WEBVTT
Region: id=rollup2 lines=2 scroll=up
00:00:11.144 --> 00:00:13.747 region:rollup2
TRY TO ESTABLISH A QUORUM BUT
00:00:12.513 --> 00:00:15.749 region:rollup2
WE WILL START AS A SUB COMMITTEE
00:00:13.747 --> 00:00:17.684 region:rollup2
AT THIS POINT IN TIME. FOR THOSE
00:00:15.749 --> 00:00:19.786 region:rollup2
OF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THIS
00:00:17.684 --> 00:00:21.889 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE WE HAVE A. A NEW FACE
00:00:19.786 --> 00:00:22.923 region:rollup2
HERE ON THE DYESS YOU WILL
00:00:21.889 --> 00:00:23.891 region:rollup2
NOTICE AND.
00:00:22.923 --> 00:00:27.461 region:rollup2
I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE OUR
00:00:23.891 --> 00:00:29.263 region:rollup2
NEWEST COMMITTEE COUNSEL JOSH.
00:00:27.461 --> 00:00:30.464 region:rollup2
BECAUSE NY WHO HAS JOINED US A
00:00:29.263 --> 00:00:32.432 region:rollup2
WELCOME ABOARD. AND TO.
00:00:30.464 --> 00:00:33.634 region:rollup2
.
00:00:32.432 --> 00:00:34.768 region:rollup2
OF I'M SURE WILL KEEP YOU VERY
00:00:33.634 --> 00:00:36.904 region:rollup2
BUSY ALONG WITH THE REST OF THIS
00:00:34.768 --> 00:00:38.772 region:rollup2
WONDERFUL STAFF.
00:00:36.904 --> 00:00:40.340 region:rollup2
WE DO HAVE FIVE ITEMS ON
00:00:38.772 --> 00:00:42.276 region:rollup2
PROPOSED CONSENT WHICH.
00:00:40.340 --> 00:00:44.344 region:rollup2
.
00:00:42.276 --> 00:00:46.013 region:rollup2
BASICALLY MEANS THAT WE WILL NOT
00:00:44.344 --> 00:00:48.782 region:rollup2
BE TAKING TESTIMONY ON THOSE
00:00:46.013 --> 00:00:51.251 region:rollup2
MEASURES THEIR FILE ITEM ONE S.
00:00:48.782 --> 00:00:52.686 region:rollup2
B. EIGHT EIGHTY ONE BY.
00:00:51.251 --> 00:00:55.989 region:rollup2
A US SENATOR Y. KOWSKI FILE ITEM
00:00:52.686 --> 00:00:57.925 region:rollup2
THREE. SB NINE SIXTY NINE BY
00:00:55.989 --> 00:01:01.695 region:rollup2
SENATOR DODD.
00:00:57.925 --> 00:01:04.665 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM FOR S. B. NINE SEVENTY
00:01:01.695 --> 00:01:05.632 region:rollup2
BY A PRESS INFOTAINMENT ATKINS.
00:01:04.665 --> 00:01:08.969 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM SEVEN S. B. ELEVEN
00:01:05.632 --> 00:01:11.872 region:rollup2
FIFTY SENATOR JACKSON. FILE ITEM
00:01:08.969 --> 00:01:14.041 region:rollup2
ELEVEN SP THIRTEEN TWENTY BY
00:01:11.872 --> 00:01:16.643 region:rollup2
SENATOR STUBBORN SO IF ANY OF
00:01:14.041 --> 00:01:17.010 region:rollup2
YOU ARE HERE TO SPEAK ON THOSE
00:01:16.643 --> 00:01:19.446 region:rollup2
MATTERS.
00:01:17.010 --> 00:01:20.948 region:rollup2
YOU CAN GO HOME OR IF YOU WOULD
00:01:19.446 --> 00:01:23.850 region:rollup2
JUST LIKE TO ENJOY THIS
00:01:20.948 --> 00:01:26.720 region:rollup2
FASCINATING. OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:01:23.850 --> 00:01:29.423 region:rollup2
WE WILL BE HEADED ON WITH A
00:01:26.720 --> 00:01:31.058 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF BILLS GOING FORWARD.
00:01:29.423 --> 00:01:32.793 region:rollup2
STAND AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME
00:01:31.058 --> 00:01:35.028 region:rollup2
WHEN WE HAVE ESTABLISHED A
00:01:32.793 --> 00:01:36.663 region:rollup2
QUORUM WE WILL. MOVE THE CONSENT
00:01:35.028 --> 00:01:38.565 region:rollup2
CALENDAR AT THAT TIME AND WE DO
00:01:36.663 --> 00:01:40.801 region:rollup2
HAVE AN AUTHOR PRESENT AND SO WE
00:01:38.565 --> 00:01:43.170 region:rollup2
WILL. PROCEED.
00:01:40.801 --> 00:01:44.338 region:rollup2
WITH FILE ITEM THIRTEEN LUCKY
00:01:43.170 --> 00:01:47.207 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN.
00:01:44.338 --> 00:01:50.377 region:rollup2
SP THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR BY
00:01:47.207 --> 00:01:53.113 region:rollup2
SENATOR NEWMAN.
00:01:50.377 --> 00:01:54.982 region:rollup2
SENATOR MOVE NEWMAN WELCOME.
00:01:53.113 --> 00:01:56.650 region:rollup2
AND DIE I WOULD LIKE TO INDICATE
00:01:54.982 --> 00:01:57.517 region:rollup2
TO THAT THE WAY THIS SITE
00:01:56.650 --> 00:01:59.052 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE DOES.
00:01:57.517 --> 00:02:00.887 region:rollup2
OPERATE.
00:01:59.052 --> 00:02:03.924 region:rollup2
IS THAT.
00:02:00.887 --> 00:02:06.460 region:rollup2
WE ALLOW THE OF.
00:02:03.924 --> 00:02:08.428 region:rollup2
AUTHOR TO SPEAK GO WE DON'T
00:02:06.460 --> 00:02:10.464 region:rollup2
NECESSARILY CREATE A TIME. A
00:02:08.428 --> 00:02:10.931 region:rollup2
LIMIT BUT BUT WE DO THEN ASK
00:02:10.464 --> 00:02:13.367 region:rollup2
THAT THERE BE TWO MAIN
00:02:10.931 --> 00:02:15.802 region:rollup2
WITNESSES.
00:02:13.367 --> 00:02:16.403 region:rollup2
TWO MINUTES EACH IN SUPPORT OF A
00:02:15.802 --> 00:02:18.005 region:rollup2
WILL THEN ASK OTHERS WHO WISH
00:02:16.403 --> 00:02:20.340 region:rollup2
TO.
00:02:18.005 --> 00:02:21.775 region:rollup2
TESTIFIED TO COME UP TO THE
00:02:20.340 --> 00:02:23.877 region:rollup2
MICROPHONE GIVE THEIR NAME
00:02:21.775 --> 00:02:26.113 region:rollup2
AFFILIATION AND OBVIOUSLY THEIR
00:02:23.877 --> 00:02:32.319 region:rollup2
POSITION. BY IN SUPPORT OR
00:02:26.113 --> 00:02:33.754 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION WITHOUT OVER. THE.
00:02:32.319 --> 00:02:35.222 region:rollup2
PRECIPITATION JUST NAME AND A
00:02:33.754 --> 00:02:35.956 region:rollup2
IDENTIFICATION. AND THEN WE WILL
00:02:35.222 --> 00:02:36.723 region:rollup2
SIMILARLY HAVE TWO MAIN
00:02:35.956 --> 00:02:39.159 region:rollup2
WITNESSES.
00:02:36.723 --> 00:02:41.561 region:rollup2
IF THERE ARE TWO TO APPEAR IN
00:02:39.159 --> 00:02:44.431 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION TWO MINUTES EACH FOR
00:02:41.561 --> 00:02:46.299 region:rollup2
THEIR OPPOSITION IN AGAIN ALL
00:02:44.431 --> 00:02:48.335 region:rollup2
OTHERS WHO WISH TO OPPOSE A
00:02:46.299 --> 00:02:49.436 region:rollup2
MEASURE TO COME FORWARD. BY AND
00:02:48.335 --> 00:02:52.005 region:rollup2
TO STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR
00:02:49.436 --> 00:02:54.641 region:rollup2
POSITION OCCASIONALLY WE HAVE A
00:02:52.005 --> 00:02:56.576 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHO WERE ENTHUSIASTICALLY
00:02:54.641 --> 00:02:58.912 region:rollup2
NEUTRAL. AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO
00:02:56.576 --> 00:03:01.281 region:rollup2
COME UP AND STATE YOUR POSITION
00:02:58.912 --> 00:03:02.549 region:rollup2
ON THAT TO ARE. CERTAINLY
00:03:01.281 --> 00:03:04.151 region:rollup2
WELCOME TO DO THAT.
00:03:02.549 --> 00:03:05.919 region:rollup2
SO WITH THAT SENATOR NEWMAN
00:03:04.151 --> 00:03:09.656 region:rollup2
WELCOME AND PLEASE PROCEED.
00:03:05.919 --> 00:03:10.957 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
00:03:09.656 --> 00:03:11.491 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR AND SENATORS I AM
00:03:10.957 --> 00:03:12.726 region:rollup2
HERE BEFORE YOU TODAY TO
00:03:11.491 --> 00:03:14.361 region:rollup2
ADVOCATE ON BEHALF OF SP
00:03:12.726 --> 00:03:16.329 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR. UNDER ITS
00:03:14.361 --> 00:03:17.731 region:rollup2
PROVISIONS BY ELIMINATING COMMON
00:03:16.329 --> 00:03:19.399 region:rollup2
PRACTICES IN THE GATHERING OF
00:03:17.731 --> 00:03:20.567 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES FOR BALLOT MEASURES
00:03:19.399 --> 00:03:22.569 region:rollup2
WHICH INCENTIVIZE THE WILLFUL
00:03:20.567 --> 00:03:24.438 region:rollup2
DECEPTION VOTERS SP THIRTEEN
00:03:22.569 --> 00:03:25.472 region:rollup2
NINETY FOUR WILL TAKE NECESSARY.
00:03:24.438 --> 00:03:26.573 region:rollup2
AND IMPORTANT STEPS TOWARD
00:03:25.472 --> 00:03:27.974 region:rollup2
SAFEGUARDING THE INTEGRITY OF
00:03:26.573 --> 00:03:30.844 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA'S INITIATIVE
00:03:27.974 --> 00:03:32.245 region:rollup2
REFERENDUM AND RECALL PROCESSES.
00:03:30.844 --> 00:03:34.147 region:rollup2
TUB FIRST A LITTLE BACKGROUND IS
00:03:32.245 --> 00:03:35.615 region:rollup2
IN ORDER. TO AS A RESULT OF THE
00:03:34.147 --> 00:03:37.417 region:rollup2
PROGRESSIVE REFORMS OF THE EARLY
00:03:35.615 --> 00:03:38.785 region:rollup2
TWENTY CENTURY CALIFORNIA'S
00:03:37.417 --> 00:03:39.920 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTION MAKES EXPLICIT
00:03:38.785 --> 00:03:41.755 region:rollup2
PROVISIONS THAT ALLOW FOR THE
00:03:39.920 --> 00:03:43.523 region:rollup2
CITIZENRY. TO TAKE DIRECT ACTION
00:03:41.755 --> 00:03:45.759 region:rollup2
OUTSIDE THE NORMAL LEGISLATIVE
00:03:43.523 --> 00:03:47.360 region:rollup2
PROCESS IN ORDER TO ENACT REPEAL
00:03:45.759 --> 00:03:48.628 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION ORDER MOVIE CORRUPT
00:03:47.360 --> 00:03:50.630 region:rollup2
OR MALFEASANCE ELECTED OFFICIAL
00:03:48.628 --> 00:03:52.599 region:rollup2
FROM OFFICE. AS FORMER GOVERNOR
00:03:50.630 --> 00:03:53.266 region:rollup2
HIRAM JOHNSON AND HIS FELLOW
00:03:52.599 --> 00:03:55.202 region:rollup2
PROGRESSIVE REFORMERS ENVISIONED
00:03:53.266 --> 00:03:56.903 region:rollup2
AT. THE PROVISION FOR A PROCESS
00:03:55.202 --> 00:03:58.505 region:rollup2
WHEREBY AN ELECTED OFFICIAL
00:03:56.903 --> 00:04:00.140 region:rollup2
COULD BE RECALLED BY HIS OR HER
00:03:58.505 --> 00:04:04.644 region:rollup2
VOTERS WOULD ALLOW FOR THEIR OR
00:04:00.140 --> 00:04:07.114 region:rollup2
ALLOW. THAT FOR THE REPEAL OR
00:04:04.644 --> 00:04:08.715 region:rollup2
REPLACEMENT OF UNJUST LAWS.
00:04:07.114 --> 00:04:09.282 region:rollup2
GOD OR THE REPLACEMENT RECALL
00:04:08.715 --> 00:04:10.517 region:rollup2
SOME PUBLIC SERVANTS WHO HAD
00:04:09.282 --> 00:04:11.618 region:rollup2
COMMITTED AN ACT OF MALFEASANCE
00:04:10.517 --> 00:04:12.986 region:rollup2
OR OTHERWISE REACH THE PUBLIC'S
00:04:11.618 --> 00:04:14.187 region:rollup2
TRUST. SUCH AS THE REMOVAL PRIOR
00:04:12.986 --> 00:04:14.788 region:rollup2
THE NEXT ELECTION SITE WILL BE
00:04:14.187 --> 00:04:14.988 region:rollup2
IN THE SERVICE OF THE GREATER
00:04:14.788 --> 00:04:15.555 region:rollup2
GOOD.
00:04:14.988 --> 00:04:16.323 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THE FRAMERS OF THE
00:04:15.555 --> 00:04:17.924 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE REFERENDUM AND RECALL
00:04:16.323 --> 00:04:20.093 region:rollup2
PROCESSES REGARD THESE ACTIONS
00:04:17.924 --> 00:04:21.461 region:rollup2
AS POPULIST ACTIONS OF LAST
00:04:20.093 --> 00:04:23.063 region:rollup2
RESORT. THEY DELIVER EARLY
00:04:21.461 --> 00:04:24.131 region:rollup2
PROVIDED THAT IN ORDER TO
00:04:23.063 --> 00:04:25.532 region:rollup2
QUALIFY FOR THE BALLOT THE
00:04:24.131 --> 00:04:26.266 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS OF ANY OF THESE
00:04:25.532 --> 00:04:28.168 region:rollup2
DIRECT TO THE VOTERS PLEASE
00:04:26.266 --> 00:04:29.970 region:rollup2
BESIDES WOULD FIRST BE REQUIRED
00:04:28.168 --> 00:04:31.905 region:rollup2
TO GATHER A SUFFICIENT NUMBER OF
00:04:29.970 --> 00:04:33.273 region:rollup2
VOTER SIGNATURES. AS A NECESSARY
00:04:31.905 --> 00:04:36.176 region:rollup2
BASIS FOR VALIDATING THE
00:04:33.273 --> 00:04:37.377 region:rollup2
LEGITIMACY AND POPULAR SUPPORT
00:04:36.176 --> 00:04:38.612 region:rollup2
FOR SUCH AN ACTION SET OF.
00:04:37.377 --> 00:04:40.046 region:rollup2
IT'S BEEN.
00:04:38.612 --> 00:04:41.481 region:rollup2
I APOLOGIZE FOR INTERRUPTING WE
00:04:40.046 --> 00:04:43.116 region:rollup2
DO HAVE A QUORUM I'D LIKE TO
00:04:41.481 --> 00:04:45.051 region:rollup2
ESTABLISH A QUICKLY BECAUSE I
00:04:43.116 --> 00:04:46.486 region:rollup2
KNOW SOME OF THESE PEOPLE ARE
00:04:45.051 --> 00:04:47.988 region:rollup2
GOING TO HAVE TO BE RUNNING BACK
00:04:46.486 --> 00:04:49.623 region:rollup2
AND FORTH SO. MADAM SECRETARY
00:04:47.988 --> 00:04:52.392 region:rollup2
LET'S ESTABLISH A QUORUM PLEASE
00:04:49.623 --> 00:04:53.727 region:rollup2
CALL THE ROLL. JACKSON HERE
00:04:52.392 --> 00:04:56.096 region:rollup2
JACKSON HERE MORE LOCK.
00:04:53.727 --> 00:04:58.765 region:rollup2
ELECT HERE ANDERSON HERTZBERG
00:04:56.096 --> 00:05:00.700 region:rollup2
MORNING. MORNING HERE STERN
00:04:58.765 --> 00:05:02.936 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI HERE'S MY CASKET HERE
00:05:00.700 --> 00:05:04.538 region:rollup2
ART WE HAVE ESTABLISHED A QUORUM
00:05:02.936 --> 00:05:06.673 region:rollup2
PLEASE PROCEED WELCOME CENTER
00:05:04.538 --> 00:05:08.441 region:rollup2
MORE LIKE. A REGARDING S. B.
00:05:06.673 --> 00:05:09.242 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR. THAT TO
00:05:08.441 --> 00:05:10.443 region:rollup2
THE ORIGINAL FRAMERS WAY OF
00:05:09.242 --> 00:05:12.345 region:rollup2
THINKING THE INITIAL REFERENDUM
00:05:10.443 --> 00:05:13.947 region:rollup2
AND RECALL REPRESENT A MEANS FOR
00:05:12.345 --> 00:05:15.482 region:rollup2
THE LITTLE GUY TO CHIU DIRECT
00:05:13.947 --> 00:05:17.217 region:rollup2
CURATIVE IN REFORMS ACTIONS THAT
00:05:15.482 --> 00:05:19.085 region:rollup2
ELECTED INVESTED INTEREST MIGHT
00:05:17.217 --> 00:05:20.620 region:rollup2
OTHERWISE THWART. OVER THE YEARS
00:05:19.085 --> 00:05:21.922 region:rollup2
ESPECIALLY IN RECENT DECADES
00:05:20.620 --> 00:05:23.390 region:rollup2
HOWEVER SOMETHING VERY DIFFERENT
00:05:21.922 --> 00:05:25.125 region:rollup2
HAS TRANSPIRED THESE IDEALISTIC
00:05:23.390 --> 00:05:25.792 region:rollup2
WE FORGED TOOLS OF DIRECT
00:05:25.125 --> 00:05:27.427 region:rollup2
DEMOCRACY HAVE BEEN EFFECTIVELY
00:05:25.792 --> 00:05:28.795 region:rollup2
COOPTED BY THE VERY MONEY
00:05:27.427 --> 00:05:31.097 region:rollup2
INTEREST THEY WERE ORIGINALLY
00:05:28.795 --> 00:05:32.399 region:rollup2
INTENDED. TO OFF SET WELL FUNDED
00:05:31.097 --> 00:05:33.733 region:rollup2
ORGANIZATIONS WITH INCREASINGLY
00:05:32.399 --> 00:05:35.502 region:rollup2
EXPLICIT SELF INTERESTED
00:05:33.733 --> 00:05:37.170 region:rollup2
MOTIVATIONS HAVE BECOME EVER
00:05:35.502 --> 00:05:38.605 region:rollup2
MORE ADEPT AT USING INITIATIVE
00:05:37.170 --> 00:05:39.973 region:rollup2
REFERENDUM AND RECALL PROCESS
00:05:38.605 --> 00:05:42.042 region:rollup2
CITIES TO THEIR TACTICAL AND
00:05:39.973 --> 00:05:43.410 region:rollup2
STRATEGIC ADVANTAGE. FEELING AN
00:05:42.042 --> 00:05:44.811 region:rollup2
ARMS RACE OF SORTS ESPECIALLY TO
00:05:43.410 --> 00:05:46.780 region:rollup2
AS IT PERTAINS TO SIGNATURE
00:05:44.811 --> 00:05:47.814 region:rollup2
GATHERING. AT THE CENTER OF ALL
00:05:46.780 --> 00:05:49.149 region:rollup2
THIS INTENSE SPECIAL INTERESTS
00:05:47.814 --> 00:05:50.717 region:rollup2
DRIVEN ACTIVITY THEIR SMALL
00:05:49.149 --> 00:05:52.853 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF SPECIALIZED FIRMS WITH
00:05:50.717 --> 00:05:54.688 region:rollup2
EXPERTISE IN SIGNATURE GATHERING
00:05:52.853 --> 00:05:55.989 region:rollup2
HAVE RISEN TO THE FOR. OFFERING
00:05:54.688 --> 00:05:59.392 region:rollup2
THEIR SERVICES TO PROPONENTS
00:05:55.989 --> 00:05:59.759 region:rollup2
SEEKING A PLACE A MEASURE ON THE
00:05:59.392 --> 00:06:01.261 region:rollup2
BALLOT.
00:05:59.759 --> 00:06:02.128 region:rollup2
ONE OF THE PRINCIPAL TACTICS
00:06:01.261 --> 00:06:02.696 region:rollup2
USED BY THESE HIGHLY PAID SIX
00:06:02.128 --> 00:06:03.597 region:rollup2
ARE GATHERING FIRMS IS THE
00:06:02.696 --> 00:06:04.931 region:rollup2
DEPLOYMENT OF WELL TRAINED
00:06:03.597 --> 00:06:06.299 region:rollup2
PROFESSIONAL GATHERS SINGER
00:06:04.931 --> 00:06:08.268 region:rollup2
GATHERS ON BEHALF OF THEIR
00:06:06.299 --> 00:06:09.836 region:rollup2
CLIENTS PETITIONS. TYPICALLY THE
00:06:08.268 --> 00:06:11.972 region:rollup2
SINGER GATHERS ARE PAID ON A PER
00:06:09.836 --> 00:06:13.873 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE OR COMMISSION BASIS
00:06:11.972 --> 00:06:15.508 region:rollup2
ALSO KNOWN AS A BOUNTY AT A RATE
00:06:13.873 --> 00:06:16.977 region:rollup2
DETERMINED BY THE MARKET AS IT
00:06:15.508 --> 00:06:17.911 region:rollup2
IS ASSESSED AT THE TIME.
00:06:16.977 --> 00:06:19.346 region:rollup2
DEPENDING ON THE NATURE THE AN
00:06:17.911 --> 00:06:20.580 region:rollup2
ISSUE OF THE CHARACTERISTICS OF
00:06:19.346 --> 00:06:21.982 region:rollup2
THE DISTRICT THE TIME OF YEAR
00:06:20.580 --> 00:06:23.350 region:rollup2
MORE COMPETITION WITH OTHER
00:06:21.982 --> 00:06:24.517 region:rollup2
INITIATIVES AT A GIVEN TIME THE
00:06:23.350 --> 00:06:26.253 region:rollup2
COST PER SIGNATURE CAN VARY
00:06:24.517 --> 00:06:27.520 region:rollup2
WIDELY. FROM AS LOW AS TWO
00:06:26.253 --> 00:06:29.489 region:rollup2
DOLLARS PER SIGNATURE GATHERED
00:06:27.520 --> 00:06:30.690 region:rollup2
TO AS HIGH AS TWENTY DOLLARS PER
00:06:29.489 --> 00:06:32.559 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE GATHERED. BECAUSE
00:06:30.690 --> 00:06:34.127 region:rollup2
BOUNTY PAGE SIGNATURES GATHERS
00:06:32.559 --> 00:06:35.462 region:rollup2
OPTIMIZE THEIR YIELD BASED ON
00:06:34.127 --> 00:06:37.364 region:rollup2
HOW RAPIDLY THEY CAN SECURE
00:06:35.462 --> 00:06:38.598 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES FROM VOTERS. THEY
00:06:37.364 --> 00:06:40.033 region:rollup2
FRUGALLY TRAFFICKING MISLEADING
00:06:38.598 --> 00:06:41.768 region:rollup2
INFORMATION AND SOMETIMES
00:06:40.033 --> 00:06:42.869 region:rollup2
OUTRIGHT FALSEHOODS IN ORDER TO
00:06:41.768 --> 00:06:45.138 region:rollup2
INDUCE AS MANY VOTERS AS
00:06:42.869 --> 00:06:45.839 region:rollup2
POSSIBLE TO SIGN IN THE MINIMUM
00:06:45.138 --> 00:06:47.941 region:rollup2
AMOUNT OF TIME.
00:06:45.839 --> 00:06:49.075 region:rollup2
THIS DESPITE THE FACT THAT UNDER
00:06:47.941 --> 00:06:50.744 region:rollup2
EXISTING ELECTIONS IN GOVERNMENT
00:06:49.075 --> 00:06:52.879 region:rollup2
CODE CALIFORNIA IT IS ALREADY
00:06:50.744 --> 00:06:55.048 region:rollup2
EXPRESSLY ILLEGAL IN OUR STATE
00:06:52.879 --> 00:06:56.349 region:rollup2
TO INTENTION TO MSLEAD A VOTER
00:06:55.048 --> 00:06:57.517 region:rollup2
AS TO THE NATURE AND INTENT OF
00:06:56.349 --> 00:06:58.184 region:rollup2
THE SIGNATURE GATHERING EFFORT.
00:06:57.517 --> 00:06:59.819 region:rollup2
PER THE ELECTION OF THE
00:06:58.184 --> 00:07:01.321 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ELECTIONS CODE
00:06:59.819 --> 00:07:03.256 region:rollup2
SECTION EIGHTEEN SIX HUNDRED.
00:07:01.321 --> 00:07:04.824 region:rollup2
AND I'LL READ EVERY PERSON IS
00:07:03.256 --> 00:07:06.293 region:rollup2
GUILTY OF A MISDEMEANOR WHO.
00:07:04.824 --> 00:07:07.560 region:rollup2
IT WHEN CIRCULATING AS
00:07:06.293 --> 00:07:09.729 region:rollup2
PRINCIPAL OR AGENT OR AT FOR
00:07:07.560 --> 00:07:10.997 region:rollup2
HAVING CHARGE OR CONTROL OF THE
00:07:09.729 --> 00:07:12.933 region:rollup2
CIRCULATION. OF RETAINING
00:07:10.997 --> 00:07:15.068 region:rollup2
SEIZURES TO ANY STATE OR LOCAL
00:07:12.933 --> 00:07:16.269 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE.
00:07:15.068 --> 00:07:17.370 region:rollup2
INTENSELY MAKES ANY FALSE
00:07:16.269 --> 00:07:19.706 region:rollup2
STATEMENT CONCERNING THE
00:07:17.370 --> 00:07:21.174 region:rollup2
CONTENTS PURPORT OR AFFECTED THE
00:07:19.706 --> 00:07:22.575 region:rollup2
PETITION TO ANY PERSON WHO SIGNS
00:07:21.174 --> 00:07:23.743 region:rollup2
OR DESIRES TO SIGN OR WHO IS
00:07:22.575 --> 00:07:25.445 region:rollup2
REQUESTED TO SIGN OVER MAKES
00:07:23.743 --> 00:07:26.579 region:rollup2
INQUIRES WITH REFERENCE TO IT OR
00:07:25.445 --> 00:07:28.748 region:rollup2
TO WHOM IT IS PRESENTED FOR HIS
00:07:26.579 --> 00:07:29.683 region:rollup2
OR HER SIGNATURE. THE OPPOSITION
00:07:28.748 --> 00:07:30.817 region:rollup2
THAT THEY'RE DESPERATE THIRTEEN
00:07:29.683 --> 00:07:31.985 region:rollup2
NINETY FOUR IS LIKELY TO TRY TO
00:07:30.817 --> 00:07:33.253 region:rollup2
PERSUADE YOU TODAY THAT THERE
00:07:31.985 --> 00:07:34.688 region:rollup2
HAVE BEEN RELATIVELY FEW
00:07:33.253 --> 00:07:35.789 region:rollup2
INSTANCES OF PROFESSIONAL
00:07:34.688 --> 00:07:38.525 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE GATHERERS EMPLOYING
00:07:35.789 --> 00:07:40.226 region:rollup2
THIS. IN THE CONTEXT OF
00:07:38.525 --> 00:07:42.028 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE GATHER CAMPAIGNS LE I
00:07:40.226 --> 00:07:43.396 region:rollup2
HAVE A WITNESS WHO WILL TESTIFY.
00:07:42.028 --> 00:07:45.398 region:rollup2
TO VERY VIVID FACT TO THE
00:07:43.396 --> 00:07:46.666 region:rollup2
CONTRARY GOT MORE OVER ANYONE
00:07:45.398 --> 00:07:47.934 region:rollup2
WHO IS AT ANY LEVEL OF DIRECT
00:07:46.666 --> 00:07:48.468 region:rollup2
EXPOSURE TO PETITIONS AND
00:07:47.934 --> 00:07:49.336 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE GATHERING IN OUR
00:07:48.468 --> 00:07:51.004 region:rollup2
STATE.
00:07:49.336 --> 00:07:52.806 region:rollup2
IN RECENT YEARS KNOWS FULL WELL
00:07:51.004 --> 00:07:54.074 region:rollup2
THAT THIS IS FAR FROM TRUE WHAT
00:07:52.806 --> 00:07:55.709 region:rollup2
IS TRUE HOWEVER IS THAT THERE
00:07:54.074 --> 00:07:57.544 region:rollup2
ARE RELATIVELY FEW DOCUMENTED
00:07:55.709 --> 00:07:58.978 region:rollup2
CASES OF SIX YOUR GATHERS BEING
00:07:57.544 --> 00:08:00.647 region:rollup2
CITED FOR SUCCESSFULLY
00:07:58.978 --> 00:08:02.449 region:rollup2
PROSECUTED FOR VIOLATIONS OF
00:08:00.647 --> 00:08:04.084 region:rollup2
EXISTING LAW. THIS IS TRUE FOR
00:08:02.449 --> 00:08:05.251 region:rollup2
TWO REASONS FIRST THERE IS A
00:08:04.084 --> 00:08:06.753 region:rollup2
PRESUMPTION THAT THE KINDS OF
00:08:05.251 --> 00:08:08.254 region:rollup2
SPEECH EMPLOYED DURING THE
00:08:06.753 --> 00:08:10.156 region:rollup2
CONDUCT OF POLITICAL CAMPAIGNS.
00:08:08.254 --> 00:08:11.291 region:rollup2
SHOULD BE GRANTED WIDE LATITUDE
00:08:10.156 --> 00:08:12.759 region:rollup2
SO THAT THERE IS A HIGH LEVEL OF
00:08:11.291 --> 00:08:14.361 region:rollup2
AMBIGUITY AS TO WHAT MIGHT CROSS
00:08:12.759 --> 00:08:15.462 region:rollup2
THE LINE FOR WHAT HAS BECOME
00:08:14.361 --> 00:08:17.530 region:rollup2
ACCEPTED IN THE CONDUCT OF
00:08:15.462 --> 00:08:18.031 region:rollup2
CAMPAIGNS AND WHAT MIGHT QUALIFY
00:08:17.530 --> 00:08:21.501 region:rollup2
AS A VIOLATION OF STATE
00:08:18.031 --> 00:08:22.035 region:rollup2
STATUTES.
00:08:21.501 --> 00:08:23.103 region:rollup2
SECOND THE ISSUES AROUND
00:08:22.035 --> 00:08:23.837 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT ARE AMPLIFIED BY A
00:08:23.103 --> 00:08:25.171 region:rollup2
COMBINATION BEEN HEARING OF
00:08:23.837 --> 00:08:26.039 region:rollup2
INHERENT CHALLENGES WITH RESPECT
00:08:25.171 --> 00:08:28.007 region:rollup2
TO THE GATHERING OF
00:08:26.039 --> 00:08:28.675 region:rollup2
ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE OF
00:08:28.007 --> 00:08:30.443 region:rollup2
WRONGDOING BY PETITION
00:08:28.675 --> 00:08:31.144 region:rollup2
SOLICITORS. ANY DISINCLINATION
00:08:30.443 --> 00:08:32.779 region:rollup2
ON THE PART OF THOSE WITH
00:08:31.144 --> 00:08:34.814 region:rollup2
JURISDICTION OVER PROSPECTIVE
00:08:32.779 --> 00:08:36.316 region:rollup2
VIOLATIONS WHO ARE IT IS WORTH
00:08:34.814 --> 00:08:38.551 region:rollup2
NOTING MOST OF ELECTED OFFICIALS
00:08:36.316 --> 00:08:39.219 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES. DOT ARE DISINCLINED
00:08:38.551 --> 00:08:40.286 region:rollup2
TO WADE INTO THE FRAY AND
00:08:39.219 --> 00:08:40.787 region:rollup2
THEREBY PUT THEIR OWN POLITIAL
00:08:40.286 --> 00:08:42.989 region:rollup2
PROSPECTS AT RISK IN THE
00:08:40.787 --> 00:08:44.524 region:rollup2
PROCESS.
00:08:42.989 --> 00:08:45.658 region:rollup2
IT'S AGAINST THIS BACKDROP BUT
00:08:44.524 --> 00:08:47.127 region:rollup2
THAT THE DETERMINE FACTOR FOR
00:08:45.658 --> 00:08:48.561 region:rollup2
GETTING A MEASURE ON THE BALLOT
00:08:47.127 --> 00:08:50.430 region:rollup2
TOO OFTEN HAS LESS TO DO WITH
00:08:48.561 --> 00:08:52.065 region:rollup2
THE POLICY MERITS OF A PETITION
00:08:50.430 --> 00:08:53.633 region:rollup2
THAN THE DEPTH OF THE PETITION
00:08:52.065 --> 00:08:55.502 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS POCKETS. AND OF
00:08:53.633 --> 00:08:56.803 region:rollup2
COURSE THIS IS PRECISELY THE
00:08:55.502 --> 00:08:58.004 region:rollup2
OPPOSITE OF WHAT THE FRAMERS OF
00:08:56.803 --> 00:08:59.539 region:rollup2
THE INITIATIVE RECALL IN
00:08:58.004 --> 00:09:00.840 region:rollup2
REFERENDUM HAD IN MIND. THE
00:08:59.539 --> 00:09:02.675 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE REFERENDUM AND RECALL
00:09:00.840 --> 00:09:04.277 region:rollup2
PROCESS CAN AND SHOULD PLAY AN
00:09:02.675 --> 00:09:04.811 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT VALUED ROLE IN
00:09:04.277 --> 00:09:06.279 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA'S POLITICS AND
00:09:04.811 --> 00:09:07.947 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT. IT HAS BECOME CLEAR
00:09:06.279 --> 00:09:09.916 region:rollup2
HOWEVER THAT UNDER THE CURRENT
00:09:07.947 --> 00:09:11.584 region:rollup2
SYSTEM DRIVEN BY PER SIGNATURE
00:09:09.916 --> 00:09:13.420 region:rollup2
BOUNTIES THEIR SCANT PROSPECTS
00:09:11.584 --> 00:09:14.654 region:rollup2
FOR DETERRING BAD ACTORS WHO
00:09:13.420 --> 00:09:16.322 region:rollup2
WILLFULLY MISLEAD VOTERS AT THE
00:09:14.654 --> 00:09:18.391 region:rollup2
EXPENSE OF THE INTEGRITY OF THE
00:09:16.322 --> 00:09:19.626 region:rollup2
ELECTORAL PROCESS. TO OPTIMIZE
00:09:18.391 --> 00:09:22.762 region:rollup2
ITS DETERRENT IMPACT AND THEREBY
00:09:19.626 --> 00:09:23.797 region:rollup2
ENSURE ETHICAL CONDUCT IN THE
00:09:22.762 --> 00:09:25.365 region:rollup2
GATHERING OF ALISON SHE'S ABOUT
00:09:23.797 --> 00:09:26.232 region:rollup2
BALLOT MEASURES. SB THIRTY
00:09:25.365 --> 00:09:27.834 region:rollup2
NINETY FOUR WOULD IMPOSE UPON
00:09:26.232 --> 00:09:29.068 region:rollup2
VIOLATORS EITHER A TOTAL FINE OF
00:09:27.834 --> 00:09:30.303 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS. OR
00:09:29.068 --> 00:09:31.704 region:rollup2
FIFTY DOLLARS PER SIGNATURE
00:09:30.303 --> 00:09:33.807 region:rollup2
UNLAWFULLY GATHERED WHICHEVER
00:09:31.704 --> 00:09:35.108 region:rollup2
AMOUNT IS GREATER FOR ENGAGING
00:09:33.807 --> 00:09:36.276 region:rollup2
IN THE PRACTICE OF OFFERING
00:09:35.108 --> 00:09:37.811 region:rollup2
DOWNEY PAVEMENTS IN SIGNATURE
00:09:36.276 --> 00:09:38.778 region:rollup2
GATHERING OPERATIONS. I WANT TO
00:09:37.811 --> 00:09:40.046 region:rollup2
POINT OUT THAT THIS PENALTY
00:09:38.778 --> 00:09:42.615 region:rollup2
WOULD APPLY TO THE COMPANY
00:09:40.046 --> 00:09:43.116 region:rollup2
EMPLOYING SIX GATHERS AND NOT TO
00:09:42.615 --> 00:09:44.451 region:rollup2
THE SIGNATURE GATHERERS
00:09:43.116 --> 00:09:45.885 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES. UNLIKE THREE
00:09:44.451 --> 00:09:46.453 region:rollup2
PREVIOUS SIMILAR MEASURES THAT
00:09:45.885 --> 00:09:48.087 region:rollup2
MADE IT ALL THE WAY TO THE
00:09:46.453 --> 00:09:49.489 region:rollup2
GOVERNOR'S DESK THIS BILL WILL
00:09:48.087 --> 00:09:50.924 region:rollup2
EMPOWER VOTERS TO WITNESS FRAUD
00:09:49.489 --> 00:09:52.025 region:rollup2
FIRST HAND TO ACT AS
00:09:50.924 --> 00:09:54.027 region:rollup2
WHISTLEBLOWERS THEMSELVES
00:09:52.025 --> 00:09:55.995 region:rollup2
THEREBY PROTECTING THE INTEGRITY
00:09:54.027 --> 00:09:57.597 region:rollup2
AND TRANSPARENCY TRANSPARENCY.
00:09:55.995 --> 00:09:59.199 region:rollup2
OF SINGER GATHER CAMPAIGNS BY
00:09:57.597 --> 00:10:01.501 region:rollup2
ALLOWING INDIVIDUALS TO BRING
00:09:59.199 --> 00:10:02.635 region:rollup2
CIVIL ACTION FOR VIOLATIONS IF
00:10:01.501 --> 00:10:04.370 region:rollup2
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL A LOCAL LAW
00:10:02.635 --> 00:10:05.405 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT CHOOSES NOT TO. FIVE
00:10:04.370 --> 00:10:07.307 region:rollup2
OTHER STATES HAVE SIMILAR
00:10:05.405 --> 00:10:08.208 region:rollup2
EXAMINED THE ISSUES ARE
00:10:07.307 --> 00:10:09.676 region:rollup2
SURROUNDING PAGE SINGER
00:10:08.208 --> 00:10:10.210 region:rollup2
GATHERING. AND PER SIGNATURE
00:10:09.676 --> 00:10:12.412 region:rollup2
BOUNTIES AND HAVE ADOPTED
00:10:10.210 --> 00:10:13.046 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION PROHIBITING
00:10:12.412 --> 00:10:14.647 region:rollup2
PROCEDURE BOUNTY PAYMENTS FOR
00:10:13.046 --> 00:10:16.483 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE GATHERING AND
00:10:14.647 --> 00:10:17.283 region:rollup2
REQUIRING THAT DOT THAT SINGS
00:10:16.483 --> 00:10:24.257 region:rollup2
AGAIN HE MAY ONLY BE MADE ON AN
00:10:17.283 --> 00:10:25.058 region:rollup2
HOURLY OR SALARY BASIS IN THEIR
00:10:24.257 --> 00:10:26.292 region:rollup2
STATES. THE
00:10:25.058 --> 00:10:28.261 region:rollup2
OPPONENTS OF S. B. THIRTY NINETY
00:10:26.292 --> 00:10:29.262 region:rollup2
FOUR HAVE MADE THE POINT BY THAT
00:10:28.261 --> 00:10:30.130 region:rollup2
THE STATE TO ADOPT A SIMPLICITY
00:10:29.262 --> 00:10:31.264 region:rollup2
TO GATHER MEASURES ARE FINALLY
00:10:30.130 --> 00:10:32.298 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT IN CALIFORNIA. AYE IN
00:10:31.264 --> 00:10:32.999 region:rollup2
MOST CASES SMALLER IN FACT IN
00:10:32.298 --> 00:10:33.933 region:rollup2
ALL CASES SMALLER THAT GIVEN
00:10:32.999 --> 00:10:35.268 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA'S MUCH LARGER
00:10:33.933 --> 00:10:36.736 region:rollup2
POPULATION GEOGRAPHIC EXPANSE
00:10:35.268 --> 00:10:37.403 region:rollup2
THAT ANY ATTEMPT TO REIN IN
00:10:36.736 --> 00:10:38.204 region:rollup2
UNETHICAL BEHAVIOR BY SIX
00:10:37.403 --> 00:10:38.905 region:rollup2
GATHERS. BY THE MEANS PROPOSED
00:10:38.204 --> 00:10:40.640 region:rollup2
IN THIS BILL SHOULD BE
00:10:38.905 --> 00:10:42.275 region:rollup2
DISALLOWED SINCE DOING SO WILL
00:10:40.640 --> 00:10:43.843 region:rollup2
MAKE IT HARDER FOR PROPONENTS TO
00:10:42.275 --> 00:10:45.378 region:rollup2
GATHER THE NECESSARY NUMBER OF
00:10:43.843 --> 00:10:47.647 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES STATEWIDE TO QUALIFY
00:10:45.378 --> 00:10:48.615 region:rollup2
IMAGE FOR THE BALLOT. THIS IS I
00:10:47.647 --> 00:10:49.949 region:rollup2
WOULD POINT OUT AT BEST A
00:10:48.615 --> 00:10:51.384 region:rollup2
SPECIOUS ARGUMENT AND IT'S A
00:10:49.949 --> 00:10:52.585 region:rollup2
PATENTLY SELF SERVING ONE AT
00:10:51.384 --> 00:10:54.087 region:rollup2
THAT UNDER THE TERMS ENVISIONED
00:10:52.585 --> 00:10:55.755 region:rollup2
BY THE FRAMERS OF THE INITIAL
00:10:54.087 --> 00:10:56.756 region:rollup2
THE REFERENDUM THE RECALL. THAT
00:10:55.755 --> 00:10:58.291 region:rollup2
STANDARD FOR QUALIFYING A
00:10:56.756 --> 00:10:59.792 region:rollup2
MEASURE THE BALLOT WAS ALWAYS
00:10:58.291 --> 00:11:01.327 region:rollup2
INTENDED AS RIGOROUS FOR IT WAS
00:10:59.792 --> 00:11:02.695 region:rollup2
THE VERY ACT OF SECURING A
00:11:01.327 --> 00:11:04.130 region:rollup2
DELIBERATELY CHALLENGING NUMBER
00:11:02.695 --> 00:11:05.798 region:rollup2
SIX YEARS THAT WAS SEEN AS THE
00:11:04.130 --> 00:11:07.267 region:rollup2
PROPER BASIS FOR VALIDATING ITS
00:11:05.798 --> 00:11:09.135 region:rollup2
VALIDITY. NOT ALL MEASURES
00:11:07.267 --> 00:11:10.270 region:rollup2
SHOULD QUALIFY FOR THE BALLOT
00:11:09.135 --> 00:11:11.971 region:rollup2
ONLY THOSE WHICH ME TO DELIVER
00:11:10.270 --> 00:11:13.506 region:rollup2
THE HIGH STANDARD AFTER ALL THE
00:11:11.971 --> 00:11:16.042 region:rollup2
DIRECTLY BESIDE PROCESS FOR
00:11:13.506 --> 00:11:17.477 region:rollup2
WHICH. THESE MEASURES DEEP
00:11:16.042 --> 00:11:18.111 region:rollup2
EVERITT INITIATIVE REFERENDUM
00:11:17.477 --> 00:11:19.879 region:rollup2
AND RECALL WERE DEVELOPED WERE
00:11:18.111 --> 00:11:21.347 region:rollup2
INTENDED TO SUPERSEDE NOT RUN
00:11:19.879 --> 00:11:22.982 region:rollup2
PARALLEL TO OR SERVE AS A
00:11:21.347 --> 00:11:24.884 region:rollup2
SUBSTITUTE FOR THE LEGISLATIVE
00:11:22.982 --> 00:11:26.452 region:rollup2
PROCESS. FURTHERMORE A GOOD CASE
00:11:24.884 --> 00:11:27.754 region:rollup2
CAN BE MADE THAT THE PHENOMENON
00:11:26.452 --> 00:11:29.355 region:rollup2
OF SO MANY PROPOSITIONS IN
00:11:27.754 --> 00:11:30.657 region:rollup2
REFERENDUM PERENNIAL ON THE
00:11:29.355 --> 00:11:32.659 region:rollup2
BALLOT CALIFORNIA HAS HAD A
00:11:30.657 --> 00:11:33.960 region:rollup2
NEGATIVE IMPACT ON OUR POLITICS
00:11:32.659 --> 00:11:35.361 region:rollup2
AND OUR GOVERNMENTS AS THE
00:11:33.960 --> 00:11:37.063 region:rollup2
VOTING PUBLIC STRUCK PUBLIC.
00:11:35.361 --> 00:11:38.031 region:rollup2
STRUGGLES TO SORT THE GOOD IDEAS
00:11:37.063 --> 00:11:39.933 region:rollup2
IN THE GOOD PROPOSITIONS FROM
00:11:38.031 --> 00:11:42.035 region:rollup2
THE BAD WHILE ASKING THE OBVIOUS
00:11:39.933 --> 00:11:43.236 region:rollup2
QUESTION OF WHY THEY ARE BEING
00:11:42.035 --> 00:11:45.438 region:rollup2
FORCED TO MAKE POLICY FOR THE
00:11:43.236 --> 00:11:47.106 region:rollup2
GREAT STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
00:11:45.438 --> 00:11:49.576 region:rollup2
DESPITE HAVING HIRED US FOR THAT
00:11:47.106 --> 00:11:50.343 region:rollup2
EXPECT EXPRESS PURPOSE GLASS OF
00:11:49.576 --> 00:11:50.944 region:rollup2
THE OPPONENTS OF S. B. THIRTY
00:11:50.343 --> 00:11:52.545 region:rollup2
NINETY FOUR WILL ASSERT THAT
00:11:50.944 --> 00:11:53.413 region:rollup2
THIS IS AN ATTEMPT TO UNDERMINE
00:11:52.545 --> 00:11:54.948 region:rollup2
THE RIGHTS OF BOTH PETITIONERS
00:11:53.413 --> 00:11:56.082 region:rollup2
AND THEIR PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES.
00:11:54.948 --> 00:11:57.483 region:rollup2
BY INTERFERING WITH THE ABILITY
00:11:56.082 --> 00:11:59.552 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS TO ENTER INTO VALID
00:11:57.483 --> 00:12:00.987 region:rollup2
CONTRACTS IN PURSUIT OF THEIR
00:11:59.552 --> 00:12:02.622 region:rollup2
GOALS. EARLIER ON SUCCESSFUL
00:12:00.987 --> 00:12:03.723 region:rollup2
EFFORTS TO ELIMINATE LYING IN
00:12:02.622 --> 00:12:05.425 region:rollup2
THE SERVICE ABOUT PETITIONS
00:12:03.723 --> 00:12:08.061 region:rollup2
PROPOSED RESTRICTING SIX GATHER
00:12:05.425 --> 00:12:09.195 region:rollup2
TO ONLY UNPAID VOLUNTEERS. S. B.
00:12:08.061 --> 00:12:10.663 region:rollup2
THIRTY NINETY FOUR DOES NO SUCH
00:12:09.195 --> 00:12:12.031 region:rollup2
THING THE PASSAGE OF SB THIRTY
00:12:10.663 --> 00:12:13.166 region:rollup2
NINETY FOUR WILL IN NO WAY
00:12:12.031 --> 00:12:14.467 region:rollup2
INTERFERE WITH ANYONE
00:12:13.166 --> 00:12:16.236 region:rollup2
PREROGATIVE TO HIRE AND PAY
00:12:14.467 --> 00:12:17.737 region:rollup2
WORKERS TO ADVOCATE ON BEHALF OF
00:12:16.236 --> 00:12:22.342 region:rollup2
THEIR PETITIONS SUPPORT TO PAY
00:12:17.737 --> 00:12:22.709 region:rollup2
THEM AS MUCH AS THEY CHOOSE.
00:12:22.342 --> 00:12:24.377 region:rollup2
WHAT IT WILL DO
00:12:22.709 --> 00:12:25.445 region:rollup2
BY ELIMINATING THE INCENTIVIZING
00:12:24.377 --> 00:12:26.112 region:rollup2
ON IT OF UNETHICAL BEHAVIOR
00:12:25.445 --> 00:12:27.313 region:rollup2
THROUGH THE PAYMENT OF PROCEDURE
00:12:26.112 --> 00:12:28.014 region:rollup2
BOUNTIES IS TO MORE PROPERLY
00:12:27.313 --> 00:12:28.715 region:rollup2
ALIGNED THOSE PAID ACTIVITIES
00:12:28.014 --> 00:12:30.550 region:rollup2
WITH THE PUBLIC'S VERY CLEAR
00:12:28.715 --> 00:12:32.185 region:rollup2
INTEREST? IN GREATER HONESTY AND
00:12:30.550 --> 00:12:33.886 region:rollup2
TRANSPARENCY IN THE CONDUCT OF
00:12:32.185 --> 00:12:35.388 region:rollup2
BALLOT MEASURE CAMPAIGNS I
00:12:33.886 --> 00:12:36.489 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:12:35.388 --> 00:12:38.358 region:rollup2
VOTE TODAY.
00:12:36.489 --> 00:12:40.360 region:rollup2
THANK YOU WITH US TODAY TO TEST
00:12:38.358 --> 00:12:42.328 region:rollup2
VICE CRAIG NORRIS A RESIDENT OF
00:12:40.360 --> 00:12:44.130 region:rollup2
IRVINE GUY WHO IS A COAST GUARD
00:12:42.328 --> 00:12:45.131 region:rollup2
VETERAN AND WITNESS FIRSTHAND
00:12:44.130 --> 00:12:46.265 region:rollup2
THE LANGUAGE DOWN BALLOT TO
00:12:45.131 --> 00:12:47.400 region:rollup2
SECURE GATHERS AWAY TO GO. IN
00:12:46.265 --> 00:12:49.302 region:rollup2
ORDER TO GET THEIR SIGNATURES
00:12:47.400 --> 00:12:51.871 region:rollup2
THANK YOU SENATOR NEWMAN AND HOW
00:12:49.302 --> 00:12:54.707 region:rollup2
DO YOU REALLY FEEL ABOUT THIS I
00:12:51.871 --> 00:12:57.076 region:rollup2
CAN GO ON AND ON.
00:12:54.707 --> 00:12:58.811 region:rollup2
THANK YOU IS NOT TO KNOW NOT TO
00:12:57.076 --> 00:13:01.748 region:rollup2
DO THAT SIR SENATOR ARE
00:12:58.811 --> 00:13:02.782 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI VENTURA MOVED.
00:13:01.748 --> 00:13:03.850 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT WE DO HAVE A MOTION.
00:13:02.782 --> 00:13:06.486 region:rollup2
THEN IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK TO
00:13:03.850 --> 00:13:07.787 region:rollup2
MINUTES PLEASE.
00:13:06.486 --> 00:13:08.988 region:rollup2
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF
00:13:07.787 --> 00:13:11.624 region:rollup2
THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU FOR
00:13:08.988 --> 00:13:14.360 region:rollup2
HAVING ME HERE SPEAK. HOMONYMS
00:13:11.624 --> 00:13:15.695 region:rollup2
CRAIG NORRIS AND SENATE AND
00:13:14.360 --> 00:13:17.497 region:rollup2
SETTLEMENT COAST GUARD VETERAN
00:13:15.695 --> 00:13:18.264 region:rollup2
AND DAY OUT OF LIFELONG RESIDENT
00:13:17.497 --> 00:13:20.533 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA HERE'S BEGIN AND
00:13:18.264 --> 00:13:22.268 region:rollup2
SUPPORT OF SB THIRTEEN NINETY
00:13:20.533 --> 00:13:24.070 region:rollup2
FOUR.
00:13:22.268 --> 00:13:24.737 region:rollup2
UNLESS YOU'RE A VOLUNTEER DONOR
00:13:24.070 --> 00:13:25.672 region:rollup2
FIND THE TIME TO STOP A
00:13:24.737 --> 00:13:26.472 region:rollup2
FRAUDULENT PETITION AIMED AT
00:13:25.672 --> 00:13:27.573 region:rollup2
CREATING A BALLOT INITIATIVE
00:13:26.472 --> 00:13:28.074 region:rollup2
THAT VOTERS WERE TOLD WOULD
00:13:27.573 --> 00:13:29.642 region:rollup2
QUOTE SAVE THE VETERANS
00:13:28.074 --> 00:13:31.010 region:rollup2
CEMETERY.
