COUPLE MINUTES
CHUCK WE VETO OUR GUESTS.
THAT ARE VISITING US
EXCUSE ME I'M A. LITTLE UNDER
THE WEATHER TODAY.
WE'RE GONNA CALL THIS MEETING
TO HEAR.
WE DO HAVE QUORUM LIFTED LET'S
BEGIN BY ESTABLISHING OUR QUORUM.
ARE SURGERY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
LARA HERE LARA HERE BATES. BATES
HERE BELL.
BRADFORD BRADFORD HERE HILL HILL
HERE NIELSEN WIENER.
PERFECT WE HAVE ARE HEARING WE
HAVE A QUORUM.
WE HAVE SEVENTY SIX BILL SO
HERE TODAY ONLY ONE OF WHICH IS
ELIGIBLE FOR A TO PASS. THE
REMAINING BILLS ARE SUSPENSE
ITEMS
WE ARE WE HAVE A NUMBER OF BILLS
ON FILE THAT WHEN.
THEY WILL BE SCHEDULED FOR FINAL
REGULAR ORDER HEARING.
THE SERGEANTS HELLO FULL LIST.
BUT FOR THE RCORD THESE ARE THE
FOLLOWING BILLS ARE BEING PUT
OVER S. B. TEN THIRTEEN SP TEN
SEVENTY TWO. S. B. TEN EIGHTY
EIGHT S. B. ELEVEN TEN S. B.
ELEVEN THIRTY FIVE SB ELEVEN
SIXTY NINE S. B. TWELVE SIXTY
ONE. S. B. THIRTEEN OH ONE. SP
THIRTEEN OH NINE S. B. THIRTEEN
TEN S. B. THIRTEEN SIXTEEN S. B.
THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE SB THIRTEEN
THIRTY NINE. S. B. THIRTEEN
SIXTY FIVE SB THIRTEEN SEVENTY
FOUR S. B. THIRTEEN NINETY NINE
AN SP FOURTEEN FOURTEEN.
.
THOSE ARE BILLS ARE GONNA BE PUT
OVER TO OUR LAST HEARING.
THE SERGEANTS AGAIN HAVE A FINAL
LIST OF THOSE.
AND.
REMINDER TO OUR AUDIENCE AND TO
OUR TESTIMONIES WERE GONNA STICK
TO THAT. FISCAL ASPECTS OF THE
BILL CASEY SENATOR WHEN IS HERE.
WITH HER BUDDIES COME ON UP
FROM IRWIN.
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY CENTER
WHEN.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN.
AND VICE CHAIR AND SENATORS NOT
TO DATE.
TODAY NEXT TO ME IS.
OUR PRINCIPAL CO AUTHOR SOME
WOMEN ASH CAR AS WELL. I'M I'M
PROUD TO PRESENT S. B. EIGHT
NINE FIVE FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
S. B. EIGHT NINE FIVE EXCEPTIONS
CALIFORNIA'S FIRST MODEL
CURRICULUM ON THE VIETNAMESE.
AMERICAN REFUGEE EXPERIENCE
AS YOU CAN TELL BY THE NUMBER OF
PEOPLE WITH US HERE TODAY THE
BILL BEFORE YOU HAS GARNERED
WIDESPREAD SUPPORT THROUGHOUT
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. WE HAVE.
WITH US TODAY RESIDENTS FROM
ALL OVER INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO.
SAN DIEGO ORANGE LOS ANGELES
SAN JOSE OAKLAND FREMONT FRESNO
SAN FRANCISCO IT'S SO MANY MORE
MANY OF THEM HAVE TRAVEL
OVERNIGHT AND I WANT TO THANK
THEM PERSONALLY FOR TAKING THEIR
TIME HERE TO BE HERE TO SHARE
THEIR SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL. AND
ADDITIONS TO THE RESIDENTS HERE
TODAY I AM SO ALSO SUBMITTING
SIX THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED AND
FORTY SIGNATURES. THAT HAVE BEEN
COLLECTED IN SUPPORT OF SB EIGHT
NINE FIVE I BELIEVE THAT THE
OVERWHELMING SUPPORT OF THE
COMMITTEE SPEAKS VOLUMES OF THE
IMPORTANCE OF S. B. EIGHT NINE
FIVE TWO RESIDENTS THROUGHOUT
THE STATE CALIFORNIA. COLLEAGUES
AS IT STANDS S. B. EIGHT NINE
FIVE WILL EXPAND UPON THOSE
CORRECT THE CURRENT CURRICULUM
ON THE VIETNAM WAR AIR. BY
EQUIPPING THE VOICES OF THOSE
WHO LIVED DURING THIS TIME
INCLUDE MEMBERS OF THE REPUBLIC
OF VIETNAM ARMED FORCES AND THE
VIETNAMESE BOAT PEOPLE. S. B.
EIGHT NINE FIVE WAS SPECIFICALLY
MAKE AVAILABLE TO MORE TO A MORE
COMPREHENSIVE CURRICULUM THAT
SCHOOL DISTRICTS THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIAN ACCESS WHEN TEACHING
ABOUT THE VIETNAM WAR AND THE
POST VIETNAM WAR AIR.
WITH THE UNANIMOUS SUPPORT OF
THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE.
I NOW PROBABLY BRING THIS BILL
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION AND THE
LAST FOUR YEARS. THE CURRICULUM
FOR OUR K. TO TWELVE EDUCATION
SYSTEM HAS BEEN EXPANDED THROUGH
LEGISLATIVE PROCESS.
AND ACTIONS
THESE ACTIONS HELP TELL THE
STORIES OF THE PEOPLE OF THE
GREAT STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
SOME EXAMPLE IN TWO THOUSAND
FOURTEEN THE LEGISLATIVE PASS S.
B. IT THIRTEEN EIGHTY WHICH
HELPED EDUCATE STUDENTS ON A
MEDIAN GENOCIDE. IN TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN WITH AB TWENTY EIGHT
SIXTY FOUR THE LEGISLATIVE VOTED
TO SUPPORT THE CORRECT THE
CREATION OF CURRICULUM ON THE
CHINESE EXCLUSION ACT.
AND JUST LAST YEAR ALONE. THE
LET'S SAY PROVE A BEAT SEVEN
THREE EIGHT CREATING THE
CURRICULUM ON NATIVE AMERICAN
STUDIES
ALL THESE STORIES ARE VERY
MEANINGFUL EMBRACE A GREAT
DIVERSIFY OUR GREAT STATE. AND
PROVIDE STUDENTS ACCESS TO A
COMPLETE HISTORICAL COLLECTION
THAT ONLY ENHANCES THE
EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCES.
IN TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN AT THE
FORTY YEAR ANNIVERSARY THE FALL
OF SAIGON IT BECAME APPARENT
THAT THE VIETNAM WAR AIR STORIES
AND THE GENERATION. THAT CAN
SHARE FIRSTHAND KNOWLEDGE OF
THIS PERIOD WERE SLOWLY BEING
LOST TO TIME.
THESE ARE THE REASONS THAT
COMPEL US TO ASK THAT YOU LOOK
BEYOND THE FINANCIAL COSTS
AND SEE THE TRUE VALUE OF THIS
PROPOSAL. THE COMMITTEE EL
ANALYZE PUTS THE COST OF THE
BILL AT A HUNDRED AND FIFTY
THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS.
FOR STAFF TIME IN ANY OTHER
POTENTIAL COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH
THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
CURRICULUM. ALTHOUGH I
UNDERSTAND EVERYTHING WE DO HERE
HAS A COST IT IS IMPORTANT
REMEMBER THAT ACHIEVING.
THE ARCHIVING HISTORY AND
EDUCATING OUR STUDENTS HAS OF
VALUE THAT CANNOT BE MEASURED BY
A DOLLAR AMOUNTS.
THE INDIVIDUALS I HAVE JOIN ME
HERE TODAY ARE NOT ONLY PROUD
AND GRATEFUL RESIDENTS OF THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA BUT ALSO.
BUT ALSO HISTORIANS WHO HOLE
VALUABLE LESSONS THAT CAN ONLY
BENEFIT OUR STUDENTS.
COLLEAGUES YOUR SUPPORT FOR S.
B. EIGHT NINE FIVE WOULD ELEVATE
THE QUALITY OF OUR. K. TO TWELVE
CURRICULUM OUR STUDENTS DESERVE
TO HAVE ACCESS TO THE COMPLETE
HISTORY OF THE VIETNAM WAR ERA
ONE THAT WOULD HELP THEM
UNDERSTAND HOW OUR HISTORY
SHAPES HOWEVER WAR VIEW. WITH
THIS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT I HAVE HERE WITH ME.
THE HONORABLE COUNCILMAN
PATRICK THAT BULLY FROM GARDEN
GROVE AND ALSO THE CHAIRMAN OF.
THE VIETNAMESE AMERICAN
FEDERATION OF SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA.
I'VE GOT I HAVE MISTER GREAT
HASKIN A COMMUNION MEMBER WHO
HAS LIVED IN THE LITTLE SAIGON
AREA IN ORANGE COUNTY AND HIS
WIFE. WHO IS A LOCAL SCHOOL
PRINCIPAL WHO HAS BEEN TEACHING
THE VIETNAMESE CULTURE AND
TRADITION IN THE SCHOOL FOR MANY
YEARS?
MR TIDO A LONG BEACH POLICE
OFFICER WHO WAS HERE ON HIS OWN
TIME WHO IS HERE WHO WILL BE
SHARING SOME OF HIS VIEW OF THE
IMPORTANCE OF ENEMIES AMERICAN
REFUGEES. I ALSO HAVE TIME WHEN
VICE PRESIDENT OF THE VIETNAMESE
COMMUNITY OF SAN DIEGO TO ALSO
SHARE SOME THOUGHTS AS WELL BUT
BEFORE THEY SPEAK I WOULD LIKE
TO ASK. THE ASSEMBLYMAN TO SAY
FEW WORDS MOSQUERA PLEASE.
THANK YOU THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN SANDERS THANK YOU
CENTER WHEN A FEW ME THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OF SB A NINETY FIVE I'M HONORED
TO BE A PRINCIPAL CO AUTHOR. OF
THIS BILL I I I THINK THAT YOU
KNOW CERTAINLY REPRESENTING THE
CITY OF SAN JOSE WHICH HAS THE
LARGEST. VIETNAMESE COMMUNITY OF
ANY SINGLE CITY OUTSIDE OF
VIETNAM.
IT IS OF SPECIFIC IMPORTANCE TO
ME BUT I JUST WANT ALSO JUST
LEAVE FLOW WITH THAT SINGULAR
MESSAGE THAT THIS IS IMPORTANT
FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS AND ALL
AMERICANS.
WE SEE EVERY YEAR EVERY COUPLE
YEARS WE COME FORWARD AS A
LEGISLATURE OF MOOD TO ENHANCE
THE CURRICULUM THAT OUR STUDENTS
LEARN CRITICALLY AS APPLIES TO
HISTORY. AND THAT'S BECAUSE AS
WE KNOW.
AS HISTORY WAS WRITTEN WAS IN
THAT IT DOES NOT TAKE INTO
ACCOUNT ALL VOICES HAS REALLY
BECOME MORE DIVERSE AS A
COMMUNITY AS A STATE CERTAINLY
WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT THOSE
THAT ARE CONTRIBUTING AS
CALIFORNIANS. AND AS AMERICANS
HAVE THEIR STORIES TOLD AS WELL
AND SO I THINK IN THIS CASE IN
PARTICULAR OF SPEAKING ABOUT THE
VIETNAMESE REFUGEE EXPERIENCE.
OF THE IT'S A POWERFUL LESSON
IT'S A POWERFUL HISTORY AND IT
ALSO SPEAKS TO A COMMUNITY.
THAT IS INGRAINED IN CALIFORNIA
AND IS AND IN AMERICA AND HAS
MADE SIGNIFICANT CONTRIBUTIONS I
THINK NOT ONLY IS IT FAIR THAT
THEIR STORY BE TOLD I THINK
IT'LL ENHANCE EDUCATION. OF OUR
STUDENTS OF OUR YOUNG PEOPLE TO
KNOW MORE ABOUT THEIR NEIGHBORS
KNOW MORE ABOUT THEIR FELLOW
AMERICANS ABOUT THE EXPERIENCES
THEY WENT THROUGH AS WELL AS
WHAT THEY CONTRIBUTE TO THIS DAY.
AS TO WHAT THAT I RESPECTFULLY%
ASK FOR A AN AYE VOTE ON S. B.
NINETY BY TAKING ASSURE CHAIR.
THANK YOU WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
COUNCILMAN WELCOME.
BUT MONNING ON A REBEL CHAIRMAN
THAT LARA AND UNDER WAS SEATED
US MY NAME IS FAT WE GOT SO
MEMBER UP THE SEED OF GOD AND
ROLL AWAY AND OUT TO. WHERE I
REPRESENT TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND?
RESIDENTS ABOUT.
SEVENTY THOUSAND OF WHICH I
HAVE ENEMIES AMERICANS.
I WAS ALSO ELECTED BY FORTY
THOUSAND VOTE TO REPRESENT THE
VIETNAMESE COMMUNITY IN SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA US. WEST SOME THREE
NOT PROBLEM PEOPLE CALL HOMES.
IT'S AN HONOR FOR ME TO BE HERE
UP TO SUPPORT S. B. EIGHT NINETY
FIVE.
A AS YOU KNOW AFTER. THE FALL OF
SAIGON IN NINETEEN SEVENTY FIVE
MORE THAN TWO MINUTES PEOPLE
REESE THAT LIES ESCAPING IN
SMALL BOATS.
AT TO ESCAPE THE BRUTAL RULING
OTHER COMPANIES GOVERNMENT AT
HOME.
WE FACE GREW SOME STORMS IN OPEN
SEA AND PROGRESS PIRATES.
COME.
MORE THAN A A MILLION PLUS ABOUT
PEOPLE PARRIS UNDER THE OF MASS
OCEAN AND THOSE WHO WOULD NOT BE.
ABOUT TO MAKE GUY IT TO THE
REFUGEE CAMPS WERE GIVEN A
SECOND CHANCE.
TO SETTLE IN THIS GREAT LAND OF
AMERICA. WE CAME HERE EMPTY
HANDED. NOT EVEN A PENNY HOT
BROKE GUNS AND VERY LITTLE
ENGLISH. BUT THOSE HUMBLE
BEGINNINGS TAUGHT US THE BALLOT
PAT WORKS AND EVEN BACK TO THE
COMMUNITY. MANY BECAME
SCIENTISTS AND MANY OF US JOINED
THE US. ARMY TO AND CERTIFIED TO
PROTECT OUR NEW HOME.
YET MANY NEW BONDS OF US.
AND OTHERS U. S. CITIZEN HAVE NO
KNOWLEDGE OF THE ROOT OF OUR
HUMBLE BEGINNINGS AS THE BOAT
PEOPLE.
I AND EVEN THAT.
THIS BOOK THAT I BROUGHT WITH ME
HERE TODAY WAS. PUBLISHED BY A
OUT MALAISE AND SEATED IN TWO
THOUSAND SIX.
IT WAS SUPPRESSED BY THE MALAISE
AND GOLDMAN FROM.
BEING DISPLAYED IN LIBRARIES
BECAUSE THE VIETNAMESE COMPANIES
DO NOT ONE THAT.
AND.
YOU CAN SEE THAT THE VIETNAMESE
COMMUNISTS GOT MONEY TRYING TO
SUPPRESS HIS STORY.
AND SO.
I SIMPLY.
I SINCERELY HUMBLED TO OUR
REQUEST. THE UP COMMITTEE TO
PASS A YES VOTE TO BRING THIS
SENATE BILL. AS WE AT NINETY
FIVE TO THE SEAT IT FOR OUR SO
THAT OUR HISTORY AND HISTORY AND
HERITAGE CAN BE UNDERSTOOD BY
THE STUDENTS AND BY A RESIDENT.
OF THIS GREAT.
STATES OF CALIFORNIA AND GIVES
IT.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
MY NAME IS TANYA LYNN. AND THE
VICE PRESIDENT OF THE VIETNAMESE
COMMUNITY OF SAN DIEGO.
I'M HERE TODAY TO REPRESENT THE
SANDIA COMMUNITY.
AND I AM ASKING FOR YOUR SUPPORT
OF SENATOR JANET NGUYEN SENATE
BILL EIGHT NINE FIVE.
VIETNAMESE AMERICAN REFUGEE
EXPERIENCE MODEL CURRICULUM.
THE UNITED STATES.
AND THE REPUBLIC OF SOUTH
VIETNAM FOUGHT A VALIANT WAR ON
THE SOIL OF VIETNAM.
TO UPHOLD FREEDOM DEMOCRACY AND
HUMAN RIGHTS AGAINST THE NORTH
VIETNAMESE COMMUNIST.
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF US
SOLDIERS AND MILLIONS OF SOUTH
VIETNAMESE SOLDIERS FOUGHT A
VALUED WAR.
OF WHICH FIFTY EIGHT THOUSAND.
US SOLDIERS DIED IN VIETNAM.
AFTER THE END OF HE VIETNAM WAR
IN A ON APRIL NINTH THIRTIETH OF
NINETEEN SEVENTY FIVE.
CONGRESS AND PRESIDENT GERALD
FORD BOTH AGREED.
TO PASS THE INDOCHINA MIGRATION
AND REFUGEE ASSISTANCE ACT IN
NINETEEN SUNNY FIGHT THIS ALLOW
FOR THE VIETNAMESE REFUGEES TO
ENTER THE UNITED STATES.
UNDER SPECIAL STATUS AND
ALLOCATED A COUPLE HUNDRED FIVE
MILLION SPIN BE SEVEN EIGHT
TODAY OVER FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
VIETNAMESE RESIDE IN CALIFORNIA
ALONE. OF WHICH FORTY THOUSAND
IS IN SAN DIEGO.
PREVIOUSLY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA HAS RECOGNIZE. THIS
FACT THE HERITAGE FLAG.
AS THE FLAG OF THE VIETNAMESE
COMMUNITY.
WE RESPECTFULLY.
REQUEST THAT OUR STORY BE
INCLUDED IN THE SCHOOL
CURRICULUM AND THAT IT
INCORPORATES THE STORIES OF THE
RESILIENCE ANTI ENDS UP THE
VIETNAMESE COMMUNITY OTHER
REFUGEES WHO RESIDE HERE THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU A SENATOR GREGG HASKIN
FOUNTAIN VALLEY. OF MY WIFE
CARRIE WHO WISHES SHE COULD BE
HERE TODAY IS PRINCIPLE OF STAR
BICU ELEMENTARY SCHOOL IN
WESTMINSTER. DOES START VIEW IS
FORTUNATE TO HAVE A NUMBER OF
STAFF AND COMMUNITY VOLUNTEERS
THAT ORGANIZE LESSONS. ON A
REGULAR BASIS EVERY YEAR.
DEALING WITH HISTORY IN THE
CULTURE OF THE VIETNAMESE PEOPLE.
AND THIS IS PART OF SEEN AS A
TREMENDOUS COMMUNITY ASSET.
THE.
THE THERE ARE JUST A FEW YEARS
EARLIER SHE WAS PRINCIPAL AT.
AND NEIGHBORING SCHOOL SAME
SCHOOL DISTRICT JUST A FEW MILES
AWAY. THEY DIDN'T HAVE THESE
RESOURCES AND.
THEY DIDN'T HAVE ANYTHING
REALLY TO OFFER IN TERMS OF THE
HISTORY AND THE CULTURE OF THE
VIETNAMESE PEOPLE OR THE
VIETNAMESE AMERICAN EXPERIENCE.
HAD S. B..
AT EIGHT NINE FIVE BEEN IN
PLACE HAD THIS CURRICULUM BEEN
AVAILABLE THEY WOULD HAVE GLADLY
USE THAT. IN THEIR SCHOOL THERE
AND EVEN TODAY HIT START VIEW ON
ENTRY SCHOOL I'M BY THE WAY
START VIEW IS IT I NEWLY HONORED
DISTINGUISH SCHOOL SO THEY HAVE
A WONDERFUL. RESOURCES THERE.
IN FROM THE COMMUNITY BUT.
EVEN TODAY RATHER THAN USING
THE IMPROVISED LESSONS THAT THEY
PUT TOGETHER THEY WOULD MUCH
PREFER TO HAVE A STANDARDIZED
ORGANIZED TO BE I AM CURRICULUM.
THAT TO WOULD BE OFFERED UNDER
S. B. EIGHT NINE FIVE.
THE VIETNAMESE AMERICAN
COMMUNITY HAS DONE A BEAUTIFUL
JOB OF ASSIMILATING TO OUR
SOCIETY THEY BROUGHT TREMENDOUS
RESOURCES TO US.
IN SO MANY WAYS BUT THEY HAVE A
VERY RICH
AND VALUABLE CULTURE THAT.
WE SHOULD ALL LEARN MORE ABOUT
WE WOULD BENEFIT FROM LEARNING
MORE ABOUT THAT. AND WE WOULD BE
A MUCH RICHER LACK COMMUNITY
ALTOGETHER.
ESPECIALLY IN THESE AREAS WHERE.
WE HAVE SUCH STRONG LEVELS OF
VIETNAMESE AMERICAN.
POPULATIONS THAT HAVING THAT
UNDERSTANDING REALLY GOES A LONG
WAYS TO BUILDING A MUCH MORE
PRODUCTIVE COMMUNITY.
SO I'M HERE TODAY TO URGE YOUR
YES VOTE ON S. B. EIGHT NINE
FIVE.
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
A GOOD MORNING MY AM ASIDE TIDO
AND I.
A POLICE OFFICE OF THE SYLLABUS
FOR TWENTY TWO YEARS.
MY SON'S A POLICE OFFICER FROM
LONG BEACH BE DIFFERENT WAYS
HERE.
CLOTHING YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO ADDRESS THE
COMMITTEE HERE.
I WAS A VIETNAMESE REFUGEE.
WHEN WAS FOURTEEN YEARS OLD.
MY PARENTS.
SPENT HER DAY ENTIRE LIFESAVING
BOOK ME ON THE BOTH TO SKIP
VIETNAM.
JOURNEY UP TO FREEDOM WE CAN DO
A LOT OF.
HARDSHIP WE WERE ATTACKED BY
THAI FISHERMEN WHAT WE CALLED
THE SO CALLED PIRATE THEY PREY
UPON OUR REFUGEE THOUGH
VULNERABLE BUG BIT ME REFUGEE.
I STAINED AND THE VERY PRETTY
CAMP FOR TWO YEARS. AND
IMMIGRATED TO UNITED STATES WHEN
I WAS SEVENTEEN. THAT NO MONEY
MY POCKET AND.
.
CLINT MARIKA HAVE WELCOMED ME
WITH OPEN ARMS AND GIVE ME AN
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE AN EDUCATION.
HAVE A PROPER REAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER.
.
GO I USE TO WORK THREE JOBS. A
DEFIANT MAYOR ROOM.
GO TO SCHOOL AND I GET ABOUT
FOUR IN THE MORNING BILLY FOR
NEWSPAPER.
ON THE WEEKEND.
WORKING AS GENERAL CLEANING
BANKS IN OFFICE.
TO MAKE EXTRA MONEY.
BUT THE REASON THAT I COME HERE
TO SUPPORT SB A NINETY FIVE
BECAUSE AS A AS A POLICE OFFICER
I HAVE TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE
PUBLIC.
AND NOT.
YOU KNOW WE ALL KNOW ABOUT THE
GOLDEN RULE DRAGGED WE TREAT
PEOPLE THE WAY WE WANT TO BE
TREATED BUT THE THING IS A
PROBLEM A WITH A NINETY THREE
LANGUAGES SPOKEN IN CALIFORNIA.
WE CANNOT TREAT PEOPLE THE WAY
WE WANT TO BE TREATED BECAUSE
THAT MIGHT BE OFFENSIVE TO OTHER
PEOPLE.
STUDIED THE DOES AND MASTER BUT
THAT YOU CAN ONE SAY.
UNDERSTANDING IS ABOUT A SONG
SON OF LOVE WE HAVE TO
UNDERSTAND HOW PEOPLE SO THAT WE
CAN COMMUNICATE EFFECTIVELY.
.
SO THE GOLDEN RULE IS NOT GOOD
ENOUGH FOR ME I HAVE TO LEARN
HOW TO COMMUNICATE EFFECTIVELY
AND MY.
GREAT MENTOR WHO WAS A RETIRED
LOS ANGELES SHARE.
LIEUTENANT MIKE A TRIP HE
TAUGHT ME THAT.
BLACKMUN RULE.
CHIEF PEOPLE THE WAY THEY WANT
TO BE TREATED.
AN OFFER YOU TO TREAT PEOPLE THE
WAY THEY WANT TO BE TREATED YOU
HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT THE
OTHER INNOCENT OF FEAR AND
FRUSTRATION. YEAH OTHER
UNDERSTAND THE SUFFERING HAVE
BEEN STANDARD CULTURE.
SO IT'S VERY IMPORTANT THAT WE
HAVE TO AND YOU KNOW THE
AMERICAN HAVE TO UNDERSTAND.
THE ASIANS THE VIETNAMESE
AMERICAN WHO HAVE CONTRIBUTE AND
RICH. ARE SOCIALLY CULTURALLY
ECONOMICALLY FOR CALIFORNIA.
AFTER FORTY THREE YEARS.
AND THAT'S WHY.
I WOULD LIKE TO OF.
BASS.
THE COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT THE S.
B..
A NINETY FIVE.
BUT KATO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
EXCUSE ME THE DIGITAL. IN
SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND THE
MONTHS MY NAME IT DIDN'T GO
ANDREAS WHO DON'T HELP THE.
VIETNAMESE CATHOLIC CONSTANCE
RULE IN SAN JOSE SANTA CLARA
COUNTY. I'M HERE TO SUPPORT IN
DESPERATELY ES WHO IT'S FOR A
YES VOTE. ON A S. B. EIGHT
NINETY FONG RECANTING THANK YOU.
COOPER.
HONEY AND LEMON LADY AND
GENTLEMAN MY NAME CUNNINGHAM AND
LIVING IN SAN JOSE. AND SANTA
CLARA COUNTY BECOME HE FOR
SPORTING HP. A KNIFE I THINK YOU
THINK YOU.
HI EVERYONE.
MY NAME IS.
DOING SO LONG I DELAY IN BB
THOUGHTS.
PRETTY.
I AM PHOTOGRAPHER.
I COME HERE TO SUPPORT.
FORMERLY A WE ARE MY HEART SB A
KNIFE FIGHT THANK YOU.
MY NAME TOM WINDHAM.
IN SOME STOCKTON AND A FULL MOON
CHAIRMAN IN THEM.
SOMERS STOPPED IN CALIFORNIA.
AND I'M SMALL.
AT B. EIGHT NIGHT FINE THANK YOU.
I AM HIDDEN WITHIN. TREASURER OF
THE OVERSEE VIETNAMESE WOMAN
ASSOCIATION IN NORTH CALIFORNIA.
AND ALSO RAISE THE DEAD OF SAN
JOSE.
I COME OVER HERE TO SUPPORT THE.
RESOLUTION AND S. B. EIGHT
NINETY FIVE OF FROM SENATOR
JANET NGUYEN THANK YOU.
THE MORNING THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO BE HERE MY NAME
IS SAM HALL. AND A CURRENT
DIRECTOR AT A COMMUNITY COLLEGE
AND ALSO PRESIDENT OF THE
NEIGHBORHOOD SO SO ASSOCIATION
IN SAN JOSE.
I'M HERE TO SUPPORT S. B. EIGHT
NINETY FIVE BECAUSE THAT
REPRESENT EDUCATION WHICH IS THE
HALLMARK OF THE GREAT SEAL
CIVILIZED SOCIETY. AND WE NEED
TO INTEGRATE OUR VOICES IN ORDER
FOR OUR STUDENTS TO BE FULLY
DEVELOPED AND SERVE BECOME
GLOBAL CITIZENS. AND WE ASK THAT
YOU SUPPORT. EIGHT ARE S. B.
EIGHT NINETY FIVE BECAUSE I WAS
STORIES FROM MILITARY PERSONNEL
FROM VIETNAMESE BOAT PEOPLE FOR
THE PEOPLE WHO ARE VICTIMS OF
THE VIETNAM WAR. THE WHOLE STORY
OF THE BERMAN VIETNAM WAR NEED
ALL VOICES BECAUSE THOSE ALL
VOICES WILL REMIND ALL OF US OF
FREEDOM DEMOCRACY AND HUMAN
RIGHTS FOR VIETNAM AND FOUGHT OF
US THANK YOU. ADVANTAGES FOR MY
PEOPLE TO PER SAY THEIR NAME AND
THE POSITION FOR THE BELL WE HAD
FULL TESTIMONY AND
SUPPORT.
GO AHEAD.
BOY GO DUMP I TOOK OJ LONG CLIP
GOOD NOT TO LAUGH FROM SHEEP YOU.
ANDONG WE ALL YOU KNOW THAT BIT
TOM THUMB DIDN'T I'M. NOT TOLD
ME SHE CRITICALLY ENDANGERED.
THANK YOU.
A DOZEN COULDN'T OUT WE GET A.
DIRT THAT LIES GODLY.
BUT ON ONE SIDE TO AUTOMATE Y.
SHOULD THE A YEAH TO OPEN ALL
THE LOOK GUY IT BE EIGHT NINE I
TRY. THANK YOU.
YOU DON'T NEED ME TO TRANSLATE.
THINKING WITHOUT WITH A BOLD
LINEUP MAKE MILLION.
THOUGH INFORMED CENTER THEY BUY.
WHO HALL IS A LOT?
SAM KEEN NAM.
THANK YOU.
ABDULLAH EVEN THAT LOGIC TO
ATTACKING.
IT'S OR AT LIMON THAT THAT ME
SEE ETHERNET MEAN AND WHAT I
THINK. I'M CUTE NAM. AND MAKE IT
BIG EVENT. WHAT TO DO FOOT
AMBIKA THE DENTAL YOU PUBLICITY
NOT PLEASE SEE I DON'T BUDGET
KNUCKLE AND I DIDN'T CALL YOU
BACK FROM MIDDLE? CLASS.
PRETTY.
WE HAVE ONE HUNDRED.
BUT.
BERRYHILL WHO IN.
THE ONLY A LITTLE HALL.
NEW DO NOT FANCY NAM.
SEVEN BILLION.
BUT I COULDN'T WIN CAME FROM SAN
JOSE LAWS IN OUR I'M JEANNE NAM.
INCOME OF.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN. MY NAME WITH THE BLOW
A.
I STAY AT A SAN JOSE OF WICCA.
COMMUNITIES PICK THE MEASURE.
AND.
I.
ONE MY HA.
SUB BUCKLEY SB A KNIFE FIGHT
THANK YOU AND BODY IF YOU.
SUNLAND FUND THOUSAND.
I SUPPORT S. B. IT NOT PARK
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS TROUBLE.
I'M
BY PRESIDENT OF THE ENEMY
COMMUNITY AND.
NOT ON CALIFORNIA I COME TO
SUPPORT.
S. BE IT LIVE FIVE THANK YOU.
WERE LARGELY EVERYBODY. MY NAME
IS A LONG WAY ON.
OUR OUR MEMBERS OF.
VIETNAMESE FELT COMMENDED DE
OPSAHL UP CALIFORNIA.
ARE I WANT DISTRICT BOUGHT FALL
S. B..
ARE NOT I NOT DEFY PLEASE.
BY ARE THANK YOU VERY CLOSE BUT
NEVER COMING.
VIDEO NOTED LOSES THE MONEY.
MY NAME MAIN NAJIMY LOW.
I'M.
VITOR AND.
VIETNAM LAW BEFORE.
OF FLOW CONFIRMED GO CHAU WHO
IS A.
I'M SHE BOUGHT JOB. S. B..
A KNIFE.
FIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MY NAME MAMOULIAN FROM SEMI DAY
IDEA FOR A P. A. KNIFE I.
THANK YOU.
SIT DOWN WITH A THUD THAN NOT
PONDO THOUGH THAT THE YOUNG
GOODMAN VOTE SAN JOSE BUT HEY
MARK YEAH HOEDOWN LEAGUE GOT
DON'T DON YOUNG KITTEN YOUNG
QUEEN DEBIT NAM. THE OVERHAUL
YOU KNOW. S. B. DAM DIDN'T I'M
THINK I'M ON WE'VE A.
GOOD MORNING EVERYONE I'M THE
SAME VOTE AND SACRAMENTO
APPEARED SUPPORT STANDING IN SB.
ENOUGH I THINK YOU'RE HERE.
SINKING THAT WE. BOY DID THAT
THAT
HOLD WHO KNOWS HOW TO OPEN THE
VIETNAM HIGHLIGHT MCCALLIE
COMMITTED A. VOICE TO POP.
THE LEASES SENEGALIA MUCH OF
BALK A BIT BUMPY NAM.
INCOME OF.
THINK OUT WE KNOW IT.
WE'VE GOTTEN QUOTA HOPEFULLY
MOVE GLOBAL HOPEFULLY THAT
HAMMOND Y. BACK DALY FONG YEAH.
BUT THE MOOD LIKE A BALL.
ACKLEY* ACTING NAM COME FROM
THEM DOSING. OVERHAUL MURAL.
S. BREAKDANCING NAM MISSING
GOVERNMENT QUICKLY.
THANK YOU.
NWA.
FULLER PATAN MARINE.
TO WILL NINE ONE THAT COULD NOT
WHEN YOU ARE.
HEY THAT GUY.
WHAT MEAN TO HAVE?
BOJAN.
WELL YOU LOOK AT IT BENITO PART
OR.
TURNER CHASER NICOTINE.
THANK YOU.
I'M NON NGUYEN FUND SANTANA. I
SUPPORT S. B. EIGHT KNIFE I
THINK YOU THINK YOU.
YEAH CAN DOWN WE'VE A. ALONG
WITH WAY AND THAT THE INFO THAT
IN SOCAL LEAVE WHO CAN.
BLOOM ALL.
AND YOU LOOK.
BANK BE PUMPKIN NAM GAMMON.
GOOD MORNING COMMUNITY.
I MEDICAL DOCTOR MY NAME'S
HIDDEN. BLUNT JOHN YEAH.
I'M LIVING IN ONE KNOCKED.
WE DON'T DOOR RUSSIA'S JUST COPY
AM SCARED TOO STRONGLY TO
SUPPORT. THE BILL.
S. B..
AYE KNIFE AYE.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME JACQUI
NGUYEN I AM THAT BOOK PEOPLE I'M
ALSO WROTE.
VISIT WOMAN I COME HERE FROM
SAN JOSE I COME TO SUPPLY US. F.
B. PACE KNIFE FIGHT WHICH JANET
NGUYEN THANK YOU.
HI EVERYBODY MY NAME IT DAD
PUBLIC THAT WITH THE LIT MY KIND
IDEA SAN JOSE I CAN BE AT THE
SUPERMARKET. AND UNIT THAT S. B.
NINE EIGHT KNIFE I THINKING.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMAN MY NAME ADVANCE ONLY I
CAME FROM SAN JOSE. AND I.
CUMBIA AND EYES RUDY SUPPORT OF
A FOUGHT JANET NGUYEN FROM
BOTTOM OF MY HEART WITH. THE S.
B. A KNIFE I THINK IT'S SO MUCH.
THANK YOU HAVE A GOOD ONE.
THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS JAMES SO UP PRESIDENT
OF THE VIETNAMESE. NATIONAL
MILITARY ACADEMY ALUMNI
ASSOCIATION I'M SUPPORTING.
S. B. IT LIFE I.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN MENANDER DJIBOUTI
KENYA.
PRESIDENT OF CENTRAL
COORDINATING ARMY OF FREE PUBLIC
IF VIETNAM IN SOUTHWESTERN U. S.
I ALSO HELD A CUP TO PILOT IN
VIETNAM. I'M HERE TODAY GIVEN I
BELIEVE IN IN HAVING THIS AND
COUNTY AND I'M HERE TODAY
SUPPORT FOR SP IT NOW IF I THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
YEAH HUNGER. MIAMI LIFE PHAM
HIGH LIVING IN SAN JOSE AND
TODAY I COME HERE TO SUPPLY AKA
TENET PLAYING ABOUT S. B. HEY
NINE FIVE FALL.
AND MY AND.
MY BRAGA AND.
I LATER TO KNOW ABOUT HISTORY
ABOUT IT NOT ME WAR. PEN TO SO
MUCH.
ERIC DOT NET OUT TO LUNCH AT THE
MENTAL. AUTOMATICALLY MEAN BACK.
ADMITTED PAYER ONE HOW YOU
CREATE.
YOUR HONOR AT BET PROMPTING NAM
QUIRK. GOAL YOU JANET NGUYEN
SOME DRUMMER.
BUT MONNING LADY AND GENTLEMAN
MY NAME BE YOU DEFINE.
I CONFIRM THAT GROWTH SOUTH
CALIFORNIA.
I MEAN THEN FLAW. BE BUT THEY TO
FIT THEM FOUNDATION.
I COME HERE AT THE SUPPORT GROUP
RELATION S. B..
I KNOW I FIVE BECAUSE I WAS SO
YOU'RE IT VIETNAM Y. AND THEY
KNOW. EIGHTY ONE EIGHTY FIVE.
THOUSAND.
AMERICAN SO YOU DON'T NOW I
DIDN'T VIETNAM Y. AND MONDAY
TONY HUNDRED THOUSAND.
SO YOU A VIETNAM BANG HIDDEN
DAVID KNOW WHAT IT.
ARE PEOPLE WOULD MAKE LENTIL
SOUP BLOCK BIG PICKUP. WE'VE GOT
IS A VERY GOOD FOR ALL OF
VIETNAMESE AND A CURE THANK YOU
SO MUCH THANK YOU.%
I DON'T.
MY NAME IS DON'T AMONG UP I'M A
STUDENT FROM CONTRA COSTA POLISH.
I'M COME COME HERE FROM THE AND
SO BRAIN DEAD TODAY COME HERE TO
SUPPORT OUR S. B.. BASED KNIFE
FIGHT THINK YOU.
WHAT MONDAY EVERYONE?
I AM TIERED PATENT.
ADDED LIPID MOUNTING UP BABY I
COMEY YEAH I SAMAKH.
AT B..
A KNIFE FIGHT.
PARDON REDNECK YEAH THANK YOU
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
MOVE. WOULD MONEY AND LET THE
LADY UP.
THAT MEN AND.
MY NAME A CRIT DEL.
I'M UP PRESIDE IN.
HOT UM DEBATE ME ASSURE SAY SAID
UP TO I DIDN'T MAY I LEAVE IT
INTO THAT SENTIMENTAL NO
CALIFORNIA. I COULD MEDIA TO.
SHABBAT.
THE AND.
I EIGHT BE.
A KNIFE I OBSERVE THAT AGREEING
THANK YOU.
BEEN W..
THOUGH IT GOT WOULDN'T QUIT.
BIGELOW DIAPER BAG WHEN I.
YOU DID THAT THAT GO TO PICK HER
PICNICKING Y.. ETHICAL OAKLAND
I'M NIGHT OVER TAG MIGHT GET
ODOM'S WRITTEN DIRECTED Y. I'M
AYE.
SHOULD KNOW WHO ALL COULD LOOK.
ACTING NAM QUADRATICALLY IN.
THE MONTH.
THANK YOU.
NO I WANT.
MY PHONE EMMYS JOHN WHEN FAT I
AM STUDENT I COME FROM ASA JOSE
ECHO I GOT TO BE HERE TO SUPPORT
OF SB. HA A KNIFE I THINK YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
PENINSULA UP ON FROM SAN JOSE.
ARE COMPARED TO SUPPORT RESOURCE
AND S. B. AT NIGHT FIVE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
GOOD MORNING LADIES GENTLEMEN MY
NAME HALL. EILEEN FULTON VIOLATE
I CAN WEAR TO SUPPORT.
AND I HATE IT BE A KNIFE I THINK
YOU'RE VERY MUCH.
PINTO COULD BE TWO GOAL LEAD TO
DONE SHOWN TYPING PORTS HUNDRED
DAY. TO BILDENDE DE WHOM ALL
TALK TO EACH HE'S ON THAT WITHIN
THE LAST YEAR LOT XP BOB ENOUGH.
SHE ENCUMBERED BONTA EQUITY.
A GOOD MORNING AND HIS IDEA AND
JAZZ GENTLEMAN. MY NAME USED TO
WIN.
I'M LIVING IN NOVI CITY ARE AND
COUNTY I'M HERE TODAY TO SUPPORT
TO STASH SENATOR JANET NGUYEN
FOR. S. B. A EIGHTEEN NIGHTY
FIVE THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LIDDY AND THEN A
MINE MINE ENEMY TO THE I AM HOW
KEEPER I LEAVING IN THE ART AND
COUNTY.
EYES SOAPBOX.
AT THE. IT KNIFE I THINK ILL
HERE.
CENTER OF THE COME ON THAT I.
THE ONLY. PRINTER NAM CALIFORNIA.
THE COMMENT THAT THEY DID
SUPPORT THE ARE YOU NOT. S. B..
IT NINETY FIVE I THINK A VERY
MUST.
