOME IS BEING
SPENT SOME IS THEN.
IT'S NOT VERY WELL STRUCTURED
IN A NUMBER OF COUNTIES WE WANT
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE
FOCUSING THESE FUNDS.
IN AREAS WHERE WE CAN REALLY
MOVE.
THE NEEDLE AND WE PARTICULARLY
WANT TO MAKE SURE I THAT WE ARE
PROVIDING STRONG MENTAL HEALTH
SUPPORT FOR YOUNG PEOPLE BECAUSE
ONE HALF OF MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES
ARISE BY THE AGE OF FIFTEEN.
SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT BY THE AGE
OF TWENTY FIVE WE THE SUPPORT AT
PEOPLE IN ALL STAGES OF LIFE BUT
WE REALLY NEED TO SUPPORT OUR
USED. I SP ONE THOUSAND FOUR
WILL TAKE US IN THAT DIRECTION I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE
THAT WE GOT WILL DEBATE GOING
OVER HERE TO THE RIGHT.
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING THEM EYES
THIRTY THREE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON THE
FILE ITEM SEVENTY TWO SENATOR
LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TEN THIRTEEN BY
SENATOR LOTT A AN ACT LINDA
GREENHOUSE GASES
SENATE LARA THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS AS WE TOOK A
TEN THIRTEEN ADDRESSES. AGENCY
SUPER POLLUTANTS A SB TEN
THIRTEEN BACKSTOPS EPA'S
REGULATIONS AND PROVIDES
INCENTIVES FOR BUSINESSES TO
TRANSITION TO BETTER
REFRIGERANTS.
I WITH THIS BILL WE ARE
HIGHLIGHTING THE MOST IMPACTFUL
AND LEAST KNOWN POLLUTANTS THESE
CHEMICALS ARE IN OUR SUPERMARKET
REFRIGERATION. SYSTEMS LARGE
COLD STORAGE WAREHOUSES AND IN
OUR HOME REFRIGERATORS THEY ARE
INVISIBLE BUT ONCE THE LEAK
AGENCIES ARE THOUSANDS OF TIMES
MORE IMPACTFUL ON RETIREMENT
THAN CARBON DIOXIDE. NEW
REFRIGERATION SYSTEMS ARE OFTEN
MORE ENERGY EFFICIENT SO
INVESTING AND INCENTIVES CAN BE
A WIN WIN SITUATION. MEMBERS OF
BEEN QUESTIONS ABOUT THE CHARGE
SIZES AND WHAT HAPPENS TO NEW
TECHNOLOGIES IN THE FUTURE AND
THE FUTURE WHICH HAVE COME UP IN
COMMITTEE WE HAVE BEEN WORKING
WITH A R. B. THE CLARIFY THE
LANGUAGE. IN THIS BILL TO
ADDRESS THE SPECIFIC ISSUES
WE TOOK AMENDMENTS AND SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS.
THE CAR CLARIFY A ARBY'S
AUTHORITY TO MAKE FUTURE CHANGES
TO THE TIME LINES AND ALLOW FOR
FLEXIBILITY OF NEW TECHNOLOGIES
TO COME IN. ONLINE A WE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY PROVIDE MARKET
CERTAINTY AND HOW. BUSINESSES
TRANSITION TO BETTER
ALTERNATIVES BUSINESSES HAVE
BEEN PLANNING FOR THIS TIME
LINES IS TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN
AND THIS BILL PROVIDES A
CONSISTENT APPROACH. WITH THE
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES TO HELP
BUSINESSES PURCHASE BETTER
ALTERNATIVES ARE STRICTLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
THUNDERSTONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
RESPECTFULLY STAND IN OPPOSITION
TO SB TEN THIRTEEN SB TEN
THIRTEEN IS ADDRESSING AN ISSUE
THAT OUR AIR RESOURCES BOARD IS
ALREADY SEEKING TO ADDRESS.
I THINK OF ALL THIS ISSUE IS AN
IMPORTANT ISSUE AND I AGREE THAT
WE NEED TO FIND AN ANSWER TO
FACES DANGER TO OUR CLIMATE
PLACING THIS IN STATUTE IS A
MISTAKE AT THIS TIME.
IN REGARDS TO THESE ISSUES AND
CONCERNS I THINK WE'RE BEST
LEADING HARBOR DRESS THE ISSUE.
THEY'VE ALREADY HELD HEARINGS ON
THIS LAST MARCH AND CARP HAS
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESSES IN
PLACE TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL
INTERESTED IN CONCERNED PARTIES
ARE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE. IN THIS
ISSUE BY ADOPTING THE FEDERAL
REGULATIONS DIRECTLY THROUGH
THIS BILL RATHER THAN THROUGH
THE FORMAL RULE MAKING PROCESS
THIS BILL WILL ALLOW CARD TO
AVOID HAVING TO PREPARE A
DETAILED. AND LEGALLY DEFENSIBLE
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF THESE RULES
AND BYPASS THE CALIFORNIA
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES ACT
LETS MCCARTY THEIR JOB I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NO VOTE AND
TENSE THIRTEEN.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE THING AND
HEARING NONE SEVERAL ARE WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT JUST TO CLARIFY
A ARE BE. ALREADY HAS THE
AUTHORITY TO DO THIS WILL
HOWEVER WERE DOING IN THIS BILL
IS CREATING THE INCENTIVES AND
CREAM THE FLEXIBILITY SO THAT
BUSINESSES GOT ARE ABLE TO
COMPLY. YET AGAIN TRYING TO MEET
THE NEEDS OF OUR BUSINESS
INDUSTRY AS THEY'RE PREPARING TO
MEET.
THE TREND CURRENT TRANSITION
DEADLINES THAT.
WE'VE ESTABLISHED IN S. B.
THIRTEEN EIGHTY THREE FROM LAST
YEAR A STRICTLY ANSWER AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL. NO BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
LOTTE.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NELSON.
WE KNOW.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I.
ROTH.
SKINNER STERN.
BY STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT NO AYE CASKEY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
NOW. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN.
I.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
GALGIANI.
JACKSON.
I.
MITCHELL.
MORE NIELSEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I TWENTY ONE KNOWS TEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM SEVENTY FIVE SENATOR BELL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN NINETEEN BY
SENATOR BELL AN ACT RELATING TO
YOUTH MENTAL HEALTH SENATOR BELL.
BETTER PRESIDENT CENTERS SAUDI
SP.
.
TEN NINETEEN IS A BILL THAT
CREATES PARITY IN CRISIS
INTERVENTION. DOLLARS IN BOOZ
MENTAL HEALTH CARE PARTNERSHIPS
BETWEEN SCHOOLS. AND REGIONAL
MENTAL HEALTH AGENCIES OF. THE
BILL.
ALLOCATES AT LEAST HAVE TO
TRIAGE GRANT FUNDING FOR
SERVICES.
TARGETED TO YOUTH EIGHTEEN YEARS
OF AGE OR YOUNGER AND ENCOURAGES
OF.
FOR THE FIRST TIME I THINK.
PARTNERSHIPS BETWEEN SCHOOLS
AND LOCAL MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
THROUGH AN ESTABLISHED RUN. NOW
CURRENTLY THEM THE MENTAL HEALTH
CRISIS FUNDING FOR USE CITRIC
PROGRAMS. RECEIVED.
ONLY FIFTEEN PERCENT. OF THE
TOTAL AVAILABLE FUNDS WITH THE
REMAINING.
EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT WERE
ALLOCATED TWO ADULTS SO IT WAS.
LITTLE BIT ADULTS LE ORIENTED.
WE MUST ENSURE THAT CHILDREN A
MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS ARE GIVEN
EQUAL ACCESS.
TO RESOURCES THAT ADULT RECEIVED
SO. THIS PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN
SCHOOLS.
AND COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH%
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PROFESSIONALS
OFFERS STUDENTS AND FAMILIES AND
EXTENDED NETWORK. OF MENTAL
HEALTH PROGRAMS AND SERVICES
THAT ARE EASILY ACCESSIBLE. OF
THE BILL IS SPONSORED BY THE
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES OVERSIGHT
AND ACCOUNTABILITY COMMISSION.
AND ENJOYS THE SUPPORT OF THE
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION.
WHO WOULD LIKE TO HAVE
BEHAVIORAL SERVICES IN OUR
SCHOOLS AS WELL?
SO I. I REQUEST SUPPORT OF.
S. B..
TEN NINETEEN THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER BELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
HEARING AND SEEING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION TO USING A
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
HEARING AND SEEING THEM EYES
THIRTY TWO NO ZERO AND THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM SEVENTY
SIX SENATOR HERNANDEZ MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL TEN TWENTY THREE BY SENATOR
HERNANDEZ ENACT GROWING TO
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE
COVERAGE. CENTER HERNANDEZ THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
TELEHEALTH IS EXPANDING ITS A
VITAL PART OF OUR HEALTHCARE
SYSTEM. THAT INCREASES ACCESS TO
CARE TO LOWER COSTS ESPECIALLY
IN RURAL UNDERSERVED AREAS OF
OUR STATE.
RIGHT NOW CALIFORNIA THE RELEASE
FOR WEBSITES OR MOBILE APPS THAT
PATIENTS CAN USE TO REQUEST
TESTS. FROM CERTAIN STDS AND
HORMONAL BIRTH CONTROL WITHOUT
AN OFFICE VISIT.
HOWEVER THE SPONSOR OF S. B. TEN
TWENTY THREE FOUND THAT IN SOME
AREAS OF THE STATE. HEALTH
INSURANCE REIMBURSEMENT FOR
THESE TYPES TELL HEALTH SERVICES
IS LIMITED.
THIS ILL CLARIFIES IT INSURANCE
COVERAGE IS AVAILABLE FOR
CERTAIN REPRODUCTIVE SERVICES.