00:13:29.642 --> 00:13:33.212 region:rollup2
HIS CAMPAIGN HAD THREE DISTINCT
00:13:31.010 --> 00:13:34.180 region:rollup2
CHARACTERISTICS TO USE MANY
00:13:33.212 --> 00:13:35.715 region:rollup2
BOUNTY SIGNATURE GATHERERS IT
00:13:34.180 --> 00:13:37.517 region:rollup2
WAS DOCUMENTED MISLEADING VOTERS
00:13:35.715 --> 00:13:39.218 region:rollup2
IN ORDER TO GATHER THE REQUISITE
00:13:37.517 --> 00:13:40.253 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF SIGNATURES.
00:13:39.218 --> 00:13:42.221 region:rollup2
AND THE CAMPAIGN OF SIX IF THE
00:13:40.253 --> 00:13:43.289 region:rollup2
CAMPAIGN WAS SUCCESSFUL HE WOULD
00:13:42.221 --> 00:13:46.359 region:rollup2
BY ALL ACCOUNTS STOP THE VETERAN
00:13:43.289 --> 00:13:47.660 region:rollup2
CEMETERY FROM BEING BUILT.
00:13:46.359 --> 00:13:49.262 region:rollup2
I WAS WITNESS TO TWO EXAMPLES
00:13:47.660 --> 00:13:50.830 region:rollup2
CITED AN SP THIRTEEN ANY FORCE
00:13:49.262 --> 00:13:51.931 region:rollup2
FACT SHEET.
00:13:50.830 --> 00:13:53.299 region:rollup2
ONE PRODUCER TOLD ME VETERANS
00:13:51.931 --> 00:13:54.500 region:rollup2
BODIES WOULD BE EXHUMED HAND
00:13:53.299 --> 00:13:57.370 region:rollup2
MOVED UNLESS I SIGNED THE
00:13:54.500 --> 00:13:59.539 region:rollup2
PETITION. AND ANOTHER ANOTHER
00:13:57.370 --> 00:14:01.174 region:rollup2
CLAIM TO VETERANS JOB CENTER
00:13:59.539 --> 00:14:01.674 region:rollup2
WOULD BE BILLED AS ORIGINALLY
00:14:01.174 --> 00:14:02.608 region:rollup2
PLANNED IF I SIGNED THE
00:14:01.674 --> 00:14:04.077 region:rollup2
PETITION.
00:14:02.608 --> 00:14:05.545 region:rollup2
IF I DID NOT ONLY A CEMETERY
00:14:04.077 --> 00:14:07.013 region:rollup2
WOULD BE BUILT I KNEW EACH OF
00:14:05.545 --> 00:14:08.214 region:rollup2
THESE CLAIMS TO BE FALSE OPERATE
00:14:07.013 --> 00:14:09.482 region:rollup2
TO WOULD HAVE SIGNED THE
00:14:08.214 --> 00:14:10.917 region:rollup2
PETITION IN AN INSTANT.
00:14:09.482 --> 00:14:12.385 region:rollup2
THOMAS JEFFERSON'S CREDIT OF THE
00:14:10.917 --> 00:14:14.287 region:rollup2
SAYING AN EDUCATED CITIZENRY AS
00:14:12.385 --> 00:14:17.156 region:rollup2
A VITAL REQUISITE FOR OUR
00:14:14.287 --> 00:14:17.824 region:rollup2
SURVIVAL AS A FREE PEOPLE.
00:14:17.156 --> 00:14:19.058 region:rollup2
WHERE I LIVE IN IRVINE WE HAVE
00:14:17.824 --> 00:14:21.527 region:rollup2
ONE OF THE MOST ACTIVE LOCAL
00:14:19.058 --> 00:14:23.296 region:rollup2
POLITICAL LANDSCAPES AND THINGS
00:14:21.527 --> 00:14:24.464 region:rollup2
THAT THERE IS ALWAYS ALMOST
00:14:23.296 --> 00:14:25.031 region:rollup2
ALWAYS A GRASS ROOTS PETITION
00:14:24.464 --> 00:14:26.399 region:rollup2
SEEKING SIGNATURES FOR SOME
00:14:25.031 --> 00:14:27.867 region:rollup2
BECAUSE?
00:14:26.399 --> 00:14:29.068 region:rollup2
AS A VETERAN I APPRECIATED
00:14:27.867 --> 00:14:31.037 region:rollup2
SEEING RESIDENTS GET INVOLVED BY
00:14:29.068 --> 00:14:32.171 region:rollup2
SIGNING PETITIONS AFTER ALL I
00:14:31.037 --> 00:14:33.172 region:rollup2
SWORE AN OATH TO DEFEND THE
00:14:32.171 --> 00:14:34.407 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTION ENSURE THEIR RIGHT
00:14:33.172 --> 00:14:35.007 region:rollup2
TO FREE SPEECH.
00:14:34.407 --> 00:14:37.677 region:rollup2
AND I STILL BELIEVE I HAVE A
00:14:35.007 --> 00:14:39.245 region:rollup2
DUTY TO DO SO.
00:14:37.677 --> 00:14:40.446 region:rollup2
I BELIEVE SIGNING PETITIONS WAS
00:14:39.245 --> 00:14:43.149 region:rollup2
AN HONORABLE YOU SOME MY RIGHTS
00:14:40.446 --> 00:14:44.584 region:rollup2
UNTIL I SAW THE BALD FACED LIES.
00:14:43.149 --> 00:14:46.419 region:rollup2
BEING TOLD TO PUSH THE ANTI
00:14:44.584 --> 00:14:47.887 region:rollup2
CEMETERY PETITION.
00:14:46.419 --> 00:14:48.654 region:rollup2
I LIKE I SAID IN OCTOBER AND
00:14:47.887 --> 00:14:50.790 region:rollup2
NOVEMBER AT SEVENTEEN I
00:14:48.654 --> 00:14:53.126 region:rollup2
VOLUNTEERED TRANSEPT THIS
00:14:50.790 --> 00:14:53.793 region:rollup2
PETITION FROM GOING FORWARD.
00:14:53.126 --> 00:14:56.395 region:rollup2
THE TEAM I WORKED WITH IS ABLE
00:14:53.793 --> 00:14:57.697 region:rollup2
TO DOCUMENT THE DISHONEST WAYS
00:14:56.395 --> 00:14:59.098 region:rollup2
IN WHICH PETITIONS WERE ABLE TO
00:14:57.697 --> 00:14:59.699 region:rollup2
GET SIGNATURES AS STATED IN THE
00:14:59.098 --> 00:15:00.800 region:rollup2
SP THIRTEEN NINETY FOUR FACT
00:14:59.699 --> 00:15:03.770 region:rollup2
SHEET. PROVIDING IMPORTANT
00:15:00.800 --> 00:15:05.638 region:rollup2
MATERIAL SUPPORT AS TO WHY THIS
00:15:03.770 --> 00:15:07.507 region:rollup2
BILL IS DESPERATELY NEEDED.
00:15:05.638 --> 00:15:08.341 region:rollup2
FROM WHAT I PERSONALLY OBSERVE
00:15:07.507 --> 00:15:09.442 region:rollup2
DOWNEY SIGNATURE GATHERERS A
00:15:08.341 --> 00:15:11.043 region:rollup2
MAIN MAINLY MOTIVATED BY ONE
00:15:09.442 --> 00:15:12.945 region:rollup2
THING. GETTING SIGNATURES SO
00:15:11.043 --> 00:15:15.014 region:rollup2
THEY CAN GET PAID.
00:15:12.945 --> 00:15:16.048 region:rollup2
AND THE SAD REALITY IS. HOW MANY
00:15:15.014 --> 00:15:17.116 region:rollup2
OF THESE FOLKS CONTRACTED TO GET
00:15:16.048 --> 00:15:18.484 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES ARE IN DIRE NEED OF
00:15:17.116 --> 00:15:20.019 region:rollup2
FINANCIAL SUPPORT? THEIR
00:15:18.484 --> 00:15:20.987 region:rollup2
HOMELESS.
00:15:20.019 --> 00:15:23.022 region:rollup2
AND OFTEN THEY'RE UNABLE TO MEET
00:15:20.987 --> 00:15:24.056 region:rollup2
BASIC NEEDS ONE MAN I
00:15:23.022 --> 00:15:25.625 region:rollup2
ENCOUNTERED LIVED IN HIS CAR.
00:15:24.056 --> 00:15:26.826 region:rollup2
WITH HIS WIFE.
00:15:25.625 --> 00:15:28.594 region:rollup2
WHO HE SAID SUFFERED FROM
00:15:26.826 --> 00:15:29.862 region:rollup2
SCHIZOPHRENIA?
00:15:28.594 --> 00:15:30.963 region:rollup2
I OBSERVE NONTRADITIONAL
00:15:29.862 --> 00:15:31.731 region:rollup2
RUMMAGED THROUGH THE GARBAGE FOR
00:15:30.963 --> 00:15:34.200 region:rollup2
FOOD IN BETWEEN ASKING FOR
00:15:31.731 --> 00:15:35.067 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES.
00:15:34.200 --> 00:15:36.002 region:rollup2
OTHER PETITIONS TOLD OUR TEAM
00:15:35.067 --> 00:15:38.738 region:rollup2
THEY'VE BEEN PICKED UP FROM
00:15:36.002 --> 00:15:41.174 region:rollup2
HOMELESS SHELTERS.
00:15:38.738 --> 00:15:42.308 region:rollup2
AND I SAN BERNADINO AND BROUGHT
00:15:41.174 --> 00:15:44.343 region:rollup2
TO BEAR IN MIND JUST FOR THIS
00:15:42.308 --> 00:15:45.144 region:rollup2
PETITION.
00:15:44.343 --> 00:15:46.078 region:rollup2
AS THE FACT SHEET STATES THERE'S
00:15:45.144 --> 00:15:47.747 region:rollup2
NO THERE'S NO DETERRENT FOR
00:15:46.078 --> 00:15:48.848 region:rollup2
MISLEADING VOTERS AND FACT I
00:15:47.747 --> 00:15:50.383 region:rollup2
WOULD ARGUE THAT MOST CASES
00:15:48.848 --> 00:15:52.351 region:rollup2
MISLEADING VOTERS ISN'T IS
00:15:50.383 --> 00:15:54.220 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY INCENTIVIZED. HAS THE
00:15:52.351 --> 00:15:55.688 region:rollup2
NATURE PAPER SIGNATURE MODELS
00:15:54.220 --> 00:15:57.623 region:rollup2
ARE INHERENTLY FLAWED BY THE
00:15:55.688 --> 00:15:59.559 region:rollup2
HIGH REWARD FOR LYING. AND
00:15:57.623 --> 00:16:01.561 region:rollup2
EVERYWHERE TO SHORT TERM WELL
00:15:59.559 --> 00:16:03.996 region:rollup2
THAT WHILE THE LONG TERM
00:16:01.561 --> 00:16:04.931 region:rollup2
CONSERVATION I.
00:16:03.996 --> 00:16:06.699 region:rollup2
IF IT'S TRUE THEN EDUCATED
00:16:04.931 --> 00:16:09.402 region:rollup2
CITIZENRY IS ESSENTIAL TO OUR
00:16:06.699 --> 00:16:10.436 region:rollup2
SURVIVAL AS JEFFERSON SAID HE
00:16:09.402 --> 00:16:11.537 region:rollup2
WOULD CERTAINLY SEEM NECESSARY
00:16:10.436 --> 00:16:12.672 region:rollup2
THOSE SEEKING REDRESS USING THE
00:16:11.537 --> 00:16:13.439 region:rollup2
RECALL REFERENDUM INITIATIVE
00:16:12.672 --> 00:16:15.041 region:rollup2
PROCESS.
00:16:13.439 --> 00:16:16.008 region:rollup2
EDUCATE CITIZENS USING FACTS
00:16:15.041 --> 00:16:17.243 region:rollup2
RATHER THAN PROVABLY FALSE
00:16:16.008 --> 00:16:18.044 region:rollup2
CLAIMS THAT ARE ONLY INTENDED TO
00:16:17.243 --> 00:16:19.579 region:rollup2
APPEAL TO EMOTION.
00:16:18.044 --> 00:16:20.613 region:rollup2
SIMILARLY INFORMATION PRESENTED
00:16:19.579 --> 00:16:21.814 region:rollup2
A VOTERS INTENDED TO CAUSE THEM
00:16:20.613 --> 00:16:22.315 region:rollup2
TO TAKE SOME KIND DEMOCRATIC
00:16:21.814 --> 00:16:23.516 region:rollup2
ACTION SUCH AS SIGNING A
00:16:22.315 --> 00:16:25.785 region:rollup2
PETITION.
00:16:23.516 --> 00:16:26.385 region:rollup2
I MUST BE BASED IN TRUTH.
00:16:25.785 --> 00:16:28.120 region:rollup2
THANK CLOSING OF
00:16:26.385 --> 00:16:29.856 region:rollup2
MISREPRESENTATION OF THE TRUTH
00:16:28.120 --> 00:16:31.624 region:rollup2
CONTINUES TO BE AN UNDER CERTAIN
00:16:29.856 --> 00:16:33.392 region:rollup2
LAWFUL WAY TO ACHIEVE AN AND IN
00:16:31.624 --> 00:16:34.660 region:rollup2
THIS CASE TOGETHER THOUSANDS OF
00:16:33.392 --> 00:16:36.095 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES THAT WE CAN EXPECT
00:16:34.660 --> 00:16:37.296 region:rollup2
ANY HUNTERS. BOUNTY SIGNATURE
00:16:36.095 --> 00:16:39.198 region:rollup2
GATHERERS AND THE COMPANIES THEY
00:16:37.296 --> 00:16:40.766 region:rollup2
REPRESENT TO BE UNTRUTHFUL
00:16:39.198 --> 00:16:42.902 region:rollup2
VOTERS AND FIRST SENTENCES
00:16:40.766 --> 00:16:44.370 region:rollup2
CITIZENRY TO ME INTENTIONALLY.
00:16:42.902 --> 00:16:46.539 region:rollup2
MISLED INTO TAKING DEMOCRATIC
00:16:44.370 --> 00:16:48.241 region:rollup2
ACTION BY THE SAME BIG MONEY
00:16:46.539 --> 00:16:49.408 region:rollup2
VESTED INTERESTS.
00:16:48.241 --> 00:16:50.009 region:rollup2
WHOSE POWER THE FOUNDERS
00:16:49.408 --> 00:16:51.444 region:rollup2
ORIGINALLY ENDEAVOR TO LIMIT
00:16:50.009 --> 00:16:53.179 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND SINCE
00:16:51.444 --> 00:16:55.147 region:rollup2
THERE ISN'T A SECOND.
00:16:53.179 --> 00:16:56.749 region:rollup2
WITNESS WE LET'S GO A LITTLE
00:16:55.147 --> 00:16:57.984 region:rollup2
LONGER BUT. WITHIN THE TIGHTNESS
00:16:56.749 --> 00:16:59.852 region:rollup2
SUPPLEMENT GOING FORWARD OTHER
00:16:57.984 --> 00:17:01.153 region:rollup2
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
00:16:59.852 --> 00:17:02.855 region:rollup2
IF YOU'D STEP UP TO THE
00:17:01.153 --> 00:17:04.891 region:rollup2
MICROPHONE AND GIVE YOUR NAME
00:17:02.855 --> 00:17:06.259 region:rollup2
AND AFFILIATION.
00:17:04.891 --> 00:17:22.542 region:rollup2
MANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION IF
00:17:06.259 --> 00:17:22.542 region:rollup2
YOU'D STEP FORWARD
00:17:24.010 --> 00:17:26.913 region:rollup2
.
00:17:24.143 --> 00:17:29.849 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON LONG TIME NO SEE
00:17:26.913 --> 00:17:31.317 region:rollup2
I DON'T.
00:17:29.849 --> 00:17:32.852 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR IT'S ALWAYS GOOD TO
00:17:31.317 --> 00:17:35.288 region:rollup2
SEE YOU AND OF COURSE I DO
00:17:32.852 --> 00:17:35.888 region:rollup2
PROMISE OF JESUS THANKED MEMBERS
00:17:35.288 --> 00:17:36.555 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON DAVID WILL FOR
00:17:35.888 --> 00:17:37.957 region:rollup2
THE HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
00:17:36.555 --> 00:17:39.825 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION WERE IN OPPOSITION
00:17:37.957 --> 00:17:42.228 region:rollup2
TO U. S.. S. B. THIRTEEN NINETY
00:17:39.825 --> 00:17:43.563 region:rollup2
FOUR SENATOR NEWMAN TALKED ABOUT
00:17:42.228 --> 00:17:47.833 region:rollup2
LOOKING OUT FOR THE LITTLE MAN
00:17:43.563 --> 00:17:49.402 region:rollup2
AND HOW WE SHOULD STOP.
00:17:47.833 --> 00:17:51.137 region:rollup2
DOING PAID SIGNATURE GATHERING
00:17:49.402 --> 00:17:52.238 region:rollup2
IN HAVES SIGNATURE GATHERERS BE
00:17:51.137 --> 00:17:53.472 region:rollup2
PAID ON AN HOURLY LIKE HOURLY
00:17:52.238 --> 00:17:54.707 region:rollup2
RATE IN ORDER TO LOOK OUT FOR
00:17:53.472 --> 00:17:55.641 region:rollup2
THE LITTLE MAN AND MAKE IT
00:17:54.707 --> 00:17:58.277 region:rollup2
EASIER TO COUGH AYE INITIATIVES.
00:17:55.641 --> 00:18:00.112 region:rollup2
FOR THE BALLOT MEMBERS.
00:17:58.277 --> 00:18:02.882 region:rollup2
LISTEN
00:18:00.112 --> 00:18:04.250 region:rollup2
THERE IS AN OVER RELIANCE ON
00:18:02.882 --> 00:18:06.052 region:rollup2
PAID SIGNATURE GATHERING IN OUR
00:18:04.250 --> 00:18:07.587 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE PROCESS.
00:18:06.052 --> 00:18:09.255 region:rollup2
THERE ABSOLUTELY IS WE DON'T
00:18:07.587 --> 00:18:11.123 region:rollup2
DISPUTE THAT WE THINK THE FACT
00:18:09.255 --> 00:18:12.658 region:rollup2
THAT IT TAKES MILLIONS UPON
00:18:11.123 --> 00:18:14.694 region:rollup2
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO QUALIFY
00:18:12.658 --> 00:18:15.528 region:rollup2
AND INITIATIVE AS SOMEONE WHO
00:18:14.694 --> 00:18:17.997 region:rollup2
REPRESENTS A GRASSROOTS
00:18:15.528 --> 00:18:19.565 region:rollup2
TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION IS ALL
00:18:17.997 --> 00:18:20.766 region:rollup2
FRUSTRATED. NOT GONNA LIE ABOUT
00:18:19.565 --> 00:18:22.034 region:rollup2
THAT.
00:18:20.766 --> 00:18:23.769 region:rollup2
BUT YEAH.
00:18:22.034 --> 00:18:25.071 region:rollup2
WE NEED TO FACE FACTS RIGHT
00:18:23.769 --> 00:18:26.572 region:rollup2
RIGHT NOW DO QUALIFY
00:18:25.071 --> 00:18:28.074 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT FOR HE
00:18:26.572 --> 00:18:29.542 region:rollup2
BALLOT. TAKES ABOUT A MILLION
00:18:28.074 --> 00:18:30.876 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES.
00:18:29.542 --> 00:18:32.678 region:rollup2
OKAY AND IT'S GONNA BE VERY
00:18:30.876 --> 00:18:34.780 region:rollup2
DIFFICULT TO CONDUCT THIS
00:18:32.678 --> 00:18:36.449 region:rollup2
PROCESS EVEN IF DE. INDIVIDUALS
00:18:34.780 --> 00:18:39.151 region:rollup2
GATHERING THE PAID SIGNATURES
00:18:36.449 --> 00:18:40.853 region:rollup2
ARE PAID ON AN HOURLY RATE.
00:18:39.151 --> 00:18:42.955 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT SHOULDN'T BE
00:18:40.853 --> 00:18:46.626 region:rollup2
INFRINGING ON A CONTRACT BETWEEN
00:18:42.955 --> 00:18:47.159 region:rollup2
PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS TO GATHER
00:18:46.626 --> 00:18:47.426 region:rollup2
THE SIGNATURE FIRM AND THE
00:18:47.159 --> 00:18:49.962 region:rollup2
CAMPAIGN.
00:18:47.426 --> 00:18:50.596 region:rollup2
.
00:18:49.962 --> 00:18:51.764 region:rollup2
IF WE REALLY WANT TO SOLVE THIS
00:18:50.596 --> 00:18:53.265 region:rollup2
PROBLEM.
00:18:51.764 --> 00:18:54.500 region:rollup2
IF WE REALLY WANT TO SOLVE THE
00:18:53.265 --> 00:18:56.435 region:rollup2
PROBLEM OF AN OVER RELIANCE ON
00:18:54.500 --> 00:18:57.570 region:rollup2
PAID SIGNATURE GATHERERS THERE
00:18:56.435 --> 00:18:59.405 region:rollup2
ARE COUPLE OF THINGS THAT WE CAN
00:18:57.570 --> 00:19:01.207 region:rollup2
DO. NOT BAN THE PROCESS OUTRIGHT
00:18:59.405 --> 00:19:03.275 region:rollup2
BUT MAKE IT MORE COST EFFECTIVE
00:19:01.207 --> 00:19:04.610 region:rollup2
FOR THE INDIVIDUALS. AND THE
00:19:03.275 --> 00:19:06.512 region:rollup2
BUSINESSES THAT DO ENGAGE IN
00:19:04.610 --> 00:19:08.681 region:rollup2
THIS PROCESS.
00:19:06.512 --> 00:19:09.548 region:rollup2
WE CAN FOR INSTANCE INCREASE THE
00:19:08.681 --> 00:19:11.050 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF TIME IT TAKES TO
00:19:09.548 --> 00:19:12.651 region:rollup2
QUALIFY A MEASURE FOR THE BALLOT
00:19:11.050 --> 00:19:14.487 region:rollup2
FROM SIX MONTHS TO SOMETHING
00:19:12.651 --> 00:19:16.355 region:rollup2
MORE. IF WE BROUGHT INTO THAT
00:19:14.487 --> 00:19:17.423 region:rollup2
TWO YEAR I GUARANTEE YOU THERE
00:19:16.355 --> 00:19:19.525 region:rollup2
WOULDN'T BE PEOPLE OUT THERE
00:19:17.423 --> 00:19:21.694 region:rollup2
EVEN RIGHT NOW PAYING SIX OR
00:19:19.525 --> 00:19:23.629 region:rollup2
SEVEN DOLLARS TO SIGNATURE. TO
00:19:21.694 --> 00:19:25.164 region:rollup2
GET INITIATIVES ON THE BALLOT
00:19:23.629 --> 00:19:27.533 region:rollup2
BRIGHTEN UP THE TIMELINE.
00:19:25.164 --> 00:19:29.001 region:rollup2
OR ALSO DECREASE THE NUMBER OF
00:19:27.533 --> 00:19:30.469 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES NEEDED TO QUALIFY A
00:19:29.001 --> 00:19:31.337 region:rollup2
MEASURE FOR THE BALLOT RIGHT NOW
00:19:30.469 --> 00:19:32.838 region:rollup2
WHAT IT'S THREE HUNDRED AND
00:19:31.337 --> 00:19:33.806 region:rollup2
FIFTY THOUSAND FOR STATUTORY
00:19:32.838 --> 00:19:35.074 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE SEVEN HUNDRED
00:19:33.806 --> 00:19:37.176 region:rollup2
THOUSAND FOR CONSTITUTIONAL
00:19:35.074 --> 00:19:39.045 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE. AGAIN TO BE SAFE
00:19:37.176 --> 00:19:39.645 region:rollup2
NEED ABOUT A MILLION SIGNATURES
00:19:39.045 --> 00:19:40.379 region:rollup2
WHY DON'T WE DROP THAT DOWN A
00:19:39.645 --> 00:19:42.081 region:rollup2
LITTLE BIT.
00:19:40.379 --> 00:19:43.382 region:rollup2
WHY NOT?
00:19:42.081 --> 00:19:45.184 region:rollup2
I THINK WE ALL AGREE IN DIRECT
00:19:43.382 --> 00:19:46.285 region:rollup2
DEMOCRACY HERE AND WE ALL AGREE
00:19:45.184 --> 00:19:47.720 region:rollup2
THAT THERE'S AN OVER RELIANCE ON
00:19:46.285 --> 00:19:49.188 region:rollup2
PAID SIGNATURE GATHERS THAT THIS
00:19:47.720 --> 00:19:51.390 region:rollup2
IS THE WRONG WAY TO SOLVE THE
00:19:49.188 --> 00:19:53.059 region:rollup2
PROBLEM ASK FOR AND ABOUT.
00:19:51.390 --> 00:19:55.695 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY OTHER
00:19:53.059 --> 00:19:57.129 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
00:19:55.695 --> 00:20:00.166 region:rollup2
BUT WILL BRING IT TO THE DYESS.
00:19:57.129 --> 00:20:01.934 region:rollup2
SENATOR MONNING.
00:20:00.166 --> 00:20:03.269 region:rollup2
THANK YOU SENATOR NEWMAN FOR
00:20:01.934 --> 00:20:05.037 region:rollup2
BRINGING THIS FORWARD HAS HAD A
00:20:03.269 --> 00:20:05.938 region:rollup2
QUESTION FOR YOUR WITNESS
00:20:05.037 --> 00:20:07.606 region:rollup2
THROUGH THE CHAIR IS THAT
00:20:05.938 --> 00:20:10.509 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT THAT OBJECTION.
00:20:07.606 --> 00:20:11.143 region:rollup2
THE EXAMPLES YOU GAVE TOM I
00:20:10.509 --> 00:20:12.411 region:rollup2
MIGHT HAVE MISSED THIS BIT WHERE
00:20:11.143 --> 00:20:14.747 region:rollup2
THEY.
00:20:12.411 --> 00:20:16.215 region:rollup2
BACK WHERE THEY GETTING A BOUNTY
00:20:14.747 --> 00:20:16.849 region:rollup2
FOR THE SIGNATURES ETCETERA.
00:20:16.215 --> 00:20:18.384 region:rollup2
IN THE MY QUESTION FOR THE
00:20:16.849 --> 00:20:21.020 region:rollup2
AUTHOR.
00:20:18.384 --> 00:20:23.723 region:rollup2
UNDER YOUR BILL COULD EMPLOYER.
00:20:21.020 --> 00:20:25.191 region:rollup2
WHO'S PAYING AN HOURLY RATE.
00:20:23.723 --> 00:20:26.792 region:rollup2
HAVE A QUOTE OF THE MINIMUM
00:20:25.191 --> 00:20:29.762 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF SIGNATURES THAT WOULD
00:20:26.792 --> 00:20:32.998 region:rollup2
HAVE TO ME. GATHERED TO TURN
00:20:29.762 --> 00:20:33.999 region:rollup2
THAT HOURLY RATE. ADDED ON TO MY
00:20:32.998 --> 00:20:35.634 region:rollup2
BILL I SUPPOSE THAT'S TRUE MY MY
00:20:33.999 --> 00:20:37.670 region:rollup2
BILL SEEKS TO EXPRESSLY PROHIBIT
00:20:35.634 --> 00:20:39.305 region:rollup2
THE DE PAYMENT A BOUNTY CENTER.
00:20:37.670 --> 00:20:40.606 region:rollup2
IT.
00:20:39.305 --> 00:20:41.607 region:rollup2
DID YOU KNOW DID DID THE WITHIN
00:20:40.606 --> 00:20:43.042 region:rollup2
THAT I'M SURE THERE ARE LOTS OF
00:20:41.607 --> 00:20:44.510 region:rollup2
WAYS TO PAY EMPLOYEES THAT
00:20:43.042 --> 00:20:45.544 region:rollup2
ENSURE TRANSPARENCY HONESTY AT
00:20:44.510 --> 00:20:47.413 region:rollup2
NIGHT NO PROMINENT.
00:20:45.544 --> 00:20:49.849 region:rollup2
BECAUSE I COULD SEE. IF YOU HAD
00:20:47.413 --> 00:20:51.584 region:rollup2
CERTAIN QUOTAS.
00:20:49.849 --> 00:20:52.618 region:rollup2
THAT WERE UNREALISTIC HE COULD
00:20:51.584 --> 00:20:54.286 region:rollup2
ALSO INCENTIVIZE THE SIGNATURE
00:20:52.618 --> 00:20:57.022 region:rollup2
GATHER.
00:20:54.286 --> 00:20:58.424 region:rollup2
TO ENGAGE IN DECEPTION.
00:20:57.022 --> 00:20:59.925 region:rollup2
FRAUD COMPING NAME SET OF PHONE
00:20:58.424 --> 00:21:01.961 region:rollup2
BOOKS IF.
00:20:59.925 --> 00:21:03.696 region:rollup2
IF THEY'RE PAYING AN HOURLY RATE
00:21:01.961 --> 00:21:05.664 region:rollup2
AND THEY'VE GOT TO GET TWENTY
00:21:03.696 --> 00:21:06.665 region:rollup2
SIGNATURE HOURS AN HOUR I AND I
00:21:05.664 --> 00:21:08.601 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE YOUR POINT NOW NOW IF
00:21:06.665 --> 00:21:10.402 region:rollup2
YOU WERE COPYING SIGNATURES OUT
00:21:08.601 --> 00:21:12.538 region:rollup2
OF OF PHONE BOOKS. THOSE WOULD
00:21:10.402 --> 00:21:14.807 region:rollup2
NOT BE VALIDATED BY REGISTRAR.
00:21:12.538 --> 00:21:16.542 region:rollup2
THE JOKE WOULD THEN BE ON THE
00:21:14.807 --> 00:21:18.110 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW THE PAYER I IN THIS
00:21:16.542 --> 00:21:20.479 region:rollup2
ASE WHAT HAPPENS IS AYE
00:21:18.110 --> 00:21:21.213 region:rollup2
UNWITTING CITIZENS TYPICALLY ON
00:21:20.479 --> 00:21:23.149 region:rollup2
THE WAY INTO A STORE OF.
00:21:21.213 --> 00:21:25.151 region:rollup2
OF SOME KIND.
00:21:23.149 --> 00:21:27.052 region:rollup2
R. BUTTON BUTTON HOLED BY
00:21:25.151 --> 00:21:29.655 region:rollup2
DECISION GATHERS THAT ARE ONLY
00:21:27.052 --> 00:21:30.923 region:rollup2
SEEKING TO OPTIMIZE THEIR YIELD
00:21:29.655 --> 00:21:32.291 region:rollup2
THE AND THE SERVICES THAT
00:21:30.923 --> 00:21:34.160 region:rollup2
THEY'RE THERE ARE NO EFFECTIVE
00:21:32.291 --> 00:21:35.828 region:rollup2
PROHIBITIONS FROM
00:21:34.160 --> 00:21:36.896 region:rollup2
MISREPRESENTATION RIGHT NOW.
00:21:35.828 --> 00:21:38.998 region:rollup2
ABOUT YOU WHAT WE'RE ENDEAVOR TO
00:21:36.896 --> 00:21:40.699 region:rollup2
DO HERE IS AGAIN THERE'S SOME
00:21:38.998 --> 00:21:41.567 region:rollup2
LEVEL SIMPLY FOR THE SIGNATURE
00:21:40.699 --> 00:21:43.536 region:rollup2
GATHERER THEY HAVE A RIGHT TO
00:21:41.567 --> 00:21:44.970 region:rollup2
MAKE A LIVING. IT'S THE SYSTEMIC
00:21:43.536 --> 00:21:48.874 region:rollup2
ISSUES THAT THE BILL TO ATTEMPTS
00:21:44.970 --> 00:21:49.241 region:rollup2
TO ADDRESS. BUT I AND TO MISTER
00:21:48.874 --> 00:21:53.078 region:rollup2
WILLS COMMENT.
00:21:49.241 --> 00:21:54.180 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW AGAIN.
00:21:53.078 --> 00:21:55.181 region:rollup2
THERE IS NO RIGHT TO GET AN
00:21:54.180 --> 00:21:56.682 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE ON THE BALLOT IN
00:21:55.181 --> 00:21:57.783 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA THE YOU KNOW THE
00:21:56.682 --> 00:21:59.718 region:rollup2
FOUNDERS.
00:21:57.783 --> 00:22:01.420 region:rollup2
BACK IN AN EARLIER TIME HAD A
00:21:59.718 --> 00:22:02.421 region:rollup2
DELIBERATELY RIGOROUS STANDARD
00:22:01.420 --> 00:22:04.156 region:rollup2
THAT STANDARD I WOULD ARGUE IS
00:22:02.421 --> 00:22:06.258 region:rollup2
PROPORTIONALLY ABOUT THE SAME
00:22:04.156 --> 00:22:08.861 region:rollup2
TODAY AND THAT MAKES SENSE.
00:22:06.258 --> 00:22:10.563 region:rollup2
BECAUSE. WE DON'T WE LEGISLATE
00:22:08.861 --> 00:22:12.364 region:rollup2
THROUGH THE RECALL THE
00:22:10.563 --> 00:22:14.533 region:rollup2
INITIATIVE AND THE REFERENDUM.
00:22:12.364 --> 00:22:15.968 region:rollup2
IDEALLY AS A MEASURE OF LAST
00:22:14.533 --> 00:22:16.602 region:rollup2
RESORT FOR ME WHERE THE CITIZENS
00:22:15.968 --> 00:22:17.469 region:rollup2
HAVE TO TAKE MATTERS INTO THEIR
00:22:16.602 --> 00:22:19.805 region:rollup2
OWN HANDS.
00:22:17.469 --> 00:22:21.006 region:rollup2
OUTSIDE THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS
00:22:19.805 --> 00:22:23.142 region:rollup2
IT SHOULDN'T BE EASY.
00:22:21.006 --> 00:22:23.676 region:rollup2
THERE'S NOTHING ABOUT THIS THAT
00:22:23.142 --> 00:22:24.577 region:rollup2
WOULD INTERFERE WITH THE
00:22:23.676 --> 00:22:26.745 region:rollup2
CONTRACT.
00:22:24.577 --> 00:22:28.247 region:rollup2
BETWEEN A PAID EMPLOYEE AND
00:22:26.745 --> 00:22:29.849 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER WHAT WE ENDEAVOR TO DO
00:22:28.247 --> 00:22:32.284 region:rollup2
IS TO TO TRY AND ADDRESS THE
00:22:29.849 --> 00:22:33.986 region:rollup2
SYSTEMIC FEATURES THAT SEEMED TO
00:22:32.284 --> 00:22:34.620 region:rollup2
ENCOURAGE MISREPRESENTATION.
00:22:33.986 --> 00:22:36.856 region:rollup2
THANK YOU AND.
00:22:34.620 --> 00:22:39.425 region:rollup2
IN ADDITION TO THE EXAMPLE
00:22:36.856 --> 00:22:41.293 region:rollup2
PROVIDED BY YOUR WITNESS COME.
00:22:39.425 --> 00:22:43.829 region:rollup2
I AM AWARE OF MANY EXAMPLES
00:22:41.293 --> 00:22:46.565 region:rollup2
AROUND THE CITY OF DECEPTION BY
00:22:43.829 --> 00:22:49.101 region:rollup2
PAID SIGNATURE GATHERS BOUNTY.
00:22:46.565 --> 00:22:51.237 region:rollup2
BOUNTY SIGNATURE GATHERER SO I'M
00:22:49.101 --> 00:22:52.605 region:rollup2
SUPPORTIVE OF OF THE OBJECTIVES
00:22:51.237 --> 00:22:54.607 region:rollup2
OF THIS BILL.
00:22:52.605 --> 00:22:57.076 region:rollup2
I THINK THERE'S STILL A
00:22:54.607 --> 00:23:00.012 region:rollup2
DISPROPORTIONATE. A RESULT IN
00:22:57.076 --> 00:23:02.548 region:rollup2
OUR SYSTEM WHEN. THOSE WITH DEEP
00:23:00.012 --> 00:23:03.882 region:rollup2
POCKETS COULDN'T.
00:23:02.548 --> 00:23:05.718 region:rollup2
PAY NOT ONLY WHAT THE MARKET
00:23:03.882 --> 00:23:07.186 region:rollup2
WILL BEAR BIT. DOUBLE OR TRIPLE
00:23:05.718 --> 00:23:09.588 region:rollup2
THAT TO.
00:23:07.186 --> 00:23:11.323 region:rollup2
PAY PEOPLE HOURLY TO CLICK
00:23:09.588 --> 00:23:13.459 region:rollup2
SIGNATURES PARA NO WHERE'S
00:23:11.323 --> 00:23:15.261 region:rollup2
SOMEBODY WITH A NOBLE CAUSE AND
00:23:13.459 --> 00:23:16.562 region:rollup2
WITHOUT THE DEEP POCKETS. IS
00:23:15.261 --> 00:23:18.297 region:rollup2
STILL NOT GOING TO BE ON A LEVEL
00:23:16.562 --> 00:23:21.100 region:rollup2
PLAYING FIELD BUT I SUPPORT.
00:23:18.297 --> 00:23:23.369 region:rollup2
THIS TRYING TO AT LEAST REMOVE.
00:23:21.100 --> 00:23:24.503 region:rollup2
OCCURRING INCENTIVE THAT HAS
00:23:23.369 --> 00:23:26.872 region:rollup2
LEAD TO DECEPTION AND
00:23:24.503 --> 00:23:28.741 region:rollup2
MISREPRESENTATION BY SIGNATURE
00:23:26.872 --> 00:23:29.375 region:rollup2
GATHER SO I THINK YOU HAVE A
00:23:28.741 --> 00:23:31.143 region:rollup2
MOTION BEFORE YOU WILL BE
00:23:29.375 --> 00:23:32.878 region:rollup2
PREPARED TO SUPPORT THIS AT THE
00:23:31.143 --> 00:23:34.446 region:rollup2
PROPER TIME THANK YOU SENATOR
00:23:32.878 --> 00:23:35.514 region:rollup2
MONNING SENATOR MORLOCK. THANK
00:23:34.446 --> 00:23:36.482 region:rollup2
YOU MADAM CHAIR I'M SORT OF
00:23:35.514 --> 00:23:38.217 region:rollup2
REMINDED OF THE TO TRAVELING
00:23:36.482 --> 00:23:39.752 region:rollup2
SALESMAN IN THE IN MINNESOTA IN
00:23:38.217 --> 00:23:42.855 region:rollup2
THE WINTER. THEY PULLED INTO A
00:23:39.752 --> 00:23:44.490 region:rollup2
SMALL HOTEL BECAUSE OF HIGH.
00:23:42.855 --> 00:23:45.958 region:rollup2
PROBABILITY OF A WINTER STORM IN
00:23:44.490 --> 00:23:47.927 region:rollup2
THE MORNING THEY WOKE UP AND SAW
00:23:45.958 --> 00:23:49.361 region:rollup2
A MAJOR SNOW DRAFT TO MAKE WENT
00:23:47.927 --> 00:23:51.030 region:rollup2
TO THE PROPRIETOR AND SAID. HOW
00:23:49.361 --> 00:23:52.431 region:rollup2
ARE WE GONNA GET OUT OF HERE CAN
00:23:51.030 --> 00:23:53.632 region:rollup2
WE GET OUT OF HERE?
00:23:52.431 --> 00:23:55.467 region:rollup2
AND THE PROPRIETOR SAID WELL IT
00:23:53.632 --> 00:23:59.405 region:rollup2
ALL DEPENDS ON WHETHER YOU'RE ON
00:23:55.467 --> 00:24:01.073 region:rollup2
SALARY. OR ON COMMISSION.
00:23:59.405 --> 00:24:02.841 region:rollup2
THOSE THOSE RUN COMMISSION WILL
00:24:01.073 --> 00:24:03.776 region:rollup2
FIGURE A WAY TO. TO GET OUT AND
00:24:02.841 --> 00:24:05.277 region:rollup2
SO.
00:24:03.776 --> 00:24:08.080 region:rollup2
IT'S A DIFFERENT MOTIVATING
00:24:05.277 --> 00:24:09.381 region:rollup2
APPROACH IN COMPENSATING PEOPLE
00:24:08.080 --> 00:24:12.017 region:rollup2
AND SO I'M HAVING A DIFFICULTY
00:24:09.381 --> 00:24:12.885 region:rollup2
WITH.
00:24:12.017 --> 00:24:14.486 region:rollup2
THAT YOU KNOW CHANGING THE
00:24:12.885 --> 00:24:16.155 region:rollup2
APPROACH BECAUSE JUST BECAUSE
00:24:14.486 --> 00:24:17.623 region:rollup2
YOU HAVE SOME BAD. APPLES
00:24:16.155 --> 00:24:18.791 region:rollup2
DOESN'T MEAN THAT EVERYONE HAS
00:24:17.623 --> 00:24:20.592 region:rollup2
HIS HIS SCRIPT SHOULD BE SHOULD
00:24:18.791 --> 00:24:21.660 region:rollup2
BE. REMOVED FROM THAT APPROACH
00:24:20.592 --> 00:24:23.395 region:rollup2
SITE MISTER
00:24:21.660 --> 00:24:24.697 region:rollup2
SENATOR NEWMAN I'M JUST CURIOUS.
00:24:23.395 --> 00:24:26.432 region:rollup2
ON THE FLIP SIDE OF CENTER
00:24:24.697 --> 00:24:28.100 region:rollup2
MONIES QUESTION.
00:24:26.432 --> 00:24:30.135 region:rollup2
IF IF A SIGNATURE GATHERERS
00:24:28.100 --> 00:24:31.804 region:rollup2
BEING PAID BY THE HOUR. WOULD HE
00:24:30.135 --> 00:24:33.906 region:rollup2
BE ENTITLED HERSHEY.
00:24:31.804 --> 00:24:35.574 region:rollup2
TWO OF THE BONUSES IF THEY MEET
00:24:33.906 --> 00:24:36.875 region:rollup2
CERTAIN.
00:24:35.574 --> 00:24:38.344 region:rollup2
THERE'S NOTHING ABOUT THIS BILL
00:24:36.875 --> 00:24:39.945 region:rollup2
WOULD PROHIBIT THAT'S DISH AND
00:24:38.344 --> 00:24:41.480 region:rollup2
MORE LIKE THAT BUT THERE'S A
00:24:39.945 --> 00:24:43.082 region:rollup2
FEATURE OF THE BILL THAT I THINK
00:24:41.480 --> 00:24:44.616 region:rollup2
WOULD WOULD SAFEGUARD THE PUBLIC
00:24:43.082 --> 00:24:46.785 region:rollup2
INTEREST IN THAT SPECIFICALLY IS
00:24:44.616 --> 00:24:48.587 region:rollup2
THE WHISTLEBLOWER COMPONENT.
00:24:46.785 --> 00:24:49.855 region:rollup2
AND AND THAT IS IT MATERIAL IN
00:24:48.587 --> 00:24:51.190 region:rollup2
THIS CASE CHAU CHAU UNDER THE
00:24:49.855 --> 00:24:54.059 region:rollup2
CURRENT REGIME.
00:24:51.190 --> 00:24:56.061 region:rollup2
THEY'RE THE ONLY RECOURSE FOR
00:24:54.059 --> 00:24:56.628 region:rollup2
THE CITATION PROSECUTION
00:24:56.061 --> 00:25:00.566 region:rollup2
OFFENSES.
00:24:56.628 --> 00:25:02.201 region:rollup2
ACCRUES TO PUBLIC OFFICIALS GUY
00:25:00.566 --> 00:25:03.736 region:rollup2
AND THERE IS IT SEEMS PERSONALLY
00:25:02.201 --> 00:25:05.237 region:rollup2
IMPOSSIBLE HIT TO GET A
00:25:03.736 --> 00:25:07.239 region:rollup2
REGISTRAR DE A OR THE ATTORNEY
00:25:05.237 --> 00:25:08.974 region:rollup2
GENERAL TO INTERCEDE AND AND
00:25:07.239 --> 00:25:10.042 region:rollup2
AGAIN AS I MENTIONED. DIED THERE
00:25:08.974 --> 00:25:11.310 region:rollup2
ARE PROBLEMS WITH RESPECT TO THE
00:25:10.042 --> 00:25:13.412 region:rollup2
ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE SO IF
00:25:11.310 --> 00:25:15.614 region:rollup2
I WERE TO ENGAGE A SIGNATURE
00:25:13.412 --> 00:25:17.015 region:rollup2
GATHERER WHOSE FLAT OUT LYING BY
00:25:15.614 --> 00:25:17.850 region:rollup2
AND IF I WERE TO RECORD HIM OR
00:25:17.015 --> 00:25:19.284 region:rollup2
HER.
00:25:17.850 --> 00:25:21.286 region:rollup2
THAT EVIDENCE THAT WE WOULD NOT
00:25:19.284 --> 00:25:22.488 region:rollup2
BE ADMISSIBLE IF IT WAS SECURE
00:25:21.286 --> 00:25:24.356 region:rollup2
WITHOUT HIS OR HER INTENT OR
00:25:22.488 --> 00:25:26.759 region:rollup2
WITHOUT THE ADMONITION AS TO HOW
00:25:24.356 --> 00:25:28.060 region:rollup2
WOULD BE USED THAT BEFOREHAND.
00:25:26.759 --> 00:25:30.429 region:rollup2
SHOW BY MAKING THE A IN AN
00:25:28.060 --> 00:25:31.864 region:rollup2
AVERAGE VOTER DIE EMPOWER TO
00:25:30.429 --> 00:25:34.366 region:rollup2
FILE A COMPLAINT AND IN FACT
00:25:31.864 --> 00:25:35.701 region:rollup2
GIVING THEM THE SAME LEVEL OF.
00:25:34.366 --> 00:25:37.669 region:rollup2
NATALIE LEVERAGE BUT A
00:25:35.701 --> 00:25:40.439 region:rollup2
PROSPECTIVE RETURN.
00:25:37.669 --> 00:25:42.207 region:rollup2
AS A SHARE OF THE PENALTY I'D
00:25:40.439 --> 00:25:43.208 region:rollup2
AS WE DO WITH FALSE CLAIMS IN
00:25:42.207 --> 00:25:44.843 region:rollup2
OTHER KINDS OF ABUSES.
00:25:43.208 --> 00:25:49.114 region:rollup2
I THINK THAT WILL GO A LONG WAY
00:25:44.843 --> 00:25:49.681 region:rollup2
TO SOLVING THE PROBLEMBUT THE
00:25:49.114 --> 00:25:49.982 region:rollup2
PERSPECTIVE FROM THAT YOU'VE
00:25:49.681 --> 00:25:50.516 region:rollup2
IDENTIFIED.
00:25:49.982 --> 00:25:51.150 region:rollup2
BUT IT.
00:25:50.516 --> 00:25:52.051 region:rollup2
WE WERE STILL TRYING TO FIGURE
00:25:51.150 --> 00:25:54.319 region:rollup2
OUT HOW TO COMPENSATE SOMEONE
00:25:52.051 --> 00:25:55.487 region:rollup2
FOR DOING A TASK.
00:25:54.319 --> 00:25:57.156 region:rollup2
IT'S A MADAM CHAIR I HAVE A
00:25:55.487 --> 00:25:58.824 region:rollup2
PROBLEM WITH THAT.
00:25:57.156 --> 00:26:01.126 region:rollup2
THANK YOU FOR ANY AND IF I
00:25:58.824 --> 00:26:01.960 region:rollup2
MEASURE IT YOU KNOW SO SO. WE AS
00:26:01.126 --> 00:26:03.996 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT.
00:26:01.960 --> 00:26:05.497 region:rollup2
PARTICIPATE OR INTERFERE IN
00:26:03.996 --> 00:26:06.932 region:rollup2
CONTRACTS ALL THE TIME.
00:26:05.497 --> 00:26:08.233 region:rollup2
THERE ARE MANY CASES IN TO
00:26:06.932 --> 00:26:09.868 region:rollup2
FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRY
00:26:08.233 --> 00:26:11.670 region:rollup2
WHERE WE VERY CLEARLY STIPULATE
00:26:09.868 --> 00:26:12.671 region:rollup2
HOW YOU WILL OR WON'T GET PAID I
00:26:11.670 --> 00:26:14.373 region:rollup2
THINK IT'S FAIR IN THIS CASE
00:26:12.671 --> 00:26:15.941 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR WITH THE PUBLIC
00:26:14.373 --> 00:26:17.709 region:rollup2
INTEREST IS AT STAKE.
00:26:15.941 --> 00:26:19.378 region:rollup2
AND WILL TAKE THAT AS YOUR
00:26:17.709 --> 00:26:20.946 region:rollup2
CLOTHES I JUST WANTED TO POINT
00:26:19.378 --> 00:26:23.916 region:rollup2
OUT. THAT.
00:26:20.946 --> 00:26:25.918 region:rollup2
THE INITIATIVE PROCESS STARTED
00:26:23.916 --> 00:26:27.886 region:rollup2
IN CALIFORNIANS TO.
00:26:25.918 --> 00:26:29.188 region:rollup2
NINETEEN ELEVEN.
00:26:27.886 --> 00:26:30.522 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA BECAME THE TENTS
00:26:29.188 --> 00:26:34.293 region:rollup2
STATE IN THE COUNTRY.
00:26:30.522 --> 00:26:35.928 region:rollup2
TO ENACT THIS AND AT THE TIME
00:26:34.293 --> 00:26:38.297 region:rollup2
IT WAS DONE BECAUSE.
00:26:35.928 --> 00:26:41.266 region:rollup2
SACRAMENTO HAD BECOME A ONE
00:26:38.297 --> 00:26:43.001 region:rollup2
COMPANY TOWN THE RAILROADS WERE.
00:26:41.266 --> 00:26:45.170 region:rollup2
TAKING OVER AND WE DIDN'T THE
00:26:43.001 --> 00:26:46.705 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WERE NOT CONSIDERED AND
00:26:45.170 --> 00:26:49.608 region:rollup2
THE INITIATIVE PROCESS WAS
00:26:46.705 --> 00:26:52.111 region:rollup2
DESIGNED TO CIRCUMVENT OVERCOME.
00:26:49.608 --> 00:26:54.913 region:rollup2
THIS SO THE CORPORATE THE.
00:26:52.111 --> 00:26:56.448 region:rollup2
HOLD ON OUR ELECTION PROCESS
00:26:54.913 --> 00:26:56.982 region:rollup2
TODAY IF YOU FAST FORWARD AND
00:26:56.448 --> 00:26:58.851 region:rollup2
THEN OVER THE PAST SEVERAL
00:26:56.982 --> 00:27:02.020 region:rollup2
YEARS.
00:26:58.851 --> 00:27:03.455 region:rollup2
WE NOW SEE THE THE VERY REASON
00:27:02.020 --> 00:27:05.324 region:rollup2
FOR ENACTING THE INITIATIVE IS
00:27:03.455 --> 00:27:07.159 region:rollup2
IS ACTUALLY CONSIDERED IN MANY
00:27:05.324 --> 00:27:09.161 region:rollup2
RESPECTS ITS DOWNFALL BECAUSE AS
00:27:07.159 --> 00:27:11.497 region:rollup2
WAS MENTIONED IT'S. ALL TOO EASY
00:27:09.161 --> 00:27:12.998 region:rollup2
FOR A FEW. WELL FUNDED
00:27:11.497 --> 00:27:15.534 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS FREQUENTLY.
00:27:12.998 --> 00:27:16.635 region:rollup2
A PEOPLE WHO DO NOT EVEN LIVE
00:27:15.534 --> 00:27:18.704 region:rollup2
IN CALIFORNIA.
00:27:16.635 --> 00:27:20.572 region:rollup2
COMING FROM NEW YORKER VIRGINIA
00:27:18.704 --> 00:27:22.608 region:rollup2
TESTING OUT DATA TO SEE IF THEY
00:27:20.572 --> 00:27:24.109 region:rollup2
CAN GET PASSED AN INITIATIVE
00:27:22.608 --> 00:27:26.111 region:rollup2
THAT ACTUALLY WILL UNDERMINE.
00:27:24.109 --> 00:27:27.212 region:rollup2
THE WILL OF OF THE PEOPLE IN
00:27:26.111 --> 00:27:28.981 region:rollup2
THE LEGISLATURE.
00:27:27.212 --> 00:27:30.249 region:rollup2
AND THEY DO IT BY BRINGING
00:27:28.981 --> 00:27:31.617 region:rollup2
PEOPLE INFREQUENTLY FROM OUT OF
00:27:30.249 --> 00:27:33.085 region:rollup2
STATE.
00:27:31.617 --> 00:27:35.787 region:rollup2
THEY BRING PEOPLE IN I KNOW FROM
00:27:33.085 --> 00:27:37.256 region:rollup2
ARIZONA AND OTHER PLACES THEY.