SINCE I'LL ACTUALLY PALOUSE
INDEED ALL.
GLORIA SOMEWHAT REDMOND THE
BOTTLE LAST NIGHT EASY AND DON'T
DIE OUT COLD BICU MOVES INTO
LITTLE TOOK NUMBER I MEAN I'M.
AS SANE OUT BODEGA WHOM HALL
THOUGH NOT DIE SBC PROMPTING
THEM SAW.
THAT MUSIC YEAR. DENTON WE
INVESTED GOVERNMENT THE
CAPTIVITY.
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME BUT WHEN.
I AM PHAM.
THE ORANGE COUNTY I LIVE IN
MIDWAY CITY. I AM SUPPORT S. B.
EIGHT NINE FIVE. THANK YOU THANK
YOU.
PUT MONEY IN AND LADY AND JIM
AMEND MY NAME IT PRE JULIAN I
LEAP IN AND I AM SICK THEY. ARE
RUN CAUGHT THE EYES COMEY OF
PASTA BALK AT BE. BADLY FIGHT
PENFIELD.
WAS MEINEN.
GOOD MORNING LADIES GENTLEMAN.
MY NAM IT LATE KIM PHUNG I LABOR
AND SANTANA ARE AND COUNTY.
I CAN HIT THOSE FOR.
S. B. ED KNIFE I.
THANK YOU.
PUT MONEY IN.
BUT THEN THAT MY DANTE A CONVO
HAD AND GROW BUT AND CUT THE.
BILLION A LAWYER LOOK SB.
TEMPTED NAM.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
SINCE AND OUT BONTA COOLEY.
PADILLA TO LOOK SHOWED.
BUT AS YET MOVE HERE COOK DOT
CHILDREN GO.
BOB WHAT.
BRITAIN BY. BEAR WHOM HALL.
DENISE IS AMERICAN AND RICHARD.
SELECT.
BUT WE.
TOM TO NAM FOR OFTEN THE SHOES
AND AND THE AND THE EXCHANGE.
CHEN COME UNCOMMITTED. THANK YOU.
WHAT MORE NAY IN MY NAME IS YOU
ONLY I LIVED IN MOUNTING GOT
THEY THANK HIM MAYOR I SUPPOSE?
HERB BE IT BE A KNIFE I THANK
YOU.
HELLO ANYBODY AND MY NET DE IN
BAND I LEAP THAT THE CONVO
WHITMAN THAT.
I. HAVEN'T DO YOU LOS ALAMOS
YELLOW.
TOM A. FI. PHOTOGENIC FEEDING
THANK YOU.
AND.
GOOD MORNING. I AM WHO FOUND.
I LAY WHERE MEAN DOES SHE DE.
AND ARE AND GO TO A.
I DRIVE BRIDGE HIDDEN.
GOING HOME. OVERSEE.
PERMISSION.
I SHOULD UP LOW PAY BE.
PAGE NOT DEFY.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME UP TIGHT
TREND I COME FROM SAN JOSE.
ACTOR PAUL.
S. B. EIGHT NINE FIVE THANK YOU.
THE GUY WITH ME.
BUT I DON'T HAVE TIME TAKE.
THAT BILLIARD BUTTONHOLE WE GO
NOW. BEEN I'M TECHNO THEY.
BOB HOLT GOING TO LOOK.
BUT I DIDN'T TAKE NO.
BUT WE DIDN'T IDENTITY.
BUTTONHOLE.
GOAL YOU HADN'T WRITTEN.
GOOD.
WE'RE NOT.
AT ME.
BOB DIDN'T I'M.
RECALL WHAT I MORE THAN LIKELY.
BUT NO I DIDN'T I COULD COME
WOULDN'T GO.
THE TOP.
HEAD BODY IS MY NAME BEING
RUNNING WHEN I LEAVE SANTA ANA.
I A PRETEND FOR A BUDGET FOR.
AYE SUPPORT OR.
IT'S BE.
A KNIFE FIGHT THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
MY NAME IS ZACH AL.
FREDO. CITIZEN AT SOPHISTICATES
AND.
A FARMER MINIMALLY POLITICAL.
PRISONER.
I.
KALINKA DE.
I SYMBOLIC.
P..
S. B..
PAGE.
HI FI PAINKILLER.
THING DOT WITH A. PLOY ALL UN.
FONG WHO WAS THE CLINTON KEPT UP
THE KILEY.
THEN I THEME OVERALL YOU KNOW.
WHY?
A MAGNETIC MARIA YOU LOOK.
BUT BE. DUMB GET NUMB THANK YOU.
MONNING MAYBE AND GENTLEMAN.
WHO AND TREATMENT AND EVEN IN
ARE AND KATHY I COME HERE FOR A
SUPER XIN NGUYEN AND YOU LOOK?
S. B.. A KNIFE I THINK CLEAR
PICTURE.
BINGO PRIVY.
SELECT AND TO BROOKLYN OF
CONTEMPT WILL GET OUT OF VIETNAM
GONNA.
TICKET THOSE HE DIDN'T LIKE A
FAT AND YOU WILL COME WHEN HE
DIDN'T WIN TUNEFUL HAPPY TO TALK
DON'T ONLY. THEN DIDN'T DO IT I.
BUT IN DAY.
OKAY.
A FOOTNOTE YOU LOOK.
AT LEAST.
BOB DO NOT.
COR BODY THEY CAN THANK YOU.
MONNING LADY AND GENTLEMAN MY
NAME IS SAMANTHA READING.
I CAME I AM VERY PROUD TO BE
HERE. TO DAY.
AND NOW. CAME FROM MEET GRACIE
B. ORANGE COUNTY.
AND.
I AM VERY PROUD TO SOUP BARK.
S. B. EIGHT NINE FIVE AND I HOPE
OWN UP TO LEAD THE END CHEN
THURMOND SOAPBOX. PIECE.
S. B. EIGHT NINE TO FIVE THANK
YOU VERY MUCH BE AND HAVE A NICE
DAY THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
CAN GET AWAY EIGHT BUT THEN
AGAIN KNOWN GANG.
ó AND COUNTY MAN NAM. KELLY.
.
THOUGH YOU KNOW YOU LOOK UP AT
ME.
AND GIVING THEM.
DON'T LET THEM ONLY A. GOOD BET
AND MEDICARE.
GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY MY NAME
IS DAWN NGUYEN. PHENOM FROM
SANTA ANA ORANGE COUNTY.
FINALLY OP THOUGH FORTY THIRTY
YEARS DESY MARTYRIUM COM TRUE.
I AM VERY APPRECIATED I MEAN.
I WE REMEMBERED THIS DAY FOR
EVER.
OKAY SO PROPERLY APPRECIATE IT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU WELCOME.
I DIDN'T OUT QUICKLY.
.
POLYTECHNIC Y..
GOOGLE OFTEN PULL ANYTHING BACK.
BUT AND I.
BELMONT ZERO US S. B. PROMPTED
NAM QUOTE AND SAY THAT NAY
SAYERS JANET NGUYEN.
TO COME ON QUICKLY.
THINKING OUT WE. GOING UP WE END
UP THANKFUL HUNDRED THAN BEACH
NAMPALLY FINE YEAH.
THE ALEJO'S SP FANCY NAM.
SEEN COME ON.
BUT MORNING GENTLEMAN.
LADY AND GENTLEMEN I GIVE ME A
PHARMACY DEL UP WITHOUT INTRO. I
CAN GET THE SUPPORT FOR.
AT B. IT MY FIGHT TO GIVE IT A
MUCH.
LEARNING I NEVER MY MOTHER
TONGUE NGUYEN.
I I'D I'D THE GROUP THOUGH GODLY
DIARRHEA AND MEDICA.
MA I DIVERSITY THAT ANGLE I COME
HIS FOUGHT FOR. PET.
S. B. SHAPED MY WHEN IT NOT BY
THINKING.
WHO DON'T MEET GOOD MORNING LADY
AND GET THEM AND I CAME FROM
QUESTIONING DON'T ARAKAKI?
I CAME HERE TO SUPPORT. IT BE. A
KNIFE I THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME WHITMAN
JOHN.
I'M LEAVE A GOTTEN DRAW AND
ORANGE COUNTY.
I REPRESENT FAR BUDGET.
I COMEY ISOBAR.
FLORA S. B. A KNIFE ON.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LESBIAN CHEN THE
BOND.
MY NAME EAST LA FONG.
M. FROM CORONA CITY UP.
RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
I'M HERE TO SUPPORT SINISTER
JANET NGUYEN.
S. B..
BUT IT NINETY FIVE THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING EVERYONE.
MY THEM MY LITTLE FAMILY FELLOWS
DAY.
AS FAR AS WE.
AT DIE I THINK YOU.
GOOD MORNING FAYE EMERSON QUAN
DARK.
LEAVE US I.
SAU PRETTY FUN YEAH.
AS A BAR.
ERIC NINE FIVE. TIED TO.
HI MY NAME AT LEAST SOMEONE I
LIVE IN IN THAT THAT MEDICAL
LACK CALIFORNIA RIVERSIDE. A I'M
CIVIL GOV S. B. EIGHT NINE FIVE
THANK YOU.
GOOD MONEY.
MY NAME BEATING THAT.
POP AND VIOLATE CITY OUT AND
COUNTY CALIFORNIA.
I SUPPORT.
AT B. AT NIGHT HI THANK YOU.
MORRELL LEGEND GENTLEMAN MY
NUMBER TIME INFORMED WESTMINSTER
CALIFORNIA I SUPPORT. S. B.
EIGHT NINE FIVE FORM SENATOR
JANET NGUYEN THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN SMUGNESS MCCARTY LEAST
I'M IT'S PROBABLY SOMEWHAT
SURPRISED TO ATURE A JET NGUYEN
AND ON CELLS TO PAR FALL.
THE ADS BE A KNIFE FIGHT BY
YAHOO SYSTOLE APPRECIATION.
THANK YOU.
SINCE CAL II. BOWLING IN
HANDLING A THIGH SAN JOSE.
BURDEN THEY THEY OWN HOME HERE.
AS THEY. FOUND ENOUGH.
SENATE WAITING.
WE COULD.
SINGLE GAL WITH A.
THE ELAVIL BUT EVEN HIGHER
THOUGH WOULDN'T DAM.
BUT ONLY HALL IS A LOT.
AND MAY.
BAM DE NAM QUOTE ON THE CITY'S
HONESTLY AND SINGLE MON.
WHO'D BEEN A.
I AM TOM BROKAW I LIED.
BUT ENTERED.
CITY.
I.
IT. HIGHEST A BALL.
BUT BAY.
AT NIGHT FIVE.
RENDON GROUP.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN. MY NAME WEEKLY
LETTING THEM NOW. I COME THROUGH
ITS BOUGHT FOR. IT BE.
DATE KNIFE BY ARTS BOOK FOR IT
AND. GET ON THE.
LOOKING NGUYEN THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
GOOD JOB WITH HE. BORDER ZONE
MILLION.
ASSEMBLY TODAY WHO MADE THE
DIDN'T IDEAL WALL.
YOU LOOK AT BE IT NOT APPLY
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
LOOKING AT ME.
MY NAME BILL WOULDN'T.
I BELIEVE IN YEAH YEAH.
BUT IT TURNS.
ARAMBULA BAY HE LA FOR NAFTA.
I STEP OUT OF.
AT MAY.
BUT NOT A FACTOR NGHE THANK YOU
WELCOME.
GOOD MORNING BRANAM THEN THAT'LL
YA. I COME FROM SHE'D GOTTEN.
AND I AM SHIP THOUGHT I'D BE. A
KNIFE I CAN GIVE IT HIM AT.
I MYERS ALL GUNG WHERE. MARINA
VIETNAMESE MARINE CALL I MADE ON.
THE IN THE BAND DON'T COME FROM
WHAT THEY TIME ANTIPOPE.
PET ME I KNOW I FIVE TANGO.
MY MEDICAL PLEASE.
I I LEVY ISLAM WAS LED BY IS THE
BOARD. S. B. A NINETY FIVE THANK
YOU FOR ALL YOU.
MY NAME IS NOT TN DONE. VESTED
IN OP WELL WHAT MISTER.
I'M SUPPORT.
S. B. AT NIGHT FIVE THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
LADIES GENTLEMAN.
MY NAME IS THAT CAN MEAN MILLION
I LIVING IN THE SAN JOSE AND
TODAY I COME DESERVE SIR
SACRAMENTO TO. SUPPORT.
BUT SENATOR CHEN NOT. SHANNON
NAY IN. AND.
S. B. A NIGHT FINE THANK YOU.
HELLO MY NAME RUPTURED.
AT WILL SACRAMENTO.
I COME HERE TO SUPPORT.
S. B. A KNIFE I THINK YOU.
GOOD MORNING THE BODY MY
NAMELY THAT DIDN'T JUNE.
I'M NOT. OBLIVION THAT ORDER AND
COUNTY
SUCKLING VIDEO OUTPUT YEAH TO
DAY I COME HERE TO SUPPORT.
S. B. A DI FI UP TO I DIDN'T
LIAM CAN GIVE.
AT THAT THE IN.
HANG NGUYEN AND INTO A THING
POLL I SANDRA DAY.
PAT BOYLE WHO I DO NOT AND IT'S
ME I'M THREE NOT. SEEN HOW MUCH.
MY NAME IS NICK SAID NGUYEN
GRADUATE AND ALL OF THE COUNTY.
OF ORANGE.
AND THE CITY OF WESTMINSTER I
STRONGLY SUPPORT THE BILL.
S. B. EIGHT KNIFE I.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS MONDAY.
I AM VETERAN SOUTH VIETNAM
BELIEVE SACRAMENTO. AND I A
SIMPLE.
S. B. A KNIFE I THINK YOU.
I AM FROM FARMLAND AND HANG AND
STRONGLY SUPPORT. S. B. EIGHT
NINE TRIED THANK YOU SO MUCH
THANK YOU.
THE MORNING SENATORS I REALLY
APPRECIATE YOUR PATIENCE AND
CONSIDERATION I CAME HERE FOR
ANOTHER BILL THAT I'M I'M GONNA
AN AND I AM SO MOVED BY THIS
BILL I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW IT
EXISTED. BUT I'M THE FIRST
PERSON ONE IN THIS COUNTRY FROM
BOTH SIDES OF MY FAMILY. AND I
DON'T KNOW MY HISTORY.
AND THIS WOULD BE AMAZING.
TO UNDERSTAND WHERE MY FAMILY
BUT THAT.
SO PLEASE.
HELP PEOPLE FROM MY GENERATION
UNDERSTAND WHERE WE BLOCK.
THANK YOU WELCOME.
BUT MONEY JANETTA MANY BET ON
NGUYEN.
IT DIDN'T NEED TO AMERICAN A
COMMUNITY OF SENTIMENTAL.
I AM VERY HAPPY TO COME HERE TO
SUPPORT AT BE IT KNIFE I.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NOW THE GOVERNOR TOOK THAT
ENOUGH I'M AGAIN TO YOU BY
SACRAMENTO. BUT THEN DAY YEAH
THEM OPEN WHILE YOU'RE LOCAL
BECAUSE I DIDN'T IN S. B. BOMB
PIN NAM.
SHE GOT MONTH.
A COUPLE OF PROBLEMS SAID TO
PICK MY NOSE AND GOVERNMENT
VEHICLES ABBOTT CALIFORNIA.
SCENE DIES YET DUTCH AND WHATNOT.
WHO HAD BUCKLEY TO BOISE IT NOW
OWN HOTELS HE LOOKED AT ME IT
PROMPTED NOT SICK COMMITMENT?
THE LOW FUNGI.
AT I.
COMPOSED THAN THEM.
BILDENDE THERE I'M HOLE YOU LOOK
LIKE FAIR.
BOB.
THE NUMBER.
SINGLE MY.
GOOD MORNING.
I AM A COURTROOM I CALMLY AS
SIMPLE IDENTIFY.
THE COUNTRY WHERE MOST.
MONEY IN MY NAME IS SUZANNE MALL
AND LEAPING SUPPLEMENTAL. AM
SUPPORT.
I S. B. H. NINETY FIVE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MEND THEM BE SUING
THEM AND EVEN WEST MINTA.
I SEBAB THE S. B. A KNIFE Y.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU.
GOOD MORNING EVERYONE. BY
LEVITON FULL BEEN.
I LIVING IN NOW WAS BEING TONY
COTTEE. I COME HERE TODAY FOR
YOUR SUPPORT IN S. B..
IT NOT I FIVE I SHUT IT GRANT.
I.
THIS MORNING. MANIMALA CONFIRM.
M. ROOM.
WELL I WISH SAMANTHA THE COME
VIA THE SURPLUS.
S. B..
A KNIFE BY.
THANK YOU.
I AM ALLOWING AGAR COMPROMISE ON
HIM. THAT COMETH GOES. IT SB IT
KNIFE PLAN.
THANK YOU.
NAM PHILLIP DREW A LIVING IN
SACRAMENTO.
I COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT SB A
KNIFE FIGHT THANK YOU.
MY NAME'S MATT FOUND EYELID NEED
NOT AND ROLL OUT AND COUNTY I AM
SO FAR. S. B. A KNIFE I.
THANK YOU.
THEY INVOICE BATTLE BOTTLED UP
GOOD GETTING SACRAMENTO.
BUT WILL HOLD YOU LOOK AT MEDIA
AND.
BOB IT NOW THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
BUT ALSO WE HAVE TO TRANSLATE
THAT AND.
BLAME WHAT HAPPENED WAS HE SAID.
I AM THE BREAST SEDAN OFF
VIETNAMESE SENIOR ASSOCIATES AND
I COME VIA. TO SUPPORT MRS WHEN
N. S. B. A KNIFE I THINK HERE.
WHAT WHAT HAPPENED WAS THAT THE
GENTLEMAN SAID SPT AND WHICH IS
A SITE ON BROADCAST TELEVISION
NETWORKS? AND THEN SO THAT'S WHY
WE ALL KIND OF CHUCKLE OUT A HE
MENTIONED THAT AND THEN S. B.
BECAUSE HE. THOUGHT THAT SOME OF
IT I GOT IT.
MONNING MY NAME WHO IN MILLION.
A LIVING GOD INTRO CUT FLOORING
COUNTY ARTS BOUGHT TO THE. SP A
KNIFE FIGHT THANK YOU.
I AM CERTAINLY IN.
I'M ME. FROM C. THINK AND GROW
ARE A COPY. I'M HERE TODAY
BECAUSE THE PAW AS BE EIGHT NINE
FIVE THANK YOU THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SALIVATE BOTH THE
LEVEL TWO AND US SOMETHING FOR
SOMEONE THAT THEY'VE BEEN MASON
ALEJO'S DO NOT. FANCY NAM.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING AT NAOMI GRIN FROM
ANAHEIM ORANGE COUNTY I SUPPORT
SB EIGHT KNIFE FIGHT THANK YOU.
BEEN DOUBLY OF A BOWLING LOW
VIETNAM WHO GIVES UP A MONTH AGO
THEN DIE THAT OVERHAUL. YOU LOOK
AT AT MIDDAY BOBBY NAM.
GETTING BACK.
BUT THERE IN PHAM PONTOON BUT
COULDN'T PULL WHITMAN BOTH PAN
FULL MOON OR UNCUT THE BOATLOADS
YOU LOOK. AT BE TOM BICU NAM
POOL OF COOLEY SHE'S CERTAINLY.
PULLING HIM DOWN EXCEPT THOSE
WITH THE WHOLE OR. AND AT ME I'M
DENOUNCING ABOUT.
WOULD MONNING. MONDAY NIGHT THAT
THE.
DIDN'T DO THAT.
WATCH GOD WILL GET.
WHAT WITH?
HE RESTED.
POSSIBLE.
YOU LOOK.
AT ME.
IT KNIFE I THANK YOU.
MY NAME MILEY.
IRON LEAVE WAS SETTLEMENT OF BY
WHOM HE ESPOO. AT BE.
A KNIFE I THANK YOU.
DODD THE LIKE HIM WITH SOME Y.
SENTIMENTAL INTIMIDATE WHO
WHOLLY.
YOU KNOW AND IT DIDN'T AND.
I THINK.
BUT THEN HURDLE OF SACRAMENTO
VOTE POLL YOU LOOK AT THE THANK
YOU NAM.
PUT MONNING I AM I WANT DONE.
LEAVE A SUPPLEMENTAL AYE
SPOKESMAN S. B. IE KNIFE I THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU.
BULLOCK ONE BULLET WE GET
NOTHING HAVING FOOT ONLY GAME.
ONLY DO NOT GET MEET THE BOMB
DIDN'T I'M BY HEADLONG GOD
WOULDN'T GO NEED TO GET THAT WIN
GO.
PUT A BY NEVER COULD DIDN'T.
VIETNAM VETERANS.
FROM THE WAY CITY.
I SUPER.
S. BE EDIT NOT FIVE TAKE YOU.
MORNING MY NAME IS VAN*
LEAVING INGRESS MADERA.
SHE DE CALIFORNIA ICEBOX STORIES
S. B. AT MY FIVE. THANK YOU.
TO LEARN FROM WHO IN ADDITION
TODAY.
KING BUTTONHOLE GOOD LOOK.
AT BE BONTA NUMB.
HIM GO COTTO ICON ONLY A SIMPLE
I COME HERE TO SEEK OUT. THE HOT IN THE OCEAN
RIGHT MENTAL BUT INUNDATED LOW
YOU LOOK AT ME THANK YOU
NINETEEN GOVERNOR.
GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY.
MY NAME IS THAT THOMAS FARM
INCOME FROM.
YEP AND GROW I COMPETE TO US
UPON THE S. B. IT NOW DEFY.
MY THE REASON FOLKS. LIKE ALL
HOPES OF PEOPLE IS THE ONE KNOW.
ABOUT THE.
AMERICAN.
WHOOPS UPON MY COUNTRY.
IN THIS TIME A BLACK AND. BEEN
RIGHT NOW.
AND YOU NEED A SIMPLE EVERYTHING
FOR MY COUNTRY.
AND THE SECOND IS A LIT THE.
COULDN'T DO YOU NEED US TRINITY
SOME.
THE NICK S. B. KNIFE I THANK YOU.
SINKING DOWN GROOVY BUT THEN THE
CIVIL LAW GREW YOUNG CAN POST
PHOTOS A POLITE VOTING DAY
DAEWOO HOLE. YOU LOOK.
S. B.. NAM SYNCML.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN AND FROM SAN JOSE
SANTA CLARA COUNTY I MEET TODAY
TO SUPPORT SENATOR JANET NGUYEN
AND S. B. A KNIFE FIGHT.
Q..
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS JOHN DOW
I LEVY INSIPID HIS SPEAR
VICTORIA VIOLATE I CAME INTO
SPOT AT BE. A KNIFE I THANK YOU.
THE WEEKLY THEN.
SUMMER DAY THEN READING ACT
MONDAY DAY LOVE.
I DO NOT AND MAY.
I DO NOT. COMMIT.
I AM CANYON LOW AND IF IN FACT
ABOUT A CD OR ASK OUT THE.
ACKERMAN THROUGH THE PARK S. ME
AT KNIFE I THANK YOU.
TO GET OUT DANTE LIAISE. THOUGHT
THEN THAT KRYSTEN HOLLOW BILL
O'DONNELL PHONE ALBEIT NAM JAI
WHITE KELLY.
COME NIGHT BUT THEN PAY DAY
ALONE HALL CLOTHES AND NICK WHEN.
HE LOOKED AT ME AND HE NAM BLACK
AND TING CLOTHING YOU NOW TO
THOUGHT EIGHT DAY LAND PATENT
GALA ROCK THAT NEIL MIGHT THEM.
DECADE BOND AMONG LITMUS GLOWED
KOENIG LANE TO GOVERNMENT THEM
PAY WE YEAH.
THANK YOU.
TIM DUNCAN'S OUT QUICKLY BUT I'M
UPSET THE FLAMBEAU WING BANG THIS MORNING.
DALY AND GENTLEMEN.
MY NAME IS TOM MIGHT DIANNE. AND
EVEN IN SANDRA DAY ISOBAR.
IF I.
AT NIGHT BY. IT BE EGGMAN FONG.
PUT INTO DON'T TELL ME THEY
DON'T ACT ON HOME NOW YOU CALL
LOCAL CONNECTING TO A VIETNAM AT
THAT TEMPO STOPPED ON.
SHE NO MALL YOU LOOK AT ME TOM
DO YOU NAM.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME READING
THEM.
I LIVE IN THAT HELP ROLE CT.
I COME HERE POST ABOUT.
S. B. ANI FIVE THANK YOU.
I REALLY THOUGHT OF OPENING
STATEMENT I FIX HAVE NO ONE HOA
S. B. THOMPSON NAM.
THANK YOU.
THAT PERSON WASN'T.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN MY NAME LEAVING CHEN
WITH A LEAPING ACROSS SACRAMENTO.
I COME HERE TODAY TO SHARE
PRODUCT S. B. AT NIGHT BY IN Q..
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS STANLEY
FARM.
SACRAMENTO I COME HERE TO
SUPPORT THE ASKED WE. TAKE.
AND I FIVE THINK IT.
DIDN'T DIDN'T GET OUT WE ME. BUT
THEN TO WEAN US ON OJ BUTTON AND
IT WILL.
M. BE. BACK.
LONDON NAM THAT.
THANK YOU.
SILICON VALLEY PRODUCT I'M
WAITING FOR THE YOUNG GUY DIDN'T
SHOW I'M NOT TOO GOOD AND I.
DON'T OVERHAUL YOU LET US THE
INEVITABLY THE.
.
THE DELAY OF SOME THAT ANNOUNCER
GOT A FUN YEAH.
BUT AND I HOME OWE YOU LOOK. AS
BE FOUND DIDN'T I'M COOL BECAUSE
I REMEMBER. THERE WAS A.
OF GOOD MORNING EVERYONE I AM OF
YOU THEM HE.
VETERAN.
I WOULD ASK EVERYONE OF YOU
PREVIOUS UP ALL THAT BE A UNITED.
PAGE THEY ALL ON THE TO MAKEUP OR
MONEY PLAYED BY THE VIETNAMESE
COMMUNITY COULD GO A MOMENT.
THERE Y. OUT EVERYONE OF YOU
PEACEABLE BUT BE A NEED. A NOT A
PART.
THANK YOU.
BUT MOM EGGMAN ADMITTING ALL
ABOUT MAC LA PINGAT A DROLL
KILEY FIVE YEAH I SUPPOSE S. B.
EIGHT NINE FIVE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
LADY ENDS AT THE MONEY MY NAME
EAST ANGLIAN.
I BELIEVE IN THE CITY OFFICE
WINDOW AROUND COCKY.
AT I'M HAPPY. A HERE.
DO SO FAR.
S. B.. AT LIFE I THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING I'M A IN FRONT.
PROBLEM HUNTINGTON BEACH.
ALRIGHT KATHY AICHA BOOK S. B.
IE NIGHT FIVE. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME TOMORROW
WE'LL. PRIVATIZE THERE. COMEDIA.
TO BALK.
IT BE.
A NIGHT BY THE GUILT.
GOOD MORNING.
I AM LONG BANG. AM LEAVING A
MAYBE THOUGHTS.
I AM SO BALK HEAD P. PAY KNIFE
FIGHT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS CLEANLY AND I LEAVE
EMAIL PETERS I COME HERE TO
SUPPORT IT A S. B. A KNIFE I
THINK.
WOULD MONNING EVERYBODY AND DO
THEM CHEN I LIVE IN THAT GARDEN
GROVE CALIFORNIA I COMEHERE TO
SUPPORT S. B. EIGHT NIGHTS I
THINK YOU.
GOOD MORNING EVERYONE.
I AM DYING WHEREIN. I LIVING IN
GOD AT ALL CALIFORNIA.
I AM A. GOOD FOR YOU KNOW AND
RETIRED.
AND I COME HERE.
IT'S A BALK.
FOR S. B..
AT NINE FIVE. THANK YOU.
ONE IN EVERYONE MY NAME CUTTING
WAITING AT THE MAP BY OFF THE
BEATEN ME AMERICAN COMMUNITY.
AND COOLEY SAID NOT THAT NOT
THAT IN CALIFORNIA I COMMITTEES
STRONGLY SUPPORT AS BE AT NIGHT
FIVE FARM SINOPEC DIDN'T WING
PINK INSTANT THEN THEN WE.
THANK YOU.
TOILET CAN WIN YOU KNOW.
TO COME DOWN DE SHUT ME LAUNCH
DATE AND I.
A WALL.
YOU KNOW. WHAT CAN I QUIT?
AT MAY.
DIDN'T AUTUMN HIDDEN NAM.
THANK YOU.
LORELAI LATE EVENING AFTER YOU
CAN GO TO SAN DIEGO.
AND THEN A DAY OMAHA YOU LOOK I
STE MAY PROMPTED NAM BACK THAT
HE SEES CHEN NICK WINGS INCOME
AND WE.
LEARN I LIVE HOW MEANT THOSE
SANTIAGO ALLENDE DAY YOU DAY
YEAH BUTTONHOLE YOU LOOK AT THE
EMPTY NAM ORGANICALLY.
A SYNCHRONOUS OUTGREW IT.
BELLA WOULDN'T RUN.
GOODS AND TYSON WAS A.
INDOOR DIED I THEIR OWN LAWS A
LOT AT MAY. TIME TO NUMB
RECOGNITION.
INFANTILE QUIT.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS DENNIS
FLAN PANAMERA TIRED SCHOOL
ADMINISTRATOR.
FROM STOCKTON CALIFORNIA AND I
THINK THAT THE VIETNAMESE
EXPERIENCE.
IS REPRESENTATIVE OF MANY
IMMIGRANT AND REFUGEE
COMMUNITIES IN THE UNITED STATES
AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT.
AS P. THREE NINETY FIVE.
COME OF.
THANK YOU.
JANA. AND MEN AND THE PURPOSE OF
THE RIVER THEN THE DIVIDEND
ASCENDANT HOT.
SO AND AND.
AND SHARE A CHIP CHAPLAIN ALSO
THAT.
MEDICAL MISSIONARY AND THE CEO
AND PRESIDENT OF THE VIETNAMESE
AMERICAN. COMMUNITY CENTER AND
BROKE WAY CRISIS CENTER AND WE
COME IN PROMOTING COUNTY AND WE
USE SUPPORT THE SP. A.
HAVE. A NIGHT IF I THINK IT.
HI GOOD MORNING AMTRAK.
I COME FROM.
THAT NUMERO CALIFORNIA I'M
REALLY TUITION.
I COME HERE TO.
SHOWING MY SPOT.
S. B. A MAGNIFIED BECAUSE
BECAUSE I THINK THESE WHO HELP
THE NEXT GENERATION. KNELT UP
HOW.
THE COMMUNIST.
AND WHAT VISIT TO INDIA USE IT
IN HIS HOUSE STARTED HISTORIC.
THANK YOU.
BUT NO ONE IN MY NAME ZOOMING
WHEN I LIFT AND A WHITE MEDINA.
ORANGE COUNTY I COME HERE TO
SPOCK.
NOT BE A KNIFE I THINK YOU.
MY NAME NAM WILL ALLEVIATE AND I
AM OUT AND GOATEE. AS SPOT IT BE
A KNIFE I.
GOOD MORNING LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN MY NAME E. C. PATRICK
NOR I LEAVE A IN SAID OKAY
CALIFORNIA. I SUPPORT FOR S. B.
AT NINETY FIVE.
UP JANET NGUYEN THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS NOT ALONE AMID%
REPORTER FOR WHOM THE TV AND
LATEST THING ON RADIO. THE
FLORIO THE BLUE THAT WE'VE FOUND
OUT ONLY LAST YEAR PRINTED IN
TWO THOUSAND SIX.
AND I MET THE OLD A WIFE.
HER SIGNATURE AND HOPEFUL NUMBER
ON FACEBOOK YOU CAN CALL HER AND
ASK.
HOW HER HUSBAND THE ODOR OF THE
BOOK MEDINA AND COOL LONG
RESCUERS? IDENTIFIED THE BODY.
WHAT THE U. S. S. C. ARE AND
VISIT ONLY ENGLISH DOCUMENTARY
BOOK?
THAT GAVE I WOULD DEBT PEOPLE
THE VOICE.
WE ARE ON THE SAME JOURNEY FOR
FREEDOM THAT ALIVE.
WHEN WE WENT TO MALAYSIA THE
STATE'S ATORNEY AND NEW. THIS
MARCH.
THE PEOPLE IN MALAYSIA
ESPECIALLY IN THE STATE OF
TENDER NEW.
CALL US VB P..
I DON'T KNOW WHAT PBP ME.
I ASK THEM AND THEY SAY. VPP
ALTHOUGH GRAVY ARE.
ALL ORDERED WHERE YOU ARE INTENT
ON NEW.
GOT A NOTE HOME NAME VB PETE.
RITA MEANS THE BOAT PEOPLE.
THAT ARE ALIVE WE ON THE SAME
JOURNEY. AND PLEASE LET BURKE
CHIU SHYPE THROUGH. FOR OUR
GENERATION TO GENERATION KNOW
PEOPLE DIE FOR FREEDOM.
PLEASE SAY YES TO SB IT BY THANK
YOU.
MY NAME AYE TOMALIN AYE LEAPER
WHAT'S BEEN TO OWN IT COUNTY.
I JUST.
SUPPORT OCHRE S.. EIGHT THAT I
FIVE.
THANK YOU.
THAT AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS MY
NAME IS SET THREE BUT THREE
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
REPRESENTING AMERICAN GI FORM
AMERICAN LEGION.
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION COUNTY
VETERANS SERVICE OFFICERS
CALIFORNIA STATE COMMANDERS
VETERANS COUNCIL MILITARY
OFFICERS ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA
VIETNAM VETERANS OF AMERICA
CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL. ON
SUPPORT OF THIS LEGISLATION
THANK YOU.
NOW WE EIGHT OPEN UP DOWNWIND
COULD YET I AM. THE NAY YET WILL
YOU LOOK TIME COULD NOT.
BUT.
CRISTINA WELL YOU LOOK AT BAKED
I'M KEEPING THEM BLACK GUMBO.
THE CITY THE SENATE MILLION.
THANK YOU.
MY NAM LOOMING IN SAN JOSE.
BEAT ME MARIN.
VETERAN I COME HERE TO SUPPORT
THE S. B. A NAY I DEFY AND TANKS
SENATOR. JANET GOING TANK THANK
YOU.
LAST BUT NOT LEAST I KNOW MY
NAME. LOCKED BANG THE.
PHONE GOT AND GO.
I SUPPORT.
BUT BE.
A KNIFE I.
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
MY NAME A LAMP GRANDFATHER MA
ARE AND COUNTY.
I AM HERE TO SUPPORT THAT IT BE
A KNIFE I THANK YOU.
THANK YOU I'M.
SHOULD S. RUINOUS IS IN
OPPOSITION. BURKE THAT.
ISRAELI WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
TO THE SENATOR WINDS S. B. EIGHT
NINE FIVE.
SEEING NONE FINANCE
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS JULIE EDITOR WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AYE
NOTWITHSTANDING THE POLICY
MERITS OF THIS MEASURE FINANCES
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL.
A WE WOULD NOTE THATABSENT NON
STATE FUNDING CONTRIBUTIONS THE
BILL WOULD CREATE ONE TIME NON
PROPOSITION NINETY EIGHT.
GENERAL FUND COST OF SEVEN
HUNDRED TWENTY THREE THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
TO DEVELOP A NEW MODEL
CURRICULUM ON THE VIETNAMESE
AMERICAN REFUGEE EXPERIENCE.
IT ALSO CREATES PROPOSITION
NINETY EIGHT GENERAL FUND COST
PRESSURES BY ENCOURAGING LOCAL
EDUCATIONAL EDGY AGENCIES. TO
OFFER COURSES ON THE VIETNAMESE
AMERICAN REFUGEE EXPERIENCE TO
STUDENTS IN GRADES ONE TO TWELVE.
ADDITIONALLY THE INSTRUCTIONAL
QUALITY COMMISSION ALREADY HAS A
PROCESS TO CONSIDER THE
INCLUSION OF SPECIFIC SUBJECT
AREAS IN THE STATE'S CURRICULUM
FRAMEWORK.
AND THIS CURRICULUM OF ON THE
REFUGEE EXPERIENCE MAY BE
CONSIDERED BY THE COMMISSION
THROUGH THIS PROCESS.
AND FINALLY THE COMMISSION
RECENTLY BEGAN WORK ON A NEW
ETHNIC STUDIES MODEL CURRICULUM.
WHICH MAY INCLUDE.
TOPICS RELATED HARLEM. TO THIS
ISSUE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
FROM COMMITTEE WILL BEGIN WITH
CENTER BRADFORD SENATOR PELL.
DINNER BELL I'M BATES AFTER SO
BRADFORD THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
AND I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
OF SENATOR WHEN FOR THIS
IMPORTANT. MEASURE AND
ASSEMBLYMAN ARCH KALRA AND I
THINK MORE IMPORTANTLY THAN%
INDIVIDUALS WHO'VE TAKEN TIME
OUT THIS MORNING TO COME.
AND TESTIFY FOR THIS MEASURE I
THINK IT ONLY HIGHLIGHT THE MIS
EDUCATION. OR THE WHITE WATCHIN
OF AMERICAN HISTORY THAT WE'VE
SEEN SINCE THE BEGINNING OF TIME
IT SEEMS THAT WE ONLY VALUE THE
STORIES OF THOSE WHO LOOK LIKE
THE FOUNDING FATHERS OF THIS
COUNTRY.
IF WE TRULY EDUCATED AMERICANS
WE WOULD KNOW THE RICH
CONTRIBUTIONS OF NOT ONLY THE
VIETNAMESE AND WHAT THEIR ROLE
PLAYED ND. ARE HELPING CIVIL
RIGHTS IN THIS COUNTRY BECAUSE
IN THE VIETNAM WAR WAS THE FIRST
TIME IN AMERICAN HISTORY THAT
BLACK BROWN LATINO AND ASIAN
FOUGHT SIDE BY SIDE IN A NON
SEGREGATED UNIT. IN THAT WAR BUT
ALSO WE WOULD UNDERSTAND THE
GREAT CONTRIBUTIONS OF AFRICAN
AMERICANS AS WELL THAT GO FAR
BEYOND SLAVERY IN SPORTS AND
ENTERTAINMENT. THE OUT OF THE
MEXICAN AMERICANS ARE FAR BEYOND
FARM HANDS AND OUT OF THE TRULY
INDIGENOUS PEOPLE THE NATIVE
AMERICANS WHO STORY IS FAR
BIANCO BOYS IN INDIAN SO. I
APPRECIATE THIS MEASURE AND I
LOOK FOR IT WHEN IT COMES UP
SUSPENSE INSUBORDINATE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER BELL.
WHEN I WAS IN AWE HIGH SCHOOL.
.
MY TRACK COACH.
WORDS FATHER DE EVELYN WHOSE
BROTHER WAS BOUGHT DOUBLE. BOTH
PEOPLE OF TREES.
.
FATHER DEVLIN US THROUGH THE
VIETNAMESE PEOPLE.
FATHER DEADLINE LAWS BROTHER WAS.
TEACHING IN MY SCHOOL.
I LEARNED A LOT ABOUT.
THE SITUATION.
FROM HIM.
AND I ALSO WHEN I WAS ASSEMBLY
STATE ARE LEARNED OF HIS DOCTOR
LARRY ENGELMANN.
WHO IS COLLECTED HUGE ARCHIVES?
ON.
.
THE VIETNAMESE PEOPLE AND NOW
IT'S STILL RESIDES AT SOUND THE
STATE IN THE ARCHIVES THERE.
THERE ARE HUGE AMOUNTS OF
INFORMATION THAT HAVE BEEN
COLLECTED.
AT.
COUNTS CALIFORNIA'S SAN JOSE
STATE UNIVERSITY.
.
THERE IS ALSO A HUGE AMOUNTS OF
RECORDS THAT PEOPLE HAVE.
THAT WE CAN COLLECT.
AND.
CREATE.
WITH THIS EFFORT WHICH IS A
MAGNIFICENT EFFORT. TO CREATE A
HISTORICAL RECORD.
FOR THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA.
AND.
THE COST TO ME IS A VERY SMALL
COST IN LIGHT OF THE BENEFIT.
THAT WE WOULD RECEIVE.
FROM ACCOMPLISHING THIS.
.
I THINK CALIFORNIA IS THE STATE
TO DO THOSE.
WE CAN'T WE CAN'T FOR SEE. A
GREAT BENEFIT TO THE EDUCATION
OF ALL STUDENTS.
IN CALIFORNIA.
AND.
.
THERE EFFORTS THAT.
SAN JOSE'S COMMUNITY WHICH I
REPRESENT.
TO CREATE A. VIETNAMESE CULTURAL
AND HISTORICAL CENTER WOULD ALSO
BENEFIT. FROM THE COLLECTION OF
ARCHIVE MATERIAL RECORDS
AND.
THE HISTORY CURRICULUM FOR THE
STUDENTS.