DELIVERED THROUGH TELEHEALTH. IT
ALSO REQUIRES THAT OUR FAMILY
PACK PROGRAM TO PROVIDE THIS
COVERAGE.
MEMBERS THIS BILL ENSURES THAT
INDIVIDUAL SEEKING REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CARE SERVICES. REGARDLESS
OF LOCATION CAN RECEIVE THE CARE
THEY NEED IN THE MOST EFFICIENT
WAY AND MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK AND I WILL.
THANK YOU CENTER HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ MEMBERS IN HIS
QUESTION AND OR DEBATE HEARING
AND SEEING THAT MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
NO.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I.
BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL. AYE HUESO. AYE JACKSON.
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE. AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
VIDE ACT.
AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
BATES.
ALLEN I.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA. DAILY ON. FULLER.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK
MORRELL.
NO.
NIELSEN.
ROTH STONE.
NO.
EYES TWENTY FOUR KNOWS FIVE THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM SEVENTY
SEVEN SENATOR WILK MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN TWENTY FOUR BY
SUNDER WILK AN ACT RELATING TO
ANIMAL ABUSE.
SENATOR WILK THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS
SENATE BILL TEN TWENTY FOUR
BRINGS CHANGES TO CALIFORNIA'S
HANDLING OF ANIMAL ABUSE
OFFENDERS SO THAT WE. CAN BEGIN
TO BREAK THE LINK BETWEEN ANIMAL
CRUELTY AND VIOLENCE TOWARDS
PEOPLE.
S. B. TEN TWENTY FOUR WALAU
WHAT'S TO REDIRECT THE MOST
SERIOUS ANIMAL ABUSE OFFENDERS.
INTO MENTAL HEALTH EVALUATIONS
IN TREATMENTS SO THAT WE CAN
IDENTIFY AND ADDRESS THE
UNDERLYING CAUSES OF THEIR
VIOLENT BEHAVIOR AND BEGIN TO
SNAP THE LINK BETWEEN ANIMAL
CRUELTY. AND TRAGIC ACTS OF
VIOLENCE COMMITTED LATER BY MANY
THE SAME OFFENDERS.
ADDITIONALLY THIS BILL WILL
IMPLEMENT AN ANIMAL OWNER
EDUCATION COURSE.
TO SURE ANIMAL. ABUSE IT
OFFENCES ROOTED IN IGNORANCE.
ARE NOT REPEATED IF YOU LOOK AT
THE DATA. NEARLY FIFTY PERCENT
OF ALL CONVICTED RAPISTS START
WITH THE ANIMAL ABUSE SEVENTY
ONE.
PERCENT OF THOSE CONVICTED
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN NINETY
PERCENT OF THOSE OF MASS
SHOOTERS SO WE'VE SEEN THE DATA.
WE'VE SEEN THE END AT THE
ANECDOTAL PROOF IN OUR DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE SHELTERS IN OUR SCHOOLS
IN ON THE NIGHTLY NEWS.
WE NO THE LINK BETWEEN ANIMAL
VIOLENCE AND FUTURE BALLOTS
WORDS PEOPLE IS STRONG BUT IT IS
AN UNBREAKABLE. SP TEN TWENTY
FOUR WILSHIRE CALIFORNIA'S
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS BEING
ADEQUATELY UTILIZED AS A
MECHANISM OF INTERVENTION AND
REHABILITATION IN THE AREA OF
ANIMAL ABUSE OFFENDERS.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
YOU CENTER WELL MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL. AYE BERRYHILL.
I.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
I LARA. AYE LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE
AYE MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE BY JACK.
AYE WIECKOWSKI. AYE WIENER.
I WILK.
I.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN.
I.
CANNELLA. DELEON.
GLAZER. AYE MITCHELL MORLOCK.
NIELSEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
EYES THIRTY TWO NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE HAVE
BROKEN FIFTY BILLS WE ARE ON A
ROLL WE'RE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
SEVENTY EIGHT SENATOR MCGUIRE
MISTER SECRETARY. PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TEN TWENTY NINE TO
SENATOR. AND ACTUALLY
TRANSPORTATION
CENTER MCGUIRE.
JUST OR YOU VERY QUICKLY THIS IS
A DISTRICT BILL WHERE THE
CURRENT RARE ROAD RUNS THROUGH
FIVE AND THE SEVEN COUNTIES IN
OUR NORTH COAST DISTRICT
HUMBOLDT TRINITY MENDOCINO
CINEMA IN MARIN. THE RAIL LINE
IS CURRENTLY OWNED BY THE NORTH
COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY WHICH
IS CREATED BY THE LEGISLATURE IN
NINETEEN EIGHTY NINE. AFTER
MONTHS OF RESEARCHING DISCUSSION
LAST YEAR WE ARE SADDENED TO
CONCLUDE THAT THE REBUILDING OF
THE RAIL LINE WAS SIMPLY NOT A
FEASIBLE ALTERNATIVE BOTH
FINANCIALLY OR PHYSICALLY. THE
REMOTENESS OF THE LINE THE LACK
OF SHIPPERS IN THE EXTREME
GEOLOGIC CHALLENGES ALL COMBINE
TO MAKE A RAIL LINE IMPOSSIBLE.
AT THIS POINT IN SEE ARE A IS
NEARLY BANKRUPT AND HAS NO
ABILITY TO BE A DEAL WITH THEIR
PROBLEMS. THEY'VE RACKED UP A
SUFFOCATING DEBT HAVE VIRTUALLY
NO STAFF
THE TRACKS IN CROSSINGS ARE
DISINTEGRATING AND THEY'RE
LISTED BY THE STATE AS A HIGH
RISK AGENCY.
BUT THIS ISN'T THE END WE NOW
THAN OPPORTUNITY TO REMAKE THIS
RIGHT AWAY INTO SOMETHING
SPECTACULAR FOR THE NORTH COAST
AND EVERYONE ELSE.
AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE BEFORE
YOU TODAY THE NC ARE A WILL BE
DISSOLVED THROUGH S. B. TEN
TWENTY NINE IN A THREE HUNDRED
MILE LONG RIGHT AWAY WILL BE
DIVIDED ROUGHLY AT THE HALFWAY
POINT. WITH THE EXISTING SINAMA
MARINE AREA RAIL TRANSIT
AUTHORITY. WHO RUNS OPERATIONS
IN THE SOUTH FOR PASSENGER RAIL
IN THE NEWLY ESTABLISHED GREAT
RIVER TRAIL AGENCY MANAGE
OPERATIONS IN THE NORTH?
RIGHT NOW IN SIERRA REYES
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTED MISSION IS
SIMPLY IMPOSSIBLE AND WE NEED TO
MAKE A CHANGE ACOSTA LIABILITIES
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS BILL ARE
ALREADY. UP WITH NCR A IN THE
CURRENT TRACKS IN THIS BILL JUST
BEGINS TO BE ABLE TO RESOLVE
THEM ONCE AND FOR ALL. WE'VE
BEEN WORKING DILIGENTLY ON THIS
PROJECT OVER THE LAST YEAR AND
RESOLVE MANY OF THE SIGNIFICANT
ISSUES THE RIGHT OF WAY HAS FACE.
AND WE'RE GONNA CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH THOSE WHO SUPPORT OR MAY
HAVE SOME CHALLENGES AYE AS WE
MAKE OUR WAY IN THE ASSEMBLY.
ALONG WITH THE ADMINISTRATION ON
THE FINANCING DETAILS WHICH
INCLUDING ALLOCATION THAT IS
CURRENTLY IN THE SENATE BUDGET.
ENCLOSING THERE'D BEEN NO NO
VOTES ON THIS BILL THROUGH THREE
COMMITTEES AND APPRECATE
SUPPORT OF THIS DISTRICT THAT
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SENATE
MCGUIRE MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I. BATES.
I BILL. AYE BERRYHILL. AYE
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON YEAH DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GOT JOINING.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
ISLA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
MONNING.
MORE LOCKED.
MORRELL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN. PAN AYE AYE AYE
PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE AYE DAK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
WIENER.
BY WILK AYE.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON AYE CANNELLA. DELEON.
MITCHELL MONNING AYE.
MORE LOCK.
NIELSEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
WHY CASSIE?
I CITY ONE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
FILE ITEM EIGHTY SENATOR WIENER
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN FORTY FIVE A
SENATOR WINNER AND ACT RELATING
TO CONSERVATORSHIP
SENATOR WIENER I'VE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT. BY COLLEAGUES
SP TEN FORTY FIVE AND I WANT TO
THANK.
THE SENATOR.
FROM VENTURA COUNTY FOR HIS.
JOINT AUTHORSHIP BY CREATES A
NEW CONSERVATORSHIP FOR.
A PERSON WHO IS CHRONICALLY
HOMELESS.
INCAPABLE OF CARING.
FOR THEIR OWN HEALTH AND WELL
BEING.
DUE TO SERIOUS.
MENTAL ILLNESS AND SUBSTANCE
ABUSE DISORDER. AYE AS EVIDENCED
BY HIGH FREQUENCY EMERGENCY
DEPARTMENT USE HIGH FREQUENCY
JAIL DETENTION.
AND HIGH FREQUENCY.
FIFTY ONE FIFTIES
PSYCHIATRIC ODD DETENTIONS.
BY THIS BILL IS LIMITED TO LOS
ANGELES AND SAN FRANCISCO
COUNTIES EYES PART OF A FIVE
YEAR PILOT PROGRAM FOR THESE TWO
COUNTIES.
I HAD THE BILL IS FUNDAMENTALLY
ABOUT GIVING COUNTIES A NARROW
TOOL. I TOOK FOR AYE AND FRANKLY
TO SAVE THE LIVES OF OUR MOST
VULNERABLE.
RESIDENTS PEOPLE WHO ARE LIVING
AND FRANKLY DYING.
A TEARY IRANIAN DYING ON OUR
STREETS.