00:27:35.787 --> 00:27:38.690 region:rollup2
PUT HIM ON A BUS THEY IN THE
00:27:37.256 --> 00:27:40.526 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA THEY'RE HERE FOR TO
00:27:38.690 --> 00:27:41.493 region:rollup2
COLLECT THE SIGNATURES AND THEN
00:27:40.526 --> 00:27:43.195 region:rollup2
THEY'RE GONE SO IT'S ALMOST
00:27:41.493 --> 00:27:45.531 region:rollup2
IMPOSSIBLE EVEN IF WE DID WANT
00:27:43.195 --> 00:27:47.833 region:rollup2
TO. PURSUE ANY KIND OF OF
00:27:45.531 --> 00:27:49.468 region:rollup2
REDRESS FOR THAT BEHAVIOR AND.
00:27:47.833 --> 00:27:51.503 region:rollup2
I DO THINK THAT.
00:27:49.468 --> 00:27:54.706 region:rollup2
A WELL INTENDED SYSTEM HAS
00:27:51.503 --> 00:27:56.942 region:rollup2
REALLY BECOME A CORRUPTED BY.
00:27:54.706 --> 00:27:59.077 region:rollup2
GUY I WANT TO THE PEOPLE WORK
00:27:56.942 --> 00:28:01.113 region:rollup2
ON COMMISSION ARE THE FALL ARE
00:27:59.077 --> 00:28:02.781 region:rollup2
THE PROBLEM BUT WHEN PEOPLE WORK
00:28:01.113 --> 00:28:05.083 region:rollup2
ON COMMISSION WE STILL EXPECT
00:28:02.781 --> 00:28:06.752 region:rollup2
THEM TO BE. REPRESENTING THEIR
00:28:05.083 --> 00:28:08.954 region:rollup2
PRODUCT FAITHFULLY AND
00:28:06.752 --> 00:28:10.689 region:rollup2
ACCURATELY AND WHAT WE SEE HERE
00:28:08.954 --> 00:28:12.858 region:rollup2
AND I HAVE PERSONALLY
00:28:10.689 --> 00:28:13.058 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCED THIS TO. A BALLOT
00:28:12.858 --> 00:28:15.794 region:rollup2
DID.
00:28:13.058 --> 00:28:17.996 region:rollup2
COLLECTIONS OR THOSE SIGNATURE
00:28:15.794 --> 00:28:20.032 region:rollup2
COLLECTORS WHO PRETEND THAT THE
00:28:17.996 --> 00:28:22.000 region:rollup2
PRODUCT THAT THEY ARE SELLING IF
00:28:20.032 --> 00:28:24.002 region:rollup2
YOU WILL IS CLEAN AIR AND CLEAN
00:28:22.000 --> 00:28:25.470 region:rollup2
WATER ONLY TO DISCOVER IT HAS
00:28:24.002 --> 00:28:27.472 region:rollup2
ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO DO WITH
00:28:25.470 --> 00:28:28.974 region:rollup2
EITHER. A BUT PLEASE SIGN HERE
00:28:27.472 --> 00:28:30.509 region:rollup2
IS YOU'RE GOING TO THE GROCERY
00:28:28.974 --> 00:28:31.910 region:rollup2
STORE AND THEY HAVE NO
00:28:30.509 --> 00:28:34.046 region:rollup2
RESPONSIBILITY.
00:28:31.910 --> 00:28:36.148 region:rollup2
AND MOST PEOPLE OF COURSE THEY
00:28:34.046 --> 00:28:37.649 region:rollup2
ARE ANXIOUS TO GET ON WITH THEIR
00:28:36.148 --> 00:28:39.184 region:rollup2
BUSINESS AND EVERYBODY WANTS
00:28:37.649 --> 00:28:41.787 region:rollup2
CLEAN AIR AND CLEAN WATER SO.
00:28:39.184 --> 00:28:43.522 region:rollup2
THERE HAVE BEEN PROBLEMS I
00:28:41.787 --> 00:28:45.457 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THAT THIS. THIS BILL
00:28:43.522 --> 00:28:48.660 region:rollup2
ADDRESSES A VERY IMPORTANT
00:28:45.457 --> 00:28:48.927 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT INTEREST AND.
00:28:48.660 --> 00:28:51.863 region:rollup2
BOB I'M.
00:28:48.927 --> 00:28:55.100 region:rollup2
APPRECIATIVE OF YOUR EFFORTS.
00:28:51.863 --> 00:28:57.769 region:rollup2
THERE THE THE THE ABILITY THE.
00:28:55.100 --> 00:28:59.705 region:rollup2
KIND OF CREATIVITY OF PEOPLE IS
00:28:57.769 --> 00:29:01.206 region:rollup2
NEVER ENDING. A.
00:28:59.705 --> 00:29:03.709 region:rollup2
BOB BUT WITHOUT WE WILL.
00:29:01.206 --> 00:29:05.611 region:rollup2
THANK YOU FOR THIS BILL AND A
00:29:03.709 --> 00:29:06.678 region:rollup2
AT THIS POINT TIME MADAM
00:29:05.611 --> 00:29:09.247 region:rollup2
SECRETARY PLEASE.
00:29:06.678 --> 00:29:10.916 region:rollup2
CALL THE ROLL THE MEASURE IS TO
00:29:09.247 --> 00:29:13.151 region:rollup2
PASS TO PUBLIC SAFETY.
00:29:10.916 --> 00:29:15.487 region:rollup2
JACKSON HIGH JACKSON AYE MORE
00:29:13.151 --> 00:29:18.490 region:rollup2
LOCK. BLOCK NO ANDERSON
00:29:15.487 --> 00:29:20.993 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG MINING. MINING AYE
00:29:18.490 --> 00:29:23.328 region:rollup2
STERN LIKE ASKING AYE WIECKOWSKI
00:29:20.993 --> 00:29:25.964 region:rollup2
AYE.
00:29:23.328 --> 00:29:42.447 region:rollup2
ALICIA THREE TO ONE AND WE WILL
00:29:25.964 --> 00:29:42.447 region:rollup2
HOLD THE ROLE THAT YOU MANAGER
00:29:46.618 --> 00:29:48.320 region:rollup2
.
00:29:46.752 --> 00:29:48.587 region:rollup2
SENATOR LEYVA WE'RE GONNA LET
00:29:48.320 --> 00:29:50.188 region:rollup2
YOU.
00:29:48.587 --> 00:29:52.157 region:rollup2
.
00:29:50.188 --> 00:29:53.025 region:rollup2
BRING YOUR BILL FIRST SENATOR
00:29:52.157 --> 00:29:55.227 region:rollup2
WIENER THAT EVER THE GENTLEMAN
00:29:53.025 --> 00:29:56.995 region:rollup2
HAS AGREE.
00:29:55.227 --> 00:29:59.031 region:rollup2
WE ALL OF FOR
00:29:56.995 --> 00:30:00.365 region:rollup2
THAT HE HAS TO BILLS AND.
00:29:59.031 --> 00:30:01.366 region:rollup2
YOURS IS FILE I
00:30:00.365 --> 00:30:03.635 region:rollup2
TIME.
00:30:01.366 --> 00:30:05.771 region:rollup2
FIVE.
00:30:03.635 --> 00:30:08.507 region:rollup2
S. B. TEN THIRTY EIGHT AGAIN TWO
00:30:05.771 --> 00:30:10.876 region:rollup2
WITNESSES TWO MINUTES EACH AND
00:30:08.507 --> 00:30:12.711 region:rollup2
THE SAME IN THE. OPPOSITION SIDE
00:30:10.876 --> 00:30:14.212 region:rollup2
IF THERE IS ANY SO.
00:30:12.711 --> 00:30:16.081 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON SENATOR LABOR
00:30:14.212 --> 00:30:17.149 region:rollup2
PLEASE PROCEED GOOD AFTERNOON
00:30:16.081 --> 00:30:19.217 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR GOOD AFTERNOON
00:30:17.149 --> 00:30:20.819 region:rollup2
MEMBERS SP TEN THIRTY EIGHT
00:30:19.217 --> 00:30:22.287 region:rollup2
WOULD CLARIFY THAT INDIVIDUALS
00:30:20.819 --> 00:30:22.821 region:rollup2
MAY BE HELD PERSONALLY LIABLE
00:30:22.287 --> 00:30:24.322 region:rollup2
FOR RETALIATING AGAINST A
00:30:22.821 --> 00:30:25.824 region:rollup2
PERSON.
00:30:24.322 --> 00:30:26.825 region:rollup2
FOR EXERCISING THEIR RIGHTS
00:30:25.824 --> 00:30:28.927 region:rollup2
UNDER THE FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND
00:30:26.825 --> 00:30:30.128 region:rollup2
HOUSING ACT
00:30:28.927 --> 00:30:31.730 region:rollup2
THE HA. UNDER CURRENT LAW A
00:30:30.128 --> 00:30:33.765 region:rollup2
PERSON MAY ALREADY BE HELD
00:30:31.730 --> 00:30:35.267 region:rollup2
PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR HARASSMENT
00:30:33.765 --> 00:30:37.235 region:rollup2
CLAIMS UNDER FEE HA.
00:30:35.267 --> 00:30:38.603 region:rollup2
HOWEVER INDIVIDUALS MAY NOT BE
00:30:37.235 --> 00:30:40.072 region:rollup2
HELD PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR
00:30:38.603 --> 00:30:41.773 region:rollup2
RETALIATION DUE TO AN
00:30:40.072 --> 00:30:44.142 region:rollup2
INTERPRETATION BY THE CALIFORNIA
00:30:41.773 --> 00:30:45.544 region:rollup2
SUPREME COURT. IN JONES VERSUS
00:30:44.142 --> 00:30:47.646 region:rollup2
THE LOGIC TORREY PINES
00:30:45.544 --> 00:30:49.815 region:rollup2
PARTNERSHIP. THAT RENDERED THIS
00:30:47.646 --> 00:30:51.283 region:rollup2
ISSUE UNCLEAR.
00:30:49.815 --> 00:30:52.517 region:rollup2
ONE IMPORTANT REASON TO HOLD
00:30:51.283 --> 00:30:53.819 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS PERSONALLY LIABLE
00:30:52.517 --> 00:30:55.120 region:rollup2
FOR BOTH HARASSMENT AND
00:30:53.819 --> 00:30:56.788 region:rollup2
RETALIATION IS THAT AN
00:30:55.120 --> 00:30:58.724 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL WHO RETALIATES
00:30:56.788 --> 00:31:05.797 region:rollup2
AGAINST ANOTHER TO SILENCE OR
00:30:58.724 --> 00:31:06.665 region:rollup2
INTIMIDATE SHOULD NOT ESCAPE
00:31:05.797 --> 00:31:08.700 region:rollup2
BLACK.
00:31:06.665 --> 00:31:10.268 region:rollup2
THE HARASSER TO JUST GET RID OF
00:31:08.700 --> 00:31:12.037 region:rollup2
THE PERSON WHO'S HARASSED. IN
00:31:10.268 --> 00:31:13.572 region:rollup2
THE IN THE HARASSER MIGHT EVEN
00:31:12.037 --> 00:31:15.207 region:rollup2
AVOID LIABILITY FOR THE
00:31:13.572 --> 00:31:17.676 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AS WELL IF THEY
00:31:15.207 --> 00:31:18.543 region:rollup2
SUCCESSFULLY SILENCE THE VICTIM.
00:31:17.676 --> 00:31:20.779 region:rollup2
IN ORDER FOR A PERSON TO BE
00:31:18.543 --> 00:31:22.914 region:rollup2
FOUND LIABLE FOR RETALIATION THE
00:31:20.779 --> 00:31:23.448 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF MUST PROVE THAT THERE
00:31:22.914 --> 00:31:25.117 region:rollup2
WAS AN ADVERSE EMPLOYMENT
00:31:23.448 --> 00:31:27.552 region:rollup2
ACTION.
00:31:25.117 --> 00:31:28.787 region:rollup2
AS IN A DEMOTION OR TERMINATION
00:31:27.552 --> 00:31:30.922 region:rollup2
AND THAT THE ACTION WAS
00:31:28.787 --> 00:31:31.323 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY MOTIVATED BY THE
00:31:30.922 --> 00:31:31.957 region:rollup2
PROTECTED ACTIVITY
00:31:31.323 --> 00:31:34.559 region:rollup2
REPORTING-SEXUAL HARASSMENT. BUT
00:31:31.957 --> 00:31:35.660 region:rollup2
WOULD
00:31:34.559 --> 00:31:37.496 region:rollup2
LIKE TO MAKE IT CLEAR THAT THIS
00:31:35.660 --> 00:31:39.364 region:rollup2
BILL BILL DOES NOT PLACE FULL
00:31:37.496 --> 00:31:41.800 region:rollup2
LIABILITY ON EITHER THE
00:31:39.364 --> 00:31:43.869 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL NOR THE EMPLOYER IT
00:31:41.800 --> 00:31:46.438 region:rollup2
MERELY CREATES JOINT AND SEVERAL
00:31:43.869 --> 00:31:47.706 region:rollup2
LIABILITY. AS WE'VE SEEN IN THE
00:31:46.438 --> 00:31:49.875 region:rollup2
ME TOO AND WE SAID ENOUGH
00:31:47.706 --> 00:31:51.042 region:rollup2
MOVEMENTS THREATS OF RETALIATION
00:31:49.875 --> 00:31:52.878 region:rollup2
OR WHEN THE BIGGEST BARRIERS FOR
00:31:51.042 --> 00:31:55.213 region:rollup2
WOMEN AND MEN WHO WISH TO SPEAK
00:31:52.878 --> 00:31:56.348 region:rollup2
OUT WHAT FILE SEXUAL HARASSMENT
00:31:55.213 --> 00:31:58.083 region:rollup2
COMPLAINTS.
00:31:56.348 --> 00:31:59.885 region:rollup2
THESE FEARS ARE CERTAINLY VALID
00:31:58.083 --> 00:32:01.153 region:rollup2
AND WELL FOUNDED.
00:31:59.885 --> 00:32:02.921 region:rollup2
ACCORDING TO A TWO THOUSAND
00:32:01.153 --> 00:32:04.556 region:rollup2
SIXTEEN STUDY BY THE US EQUAL
00:32:02.921 --> 00:32:06.458 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY
00:32:04.556 --> 00:32:08.226 region:rollup2
COMMISSION EEOC. SELECT HOUSE
00:32:06.458 --> 00:32:10.695 region:rollup2
FORCE ONTHE STUDY OF HARASSMENT
00:32:08.226 --> 00:32:12.497 region:rollup2
THE WORKPLACE ONE IN FOUR WOMEN
00:32:10.695 --> 00:32:13.832 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCE SEXUAL HARASSMENT IN
00:32:12.497 --> 00:32:15.767 region:rollup2
THE WORKPLACE.
00:32:13.832 --> 00:32:17.869 region:rollup2
AND IN SOME REPORTS WITHIN THAT
00:32:15.767 --> 00:32:19.905 region:rollup2
STUDY THE NUMBER WAS AS HIGH AS
00:32:17.869 --> 00:32:22.174 region:rollup2
EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT. THIS LARGE
00:32:19.905 --> 00:32:23.642 region:rollup2
GAP MAY BECAUSE MANY WOMEN DO
00:32:22.174 --> 00:32:24.910 region:rollup2
NOT NECESSARILY REPORT. WHEN
00:32:23.642 --> 00:32:26.077 region:rollup2
REPORTS COME OUT THAT SOMEONE
00:32:24.910 --> 00:32:27.746 region:rollup2
HAS BEEN HARASSED IN THE
00:32:26.077 --> 00:32:30.382 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE ONE OF THE MOST COMMON
00:32:27.746 --> 00:32:32.017 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS THAT ARISES IS. WHY
00:32:30.382 --> 00:32:34.619 region:rollup2
DIDN'T SHE SAY ANYTHING? THAT
00:32:32.017 --> 00:32:36.588 region:rollup2
SAME STUDY BY THE EEOC ALSO
00:32:34.619 --> 00:32:38.089 region:rollup2
FOUND THAT SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT
00:32:36.588 --> 00:32:39.524 region:rollup2
OF EMPLOYEES WHO SPOKE OUT
00:32:38.089 --> 00:32:42.394 region:rollup2
AGAINST WORKPLACE RETALIATES
00:32:39.524 --> 00:32:44.396 region:rollup2
MISTREATMENT FACE SOME FORM OF
00:32:42.394 --> 00:32:45.697 region:rollup2
RETALIATION. INDIVIDUALS NEED TO
00:32:44.396 --> 00:32:47.199 region:rollup2
UNDERSTAND THAT THEY WILL BE
00:32:45.697 --> 00:32:48.667 region:rollup2
HELD ACCOUNTABLE IF THEY TRY TO
00:32:47.199 --> 00:32:50.769 region:rollup2
INTERFERE WITH OR THREATEN
00:32:48.667 --> 00:32:51.803 region:rollup2
SOMEONE WHO HAS MADE A SEXUAL
00:32:50.769 --> 00:32:54.005 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT CLAIM.
00:32:51.803 --> 00:32:55.707 region:rollup2
WE MUST NEVER ALLOW VICTIMS TO
00:32:54.005 --> 00:32:57.476 region:rollup2
BE SILENCED AGAIN I WOULD LIKE
00:32:55.707 --> 00:32:59.411 region:rollup2
TO INTRODUCE CALIFORNIA
00:32:57.476 --> 00:33:01.813 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS ASSOCIATION
00:32:59.411 --> 00:33:03.682 region:rollup2
MEMBERS BARBARA FOR GARI. AND
00:33:01.813 --> 00:33:05.517 region:rollup2
HAVE VEEN TOMBER BOTH HERE IN
00:33:03.682 --> 00:33:06.985 region:rollup2
SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
00:33:05.517 --> 00:33:09.387 region:rollup2
THEN BEFORE WE PROCEED.
00:33:06.985 --> 00:33:10.989 region:rollup2
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING YOU ARE
00:33:09.387 --> 00:33:12.290 region:rollup2
ACCEPTING THE PROPOSED
00:33:10.989 --> 00:33:13.892 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS IS AUTHORS AMENDMENT
00:33:12.290 --> 00:33:15.994 region:rollup2
SAID IS CORRECT VERY GOOD THANK
00:33:13.892 --> 00:33:19.497 region:rollup2
YOU TWO MINUTES EACH.
00:33:15.994 --> 00:33:20.999 region:rollup2
WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK FIRST?
00:33:19.497 --> 00:33:22.901 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
00:33:20.999 --> 00:33:25.103 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:33:22.901 --> 00:33:26.304 region:rollup2
MY NAME'S PREVENT TIMBRE AND I
00:33:25.103 --> 00:33:27.439 region:rollup2
AM ON AMONG TOLKIEN'S ATTORNEY
00:33:26.304 --> 00:33:29.641 region:rollup2
SHE'S CURRENTLY PURSUING A
00:33:27.439 --> 00:33:30.842 region:rollup2
RETALIATION CASE AGAINST HER
00:33:29.641 --> 00:33:32.711 region:rollup2
FORMER EMPLOYER. WHO
00:33:30.842 --> 00:33:34.145 region:rollup2
SYSTEMATICALLY PUNISHER OVER THE
00:33:32.711 --> 00:33:36.114 region:rollup2
COURSE OF YEARS BECAUSE SHE
00:33:34.145 --> 00:33:38.450 region:rollup2
REBUFFED HER SUPERVISE ALL SEX
00:33:36.114 --> 00:33:40.318 region:rollup2
SEXUAL ADVANCES? HER EXPERIENCE
00:33:38.450 --> 00:33:42.187 region:rollup2
IS UNFORTUNATELY VERY COMMON IN
00:33:40.318 --> 00:33:45.257 region:rollup2
THE STORIES THAT I HEAR AND WITH
00:33:42.187 --> 00:33:47.359 region:rollup2
THE CLIENTS THAT I REPRESENT.
00:33:45.257 --> 00:33:48.860 region:rollup2
WORKERS LIKE ANA.
00:33:47.359 --> 00:33:50.529 region:rollup2
NOT ONLY HAVE TO PUT UP WITH
00:33:48.860 --> 00:33:52.597 region:rollup2
SEXUALLY HARASSING CONDUCT WHICH
00:33:50.529 --> 00:33:53.732 region:rollup2
HAPPENS QUITE OFTEN THEY'RE
00:33:52.597 --> 00:33:54.900 region:rollup2
FORCED TO PUT UP WITH THEM AND
00:33:53.732 --> 00:33:56.735 region:rollup2
NAVIGATE A WORKPLACE THAT
00:33:54.900 --> 00:33:58.503 region:rollup2
INSTILLS FEARS.
00:33:56.735 --> 00:34:00.071 region:rollup2
AND ANYBODY WHO STANDS UP FOR
00:33:58.503 --> 00:34:01.439 region:rollup2
THEIR RIGHTS OR EVEN SPEAKS
00:34:00.071 --> 00:34:03.074 region:rollup2
ABOUT WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO THEM.
00:34:01.439 --> 00:34:04.809 region:rollup2
I ASK YOU TO SUPPORT SB TEN
00:34:03.074 --> 00:34:06.411 region:rollup2
THIRTY EIGHT BECAUSE INDIVIDUALS
00:34:04.809 --> 00:34:07.712 region:rollup2
MUST BE HELD PERSONALLY
00:34:06.411 --> 00:34:09.247 region:rollup2
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE RETALIATES.
00:34:07.712 --> 00:34:11.016 region:rollup2
RETALIATORY CONDUCT IN THE
00:34:09.247 --> 00:34:12.284 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE. I'LL GIVE THE REST OF
00:34:11.016 --> 00:34:14.085 region:rollup2
THE TIME TO ON A TO TELL HER
00:34:12.284 --> 00:34:14.653 region:rollup2
STORY AND CAN ANSWER ANY
00:34:14.085 --> 00:34:17.589 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS IF YOU MAKING MAY
00:34:14.653 --> 00:34:19.090 region:rollup2
HAVE.
00:34:17.589 --> 00:34:21.493 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
00:34:19.090 --> 00:34:25.297 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE THANK
00:34:21.493 --> 00:34:26.998 region:rollup2
YOU FOR ALLOW ME TO HAVE POINTS.
00:34:25.297 --> 00:34:29.000 region:rollup2
MY NAME WITHOUT A MONTH OF ONE I
00:34:26.998 --> 00:34:29.801 region:rollup2
WORKED FOR A MULTINATIONAL.
00:34:29.000 --> 00:34:30.802 region:rollup2
RELIGIOUS SIX COMPANY.
00:34:29.801 --> 00:34:33.305 region:rollup2
WITH ABOUT THREE HUNDRED OFFICES
00:34:30.802 --> 00:34:36.174 region:rollup2
GLOBALLY BUT I WAS DOMICILE IN
00:34:33.305 --> 00:34:37.575 region:rollup2
BRISBANE CALIFORNIA.
00:34:36.174 --> 00:34:39.477 region:rollup2
BECAUSE OF MY HEART IN I WORKED
00:34:37.575 --> 00:34:41.212 region:rollup2
THERE FOR THIRTEEN YEARS BECAUSE
00:34:39.477 --> 00:34:42.948 region:rollup2
OF MY HARD WORK IN JOB
00:34:41.212 --> 00:34:44.816 region:rollup2
PERFORMANCE I WAS PERFECT I WAS
00:34:42.948 --> 00:34:47.285 region:rollup2
PROMOTED TO THE POSITION OF
00:34:44.816 --> 00:34:47.852 region:rollup2
REGIONAL ACCOUNT MANAGER FOR THE
00:34:47.285 --> 00:34:48.820 region:rollup2
COMPANY IN TWO THOUSAND AND
00:34:47.852 --> 00:34:50.789 region:rollup2
FOUR.
00:34:48.820 --> 00:34:52.324 region:rollup2
IN TWO THOUSAND AND SIX I WAS
00:34:50.789 --> 00:34:53.992 region:rollup2
RECRUITED TO SERVE AS A REGIONAL
00:34:52.324 --> 00:34:56.595 region:rollup2
ACCOUNT MANAGER FOR THE HIGHEST
00:34:53.992 --> 00:34:58.330 region:rollup2
PROFITING. GLOBAL ACCOUNT FOR MY
00:34:56.595 --> 00:35:00.031 region:rollup2
COMPANY.
00:34:58.330 --> 00:35:02.033 region:rollup2
IN TWO THOUSAND AND SEVEN I WAS
00:35:00.031 --> 00:35:03.602 region:rollup2
GIVEN AN EXCITING OPPORTUNITY TO
00:35:02.033 --> 00:35:05.570 region:rollup2
MOVING TO A NEW POSITION WITH
00:35:03.602 --> 00:35:08.406 region:rollup2
ANOTHER ACCOUNT. THAT WOULD HAVE
00:35:05.570 --> 00:35:10.408 region:rollup2
TAKEN ME TO BARCELONA SPAIN.
00:35:08.406 --> 00:35:13.345 region:rollup2
HOWEVER WELL THIS WOULD BE TAKEN
00:35:10.408 --> 00:35:14.879 region:rollup2
AWAY FROM ME BECAUSE I REJECTED
00:35:13.345 --> 00:35:16.915 region:rollup2
THE ADVANCES OF MY SUPERVISOR.
00:35:14.879 --> 00:35:18.783 region:rollup2
A MAN WHO LITERALLY HELD MY
00:35:16.915 --> 00:35:20.018 region:rollup2
CAREER IN HIS HANDS.
00:35:18.783 --> 00:35:21.720 region:rollup2
IT'S ALL HAPPENED AFTER A
00:35:20.018 --> 00:35:23.455 region:rollup2
BUSINESS DINNER WITH HIM AND
00:35:21.720 --> 00:35:25.190 region:rollup2
OTHER EXECUTIVES DURING THE
00:35:23.455 --> 00:35:28.126 region:rollup2
DINNER HE BEGUN CARESSING MY
00:35:25.190 --> 00:35:29.694 region:rollup2
LEGS. UNDER THE TABLE I PULLED
00:35:28.126 --> 00:35:31.396 region:rollup2
AWAY AND IMMEDIATELY RECESS TO
00:35:29.694 --> 00:35:33.298 region:rollup2
HIS PROPOSITIONS. AT THE END OF
00:35:31.396 --> 00:35:35.567 region:rollup2
THE DINNER.
00:35:33.298 --> 00:35:37.335 region:rollup2
HE HEADED OUT ON A TRIP TO CHINA
00:35:35.567 --> 00:35:39.637 region:rollup2
AND I HEADED HOME HE KISSED MY
00:35:37.335 --> 00:35:42.073 region:rollup2
MOUTH. BUT WAS SHOCKED AND PULL
00:35:39.637 --> 00:35:43.775 region:rollup2
BACK IMMEDIATELY ONCE AGAIN. THE
00:35:42.073 --> 00:35:45.577 region:rollup2
FOLLOWING DAY HE CALLED ME AT
00:35:43.775 --> 00:35:47.212 region:rollup2
THE OFFICE AND DEMANDED THAT I
00:35:45.577 --> 00:35:48.279 region:rollup2
KEEP QUIET ABOUT WHAT HAD
00:35:47.212 --> 00:35:50.181 region:rollup2
HAPPENED.
00:35:48.279 --> 00:35:52.250 region:rollup2
BUT WAS.
00:35:50.181 --> 00:35:55.720 region:rollup2
TERRIFIED ABOUT WHAT HE COULD DO
00:35:52.250 --> 00:35:57.122 region:rollup2
TO MY CAREER SO I JUST.
00:35:55.720 --> 00:35:58.723 region:rollup2
REPEATED THAT I WAS NOT
00:35:57.122 --> 00:35:59.858 region:rollup2
INTERESTED IN HIS GESTURES AND
00:35:58.723 --> 00:36:01.660 region:rollup2
INTO THE CONVERSATION WITHIN A
00:35:59.858 --> 00:36:04.095 region:rollup2
WEEK.
00:36:01.660 --> 00:36:06.564 region:rollup2
I REPORTED THAT CONDUCT TO MY
00:36:04.095 --> 00:36:08.666 region:rollup2
COLLEAGUE HUBBY NOTES TO ME. MY
00:36:06.564 --> 00:36:10.468 region:rollup2
COLLEAGUE AND THEN MY SUPERVISOR
00:36:08.666 --> 00:36:12.871 region:rollup2
HAD WORKED TOGETHER PREVIOUSLY
00:36:10.468 --> 00:36:15.473 region:rollup2
IN ANOTHER OFFICE AND REMAINED
00:36:12.871 --> 00:36:18.276 region:rollup2
GOOD FRIENDS. SO SHE TOLD HIM OF
00:36:15.473 --> 00:36:20.645 region:rollup2
MY ACCUSATIONS THAT I REPORTED.
00:36:18.276 --> 00:36:22.280 region:rollup2
SOON AFTER THE WORK OPPORTUNITY
00:36:20.645 --> 00:36:24.315 region:rollup2
OF ARSENAL LA BARCELONA WAS
00:36:22.280 --> 00:36:26.351 region:rollup2
TAKEN AWAY FROM ME. AND THAT'S
00:36:24.315 --> 00:36:30.355 region:rollup2
HARD BUT I TRY TO GET MY CAREER
00:36:26.351 --> 00:36:31.322 region:rollup2
BACK ON TRACK I WAS CONTINUOUSLY
00:36:30.355 --> 00:36:31.923 region:rollup2
RETALIATED AGAINST
00:36:31.322 --> 00:36:33.758 region:rollup2
BUT THAT SAME SUPERVISOR AND
00:36:31.923 --> 00:36:36.194 region:rollup2
HIDE.
00:36:33.758 --> 00:36:38.163 region:rollup2
IT HE WAS ABLE TO COMPLETELY
00:36:36.194 --> 00:36:39.798 region:rollup2
DERAIL MY CAREER.
00:36:38.163 --> 00:36:42.033 region:rollup2
SOME OF THOSE RETALIATIONS THAT
00:36:39.798 --> 00:36:45.303 region:rollup2
OCCUR WHERE I WAS PROMOTED BY
00:36:42.033 --> 00:36:48.406 region:rollup2
TITLE BUT STOPPED ADOPTING PAY
00:36:45.303 --> 00:36:50.341 region:rollup2
INTO A DIFFERENT OCCASIONS.
00:36:48.406 --> 00:36:51.810 region:rollup2
HI BASED DISPARITY OF THOSE
00:36:50.341 --> 00:36:54.446 region:rollup2
HOLDING SAME POSITIONS STOCK
00:36:51.810 --> 00:36:56.548 region:rollup2
OPTIONS WERE NO LONGER GRANTED.
00:36:54.446 --> 00:36:58.650 region:rollup2
PAST THREE TIMES FOR EQUAL THAT
00:36:56.548 --> 00:37:00.585 region:rollup2
BASSMAN AND PROMOTION AND AN
00:36:58.650 --> 00:37:02.587 region:rollup2
ACCOUNT THAT I DEVELOPED. BY
00:37:00.585 --> 00:37:05.356 region:rollup2
GIVING IT TO OTHERS. WITH GIVEN
00:37:02.587 --> 00:37:07.392 region:rollup2
SIPPAR ACCOUNTS. GIVEN SO PART
00:37:05.356 --> 00:37:10.095 region:rollup2
IN WHOSE STYLE REVIEWS. THE ABLE
00:37:07.392 --> 00:37:12.530 region:rollup2
TO ON MY REVIEWS OF BEING
00:37:10.095 --> 00:37:14.666 region:rollup2
DRAMATIC AND TOO OUTSPOKEN.
00:37:12.530 --> 00:37:15.767 region:rollup2
INTIMIDATION OF DEMOTION STARTED
00:37:14.666 --> 00:37:17.669 region:rollup2
IN TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN
00:37:15.767 --> 00:37:19.337 region:rollup2
UNTIL HE FINALLY DID IN TWO
00:37:17.669 --> 00:37:21.439 region:rollup2
THOUSAND AND FIFTEEN. ULTIMATELY
00:37:19.337 --> 00:37:23.975 region:rollup2
BEING DEMOTED AND I WAS FORCED
00:37:21.439 --> 00:37:26.811 region:rollup2
OUT. PIECE INCIDENTS IMPACTED MY
00:37:23.975 --> 00:37:29.047 region:rollup2
PROFESSIONAL CAREER. I WORKED SO
00:37:26.811 --> 00:37:31.382 region:rollup2
VERY HARD TO BILLS. YOU INSTILL
00:37:29.047 --> 00:37:33.218 region:rollup2
FEAR OF LOSING MY JOB CONTINUE
00:37:31.382 --> 00:37:34.753 region:rollup2
EMOTIONAL DISTRESS LACK OF
00:37:33.218 --> 00:37:37.689 region:rollup2
CONFIDENCE IN TREMENDOUS
00:37:34.753 --> 00:37:39.624 region:rollup2
FINANCIAL LOSSES MY SUPERVISOR
00:37:37.689 --> 00:37:41.359 region:rollup2
WAS NOT WAS TO MAKE. ABLE TO
00:37:39.624 --> 00:37:43.561 region:rollup2
EXPLOIT HIS POSITION OF POWER IN
00:37:41.359 --> 00:37:47.165 region:rollup2
MAKE SEXUAL ADVANCES TOWARDS ME.
00:37:43.561 --> 00:37:48.466 region:rollup2
AND THEN SILENCE ME AND PUNISH
00:37:47.165 --> 00:37:50.101 region:rollup2
ME FOR SPEAKING OUT ABOUT IT.
00:37:48.466 --> 00:37:51.603 region:rollup2
I HAVE HEARD FROM OTHER
00:37:50.101 --> 00:37:52.170 region:rollup2
EXECUTIVE IN THE COMPANY THAT
00:37:51.603 --> 00:37:54.038 region:rollup2
HE'S DONE THIS TWENTY YEARS
00:37:52.170 --> 00:37:56.274 region:rollup2
BACK.
00:37:54.038 --> 00:37:57.842 region:rollup2
A.
00:37:56.274 --> 00:37:58.743 region:rollup2
IN RATHER THAN BEING HELD
00:37:57.842 --> 00:37:59.844 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABLE FOR HIS
00:37:58.743 --> 00:38:01.846 region:rollup2
INAPPROPRIATE AND UNLAWFUL
00:37:59.844 --> 00:38:03.181 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR I HAVE BEEN PUNISHED
00:38:01.846 --> 00:38:05.116 region:rollup2
AND HE WAS ACTUALLY BEING
00:38:03.181 --> 00:38:06.317 region:rollup2
PROMOTED WITHIN THE COMPANY.
00:38:05.116 --> 00:38:08.353 region:rollup2
THERMOSBE PERSONAL
00:38:06.317 --> 00:38:10.155 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABILITY TO THIS KIND OF
00:38:08.353 --> 00:38:11.656 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR.
00:38:10.155 --> 00:38:14.359 region:rollup2
IF INDIVIDUALS LIKE HIM. ARE
00:38:11.656 --> 00:38:15.593 region:rollup2
ABLE TO RETALIATE AGAINST THOSE
00:38:14.359 --> 00:38:17.562 region:rollup2
THE PAPER TRADE ACCOUNTS AND
00:38:15.593 --> 00:38:19.831 region:rollup2
PUSH THEM OUT OF THEIR CAREERS
00:38:17.562 --> 00:38:20.298 region:rollup2
WE WILL NEVER MAKE ANY PROGRESS
00:38:19.831 --> 00:38:24.969 region:rollup2
TOWARDS ENDING SEXUAL
00:38:20.298 --> 00:38:26.171 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT.
00:38:24.969 --> 00:38:27.338 region:rollup2
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
00:38:26.171 --> 00:38:28.907 region:rollup2
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE TWO MINUTES
00:38:27.338 --> 00:38:30.208 region:rollup2
PLEASE.
00:38:28.907 --> 00:38:31.776 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
00:38:30.208 --> 00:38:33.244 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME
00:38:31.776 --> 00:38:34.646 region:rollup2
IS BARBARA FERRARI AND I'M A
00:38:33.244 --> 00:38:35.713 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF SIDE EMPLOYMENT LAWYER
00:38:34.646 --> 00:38:36.948 region:rollup2
AND BOARD MEMBER FOR THE
00:38:35.713 --> 00:38:38.383 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA PLANET LAWYERS
00:38:36.948 --> 00:38:40.485 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION.
00:38:38.383 --> 00:38:42.320 region:rollup2
I'M HAPPY TO BE HERE ALONGSIDE
00:38:40.485 --> 00:38:43.955 region:rollup2
MY CLIENT NIKITA RICE WHO WILL
00:38:42.320 --> 00:38:45.990 region:rollup2
TELL HER STORY ABOUT HAVING TO
00:38:43.955 --> 00:38:47.325 region:rollup2
AND YOUR SEXUAL HARASSMENT.
00:38:45.990 --> 00:38:49.194 region:rollup2
SHE WORKED IN A MALE DOMINATED
00:38:47.325 --> 00:38:51.062 region:rollup2
INDUSTRY WERE SEXUAL HARASSMENT
00:38:49.194 --> 00:38:52.597 region:rollup2
IS NOT ONLY MORE PREVALENT BUT
00:38:51.062 --> 00:38:54.399 region:rollup2
WHERE YOU ALSO COMMONLY SEE MEN
00:38:52.597 --> 00:38:55.733 region:rollup2
COVERING UP AND PROTECTING THEIR
00:38:54.399 --> 00:38:58.102 region:rollup2
MALE COLLEAGUES WHO ARE ENGAGING
00:38:55.733 --> 00:38:59.170 region:rollup2
IN THE HARASSING CONDUCT.
00:38:58.102 --> 00:39:01.372 region:rollup2
SHE CAN TELL YOU HOW DESTRUCTIVE
00:38:59.170 --> 00:39:02.974 region:rollup2
RETALIATION IS TO ONE'S CAREER
00:39:01.372 --> 00:39:04.175 region:rollup2
AND HOW IT OFTEN PUTS VICTIMS OF
00:39:02.974 --> 00:39:05.843 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT IN THE
00:39:04.175 --> 00:39:07.745 region:rollup2
POSITION OF HAVING TO JUST PUT
00:39:05.843 --> 00:39:09.147 region:rollup2
UP WITH IT. OR IN HER CASE
00:39:07.745 --> 00:39:10.348 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY BEING PENALIZED AND
00:39:09.147 --> 00:39:11.950 region:rollup2
OSTRACIZED FOR STANDING UP
00:39:10.348 --> 00:39:13.551 region:rollup2
AGAINST IT.
00:39:11.950 --> 00:39:15.086 region:rollup2
THIS LEGISLATION IS IMPORTANT
00:39:13.551 --> 00:39:16.921 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THERE MUST BE PERSONAL
00:39:15.086 --> 00:39:18.856 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABILITYFOR THOSE WHO TRY
00:39:16.921 --> 00:39:20.758 region:rollup2
TO SILENCE AND PUNISH THE
00:39:18.856 --> 00:39:22.327 region:rollup2
VICTIMS OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT.
00:39:20.758 --> 00:39:24.295 region:rollup2
GREATER ACCOUNTABILITY IS THE
00:39:22.327 --> 00:39:24.796 region:rollup2
ONLY WAY WE CAN CHANGE THIS ALL
00:39:24.295 --> 00:39:26.097 region:rollup2
TOO COMMON BEHAVIOR THAT
00:39:24.796 --> 00:39:28.032 region:rollup2
FURTHER%
00:39:26.097 --> 00:39:29.300 region:rollup2
VICTIMIZERS THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN
00:39:28.032 --> 00:39:30.735 region:rollup2
SEXUALLY HARASSED AND IT DERAILS
00:39:29.300 --> 00:39:32.203 region:rollup2
THEIR CAREER.
00:39:30.735 --> 00:39:33.938 region:rollup2
I WILL GIVE THE BALANCE OF MY
00:39:32.203 --> 00:39:35.139 region:rollup2
TIME TO MY CLIENT NIKITA WILL BE
00:39:33.938 --> 00:39:36.674 region:rollup2
HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
00:39:35.139 --> 00:39:38.042 region:rollup2
THE COMMITTEE HAS.
00:39:36.674 --> 00:39:40.011 region:rollup2
WE GIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:39:38.042 --> 00:39:42.180 region:rollup2
PLEASE PROCEED AND AGAIN TRIED
00:39:40.011 --> 00:39:44.249 region:rollup2
TO KEEP PICTURE WE GET I THINK.
00:39:42.180 --> 00:39:48.052 region:rollup2
MOST OF US HERE GET THE. GET THE
00:39:44.249 --> 00:39:50.255 region:rollup2
POINT THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:39:48.052 --> 00:39:52.857 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF.
00:39:50.255 --> 00:39:54.292 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON. MADAM CHAIR AND
00:39:52.857 --> 00:39:55.426 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME
00:39:54.292 --> 00:39:57.095 region:rollup2
IS THE KEY TO RISE AND I'M PROUD
00:39:55.426 --> 00:39:58.129 region:rollup2
TO TESTIFY TODAY AN EFFORT TO
00:39:57.095 --> 00:40:00.732 region:rollup2
STRENGTHEN. THE SEXUAL
00:39:58.129 --> 00:40:02.600 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT RETALIATION CLAIM IN
00:40:00.732 --> 00:40:03.868 region:rollup2
THIS STATE. I MYSELF WAS A
00:40:02.600 --> 00:40:05.637 region:rollup2
VICTIM OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT
00:40:03.868 --> 00:40:07.372 region:rollup2
RETALIATION AND I'M HERE TO
00:40:05.637 --> 00:40:08.640 region:rollup2
STAND UP FOR MYSELF TODAY. ALONG
00:40:07.372 --> 00:40:10.041 region:rollup2
WITH ALL WORKERS WHO ARE
00:40:08.640 --> 00:40:11.476 region:rollup2
SUBJECTED TO THIS RESPONSIBLE
00:40:10.041 --> 00:40:12.910 region:rollup2
CONDUCT.
00:40:11.476 --> 00:40:14.746 region:rollup2
I WAS HIRED BY CHRYSLER ON
00:40:12.910 --> 00:40:16.848 region:rollup2
NOVEMBER TWENTY NINTH TWENTY TEN
00:40:14.746 --> 00:40:18.583 region:rollup2
AS AN OPERATIONS MANAGER. AT THE
00:40:16.848 --> 00:40:19.884 region:rollup2
LOS ANGELES PARTS DISTRIBUTION
00:40:18.583 --> 00:40:22.186 region:rollup2
CENTER LOCATED IN ONTARIO
00:40:19.884 --> 00:40:23.788 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA AND FROM TWENTY TEN
00:40:22.186 --> 00:40:25.423 region:rollup2
AND TO THE NEW ARRIVAL OF THE
00:40:23.788 --> 00:40:26.824 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR OF TWENTY TWELVE I
00:40:25.423 --> 00:40:28.359 region:rollup2
WAS NEVER DISCIPLINED OR PUT ON
00:40:26.824 --> 00:40:30.228 region:rollup2
ANY SORT OF PERFORMANCE.
00:40:28.359 --> 00:40:31.696 region:rollup2
IMPROVEMENT PLAN OR DEMOTED
00:40:30.228 --> 00:40:33.631 region:rollup2
ANYWAY.
00:40:31.696 --> 00:40:36.067 region:rollup2
THIS CHANGES THE CHANGE HOWEVER
00:40:33.631 --> 00:40:38.269 region:rollup2
IN TWENTY TWELVE WHEN CHRYSLER
00:40:36.067 --> 00:40:39.437 region:rollup2
MADE JAMES PARKER THE MANAGER OF
00:40:38.269 --> 00:40:41.706 region:rollup2
THE ONTARIO PLAN.
00:40:39.437 --> 00:40:43.675 region:rollup2
THE FOLLOWING YEAR WHERE HE HAD
00:40:41.706 --> 00:40:45.910 region:rollup2
HIRED A FRIEND TO TAKE OVER MY
00:40:43.675 --> 00:40:48.479 region:rollup2
POSITION AS OPERATIONS MANAGER.
00:40:45.910 --> 00:40:50.481 region:rollup2
AND AS A RESULT I WAS DEMOTED AS
00:40:48.479 --> 00:40:51.549 region:rollup2
A WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR. AS A
00:40:50.481 --> 00:40:52.750 region:rollup2
WAREHOUSE SUPERVISOR MY JOB WAS
00:40:51.549 --> 00:40:54.452 region:rollup2
A SUPERVISOR WORKERS WHO
00:40:52.750 --> 00:40:56.888 region:rollup2
ASSEMBLED THE PARTS INCLUDING
00:40:54.452 --> 00:40:59.223 region:rollup2
SCHEDULING PERFORMANCE REVIEWS
00:40:56.888 --> 00:41:00.425 region:rollup2
QUALITY CONTROL SHIPPING AND
00:40:59.223 --> 00:41:02.093 region:rollup2
RECEIVING PARTS.
00:41:00.425 --> 00:41:03.961 region:rollup2
ALL THE WORKERS I DIRECTED
00:41:02.093 --> 00:41:05.897 region:rollup2
SUPERVISED WERE MEN THAT THE
00:41:03.961 --> 00:41:08.533 region:rollup2
ONTARIO PLANT APPROXIMATELY
00:41:05.897 --> 00:41:10.134 region:rollup2
NINETY PERCENT WERE MALE AND TEN
00:41:08.533 --> 00:41:11.502 region:rollup2
PERCENT WERE FEMALE.
00:41:10.134 --> 00:41:13.771 region:rollup2
I WAS A SUPERVISOR THAT I WAS
00:41:11.502 --> 00:41:16.007 region:rollup2
SUBJECTED TO DEMANDS FOR DATES
00:41:13.771 --> 00:41:18.710 region:rollup2
BOTH IN PERSON AND VIA PHONE
00:41:16.007 --> 00:41:20.244 region:rollup2
PHONE CALLS AND TEXT MESSAGES.
00:41:18.710 --> 00:41:21.813 region:rollup2
NEARLY EVERY DAY I WORKED AT THE
00:41:20.244 --> 00:41:23.481 region:rollup2
ONTARIO PLANT. HOUSE
00:41:21.813 --> 00:41:25.016 region:rollup2
CONSISTENTLY CALLED A* BY
00:41:23.481 --> 00:41:26.250 region:rollup2
THE MALE EMPLOYEES I SUPERVISED
00:41:25.016 --> 00:41:28.019 region:rollup2
INFREQUENTLY IN FRONT OF MY OWN
00:41:26.250 --> 00:41:29.187 region:rollup2
SUPERVISORS.
00:41:28.019 --> 00:41:32.056 region:rollup2
I WAS ASKED FOR MY PHONE NUMBER
00:41:29.187 --> 00:41:34.992 region:rollup2
REPEATEDLY CURSED OUT BY MAIL
00:41:32.056 --> 00:41:36.861 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES WHEN I COULD EVEN.
00:41:34.992 --> 00:41:39.197 region:rollup2
THINK ABOUT EVEN GOING OUT ON
00:41:36.861 --> 00:41:41.733 region:rollup2
DATES AND I WOULD NOT PROVIDE MY
00:41:39.197 --> 00:41:43.501 region:rollup2
PHONE NUMBER TO THESE. WORKERS
00:41:41.733 --> 00:41:45.203 region:rollup2
THE MALE EMPLOYEES HUNG PICTURES
00:41:43.501 --> 00:41:46.971 region:rollup2
UP OF NAKED WOMEN IN THE
00:41:45.203 --> 00:41:49.240 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE IT REFUSE TO TAKE THEM
00:41:46.971 --> 00:41:51.008 region:rollup2
DOWN NOR DID MANAGEMENT DO THAT.
00:41:49.240 --> 00:41:52.510 region:rollup2
ONE OF THE WORKERS I SUPERVISE
00:41:51.008 --> 00:41:54.746 region:rollup2
TOLD ME THAT HE ONLY AGREED TO
00:41:52.510 --> 00:41:57.115 region:rollup2
PERFORM THE TASK ONLY IF I GAVE
00:41:54.746 --> 00:41:59.550 region:rollup2
HIM MY NUMBER.
00:41:57.115 --> 00:42:01.386 region:rollup2
ANOTHER WORKER BY ONLY LINED LA
00:41:59.550 --> 00:42:03.788 region:rollup2
UP EXCUSE ME ANOTHER WORKER BY
00:42:01.386 --> 00:42:06.024 region:rollup2
ONLY AND PHYSICALLY LUNGED AT ME
00:42:03.788 --> 00:42:06.958 region:rollup2
AND TOLD MY MANAGER.
00:42:06.024 --> 00:42:07.759 region:rollup2
I MEAN WHEN I DID I TOLD THEM
00:42:06.958 --> 00:42:09.026 region:rollup2
THAT PHONE IT THREATENING AND
00:42:07.759 --> 00:42:10.762 region:rollup2
INTIMIDATING IN THE PHYSICAL
00:42:09.026 --> 00:42:12.230 region:rollup2
THREAT OCCURRED DIRECTLY IN
00:42:10.762 --> 00:42:14.265 region:rollup2
FRONT OF MY MANAGER ARE ALSO
00:42:12.230 --> 00:42:15.833 region:rollup2
REPORTED TO MY MANAGER. THAT
00:42:14.265 --> 00:42:17.635 region:rollup2
ANOTHER WORK REPEATEDLY CALL ME
00:42:15.833 --> 00:42:18.936 region:rollup2
A** WHILE I WAS
00:42:17.635 --> 00:42:21.205 region:rollup2
SUPERVISING THEM ON THE LOADING
00:42:18.936 --> 00:42:22.740 region:rollup2
DOCK. EVEN AFTER THAT I WAS
00:42:21.205 --> 00:42:24.675 region:rollup2
REQUIRED TO WORK ALL HOURS OF
00:42:22.740 --> 00:42:26.677 region:rollup2
THE DAYS AND NIGHTS. INCLUDING
00:42:24.675 --> 00:42:27.812 region:rollup2
IN THE MIDDLE OF THE SHIFT OF
00:42:26.677 --> 00:42:30.181 region:rollup2
THE LOADING DOCK WITH MEN WHO
00:42:27.812 --> 00:42:31.416 region:rollup2
HARASSED ME WHEN I WAS THE ONLY
00:42:30.181 --> 00:42:32.683 region:rollup2
FEMALE PRESENT. WHEN I
00:42:31.416 --> 00:42:35.119 region:rollup2
COMPLAINED ABOUT THIS I WAS
00:42:32.683 --> 00:42:36.954 region:rollup2
BLAMED FOR NOT GETTING ALONG
00:42:35.119 --> 00:42:38.556 region:rollup2
WITH MY SUPPORT EMPLOYEES AND
00:42:36.954 --> 00:42:40.858 region:rollup2
SOMEHOW THEIR CONDUCT TOWARD ME
00:42:38.556 --> 00:42:42.059 region:rollup2
WAS MY FAULT. WANNA ELEVATED THE
00:42:40.858 --> 00:42:44.128 region:rollup2
COMPLACENT MY SUPERVISOR I
00:42:42.059 --> 00:42:44.762 region:rollup2
COVERED UP MY MAIL EMPLOYEE THEY
00:42:44.128 --> 00:42:47.131 region:rollup2
WERE COVERED UP BY THE MILLION
00:42:44.762 --> 00:42:48.966 region:rollup2
PLEASE OR HARASSING ME. AND
00:42:47.131 --> 00:42:50.635 region:rollup2
INSTEAD IT WAS RECOMMENDED BY MY
00:42:48.966 --> 00:42:52.570 region:rollup2
SUSPENSION DETERMINATION FROM
00:42:50.635 --> 00:42:54.172 region:rollup2
THE COMPANY. OF THE PERFORMANCE
00:42:52.570 --> 00:42:55.373 region:rollup2
ISSUE CENTERING ON THE
00:42:54.172 --> 00:42:58.342 region:rollup2
COMMUNICATION WITH SOME OF THE.
00:42:55.373 --> 00:42:59.744 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS WHO SEXUALLY
00:42:58.342 --> 00:43:00.311 region:rollup2
HARASSED ME ON A DAILY BASIS.
00:42:59.744 --> 00:43:01.746 region:rollup2
SOME OF THE THINGS ARE A FEW
00:43:00.311 --> 00:43:02.580 region:rollup2
OTHER EXAMPLES OF WHAT HAS
00:43:01.746 --> 00:43:04.315 region:rollup2
HAPPENED TO ME IS THAT.
00:43:02.580 --> 00:43:06.384 region:rollup2
.
00:43:04.315 --> 00:43:08.086 region:rollup2
AS I MENTIONED EARLIER JUST NAM
00:43:06.384 --> 00:43:09.587 region:rollup2
TAUNTING ME CALLING ME A BIT
00:43:08.086 --> 00:43:11.656 region:rollup2
SHARING INAPPROPRIATE POSTERS OF
00:43:09.587 --> 00:43:13.091 region:rollup2
NUDE WOMEN MAKING STATEMENTS
00:43:11.656 --> 00:43:14.759 region:rollup2
LIKE HEY MAN YOU KNOW.