THERE IS A LOT OF WORK THAT'S
BEING DONE. AND I THINK THE
STATE CALIFORNIA'S TO SUPPORT IT.
IT'S GOING TO BE A BIG EFFORTS
GONNA TAKE A LOT OF WORK.
BUT.
WE ALL WILL COMPLETE THIS WORK
AND NOW.
COMPLETE DECIPHERED THAT WE HAVE
TO DO.
TO.
PIECED TOGETHER.
THESE HISTORICAL RECORDS SO
MISTER CHAIRMAN I HOPE TO DO IS.
.
THE BIG THE OUTSTANDING BENEFIT
CAN BE CONSIDERED BY THE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. IN THE
FINAL DECISION OF THIS COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU OF VICE CHAIRWOMAN
BATES.
THANK YOU ARE.
I JUST WANT TO ECHO I'VE SENATOR
BILL'S COMMENTS THAT I THINK
THAT THIS IS EXTREMELY
WORTHWHILE. A PIECE OF HISTORY
THAT NEEDS TO BE INCLUDED IT OFF
FOR THE GENERATIONS TO COME. I
WAS PART OF THE GENERATION WHEN
THE VIETNAM WAR WAS GOING ON AND
WE CONSIDERED OURSELVES I THINK
THEY WERE THE HAWKS AND THE
DOVES. HAWKS TOOK A LOTOF FUN
CRITICISM FOR SUPPORTING A WAR.
ON THAT WAS GOING ON BUT IT WAS
VERY IMPORTANT TO THOSE OF US
WHO SUPPORTED IT BECAUSE IT WAS
ABOUT FREEDOM FREEDOM FROM
COMMUNISM WHICH WAS A MAJOR
THREAT TO OUR NATION. BY DURING
THOSE YEARS SO THANK YOU SENATOR
NGUYEN AW THANK YOU ALL THANK
YOU ALL FOR YOUR LIFE STORY
BRING THAT FORWARD BECAUSE WE
KNOW WHAT. RESILIENCE YOU HAVE
IN YOUR CULTURE WE KNOW WHAT
PASSION WHAT COURAGE YOU HAVE
AND THAT IS CERTAINLY A HALLMARK.
ON THIS PARTICULAR OUR CULTURE.
WE NEED REWARDED BY APPROVING
THIS BILL AND SO YOU WILL HAVE
MY STRONG SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SENATOR BATES AT HOME
BEFORE WE CLOSE I WANTED TO
SOMETHING A FEW WORDS. TO OUR
VETERANS THAT ARE HERE TODAY
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE. IT
MEANS THE WORLD TO HAVE YOU HERE.
AND TO OUR GUEST WELCOME TO
CALIFORNIA STATE CAPITOL. A I
WAS AS YOU KNOW I'M I'M SICK
TODAY AND I WAS LOOKING FORWARD
TO THIS COMMITTEE HEARING. BUT
SEEN YOU ARE HERE.
REALLY BRIGHTEN MY DAY BECAUSE
I'LL IT WASN'T TOO LONG AGO
WHERE IT WAS FROWNED UPON TO
HAVE PEOPLE TESTIFY IN THEIR
NATIVE LANGUAGE. HERE IN THIS
OWN CAPITAL ATTACKS HAVE YOU
HERE HAVE YOU TESTIFIED THE
LANGUAGE THAT YOU FEEL
COMFORTABLE AND IT'S SOMETHING
THAT BRINGS ME JOY AND IT
REMINDS ME OF. WHY CALIFORNIA IS
SUCH AN AMAZING PLACE?
PLACE WHERE WE ACCEPT EVERYONE
AND AT A TIME AND PLACE WHERE IN
MANY OTHER PARTS OF OUR COUNTRY.
THERE'S EFFORTS TO ERASE OUR
IMMIGRANT REFUGEE EXPERIENCE.
WHEN YOU SEE WHAT'S HAPPENING
IN ARIZONA WITH TRYING TO BANMEXICAN AMERICAN STUDIES.
AND TO THE YOUNG LADY WHO WAS
ANYONE HERE TO TESTIFY FOR THE
BILL.
SHE MOVED ME BECAUSE I ACTUALLY
LIVE THAT SAME EXPERIENCE WHEN
SHE SAID. ALLOW FOR US TO
UNDERSTAND WHERE WE COME FROM.
AND GROWING UP EVEN IN LOS
ANGELES AS A YOUNG KID WHERE WE
WERE CALLED MEXICAN HERE AND WE
WILL GO TO MEXICO AND WE WERE
CALLED AMERICA AND WHEN WE WERE
LITTLE MEXICO. WE HAD NO IDEA
WHERE WE BELONGED.
AND WE DIDN'T SEE OURSELVES IN
OUR TEXTBOOKS WE DIDN'T SEE
OURSELVES OR OUR EXPERIENCE IS
SO IT CREATES.
A SENSE OF ANIMOSITY THE SENSE
THAT YOU DON'T BELONG. BUT WHAT
EN AND EDIT AND I'M ALSO A BIT
SAD THAT WE HAVE TO ACTUALLY
LEGISLATE.
IN THIS TYPE OF BILLS TO
INCLUDE OUR CURRICULUM OUR OWN
EXPERIENCE.
IN.
IN CALIFORNIA WHERE EVERYTHING
AND AND CONVERSELY I DON'T SEE
THIS BILL JUST BENEFITING THE
VIETNAMESE AMERICAN COMMUNITY
BUT BENEFITING ALL CHILDREN IN
CALIFORNIA. BECAUSE WE ALL
BECOME BETTER.
IF WE UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER'S
EXPERIENCE AND WE BECAME WE BE
WE BECOMING A A MORE OPEN ALONE
MORE SENSITIVE TO EVERYBODY'S
EXPERIENCE.
BUT BEING THE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE THAT IS.
AND WE ARE LOOKING AT THE COST
OF THE BILL.
AND IT IS A SUSPENSE I DON'T BUT
WE WILL CONSIDER IT. A AS WE'VE
DONE ALL THE OTHER MEASURE
SIMILAR TO THIS.
WE'VE DONE SIMILAR BILLS ON THE
ARMENIAN GENOCIDE WE ARE HAVING
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT OTHER
CAMBODIAN GENOCIDE AS WELL ARE
LGBT.
HISTORY AS WELL WE HAVE TO OF
FORTUNE HAVE TO LEGISLATE ARE
THIS CURRICULUM BUT I WANT TO
THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE
YOU'VE REALLY MADE. OF MY
MORNING.
AS VISIBLE THEY FEEL HOT RIGHT
NOW.
THANK YOU FOR COMING FROM
AROUND THE STATE THIS IS YOUR
CAPITAL YOU BELONG HERE WE WANT
YOU TO FEEL WELCOME AND YOU
DESERVE. EVERY PART OF THE
AMERICAN EXPERIENCE SO WITH THAT
CENTER WHEN WHICH I LIKE TO
CLOSE. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN.
BEFORE CLOSE I JUST WANT TO
MAKE A COMMENT.
REGARDING THE.
DEPARTMENT FINANCES COMET AND
SHE DID MENTION THAT WE SHOULD
HAVE GONE THROUGH THE AYE QC
PROCESS AND THERE WERE THERE
WHEN WE TRY.
WE DID.
AND AYE QC AYE SHE HAS CLOSE
THE DOORS UPDATED NOT REJECT US
BUT THEY SAID AT THIS TIME THEY
WOULD NOT BE ACCEPTING ANY MORE.
STUDIES INTO THE CURRICULUM AND
THE NEXT PROCESS AS A START TO
EIGHT YEARS.
BOB SO WE HAVE STARTED THAT
PROCESS AND THE ACTUALLY THE
VIETNAMESE AMERICAN COMMUNITY
DID NOT KNOW THAT I START THAT
PROCESS TWO YEARS GO.
WE WANTED TO GO THE RIGHT WAY.
THE RESPECTFUL WAY TO THE
DEPARTMENT.
BUT BECAUSE THE DOORS CLOSE
UPON NUYS WE ONLY ARE ONLY IN
THE* OPTION THAT I WAS TOLD
US TO PUT IN A BILL AND SO
THAT'S WHAT WE DID SO. AND
MISTER CHAIRMAN I.
.
YOU KNOW THE BOOK THAT WAS
MENTIONED EARLIER ON THE FIFTH
SESSION FIRST TIME I'VE SEEN
THIS TODAY AND. I AM IT ALSO
HERE X. STATED FOR THE FIRST
TIME ON THAT I'M AWARE OF. THAT
ONE MILLION VIETNAMESE REFUGEES
DIE.
ESCAPING
ACROSS SEE MY FAMILY WAS ONE OF
THEM ON THAT WAS LUCKY ENOUGH TO
MAKE SCAPIN ACTUALLY MADE IT TO
THE ISLAND OF THAILAND.
A AND SO YOU KNOW AYE A YEAR. IT
DID THAT YOUNG LADY YOU
MENIONED MISTER CHAIRMAN
ACTUALLY THAT WAS WHERE I WAS
TWENTY PLUS YEARS AGO. I CAME
HERE AS A ONE POINT FIVE
GENERATION VIETNAMESE AMERICAN I
WAS THE ONE WHO WAS BORN IN
VIETNAM. AND CAME TO AMERICA AT
THE AGE OF FIVE LEFT VIETNAM AT
THE AGE OF THREE.
I DIDN'T SPEAK ANY ENGLISH I
DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE
HISTORY.
I ASK YOU DID EVEN LIVE IN AN
AREA OF I LIVE IN SAN MEDINA
COUNTY WHERE THERE'S HARDLY ANY
VIETNAMESE AND THERE'S TWO OF US.
AND WE WENT FROM.
OF FROM YOU KNOW FIRST GRAY ALL
THE WAY TO SIX GRADE EVERYBODY
THOUGHT WE WERE COUSINS EVEN TO
THIS DAY BECAUSE OF OUR LAST
NAME.
A I ACTUALLY LEARNED ABOUT THE
VIETNAMESE.
EXPERIENCE TO MY PARENTS.
BUT MORE THAT I FACT SHEET HAVE
BEEN VERY BLESSED AND HONORED
FOR OVER THE LAST TWENTY YEARS.
AND OVER A THAT I'VE BEEN ABLE
TO BE PART OF THE LITTLE SAIGON
ORANGE COUNTY AREA WHERE I
FASHION WITNESS AND LEARN. FROM
THESE INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE
FOUGHT. AND FAMILIES HAS DIED.
HARASSING AND TRY TO COME TO
THIS COUNTRY AND FREEDOM OF FOR
FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY.
I DON'T KNOW MUCH ABOUT THE
HISTORY UNTIL I WAS A MEMBER. OF
AS ELECTED OFFICIALS. ACTUALLY
COMMUNITY CAN ATTEST I ACTUALLY
BACK THEN COULD EVEN SPEAK THE
LANGUAGE.
I AM NOW FLUENT AFTER OVER A
DECADE.
BUT IT TOOK ME A LONG TIME BUT
I DON'T WANT THAT STORY IN
HISTORY TO BE LOSS IN MY TWO
YOUNG CHILDREN WHO ARE SEVEN AND
FIVE TODAY.
HOPEFULLY ONE DAY WHEN THE
VIETNAM WAR CURRICULUM IS TAUGHT
THE TRUTH WILL BE TIGHT Y. MY
PARENTS DID MADE THE OUR
ULTIMATE SACRIFICE AND FORCE OUR
WAY OUT OF THAT OUT OF VIETNAM.
AND SO MISTER CHAIRMAN.
I DO ASK AGAIN FOR THE
CONSIDERATION OF THE COMMITTEE
THIS IS THE AMOUNT OF MONEY IS
BEYOND.
AND. YOU KNOW THE VALUE OF WHAT
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT IS BEYOND
THE DOLLAR AMOUNTS. AND I SO I.
ALSO WANNA ON RECORD MAKE
MENTION THAT.
.
WE'VE HAD SUPPORT FROM
CONGRESSMAN Y. KANA WHO SENT IN
A LETTER LAST TIME I AM HIS NAME
WAS NOT MENTIONED ON THE SUPPORT.
THE CITY OF SANTA ANA HAS ALSO-OFFICIALLY SUPPORTED.
CONGRESSMAN SCOTT PETERS FROM
SAN DIEGO HAS ALSO ON ME AND
CALLED INTO THE SAN DIEGO OF
ENEMIES AMERICAN COMEDIAN AS AND
HAS STATED THAT HE IS IN SUPPORT
AS WELL. ON ENDS AND SO MANY
OTHER INDIVIDUALS AND AGAIN
TODAY HERE ALONE IS OVER THREE
HUNDRED PEOPLE THIS IS THEIR
FIRST TIME. MOST OF THEM THEIR
FIRST TIME TO THIS CAPITAL.
TO TRAVEL TEN HOURS SINCE
MIDNIGHT LAST NIGHT.
COME HERE TO TESTIFY BEFORE YOU.
IT'S VERY MOVING FOR ME BECAUSE
I'M NOT GENERATION BUT DON'T
KNOW WHAT HAPPENED DURING THE
WAR.
AND I JUST.
BENEFITING FROM THEIR SACRIFICE.
AND SO I ASK THAT YOU PLEASE
PLEASE CONSIDER THAT THERE'S ONE
BILL THIS YEAR THAT'S WHY MY
PRIORITY THIS IS IT. AND SO
AGAIN I.
IF I CAN MISTER CHAIRMAN SAY
FEW WORDS AND IMAGES TO THANK
EVERYBODY FOR BEING HERE B. R.
PLUMAS THANK YOU A. DUPLEX
GENITALS IN CANADA MONTH WE'D BE
WE DON'T WHO THAT THEY DAY WE
NAME BUT WE NUYS THAT THEY DAY
TO GIVE TO COMPLETELY. BUT NIGHT
THE MCKNIGHT BOTH THE CALL HOME
BACKED HIM LEAVE ME CDVA THEY
NOW.
HOLDEN NUMB DEFINITELY. ó. I'M
SORRY THERE'S OVER FIVE HUNDRED
PEOPLE HIGH WAS
I'D. I APOLOGIZE UNCLE HO NAM
DIMLY MAKE VICTORY NAM DO CIVIC
NAMPA Y. THAT THEY BUT NIGHT
THEY NIGHT TO TO BEING THAT BY
SAU. IN THAT SUIT BUT GIVEN WANT.
GOOGLE NAM COMPOUND FI YOU LIVE
A FIVE I DON'T CONSULTANT WITH
THE BAND CAN LEAD THEY TOOK ONGC
ITEM THOU BUT GONG GUY WELCOMED
A MAN'S SUIT QB THE HEEL. HILL
DAY. BUT SU COOK WE'D BE VOTE
COUNT BAG DAY JOB THEY BEAT BUT
I SAW WHO BEAT NAM THE NOW I
THINK THAT ARE NOT MADE A.
FORMAL IN THE GENESIS INCOME
MONTH LEVY HAD BEEN NAY YET LET
UP DAM THAT WE DID JANET THE
COAL DUST WHEN YOU PREVIA THEY
BUT NIGHT. OF THE SOUL SYMPTOM
OF LINDA SINCE INCOME ON FREEDOM
WHO.
AND I'VE.
I RESPOND.
FOR A.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION FOR AN AYE VOTE IN
THE FUTURE THANK YOU THANK YOU
THANK YOU MEMBERS ASSIST ACCOUNT
FOR SUSPENSE WITHOUT OBJECTION
WE MOVE THIS ITEM TO A SUSPENSE
WELL THANK YOU CENTER WHEN. IT
THANK YOU EVERYONE FOR BEING
HERE.
MEMBERS WANT TO TAKE A QUICK
FIVE MINUTE RECESS TO ALLOW US
TO.
.
WE ORGANIZE OURSELVES FOR A
QUICK
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
WHERE SENATOR TRUCKS NAM MY
AGENDA?
PAGE TWO.
SENATE JACKSON YOU HAVE TWO
ITEMS.
BOTH SUSPENSE.
CABINETS WAS BEGIN WITH S. B.
TEN TWENTY SIX PLEASE THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS AYE I
PROMISE I WON'T BE QUITE AS LONG
AS THE LAST.
OF PRECIPITATION PIT WHICH IS I
THINK A SAFE BET BUT.
A THIS MEASURE S. B. TEN TWENTY
SIX THE DIGNITY AT HOME ACT FALL
PREVENTION.
SEEKS TO ALLOW MORE SENIORS AND
DISABLED INDIVIDUALS TO AGE IN
PLACE AND STAY IN THEIR OWN
HOMES THROUGH THE USE OF SIMPLE
INEXPENSIVE HOME MODIFICATIONS.
THE REDUCE THE RISK OF FALLING.
SENIORS HAVE A ONE IN THREE RISK
OF FALLING IT FOR EVERY YEAR
OVER THE AGE OF SIXTY FIVE.
WHICH MAKES A FEW OF US IN THIS
ROOM I THINK WILL NERVOUS BUT.
THIRTY THREE PERCENT OF ALL
FALLS IN THE ELDERLY POPULATION
INVOLVE HAZARDS AT HOME.
FACTORS LIKE POOR LUBA LIGHTING
LOOSE CARPETS AND A LACK OF
SAFETY EQUIPMENT THINGS LIKE.
GRAB BARS STAIR RAILS AND HIGHER
TOILETS ARE PARTICULAR OUR
PARTICULAR RISK.
EIGHTY PERCENT OF THESE FALSE
HAPPEN IN THE BATHROOM.
EIGHTY PERCENT.
MORE THAN SEVEN HUNDRED THOUSAND
AMERICANS ARE HOSPITALIZED EVERY
YEAR BECAUSE OF A FALL MOST
OFTEN DUE TO A BROKEN HIP OR
HEAD INJURY.
IN TWENTY THIRTEEN WHICH IS SO
LAST YEAR WE HAVE THE DATA.
DIRECT MEDICAL COSTS FOR FALLS
WHAT PATIENTS AND INSURANCE
COMPANIES PAY TOTALED THIRTY
FOUR BILLION DOLLARS.
WITH MEDICARE PICKING UP ROUGHLY
SEVENTY EIGHT PERCENT OF THOSE
COSTS
BECAUSE THE U. S. POPULATION IS
AGING AND THE CALIFORNIA
POPULATION IS AGING AS WELL.
BOTH A NUMBER OF FALSE AND THE
COST TO TREAT THEM ARE LIKELY TO
RISE THAT'S WHERE THIS MEASURE
S. B. TEN TWENTY SIX COMES SAN
FOR AS LITTLE AS SEVEN HUNDRED
DOLLARS. WHICH IS THE AVERAGE
COST OF A MODIFICATION A HOME
CAN BE OUTFITTED WITH SIMPLE
THINGS LIKE GRAB BARS OR IMPROVE
LIGHTING. THESE IMPROVED.
IMPROVEMENTS CAN MEAN THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN AGING IN
PLACE AND FEATURED FACING A
FUTURE OF INSTITUTIONALIZATION
AND WE KNOW THAT THAT IS
EXTREMELY EXPENSIVE AND FRANKLY.
WE DON'T HAVE ADEQUATE
FACILITIES BETTER FOR PEOPLE TO
AGE IN PLACE IF THEY CAN.
BROTHER COMMITTEE IS IDENTIFIED
COSTS OF THREE HUNDRED AND
SEVENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS. FOR
THE DEPARTMENT OF AGING TO
OVERSEE THE PROGRAM.
I KNOW THERE WERE ALREADY
PURSUING A TWO AND A HALF
MILLION DOLLAR ALLOCATION
THROUGH THE BUDGET PROCESS FOR
THIS PROGRAM. AND WE LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
COMMITTEE AS THE BILL IS ON
SUSPENSE.
TO TRY TO TRIM ADMINISTRATIVE
COSTS TO MAXIMIZE THE FUNDING
THAT CAN FLOW TO THESE NEEDY
SENIORS AND DISABLED COMMUNITY
MEMBERS AND WITH ME. IS STERILE
CAL CHOOSE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
AREA AGENCIES ON AGING. TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU
MIGHT HAVE IN THE QUEUE
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT YES MISTER
CHAIRMAN GERALD CULTURE WITH THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF. HARRY
AGENCIES ON AGING WE'RE VERY
pAPPRECIATIVE OF THE SENATE
HEARING CARRYING THIS BILL.
HILL FALLS AND THE POTENTIAL
FALLS.
IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT SCARE
OLDER PEOPLE THE MOST.
FOLLOWS DO REMAIN AT THE LEADING
CAUSE OF DEATH FOR OLDER
AMERICANS.
FALLS THREATENS.
SENIORS SAFETY AND DEPENDENCE.
BESIDES CREATING ENORMOUS COSTS
FOR HEALTHCARE SYSTEM.
HAS THE CENTER SAID PROBABLY ONE
THIRD OF THE ADULTS OVER THE AGE
OF SIXTY.
AND FIFTY PERCENT OF ADULTS OVER
HAITI WILL FALL EACH YEAR.
BECAUSE OF THE LEADING CAUSE HIM
ANY INJURY TESTS AMONG PEOPLE
OVER AGE EIGHTY.
EVERY DAY IN CALIFORNIA TO
SENIORS DIE AS A RESULT OF THE
FALL. EITHER IMMEDIATELY OR UPON
GOING TO THE HOSPITAL.
HER HAND GOING TO A CONVALESCENT
HOME.
IT'S ESTIMATED BY THE CENTERS
FOR DISEASE CONTROL AT THAT TWO
POINT EIGHT MILLION PEOPLE ARE
TREATED IN EMERGENCY ROOMS EVERY
YEAR. PER FALLS IN HENDRY'S AN
EIGHT OO AND OVER EIGHT HUNDRED
PATIENTS A YEAR HER HOSPITALIZED.
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT ISSUE.
ONE IN WHICH THE AREA AGENCIES
ON AGING.%
HE IS WILLING TO STEP FORWARD
AND IMPLEMENT THE PROVISIONS OF
THIS GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY. HAND
THE SUPPORT AND WE ASK FOR HERE
I HAVE A.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WHEN THIS
ISN'T SUPPORTER AND DRILLING WE
ON BEHALF OF THE COUNTY OF SAN
DIEGO IN SUPPORT.
HER CHILD DISABILITY RIGHTS
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES APART
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
NANCY PARRISH CONGRESS OF
CALIFORNIA SENIORS IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU WHEN THIS IS AN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE YOU FILE. PROFILE
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
SEEN ANTHONY JOHNSON AGAIN THANK
YOU FOR LOOKING OUT FOR ALL OF
US.
YEAH I WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE THANK
YOU GIVE US JUST BRIEFLY AGAIN.
THERE IS.
FUNDING WE BELIEVE THAT IS.
BEING PURSUED IN THE ACTUAL
BUDGET ITSELF OF ABOUT TWO AND A
HALF MILLION DOLLARS. AND THE
DEPARTMENT ESTIMATES ABOUT THREE
HUNDRED SEVENTY THOUSAND TO
ADMINISTER THE PROGRAM. THIS IS.
ALMOST A KIND OF A NO BRAINER
IN THAT WE WE CAN IDENTIFY THE
SOURCE OF TREMENDOUS EXPENSE AND
DIED OF A DANGER TO OUR SENIORS
THAT CAN BE CORRECTED WITH THE
SMALL.
CONTRIBUTION UP BY THE STATE.
IT WILL NOT ONLY HELP THE
SENIORS BUT IT WILLAS OUR
POPULATION AGES THE.
THE COST OF NURSING HOME CARE IS
JUST PROHIBITIVE THE M. NOT A
NUMBER OF NURSING HOMES
AVAILABLE. IS HIGH IN INADEQUATE
THIS IS A WAY TO LET PEOPLE AGE
IN PLACE I THINK OF IT SO THE
VERY STRONG AND POSITIVE
INVESTMENT FOR THE STATE. THANK
YOU.
PLAN MEMBERS IS THE CANVAS FOR
SUSPENSE SO WITHOUT OBJECTION
MOVE THIS ITEM SO SUSPENSE WHILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY
THREE.
GOOD MORNING.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS TODAY I
PRESENT TO YOU S. B. ELEVEN
TWENTY THREE.
THIS IS A BILL TO EXPAND
CALIFORNIA'S PAID FAMILY LEAVE
PROGRAM WHICH IS A WAGE
REPLACEMENT PROGRAM. TO INCLUDE
CERTAIN TYPES OF LEAVE TAKEN
WHEN A FAMILY MEMBER WHO IS IN
THE ARMED SERVICES IS DEPLOYED
OVERSEAS.
AND RECOGNIZING THE SIGNIFICANT
STRESS XIN NEEDS THAT ARISE FROM
THESE DEPLOYMENTS SITUATIONS
SOME WHICH COME WITH AS LITTLE
AS SEVEN DAYS NOTICE.
ABOUT TEN YEARS AGO THE FEDERAL
FAMILY AND MEDICAL LEAVE ACT
WHICH WE CALL FMLA WAS EXPANDED
TO ALLOW EMPLOYEES THAT WORK FOR
EMPLOYERS OF FIFTY OR MORE.
TAKE UP TO TWELVE WEEKS OF JOB
PROTECTED LEAVE.
TO CARE FOR THIS SPECIFIC KIND
OF NEAT ARISING FROM A FAMILY
MEMBERS
EMPLOYMENT KNOWN AS QUALIFIED
EXIGENCY LEAVE.
BUT THIS LEAVE DOES NOT COVER
THE LEAVE OF A MILITARY SERVICE
MEMBER HIM OR HERSELF.
JUST THOSE OF THEIR SPOUSES OR
DOMESTIC PARTNERS THEIR PARENTS
OR THEIR WORKING CHILDREN AND
THIS BILL. WOULD ALLOW THEM TO
TAKE PAID TIME OFF THROUGH THE
PARTIAL REIMBURSEMENT PROGRAM
THAT'S AVAILABLE TO TAKE CARE OF
FINANCIAL AND LEGAL ISSUES. AND
COOK INCLUDING THINGS LIKE
SECURING WHEELS AND POWERS OF
ATTORNEY MAKING ALTERNATE SCHOOL
OR DAYCARE ARRANGEMENTS OR ELDER
CARE ARRANGEMENTS OR ATTENDING
HOMECOMINGS FOR DEPLOYED FAMILY
MEMBERS. IT IS BEEN APPOINTED
OUT THAT. THE MILITARY TWENTY
THIRTY FORTY YEARS AGO WAS OFTEN
AND MOSTLY COMPRISED OF SINGLE
MEN.
TODAY THE MILITARY IS COMPRISED
OF FAMILIES.
AND SO THOSE FAMILIES HAVE
CERTAIN.
NEEDS AND RESPONSIBILITIES THIS
BILL WILL ACKNOWLEDGE THEM AND
IT ENSURES THAT THE SALINGER
BOMB PLOY THESE WHILE RECEIVING
JOB PROTECTED LEAVE CAN ALSO
ACCESS THE PAID FAMILY LEAVE
PROGRAM. THAT THEY PAY INTO AND
ALLOWS THEM TO RECEIVE PARTIAL
WAGE REPLACEMENT DURING THE TIME.
I'DLIKE TO TAKE A MOMENT TO
ADDRESS THE COST ESTIMATES
PROVIDED BY EDT FOR THIS BILL.
FIRST SMALL IT'S IMPORTANT TO
NOTE THE COST FOR THIS PROGRAM
WOULD BE COVERED BY OUR STATE'S
WORKER FUNDED STATE DISABILITIES
INSURANCE PROGRAM NOT BY GENERAL
FUND DOLLARS BIG DEBTS
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT. THESE ARE
FUNDS THAT ALL EMPLOYEES PAY
INTO THIS PROGRAM. AS A VERY
SPECIFIC FUND THAT IS THE SUPER
A SEQUESTERED FROM ACCESS BY THE
GENERAL FUND AND AS HE ANALYSIS
STATES THE EXPERT EXPANSION
PROPOSED. UNDER THIS BILL WILL
RESULT IN NO ADDITIONAL WORKER
CONTRIBUTIONS NOR ANY INCREASE
IN THE STI CONTRIBUTION RATE.
YET EVEN AT THAT I DO BELIEVE
THAT EDT HAS VASTLY OVER
ESTIMATED A THE COST OF THIS
PROGRAM AND. A ONE THOUGH
THEY'VE ASSUMED THAT OF THE
ESTIMATED TWENTY SEVEN THOUSAND
CALIFORNIA SERVICE MEMBERS
DEPLOYED OVERSEAS EVERY DEPLOYED
SERVICE MEMBER. WOULD RESULT IN
ONE RELATIVE UTILIZING ABOUT
FIVE POINT FOUR WEEKS OF APPEAL
A BENEFITS.
HIGHLY UNLIKELY I BELIEVE AND WE
HAVE YET TO SEE.
FAMILY MEMBERS TAKING MORE THAN
A MAXIMUM TWO WEEKS AT THE MOST
FREQUENTLY IT'S JUST A NUMBER OF
DAYS WHILE THEY TRY TO MAKE
ARRANGEMENTS TO ACCOMMODATE THE
DEPLOYED FAMILY MEMBERS SLEEVE.
AND NOT ALL FAMILY MEMBERS OF
THESE DEPLOYED SERVICEMEMBERS
WILL USE THIS PROGRAM NOR BE
ELIGIBLE FOR JOB PROTECTED OF
LEAVE UNDER FMLA A BECAUSE HE
WANTED SERVED A LENGTHY PERIOD
OF TIME BECAUSE THEY WORK FOR AN
EMPLOYER FEWER THAN FIFTY
EMPLOYEES. WE KNOW THAT.
FROM RESEARCH THAT A LACK OF
JOB PROTECTION IS ALSO A
SIGNIFICANT BARRIER FOR USING
THE PROGRAM. AND ARE IN ADDITION
IN CALCULATING COSTS ET DE
ASSUMES THE AVERAGE AMOUNT TAKEN
AS I MENTIONED WOULD BE ABOUT
FIVE POINT FOUR WEEKS I I THINK
THAT'S.
UNREALISTIC WHILE RECOGNIZING
THE FACT THAT WE ALSO.
DON'T KNOW EXACT FIGURES AND WE
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH STAFF
AND I TRY TO GET THE AT LEAST AS
MOVE. PAST ESTIMATE IS WE CAN.
WE KNOW THIS TYPE OF LEAVE IT
IS BEING USED NATIONALLY IN A
MUCH SHORTER TIME FRAME SO
THAT'S HELPFUL TO US.
A A AS I MENTIONED A DAY HERE
TWO DAYS THERE FOR.
OF.
I'M WEEK AT THE MOST AS I
UNDERSTAND IT BUT ALLOWING
FAMILY MEMBERS OF THOSE DEPLOYED
TO USES WORKED WAGE REPLACEMENT
PROGRAM FOR THE FEW PRECIOUS
DAYS OR WEEK.
TO GET THEIR AFFAIRS IN ORDER
BEFORE THEY SHIP OFF OVERSEAS IS
TO USETHAT HAS BEEN ALLOWED
UNDER FEDERAL LAW FOR A NUMBER
OF YEARS AND INTERESTINGLY
ENOUGH NEW YORK AND WASHINGTON
STATE. HAVE RECENTLY EXPANDED
THEIR PAID FAMILY LEAVE PROGRAMS
TO INCLUDE THIS KIND OF MILITARY
FAMILY LEAVE AND CERTAINLY IS
THE STATE THAT INVENTS THE
FUTURE I DO BELIEVE CALIFORNIA.
WOULD BE.
WELL SERVE TO DO THE SAME.
NOW I KNOW THE BILL IS GOING TO
SUSPENSE AS I MENTIONED WILL TRY
TO KEEP WORKING TO TRY TO GET A
MORE REALISTIC NUMBER. BUT I
HAVE WITH ME TODAY VETERANS
ADVOCATE SETS READ AND ROB WHITE
A VETERAN HIMSELF WITH A A RP TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU WHEN THIS IS A PART.
MY NAME IS SET THREE WITH THREE
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
REPRESENTING AMERICAN JEFF FORM
OF CALIFORNIA. AMERICAN LEGION
DEPARTMENT CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATIONS COUNTY VETERANS
SERVICE OFFICERS. CALIFORNIA
STATE COMMANDERS VETERANS
COUNCIL MILITARY OFFICERS
ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA.
CALIFORNIA COUNCIL CHAPTERS AND
THE VIETNAM VETERANS OF AMERICA
CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL.
THIS BILL AT THIS BILL WOULD
DRAW FROM EXISTING FUND. FUNDED
BY WORKER CONTRIBUTION NOT.
NOT AFFECTING THE GENERAL FUND.
AS A YOUNG COMBAT VETERAN KNOW
THE STRESS INVOLVED.
AND KNOW HOW BENEFICIAL
SOMETHING LIKE THIS CAN BE FOR
DEPLOYING SERVICEMEMBER OR EVEN
RETURNING HOME SERVICE MEMBER.
THANK YOU.
DIGITAL ONE ISN'T SUPPORT.
THIS WILL ROB WHY PUT A OUR P..
R. M. A COLD WAR VETERAN SO I
WAS SERVING TO IN THE EIGHTIES
AND HELP IN THE COLD WAR. ó
BUT TODAY I'M HERE TO SAY THANK
GOOD MORNING AND THANK YOU TO
SENATOR LAURA FOR HER FORESIGHT
I WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE.
FOR HEARING THIS BILL TODAY IN A
TIMELY FASHION.
A A RP STANDS IN STRONG SUPPORT
WE'VE ANALYZED THIS BILL AND WE
THINK IT IS VERY VERY GOOD FOR.
FOR VETERANS AND.
AND WE SUPPORT IT ONE HUNDRED
PERCENT. ARE AS PREVIOUSLY
STATED IT WILL NOT COME FROM THE
GENERAL FUND THE THINGS WILL
FALL OUT THERE ARE OUT THERE ARE
READY FUNDS AVAILABLE. IN THE.
CALIFORNIA WORKERS ARE WE
PROVIDING THOSE FUNDS IN THE
WORKING.
.
BEEN WORKING SO WHAT HAPPENED
COME FROM TAX TAX DOLLARS
NECESSARILY OKAYED OF FEDERAL
LAW. ALREADY HAS THE QUALIFYING
EXTENSION C. LEAF WHAT TYPE HAVE
TO TAKE IT ARE THE BEST COME
FROM TIME TO TIME.
BUT IT DOES NOT ALLOW YOU TO
GET ANY PAY WHILE THIS IS GOING
NO ONE IT JUST.
SECURITY SHOULD JOB AND MAKES IT
SO THAT YOU CAN COME BACK TO
YOUR JOB WITH YOUR FAMILY
SUPPERS FINANCIALLY DURING THE
MEET AND DURING THE INTERIM.
YOU YOU'RE MAKING ARRANGEMENTS
FOR CHILDCARE YOU MAKING
ARRANGEMENTS YOU KNOW TO TAKE
CARE OF AN ELDERLY PARENT.
YOU'RE MAKING YOU KNOW LIFE GOES
ON WHILE YOU'RE IN THE MILITARY
AND YOU HAVE RESPECT
RESPONSIBILITIES TO YOUR
FAMILIES.
AND SO THAT'S WHY THE MILITARY
CREATED THE EXTENT AND SEE.
BUT CALIFORNIA WE USUALLY ARE
THE LEADERS.
WHEN IT COMES TO SUPPORTING
CITIZENS AND KNEES AREAS MEANS
GRAY AREAS BUT ACTUALLY I THINK
NEW YORK AND WASHINGTON.
I'VE KIND OF TAKEN THE LEAD ON
THIS.
AND WE DON'T WANT TO BE THE
CABOOSE ON NEXT ONE AHA I HOPE
THAT YOU WILL SUPPORT THIS BILL.
ONE HUNDRED PERCENT THANK YOU
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
WELL THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE NO FILE COMMENTS
OR QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
SEEING NONE SENATE JACKSON WHICH
ARE TOO CLOSE ADJUST TO ASK FOR
YOUR CONSIDERATION AT THE
APPROPRIATE TIME THANK YOU
WITHOUT OBJECTION WE WILL THIS
ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO BRING UP.
.
THE ONE ITEM THAT WE HAVE THAT
DO PASSED FROM SENATOR BATES.
I KNOW SOME OF YOU HAVE TO LEAVE
TO CHECK YOUR OWN COMMITTEES.
AND WHAT DO THIS REALLY QUICKLY.
MEMBERS THIS IS. S. B. E. ELEVEN
OWN NINE.
WHICH IS OUR ONLY TO PASS BILL
FOR TODAY.
AND IT GOES TOWARD VICE
CHAIRWOMAN.
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY SERVICE.
WELL THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS SENATE BILL ELEVEN NO
NINE SEEKS TO ADDRESS THE OPIOID.
EPIDEMIC BY PROVIDING PRINT
PREVENTATIVE EDUCATION FOR ALL
INVOLVED. AS NOTED IN THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS THE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH IMPLEMENTING THE
BILL ARE MINOR AN OBSERVABLE.
OBSERVABLE US SPECIFICALLY THE
BILL REQUIRES THE EXISTING
CONTINUING EDUCATION
REQUIREMENTS FOR PRESCRIBERS TO
INCLUDE THE RISK OF ADDICTION
OVERDOSE ASSOCIATED WITH THE USE
OF SCHEDULED TO. CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCE SINCE IT REQUIRES A
WARNING LABEL ON ALL SCHEDULED
TO CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES
PRESCRIPTION BOTTLES. ON THE
ASSOCIATED ADDICTION AN OVERDOSE
RISKS HE REQUIRES A DISCUSSION
WITH THE PRESCRIBER FOR ANY
MINOR RECEIVING AN INITIAL. ARE
OPIOID PRESCRIPTION AND LASTLY
WHY S. B. ELEVEN OO NINE
REQUIRES AN INFORMATION SHEET ON
THE RISKS OF OPIOID TO BE SIGNED
BY A MINOR ATHLETE. AND THEIR
PARENTS OR GUARDIAN BEFORE
PARTICIPATION BY IN AN ORGANIZED
ON AN ORGANIZED SPORTS TEAM
INSURING PATIENTS MINERS AND
THEIR PARENTS HAVE THE NECESSARY
INFORMATION. BEFORE TAKING THESE
MEDICATIONS WILL HELP PREVENT.
FUTURE ADDICTIONS AND OVERDOSES
WITH DRUGS I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
THE STAKEHOLDERS WE WORKED OUT.
OVER THE MONTHS.
AREN'T ON THE ISSUES THAT WERE
OF CONCERN TO THEM THEY WILL
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
REMAINING OPPOSITION TO RESOLVE.
THEIR CONCERNS SOMNATH THE BILL
PROCEEDS TO THE ASSEMBLY. I AM
PROUD TO JOIN SAN DIEGO DISTRICT
ATTORNEY SUMMER STEPHAN WHO
SPONSORING S. B. ELEVEN OO NINE
IN REPRESENTING HER TODAY IS
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY LARA.
COUNTY AND SHE'S HERE TO ANSWER
IT ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS GREAT THANK YOU
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
MAURITANIA ON BEHALF OF.
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO DISTRICT
ATTORNEY SUMMER STEFAN SPONSOR
OF THE BILL LIKE TO THINK
SENATOR BATES FOR BRINGING THIS
I COMMONSENSE FISCALLY
RESPONSIBLE LEGISLATION. AS WELL
AS THE STAKEHOLDERS HAVE WORKED
WITH US AYE I'M HERE FOR ANY
QUESTIONS IF YOU HAVE THEM THANK
YOU DISHING AWARENESS IS IN
SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS MAKEIT ALRIGHT ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION NOT ONLY ARE MOVING
OPPOSITION BUT COMING ON IN FULL
SUPPORT OF SENATE BILL OF A NOW
NINE.
BUT WE REALLY APPRECIATE THE
TIME THE SPONSOR AND THE OTHERS
DILIGENT WORK ON THIS. AND SEE
ME NOW BELIEVES THAT S. B.
ELEVEN ARE NINE AS AMENDED BOTH
ACTIVELY INSTITUTE MEASURES THAT
PROVIDE OUTREACH AND EDUCATION
ON OPIOID USE DISORDERS AND THE
POTENTIAL FOR ADDICTION ANYA.
WE UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE
MANY MEASURES THIS YEAR DEALING
WITH OPIOID ADDICTION DIVERSION
A MISUSE.
BUT WE BELIEVE THAT THIS IS A
MEASURE THAT ENCOMPASSES
MULTIPLE PROACTIVE STEPS WHICH
WILL BE AFFECTED BOTH IN THE
LONG AND SHORT TERM. AND WOULD
URGE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES AND SUPPORT
A JOHN LEVEL ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA NARCOTICS OFFICERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT. WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE
NO FIRE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
MEMBERS IS THIS TO THE STUFF
ENJOY A TO PASS RECOMMENDATION
TO THE SENATE FLOOR.
THERE IS A MOTION BY SENATOR
BALLOT CENTER BASE WHICH LIKE TO
CLOSE.
THANK YOU OFFER HEARING AND ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU FOR
WORK ON THIS ON THIS IMPORTANT
ISSUE CENTER BATES SENATOR
PLEASE KALRA. LARA AYE AYE LARA
AYE BATES.
BATES AYE BELL BELL AYE BRADFORD
HILL.
NIELSEN WIENER.
WIENER AYE.
FOUR ZERO WILL KEEP THE ROPE
INTO A LARGE ABSENT MEMBERS TO
ADD ON CENTER SKINNER.