BY CHRONIC HOMELESS WHO ARE
SUFFERING FROM SEVERE. DRUG
ADDICTION AND MENTAL HEALTH BY
ISSUES
PEOPLE WHO ARE INCAPABLE OF
MAKING DECISIONS FOR THEMSELVES.
SAN FRANCISCO ESTIMATES THAT
THIS POPULATION ACCOUNTS FOR
APPROXIMATELY ONE PERCENT.
ADVERSITIES OVERALL HOMELESS
POPULATION THE VAST MAJORITY OF
HOMELESS PEOPLE DON'T EVEN COME
CLOSE TO MEETING THE NARROW
CRITERIA. IN THIS BILL.
YOUR PEOPLE WALKING DOWN THE
STREETS NOT JUST IN SAN
FRANCISCO AND LA BUT IN SOME
OTHER CITIES AS WELL. WONDER.
I DON'T KNOW WHY ARE WE NOT
DOING ANYTHING. ABOUT THIS
PERSON WHO I SEE EVERY DAY. WHO
IS?
JUST DYING ON OUR STREETS WHY IS
NO ONE DOING ANYTHING. ABOUT IT
IS VERY VERY FRUSTRATING AND
PERPLEXING.
WHAT'S PEOPLE.
AND THE REALITY IS.
DIE IRE COUNTIES ARE TELLING US.
THAT THIS HAPPENS BECAUSE OUR
CURRENT LAW. IS INADEQUATE. IN
TERMS OF GETTING THESE FOLKS THE
HELP THAT THEY NEED.
GETTING THEM INTO CARE. GETTING
THEM IF NECESSARY INTO A
CONSERVATORSHIP.
AND THAT'S WHAT THISBILL AIMS
TO REMEDY TO GIVE OUR COUNTIES
THE TOOLS THAT THEY NEED.
TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE ARE NOT
DYING.
ON OUR STREETS.
THIS BILL MAINTAINS ALL OF THE
DUE PROCESS PROTECTIONS THAT
CURRENT CALIFORNIA LAW PROVIDES
OPPORTUNE SERVITUDE SHIPS A
JUDGE AND JURY. THE RIGHT TO
COUNSEL PERIODIC REVIEW.
I THIS BILL HAS MANY MANY CHECKS
AND BALANCES.
AND THE GOAL HERE IS HOUSING AND
SERVICES NOT LOCKED FACILITIES
MANY PEOPLE CONSERVATORSHIP DO
NOT NEED TO BE UNLOCKED
FACILITIES. THEY CAN BE IN
HOUSING WITH SOMEONE TEMPORARILY
MAKING DECISIONS FOR THEM. UNTIL
THEY CAN GET HEALTHY AND GET
THEIR LIVES BACK TOGETHER. UNDER
CURRENT LAW.
BUT PARTICULARLY FOR PEOPLE WHO
ARE ADDICTED TO DRUGS.
I AFTER A SEVENTY TWO HOUR HOLD
BILL GO BEFORE A JUDGE. AND THEY
MAY HAVE SOBERED UP AND SEEM
COMPLETELY NORMAL AND THE JUDGE
WILL RELEASE SOME NEVER MIND
THAT THEY'VE BEEN FIFTY ONE
FIFTY TEN TIMES. IN THE PAST
YEAR. I'VE THIS BILL.
WILL HELP OUR COUNTIES HELP
THESE INDIVIDUALS GOT HELPING OF
THEIR LIVES ON TRACK.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK DERIVE O..
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
BY ATKINS.
BY BATES AYE BILL.
BY BERRYHILL AYE BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES
AYE GALGIANI AYE GLAZER. AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO.
JACKSON.
I LARA.
LEYVA.
MCGUIRE.
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LOCK MORALE.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN. PAN.
I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE. BY. AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WIENER. AYE WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN.
BY.
CANNELLA.
DELEON HUESO.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL MORLOCK MORALE.
BY NELSON.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I THIRTY ONE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PATH.
MOVING ON FILE ITEM.
EIGHTY OR.
AB THREE VERY GOOD CENTER DIED
MISS SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN EIGHTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR DODD AND ACT GOING TO
DISASTER PREPAREDNESS.
SENATOR DODD.
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS IN THE
LAST TWO DECADES CALIFORNIA'S
BEEN BESIEGED WITH DEVASTATING
WILDFIRES.
THE REASON WHY COUNTRY WILDFIRES
COST ESTIMATED TEN BILLION
DOLLARS IN PROPERTY DAMAGE IN
THE LOSS. OF OVER FORTY LIVES.
THE FIRE FIGHTING BECAUSE COUPLE
WITH THE COST RECOVERY TOTAL IN
THE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
WERE WILD LANDS A BUT URBAN
DEVELOPMENT THE SO SO CALLED
WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE.
DOWN IN ARCANE POWER LINES HAVE
OFTEN BEEN IDENTIFIED AS THE
POINT OF WILDFIRE IGNITION.
S. B. TEN EIGHTY EIGHT WOULD
ESTABLISH REQUIREMENTS FOR
UTILITIES TO REDUCE THE RISK OF
LIGHTLY EXCUSE ME OF IGNITING
WILDFIRES BY INVESTING IN
UPGRADES TO THEIR INFRASTRUCTURE.
IN PROTECT AGAINST DAMAGE FROM
OTHER NATURAL DISASTERS LIKE
EARTHQUAKES AND FLOODS.
NOT WITHSTANDING APPROVING COST
SAVINGS OF AT LEAST THREE TO ONE.
THE CPUC HAS NOT ESTABLISHED
ADEQUATE STANDARDS FOR UTILITIES
TO REDUCE THE RISK OF WILD FIRES
CAUSED BY UTILITY EQUIPMENT. IT
TO MAKE THEIR EQUIPMENT MORE
RESILIENT AND RESISTANT TO
DAMAGE FROM MAJOR DISASTER YOU
VETS.
S. B. TEN EIGHTY EIGHT WOULD
REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
SERVICES OH YES IN CONJUNCTION
WITH THE CPUC CAL FIRE AND OTHER
AGENCIES. TO ESTABLISH STANDARDS
FOR UTILITIES TO HARDEN THEIR
GRIP.
S. B. TEN EIGHTY EIGHT REQUIRED
UTILITIES FILE SAFETY RELIABLE
LET RELIABILITY RESILIENCE
PLANTS WITH THE CPUC SPECIFYING
HOW THE UTILITY WILL MEET THE.
STANDARDS SET BY NO A HOUSE.
ESTABLISHING A STANDALONE SAFETY
PROCEEDING WOULD REQUIRE
INVESTOR OWNED UTILITIES IN THE
CPUC TO GIVE GREATER ATTENTION.
AND CARE TO SAFETY AND
RELIABILITY.
LET ME KNOW THAT THE AMENDMENTS
TAKEN APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HAVE REMOVED THE OPPOSITION OF
THE DISTRIBUTED ENERGY RESOURCES
COMPANIES.
LET ME ALSO NOTE THAT THE
ELECTRIC UTILITIES CANNOT
IMPLEMENT THE SAFETY A RELIABLE
RIPPED RELIABILITY. AND
RESILIENCE PLANTS INTO THE OR
APPROVED BY THE CPUC.
ANY CHANGES TO TELL THE RATES
MAY NOT BE IMPOSED UNTIL AND
UNLESS THE CPUC IS COMPLETED
THIS EXTENSIVE PUBLIC PROCESS TO
APPROVE. RATE CHANGES.
MEMBERS IN A WORLD OF DRAMATIC
CLIMATE CHANGE WERE WILDFIRE
RISK THREATENS ALL YOUR LONG AND
WERE DEVELOPMENT IS PUSHING
FURTHER INTO THE HINTERLANDS.
WE MUST REQUIRE UTILITIES TO
MEET THEIR RESPONSIBILITY FOR
PRO ACTIVELY INVEST IN THEIR
SYSTEMS TO MINIMIZE THE
POSSIBILITY GUIDING. YET ANOTHER
DEVASTATING FIERY. S. B. TEN
EIGHTY EIGHT IS SUPPORTED BY
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS LABOR
UTILITIES THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
FIREFIGHTERS AND MORE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU RIGHT
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD SENATOR
BATES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT OB
EARLIER THIS YEAR THE GOVERNOR
IN THE FOR LEGISLATIVE LEADERS
STATED OUR INTENT.
TO PARTNER ON SOLUTIONS TO MAKE
CALIFORNIA MORE RESILIENT
AGAINST THE IMPACTS OF NATURAL
DISASTERS AND CLIMATE CHANGE. WE
STATED IN NEED TO TAKE STRONG
AND COMPREHENSIVE ACTION TO
CRAFT SOLUTIONS FOR ISSUES
INCLUDING UPDATING RULES AND
REGULATIONS FOR UTILITY SERVICE
IN LIGHT OF THE CHANGING CLIMATE.
I WANT TO THANK THE OFFER AUTHOR
FOR HIS EFFORTS TO DATE ON THIS
BILL IN PARTICULAR THOSE TAKEN
AND NOT ASSEMBLY APPROPRIATIONS.
THE ISSUES CONTEMPLATED IN S.
MEETIN EIGHTY EIGHT SHOULD BE
INCLUDED IN THE BROADER
DISCUSSION TO ENSURE A MORE
COMPREHENSIVE UPDATE. IN ORDER
FOR THAT TO OCCUR S. B. TEN
EIGHTY EIGHT NEEDS TO ADVANCE
THE BILL TAKES LONG OVERDUE
STEPS TO REFORM THE SEED. CPUC
PROCESS FOR PLANNING AND
IMPROVING CRITICAL. OUR
INVESTMENTS ON OUR STATES ADS
AGING UTILITY IFRASTRUCTURE. WE
ALL KNOW THAT GREED SAFETY AND
RELIABILITY SHOULD ALWAYS BE OUR
FOCUS.