00:43:13.091 --> 00:43:16.427 region:rollup2
SHE KNOWS WHAT IT'S LIKE
00:43:14.759 --> 00:43:18.129 region:rollup2
GETTING DOWN THERE HA HA HA HA.
00:43:16.427 --> 00:43:20.331 region:rollup2
AND ALSO DO IS PUTTING YOUR ARM
00:43:18.129 --> 00:43:21.432 region:rollup2
AROUND ME TRYING TO KISS ME PULL
00:43:20.331 --> 00:43:22.967 region:rollup2
ME IN.
00:43:21.432 --> 00:43:24.836 region:rollup2
TRYING TO CURSE ME.
00:43:22.967 --> 00:43:26.938 region:rollup2
PURPOSELY BRUSHING UP AGAINST
00:43:24.836 --> 00:43:29.340 region:rollup2
ME MAKING SEXUAL OP COMMENTS
00:43:26.938 --> 00:43:30.842 region:rollup2
ABOUT MY APPEARANCE THEY LOVE
00:43:29.340 --> 00:43:32.477 region:rollup2
THE WAY MY LOOK LIP GLOSS.
00:43:30.842 --> 00:43:34.011 region:rollup2
WHEN I WORE MY LIP GLOSS
00:43:32.477 --> 00:43:35.246 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THEY COULD IMAGINE WHAT
00:43:34.011 --> 00:43:37.148 region:rollup2
I COULD DO FOR THEM AND IT WOULD
00:43:35.246 --> 00:43:38.783 region:rollup2
BE EASY TO SLIP UP AND DOWN
00:43:37.148 --> 00:43:40.151 region:rollup2
THEIR GENITALS. HEY I THINK I
00:43:38.783 --> 00:43:42.520 region:rollup2
THINK YOU MADE YOUR POINT HERE.
00:43:40.151 --> 00:43:43.454 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE YOUR TESTIMONY.
00:43:42.520 --> 00:43:46.657 region:rollup2
AND.
00:43:43.454 --> 00:43:48.059 region:rollup2
WITH GIVING YOU EACH.
00:43:46.657 --> 00:43:49.994 region:rollup2
A LITTLE EXTRA TIME AND AND I
00:43:48.059 --> 00:43:51.162 region:rollup2
PRAY I. I KNOW WE ALL APPRECIATE
00:43:49.994 --> 00:43:52.897 region:rollup2
THE FRUSTRATION AND THE
00:43:51.162 --> 00:43:55.666 region:rollup2
HUMILIATION THAT THIS UNIX
00:43:52.897 --> 00:43:57.335 region:rollup2
UNACCEPTABLE BEHAVIOR BECAUSE.
00:43:55.666 --> 00:43:59.637 region:rollup2
SO WITH WITHOUT.
00:43:57.335 --> 00:44:02.173 region:rollup2
LET'S HAVE OF THOSE WHO ARE IN
00:43:59.637 --> 00:44:03.508 region:rollup2
SUPPORT. OF AS WELL OF THIS
00:44:02.173 --> 00:44:05.076 region:rollup2
MEASURE PLEASE SHOW STEP FOR
00:44:03.508 --> 00:44:06.511 region:rollup2
WITH YOUR NAME AND AFFILIATION
00:44:05.076 --> 00:44:08.179 region:rollup2
HERE AT THE MIKE EACH OF YOU IF
00:44:06.511 --> 00:44:10.181 region:rollup2
YOU COME FORWARD.
00:44:08.179 --> 00:44:12.250 region:rollup2
THANK YOU PAMELA LOPEZ PAMELA
00:44:10.181 --> 00:44:13.084 region:rollup2
LOPEZ WITH WORK EQUITY THANK YOU
00:44:12.250 --> 00:44:15.553 region:rollup2
BOTH FOR YOUR COURAGE WE ARE IN
00:44:13.084 --> 00:44:17.555 region:rollup2
SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
00:44:15.553 --> 00:44:19.657 region:rollup2
MANDY BENSON WITH WORK EQUITY
00:44:17.555 --> 00:44:20.291 region:rollup2
AND IN DEFENSE AND CONSULTING
00:44:19.657 --> 00:44:22.160 region:rollup2
WHERE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL THE
00:44:20.291 --> 00:44:23.294 region:rollup2
QUEUE.
00:44:22.160 --> 00:44:24.829 region:rollup2
BRITNEY MCCARTHY FROM SANTA
00:44:23.294 --> 00:44:26.464 region:rollup2
MONICA CALIFORNIA HERE WITH WORK
00:44:24.829 --> 00:44:27.198 region:rollup2
EQUITY AND SUPPORT THANK YOU FOR
00:44:26.464 --> 00:44:29.834 region:rollup2
YOUR TESTIMONY.
00:44:27.198 --> 00:44:31.169 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
00:44:29.834 --> 00:44:31.836 region:rollup2
MEANING A CASINOS WITH THE
00:44:31.169 --> 00:44:33.171 region:rollup2
COUNCIL ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC
00:44:31.836 --> 00:44:35.773 region:rollup2
RELATIONS CALIFORNIANS STRONG
00:44:33.171 --> 00:44:37.341 region:rollup2
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
00:44:35.773 --> 00:44:38.576 region:rollup2
I JENNA GARY WITH LEGALLY
00:44:37.341 --> 00:44:40.111 region:rollup2
NETWORK IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
00:44:38.576 --> 00:44:41.512 region:rollup2
YOU.
00:44:40.111 --> 00:44:42.613 region:rollup2
TECHIES TURN OVER THE CONSUMER
00:44:41.512 --> 00:44:43.948 region:rollup2
ATTORNEYS OF CALIFORNIANS PART.
00:44:42.613 --> 00:44:45.283 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
00:44:43.948 --> 00:44:47.385 region:rollup2
JESSICA STAND WITH EQUAL RIGHTS
00:44:45.283 --> 00:44:48.619 region:rollup2
ADVOCATES A SPONSOR AND STRONGER
00:44:47.385 --> 00:44:50.087 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ADVOCATES NETWORK
00:44:48.619 --> 00:44:52.056 region:rollup2
BOTH IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
00:44:50.087 --> 00:44:52.623 region:rollup2
YOU.
00:44:52.056 --> 00:44:53.691 region:rollup2
VERY GET YOUR SHOWER WITH A
00:44:52.623 --> 00:44:55.026 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS
00:44:53.691 --> 00:44:56.694 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION ALSO PROUD TO
00:44:55.026 --> 00:44:58.696 region:rollup2
COSPONSOR THIS BILL IS BIGGER A
00:44:56.694 --> 00:44:59.764 region:rollup2
MUCH.
00:44:58.696 --> 00:45:00.965 region:rollup2
BRIAN HOW WOULD THE CALIFORNIA
00:44:59.764 --> 00:45:02.633 region:rollup2
FEDERATION OF TEACHERS WE DON'T
00:45:00.965 --> 00:45:03.935 region:rollup2
HAVE A FORM POSITION ON IT BUT
00:45:02.633 --> 00:45:06.037 region:rollup2
I'LL BE RECKONING A STRONG
00:45:03.935 --> 00:45:07.171 region:rollup2
SUPPORT ON THIS. THANK YOU SIR.
00:45:06.037 --> 00:45:08.573 region:rollup2
FROM MY CAROL WITH THE WESTERN
00:45:07.171 --> 00:45:09.473 region:rollup2
CENTER ALONG POVERTY IN MARIN
00:45:08.573 --> 00:45:11.108 region:rollup2
SUPPORT ALSO.
00:45:09.473 --> 00:45:12.610 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
00:45:11.108 --> 00:45:13.611 region:rollup2
WITNESSES HAD OPPOSITION ARE
00:45:12.610 --> 00:45:15.413 region:rollup2
THERE ANY WITNESSES IN
00:45:13.611 --> 00:45:16.914 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION PARTY TO PEOPLE IF
00:45:15.413 --> 00:45:18.149 region:rollup2
YOU WOULD COME FORWARD WILL HAVE
00:45:16.914 --> 00:45:23.688 region:rollup2
TO GIVE UP TO THE SEATS IN THE
00:45:18.149 --> 00:45:25.690 region:rollup2
FRONT.
00:45:23.688 --> 00:45:26.557 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON. AFTERNOON MADAM
00:45:25.690 --> 00:45:27.558 region:rollup2
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:45:26.557 --> 00:45:28.759 region:rollup2
JENNIFER BROWN BEHALF THE
00:45:27.558 --> 00:45:29.794 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
00:45:28.759 --> 00:45:30.261 region:rollup2
AND WE ARE OPPOSED TO THE
00:45:29.794 --> 00:45:31.095 region:rollup2
MEASURE.
00:45:30.261 --> 00:45:32.396 region:rollup2
FIRST WE WANNA MAKE IT CLEAR
00:45:31.095 --> 00:45:33.564 region:rollup2
OBVIOUSLY HARASSMENT THERE'S
00:45:32.396 --> 00:45:34.799 region:rollup2
ALREADY PERSONAL LIABILITY FOR
00:45:33.564 --> 00:45:35.900 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AND SO A LOT OF THIS
00:45:34.799 --> 00:45:37.001 region:rollup2
CONDUCT THAT WAS TESTIFIED
00:45:35.900 --> 00:45:38.703 region:rollup2
THAT'S ALREADY COVERED UNDER
00:45:37.001 --> 00:45:39.570 region:rollup2
EXISTING LAW FOR HARASSMENT. BUT
00:45:38.703 --> 00:45:41.038 region:rollup2
THERE'S A DISTINCTION THE
00:45:39.570 --> 00:45:42.406 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT MADE
00:45:41.038 --> 00:45:43.941 region:rollup2
BETWEEN HARASSMENT ALLEGATION IN
00:45:42.406 --> 00:45:45.276 region:rollup2
ONE IS BECAUSE HARASSMENT IS NOT
00:45:43.941 --> 00:45:46.677 region:rollup2
NECESSARY FOR SUPERVISOR TO
00:45:45.276 --> 00:45:47.678 region:rollup2
CARRY OUT THEIR DAILY JOB RIGHT
00:45:46.677 --> 00:45:48.713 region:rollup2
THEY DON'T HAVE TO HARASS AN
00:45:47.678 --> 00:45:49.947 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEE IN ORDER TO PERFORM
00:45:48.713 --> 00:45:51.649 region:rollup2
THEIR JOBS AS A SUPERVISOR
00:45:49.947 --> 00:45:53.251 region:rollup2
WHEREAS WITH A SUPERVISOR. THEY
00:45:51.649 --> 00:45:54.418 region:rollup2
HAVE TO MAKE PERSONAL DECISIONS
00:45:53.251 --> 00:45:55.686 region:rollup2
AND PERSONNEL DECISIONS ARE WHAT
00:45:54.418 --> 00:45:56.821 region:rollup2
ARE THE BASIS FOR RETALIATION
00:45:55.686 --> 00:45:58.389 region:rollup2
COMPLAINT AND IF YOU HOLD THEM
00:45:56.821 --> 00:45:59.624 region:rollup2
PERSONALLY LIABLE FOR PERSONNEL
00:45:58.389 --> 00:46:00.491 region:rollup2
DECISIONS YOU'RE BASICALLY
00:45:59.624 --> 00:46:01.726 region:rollup2
PUTTING THEM IN A CONFLICT
00:46:00.491 --> 00:46:03.227 region:rollup2
POSITION. WHERE THEY'RE MAKING
00:46:01.726 --> 00:46:05.429 region:rollup2
PERSONNEL DECISIONS THAT COULD
00:46:03.227 --> 00:46:06.564 region:rollup2
IMPACT THEIR PERSONAL LIABILITY?
00:46:05.429 --> 00:46:07.798 region:rollup2
AND HAVING TO FOLLOW THE
00:46:06.564 --> 00:46:08.899 region:rollup2
DIRECTION OF THE SUPERVISORS OF
00:46:07.798 --> 00:46:10.134 region:rollup2
THAT IS THE DISTINCTION THAT THE
00:46:08.899 --> 00:46:11.636 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT MADE
00:46:10.134 --> 00:46:12.970 region:rollup2
BETWEEN HARASSMENT WHICH IS
00:46:11.636 --> 00:46:14.572 region:rollup2
UNNECESSARY FOR PERFORMANCE OF
00:46:12.970 --> 00:46:15.740 region:rollup2
THE JOB VERSUS. A PERSONNEL
00:46:14.572 --> 00:46:16.941 region:rollup2
DECISIONS THAT ARE THE BASIS FOR
00:46:15.740 --> 00:46:18.509 region:rollup2
THE RETALIATION COMPLAINT THAT
00:46:16.941 --> 00:46:19.910 region:rollup2
ARE NECESSARY FOR THE JOBI WANT
00:46:18.509 --> 00:46:21.646 region:rollup2
TO TALK ABOUT THAT OF PERSONAL
00:46:19.910 --> 00:46:22.913 region:rollup2
LIABILITY FOR A MOMENT IF I MAY.
00:46:21.646 --> 00:46:24.415 region:rollup2
THE WHOLE IDEA THERE IS PERSONAL
00:46:22.913 --> 00:46:25.983 region:rollup2
LIABILITY AND THIS BILL IS KIND
00:46:24.415 --> 00:46:27.151 region:rollup2
OF A FALSE THREAT. BECAUSE UNDER
00:46:25.983 --> 00:46:29.520 region:rollup2
LABOR CODE TWENTY EIGHT OH TWO
00:46:27.151 --> 00:46:29.520 region:rollup2
OF THAT OF OUR LABOR CODE
00:46:29.587 --> 00:46:33.224 region:rollup2
SHALL INDEMNIFY AND DEFEND ANY
00:46:31.389 --> 00:46:35.960 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEE WHO SUFFERS A LOSS AS A
00:46:33.224 --> 00:46:36.961 region:rollup2
RESULT OF THEIR WORK. AND THAT.
00:46:35.960 --> 00:46:38.329 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS OF THE BILL I
00:46:36.961 --> 00:46:39.897 region:rollup2
NOTICED IN THE ANALYSIS CITED
00:46:38.329 --> 00:46:41.032 region:rollup2
THE JACOBUS DECISION IF IT CORPS
00:46:39.897 --> 00:46:42.333 region:rollup2
ARE THE COMMITTEE WILL INDULGE
00:46:41.032 --> 00:46:44.001 region:rollup2
ME FOR JUST A MINUTE I WANT TO
00:46:42.333 --> 00:46:45.236 region:rollup2
TALK ABOUT THOSE FACTS. THERE
00:46:44.001 --> 00:46:47.038 region:rollup2
WAS THIS A CHIEF FINANCIAL
00:46:45.236 --> 00:46:48.839 region:rollup2
OFFICER IN THAT CASE WHO SENT.
00:46:47.038 --> 00:46:51.409 region:rollup2
SEXUAL PICTURES OF SEXUAL
00:46:48.839 --> 00:46:53.277 region:rollup2
INNUENDOS EXPLICIT YET EMAIL AND
00:46:51.409 --> 00:46:55.379 region:rollup2
TEXT MESSAGES TO A COLLEAGUE AN
00:46:53.277 --> 00:46:56.414 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEE IN THE WORKPLACE ON THE
00:46:55.379 --> 00:46:57.782 region:rollup2
TALK ABOUT GOING TO STRIP CLUBS
00:46:56.414 --> 00:46:58.282 region:rollup2
TOGETHER THEY WOULD TALK ABOUT
00:46:57.782 --> 00:46:59.483 region:rollup2
THEIR SEXUAL ENCOUNTERS
00:46:58.282 --> 00:47:00.418 region:rollup2
TOGETHER.
00:46:59.483 --> 00:47:02.953 region:rollup2
THEY WERE TALK ABOUT.
00:47:00.418 --> 00:47:06.957 region:rollup2
DIFFERENCE ACTUAL CONTEXTUAL A.
00:47:02.953 --> 00:47:07.825 region:rollup2
IT MESSAGES INKATHA CONTEXT
00:47:06.957 --> 00:47:08.325 region:rollup2
RATE.
00:47:07.825 --> 00:47:09.527 region:rollup2
HE GETS SUED FOR SEXUAL
00:47:08.325 --> 00:47:10.594 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT EMPLOYER SAYS THERE
00:47:09.527 --> 00:47:11.762 region:rollup2
IS NO WAY I AM AND HAD BEEN DONE
00:47:10.594 --> 00:47:13.264 region:rollup2
DEFENDINGYOU IN THIS CASE AND
00:47:11.762 --> 00:47:14.832 region:rollup2
I'M NOT PAYING FOR IT BECAUSE
00:47:13.264 --> 00:47:16.100 region:rollup2
YOU CONDUCTED SEXUAL HARASSMENT.
00:47:14.832 --> 00:47:17.868 region:rollup2
THE COURTS SAID I KNOW YOU HAVE
00:47:16.100 --> 00:47:19.003 region:rollup2
AN OBLIGATION YOU AVE TO DEFEND
00:47:17.868 --> 00:47:20.104 region:rollup2
THEM EMPLOYER YOU HAVE TO PAY
00:47:19.003 --> 00:47:21.238 region:rollup2
FOR THE LIVES OF ALL THOSE
00:47:20.104 --> 00:47:22.807 region:rollup2
EXPENSES EMPLOYERS BECAUSE
00:47:21.238 --> 00:47:24.008 region:rollup2
SEXUAL BANTER IT'S A PART OF THE
00:47:22.807 --> 00:47:25.643 region:rollup2
EXPECTED ON PART OF THE
00:47:24.008 --> 00:47:27.211 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE. AND AS AN EMPLOYER
00:47:25.643 --> 00:47:27.745 region:rollup2
YOU SHOULD EXPECT TO KNOW THAT
00:47:27.211 --> 00:47:28.946 region:rollup2
THAT COULD HAPPEN IN YOUR
00:47:27.745 --> 00:47:30.748 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE AND YOU HAVEA DUTY TO
00:47:28.946 --> 00:47:31.782 region:rollup2
DEFEND SO HERE WE HAVE PERSONNEL
00:47:30.748 --> 00:47:33.884 region:rollup2
DECISIONS THAT IS DEFINITELY
00:47:31.782 --> 00:47:34.819 region:rollup2
GOING TO BE IF IF SEXUAL BANTER
00:47:33.884 --> 00:47:36.253 region:rollup2
IS AN EXPECTED PART OF THE
00:47:34.819 --> 00:47:37.221 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE. PERSONAL DECISIONS
00:47:36.253 --> 00:47:38.222 region:rollup2
ARE GOING TO BE A PART OF THE
00:47:37.221 --> 00:47:39.557 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE AND SO WHERE IS THAT
00:47:38.222 --> 00:47:40.925 region:rollup2
LIABILITY GONNA FALL IT'S GOING
00:47:39.557 --> 00:47:42.660 region:rollup2
TO FALL ON THE EMPLOYERS TO ALL
00:47:40.925 --> 00:47:43.694 region:rollup2
THIS BILL DOES. IS CREATE TWO
00:47:42.660 --> 00:47:44.829 region:rollup2
SHOTS OF THE EMPLOYER FOR
00:47:43.694 --> 00:47:46.464 region:rollup2
LIABILITY BECAUSE WORD ON THE
00:47:44.829 --> 00:47:47.398 region:rollup2
HOOK FOR RETALIATION COMPLAINT
00:47:46.464 --> 00:47:48.733 region:rollup2
ALREADY RIGHT THE EMPLOYERS
00:47:47.398 --> 00:47:50.134 region:rollup2
ALWAYS UNNAMED PARTY IN THESE
00:47:48.733 --> 00:47:51.969 region:rollup2
CASES. AND IF YOU MEAN THE
00:47:50.134 --> 00:47:52.737 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR AS WELL NOW THE
00:47:51.969 --> 00:47:54.271 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER HAS TO DEFEND
00:47:52.737 --> 00:47:56.707 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES PETE FOR THE ATTORNEY
00:47:54.271 --> 00:47:58.008 region:rollup2
OF THE OF THE INDIVIDUAL AND FOR
00:47:56.707 --> 00:47:58.943 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW MOSTLY SKATES TO SETTLE
00:47:58.008 --> 00:47:59.810 region:rollup2
THEY'RE GONNA HAVE TO PAY FOR
00:47:58.943 --> 00:48:01.078 region:rollup2
THE SETTLEMENT BECAUSE THERE IS
00:47:59.810 --> 00:48:02.513 region:rollup2
NO DETERMINATION THAT IT WAS
00:48:01.078 --> 00:48:04.148 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL CONDUCT OUTSIDE. OF THE
00:48:02.513 --> 00:48:05.449 region:rollup2
SCOPE OF THE WORKPLACE AND EVEN
00:48:04.148 --> 00:48:07.251 region:rollup2
IF IT DID GET TO A JUDGMENT I
00:48:05.449 --> 00:48:08.486 region:rollup2
SUSPECT SIMILAR TO THE JACOBUS
00:48:07.251 --> 00:48:09.820 region:rollup2
DECISION THAT THE COURT WOULD
00:48:08.486 --> 00:48:10.721 region:rollup2
SAY THIS IS WITHIN THE COURSE
00:48:09.820 --> 00:48:11.922 region:rollup2
AND SCOPE OF EMPLOYMENT AND
00:48:10.721 --> 00:48:13.657 region:rollup2
IMPLORE YOU HAVE AN OBLIGATION
00:48:11.922 --> 00:48:15.059 region:rollup2
NOT T PAY FOR THIS DEFENSE. SO
00:48:13.657 --> 00:48:16.527 region:rollup2
ALL THIS BILL IS DOING IS
00:48:15.059 --> 00:48:18.396 region:rollup2
PUTTING TO JUDGMENTS NOW ON AN
00:48:16.527 --> 00:48:19.196 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER INSTEAD OF ONE THERE IS
00:48:18.396 --> 00:48:20.898 region:rollup2
NO TRUE THREAT OF PERSONAL
00:48:19.196 --> 00:48:22.399 region:rollup2
LIABILITY THE WAY TO DO THAT IS
00:48:20.898 --> 00:48:24.034 region:rollup2
EXCLUDED FROM THE REQUIREMENT
00:48:22.399 --> 00:48:25.035 region:rollup2
THAT WE AYE REIMBURSE YOU UNDER
00:48:24.034 --> 00:48:25.736 region:rollup2
LABOR CODE SECTION TWENTY EIGHT
00:48:25.035 --> 00:48:27.338 region:rollup2
OR TWO. AND THEN THERE'S
00:48:25.736 --> 00:48:28.873 region:rollup2
PERSONAL LIABILITY FOR THOSE
00:48:27.338 --> 00:48:30.808 region:rollup2
REASONS FOR POST THANK YOU VERY
00:48:28.873 --> 00:48:32.576 region:rollup2
MUCH NEXT WITNESS PLEASE GOOD
00:48:30.808 --> 00:48:33.744 region:rollup2
AFTERNOON CHAIR JACKSON MEMBERS.
00:48:32.576 --> 00:48:35.412 region:rollup2
MY NAME IS MICHAEL CALLED AND
00:48:33.744 --> 00:48:37.248 region:rollup2
FULL DISCLOSURE I REPRESENT OF
00:48:35.412 --> 00:48:38.482 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER IN THE JONES VERSUS
00:48:37.248 --> 00:48:40.084 region:rollup2
LODGED TWENTY PINTS CASE.
00:48:38.482 --> 00:48:41.585 region:rollup2
HOWEVER I'M APPEARING BEFORE YOU
00:48:40.084 --> 00:48:42.887 region:rollup2
TODAY IN MY CAPACITY AS THE
00:48:41.585 --> 00:48:45.156 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT A FAIR SHOT FOR CAL
00:48:42.887 --> 00:48:46.524 region:rollup2
SHERMAN. AND I DO SO BECAUSE OUR
00:48:45.156 --> 00:48:48.359 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND HUMAN
00:48:46.524 --> 00:48:50.327 region:rollup2
RESOURCE PROFESSIONALS MEMBERS
00:48:48.359 --> 00:48:51.762 region:rollup2
IN CALIFORNIA WILL BE AMONG THE
00:48:50.327 --> 00:48:53.864 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OR INDIVIDUALS MOST
00:48:51.762 --> 00:48:56.967 region:rollup2
IMPACTED AND MORE SPECIFICALLY
00:48:53.864 --> 00:48:57.368 region:rollup2
NEGATIVELY IMPACTED BY THE
00:48:56.967 --> 00:48:57.902 region:rollup2
PROPOSED CHANGE.
00:48:57.368 --> 00:48:59.036 region:rollup2
THE QUESTION TODAY IS NOT
00:48:57.902 --> 00:49:00.905 region:rollup2
WHETHER THE LEGISLATURE SHOULD
00:48:59.036 --> 00:49:02.039 region:rollup2
OUT WHILE RETALIATION.
00:49:00.905 --> 00:49:03.774 region:rollup2
THE WHOLE ORDEAL PROHIBITS
00:49:02.039 --> 00:49:05.042 region:rollup2
RETALIATION.
00:49:03.774 --> 00:49:06.277 region:rollup2
THE QUESTION IS ALSO NOT WHETHER
00:49:05.042 --> 00:49:08.145 region:rollup2
ADDING A NEW LAW WILL CURVE BALL
00:49:06.277 --> 00:49:09.346 region:rollup2
RETALIATION.
00:49:08.145 --> 00:49:10.881 region:rollup2
FEE HER HAS LONG PROHIBITED
00:49:09.346 --> 00:49:12.516 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT
00:49:10.881 --> 00:49:13.684 region:rollup2
AND RETALIATION INCLUDING WITH
00:49:12.516 --> 00:49:15.586 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL LIABILITY FOR
00:49:13.684 --> 00:49:16.754 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT BUT THIS DID NOT
00:49:15.586 --> 00:49:17.755 region:rollup2
DETER HARVEY WEINSTEIN AND
00:49:16.754 --> 00:49:19.423 region:rollup2
OTHERS FROM ENGAGING IN
00:49:17.755 --> 00:49:20.958 region:rollup2
HARASSING BEHAVIOR.
00:49:19.423 --> 00:49:22.526 region:rollup2
QUESTION IS REALLY WHETHER THIS
00:49:20.958 --> 00:49:24.261 region:rollup2
LEGISLATURE WILL FUNDAMENTALLY
00:49:22.526 --> 00:49:25.996 region:rollup2
FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE THE FEE HER
00:49:24.261 --> 00:49:27.465 region:rollup2
AND FOIST A MODERN DAY SORT OF
00:49:25.996 --> 00:49:28.699 region:rollup2
DAMOCLES OVER EVERY HUMAN
00:49:27.465 --> 00:49:30.201 region:rollup2
RESOURCE PROFESSIONALS WITHIN
00:49:28.699 --> 00:49:31.569 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA.
00:49:30.201 --> 00:49:33.003 region:rollup2
THIS LEGISLATURE HAS
00:49:31.569 --> 00:49:34.572 region:rollup2
HISTORICALLY BEEN VERY CAUTIOUS
00:49:33.003 --> 00:49:36.540 region:rollup2
IN ALLOWING INDIVIDUAL LIABILITY
00:49:34.572 --> 00:49:37.875 region:rollup2
UNDER THE FIA. INDEED DESPITE
00:49:36.540 --> 00:49:39.443 region:rollup2
DECADES OF AMENDMENTS TO
00:49:37.875 --> 00:49:41.612 region:rollup2
NUMEROUS FEE HAVE PROVISIONS THE
00:49:39.443 --> 00:49:43.647 region:rollup2
LEGISLATURE HAS ONLY AUTHORIZED
00:49:41.612 --> 00:49:44.949 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL LIABILITY FOR
00:49:43.647 --> 00:49:46.617 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT.
00:49:44.949 --> 00:49:48.219 region:rollup2
IT'S LEGISLATIVE RESTRAINT FLOWS
00:49:46.617 --> 00:49:49.386 region:rollup2
FROM THE FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCE
00:49:48.219 --> 00:49:51.522 region:rollup2
BETWEEN THE TWO TYPES OF
00:49:49.386 --> 00:49:53.257 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR INVOLVED. HARASSMENT
00:49:51.522 --> 00:49:55.492 region:rollup2
INVOLVES PERSONALLY MOTIVATED
00:49:53.257 --> 00:49:57.495 region:rollup2
MISCONDUCT UNNECESSARY TO JOB
00:49:55.492 --> 00:49:59.196 region:rollup2
DUTIES AND THEREFORE SOMETHING
00:49:57.495 --> 00:50:01.232 region:rollup2
THE SUPERVISOR CAN REFRAIN FROM.
00:49:59.196 --> 00:50:02.900 region:rollup2
IN CONTRAST DISCRIMINATION AND
00:50:01.232 --> 00:50:03.901 region:rollup2
RETALIATION INVOLVED PERSONALLY
00:50:02.900 --> 00:50:05.369 region:rollup2
RELATE PERSONAL RELATED
00:50:03.901 --> 00:50:06.470 region:rollup2
DECISIONS.
00:50:05.369 --> 00:50:08.205 region:rollup2
ALLEGEDLY MOTIVATED BY AN
00:50:06.470 --> 00:50:09.506 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL INTENT.
00:50:08.205 --> 00:50:11.275 region:rollup2
UNLIKE PERSONALLY MOTIVATED
00:50:09.506 --> 00:50:12.743 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT THE HUMAN RESOURCE
00:50:11.275 --> 00:50:14.345 region:rollup2
PROFESSIONALS CAN NOT AVOID
00:50:12.743 --> 00:50:16.113 region:rollup2
MAKING THESE PERSONNEL RELATED
00:50:14.345 --> 00:50:17.381 region:rollup2
DECISIONS. AT LEAST NOT IF THEY
00:50:16.113 --> 00:50:19.250 region:rollup2
WANT TO CONTINUE WORKING AS
00:50:17.381 --> 00:50:20.584 region:rollup2
HUMAN RESOURCE PROFESSIONALS.
00:50:19.250 --> 00:50:22.052 region:rollup2
COUNT SHERMAN SHERM ONE OUR
00:50:20.584 --> 00:50:23.120 region:rollup2
MEMBERS TO REPORT UNLAWFUL
00:50:22.052 --> 00:50:24.955 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT SO WE CAN ADDRESS IT
00:50:23.120 --> 00:50:26.590 region:rollup2
INCLUDING.
00:50:24.955 --> 00:50:28.959 region:rollup2
DISCIPLINING HARASSERS BUT OUR
00:50:26.590 --> 00:50:30.427 region:rollup2
HR DUTIES ALSO INCLUDE MAKING
00:50:28.959 --> 00:50:32.329 region:rollup2
PERSONAL MANAGEMENT DECISIONS
00:50:30.427 --> 00:50:34.231 region:rollup2
SOMETIMES INVOLVING INDIVIDUALS
00:50:32.329 --> 00:50:35.699 region:rollup2
WHO HAD PREVIOUSLY COMPLAINED.
00:50:34.231 --> 00:50:37.234 region:rollup2
OUR MEMBERS WILL NOT RETALIATE
00:50:35.699 --> 00:50:39.103 region:rollup2
BUT THEY MUST BE ALLOWED TO MAKE
00:50:37.234 --> 00:50:40.571 region:rollup2
THE BEST PERSONAL DECISIONS NOT
00:50:39.103 --> 00:50:41.805 region:rollup2
SIMPLY THE PERSONAL DECISION
00:50:40.571 --> 00:50:43.374 region:rollup2
LEAST LIKELY TO PROMPT
00:50:41.805 --> 00:50:44.508 region:rollup2
RETALIATION CLAIM.
00:50:43.374 --> 00:50:45.910 region:rollup2
AND SEVERAL MINUTES THE
00:50:44.508 --> 00:50:47.411 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE WILL CONSIDER SP
00:50:45.910 --> 00:50:49.613 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN HUNDRED TO AMEND FEE
00:50:47.411 --> 00:50:51.181 region:rollup2
HAD TO LIMIT. EMPLOYEES FOR
00:50:49.613 --> 00:50:52.816 region:rollup2
POTENTIAL SPOT EXPOSURE FOR
00:50:51.181 --> 00:50:54.318 region:rollup2
COSTS. TO AVOID DISSUADING
00:50:52.816 --> 00:50:56.287 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES FROM BRINGING THEIR
00:50:54.318 --> 00:50:57.821 region:rollup2
CHOICE CLAIMS THAT ONE THING BUT
00:50:56.287 --> 00:50:58.856 region:rollup2
IF YOU SUMA POTENTIAL FIVE
00:50:57.821 --> 00:51:00.524 region:rollup2
THOUSAND ARE COSTS WOULD MIGHT
00:50:58.856 --> 00:51:01.959 region:rollup2
TO SWEDEN EMPLOYEE FROM BRING A
00:51:00.524 --> 00:51:03.460 region:rollup2
VIABLE CLAIM WHY WOULD YOU
00:51:01.959 --> 00:51:05.195 region:rollup2
ASSUME THAT POTENTIAL SEVEN
00:51:03.460 --> 00:51:07.264 region:rollup2
FIGURE FEE HAVE EXPOSURE OR
00:51:05.195 --> 00:51:08.732 region:rollup2
LEAST TWO YEARS OF LITIGATION.
00:51:07.264 --> 00:51:10.100 region:rollup2
AND SIX YEAR SIX FIGURES WORTH
00:51:08.732 --> 00:51:11.602 region:rollup2
OF ATTORNEYS FEES WOULD NOT
00:51:10.100 --> 00:51:12.903 region:rollup2
DISSUADE THE HR PROFESSIONAL
00:51:11.602 --> 00:51:14.905 region:rollup2
FROM MAKING TOUGH AND PERSONAL
00:51:12.903 --> 00:51:16.240 region:rollup2
DECISIONS. IN CONCLUSION CAO
00:51:14.905 --> 00:51:18.008 region:rollup2
SHERMAN'S COMMITTED TO
00:51:16.240 --> 00:51:19.777 region:rollup2
PREVENTING UNLAWFUL RETALIATION
00:51:18.008 --> 00:51:21.412 region:rollup2
AND WORKING WITH EMPLOYERS THIS
00:51:19.777 --> 00:51:23.847 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE AND THIS LEGISLATURE
00:51:21.412 --> 00:51:25.115 region:rollup2
TO PREVENT IT BUT CAO SUREPOS SP
00:51:23.847 --> 00:51:26.750 region:rollup2
TEN THIRTY EIGHT BUT BECAUSE IT
00:51:25.115 --> 00:51:29.053 region:rollup2
WOULD KILL EFFECTIVE WORKPLACE
00:51:26.750 --> 00:51:30.187 region:rollup2
MANAGEMENT. I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER
00:51:29.053 --> 00:51:31.956 region:rollup2
ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
00:51:30.187 --> 00:51:33.624 region:rollup2
THE DECISION IN JONES VERSUS
00:51:31.956 --> 00:51:34.892 region:rollup2
LOGIC TORREY PINES THE DESCENT
00:51:33.624 --> 00:51:36.260 region:rollup2
TALKS ABOUT THIS TORTURED
00:51:34.892 --> 00:51:38.028 region:rollup2
REASONING OF THE DEFINITION OF A
00:51:36.260 --> 00:51:39.897 region:rollup2
PERSON.
00:51:38.028 --> 00:51:40.864 region:rollup2
AND AS WE READ THE STAFF REPORT
00:51:39.897 --> 00:51:43.367 region:rollup2
IT SEEMS TORTURED.
00:51:40.864 --> 00:51:44.134 region:rollup2
TO ME.
00:51:43.367 --> 00:51:45.536 region:rollup2
HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO CSUS AND
00:51:44.134 --> 00:51:47.638 region:rollup2
THE
00:51:45.536 --> 00:51:50.307 region:rollup2
THIS DISSENTED LEASE CRISIS OUT
00:51:47.638 --> 00:51:51.575 region:rollup2
FOR THE STATE LEGISLATURE TO
00:51:50.307 --> 00:51:54.445 region:rollup2
BRING SOME CLARITY OF WHAT A
00:51:51.575 --> 00:51:56.146 region:rollup2
PERSON AS WHY WOULD WE NOT WANT
00:51:54.445 --> 00:51:57.615 region:rollup2
TO DO THAT? WHAT YOU EAT?
00:51:56.146 --> 00:51:58.716 region:rollup2
WITHOUT INTO INTO THE WEEDS YOU
00:51:57.615 --> 00:52:00.217 region:rollup2
WOULD NOT BE CLARIFYING LONG
00:51:58.716 --> 00:52:01.485 region:rollup2
YOU'D BE CHANGING THE LOGS THE
00:52:00.217 --> 00:52:02.386 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT HAS
00:52:01.485 --> 00:52:03.787 region:rollup2
ALREADY RULED ON BUT HAVING SAID
00:52:02.386 --> 00:52:05.456 region:rollup2
THAT. I READ THE ENTIRE
00:52:03.787 --> 00:52:06.957 region:rollup2
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY THAT ADD TO
00:52:05.456 --> 00:52:08.392 region:rollup2
THOSE WORDS PERSON TO THE
00:52:06.957 --> 00:52:09.893 region:rollup2
RETALIATION PROVISION THERE WAS
00:52:08.392 --> 00:52:13.063 region:rollup2
NOT ONE WORD OF LEGISLATIVE
00:52:09.893 --> 00:52:15.699 region:rollup2
INTENT. EXPRESSING ANY DESIRE TO
00:52:13.063 --> 00:52:16.967 region:rollup2
IMPOSE INDIVIDUAL LIABILITY. IF
00:52:15.699 --> 00:52:20.037 region:rollup2
YOU KILL BILL WHEN I WAS HERE
00:52:16.967 --> 00:52:21.905 region:rollup2
AND THAT WAS GOOD TIGHTENING
00:52:20.037 --> 00:52:23.707 region:rollup2
CATCH UP WHICH WOULD GO AHEAD.
00:52:21.905 --> 00:52:24.341 region:rollup2
AT NO THIS DOES SHE LOOK Q. BILL
00:52:23.707 --> 00:52:25.642 region:rollup2
WAS THE ONE THAT ADDED I'M HER
00:52:24.341 --> 00:52:28.012 region:rollup2
PERSONAL LIABILITY FOR
00:52:25.642 --> 00:52:30.080 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AFTER THE CARE SOLACE
00:52:28.012 --> 00:52:31.949 region:rollup2
DECISION. THE WORDS THAT ADDED
00:52:30.080 --> 00:52:33.450 region:rollup2
THE WORD IN PERSON IN NINETEEN
00:52:31.949 --> 00:52:34.985 region:rollup2
EIGHTY SEVEN TO RETALIATION
00:52:33.450 --> 00:52:36.487 region:rollup2
STATUTE THAT WAS NO DISCUSSION.
00:52:34.985 --> 00:52:38.522 region:rollup2
ABOUT IMPOSING INDIVIDUAL
00:52:36.487 --> 00:52:42.092 region:rollup2
LIABILITY IN THIS LEGISLATURE
00:52:38.522 --> 00:52:43.994 region:rollup2
KNOWS HOW TO DO ONE INTENDS TO
00:52:42.092 --> 00:52:44.728 region:rollup2
IMPOSE INDIVIDUALIZED BUILDING.
00:52:43.994 --> 00:52:45.896 region:rollup2
RIGHT BUT THAT'S AND I'M I'M
00:52:44.728 --> 00:52:47.965 region:rollup2
LOOKING AT PAGE EIGHT WHEN THEY
00:52:45.896 --> 00:52:50.467 region:rollup2
SAY THAT THE COURT LEFT OPEN THE
00:52:47.965 --> 00:52:51.068 region:rollup2
ISSUE OF FIRE IF YOU FIND THAT
00:52:50.467 --> 00:52:52.836 region:rollup2
THERE'S HARASSMENT THEY'RE NOT
00:52:51.068 --> 00:52:54.938 region:rollup2
GOOD IT'S NOT PRESENTED TO AT
00:52:52.836 --> 00:52:57.508 region:rollup2
LEAST THE. FACTORY PINES THE
00:52:54.938 --> 00:52:58.842 region:rollup2
LOGIC TORREY PINES ACCORD SAID
00:52:57.508 --> 00:52:59.743 region:rollup2
THAT THERE'S THEY OFFER NO
00:52:58.842 --> 00:53:01.178 region:rollup2
OPINION AS TO WHETHER AN
00:52:59.743 --> 00:53:03.280 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL IS PERSONALLY LIABLE
00:53:01.178 --> 00:53:04.481 region:rollup2
ON HARASSMENT MIGHT ALSO BE
00:53:03.280 --> 00:53:05.849 region:rollup2
PERCENT LEVEL ON RETALIATION
00:53:04.481 --> 00:53:09.887 region:rollup2
SECOND IT SEEMS LIKE THAT'S AN
00:53:05.849 --> 00:53:10.921 region:rollup2
INVITATION. TO THE SET THE LIKE
00:53:09.887 --> 00:53:12.189 region:rollup2
THE LEGISLATURE'S TO.
00:53:10.921 --> 00:53:13.257 region:rollup2
PROVIDE SOME CLARITY HERE WILL
00:53:12.189 --> 00:53:14.324 region:rollup2
DO THE LEGISLATURE ALWAYS HAS
00:53:13.257 --> 00:53:15.993 region:rollup2
THE ABILITY TO CHANGE THE LAW
00:53:14.324 --> 00:53:17.094 region:rollup2
WHO WANTS AND THAT'S WHAT YOU
00:53:15.993 --> 00:53:19.329 region:rollup2
WOULD BE DOING HERE WE WOULD
00:53:17.094 --> 00:53:20.364 region:rollup2
SUSPEND SUGGEST THAT. CHANGING
00:53:19.329 --> 00:53:21.832 region:rollup2
THE LAW IN THIS RESPECT WOULD
00:53:20.364 --> 00:53:23.534 region:rollup2
REFLECT BAD PUBLIC POLICY WE
00:53:21.832 --> 00:53:24.802 region:rollup2
WOULD URGE YOU NOT TO DO SO FOR
00:53:23.534 --> 00:53:26.437 region:rollup2
THE REASONS WE DISCUSS HERE
00:53:24.802 --> 00:53:27.838 region:rollup2
TODAY BUT THE JONES CASE WAS. IF
00:53:26.437 --> 00:53:30.140 region:rollup2
YOU READ THE ENTIRE JUNKIES AND
00:53:27.838 --> 00:53:30.774 region:rollup2
YOU MAY WELL HAVE IT IS VERY
00:53:30.140 --> 00:53:32.643 region:rollup2
CLEAR IN TERMS OF WHAT THEY WERE
00:53:30.774 --> 00:53:34.144 region:rollup2
HOLDING.
00:53:32.643 --> 00:53:35.145 region:rollup2
LIMIT KICK* QUESTIONS TURN
00:53:34.144 --> 00:53:37.381 region:rollup2
CENTER HURT TO HEAR SOME ON THE
00:53:35.145 --> 00:53:39.316 region:rollup2
SLEUTHING. LOOK THE EASE CASES
00:53:37.381 --> 00:53:41.018 region:rollup2
ARE NOT ABOUT WHAT THE ULTIMATE
00:53:39.316 --> 00:53:42.953 region:rollup2
LIABILITY IS MY QUESTION IS NO
00:53:41.018 --> 00:53:44.154 region:rollup2
INSURANCE COMPANY OR EMPLOYER IS
00:53:42.953 --> 00:53:45.622 region:rollup2
GOING TO PAY THE LEGAL FEES WHEN
00:53:44.154 --> 00:53:47.257 region:rollup2
THERE'S AN INDIVIDUAL PARTY.
00:53:45.622 --> 00:53:49.226 region:rollup2
NAME AND SO THAT THE INDIVIDUAL
00:53:47.257 --> 00:53:50.961 region:rollup2
PARTY'S GOING TO HAVE TO PAY FOR
00:53:49.226 --> 00:53:51.528 region:rollup2
THEIR OWN LAWYER AND MAYBE THEN
00:53:50.961 --> 00:53:52.763 region:rollup2
LITIGATE I KNOW WHAT I KNOW
00:53:51.528 --> 00:53:54.565 region:rollup2
WHAT.
00:53:52.763 --> 00:53:56.800 region:rollup2
TWENTY THOUGH TO SAYS I KNOW
00:53:54.565 --> 00:53:58.302 region:rollup2
TWENTY TO TO SAYS BUT WHEN THE
00:53:56.800 --> 00:53:59.903 region:rollup2
LAW SPECIFICALLY SAYS IT'S
00:53:58.302 --> 00:54:00.971 region:rollup2
RELIABLE PUSH TO THINGS WHAT HE
00:53:59.903 --> 00:54:01.505 region:rollup2
UGHT TO BELIABLE FOR PEOPLE
00:54:00.971 --> 00:54:02.973 region:rollup2
BRING ALL KINDS OF ACTIONS
00:54:01.505 --> 00:54:06.877 region:rollup2
AND-NOT SAYING THE RIGHT OR THE
00:54:02.973 --> 00:54:08.612 region:rollup2
WRONG. BUT OFTEN THE THING THAT
00:54:06.877 --> 00:54:09.213 region:rollup2
BREAKS YOUR LEGAL FEES.
00:54:08.612 --> 00:54:10.247 region:rollup2
BUT JUST BREAK YOU AND IF THE
00:54:09.213 --> 00:54:11.215 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL CAN'T AFFORD TO SPEND
00:54:10.247 --> 00:54:12.816 region:rollup2
ALL THE MONEY TO TRY CASE WHICH
00:54:11.215 --> 00:54:14.384 region:rollup2
TO TELL GET TO THE TRUTH. THEIR
00:54:12.816 --> 00:54:14.852 region:rollup2
BROKEN BEFORE IT GETS THERE
00:54:14.384 --> 00:54:16.286 region:rollup2
BEFORE YOU CAN GET TO
00:54:14.852 --> 00:54:17.521 region:rollup2
DETERMINATION SO I'LL TRY TO
00:54:16.286 --> 00:54:18.922 region:rollup2
UNDERSTAND WHAT THAT MEANS IN
00:54:17.521 --> 00:54:20.057 region:rollup2
THE PRACTICAL WORLD. YEAH IN THE
00:54:18.922 --> 00:54:21.158 region:rollup2
PRACTICAL WORLD IF YOU LOOK AT
00:54:20.057 --> 00:54:21.925 region:rollup2
LABOR CODE TWENTY YOU GO TO IN
00:54:21.158 --> 00:54:23.260 region:rollup2
TALKS ABOUT NECESSARY
00:54:21.925 --> 00:54:24.995 region:rollup2
EXPENDITURES IT SPECIFICALLY
00:54:23.260 --> 00:54:26.797 region:rollup2
CALLS OUT ATTORNEY'S FEES TO
00:54:24.995 --> 00:54:28.132 region:rollup2
DEFEND THE INDIVIDUAL AS
00:54:26.797 --> 00:54:29.700 region:rollup2
UNNECESSARY EXPENDITURE THATTHE
00:54:28.132 --> 00:54:31.001 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER HAS AN OBLIGATION TO
00:54:29.700 --> 00:54:32.703 region:rollup2
PAY FOR DISTINCTION IN THESE
00:54:31.001 --> 00:54:34.338 region:rollup2
CASES IS TO WHEN SOMEBODY IS.
00:54:32.703 --> 00:54:35.072 region:rollup2
NAMED YOU ALWAYS NAME EVERYBODY
00:54:34.338 --> 00:54:36.473 region:rollup2
BECAUSE YOU WANT YOUR STICTION
00:54:35.072 --> 00:54:38.242 region:rollup2
OVER THEM IF THE LAW
00:54:36.473 --> 00:54:39.743 region:rollup2
SPECIFICALLY AMPLE IMPART HOSES
00:54:38.242 --> 00:54:40.811 region:rollup2
LIABILITY THE UP TO GET A
00:54:39.743 --> 00:54:42.212 region:rollup2
SEPARATE LAWYER THAT'S ON TRYING
00:54:40.811 --> 00:54:42.880 region:rollup2
TO GET THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS IN
00:54:42.212 --> 00:54:44.214 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT CASES WHERE THE
00:54:42.880 --> 00:54:45.482 region:rollup2
SUPERVISORS ARE INDIVIDUALLY
00:54:44.214 --> 00:54:46.316 region:rollup2
PERSONALLY LIABLE THE EMPLOYER
00:54:45.482 --> 00:54:46.950 region:rollup2
WILL END UP. PAYING FOR TWO
00:54:46.316 --> 00:54:52.189 region:rollup2
ATTORNEYS THE INDIVIDUALS NAMED
00:54:46.950 --> 00:54:54.324 region:rollup2
AND WHAT
00:54:52.189 --> 00:54:55.092 region:rollup2
HAPPENS IS THE EMPLOYER PAYS FOR
00:54:54.324 --> 00:54:56.126 region:rollup2
BOTH AND THEN THERE'S A
00:54:55.092 --> 00:54:57.227 region:rollup2
SETTLEMENT AGAINST BOTH AND THE
00:54:56.126 --> 00:54:58.796 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER PAYS FOR BOTH
00:54:57.227 --> 00:55:00.330 region:rollup2
SETTLEMENTS SO THERE IS NO
00:54:58.796 --> 00:55:02.199 region:rollup2
ACTUAL PERSONAL LIABILITY FOR
00:55:00.330 --> 00:55:06.103 region:rollup2
THESE INDIVIDUAL SUPERVISORS
00:55:02.199 --> 00:55:07.771 region:rollup2
BECAUSE OF TWENTY EIGHT OH TO.
00:55:06.103 --> 00:55:10.107 region:rollup2
LOOKING MISTER YET MISTER CHAIR
00:55:07.771 --> 00:55:13.343 region:rollup2
CAN WE RESPOND.
00:55:10.107 --> 00:55:15.746 region:rollup2
SURE THANK YOU THINK HIS SHARE
00:55:13.343 --> 00:55:17.447 region:rollup2
OF. THE KEY WORD IN TWENTY EIGHT
00:55:15.746 --> 00:55:18.782 region:rollup2
OF TWO IS UNNECESSARY EXPENSE AN
00:55:17.447 --> 00:55:21.151 region:rollup2
EXPENSES NECESSARY IF THE
00:55:18.782 --> 00:55:21.919 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER AUTHORIZED RETALIATION
00:55:21.151 --> 00:55:22.686 region:rollup2
AND IN THAT CASE THAT WOULD BE
00:55:21.919 --> 00:55:23.387 region:rollup2
UNNECESSARY EXPENSE IF THE
00:55:22.686 --> 00:55:24.188 region:rollup2
RETALIATION OCCURRED IN THE
00:55:23.387 --> 00:55:26.123 region:rollup2
COURSE AND SCOPE OF THE
00:55:24.188 --> 00:55:27.658 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT. THEN THE EMPLOYER
00:55:26.123 --> 00:55:28.592 region:rollup2
MUST INCUR THE NECESSARY EXPENSE
00:55:27.658 --> 00:55:31.762 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THE AUTHOR IS THE
00:55:28.592 --> 00:55:32.996 region:rollup2
CONDUCT BUT TWENTY TWO TO MAYES
00:55:31.762 --> 00:55:33.797 region:rollup2
CLEAR AND SO DOES. OUR
00:55:32.996 --> 00:55:34.998 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT CA NINETY FIVE POINT
00:55:33.797 --> 00:55:37.701 region:rollup2
ONE RELATING TO PUBLIC ENTITIES
00:55:34.998 --> 00:55:39.236 region:rollup2
IF THE RETALIATION WAS NOT IN
00:55:37.701 --> 00:55:40.404 region:rollup2
THE COURSE AND SCOPE MEANING YOU
00:55:39.236 --> 00:55:42.606 region:rollup2
HOT A ROGUE ACTOR MEANING THE
00:55:40.404 --> 00:55:44.775 region:rollup2
COMPANY DID NOT. AUTHORIZE THE
00:55:42.606 --> 00:55:45.776 region:rollup2
RETALIATION TO OCCUR THEN IN
00:55:44.775 --> 00:55:48.512 region:rollup2
THAT INSTANCE THAT IS NOT
00:55:45.776 --> 00:55:49.279 region:rollup2
UNNECESSARY EXPENDITURE AND THE.
00:55:48.512 --> 00:55:54.284 region:rollup2
AND AND THAT IS NOT SOMETHING
00:55:49.279 --> 00:55:55.485 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER WOULD HAVE TO.
00:55:54.284 --> 00:55:56.920 region:rollup2
THE ACCOUNTABLE FOR THE KEYWORD
00:55:55.485 --> 00:55:59.089 region:rollup2
IS NECESSARY AND THE KEY INQUIRY
00:55:56.920 --> 00:56:01.458 region:rollup2
IS COURSE AND SCOPE THANK YOU
00:55:59.089 --> 00:56:01.959 region:rollup2
OTHERS OPPOSED TO. S. B. TEN
00:56:01.458 --> 00:56:02.793 region:rollup2
THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE COME
00:56:01.959 --> 00:56:05.762 region:rollup2
FORWARD.
00:56:02.793 --> 00:56:09.733 region:rollup2
THIS IS OPPOSITION TO SB TEN
00:56:05.762 --> 00:56:11.034 region:rollup2
THIRTY EIGHT ZERO THANK YOU.