SIR SKINNER MY UNDERSTANDING IS
YOUR PARTICULAR PRESENTING ON
TWO ITEMS BEGINNING.
WHAT HITS SP TEN FOURTEEN
INDUSTRY FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN?
ALL WAVE ON TEN FOURTEEN ALL
JUST PRESENT ON FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN.
OKAY FRASER'S.
SP FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN. IS.
.
BASICALLY ADDRESSES THE FACT
THAT CALIFORNIA'S MURDER STATUTE
IS BROAD.
AND WHAT'S HAPPENED OVER TIME IS
THE PROSECUTORS HAVE
INCREASINGLY WIDENS
THEIR APPLICATION OF THAT MURDER
STATUTE.
BRINGING A MURDER CHARGE EVEN
WHEN A DEATH WAS ACCIDENTAL.
UNINTENTIONAL OR OCCURRED
WITHOUT EVEN INDIVIDUAL WHO IS
BEING CHARGED KNOWLEDGE.
THE RESULT IS THAT WE HAVE MANY
PEOPLE WHO DID NOT COMMIT MURDER.
WHO ARE THEN CHARGED WITH FIRST
DEGREE MURDER? AND THEN SERVED
DISPROPORTIONATELY LONG
SENTENCES
FOR EXAMPLE SEVENTY TWO PERCENT
OF THE WOMEN. NOW HELD IN
CALIFORNIA STATE FACILITIES
WHO WERE INCARCERATED UNDER THIS
DOCTRINE. AND HAVE RECEIVED LIFE
SENTENCES DID NOT COMMIT MURDER.
SO WHAT S. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN DOES.
IS NERO'S CALIFORNIA MURDER
STATUTES OF THAT THE SENTENCE
MORE ACCURATELY REFLECTS
IT'S NOT JUST THAT THE SENTENCE
BUT RATHER. THE ABILITY TO
CHARGE.
AND THAT'S THE SENTENCE THAT
FOLLOWS THE CHARGE MORE
ACCURATELY REFLECTS THE PERSON'S
CULPABILITY FOR THE CRIME. SO
THAT THOSE WHO INTENTIONALLY
PLANNED OR ACTUALLY COMMITTED
THE MURDER. OR HAD MORE DIRECT
INVOLVEMENT WOULD BE THE ONLY
ONES WHO WOULD BE ABLE TO BE
CHARGED
WITH FELONY MURDER.
THIS ALLIANCE CALIFORNIA WITH A
NUMBER OF OTHER STATES WHO HAVE
ACTED SIMILARLY STATES SUCH AS
ARKANSAS KENTUCKY OHIO.
MASSACHUSETTS HAWAII IN MICHIGAN
HAVE ALL NARROWED THEIR MURDER
STATUTE IN THE SIMILAR WAY THAT
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN PROPOSES.
ADDITIONALLY FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN ESTABLISHES A PROCESS FOR
RE SENTENCING FOR THOSE WHO WERE.
CHARGED WITH FELONY MURDER IN
THE MOST EGREGIOUS TYPE OF WAYS
AND IN THE LONG RUN IN THIS IS
WHERE IT'S GERMANE TO A PROBES.
THAT WILL SAVE MILLIONS OF
DOLLARS WILL IN THE SHORT RUN IF
WE FIX THE MURDER STATUTE THEN
WE WILL NOT BE.
IN THE FUTURE.
PUTTING PEOPLE IN FOR LIFE
WITHOUT PAROLE WHO DID NOT HAVE
THIS MORE DIRECT ROLE IN THE
CRIME. BUT IN THAT FOR. THOSE
WHO MAY BE MAY POSSIBLY BE RE
SENTENCED
IF YOU ARE INCARCERATED AT EACH
AGE TWENTY.
UNDER THIS OLD POLICY. AND YOU
LIVE TO SEVENTY.
IN OUR STATE FACILITY WHICH IS
CURRENTLY AT ABOUT EIGHTY
THOUSAND A YEAR.
THE COST FOR THAT ONE INDIVIDUAL
IS FOUR MILLION.
SO THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE THE
COSTS
FOR MEDICAL CARE FOR THE AGING
POPULATION. AND OUR CORRECTIONS
BUDGET.
MEDICAL CARE COSTS ALONE WENT UP
BY TWO BILLION IN THE LAST FOUR
YEARS.
SO WITH THAT I WOULD LIKE MY
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT I HAVE.
JACK WILSON FROM WHO'S THE SF
PUBLIC DEFENDER AND KATE
CHATFIELD FROM RESTORE JUSTICE
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
MY NAME IS JACKIE WILSON AND.
PUBLIC DEFENDER WITH THE SAN
FRANCISCO PUBLIC DEFENDER'S
OFFICE.
THIS IS MY FATHER MAC WILL SEND
AN IS A RETIRED AIRFORCE
SERGEANT.
HE SERVED IN VIETNAM. TWO
DIFFERENT TWO TOURS OF DUTY WITH
DISTINCTION.
HE'S MY HERO AND MY INSPIRATION.
WE ARE HERE BECAUSE MY YOUNGER
BROTHER IS CHARGED WITH FELONY
MURDER.
THIS IS TRUE EVEN THOUGH MY
BROTHER DID NOT KILL ANYONE.
NOR ATTEMPT TO KILL ANYONE.
NOR INTEND TO KILL ANYONE.
SHE WASN'T EVEN PRESENT AT THE
SCENE.
BUT UNDER THE FELONY MURDER RULE.
NONE OF THAT MATTERS.
S. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN DOES
NOT ABOLISH THE FELONY MURDER
RULE.
IT MERELY LIMITS ITS APPLICATION.
MY FAMILY IS NOT THE ONLY FAMILY
WHICH HAS BEEN DEVASTATED BY
THIS ANTIQUATED PRACTICE.
THE FELONY MURDER RULE HAS TAKEN
THE HEAVIEST TOLL ON YOUNG
PEOPLE.
WOMEN.
AND PEOPLE OF COLOR.
THIS TOLD THE ONLY BE MEASURED
AND HEARTBREAK.
MY EIGHTY THREE YEAR OLD FATHERS.
LAST WISH.
IS TO BUILD A HUG HIS SON AGAIN.
MY NIECE.
HER WISH IS TO BE REUNITED WITH
HER FATHER. WHO IS NOT A KILLER?
IT COST OVER EIGHTY THOUSAND
DOLLARS ANNUALLY TO INCARCERATED
PERSON.
THIS BILL WILL SAVE TAXPAYERS
MILLIONS.
FURTHER EFFECTIVE LAWYERS LEAVE
NO STONE UNTURNED WHEN
LITIGATING. ACCOMPLICE LIABILITY
FELONY MURDER CASES.
THAT MEANS THE CASES AREN'T THE
TRIAL COURT FOR YEARS PRIOR TO
TRIAL.
THIS CAN COST THE COURTS IN
COUNTIES HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS
OF DOLLARS PER DEFENDANT.
THE PEOPLE WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
ARE NOT MURDERERS DESPITE THEIR
LABEL.
THEY ARE SONS
DARTERS.
BROTHERS
SISTERS.
FRIENDS AND COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
OVER THIRTY FIVE YEARS AGO THE
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT CALLED
THE FELONY MURDER RULE BARBARIC.
WHEN ASKED THIS LEGISLATURE TO
FIX IT.
YOU ALL HAVE THE POWER TO MAKE
THAT CHANGE.
WE URGE YOU TO SUPPORT S. B.
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
YES THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS KATE CHATFIELD I'M
THE POLICY DIRECTOR FOR RESTORED
JUSTICE.
.
THREE FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN AS A
RULE OF THE INDIVIDUAL
RESPONSIBILITY.
IT IS A BEDROCK PRINCIPLE OF THE
LAW AND OF FAIRNESS THAT A
PERSON SHOULD BE PUNISHED FOR
HIS OR HER ACTIONS ACCORDING TO
HIS OR HER OWN LEVEL OF
INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY. AND
NOT FOR THE ACTIONS OF ANOTHER.
LIFE SENTENCES FOR NON
PERPETRATORS OF THE FATAL ACT
NOT ONLY FAILS TO PLACE BLAME
SQUARELY WHERE IT BELONGS BUT IT
APPROACH IS CRUEL AND UNUSUAL
PUNISHMENT.
AND WHEN THERE IS AN UNJUST LAW
IT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED.
WE BELIEVE THAT SENATE BILL
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN WILL NOT
ONLY ADDRESS AN UNJUST LAW.
BUT WE AGREE WITH THE ANALYSIS
THAT IT WILL RESULT IN MAJOR
LONG TERM COST SAVINGS TO THE
CITY STATE.
TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY ARE NEAR
TERM EXPENSES ASSOCIATED.
WITH SOME OF THE NUMBER OF
PEOPLE WHO WOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR
RE SENTENCING WE ARE.
OF COURSE THE AUTHOR.
IN OUR ORGANIZATION AND OTHER
CO SPONSORS ARE WILLING TO WORK
TOGETHER AND WITH ANY OPPOSITION.
TO SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE THE
FISCAL IMPACT
ON ON THE COURTS OF RE
SENTENCING THANK YOU.
ADDITIONAL ONE THIS IS A PART.
GOOD MORNING ANDREA PERRY WITH
ZAPPA CALIFORNIANS FOR SAFETY
AND JUSTICE WE ARE CO SONSORS
OF THIS LEGISLATION REALLY HOPE
FOR AN AYE BUT. THANK YOU.
I IS ABOUT GUTHRIDGE ON BEHALF
OF ADVOCATES FOR JUSTICE SUPPORT
SB FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN.
ENOUGH YOUR HERNANDEZ ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEYS FOR
CRIMINAL JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
MY NAME'S THE MY NAME IS DENNIS
FLAN HAND THEM A FOUNDER AND
LEAD ADVOCATE FOR CURES FOR
YOUTH A STATEWIDE ORGANIZATION.
TO REFORM EXTREME SENTENCES FOR
YOUTH.
AND ALSO.
THE PARENT.
OF A YOUNG DAUGHTER THESE HER TO
MY DAUGHTER SO ONCE FIFTEEN
WANTS TO IN THIS PICTURE. OF MY
OLDEST DAUGHTER HAS.
SERVE TWENTY TWO YEARS OF A
THIRTY THREE YEAR TO LIFE
SENTENCE UNDER THE FELONY MURDER
RULE. NOT PRESENT.
OR PLAN TO ANYTHING IN TERMS OF
A MURDER AND ONE OF THE PEOPLE
WAS ACTUALLY THERE.
WAS OUT IN FIVE YEARS.
JERRY MEMBERS COMING BACK WITH
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION
OF CALIFORNIA HOUSEHOLDS.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
FINANCE.
NO FILE. NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE CENTER
ABOUT.
OF. JUST A COUPLE QUESTIONS WHEN
WE LOOKED AT THE.
STAFF ROME.
TESTAMENT.
AND IT TALKS ABOUT TWO OF THE
COST.
AND THEN THE COST SAVINGS WHEN I
LOOK TO THE THE COSTS AND THE
COST CITIZENS LOOKING AT.
.
THERE WAS SO.
FOURTEEN THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED
AND SEVENTY THREE INMATES.
SERVING A TERM FOR. FIRST DEGREE
MURDER.
AND.
SEVENTEEN SO SEVEN THOUSAND TWO
OR NINE NINE SERVING.
FOR SECOND DEGREE MURDER.
THAT SAYS IF YOU TAKE TEN
PERCENT.
WOULD BE FILING PETITIONS FOR.
RESEND SAYING AND SO FORTH.
.
IT COST SOME MONEY BECAUSE SEVEN
BILLION DOLLARS.
BUT IF WE TOOK.
TWO THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY
SEVEN PEOPLE.
TIMES NINETY THOUSAND DOLLARS A
YEAR.
THAT'S.
SO IT'S TWO HUNDRED MILLION
DOLLARS.
SO SO MIGHT MY I THINK IN MY
RIGHT.
YES OKAY SO.
.
AND THEN YOU MY LOOK AT THE
FUTURE LOOKING DOWN THE ROAD.
.
THAT'S JUST ONE YEARS THAT'S
UNDER NINETY FIVE BUT TO OUR
MILLION A YEAR.
SOPHIE LOOK AT OVER FIVE YEARS
THAT'S A BILLION DOLLARS.
SO.
IF WE CAN LOOK AT IT MORE FROM.
.
STANDPOINT OF.
WHAT HAPPENS?
AFTER THIS THEN THE OTHER
QUESTION I HAVE IS THERE SO YOU
KNOW THE.
I KNOW THIS IS TRUE BECAUSE I
VISITED.
MANY PRESENT BRIDGES THE WOMEN'S
PRISON.
IN CHOWCHILLA.
THERE'S SOME PEOPLE THAT ARE
LIKE GO.
TRIED IS IT BOLTS.
AND THEY WERE CONVICTED UNDER
THIS STATUTE.
AND THEY WEREN'T INVOLVED
DIRECTLY IN THE MURDER.
BUT YOUR TRIES AS DOES HIS
YOUNGEST FIFTEEN YEARS OLD.
HAVE YOU RESEARCH THAT ISSUE OF
THE UNDER THE PEOPLE THAT AR.
AS ANYBODY RESEARCH I JUST PUT
THOUGH IT.
ABOUT HOW MANY PEOPLE WERE
CONVICTED UNDER UNDER.
UNDER THE AGE OF ADULT BUT
CONVICTED UNDER THE STATUTE.
HAS THAT BEEN RESEARCHED ALL.
WHO'S AROUND IT. BERMAN THE
WOMEN'S PRISON.
BUT I'M AS YOU KNOW CENTER ABOUT
WE'RE ACTUALLY WORKING ON
LEGISLATION.
TO ADDRESS THE MINOR ISSUE BUT
IF YOU HAVE YOU HAVE ANY OR COST
THIS BILL RIGHT. RIGHT.
AND I DIDN'T SORRY I AM I DON'T.
WHERE'S ON THOSE WHO WERE.
SENTENCED UNDER THIS.
THE PENAL CODE SECTION ONE
EIGHTY NINE AS MINORS BUT I CAN
TELL YOU THAT THAT NUMBER IS
SICKENING.
COM AND THAT'S WHO WERE.
IS YOUNG AS OF FOURTEEN PERHAPS
A LITTLE MORE THERE WAS JUST
FIFTEEN WHEN I WAS.
NO I AYE YOU SAY FOURTEEN OR
SOMEONE BUT AND HOPEFULLY THAT
WILL BE ADDRESSED.
YEAH OKAY OKAY THANK YOU.
THANK IF THAT'S ONLY QUESTION
I'LL USE ONE OF THOSE THINGS ON
THE ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS WELCOME
SIR IT'S GREAT TO HAVE YOU HERE
THANK YOU FOR SERVICE.
SENATOR SKINNER WOULD LIKE TO
CLOSE.
.
I THINK THE WITNESSES WERE QUITE
ARTICULATE ABOUT THE NEED FOR
THIS.
AND I THINK THAT.
WHILE IT'S.
DISS THE PROBES COMEDIAN IT'S
APPROPRIATE TO THINK ABOUT IT IN
TERMS OF WHAT THE FINANCIAL
IMPLICATIONS ARE BOTH.
FOR SAVINGS FOR THE FUTURE AND
THEN ALSO OF COURSE THE POSSIBLE
COST OF RECENT SING I THINK THAT
THE. REAL WAY WE NEED TO LOOK AT
THIS. IS THAT.
WE ARE OUR CHARGING FOR CRIMES
IN OUR SENTENCING FOR CRIMES
SHOULD BE A.
PROPORTIONATE TO THE PERSON'S
CULPABILITY TO THE CRIME. AND I
THINK AS WAS MENTIONED THE
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT'S OWN
INDICATION. THAT OUR LACK OF
APPROPRIATE LEE. LIMITING OUR
MURDER STATUTE HAS HAD A VERY
THE THE RESULT HAS BEEN A VERY
BARBARIC PRACTICE.
SO AS WAS SAID WE ARE NOT
ELIMINATING FELONY MURDER WE
THERE WILL STILL BE CLEARLY THE
ABILITY TO CHARGE MURDER FOR
THOSE WHO INTENTIONALLY
COMMITTED A HOMICIDE FOR THOSE
WHO PLAN TO HOMICIDE. FOR THOSE
WHO PAID FOR A HOMICIDE FOR ANY
NUMBER OF MORE DIRECT AND
INTENTIONAL RULES.
BEEN THERE STILL REMAINS ON OUR
BOOKS.
ACCOMPLICE
IN.
TO MURDER ACCESSORY TO MURDER
ALL OF THOSE OTHER THINGS STAND
ON THE BOOKS IT IS PURELY THAT
THIS BILL S. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN WOULD MAKE SURE. THAT OUR.
FELONY MURDER CHARGE WAS BROUGHT
FOR THOSE PEOPLE CULPABLE FOR
THAT CHARGE
AND I'LL ASK YOUR OUTSIDE YOUR
CONSIDERATION BECUZ CENTER
SKINNER FOR WORK ON THIS ISSUE
CLEARLY. HOW?
THIS
AGAIN REMINDS OF THE WHOLE TOUGH
ON CRIME ERA WHERE WE SHOULD
HAVE ALWAYS BEEN SMARTER CRIME.
I THINK YOU FOR YOUR WORK ON
THIS ISSUE WITHOUT.
OBJECTION MOVE THIS ITEM TO THE
SOUTH ASSISTANCE COUNTY.
AND.
I THINK WE ARE.
AND I'M NOT SURE IF WE'RE TAKING.
AMENDMENTS IN COMMITTEE OR NOT
BUT IF THERE ARE CO AUTHORS WHO
WANT TO BE ADDED ON WERE HAPPY
TO DO SO ABSOLUTELY YOU DRIVE ME
PLEASE YES THINKING. WE WILL
DISCUSS THAT DURING THE SUSPENSE
FILE PROCESS I THINK YOU.
SENATOR WILK.
I SEE YOU.
THERE IS.
SENATE WILK YOU HAVE TWO ITEMS I
DO. LET'S BEGIN OTHER BOTH
SUSPENSE ITEMS LET'S BEGIN WITH
S. B. TEN TWENTY FOUR PLEASE.
GOOD I THINK YOU MISTER CHAIR
VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION I HAVE BEFORE YOU
SENATE BILL TEN TWENTY FOUR.
WHICH BRINGS CHANGES TO
CALIFORNIA'S HANDLING OF ANIMAL
ABSE OFFENDERS OVER THE PAST
SEVERAL DECADES STUDY AFTER
STUDY HAS SUPPORTED THE FACT
THAT THERE EXISTS. AN UNDENIABLE
LINK BETWEEN ANIMAL BEAT OF
ABUSE AND VIOLENCE TOWARD PEOPLE.
WE KNOW THAT SEVENTY ONE PERCENT
OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OF VIOLENT
OFFENDERS HAVE ABUSED ANIMALS AT
SOME POINT. WE'VE SEEN A SEVENTY
PERCENT A MOST VIOLENT PRISON
AIM INMATES ALSO OF ABUSED
ANIMALS IN THEIR HISTORY AND SAT
SADLY WE KNOW THAT NINETY
PERCENT. OF MASS SHOOTING
SUSPECTS HAVE ALSO PERPETRATED
ABUSE ON ANIMALS.
WE KNOW ALL THIS* CURRENTLY
WE'RE NOT UTILIZING THIS
KNOWLEDGE FOR POSITIVE CHANGE SP
TEN TWENTY FOUR WILL ALLOW US TO
REDIRECT THE MOST SERIOUS ANIMAL
ABUSE OFFENDERS. INTO MENTAL
HEALTH EVALUATIONS AND
TREATMENTS SO THAT WE CAN
IDENTIFY AND ADDRESS THE
UNDERLYING CAUSE OF THEIR
VIOLENT BEHAVIOR AND BEGIN TO
WEAKEN THE LINK BETWEEN ANIMAL
CRUELTY. AND TRAGIC ACCIDENTS
COMMITTED LATER BY MANY OF THE
SAME OFFENDERS.
ADDITIONALLY THIS BILL WILL
IMPLEMENT A MANDATORY ANIMAL
OWNER EDUCATION COURSE TO ENSURE
ANIMAL ABUSE OFFENDERS ROOTED IN
IGNORANCE.
ARE NOT REPEATED.
WE'VE READ THE DATA.
WE'VE SEEN ANECDOTAL PROOF IN
OUR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SHELTERS
OUR SCHOOLS AND ON THE NIGHTLY
NEWS WE KNOW THE LINK BETWEEN
ANIMAL VIOLENCE IN FUTURE
VIOLENCE TOWARDS PEOPLE A STRONG.
BUT IT IS AN UNBREAKABLE.
S. B. TEN TWENTY FOUR IS A BIG
STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION TO
SURE CALIFORNIA'S CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SYSTEM IS BEING
ADEQUATELY UTILIZED AS A
MECHANISM OF INTERVENTION. AND
REHABILITATION FOR ANIMAL ABUSE
OFFENDERS.
CURRENTLY ASSIGNMENT TO MENTAL
HEALTH COUNSELLING IS LIMITED TO
ONE ANIMAL ABUSE CODE SECTION
AND THERE'S NO PROVISION IN
STATUTE ALLOWING FOR ANY
EDUCATION FOR THOSE OFFENDERS.
THISBILL EXPAND THE UTILIZATION
OF MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT FOR
THESE OFFENDERS TO EIGHT ANIMAL
ABUSE CODE SECTIONS IT WILL
IMPLEMENT A FIRST OF ITS KIND
EDUCATION PROGRAM FOR ANIMAL
ABUSERS.
WE BELIEVE THE COSTS ASSOCIATED
WITH THIS BILL BE MINOR.
PAN OBSERVABLE AS OUR DATA
INDICATES IS WOULD NOT AFFECT A
LARGE NUMBER OF OFFENDERS.
IN SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY FOR
EXAMPLE TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN
SARGIS FORTY SIX TOTAL ANIMAL
ABUSE CRIMES.
WITH ONLY THIRTY THREE FALLING
UNDER THOSE SECTIONS WERE MENTAL
HEALTH EVALUATIONS WOULD BE
NEEDED UP THOSE THIRTY THREE
TWENTY NINE ARE ALREADY SUBJECT
TO MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT UNDER
CURRENT LAW.
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE COURT
ITSELF ARE NON REIMBURSABLE
UNDER GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION
SEVENTEEN FIVE FIVE SIX SO THOSE
SHOULD NOT BE FACTORED IN TO THE
COST THIS BILL. WITH THAT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
WHEN APPROPRIATE THANK YOU
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT PLEASE
COME FORWARD.
SOCIAL COMPASSION LEGISLATION
AND SUPPORT.
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES APART WHEN
THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
GRAND JURY MEMBERS KEVIN BACON
WITH AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES
UNION OF CALIFORNIA DESPITE THE
AUTHOR'S OBVIOUS GOOD INTENTIONS.
WE SEE THAT THERE IS A PROBLEM
WITH THE EXCESSIVE FINES AND
PENALTIES ARE ALREADY PREVALENT
IN THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
THE STATE'S.
BILL WOULD FORTUNATELY DOUBLE
THOSE OF THE ENTITIES YOU KNOW
TWO THOUSAND DOLLAR FINE MAY
SOUND REASONABLE BECOME CAN
BECOME AN EIGHT THOUSAND DOLLAR
LIABILITY BY THE TIME ALL THE
MANDATORY FEES AND ACCEPT ARE
ADDED.
WE ALSO ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
SORT OF THE MANDATORY
REQUIREMENT OF MENTAL HEALTH OF
PROVISION THAT'S DISCRETIONARY
RIGHT NOW WITH THE COURTS REVIEW
THE JUDGES ARE THE BEST A PERSON.
THANK YOU.
THIS AWARENESS IS AN OPPOSITION
FINANCE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
FINANCE AND WHAT WHICH ARE TO
CLOSE CARE AT THANK YOU AND
WE'LL BE SAYS OFTEN THE FIRST
ACT OF VIOLENCE COMMITTED BY A
TROUBLED INDIVIDUAL. IS TYPICAL
THAT THE FAMILY FAT A PET BE THE
TARGET OF VIOLENCE BEFORE THE
WIFE THE KIDS IN THE COMMUNITY.
FOR THAT REASON IS IMPAIRED AT
THAT WE DO SOMETHING TO
INTERVENE AT THE VERY EARLY
STAGES BEFORE AT THE VICTIM
COUNT RISES.
AGAIN CALIFORNIA'S BEEN A
LEADER TIME AND TIME AGAIN IN
THE REALM A PUBLIC POLICY WE
HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ONCE
AGAIN.
LEAD HOT AGAIN THE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THISBILL IF ANY
WOULD BE MINOR AND OBSERVABLE TO
THE STATE AND THE MAJORITY OF
COSTS WILL BE BORNE BY THE
INDIVIDUAL FENDER.
BEGIN WITH THAT I ASK FOR YOUR
AYE AYE VOTE WHEN YOU CONSIDER
THAT LATER THANK YOU WITHOUT
OBJECTION WE MOVE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FILE.
ITS WILL ON TIER S. B. FORTINO
NINE.
WELL YOU MADE A GOOD.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS SAID THE FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION IS SENATE BILL
FOURTEEN NO NINE. THIS MEASURE
WILL UPDATE CURRENT LAW TO
STREAMLINE THE PRODUCTION IN
CULTIVATION OF INDUSTRIAL HEMP
IN CALIFORNIA. AND ALLOW OUR
FARMERS TO GROW AND PRODUCE NON
INTOXICATING HIPS HIP SEED OIL
FIBER AND EXTRACT FOR COMMERCIAL
AND INDUSTRIAL USES. INDUSTRIAL
HEMP IS AN AGRICULTURAL CROP IS
GROWN AND PROCESSED IN OVER
THIRTY NATIONS IN NINETEEN
STATES ACROSS THE U. S..
CALIFORNIA'S NO STRANGER TO
DROUGHT IN THE WATER
CONSERVATION VALUE IN GROWING
INDUSTRIAL HAPPY IS REMARKABLE.
INDUSTRIAL HEMP REQUIRES LESS
WATER IT PESTICIDES THAN MANY
OTHER CROPS AN EXAMPLE FROM MY
OWN DISTRICT THE LARGEST.
CROP PRODUCED HIS ALFALFA WHICH
I CONSUME SEVEN ACRE FEET OF
WATER PER ACRE INDUSTRIAL HEMP
USES LESS THAN TWO.
AT ONE POINT CALIFORNIA'S WELL
POSITIONED TO GROW INDUSTRIAL
HEMP IN THIS BODY ENACTED S. B.
FIVE SIX SIX BY SENATOR LENO
BACK IN TWENTY THIRTEEN. WHICH
ESTABLISH AN INDUSTRIAL HEMP UP
FARMING PILOT PROGRAM UPON
FEDERAL AUTHORIZATION.
IN TWENTY FOURTEEN THE FEDERAL
FARM ACT WAS PASSED AUTHORIZING
INDUSTRIAL HIP RESEARCH IN
STATES WHICH HAVE PASSED
LEGISLATION AUTHORING STATE
DEPARTMENTS OF AGRICULTURE. TO
ESTABLISH PILOT PROGRAMS AT
INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION
TO CONDUCT
BECAUSE.
CULTIVATION FOR RESEARCH
BUT FOR SHIRLEY PROP SIXTY FOUR
CONTAIN FROM IT PROVISIONS THAT
ESSENTIALLY ON DID MUCH OF THE
PROGRESS MADE UNDER S. B.. FIVE
SIX SIX.
SO S. B. FORTINO NINE BRINGS
CALIFORNIA'S HIP LAWS UP TO DATE
BY ADDING PILOT PROGRAM STATUS
TO CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF FOOD
AND AGRICULTURE'S HIP PROGRAM.
HAS REQUIRED BY THE FEDERAL
AUTHORIZATION THINGS ARE MOVING
AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL AS WELL
RECENTLY U. S. SENATORS MITCH
MCCONNELL AND CHUCK SCHUMER.
INTRODUCE FEDERAL LEGISLATION
CATEGORIZING INDUSTRIAL HEMP AS
AN AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT.
OUR OFFICE BELIEVES THE REVENUE
GENERATED BY THE AGRICULTURE
DEMAND.
TO GROW HEMP WILL OFFSET THE
COST TO THE DEPARTMENT TO
ADMINISTER THE PROGRAM. SP
FOURTEEN NO NINE WILL ALLOW
FARMERS OPPORTUNITY TO DIVERSIFY
THEIR FARM OPERATIONS REDUCE
WATER CONSUMPTION AND CREATE
JOBS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NIGHT VOTE WITH ME TODAY IS ANY
PER NAQI REPRESENTING OJAI
ENERGETICS AND VOTE HEMP.
BECKY WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ANY
BERNACCHI MAP OF VOTE HEMP IN
OJAI ENERGETICS.
POLICE CENTER WILL DO NEXT ONE
JOB OF OUTLINING THE IMPORTANCE
AND THE.
BENEFITS OF INDUSTRIAL HEMP
CULTIVATION IN THE STATE I WOULD
ONLY ADD THAT THEREARE TWENTY
OTHER STATES THAT HAVE JUMPED
AHEAD OF CALIFORNIA AND
AUTHORIZING THE. CULTIVATION OF
INDUSTRIAL HELP.
WE WERE AHEAD OF THE CURVE WE
ARE NOW BEHIND THE CURVE.
IF WE CAN GET S. B. FORTINO
NINE TO THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE
AND PASSED IT WILL PROVIDE A
GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR
CALIFORNIA'S FARMERS TO
PARTICIPATE IN THAT INDUSTRY.
AND PROVIDE CALIFORNIA WITH OF
SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC AND ALL AND
ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS SO FOR
THAT REASON THIS BILL COMES UP
FOR CONSIDERATION WE ARE A
DRIVER. THINK HE'LL ADDITIONAL
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMES OF COURSE
ISN'T READY.
SAY NOTHING WILL PROJECTS CLOSE
THE ABSOLUTELY GET APPRECIATE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PERCENT AYE
INDUSTRIAL HIP IS INCREDIBLE
PRODUCTS. IN EUROPE THE SKINS OF
THE CARS ARE MADE OUT OF HIM
BECAUSE THE FIBERS INCREDIBLY
STRONG IN LIGHT. OF THE ALSO USE
HEMP CREATE IN THEIR ROSE
HIMSELF CONCRETE TO SEND CREEK
WHICH IS STRONGER MORE DURABLE
AND SEQUESTERSCARBON.
THEY'RE USING HEMP IN CANADA.
FOR FOR BUILDING MATERIALS AND
IT IT WORKS SO WELL IT INSULATES
SEVENTY DEGREES WEATHER SUMMER
OR WINTER AND FINALLY THIS BILL
IS REALLY BACK TO THE FUTURE FOR
AMERICA.
AT THE TAX THE MATTER IS THOMAS
JEFFERSON AND GEORGE WASHINGTON
GREW HAP ARE THEY DID THAT THE
DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
WRITTEN ON HIM.
BUT THE FIRST FLAG PRODUCED BY
BETSY ROSS MADE OUT OF HIM.
SO WE JUST NEED TO GO BACK TO
OUR ROOTS. AND AND IT LITERALLY
PARTICULARLY AND PRODUCE A
PRODUCT THAT HAS AN IN
INCREDIBLE.
VERSATILITY IN HOUSTON ALL
KINDS OF THINGS I KNOW
PERSONALLY I GOT MANUFACTURING
COMPANIES THAT WANT TO COME TO
MY DISTRICT.
AND AND CREATE JOBS.
WHAT IF THE HEAD MARKET BECOMES
AVAILABLE TO THEM SO WITH THAT
IDEA AND?
URGE YOU TO CONSIDER THIS
STRONGLY MICHAEL'S BEFORE YOU
LATER THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER
WELCOME LIKE THE FERVOR.
WITHOUT OBJECTION WE MOVE THE
SENATE TO SUSPENSE FILE.
SENATE GO JOHNNY.
THURGOOD JOHNNY YOU HAVE YOU'RE
PRESENTING ON ONE ITEM S. B.
THIRTEEN NINETY. YES THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIRMAN FIRST SB
THIRTEEN NINETY WOULD ALLOW FOR
CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND
PARKING ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS TO
ENROLL IN THE DMB
CONFIDENTIALITY PROGRAM.
BECAUSE THE PROGRAM IS VOLUNTARY
ONLY THOSE OFFICERS WHO FEEL IT
NECESSARY WILL ENROLL IN THE
PROGRAM WITH THE RECENT CHANGE
IN STATE LAW REGARDING MARIJUANA.
COULD ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS MAY
BE TASKED WITH ENFORCING ILLEGAL
GROW HOUSES.
ACCORDING TO DATA PROVIDED BY
COULD ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND
PARKING CONTROL OFFICERS RESPECT
RESPECTIVELY ABOUT FOUR HUNDRED
COULD ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS AND
THREE HUNDRED PARKING CONTROL
OFFICERS. WOULD BE NEWLY
ELIGIBLE IF THIS BILL WERE TO BE
ENACTED TAKEN TOGETHER THE THREE
COHORTS COVERED BY S. B.
THIRTEEN NINETY WOULD MAKE
BETWEEN NINE HUNDRED TO ELEVEN
PEOPLE. ELEVEN HUNDRED PEOPLE
ELIGIBLE FOR CONFIDENTIALITY
PROTECTION THEIR JOBS PUT THEM
AT RISK EVERY DAY AND
POTENTIALLY COULD PUT THE
OFFICER AND HIS OR HER FAMILY
MEMBERS IN DANGER. THIS BILL
CLASSIFY THEIR INFORMATION AS
CONFIDENTIAL
ADDITIONALLY WE HAVE OFFERED
AMENDMENTS THAT WILL ALLOW DMV
TO CHARGE A USER FEE TO COVER
COST THEREFORE THIS BILL SHOULD
NOT INCUR ANY COSTS TO THE
GENERAL FUND. WITH ME TODAY TO
HELP ANY QUESTIONS IS JOHN LEVEL
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
THANK YOU THANK YOU MISTER LEVEL.
ET SO A GOOD AFTERNOON ON.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE ON MY NAME IS JOHN
LEVEL I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS.
AND THE.
CALIFORNIA PARKING CONTROL
OFFICERS THIS BILL IS A CLEAN UP
BILL A NUMBER OF THOSE FOLKS IN
BOTH CATEGORIES ARE ALREADY
COVERED. BY THE LAW AND THE TRUE
GENIUS OF THIS BILL. IS THAT IT
HAS LANGUAGE IN THE BILL THAT
SAYS THE DEPARTMENT SHALL CHARGE
A PERSON A FEE.
TO COVER THE REASONABLE COSTS
INCURRED BY THE DEPARTMENT.
FOR REQUEST FOR CONFIDENTIALITY
UNDER SUBDIVISION A WHICH IS
THIS ENTIRE PROGRAM. GIVEN THAT
REALITY IT IS.
A MYSTERY THAT WE DON'T
UNDERSTAND.
THAT THE.
ANALYSIS
ESTIMATES FIRST YEAR COSTS OF
TWO HUNDRED AND SEVENTY FIVE
THOUSAND AND NINETY THOUSAND
ANNUALLY BECAUSE ALL OF THAT ALL
OF THAT. IS TO BE COVERED BY THE
FEE. OF IN OUR VIEW THIS IS A
BILL THAT.
IS NOT A SUSPENSE CANDIDATE BUT
IS APPROPRIATE FOR ANY VALUE TO
VOTE.
BY THE COMMITTEE I'M HERE DAY
AND HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
DIDN'T WIN SINCE WHAT WITNESSES
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
FINANCE ON THE JOHNNY WOULD LIKE
TO CLOSE.
I'M IN LIGHT OF THE AMENDMENTS
THAT WE TOOK TURNS TO COVER THE
COSTS FOR THE BILL I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU A TURN THE JOHNNY SO
JUST TO CLARIFY YOU KNOW WE. ARE
IN THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS WELL
THAT THE FEE ALLEVIATES A
PRESSURES TO THE DMV.
TEAM IS OPERATING FUND THE
POTENTIAL INCREASE IN WORKLOAD
WOULD STILL REMAIN.
SO WE JUST WANNA REMIND
INDIVIDUALS THAT WHEN THE
COMMITTEE EXAMINES THE BILL'S
FISCAL IMPACT. WE TAKE INTO
ACCOUNT THE NEW EXPANDED
WORKLOAD THAT WOULD DIVERT
DEPARTMENT STAFF. FROM THE
EXISTING DUTIES AND
RESPONSIBILITIES
SO THAT'S NOT. A. JUST TO
EXPLAIN TO WHY WE'RE PUTTING IN
SUSPENSE BUT WE'RE NOT.
NECESSARILY OPINIE ONE WAY OR
ANOTHER ONE TO MAKE SURE THAT.
WE WE CLARIFY FURTHER THE
DECISION FOR THE SUSPENSE.
CAT IT BUT WE DO SO WITHOUT ANY
TYPE OF POP PREJUDICE OF COURSE.
THANK YOU I RSPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE THE BREAK YOU. WITHOUT
OBJECTION TO MOVE THIS ITEM TO
THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MEMBER OF CENTER WIENER.
MEMBERS ARE WINNERS THAT OF
MINOR BILL HERE.
WELL ACTUALLY YOU HAVE TO ITEMS.
YEAH THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
WHY DON'T WE BEGIN WHERE.
REFINES ON MY AGENDA FEELS
SOMEONE.
WHEN WE BEGIN WITH YOUR.
SP TEN FORTY FIVE FIRST
FOR THAT YEAH.
WHICH IS THE BEST WITHOUT.
PUT IT AROUND AND.
MEMBERS IS S. B. TEN FORTY FIVE.
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY CENTER
WHERE.
I'VE THANK YOU OUGHT MISTER
CHAIRMAN.
INCOME RATE OF.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN. ARE
SENATE BILL TEN FORTY FIVE.
GIVES AYE TO COUNTIES LOS
ANGELES COUNTY.
AND SAN FRANCISCO COUNTY.
ARE UNDER A PILOT PROGRAM A NEW.
NARROW CONSERVATORSHIP TO CARE
FOR THE MOST VULNERABLE PEOPLE
ON OUR STREETS.
A CHRONIC HOMELESS WHO WERE
DEBILITATED BY DUE TO SEVERE
MENTAL ILLNESS AND SUBSTANCE
ABUSE ODD DISORDER.
ABOUT PEOPLE WHO ARE
INCAPACITATED AND LITERALLY
DYING ON OUR STREETS WE SEE
THAT'S CERTAINLY IN SAN
FRANCISCO AND LOS ANGELES EVERY
DAY. AND OTHER COUNTIES AS WELL.
BODIES ARE PEOPLE WHOM ARE AYE
COUNTIES ARE CURRENTLY
STRUGGLING TO REACH.
AND FRANKLY FAILING TO REACH
WITH EXISTING INADEQUATE LEGAL
TOOLS AND VOLUNTARY SERVICES.
ARE WE SEE THESE PEOPLE EVERY
DAY.
AND MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY WHO
WALKED BY WONDER WHAT THE HECK
IS GOING ON AND WHY IS NOBODY
HELPING.
THESE PEOPLE.
TEN FORTY FIVE. EXTRA TEN FORTY
FIVE IS ABOUT GIVING. OUR LOCAL
COMMUNITIES THAT ADDITIONAL TOOL.
TO SAVE THE LIVES OF THESE
INDIVIDUALS.
THIS BILL IS NARROW AND FOCUSED.
THIS IS A TINY SUBSET OF OUR
HOMELESS POPULATION.
THE SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH ESTIMATES THAT
APPROXIMATELY FIFTY TO A HUNDRED
PEOPLE WERE ABOUT ONE PERCENT OF
SAN FRANCISCO'S TOTAL HOMELESS
POPULATION. OF WOULD BE COVERED
BY THIS BILL THE VAST MAJORITY
OF HOMELESS PEOPLE WILL NOT BE
IMPACTED BY THIS NEW
CONSERVATORSHIP.
OUR THE BILL WHILE HAVING A COST
WILL ALSO SAY FUNDS
BOB BECAUSE AS YOU WILL HEAR.
OUR FIRST RESPONDERS POLICE FIRE
PARAMEDICS.
SPEND SIGNIFICANT RESOURCES
CONSTANTLY RESPONDING TO CALLS
ABOUT THE SMALL POPULATION AS WE
HAVE OF PEOPLE WHO ARE.
IT'S IT'S INCAPACITATED AND ARE
CONSTANTLY BEING CYCLED THROUGH
FIFTY ONE FIFTIES TO SITE
EMERGENCY AND UNFORTUNATELY INTO
THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
WHICH IS NOT WHERE WE WANT THEM.
TO BE.
THAT'S THREE TEN FORTY FIVE
CREATES A NEW CONSERVATIVE SHIP
IN A NARROW ONE IN THE WELFARE
INSTITUTIONS CODE. FOR CHRONIC
HOMELESS WHO ARE INCAPABLE OF
CARING FOR AND MAKING DECISIONS
FOR THEMSELVES.
DUE TO SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS AND
SEVERE SUBSTANCE ABUSE DISORDER
INCLUDING A FREQUENT.