THE ONGOING RISK OF CATASTROPHIC
WILDFIRES SHOULD ONLY SERVED TO
HEIGHTEN OUR SENSE OF URGENCY.
HOWEVER I DO WANT TO POINT OUT
THAT THE BILL IS NOT FULLY
COOKED GOING FORWARD I BELIEVE
MANY QUESTIONS MUST BE
CONTEMPLATED UNANSWERED. FOR
EXAMPLE ALL OF THE NEW
REQUIREMENTS IN THE BILL WILL
COME AND SIGNIFICANT COSTS TO
RATEPAYERS AND WE'VE SEEN THAT.
POP FOLKS IN MANY OF THE BILL'S
LIVE COM FOLLOW THROUGH THE
ENERGY COMMITTEE. HOW CAN WE
PROVIDE APPROPRIATE OVERSIGHT
AND RESTRICTION ON THOSE COSTS
THE BILL REQUIRES CLEAR EVIDENCE
THE UTILITY HAVE BEEN ADEQUATELY
SIZED? AND TRAINED WORKFORCE TO
PROMPTLY RESTORE SERVICE AFTER A
MAJOR EVENT.
IS THIS REQUIREMENT MET BY JUST
REPORTING THE NUMBER OF LINEMEN
THEY EMPLOY.
HOW DOES THE UTILITIES
DETERMINED THE NUMBER THAT IS
ADEQUATE SINCE EACH EVENT IS
DIFFERENT?
HOW DO WE BALANCE THE SIZE OF A
WORKFORCE FOR CATASTROPHIC
EVENTS WITH THE COST OF
MAINTAINING SUCH A WORKFORCE?
THERE ARE BIG TERMS IN THE BILL
THE BILL DEFINES A MAJOR ADVANCE.
AS A LARGE STORM BLOOD MUD SLIDE
FIRE EARTHQUAKER OTHER
OCCURRENCE THAT SIGNIFICANTLY
AFFECTS
THE SAFETY AND RELIABILITY OF
THE ELECTRICAL. OR GAS
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM.
WHAT DOES SIGNIFICANTLY AFFECTS
MEAN WHAT CONSTITUTES A
SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE?
WHO AND WHAT IS A QUALIFIED
INDEPENDENT INDEPENDENT
EVALUATOR?
THE BILL REQUIRES EACH
ELECTRICAL AND GAS CORPORATION
TO SUBMIT.
BY JANUARY FIFTEENTH TWENTY
NINETEEN. A SAFETY RELIABILITY
AND RESILIENCE LEAD PLAN FOR
APPROVAL BY THE COMMISSION. THE
BILL TAKES A FACT ON JANUARY
FIRST TWENTY NINETEEN.
THE PLANTS HAVE NUMEROUS
REQUIRED ELEMENTS SO HOW ARE THE
UTILITIES SUPPOSED TO COMPLY
WITH THE MANDATE. THERE ARE MANY
OTHER QUESTIONS THAT NEED TO BE%
ANSWERED I WILL VOTE TO ADVANCE
THIS LEGISLATION TODAY ABOUT.
I WOULD ASK THAT OUR CAUCUS
BE INCLUDED IN THE DISCUSSIONS
ON THE BILL AND THE BROADER
DISCUSSION THAT WE ARE ALL
COMMITTED TO HAVE.
THIS ISSUE IS TOO IMPORTANT FOR
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF OUR
DISTRICTS TO HAVE A BILL CRAFTED.
BY AN INSULATED GROUP AND JUMPS
BACK ON TO THE SENATE FLOOR ON
CONCURRENCE WITHOUT INPUT FROM
ALL AFFECTED STAKEHOLDERS.
BAH I CERTAINLY OFF OUT OF THE
AUTHOR IN I WILL BE VOTING IN
SUPPORT TODAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR BATES SENATOR
HILL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT OF
MEMBERS I RISE TODAY.
IN A NUTSHELL.
THIS BILL IS ABOUT MONEY NOT
SAFETY.
THE PROBLEM IS NOT CLIMATE
CHANGE.
THE PROBLEM IS NOT MONEY.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT.
A TWENTY THE TWO THOUSAND AND
SEVEN FIRES IN SAN DIEGO COUNTY.
WERE CAUSED BY UTILITY
VIOLATIONS OF STATE LAW.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT THE TWO
THOUSAND FIFTEEN FIRES. FIRE IN
BUTTE.
COUNTY WHICH CAUSED BY UTILITY
VIOLATION OF STATE LAW.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT THREE OF THE
FOUR OCTOBER FIRES WHOSE
INVESTIGATIONS CALIPHATE
RELEASED LAST FRIDAY.
WERE FOUND TO BE STARTED AS A
RESULT OF.
VIOLATIONS OF STATE LAW.
THE PROBLEM IS NOT CLIMATE
CHANGE IT IS NOT ABOUT UTILITIES
NOT HAVING ENOUGH MONEY TO SPEND.
S. B. TEN EIGHTY EIGHT DOES NOT
IMPROVE SAFETY.
IT ONLY ENSURES THE UTILITY'S
GET PAID NO MATTER HOW
DISASTROUS DISASTER RELIEF
PERSONALLY.
THERE SYSTEMS MAY FAIL US.
THIS BILL REQUIRES UTILITIES TO
WRITE PLANS NOT ABOUT SAFETY BUT
ABOUT STRATEGY.
IF THEY CAN GET THE P. YOU SEE
TO SIGN OFF ON THEIR PLAN THEY
NEVER NEED TO WORRY. ABOUT
SUFFERING THE CONSEQUENCES OF
MISMANAGEMENT.
BECAUSE IT WILL BE OUR FAMILIES
AND COMMUNITIES ON THE HOOK FOR
PAIN.
THIS IS AN ISSUE AFFECTING ALL
OF OUR DISTRICTS NOT JUST THOSE
THAT HAVE EXPERIENCE FIRES. OR
PIPELINE EXPLOSIONS.
AFTER THE DEVASTATING EXPLOSION
IN SAN BRUNO.
I VOWED TO NEVER LET A SIMILAR
DISASTER HAPPEN AGAIN.
I CANNOT KEEP THAT VOW AND VOTE
FOR THIS BILL.
I THINK YOU SENATOR HILL SENATOR
ALAN.
MEMBERS ARE I. WAS INITIALLY
VERY SKEPTICAL THE BILL LIKE
STILL CONSENT CONTINUE TO HAVE
CONCERNS ALTHOUGH I HAVE HAD A
CONVERSATION WITH THE AUTHOR.
ABOUT ADDRESSING ONE OF SEVERAL
THE CRITICAL CONCERNS HAVE BEEN
RAISED BY THE CCA COMMUNITY. AND
WITH HIS COMMITMENT TO HAVE HIS
RD REMOVED ALL OF TWENTY EIGHT
NINETY NINE POINT THREE BUT WITH
IS ALSO A COMMITMENT TO. ADDRESS
THE ISSUE OF ALLOWING FOR THE
COMMITTEE CHOICE AGGREGATORS TO
SELF PROVIDE RESOURCES REQUIRED.
FOR RELIABILITY IS DETERMINE THE
COMMISSION SO AS TO NOT. PUT A
SITUATION WHERE CONSUMERS WERE
CUSTOMERS ARE BEING PAID A FEE
FOR SERVICE WE PAID.
TWICE FOR RELIABILITY SERVICES
I'M I'M.
GONNA SUPPORT TODAY AND I DO
APPRECIATE THE THE CENTER FOR
WORKING.
ON THIS ISSUE AND I APPRECIATE
THE FACT THAT HE'S TAKING THE
CONCERNED.
HE SAID YOU KNOW COUNTY LOBBYIST
THAT CONCERNS REFERENCE FROM CCA
COMMUNITY.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN SENATOR
WIENER.
I FIGURE VERY MUCH ON PRESIDENT
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF SB TEN
EIGHTY A I WANT TO THANK. OF THE
AUTHOR OF FOR WORKING VERY HARD
I TO ADDRESS BY SOME OF THE
CONCERNS THAT I AND OTHERS HIDE
OF WITH SOME PROVISIONS IN THE
BILL.
THE BILL AYE WHEN WENT THROUGH
COMMITTEE I HAD SOME PROVISIONS
RELATING TO DISTRIBUTED ENERGY
RESOURCES ODD THAT IN MY VIEW
AND THE VIEW OF OTHERS OF WOOD
ON THEIR MIND.
CALIFORNIA'S CLEAN ENERGY OUR
FUTURE AYE SO AFTER ON EXTENSIVE
DISCUSSION OF THE AUTHOR MADE
AMENDMENTS OUT THE RESOLVE THOSE
ISSUES AND AGAIN I WANT TO THANK
HIM FOR DOING THAT.
THIS BILL.
I THINK IS AN IMPORTANT STOP.
IN BEIJING OUR ENERGY SYSTEM
MORE ARE RESILIENT.
MAKING SURE THAT WE ARE QUOTE
UNQUOTE HARDENING OF THE SYSTEM
AND I AM HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT
THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER
WIENER SENATOR ANDERSON.
MEMBERSHIP IF YOU ARE RECALL WE
USED TO HAVE A COMMERCIAL IN
ILLICIT. IN THE COMMERCIAL.
HE WOULD SAY YOU CAN PAY ME NOW
OR YOU CAN PAY ME LATER.
AND.
WHAT I LIKE ABOUT THIS BILL?
IS THAT THERE'S ONLY ONE SOURCE
OF REVENUE FOR UTILITIES AND
RATEPAYERS.
YEAH AND
IF THE UTILITIES
FAILED TO DO THEIR JOBS AS
STATED WITH SOME THE FIRES.
WE END UP PAYING FOR THAT BUT
NOT ONLY DO WE PAY FOR IT WILL
YOU PAY FOR THE P. YOU SEE FINDS.
THAT COME TO THE DISTRICT AND
THEN HIT THE UTILITIES.