00:56:09.733 --> 00:56:12.903 region:rollup2
THAT WAS GOOD GOOD SEGUE I'M
00:56:11.034 --> 00:56:14.838 region:rollup2
VERY HAPPY I'M SORRY YOU HAVE TO
00:56:12.903 --> 00:56:15.339 region:rollup2
SPEAK UP IS SORRY GOOD AFTERNOON
00:56:14.838 --> 00:56:16.006 region:rollup2
KIDDING AND SOME OF THE
00:56:15.339 --> 00:56:18.609 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
00:56:16.006 --> 00:56:21.511 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION AND OPPOSITION FOR
00:56:18.609 --> 00:56:22.346 region:rollup2
THE REASONS STATED. THANK YOU.
00:56:21.511 --> 00:56:22.980 region:rollup2
BUT IF YOU DON'T GET BINS WITH
00:56:22.346 --> 00:56:24.481 region:rollup2
THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
00:56:22.980 --> 00:56:26.049 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION OPPOSITION FOR THE
00:56:24.481 --> 00:56:27.384 region:rollup2
REASONS STATED.
00:56:26.049 --> 00:56:30.020 region:rollup2
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
00:56:27.384 --> 00:56:30.888 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION.
00:56:30.020 --> 00:56:31.555 region:rollup2
WHY LET'S BRING THIS BACK TO THE
00:56:30.888 --> 00:56:34.391 region:rollup2
DYESS?
00:56:31.555 --> 00:56:36.326 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
00:56:34.391 --> 00:56:37.861 region:rollup2
GO HAD ANY ANY QUESTION TODAY
00:56:36.326 --> 00:56:39.229 region:rollup2
CENTER HERTZBERG. HIS FOLLOW UP
00:56:37.861 --> 00:56:39.897 region:rollup2
YOUR YOUR POINT.
00:56:39.229 --> 00:56:41.064 region:rollup2
I GET YOUR POINT ABOUT NESSA SIX
00:56:39.897 --> 00:56:42.899 region:rollup2
ACCURATE I'M TRYING TO GET TO.
00:56:41.064 --> 00:56:46.303 region:rollup2
WHAT WE MISSION THE LAW ALL THE
00:56:42.899 --> 00:56:48.205 region:rollup2
TIME IS THE? OVER ARCHING INTENT
00:56:46.303 --> 00:56:49.940 region:rollup2
WHICH IS ALWAYS GOOD AND YOU CAN
00:56:48.205 --> 00:56:51.508 region:rollup2
ALWAYS WHEN THOSE THINGS AND
00:56:49.940 --> 00:56:52.075 region:rollup2
VOTER THOUSAND OF WOMEN WAS IN
00:56:51.508 --> 00:56:53.377 region:rollup2
VOTE ON THE BILL THAT'S TO
00:56:52.075 --> 00:56:55.746 region:rollup2
SUBJECT TO THAT LITIGATION
00:56:53.377 --> 00:56:56.546 region:rollup2
TWENTY YEARS AGO. BUT WHAT I'M
00:56:55.746 --> 00:56:59.216 region:rollup2
INTERESTED IN IS THE PRACTICAL
00:56:56.546 --> 00:57:00.417 region:rollup2
REALITY. SO YOU CAN SAY
00:56:59.216 --> 00:57:01.051 region:rollup2
NECESSARY NECESSARY.
00:57:00.417 --> 00:57:03.487 region:rollup2
SOMEONE IS CHARGED WITH
00:57:01.051 --> 00:57:04.855 region:rollup2
SOMETHING. EVERYBODY.
00:57:03.487 --> 00:57:05.822 region:rollup2
THE FUNDAMENTAL HAS A RIGHT TO
00:57:04.855 --> 00:57:06.690 region:rollup2
DEFENSE EVEN THE SCHMUCK HE'S
00:57:05.822 --> 00:57:08.425 region:rollup2
PERSON THE WORLD HAS A RIGHT TO
00:57:06.690 --> 00:57:10.260 region:rollup2
DEFENSE.
00:57:08.425 --> 00:57:11.928 region:rollup2
IF YOU GOT A CRUMMY EMPLOYER. OR
00:57:10.260 --> 00:57:14.631 region:rollup2
IF THE HR DEPARTMENT DID
00:57:11.928 --> 00:57:16.867 region:rollup2
SOMETHING IN RETALIATION BRIGHT
00:57:14.631 --> 00:57:18.435 region:rollup2
AND YOU GET NAMED IN THE CASE
00:57:16.867 --> 00:57:19.937 region:rollup2
THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER IS THE
00:57:18.435 --> 00:57:21.505 region:rollup2
LAWYER'S FEES CAN BANKRUPT YOU
00:57:19.937 --> 00:57:22.906 region:rollup2
AND WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN IS I
00:57:21.505 --> 00:57:25.309 region:rollup2
DON'T AGREE WITH THE CHAMBER.
00:57:22.906 --> 00:57:26.643 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE NOTION OF THE LAND OF
00:57:25.309 --> 00:57:28.378 region:rollup2
THE THE LOW LAWYER BUT MEAN OF
00:57:26.643 --> 00:57:30.580 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER BEING A VIABLE
00:57:28.378 --> 00:57:32.149 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER SAYS A SMALL COMPANY
00:57:30.580 --> 00:57:33.950 region:rollup2
THE HR PERSON DOES SOMETHING.
00:57:32.149 --> 00:57:36.687 region:rollup2
YOU GET NAMED IN THE CASE YOU'RE
00:57:33.950 --> 00:57:38.388 region:rollup2
STUCK NAMED IN THE CASE AND AND
00:57:36.687 --> 00:57:42.025 region:rollup2
AND YOU SAY YOU TAKE YOUR VIEW
00:57:38.388 --> 00:57:42.959 region:rollup2
OF THE LAW. THAT IT'S NECESSARY.
00:57:42.025 --> 00:57:43.760 region:rollup2
THE LAWYERS THAT THEY THEY DON'T
00:57:42.959 --> 00:57:44.795 region:rollup2
HAVE THE MONEY OR THEY DON'T
00:57:43.760 --> 00:57:46.596 region:rollup2
HAVE INSURANCE THEY SAY I'M NOT
00:57:44.795 --> 00:57:48.899 region:rollup2
GOING TO PAY.
00:57:46.596 --> 00:57:50.233 region:rollup2
ARE SOMEBODY SITTIN THERE HERE
00:57:48.899 --> 00:57:51.768 region:rollup2
SINCE SENATOR LEYVA SITTIN THERE
00:57:50.233 --> 00:57:53.070 region:rollup2
SHE'S CHARGED.
00:57:51.768 --> 00:57:54.304 region:rollup2
AND WHAT DO YOU DO. RIGHT THAT'S
00:57:53.070 --> 00:57:56.406 region:rollup2
THAT'S THE ISSUE THE THIRD PARTY
00:57:54.304 --> 00:57:57.407 region:rollup2
RELATIONSHIP AND BEING CHARGING
00:57:56.406 --> 00:57:58.542 region:rollup2
THESE THINGS AND TRYING TO HAVE
00:57:57.407 --> 00:58:00.811 region:rollup2
A DEFENSE UNDER THOSE
00:57:58.542 --> 00:58:02.546 region:rollup2
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT TO ME. IS IS
00:58:00.811 --> 00:58:04.381 region:rollup2
ONE OF THE BALANCING ACTS YOU
00:58:02.546 --> 00:58:06.149 region:rollup2
HAVE BAD ACTORS RIGHT BUT
00:58:04.381 --> 00:58:07.351 region:rollup2
ULTIMATELY.
00:58:06.149 --> 00:58:08.452 region:rollup2
EVERYBODY HAS A TRIAL IS TO
00:58:07.351 --> 00:58:12.189 region:rollup2
PROVE THAT WHAT THEY DID WAS
00:58:08.452 --> 00:58:13.790 region:rollup2
pWHATEVER BUT EASY TRIALS ARE
00:58:12.189 --> 00:58:15.158 region:rollup2
STILL. HORRIBLY EXPENSIVE I'VE
00:58:13.790 --> 00:58:16.693 region:rollup2
BEEN WORKING ON BAIL REFORM AND
00:58:15.158 --> 00:58:18.662 region:rollup2
WORKING ON.
00:58:16.693 --> 00:58:20.997 region:rollup2
TRAFFIC TICKET REFORM BECAUSE
00:58:18.662 --> 00:58:22.232 region:rollup2
I'M SO DEEPLY CONCERNED ABOUT
00:58:20.997 --> 00:58:23.567 region:rollup2
THE JUDICIAL BRANCH OF
00:58:22.232 --> 00:58:25.502 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT AND HOW IT'S ONYX
00:58:23.567 --> 00:58:27.637 region:rollup2
INACCESSIBLE THE FOLKS AT EVERY
00:58:25.502 --> 00:58:28.939 region:rollup2
LEVEL. AND THE GOVERNMENT NEEDS
00:58:27.637 --> 00:58:30.173 region:rollup2
TO BE AN THE IT TO BE AT A PLACE
00:58:28.939 --> 00:58:30.741 region:rollup2
WHERE IT PROVIDES NOT JUST
00:58:30.173 --> 00:58:32.709 region:rollup2
RIGHTS BUT ALSO DEFENSE WITH
00:58:30.741 --> 00:58:34.678 region:rollup2
ITS.
00:58:32.709 --> 00:58:35.612 region:rollup2
POOR PEOPLE WITH WITH LEGAL AID
00:58:34.678 --> 00:58:36.680 region:rollup2
AND ALL OF THOSE THINGS
00:58:35.612 --> 00:58:38.382 region:rollup2
SO MY QUESTION ABOUT THE
00:58:36.680 --> 00:58:39.850 region:rollup2
NECESSARY PART. IS NOT THE BIG
00:58:38.382 --> 00:58:41.752 region:rollup2
COAST.
00:58:39.850 --> 00:58:43.120 region:rollup2
BUT THE LITTLE PEOPLE IN COMPANY
00:58:41.752 --> 00:58:44.254 region:rollup2
SMALL BUSINESSES BASICALLY WHAT
00:58:43.120 --> 00:58:46.623 region:rollup2
I MEAN WHEN THEY DON'T HAVE THE
00:58:44.254 --> 00:58:49.026 region:rollup2
RESOURCES AND SOMEONE STUCK IN
00:58:46.623 --> 00:58:49.659 region:rollup2
THAT SITUATION OF A FAIR HEARING
00:58:49.026 --> 00:58:50.694 region:rollup2
THAT'S I'D LOVE TO HEAR YOU GET
00:58:49.659 --> 00:58:52.095 region:rollup2
A LITTLE SENATOR IF I COULD JUST
00:58:50.694 --> 00:58:53.563 region:rollup2
JUMPING UP AND I THINK THIS IS
00:58:52.095 --> 00:58:55.799 region:rollup2
THE SAME. QUESTION WE HAVE IN
00:58:53.563 --> 00:58:57.801 region:rollup2
THE BASIC A HARASSMENT SITUATION
00:58:55.799 --> 00:58:59.035 region:rollup2
WHICH IS NOW IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN
00:58:57.801 --> 00:59:00.771 region:rollup2
THIS BILL.
00:58:59.035 --> 00:59:03.507 region:rollup2
IS JUST GOING TO ADD.
00:59:00.771 --> 00:59:04.241 region:rollup2
RETALIATION TO THAT SAME
00:59:03.507 --> 00:59:05.275 region:rollup2
CONSTRUCT
00:59:04.241 --> 00:59:07.911 region:rollup2
SO YOU'RE ASKING LEGITIMATE
00:59:05.275 --> 00:59:09.346 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS BUT THEY BUT THIS IS
00:59:07.911 --> 00:59:10.614 region:rollup2
NOT A NEW SET OF ISSUES THIS IS.
00:59:09.346 --> 00:59:11.581 region:rollup2
WHAT IT IS BECAUSE WERE TAUGHT
00:59:10.614 --> 00:59:12.783 region:rollup2
WE GET WHAT WAS EXPLAINED HERE
00:59:11.581 --> 00:59:14.117 region:rollup2
WHEN YOU OUT OF THE ROOM? IS
00:59:12.783 --> 00:59:15.752 region:rollup2
RETALIATION COULD BE YOUR HR
00:59:14.117 --> 00:59:17.454 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT DOING SOMETHING
00:59:15.752 --> 00:59:19.289 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT TO DIRECT ACT BY AN
00:59:17.454 --> 00:59:21.091 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL.
00:59:19.289 --> 00:59:23.427 region:rollup2
THAT'S A DIFFERENT ALLOCATED WAS
00:59:21.091 --> 00:59:24.761 region:rollup2
SO SO PAYMENT TERMS OF EATING
00:59:23.427 --> 00:59:26.496 region:rollup2
WELL HAVE CONTROL OVER HAPPINESS
00:59:24.761 --> 00:59:27.798 region:rollup2
AT THAT BUT I THINK WHAT THIS
00:59:26.496 --> 00:59:29.633 region:rollup2
BILL DOES AND THEN I'LL I'LL LET
00:59:27.798 --> 00:59:30.600 region:rollup2
YOU ALL ANSWERING TO GO. THROUGH
00:59:29.633 --> 00:59:32.102 region:rollup2
LIFTING BECAUSE ANOTHER
00:59:30.600 --> 00:59:32.769 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE SO I DID I APOLOGIZE I
00:59:32.102 --> 00:59:35.238 region:rollup2
DIDN'T IS SLOW BUT OF THE
00:59:32.769 --> 00:59:35.806 region:rollup2
DISCUSSION BUT MY UNDERSTANDING
00:59:35.238 --> 00:59:36.640 region:rollup2
IS. THAT.
00:59:35.806 --> 00:59:37.974 region:rollup2
THAT THE THE QUESTION THAT
00:59:36.640 --> 00:59:42.312 region:rollup2
YOU'RE RAISING IS.
00:59:37.974 --> 00:59:43.447 region:rollup2
ONE IF HR OR IF A THIRD PARTY'S
00:59:42.312 --> 00:59:45.949 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR.
00:59:43.447 --> 00:59:47.984 region:rollup2
GUY IS NOT DIRECTLY ENGAGED IN
00:59:45.949 --> 00:59:49.686 region:rollup2
THE BEHAVIOR BUT LET'S SAY IS
00:59:47.984 --> 00:59:52.022 region:rollup2
THAT IT IS TOLD THAT THEY NEEDED
00:59:49.686 --> 00:59:53.490 region:rollup2
TO FIRE THAT EMPLOYEE AS A
00:59:52.022 --> 00:59:56.159 region:rollup2
MATTER OF RETALIATION.
00:59:53.490 --> 00:59:58.395 region:rollup2
MIKE MY QUESTION WAS.
00:59:56.159 --> 01:00:00.330 region:rollup2
IF THAT THIRD PARTY HAS HAD
00:59:58.395 --> 01:00:01.965 region:rollup2
NOTHING TO DO WITH IT BUT AS IN
01:00:00.330 --> 01:00:03.166 region:rollup2
A SOUP OF ASORIO POSITION IS THE
01:00:01.965 --> 01:00:05.335 region:rollup2
ONE THAT SAID YOU HAVE TO GO
01:00:03.166 --> 01:00:07.404 region:rollup2
FIRE THEM. ARE THEY NOW STILL
01:00:05.335 --> 01:00:08.472 region:rollup2
RESPONSIBLE FOR RETALIATION AND
01:00:07.404 --> 01:00:09.840 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD BE TO MEET THE
01:00:08.472 --> 01:00:11.108 region:rollup2
DISTINCTION I UNDERSTAND WHAT
01:00:09.840 --> 01:00:12.476 region:rollup2
YOU'RE SAYING CAN YOU ANSWER
01:00:11.108 --> 01:00:14.077 region:rollup2
THAT QUESTION IF I'M IN A
01:00:12.476 --> 01:00:15.512 region:rollup2
PHARMACEUTICAL VISOR I HAVEN'T
01:00:14.077 --> 01:00:17.380 region:rollup2
BEEN INVOLVED IN THIS.
01:00:15.512 --> 01:00:19.483 region:rollup2
THERE THERE HAS BEEN SEXUAL
01:00:17.380 --> 01:00:21.718 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT. THE INDIVIDUALS NOW.
01:00:19.483 --> 01:00:23.887 region:rollup2
WHO IS THE VICTIM?
01:00:21.718 --> 01:00:26.389 region:rollup2
HAS A BLOWN THE WHISTLE ON THIS
01:00:23.887 --> 01:00:28.425 region:rollup2
AND THE EMPLOYER SAYS TO ME YEAR
01:00:26.389 --> 01:00:30.393 region:rollup2
THAT YEAR HER SUPERVISOR. AND
01:00:28.425 --> 01:00:32.462 region:rollup2
YOU HAVE TO GO FIRE HER. THAT AS
01:00:30.393 --> 01:00:34.331 region:rollup2
A RETALIATORY ACTORS IS A
01:00:32.462 --> 01:00:36.900 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR LIBEL BECAUSE THE
01:00:34.331 --> 01:00:38.902 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR HAS A CHOICE EITHER I
01:00:36.900 --> 01:00:40.504 region:rollup2
CARRY OUT THE DIRECTIVE FROM MY
01:00:38.902 --> 01:00:42.806 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER. OR.
01:00:40.504 --> 01:00:45.509 region:rollup2
OR I DON'T AND LOSE MY JOB HOW
01:00:42.806 --> 01:00:46.510 region:rollup2
TO HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THAT
01:00:45.509 --> 01:00:48.612 region:rollup2
BECAUSE SAID I THINK IS.
01:00:46.510 --> 01:00:50.480 region:rollup2
THE NUTS AND BOLTS OF WHAT THE
01:00:48.612 --> 01:00:51.081 region:rollup2
THE CONCERN IS LEGAL AND WHAT
01:00:50.480 --> 01:00:52.182 region:rollup2
THIS WOULD BE AT THE SLOW WHEN
01:00:51.081 --> 01:00:53.850 region:rollup2
ACTED.
01:00:52.182 --> 01:00:55.652 region:rollup2
WELL IF YOU STUCK MY I'M TALKING
01:00:53.850 --> 01:00:56.052 region:rollup2
TO THE PLAINTIFFS COUNSEL IF YOU
01:00:55.652 --> 01:00:57.754 region:rollup2
WOULD MIND.
01:00:56.052 --> 01:00:58.722 region:rollup2
HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THAT
01:00:57.754 --> 01:01:00.790 region:rollup2
CONSUMER?
01:00:58.722 --> 01:01:02.025 region:rollup2
IN THAT CASE MADAM CHAIR IF THE
01:01:00.790 --> 01:01:03.727 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR AUTHORS* HIS
01:01:02.025 --> 01:01:05.095 region:rollup2
MARROW JUST POINTED OUT NOT THE
01:01:03.727 --> 01:01:06.930 region:rollup2
PLANE'S CONSUMMATE THE AUTHORS
01:01:05.095 --> 01:01:08.865 region:rollup2
COUNSEL I CAN'T GET A LAWYER OUT
01:01:06.930 --> 01:01:10.400 region:rollup2
OF A QUORUM THE MATTER WHAT YOU
01:01:08.865 --> 01:01:11.568 region:rollup2
TRY TO DO MY APOLOGIES.
01:01:10.400 --> 01:01:14.704 region:rollup2
TO THE PLAINTIFFS A TO THE TO
01:01:11.568 --> 01:01:16.173 region:rollup2
THE AUTHORS COUNCIL.
01:01:14.704 --> 01:01:16.740 region:rollup2
WE PROUDLY WEAR THE BADGE OF
01:01:16.173 --> 01:01:18.175 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFFS COUNSEL WHO MADAM
01:01:16.740 --> 01:01:19.843 region:rollup2
CHAIR BUT IN THAT PARTICULAR
01:01:18.175 --> 01:01:21.478 region:rollup2
INSTANCE WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IN
01:01:19.843 --> 01:01:23.246 region:rollup2
THAT CASE IS THE SUPERVISORS
01:01:21.478 --> 01:01:24.648 region:rollup2
BEING DIRECTED TO DO SOMETHING.
01:01:23.246 --> 01:01:25.615 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD BE AN INSTANCE WHERE
01:01:24.648 --> 01:01:27.250 region:rollup2
THEY ARE ACTING IN THE COURSE
01:01:25.615 --> 01:01:28.485 region:rollup2
AND SCOPE OF THEIR EMPLOYMENT
01:01:27.250 --> 01:01:30.654 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN DIRECTED
01:01:28.485 --> 01:01:32.923 region:rollup2
BY HR TO DO SOMETHING. HOWEVER
01:01:30.654 --> 01:01:34.257 region:rollup2
REPREHENSIBLE IT MAY BE AND IN
01:01:32.923 --> 01:01:37.093 region:rollup2
THAT CASE THEY WOULD BE
01:01:34.257 --> 01:01:38.228 region:rollup2
INDEMNIFIED FOR THEIR COST OF OF
01:01:37.093 --> 01:01:39.796 region:rollup2
DEFENSE BECAUSE IT IS IT IS IT
01:01:38.228 --> 01:01:41.097 region:rollup2
IS IT IS IN THE COURSE AND SCOPE
01:01:39.796 --> 01:01:43.667 region:rollup2
OF THEIR EMPLOYMENT. AND THAT'S
01:01:41.097 --> 01:01:45.502 region:rollup2
THE NECESSARY INQUIRY IS WHETHER
01:01:43.667 --> 01:01:46.970 region:rollup2
IT IS. IT IS WHETHER UNDER
01:01:45.502 --> 01:01:48.605 region:rollup2
TWENTY YOU KNOW TO IT'S
01:01:46.970 --> 01:01:50.674 region:rollup2
UNNECESSARY EXPENSE AND THAT.
01:01:48.605 --> 01:01:51.575 region:rollup2
THE IRAQI AGREE TO ANSWER THAT
01:01:50.674 --> 01:01:53.176 region:rollup2
QUESTION IS IF IT WAS THE COURSE
01:01:51.575 --> 01:01:54.377 region:rollup2
SINCE IF IT IF THE ACTION WAS IN
01:01:53.176 --> 01:01:56.012 region:rollup2
IN THE CURRENT IN THE COURSE AND
01:01:54.377 --> 01:01:57.647 region:rollup2
SCOPE OF THEIR EMPLOYMENT. THE
01:01:56.012 --> 01:01:58.548 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT BROAD PROPOSITION
01:01:57.647 --> 01:02:00.483 region:rollup2
WOULD BE IF YOU HAVE A ROGUE
01:01:58.548 --> 01:02:01.551 region:rollup2
ACTOR WHO DECIDES I'M GONNA
01:02:00.483 --> 01:02:02.819 region:rollup2
RETALIATE AND I'M NOT GOING TO
01:02:01.551 --> 01:02:04.154 region:rollup2
TELL THE JURY WHAT I'M DOING I'M
01:02:02.819 --> 01:02:05.689 region:rollup2
JUST GONNA RECOMMEND THIS PERSON
01:02:04.154 --> 01:02:08.158 region:rollup2
FOR TERMINATION. BECAUSE I'M
01:02:05.689 --> 01:02:09.659 region:rollup2
COVERING UP FOR MY FRIENDS OR IN
01:02:08.158 --> 01:02:11.094 region:rollup2
SOME OTHER ROGUE ACTION AND
01:02:09.659 --> 01:02:12.929 region:rollup2
DIDN'T TELL EACH OTHER TRUE
01:02:11.094 --> 01:02:14.698 region:rollup2
MOTIVATIONS SO HR WAS THE ONE IN
01:02:12.929 --> 01:02:16.566 region:rollup2
THE DARK. IN THAT INSTANCE YOU
01:02:14.698 --> 01:02:17.367 region:rollup2
WOULD HAVE PERSONAL LIABILITY
01:02:16.566 --> 01:02:18.668 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THAT IS AN ACTION AND
01:02:17.367 --> 01:02:20.003 region:rollup2
RENT AND I THINK IT'S VERY
01:02:18.668 --> 01:02:21.204 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT TO POINT OUT.
01:02:20.003 --> 01:02:22.939 region:rollup2
WITH DUE RESPECT THAT
01:02:21.204 --> 01:02:24.874 region:rollup2
RETALIATION IS AN INDIVIDUAL
01:02:22.939 --> 01:02:28.278 region:rollup2
ACTION JUST LIKE HARASSMENT IT
01:02:24.874 --> 01:02:29.412 region:rollup2
ABSOLUTELY CAN BE AND IS
01:02:28.278 --> 01:02:30.113 region:rollup2
EVERYDAY.
01:02:29.412 --> 01:02:31.181 region:rollup2
BUT AND THAT ISN'T MY CONCERN MY
01:02:30.113 --> 01:02:32.649 region:rollup2
CONCERN IS THAT AS YOU MENTIONED
01:02:31.181 --> 01:02:34.551 region:rollup2
IN THE COURSE AND SCOPE OF THEIR
01:02:32.649 --> 01:02:36.853 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT SO IF I COULD ASK THE
01:02:34.551 --> 01:02:38.054 region:rollup2
CHAMBER. TO RESPOND DO YOU AGREE
01:02:36.853 --> 01:02:39.723 region:rollup2
OR DISAGREE WITH THAT
01:02:38.054 --> 01:02:41.324 region:rollup2
DISTINCTION AND WHETHER THIS
01:02:39.723 --> 01:02:42.826 region:rollup2
BILL DOES INCLUDE THAT AND THEN
01:02:41.324 --> 01:02:44.694 region:rollup2
CENTER HERTZBERG THAT DOESN'T
01:02:42.826 --> 01:02:45.996 region:rollup2
ANSWER QUESTIONS SO OF GIVE THE
01:02:44.694 --> 01:02:47.530 region:rollup2
MIKE BACK TO YOU. SIR IF I MAY
01:02:45.996 --> 01:02:49.332 region:rollup2
UM I DON'T THINK IT'S EVER S.
01:02:47.530 --> 01:02:50.367 region:rollup2
CRYSTAL CLEAR AS YOU GO AND
01:02:49.332 --> 01:02:51.635 region:rollup2
TERMINATE THIS INDIVIDUAL
01:02:50.367 --> 01:02:52.969 region:rollup2
BECAUSE I WANT YOU TO RETALIATE
01:02:51.635 --> 01:02:54.304 region:rollup2
AGAINST THEM FOR DOING SEXUAL
01:02:52.969 --> 01:02:55.572 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT RIGHT I DON'T THINK.
01:02:54.304 --> 01:02:56.773 region:rollup2
I MEAN I WOULD SAY NINETY NINE
01:02:55.572 --> 01:02:58.041 region:rollup2
POINT NINE PERCENT OF THE CASES
01:02:56.773 --> 01:02:59.409 region:rollup2
THAT IN DIRECT INSTRUCTION IS
01:02:58.041 --> 01:03:00.477 region:rollup2
NEVER GIVEN IT'S JUST YOU NEED
01:02:59.409 --> 01:03:01.878 region:rollup2
TO GO DISCIPLINE THIS INDIVIDUAL
01:03:00.477 --> 01:03:03.313 region:rollup2
UNITS TERMINATED SO HOW'S THE
01:03:01.878 --> 01:03:04.614 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR AT THAT POINT. ABLE
01:03:03.313 --> 01:03:05.982 region:rollup2
TO DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT
01:03:04.614 --> 01:03:06.850 region:rollup2
YOU'RE ASKING ME TO DO SOMETHING
01:03:05.982 --> 01:03:08.018 region:rollup2
WITHIN THE COURSE AND SCOPE OF
01:03:06.850 --> 01:03:09.219 region:rollup2
MY EMPLOYMENT OR WHETHER YOU
01:03:08.018 --> 01:03:10.453 region:rollup2
ASKED ME TO DO SOMETHING THAT'S
01:03:09.219 --> 01:03:11.921 region:rollup2
RETALIATORY YOU'RE PUTTING THEM
01:03:10.453 --> 01:03:12.889 region:rollup2
IN A HORRIBLE POSITION. OF
01:03:11.921 --> 01:03:15.125 region:rollup2
HAVING TO DECIDE WHETHER I
01:03:12.889 --> 01:03:16.559 region:rollup2
FOLLOW MY MY EMPLOYER MY BOSS
01:03:15.125 --> 01:03:18.028 region:rollup2
WERE AT I DON'T FOLLOW MY BOSS
01:03:16.559 --> 01:03:19.696 region:rollup2
AND JEOPARDIZE MY JOB AND I HAVE
01:03:18.028 --> 01:03:21.464 region:rollup2
NO IDEA TO DO. TERM IN THE
01:03:19.696 --> 01:03:23.166 region:rollup2
INTENT OF THE EMPLOYER A CASE
01:03:21.464 --> 01:03:24.567 region:rollup2
THAT'S ONE EXAMPLE NOW IF THE
01:03:23.166 --> 01:03:26.002 region:rollup2
SUPERVISORS THAT'S WHAT THE ONE
01:03:24.567 --> 01:03:29.005 region:rollup2
I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THE ONE I'M
01:03:26.002 --> 01:03:29.739 region:rollup2
CONCERNED ABOUT. BE A IS WHERE
01:03:29.005 --> 01:03:32.075 region:rollup2
THEY ARE TOLD.
01:03:29.739 --> 01:03:35.445 region:rollup2
THE WHAT IS GOING ON AND THEY
01:03:32.075 --> 01:03:36.079 region:rollup2
ARE GIVEN A DIRECTIVE TO FIRE
01:03:35.445 --> 01:03:37.180 region:rollup2
THAT EMPLOYEE.
01:03:36.079 --> 01:03:38.114 region:rollup2
THAT'S WHAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT
01:03:37.180 --> 01:03:39.649 region:rollup2
WHAT IS THERE WHAT DID THEY DO
01:03:38.114 --> 01:03:40.884 region:rollup2
IN THAT CIRCUMSTANCE APPRECIATE
01:03:39.649 --> 01:03:42.719 region:rollup2
THAT I'M GONNA SAY THE BILL IS
01:03:40.884 --> 01:03:44.087 region:rollup2
MUCH BROADER RIGHT INCLUDES MY
01:03:42.719 --> 01:03:45.755 region:rollup2
SITUATION BUT YOUR TO YOUR
01:03:44.087 --> 01:03:47.223 region:rollup2
QUESTION IS. THE EMPLOYERS
01:03:45.755 --> 01:03:48.124 region:rollup2
TELLING THE SUPERVISOR TO GOING
01:03:47.223 --> 01:03:50.026 region:rollup2
TERMINATE AN EMPLOYEE IN
01:03:48.124 --> 01:03:51.061 region:rollup2
RETALIATION FOR THEM COMPLAINING
01:03:50.026 --> 01:03:52.762 region:rollup2
ABOUT HARASSMENT RIGHT THE
01:03:51.061 --> 01:03:54.464 region:rollup2
PLAYERS ON THE HOOK.
01:03:52.762 --> 01:03:55.265 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYERS ON THE HOOK YOU
01:03:54.464 --> 01:03:56.166 region:rollup2
READY HAVE SOMEBODY WHO'S AT
01:03:55.265 --> 01:03:58.401 region:rollup2
RESPONSIBLE OR LIABLE AND THAT'S
01:03:56.166 --> 01:04:00.070 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER.
01:03:58.401 --> 01:04:01.805 region:rollup2
DO YOU AGREE OF OF AUTHORS
01:04:00.070 --> 01:04:03.306 region:rollup2
WITNESS DO YOU HAVE DO YOU AGREE
01:04:01.805 --> 01:04:04.374 region:rollup2
WITH THAT AND IF THAT. IS
01:04:03.306 --> 01:04:05.742 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT YOU DON'T AGREE
01:04:04.374 --> 01:04:07.143 region:rollup2
MAYBE WE CAN TIGHTEN TIGHTEN UP
01:04:05.742 --> 01:04:09.112 region:rollup2
THE LANGUAGE BECAUSE I THINK
01:04:07.143 --> 01:04:11.147 region:rollup2
THAT'S A HOBSON'S CHOICE FOR. A
01:04:09.112 --> 01:04:12.615 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR THEY'RE NOT ENGAGED
01:04:11.147 --> 01:04:14.150 region:rollup2
IN THE ACTIVITY THEMSELVES BUT
01:04:12.615 --> 01:04:16.086 region:rollup2
THEY'VE JUST BEEN DIRECTED BY
01:04:14.150 --> 01:04:17.320 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER.
01:04:16.086 --> 01:04:19.456 region:rollup2
FOR A FOR A. YOU KNOW AN
01:04:17.320 --> 01:04:21.057 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL RIFF THIS BILL PASSED
01:04:19.456 --> 01:04:22.058 region:rollup2
IN LAWFUL RECENT. TO THEY HAVE
01:04:21.057 --> 01:04:23.426 region:rollup2
LIABILITY SHOULD THEY HAVE
01:04:22.058 --> 01:04:25.161 region:rollup2
LIABILITY AND DO THEY UNDER THE
01:04:23.426 --> 01:04:26.396 region:rollup2
BILL.
01:04:25.161 --> 01:04:27.363 region:rollup2
UNDER THE BILL AT MADAM CHAIR
01:04:26.396 --> 01:04:29.232 region:rollup2
THEY WOULD NOT BECAUSE YOU HAVE
01:04:27.363 --> 01:04:31.067 region:rollup2
TO CHAU RETALIATORY INTENT AS OF
01:04:29.232 --> 01:04:33.169 region:rollup2
CAUSATION PRONG OF THE CAUSE OF
01:04:31.067 --> 01:04:34.537 region:rollup2
ACTION SO.
01:04:33.169 --> 01:04:36.539 region:rollup2
IT'S NOT A QUESTION OF JUST DID
01:04:34.537 --> 01:04:38.641 region:rollup2
IT OCCUR IT'S A QUESTION OF DID
01:04:36.539 --> 01:04:40.777 region:rollup2
IT OCCUR AND WAS THERE SPECIFIC
01:04:38.641 --> 01:04:41.878 region:rollup2
RETALIATORY INTENT IF THEY KNEW
01:04:40.777 --> 01:04:43.246 region:rollup2
ABOUT WHAT THEY WERE AND WHAT
01:04:41.878 --> 01:04:44.547 region:rollup2
THEY WERE DOING. AND THEY
01:04:43.246 --> 01:04:46.282 region:rollup2
INTENDED TO RETALIATE AGAINST
01:04:44.547 --> 01:04:47.817 region:rollup2
THE INDIVIDUAL THEN THAT WOULD
01:04:46.282 --> 01:04:50.053 region:rollup2
BE SOMETHING THERE PUT BUT I'M
01:04:47.817 --> 01:04:53.723 region:rollup2
TALKING ABOUT THE THE SUPERVISOR
01:04:50.053 --> 01:04:55.525 region:rollup2
WHO IS DIRECTED BY HR.
01:04:53.723 --> 01:04:58.461 region:rollup2
TO TO FIRE SOMEBODY.
01:04:55.525 --> 01:05:00.363 region:rollup2
FOR BECAUSE THE EVA AND AND
01:04:58.461 --> 01:05:02.332 region:rollup2
LET'S ASSUME THEY TOLD WHY.
01:05:00.363 --> 01:05:04.367 region:rollup2
THE THE IMPLANT THE SUPERVISOR
01:05:02.332 --> 01:05:05.935 region:rollup2
HAS A HOBSON'S CHOICE EITHER
01:05:04.367 --> 01:05:08.738 region:rollup2
THEY TELL HR TO GO JUMP IN THE
01:05:05.935 --> 01:05:11.608 region:rollup2
LAKE. OR THE A AND LOSE THEIR
01:05:08.738 --> 01:05:13.243 region:rollup2
JOB OR THEY COMPLETE THE TASK
01:05:11.608 --> 01:05:15.111 region:rollup2
AND ARE THEY ON THE HOOK UNDER
01:05:13.243 --> 01:05:17.380 region:rollup2
THIS BILL THAT'S MY ONLY CONCERN
01:05:15.111 --> 01:05:18.848 region:rollup2
AND YES AND THEN SENATOR FIGHT
01:05:17.380 --> 01:05:20.617 region:rollup2
HAPPENED GOTTEN YOUR QUESTION.
01:05:18.848 --> 01:05:21.918 region:rollup2
FEEL FREE TO JUMP IT HUNNICUTT
01:05:20.617 --> 01:05:23.520 region:rollup2
SCENARIO YES PLEASE EMPLOYER
01:05:21.918 --> 01:05:25.455 region:rollup2
WOULD BE ON THE HOOK BECAUSE THE
01:05:23.520 --> 01:05:27.757 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEE OR THE SUPERVISOR WAS
01:05:25.455 --> 01:05:28.558 region:rollup2
TOLD AS IT YOU MUST DO THIS IN
01:05:27.757 --> 01:05:30.260 region:rollup2
THE COURSE OF YOUR JOB YOU HAVE
01:05:28.558 --> 01:05:32.495 region:rollup2
TO DO TAKE THIS ACTION. AND AS
01:05:30.260 --> 01:05:34.230 region:rollup2
MY OF FELLOW WITNESS POINT OUT
01:05:32.495 --> 01:05:35.031 region:rollup2
THERE'S ALSO REQUIREMENT TO SHOW
01:05:34.230 --> 01:05:37.133 region:rollup2
THAT THERE WAS RETALIATES OR
01:05:35.031 --> 01:05:38.968 region:rollup2
INTENT SO THE ADVERSE ACTION
01:05:37.133 --> 01:05:40.637 region:rollup2
AGAINST THE EMPLOYEE HAS TO BE
01:05:38.968 --> 01:05:43.573 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY MOTIVATED BY.
01:05:40.637 --> 01:05:45.241 region:rollup2
GBIT INTEND TO DO TO RETALIATE
01:05:43.573 --> 01:05:46.776 region:rollup2
FOR THE EMPLOYEE HAVING ENGAGE
01:05:45.241 --> 01:05:47.744 region:rollup2
IN A BATTLE LET'S SAY THE
01:05:46.776 --> 01:05:49.045 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT OFFENSIVE THE HELIUM
01:05:47.744 --> 01:05:51.047 region:rollup2
PLOT WE HAVE NO INTENT THE
01:05:49.045 --> 01:05:53.883 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR KNOWS EXACTLY WHY THE
01:05:51.047 --> 01:05:57.320 region:rollup2
BOSS WANTS TO FIRE THIS PERSON.
01:05:53.883 --> 01:05:58.188 region:rollup2
AND THE BOSS SAYS YOU GO AND YOU
01:05:57.320 --> 01:05:59.956 region:rollup2
HAVE TO GO AHEAD AND FIRE THEM.
01:05:58.188 --> 01:06:02.192 region:rollup2
THAT'S LEAVING THE SUPERVISOR IN
01:05:59.956 --> 01:06:03.359 region:rollup2
A DEBT VERY DIFFICULT SITUATION
01:06:02.192 --> 01:06:04.961 region:rollup2
IF THEY DON'T GO AHEAD AND DO
01:06:03.359 --> 01:06:07.230 region:rollup2
WHAT THEY'RE TOLD THEY'RE LIKELY
01:06:04.961 --> 01:06:09.799 region:rollup2
TO GET FIRED. IF THEY DO WHAT
01:06:07.230 --> 01:06:11.868 region:rollup2
THEY'RE TOLD THEY'RE ACTUALLY.
01:06:09.799 --> 01:06:13.203 region:rollup2
NOW ON THE HOOK FOR SOMETHING
01:06:11.868 --> 01:06:14.504 region:rollup2
THAT THEY DIDN'T DO BUT IT'S NOW
01:06:13.203 --> 01:06:16.005 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE TO DO IT IN ORDER TO
01:06:14.504 --> 01:06:17.307 region:rollup2
KEEP THEIR JOB.
01:06:16.005 --> 01:06:18.741 region:rollup2
YES AND JUST TO BE CLEAR THE
01:06:17.307 --> 01:06:19.843 region:rollup2
HEAR THEM PLOY WILL BE ON THE
01:06:18.741 --> 01:06:22.612 region:rollup2
HOOK NOT EXIT RIGHT OFF THE
01:06:19.843 --> 01:06:23.213 region:rollup2
SUPER OKAY AND SO WHAT I HEAR IS
01:06:22.612 --> 01:06:25.248 region:rollup2
THERE'S A DIFFERENCE OF
01:06:23.213 --> 01:06:26.616 region:rollup2
AGREEMENT. I SUSPECT YOU'RE NOT
01:06:25.248 --> 01:06:28.918 region:rollup2
TRYING TO PUT THE EMPLOYEE AND
01:06:26.616 --> 01:06:29.919 region:rollup2
THE SUPERVISOR ON THE HOOK WHEN
01:06:28.918 --> 01:06:31.154 region:rollup2
THEY'RE JUST BEING ASKED TO.
01:06:29.919 --> 01:06:33.456 region:rollup2
THE COMPLETED TASK THAT THEY HAD
01:06:31.154 --> 01:06:35.959 region:rollup2
NOTHING TO DO WITH SO PERHAPS WE
01:06:33.456 --> 01:06:37.560 region:rollup2
CAN THAT YOU CAN CONTINUE TO
01:06:35.959 --> 01:06:38.495 region:rollup2
CLARIFY THAT LANGUAGE THAT'S MY
01:06:37.560 --> 01:06:40.063 region:rollup2
ONLY PROBLEM WITH THE BILL I
01:06:38.495 --> 01:06:41.798 region:rollup2
THINK IT'S GREAT BILL. BUT I
01:06:40.063 --> 01:06:43.666 region:rollup2
THINK DEBT HOBSON'S CHOICE PUTS
01:06:41.798 --> 01:06:45.835 region:rollup2
PEOPLE IN A SITUATION WHO
01:06:43.666 --> 01:06:47.170 region:rollup2
SHOULDN'T NECESSARILY AURA OF
01:06:45.835 --> 01:06:48.338 region:rollup2
WHO I DON'T THINK YOU WANT TO BE
01:06:47.170 --> 01:06:50.440 region:rollup2
IN THAT POSITION ELECTION
01:06:48.338 --> 01:06:51.841 region:rollup2
RESPOND. THEN SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:06:50.440 --> 01:06:52.909 region:rollup2
AND THEN WE'LL MOVE ON I TOSS A
01:06:51.841 --> 01:06:54.544 region:rollup2
ONE OF A QUICK THING ON THAT.
01:06:52.909 --> 01:06:56.179 region:rollup2
THE PLANES PARTS QUITE GOOD AT
01:06:54.544 --> 01:06:58.448 region:rollup2
THESE THINGS SO EVEN THOUGH THEY
01:06:56.179 --> 01:06:59.582 region:rollup2
MIGHT NOT HAVE LIABILITY
01:06:58.448 --> 01:07:00.884 region:rollup2
SOMEWHERE DOWN THE LINE.
01:06:59.582 --> 01:07:01.718 region:rollup2
THAT DETERMINATION CAN BE MADE
01:07:00.884 --> 01:07:02.752 region:rollup2
TWO YEARS FROM NOW. WHAT'S GOING
01:07:01.718 --> 01:07:04.220 region:rollup2
TO HAPPEN IS THEY'RE GOING TO
01:07:02.752 --> 01:07:06.422 region:rollup2
SUE THE SUPERVISOR MADE THE
01:07:04.220 --> 01:07:08.191 region:rollup2
DIRECTIVE. AND THE HR PERSONNEL
01:07:06.422 --> 01:07:10.326 region:rollup2
AND A CENTER HERTZBERG POINT
01:07:08.191 --> 01:07:11.060 region:rollup2
ABOUT ACCESS I JOKE I COULD
01:07:10.326 --> 01:07:13.062 region:rollup2
AFFORD ME.
01:07:11.060 --> 01:07:14.597 region:rollup2
HOW IS E.?
01:07:13.062 --> 01:07:17.333 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR HR PERSONAL GONNA
01:07:14.597 --> 01:07:18.501 region:rollup2
FIRE AFFORD FOR TWO YEARS
01:07:17.333 --> 01:07:19.836 region:rollup2
SEVERAL HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
01:07:18.501 --> 01:07:20.803 region:rollup2
WITH ATTORNEYS FEES TO HOPEFULLY
01:07:19.836 --> 01:07:22.472 region:rollup2
GET TO THE POINT WHERE THEY
01:07:20.803 --> 01:07:24.774 region:rollup2
DETERMINED AFTER THE FACT THAT
01:07:22.472 --> 01:07:27.677 region:rollup2
THEY DID NOT HAVE LIED BUILDING.
01:07:24.774 --> 01:07:28.478 region:rollup2
AND I I THINK IT'S A.
01:07:27.677 --> 01:07:29.012 region:rollup2
IT'S BEEN A RATHER ACTIVE DAY
01:07:28.478 --> 01:07:30.446 region:rollup2
HERE.
01:07:29.012 --> 01:07:32.582 region:rollup2
I THINK.
01:07:30.446 --> 01:07:34.250 region:rollup2
IN THAT SITUATION THE EMPLOYER
01:07:32.582 --> 01:07:36.486 region:rollup2
WILL.
01:07:34.250 --> 01:07:37.887 region:rollup2
MOST LIKELY BE A PAYING THOSE
01:07:36.486 --> 01:07:39.455 region:rollup2
ATTORNEYS FEES AND.
01:07:37.887 --> 01:07:40.957 region:rollup2
I APPRECIATE THAT THERE'S
01:07:39.455 --> 01:07:42.859 region:rollup2
CONCERN BUT.
01:07:40.957 --> 01:07:44.594 region:rollup2
IF YOU CAN CLARIFY THIS
01:07:42.859 --> 01:07:46.763 region:rollup2
BY IT ISSUE.
01:07:44.594 --> 01:07:48.564 region:rollup2
I THINK THAT THAT WILL GO A
01:07:46.763 --> 01:07:50.033 region:rollup2
LONG WAY TOWARDS RESOLVING WHAT
01:07:48.564 --> 01:07:51.367 region:rollup2
MAY BE SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:07:50.033 --> 01:07:52.568 region:rollup2
CONCERNED.
01:07:51.367 --> 01:07:54.170 region:rollup2
BUT I DON'T WANNA SPEAK FEW
01:07:52.568 --> 01:07:56.139 region:rollup2
SENATOR FIT LIKE TO RESPOND
01:07:54.170 --> 01:07:58.107 region:rollup2
THANK YOU E. DO HAD EXACTLY MY
01:07:56.139 --> 01:07:59.008 region:rollup2
POINT BUT I'M TRYING TO APPLY
01:07:58.107 --> 01:08:00.543 region:rollup2
THE PRACTICAL OTHER FACTS AND
01:07:59.008 --> 01:08:02.712 region:rollup2
LOG ON AND OFF FOR THIRTY NINE
01:08:00.543 --> 01:08:04.280 region:rollup2
YEARS. AND IS EXACTLY THE POINT
01:08:02.712 --> 01:08:05.748 region:rollup2
WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN IS SOMEONE'S
01:08:04.280 --> 01:08:07.917 region:rollup2
GOING TO BRING UP SUMMONS A
01:08:05.748 --> 01:08:09.385 region:rollup2
COMPLAINT. WHEN YOU GETS FOR SO
01:08:07.917 --> 01:08:10.987 region:rollup2
I'LL ANYBODY IN THIS ROOM GET
01:08:09.385 --> 01:08:13.156 region:rollup2
SERVE THEY GOTTA GO OUT AND IF
01:08:10.987 --> 01:08:15.058 region:rollup2
THEY WANT TO HIRE A LAWYER
01:08:13.156 --> 01:08:15.992 region:rollup2
THAT'S REALLY EXPENSIVE.
01:08:15.058 --> 01:08:17.727 region:rollup2
THE BIG THE THAT BECAUSE THE LAW
01:08:15.992 --> 01:08:19.562 region:rollup2
SAYS ALL YOUR PERSONALLY LIABLE
01:08:17.727 --> 01:08:21.497 region:rollup2
UNDER THIS THE THE PLAYERS GOING
01:08:19.562 --> 01:08:23.499 region:rollup2
TO FIND A THOUSAND EXCUSES NOT
01:08:21.497 --> 01:08:25.268 region:rollup2
TO PAY FOR THAT SECOND LAWYER.
01:08:23.499 --> 01:08:26.803 region:rollup2
IT EVEN AT THAT THE THE IDEA OF
01:08:25.268 --> 01:08:28.504 region:rollup2
THE INDEMNITY IS IRRELEVANT ACT
01:08:26.803 --> 01:08:30.039 region:rollup2
DEFINED BANKRUPTED.
01:08:28.504 --> 01:08:31.774 region:rollup2
OR I HAVE TO GIVE IF I HAVE TO
01:08:30.039 --> 01:08:33.710 region:rollup2
JUST LIKE IN THE BILL CASES OR
01:08:31.774 --> 01:08:34.243 region:rollup2
INCOMPLETE CASES I HAVE TO GIVE
01:08:33.710 --> 01:08:35.545 region:rollup2
UP BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE
01:08:34.243 --> 01:08:37.246 region:rollup2
ENOUGH MONEY.
01:08:35.545 --> 01:08:38.381 region:rollup2
YOU CAN'T IGNORE THAT IN TERMS
01:08:37.246 --> 01:08:40.383 region:rollup2
OF THIS AND THE DISTINCTION
01:08:38.381 --> 01:08:42.819 region:rollup2
THAT'S DIFFERENT IS EXACTLY WHAT
01:08:40.383 --> 01:08:44.654 region:rollup2
YOU SAID RETALIATORY INTENT.
01:08:42.819 --> 01:08:45.321 region:rollup2
IN ONE CASE THE SUMMONS A
01:08:44.654 --> 01:08:47.924 region:rollup2
COMPLAINT THE PLEADINGS GOING TO
01:08:45.321 --> 01:08:49.626 region:rollup2
SAY. PERSON A DID THIS THIS THIS
01:08:47.924 --> 01:08:51.527 region:rollup2
THIS AND THIS IT'S GOING TO BE
01:08:49.626 --> 01:08:52.095 region:rollup2
CLEAR AND THE ACCUSATIONS AGAIN
01:08:51.527 --> 01:08:53.429 region:rollup2
TO BE CLEAR AS TO WHAT THEY
01:08:52.095 --> 01:08:55.732 region:rollup2
WORK.
01:08:53.429 --> 01:08:57.533 region:rollup2
IN THE SECOND CASE BEATS
01:08:55.732 --> 01:08:58.868 region:rollup2
A SERIES OF A COMPANY WHERE
01:08:57.533 --> 01:09:00.870 region:rollup2
OTHER PEOPLE COULD HAVE MADE A
01:08:58.868 --> 01:09:02.639 region:rollup2
DECISION AND THAT TO ME IS A
01:09:00.870 --> 01:09:03.906 region:rollup2
VERY BIG DISTINCT I WAS HERE
01:09:02.639 --> 01:09:05.241 region:rollup2
WHEN THIS LAW PASSED LAST TIME
01:09:03.906 --> 01:09:06.609 region:rollup2
BEFORE THIS CASE WAS. I WAS
01:09:05.241 --> 01:09:08.177 region:rollup2
INVOLVED IN THESE DISCUSSIONS IN
01:09:06.609 --> 01:09:10.213 region:rollup2
THESE DEBATES AND I THOUGHT THAT
01:09:08.177 --> 01:09:12.315 region:rollup2
THERE WAS A VERY BIG REASON WHY
01:09:10.213 --> 01:09:15.051 region:rollup2
THE NATURE OF THAT BEHAVIOR BIT
01:09:12.315 --> 01:09:16.285 region:rollup2
BAD BEHAVIOR SHOULD BE.
01:09:15.051 --> 01:09:17.487 region:rollup2
REPREHENSIBLE AND PUNISH
01:09:16.285 --> 01:09:19.589 region:rollup2
EVERYWHERE HAVE A PROBLEM WITH
01:09:17.487 --> 01:09:20.523 region:rollup2
THAT BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT REALLY
01:09:19.589 --> 01:09:21.824 region:rollup2
GOES ON IN THE REAL WORLD IT
01:09:20.523 --> 01:09:22.959 region:rollup2
TAKES YEARS BY THE TIME YOU GET
01:09:21.824 --> 01:09:24.293 region:rollup2
THESE CASES SETTLED AND YOU'RE
01:09:22.959 --> 01:09:26.629 region:rollup2
BANKRUPT.
01:09:24.293 --> 01:09:28.197 region:rollup2
AND THEN ON UNFAIR CHARGES AND
01:09:26.629 --> 01:09:29.165 region:rollup2
THAT'S THE QUESTION OR FAIR
01:09:28.197 --> 01:09:30.500 region:rollup2
CHARGES WHATEVER THE CASES
01:09:29.165 --> 01:09:31.701 region:rollup2
BECAUSE YOUR EMPLOYER YOU'RE A
01:09:30.500 --> 01:09:33.269 region:rollup2
BAD PERSON AND YOUR EMPLOYER
01:09:31.701 --> 01:09:34.671 region:rollup2
DOESN'T PAY YOU.