FIFTY ONE FIFTIES PSYCHIATRIC
COMMITMENTS OF EMERGENCY ROOM
VISITS AND ARRESTS.
I WILL KNOW I JUST FROM PAST
HEARINGS OF THE OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL AND I. ARE
TREMENDOUSLY RESPECT AND I'M
USUALLY ALIGNED WITH THE
OPPOSITION THIS BILL.
HAS BEEN CHERRY PICKING FROM
THE BILL.
AND.
CHERRY PICKING IN OUR
INDIVIDUAL ELEMENTS OF THE BILL
AND SAYING HEY IF YOU'RE
ARRESTED A FEW TIMES ARE GOING
TO CUTS CONSERVE. OR PURE FIFTY
ONE FIFTIES IF YOU TIME YOUR
GONNA GET CONSERVE THERE ARE
MANY PROTECTIONS IN THIS BILL. A
LOT OF REQUIREMENTS TO REACH THE
THRESHOLD OF BEING ELIGIBLE.
PUBLIC FULL DUE PROCESS
PROTECTIONS OF JUDGE JURY.
AND GREAT TO.
COUNCIL OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES
ARE TELLING US THAT THE CURRENT
LAW IS INADEQUATE THAT IT
DOESN'T CREATE ENOUGH
FLEXIBILITY TO CARE FOR THE MOST
DEBILITATED INDIVIDUALS ON OUR
STREETS.
PEOPLE ARE SIMPLY SITE GOING
THROUGH THE SYSTEM.
AND PEOPLE ARE DYING. BOMB ONCE
OUTLOOK COMES ONCE A CONCERT THE
LAW PRIORITIZE HOUSING. AND
PROVIDE SIGNIFICANT FLEXIBILITY
TO DETERMINE THE BEST PLACEMENT
FOR CONCERT INDIVIDUAL WHETHER
IT'S SUPPORT HOUSING. I'M OTHER
IN COMMUNITY PLACEMENTS OR A
MORE SECURE FACILITY EACH CASE
IS UNIQUE.
SO BOTH OF SAN FRANCISCO AND
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES OR I
HAVE ENDORSED THIS BILL.
AND LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS HAS PASSED A MORE
GENERAL. A RESOLUTION ASKING FOR
A CHANGE.
WHICH MADE ME TODAY.
ARE TWO WITNESSES.
ACT.
BOB WAS STARTED ON THIS
ADJOURNMENTS WHO TODAY ARE TWO
WITNESSES CAPTAIN SIMON PAYING
FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO FIRE
DEPARTMENT. I'M KILLING HER MOTO
FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
THANK YOU WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
I HAVE A FEW PHOTOGRAPHS THAT
WOULD LIKE.
YOU TO SEE WHAT HAVE SERGEANTS
PASS.
OKAY THANK YOU CRAP.
BOB SIMON BANG I SAN FRANCISCO
PARAMEDIC CAPTAIN.
I WORK IN A UNIT THAT RESPONDS
TO FREQUENT NINE ONE ONE USERS
SHEPHERDING PEOPLE TOWARD
SHELTERS DETOX TREATMENT.
MENTAL HEALTH CARE AND SUPPORT
OF HOUSING.
OF THE FIVE HUNDRED FIFTEEN
FREQUENT NINE AND ONE USERS AND
LAST YEAR. ABOUT A DOZEN WERE SO
SICK AND MENTALLY DISORGANIZED
BUT THEY COULDN'T PERFORM ACTS
OF DAILY LIVING.
THESE INDIVIDUALS REPEATEDLY
REFUSED SUPPORTIVE HOUSING CASE
MANAGEMENT DRUG TREATMENT.
AND MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES.
I'LL GIVE TWO EXAMPLES.
JOHN.
I DIABETIC METH USER.
WITH CHRONIC INCONTINENCE.
NEEDS A NURSE TO CLEAN HIM EVERY
TIME HE HAS A BALLOT MOVEMENT.
HE HAD MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED
EMERGENCY RESPONSES LAST YEAR.
SOMETIMES FOR ACUTE EMERGENCIES.
BUT USUALLY BECAUSE A BYSTANDER
SAW A LEGLESS PERSON COVERED IN
EXCREMENT WHO COULDN'T GET BACK
INTO HIS WHEELCHAIR.
HE WOULD LEAVE HOSPITALS WITH
INSULIN AND WOUND CARE SUPPLIES
AND THROW THEM AWAY IMMEDIATELY.
MY TEAM MET WITH HIM FORTY EIGHT
TIMES.
AND OFFERED HIM SHELTER
TREATMENT AND OTHER HELP EACH
TIME.
JOHN IS DEAD NOW.
IN JANUARY HE WAS FOUND
HYPOTHERMIC BY PARAMEDICS IN
URINE SOAKED CLOTHES.
HE DIED IN AN EMERGENCY ROOM.
JOHN WAS NOT ABLE TO BE
CONSERVED UNDER CURRENT LAW.
NOR DID HE QUALIFY FOR LOWERS LA.
FOR ANOTHER INDIVIDUAL FRANK.
THE PERSON IN THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS
AND I PASSED AROUND.
SITS IN A WHEEL CHAIR WITH AN
ABSCESS ON HIS BACKSIDE THAT HAS
TUNNELED INTO HIS BODY.
CAUSING HIS LEGS TO ATROPHY.
BUT TUNNELED ABSCESS HAS ALMOST
REACHES BONE WHEN IT REACHES AS
BONE THE DOCTORS SAY HE WILL DIE.
HE IS A MATH USER AND YOU CANNOT
PERFORM SIMPLE ACTS OF DAILY
LIVING.
BUT HE CAN'T BE HELD BECAUSE IT
ISN'T CLEAR WHETHER IT'S THE
RESULT OF MENTAL ILLNESS OR
SUBSTANCE ABUSE.
AND THE LAST YEAR HE HAS REFUSE
RESOURCES THAT MY TEAM HAS
PERSONALLY OFFERED HIM FIFTY
THREE TIMES INCLUDING SUPPORTIVE
HOUSING.
LAST TIME I RESPONDED TO HIS
NINE ONE ONE CALL.
FAMILIES WERE STEPPING AROUND
HIM AS THEY LEFT THEIR
APARTMENTS.
HE WAS SURROUNDED BY FLIES WITH
EXCREMENT ON HIS SWOLLEN
INFECTED HANDS.
WHICH HELD A COUPLE OF DOLLARS.
HE WAS TRYING TO GET PASSERS BY
TO WHEEL HIM TO A DONUT SHOP OR
YOU COULD PASS THAT DOLLAR.
ENTER CIRCULATION AND GET A
DONUT.
UNDER EXISTING LAW DOCTORS AND
PSYCHIATRISTS HAVE SAID THEY
CAN'T HOLD HIM I.
THERE HAVE BEEN SEVEN DEATHS OF
PEOPLE THAT I HAVE PERSONALLY
WORKED WITH IT IS NO CLICHE.
PEOPLE ARE DYING ON THE STREET.
CURRENT CONSERVATORSHIP LAWS ARE
NOT WORKING.
S. B. TEN FORTY FIVE COULD OFFER
THESE PEOPLE A PAUSE IN THIS
VICIOUS CIRCLE TO CLEAR.
AND POSSIBLY HAVE A CHANCE.
AND I WOULD ENCOURAGE ANYONE IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
COME TO WORK WITH ME FOR A FEW
HOURS AND SEE FOR YOURSELF THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON SHARYL ARE AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
KELLY HER MOTO AND I AM THE
DIRECTOR TRANSITIONS WITH THE
SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH.
MY TEAM IS RESPONSIBLE FOR
PROVIDING PER APPROPRIATE
PLACEMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO
ARE PLACED ON CONSERVATIVE SHIPS
OR DO NOT HAVE A PLACE TO GO
AFTER LEAVING THE HOSPITAL.
AS YOU'VE HEARD SB TEN FORTY
FIVE IS INTENDED TO HELP ARE
HARDEST TO REACH INDIVIDUALS.
THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE KNOWN BY
THE SYSTEM THE CARE BUT ARE
CURRENTLY HARD TO REACH.
I LIKE TO OFFER AN EXAMPLE OF
WHO THAT MIGHT BE.
MISTER JOHNSON IS A FIFTY SIX
YEAR OLD MAN WITH A LONG HISTORY
WITHIN THE CITY SYSTEM OF CARE
BUT ONLY WITH CRISIS SERVICES OR
JAIL. IN THE PAST YEAR HE HAS
BEEN BROUGHT TO A PSYCHIATRIC
EMERGENCY SERVICES FIFTEEN TIMES
HE HAS HAD TEN ENCOUNTERS WITH
THE SAN FRANCISCO POLICE
DEPARTMENT.
HE IS KNOWN TO BE HOMELESS HAS A
MAJOR DEPRESSION DIAGNOSIS AND
IS NOT ENGAGED IN ANY TREATMENT
SERVICES ARE BEING OFFERED ANY
CURRENT HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES
BECAUSE OF ITS ACT OF SUBSTANCE
ABUSE.
METHAMPHETAMINE USE IS OBSERVED
AS A PRIMARY ISSUE DURING HIS
PSYCHIATRIC EMERGENCY VISITS AND
AFTER TWELVE HOURS DAY HE TENDS
TO CLEAR UP ENOUGH TO NO LONGER
MEET MEDICAL NECESSITY IN IS
RELEASED.
HE RETURNED SAYS LIKE EMERGENCY
LATER THAT WEEK HAVING BEEN
PICKED UP BY THE POLICE FOR
BEING UNDER THE INFLUENCE AND
DRESSING IN PUBLIC EXHIBITING
AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIORS TOWARD
OTHERS ON THE STREET.
HE ONCE AGAIN CLEARS AFTER AN
OVERNIGHT STAY IN IS RELEASED IN
THEMORNING BECAUSE HE NO LONGER
MEETS GAVE DISABILITY CRITERIA
SITTING HE WILL GO TO SAINT
ANTHONY'S FOR LUNCH AND WILL GO
TO THE SHELTER AFTER THAT TO
WAIT FOR A BAD.
WHEN HE IS DISCHARGED HE STARTS
OUT FOR ST ANTHONY'S BUT ENDS UP
LOOKING FOR DRUGS ON THE WAY.
UNFORTUNATELY I COULD SHARE MORE
EXAMPLES LIKE THIS INCLUDING
ONES OF AGING INDIVIDUALS WHO
HAVE SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS
SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER AND OTHER
CONDITIONS LIKE DIABETES OR HIV.
SAN FRANCISCO HAS A LONG HISTORY
OF PROVIDING COMPASSIONATE CARE
IN FOLLOWING A RECOVERY ORIENTED
MODEL. RECENTLY WE STARTED AN
INTERAGENCY WORKING GROUP TO
CREATE CARE PLANS FOR FORTY TO
FIFTY OF OUR HIGHEST UTILIZES A
MULTIPLE SYSTEMS.
SOME AMONG THIS GROUP HAVE BEEN
KNOWN TO THE CITY FOR YEARS AND
WE HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO HELP
THEM STABILIZE NOT BECAUSE WE
HAVEN'T TRIED BUT BECAUSE THEIR
ABILITY FOR SELF CARE HAS
DETERIORATED OVER TIME.
INVOLUNTARY SERVICES ARE HARDER
AND HARDER FOR THEM TO ACCEPT
FOR THEM S. B. TEN FORTY FIVE
CAN BE A PATH TO STABILITY
HOUSING AND A VASTLY IMPROVED
QUALITY OF LIFE.
THANK YOU AND THANK YOU CANCERS
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
SUPPORT THE STATE YOUR NAME AND
ORGANIZATION.
THE OBVIOUS ALICIA ON BEHALF OF
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES AND ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA
MONICA SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
YOU.
DIGITAL WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
SO WHEN THIS WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION TO THE WAR.
IT'S GREAT WHEN EVERYBODY.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS KURT CHILD
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA.
WERE APPEARING ON BEHALF OF A
COALITION OF.
CIVIL RIGHTS.
DISABILITY RIGHTS
AND HOMELESS ADVOCATES ALONG
WITH THE LABOR ORGANIZATIONS TO
OPPOSE THIS SIR.
BILL. A UNFORTUNATELY WHAT THIS
BILL STARTS LOOKING TOWARD IS
EXPANDING INVOLUNTARY TREATMENT
BEYOND WHAT EXISTS CURRENTLY IN
THE LAND OF MINT PICTURE SHORTER
LAURA'S LAW.
FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE THAT HAS
FOR DECADES BEEN ABLE TO SERVE
THE NEEDS OF THE COMMUNITIES FOR
PERSONS WHO ARE SUFFERING FROM
GRAVE DISABILITIES OR ARE A
DANGER TO THEMSELVES OR OR
OTHERS. WHAT WE'VE BEEN TOTALLY
UNABLE TO LEARN I THINK THROUGH
THE PROCESS OF THIS BILL IS
UNDERSTANDING WHAT IS NOT
WORKING WITH THE AND THE
EXISTING LAW? TO ASSURE THAT
INDIVIDUALS ARE GIVEN THE
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE THE SERVICES
AND TREATMENT.
THAT THEY MAY NEED. SO.
JUST FOCUSING SOME ON THE CAR
SINCE THE SUSAN APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE HEARING IS THAT
LOOKING FIRST OF ALL.
THAT THE CARS THAT'S BEEN
IDENTIFIED IN THE ANALYSIS ARE
LOOKING SOLELY TO WHAT ARE THE.
THE COURT COSTS AND MOST
IMPORTANTLY THOUGH I THINK WITH
THOSE ARE LOOKING AT IS.
THE POTENTIAL NUMBERS OF
PERSONS WHO COULD POTENTIALLY BE
IMPACTED BY THIS BILL THE THE
NUMBER HAS RANGE QUITE BROADLY.
FROM THE LAST FEW HEARINGS THAT
WE HAD INITIALLY STARTING
SOMEWHERE AROUND THIRTY AND I
HEARD A REALLY FOR THE FIRST
TIME THIS MORNING THAT THIS IS A
BILL. TO THAT WOULD FIFTY TWO
HUNDRED PEOPLE.
IN SAN FRANCISCO.
AND I THINK THE ANALYSIS WAS
SUGGESTING WOULD BE THREE TIMES
AS MANY. IN THE.
IN THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES WE
WHICH SUGGESTS THAT THE COSTS
ARE MUCH HIGHER BUT MOST
IMPORTANTLY WHAT WE THINK IT IS.
NOW TO REALLY LOOK AT WHAT FOR
EXAMPLE THE GOVERNOR HAS
PROPOSED IN HIS MAY REVISE THERE
HE IS. PROVIDING TO THE.
TO THE COUNTIES ADDITIONAL
DOLLARS FOR MENTAL HEALTH
TREATMENT AND FOR HOUSING IN
SUPPORT OF HOUSING THAT'S WHAT
WE NEED TO RESOLVE THE ISSUES
THAT ARE RAISED BY.
THE INDIVIDUAL SUPPORTING.
THIS BILL NOT ANOTHER TOOL TO
HOLD PEOPLE INVOLUNTARILY THANK
YOU.
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS THE
SHOCK UPDATE WITH THE SERVICE
EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION
AND ON BEHALF OF OUR I'M
MEMBERSHIP WHICH INCLUDES PUBLIC
GUARDIANS WHO DAY IN AND DAY OUT
ARE ACTIVELY. I'M WORKING TO TRY
TO GET FOLKS INTO
CONSERVATORSHIP.
THERE ARE A COUPLE OF.
KEY CONCERNS WINE IN ADDITION
TO ALL OF.
THE POINTS RESPECT DISABILITY
RIGHTS CALIFORNIA I'M IS THIS
ISSUE OF
BETTER RESOURCE IN THE EXISTING
SYSTEM.
OUR PUBLIC GUARDIAN MEMBERS IN
LOS ANGELES HAVE EIGHT CASELOADS
OF EIGHTY INDIVIDUALS WHO
THEY'RE RESPONSIBLE FOR.
AND THE ABSOLUTELY LACK
PLACEMENTS FOR THEM THEY LACK
PLACES TO KEEP THEM WHILE
THEY'RE IN GOT UNDERGOING THE
COURT PROCESS TO.
GET THEM CONSERVED
AND THEN OF COURSE AFTER THAT
THE TREATMENT AND THE SERVICES
THAT ARE NEEDED TO GET THEM
BETTER.
ON THE OTHER KIND OF ISSUE THAT
CAME UP WHICH.
MADE A LOT OF SENSE TO US IS
THAT WITH THIS NEW CLASS OF
CONSERVATORSHIP.
THE ASSUMPTION IS THAT YOU
WOULD SOMEHOW BE BETTER ABLE TO
TREAT INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE IN THE
THROES OF SUBSTANCE USE
DISORDERS. AND ARE CONSERVATIVE
OUR PUBLIC PARTY MEMBERS SEE.
YOU CANNOT REALLY COMPULSORILY
TO GET BETTER WITH THE SUBSTANCE
USE DISORDER THE NEED TO WANT TO
GET BETTER AND SO THIS WILL NOT
ACTUALLY SOLVE THE PROBLEM THAT
IT'S SEEKING TO SOLVE.
BECAUSE THE PEOPLE WHO CYCLE
BACK THROUGH CONSERVATORSHIP
STOOD DAY WILL CONTINUE TO CYCLE
BACK THROUGH. UNTIL THEY'VE MADE
A DECISION THEMSELVES THAT THEY
WANT TO GET BETTER AND SO. YES
WORK AND WE WOULD CREATE A
NECESSARILY A NEW KIND OF
CONSERVATORSHIP BUT NOT ACTUALLY
SOLVE THE UNDERLYING ISSUES
RELATED TO ADDICTION AND FOR
THOSE REASONS WE ARE OPPOSE.
GEN FOR ON BEHALF OF WESTERN
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY AND
JUST TO BE BRIEF.
THE AUTHOR INDICATED THAT
OPPOSITION HAS BEEN CHERRY
PICKING THE BILL TO FIND
OPPOSITION BUT I WANT TO BE
ABSOLUTELY CLEAR IT IS THIS.
SURE OF THE BILL ITSELF WE ARE
OPPOSED TO.
SPECIFICALLY THE CHURCH
STRUCTURE THAT MAKES
HOMELESSNESS
A PART OF A CONSERVATORSHIP
DETERMINATION.
IN WESTERN CENTER IS YOU TO DO
THAT FURTHER STIGMATIZES BEING
HOMELESSNESS HOMELESS IT CREATES
A NEW SUSPECT CLASS.
AND IT WILL BE PERCEIVED BY
INDIVIDUALS LIVING ON THE STREET
AS AN ATTEMPT TO ROUND UP
HOMELESS PEOPLE.
THE FURTHER MORE THE BILL
INCENTIVIZE IS ARRESTING PEOPLE
LIVING ON THE STREET BECAUSE
THAT IS ONE OF THE MEASURES OF
HOW YOU DETERMINE WHETHER
SOMEONE IS SUBJECT TO A
CONSERVATIVE.
AT CONSERVATORSHIP SORRY SO IT'S
NOT JUST YOU KNOW LITTLE PIECES
HERE AND THERE IT IS THE WHOLE
BICU OF CREATING A NEW PROCESS
THE ONLY PEOPLE WHO ARE HOMELESS
COULD EVER BE SUBJECT TO. IF
THERE'S A PROBLEM WITH THE
CURRENT LPS ARE A O. T. LAWS
THEY NEED TO BE DEALT WITH WITH
A NEW AYE LOOKING AT SUBSTANCE
ABUSE TO SEE IF THERE IS
SOMETHING TO BE DONE THERE. IT
MAY BE THAT WE CAN'T FIND THE
RIGHT ANSWER BUT THE ANSWER IS
NOT TO SUBJECT HOMELESS PEOPLE
TO A DIFFERENT SET OF LOS.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
THE JURY MEMBERS HAVEN'T BAKER
FOR THE AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES
UNION OF CALIFORNIA ALSO
REGRETTABLY IN OPPOSITION THINK.
THANK YOU.
I HAVE FINANCE AND FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
CNN SENATOR WE KNOW WOULD LIKE
TO CLOSE FIVE THANK YOU ARE VERY
MUCH AS A CHAIRMAN AND.
I'D JUST BRIEFLY YOU KNOW I
THINK THIS IS ULTIMATELY ABOUT.
WEATHER IS THE STATUS QUO
WORKING.
AND AYE AYE QUICK QUESTION FOR
ONE IS HOW IS IT WORKING. IT'S
NOT.
I AND OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES ARE
TELLING US.
DIE.
PROVIDING THE SERVICES AND I AM
HUNDREDPERCENT SUPPORTIVE OF
INCREASING FUNDING FOR MENTAL
HEALTH. FOR SUPPORTIVE HOUSING
FOR DRUG ADDICTION SERVICES
HUNDRED PERCENT SUPPORTED.
THERE TELLING US THAT THAT IS
NOT ENOUGH WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT
THIS TINY.
GROUP OF PEOPLE THE SMALL
PERCENTAGE OF PEOPLE AND YOU
HEARD FROM THE CAPTAIN. I BET
YOU KNOW THESE ARE NOT PEOPLE
WHO YOU CAN CONVINCE HEY WHAT
ARE YOU GOING TO DRUG TREATMENT
WE ALL KNOW PEOPLE WHO'VE GONE
INTO RECOVERY AND THEY
ULTIMATELY HAVE TO MAKE THAT
CHOICE.
THESE ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE
DETERIORATING AND DYING ON OUR
STREETS WHO ARE INCAPABLE OF
MAKING THOSE DECISIONS.
BOB FOR THEMSELVES AND WE'RE
BEING TOLD LPS AYE IS SIMPLY NOT
ENOUGH.
FINALLY I WANT TO ADDRESS.
THOUGH WHAT'S INCIDENTS POINT
ABOUT HOW THIS AUDIT FOCUSES ON
PEOPLE WHO ARE CHRONICALLY
HOMELESS.
.
THE ALTERNATIVE IS TO HAVE A
MUCH BROADER EXPANSION OF LPS.
AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU IF THIS
BILL WERE LIMITED TO CHRONIC
HOMELESS TO CRITICISM WILL BE
YOU ARE TOUCHED BLOWING A HOLE
IN THE SIDE OF THE LPS AND IT'S
GONNA HAVE A LARGE NUMBER OF
PEOPLE WHO WILL BECOME ELIGIBLE.
I AND IN FACT I BELIEVE THE SAME
COALITION IS OPPOSING A BILL BY
IN THE ASSEMBLY BY SOMETHING
MEMBERS SANTIAGO AND FRIEDMAN
WHICH DOES SIMPLY CHANGE THE
DEFINITION OF GREAT GREAT
DISABILITY SO. I LOOK ORWARD TO
CONTINUE DISCUSSION AND THE I
ASK FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
THANK YOU I'M DEFINITELY OUT
INTERESTING TOPIC I REALLY
UNDERSTAND THAT. PROPONENTS AND
OPPONENTS.
I WILL CONTINUE TO HAVE A
DIALOGUE ONE IT'S AND SUSPENSE
WITHOUT OBJECTION REMOVE THIS
ITEM. TO SUSPENSE FILE.
SENATOR WE KNOW YOU HAVE FOUND
YOUR EIGHT TWENTY TWO WHEN WE.
FOUND. BUDGET BEGAN ON THE
CERTIFICATE I'VE THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIRMAN OUR COLLEAGUES
ARE SENATE BILL EIGHT TWENTY TWO.
ESTABLISHES A STRONG AND
COMPREHENSIVE NET NEUTRALITY A
REQUIREMENT FOR CALIFORNIA.
BY CAPTURING THE PROTECTIONS OF
THE FCC'S TWENTY FIFTEEN OPEN
INTERNET ORDER.
AND BANNING INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS UP FROM.
ENGAGING IN ANTI COMPETITIVE
AND ABUSIVE PRACTICES LIKE
BLOCKING OR SLOWING ACCESS TO
WEBSITES OR DISCRIMINATING OR
PLAYING FAVORITES BASED ON WHO'S
PAYING MORE. BY THIS BILL.
OF COURSE IS IN RESPONSE TO
DONALD TRUMP'S FCC OF
OBLITERATING.
FEDERAL I KNOW WHOSE HOLIDAY
PROTECTIONS.
AND.
NOTS IS GOING BACK TO THE CREED
TWENTY FIFTEEN.
ERA BUT WIPING EVERYTHING A WAY.
THIS BILL PREVENTS AND BANS
ISPS FROM VIOLATING.
THE THREE BRIGHT LINE RULES OF
NO BLOCKING THE THROTTLING AND
NO PAID PRIORITIZATION BOTH WERE
CONTENT IS DELIVERED TO
CONSUMERS AND AT THE POINT OF
INTERCONNECTION.
THE BILL ALSO CAPTURES THE
IMPORT PROTECTIONS OF THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN FCC ORDER THAT WERE NOT
SPELLED OUT IN THOSE THREE RULES
BUT THAT WERE EXPLAINED IN THE
BODY OF THE F. C. C.'S ORDERS
SUCH AS. INCORPORATING CLASSES
OF APPLICATIONS AND SERVICES IN
THE DEFINITIONS PREVENTING THAT
NEUTRALITY RULES FROM BEING
CIRCUMVENTED AT THE POINT
AMERICAN ACTION. AND PROHIBITING
SPEEDING UP WEBSITES AND IN
ADDITION TO SLOWING OTHER
WEBSITES DOWN.
TO BE CLEAR THIS ODD BILL
CONTRARY TO THE CLAIMS OF THE
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS DOES
NOT GO BEYOND.
THE PROTECTIONS OF THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN ORDER DOT IS INACCURATE
WE ARE NOT THE FCC AND WE HAVE
TO REGULATE IN A DIFFERENT WAY.
BY THE AREAS THAT THE.
ISPS CLAIM GO BEYOND THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN ORDER INCLUDING.
THE RESTRICTIONS ON ZERO RATING
AND ON ABUSIVE INTERCONNECTION
ARRANGEMENTS WORK CONTAINS IN
THE FCC'S ORDER.
ZIP SP TWENTY TWO CREATES AYE
ENFORCEABLE BRIGHT LINE RULES.
FOR.
AT ALL OF THESE PRACTICES
INCLUDING ZERO RATING.
WHICH IS A FORM OF.
REQUIRING PAYMENT.
TYPICALLY IN ORDER TO HAVE A
PARTICULAR APPLICATION NOT
CONSUME DATA. OR HAVING A
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS SAY
IF YOU USE MY PRODUCT.
IT WON'T COUNT AGAINST YOUR DATA
IF USE MY COMPETITOR'S PRODUCT
IT WILL COUNT AGAINST YOUR DATA
WHICH HAS MONOPOLISTIC.
VIEWS OUGHT THE BILL ALSO
PROVIDES I AM FORCED EMPOWER.
TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
AND NOT TO THE CPU CITY OF
WHICH IS A BROADLY SHARE GOAL OF
NOT EXPANDING THE POWERS OF THE
CPU SEE.
AND I WANT TO THANK ATTORNEY
GENERAL TO SARAH OFFER
EXPRESSING HIS STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS BILL.
.
SO FUNDAMENTALLY THIS BILL AS
I'D IS ABOUT NOT ALLOWING
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS.
TO PICK WINNERS AND LOSERS ON
THE INTERNET OR TO THE SIDE WHO.
HAS A FAST LANE WHO IS THE SLOW
LANE WHITE WEBSITES ARE EASYTO
ACCESS WHAT WEBSITES OR HARD.
NOT TO ACCESS A FREE AND OPEN
INTERNET MEANS THAT WE GET TO
MAKE THOSE DECISIONS.
AND NOT INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS.
IT'S FUN.
I'VE I WE HAVE TWO WITNESSES WHO-ME TODAY.
BAR A BARBER MENSHEVIK WHO IS A
LAW PROFESSOR AT STANFORD
DIRECTOR OF STAMFORD CENTER FOR
INTERNET AND SOCIETY. AN ANSWER
MCCOLLUM WHO IS THE CHIEF
EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF BY LOW.
THANK YOU WHEN THIS IS A PART
PLEASE COME.
BUT.
HELLO THANKS FOR HAVING ME TODAY.
MY NAME'S EDDY MCCOLLUM I'M THE
CEO OF A START UP COMPANY CALLED
FILO AND SAN FRANCISCO.
OVER THE COURSE OF MY CAREER IN
TECHNOLOGY I'VE REALLY SEEN THE%
POWER.
OF THE INNOVATION THAT THE.
IT'S FIRSTHAND I
FIRST ON.
FUNDING TEMA FACEBOOK I'VE BEEN
INACTIVE ANGEL INVESTOR AND
ADVISOR FOR TECH COMPANIES FOR.
A LONG PERIOD OF TIME AND ALSO
AND SO I'VE SEEN THAT THE THE
POWER THAT A FREE AND OPEN%
INTERNET BRINGS TO ENABLING.
INNOVATION AND TECHNOLOGY HAVE
ALSO SEEN FIRST HAND JUST HOW
MUCH OF A STRUGGLE IT IS FOR A
FLEDGLING COMPANY THAT'S COMING
INTO THE MARKET IN TRYING TO.
BRING INNOVATION TO SORT OF
FIGHT THE UP HILL BATTLE THAT IT
TAKES TO BRING SOMETHING INTO
EXISTENCE PARTICULARLY WHEN YOU
THAT UPHILL BATTLE.
INVOLVES A INCOME AND COMPANIES
THAT WOULD PREFER TO.
BLOCK INNOVATION AND MAINTAIN
THE STATUS QUO MY CURRENT
COMPANY FILO IS A.
LIVE TV STREAMING COMPANY WE
OFFER SERVICE THAT ENABLES YOU
TO SUBSCRIBE TO.
TH DIE THE THIRTY SEVEN OR
FORTY SIX LIVE TV CHANNELS.
FOUR BY THREE EITHER SIXTEEN OR
TWENTY DOLLARS A MONTH AND A A
SERVICE LIKE OURS IS REALLY.
DIRECTLY POTENTIALLY DIRECTLY
AFFECTED BY ALL OF THE DIFFERENT.
SORT OF.
.
AT NEGATIVE BEHAVIORS AT THIS
BILL INTENDS TO PREVENT.
WE'RE LIVE VIDEO SERVICE SO
BATES BANDWIDTH INTENSIVE AND
IT'S VERY SENSITIVE TO.
THROTTLING OR PRIVATIZATION.
IT DOESN'T TAKE VERY MUCH.
IN A INFLUENCE ON THE NETWORK
TO MAKE LIVE VIDEO A REALLY A
FRUSTRATING EXPERIENCE AND IT IS
BAD WITH INTENSIVE SO.
WE ARE ALSO A VERY SENSITIVE TO
THE ASPECTS OF THIS BILL IT
TOUCH ON THINGS LIKE ZERO RATING.
JUST TO SORT OF US GOING TO A
LITTLE BIT MORE DETAIL THERE
WHEN YOU LOOK AT A PRACTICE LIKE
ZERO RATING IT HAS A NUMBER OF
POTENTIAL EFFECTS ON A SERVICE
LIKE OURS. OF FIRST OF ALL.
WE COMPETE WITH ALL THE LARGEST
SIZE PIECE DIRECTLY TO OFFER TV
SERVICES
SO WHEN THOSE COMPANIES HAVE
THEIR OWN VIDEO SERVICES.
THEY CAN ELECT TO HAVE THEM.
NOT COUNT TOWARDS THERE
CUSTOMERS DATA CAPS AND WHICH
GIVES THEM AN UNFAIR ADVANTAGE
IN THE MARKETPLACE.
WHICH FORCES US TO AYE THEY'RE.
PAY THE FEES TO THOSE COMPANIES
TOE AND AS A RESULT RAISE OUR
PRICES OR OR SIMPLY.
YOU KNOW GIVE OUR CUSTOMERS.
FORCE OUR CUSTOMERS TO PAY
THOSE FEES THROUGH.
IT YOU KNOW DAY DID YOU DATA
USAGE FEES.
ADDITIONALLY THERE'S A SEPARATE
PROBLEM WITH A ZERO RATING EVEN
WENT UNPAID WHICH IS THAT OVER
THE RECENT YEARS THERE'S BEEN A
MOVE TO MOVE MORE AND MORE OF
THE TRAFFIC ON THE INTERNET TO
ENCRYPTED COMMUNICATION TO HTTP
US.
AND IT'S.
A REQUIREMENT OF ZERO RATING TO
BASICALLY UNMASK THAT TRAFFIC
CAN IDENTIFY IT TIES PIECE SO
THAT THEY CAN EXEMPTED FROM DATA
CAPS.
AND WE'RE VERY COMFORTABLE WITH
THE PRIVACY IMPLICATIONS OF
DOING THAT WE BELIEVE IN OF
MAINTAINING AND PROTECTING THE
PRIVACY OF OUR CUSTOMERS THE
GREATEST DEGREE THAT WE CAN. AND.
SO EVEN IN THE IN THE BEST CASE
IT REQUIRES SOME SIGNIFICANT
COMPROMISES TO ENABLE A ENABLE
THOSE THINGS. SO YOU KNOW I'M
HERE TODAY.
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
I THINK THAT IT'S ESSENTIAL FOR
PROTECTING THE A FREE AND OPEN
INTERNET WE'VE HAD THAT'S
ENABLED SUCH AMAZING INNOVATION
ESPECIALLY. IN A WHAT WE'VE SEEN
IN AND IN THE STATE AND. I
CERTAINLY HOPE THAT WE CANNOT
SEE
SEE IT BECOME LAW.
X. WITNESS.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS ROBERT AND
SHE VIC I'M A PROFESSOR AT
STANFORD LAW SCHOOL AND DIRECTOR
CENTER FOR INTERNET AND SOCIETY
HERE.
I'M A LAWYER WITH A PHD IN
COMPUTER SCIENCE.
I'M HERE AS AN INDEPENDENT
ACADEMIC WHO HAS WORKED ON NET
NEUTRALITY FOR SEVENTEEN YEARS.
THE FCC'S TWENTY TEN AND TWENTY
FIFTEEN OPEN INTERNET RULES
RELIED HEAVILY ON MY WORK. AS
DID THE INDIAN AND CANADIAN
ORDERS ON ZERO RATING AND THE
EUROPEAN UNION'S NET NEUTRALITY
GUIDELINES.
TODAY YOU HAVE AN AMAZING
OPPORTUNITY.
YOU CAN BRING BACK NET
NEUTRALITY TO CALIFORNIA AND
RESTORE THE IMPORTANT FCC
PROTECTIONS THAT WILL END ON
JUNE ELEVENTH.
THIS BILL IS WIDELY VIEWED AS AN
AND NEUTRALITY MODEL OF THE.
IT'S THE ONLY STATE OF A BILL
THAT FULLY RESTORE US ALL OF THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN NET NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS.
INCLUDING BOTH THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN RULES AND THE IMPORTANT
PROTECTIONS FROM THE TEXT OF THE
ORDER.
THAT'S WHY FCC CHAIRMAN TOM
WHEELER WHO LITERALLY WROTE THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN ORDERS SUPPORTS
THIS BILL. AND WHY NEWARK STATE
LAWMAKERS INTRODUCED AN ALMOST
VERBATIM COPY TWO WEEKS AGO.
IT'S WHITE SILICON VALLEY AND
THE NATIONAL PRESS A WATCHING
THIS BILL SO CLOSELY.
WITHOUT THIS BILL THE FCC'S
RADICAL DECISION TO ELIMINATE
ALL NET NEUTRALITY PROTECTIONS
WILL SEVERELY DAMAGE
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY.
THERE WILL BE FEW ESTADO UPS
FEWER SMALL BUSINESSES AND FEWER
MEDIA OUTLETS.
THAT MEANS FEWER JOBS AND LESS
TAX REVENUE.
IN SHORT. THE PRICE OF NOT
PROTECTING CALL FINANCE ECONOMY
FROM THE REPEAL OF NET
NEUTRALITY PROTECTIONS. WHICH
WORE OFF WHAT IT WOULD COST THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE TO
ENFORCE THE BILL IT'S BRIGHT
LINE RULES.
TODAY. THE INTERNET IS A SPACE
WHERE EVERY CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
OWNER AND ENTREPRENEUR. NO
MATTER THE COLOR OF THE SKIN OF
THE SIZE OF THE WALLETS HAS AN
EQUAL CHANCE OF REACHING PEOPLE
ONLINE.
IT'S A SPACE WHERE WE THE PEOPLE
NOT AGENCY OR COMCAST DETERMINE
WHAT SUCCEEDS IN OUR ECONOMY.
ALL OUR CULTURE AND OUR
DEMOCRACY.
I HOPE YOU WILL VOTE TO KEEP IT
THAT WAY.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION.
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES AND SUPPORT
HAS COME FORWARD.
HI I'M JUDY MAN CREW SO I SPENT
THE FIRST TWENTY YEARS OF MY
LIFE IN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY.
AND THE LAST TWELVE YEARS HAVE
BEEN A NONPROFIT SOCIAL
COMPASSION IN LEGISLATION AND
THIS IS HUGELY IMPORTANT TO US
AS A NONPROFIT AND IT'S IT
SHOULD BE EQUAL AND THREW OUT.
NO MATTER WHO YOU ARE DON'T MESS
WITH OUR BANDWIDTH AND THANK YOU.
SUPPORT THE BILL.
MO JOHN KREIDLER REPRESENTING
COMPUTER USING EDUCATORS THAT
CATERS TO KILL AND THEY
REPRESENT OVER TWENTY THOUSAND.
TEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS IN
CALIFORNIA.
WE'RE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
BILL AND IN FACT BECAUSE OF THE
IMPORTANCE FOR STUDENTS AND IT'S
IMPORTANT FOR KIDS TO BE ABLE TO
DO HOMEWORK SIXTY PERCENT OF
STUDENTS.
HAVE TO DO THEIR HOMEWORK ONLINE
WE ALSO WERE THE PRIME SPONSOR
FOR A BILL.
THANK YOU I'M LIMON MALL AND ON.
AJ ARE SEVEN WHICH
THE RESOLUTION RELATED BANK HERE.
SUPPORT OF HOMER CON.
BY THAT. TIME CRISTINA CAHILL
WITH INDIVISIBLE CALIFORNIA
STATE STRONG.
COALITION OF GRASSROOTS GROUPS
REPRESENTING OVER TWO HUNDRED
THOUSAND CONSTITUENTS AND WERE
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
I'M JULIE CHAPMAN WITH
INDIVISIBLE SACRAMENTO WE ABOUT
TWO THOUSAND MEMBERS AND WERE
STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
HELLO SANDRA FLUKE ON BEHALF OF
THE MEMBERS OF VOICES FOR
PROGRESS BUSINESS OWNERS WHO ARE
CONCERNED ABOUT COMPETITIVE
DISADVANTAGES BEING CREATED FOR
SMALL BUSINESS WITHOUT THIS BILL
ENTREPRENEURS WHO ARE VERY
CONCERNED ABOUT THE START UP. OF
COSTS AND BARRIERS TO ENTRY THAT
WOULD BE CREATED OTHERWISE AND
FINALLY PHILANTHROPISTS WHO ARE
CONCERNED ABOUT THE IMPACT ON
OUR DEMOCRACY IF UNPOPULAR IDEAS
ARE CENSORED BY ISPS.
THANK YOU SIR.
AND NOW YOU'RE TAX BRACKET.
MARY DOLAN WITH CAL STATE
UNIFICATION IN SUPPORT.
THE MORNING MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
JENNIFER FEARING ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
NONPROFITS AND UP WHICH IS A
POLICY ALLIANCE OF MORE THAN TEN
THOUSAND NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS
URGE YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU.
BOB.
GOOD MORNING MORNING CARB
ALTERNATIVE STRATEGY GROUP ON
BEHALF OF THE UTILITY REFORM
NETWORK AS WELL AS THE CONSUMER
FEDERATION OF CALIFORNIA AND
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU UP BEFORE WE GO TO.
AS AN ADDITIONAL WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
BEFORE WE ASK THE OPPOSITION TO
COME FOR A ONE TO ASK A COUPLE
QUESTIONS CENTER WIENER AND JUST
BECAUSE I WANT. THEM ANNOUNCED
THE SAME QUESTION FOR THE
OPPOSITION.
SO MANAGE SOMETHING IS THAT YOUR
BILL THE INTENT IS TO APPLY TO
THE TWENTY FIFTEEN OBAMA ERA.
IF THE FEE RULES RIGHT WHICH IS
A BALL. REGARDING THAT
NEUTRALITY AFRICA BUT HE'S DOING
BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA.
SO I'VE HEARD FROM THE OPPONENTS
THAT OPPONENTS CONTEND THAT IT
GOES BEYOND THOSE RULES. AND IT
STIFLES THE FREE MARKET SO CAN
YOU CLARIFY FOR ME.
ARE HOW THE ISSUE OF THE FEDERAL
RATING IN YOUR BILL COMPARISON
SPIRIT OF THE A BOMB OR ERA
RULES. AND WHAT ARE THE WHAT IF
WHAT ADDITIONAL THINGS ARE WE
ADDING TO YOUR BILL IF ANY.
THAT GO BEYOND THE OBAMA ERA
RULES I'M JUST TRYING TO. BE
ABLE.