THIS BILL ALLOWS THEM TO PREEMPT
THOSE FINES BY HAVING A PLAN IN
ADVANCE
AND HARD. TO HARDEN THEIR ASSETS
IN MAKE MORE RELIABLE I THINK
SAFETY RELIABILITY ARE VERY
IMPORTANT. IN THIS BILL PUTS A
PRIORITY ON THAT ON THE FRONT
SIDE NOT AS AN AFTERTHOUGHT
AFTER THE ACCIDENT AFTER THE
FIRE. SO FOR THAT REASON I
ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT THIS
BILL.
BIG YOU CENTER AND.
TODAY BECAUSE I THINK IT'S A
START IT SAID.
IT'S AT THE BEGINNING OF GIVING
US SOME CERTAINTY
I THINK EVERYONE NEEDS SOME
CERTAINTY.
I THINK THAT. BE OUT THERE HAS
ASSURED ME HE'LL CONTINUE TO
WORK.
WITH OF ALL SIDES THERE ARE
STILL SOME SIGNIFICANT TECHNICAL
ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE TACKLED
BUT A LOT HAS BEEN DONE IN A
SHORT TIME.
AND.
I.
I FEEL VERY CERTAIN. THAT WILL
BE ABLE TO GET TO THE.
THE BEST PLACE IN THIS BILL THAT
GIVES THE CERTAINTY. AND HELPS
PEOPLE WHO HAVE SOME FEARS RIGHT
NOW.
ABOUT ON HOW FAR THIS BILL
REACHES THINKING.
THANK YOU SENATOR FOR SENATE
HUESO.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
DON'T WANNA.
OF.
IT KNOW BE LABOR THIS THIS SOB
BILL BUT IT IS AN IMPORTANT BILL
AND I JUST WANTED.
TO.
.
YOU NOT PROVIDE SOME ADDITIONAL
INSIGHTS INTO WHAT BILL ACTUALLY
DOES WE SAW THIS BILL IN
COMMITTEE AND WE WENT.
THROUGH IT VERY THOROUGHLY.
AND AND THERE ARE SOME MEASURES
IN THIS BILL THAT ARE EXTREMELY
IMPORTANT CLIMATE CHANGE IS
HAPPENING. IT'S CHANGING H.
REQUIRING US TO RE LOOK AT THE
STANDARDS THAT WERE SETTING FOR
POWER LINES IN THE WAY WE
DISTRIBUTE ENERGY. THAT IS A
FACT.
AND WHILE THERE HAVE BEEN.
.
YOU KNOW WHERE IT WILL UTILITIES
HAVE A IN THE PAST.
NOT DONE THEIR JOBS IN IN IN.
IN DOING THE WORK THEY PROMISE
THE REPAIRS THAT THEY'RE GONNA
DO THEY PROMISED TO BE YOU SEE
AND REPAIRS THERE AGAIN DO SENT
WORK IT DIDN'T HAPPEN RESULTED
IN ACCIDENTS.
AND THAT'S A DIFFERENT ISSUE.
THAT THAT IS A DIFFERENT ISSUE
THEN THIS BILL THIS BILL WILL
WILL REQUIRE THAT THE OF THE.
OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES IN
THE STATE.
TO COME UP WITH THE.
.
A A DOCUMENT WITH COME UP WITH
PLANS THAT ACCOUNT FOR THE
CHANGES IN CLIMATE CHANGE WERE
STARTING TO GET.
STRONGER WINDS MORE EXTREME
WEATHER. THAT REQUIRES US TO
LOOK AT OUR INFRASTRUCTURE AND
START TO PLAN ACCORDINGLY.
TO COUNTER THESE EVENTS IF YOU
IF THAT'S NOT THE PROCESS TO
ENSURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE
ADDITIONAL ACCIDENTS IN THE
STATE I DON'T KNOW WHAT IS.
I MEAN WE HAVE GONE THROUGH THIS
EXTENSIVELY AND I THINK THIS
BILL PROPOSES
THE BEST WAY TO FIX.
OUR OUR CRUMBLING INFRASTRUCTURE
THE BEST WAY TO FIX
OF THE FACT THAT WE HAVE OF
FACILITIES IN STATE THERE ARE NO
LONGER CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE
NEED.
TO WITHSTAND MAJOR EVENTS IN IN
IN THE FUTURE.
SO THIS IS OUR ARE A WONDERFUL
STEP FORWARD IN AND I UNDERSTAND
THEY'RE THEY'RE STILL THINGS
THAT CAN BE FIXED IN THE BILL I
UNDERSTAND THAT. AND I ENCOURAGE
THE AUTHOR TO CONTINUE TO WORK
ON THAT I KNOW THAT HE WILL. HE
HAS A GREAT REPUTATION FOR DOING
THAT AND I FEEL CONFIDENT THAT
THIS BILL IS HEADED IN THE RIGHT
DIRECTION AND THAT WE NEED TO
SUPPORT IT HERE TODAY.
THANK YOU CENTER HUESO. MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
AUTHORITIES HAVE SENATOR JACKSON.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES TO IS THE.
OF SENATOR REPRESENTING AREA
THAT WAS SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTED
BY OF. THE LARGEST WILDFIRE IN
OUR STATE'S HISTORY IN THE
SUBSEQUENT. DEBRIS FLOW I'M VERY
ANXIOUS TO SEE OF WHAT WE CAN DO
GOING FORWARD TO PREVENT THIS
KIND OF CATASTROPHIC RESPONSE.
AND THE WE ARE IN A BIT OF A
CONUNDRUM. A ON THIS ISSUE OF
BECAUSE WE HAVE A TRIED TO
CREATE A SYSTEM WHICH PUTS THE
RESPONSIBILITY IN THE ONUS. FOR
FIRES THAT ARE CAUSED BY. OUR
STRUCTURES AND OF PORTIONS OF OF
GRIDS AND.
HARDWARE IF YOU WILL FROM OUR
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM SO THAT THEY
HAVE THE DUTY. TO PROTECT THEM
FROM THESE KINDS OF NATURAL
EVENTS.
A SOME OF THESE ADVANCE ARE.
ARGUABLY BECAUSE BY THEIR
NEGLIGENCE WE HAVE JUST OF
FINDING A PRELIMINARY FINDING.
LAST WEEK THAT.
.
THE FIRES OR PARTS OF THE FIRES
UP IN THE NORTHERN PART OF THE
STATE WERE. CAUSED BY A DOWN
PIRATES OF A POWER LINES THERE
IS CONCERN IN THE THOMAS FIRE.
THAT THAT FIRE WAS ALSO CAUSED
BY THESE KINDS OF THE VANCE
ALTHOUGH THE JURY'S OUT WE DON'T
TOTALLY KNOW BUT CERTAINLY THERE
IS AN INDICATION WITH HIGH WINDS.
WINSOCK CONTINUE TO GET STRONGER
AND STRONGER WITH PARCHED EARTH
THAT IS PARCHED BECAUSE OF THE
CONTINUING DROUGHTS. OF THAT WE
ARE EXPERIENCING AS A RESULT OF
CLIMATE CHANGE.
WE REALLY HAVE TO ADDRESS.
WHAT WE CAN DO TO PREVENT THESE
IN THE FUTURE?
SO LEADING COMPANIES OFF THE
HOOK OBVIOUSLY ISN'T THE ANSWER
AND I HAVE EVERY CONFIDENCE.
THAT SENATOR THE GOOD SENATOR
FROM NAPA WILL MAKE SURE THAT WE
ARE NOT.
GIVING IT OUT.
TO INDUSTRIES THAT HAVE A
RESPONSIBILITY A STRONG
RESPONSIBILITY. ARE AS A RESULT
OF THEIR ABILITY TO PAP
MONOPOLIES THE FACT THAT THEY
CAN GO INTO OUR LAND AND BEING A
GRANTED EASEMENTS ACROSS OUR OWN
PROPERTY. TO DO WHAT THEY DO A
TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE DOING THE
VERY BEST TO PROTECT AGAINST
THESE EVENTS WHILE AT THE SAME
TIME ENCOURAGING THEM. TO DO
EVERYTHING POSSIBLE ARE TO
PROTECT OUR COMMUNITIES FROM
THESE DEVASTATING EVENTS
AT THE SAME TIME. WE DO NEED TO
WRECK THE REALISTICALLY
UNDERSTAND.
THE MAXIMUM THE POINT AT WHICH
WE A PUSHED AS FAR AS WE HUMANLY
CAN.
TO PROTECT OUR COMMUNITIES I
DON'T ENVY THE GOOD SENATOR THE
TASK.
BUT I DO BELIEVE THAT.
HE HAS A AN OPENNESS OF MIND AND
SPIRIT ON THIS ISSUE I LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH HIM AND
SO MANY OF MY COLLEAGUES HAD
ALSO INDICATED. I AM GOING TO
RESERVE THE RIGHT TO TO ADDRESS
THIS BILL.
WHEN IT COMES BACK I'M SURE
WILL ON CONCURRENT BUT I DO
APPRECIATE HIS EFFORT A ON
BEHALF OF MY CONSTITUENTS IN A
AND CERTAINLY. ON BEHALF OF THE
OTHER FOLKS WHO HAVE SUFFERED
FROM THESE DEVASTATING WILDFIRES
WE HAVE TO FIND A WAY ANTI LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE GOOD
SENATOR FROM NAPA IN DOING SO.
AND WITH THAT WOULD URGE AN AYE
VOTE ON THIS MISSION THANK YOU
SENATOR JACKSON SENATOR DODD
PLEASE CLOSE.
BETTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS.
THIS BILL IS ALL ABOUT MAKING
OUR COMMUNITIES SAFER.
IF IT WEREN'T FOR THAT I WOULD
NOT BE WRITING THIS BILL THIS
BILL IS NOT ABOUT MAKING IT
EASIER. FOR ANYBODY TO COLLECT
THIS BILL IS NOT.