01:09:33.269 --> 01:09:36.005 region:rollup2
SO THAT'S WHAT MY CONCERN IS
01:09:34.671 --> 01:09:37.340 region:rollup2
BECAUSE IT'S THE INTENT PROBLEM
01:09:36.005 --> 01:09:39.642 region:rollup2
IT'S JUST THE PRACTICAL
01:09:37.340 --> 01:09:41.144 region:rollup2
APPLICATION OF EXACTLY WHAT THE
01:09:39.642 --> 01:09:43.179 region:rollup2
CHAIR JUST ARTICULATED THAT'S.
01:09:41.144 --> 01:09:46.783 region:rollup2
BUT I'M TRYING TO EXPRESS.
01:09:43.179 --> 01:09:47.417 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR IF I MAY AS.
01:09:46.783 --> 01:09:49.218 region:rollup2
AND I'LL MAKE IT MY CLOSING OUR
01:09:47.417 --> 01:09:51.020 region:rollup2
HAPS IS HERE ANY WAY WE CAN ASK
01:09:49.218 --> 01:09:52.155 region:rollup2
HIM TO TONE IT DOWN A BIT OR
01:09:51.020 --> 01:09:52.955 region:rollup2
EITHER LIFT THE VOLUME HERE
01:09:52.155 --> 01:09:55.591 region:rollup2
BECAUSE.
01:09:52.955 --> 01:09:57.660 region:rollup2
IT'S VERY HARD.
01:09:55.591 --> 01:09:59.562 region:rollup2
IS THAT WHAT CHECK. CONTEST SO
01:09:57.660 --> 01:10:01.130 region:rollup2
IT'S A PROTEST ó OKAY WELL IN
01:09:59.562 --> 01:10:03.399 region:rollup2
THAT CASE. WOULD YOU RAISE THE
01:10:01.130 --> 01:10:04.033 region:rollup2
LEVEL OF THE MICROPHONE SO WE
01:10:03.399 --> 01:10:05.601 region:rollup2
HEAR IN THIS ROOM.
01:10:04.033 --> 01:10:08.604 region:rollup2
CAN HAVE A
01:10:05.601 --> 01:10:10.540 region:rollup2
HEARING.
01:10:08.604 --> 01:10:12.775 region:rollup2
SO IF I MAY AS MAY BE THE ONLY
01:10:10.540 --> 01:10:13.609 region:rollup2
NON LAWYER IN THE ROOM.
01:10:12.775 --> 01:10:15.712 region:rollup2
BRING US BACK
01:10:13.609 --> 01:10:17.246 region:rollup2
A LITTLE BIT
01:10:15.712 --> 01:10:18.715 region:rollup2
ONE OF FOUR WOMEN EXPERIENCE
01:10:17.246 --> 01:10:20.550 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT ONE IN FOUR
01:10:18.715 --> 01:10:22.385 region:rollup2
WOMEN.
01:10:20.550 --> 01:10:24.454 region:rollup2
BUT SEVENTY FIVE PERCENT OF
01:10:22.385 --> 01:10:25.922 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES WHO SPEAK OUT ABOUT
01:10:24.454 --> 01:10:27.557 region:rollup2
WORK PLACEMENTS MISTREATMENT OR
01:10:25.922 --> 01:10:29.158 region:rollup2
RETALIATED AGAINST
01:10:27.557 --> 01:10:31.427 region:rollup2
SO WHATEVER WE'RE DOING NOW IS
01:10:29.158 --> 01:10:33.096 region:rollup2
NOT WORKING.
01:10:31.427 --> 01:10:35.531 region:rollup2
ALL THIS DOES IS THIS TELLS
01:10:33.096 --> 01:10:38.434 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHO BEHAVE IN RETALIATORY
01:10:35.531 --> 01:10:40.269 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR THAT THEY WILL HAVE TO
01:10:38.434 --> 01:10:42.472 region:rollup2
FACE THE CONSEQUENCES. AND I
01:10:40.269 --> 01:10:44.407 region:rollup2
COMPLETELY DISAGREE WITH THE
01:10:42.472 --> 01:10:46.909 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION WHEN THEY SAY THAT
01:10:44.407 --> 01:10:49.045 region:rollup2
SEXUAL BANTER ISEXPECTED PART
01:10:46.909 --> 01:10:49.979 region:rollup2
OF THE WORKPLACE I KNOW YOU YOU
01:10:49.045 --> 01:10:51.080 region:rollup2
SEE THAT I'M NOT SAYING IT'S
01:10:49.979 --> 01:10:52.348 region:rollup2
YOUR OPINION UNDER SAY I
01:10:51.080 --> 01:10:53.583 region:rollup2
COMPLETELY DISAGREE WITH WHERE
01:10:52.348 --> 01:10:55.518 region:rollup2
YOU GOT A FROM I'VE BEEN AN
01:10:53.583 --> 01:10:57.220 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER FOR FIFTEEN YEARS. AND
01:10:55.518 --> 01:10:58.688 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD NEVER BE ALLOWED IN
01:10:57.220 --> 01:11:00.990 region:rollup2
ANY PLACE THAT I WORKED AT WE'VE
01:10:58.688 --> 01:11:02.959 region:rollup2
NEVER AL THAT THAT BE EXPECTED.
01:11:00.990 --> 01:11:05.194 region:rollup2
IF YOU ARE A SUPERVISOR OR YOU
01:11:02.959 --> 01:11:06.896 region:rollup2
ARE AN EMPLOYEE YOU CANNOT
01:11:05.194 --> 01:11:08.731 region:rollup2
RETALIATE AGAINST SOMEONE FOR
01:11:06.896 --> 01:11:10.333 region:rollup2
COMING FORWARD AND SAYING I HAVE
01:11:08.731 --> 01:11:11.534 region:rollup2
BEEN SEXUALLY HARASSED RIGHT NOW
01:11:10.333 --> 01:11:13.269 region:rollup2
THAT CAN HELP IN THE WAY THE LAW
01:11:11.534 --> 01:11:14.337 region:rollup2
IS. WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
01:11:13.269 --> 01:11:15.738 region:rollup2
CHANGE THE LAW WE HAVE AN
01:11:14.337 --> 01:11:17.140 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO SEE WHETHER YOU
01:11:15.738 --> 01:11:18.775 region:rollup2
ARE AN EMPLOYEE WHO IS
01:11:17.140 --> 01:11:20.109 region:rollup2
RETALIATING AGAINST SOMEONE OR
01:11:18.775 --> 01:11:22.111 region:rollup2
YOU A SUPERVISOR WHO IS
01:11:20.109 --> 01:11:24.847 region:rollup2
RETALIATING AGAINST SOMEONE. IT
01:11:22.111 --> 01:11:26.182 region:rollup2
IS NOT OKAY BUT ONE ANALYST LAST
01:11:24.847 --> 01:11:28.151 region:rollup2
THING IF I AM AN EMPLOYER AND I
01:11:26.182 --> 01:11:30.186 region:rollup2
SAY TO MY SUPERVISOR HEY I NEED
01:11:28.151 --> 01:11:31.621 region:rollup2
YOU TO GO AND FIRE. SUSIE OVER
01:11:30.186 --> 01:11:34.190 region:rollup2
THERE.
01:11:31.621 --> 01:11:36.392 region:rollup2
IF I DO IT IF IT IS NOT ILLEGAL
01:11:34.190 --> 01:11:37.994 region:rollup2
OR IMMORAL I HAVE TO DO WHAT MY
01:11:36.392 --> 01:11:39.362 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER TELLS ME TO DO IT DOES
01:11:37.994 --> 01:11:41.998 region:rollup2
NOT MEAN THAT I AM RETALIATING
01:11:39.362 --> 01:11:42.632 region:rollup2
AGAINST EMPLOYEES. BECAUSE I'M
01:11:41.998 --> 01:11:44.200 region:rollup2
NOT THERE'S NOTHING FROM YOUR
01:11:42.632 --> 01:11:45.835 region:rollup2
TELL YOU I AM FOLLOWING THE
01:11:44.200 --> 01:11:46.936 region:rollup2
INSTRUCTIONS OF MY EMPLOYER THE
01:11:45.835 --> 01:11:48.304 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER IS GOING TO BE ON THE
01:11:46.936 --> 01:11:50.106 region:rollup2
HOOK WOULD BE MY THOUGHT. BUT
01:11:48.304 --> 01:11:51.741 region:rollup2
NOT THE ACTUAL SUPERVISOR WHO
01:11:50.106 --> 01:11:53.409 region:rollup2
WAS JUST FOLLOWING WHAT THEIR
01:11:51.741 --> 01:11:54.877 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER ASKS HIM TO DO AND IT
01:11:53.409 --> 01:11:56.946 region:rollup2
WAS NOT ILLEGAL AND IT WAS NOT
01:11:54.877 --> 01:11:58.281 region:rollup2
IMMORAL BUT WE CAN CONTINUE DOWN
01:11:56.946 --> 01:11:59.649 region:rollup2
THE ROAD THAT WE HAVE BEEN GOING
01:11:58.281 --> 01:12:00.850 region:rollup2
DOWN. AND CONTINUE TO UP THE
01:11:59.649 --> 01:12:03.152 region:rollup2
NUMBER GROW MAYBE NEXT TIME
01:12:00.850 --> 01:12:04.353 region:rollup2
AROUND IT WILL BE TO AND FOUR
01:12:03.152 --> 01:12:06.489 region:rollup2
WOMEN ARE HARASSED AT WORK.
01:12:04.353 --> 01:12:09.225 region:rollup2
RETALIATION HAPPENS EVERY SINGLE
01:12:06.489 --> 01:12:11.160 region:rollup2
DAY ALL THIS BILL DOES IS SAY
01:12:09.225 --> 01:12:12.762 region:rollup2
THAT IT'S NOT O. K. AND IT GIVES
01:12:11.160 --> 01:12:14.931 region:rollup2
A PERSON BEING RETALIATED
01:12:12.762 --> 01:12:16.833 region:rollup2
AGAINST AN OPPORTUNITY. TO HAVE
01:12:14.931 --> 01:12:18.634 region:rollup2
THEIR DAY IN COURT SO TO SPEAK
01:12:16.833 --> 01:12:21.604 region:rollup2
WITHOUT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:12:18.634 --> 01:12:23.940 region:rollup2
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU BILL.
01:12:21.604 --> 01:12:26.275 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT DID. THE BILL MOTIONED A
01:12:23.940 --> 01:12:28.144 region:rollup2
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:12:26.275 --> 01:12:29.846 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATIONS.
01:12:28.144 --> 01:12:31.781 region:rollup2
WITH THAT OF MADAM SECRETARY
01:12:29.846 --> 01:12:34.116 region:rollup2
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:12:31.781 --> 01:12:37.887 region:rollup2
JACKSON HIGH JACKSON I AM MORE
01:12:34.116 --> 01:12:41.324 region:rollup2
LOCK. ANDERSON HERTZBERG.
01:12:37.887 --> 01:12:42.892 region:rollup2
MONNING. STERN.
01:12:41.324 --> 01:12:44.794 region:rollup2
STERN AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE
01:12:42.892 --> 01:12:46.562 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI AYE. PART DOCUMENTUM
01:12:44.794 --> 01:12:49.065 region:rollup2
CHAIR OF THE A BILL HAS THREE
01:12:46.562 --> 01:12:49.632 region:rollup2
VOTES AND WE'LL PLACED ON CALL I
01:12:49.065 --> 01:12:51.167 region:rollup2
THINK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:12:49.632 --> 01:12:52.435 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT.
01:12:51.167 --> 01:13:00.910 region:rollup2
WE HAVE TO BILLS BY SENATOR
01:12:52.435 --> 01:13:04.080 region:rollup2
WIENER.
01:13:00.910 --> 01:13:04.413 region:rollup2
HOW TO PRESERVE WHAT IS FOR?
01:13:04.080 --> 01:13:06.816 region:rollup2
ALL RIGHT AND.
01:13:04.413 --> 01:13:08.818 region:rollup2
.
01:13:06.816 --> 01:13:10.820 region:rollup2
LET'S START WITH THE FILE ITEM
01:13:08.818 --> 01:13:14.757 region:rollup2
TO. S. B. NINE THIRTY SEVEN.
01:13:10.820 --> 01:13:15.992 region:rollup2
LACTATION ACCOMMODATION.
01:13:14.757 --> 01:13:19.161 region:rollup2
AND I BELIEVE THERE ARE
01:13:15.992 --> 01:13:21.764 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS THAT.
01:13:19.161 --> 01:13:22.798 region:rollup2
BY THAT MEASURE ON BECAUSE OF
01:13:21.764 --> 01:13:23.866 region:rollup2
CENTER STERN IS GOOD BECAUSE
01:13:22.798 --> 01:13:25.268 region:rollup2
PRESENTING WITH ME AND YET STILL
01:13:23.866 --> 01:13:28.437 region:rollup2
LEAVES SO IF IT'S POSSIBLE TO
01:13:25.268 --> 01:13:30.172 region:rollup2
TAKE TEN FORTY FIVE FIRSTS.
01:13:28.437 --> 01:13:31.474 region:rollup2
I THINK THIS ONE IS GOING TO
01:13:30.172 --> 01:13:32.808 region:rollup2
MOVE A LITTLE QUICKER.
01:13:31.474 --> 01:13:38.180 region:rollup2
.
01:13:32.808 --> 01:13:40.483 region:rollup2
AND.
01:13:38.180 --> 01:13:45.054 region:rollup2
WELL.
01:13:40.483 --> 01:13:46.022 region:rollup2
THEY'RE CALLING THEIR DOING
01:13:45.054 --> 01:13:46.656 region:rollup2
VOTES NOT A GOOD WILL GESTURE.
01:13:46.022 --> 01:13:46.989 region:rollup2
RIGHT WELL THEN YOU'LL BE BACK
01:13:46.656 --> 01:13:48.291 region:rollup2
IN TIME FOR.
01:13:46.989 --> 01:13:50.826 region:rollup2
THEN YOU'LL BE BACK IN TIME FOR.
01:13:48.291 --> 01:13:51.961 region:rollup2
OF FILE ITEM SIX
01:13:50.826 --> 01:13:54.096 region:rollup2
IF YOU IF YOU JUST HAVE TO GO
01:13:51.961 --> 01:13:55.097 region:rollup2
VOTE THEN WILL IT'LL TAKE A FEW
01:13:54.096 --> 01:13:57.600 region:rollup2
MINUTES I'M SURE TO DO THIS AND
01:13:55.097 --> 01:13:59.435 region:rollup2
WHEN YOU COME BACK.
01:13:57.600 --> 01:14:02.338 region:rollup2
IT WILL ALLOW YOU WILL BE READY
01:13:59.435 --> 01:14:03.839 region:rollup2
TO HAVE FEW COLD PERCENT.
01:14:02.338 --> 01:14:06.909 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT SO LET'S GO AHEAD.
01:14:03.839 --> 01:14:08.377 region:rollup2
WITH FILE ITEM TO S. B. NINE
01:14:06.909 --> 01:14:09.745 region:rollup2
THIRTY SEVEN LACTATION
01:14:08.377 --> 01:14:11.681 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION.
01:14:09.745 --> 01:14:13.816 region:rollup2
I UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE
01:14:11.681 --> 01:14:14.817 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS THAT YOU WILL BE
01:14:13.816 --> 01:14:18.621 region:rollup2
TAKING.
01:14:14.817 --> 01:14:19.922 region:rollup2
ON THIS ITEM IN TRANSPORTATION
01:14:18.621 --> 01:14:21.324 region:rollup2
AND HOUSING IS THAT CORRECT.
01:14:19.922 --> 01:14:23.059 region:rollup2
THAT IS CORRECT VERY GOOD IN
01:14:21.324 --> 01:14:28.064 region:rollup2
THOSE ARE ON PAGES TWELVE
01:14:23.059 --> 01:14:29.832 region:rollup2
THROUGH FOURTEEN COMMENT NINE.
01:14:28.064 --> 01:14:31.400 region:rollup2
OKAY. VERY GOOD HER MANAGER
01:14:29.832 --> 01:14:35.304 region:rollup2
THINKS YOU'RE HEARING THIS.
01:14:31.400 --> 01:14:37.873 region:rollup2
TODAY ON MY NOTES A SECOND TIME
01:14:35.304 --> 01:14:40.042 region:rollup2
YOU LOOK AT IT THIS.
01:14:37.873 --> 01:14:41.177 region:rollup2
TOM THE COLORS LAST YEAR.
01:14:40.042 --> 01:14:42.178 region:rollup2
MY FORMER COLLEAGUE ON THE SAN
01:14:41.177 --> 01:14:43.512 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
01:14:42.178 --> 01:14:44.814 region:rollup2
KITTANNING. PA AUTHORED FIRST IN
01:14:43.512 --> 01:14:47.183 region:rollup2
THE NATION LEGISLATION TO
01:14:44.814 --> 01:14:48.217 region:rollup2
REQUIRE BY LAW THAT EMPLOYERS
01:14:47.183 --> 01:14:49.518 region:rollup2
PROVIDE SAFE AND COMFORABLE
01:14:48.217 --> 01:14:51.954 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATIONS FOR WORKING
01:14:49.518 --> 01:14:53.823 region:rollup2
MOTHERS WHO WERE BREAST FEEDING.
01:14:51.954 --> 01:14:55.291 region:rollup2
LA I AM WORKING WITH AN
01:14:53.823 --> 01:14:58.594 region:rollup2
INCREDIBLE TEAM OF ADVOCATES.
01:14:55.291 --> 01:15:00.596 region:rollup2
TO BUY HAVE A STATEWIDE POLICY
01:14:58.594 --> 01:15:01.998 region:rollup2
TO MAKE SURE FIVE THAT WAY
01:15:00.596 --> 01:15:04.834 region:rollup2
MOTHERS NEW MOTHERS WHO RETURNED
01:15:01.998 --> 01:15:06.302 region:rollup2
TO WORK. ARE ABE TO WORK.
01:15:04.834 --> 01:15:08.204 region:rollup2
AND ALSO ABLE TO LOCK TODAY OF
01:15:06.302 --> 01:15:09.638 region:rollup2
FOR THEIR CHILD FAMILY FRIENDLY
01:15:08.204 --> 01:15:11.107 region:rollup2
WORKPLACES ARE KEY.
01:15:09.638 --> 01:15:12.408 region:rollup2
TO THE HEALTH OF MOTHERS AND
01:15:11.107 --> 01:15:14.910 region:rollup2
INFANTS.
01:15:12.408 --> 01:15:16.479 region:rollup2
AS WELL AS I ACHIEVING EQUITY
01:15:14.910 --> 01:15:18.180 region:rollup2
CAUGHT BETWEEN THE GENDERS TO
01:15:16.479 --> 01:15:19.548 region:rollup2
ALSO GOOD FOR BUSINESS BOB WOMEN
01:15:18.180 --> 01:15:21.751 region:rollup2
WITHOUT A QUICK BREAK TIME AND
01:15:19.548 --> 01:15:23.019 region:rollup2
PRIVATE SPACE ARE MORE THAN.
01:15:21.751 --> 01:15:26.288 region:rollup2
TWICE AS LIKELY TO BE BREAST
01:15:23.019 --> 01:15:27.490 region:rollup2
FEEDING EXCLUSIVELY AT SIX
01:15:26.288 --> 01:15:28.391 region:rollup2
MONTHS
01:15:27.490 --> 01:15:29.525 region:rollup2
SO COMPARED TO WOMEN WITHOUT THE
01:15:28.391 --> 01:15:30.559 region:rollup2
SUPPORT. INADEQUATE
01:15:29.525 --> 01:15:31.961 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATIONS FOR BREASTFEEDING
01:15:30.559 --> 01:15:32.962 region:rollup2
MOTHERS OFTEN LEADS TO A MOTHER
01:15:31.961 --> 01:15:35.131 region:rollup2
HAVING T MAKE A DIFFICULT
01:15:32.962 --> 01:15:37.266 region:rollup2
CHOICE BETWEEN RETURNING TO WORK
01:15:35.131 --> 01:15:38.834 region:rollup2
AND NOT BREASTFEEDING OR
01:15:37.266 --> 01:15:41.837 region:rollup2
RESTORED DELAYING A RETURN TO
01:15:38.834 --> 01:15:43.873 region:rollup2
WORK. IN ORDER TO BREAST FEED
01:15:41.837 --> 01:15:45.875 region:rollup2
FELT SO SIGNIFICANT DIE IMPACTS
01:15:43.873 --> 01:15:47.510 region:rollup2
FINANCIALLY BECAUSE FORMULA IS
01:15:45.875 --> 01:15:48.878 region:rollup2
EXPENSIVE.
01:15:47.510 --> 01:15:51.013 region:rollup2
BOB LOWER INCOME MOTHERS ARE HIT
01:15:48.878 --> 01:15:52.214 region:rollup2
THE HARDEST A WITH ITS DIFFICULT
01:15:51.013 --> 01:15:52.782 region:rollup2
CHOICE BETWEEN PAY.
01:15:52.214 --> 01:15:55.351 region:rollup2
AND.
01:15:52.782 --> 01:15:57.920 region:rollup2
ADEQUATE NUTRITION FOR A CHILD.
01:15:55.351 --> 01:15:59.088 region:rollup2
AND PURCHASING FORMULA THOUGHT
01:15:57.920 --> 01:16:00.389 region:rollup2
THIS BILL WILL EASE THE
01:15:59.088 --> 01:16:03.392 region:rollup2
TRANSITION FROM OTHERS GOING
01:16:00.389 --> 01:16:05.061 region:rollup2
BACK TO WORK WHILE CONTINUING
01:16:03.392 --> 01:16:06.128 region:rollup2
BUT TO HAVE A WORK LIFE BALANCE.
01:16:05.061 --> 01:16:06.595 region:rollup2
THOUGHT AND PLAYERS WILL BE ABLE
01:16:06.128 --> 01:16:09.031 region:rollup2
TO RETAIN HOT TALENTED
01:16:06.595 --> 01:16:11.167 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES.
01:16:09.031 --> 01:16:13.369 region:rollup2
HI THIS IS AN IMPORTANT POLICY
01:16:11.167 --> 01:16:14.537 region:rollup2
AND AND WE FOR TO THE BROAD
01:16:13.369 --> 01:16:16.105 region:rollup2
STAKEHOLDER GROUP THOUGHT TO PUT
01:16:14.537 --> 01:16:17.339 region:rollup2
IT TOGETHER.
01:16:16.105 --> 01:16:19.442 region:rollup2
VIS A BILL.
01:16:17.339 --> 01:16:22.211 region:rollup2
WILL REQUIRE.
01:16:19.442 --> 01:16:24.280 region:rollup2
INDICTMENTS LAWYERS SET ASIDE
01:16:22.211 --> 01:16:26.315 region:rollup2
PRIVATE SPACE IT'S APPROPRIATE
01:16:24.280 --> 01:16:28.250 region:rollup2
FOR LACTATION INCLUDING WITH A A
01:16:26.315 --> 01:16:29.852 region:rollup2
TABLE AND A CHAIR.
01:16:28.250 --> 01:16:31.053 region:rollup2
YEAH I WILL NEED TO BE PRIVATE
01:16:29.852 --> 01:16:32.488 region:rollup2
THERE WE NEED TO BE.
01:16:31.053 --> 01:16:33.656 region:rollup2
REFRIGERATOR.
01:16:32.488 --> 01:16:36.659 region:rollup2
CLOSE BY.
01:16:33.656 --> 01:16:38.294 region:rollup2
AND RUNNING WATER ARE CLOSE BY
01:16:36.659 --> 01:16:39.795 region:rollup2
IT WILL REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT
01:16:38.294 --> 01:16:41.797 region:rollup2
OF LABOR STANDARDS ENFORCEMENT.
01:16:39.795 --> 01:16:43.499 region:rollup2
TO ESTABLISH BEST PRACTICES ARE
01:16:41.797 --> 01:16:45.601 region:rollup2
OPTIONAL VOLUNTARY BEST
01:16:43.499 --> 01:16:48.737 region:rollup2
PRACTICES CONFRONTATION IN THE
01:16:45.601 --> 01:16:52.708 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE A SO THAT OUR BUSINESS
01:16:48.737 --> 01:16:53.042 region:rollup2
CAN HAVE MY GUIDANCE. ON
01:16:52.708 --> 01:16:54.477 region:rollup2
THE.
01:16:53.042 --> 01:16:55.344 region:rollup2
THE BILL ALLOWS MULTI TENANT
01:16:54.477 --> 01:16:56.612 region:rollup2
BUILDINGS TO SHARE LACTATION
01:16:55.344 --> 01:16:57.546 region:rollup2
SPACE IN THIS IS PARTICULARLY
01:16:56.612 --> 01:16:58.914 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT FOR SMALL RETAIL. AUTO
01:16:57.546 --> 01:17:00.583 region:rollup2
SHOPS
01:16:58.914 --> 01:17:02.418 region:rollup2
THE BILL IS VERY FLEXIBLE IN
01:17:00.583 --> 01:17:03.853 region:rollup2
TERMS OF WHAT THE SPACES I AM
01:17:02.418 --> 01:17:05.321 region:rollup2
SMALLER SPACE IT MIGHT NOT BE A
01:17:03.853 --> 01:17:07.923 region:rollup2
SEPARATE ROOM AND MIGHT BE.
01:17:05.321 --> 01:17:10.259 region:rollup2
REMOVABLE BARRIERS THAT CAN BE
01:17:07.923 --> 01:17:11.427 region:rollup2
SET UP AND TAKEN DOWN WE PROVIDE
01:17:10.259 --> 01:17:12.995 region:rollup2
A LOT OF FLEXIBILITY.
01:17:11.427 --> 01:17:15.164 region:rollup2
AND WE ALSO PROVIDE A HARDSHIP
01:17:12.995 --> 01:17:16.632 region:rollup2
EXEMPTION OF FOR THE SMALLEST
01:17:15.164 --> 01:17:18.067 region:rollup2
I'M NEVER BUSINESSES THE BILL
01:17:16.632 --> 01:17:18.601 region:rollup2
ALSO REQUIRES THE CALIFORNIA
01:17:18.067 --> 01:17:20.436 region:rollup2
BUILDING CODE IN THE NEXT
01:17:18.601 --> 01:17:21.737 region:rollup2
UPDATE.
01:17:20.436 --> 01:17:22.071 region:rollup2
OUGHT TO INCLUDE PROVISION FOR
01:17:21.737 --> 01:17:24.406 region:rollup2
AND.
01:17:22.071 --> 01:17:25.941 region:rollup2
INCLUDING NEW LACTATION SPACES
01:17:24.406 --> 01:17:27.109 region:rollup2
AND BUILDINGS OVER FIFTEEN
01:17:25.941 --> 01:17:29.545 region:rollup2
THOUSAND SQUARE FEET.
01:17:27.109 --> 01:17:31.213 region:rollup2
AS A CONDITION OF APPROVAL OF
01:17:29.545 --> 01:17:32.948 region:rollup2
THE BUILDING PERMIT.
01:17:31.213 --> 01:17:34.250 region:rollup2
SIMILAR TO HELP BUILDING COULD
01:17:32.948 --> 01:17:37.052 region:rollup2
ST DISABILITY ACCESS.
01:17:34.250 --> 01:17:38.754 region:rollup2
AND AL LINES ARE ENFORCEMENT
01:17:37.052 --> 01:17:40.289 region:rollup2
MECHANISM BOTH STOP PRIVATE
01:17:38.754 --> 01:17:40.956 region:rollup2
RIGHT OF ACTION THOUGHT AS WELL
01:17:40.289 --> 01:17:42.324 region:rollup2
AS.
01:17:40.956 --> 01:17:43.859 region:rollup2
ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLAINT
01:17:42.324 --> 01:17:46.195 region:rollup2
PROCESS.
01:17:43.859 --> 01:17:47.129 region:rollup2
SO COLLEAGUES I RESPECTFULLY
01:17:46.195 --> 01:17:50.833 region:rollup2
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
01:17:47.129 --> 01:17:51.800 region:rollup2
AND. WITH ME HERE TODAY IS A
01:17:50.833 --> 01:17:53.769 region:rollup2
DOCTOR ELEANOR SCHWARTZ.
01:17:51.800 --> 01:17:54.436 region:rollup2
.
01:17:53.769 --> 01:17:55.838 region:rollup2
AND.
01:17:54.436 --> 01:17:56.472 region:rollup2
ROBBIE GONZALEZ TALCUM THE
01:17:55.838 --> 01:17:59.341 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA.
01:17:56.472 --> 01:18:00.776 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING COALITION AND.
01:17:59.341 --> 01:18:03.779 region:rollup2
JENNA JERRY FROM THE WAY TO
01:18:00.776 --> 01:18:05.214 region:rollup2
WORK.
01:18:03.779 --> 01:18:06.549 region:rollup2
THANK YOU SENATOR WINNER GOOD
01:18:05.214 --> 01:18:08.350 region:rollup2
AFTERNOON AND I AM GOING TO
01:18:06.549 --> 01:18:09.718 region:rollup2
START HOLDING US TO TWO MINUTES
01:18:08.350 --> 01:18:11.887 region:rollup2
FOR EACH WITNESSES TO MENDOCINE.
01:18:09.718 --> 01:18:13.122 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
01:18:11.887 --> 01:18:14.290 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS I'M
01:18:13.122 --> 01:18:15.257 region:rollup2
ROBBIE GONZALEZ STYLE WITH THE
01:18:14.290 --> 01:18:17.359 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA BREASTFEEDING
01:18:15.257 --> 01:18:19.461 region:rollup2
COALITION AND WE'RE PLEASED TO
01:18:17.359 --> 01:18:21.530 region:rollup2
BE CO SPONSORS OF S. B. NINE
01:18:19.461 --> 01:18:22.998 region:rollup2
THREE SEVEN. CALIFORNIA REALLY
01:18:21.530 --> 01:18:24.533 region:rollup2
IS LEADING THE NATION IN
01:18:22.998 --> 01:18:27.169 region:rollup2
REMOVING BARRIERS TO BREAST
01:18:24.533 --> 01:18:28.971 region:rollup2
FEEDING. IN CALIFORNIA AND IN
01:18:27.169 --> 01:18:30.472 region:rollup2
TWENTY THIRTEEN WE PASSED THE
01:18:28.971 --> 01:18:31.040 region:rollup2
TEN STEPS TO SUCCESSFUL
01:18:30.472 --> 01:18:33.275 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING AND HOSPITALS.
01:18:31.040 --> 01:18:35.811 region:rollup2
AND.
01:18:33.275 --> 01:18:37.746 region:rollup2
OF THAT RESULTED IN SUPPORTING
01:18:35.811 --> 01:18:39.114 region:rollup2
PARENTS TO BREASTFEED EARLY. AND
01:18:37.746 --> 01:18:41.417 region:rollup2
MOST PARENTS DO WANT TO
01:18:39.114 --> 01:18:42.751 region:rollup2
BREASTFEED IN FACT MOST TO DO
01:18:41.417 --> 01:18:44.853 region:rollup2
BREAST BEGIN TO BREASTFEED
01:18:42.751 --> 01:18:46.822 region:rollup2
IMMEDIATELY AFTER BIRTH HOWEVER
01:18:44.853 --> 01:18:49.291 region:rollup2
AT SIX MONTHS POSTPARTUM. TWENTY
01:18:46.822 --> 01:18:51.126 region:rollup2
FOUR POINT EIGHT PERCENT ARE
01:18:49.291 --> 01:18:52.494 region:rollup2
EXCLUSIVELY BREASTFEEDING. AND
01:18:51.126 --> 01:18:55.064 region:rollup2
THIS IS OF GREAT CONCERN TO US
01:18:52.494 --> 01:18:55.831 region:rollup2
BECAUSE ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
01:18:55.064 --> 01:18:58.567 region:rollup2
RECOMMENDS.
01:18:55.831 --> 01:19:00.536 region:rollup2
THAT INFANTS BE FRED ONLY BREAST
01:18:58.567 --> 01:19:02.638 region:rollup2
MILK FOR THE FIRST SIX MONTHS IN
01:19:00.536 --> 01:19:04.306 region:rollup2
AT LEAST TWO YEAR AS SOLIDS ARE
01:19:02.638 --> 01:19:06.075 region:rollup2
ADDED TO THE INFANTS DIET. BUT
01:19:04.306 --> 01:19:07.810 region:rollup2
PARENTS ARE STRUGGLING TO MEET
01:19:06.075 --> 01:19:09.111 region:rollup2
THIS RECOMMENDATION BECAUSE THEY
01:19:07.810 --> 01:19:11.180 region:rollup2
FACE BARRIERS TO CONTINUE
01:19:09.111 --> 01:19:12.982 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING WHEN THEY RETURN
01:19:11.180 --> 01:19:14.550 region:rollup2
TO WORK AND MOMS WITH THE LOWER
01:19:12.982 --> 01:19:16.685 region:rollup2
HOUSEHOLDS.
01:19:14.550 --> 01:19:18.854 region:rollup2
LOWER HOUSEHOLD INCOME ARE LESS
01:19:16.685 --> 01:19:20.389 region:rollup2
LIKELY TO HAVE WORKPLACE
01:19:18.854 --> 01:19:22.558 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING SUPPORT THAN THOSE
01:19:20.389 --> 01:19:23.659 region:rollup2
WITH HIGHER INCOME.
01:19:22.558 --> 01:19:25.728 region:rollup2
AND THE GREAT THING ABOUT US
01:19:23.659 --> 01:19:27.830 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER SUPPORTING THE NEEDS OF
01:19:25.728 --> 01:19:29.265 region:rollup2
LACTATING PARENTS IS THAT IT'S
01:19:27.830 --> 01:19:31.200 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATED WITH BOTTOM LINE
01:19:29.265 --> 01:19:32.301 region:rollup2
BENEFITS FOR EMPLOYERS SUCH AS A
01:19:31.200 --> 01:19:34.903 region:rollup2
THREE TO ONE RETURN ON
01:19:32.301 --> 01:19:36.872 region:rollup2
INVESTMENT. LOWER ABSENTEEISM
01:19:34.903 --> 01:19:38.407 region:rollup2
RATES LOWER INSURANCE CLAIMS FOR
01:19:36.872 --> 01:19:40.509 region:rollup2
BUSINESSES.
01:19:38.407 --> 01:19:42.144 region:rollup2
HELPS RETAIN AND RECRUIT GOOD
01:19:40.509 --> 01:19:44.480 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES AND IMPROVES
01:19:42.144 --> 01:19:46.682 region:rollup2
PRODUCTIVITY BUILDS EMPLOYEE
01:19:44.480 --> 01:19:48.384 region:rollup2
MORALE AND LOYALTY.
01:19:46.682 --> 01:19:52.054 region:rollup2
AND I'VE SEEN THIS FIRSTHAND I
01:19:48.384 --> 01:19:52.054 region:rollup2
WORK IN THE CENTRAL COAST AND
01:19:52.121 --> 01:19:55.391 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS THE AGRICULTURE.
01:19:53.756 --> 01:19:57.326 region:rollup2
INDUSTRY.
01:19:55.391 --> 01:19:59.161 region:rollup2
CREATE WORKPLACE POLICY AND IN
01:19:57.326 --> 01:20:00.896 region:rollup2
TRAINED THE SUPERVISORS TO
01:19:59.161 --> 01:20:02.665 region:rollup2
SUPPORT WOMEN TO PUMP IN THE
01:20:00.896 --> 01:20:04.199 region:rollup2
FIELDS AND IF WE CAN SUPPORT
01:20:02.665 --> 01:20:06.635 region:rollup2
WOMEN IN THE FIELDS.
01:20:04.199 --> 01:20:08.570 region:rollup2
WE CAN REALLY ANY WORK PLACE TO
01:20:06.635 --> 01:20:09.505 region:rollup2
BE ABLE TO SUPPORT WOMEN WITH
01:20:08.570 --> 01:20:11.206 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATIONS TO EXPRESS MILK
01:20:09.505 --> 01:20:12.541 region:rollup2
AT WORK.
01:20:11.206 --> 01:20:14.443 region:rollup2
POLICY REALLY DOES MAKE A
01:20:12.541 --> 01:20:15.944 region:rollup2
DIFFERENCE IN INSURERS THAT
01:20:14.443 --> 01:20:17.613 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES HAVE ACCESS TO
01:20:15.944 --> 01:20:19.782 region:rollup2
CONSISTENT SUPPORT. IN THE
01:20:17.613 --> 01:20:21.583 region:rollup2
POLICY HELPS CLEARLY DEFINE THE
01:20:19.782 --> 01:20:23.952 region:rollup2
ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES FOR
01:20:21.583 --> 01:20:24.486 region:rollup2
BOTH SUPERVISORS AND EMPLOYEES
01:20:23.952 --> 01:20:25.854 region:rollup2
AND I'VE BEEN TOLD BY MANY
01:20:24.486 --> 01:20:27.623 region:rollup2
WOMEN.
01:20:25.854 --> 01:20:28.991 region:rollup2
THAT IF THEY HADN'T HAD THE
01:20:27.623 --> 01:20:30.559 region:rollup2
SUPPORT THEY WOULDN'T OF
01:20:28.991 --> 01:20:32.528 region:rollup2
RETURNED AS EARLY AS THEY DID.
01:20:30.559 --> 01:20:33.996 region:rollup2
ONE MOM TOLD ME THAT SHE WOULD
01:20:32.528 --> 01:20:35.364 region:rollup2
HAVE STAYED HOME AND THEN
01:20:33.996 --> 01:20:37.599 region:rollup2
RETURNED THE NEXT HARVEST SCENES
01:20:35.364 --> 01:20:39.468 region:rollup2
SEASON. BUT SHE WITH INSTEAD SHE
01:20:37.599 --> 01:20:40.803 region:rollup2
WAS ABLE TO RETURN TO WORK SHE
01:20:39.468 --> 01:20:42.004 region:rollup2
MET HER BREASTFEEDING GOALS AND
01:20:40.803 --> 01:20:43.972 region:rollup2
SHE HAS.
01:20:42.004 --> 01:20:45.841 region:rollup2
INCOME THANK YOU.
01:20:43.972 --> 01:20:47.543 region:rollup2
THANKS VERY MUCH OKAY NEXT
01:20:45.841 --> 01:20:49.178 region:rollup2
WITNESS AG AFTERNOON THANK YOU
01:20:47.543 --> 01:20:50.979 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR. MY NAME IS JENNY
01:20:49.178 --> 01:20:52.181 region:rollup2
GARRY NAM ATTORNEY WITH LEGAL
01:20:50.979 --> 01:20:54.116 region:rollup2
AID AT WORK WHERE NONPROFIT
01:20:52.181 --> 01:20:54.583 region:rollup2
ADVOCATES ON BEHALF OF LOW
01:20:54.116 --> 01:20:55.851 region:rollup2
INCOME WORKERS ACROSS
01:20:54.583 --> 01:20:58.220 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA.
01:20:55.851 --> 01:20:59.688 region:rollup2
SIMPLY PUT SB NINE THIRTY SEVEN
01:20:58.220 --> 01:21:01.890 region:rollup2
WILSHIRE ALL LIFE LACTATING
01:20:59.688 --> 01:21:03.559 region:rollup2
PARENTS ARE ABLE TO MEET THE
01:21:01.890 --> 01:21:05.928 region:rollup2
MOST BASIC NEEDS OF THEIR CHILD.
01:21:03.559 --> 01:21:07.696 region:rollup2
PROVIDING FOOD ILLEGALLY TO WORK
01:21:05.928 --> 01:21:09.465 region:rollup2
WE HEAR FROM FAR TOO MANY
01:21:07.696 --> 01:21:11.166 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES WHO'VE LACK ADEQUATE
01:21:09.465 --> 01:21:13.068 region:rollup2
SUPPORT WITHIN THE WORKPLACE TO
01:21:11.166 --> 01:21:14.570 region:rollup2
EXPRESS MILK. FOR EXAMPLE WHEN A
01:21:13.068 --> 01:21:16.405 region:rollup2
QUICKLY SHARE ONE STORY OF OUR
01:21:14.570 --> 01:21:18.006 region:rollup2
CLIENT TARA TARA WAS A WAITRESS
01:21:16.405 --> 01:21:19.007 region:rollup2
AT A RESTAURANT.
01:21:18.006 --> 01:21:21.310 region:rollup2
WHEN SHE GAVE BIRTH TO HER FIRST
01:21:19.007 --> 01:21:21.844 region:rollup2
CHILD SHE RETURNED AND HOPE TO
01:21:21.310 --> 01:21:22.778 region:rollup2
CONTINUE TO BREASTFEED HER
01:21:21.844 --> 01:21:24.913 region:rollup2
CHILD.
01:21:22.778 --> 01:21:26.482 region:rollup2
UNFORTUNATELY THE ONLY OPTION
01:21:24.913 --> 01:21:28.817 region:rollup2
SHE WAS GIVEN WAS TO PRESS TO
01:21:26.482 --> 01:21:30.152 region:rollup2
PUMP IN THE BASEMENT THAT WAS
01:21:28.817 --> 01:21:31.653 region:rollup2
DIRTY THAT DIDN'T HAVE
01:21:30.152 --> 01:21:33.455 region:rollup2
ELECTRICITY AND SHE HAD TO STAND
01:21:31.653 --> 01:21:34.556 region:rollup2
UP TO PUMP.
01:21:33.455 --> 01:21:37.126 region:rollup2
THAT'S WITH INSUFFICIENT AND SHE
01:21:34.556 --> 01:21:37.726 region:rollup2
COULDN'T CONTINUE TO WORK AND
01:21:37.126 --> 01:21:39.828 region:rollup2
CONTINUE TO BREAST FEED HER
01:21:37.726 --> 01:21:41.597 region:rollup2
CHILD. NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO
01:21:39.828 --> 01:21:44.299 region:rollup2
MAKE THAT DECISION THAT DECISION
01:21:41.597 --> 01:21:45.000 region:rollup2
IS PERSONAL AND EVERY PERSON TO
01:21:44.299 --> 01:21:46.401 region:rollup2
GET THE SUPPORT THEY NEED IN THE
01:21:45.000 --> 01:21:47.836 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE SO THEY CAN CONTINUE
01:21:46.401 --> 01:21:48.871 region:rollup2
TO WORK AND CONTINUE TO FEED
01:21:47.836 --> 01:21:50.272 region:rollup2
THEIR CHILD.
01:21:48.871 --> 01:21:52.541 region:rollup2
FOR THESE REASONS WE ASK FOR
01:21:50.272 --> 01:21:54.376 region:rollup2
YOUR SUPPORT AND FOR YOUR AYE
01:21:52.541 --> 01:21:56.645 region:rollup2
VOTE THANK YOU. VERY MUCH
01:21:54.376 --> 01:21:58.080 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT PLEASE.
01:21:56.645 --> 01:21:58.947 region:rollup2
I'M DOCTOR ELEANOR SCHWARTZ FROM
01:21:58.080 --> 01:21:59.915 region:rollup2
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
01:21:58.947 --> 01:22:01.550 region:rollup2
DAVIS I'M A PROFESSOR OF
01:21:59.915 --> 01:22:03.085 region:rollup2
MEDICINE WHO SPECIALIZES IN
01:22:01.550 --> 01:22:04.419 region:rollup2
WOMEN'S HEALTH. I WANTED TO JUST
01:22:03.085 --> 01:22:05.854 region:rollup2
HIGHLIGHT THE WAYS IN WHICH
01:22:04.419 --> 01:22:08.257 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING HELPS WOMEN
01:22:05.854 --> 01:22:09.425 region:rollup2
RECOVER FROM PREGNANCY HAS VERY
01:22:08.257 --> 01:22:10.959 region:rollup2
LARGE LONG TERM EFFECTS ON
01:22:09.425 --> 01:22:13.195 region:rollup2
WOMEN'S HEALTH SO. DECREASING
01:22:10.959 --> 01:22:14.663 region:rollup2
RISK OF BREAST CANCER AND HEART
01:22:13.195 --> 01:22:16.431 region:rollup2
DISEASE THESE ARE LONG TERM
01:22:14.663 --> 01:22:18.066 region:rollup2
EFFECTS THAT HAVE. IMPACTS ON
01:22:16.431 --> 01:22:19.568 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS BOTTOM LINE SO I
01:22:18.066 --> 01:22:20.469 region:rollup2
HIGHLY SUPPORT THIS IS WELL
01:22:19.568 --> 01:22:22.304 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF THE
01:22:20.469 --> 01:22:23.505 region:rollup2
WITNESS'S NAME AFFILIATION ONLY
01:22:22.304 --> 01:22:24.973 region:rollup2
PLEASE THINK ABOUT CHAIR ALICE
01:22:23.505 --> 01:22:26.275 region:rollup2
KESSLER BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN
01:22:24.973 --> 01:22:27.843 region:rollup2
COLLEGE OF OBSTETRICIANS
01:22:26.275 --> 01:22:28.710 region:rollup2
GYNECOLOGISTS SHOULD NINE WITH
01:22:27.843 --> 01:22:31.013 region:rollup2
THE AMENDMENTS REFERENCE WERE
01:22:28.710 --> 01:22:33.215 region:rollup2
MOVING TO A SUPPORT POSITION.
01:22:31.013 --> 01:22:34.016 region:rollup2
THINK EXCELLENT THANK YOU.
01:22:33.215 --> 01:22:34.917 region:rollup2
VERY GOOD A SHOWER WITH THE
01:22:34.016 --> 01:22:38.554 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS
01:22:34.917 --> 01:22:39.388 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THINKING.
01:22:38.554 --> 01:22:40.856 region:rollup2
CATHERINE OF ARAGON ON BEHALF OF
01:22:39.388 --> 01:22:42.791 region:rollup2
FIRST FIVE CALIFORNIA IN STRONG
01:22:40.856 --> 01:22:44.359 region:rollup2
SUPPORT. BIG YOU.
01:22:42.791 --> 01:22:46.895 region:rollup2
BRIAN HOW WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:22:44.359 --> 01:22:48.530 region:rollup2
FEDERATION OF TEACHERS WERE ITS
01:22:46.895 --> 01:22:49.531 region:rollup2
OWN SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
01:22:48.530 --> 01:22:51.233 region:rollup2
KAREN LAYING ON BEHALF OF THE
01:22:49.531 --> 01:22:52.568 region:rollup2
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
01:22:51.233 --> 01:22:54.169 region:rollup2
AND MARK MAYOR MARK FOR ON
01:22:52.568 --> 01:22:55.170 region:rollup2
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:22:54.169 --> 01:22:56.405 region:rollup2
JESSICA STUNNER ON BEHALF OF
01:22:55.170 --> 01:22:57.940 region:rollup2
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES AND
01:22:56.405 --> 01:22:59.007 region:rollup2
STRONGER CALIFORNIA ADVOCATES
01:22:57.940 --> 01:23:00.909 region:rollup2
NETWORK IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
01:22:59.007 --> 01:23:02.044 region:rollup2
VERY MUCH.
01:23:00.909 --> 01:23:03.545 region:rollup2
JACKIE ST ON BEHALF OF THE
01:23:02.044 --> 01:23:06.448 region:rollup2
CONSUMER ATTORNEYS OF CALIFORNIA
01:23:03.545 --> 01:23:07.616 region:rollup2
AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:23:06.448 --> 01:23:08.917 region:rollup2
ANSWER KEVIN PEAK OF AMERICAN
01:23:07.616 --> 01:23:10.319 region:rollup2
CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF
01:23:08.917 --> 01:23:12.488 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ALSO INSTRUCTS PART.
01:23:10.319 --> 01:23:14.523 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY OTHER
01:23:12.488 --> 01:23:26.068 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
01:23:14.523 --> 01:23:27.569 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
01:23:26.068 --> 01:23:28.170 region:rollup2
I GOOD AFTERNOON MY
01:23:27.569 --> 01:23:29.271 region:rollup2
DEFINITIVAMENTE THANK YOU SO
01:23:28.170 --> 01:23:30.439 region:rollup2
MUCH FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
01:23:29.271 --> 01:23:31.807 region:rollup2
TESTIFIED TODAY MY NAME'S LAURA
01:23:30.439 --> 01:23:32.708 region:rollup2
CURTIS AND I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF
01:23:31.807 --> 01:23:34.443 region:rollup2
THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
01:23:32.708 --> 01:23:35.611 region:rollup2
COMMERCE. AND WE ARE IN A
01:23:34.443 --> 01:23:37.579 region:rollup2
PROPOSAL MUST AMENDED POSITION
01:23:35.611 --> 01:23:38.480 region:rollup2
WITH S. B. NINE THIRTY SEVEN WE
01:23:37.579 --> 01:23:39.915 region:rollup2
DO WANT TO THANK THE AUTHORS
01:23:38.480 --> 01:23:41.750 region:rollup2
OFFICE THEY'VE BEEN WONDERFUL TO
01:23:39.915 --> 01:23:43.051 region:rollup2
WORK WITH US ON HAN POTENTIAL
01:23:41.750 --> 01:23:44.686 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS AND LANGUAGE AND
01:23:43.051 --> 01:23:46.188 region:rollup2
DISCUSSING OUR CONCERNS. AND
01:23:44.686 --> 01:23:47.589 region:rollup2
THEY'VE GIVEN US LOTS OF TIMES
01:23:46.188 --> 01:23:49.458 region:rollup2
WE GREATLY APPRECIATE THAT I'M A
01:23:47.589 --> 01:23:51.660 region:rollup2
FEW THINGS THAT AS THE LANGUAGE
01:23:49.458 --> 01:23:52.995 region:rollup2
IS CURRENTLY DRAFTED AND AND IS
01:23:51.660 --> 01:23:55.097 region:rollup2
THAT THERE ARE FEDERAL
01:23:52.995 --> 01:23:55.530 region:rollup2
PROTECTIONS FOR AND EMPLOYEES
01:23:55.097 --> 01:23:56.865 region:rollup2
REGARDING LACTATION
01:23:55.530 --> 01:23:58.433 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION. WE WOULD LIKE
01:23:56.865 --> 01:23:59.968 region:rollup2
THIS TO BE AND THE SAME AS THE
01:23:58.433 --> 01:24:01.470 region:rollup2
FEDERAL REGULATIONS SO THE
01:23:59.968 --> 01:24:03.272 region:rollup2
HARDSHIP EXEMPTION FOR SHOULD
01:24:01.470 --> 01:24:04.606 region:rollup2
COMPLY WITH FEDERAL AND AS OF
01:24:03.272 --> 01:24:05.908 region:rollup2
RIGHT NOW IT SAID PROVIDES A
01:24:04.606 --> 01:24:06.875 region:rollup2
SEPARATE HARDSHIP EXEMPTION WE
01:24:05.908 --> 01:24:08.010 region:rollup2
FEEL THAT IT SHOULD BE THE SAME
01:24:06.875 --> 01:24:09.077 region:rollup2
AS FEDERAL HARDSHIP EXEMPTION.
01:24:08.010 --> 01:24:10.112 region:rollup2
OFFICIALLY THEIR SPECIFIC
01:24:09.077 --> 01:24:10.946 region:rollup2
PROVISIONS IN THE BILL THESE
01:24:10.112 --> 01:24:12.814 region:rollup2
MIGHT HAVE BEEN.
01:24:10.946 --> 01:24:14.316 region:rollup2
STRUCK A STRICKEN I APOLOGIZE
01:24:12.814 --> 01:24:15.417 region:rollup2
IF THEY HAVE BUT AS FAR AS THE
01:24:14.316 --> 01:24:16.985 region:rollup2
TICKET THE SMALL NOTICE
01:24:15.417 --> 01:24:18.520 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS AND THE.
01:24:16.985 --> 01:24:20.088 region:rollup2
RESPONSE REQUIREMENTS AND
01:24:18.520 --> 01:24:21.223 region:rollup2
DOCUMENT RETENTION REQUIREMENTS
01:24:20.088 --> 01:24:22.057 region:rollup2
THERE'S A FIVE DAY NOTICE
01:24:21.223 --> 01:24:23.992 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENT FOR AN EMPLOYEE TO
01:24:22.057 --> 01:24:24.860 region:rollup2
RESPOND AND AGAIN THIS IS
01:24:23.992 --> 01:24:26.728 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT.
01:24:24.860 --> 01:24:27.829 region:rollup2
IF THE EMPLOYEE OR IF THE
01:24:26.728 --> 01:24:29.131 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER PROVIDES A REASONABLE
01:24:27.829 --> 01:24:31.433 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION THEN.
01:24:29.131 --> 01:24:32.367 region:rollup2
THEY EMPLOYER COULD STILL BE ON
01:24:31.433 --> 01:24:33.802 region:rollup2
THE HOOK FOR THAT THE THREE YEAR
01:24:32.367 --> 01:24:35.137 region:rollup2
DOCUMENTATION REQUIREMENTS AS
01:24:33.802 --> 01:24:36.405 region:rollup2
WELL AS SOMETHING THAT IF THE
01:24:35.137 --> 01:24:37.005 region:rollup2
AMP EVEN IF THE EMPLOYER
01:24:36.405 --> 01:24:37.906 region:rollup2
PROVIDES A REASONABLE
01:24:37.005 --> 01:24:39.408 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION.