I CAN GET MY HEAD AROUND AT THIS
ISSUE ABSOLUTELY DO MAKE THAT
CLAIM THEY ALSO CLAIM THAT NET
NEUTRALITY VIOLATIONS NEVER
HAPPENED WHICH IS ALSO
INACCURATE.
SO.
ON BOTH ZERO RATING AND.
ABUSIVE INTERCONNECTION
AGREEMENTS.
WERE INCLUDED IN THAT TWENTY
FIFTEEN FCC ORDER THEY'RE
ABSOLUTELY IN THEIR.
THEY INDICATED THAT THEY WOULD
BE.
JUDGING THEM ON A CASE BY CASE
BASIS AND WE ACTUALLY.
WITH RESOURCES ZERO RATING THE
FCC WITH STARTING TO GEAR UP
ENFORCEMENT OF WHEN DONALD TRUMP
TOOK OFFICE AND AND STOPPED AT
ENFORCEMENT SO THOSE ARE
ABSOLUTELY IN THEIR. EYES A
MENTION AT THE BEGINNING A
BECAUSE WE'RE NOT THE FCC.
WE HAVE TO DO IT IN A DIFFERENT
WAY.
AND SO WE HAVE DONE THE IN THE
IN THAT WE CAN DO IT EXACTLY THE
SAME WAY BUT BOTH OF THOSE
THINGS WERE ABSOLUTELY IN THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN. OF ORDER AND
PERHAPS PROFESSOR.
CAN I CLARIFY EVEN OFF FURTHER.
CURRENT THINK SO FOUR ZERO
RATING THE FCC IN ITS OPEN
INTERNET ORDER SAID THEY CAN
SOMETIMES BE GOOD AND SOMETIMES
YOU BATH AND THEREFORE WE LOOK
AT THEM CASE BY CASE.
AND.
AS SENATOR WE KNOW SAYS THE
PROBLEM IN TRYING TO TRANSLATE
THIS INTO THE CALIFORNIA
CONTEXTS IS THAT. YOU DON'T WANT
TO GIVE THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
UTILITIES COMMISSION BROUGHT.
SO IF LATITUDE TO TO ACT AS A
REGULATOR AND THE SPACE. AND THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS EXPRESSED A
STRONG PREFERENCE FOR BRIGHT
LINE RULES THAT A LOT EASIER AND
LESS COSTLY TO ENFORCE.
AND SO THE SOLUTION THAT SANTA
WE KNOW THIS BILL ADOPTS IS TO
SAY THESE KINDS OF SEER RATING A
CLEARLY HARMFUL SO THEY
EXPLICITLY PROHIBITED. THESE
KINDS OF ZERO RATING A CLEAR THE
ALLOWABLE AND SO THEY ARE
CLEARLY NOT HARMFUL SO THEY
EXPLICITLY ALLOWED AND THEN
THERE IS A GROUP OF ZERO RATING
PLANS THAT I MORE OFTEN GRAY
AREA. THEY REMAIN ALLOW IT.
BUT A SUBJECT TO CASE BY CASE
REVIEW BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN WHICH
ARE EXACT PRACTICES WILL BE
ALLOWED I'D BE HAPPY TO CAN YOU
PLEASE TO SAY YES OF COURSE.
SO THE TWO KINDS OF HARMFUL%
PRACTICES ARE THE FOLLOWING
SO THE FETUSES ZERO READING IN
EXCHANGE FOR PAYMENT FROM
WEBSITES AND SERVICES.
SO BASICALLY THESE ARE PLANTS
WHERE IT WAS WHERE INTERNET
SERVICE PROVIDERS LIKE EIGHTEEN
HERE CON BECAUSE MIGHT SAY HEY.
IF YOU PAY US A FEE FELLOW THEM
WE'RE NOT COUNTY DATA AGAINST
USES DATA CAPS.
TO THE REASONS THE BILL BANS THE
USE OF THESE PLANS IS THAT IT'S
BATES SEEKS THE THE FLIPSIDE OF
ONLINE FAST LANES.
YOU KNOW WITH THE ONLINE FAST
LANES WE ARE WORRIED THAT
COMPANY SINCE BECAUSE WITHOUT
DEEP POCKETS WILL NOT BE ABLE TO
PAY FOR A FAST LANE. AND AS A
RESULT THEY FIND IT HARDER TO
COMPETE AND BE HOOKED.
IT'S THE EXACT SAME THING IF
STARTUPS AND SMALL BUSINESSES ON
ABLE TO PAY FOR FAST LANE. THEY
ON ABLE BETA EXAM FROM DATA CAPS
EITHER. BUT THE KIND OF
ADVANTAGE FOR THE COMPETITIVE
ADVANTAGE OF BEING IN A FIVE
SALINAS COMPATIBLE TO THE
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE OF BEING
EXEMPTED FROM USES DATA CAPS. SO
BASICALLY THOUGH IT
JURISDICTIONS AROUND THE WORLD
THAT HAVE ADOPTED DETAILS YOUR
RATING PLANS INDIA.
AND CANADA HOUSE BAND THESE
FORMS OF SEWER RATING AS CLEARLY
HOMES THAT'S CATEGORY ONE.
CATEGORY TWO. ARMS ZERO RATING A
FEW APPLICATIONS AND BECAUSE OF
SIMILAR APPLICATION SO HERE'S
THE INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER
SELECT SWITCH APPLICATIONS TWO
ZERO RIGHT BUT THERE IS NO FEET.
SO FOR EXAMPLE A EIGHTEEN SHE
MIGHT STILL ZERO RATE DIRECT TV
ITS OWN ONLINE VIDEO APPLICATION
BUT IT COULD ALSO BE THAT
ANOTHER AYE AS PETER'S TO SITES
DETERIORATE FACEBOOK.
I'M SO DOESN'T HAVE YOU TO BE
YOUR OWN OUR APPLICATION. THAT
SUITS THE ESSENCE OF THE NET
NEUTRALITY APPLICATION AND
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER
PICKING WINNERS AND LOSERS.
THAT'S BECAUSE YOU KNOW THEY
WILL CHOOSE WHICH APPLICATIONS
DON'T COUNT AGAINST THE CAP AND
THEY WILL THEN HAVE A
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE. WHERE IS
THE OTHER APPLICATIONS THAT
DON'T COMPETE WITH THAT ARE IN
THE SAME CLASS THAT DIRECTLY
COMPETE?
WILL NOT WILL CONTINUE TO COUNT
AGAINST THE CAP AND THEREFORE
WILL FIND IT HARDER TO COMPETE
SO IT'S BASICALLY THE FLIPSIDE
OF SPEEDING UP.
FEW APPLICATIONS BUT NOT OTHER
COMPETING APPLICATION.
AND SO THE AIR AGAIN AND SEE IF
JURISDICTIONS AROUND THE WORLD
THAT HAVE.
I LOOK MORE DEEPLY INTO ZERO
RATED ZERO RATING HAVE
PROHIBITED. THESE FORMS OF
SENIOR RATING.
AND YOU KNOW JUST. ONE WAY TO
THINK ABOUT BE IT IT WOULD BE
LIKE WHAT FACEBOOK EXISTS TODAY
OF MY SPACE HAD BEEN ZERO RATED
YOU KNOW ICE FEES ARE LIKELY TO
PICK THE MOST POPULAR.
APPLICATIONS OF WEBSITES WHEN
THEY SAY IF VOLUNTARILY CHOOSE
TO ZERO EIGHT SOMETHING WITHOUT
PAYMENT AND SO THIS WOULD JUST
GIVE AN ADVANTAGE TO. INCUMBENTS
ALL POPULAR CONTENT BUT WILL
SORT OF HOOT. MINORITY VOICES
MARGINALIZED VOICES AND THAT
START UPS AND SMALL BUSINESSES
AND SO THE THIRD OPTION THE
THIRD. SCENARIO COMMUNITY THAT
OUT FOR ME WHERE IT'S GOALS CASE
BY CASE BASIS YEAH SO THOSE ARE.
CASES WHERE.
.
THE THOSE URANIUM PROGRAM IS
OPEN TO ALL APPLICATIONS IN A
CATEGORY AND THERE IS NO FEE
FROM THE H. PROVIDE. SO GOOD
EXAMPLES ARE TWO MORE VOTES
MUSIC FREEDOM AND BINGE ON
PROGRAM.
SOME OF THESE PROGRAMS ARE OPEN
TO ALL ONLINE MUSIC AND ONLINEVIDEO PROVIDERS THAT MEATY MORE
LET'S TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS.
AND THERE IS NO FEE FROM THE ON
A MUSIC ONLINE VIDEO PROVIDED TO
BE PART OF THE PROGRAM. SO THEY
ARE NOT AS HARMFUL AS YOUR
RATING FOR A FEE BECAUSE THEY
DON'T REQUIRE PAYMENT.
AND THEY ARE NOT AS HARMFUL AS
THE OTHER ON THE SECOND CATEGORY
BECAUSE IT'S AS LEAST OPEN TO
ALL APPLICATIONS AND A CATEGORY.
SO THAT'S WHY IT'S MORE FOR GRAY
AREA SO NOW YOU MIGHT US WHY
DON'T YOU JUST ALLOW THESE LIKE
OUT OF OUT OF THE GATE.
THE PROBLEM IS DOT YOU CAN
STRUCTURE THESE ARE PROGRAMS IN
WAYS THAT ARE STILL REALLY HAND
ANTI COMPETITIVE.
SO FOR EXAMPLE WHEN TO MOVE I
STARTED BINGE ON THE TECHNICAL
REQUIREMENTS WERE REALLY
SUBSTANTIAL.
AND MADE IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR QUITE
A BIT OF ONLINE VIDEO PROVIDERS
TO BE PART OF THE PROGRAM.
AND SO.
IT OFTEN TAKES A LONG TIME FOR
THE YEAR INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDER TO WORK WITH YOU TO TO
GET YOU INTO THE PROGRAM BECAUSE
AS. ANDREW MENTIONED IT'S NOT
TRIVIAL TO IDENTIFY AN
APPLICATION
YOU KNOW THE APPLICATION OFTEN
HAS TO MAKE CHANGES TO ITS
PROGRAM AND THE ICE HE HAS TO
WORK WITH THEM.
AND SO WHAT WE HAVE SEEN US. FOR
A SUMMIT TO MOBILE HAS OFTEN
ADDED LOTS POPULAR PROVIDERS
FIST Y. SMALL ONLINE MUSIC
SERVICES HAD TO WAIT A LONG TIME
TO BE KIND OF PART OF THE
PROGRAM LIKE ONE AND A HALF
YEARS.
WAS THE TIME IT TOOK A SMALL.
BUT VERY POPULAR MUSIC STATION
FROM SAN FRANCISCO TO BECOME
PART OF PINS ON.
SO WHAT I'M TRYING TO SAY AS DOT
IN THESE PROGRAMS EVEN THOUGH
THEY SOUND A LOT LESS
PROBLEMATIC. THERE IS STILL
SIGNIFICANT HURDLES FOR ONLINE
INNOVATION AND POTENTIALLY
SPEECH AND SO YOU WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
CAN INTERVENE IF SOMEONE.
MAKES IT SOUND AS IF THIS IS
READY OPEN BUT IN REALITY STILL
ESTABLISHES BIG ROADBLOCKS.
AND THEN FINAL CATEGORY WHAT'S
CLEAR LOUD AND I THINK THAT'S
IMPORTANT TO NOTICE TO. THERE IS
DE SO ZERO RATING PLANS WHERE
THERE IS NO FEE FROM THE EDGE
PROVIDERS. AND THEY ARE WHAT WE
CALL APPLICATION AGNOSTIC THEY
DON'T MAKE DISTINCTIONS AMONG
APPLICATIONS OR CLASSES OF
APPLICATIONS AND THE BEST
EXAMPLE IS WHAT CANADIAN EYES
FEASTED.
A LOT OF THEM ZERO RATE
EVERYTHING YOU DO YOU BETWEEN
MIDNIGHT AND SIX AM IN THE
MORNING.
THAT CAN BE REALLY GREAT FOR
CUSTOMERS IT'S LIKE THE
EQUIVALENT OF FREE NIGHT AND
WEEKEND MINUTES.
AND THEN YOU CAN SCHEDULE YOUR
BACKUPS TO THE CLOUD DURING THAT
TIME WITHOUT IT COUNTING AGAINST
YOUR CAP.
AND THEO THEY DON'T CREATE RAISE
ANY CONCERNS FOR USER CHOICE
OFFER APPLICATION INNOVATION AND
FREE SPEECH AND THEREFORE THE
BILL JUST.
EXPLICITLY ALLOWS THESE PROGRAMS.
AND SO BASICALLY ALL OF THESE
BRIGHT LINE RULES WERE NOT PART
OF THE TWENTY FIFTEEN ORDER. BUT
AS SENATOR WE KNOW SAID THE FCC
HOW IT'S TAKEN STEPS TO START
LOOKING AT SPECIFIC PRACTICES
BUT DOT PRODUCT THAT PROCESS WAS
STOPPED WHEN THE ELECTION
HAPPENED. GARNER.
OKAY SO THEY WERE THEY WERE IN
THEIR BOTTOMS CASE BY CASE AND
ON INTERCONNECTION. AGREEMENTS
IBISES ON THE MOST FAMOUS
INTERCONNECTION AGREEMENTS IS
ONE I'VE NETFLIX STARTED TO
EXPERIENCE DRAMATIC DEGRADATION
SO PEOPLE CAN ACCESS IT. I
EASILY AND ULTIMATELY PAID WE
DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH BUT
PRESUMABLY A PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL
BUT FEE.
SO THAT CUSTOMERS WERE ABLE TO
ACTUALLY ACCESS AYE NETFLIX AYE
AND EVEN THOUGH NETFLIX OF
COURSE NO ONE'S GONNA CRY FOR
THEM BECAUSE THEY HAVE AN
ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF MONEY. BUT
WHEN YOU ARE ONE OF THE SMALLER
COMPANIES IN THE WORLD AND
COMCAST AGENCY IS SAYING WELL IF
YOU WANNA REACH OUR CUSTOMERS
AND NOT HAVE TO AGREE THAT
SERVICE. ALL YOU NEED TO PASS A
FEE NOT EVERYONE'S GOING TO DO
THAT IT'S GONNA ALWAYS FAVORED
THE BIG COMPANIES OVER THE SMALL.
YOU PAY A FEE YOUR CUSTOMERS GET
BETTER ACCESS TO GET FASTER
SPEEDS THAT WILL THAT WILL FAVOR
THE THE BIG COMPANIES AND THE
START UPS AND I ADVOCACY
ORGANIZATIONS.
AT ALL THE PEOPLE CAMPAIGN A
LOT OF MONEY ARE GONNA BE OUT.
OKAY THANK YOU ANDERSON THANK
YOU FOR THE ADDITIONAL ARE.
ANSWERS THE QUESTION MISTER
MACHINIST ON THIS FULLY UP WHEN
THIS IS AN OPPOSITION PLEASE
COME FORWARD
.
WELCOME.
AB MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
CAROLINE MCINTYRE ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA CABLE AND
TELECOMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION
HERE IN OPPOSITION TO SB TO TO.
LET ME START BY SAYING THAT THAT
MEMBER OF THE CCT A ALL SUPPORT
IN OPEN AND ARE NOT.
WEEK COMPLETELY ARE COMMITTED
TO AND ENSURING THAT THE
INTERNET CONTINUES TO OPERATE AS
IT HAS FOR THE MANY YEARS THAT
THE ECONOMY THAT THE THE THE
INNOVATION ECONOMY HAS BEEN
ALLOWED TO THRIVE.
THE NEED TWENTY SEVENTEEN ORDER
HERE HAD WHICH HAS BEEN REFERRED
TO AS A FAD THE TRUMP ORDER.
ACTUALLY DID NOT ELIMINATE RULES
REGARDING HOW WE OPERATE THE
INTERNET IT'S SIMPLY RESTORED
THE SAME LIGHT TOUCH REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK THAT HAD BEEN IN PLACE
FOR TWENTY YEARS. PRIOR TO THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN ORDER BEING
ENACTED. IT IS THE SAME LIGHT
TOUCH REGULATORY FRAMEWORK UNDER
WE EACH IN THE APP ECONOMY AND
THE INTERNET INNOVATION ECONOMY
THAT WE KNOW TODAY HAS BEEN
ALLOWED TO THRIVE. SB EIGHT TO
TWO DOZEN FAT GO BEYOND THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN OBAMA ORDER. I'M
YOU'VE IDENTIFIED A COUPLE OF
THOSE AREAS BY CALLING APPLE
ZERO RATING. AND THE
INTERCONNECTION PROVISIONS.
I'D BUT IT
S. B. EIGHT TWO TWO ALSO IGNORES
THE FACT THAT THE TWENTY FIFTEEN
ORDER AND THE TWENTY SEVENTEEN
ORDER WHICH IS ABOUT TO TAKE A
FAT.
BOTH ALSO PRE EMPTED THE STATE'S
FROM BEING ABLE TO ENACT
LEGISLATION IN THIS SPACE
RECOGNIZING THAT THE INTERNET IS
IN FACT AN INTERSTATE SERVICE IT
IS VERY DIFFICULT. TO HAVE STATE
BY STATE PATCHWORK REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK I'M AND WILL
UNDOUBTEDLY RESULT IN
SIGNIFICANT LITIGATION. I THINK
THE COST OF THAT LITIGATION I'M
HAS NOT BEEN AND I RECOGNIZED IN
THE ANALYSIS I THINK THAT WOULD
BE OVER AND ABOVE WHAT HAS IN
FACT BEEN IDENTIFIED.
THE COST ASSOCIATED WITH
ENFORCING SBA TO TO.
AND THAT WOULD BE OSTS THAT IS
IS IN FACT RECOGNIZED.
IN THE ANALYSIS IS BY LOOKING
TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO
ENFORCE ITS PROVISIONS BUT IT
FAILS TO RECOGNIZE THAT THE BILL
ALSO ALLOWS FOR. A PRIVATE RIGHT
OF ACTION WHICH MEANS THAT JOHN
DOE CONSUMER MAY BRING FORTH
LAWSUITS IT ALSO FAILS TO
RECOGNIZE THAT FIFTY EIGHT
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS. MULTIPLE
CITY ATTORNEYS WILL ALSO HAVE
THE ABILITY TO PROSECUTE IN THIS
SPACE.
LASTLY THE BILL I'M ALSO
PROHIBITS A PROCUREMENT
CONTRACTS.
WITH ANY ENTITY THAT IS ALLEGED
TO HAVE VIOLATED ANY OF ITS
PROVISIONS THAT IN FACT IS A
OPPOSE ADMISSION THAT APPLIES TO
ALL PUBLIC ENTITIES ITS STATE
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT. AGAIN I
THINK.
FAILING TO RECOGNIZE THAT THERE
IS A COST ALSO ASSOCIATED WITH
LOCAL GOVERNMENT HAVING TO
ENFORCE IN THIS SPACE SO FOR
THOSE REASONS I WE REQUEST DIE
YOU'RE NO VOTE AND NOTE THAT
THIS BILL IS IN FACT NOT NEED IT.
SO I'M. CAROLYN CAN YOU JUST
READ SO THAT INVENTION OF DEPTH
THE PREEMPTION.
.
IN THE STATUTE WAS AND ALSO
ENACTED ETHICS PLACED TWENTY
SEVENTEEN USURPED TWENTY
SEVENTEEN ORDER AND THE TWENTY
FIFTEEN ORDER AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL OR BOTH.
EXPLICITLY PREEMPTED THE STATES
FROM ENACTING ADDITIONAL RULES
AND REGULATION THE PRIVATE RIGHT
OF ACTION IS SOMETHING THAT'S
THE PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION IS
IN FACT SOMETHING THAT IS
AUTHORIZED UNDER STATE LAW. E.
AND IS IN FACT PERMITTED UNDER
THE SPELL OKAY THANK YOU I'M
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE I GET ALL
THIS CORRECT. CORRECT MISTER
CHAIR MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS BILL
DIVIDE AND I REPRESENT EIGHTEEN
T..
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
BE HERE TODAY.
JUSTICE CAROLYN TESTIFIED WE
SUPPORTED OPEN INTERNET WE DO
NOT BLOCK WEBSITES WE DO NOT
THROTTLE TRAFFIC.
AND WE DO NOT CENSOR ONLINE
CONTENT THESE COMMITMENTS ARE
PUBLISHED ON OUR WEBSITE THEIR
ENFORCEABLE BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT AS WELL AS BY THE
CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY GENERAL. BUT
WE ARE HERE TO OPPOSE S. B.
EIGHT TWENTY TWO.
AND I WANT TO EMPHASIZE S. B.
EIGHT TWENTY TWO AS YOU JUST
HEARD FROM THE PROPONENTS.
IS NOT THE TWO THOUSAND AND
FIFTEEN OBAMA FCC ORDER IT GOES
FAR BEYOND THAT.
BUT TODAY I'D LIKE TO FOCUS ON
THE COST WHICH IS THE
JURISDICTION OF THIS COMMITTEE.
AG A TWENTY TWO IS REALLY BUILT
UPON SPECULATION
SPECULATION THAT SOMEBODY
SOMEWHERE SOMETIME IN THE FUTURE
MIGHT VIOLATE NET NEUTRALITY
RULES. AND DESPITE THE
ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY OF THE
CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY GENERAL.
CALIFORNIA MUST NOW START TO
REGULATE THE INTERNET.
SO HERE'S A QUESTION HERE SOME
ISSUES RELATED TO COST
WE CREATE SIGNIFICANT NEW COSTS
IN THIS BILL INCLUDING STATE
MANDATES ON LOCAL AGENCIES IN
CALIFORNIA.
FIRST EIGHT TWENTY TWO REQUIRES
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL AS YOU'VE
ALREADY HEARD TO REVIEW
COMPLAINTS.
AND. EXAMINE ALLEGED VIOLATIONS
OF THIS BILL IS VERY COMPLEX
AND CONFUSING PROVISIONS THERE
WILL BE A SIGNIFICANT FISCAL
IMPACT THEIR. SECOND EIGHT
TWENTY TWO REQUIRES EVERY PUBLIC
ENTITY AND THAT'S A QUOTE EVERY
PUBLIC ENTITY STATE AND LOCAL
THAT PURCHASES OF. SERVICE FROM
AN ISP TO DETERMINE BEFORE
AWARDING A CONTRACT
WHETHER THE I SP IS COMPLIANT
WITH A TWENTY TWOS PROVISIONS.
STATE AND LOCAL ENTITIES WILL BE
REQUIRED TO EVALUATE ISP
COMPLIANCE WITH THE BILL.
THROUGHOUT THE LIFE OF THE
CONTRACT
FURTHER IF AN AGENCY FOGLIGHTS
JUST THE AGENCY FINDS A THE ISP
IS VIOLATED THEIR INTERPRETATION
OF NET NEUTRALITY RULES. THE
AGENCY MAKE DECLARE THE CONTRACT
AVOID AND REQUIRE REPAYMENT OF
MONIES FOR SERVICES RENDERED.
EIGHT TWENTY TWO IS A NEW STATE
MANDATE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT TO
ENFORCE NET NEUTRALITY RULES ON
ALL LOCAL AGENCIES THAT PURCHASE
BROADBAND SERVICE.
THE FISCAL IMPACT ON AGENCIES OF
DEVELOPING THE EXPERTISE
CREATING NEW ENFORCEMENT TOOLS
ONGOING COMPLIANCE RULES REVIEWS
I SHOULD SAY THROUGHOUT THE LIFE
OF THE CONTRACT. AND
INVESTIGATIONS AND FRANKLY
LITIGATION WILL INCREASE
CONTRACTING COST TO THE STATE
AND LOCAL AGENCIES.
AND THE COSTS DON'T END THERE SP
EIGHT TWENTY TWO IMPOSES
ADDITIONAL SIGNIFICANT COSTS AS
WELL FOR EXAMPLE CAROLYN SPOKE
TO THE ISSUE OF PREEMPTION.
A TWENTY TWO IS PREEMPTED BY
FEDERAL LAW EVEN THE FCC THAT'S
REFERRED TO BY SENATOR WIENER
THE OBAMA FCC. PREEMPTED STATE
ACTION IN THIS SPACE IN FACT THE
LAST FOUR ADMINISTRATIONS.
I RECOGNIZE THE INTERNET ISN'T
INTERSTATE SERVICE
AND INCLUDED FEDERAL PREEMPTION
IN ALL NET NEUTRALITY ORDERS.
MEMBERS EIGHTEEN T. WILL RESULT
IN INCREASED LITIGATION COSTS TO
THE STATE. INCREASED COMPLIANCE
COST AT AGENCIES AND INCREASED
COST OF ENFORCEMENT.
THE INEVITABLE DELAYS IN
INNOVATION AND INVESTMENT IN
BROADBAND NETWORKS
AND IN A TWENTY TWO WILL BE
CHALLENGED IN THE COURTS AND
DELAYED THE ROLLOUT OF THE
INTERNET IN CALIFORNIA.
ONE HALLMARK OF THE INTERNET IS
THAT WE CANNOT ANTICIPATE.
WHAT INNOVATION IS COMING NEXT
NOR CAN CONSUME WHAT CONSUMERS
WILL EMBRACE?
AND WE MOST CERTAINLY CANNOT
PREDICT THE SPEED OF THAT
INNOVATION. EIGHT TWENTY TWO
CREATES REGULATORY COMPLIANCE AT
A LITIGATION ENVIRONMENT THAT IS
HARMFUL TO STAY CALIFORNIA WE
URGE YOU OPPOSE A TWENTY TWO.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL ONE IS IN
THE NATURE MEMBERS STEVE CARLSON
FOR US HE QUE WERE THE WIRELESS
TRADE ASSOCIATION NOT A LOT TO
ADD FROM MY COLLEAGUES HAD SAID.
.
WE BELIEVE AND I THINK THE
WITNESS'S TESTIMONY REALLY
POINTED OUT THAT.
THIS GOES WELL BEYOND THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN ORDER WELL WE
HAVE TO DO IT DIFFERENTLY
BECAUSE WE'RE NOT THE FCC WELL I
THINK THAT THAT ALMOST ANSWERED
THE QUESTION ITSELF SO WELL
HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
BUT.
PROPOSED.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION PLEASE STATE YOUR
NAME AND ORGANIZATION.
MISTER CHAIRMAN CHRIS MCKAY WE
ON BEHALF OF THE COMPUTING
TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
IN OPPOSITION.
CHAIR MEMBERS JOHN DORY ON
BEHALF THE CIVIL JUSTICE
ASSOCIATION A CALIFORNIA
CONCERNED ABOUT THE PRIVATE
RIGHT OF ACTION GOING FROM ONE
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY TO THOUSANDS.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR NOVA.
I LIMITS SOME BE HALF OF
CONSOLIDATED COMMUNICATIONS IN
OPPOSITION.
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS HIDING
PERSONALLY ON BEHALF OF VERIZON
ALSO IN OPPOSITION.
ERIC HARRIS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
NAACP IN OPPOSITION.
YOU WANNA BENSON ON BEHALF OF
CAL CALM SERVING RURAL
CALIFORNIA FOR RURAL CALIFORNIA
WHICH IS ALREADY HIGH COST TO
SERVE. THIS WILL ADD ADDITIONAL
COSTS THAT WE JUST CAN'T BEAR.
CHRISTY RECENT GRAVITY MOBILE IN
OPPOSITION.
I REQUEST YOU HAVE HAVE A
COMCAST IN OPPOSITION.
DOMINIC TOMORROW HERE ABOUT OF
FRONTIER COMMUNICATE
COMMUNICATIONS IN OPPOSITION.
NANCY MERGED WITH THE CONGRESS
OF CALIFORNIA SENIORS IN
OPPOSITION.
DUNCAN PRESSURES ON BEHALF OF
CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS AND
OPPOSITION.
BRENDA PALOMINO BEHALF OF SPRINT
OPPOSITION.
THREE PEOPLE WHO MAY HAVE
OCCURRED IN LAST OPPOSITION.
FOOD ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE IN
OPPOSITION.
JUST OF ALL BEHALF OF TECH THAT
IN OPPOSITION.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE WILL FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
SENATOR BATES AYE YES SENATOR
WIENER AYE WHAT I'VE HEARD. FROM
MANY NOT JUST THOSE WHO ARE HERE
OPPOSING AT ABOUT THAT THERE'S A
CONCERN THAT. AS WOULD TRAVEL
THE THE.
UNITED STATES NOW AND.
EVERY. AYE JURISDICTION HAS A
DIFFERENT WAY OF INTERPRETING
THE OFF LINE CREATING OUT. YOU
KNOW A NEW SYSTEM THAT YOU COULD
POSSIBLY HAVE TO CARRY A BUNCH
OF DIFFERENT CELL PHONES COULD
YOU RESPOND ABOUT. ARE WE HAVE A
BUNCH OF DIFFERENT RULES AND IN
EVERY JURISDICTION.
I DON'T THINK THAT'S THE CASE
BUT LET'S BE.
I WANNA BE REALLY CRYSTAL CLEAR
HERE IN HIS ISRAEL PEOPLE I WORK
WITH AND PEOPLE I THINK VERY
VERY HIGHLY OF AND AND IT'S AN
INDUSTRY THAT I WORK WITH SUSAN
IS NOT ABOUT DEMONIZING AN
INDUSTRY.
THE TELECOM AND CABLE INDUSTRIES
MADE A CHOICE
WHEN DONALD TRUMP TOOK OFFICE
THEY SAW AN OPPORTUNITY AND THEY
WENT IN AND THEY OPEN LIBERATED.
THE NET NEUTRALITY RULES BEEN
JUST GO BACK TO TWENTY TWO THE
PRE TWENTY FIFTEEN. THEY GOT RID
OF THEM ENTIRELY THEY GOT THE
FCC TO SAY WE NO LONGER HAVE A
ROLE HERE WHATSOEVER.
THE INDUSTRY MADE THAT CHOICE WE
WOULD ALL PREFER TO HAVE.
FEDERAL UNIFORM THAT NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS.
BUT THOSE WERE GOOD INDUSTRY
MADE A CHOICE TO GET TRUMP'S FCC
TO GET RID OF THOSE PROTECTIONS.
SO WE NOW ARE LEFT WITH
REGULATING TIS AT THE STATE
LEVEL.
I WOULD LOVE. FOR CONGRESS AND
THE PRESIDENT OF THE FCC TO ACT.
TO A.
TAKE THE TWENTY FIFTEEN ORDER
AND PUT IT BACK IN PLACE. IF
THEY WON'T DO IT WE HAVE TO DO
IT HERE.
AND I ALSO DON'T THINK IT'S
PREEMPTED.
BUT THE FCC DOES NOT HAVE THE
POWER TO PREEMPT STATE ACTION
AND HAVE LOST THAT ARGUMENT IN
COURT BEFORE AND CONGRESS HAS
NOT. PREEMPTED STATE MENTALITY
PROTECTIONS.
THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL
COMMENTS.
FOR QUESTIONS.
CREEK SENT BY ABILITY TO ONE OF.
ASK A QUESTION. I'VE NOT AND I
JUST WANT TO MAKE AN OBSERVATION
MISTER CHAIRMAN IF I MAY.
OF THE.
CURRENT FCC OF FOR THE FIRST
FOR THE FIRST EIGHTEEN YEARS OF
THE INTERNET.
THE.
ARE THE INTERNET WAS TREATED AS
QUOTE AN INFORMATION SERVICE BY
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND THAT
WAS ENTITLED WON THE TWO
THOUSAND FIFTEEN ORDER MOVED THE
INTERNET FROM TITLE ONE AND
INFORMATION SERVICE AND RE
DEFINED IT AS A
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICE. AND
MOVED IT INTO TITLE TO THAT WAS
THE SECTION THAT REGULATED
TELEPHONE MONOPOLIES SINCE THE
NINETEEN THIRTIES.
TOTALLY INAPPROPRIATE WHAT THE
CURRENT FCC DID WAS TO MOVE IT
BACK THE TITLE ONE AND IT DIDN'T
INCLUDE RULES RELATED TO
TRANSPARENCY THAT ARE FULLY
ENFORCEABLE. AS A ROOM FOR
CELERITY FIGURED SONIC SURE I
GIVE CENTER WE ARE OPPORTUNITY
TO RESPOND IF YOU HAVE. HERE AND
I ARE THE PROFESSOR CAN REBUT
THAT COMMENT BECAUSE WE DON'T
THINK YEAH I JUST THINK THAT
IT'S GONNA BE ABLE TO GIVE YOU A
COUPLE TIMES I KNOW THIS IS A
VERY.
YOU KNOW COMPLICATED BILL SO
MAKE SURE THE COMMITTEE FOLKS
HAVE ALL THE DATA AND
INFORMATION.
GO HAVE TO THEIR VOTE THERE ARE
TWO DIFFERENT ASPECTS THAT YOU
WANT TO KEEP SEPARATE IN YOUR
MIND ONE IS THE ACTUAL NET
NEUTRALITY RULES AND THE SECOND
ONE IS THE LEGAL FOUNDATION FOR
THE NET NEUTRALITY RULES.
IN TERMS OF ACTION AND YOU CHILD
WHO RULES THE FCC IS ELIMINATING
THE TWENTY FIFTEEN RULES THAT
DOESN'T BRING US BACK TO WHERE
WE WERE BEFORE TWENTY FIFTEEN
BEFORE BECAUSE BEFORE TWENTY
FIFTEEN WE HAD THE TWENTY TENDED
NEUTRALITY GROUPS WHEN I COME
BACK TO THOSE.
WE DON'T EVEN GOING BACK TO
BEFORE WE WERE WHERE WE WERE
BEFORE TWENTY TEN BECAUSE. SINCE
TWO THOUSAND FIVE WE HAD WHAT
WAS CALLED THE INTERNET POLICY
STATEMENT. WHICH WAS A STATEMENT
OF PRINCIPLES BY THE FCC USERS
HAVE THE RIGHT TO USE THE
APPLICATIONS OF THAT CHOICE TO
ACCESS A CONTINENT THAT CHOICE
TO ATTACH THE DEVICES OF THEIR
CHOICE TO THE NETWORK. AND THE
FCC HAD SAID WHILE THE SUN NOT
FORMAL RULES WE WILL NOT
HESITATE TO INTERVENE AND
ENFORCE THESE PRINCIPLES IF YOU
VIOLATE THEM BASED ON.
LEGAL AUTHORITY UNDER SECTION
ONE TITLE ONE OF THE
COMMUNICATIONS ACT AND WHEN
CONTEST DID VIOLATE THESE
PRINCIPLES. THE FCC IMMEDIATELY
INTERVENED AND ENFORCED.
THESE PRINCIPLES
AND EVEN BEFORE TWO THOUSAND
FIVE WE HAD NAY NEUTRALITY
PROTECTIONS BASED ON. TITLE TO
FOR IDEAS ON NETWORKS AND THEN
EVEN BEFORE THAT ON THE
TECHNOLOGY SO THAT'S THE NET
NEUTRALITY PIECE AND THE YEAR
THE FCC IS ELIMINATING ALL
SUBSTANTIVE PROTECTIONS AND THAT
BRINGS US TO A PLACE WHERE WE
HAVE NEVER BEEN.
SO WHAT I'M IS THE AGENCY
REPRESENTATIVE IS TALKING ABOUT
IS THE LEGAL FOUNDATION FOR THE
NET NEUTRALITY RULES.
THERE HE SAYS.
THE INTERNET WAS NEVER SUBJECT
TO TITLE TO THIS IS INACCURATE.
UNTIL TWO THOUSAND FIVE.
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDED OVER
BROADBAND NETWORKS WAS SUBJECT
TO TITLE TO OFF THE
COMMUNICATIONS ACT.
AND THAT WAS ACTUALLY HUGELY
IMPORTANT BECAUSE WHEN. BUT YES
ALL PROVIDER CALLED MADISON
RIVER STARTED BLOCKING.
INTERNET TELEPHONY APPLICATION
BONDAGE AND TWO THOUSAND THREE
TWO THOUSAND FOR. THE FCC ON A
REPUBLICAN CHAIRMAN POWELL
IMMEDIATELY INTO THE IN BASED ON
TITLE TO DIRECTLY.
AND STOPPED THE BLOCKING OFF
ONLINE SO I FOR ME AND THAT WAS
IT CITED TITLE TO SO I AM
TOTALLY NOT MAKING THIS UP.
AND THEN FROM TWO THOUSAND TWO
TO TWO THOUSAND FIVE TO TWENTY
FIFTEEN.
IT'S CORRECT THAT ALL INTERNET
SERVICE OVERBROAD BEEN WAS
SUBJECT TO TITLE TO BUT THAT'S.
TWO TITLE ONE OF THE
COMMUNICATIONS ACT.
BUT THAT'S TRULY IRRELEVANT FOR
THE PURPOSES OF OUR DISCUSSION
HERE BECAUSE YOU KNOW I'M NOT
WORRYING ABOUT THE LEGAL
FOUNDATION YOU ADOPTING A BILL
THAT DIRECTLY APPLIES NINE
NEUTRALITY RULES.
AND THE OTHER QUESTION IS NOT
CITY OF ARE WE GOING BACK TO
WHERE WE WERE BEFORE TWENTY
FIFTEEN NO WE ARE NOT GREAT
THANK YOU RIGHT THAT IN A BAND
APOLOGIZE TOOK COMMITTEE. AND
CHRIS HAVE A SOMETIMES WE GET
ALL THE INFORMATION FROM BOTH
SIDES AS WERE DELIVERING A VERY
COMPLEX.
ISSUE.
SO I BUT THANK YOU FOR THAT. BY
SENATOR WIENER WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
I THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
I ALSO I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
INDULGENCE IN THIS HEARING AND
FOR YOUR REALLY TRYING TO FLUSH
OUT THE ISSUES I VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE IT. I'D SO STUCK A
COUPLE OF SMALL THINGS.
.
THAT WITH RESPECT TO PRIVATE
RIGHT OF ACTION BUT THEY'RE
OBJECTING TO. I'VE DIED INCLUDES.
WE BELIEVE THE ENTIRETY OF CRY
RIGHT OF ACTION AND THAT'S
BEFORE SIXTY PERCENT ARE DALY ON
THAT THE CAN OUT OF THIS
COMMITTEE. US IS NOT GO BEYOND
THE PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION.
ANYWAY. ON I ALSO.
RESPECTED EACH IN CITIES
STATEMENT OUT THERE BUT THIS IS
LIKE THIS THEORETICAL FANTASY
ART THERE MIGHT BE IN THE FUTURE
VIOLATIONS UNDER TRIAL ATTY. AYE
THERE IS A LONG LASTING FOR
HAPPY TO PROVIDE A INCLUDING ONE
AND.
AGENCY BLOCKED US GUY. WHEN I
EIGHTEEN TO SPRINT VERIZON
BLOCKED GOOGLE WALLET.
WHEN EACH INTO.
I INDICATED IT WOULD DISABLE
SPACE TIME.
SO WE HAVE AND AND NOT SUCH A
FEW EXAMPLES ON PICKING ON
AGENCIES IS BECAUSE MOST OF THE
TIME AT THE CON THAT.
BUT THEY'VE THEY'VE ALL DONE AT
ONE POINT OR ANOTHER SO IT'S NOT.
A THEORETICAL MODEL AND SINCE TO
BE REAL CLEAR POT DE ICED TEAS.
ABOUT WHAT THEY'RE ADVOCATING
FOR. I BEAR ADVOCATING.
.
WIPING AWAY THE OBAMA ORDER AND
NOW OPPOSES TO OTHER ADVOCATING.
THAT THEY SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO
BLOCK WEBSITES
BUT AGE SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO
HAVE A FAST LANE AND A SLOW LANE
DEPENDING ON WHO PAYS MORE. OR
LESS. A THEY'RE ADVOCATING DIED
FILO THIS START UP VIDEO
STREAMING COMPANY SIXTEEN TO
TWENTY DOLLARS A MONTH.
COMPETING AGAINST MUCH MORE
EXPENSIVE.
AYE IN A TNT PLANS I SHOULD BE
ABLE TO BE A STYLE BECAUSE THEY
ARE SUBJECT TO ZERO RATING AND
THEY HAVE TO USE THAT DATA. ODD
SO I THIS IS AN IMPORTANT ISSUE
AND MISTER CHAIRMAN I APPRECIATE
IT.
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK.
THIS COME OF SUSPENSE AND GO TO
THE FLOOR THANK YOU. THANK YOU
AGAIN I WANT TO THANK BOTH THE
OPPOSITION AND SUPPORT FOR
INDULGING THE COMMITTEE AS WE
CONTINUE TO HAVE.
THIS DIALOGUE DURING THE
SUSPENSE ABOUT FILE.
BY THAT TIME TIMEFRAME WITHOUT
SO THAT WITHOUT OBJECTION MOVE
THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE FAR.
THANK YOU.
SENATE MCGUIRE IS COMPOSED.
WHERE IS?
PROBLEMS.
I JUST.
THANK YOU SIR MCGUIRE.
YOU WAVING ON YOUR ITEMS AND I
BELIEVE YOU'RE PRESENTING ON
TEST POTENTIALLY NINE.
ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU PLEASE GO
AHEAD MUCH DO APPRECIATE IT
MISTER CHAIR I KNOW YOU'VE HAD A
LONG HEARING I'VE BEEN A VICE
CHAIR IS WELL I IN GRATEFUL TO
BE HERE. AND THANK YOU FOR
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT TODAY ON
IS BETWEEN TWENTY NINE THE GREAT
RIVER TRAIL ACT AND YES WE ARE
WAITING ALL OTHERS. I JUST OR
YOU VERY QUICKLY.
THE CURB RAILROAD RUNS THROUGH
FIVE FIVE OF THE SEVEN COUNTIES
IN NORTH COAST DISTRICTS I'M
HONORED TO BE ABLE TO WORK.
IN EVERY DAY MENDOCINO SINAMA
MARINE HUMBLE IN TRINITY
SO WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT IS
ESSENTIALLY FROM THE CENSUS CHO
BAY ALL THE WAY UP TO THE
HUMBOLDT BAY RIGHT HERE.
WHICH IS A SPECTACULAR PIECE OF
EARTH THERE ON THE NORTH COAST.
AYE AFTER MONTHS OF RESEARCH AND
DISCUSSION LAST YEAR WE WERE
SADDENED TO CONCLUDE THAT
REBUILDING MUCH OF WHAT THIS
PREVIOUS RAIL WAS WAS SIMPLY NOT
FEASIBLE. IT WAS NOT A FEASIBLE
ALTERNATIVE BOTH FINANCIALLY OR
PHYSICALLY. THE REMOTENESS OF
THE LINE THE LACK OF SHIPPERS IN
THE EXTREME GEOTECHNICAL
CHALLENGES ALL COMBINE TO MAKE
RAIL IMPOSSIBLE ON A LARGE
SECTION OF THIS LINE.
AT THIS POINT NORTH COAST
RAILROAD AUTHORITY HAS NO
ABILITY TO DEAL WITH THESE
PROBLEMS
THEY HAVE RACKED UP SUFFOCATING
DEBT THEY VIRTUALLY AT THEY HAVE.
VIRTUALLY NO STAFF THE TRACKS IN
CROSS SCENES ARE DISINTEGRATING
OR IN THE RIVER AND THEY ARE
LISTED THAT IS IN THE END.
WE NOW HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
REMAKE THIS RIGHT AWAY DO
SOMETHING SPECTACULAR FROM THE
NORTH COAST AND THE REST OF THE
WORLD. AND THAT IS WHY.
WE ARE BEFORE YOU HERE TODAY
THE NCR A WILL BE DISSOLVED
THROUGH S. B. TEN TWENTY NINE IN
A THREE HUNDRED MILE LONG RIGHT
AWAY.
I DID ROUGHLY AT THE HALFWAY
POINT THE SOUTHERN SEGMENT
RUNNING FROM CINEMA WILLITS WILL
BE TRANSFERRED TO THE SNOW
MEMORY NEARER RAIL TRANSIT
AGENCY.
WHICH WAS CREATED BY A VOTERS
SEVERAL YEARS AGO AND IS
RESPONSIBLE FOR PASSENGER TRAIL
A TRAIN IN REAL. AYE IN THEY'LL
BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE FREIGHT
AND PASSENGER RAIL OPERATION IN
FOR CREATING THE SOUTHERN
SECTION OF THE GREAT REDWOOD
TRAIL. THE ANALYSIS DOES A GREAT
JOB OF HIGHLIGHTING THE EXTREME
ISSUES WITHIN CRA THAT WE'RE
SEEKING TO RESOLVE. AND MOST OF
THE COSTS AND LIABILITIES
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS BILL ARE
ALREADY WITH IN CRA AND THE
CURRENT TRACKS.
BUT I I IN THE CURRENT TRACKS
THIS BILL JUST BEGINS RESOLVING
THEM ONCE AND FOR ALL.
UNDER THE AMENDMENTS THAT WERE
SUBMITTING TO YOUR COMMITTEE
TODAY MISTER CHAIR THE NORTHERN
SEGMENT FROM WILLITS ARCADIA
WILL BE TRANSFERRED DIRECTLY TO
THE NEWLY CREATED GREAT REDWOOD
TRAIL AGENCY AND NOT TO THE
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION.
THE G. RTA WILL BE RESPONSIBLE
FOR RAIL BANKING THE RAILROAD
AND CREATING THE TRAIL.
WELL WE'VE BEEN WORKING HARD ON
THIS PROJECT OVER THE PAST YEAR
THERE ARE STILL MANY DETAILS
MANY DETAILS TO BE WORKED OUT
AMONGST THE PARTIES.
BUT FOR THE FIRST TIME IN
DECADES EVERYONE IS AT THE TABLE
TO HELP CREATE A BETTER FUTURE
FOR THIS AMAZING RIGHT AWAY. AND
I WOULD GREATLY APPRECIATE THE
COMMITTEE'S WILLINGNESS TO LET
US PROCEED.
WE'VE TREMENDOUS SUPPORT ACROSS
THE STATE IN THE DISTRICT BUT
THERE ARE CONCERNS FROM
LANDOWNERS ADJACENT TO THE RIGHT
AWAY.
I A AND WE ARE CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH EACH AND EVERY LANDOWNER
WHO CONTACTS.
THIS IS EXPECTED BY THE WAY
ANYTIME THAT A POTENTIAL TRAIL
OF BECOMING CLOSE TO A PIECE OF
PROPERTY THERE WILL BE CONCERNS
AND WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
COOPERATIVELY WITH THE
LANDOWNERS.
OUR BELIEF IS THIS OUR BELIEF
IS TO DO THIS PROJECT RIGHT NOT
FAST.
IN CLOSING MISTER CHAIR AND I
DON'T USUALLY DO THIS BUT I'D
LIKE TO QUICKLY OF MENTION MY
EXTREME DISAPPOINTMENT IN THE
STATE FARM BUREAU ON THIS BILL.
THEY'RE USUALLY WONDERFUL TO
WORK WITH
THEIR LETTER OF OPPOSITION CAME
AS AN ABSOLUTE.
SURPRISE
THE LAST THING WE HEARD FROM
THEM WAS THAT THEY ARE GOING TO
KEEP WORKING WITH US.
THEIR GRASP OF THE COMPLEX AND
LONG TERM ISSUES OF THIS BILL
SEEMS TENUOUS AT BEST.
AGAIN THEY SAID THEY'D KEEP
MEETING WITH US BUT THEY DID THE
EXACT OPPOSITE.
AFTER MEETING WITH THEM TO
DISCUSS THE LEGISLATION THE FARM
BUREAU OFFERED OUR OFFICE
AMENDMENTS THAT REPLACE
VIRTUALLY EVERY LINE OF THE BILL.
AND INSTEAD PUT IN PLACE A
BUREAUCRACY WITH AN EXPENSIVE ON
WORKABLE AND UNINFORMED PROCESS.
AS THE MEMBER WITH THE RULE
DISTRICT IN SOMEBODY WAS WORK
CLOSELY WITH THE FARM BUREAU FOR
WELL OVER A DECADE ON NOT ONLY
DISAPPOINTED BUT CONCERNED ABOUT
THEIR UNDERSTANDING OF THE
ISSUES WE ARE WORKING SO HARD TO
RESOLVE.
WE'LL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
LOCAL LANDOWNERS A LOCAL FARM
BUREAUS ON THE ISSUES THAT ONE
ACTUALLY ARISE FROM PEOPLE WHO
ONLY IN THE LONG A PUBLIC RIGHT
OF WAY EASEMENTS. BUT THIS
APPROACH CAME OUT OF LEFT FIELD
LEFT FIELD AND IT'S HARD TO
COMPREHEND WHY THEIR
REPRESENTATIVE WOULD TAKE THIS
APPROACH.
FINALLY WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON
AMENDMENTS AND WE LOOK FORWARD
TO WORKING WITH YOUR STAFF AYE
AS THE BILL SITS ON SUSPENSE.
I HAVE WITH ME TODAY.
JACQUELINE WHOSE IP CAMPION
WHO'S IT REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
COMMISSION STEVE WALLACH
REPRESENT THE CINEMA RAINY OR
RICK MARINE AREA RAIL TRANSIT
AUTHORITY AS WELL AS PAUL MASON
FROM THE PACIFIC.
AREA TRUSTS FORCE TRUST.
MADAM CHAIR.
A KEY SENATOR I'LL WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT YOU HAVE THOSE HERE.
REFUSE TO BALK ON BEHALF THE
CINNAMON ORDINARY REAL TRANSIT.
DOUBT DISTRICT HOURS STRONG
SUPPORT THIS BILL WE THINK IT'S
A CRITICAL PIECE IN ORDER TO
PRESERVE THIS RIGHT AWAY IN THIS
THE RAIL SERVICE IN THAT AREA
SMART HIS BROAD THE FIGHTING
RAIL. PASSENGER SERVICE SINCE
LAST YEAR.
RATIO HAS EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS
WERE UNIQUELY QUALIFIED TO
ACCEPT HIS ASSETS.
BUT WE FEEL THAT THIS BILL IS
NECESSARY IN ORDER TO PRESERVE
NOT ONLY FOR WHAT OUR MEDIA
GOALS ARE WAS SMART BUT IN THE
LONG TERM.
FOR FREIGHT RAILS WAS PASSED TO
REFER OTHER UP TO THIS COURT OR
SO WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT.
ADDITIONAL ENOUGH ON SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON JACQUELINE
CAMPION WITH THE CALIFORNIA
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION. SP
TEN TWENTY NINE PRESENTS A
VEHICLE TO ADDRESS ONGOING
CONCERNS REGARDING THE FUTURE
AND VIABILITY. OF THE NORTH
COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY AND
PROTECTION OF THE IMPORTANT
STATE RESOURCES THAT HAVE BEEN
ENTRUSTED TO IT. IN JUNE TWENTY
SEVENTEEN AND SEE ARES STATED IN
A PRESENTATION TO THE COMMISSION
THAT IT WAS UNABLE TO. PROPERLY
MAINTAIN AND EXPAND ITS RAIL
SERVICE IT HAS NEVER BEEN SELF
SUFFICIENT AND IT HAS BEEN
UNABLE TO PAYITS OBLIGATIONS.
IN RESPONSE TO THIS INFORMATION
THE COMMISSION INCLUDED IN ITS
TWENTY SEVENTEEN ANNUAL REPORTS
THE LEGISLATURE. A
RECOMMENDATION TO FORM A
COMMITTEE OF STAKEHOLDERS TO
OVERSEE DEVELOPMENT OF A PLAN
FOR THE FUTURE OF THE
STATUTORILY CREATED ENTERPRISE
WE BELIEVE THAT S. B. TEN TWENTY
NINE PROVIDES OF PATH FORWARD ON
FINDING MISS.
PATHWAY.
I. PLAN FOR THE FUTURE I'M SORRY.
IN JANUARY TWENTY EIGHTEEN AND
SEE ARE A PRESENTED THEIR
STRATEGIC PLAN TO THE COMMISSION
BUT UNFORTUNATELY. THIS PLAN
FAILED TO PROVIDE SUFFICIENT
INFORMATION ABOUT THE
AUTHORITIES FINANCIAL VIABILITY
TO ALLAY CONCERNS. THE
COMMISSION BELIEVES A TRANSITION
TO NEW MANAGEMENT. IS NEEDED TO
PROTECT THE STATE'S RIGHT OF WAY
AND PROVIDE RESPONSIBLE
STEWARDSHIP OVERSEE RESOURCES
AND WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON PAUL MASON WITH
PACIFIC FOREST TRUST AND AS WITH
THE SENATOR IN THE CDC NOTED
THIS IS NEVER GOING TO BE A
RAILROAD AGAIN IT'S JUST A
MATTER OF HOW DO WE ON WINE.
NORTH COAST RAILROAD AUTHORITY
IN THE WAY THAT BEST PROTECTS
THE ASSETS AND THE. INCREDIBLE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR US TO
CALIFORNIA THERE. ICE LIVE IN
HUMBLE COUNTY OF WORK ON THIS
ISSUE FOR MANY YEARS I HAVE
FLOATED DOWN THAT LONG AND
ACCEPTABLE STRICTER RIVER IT
WOULD BE A SPECTACULAR. PLACE
FOR A TRAIL WHO BE THAT NO
ENORMOUS ASSET TO THE NORTH
COAST.
AND YOU SEE THAT REFLECTED IN
THE BREADTH OF AWESOME OF THE
SUPPORT ON THE NORTH COAST FOR
THE SUB IN THIS PROPOSAL. I'VE
GOT THIS.
LETTER TODAY WHICH INCLUDES A
POOR FROM FRIENDS OF THE ILL
RIVER. HARM AFFECTION
INFORMATION CENTER HUMBOLDT BAY
KEEPER CAL TROUT AND CALIFORNIA
WILDERNESS COALITION CALIFORNIA
BICYCLE COALITION. REDWOOD
REGION AUDUBON SOCIETY AND ALL
NOTED THE PROPOSAL IS PROBABLY
SUPPORTED BY.
THE VERBAL COMMUNITY STATEWIDE
SO WE STRONGLY URGE YOUR SUPPORT.
Q..
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
MADAM CHAIRWOMAN MEMBERS MARK
SMITH ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
TROUT IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE
CONSERVATION CORPS NORTH BAY IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
CATHERINE GARCIA WITH SIERRA
CLUB CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON ELEANOR TEETH ON
BEHALF OF SAVE THE REDWOODS
LEAGUE AND THE WILDLINGS
CONSERVANCY IN SUPPORT THINK YOU.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
ARE GOOD AFTERNOON THANK YOU.
PLEASE COME FOR.
NEW.
THANK YOU SO TURN MEMBERS FEEL
RUSHED WITH THE CALIFORNIA FARM
BUREAU WE APOLOGIZE IF OUR
OPPOSITION IS COMING AT A LATE
NOTICE WE HAVE HAD CONVERSATIONS
WITH THE AUTHORS OFFICE.
TRYING TO DISCUSS AND. A
REASONABLE PATHWAY FORWARD THAT
IS CONSIDERATE OF LOCAL LAND USE
DECISIONS AND IMPACTS TO LAND
HOLDERS TO NO AVAIL SO
UNFORTUNATE THAT LEADS US TO OUR
POSITION HERE TODAY.
AND WE ARE. APPRECIATIVE OF MR
MAGUIRE'S ATTEMPT TO PUT THE
RIGHT AWAY TO ALTERNATIVE USES
EXPRESSLY THAT WHICH WOULD HAVE
A PUBLIC BENEFIT.
BUT WE DO HAVE SOME CONCERNS
THAT S. B. TEN TWENTY NINE IS
LIMITED IN ITS DETAIL.
WITH RESPECT TO THE ISSUES THAT
ARE GERMANE TO THIS COMMITTEE.
OTHERS NO CONSIDERATION IN THE
MANAGEMENT OF THE EXISTING RAIL
THIRTIES TENS OF MILLIONS OF
DOLLARS TO IN DEBT TO MY ABILITY.
THERE'S LIMITED INFORMATION
ABOUT HOW A PROJECT THAT'S
NINETY TWO COULD BE A REASONABLY
FINANCED BOTH IN THE EXISTING.
A BUILD OUT AN ON GOING THE ENDS
UP PORTIONS OF THE RAIL LINE
ESPECIALLY WITHIN THE EEL RIVER
BASIN. IS SUBJECT TO CONTINUAL
FLOODING AND EROSION.
SO WE CAN MAKE THE ASSUMPTION
THAT ONGOING MAINTENANCE COSTS
WILL BE SIGNIFICANT AND THEN
MAYBE PORTIONS OF THE TRAIL THAT
WOULD BE CLOSE DURING SPECIFIC
TIMES OF THE SEASON.
FINALLY WE BELIEVE THAT TH
MECHANICS OF THIS BILL. LIMIT
THE ABILITY FOR LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS AND LANDHOLDERS TO
PARTICIPATE AND CONCUR WITH
IMPORTANT LAND USE DECISIONS
THAT WOULD BE ALONG THIS THREE
HUNDRED MILE TRAIL.
WE UNDERSTAND THE BILL'S A WORK
IN PROGRESS AND WE WOULD DO IN
EARNEST LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUING CONVERSATIONS WITH
MISTER MCGUIRE. AND BUT WE DO
ASK FOR MORE AT A REPROACH.
ONE WHICH IS GROUNDED IN ONGOING
PLANNING.
AND SOME FEASIBILITY STUDIES
PICKING.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION FINANCE NEW FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
ONE QUESTION I'VE NOTICED CENTER
BATES ENSURING WIRE A JUST A
QUICK QUESTION REGARDING THE
LIABILITIES THAT ARE CURRENTLY
THERE.
ARE HARD OF THOSE GET.
RETIRED IF THE TRAIL OF OF WE
CREATED TRAIL AUTHORITY AND IT
TAKES OVER. WITHOUTTAKING THE
LIABILITIES. HALF OF THE HUNDRED
DAY OUT THERE YOU KNOW A REALLY
IS A NUMBER ONE NCR A.
AS AN AGENCY HAS HARD ASSETS
WORTH ABOUT TWENTY SIX MILLION.
HOME HARD ASSETS MEANING RIGHT
AWAY RIGHT OF WAY ALONG OUR
STREETS AYE THE RAIL LINE ITSELF
EYES SOME STRUCTURES BUT HERE'S
WHAT I WOULD SAY.
A ACCORDING THE CALIFORNIA
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION THIS
AGENCY IS MILLIONS IN DEBT.
MILLIONS
IT OWES ITS CHIEF ATTORNEY
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS
IT OWES ITS ENGINEER HUNDREDS OF
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS THIS AGENCY
HAS NOT BEEN SOLVENT SINCE THE
BEGINNING.
I'M AND SO WE ARE AN ONGOING
DISCUSSIONS ABOUT WHAT THE
CONFERENCE HAS PETITIONED
COMMISSION ARE ALONG WITH.
THOSE WHO ARE INVOLVED THE
BUDGET PROCESS
ONE TO BE ABLE TO ASSIST A
RETIRING THE DEBT. AYE AND PART
OF THAT COULD MEAN SELL OFF OF
SOME OF THOSE.
AT INFRASTRUCTURE PRODUCTS LIKE
THE RAIL LINE THAT'S HOW WE SEEN
OUR IN OUR PREVIOUS.
BRAILLE BANKING OBJECTIVES.
AND I WOULD SAY THIS A.
THERE IS NO WAY.
BETTER RAIL.
RAIL SERVICE COMMERCIAL REAL
SERVICE WILL EVER GO THROUGH THE
EEL RIVER CANYON AGAIN
IT'S IMPOSSIBLE IT'S MOST YOU
LOGIC UNSTABLE SOIL HONORS. HALF
OF THAT LINE AYE IS EITHER
SLIDING IN OR IN EAGLE RIVER
CURRENTLY.
IT IS NOT FINANCIALLY VIABLE
WHAT IS A VIABLE IS MOVING
FORWARD WITH A TRAIL.
I AM AND WHAT I WOULD SAY IS.
IT IS WE'VE HAD ONGOING
DISCUSSIONS AND I COMMIT TO
HAVING ONGOING DISCUSSIONS WITH
THE STATE FARM BUREAU WE'VE HAD
NUMEROUS I'D SAY FOR DISCUSSIONS
WITH THE MENDOCINO COUNTY FARM
BUREAU. MEMBERS THE HUMBLE
COUNTY FARM BUREAU AND THEY
COMPLETELY REWROTE THE BILL.
AND THEY NEVER SAID THAT THEY'RE
GOING TO BE COMING IN IN A POST
AND THAT'S NOT HOW IT WORKS
AROUND. TYPE THIS BUILDING THESE
THAT I'M AWARE ONGOING
MAINTENANCE I'M WHAT I DID WHAT
I UNDERSTAND IS WHY HE'S IN THE
FARM BUREAU WORRIED ABOUT
ONGOING MEANS THEY'RE
SUFFOCATING DEBT NOW. I'D NEVER
SEEN THEM COME FORWARD AYE AND
WORRY ABOUT THAT. I DO BELIEVE
THIS IS GOING TO BE SIGNIFICANT
ECONOMIC GENERATOR FOR THE
COMMUNITY CALIFORNIA'S OUTDOOR
RECREATIONAL ECONOMIES WORK
NINETY TWO BILLION DOLLARS
NINETY TWO BILLION.
THIS TRAIL WILL GO THROUGH SOME
OF THE MOST ECONOMICALLY
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES IN
THIS STATE AND WILL BE
SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC DRIVER LONG
TERM HOW WHEN IT COMES TO THOSE
WHO WILL BE BE VISITED. I DO
BELIEVE THAT THIS IS GOING TO.
BE GREATLY ASSIST THOSE
COMMUNITIES IS GOING TO ONNECT
NUMEROUS STATE PARKS ALONG WITH
THE THE NATIONAL PARKSYSTEM AYE
IT WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE AN APPROPRIATE TIME.
THANK YOU A SIMILAR WITHOUT
OBJECTION WE MOVE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FILE. THANK YOU SO MUCH
THANK YOU.
IF SERGEANTS CANNOT A CALL
CENTER BRADFORD AND SENATOR
ULCER NIELSEN HERE THINNER
NIELSEN WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT A
UNITED.
I WOULDN'T CALL CENTER HEALTH SO
WE CAN VOTE OUT THE ONE MEASURE
THAT WE HAVE.
PENDING.
WORSE.
SIR NIELSEN YOU HAVE ONE ITEM IS
A SPENDS CANDIDATE IS SB
THIRTEEN EIGHTY ONE WHENEVER
YOU'RE READY THANK YOU MUST
PRESENT MEMBERS THIS IS THE
CAMPUS FREE EXPRESSION ACT.
WE BROUGHT IT FORWARD LAST YEAR.
I BELIEVE THAT WE'VE GOT EVEN
BETTER ARGUMENTS NOW.
THIS IS GOING TO ENSURE THAT OUR
CAMPUSES TRULY ARE.
PLACES FOR FREE EXCHANGE.
THAT THEY ARE.
FOR FREE SPEECH
THEN OPPORTUNITY.
THE. LEGAL PRECEDENT OF THE
FIRST AMENDMENT APPLIES IN FULL
TO OUR STUDENTS.
ON OUR CAMPUSES.
AND OVER YEARS.
THROUGH POLICIES ON CAMPUSES.
INDIVIDUALLY AND NOT ALL THE
SAME.
BUT THEY'VE BEEN VERY
RESTRICTIVE.
RESTRICTIVE THROUGH WHERE SUCH
FREE SPEECH AREAS COULD BE.
IN SOME CASES VERY SMALL AREAS.
VERY ISOLATED AREAS.
AND VERY COMPLICATED PERMITTING.
REQUIREMENTS.
THAT DETERRENT A BODY.
COME ON PAT ON CAMPUS.
IT IS.
CAREFULLY CRAFTED TO INSURE THAT
THE PROTECTION OF THE INTEGRITY
THE EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVES OF
THAT CAMPUS.
ALL THE RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
WOULD NOT BE INTERFERED WITH.
WE BELIEVE THAT WOULD BE.
AFFORDABLE.
THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES.
DIDN'T REALLY HAVE A HARD FIGURE.
NOTED CSU.
USE SEE UNITS THAT AWAY CAME UP
WITH MULTI MILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
IT WOULD SEEM LIKE THAT
INSTITUTION WOULD BE ONE OF THE
MOST.
JEALOUS THAT GUARDED AND
PROTECTED.
FREE SPEECH.
I WILL ARGUE THAT I DO NOT THINK
THAT THE EXTRA REQUIREMENTS.
OF THIS BILL.
WILL IMPOSE ANY REAL UNDUE.
BURDENS.
ON UC.
THEY TALK ABOUT TRAINING.
I'M SURE THEY'RE DOING TRAINING
NOW REGARDING WHAT FREE SPEECH
PLACES THEY DO HAVE.
SELECTING THEM. I'M SURE THAT
THEY HAVE PEOPLE THAT HAVE GOT
TO BE DEVOTED TO THAT THEY WOULD
SIMPLY NEED.
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS TO
BE RE DIRECTED.
THIS IS A VERY.
SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITY.
THE LEGISLATURE.
TO TAKE A STAND.
TRUE.
FREE SPEECH.
THAT DOES NOT.
FATTER.
THE PURPOSES OF THE CAMPUS.
BUT DOES ALLOW.
THOSE WHO ASSEMBLE THEIR.
FULL OPPORTUNITIES.
SPEAK THEIR PIECE.
THANK YOU THANKS HARRISON
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE AND FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
HEARING MANSON ESTIMATES ARE TOO
CLOSE I WOULD ASK THAT WE WOULD.
CARRY THIS TO THE HEAD OF
SUSPENSE CALENDAR AND THAT THIS
BILL WOULD MOVE OFF SUSPECTS
THANK YOU SIR ASSN WITHOUT
EXEMPT WITHOUT A JOB CHECKS HIM
LISTEN TO SUSPENSE FILE.
PARDON ME. AS A TENNIS SURVIVES
THIS HEARING.
.
SEEING.
NO OTHER AUTHORS HERE WHEN IT TO
MOVE OUR WAY.
THROUGH THE EYE CHEN DOWN THE
ITEMS THAT HAVE BEEN WAIVED.
FOR PRESENTATION.
BEGINNING WITH SENATOR WIENERS
ITEMS.
BEGINNING WITH S. B. EIGHT
TWENTY EIGHT.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCING FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
ENTERING NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
MOVE THIS I DON'T THE SUSPENSE
FILE.
THE NEXT.
I HOLD A POSITION RIGHT MOMENT
OR DO I.
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION TO THE
SENATOR WIENERS EIGHT TWENTY
EIGHT.
SEEING NON WITHOUT OBJECTION WAS
I DON'T TO SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO CENTER WINNERS ITEM
S. B.. NINE THIRTY SEVEN.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORTER.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE THING NOW WITHOUT
OBJECTION WHEN WILL THIS ITEMS
THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. NINE NINETY.
ONE THIS IS IN SUPPORT. WHEN
THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE WILL FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SEEING
AND HEARING NOW WITHOUT
OBJECTION TO MOVE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FOUND.
WE NOT TO SP TEN NO FOUR.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. WHEN THIS
IS IN OPPOSITION.
FRANCE OVER. COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION WITH THIS
ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FIVE.
MOVING OUT TO SENATOR WINDS
REMAINING ITEMS BEGINNING WITH
S. B. ELEVEN SEVENTY SIX.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE
THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD
ESTIMATES TOTAL REVENUE LOSSES
OF FORTY SIX MILLION DOLLARS IN
TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN NINETEEN.
EIGHTY MILLION DOLLARS IN TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN TWENTY AND
EIGHTY MILLION DOLLARS IN TWENTY
TWENTY TWENTY ONE.
THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD SO
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS HAVE NOT
YET BEEN DETERMINED THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
BECAUSE OF COURSE OF COMMITTEE
SAYING HEY NOW THAT OBJECTION
WILL THIS I DON'T THE SUSPENSE
FILE. MOVING ON TO THE S. B.
TWELVE FORTY ONE.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE
THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD
ESTIMATES THAT THIS BILL WOULD
REDUCE GENERAL FUND REVENUES BY
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS IN
FISCAL YEAR TWO THOUSAND
EIGHTEEN NINETEEN.
ONE MILLION DOLLARS IN TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN TWENTY AND ONE
POINT TWO MILLION DOLLARS IN
TWENTY TWENTY TWENTY ONE.
OF THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD HAS
NOT YET DETERMINED ITS
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS.
THANK YOU AROUND. COMES OF
COURSE ISN'T COMMITTEE SINGING
NON WITHOUT OBJECTION WE MOVE
THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SENATOR PANS ITEMS.
BEGINNING WHAT B. EIGHT NINETY
NINE.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT PLEASE
COME FORWARD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE
IT FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE THING IN HEARING NOW
WITHOUT OBJECTION WE WILL THE
SILENCE THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. NINE SIXTY
EIGHT. WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE AND FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
THINKING NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
THIS I DON'T THE SUSPENSE FOUND.
GOING ON TO S. B. ELEVEN OH ONE.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE WILL FILE COMMENTS
QUESTIONS OR COMMITTEE THING NOW
WITHOUT OBJECTION WITH THIS ITEM
SUSPENSE FAR.
MOVING ON TO SB ELEVEN FORTY
EIGHT. WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SING
NAM WITHOUT OBJECTION WAS ITEM
TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. THIRTEEN OH
THREE WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE THE FILE. COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SEEING
NOW WITH OBJECTIONABLE THIS
ITEMS THE SUSPENSE FILE.%
MOVING ON TO SENATOR DODD'S
ITEMS BEGINNING WITH S. B. NINE
NO ONE.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
ONE IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMES OF COURSE
ISN'T COMMITTEE SIGNAL THAT
OBJECTION ITEMS THE SUSPENSE
FILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. ELEVEN TWENTY
ONE.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE IN FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
SIGNALED THAT OBJECTIONABLE THIS
ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SENATE DOGS LAST
ITEM. S. B. ELEVEN FORTY FOUR
ONE THIS IS A SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NOVA COMMENTS OF COURSE
ISN'T COMMITTEE.
THE INTERNET WITHOUT OBJECTION
WITH THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSEFUL
WHEN OPEN UP THE ROLE JUST ALLOW
CENTER HELL TO ADD ON TO FOR SO
YOU CAN. GO ON WITH HIS DAY
BECAUSE HE'S BEEN SUCH A GOOD
COMMITTEE MEMBER.
I ABSOLUTELY AGREE.
WE'RE GONNA OPEN THE ROLE ON
CENTER BATES ITEM S. B. ELEVEN
OWN NINE SENATOR PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS BRADFORD.
HILL BY HILL AYE NIELSEN.
THANK YOU.
FIVE ZERO WILL KEEP THAT ROLE
OPEN TO ALLOW IT OF SOME AMBER
SAT ON.
MOVING ON WHAT SENATOR BATES
ITEM S. SPEED NINE NO TO.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
SITTING IN ON WHAT OBJECTIONABLE
THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE FILE
MOVING ON TO S. B. TWELVE THREE.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT. WHEN IT
IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SEEING
NONE WITHOUT OBJECTION LIST
ITEMS THE SUSPENSE FILE. MOVING
ON TO S. B. TWELVE TWENTY SIX
WHEN IS ISN'T SUPPORT.
ONE IS IS IN OPPOSITION FINANCE
FILE. COMES TO QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
SEEING NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
HOMELESS ITEMS THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SENATOR SKINNER'S
ITEMS BEGINNING UP SORRY SCOOTER
CENTER ABOUT.
MOVING US SENATOR BELLS ITEM S.
B. NINE OH SIX WHEN THIS ISN'T
SUPPORTER. WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE TO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
THING THAT WOULD OUT
OBJECTIONABLE THIS ITEM SO
SUSPENSEFUL. MOVIE NOT TO CENTER
SKINNER'S ITEM BEGINNING WITH S.
B. NINE TWENTY SIX.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
THING NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION WE
MOVE THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE FAR.
MOVING NOTS S. B. TEN NO EIGHT
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT. WHEN
THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE BILL FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE THING NOW WITHOUT
OBJECTION WE WILL THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FOUND. MOVING ON TO S.
B. TEN OH ABOUT TEN FOURTEEN.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. WHEN THIS
IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
THING AND NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
AND MOVE THIS ITEM SO SUSPENSE
FILE. MOVING ON TO S. B. ELEVEN
THIRTY EIGHT. WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
MISTER MACALUSO YES THE MOMENT A
BILL YOU COULD COME UP HERE IF
YOU'D LIKE. BOTH.
SHARE HI EVERYBODY FLOW.
.
SO WITH S. B. ELEVEN THIRTY
EIGHT MY NAME IS JUDY MAN CREW
SO I AM WAS SOCIAL COMPASSION
AND LEGISLATION WE ARE THE
SPONSOR OF THE BILL.
AND WE WERE A LITTLE
DISAPPOINTED IN THE ANALYSIS
BECAUSE IT HAS SHOWN AND I HAVE
A DOCUMENT FROM THE MARICOPA
JAIL SYSTEM. RIGHT HERE THAT
NGUYEN THEY INSTITUTED THE PLANT
BASED MEALS.
THE MEALS COST ON AVERAGE FIFTY
CENTS EACH WHICH IS MUCH LESS
THAN THE NATIONAL AVERAGE OF TWO
DOLLARS AND FIFTY CENTS. WHEN
THEY SWITCH TO SOLELY CRUMBLE IN
SO A CHICKEN STRIPS THEY SAVED A
HUNDRED THOUSAND A YEAR.
SWITCHING FROM LUNCH MEAT TO
PLANT BASED EIGHTY THOUSAND
DECREASING THE.
ELIMINATING THE DAIRY FOR PLANT
BASED FIVE HUNDRED AND SIXTY
THOUSAND THEY ARE SAVING SEVEN
HUNDRED AND FORTY THOUSAND
DOLLARS A YEAR AND IT IS
DOCUMENTED BUT BECAUSE THEY HAVE
THIS.
IMPLEMENTED FOR QUITE SOME TIME
SO I WOULD REALLY LIKE THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA TO TAKE ANOTHER
LOOK AT THIS YOU DO SAY IN YOUR
FINAL ANALYSIS THE LAST
PARAGRAPH. THAT IT COULD SAVE
MONEY NO IT WILL SAVE MONEY
WHERE YOU'VE GOT THAT. OKAY THEY
GIVE THAT'S AND SO PLEASE GET IT
OFF SUSPENSE.
THANK YOU.
ANY ADDITIONAL WITNESSES INSOFAR.
AS MISTER CHAIR JENNIFER FEARING
ON BEHALF OF THE CENTER FOR FOOD
SAFETY AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES APART.
IT'S GONNA BE SOME HEALTHCARE
COSTS TOO BY THE WAY.
PAT WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE AND FILE.
WHAT'S THE COMMENTS FROM
COMMITTEE.
SEEING THEM WITHOUT OBJECTION
LIST ITEMS THE SUSPENSE FILE.
SENATE LET'S MAKE SHIPMENT
LETTERER PER BRADFORD AND ON
TOUR.
I DON'T THINK BRADFORD YORKSHIRE
PRESENTABLE.
PLEASE.
SENATOR BRADFORD YOU HAVE.
WHAT NINETY FOUR?
I'M GOING BLIND.
CHRISTIAN.
OTHER YOU ARE. THANK YOU SIR
BRADFORD YOU HAVE S. B. TWELVE
NINETY FOUR THE FLOOR'S YOURS
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS. I'M HERE TODAY TO
PRESENT S. B. TWELVE NINETY FOUR
THE CAT OF MISC.
COLLABORATION IN INCLUSION ACT
WHICH ENABLES INDIVIDUALS FROM
DIVERSE BACKGROUNDS AND
UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES TO
PARTICIPATE IN CALIFORNIA'S
EXPANDING LEGALIZED. ADULT.
CANNABIS INDUSTRY SPECIFICALLY
S. B. TWELVE NINETY FOUR STOPS
IS A POSITION WITHIN THE BUREAU
TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.
FOR STATE EQUITY APPLICANTS AND
REQUIRED TO CREATION OF THE
CANNABIS EQUITY TASK FORCE TO
ADVISE TO BUREAU ON DEVELOPING
AND IMPLEMENTING STATEWIDE
EQUITY PROGRAMS EQUITY
APPLICATIONS ARE SMALL
BUSINESSES AND INDIVIDUALS
APPLICANTS I SHOULD SAY OUR
SMALL BUILT BUSINESSES AND
INDIVIDUALS. APPLY FOR LOCAL
CANNABIS LICENSES WHO MEET THE
REQUIREMENTS FOR JURISDICTIONAL
CALL LOCAL EQUITY PROGRAMS
SACRAMENTO SAN FRANCISCO OAKLAND
AND LOS ANGELES ARE FOR CITIES
CURRENTLY WITH A EQUITY PROGRAM
WHICH FOCUSES ON INCLUSION AND
SUPPORT TO APPLICANTS.
BUT I HAVE BEEN NEGATIVELY
NEGATIVELY IMPACTED BY CANADA'S
CRIMINALIZATION PRIMARILY BLACK
AND BROWN.
THE COMMUNITIES AND THE POOR
CONSTITUENTS UP AND DOWN THE
STATE HAVE VOICED THEIR CONCERNS
WITH THE LACK OF MINORITY
REPRESENTATION IN THE CANNABIS
INDUSTRY FOR THE MORE.
INDIVIDUALS WOULD CAPITAL AND NO
CRIMINAL CONVICTIONS ARE EVEN
BEING DENIED LICENSES AND ENTRY
INTO THE SPACE BASED SIMPLY OUR
RACIAL BIASES THAT HAVE CALMLY
KEPT MINORITIES OUT OF MANY
CALIFORNIA INDUSTRIES.
CURRENTLY ACCESS TO CAPITAL
TECHNICAL SUPPORT WORKFORCE
DEVELOPMENT AND DELIBERATE
COLLABORATION ARE THE MOST
URGENT CHALLENGES FACED BY
EQUITY A MINORITY APPLICANTS
ESPOSITO'S WHO LIVE AND
LOCATIONS WITH NO EQUITY
PROGRAMS.
TOGETHER THE TASK FORCE CREATED
UNDER THIS BILL AND THE STATE
BUREAU OF CANNABIS CONTROL WILL
SIS EQUITY APPLICANTS AND
LICENSEES.
BY CONDUCTING TRAINING
INFORMATIONAL SESSIONS ON STATE
AND LOCAL LICENSES PROCESSES AND
THE AND ASSISTANCE WITH SECURING
BUSINESS LOCATIONS TO BUREAU
ALSO IDENTIFYING DEVELOP
INCENTIVES FOR EXISTING
LICENSEES THE PARTNER WHICH
STATE EQUITY APPLICANTS. DRIVING
COLLABORATION BETWEEN LARGE AND
SMALL CANNABIS BUSINESSES
TO CREATE REAL CHANGE.
CALIFORNIA IS ALWAYS BEEN THE
NATIONAL LEADER ON SO MANY
ISSUES AND WHILE WE ARE NOT THE
FIRST TO ENTER THIS RECREATION
OR DON'T USE MARKET OR CANNABIS
WE CAN BE THE FIRST TO DO IT
RIGHT. NOW WHILE THIS BILL IS
GOING ON SUSPENSE AND I RESPECT
THAT I WANT TO SHARE THE
CRITICAL IMPORTANCE IS MEASURE
WILL HAVE NOT ONLY IN HELPING
REVERSE TO DAMAGES OUT IMPACT ON
THE WAR ON DRUGS. BUT ALSO THE
GENERAL IMPLICIT BUT ARE RACIAL
BIAS THAT EXISTS WITHIN ALL
SECTORS OUR COMMUNITY I LOOK FOR
TO CONTINUE WORKING DIALOGUE ON
THIS MEASURE AND APPRECIATE. THE
COMMITTEE STAFF AND FISCAL
ANALYSIS ON THE BILL AT A PROPER
TIME FOR ME I WOULD LOVE FOR YOU
AYE VOTE. THEY KICK YOU WHEN
THIS ISN'T SUPPORT PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
WITNESSES.
IN SUPPORT.
CHARACTERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
NAACP IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE THANK YOU. COMMENTS
OF COURSE ISN'T COMMITTEE THING
THAT'S IN A BRADFORD THANK YOU
FOR YOUR WORK ON THIS ISSUE. THE
BIGGEST IRONY NOW IS.
THAT IT'S CANNABIS OF LEGAL AND
YET.
COMMITTEES OF COLOR WILL HAVE
BEEN DECIMATED. HOW OVER THE WAR
ON DRUGS AND NO LONGER HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO PARTAKE IN AND
THIS WAS NOW LEGAL MARKET SO? I
APPRECIATE A WORK CAN AFFORD A
HAVING THE FUTURE DIALOGUE ON
THIS ISSUE AS THE BILL REMAINS
OF SUSPENSE FIGURES CHAIR OF THE
TIME. THANK YOU WITHOUT
OBJECTION MOVE THIS I DON'T WANT
TO SUSPEND FILE.
YES THAT'S ADD LET'S MAKE SURE
CENTER BRADFORD CAN ADD ON TO.
OUR ONGOING FAILURE WITH SENATOR
BATES.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ON S. B. ELEVEN
OH NINE THE MOTION IS TO PASS
THE SENATE FLOOR. BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE NIELSEN.
SIX ZERO WILL ALLOW THAT.
ROBERT TOLD OUR ABSENT MEMBER
TEN ON.
WE'RE GONNA MOVE NOW TO SENATOR
ALLEN'S AYE ITEMS BEGINNING WITH
S. B..
NINE THIRTY SIX
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SAYING
NAM WITHOUT OBJECTION WE WILL
THIS ITEM SUSPENSE FOUND. MOVING
ON TO SB TEN SEVENTEEN WHEN THIS
ISN'T SUPPORT PLEASE COME
FORWARD.GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS JENNIFER FEARING ON
BEHALF OF THE PEW CHARITABLE
TRUSTS DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE SAN
DIEGO HUMANE SOCIETY AND THE SAN
FRANCISCO SPCA. CALIFORNIA
SWORDFISH FISHERY HAS BEEN UNDER
SCRUTINY SINCE IT BEGAN IN THE
EIGHTIES DUE TO THE HIGH RATE OF
SEA TURTLE MARINE MAMMAL AND NON
TARGETED FISH BI CATCH AND
MORTALITY.