I TRIED TO MAKE STANDARDS EASIER
TRYING TO MAKE OUR COMMUNITIES
IN OUR GRADE. MORE RESILIENT
I TAKE A A. THE COMMENTS IN THE
CONCERNS.
VERY VERY SERIOUSLY AND MAKE A
COMMITMENT THAT.
THERE WILL BE A BIPARTISAN
A SOLUTION IN THIS.
BEFORE THIS BILL COMES BACK
HERE.
FOR CONCURRENCE.
I ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
AYE GAINES. AYE GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
NO.
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LEYVA.
MCGUIRE.
I.
MITCHELL.
MONEY MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
I NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
I.
BY JACK.
IOWA COUNTY.
WIENER.
I WILK.
RIGHT PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ANDERSON. AYE BATES.
I BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
BERRYHILL AYE.
DELEON.
GLAZER.
I.
LEYVA.
I MITCHELL. MONNING.
I MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NIELSEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER. BY COUNTY.
BY.
LIES THIRTY KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
SORRY I'VE THIRTY KNOWS ONE
MEASURE PASSES BUT ITEM EIGHTY
FOUR SENATOR HUESO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TEN NINETY SEVEN BY
SENATOR HUESO AND ACT REALLY
LEAD POISONING.
SUDDENLY PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES.
AS BITTER NINETY SEVEN IS AN
IMPORTANT BILL THAT RELATES TO
CHILDHOOD LEAD POISONING. ARE
RELATED AND TO THE.
CASE MANAGEMENT DATA OF HOW WE
HANDLE. CHILDHOOD LEAD POISONING
INSTEAD OF CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL.
.
WILL HELP CALIFORNIA BETTER
UNDERSTAND CHUCK CHILDHOOD LEAD
LEVELS. LEAD HAZARDS AND THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF LEAD ABATEMENT.
AND HELP DECISION MAKERS
EFFECTIVELY ADDRESS AND PREVENT
CHILDHOOD LEAD EXPOSURE THIS
THIS SO WILL GO A LONG WAY OF
REDUCING. LEAD EXPOSURE FOR
CHILDREN STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
THIS BILL PASSED A POLICY
COMMITTEE WITH STRONG BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT EYES FOR AN AYE VOTE ON
THIS A BILL THANK YOU. BIGGIE
CENTER HUESO MEMBERS IN
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING A UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING THEM EYES
THIRTY TWO NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
MOVING ON TO FILE AT IN EIGHTY
EIGHT SENATOR ATKINS.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL ELEVEN TWENTY FIE BY
SENATOR ATKINS AN ACRONYM MEDI
CAL CENTER ATKINS.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY
FIVE WILL DISMANTLE BARRIERS
MENTAL HEALTH PATIENTS IN
CALIFORNIA FACED BY ALLOWING
COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS. THE
BILL MEDI CAL FOR MENTAL HEALTH
SERVICES ON THE SAME DAY THEY
PROVIDE OTHER MEDICAL SERVICES.
COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER PATIENTS
ARE OFTEN FOUND IN THE MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES DURING THEIR
PRIMARY CARE VISIT. HOWEVER IF
THEY RECEIVE TREATMENT FOR MEDI
CAL FROM BOTH A PRIMARY CARE
PROVIDER AND A MENTAL HEALTH
PROVIDER ON THE SAME DAY. THE
HEALTH CENTER WILL ONLY BE
REIMBURSED FOR ONE VISIT. AS A
RESULT THESE COMMUNITY HEALTH
CENTERS MUST EITHER EAT THE COST
OF THE SECOND VISIT. OUR REFER
PATIENTS TO RETURN ON A
SUBSEQUENT DAY. WE SHOULD STRIVE
TO INTEGRATE KAREN TO PROVIDE
ALL NECESSARY TREATMENT TO
UNDERSERVED PATIENTS ONCE WE GET
THEM IN THE DOOR. SENATORS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
ON S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY FIVE.
I THINK YOU SENATOR ATKINS
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SENATOR PAN AYE THANK
YOUMADAM PRESIDENT I WANT TO
THANK OUR PRETEND FOR TAKING
LEADERSHIP ON THIS IMPORTANT
ISSUES A CLINIC POSITION. AYE
NOW FRUSTRATING IT IS WHEN YOU
SEE A PATIENT AND THEY HAVE A
MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE. THAT
BASICALLY THE CLINIC SAYS WELL
IF YOU GET THEM SEEN EVERY SEND
THEM DOWN THE HALL TO TALK TO
THE MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSIONAL
WE WON'T GET PAID SO. MAYBE YOU
I CONSIDER SENDING THEM HOME
HAVING TO COME BACK KNOWING HOW
WE TRANSPORTATION ISSUES THEY
HAVE. OTHER TYPES OF THINGS ARE
JUGGLING IN THEIR LIFE.
SO I GUESS I WANT THINK THE PRO
TEMPORE LEADERSHIP AND HER
TONIGHT BUT ON THIS BILL. THANK
YOU CENTER PAN SIR ECHOES WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
I GO.
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
TO USING A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY TWO NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
MOVING TO FILE ITEM EIGHTY NINE
CENTER HERTZBERG MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN THIRTY ONE BY
SENATOR HERTZBERG ENACT CLEAN
ENERGY.
THANK YOU ARE IT'S BURKE MADAM
PRESIDENT OF.
ENERGY EFFICIENT SHE'S BEEN
SOMETHING THAT WE'VE WORKED ON A
LOT THERE'S A BIG HOLE WITH
RESPECT TO INCLUDING ENERGY
EFFICIENCY IN INDUSTRIAL
AGRICULTURAL EQUIPMENT. AND
FACILITIES IN OUR EFFORT TO
REDUCE GREENHOUSE GASES I
BELIEVE THERE'S NO OPPOSITION ON
THIS ON THIS MATTER US YOUR
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SITTING IN HARRY MET MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. AYE ATKINS.
I BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
BY BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
I HUESO.
I JACKSON.
LOTTE.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
BY MORE LARK.
MORRELL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN.
I'VE PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE AYE WIECKOWSKI. AYE WIENER AYE
WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
CANNELLA DELEON. GALGIANI.
I JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCKED NELSON. ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I.
I STUDY ONE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM NINETY SENATOR
HERTZBERG MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL I'M FORTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR HERTZBERG AND TACKLING
OIL AND GAS. CENTER HERTZBERG.
THANK YOU A. MINUTE PRESENT IS
TWENTY SEVEN OFFSHORE RIGS.
FOR OIL DRILLING IN CALIFORNIA.
IN THE LAST YEARS SO TWO OF THEM
WENT BANKRUPT.
ARM AND WHEN THEY WENT BANKRUPT
THE.
THE OUR UP PROPERTIES CAME BACK
AND WERE QUICKLY BACK TO THE
STATE.
AND WHAT WE LEARNED WAS THIS
WASN'T A COMMITTEE LAST YEAR
BELIEVE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE WAS
A PRETTY BIG PROBLEM WHEN THESE
LANDSCAPE A CAME BACK TO THE
STATE LANDS COMMISSION. THAT THE
COST OF DECOMMISSIONING THESE
OIL WELLS WAS IN THE HUNDREDS OF
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND THE
STATE ONLY REQUIRED I THINK IN.
THE PLATFORM HOLLY'S CASE A
THIRTY MILLION DOLLAR BOND FOR
WHICH THE STATE COULD EXECUTE.
THIS YEAR ALONE OUR. THE WE'RE
SEEKING A HUNDRED EIGHT MILLION
DOLLAR BUDGET CHANGE PROPOSAL
FROM THE GENERAL FUND TO PAY FOR
PHASE ONE. OF DECOMMISSIONING
BOTH PLATFORMS ARE WOULD BE
WHICH IS THE PLATFORM HOLLY AND
RINCON ISLAND.
SO WHAT WE'VE DONE IS WHO
WORKING TOGETHER WITH JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE AND WORKING TOGETHER
WITH THE STATE LANDS COMMISSION
WAS TO REQUIRE A A ANY INCREASE
IN THE AMOUNT OF MONEY. THAT
THESE OFFSHORE O. COMPANIES HAVE
TO PUT UP HIS BEAT THE SIZE OF
THE BONDS THEY HAVE TO PUT UP.
IN THE EVENT THEY GO UPSIDE DOWN
AND HERE'S THE REASON WHY THIS
IS IMPORTANT SO LAST POINT THAT
I'LL MAKE. THAT WHAT'S BEEN
HAPPENING IS ALL THESE THESE BIG
COMPANIES THAT HAVE ONLY IS
OFFSHORE RIGS HAVE SOLD THEM OFF
TO COMPANIES WITH MUCH SMALLER
BALANCE SHEETS.
THESE COMPANIES ARE COMING IN
TAKING OUT THE BALANCE THE OIL
AND THEN FILING BANKRUPTCY.
AS A RESULT OF THAT WE FIND
OURSELVES IN THE SITUATION WHERE
WE AT THE STATE ARE BEING HELD
WITH A AT OBLIGA BIG OBLIGATION
SO WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS TO
BE THOUGHTFUL GET AHEAD OF THE
GAME. AND TO BASICALLY INCREASE
THESE BONDS THAT ABOUT A BONDS
THAT THEY HAVE TO PUT UP WITH
THE GOING TO CONTINUE TO OPERATE
THESE OFFSHORE RIGS AS FOR
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR JACKSON. IS THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I
WANT TO THANK MY GOOD COLLEAGUE
FROM LOS ANGELES FOR. ALL HIS
EFFORTS WITH RESPECT TO THE
BONDING ISSUE ASSOCIATED WITH
THESE RIGS.