01:24:37.906 --> 01:24:41.009 region:rollup2
FOR THE EMPLOYEE THEY COULD
01:24:39.408 --> 01:24:42.110 region:rollup2
STILL BE LIABLE FOR NOT
01:24:41.009 --> 01:24:43.312 region:rollup2
RETAINING THE DOCUMENTS FOR
01:24:42.110 --> 01:24:44.279 region:rollup2
THREE YEARS AT THAT WERE TO COME
01:24:43.312 --> 01:24:45.614 region:rollup2
UP IN A SEPARATE LITIGATION
01:24:44.279 --> 01:24:47.616 region:rollup2
MATTER AND SO THERE'S CONCERNS
01:24:45.614 --> 01:24:48.450 region:rollup2
THERE WITH THAT. ADDITIONALLY
01:24:47.616 --> 01:24:50.385 region:rollup2
AND FEE HARDY PROTECTS
01:24:48.450 --> 01:24:51.720 region:rollup2
RETALIATION FOR HER AND
01:24:50.385 --> 01:24:52.988 region:rollup2
BREASTFEEDING AND SO WE FEEL
01:24:51.720 --> 01:24:54.156 region:rollup2
THAT THESE PROVISIONS WOULD BE
01:24:52.988 --> 01:24:55.257 region:rollup2
BETTER SUITED IN THE FAIR
01:24:54.156 --> 01:24:57.225 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT HOUSING ACT
01:24:55.257 --> 01:24:58.593 region:rollup2
REGULATIONS. AND FINALLY AND
01:24:57.225 --> 01:25:00.829 region:rollup2
THERE ARE A BEST PRACTICE
01:24:58.593 --> 01:25:01.730 region:rollup2
PROVISIONS STATED IN THIS BILL
01:25:00.829 --> 01:25:04.032 region:rollup2
HOME WEEKEND FEEL THE BEST
01:25:01.730 --> 01:25:05.434 region:rollup2
PRACTICES A WITHIN THE STATUTE
01:25:04.032 --> 01:25:06.868 region:rollup2
WOULD PRESENT WOULD PROVIDE THE
01:25:05.434 --> 01:25:07.436 region:rollup2
PRESUMPTION THAT AN EMPLOYER IS
01:25:06.868 --> 01:25:08.904 region:rollup2
NOT.
01:25:07.436 --> 01:25:10.205 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATING APPROPRIATELY
01:25:08.904 --> 01:25:11.340 region:rollup2
SPECIFICALLY THE BEST PRACTICES
01:25:10.205 --> 01:25:12.574 region:rollup2
SAY THAT THERE SHOULD BE A
01:25:11.340 --> 01:25:13.642 region:rollup2
MICROWAVE AND THINGS LIKE THAT
01:25:12.574 --> 01:25:15.010 region:rollup2
IF THAT'S IN THE STATUTE WERE
01:25:13.642 --> 01:25:15.811 region:rollup2
AFRAID THAT THAT WOULD BE USED
01:25:15.010 --> 01:25:17.679 region:rollup2
AS EVIDENCE AGAINST EMPLOYER
01:25:15.811 --> 01:25:18.947 region:rollup2
LATER ON. THAT THEY DO NOT
01:25:17.679 --> 01:25:21.116 region:rollup2
PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE.
01:25:18.947 --> 01:25:22.751 region:rollup2
FABRIC OR HAD ADEQUATE
01:25:21.116 --> 01:25:27.356 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION AND WE FEEL THAT
01:25:22.751 --> 01:25:28.290 region:rollup2
THOSE KIND OF BEST PRACTICES
01:25:27.356 --> 01:25:29.624 region:rollup2
WILL BE BETTER STUDENT BAHA.
01:25:28.290 --> 01:25:30.759 region:rollup2
YOU VERY MUCH OTHER WITNESSES IN
01:25:29.624 --> 01:25:31.927 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION HUSAM CHAIR CHRIS
01:25:30.759 --> 01:25:32.527 region:rollup2
MCKINLEY THAT CALIFORNIA BUILDS
01:25:31.927 --> 01:25:32.694 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION YOU DID HEAR SOME
01:25:32.527 --> 01:25:33.595 region:rollup2
OF.
01:25:32.694 --> 01:25:35.864 region:rollup2
OUR COMMENTS LAST WEEK IN THE
01:25:33.595 --> 01:25:37.766 region:rollup2
SENATE LABOR COMMITTEE SO I WILL
01:25:35.864 --> 01:25:38.967 region:rollup2
BE BRIEF I AM I AGREE WITH THE
01:25:37.766 --> 01:25:39.468 region:rollup2
COMMENTS THE MISS CURTIS MADE
01:25:38.967 --> 01:25:41.470 region:rollup2
AND. JUST DRAW ATTENTION
01:25:39.468 --> 01:25:42.938 region:rollup2
SENATOR.
01:25:41.470 --> 01:25:45.240 region:rollup2
WIENER AND HIS STAFF HAS BEEN
01:25:42.938 --> 01:25:45.707 region:rollup2
VERY GENEROUS IN CONTINUE TO BE
01:25:45.240 --> 01:25:46.808 region:rollup2
IN WORKING WITH US AND
01:25:45.707 --> 01:25:48.010 region:rollup2
HOPEFULLY.
01:25:46.808 --> 01:25:49.645 region:rollup2
BEFORE IT'S THE SENATE FLOOR
01:25:48.010 --> 01:25:52.080 region:rollup2
WILL COME TO RESOLUTION IF NOT
01:25:49.645 --> 01:25:54.716 region:rollup2
MOST OF HOPEFULLY ALL OF THEM.
01:25:52.080 --> 01:25:55.751 region:rollup2
BUT. HE INDICATED THAT THIS IS
01:25:54.716 --> 01:25:57.019 region:rollup2
PATTERNED AFTER THE SAN
01:25:55.751 --> 01:25:57.552 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO ORDINANCE WHICH JUST
01:25:57.019 --> 01:25:59.254 region:rollup2
TOOK EFFECT ON JANUARY THE
01:25:57.552 --> 01:26:00.555 region:rollup2
FIRST.
01:25:59.254 --> 01:26:02.624 region:rollup2
AND THERE WERE TWO PROVISIONS OF
01:26:00.555 --> 01:26:04.793 region:rollup2
THE ORDINANCE THAT JUMPED OUT AT
01:26:02.624 --> 01:26:06.328 region:rollup2
ME. OTHER NOT A IN THAT
01:26:04.793 --> 01:26:08.697 region:rollup2
ORDINANCE THAT ARE IN THIS
01:26:06.328 --> 01:26:11.199 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION. THE FIRST IS IN.
01:26:08.697 --> 01:26:14.836 region:rollup2
SECTION TWO OF THE BILL.
01:26:11.199 --> 01:26:16.405 region:rollup2
SUBDIVISION GE ON THE.
01:26:14.836 --> 01:26:18.006 region:rollup2
PROVISION FOR AN UNDUE HARDSHIP
01:26:16.405 --> 01:26:19.541 region:rollup2
EXEMPTION
01:26:18.006 --> 01:26:21.143 region:rollup2
BUT WOULD LIKE TO SEE THAT THE
01:26:19.541 --> 01:26:22.744 region:rollup2
MORE BROADLY APPLICABLE TODAY
01:26:21.143 --> 01:26:25.814 region:rollup2
IT'S LIMITED TO BUSINESSES WERE
01:26:22.744 --> 01:26:27.215 region:rollup2
FIVE OR FEWER EMPLOYEES. ANOTHER
01:26:25.814 --> 01:26:30.052 region:rollup2
EXAMPLE OF A CONCERN THAT WE
01:26:27.215 --> 01:26:31.586 region:rollup2
EXPRESSED HIS IN SECTION THREE
01:26:30.052 --> 01:26:32.788 region:rollup2
OF THE BILL SUBDIVISION II.
01:26:31.586 --> 01:26:34.956 region:rollup2
WHICH NOT ONLY ALLOWS
01:26:32.788 --> 01:26:36.491 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE PUBLICAN FORSMAN BY
01:26:34.956 --> 01:26:37.859 region:rollup2
THE LABOR COMMISSIONER BUT ALSO
01:26:36.491 --> 01:26:39.461 region:rollup2
PROVIDES A PRIVATE RIGHT OF
01:26:37.859 --> 01:26:41.229 region:rollup2
ACTION WHICH IS YOU KNOW CENTER
01:26:39.461 --> 01:26:43.365 region:rollup2
JACKSON AND CENTER WIECKOWSKI
01:26:41.229 --> 01:26:45.033 region:rollup2
WE'VE. LONG EXPRESSED CONCERN
01:26:43.365 --> 01:26:47.035 region:rollup2
WITH PRIVATE RIGHT OF ACTION.
01:26:45.033 --> 01:26:48.704 region:rollup2
AND THEN BOTH SECTIONS FOUR AND
01:26:47.035 --> 01:26:51.039 region:rollup2
FIVE DO ADD NEW PROVISIONS TO
01:26:48.704 --> 01:26:52.741 region:rollup2
THE CALIFORNIA LABOR CODE WHICH.
01:26:51.039 --> 01:26:54.042 region:rollup2
OF COURSE RAISES CONCERN WITH
01:26:52.741 --> 01:26:56.211 region:rollup2
THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY ABOUT THE
01:26:54.042 --> 01:26:56.945 region:rollup2
POTENTIAL ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
01:26:56.211 --> 01:26:58.380 region:rollup2
UNDER THE PRIVATE ATTORNEYS
01:26:56.945 --> 01:27:00.615 region:rollup2
GENERAL ACT
01:26:58.380 --> 01:27:02.117 region:rollup2
SO WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
01:27:00.615 --> 01:27:03.518 region:rollup2
TO WORK WITH YOUR COMMITTEE BUT
01:27:02.117 --> 01:27:04.786 region:rollup2
CERTAINLY WAS SENATOR WIENER ON
01:27:03.518 --> 01:27:07.522 region:rollup2
RESOLVING SOME OF THESE
01:27:04.786 --> 01:27:08.423 region:rollup2
OUTSTANDING CONCERNS. THANK YOU.
01:27:07.522 --> 01:27:09.891 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHER
01:27:08.423 --> 01:27:11.693 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION NAME AND
01:27:09.891 --> 01:27:12.727 region:rollup2
AFFILIATION PLEASE.
01:27:11.693 --> 01:27:14.396 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON DOROTHY JOHNS BUT
01:27:12.727 --> 01:27:15.630 region:rollup2
THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION
01:27:14.396 --> 01:27:16.765 region:rollup2
OF COUNTIES OPPOSE LET'S AMENDED
01:27:15.630 --> 01:27:18.467 region:rollup2
FOR THE REASONS STATED BY MY
01:27:16.765 --> 01:27:19.000 region:rollup2
COLLEAGUES THANK YOU THANK YOU
01:27:18.467 --> 01:27:20.769 region:rollup2
VERY MUCH OTHER WITNESSES
01:27:19.000 --> 01:27:21.636 region:rollup2
POLICE.
01:27:20.769 --> 01:27:22.571 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS MATTHEW
01:27:21.636 --> 01:27:24.272 region:rollup2
HARPER THE CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
01:27:22.571 --> 01:27:25.707 region:rollup2
PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION WE HAVE
01:27:24.272 --> 01:27:26.541 region:rollup2
SOME BUILDING CODE PRACTICAL
01:27:25.707 --> 01:27:27.909 region:rollup2
ISSUES THAT WE'RE WORKING WITH
01:27:26.541 --> 01:27:29.644 region:rollup2
THE AUTHOR ON AND WE LOOK
01:27:27.909 --> 01:27:30.745 region:rollup2
FORWARD TO A.
01:27:29.644 --> 01:27:34.349 region:rollup2
HOW COME TO CONCLUSION ON THOSE
01:27:30.745 --> 01:27:35.584 region:rollup2
THANK YOU THANK YOU?
01:27:34.349 --> 01:27:36.284 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON KELLY HANSEN WITH
01:27:35.584 --> 01:27:37.586 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
01:27:36.284 --> 01:27:39.488 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION WERE OPPOSE A LESS
01:27:37.586 --> 01:27:44.025 region:rollup2
AMENDED FOR THE PRISONS
01:27:39.488 --> 01:27:44.860 region:rollup2
PREVIOUSLY STATED. THANK YOU.
01:27:44.025 --> 01:27:45.961 region:rollup2
THE CALL RISE CALIFORNIA
01:27:44.860 --> 01:27:48.330 region:rollup2
MANUFACTURES AND TECHNOLOGY
01:27:45.961 --> 01:27:50.632 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION ALSO POSE AS AMENDED
01:27:48.330 --> 01:27:51.900 region:rollup2
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
01:27:50.632 --> 01:27:53.935 region:rollup2
JOHN KERRY OF CIVIL JUST
01:27:51.900 --> 01:27:56.738 region:rollup2
CESSATION OPPOSING US AMENDED
01:27:53.935 --> 01:27:58.006 region:rollup2
FOR THE REASONS STATED THINKING.
01:27:56.738 --> 01:27:59.107 region:rollup2
BRIAN LITTLE CALIFORNIA FARM
01:27:58.006 --> 01:28:01.042 region:rollup2
BUREAU FEDERATION OPPOSED MOST
01:27:59.107 --> 01:28:01.610 region:rollup2
AMENDED FOR THE REASONS STATED
01:28:01.042 --> 01:28:02.978 region:rollup2
BY THE CHAIR BY THE CHAMBER
01:28:01.610 --> 01:28:04.546 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
01:28:02.978 --> 01:28:06.181 region:rollup2
THANK YOU. ANY OTHER WITNESSES
01:28:04.546 --> 01:28:09.518 region:rollup2
IN OPPOSITION.
01:28:06.181 --> 01:28:10.619 region:rollup2
CARL LET'S BRING IT BACK TO THE.
01:28:09.518 --> 01:28:13.722 region:rollup2
DYESS ANY QUESTIONS SENATOR
01:28:10.619 --> 01:28:15.357 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI.
01:28:13.722 --> 01:28:17.459 region:rollup2
I'M TRYING TO RACE DOWN ALL THE
01:28:15.357 --> 01:28:20.061 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS ON AS OUTLINED PIECE
01:28:17.459 --> 01:28:22.097 region:rollup2
TWELVE. TWELVE. MAYBE AUTHOR IT
01:28:20.061 --> 01:28:22.664 region:rollup2
SEEMS AS THOUGH SOME OF THE
01:28:22.097 --> 01:28:24.099 region:rollup2
OBJECTIONS THAT WERE REYES.
01:28:22.664 --> 01:28:26.301 region:rollup2
PALM.
01:28:24.099 --> 01:28:26.868 region:rollup2
BY THE OPPOSITION ARE SATISFIED
01:28:26.301 --> 01:28:30.138 region:rollup2
THE.
01:28:26.868 --> 01:28:32.140 region:rollup2
FIVE DAY PERIOD THE HARDSHIP
01:28:30.138 --> 01:28:34.009 region:rollup2
WAIVERS FOR FIVE EMPLOYEES. IS
01:28:32.140 --> 01:28:35.210 region:rollup2
THAT AND I DON'T KNOW IF PEOPLE
01:28:34.009 --> 01:28:36.978 region:rollup2
JUST CATCHING UP WITH THIS BILL
01:28:35.210 --> 01:28:38.680 region:rollup2
RIGHT IN THERE HAVE BEEN A
01:28:36.978 --> 01:28:40.315 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF AMENDMENTS TAKEN SO
01:28:38.680 --> 01:28:42.651 region:rollup2
PERHAPS WE WE CAN HANDLE THOSE.
01:28:40.315 --> 01:28:43.618 region:rollup2
IS WOULD YOU RESPOND TO THOSE
01:28:42.651 --> 01:28:45.854 region:rollup2
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
01:28:43.618 --> 01:28:47.756 region:rollup2
THAT ARE NOT ACCEPTABLE TO YOU
01:28:45.854 --> 01:28:49.558 region:rollup2
OR OF RESPOND FOR EXAMPLE. ONE
01:28:47.756 --> 01:28:51.893 region:rollup2
THAT COMES TO MIND IS APPLYING
01:28:49.558 --> 01:28:54.129 region:rollup2
THE FEDERAL LAW. ABOUT THAT IT
01:28:51.893 --> 01:28:56.131 region:rollup2
FREQUENTLY IT SERVES AS A FLOOR
01:28:54.129 --> 01:28:58.033 region:rollup2
NOT A CEILING AND I ASSUME THAT
01:28:56.131 --> 01:28:58.800 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD BE THE SITUATION AND
01:28:58.033 --> 01:29:00.936 region:rollup2
YOUR.
01:28:58.800 --> 01:29:02.504 region:rollup2
MIND ON THIS LEGISLATION IN ANY
01:29:00.936 --> 01:29:04.739 region:rollup2
OTHER AREAS WHERE THERE MIGHT BE
01:29:02.504 --> 01:29:06.608 region:rollup2
SOME SIGNIFICANT IF DISAGREEMENT
01:29:04.739 --> 01:29:08.176 region:rollup2
WITH WHAT IS SAW SUGGESTED BY
01:29:06.608 --> 01:29:09.477 region:rollup2
THE OPPOSITION
01:29:08.176 --> 01:29:10.645 region:rollup2
SURE AND I DON'T HAVE A COMPLETE
01:29:09.477 --> 01:29:11.880 region:rollup2
LOOK COMPLETE LIST BUT I A FEW
01:29:10.645 --> 01:29:13.315 region:rollup2
THAT COME TO MIND ODD THAT YOU
01:29:11.880 --> 01:29:14.249 region:rollup2
KNOW THE FEDERAL. STANDARDS IT'S
01:29:13.315 --> 01:29:16.351 region:rollup2
GREAT THAT THERE IS A FEDERAL
01:29:14.249 --> 01:29:18.587 region:rollup2
STANDARD IS A FLOOR IT'S A VERY
01:29:16.351 --> 01:29:19.187 region:rollup2
BASIC SEND THAT WE'RE TRYING TO.
01:29:18.587 --> 01:29:19.955 region:rollup2
FLUSH IT OUT WHAT WE'RE SAYING
01:29:19.187 --> 01:29:22.424 region:rollup2
IS NOT AYE.
01:29:19.955 --> 01:29:24.593 region:rollup2
BUT A DRAMATIC SHIFT FROM THE
01:29:22.424 --> 01:29:26.361 region:rollup2
FEDERAL BUT IT IS A A MORE SOLID
01:29:24.593 --> 01:29:27.996 region:rollup2
AYE TANGIBLE AND I THINK.
01:29:26.361 --> 01:29:30.532 region:rollup2
IT'S A BETTER APPROACH BOTTOM
01:29:27.996 --> 01:29:32.334 region:rollup2
IN TERMS OF THE THE HARDSHIP WE
01:29:30.532 --> 01:29:33.201 region:rollup2
LIMITED IT TO A LOT OF FIVE IN
01:29:32.334 --> 01:29:35.737 region:rollup2
ON THEIR.
01:29:33.201 --> 01:29:38.373 region:rollup2
AND MEN DO YOU KNOW THE REASON
01:29:35.737 --> 01:29:39.307 region:rollup2
AS. WELL WHEN YO GO HIGHER.
01:29:38.373 --> 01:29:41.810 region:rollup2
EVEN IF YOU GO TO TWENTY OR
01:29:39.307 --> 01:29:43.912 region:rollup2
FIFTY YOU YOU CUT OUT A HUGE
01:29:41.810 --> 01:29:45.614 region:rollup2
PERCENTAGE OF THE WORK FORCE.
01:29:43.912 --> 01:29:47.582 region:rollup2
AND THIS IS NOT.
01:29:45.614 --> 01:29:49.384 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW WE TALK ABOUT SOME OF
01:29:47.582 --> 01:29:50.485 region:rollup2
THE OTHER YOU KNOW. PAID
01:29:49.384 --> 01:29:53.088 region:rollup2
PARENTAL LEAVE PAID SICK LEAVE
01:29:50.485 --> 01:29:54.189 region:rollup2
THERE. REAL YOU KNOW THEIR COSTS
01:29:53.088 --> 01:29:55.690 region:rollup2
TO THE EMPLOYER AND SO THERE'S
01:29:54.189 --> 01:29:57.392 region:rollup2
MUCH MORE OF A CONVERSATION OF
01:29:55.690 --> 01:29:59.160 region:rollup2
WHAT SHOULD THE THRESHOLD BE.
01:29:57.392 --> 01:30:01.730 region:rollup2
WHEN WE TALK ABOUT. FIVE THIS
01:29:59.160 --> 01:30:03.064 region:rollup2
BILL THIS IS NOT ONEROUS.
01:30:01.730 --> 01:30:04.1000 region:rollup2
INVITED YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE TO
01:30:03.064 --> 01:30:06.001 region:rollup2
DEDICATE A SEPARATE ROOM YOU CAN
01:30:04.1000 --> 01:30:07.602 region:rollup2
COME THAT YOU CAN HAVE A LITTLE.
01:30:06.001 --> 01:30:10.238 region:rollup2
BIT OF A TENT
01:30:07.602 --> 01:30:11.706 region:rollup2
BETTER IT'S A VERY FLEXIBLE BILL
01:30:10.238 --> 01:30:12.941 region:rollup2
FIVE YOU BUT I YOU KNOW I MEAN
01:30:11.706 --> 01:30:14.276 region:rollup2
LIKE A AND I SEE THERE WERE
01:30:12.941 --> 01:30:16.044 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHO TALKED ABOUT THAT.
01:30:14.276 --> 01:30:19.080 region:rollup2
THINK WHAT PEOPLE WANT TO PUMP
01:30:16.044 --> 01:30:21.016 region:rollup2
IN A TENT SO TRY ANOTHER CALL ME
01:30:19.080 --> 01:30:23.251 region:rollup2
MISSING OUT ON THE MATCH I DON'T
01:30:21.016 --> 01:30:24.586 region:rollup2
APPLY TO ME TO PUT IN THERE I
01:30:23.251 --> 01:30:25.687 region:rollup2
SHOULD SOMETIMES AREN'T. BY
01:30:24.586 --> 01:30:26.321 region:rollup2
NATURE THE WHERE I LIVE BUT WHO
01:30:25.687 --> 01:30:27.455 region:rollup2
AND THEY'RE PEOPLE WHO TALKED
01:30:26.321 --> 01:30:28.757 region:rollup2
ABOUT THAT LAST WEEK THEIR WOMEN
01:30:27.455 --> 01:30:31.092 region:rollup2
TO TALK ABOUT THAT. ON FOR
01:30:28.757 --> 01:30:32.594 region:rollup2
EXAMPLE IN IN AN AGRICULTURAL
01:30:31.092 --> 01:30:33.628 region:rollup2
AREA WE HAVE JUST OF A TEMPER
01:30:32.594 --> 01:30:34.896 region:rollup2
IT'S CALLED A TEMPORARY
01:30:33.628 --> 01:30:36.631 region:rollup2
STRUCTURE. BETTER NUMBER EIGHT
01:30:34.896 --> 01:30:38.366 region:rollup2
STRUCTURE CAN TAKE MANY FORMS
01:30:36.631 --> 01:30:40.936 region:rollup2
AND WE HEARD LAST WEEK.
01:30:38.366 --> 01:30:43.038 region:rollup2
DOW TIME INSIDE A SMALL RETAIL
01:30:40.936 --> 01:30:44.539 region:rollup2
SPACE WHERE YOU HAVE PARTITIONS
01:30:43.038 --> 01:30:46.841 region:rollup2
THAT YOU PUT UP TO CREATE AN AD
01:30:44.539 --> 01:30:49.077 region:rollup2
HOC ROOM AND YOU TAKE IT DOWN.
01:30:46.841 --> 01:30:51.179 region:rollup2
WHEN YOU'RE DONE AND SO.
01:30:49.077 --> 01:30:55.717 region:rollup2
DESERVES A QUITE FLEXIBLE BILL
01:30:51.179 --> 01:30:57.385 region:rollup2
AND AND SO I DON'T THINK IT'S A
01:30:55.717 --> 01:30:58.520 region:rollup2
HARDSHIP ON SMALL BUSINESSES.
01:30:57.385 --> 01:30:59.354 region:rollup2
IT. MADAM CHAIR SINCE
01:30:58.520 --> 01:31:00.155 region:rollup2
THIS IS THE SECOND TIME I'VE
01:30:59.354 --> 01:31:01.222 region:rollup2
BEEN IN THE COMPETE FOR THE
01:31:00.155 --> 01:31:03.158 region:rollup2
PRESENTATION THIS BILL AND I'LL
01:31:01.222 --> 01:31:04.492 region:rollup2
BE BEFORE TRANCE NEXT WEEK WHEN
01:31:03.158 --> 01:31:06.895 region:rollup2
IT'S PRESENTED A THIRD TIME ALL
01:31:04.492 --> 01:31:08.029 region:rollup2
MOVED BILL.
01:31:06.895 --> 01:31:09.597 region:rollup2
I KNOW IT'S A VERY CONSISTENT
01:31:08.029 --> 01:31:11.266 region:rollup2
POSITION THANK YOU SENATOR Y.
01:31:09.597 --> 01:31:13.068 region:rollup2
CASCADE REPORT REFERRED AND AND.
01:31:11.266 --> 01:31:14.602 region:rollup2
I THINK THAT YOU KNOW AGAIN I
01:31:13.068 --> 01:31:14.936 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE YOUR BRINGING THIS
01:31:14.602 --> 01:31:17.972 region:rollup2
BILL.
01:31:14.936 --> 01:31:19.741 region:rollup2
I THINK. AGAIN RECOGNIZING THAT
01:31:17.972 --> 01:31:21.309 region:rollup2
WE HAVE A CHANGING WORKFORCE AND
01:31:19.741 --> 01:31:22.010 region:rollup2
WE PEOPLE IN THE WORKFORCE WHO
01:31:21.309 --> 01:31:24.412 region:rollup2
ARE.
01:31:22.010 --> 01:31:25.080 region:rollup2
AT NEEDING TO BE THEIR YOUNG
01:31:24.412 --> 01:31:26.781 region:rollup2
MOTHERS.
01:31:25.080 --> 01:31:28.750 region:rollup2
AND WE CERTAINLY FOR THE
01:31:26.781 --> 01:31:30.318 region:rollup2
REASONS THAT WERE MENTIONED
01:31:28.750 --> 01:31:31.653 region:rollup2
BRIEFLY THAT THE.
01:31:30.318 --> 01:31:33.188 region:rollup2
THERE'S VERY LITTLE QUESTION
01:31:31.653 --> 01:31:36.057 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE VALUE OF BREAST MILK
01:31:33.188 --> 01:31:38.293 region:rollup2
AND ITS BENEFITS TO OUR.
01:31:36.057 --> 01:31:40.662 region:rollup2
YOUNGEST A CALIFORNIANS.
01:31:38.293 --> 01:31:43.231 region:rollup2
IT'S A VERY. YOU KNOW POWERFUL
01:31:40.662 --> 01:31:45.467 region:rollup2
HEALING NURTURING.
01:31:43.231 --> 01:31:47.936 region:rollup2
SORT OF A SOME WOULD. EVEN SAY
01:31:45.467 --> 01:31:50.538 region:rollup2
GOD GIVEN OPPORTUNITY FOR.
01:31:47.936 --> 01:31:53.041 region:rollup2
MOTHERS AND CHILDREN TO BOND
01:31:50.538 --> 01:31:54.843 region:rollup2
AND TO FOR MOTHER TO PROVIDE THE
01:31:53.041 --> 01:31:56.544 region:rollup2
BEST NUTRITION FOR A.
01:31:54.843 --> 01:31:57.979 region:rollup2
AN INFANT IN A TOP TWO I GUESS
01:31:56.544 --> 01:32:00.081 region:rollup2
SIX MONTHS NOW WHICH.
01:31:57.979 --> 01:32:02.016 region:rollup2
FOR MOST WOMEN WHO AREN'T GIVEN
01:32:00.081 --> 01:32:03.418 region:rollup2
THE LUXURY OF BEING ABLE TO STAY
01:32:02.016 --> 01:32:05.120 region:rollup2
AT HOME FOR SIX MONTHS THEY HAVE
01:32:03.418 --> 01:32:05.620 region:rollup2
GOT TO FIND A WAY.
01:32:05.120 --> 01:32:06.221 region:rollup2
TO BE ABLE TO CONTINUE.
01:32:05.620 --> 01:32:08.823 region:rollup2
.
01:32:06.221 --> 01:32:09.224 region:rollup2
.
01:32:08.823 --> 01:32:10.592 region:rollup2
THIS PROCESS AND.
01:32:09.224 --> 01:32:12.427 region:rollup2
.
01:32:10.592 --> 01:32:14.896 region:rollup2
HAVING NURSED.
01:32:12.427 --> 01:32:16.598 region:rollup2
IN THE BREAST FED MY DAUGHTER
01:32:14.896 --> 01:32:19.000 region:rollup2
FOR THE FIRST FIVE MONTHS BUT
01:32:16.598 --> 01:32:19.968 region:rollup2
GOING BACK TO WORK AFTER I CAN'T
01:32:19.000 --> 01:32:22.270 region:rollup2
REMEMBER IT'S BEEN SO LONG AGO
01:32:19.968 --> 01:32:23.772 region:rollup2
BUT. BEFORE THEN IT'S OF IT'S A
01:32:22.270 --> 01:32:24.973 region:rollup2
REAL CHALLENGE AND I THINK WE
01:32:23.772 --> 01:32:27.175 region:rollup2
NEED TO MAKE AS MUCH OF AN
01:32:24.973 --> 01:32:29.310 region:rollup2
ACCOMMODATION. AS WE CAN AND I
01:32:27.175 --> 01:32:31.980 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE YOUR. WILLING TO WORK
01:32:29.310 --> 01:32:33.915 region:rollup2
WITH THE OPPOSITION ON THIS BUT.
01:32:31.980 --> 01:32:36.117 region:rollup2
BOB I THINK THE DETAIL ACTUALLY
01:32:33.915 --> 01:32:38.219 region:rollup2
GETS EMPLOYERS OF A ROAD MAP
01:32:36.117 --> 01:32:39.988 region:rollup2
WHICH I THINK IS VERY HELPFUL.
01:32:38.219 --> 01:32:41.623 region:rollup2
IN AND THE GREATER THE
01:32:39.988 --> 01:32:43.658 region:rollup2
SPECIFICITY SO THAT.
01:32:41.623 --> 01:32:46.061 region:rollup2
WE CAN REALLY KIND OF DRIVE HOME
01:32:43.658 --> 01:32:47.028 region:rollup2
THAT IT IS NOT. AS YOU SAY GOING
01:32:46.061 --> 01:32:48.730 region:rollup2
TO BE A.
01:32:47.028 --> 01:32:50.265 region:rollup2
THE BREAK THE BANK IN ANY ANY
01:32:48.730 --> 01:32:52.167 region:rollup2
BUSINESS.
01:32:50.265 --> 01:32:54.502 region:rollup2
BUT JUST GIVE WOMEN THE
01:32:52.167 --> 01:32:57.372 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE TO.
01:32:54.502 --> 01:32:59.407 region:rollup2
EXPRESS MILK STORED SAFELY ARE I
01:32:57.372 --> 01:33:00.942 region:rollup2
DON'T THINK IS IS THAT DIFFICULT
01:32:59.407 --> 01:33:02.777 region:rollup2
BUT IT'S A CHANGE IN OUR
01:33:00.942 --> 01:33:04.446 region:rollup2
PARADIGM HERE BUT WE NEED TO
01:33:02.777 --> 01:33:05.013 region:rollup2
MAKE THOSE CHANGES AND SO I
01:33:04.446 --> 01:33:05.880 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE DOING
01:33:05.013 --> 01:33:06.147 region:rollup2
AND.
01:33:05.880 --> 01:33:07.515 region:rollup2
WITH THAT.
01:33:06.147 --> 01:33:08.883 region:rollup2
.
01:33:07.515 --> 01:33:10.585 region:rollup2
IF YOU'D LIKE TO BRIEFLY CLOSE
01:33:08.883 --> 01:33:12.320 region:rollup2
IT'S JUST THE TWO OF US AND WE
01:33:10.585 --> 01:33:14.355 region:rollup2
BOTH A VINDICATED OUR STRONG
01:33:12.320 --> 01:33:15.957 region:rollup2
SUPPORT FOR THE MEASURE.
01:33:14.355 --> 01:33:17.459 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
01:33:15.957 --> 01:33:18.760 region:rollup2
WELDON. MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
01:33:17.459 --> 01:33:20.161 region:rollup2
CALL THE ROLL OF IT AND THE
01:33:18.760 --> 01:33:22.030 region:rollup2
MOTION IS TO PASS TO
01:33:20.161 --> 01:33:24.065 region:rollup2
TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING. AND
01:33:22.030 --> 01:33:25.333 region:rollup2
THE AMENDMENTS WILL BE TAKEN IN
01:33:24.065 --> 01:33:27.936 region:rollup2
THAT COMMITTEE PLEASE CALL TH
01:33:25.333 --> 01:33:30.672 region:rollup2
ROLL. JACKSON AYE JACKSON I AM
01:33:27.936 --> 01:33:35.710 region:rollup2
MORE LOCK ANDERSON HERTZBERG
01:33:30.672 --> 01:33:38.480 region:rollup2
MINING. STERN WIECKOWSKI POP.
01:33:35.710 --> 01:33:40.181 region:rollup2
STERN AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE.
01:33:38.480 --> 01:33:42.083 region:rollup2
THE BILL HAS THREE VOTES AND WE
01:33:40.181 --> 01:33:43.718 region:rollup2
WILL PLACE IT ON CALL PERFECT
01:33:42.083 --> 01:33:47.322 region:rollup2
TIMING.
01:33:43.718 --> 01:33:48.189 region:rollup2
SENATOR STERN FOR FILE ITEM SIX
01:33:47.322 --> 01:33:51.926 region:rollup2
WHICH IS.
01:33:48.189 --> 01:33:54.195 region:rollup2
S. B. TEN FORTY FIVE.
01:33:51.926 --> 01:33:56.598 region:rollup2
CONSERVATIVE SHIPS.
01:33:54.195 --> 01:33:59.534 region:rollup2
AND.
01:33:56.598 --> 01:34:02.704 region:rollup2
WE CONTINUE TO DISCUSS THIS.
01:33:59.534 --> 01:34:04.672 region:rollup2
WE DO HAVE AMENDMENTS.
01:34:02.704 --> 01:34:06.241 region:rollup2
THAT HAVE BEEN AGREED UPON THE
01:34:04.672 --> 01:34:08.042 region:rollup2
ME JUST GIVE YOU A MOMENT TO. BE
01:34:06.241 --> 01:34:09.410 region:rollup2
ABLE TO CONCENTRATE ON BOTH OF
01:34:08.042 --> 01:34:11.579 region:rollup2
THIS YEAR IN THIS YEAR.
01:34:09.410 --> 01:34:13.248 region:rollup2
WE DO HAVE AMENDMENTS STATE
01:34:11.579 --> 01:34:14.015 region:rollup2
YOU'VE AGREED TO TAKE IN PUBLIC
01:34:13.248 --> 01:34:16.818 region:rollup2
SAFETY.
01:34:14.015 --> 01:34:18.853 region:rollup2
THEY ARE RELATED COMMENT THREE
01:34:16.818 --> 01:34:21.055 region:rollup2
PAGES NINETEEN TWENTY ONE AND
01:34:18.853 --> 01:34:28.129 region:rollup2
TWENTY TWO. AND THEN THE COMMENT
01:34:21.055 --> 01:34:29.430 region:rollup2
TO A FOUR ON PAGE TWENTY THREE.
01:34:28.129 --> 01:34:31.399 region:rollup2
AND THAT THIS WILL BE A PILOT
01:34:29.430 --> 01:34:32.667 region:rollup2
PROJECT WITH THE UNDERSTANDING
01:34:31.399 --> 01:34:34.035 region:rollup2
THIS BILL IS GOING TO IS A WORK
01:34:32.667 --> 01:34:36.738 region:rollup2
IN PROGRESS WHERE WE'RE TRYING
01:34:34.035 --> 01:34:38.473 region:rollup2
TO DO HERE. IS TRYING TO CONNECT
01:34:36.738 --> 01:34:40.475 region:rollup2
THE DOTS ON IT IF POSSIBLE TO
01:34:38.473 --> 01:34:42.477 region:rollup2
CONNECT TO EXISTING PROGRAMS THE
01:34:40.475 --> 01:34:45.013 region:rollup2
LPS PROGRAM ON CONSERVATIVE
01:34:42.477 --> 01:34:46.548 region:rollup2
SHIPS. AND LARA'S LAW YOU
01:34:45.013 --> 01:34:48.149 region:rollup2
BELIEVE THAT THERE IS A.
01:34:46.548 --> 01:34:50.251 region:rollup2
GAP.
01:34:48.149 --> 01:34:52.353 region:rollup2
AND THE REASON FOR THIS BILL.
01:34:50.251 --> 01:34:54.222 region:rollup2
I THINK AND I THINK WITH A
01:34:52.353 --> 01:34:56.791 region:rollup2
LITTLE MORE WORK WE CAN ACTUALLY
01:34:54.222 --> 01:34:58.793 region:rollup2
CONNECTED TO OR MAKE A TWEAK SO
01:34:56.791 --> 01:34:59.827 region:rollup2
THAT WHAT WE HAVE. WILL CONTINUE
01:34:58.793 --> 01:35:01.629 region:rollup2
TO WORK.
01:34:59.827 --> 01:35:04.566 region:rollup2
AND TO SERVE THE PURPOSES OF
01:35:01.629 --> 01:35:07.268 region:rollup2
OUR SEVERELY IMPACTED HOMELESS
01:35:04.566 --> 01:35:09.237 region:rollup2
PEOPLE SO OF WITH THAT IN MY
01:35:07.268 --> 01:35:11.539 region:rollup2
THANKS FOR YOUR.
01:35:09.237 --> 01:35:13.975 region:rollup2
EFFORTS HERE THIS IS I I THINK
01:35:11.539 --> 01:35:15.743 region:rollup2
WE'RE CLOSE I THINK WE'RE CLOSE.
01:35:13.975 --> 01:35:17.912 region:rollup2
OF THE PILOTS WOULD BE IN SAN
01:35:15.743 --> 01:35:19.514 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO AND LOS ANGELES GO
01:35:17.912 --> 01:35:20.114 region:rollup2
THROUGH ITEM FOR IS A THANK YOU
01:35:19.514 --> 01:35:21.950 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR FOR.
01:35:20.114 --> 01:35:23.585 region:rollup2
TAKING QUITE A BIT OF TIME TO
01:35:21.950 --> 01:35:28.022 region:rollup2
SIT WITH US AND WORK WITH US
01:35:23.585 --> 01:35:28.623 region:rollup2
INTO YOUR STAFF EYES WATER RIVER
01:35:28.022 --> 01:35:30.491 region:rollup2
EAST OF THE THINGS THAT WE ALL
01:35:28.623 --> 01:35:31.492 region:rollup2
LIVE FOR.
01:35:30.491 --> 01:35:32.660 region:rollup2
BUT WE TAKE A SOCIAL SO WE
01:35:31.492 --> 01:35:33.595 region:rollup2
TRULY DO ARE PROJECTS IN
01:35:32.660 --> 01:35:34.829 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT ISSUE IS A VERY
01:35:33.595 --> 01:35:36.331 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT ISSUE. SIDES ISSUE
01:35:34.829 --> 01:35:38.066 region:rollup2
THAT IMPACTS CIVIL LIBERTIES AND
01:35:36.331 --> 01:35:40.468 region:rollup2
SUPPORT TAKE IT VERY SERIOUSLY.
01:35:38.066 --> 01:35:41.235 region:rollup2
AND IN TERMS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:35:40.468 --> 01:35:43.204 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS.
01:35:41.235 --> 01:35:44.372 region:rollup2
WE DO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
01:35:43.204 --> 01:35:45.907 region:rollup2
AMOUNTS WITH.
01:35:44.372 --> 01:35:47.475 region:rollup2
TO COPY AT ONE IS THAT WE WILL
01:35:45.907 --> 01:35:49.377 region:rollup2
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
01:35:47.475 --> 01:35:51.079 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE AS WE HAVE INDICATED.
01:35:49.377 --> 01:35:52.547 region:rollup2
AND THE SECOND DIED. WELL I'M
01:35:51.079 --> 01:35:54.382 region:rollup2
EVEN THOUGH SAN FRANCISCO AND
01:35:52.547 --> 01:35:55.416 region:rollup2
LOS ANGELES OR THE TWO COUNTIES
01:35:54.382 --> 01:35:56.851 region:rollup2
THAT HAVE BEEN BRINGING THIS AND
01:35:55.416 --> 01:35:58.319 region:rollup2
ALSO THERE'S AN ASSEMBLY BILL.
01:35:56.851 --> 01:36:00.355 region:rollup2
FORWARD AND WE DIDN'T RECEIVE
01:35:58.319 --> 01:36:04.592 region:rollup2
SUPPLY ENDORSEMENT OF THIS BILL
01:36:00.355 --> 01:36:06.027 region:rollup2
FROM THE LA CITY COUNCIL AS WELL
01:36:04.592 --> 01:36:07.195 region:rollup2
THAT WAS PASSED LAST WEEK.
01:36:06.027 --> 01:36:08.763 region:rollup2
WE ARE THERE ARE OTHER COUNTIES
01:36:07.195 --> 01:36:09.697 region:rollup2
WHO ARE INTERESTED AND SO THE
01:36:08.763 --> 01:36:10.565 region:rollup2
CABBIE OUT BEING THAT DOES WE
01:36:09.697 --> 01:36:12.233 region:rollup2
WORK THROUGH THE ISSUES THERE
01:36:10.565 --> 01:36:14.369 region:rollup2
MIGHT BE OTHER COUNTIES. THAT
01:36:12.233 --> 01:36:15.403 region:rollup2
WOULD LIKE TO BE INCLUDED BY AND
01:36:14.369 --> 01:36:16.971 region:rollup2
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT
01:36:15.403 --> 01:36:19.073 region:rollup2
WITHOUT WILL BE OPEN TO
01:36:16.971 --> 01:36:20.908 region:rollup2
CONSIDERATION. AND IF IF NEED BE
01:36:19.073 --> 01:36:21.509 region:rollup2
WE WILL AT SOME POINT TRIED TO
01:36:20.908 --> 01:36:23.845 region:rollup2
HAVE.
01:36:21.509 --> 01:36:25.813 region:rollup2
IT TO WORK IN ACCOMMODATION BUT
01:36:23.845 --> 01:36:26.014 region:rollup2
WE MAY AND MAY NEED TO BRING IT
01:36:25.813 --> 01:36:27.382 region:rollup2
BACK.
01:36:26.014 --> 01:36:29.350 region:rollup2
.
01:36:27.382 --> 01:36:31.119 region:rollup2
I THINK IF WE CAN FIGURE OUT HOW
01:36:29.350 --> 01:36:33.388 region:rollup2
TO HOW TO MAKE THIS WORK I THINK
01:36:31.119 --> 01:36:34.722 region:rollup2
THAT WE COULD EVEN GO BEYOND BUT
01:36:33.388 --> 01:36:36.291 region:rollup2
RIGHT NOW WE'RE STILL IN
01:36:34.722 --> 01:36:37.325 region:rollup2
UNCERTAIN WATERS AND THAT'S THE
01:36:36.291 --> 01:36:38.359 region:rollup2
REASON FOR THE WILL BE A WORK IN
01:36:37.325 --> 01:36:40.028 region:rollup2
PROGRESS AND CONTINUING
01:36:38.359 --> 01:36:42.430 region:rollup2
CONVERSATION AS WE SAY VERY
01:36:40.028 --> 01:36:43.031 region:rollup2
OFTEN IN. THIS BUILDING.
01:36:42.430 --> 01:36:44.365 region:rollup2
SO COLLEAGUES I SP TEN FORTY
01:36:43.031 --> 01:36:46.801 region:rollup2
FIVE AND I WANT TO THANK MY
01:36:44.365 --> 01:36:48.269 region:rollup2
JOINT AUTHORS SENATOR BUT STERN
01:36:46.801 --> 01:36:50.071 region:rollup2
HAS BEEN TEN FORTY FIVE IS
01:36:48.269 --> 01:36:52.573 region:rollup2
FUNDAMENTALLY ABOUT GIVING
01:36:50.071 --> 01:36:54.175 region:rollup2
COUNTIES A NARROW TOOL. TIED TO
01:36:52.573 --> 01:36:56.511 region:rollup2
CARE TO CARE FOR THE MOST
01:36:54.175 --> 01:36:58.579 region:rollup2
VULNERABLE PEOPLE ON OUR STREETS
01:36:56.511 --> 01:36:59.881 region:rollup2
CHRONICALLY HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS
01:36:58.579 --> 01:37:02.216 region:rollup2
WHO ARE SUFFERING FROM SEVERE
01:36:59.881 --> 01:37:03.184 region:rollup2
MENTAL ILLNESS AND SUBSTANCE
01:37:02.216 --> 01:37:06.054 region:rollup2
ABUSE DISORDERS.
01:37:03.184 --> 01:37:07.155 region:rollup2
THIS IS A TINY SUBSET OF OUR
01:37:06.054 --> 01:37:08.556 region:rollup2
OVERALL HOMELESS POPULATION
01:37:07.155 --> 01:37:10.358 region:rollup2
BECAUSE SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT
01:37:08.556 --> 01:37:11.793 region:rollup2
OF PUBLIC HEALTH FOR EXAMPLE
01:37:10.358 --> 01:37:14.462 region:rollup2
ESTIMATES THAT THIS POPULATION
01:37:11.793 --> 01:37:16.197 region:rollup2
IS APPROXIMATELY ONE PERCENT. OF
01:37:14.462 --> 01:37:17.732 region:rollup2
OUR OVERALL HOMELESS POPULATION
01:37:16.197 --> 01:37:20.034 region:rollup2
THE VAST MAJORITY OF HOMELESS
01:37:17.732 --> 01:37:22.570 region:rollup2
PEOPLE DO NOT EVEN COME CLOSE TO
01:37:20.034 --> 01:37:24.338 region:rollup2
MEETING THE SPELLS CRITERIA.
01:37:22.570 --> 01:37:25.707 region:rollup2
THOUGHT BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE DYING
01:37:24.338 --> 01:37:26.908 region:rollup2
ON OUR STREETS.
01:37:25.707 --> 01:37:27.108 region:rollup2
THIS IS NOT ABOUT PEOPLE WHO
01:37:26.908 --> 01:37:29.677 region:rollup2
WERE.
01:37:27.108 --> 01:37:31.012 region:rollup2
WHO ARE ACTING ABNORMALLY OR
01:37:29.677 --> 01:37:33.281 region:rollup2
OUT OF THE NEW NORMAL ON OUR
01:37:31.012 --> 01:37:33.848 region:rollup2
STREETS OR PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:37:33.281 --> 01:37:34.082 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCING CHALLENGES ARE
01:37:33.848 --> 01:37:35.750 region:rollup2
SICK?
01:37:34.082 --> 01:37:38.219 region:rollup2
THERE'S ABOUT PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:37:35.750 --> 01:37:39.754 region:rollup2
DYING ON OUR STREETS.
01:37:38.219 --> 01:37:41.189 region:rollup2
BUT ON. PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY
01:37:39.754 --> 01:37:42.757 region:rollup2
TO SEE THESE PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:37:41.189 --> 01:37:43.658 region:rollup2
DYING ON OUR STREETS AND CAN
01:37:42.757 --> 01:37:45.293 region:rollup2
CONCEIVE THAT WITH THEIR OWN TWO
01:37:43.658 --> 01:37:46.861 region:rollup2
EYES.
01:37:45.293 --> 01:37:48.096 region:rollup2
AND THEY SEE IT DAY AFTER DAY AS
01:37:46.861 --> 01:37:50.531 region:rollup2
PEOPLE DETERIORATED AND
01:37:48.096 --> 01:37:51.733 region:rollup2
ULTIMATELY DISAPPEAR WONDER WHY
01:37:50.531 --> 01:37:53.835 region:rollup2
AREN'T WE DOING ANYTHING ABOUT
01:37:51.733 --> 01:37:55.603 region:rollup2
IT.
01:37:53.835 --> 01:37:56.704 region:rollup2
AND THE REASON IS THAT. THESE
01:37:55.603 --> 01:37:57.972 region:rollup2
PEOPLE ARE FALLING THROUGH THE
01:37:56.704 --> 01:37:59.907 region:rollup2
CRACKS IN OUR SYSTEM AND THAT'S
01:37:57.972 --> 01:38:01.743 region:rollup2
WHAT THIS BILL IS TRYING TO
01:37:59.907 --> 01:38:03.911 region:rollup2
SOLVE. LOT SB TEN FORTY FIVE
01:38:01.743 --> 01:38:05.580 region:rollup2
CREATES A NEW CONSERVATORSHIP IN
01:38:03.911 --> 01:38:07.014 region:rollup2
THE WELFARE INSTITUTIONS CODE
01:38:05.580 --> 01:38:08.416 region:rollup2
OUGHT TO APPOINT A CONSERVATIVE
01:38:07.014 --> 01:38:10.518 region:rollup2
FOR A PERSON WHO IS CHRONICALLY
01:38:08.416 --> 01:38:12.120 region:rollup2
HOMELESS. GUY AND INCAPABLE OF
01:38:10.518 --> 01:38:13.387 region:rollup2
CARING FOR THEIR OWN HEALTH AND
01:38:12.120 --> 01:38:15.456 region:rollup2
WELL BEING. DUE TO SERIOUS
01:38:13.387 --> 01:38:16.691 region:rollup2
MENTAL ILLNESS AND SUBSTANCE
01:38:15.456 --> 01:38:18.459 region:rollup2
ABUSE DISORDER THOUGHT AS
01:38:16.691 --> 01:38:20.728 region:rollup2
EVIDENCED BY VARIOUS INDICIA
01:38:18.459 --> 01:38:22.263 region:rollup2
PARTICULARLY HIGH FREQUENCY
01:38:20.728 --> 01:38:24.232 region:rollup2
SOUNDS LIKE EMERGENCY.
01:38:22.263 --> 01:38:25.867 region:rollup2
HIGH FREQUENCY FIFTY ONE
01:38:24.232 --> 01:38:27.468 region:rollup2
FIFTIES AND SO FORTH. BY THE NEW
01:38:25.867 --> 01:38:29.904 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP IS COMPLETELY
01:38:27.468 --> 01:38:31.239 region:rollup2
VOLUNTARY FOR COUNTIES TALK
01:38:29.904 --> 01:38:32.640 region:rollup2
COUNTIES CAN OPT IN OR STAY OUT.
01:38:31.239 --> 01:38:33.875 region:rollup2
OF THE CONSERVATORSHIP WILL
01:38:32.640 --> 01:38:35.610 region:rollup2
PROVIDE FOR THE APPROPRIATE
01:38:33.875 --> 01:38:37.645 region:rollup2
PLACEMENT TIE IN SUPPORT OF
01:38:35.610 --> 01:38:39.113 region:rollup2
HOUSING INCLUDING A LICENSED
01:38:37.645 --> 01:38:41.416 region:rollup2
HEALTHCARE OR PSYCHIATRIC
01:38:39.113 --> 01:38:43.084 region:rollup2
FACILITY WHEN APPROPRIATE. WERE
01:38:41.416 --> 01:38:44.452 region:rollup2
AS PREFERRED COMMUNITY BASED
01:38:43.084 --> 01:38:47.989 region:rollup2
RESIDENTIAL CARE SETTING.
01:38:44.452 --> 01:38:49.590 region:rollup2
TO CARE FOR PERSONS SIDE NEEDS
01:38:47.989 --> 01:38:50.758 region:rollup2
THAT WE DO APPRECIATE THE
01:38:49.590 --> 01:38:52.360 region:rollup2
AMENDMENT FROM THE COMMITTEE ARE
01:38:50.758 --> 01:38:55.096 region:rollup2
REQUIRING THAT THE COUNTY FIRST
01:38:52.360 --> 01:38:56.764 region:rollup2
SHOW THAT IT HAS THE RESOURCES
01:38:55.096 --> 01:38:58.332 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE. BOB FOR THIS HOUSING
01:38:56.764 --> 01:39:00.701 region:rollup2
WE WANT HOUSING.