FUTURE ABOUT TRUSTS HAVE BEEN
FUNDING RESEARCH INTO A
PROMISING NEW METHOD OF CATCHING
SWORDFISH WITHOUT THE BY CATCH
ASSOCIATED WITH DRIFT GILL NET.
CHARACTER IF GILL NET GEAR FOR
SEVERAL YEARS AND WE ARE
ENCOURAGED BY THE RESULTS. THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT WAS POISED TO
TAKE ACTION BUT THE TRUMP
ADMINISTRATION PULLED BACK ON
PROPOSED REGULATIONS LAST YEAR.
S. B. TEN SEVENTEEN A SEEKS TO
REINSTATE PROTECTIONS PROPOSED
UNDER THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION
AND ESTABLISHES A VOLUNTARY
TRANSITION FRAMEWORK IN MOVE
SUPPORTED BY EIGHTY SEVEN
PERCENT OF CALIFORNIANS. WE
UNDERSTAND THE DEPARTMENT OF
FISH AND WILDLIFE HAS NO FISCAL
ON THIS BILL YET AND THIS WEEK A
BAY AND AUTHORS OFFICE ARE
MEETING WITH STAKEHOLDERS IN
LONG BEACH TO TRY TO FIND A
COMPROMISE. PLEASE ADVANCE SP
TEN SEVENTEEN FROM SUSPENSE.
WHERE THEY MEET AGAIN?
I WOULD BE YOUR DISTRICT I
BELIEVE MISTER SHARON LONGER.
RICK.
THIS AWARENESS IS A PART.
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS MARK
SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN
SPORTFISHING ASSOCIATION THE A
SAY AS LONG BEEN INVOLVED IN
THIS CONVERSATION AS WELL.
I WON'T REITERATE WHAT JENNIFER
SAID IN FRONT OF ME BUT.
SUFFICE IT TO SAY THAT THEY'RE
SUPPORTING BOTH THIS MEASURE AND
THE FEINSTEIN MEASURE WHICH HAS
BEEN INTRODUCED AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL. THEY'VE ALSO HELPED
ORGANIZE A COALITION OVER A
HUNDRED SPORTFISHING
ORGANIZATIONS AND FOR BREVITY
TODAY I WON'T READ ALL OF THEM.
BUT THERE'S A LARGE SUPPORT.
IN CONCEPT FOR THIS BILL I SAY
IN CONCEPT BECAUSE THE DETAILS
ARE STILL TO BE WORKED OUT. WE
APPRECIATE THE MEMBER
COMMUNICATING WITH THE OPPONENTS
WILL BE COMING UP BEHIND US AND.
UNDERTAKING A MEETING LIKE HE'S
DOING THIS WEEK THANK YOU THANK
YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS CASSIE
BERTIE SEAN AND THE ADVOCACY IN
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR TURTLE
ISLAND RESTORATION NETWORK OUR
MEMBERS AND SUPPORTERS ARE SOME
OF THE THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIA
CITIZENS WHO HAVE BEEN SPEAKING
OUT IN FAVOR OF THIS BILL
BECAUSE OF THE NEED TO PROTECT
OUR OCEAN WILDLIFE FOR.
GENERATIONS TO COME. THOUSANDS
MORE ARE SPEAKING OUT FROM OTHER
STATES BECAUSE KANSANS OHIOANS
AND OTHERS COME TO CALIFORNIA TO
GO WHALE WATCHING TO GO SCUBA
DIVING. AND TO SEE WHILE
CALIFORNIA'S WILDLIFE THAT IS SO
IMPORTANT TO PEOPLE ALL AROUND
THE WORLD. IT'S SHOCKING THAT
CALIFORNIA ON OFF ARE CLOSE TO
THE LAST PLACE FOR THIS FISHING
METHOD. ON IT MIGHT BE SIMPLER
JUST TO BAN DRIFT NET FISHING IT
WOULD PROBABLY BE CHEAPER TO BAN
DRIFT NET FISHING BUT THIS BILL
IS ABOUT BALANCING THE NEED TO
PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT. WITH
BEING FAIR TO THE COMMERCIAL
FISHING INDUSTRY THAT HAS BEEN
USING THESE DEADLY NETS SO WE
WILL BE ONE OF THE ORGANIZATIONS
AND MEETING DOWN IN LONG BEACH
TO HOPEFULLY. I'M FINE SOME MORE
RESOLUTION THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO COMMENT.
THANK YOU HARBINGER TIME IN THE
THIRTY THIRD SENATE DISTRICT.
I CAN SENATORS.
MY NAME IS TIFFANY LONG I'M
WITH TURTLE ISLAND RESTORATION
NETWORK I WOULD LIKE TO DRAW
YOUR ATTENTION TO A LETTER FROM
MANY BUSINESSES IN CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT OF SB TEN SEVENTEEN.
THESE BUSINESSES FROM CITIES
SUCH AS SAN FRANCISCO LA LONG
BEACH SAUSALITO HOLLYWOOD IN A
POINT MONTEREY AND MARINA DEL
REY ALL BELIEVE IN THE
IMPORTANCE OF PRESERVING OUR.
MOTIONS HEALTH.
OF FOR CALIFORNIA'S CONTINUED
PROSPERITY SO FAR THESE
BUSINESSES INCLUDE FISH
RESTAURANT TO BUY SEIZE GOMA
STATE CAPTAINS DOLPHIN AND WHALE
WATCHING SAFARI. HOLLYWOOD
DIVERS DEEP BLUE'S GO AND SWIM
CENTER YELLED AQUA BONTA GOT US
SUB WITH WADE AQUARIUS DIVE SHOP
AND TOSSED IN LA HARMFUL JEFF
NOT FISHING.
THREATENS THEIR WELL WATCHING
RECREATIONAL FISHING SCUBA
DIVING AND SUSTAINABLE SEAFOOD
BUSINESSES AND THEY'RE ASKING
THE COMMITTEE TO HELP PRESERVE
THEIR RESOURCE FOR THEIR AND THE
STATE'S ECONOMIC FUTURE THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
THANK YOU.
NICHOLAS SACKETT SOCIAL
COMPASSION LEGISLATION IN
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
IT AFTERNOON.
OFTEN BROWN.
I'M FROM SAN DIEGO I'M FROM A
FOURTH GENERATION FISHING FAMILY.
MY FAMILY OWNS AND AND OPERATES
OFFICIAL CELL DISTRIBUTION
COMPANY AS WELL AS A RESTAURANT.
I SUPPLY THEM WITH DRIFT NET
SWORDFISH SHARK OPALA EXETER IN
THIS FISHERY SUPPLIES SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA'S RESTAURANTS AND
RETAIL. MARKET TO SOME THE
FRESHEST AND MOST SUSTAINABLE
SEAFOOD IN THE WORLD.
OF THE DRIFT NET SHARK SWORDFISH
FISHERY IS EXTREMELY HEALTHY AND
WELL MANAGED.
BY FAILING I DEPEND ON THIS
FISHY FOR OUR LIVELIHOOD I'M
EXTREMELY EXTREMELY PROUD TO BE
A PART OF THIS AMAZING FISHING
INDUSTRY.
I STRONGLY OPPOSES BILL I PLEASE
US HERE NO VOTE.
ADDITIONAL ONE IS IS IN
OPPOSITION MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS ROB ROSS ON BEHALF OF
THE. ALLIANCES COMMUNITY OF.
WHO? COMMUNITIES FOR SUSTAINABLE
FISHERIES
SAN DIEGO FISHERMAN'S WORKING
GROUP IN THE CALIFORNIA
FISHERIES.
AND SEAFOOD INSTITUTE.
THE THAT PROPONENTS OF THE BILL
TALK ABOUT THE TREMENDOUS TAKE
OF MARINE MAMMALS PINNIPEDS AND
TURTLES.
WE'VE GOT THAT DOWN TO ALMOST
ZERO TWO TWO AREA CLOSURES.
GEAR MODIFICATIONS.
REMEMBER WE FISH.
IT THIS IS A FEDERAL FISHERY
MANAGEMENT THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT MANAGED BY THE
PACIFIC FISHERY MANAGEMENT
COUNCIL.
AND THE NATIONAL MARINE
FISHERIES SERVICE AND IT IS
RECOGNIZED.
BY BY MOST PEOPLE FAMILIAR WITH.
COMMENCEMENT AS THE GOLD
STANDARD AND FISHERIES
MANAGEMENT.
THERE'S NOTHING IN THE BILL
THAT WE. AGREE WITH.
WE OPPOSED THE A SEVENTY PERCENT
RAISE IN THE FISHING FEES.
THE FIRST YEAR AND IF YOU DON'T
GO TO THIS EXPERIMENTAL HERE.
THAT IS CONTROLLED BY THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT NOT TO STATE.
THEN IT GOES UP I FOUR HUNDRED
FIFTY PERCENT IF YOU DON'T DO IT
THE THIRD YEAR GOES UP NINE
HUNDRED PERCENT.
SOMEONE TOLD ME JUST BEFORE THIS
A BILL CAME UP.
THAT.
IF IF LEGISLATORS WERE ASKED TO
SHIFT FROM YOUR SALARY AND LIVE
ON YOUR PER DIEM THAT'S EXACTLY
THE ANALOGY THAT WOULD HAPPEN.
IN MOVING FROM DRIFT GILL NETS
TO THE EXPERIMENTAL.
BOOING HERE.
OBSERVERS ARE MANDATED BY THIS
BILL ON ALL BOATS AT ALL TIMES
AT SEVEN HUNDRED DOLLARS A DAY.
FISHMAN GO OUT FOR FIVE SIX DAYS
YOU CAN DO THE MATH ON THAT.
THAT WOULD BE COST PROHIBITIVE
FOR THEM TO DO THAT THE
PROPONENTS KNOW THAT.
THE ALTERNATE YEAR THE BUOY HERE
WAS INTENDED TO AUGMENT
SWORDFISH PRODUCTION NOT REPLACE
IT.
HARD CAPS.
MAKE NO SENSE IT'S BEEN
REJECTED BY THE U. S. MARINE
MAMMAL COMMISSION.
NOT THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IN
TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN. BUT I
BELIEVE SOMEBODY ELSE WAS THE
PRESIDENT.
BUYBACK Y..
WHY TO WE DON'T LIKE WHAT YOU DO
WE WANT TO PAY YOU OUGHT WE WANT
TO BUY YOU OUT WE WANT YOU OFF
THE OCEAN?
DOES IT MAKE SENSE IS A VIABLE
FISHERY RESPONSIBLY DONE. BY
RESPONSIBLE. OF FISHERMEN WHO
HAVE.
COME OVER REMARKABLE DISTANCE
IN WHAT THEY. ARE HAVE REDUCED
THEIR THEIR UP BY CATCH.
THERE ARE NO FUNDS PROVIDED IN
THE BILL. TO HELP THE INDUSTRY
ONLY HURT FISHING FAMILIES BASED
ON. UNSUBSTANTIATED CLAIMS.
CALIFORNIA FISHERY IS.
.
TAKES PLACE IN FEDERAL WATERS I
REMIND YOU AGAIN THAT'S THREE TO
TWO HUNDRED MILES THAT'S TWO
HUNDRED TWELVE. THOUSAND SQUARE
MILES.
IF WE TOOK THE TWENTY GIL
MATTERS THAT ARE WORKING TODAY.
WOULD TAKE UP ABOUT ONE NINE DS
OF ONE PERCENT OF THAT WHICH
GOES ON IN THE OCEAN.
I DON'T THINK MOST SPORT
FISHERMEN ARE OUT SEVENTY FIVE
MILES. LOOKING AND WALES OR
TRYING TO CATCH THEIR. OF
FAVORITE HOBBY SPECIES
AND.
WE ASK YOU KNOW VOTE.
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ON
THE CHAIRMAN LARA AND OUR SKI
LIFT COMMITTEE MY NAME IS GARY
BURKE I'M.
LONGTIME GILL NET FISHERMEN FOR
DRIFT NETS
STARTED A BEEN THERE SINCE
BEFORE IT STARTED FISHING SHARKS
AND IT TURNED IN THE SORT
FISHING.
LIKE TO JUST SAY THAT I'VE SEEN
A LOT OF CHANGES ALL BEEN GOOD
WE DO WE'VE REDUCE BI CATCH
TREMENDOUSLY.
WHICHIS HEAVILY REGULATED.
WE'RE NOT.
SEE GOING COWBOYS AGO KILL
EVERYTHING I'VE A MIGHT REMIND
YOU THAT WE'RE THE SIX
MOST REGULATED. BUSINESS IN THE
U. S. YOU KNOW WHAT IT'S BEHIND
IN BETWEEN.
OIL AND GAS IN AVIATION I MEAN
THAT'S PRETTY AMAZING. SOUL I
LOOK AT THIS BILL ACTUALLY TO ME
IT IT'S LIKE AS A FRESHMAN SIX
TORSION IT'S EITHER TAKE THIS
MONEY OR WE'RE GONNA FOR SURE TO
BUSINESSES EITHER WAY.
SO LET'S TALK ABOUT THE MONEY
THEY GOT TWENTY SIX ACTIVE GUYS
RIGHT NOW.
AND I WAS SO LOOKING AT SOME
THESE GUYS MAKE TWO HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS A YEAR HE GOT
FISHING EQUIPMENT HERE SO IF YOU
GOT A BY THESE GUYS OUT. LIKE
ALAN WANTS TO HERE GOING TO HAVE
TO HAVE TO HAVE ELEVEN MILLION
DOLLARS THAT'S JUST THE START
THE SECOND TIER. HERE'S ANOTHER
FINANCING IN THE THIRD ONE HE
JUST HAS A PENCIL MARK WITH A
WITH A DOLLAR SIGN WHO KNOWS
WHAT THEY'RE GOING TO GET.
SO IF YOU CONTINUE TO FISH.
THEN YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO HAVE
WHAT THEY SAID OBSERVER COVERAGE.
OBSERVER COVERAGE IS A FEDERAL.
OF DEAL THAT'S IT THAT'S WHERE
THE OBSERVERS ARE AT THEY HAVE
TO BE YOU CAN'T JUST START A
PROGRAM LIKE THAT THEY HAVE TO
GO THROUGH TRAINING IDENTIFIED.
WHAT THEY DO IT'S BE VERY
EXPENSIVE?
AND. THEN IT COMES TO HARD CAPS.
TO PUT HARD CAPS ON THIS FISHERY
AND THEN HOW TO GET HIM FORCE
THAT THIS IS LIKE ROB SAID THIS
IS A FEDERAL FISHING I SERVE.
ON THE. PACIFIC COUNCIL ON THE
HIGHLY MIGRATORY ADVISORY TEAM.
ANOTHER POINT IS THEY'RE TALKING
ABOUT IS YOU'RE GONNA GET BUT WE
CARE.
WE'RE GOING RIGHT NOW THROUGH
THE ALTERNATE SOME WHO GETS PER
pWEEK HERE.
IT'S NOT EVEN OFFICIALLY AND IT
WON'T BE AND AS IT IS NOW A LOT
OF PEOPLE SEE ALL WE DON'T WANT
MORE THAN TEN OR FIFTEEN GUYS
THERE'S ALREADY DON'T SEVEN GUYS
TRYING IT. THEY'RE GONNA GET
PRIORITY THEY'RE NOT GOING TO
GET SOME.
BUT WE HEAR FISHING IT WAS A
SUPPLEMENT IF YOU TAKE THIS
FISHER WAY.
WE JUST CAN IMPORT FISH AND IT'S
GONNA PUT THE PEOPLE OUT OF
BUSINESS. THAT GENERATE A LOT OF
REVENUE FOR THE STATE AND IT'S
IT'S ALL POLITICS IT'S NOT
SCIENCE THINKING I HEARD YOU
KNOW VOTE. THANK YOU ADDITIONAL
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
HI I'M MY NAME'S DANIEL WILLIAMS
I'M A PROUD WIFE OF ONE OF THE
TOP PRODUCING A. TRIP GIVEN A
FISHERMAN HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
AND ALSO A CO OWNER OF OUR
COMMERCIAL FISHING BUSINESS.
AND I'M ALSO THE OWNER OF A
SECOND SMALL BUSINESS FRESH FISH
FANATICS IT'S A RETAIL FISH
BUSINESS THAT WE RUN.
A AM MOST IMPORTANTLY THOUGH I'M
HERE TODAY AS THE MOTHER.
OF OF THE THIRD GENERATION OF
WILLIAMS FAMILY FISHERMEN.
MY HUSBAND MYSELF AND OUR
CHILDREN ARE A HUNDRED PERCENT
RESOURCE DEPENDENT PEOPLE.
THERE'S MANY REASONS I OPPOSE
THIS PARTICULAR BILL BUT NONE
WAY BIGGER THAN THE LIFE
ALTERING IMPACT.
OF THIS ILL CONCEIVED BILL ON MY
CHILDREN.
MY HUSBAND IS SPENT.
THE PAST THIRTY FIVE YEARS OF
HIS LIFE. DAY IN AND DAY OUT.
DOING WHAT MOST PEOPLE THAT I
KNOW WOULD NOT HAVE THE STRENGTH
OR GRIT. OR FEARLESSNESS TO DO.
HE'S WORKED IN THIS WAY TO
PROVIDE FOR A FAMILY AND SUPPORT
US.
TO PROVIDE HEALTHY SUSTAINABLE
FOOD FOR ALL OF US.
BUT HIS BIGGEST FOCUS HAS ALWAYS
BEEN THAT.
AFTER ALL IS SAID AND DONE. THAT
HE'D BE ABLE TO GIVE OUR KIDS.
THE WONDERFUL GIFT OF BEING ABLE
TO BEGIN THEIR LIVES WITH A
SOLID FOUNDATION AND HOPE FOR
THE FUTURE.
FOR US PASSING THIS BILL WILL BE
THE FINAL HAMMER.
THAT WOULD FINALLY DESTROY HIS
LIFELONG EFFORTS TO PROVIDE THIS
GIFT FOR HIS CHILDREN.
I AM A PROUD FISHERMANS Y. FUN I
OPPOSE. SB TEN SEVENTEEN THINK
TANK HERE. AND BY THE WAY THANK
YOU FOR STAYING SO LATE IN THE
COMMITTEE I KNOW BETA.
IT'S BEEN A LONG LONG COMMITTEE
HEARINGS APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
GO AHEAD.
IF YOU'VE EXTINGUISH ALL OF THE
EXISTING WELL REGULATED WASTE
FOR US FISHERMEN TO GET ARE
FLOORED FISH. IT WON'T
EXTINGUISH PEOPLE'S NEED FOR IT.
THEY'LL JUST GET THEIR SWORD
FISH FROM FOREIGN LESS REGULATED
COUNTRIES OLIVER SEAFOOD WILL BE
FROZEN IMPORTED. AND DEFINITELY
NOT FRESH FISH.
WOULDN'T BE BETTER FOR IN THE.
FOR FOR THE ENVIRONMENT TO ALLOW
OUR US FISHERMEN TO CAN CONTINUE
TO SUSTAINABLY AND RESPONSIBLY
PROVIDE SORT FISH FOREST'S. I'M
AND WILLIAMS A PROUD FISHERMAN'S
DAUGHTER AND I OPPOSE BILL TEN
SEVENTEEN. THANK YOU THANK YOU
FOR COMING TODAY.
HELLO I'M MICHAEL WILLIAMS.
I AM.
FISHMAN SON. AND APPLE.
BILL SEVEN.
TEN SEVENTEEN.
THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR COMING.
AND.
IF YOU. PASS THIS BILL.
I WILL NOT PURSUE MY DREAM TO BE.
A LAWYER.
HIS
I NEED.
TO WORK ON DAD'S MY DAD'S.
POPE.
TO PAY FOR MY COLLEGE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
HELLO MY NAME'S CHRIS WILLIAMS A
MIDRIFF GET GONNA PUT HIS SPENT.
AND UNDER THE TUTELAGE OF THE
NATIONAL MARINE FISHERY SERVICE
WE'VE COME A LONG WAY IN OUR
EFFORTS TO.
SUSTAINABLY HARVEST.
UP PRODUCTS THAT PEOPLE NEED AND
I'M PROUD OF THAT NIGHT OPPOSE
AYE TEN SEVENTEEN THANK YOU.
AS THE PROUD SON OF A. GREAT
MAN LIKE MY FATHER WHO IS NOT
ONLY BUILT THE BUSINESS FROM HIS
HANDS ON OFF THE GROUND. AND HAS-SUCCEEDED IN ONE OF THE MOST
REGULATED FIELDS IN AMERICA AS
YOU SAID FOR THE TOP SIX
REGULATED FILL.
FIELDS IN AMERICA.
I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SAY THE SUN
MY AND MY SIBLINGS FINANCIAL
FUTURE. RELIES ON THE
AVAILABILITY AND OPENNESS OF
THIS BUSINESS TO CONTINUE TO
SUCCEED.
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE A WHAT WAS
NUMBER.
AND SEVENTEEN.
BILL TEN SEVENTEEN THANK YOU
VERY MUCH THANK YOU.
RIGHT LEAVES MIKE FLYNN I'VE
PARTICIPATED IN THIS FISHERY FOR
OVER TWENTY FIVE YEARS.
I OPPOSE THIS BILL IT'S WRITTEN
WITH INTENT AND STRUCTURE TO
STRONG ARM. PERMIT HOLDERS OF
THE DRIFTS HISTORY.
OUT OF BUSINESS.
IT'S SUSTAINABLE HAS ECONOMIC
VALUE TO THE STATE.
BUT AS WELL IS THE FISHING
FAMILIES THAT RELY ON THIS.
FOR THEIR PRIMARY INCOMES.
THE DEEP BLUE YEAR CANNOT
REPLACE THIS.
IT WOULD SUPPLEMENT IT.
BUT IT WON'T REPLACE IT SO
PLEASE CONSIDER THE. LOS
SLIGHTLY HEADS OF ALL OF US WHO
HAVE WORKED DILIGENTLY.
TO KEEP THIS FISHERIES AND OUR
LIVELIHOODS INTACT.
SO.
MY CHILDREN ARE LOOKING FORWARD
TO CONTINUING BEINGS FOURTH
GENERATION FISHERMAN. ANNA I
OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
MY NAME IS JOSHUA THE GARMA
COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN OWNER AND
OPERATOR OF THE TOMMY JOHN. I'VE
BEEN COMMERCIAL FISHING FOR TEN
YEARS STARTED A YOUNG MAN AT THE
AGE TWENTY.
AND.
BUT MY WHOLE LIFE INTO THIS
FISHERIES TO.
THE FISH I LOVE MY JOB I LOVE
WHAT I DO.
BUT IF THIS BILL WERE TO GO
THROUGH IN.
REALLY HOPE IT DOESN'T I MAY
LOSE EVERYTHING I OWN.
I'VE LOST TWO YEARS I HAVE BEEN
PURCHASING BOATS.
DOING WELL FOR MYSELF FINALLY
AFTER MANY YEARS OF STRUGGLE AND.
I'M HAPPY TO BE WHERE I AM AND
IF THIS BILL PASSES UP AFRAID I
MIGHT LOSE EVERYTHING I OWN. I
LIVE ON MY BOAT SPEND TWO
HUNDRED FIFTY TO THREE HUNDRED
DAYS AT SEA A YEAR.
IF THIS FISHER THIS FISHER WERE
TO CLOSE.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT I'D BE ABLE TO
DO IT WITH IBM'S LA FORD ABOUT
I'VE GOT TO FIND SOMETHING ELSE
TO DO AND I DON'T HAVE THE MONEY
TO INVEST INTO ANOTHER FISHER
SAYS ALL I HAVE.
I OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU FOR COMING.
TOM DAHLE GRABS A MINUTE
COMMERCIAL FISHERMEN SINCE
NINETEEN EIGHTY AND THE. WITH
ALL OF ITS BEEN THE DRIFT GILL
NET FISHERIES.
I WAS SENATOR ALLEN WAS HERE
TODAY BECAUSE HE HE TALKED TO US
E. PERSONALLY TALK TO US THE
LAST COUPLE WEEKS AND.
HE FINALLY GOT THE OTHER SIDE OF
WHAT'S REALLY HAPPENING HERE.
WE HAVE OCEANIC BICU.
.
THE TERM RESTORATION PEOPLE.
THEY'VE BEEN A TAXES FOR MANY
MANY YEARS THEY.
.
PAT SMEAR CAMPAIGNS MERCURY ALL
THIS KIND OF STUFF TIED THOUGHTS
DINERS A BUMP AMAZING PERSON ON
HOW TO BRAINWASH THE PUBLIC AND
HE'S DONE A GREAT JOB.
SUCH WHY OPPOSE THIS BILL WILL
BE A FINANCIAL. BURDEN ON MAY.
AND SAN DIEGO LOSE A LOT OF
MONEY I MEAN SEVENTY FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS JUST ON
MAINTENANCE A YEAR GOES THIS OUR
OUR OUR. OUR LITTLE COMMUNITY IN
SAN DIEGO SO YOU TIMES THAT BY
TWENTY.
OVER TEN YEARS IS QUITE A BIT OF
MONEY AYE OPPOSES BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
I'M MY NAME'S TIM MULCAHY I'M
ONE OF SENATOR BATES IS
CONSTITUENTS.
AND IT I THE POINT I'D LIKE TO
MAKE IS THAT THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT JUST LICENSE THIS
FISHERY.
AND AS YOU MAY KNOW THEY ARE
TASKED BY. LAW
TO KEEP ALL FISHERIES THE UNITED
STATES HEALTHY AND SUSTAINABLE
SO.
TO ME THEY WOULDN'T OF DONE THAT
THEY WOULDN'T OF LICENSE THIS.
pYOU HEAR FROM OTHER PEOPLE THANK
YOU.
HELLO MY NAME IS STEVE MEN'S AND
I'VE BEEN.
COMMERCIAL SORT FISHING SINCE
NINETEEN EIGHTY TWO WITH US
DRIFT NET THAT THIS TEN
SEVENTEEN WANTS TO ABOLISH.
MASK INTO.
ABOLISH THE BILL BECAUSE IT
DOESN'T DO ANYTHING FOR OUR
FISHERY WHATSOEVER.
AND I ANYTHING ELSE I'D SAY
WOULD BE SOMETHING THAT THEY'VE
ALREADY SETS OF THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU THANK YOU. AND
THANK YOU AGAIN FOR WAITING SO
PATIENTLY FOR. BY THE BILL TO
COME UP THERE REALLY APPRECIATE
YOUR TIME.
ANY ADDITIONAL CROWD WITNESSES
AND OPPOSITION.
FINANCE IF I.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
SIGNAL THAT OBJECTION WE MOVE
THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FIVE
THANK YOU.
MITCHELL MOVING TO CENTER
HERTZBERG'S ITEMS. BEGINNING
WITH S. B. NINE FORTY FOUR.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT OF.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE OF WELL.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE THING NAM WITHOUT
OBJECTION WE WILL THIS ITEM TO
SUSPEND FAR.
LET'S.
WRAP UP CENTER HAS PRESENTS WITH
S. B. TWELVE FIFTEEN.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT WHEN
THIS IS AN OPPOSITION. FINANCE
FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS COMMITTEE
THING HEARING NEMATODE OBJECTION
WITH THIS ITEM SUSPENSE WELL
LET'S OPEN THE ROLE ON SENATOR
BATES AYE DOWN LOOKS LIKE WE
HAVE.
EVERYBODY HERE.
AGAIN THIS IS S. B. ELEVEN OWN
NINE UP TO PASS RECOMMENDATION
TO THE SENATE FLOOR. SENATOR
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
NIELSEN AYE.
NIELSEN
NIELSEN AYE.
SEVEN ZERO THAT ITEM IS OUT
SENATOR BATES.
MOVING RIGHT ALONG ON OUR AGENDA.
I BEGINNING WITH MY ITEMS.
OF STARTING WITH SPEED NINE
FIFTY SEVEN.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORTER.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE. COMMENTS REPORTS OF
COMMITTEES THING NON WITHOUT
OBJECTION REMOVE THIS ITEMS THE
SUSPENSEFUL.
WE WANT TO S. B. ELEVEN NINETY
FOUR WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
ONE IS IS AN OPPOSITION FINANCE
SO FILE.
THOMAS REPORTS OF COMMITTEES
THING NOW THAT OBJECTION WHEN
WILL THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE
FIVE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. NINE NINE TWO
BY SENATOR HERNANDEZ.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT. WHEN
THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCIAL FILE.
COM IS A QUESTION COMMITTEE.
SING A NOTE THAT OBJECTION WE
MOVE THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE
FIVE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. TEN TWENTY
THREE ONE THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
SEEING HEARING NOW WITHOUT
OBJECTION WHEN WILL THIS ITEMS
THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO CENTER MORALES ITEM
S. B. NINE NINE NINE WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT
.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS GOOD
MORNING AYE DAVID WOLF TODAY
ACTUALLY REPRESENTING THE ARE ST
INSTITUTE.
THE OUR STUDENTS TO HEAR IS A
NONPROFIT NONPARTISAN NATIONWIDE
THINK TANK FOCUSED ON INDIVIDUAL
LIBERTY AND FREE MARKET ISSUES
THESE INCLUDE INSURANCE ISSUES
CRIMINAL JUSTICE REFORM
INSURANCE AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES.
AN ISSUE BEFORE US TODAY
OCCUPATIONAL LICENSING EXAM XIN.
THE OUR STUDENTS TO TEACH IS THE
SPONSOR S. B. NINE NINE NINE
WHICH EXEMPTS A NUMBER OF HER
BEAUTIFICATION SERVICES
INCLUDING ARRANGING. DRESSING
CURLING IN SHAMPOOING FROM
NEEDING A BARTERING AND
COSMETOLOGY LICENSE.
MISTER CHAIRMAN I KNOW THIS.
COMMITTEE IS FOCUSED PRIMARILY
ON FISCAL APPLICATIONS I AM
GOING TO FOCUS MY POINTS ON THAT.
WE DO DISPUTE MEMBERS A COUPLE
OF POINTS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF
CONSUMER AFFAIRS ANALYSIS.
WELL THERE WILL OBVIOUSLY BE A
LOSS OF REVENUE FROM SOME
INDIVIDUALS NOT NEEDING TO BE
LICENSED THERE APPEARS TO BE
LITTLE RATIONALE FOR A FOUR
PERCENT FIGURE. AND HOW THAT WAS
DETERMINED WE BELIEVE THAT
FIGURE IS A LITTLE HIGH AND IN
ANY EVENT IT MAY WELL BE OFFSET
FROM INCREASED INCOME TAX.
BECAUSE PEOPLE WOULD NOW BE
ACTUALLY WORKING AND MAKING A
LIVING. MEMBERS WE KNOW THERE IS.
.
WE KNOW THERE'S A MARKET FOR
SHAMPOOING IN THESE OTHER THINGS
THAT WERE EXEMPTING IN THIS BILL
BECAUSE IT'S ACTUALLY ON THE
BARBARIAN COSMETOLOGY WEBSITE IF
YOU LOOK AT THEIR FREQUENTLY
ASKED QUESTIONS. THE QUESTION OF
CAN I SHAMPOO IS ACTUALLY NUMBER
EIGHT IN THERE FOR CLASS
QUESTIONS AND OF COURSE THE
ANSWER IS NO BECAUSE THEY CAN'T
SHAMPOO RIGHT NOW.
WITHOUT SPENDING YOU KNOW
FIFTEEN HUNDRED HOURS OF
EDUCATION AND MEETING TWO EXAMS
A PRACTICAL ON A WRITTEN EXAM TO
BE ABLE TO SHAMPOO SO WE KNOW
THERE'S A MARKET THERE BECAUSE
THIS IS A QUESTION A LOT OF
PEOPLE ASK ON A REGULAR BASIS.
AND MEMBERS WE ALSO AGREE WITH
THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS
THAT.
RAISES THE ISSUE OF WHETHER IN
YOU EXAM IS NEEDED AND YOU KNOW
DISPUTES THAT MIGHT NOT BE THE
CASE AND WE AGREE THAT.
SUMMARILY EXEMPTING OUT THESE
APPLICATIONS YOU SHOULDN'T EVEN
YOU EXAMINE IF YOU DO THE COSTS
ARE NOT GOING TO BE AS MUCH.
AS DCA HAS PRESENTED SO.
WE DO ASK THAT THIS BOOK OFF
SUSPENSE AT THE PROPER TIME
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU MISTER WOLF.
LISTEN WITNESSES EN SUPPORT WHEN
THIS IS IN OPPOSITION FINANCE A
FILE COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE.
CNN WHAT OBJECTION WILL THIS
ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SENATOR MAGUIRE'S
REMAINING ITEMS BEGINNING WITH
S. B. ELEVEN FIFTY EIGHT.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCING FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE.
I THINK THEM WITHOUT OBJECTION
WHEN MORE THIS ITEM TO THE
SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SP FOURTEEN FIFTEEN.
ONE THIS ISN'T SUPPORT. WHEN
THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE.
BUT FOR.
THAT GOT IT POUND CARP REPORTS
OF COMMITTEES THING NAM.
A WITHOUT OBJECTION MOVE THIS
ITEM TO SUSPENSE FAMILY NOTS SP
FOURTEEN THIRTY FOUR BY SENATOR
LEYVA. WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT
ONE THIS IS AN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE NO FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION WHEN WILL
THIS ITEMS OF SUSPENSE FOUND.
GOING ON A CENTER ANDERSON'S
ITEM S. B. TEN NINETY FOUR. WHEN
THIS ISN'T SUPPORTER. WHEN THIS
IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCING FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SAYING
NOW WITH OBJECTION WILL THIS
ITEM TO SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO CENTER MORLOCKS
ARMS BEGINNING WITH S. B. TEN
NINETY NINE.
WHEN THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMES A QUESTIONS
FROM COMMITTEE THING HERE NONE
WITHOUT OBJECTION WE MOVE THIS
ITEM TO SUSPENSE FAR. MOVING ON
TO S. B. TWELVE NINETY SEVEN.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE THE FIRE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
NONE WITHOUT OBJECTION WE MOVE
THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO SB THIRTEEN NINETY
FIVE ONE THIS ISN'T SUPPORT ONCE
IS AN OPPOSITION FINANCE A FILE.
COMMENTS OF COURSE ISN'T
COMMITTEE THING AND NOW WITHOUT
OBJECTION WILL THIS I DON'T
DISPENSED OUT.
MOVING ON TO SET OUR NEWMAN'S
ITEMS BEGINNING WITH S. B.
ELEVEN SEVENTY NINE. WHEN THIS
ISN'T SUPPORT WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION FINANCES FILE.
COMMENTS OF COURSE ISN'T
COMMITTEE THING HEARING NONE
WITHOUT OBJECTION WHEN WILL THIS
ITEM TO SUSPEND FILE. MOVING ON
TO SB THIRTEEN TWELVE WHEN THIS
ISN'T SUPPORT. WHEN THIS IS IN
OPPOSITION FINANCE A FILE.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE SINGING NONE OF THAT
OBJECTION WILL THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FILE. MOVING ON TO S.
B. THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT WHEN
THIS IS AN OPPOSITION. FINANCE A
FILE COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE SINGING NOT
OBJECTIONABLE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE WHILE. MOVING ON TO S.
B. FOURTEEN OH SEVEN. WHEN THIS
ISN'T SUPPORTER. WHEN IS AS AN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCING FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS WHO COMMITTEE THING
NAM WITHOUT OBJECTION WE MOVE
THIS ITEM SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO CENTER AGO JOHNNY'S
ITEMS.
BEGINNING WITH S. B. TWELVE
FORTY NINE WHEN THIS IS IN
SUPPORT SO SOCIAL COMPASSIONATE
LEGISLATION SPONSORED THE BILL.
THE FISCAL IMPACT A SAYS THAT.
IN THE ANALYSIS OF VIOLATIONS
OF THIS BILL LEAD TO MORE THAN
NINETEEN NEW LIMITED CIVIL CASES
MORE THAN FOUR UNLIMITED CIVIL
ARE FEW COMPLEX CASES. THEN TAKE
LONGER THAN SEVEN DAYS IT WOULD
RISE ABOVE THE SUSPENSE
THRESHOLD AND WHAT WHAT I WOULD
LIKE TO SAY IS WE DON'T BELIEVE
IT WOULD EVER COME CLOSE TO
MEETING THAT THRESHOLD. AND THE
REASON IS THIS IS A BIG BILL AND
PEOPLE ARE WATCHING IT
THROUGHOUT THE WORLD AND THERE-ARE OTHER COUNTRIES WHO HAVE
ALREADY GONE IN THIS DIRECTION.
THOUGH THE WINDS ARE IN OUR
SAILS MOVING TO CRUELTY FREE SO
WHEN THIS BECOMES LAW AND
THERE'S A A ONE YEAR DELAYED
IMPLEMENTATION.
THE COMPANIES ARE GONNA WELL
KNOW THAT THIS IS A LAW SO YOU
KNOW THIS THIS IS VERY
NEGLIGIBLE. MAYBE THERE'S A
COUPLE CASES WE DIDN'T SEE IT
WITH OUR PUPPY MILL BILL THAT
THAT WE'VE DONE AND LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS SO WE DON'T REALLY
SEE THIS HAPPENING. AND THAT'S
WHAT I WANTED TO SAY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION.
QUESTION MEMBERS ME ANYWAY ON
BEHALF OF THE PERSONAL CARE
PRODUCTS COUNCIL OPPOSED TO THE
BILL.
WE'D DO NOT DISAGREE WITH THE
GOAL WE DISAGREE WITH THE
APPROACH
ON THE FISCAL WE WANT TO THANK
THE COMMITTEE FOR VERY THOROUGH
ANALYSIS AND YOUR WISDOM IN
RECOGNIZING. THE FACT THAT THIS
COULD HAVE A VERY UNDUE BURDEN
ON OUR ALREADY STRUGGLING TRIAL
COURTS THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
GOT A. FINANCE.
WHILE.
COMES A QUESTION FROM COMMITTEE.
SINGER NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
MOVE THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE FILE
MOVING ON TO S. B. THIRTEEN
NINETY SIX.
ONE IS IN SUPPORT. WHEN THIS IS
IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE THE FILE.
COMES OF COURSE ISN'T COMMITTEE
THING NINE WITHOUT OBJECTION
WILL THIS ITEM TO SUSPECTS FOUND.
MOVING ON SAYS CENTER STONE'S
ITEM S. B. TWELVE.
IT'S THE FOUR WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT. WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE.
COMES OF COURSE ISN'T COMMITTEE.
THING HEARING NONE WITH
OBJECTIONABLE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FOUND.
MOVING ON TO S. B. TWELVE SIXTY
SIX PERCENT ARE PORTANTINO WHEN
THIS ISN'T SUPPORT. ONE IS IS AN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCING FILE.
GOMEZ REQUESTS FROM COMMITTEE
THING AND NOW WITHOUT OBJECTION
AND MOVE THIS ITEM TO SUSPENSE
FILE.
MOVING ON TO CENTER HILLS ITEMS
SP TWELVE FORTY THREE. WHEN.
I'M SORRY TWELVE SEVENTY THREE.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE IF I COME A SUPPORT
SYSTEM COMMITTEE SEEING AND
HEARING NO OBJECTION WE MOVE
THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FIVE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. FOURTEEN
SEVENTY FOUR. WHEN THIS IS IN
SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE PLAN COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE SEEING
THEIR NON WITHOUT OBJECTION MOVE
THIS ITEM TO SUSPEND STYLE.
MOVING ON TO SENATOR WESSELS
ITEM S. B. TWELVE SEVENTY EIGHT.
WHEN THIS IS.
IN SUPPORT WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS OF COMMITTEE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE. WITHOUT
OBJECTION WE MOVE THIS ITEM TO
SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO S. B. TWELVE NINETY
TWO WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
FINANCE FILE.
SCENE OUTCOMES QUIZILLA
COMMITTEE THING NAM WITH ARABS
OBJECTS GOING MOVE THIS ITEM TO
THE SUSPENSE FIVE.
MOVING ON TO SB FOURTEEN FORTY
ONE ASSISTANCE SUPPORT. WHEN
THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCING PLAN.
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE WITHOUT OBJECTION MORE
THIS ITEM TO THE SUSPENSE FILE.
MOVING ON TO OUR LAST ITEM ON
OUR AGENDA SENATOR BY SENATOR
ATKINS.
S. B. THIRTEEN FIFTY SEVEN.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WHEN THIS IS IN OPPOSITION.
FINANCE FILE. COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM COMMITTEE THING
OF HAVING DONE WITHOUT OBJECTION.
WE MOVE THIS ITEM TO THE
SUSPENSE FIRE ALL.
LOOK THINK WE ARE DONE FOR TODAY
MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR.
BEATS A PATIENT WITH US TODAY
AS WE HAD A FULL AGENDA. IS.
AND JUST A REMINDER FOR. THOSE
FOLKS ARE INTERESTED WILL
ACTUALLY MEETING ON TUESDAY NEXT
WEEK CORRECTS.
PERFECT THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE ARE JOINED