THAT I HAD ARE SOLD OFF
SERIALLY TO LESSER COMPANIES
AND THEN THEY WALK AWAY FILE FOR
BANKRUPTCY LEAVING THE STATE IN
THE TAXPAYER. TO PAY THE COST OF
DECOMMISSIONING THESE RIGS AFTER
THESE COMPANIES HAVE MADE
MILLIONS AND MILLIONS AND
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
OFF OF THESE OF OIL FACILITIES.
A THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS THAT THEY
THEN WALK AWAY LEAVING THE
TAXPAYER TO TAKE A PAY THE COST
AND. OFFER THAT I APPRECIATE THE
SENATOR'S EFFORTS I AM CONCERNED
HOWEVER.
THERE HAS BEEN A PHILOSOPHICAL
DIFFERENCE
OF MY COMMUNITY DOESN'T WANT
THESE RIGS TO BE ALLOWED TO STAY
IN THE OCEAN THE.
CONTRACT THAT WAS MADE WHEN WE
ALLOWED THESE COMPANIES TO COME
IN AND DRILL FOR OIL. IS THAT
WHEN THEY WERE DONE THEY WOULD
REMOVE THE WELLS THAT THE AND
THE PLATFORMS AND RETURN THE SEE
THROUGH ITS ORIGINAL CONDITION
REMOVING THESE. A VARIOUS.
MOUNDS OIL MOUNT SHOULD HAVE
BEEN CREATED AS A RESULT AND PUT
THE OCEAN BACK IN IT'S SAFE AND.
NONTOXIC CONDITION.
A MY CONCERN AND WHETHER IF I
MAY ASK A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
THE HERTZBERG WE TAKE A QUESTION
EARLY.
THANK YOU MY MY UNDERSTANDING IS
THAT A THIS SHOW.
MEASURE CREATES A SINKING FUND
FOR THE DECOMMISSIONING OF THE
EQUIPMENT A WOULD YOU EXPLAIN
WHAT. YOU HAVE IN MIND FOR THAT
FUND.
THAT ON ITS BURKE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH YET THE BILL CREATES A
WHAT'S CALLED THE OFFSHORE A IN
INFRASTRUCTURE DECOMMISSIONING
FUND
SO THAT IN THE EVENT THE
GOVERNMENT WANT HAS MONEY FROM
ANY OTHER SOURCE. IT COULD PUT
IT THIS FUND TO HELP PAY FOR THE
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH. OUR THIS
MEASURE THERE IS ANOTHER MEASURE
WHICH I HAVE NOT AMENDED AGAIN
YOU RAISE THE ISSUE WITH RESPECT
TO ANOTHER SENATOR ON YOUR BILL
EARLIER THAT'S IN THE ASSEMBLY
BUT THERE'S BEEN NO AMENDMENTS
TAKEN TO IT. BUT TO DO THAT IT'S
JUST SIMPLY A FUND IN THE EVENT
THE GOVERNMENT WANTS TO BE ABLE
TO PUT. ANY SOURCE OF MONEY THAT
IT HOUSE TO HELP PROTECT OUR OR.
ANY KIND OF POLLUTION BECAUSE TO
FROM THIS DE COMMISSIONING.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
CENTER JACKSON.
OUR THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
.
AGAIN.
GIVEN THE TENSIONS THAT EXIST.
IN WHAT WE'RE GONNA DO WITH
THESE RIGS ONCE THEY DO GET DE
COMMISSIONED. A I LOOK FORWARD
TO CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THE
GOOD SENATOR FROM LOS ANGELES ON
HOW WE DEAL WITH IT. UP BUT
REPRESENTING THE COMMUNITY THAT
IS MOST LIKELY TO SEE THESE RIGS
ATTEMPTED TO. A REMAIN IN THE
OCEAN A.
SOMETIMES IS PROGRAMS REFERRED
TO AS RIGS TO REEFS IN MY
COMMUNITY WE CALL IT REEKS TO
RUBBLE.
I AM GOING TO HAVE TO
RESPECTFULLY. A STAY OFF THE
BILL AND LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THE GOOD
SENATOR TO REACH OUR MUTUAL
GOALS OF PROTECTING OUR OCEAN.
OF PROTECTING THE TAXPAYER FROM
HAVING TO PAY THE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THESE COMPANIES
WALKING AWAY AFTER THEY HAVE
SQUEEZED EVERY DIME OUT OF THE
OCEAN. AT THE SAME TIME ALSO
LOOKING FORWARD TO THEM TAKING
THE RESPONSIBILITY THEIR
CONTRACTUAL DUTIES SERIOUSLY AND
REMOVING THESE RIGS FROM THE
OCEAN THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
THANK YOU SENATE JACKSON CENTER
HERTZBERG WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
I QUICKLY DID THERE'S NO THERE'S
NO. THIS IS SIMPLY SOLVING THE
PROBLEM WHERE THE STATE DOESN'T
HAVE CURRENTLY HAVE ENOUGH MONEY
WERE DUG DE COMMISSION WELLS AND
WE'RE TRYING TO PROTECT THE
COAST.
ALL ACROSS CALIFORNIA WHERE
THERE'S A WELL SO WE HAVE MONEY
TO DO THAT.
BECAUSE THESE PEOPLE PUT MORE
MONEY AND GIVE AN OPPORTUNITY
FOR OTHERS THERE'S NO OTHER
ISSUES SET FORTH IN THIS MEASURE
ESCRIBO.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
WELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
I. GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ. AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
NADA.
I LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL. MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
BUT ACT.
AYE WIECKOWSKI.
BY WINNER.
I WILK.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BATES.
I.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DELEON FULLER.
GALGIANI.
I JACKSON.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NIELSEN.
ROTH THERE.
STONE.
EYES TWENTY SIX NOSE TO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WE HAVE DISPENSED WITH
FIFTY SEVEN FIFTY EIGHT BILLS WE
HAVE THREE ON CALL AT FIVE
THIRTY WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A
FORTY FIVE MINUTE DINNER BREAK.
AND EVERYONE IS WE BACK PROMPTLY
AT SIX FIFTEEN SO WE CAN GET
STARTED BUT THAT ISN'T FOR
ANOTHER FIFTEEN MINUTES SO WE'RE
GOING TO MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM.
NINETY TWO SENATOR PORTANTINO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR PORTANTINO.
AND AQUINNAH CLASSIFIED
EMPLOYEES.
SENATOR PORTANTINO THANK YOU ARE
MADAM PRESIDENT A MEMBERS.
I RISE TO PRESENT SB ELEVEN
SEVENTY SEVEN WHICH WILL
ESTABLISH THE SUMMER BRIDGE FUND
FOR CLASSIFIED SCHOOL EMPLOYEES.
THE SUMMER BRIDGE FUND WOULD
ESTABLISH A FIVE YEAR PILOT
PROGRAM TO CREATE A PARTIALLY
SELF FUNDED ACCOUNT THAT WOULD
ALLOW CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES.
TO CONTRIBUTE UP TO TEN PERCENT
OF THEIR PAY PER SCHOOL YEAR
WHICH WOULD THEN BE MATCHED IN A
ONE TO ONE MATCH BY THE STATE.
THE COW WOULD BE RUN ON A
VOLUNTARY BASIS SOMEONE ALLOW
MEMBERS TO CASH IN THEIR BANK
HOURS DURING PERIODS OF SCHOOL
RECESS.
WITHOUT INCOME I ACCESSED
UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND LACK
OF TEMPORARY EMPLOYMENT
CLASSIFIED IN SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
FIND THEMSELVES IN A VERY
DIFFICULT POSITION. TO SURVIVE
DURING THE SUMMER MONTHS THIS
BILL ALLOWS EMPLOYEES TO
PARTICIPATE IN A FUND THAT WOULD
PREVENT THEM FROM FRANKLY BEING
HOMELESS HUNGRY AND POVERTY
DURING THE SUMMER MONTHS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS IN THE DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATOR STONE.
THEY MET PRESIDENT.
I REGRET TO.
SAY THAT I'M OPPOSED S. B.
ELEVEN SEVENTY SEVEN THIS IS
NOTHING MORE THAN A BACK DOOR.
PAY INCREASE FOR THESE
EMPLOYEES THIS WOULD BE.
SUMMING THIS NEGOTIATED THROUGH
THEIR COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
CONTRACTS
AND NOT EXPECTING THE
LEGISLATURE TO SIDESTEP.
THEIR REYES AND.
NOT BE TRANSPARENT WITH THESE
WITH TAXPAYERS FOR THAT REASON I
RECOMMEND A VOTE IN S. B. ELEVEN
SEVEN SEVEN.
I THINK THE CENTER STONE.
THERE PORTANTINO WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SIR MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
BY BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON. DOT.
FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
ISLA.
I LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
I WIENER. AYE WILK
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
CANNELLA DELEON.
DODD.
I.
FULLER.
MITCHELL MORE LOCK NGUYEN.
NELSON.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I SWIM TO KNOWS EIGHT THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING TO FILE
ITEM NINETY THREE SENATOR GLAZER
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN EIGHTY TWO BY
SENATOR GLAZER AND ACCOLADES
TAXATION TAKE EFFECT MERELY TAX
LEVY.
SENATOR GLAZER THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS. I SP ELEVEN
EIGHTY TWO WOULD REFORM AND
PROVIDE A LONG OVERDUE INCREASE
TO THE RENTERS TAX CREDIT.
WHICH HASN'T BEEN INCREASED
SINCE NINETEEN SEVENTY NINE.
ALTHOUGH THIS LEGISLATURE PASSED
A ROBUST HOUSING PACKAGE LAST
YEAR THAT PACKAGE DID NOT
PROVIDE DIRECT FINANCIAL RELIEF
TO THOSE WHO NEED IT MOST
RENTERS.
WITH THIS BILL WE HAVE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE AN IMMEDIATE
IMPACT.
AND HELP THOSE WITHIN THE LOW
INCOME COMMUNITY.
STRUGGLE THE MOST TO MAKE EACH
MONTH'S RENT.
MOST IMPORTANTLY THIS BILL MAKES
THE CREDIT MUCH MORE FAIR AND
HELPFUL TO SINGLE MOMS AND
SINGLE DADS.
AND FAMILIES.
THE CURRENT FORMULA GIVES
COUPLES WITH NO DEPENDENTS TWICE
AS MUCH AS A SINGLE PARENT WITH
KIDS.
EVEN IF THE COUPLES IN A ONE
BEDROOM APARTMENT AND THE SINGLE
MOM AND HER CHILDREN HAVE A TWO
BEDROOM APARTMENT THAT COSTS
MUCH MORE.
THIS BILL CORRECTS THAT
DISPARITY ALSO CATCHES THE
CREDIT UP TO WHERE IT WOULD HAVE
BEEN IF IT KEPT PACE WITH
INFLATION AND. SINCE NINETEEN
SEVENTY NINE.
WE FACE THIS PROPOSAL OVER FIVE
YEARS TO KEEP THE UP FRONT COSTS
OW. AND GET THE GOVERNOR THE
ABILITY TO PAUSE THE SCHEDULE.
IF THERE'S AN ECONOMIC EMERGENCY.
THIS PROPOSAL NEARLY TRIPLE THE
TOTAL CREDIT FOR SINGLE MOMS AND
DADS
WITHIN THE FIRST YEAR ALONE.
INCREASING THE AMOUNT TWO
HUNDRED AND SEVENTY EIGHT
DOLLARS.
BY THE END OF THE FIVE YEAR
PHASE IN PERIOD FAMILIES. THAT
NOW RECEIVE JUST SIXTY DOLLARS
WILL GET A CREDIT OF FOUR
HUNDRED AND THIRTY FOUR DOLLARS.
THE FIRST YEAR POSSIBLY FORTY
FOUR MILLION DOLLARS. AND EVEN
WHEN FULLY IMPLEMENTED.
THE INCREASE FOR RANCHERS WILL
BE JUST A SMALL FRACTION OF THE
GENERAL FUND COSTS OF SUBSIDIES
IN THE TAX CODE FOR HOMEOWNERS.
THIS IS A SMART PROGRESSIVE BILL
THAT GIVES DIRECT AID TO RUNNERS
WHO NEED IT THE MOST.
THE PERFECT COMPLIMENT TO OUR
LONG TERM EFFORTS TO BUILD MORE
LAW LOW INCOME HOUSING EFFORTS
TO TAKE YEARS TO TAKE ROOT
BEFORE THEY MAKE HOUSING MORE
ACCESSIBLE.
S. IS SOMETHING WE CAN DO RIGHT
NOW TO HELP FIX THE PROBLEM. AND
PRIES IT PLEASE AND APPRECIATIVE
OF THE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT THIS
BILL IS RECEIVED THROUGH THE
PROCESS AND WITH THAT I ASKED
HER KNIFE OF.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER SENATOR
WIN.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
FIRST WANNA THINK OF THE GOOD
SENATOR FROM.
pBILL OF ALLOW ME TO ALSO BE A CO
AUTHOR.
AND TODAY I RISE IN SUPPORT OF
SB ELEVEN EIGHTY TWO LIVING IN
HOUSING COSTS IN CALIFORNIA
PLACE A LARGE BURDEN ON FAMILIES.
THE AVERAGE ORANGE COUNTY FAMILY
OF FOUR WITH TWO PARENTS AND TWO
CHILDREN.
MUST BUDGET AT MINIMUM EIGHTEEN
HUNDRED DOLLARS A MONTH FOR
HOUSING AND UTILITIES.
THIS BILL WOULD INCREASE THE
VALUE OF THE RENTERS TAX CREDIT
FOR ALL RECIPIENTS BY TWENTY
TWENTY THREE THOSE RECENT
RECEIVING THE CREDIT WITH
DEPENDENTS WOULD BE RECEIVING
TWO HUNDRED FIFTY FIVE DOLLARS
MORE THAN THEY RECEIVED THIS
YEAR. HE'S DOLLARS WOULD GO A
VERY VERY LONG WAY TO HELP OUR
FAMILIES.
A LOW INCOME AND MIDDLE CLASS
FAMILY MAKES ENDS MEET I WISH IT
WOULD NOT BE HIGHER BUT I KNOW
THAT THIS IS A A IS A STEP IN
THE RIGHT DIRECTION AND SO I
ASKS FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
META PRESENT THANK YOU SENATOR
WHEN MEMBERS ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATOR WIENER THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I SUPPORT THIS AND
THANK THE SENATOR FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD.
BUT I JUST DO WANT TO NOTE THAT.
AS HOPEFUL AS A AYE RENTERS TAX
CREDIT WILL BE TO RENTERS. ARE
WHAT WILL BE EVEN MORE HELPFUL
IS TO BUILD ENOUGH HOUSING SO
RENTS GO DOWN SO I JUST WANTED
US TO KEEP THE BIG PICTURE IN
MIND. EVEN AS WE MOVE FORWARD
WHAT IS A VERY GOOD PIECE OF
LEGISLATION THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER SOONER
GLAZER WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
THANK THE SENATOR FROM SAN
FRANCISCO FOR HIS WORDS OF
WISDOM I CERTAINLY AGREE THAT.
MORE SUPPLIES IT'S BECAUSE
CRITICAL IN OUR STATE I THANK
THE SENATOR FROM ORANGE COUNTY
FOR HER CO AUTHORSHIP IN THE
MANY CENTERS ON THE FLOOR. WHO
ALSO CO AUTHORS OF THIS BILL AND
FINALLY I PARTICULAR LIKE TO
THINK THAT PRO TEM? AND HER
OFFICE FOR THE WORK ON THIS IN
PARTICULAR CHRIS WOULD IN HIS
SIDE THOUGHTFUL SUGGESTIONS OF
MADE THIS BILL EVEN BETTER. AND
WITH THAT MEMBERS ASKED FOR AN
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR
GLAZER MEMBERS IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING A UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
HEARING AND SEEING NONE EYES
THIRTY TWO NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
MEMBERS BEFORE WE BREAK FOR
DINNER WE ARE GOING TO LIFT THE
CALL ON FILE ITEM THIRTY THREE.
S. B. TWELVE FORTY NINE.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DODD.
GLAZER.
HILL.
HUESO.
I.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
PAN.
ROUGH.
BRADFORD I.
EYES TWENTY ONE KNOWS NINE THE
MEASURE PASSES.
OR I THINK WE CAN GET ONE MORE
BILL AND BEFORE OUR DINNER BREAK.
UP FILE ITEM NINETY FOUR SENATOR
HILL.
PASS SOME FILE FILE ITEM NINETY
FIVE SENATOR PELL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN EIGHTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR BILL AN ACT RELATING
TO CRIMINAL PROCEDURE.
CENTRE BELL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS TODAY PERCENT.
S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY SEVEN THIS
BILL LIMITS THE INVOLUNTARY PRE
TRIAL. CONFINEMENT OF A PERSON
SOLELY BASED ON HIS. OR HER
MENTAL COMPETE INCAPACITY TO
STAND TRIAL FOR NO LONGER THAN
TWO YEARS AND UPDATES THE
ARCHAIC STANDARDS IN DEFINITIONS.
WITHIN THE EXISTING LAW NOW BY%
SHORTENING THE MAXIMUM
COMMITMENT PERIOD.
FROM THREE TO TWO YEARS THIS
BILL INCREASES THE AVAILABILITY
OF PLACEMENTS IN RESIDENTIAL
TREATMENT FACILITIES HOSPITALS
AND DEVELOPMENTAL CENTERS.
FOR THE TREATMENT OF INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE INCOMPETENT TO STAND
TRIAL. AND I LIKE TO POINT OUT
NOW WE HAVE A BIT.
PUT IN THESE FACILITIES SAID THE
GOVERNOR AND THE BUDGET. IS
REQUESTING A HUNDRED MILLION
DOLLARS.
HE KEEPING PEOPLE.
THEN THE DEPARTMENT OF STATE
HOSPITALS.
ABED IS ANY LONGER THAN
MEDICALLY NECESSARY DOES NOT
SERVE ANYBODY'S INTEREST.
THE DEPARTMENT DOES NOT WANT
THIS TO VICTIMS DON'T WANT THIS
THE COURT DOES NOT ONE THIS.
AND THE PATIENTS AND THEIR
FAMILIES DO NOT WANT TO HAS.
THE BILL BRINGS US IN LINE WITH
THE MAJORITY OF STATES WHICH
HAVE SET REASONABLE TIME.
OFFER KAPITI RESTORATION WELL
UNDER TWO YEARS IN THE LOW WE
HAVE EXISTED.
BEFORE MY SEAT MATE WAS BORN
ACTUALLY.
ALSO. I LIKE TO POINT THAT OUT.
ULTIMATELY SB ELEVEN A SEVEN
INCREASES DUE PROCESS RIGHTS OF
INCARCERATED PEOPLE UNDERGOING
INCOMPETENCY DETERMINATIONS.
BY ASSURING THESE INDIVIDUALS
ARE NOT HELD FRONT UNNECESSARY
AMOUNT OF TIME URGENT AYE VOTE
ON THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SENATOR BILL MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG. AYE HILL. AYE
HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LARA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
MONEY.
I MORE LOCKED.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
STERN.
BY STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO AYE KATHY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS CANNELLA. DELEON.
FULLER.
NO.
MITCHELL.
MORE LOCK NIELSEN.
ROTH.
SKINNER.
I SWAYED TO KNOWS TENTH THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS A LITTLE
PROGRESS UPDATE.
WE HAVE DISPENSED WITH SIXTY TWO
BILLS WE'RE NOW GOING TO TAKE A
DINNER BREAK AND BE BACK HERE AT
SIX FIFTEEN TO PROBABLY GET
STARTED THANK YOU VERY MUCH