01:38:58.332 --> 01:39:02.970 region:rollup2
AS A TOP PRIORITY. VOLATILE
01:39:00.701 --> 01:39:04.305 region:rollup2
CONSERVATIVE SHIPS IN CALIFORNIA
01:39:02.970 --> 01:39:06.974 region:rollup2
OF THE BILL MAINTAINS FULL DUE
01:39:04.305 --> 01:39:07.542 region:rollup2
PROCESS PROTECTIONS FOR PEOPLE
01:39:06.974 --> 01:39:09.610 region:rollup2
FOR WHOM CONSERVATORSHIP IS
01:39:07.542 --> 01:39:10.812 region:rollup2
SOUGHT JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS
01:39:09.610 --> 01:39:12.447 region:rollup2
REPRESENTED SOMEBODY
01:39:10.812 --> 01:39:14.582 region:rollup2
REPRESENTATION BY COUNSEL. AND A
01:39:12.447 --> 01:39:16.617 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENT FOR PERIODIC
01:39:14.582 --> 01:39:17.919 region:rollup2
REASSESSMENT A RENEWAL. ON IT
01:39:16.617 --> 01:39:18.553 region:rollup2
FOCUSES ON THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:39:17.919 --> 01:39:20.922 region:rollup2
TRULY.
01:39:18.553 --> 01:39:21.389 region:rollup2
DYING ON OUR STREETS WERE
01:39:20.922 --> 01:39:23.157 region:rollup2
COUNTIES ARE CURRENTLY
01:39:21.389 --> 01:39:28.162 region:rollup2
POWERLESS.
01:39:23.157 --> 01:39:29.430 region:rollup2
TO HELP THEM. NON.
01:39:28.162 --> 01:39:30.331 region:rollup2
SO WHAT ONE IT'S IMPORTANT TO
01:39:29.430 --> 01:39:30.865 region:rollup2
KNOW IS PEOPLE SOMETIMES ASK WHY
01:39:30.331 --> 01:39:34.101 region:rollup2
IS IN THE CURRENT PROCESS
01:39:30.865 --> 01:39:36.737 region:rollup2
WORKING. NOT WORKING BECAUSE I
01:39:34.101 --> 01:39:38.940 region:rollup2
UNDER THE LPS WHEN YOU HAVE SAY
01:39:36.737 --> 01:39:40.107 region:rollup2
A SEVENTY TWO HOUR HOLD. ON THE
01:39:38.940 --> 01:39:41.909 region:rollup2
PERSON WHEN THEY GO BEFORE A
01:39:40.107 --> 01:39:43.644 region:rollup2
JUDGE WHETHER AFTER SEVENTY TWO
01:39:41.909 --> 01:39:45.213 region:rollup2
HOURS OF FOURTEEN DAYS. TIME
01:39:43.644 --> 01:39:46.914 region:rollup2
ESPECIALLY IF IT IS A SUBSTANCE
01:39:45.213 --> 01:39:48.716 region:rollup2
ABUSE DISORDER ODD THEY WILL
01:39:46.914 --> 01:39:51.953 region:rollup2
HAVE SOBERED UP AND THEY MAY
01:39:48.716 --> 01:39:52.520 region:rollup2
APPEAR PERFECTLY. NORMAL AND BE
01:39:51.953 --> 01:39:53.888 region:rollup2
COHERENT AND THEN THE JUDGE
01:39:52.520 --> 01:39:56.524 region:rollup2
LOOKS AT THE PERSON AND SAYS
01:39:53.888 --> 01:39:58.693 region:rollup2
THIS PERSON. THINGS COMPLETELY.
01:39:56.524 --> 01:40:00.661 region:rollup2
TIED NORMAL AND ABLE TO CARE
01:39:58.693 --> 01:40:02.830 region:rollup2
FOR HIMSELF OR HERSELF THERE'S
01:40:00.661 --> 01:40:04.498 region:rollup2
NO BASIS TO HOLD THE PERSON TODD
01:40:02.830 --> 01:40:06.467 region:rollup2
NEVER MIND THAT THE PERSONS THAT
01:40:04.498 --> 01:40:07.568 region:rollup2
FIFTY. FIFTY FIVE TEN TIMES IN
01:40:06.467 --> 01:40:09.070 region:rollup2
THE PAST YEAR NEVER MIND THAT
01:40:07.568 --> 01:40:10.271 region:rollup2
IT'S HIGHLY LIKELY THAT THEY'RE
01:40:09.070 --> 01:40:11.873 region:rollup2
GOING TO END UP INSIDE YOU ARE
01:40:10.271 --> 01:40:13.708 region:rollup2
WITHIN A WEEK OR TWO. OF BEING
01:40:11.873 --> 01:40:15.510 region:rollup2
RELEASED AND SOME PEOPLE CYCLE
01:40:13.708 --> 01:40:18.646 region:rollup2
THROUGH THE SYSTEM.
01:40:15.510 --> 01:40:20.581 region:rollup2
UNTIL. THEY'RE NO LONGER WITH
01:40:18.646 --> 01:40:21.015 region:rollup2
US.
01:40:20.581 --> 01:40:22.383 region:rollup2
AND IT.
01:40:21.015 --> 01:40:23.784 region:rollup2
AND THIS BILL AIMS TO CLOSE.
01:40:22.383 --> 01:40:25.486 region:rollup2
OR FILL IN DOT A CRACK IN THE
01:40:23.784 --> 01:40:26.554 region:rollup2
SYSTEM ABOUT WHERE WE ARE
01:40:25.486 --> 01:40:27.922 region:rollup2
FAILING SOME OF OUR MOST
01:40:26.554 --> 01:40:29.423 region:rollup2
MARGINALIZED.
01:40:27.922 --> 01:40:35.429 region:rollup2
AND.
01:40:29.423 --> 01:40:35.596 region:rollup2
I'M NOT WELL BY INDIVIDUALS CON
01:40:35.429 --> 01:40:36.163 region:rollup2
SO.
01:40:35.596 --> 01:40:37.765 region:rollup2
.
01:40:36.163 --> 01:40:39.600 region:rollup2
I'M.
01:40:37.765 --> 01:40:40.668 region:rollup2
SO COLLEAGUES UNDER THIS BILL I
01:40:39.600 --> 01:40:42.870 region:rollup2
THINK AND.
01:40:40.668 --> 01:40:45.006 region:rollup2
COMBINATION WITH OTHER TOOLS I
01:40:42.870 --> 01:40:47.008 region:rollup2
THINK ILL HELP OUR COUNTIES AYE
01:40:45.006 --> 01:40:49.410 region:rollup2
ADDRESS BECAUSE SOME OF THE MOST
01:40:47.008 --> 01:40:51.078 region:rollup2
CHALLENGED. INDIVIDUALS ON OUR
01:40:49.410 --> 01:40:53.581 region:rollup2
STREETS PEOPLE WHO ARE SICK. AND
01:40:51.078 --> 01:40:55.283 region:rollup2
DYING BY AND I WANTED TO SAY
01:40:53.581 --> 01:40:57.218 region:rollup2
THAT SAN FRANCISCO AND LOS
01:40:55.283 --> 01:40:58.719 region:rollup2
ANGELES IN PARTICULAR BUT IN
01:40:57.218 --> 01:41:01.389 region:rollup2
OTHER COUNTIES IN ORANGE COUNTY
01:40:58.719 --> 01:41:03.157 region:rollup2
IN SAN DIEGO. ALL OVER THE STATE
01:41:01.389 --> 01:41:06.761 region:rollup2
OF THIS IS AN ISSUE.
01:41:03.157 --> 01:41:07.929 region:rollup2
AND OUR LOCAL TIME COMMUNITIES
01:41:06.761 --> 01:41:08.996 region:rollup2
ARE COMING TO US.
01:41:07.929 --> 01:41:10.765 region:rollup2
SAN FRANCISCO AND LA AND OTHER
01:41:08.996 --> 01:41:12.033 region:rollup2
COMMUNITIES AND SAYING.
01:41:10.765 --> 01:41:13.100 region:rollup2
WE KNOW ALL THE TOOLS THAT ARE
01:41:12.033 --> 01:41:14.735 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE BECAUSE OF THE PEOPLE
01:41:13.100 --> 01:41:16.003 region:rollup2
WHO ARE EXPERTS
01:41:14.735 --> 01:41:17.838 region:rollup2
PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS
01:41:16.003 --> 01:41:18.406 region:rollup2
ARRIVED THEY KNOW THE TOOLS THAT
01:41:17.838 --> 01:41:20.241 region:rollup2
ARE AVAILABLE AND THEY ARE
01:41:18.406 --> 01:41:22.510 region:rollup2
TELLING US. THAT THE TOOLS
01:41:20.241 --> 01:41:24.145 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE NOW OR NOT ENOUGH AND
01:41:22.510 --> 01:41:26.581 region:rollup2
THEY NEED AN ADDITIONAL TOOL AND
01:41:24.145 --> 01:41:28.182 region:rollup2
THEY'RE ASKING FOR US TO GIVE
01:41:26.581 --> 01:41:30.284 region:rollup2
THEM ABOUT TOOL SO THAT THEY CAN
01:41:28.182 --> 01:41:31.719 region:rollup2
SAVE PEOPLE'S LIVES. AND HELP
01:41:30.284 --> 01:41:34.055 region:rollup2
PEOPLE GET HEALTHY AGAIN.
01:41:31.719 --> 01:41:35.256 region:rollup2
SO A TURNED OVER TO SENATOR
01:41:34.055 --> 01:41:36.557 region:rollup2
STERN AND THEN WE HAVE TWO
01:41:35.256 --> 01:41:37.992 region:rollup2
WITNESSES AND YOU COULD CHARGE
01:41:36.557 --> 01:41:39.260 region:rollup2
YOU FROM THE MAYORS FROM THE
01:41:37.992 --> 01:41:40.494 region:rollup2
OFFICE OF THE MAYOR OF SAN
01:41:39.260 --> 01:41:42.396 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO.
01:41:40.494 --> 01:41:44.398 region:rollup2
AND KELLY YOUR MOTO FROM SAM IN
01:41:42.396 --> 01:41:45.266 region:rollup2
SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT OF
01:41:44.398 --> 01:41:47.101 region:rollup2
PUBLIC HEALTH.
01:41:45.266 --> 01:41:48.469 region:rollup2
SENATOR. THANK YOU VERY BRIEFLY
01:41:47.101 --> 01:41:50.338 region:rollup2
IF YOU IT IS VERY VERY BRIEFLY A
01:41:48.469 --> 01:41:51.405 region:rollup2
JUST A COUPLE.
01:41:50.338 --> 01:41:53.674 region:rollup2
JARRING STATISTICS TO PUT THIS
01:41:51.405 --> 01:41:54.709 region:rollup2
IN CONTEXT.
01:41:53.674 --> 01:41:56.377 region:rollup2
EIGHT HUNDRED THIRTY ONE
01:41:54.709 --> 01:41:57.812 region:rollup2
HOMELESS PEOPLE DIED IN LA
01:41:56.377 --> 01:42:00.214 region:rollup2
COUNTY LAST YEAR.
01:41:57.812 --> 01:42:01.949 region:rollup2
AS A MASSIVE INCREASE YEAR ON
01:42:00.214 --> 01:42:03.951 region:rollup2
YEAR AND EVEN IN OUR LITTLE
01:42:01.949 --> 01:42:05.353 region:rollup2
COUNTY VENTURA COUNTY. WITH THAT
01:42:03.951 --> 01:42:08.155 region:rollup2
TWELVE YEAR HIGH IN HOMELESS
01:42:05.353 --> 01:42:09.023 region:rollup2
POPULATION BUT EVEN HIGHER THAN
01:42:08.155 --> 01:42:10.558 region:rollup2
THAT HAS BEEN THE MORTALITY
01:42:09.023 --> 01:42:11.993 region:rollup2
RATES OF THE MORTALITY RATES ARE
01:42:10.558 --> 01:42:14.862 region:rollup2
NOW ACTUALLY DOUBLE THE
01:42:11.993 --> 01:42:16.897 region:rollup2
POPULATION INCREASES. AND. THIS
01:42:14.862 --> 01:42:18.799 region:rollup2
ISSUE IS WHAT I THINK IS A SLOW
01:42:16.897 --> 01:42:20.501 region:rollup2
MOVING DISASTER ONLY OF NATURAL
01:42:18.799 --> 01:42:22.003 region:rollup2
DISASTERS AND WILD FIRES THAT
01:42:20.501 --> 01:42:24.739 region:rollup2
BURN UP A WHOLE COMMUNITIES ARE
01:42:22.003 --> 01:42:25.473 region:rollup2
STILL. WE ALL SNAP INACTION THIS
01:42:24.739 --> 01:42:27.475 region:rollup2
IS HAPPENING RIGHT UNDER OUR
01:42:25.473 --> 01:42:29.343 region:rollup2
FEET RIGHT BEFORE I SO THANK YOU
01:42:27.475 --> 01:42:29.543 region:rollup2
FOR INDULGENCE AND YOUR INSIGHT
01:42:29.343 --> 01:42:31.646 region:rollup2
AND.
01:42:29.543 --> 01:42:32.847 region:rollup2
YEAH I I I LOOK FORTY MORE
01:42:31.646 --> 01:42:34.348 region:rollup2
ENGAGEMENT ACROSS THE STATE TO
01:42:32.847 --> 01:42:35.449 region:rollup2
REALLY SOCIALIZE THIS AMONG THE
01:42:34.348 --> 01:42:36.650 region:rollup2
COUNTIES IN THE FOLKS ARE REALLY
01:42:35.449 --> 01:42:37.685 region:rollup2
ON THE FRONT LINES HERE TO MAKE
01:42:36.650 --> 01:42:38.519 region:rollup2
SURE THEY'RE COME FROM WITH THIS
01:42:37.685 --> 01:42:40.021 region:rollup2
FRAMEWORK THAT IT'S ACTUALLY
01:42:38.519 --> 01:42:40.421 region:rollup2
SOMETHING WE CAN DO BUT I WANT
01:42:40.021 --> 01:42:41.022 region:rollup2
TO SAY THE CAVIAR.
01:42:40.421 --> 01:42:42.990 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT-AMENDMENT BECAUSE IT
01:42:41.022 --> 01:42:44.792 region:rollup2
DOES TAKE
01:42:42.990 --> 01:42:45.860 region:rollup2
DOLLARS TO. AND WE CAN'T USE
01:42:44.792 --> 01:42:47.161 region:rollup2
THIS BILL AS A WAY TO DIVERT
01:42:45.860 --> 01:42:48.496 region:rollup2
DOLLARS AWAY FROM EXISTING
01:42:47.161 --> 01:42:49.497 region:rollup2
SERVICES BUT WE'VE GOT TO MAKE A
01:42:48.496 --> 01:42:52.466 region:rollup2
COMMITMENT HERE I KNOW THIS IS
01:42:49.497 --> 01:42:53.000 region:rollup2
NOT A BUDGET COMMITTEE BUT IT
01:42:52.466 --> 01:42:53.401 region:rollup2
DOES MATTER SIR. THANK FOR
01:42:53.000 --> 01:42:54.635 region:rollup2
INDULGENCE.
01:42:53.401 --> 01:42:57.038 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO WITNESSES
01:42:54.635 --> 01:42:58.606 region:rollup2
TWO MINUTES EACH PLEASE.
01:42:57.038 --> 01:42:59.707 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR JACKSON
01:42:58.606 --> 01:43:01.075 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
01:42:59.707 --> 01:43:02.743 region:rollup2
INIGO TREACHERY AND I SERVICE
01:43:01.075 --> 01:43:03.310 region:rollup2
THE SENIOR ADVISER FOR HEALTH
01:43:02.743 --> 01:43:05.379 region:rollup2
POLICY TO THE MAYOR OF SAN
01:43:03.310 --> 01:43:06.480 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO. FIND BEHALF OF MAYOR
01:43:05.379 --> 01:43:07.615 region:rollup2
FARRELL AND THE CITY AND COUNTY
01:43:06.480 --> 01:43:08.682 region:rollup2
AND I'D LIKE TO THINK THE
01:43:07.615 --> 01:43:10.217 region:rollup2
AUTHORS FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
01:43:08.682 --> 01:43:11.118 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT ISSUE. AND THANK YOU
01:43:10.217 --> 01:43:12.586 region:rollup2
ALL FOR.
01:43:11.118 --> 01:43:13.788 region:rollup2
YOUR CONTINUED SUPPORT MARK ON
01:43:12.586 --> 01:43:15.056 region:rollup2
THIS ISSUE AS WELL.
01:43:13.788 --> 01:43:16.357 region:rollup2
AS YOU'VE HEARD FROM SENATOR
01:43:15.056 --> 01:43:17.425 region:rollup2
WIENER AS BETWEEN FORTY FIVE
01:43:16.357 --> 01:43:19.126 region:rollup2
CREATES AN OPTIONAL NEW
01:43:17.425 --> 01:43:20.795 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP TO SERVE OUR
01:43:19.126 --> 01:43:22.329 region:rollup2
MOST AT RISK RESIDENTS. THOSE
01:43:20.795 --> 01:43:23.397 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCE THE COMBINED AND VERY
01:43:22.329 --> 01:43:25.066 region:rollup2
HEAVY WEIGHT OF CHRONIC
01:43:23.397 --> 01:43:25.599 region:rollup2
HOMELESSNESS SERIOUS MENTAL
01:43:25.066 --> 01:43:26.967 region:rollup2
ILLNESS AND SUBSTANCE USE
01:43:25.599 --> 01:43:28.202 region:rollup2
DISORDER.
01:43:26.967 --> 01:43:29.570 region:rollup2
WE ANTICIPATE THAT THIS BILL
01:43:28.202 --> 01:43:31.072 region:rollup2
WILL ADD TO THE SPECTRUM OF
01:43:29.570 --> 01:43:32.473 region:rollup2
SERVICES AND TOOLS THAT WE HAVE
01:43:31.072 --> 01:43:33.774 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE.
01:43:32.473 --> 01:43:35.376 region:rollup2
AND AND WILL BE EFFECTIVE IN
01:43:33.774 --> 01:43:36.243 region:rollup2
HELPING US TO DELIVER SERVICES
01:43:35.376 --> 01:43:37.378 region:rollup2
TREATMENT AND SUPPORT TO
01:43:36.243 --> 01:43:39.680 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE UNABLE TO
01:43:37.378 --> 01:43:41.415 region:rollup2
CARE FOR THEMSELVES.
01:43:39.680 --> 01:43:42.650 region:rollup2
WE AGREED THAT CAUTION MUST BE
01:43:41.415 --> 01:43:44.251 region:rollup2
EXERCISED AND CONSIDERING
01:43:42.650 --> 01:43:45.653 region:rollup2
LIMITATIONS TO CIVIL LIBERTIES
01:43:44.251 --> 01:43:47.822 region:rollup2
HOWEVER SMALL SUBSET OF OUR
01:43:45.653 --> 01:43:49.223 region:rollup2
POPULATION. FACES SUCH PROVIDE
01:43:47.822 --> 01:43:51.859 region:rollup2
CHALLENGES THAT THEY'RE UNABLE
01:43:49.223 --> 01:43:53.127 region:rollup2
TO ENGAGE IN VOLUNTARY SERVICES.
01:43:51.859 --> 01:43:54.962 region:rollup2
THEIR HEALTH IS DETERIORATING
01:43:53.127 --> 01:43:56.897 region:rollup2
FURTHER WITH EACH CRISIS AND
01:43:54.962 --> 01:43:58.432 region:rollup2
INCREASED TIME ON THE STREETS.
01:43:56.897 --> 01:44:00.201 region:rollup2
FOR THESE INDIVIDUALS AND DURING
01:43:58.432 --> 01:44:01.302 region:rollup2
REPEATED CRISES SP TEN FORTY
01:44:00.201 --> 01:44:02.536 region:rollup2
FIVE OFFERS US A WAY TO HELP
01:44:01.302 --> 01:44:04.872 region:rollup2
BREAK THE CYCLE OF STREETS
01:44:02.536 --> 01:44:06.540 region:rollup2
HOSPITALS AND JAILS.
01:44:04.872 --> 01:44:07.975 region:rollup2
CURRENT LAW THE LPS ACT AND
01:44:06.540 --> 01:44:09.343 region:rollup2
LAWYERS LAW TO FALL SHORT ON
01:44:07.975 --> 01:44:10.845 region:rollup2
SERVING THIS POPULATION BECAUSE
01:44:09.343 --> 01:44:12.146 region:rollup2
NEITHER ADDRESSES THE CONFLUENCE
01:44:10.845 --> 01:44:14.582 region:rollup2
OF HOMELESSNESS SUBSTANCE USE
01:44:12.146 --> 01:44:17.351 region:rollup2
AND SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS.
01:44:14.582 --> 01:44:19.954 region:rollup2
THE LPS ACT DOES ALLOW IT AND
01:44:17.351 --> 01:44:21.455 region:rollup2
THE DAY ADDED. ALCOHOL USE AS A
01:44:19.954 --> 01:44:23.023 region:rollup2
CRITERION FOR GREAT DISABILITY
01:44:21.455 --> 01:44:24.158 region:rollup2
COVERAGE DOES NOT CONSIDER OTHER
01:44:23.023 --> 01:44:25.392 region:rollup2
SUBSTANCE USE.
01:44:24.158 --> 01:44:26.327 region:rollup2
BUT THE REALITY IS THAT SIXTY
01:44:25.392 --> 01:44:27.862 region:rollup2
SEVEN PERCENT OF THE HOMELESS
01:44:26.327 --> 01:44:29.630 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS VISITING OUR
01:44:27.862 --> 01:44:31.031 region:rollup2
PSYCHIATRIC EMERGENCY SERVICES.
01:44:29.630 --> 01:44:32.766 region:rollup2
HAVE A SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER
01:44:31.031 --> 01:44:34.201 region:rollup2
DIAGNOSIS METHAMPHETAMINE
01:44:32.766 --> 01:44:35.970 region:rollup2
DIAGNOSES ARE THE MOST COMMON AT
01:44:34.201 --> 01:44:38.439 region:rollup2
THIRTY TWO PERCENT COMPARED TO
01:44:35.970 --> 01:44:39.974 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN PERCENT FOR ALCOHOL.
01:44:38.439 --> 01:44:41.075 region:rollup2
THE LPS ACT ALSO REQUIRES A
01:44:39.974 --> 01:44:42.376 region:rollup2
SERIES OF PROGRESSIVE
01:44:41.075 --> 01:44:44.411 region:rollup2
INVOLUNTARY HOLDS IN THE
01:44:42.376 --> 01:44:45.179 region:rollup2
HOSPITAL. AND WHILE THESE ARE
01:44:44.411 --> 01:44:47.114 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE FOR IDENTIFYING
01:44:45.179 --> 01:44:47.915 region:rollup2
PERSISTENT GRAVE DISABILITY IN
01:44:47.114 --> 01:44:49.784 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS WITH SERIOUS MENTAL
01:44:47.915 --> 01:44:51.886 region:rollup2
ILLNESS THESE HOLDS ACTS AS A
01:44:49.784 --> 01:44:53.420 region:rollup2
REVOLVING DOOR FOR PEOPLE. WHOSE
01:44:51.886 --> 01:44:56.991 region:rollup2
CRISES ARE WORSENED OR.
01:44:53.420 --> 01:44:57.892 region:rollup2
PRIMARILY DUE TO SUBSTANCE USE.
01:44:56.991 --> 01:44:59.160 region:rollup2
WE SUPPORT THE NARROW
01:44:57.892 --> 01:45:00.528 region:rollup2
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA THAT S. B.
01:44:59.160 --> 01:45:01.729 region:rollup2
TEN FORTY FIVE PROPOSES AND
01:45:00.528 --> 01:45:03.030 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THAT INCLUDE
01:45:01.729 --> 01:45:04.231 region:rollup2
SAFEGUARDS AND PROTECTIONS TO
01:45:03.030 --> 01:45:05.332 region:rollup2
PROMOTE DUE PROCESS AND AN
01:45:04.231 --> 01:45:06.834 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL'S RIGHT TO CONTEST
01:45:05.332 --> 01:45:07.802 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP.
01:45:06.834 --> 01:45:09.637 region:rollup2
AND THIS BILL WE SEE AN
01:45:07.802 --> 01:45:11.005 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO HELP OUR HIGHEST
01:45:09.637 --> 01:45:12.173 region:rollup2
AT RISK INDIVIDUALS TO STABILIZE
01:45:11.005 --> 01:45:13.674 region:rollup2
WITH A WARM AND SAFE PLACE TO
01:45:12.173 --> 01:45:14.475 region:rollup2
SLEEP EACH NIGHT AND ACCESS TO
01:45:13.674 --> 01:45:14.909 region:rollup2
SERVICES THAT THEY MAY BE
01:45:14.475 --> 01:45:16.911 region:rollup2
UNAWARE THEY NEED.
01:45:14.909 --> 01:45:17.711 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
01:45:16.911 --> 01:45:19.180 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE IT. NEXT WITNESS
01:45:17.711 --> 01:45:20.915 region:rollup2
PLEASE
01:45:19.180 --> 01:45:21.749 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
01:45:20.915 --> 01:45:23.517 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
01:45:21.749 --> 01:45:24.819 region:rollup2
KILLING OUR MOTO AND I AM THE
01:45:23.517 --> 01:45:25.920 region:rollup2
DIRECTOR SAN FRANCISCO HEALTH
01:45:24.819 --> 01:45:26.954 region:rollup2
NETWORK TRANSITIONS DIVISION
01:45:25.920 --> 01:45:28.355 region:rollup2
WITH THE SAN FRANCISCO
01:45:26.954 --> 01:45:29.590 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH. MY
01:45:28.355 --> 01:45:31.225 region:rollup2
TEAM IS RESPONSIBLE FOR
01:45:29.590 --> 01:45:32.793 region:rollup2
PROVIDING APPROPRIATE PLACEMENT
01:45:31.225 --> 01:45:34.361 region:rollup2
FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE PLACED
01:45:32.793 --> 01:45:35.763 region:rollup2
ON CONSERVATIVE SHIPS OR DO NOT
01:45:34.361 --> 01:45:37.031 region:rollup2
HAVE A PLACE TO GO AFTER LEAVING
01:45:35.763 --> 01:45:38.732 region:rollup2
HOSPITAL.
01:45:37.031 --> 01:45:40.067 region:rollup2
AS YOU HEARD SB TEN FORTY FIVE
01:45:38.732 --> 01:45:41.769 region:rollup2
IS INTENDED TO HELP OUR HARDEST
01:45:40.067 --> 01:45:42.970 region:rollup2
TO REACH INDIVIDUALS I'D LIKE TO
01:45:41.769 --> 01:45:44.271 region:rollup2
OFFER AN EXAMPLE OF WHO THAT
01:45:42.970 --> 01:45:45.439 region:rollup2
MIGHT BE.
01:45:44.271 --> 01:45:46.907 region:rollup2
MISS SMITH IS A THIRTY EIGHT
01:45:45.439 --> 01:45:48.442 region:rollup2
YEAR OLD WOMAN WHO HAS A BI
01:45:46.907 --> 01:45:49.977 region:rollup2
POLAR DEPRESSION DIAGNOSIS AN
01:45:48.442 --> 01:45:51.779 region:rollup2
ACTIVE USER OF OPIOIDS AND
01:45:49.977 --> 01:45:53.280 region:rollup2
METHAMPHETAMINES.
01:45:51.779 --> 01:45:55.249 region:rollup2
SHE INJECTS DRUGS IN PUBLIC
01:45:53.280 --> 01:45:56.717 region:rollup2
THREATENS PASSERSBY HAS VISIBLY
01:45:55.249 --> 01:45:57.885 region:rollup2
OPEN WOUNDS AND SORES IN IS
01:45:56.717 --> 01:45:59.620 region:rollup2
HOSTILE TO OUR REGION.
01:45:57.885 --> 01:46:01.188 region:rollup2
TEAMS.
01:45:59.620 --> 01:46:02.556 region:rollup2
IN THE PAST MONTH HE'S BEEN
01:46:01.188 --> 01:46:04.024 region:rollup2
PICKED UP BY THE POLICE TWICE
01:46:02.556 --> 01:46:06.193 region:rollup2
HAD TWO VISITS TO PSYCHIATRIC
01:46:04.024 --> 01:46:07.962 region:rollup2
EMERGENCY AND ONE VISIT TO THE
01:46:06.193 --> 01:46:09.096 region:rollup2
MEDICAL EMERGENCY ROOM. SHE WAS
01:46:07.962 --> 01:46:11.198 region:rollup2
LAST KNOWN TO BE ENGAGED IN
01:46:09.096 --> 01:46:12.967 region:rollup2
TREATMENT FOR YEARS AGO WHEN SHE
01:46:11.198 --> 01:46:14.201 region:rollup2
WAS TREATED FOR HEPATITIS C..
01:46:12.967 --> 01:46:15.636 region:rollup2
DURING A RECENT FIFTY ONE FIFTY
01:46:14.201 --> 01:46:17.304 region:rollup2
HOLD SHE WAS AGITATED
01:46:15.636 --> 01:46:18.939 region:rollup2
THREATENING AND HAD PARANOID
01:46:17.304 --> 01:46:19.873 region:rollup2
DELUSIONS OF HARM.
01:46:18.939 --> 01:46:21.308 region:rollup2
SHE WAS ADMITTED TO THE IN
01:46:19.873 --> 01:46:22.610 region:rollup2
PATIENT UNIT AND AFTER TWO DAYS
01:46:21.308 --> 01:46:24.478 region:rollup2
WAS LESS AGITATED HAD STARTED ON
01:46:22.610 --> 01:46:25.846 region:rollup2
MEDICATION.
01:46:24.478 --> 01:46:27.581 region:rollup2
OUR CASE WAS PRESENTED AT A
01:46:25.846 --> 01:46:28.916 region:rollup2
FIFTY TWO PROBABLE CAUSE HEARING
01:46:27.581 --> 01:46:29.750 region:rollup2
BUT TO CONTINUE TO HOLD WAS
01:46:28.916 --> 01:46:32.019 region:rollup2
DENIED BECAUSE SHE DID NOT
01:46:29.750 --> 01:46:33.254 region:rollup2
PRESENT. AS AN IMMEDIATE DANGER
01:46:32.019 --> 01:46:34.855 region:rollup2
TO HERSELF OR OTHERS AND WAS NO
01:46:33.254 --> 01:46:36.223 region:rollup2
LONGER DEEMED GRAVELY DISABLED
01:46:34.855 --> 01:46:37.424 region:rollup2
FOR SHOES ABLE TO STATE WHERE
01:46:36.223 --> 01:46:38.659 region:rollup2
SHE GOES FOR FOOD AND SHELTER
01:46:37.424 --> 01:46:40.427 region:rollup2
AND THAT SHE WANTED TO BE OUT OF
01:46:38.659 --> 01:46:41.896 region:rollup2
THE HOSPITAL. SHOES GIVEN
01:46:40.427 --> 01:46:42.963 region:rollup2
MEDICATION OFFERED REFERRALS AND
01:46:41.896 --> 01:46:45.633 region:rollup2
RECONNECTION WITH COMMUNITY
01:46:42.963 --> 01:46:47.001 region:rollup2
PROVIDERS FOUR DAYS LATER HE WAS
01:46:45.633 --> 01:46:48.469 region:rollup2
BACK AT PSYCHIATRIC EMERGENCY
01:46:47.001 --> 01:46:49.970 region:rollup2
FOR HAVING ADDRESSED IN PUBLIC
01:46:48.469 --> 01:46:51.272 region:rollup2
WALKING INTO TRAFFIC AN ACTING
01:46:49.970 --> 01:46:53.274 region:rollup2
AGGRESSIVELY TOWARD CARS AND
01:46:51.272 --> 01:46:54.608 region:rollup2
PEDESTRIANS. UNFORTUNATELY I
01:46:53.274 --> 01:46:56.176 region:rollup2
COULD SHARE MORE EXAMPLES LIKE
01:46:54.608 --> 01:46:57.578 region:rollup2
THIS INCLUDING ONES OF AGING
01:46:56.176 --> 01:46:59.513 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE SERIOUS
01:46:57.578 --> 01:47:01.615 region:rollup2
MENTAL ILLNESS. SUBSTANCE USE
01:46:59.513 --> 01:47:03.851 region:rollup2
DISORDER AND OTHER CONDITIONS
01:47:01.615 --> 01:47:04.852 region:rollup2
LIKE DIABETES OR HIV. SERVICES
01:47:03.851 --> 01:47:06.120 region:rollup2
GO HAS A LONG HISTORY OF
01:47:04.852 --> 01:47:07.288 region:rollup2
PROVIDING COMPASSIONATE CARE AND
01:47:06.120 --> 01:47:09.556 region:rollup2
FOLLOWING A RECOVERY ORIENTED
01:47:07.288 --> 01:47:10.724 region:rollup2
MODEL. RECENTLY WE STARTED AN
01:47:09.556 --> 01:47:12.359 region:rollup2
INTER AGENCY WORKING GROUP TO
01:47:10.724 --> 01:47:14.361 region:rollup2
CREATE CARE PLANS FOR FORTY TO
01:47:12.359 --> 01:47:16.163 region:rollup2
FIFTY OF OUR HIGHEST UTILIZE
01:47:14.361 --> 01:47:17.431 region:rollup2
HERS OF MULTIPLE SYSTEMS. SOME
01:47:16.163 --> 01:47:19.033 region:rollup2
AMONG THIS GROUP HAVE BEEN KNOWN
01:47:17.431 --> 01:47:20.167 region:rollup2
TO THE CITY FOR YEARS AND WE
01:47:19.033 --> 01:47:22.136 region:rollup2
HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO HELP THEM
01:47:20.167 --> 01:47:23.671 region:rollup2
STABILIZE NOT BECAUSE WE HAVEN'T
01:47:22.136 --> 01:47:25.239 region:rollup2
TRIED THE BECAUSE THEIR ABILITY
01:47:23.671 --> 01:47:26.974 region:rollup2
FOR SELF CARE HAS DETERIORATED
01:47:25.239 --> 01:47:29.109 region:rollup2
OVER TIME. AND VOLUNTARY
01:47:26.974 --> 01:47:29.843 region:rollup2
SERVICES ARE HARDER AND HARDER
01:47:29.109 --> 01:47:31.545 region:rollup2
FOR THEM TO ACCEPT.
01:47:29.843 --> 01:47:33.314 region:rollup2
FOR THEM SB TEN FORTY FIVE CAN
01:47:31.545 --> 01:47:35.049 region:rollup2
BE A PATH TO STABILITY HOUSING
01:47:33.314 --> 01:47:36.216 region:rollup2
AND A VASTLY IMPROVED QUALITY OF
01:47:35.049 --> 01:47:38.118 region:rollup2
LIFE THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
01:47:36.216 --> 01:47:39.987 region:rollup2
MUCH.
01:47:38.118 --> 01:47:40.654 region:rollup2
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF
01:47:39.987 --> 01:47:41.989 region:rollup2
THEIR OF THEIR WITNESSES IN
01:47:40.654 --> 01:47:46.160 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
01:47:41.989 --> 01:47:47.227 region:rollup2
RIGHT.
01:47:46.160 --> 01:47:51.298 region:rollup2
BOARD IT WAR BETWEEN.
01:47:47.227 --> 01:47:52.099 region:rollup2
SEC.
01:47:51.298 --> 01:47:53.934 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS SYLVIA
01:47:52.099 --> 01:47:55.903 region:rollup2
SOLELY SHAUN BEHALF OF THE CITY
01:47:53.934 --> 01:47:57.738 region:rollup2
OF LOS ANGELES ON ANY GIVEN
01:47:55.903 --> 01:47:59.473 region:rollup2
NIGHT THE CITY HAS APPROXIMATELY
01:47:57.738 --> 01:48:02.576 region:rollup2
THIRTY FOUR THOUSAND HOMELESS
01:47:59.473 --> 01:48:04.178 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS. AND WE ARE IN
01:48:02.576 --> 01:48:06.413 region:rollup2
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE.
01:48:04.178 --> 01:48:07.581 region:rollup2
WE BELIEVE THAT THIS WILL HELP
01:48:06.413 --> 01:48:09.116 region:rollup2
THOSE AT ABOUT A THIRD OF THOSE
01:48:07.581 --> 01:48:10.584 region:rollup2
FOLKS.
01:48:09.116 --> 01:48:12.753 region:rollup2
OF THE THIRTY FOUR THOUSAND NEED
01:48:10.584 --> 01:48:14.989 region:rollup2
FIVE NECESSITATE SERIOUS MENTAL
01:48:12.753 --> 01:48:16.457 region:rollup2
HEALTH TREATMENT WE THINK SB TEN
01:48:14.989 --> 01:48:18.158 region:rollup2
FORTY FIVE IS ONE TOOL TO HAVE.
01:48:16.457 --> 01:48:19.560 region:rollup2
HOPE THOSE FOLKS GET THE
01:48:18.158 --> 01:48:22.129 region:rollup2
TREATMENT THAT THEY NEED.
01:48:19.560 --> 01:48:23.130 region:rollup2
SO WE AGAIN ARE IN STRONG
01:48:22.129 --> 01:48:24.598 region:rollup2
SUPPORTER AND ALSO LIKED JST
01:48:23.130 --> 01:48:26.166 region:rollup2
FINE SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF THE
01:48:24.598 --> 01:48:28.135 region:rollup2
CITY OF SANTA MONICA THANK YOU
01:48:26.166 --> 01:48:29.436 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY OTHER
01:48:28.135 --> 01:48:30.270 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
01:48:29.436 --> 01:48:32.606 region:rollup2
FOR THEIR ANY WITNESSES IN
01:48:30.270 --> 01:48:33.007 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION.
01:48:32.606 --> 01:48:34.975 region:rollup2
GREAT IF WE COULD.
01:48:33.007 --> 01:48:36.977 region:rollup2
.
01:48:34.975 --> 01:48:42.549 region:rollup2
WE HAVE TO SO IF WE COULD ASK
01:48:36.977 --> 01:48:44.051 region:rollup2
YOU TO. GIVE THEM.
01:48:42.549 --> 01:48:47.354 region:rollup2
OKAY.
01:48:44.051 --> 01:48:49.056 region:rollup2
HER HER.
01:48:47.354 --> 01:48:50.224 region:rollup2
OPRAH DID WISH.
01:48:49.056 --> 01:48:52.192 region:rollup2
IT WAS AN INTERESTING DANCE STEP
01:48:50.224 --> 01:48:53.160 region:rollup2
YES. ALRIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD TWO
01:48:52.192 --> 01:48:54.661 region:rollup2
MINUTES EACH PLEASE OUT OF CHAIR
01:48:53.160 --> 01:48:56.096 region:rollup2
KIRK CHILD DISABILITY RIGHTS
01:48:54.661 --> 01:48:57.564 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA WERE APPEARING ON
01:48:56.096 --> 01:48:59.400 region:rollup2
BEHALF OF A COALITION OF
01:48:57.564 --> 01:49:01.435 region:rollup2
DISABILITY RIGHTS CIVIL RIGHTS
01:48:59.400 --> 01:49:04.671 region:rollup2
AND HOMELESS ORGANIZATIONS THAT
01:49:01.435 --> 01:49:05.506 region:rollup2
ARE. ALL UNITED IN. OPPOSITION
01:49:04.671 --> 01:49:07.708 region:rollup2
TO THIS.
01:49:05.506 --> 01:49:09.810 region:rollup2
PROPOSAL I I DO NEED TO MAKE
01:49:07.708 --> 01:49:11.011 region:rollup2
SURE AND ACKNOWLEDGE THE WORK
01:49:09.810 --> 01:49:13.380 region:rollup2
THAT YOUR COMMITTEE COUNSEL
01:49:11.011 --> 01:49:15.482 region:rollup2
DIDN'T THE ANALYSIS ON THIS WAS
01:49:13.380 --> 01:49:16.350 region:rollup2
AN EXCEPTIONAL ANALYSIS THOROUGH
01:49:15.482 --> 01:49:17.651 region:rollup2
AND. AND.
01:49:16.350 --> 01:49:20.220 region:rollup2
THOUGHTFUL AND WE ALWAYS
01:49:17.651 --> 01:49:21.622 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THAT I I WILL SAY IT
01:49:20.220 --> 01:49:23.557 region:rollup2
ON ON BEHALF OF THE.
01:49:21.622 --> 01:49:29.496 region:rollup2
COALITION THAT WE ARE ALWAYS
01:49:23.557 --> 01:49:30.664 region:rollup2
CONCERNED WHEN WE GIVE AWAY
01:49:29.496 --> 01:49:32.833 region:rollup2
THAT WAY TO THAT.
01:49:30.664 --> 01:49:34.601 region:rollup2
TO THAT CRISIS HISTORY IS
01:49:32.833 --> 01:49:37.304 region:rollup2
RIDDLED WITH.
01:49:34.601 --> 01:49:39.673 region:rollup2
WITH THOSE WRONGS COMMITTED
01:49:37.304 --> 01:49:40.707 region:rollup2
UNDER THE BANNER OF A OF A
01:49:39.673 --> 01:49:42.543 region:rollup2
CRISIS EIGHT YEAH I WAS JUST
01:49:40.707 --> 01:49:44.845 region:rollup2
REMINDED OF THAT TODAY AS.
01:49:42.543 --> 01:49:46.713 region:rollup2
WE'RE WORKING ON A BILL THAT'S
01:49:44.845 --> 01:49:48.749 region:rollup2
AND PUBLIC SAFETY A YOU KNOW
01:49:46.713 --> 01:49:51.084 region:rollup2
CHAIR VERY WELL ABOUT.
01:49:48.749 --> 01:49:52.886 region:rollup2
THIS HISTORY OF INVOLUNTARY
01:49:51.084 --> 01:49:53.720 region:rollup2
STERILIZATION IN OUR STATE
01:49:52.886 --> 01:49:56.490 region:rollup2
HOSPITALS AND.
01:49:53.720 --> 01:49:58.392 region:rollup2
DEVELOPMENTAL CENTERS.
01:49:56.490 --> 01:50:00.093 region:rollup2
AND THIS BILL WOULD PROVIDE FOR
01:49:58.392 --> 01:50:02.062 region:rollup2
REPARATIONS. SEEMED LIKE A GOOD
01:50:00.093 --> 01:50:04.164 region:rollup2
IDEA AT THE TIME AND I WOULD
01:50:02.062 --> 01:50:05.132 region:rollup2
SUGGEST TO THE COMMITTEE THAT
01:50:04.164 --> 01:50:08.235 region:rollup2
THIS IS ONE THAT WOULD.
01:50:05.132 --> 01:50:09.970 region:rollup2
SEEM LIKE A GOOD IDEA AT THE
01:50:08.235 --> 01:50:12.239 region:rollup2
THAT TIME I THINK.
01:50:09.970 --> 01:50:13.574 region:rollup2
WOULD I WANT TO BE A A REMIND
01:50:12.239 --> 01:50:15.409 region:rollup2
THE COMMITTEE DISABILITY RIGHTS
01:50:13.574 --> 01:50:16.777 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA SO LARGEST DISABILITY
01:50:15.409 --> 01:50:18.245 region:rollup2
RIGHTS ORGANIZATION IN THE
01:50:16.777 --> 01:50:19.580 region:rollup2
COUNTRY WE FROM REPRESENTED
01:50:18.245 --> 01:50:21.048 region:rollup2
CLIENTS FOR YEARS THESE ARE OUR
01:50:19.580 --> 01:50:23.183 region:rollup2
CLIENTS WE CARE DEEPLY ABOUT
01:50:21.048 --> 01:50:24.985 region:rollup2
THEM. SO I THINK WHAT WOULD BE
01:50:23.183 --> 01:50:28.322 region:rollup2
HELPFUL THAT IS IF YOU COULD
01:50:24.985 --> 01:50:30.724 region:rollup2
FOCUS ON. WHY THE LPS?
01:50:28.322 --> 01:50:34.561 region:rollup2
LAW ISN'T AVAILABLE IN WHY
01:50:30.724 --> 01:50:39.566 region:rollup2
LARA'S LAW WOULD NOT.
01:50:34.561 --> 01:50:40.601 region:rollup2
Y. EAT IT BECAUSE THIS KIND OF
01:50:39.566 --> 01:50:41.301 region:rollup2
DEALS WITH BOTH OF THEM SO.
01:50:40.601 --> 01:50:42.136 region:rollup2
THE THE QUESTION OR THE ISSUE IS
01:50:41.301 --> 01:50:44.104 region:rollup2
WHETHER OR NOT WE CAN CREATE A
01:50:42.136 --> 01:50:45.639 region:rollup2
THIRD. ESSENTIALLY A THIRD
01:50:44.104 --> 01:50:46.673 region:rollup2
SYSTEM TO WOOD TO DEAL WITH
01:50:45.639 --> 01:50:48.442 region:rollup2
THESE FOLKS WHO WERE.
01:50:46.673 --> 01:50:50.144 region:rollup2
SORT OF FALL WITHIN THE CRACKS
01:50:48.442 --> 01:50:52.846 region:rollup2
WHY DO YOU BELIEVE THAT THIS IS
01:50:50.144 --> 01:50:54.214 region:rollup2
A. VIOLATION OF CIVIL RIGHTS
01:50:52.846 --> 01:50:55.749 region:rollup2
THAT'S REALLY THE TRIMMING
01:50:54.214 --> 01:50:58.986 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS IT IS EXPANDING
01:50:55.749 --> 01:51:00.454 region:rollup2
INVOLUNTARY CARE. AND THAT'S THE
01:50:58.986 --> 01:51:02.489 region:rollup2
ESSENCE OF WHAT WE'RE SUBMITTING
01:51:00.454 --> 01:51:04.191 region:rollup2
IS THAT THE PROBLEM WITH THIS
01:51:02.489 --> 01:51:06.660 region:rollup2
PROPOSAL AS WE HAVE.
01:51:04.191 --> 01:51:09.229 region:rollup2
I THINK MADE MULTIPLE REQUESTS
01:51:06.660 --> 01:51:12.766 region:rollup2
TO TRY AND FIND THE ANSWER TO
01:51:09.229 --> 01:51:14.701 region:rollup2
WHY DOES LPS.
01:51:12.766 --> 01:51:16.870 region:rollup2
AND WHY DOES LAURA'S LA DOT
01:51:14.701 --> 01:51:19.139 region:rollup2
COVER THESE INDIVIDUALS.
01:51:16.870 --> 01:51:21.708 region:rollup2
I THINK THERE WAS THE ASSERTION
01:51:19.139 --> 01:51:22.509 region:rollup2
THAT IF INDIVIDUALS CAN AND
01:51:21.708 --> 01:51:25.512 region:rollup2
THEIR BROAD AND.
01:51:22.509 --> 01:51:26.980 region:rollup2
THEN RELEASE CLEAN UP BROUGHT
01:51:25.512 --> 01:51:27.915 region:rollup2
AND THEN HE RELEASED THAT'S
01:51:26.980 --> 01:51:30.484 region:rollup2
CERTAINLY AN ISSUE THAT THE
01:51:27.915 --> 01:51:31.318 region:rollup2
COURT CAN CONSIDER SHOULD
01:51:30.484 --> 01:51:31.885 region:rollup2
CONSIDER IN MAKING THAT
01:51:31.318 --> 01:51:33.787 region:rollup2
DETERMINATION UNDER EXISTING
01:51:31.885 --> 01:51:35.756 region:rollup2
LAW.
01:51:33.787 --> 01:51:39.226 region:rollup2
FOR THE ON GOING.
01:51:35.756 --> 01:51:40.761 region:rollup2
I'M GOING HOLD A AND ALL SAY
01:51:39.226 --> 01:51:43.263 region:rollup2
THAT AS WE'VE SORT OF PUSHED ON
01:51:40.761 --> 01:51:45.065 region:rollup2
THIS WE'VE NEVER FOUND SORT OF
01:51:43.263 --> 01:51:48.402 region:rollup2
WHERE THE TO. THE BOMB POINT IS.
01:51:45.065 --> 01:51:49.703 region:rollup2
ó AND SO WOULD IS STANDING IN
01:51:48.402 --> 01:51:53.073 region:rollup2
THE WAY TO REACH THESE
01:51:49.703 --> 01:51:54.841 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS THAT THE V..
01:51:53.073 --> 01:51:57.010 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS OF THIS BILL THINK
01:51:54.841 --> 01:51:58.845 region:rollup2
THAT THEY NEED TO HAVE WE DON'T
01:51:57.010 --> 01:51:59.413 region:rollup2
BELIEVE IT'S IN THE COURTS AT
01:51:58.845 --> 01:52:00.180 region:rollup2
ALL IT'S NOT AS GOOD AS YOU
01:51:59.413 --> 01:52:01.782 region:rollup2
KNOW.
01:52:00.180 --> 01:52:02.082 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR I SPENT A LOT OF
01:52:01.782 --> 01:52:04.484 region:rollup2
TIME.
01:52:02.082 --> 01:52:06.320 region:rollup2
WORKING IN THE IN THE COURTS
01:52:04.484 --> 01:52:07.721 region:rollup2
AND AND AND INDEED HAD THE
01:52:06.320 --> 01:52:09.556 region:rollup2
MENTAL HEALTH PROGRAMS.
01:52:07.721 --> 01:52:10.123 region:rollup2
WELL IS IT THE COURSE THIS WAS
01:52:09.556 --> 01:52:12.125 region:rollup2
NEVER AN ISSUE THAT WE HEARD
01:52:10.123 --> 01:52:13.560 region:rollup2
WAS%
01:52:12.125 --> 01:52:14.962 region:rollup2
A BARRIER.
01:52:13.560 --> 01:52:17.097 region:rollup2
TO.
01:52:14.962 --> 01:52:23.070 region:rollup2
INTO EXISTING.
01:52:17.097 --> 01:52:26.540 region:rollup2
EXISTING LAW.
01:52:23.070 --> 01:52:27.374 region:rollup2
THE THE OTHER.
01:52:26.540 --> 01:52:28.609 region:rollup2
FOR HIM TO ACT YEAH IT UP
01:52:27.374 --> 01:52:29.142 region:rollup2
BECAUSE I AND INTERJECTED BUT I
01:52:28.609 --> 01:52:29.776 region:rollup2
REALLY WANT TO GET TO THE
01:52:29.142 --> 01:52:31.111 region:rollup2
CRAFTSMAN OF THIS PROBLEM THAT
01:52:29.776 --> 01:52:32.779 region:rollup2
WE'VE ALL BEEN DEALING WITH AND
01:52:31.111 --> 01:52:35.215 region:rollup2
IT'S MAKING MY HAIR GRAY. IS.
01:52:32.779 --> 01:52:36.550 region:rollup2
IS THE THE QUESTION WE HAVE TO
01:52:35.215 --> 01:52:38.385 region:rollup2
EXISTING.
01:52:36.550 --> 01:52:40.587 region:rollup2
SETS OF CONSERVATORSHIP OPTIONS.
01:52:38.385 --> 01:52:42.089 region:rollup2
LPS IS ONE OF THEM LPS REQUIRES
01:52:40.587 --> 01:52:44.057 region:rollup2
GRAVELY DISABLED FOR SPRING
01:52:42.089 --> 01:52:45.792 region:rollup2
COURT HAS ALSO RULED THAT THAT
01:52:44.057 --> 01:52:48.595 region:rollup2
YOU MUST HAVE A FINDING OF GRADE
01:52:45.792 --> 01:52:50.831 region:rollup2
DISABILITY TO INVOLUNTARILY.
01:52:48.595 --> 01:52:53.700 region:rollup2
DETAIN SOMEONE WE ALSO HAVE
01:52:50.831 --> 01:52:55.135 region:rollup2
LARA'S LAW WHICH ALLOWS FOR OUT
01:52:53.700 --> 01:52:57.537 region:rollup2
PATIENT CARE.
01:52:55.135 --> 01:52:59.573 region:rollup2
SO THAT WHAT WE DO WITH THIS
01:52:57.537 --> 01:53:01.208 region:rollup2
BILL DOES IS TRY TO FIND A THIRD
01:52:59.573 --> 01:53:01.708 region:rollup2
WAY BETWEEN THE GRAVELY THE
01:53:01.208 --> 01:53:04.344 region:rollup2
GRAVE DISABILITY FINDING
01:53:01.708 --> 01:53:06.079 region:rollup2
WITCHES.
01:53:04.344 --> 01:53:07.748 region:rollup2
ONE THAT REQUIRES VERY SCRIPT.
01:53:06.079 --> 01:53:10.083 region:rollup2
SCRUTINY BY THE GUN ACCORDING
01:53:07.748 --> 01:53:11.752 region:rollup2
THE COURTS AND LARA'S LAW WHICH
01:53:10.083 --> 01:53:13.320 region:rollup2
CALLS FOR ESSENTIALLY A
01:53:11.752 --> 01:53:14.888 region:rollup2
VOLUNTARY PROGRAM OUTPATIENT
01:53:13.320 --> 01:53:18.425 region:rollup2
TYPE OF PROGRAM.
01:53:14.888 --> 01:53:20.160 region:rollup2
WHY? WHY DOES?
01:53:18.425 --> 01:53:22.529 region:rollup2
WHAT WHY DO YOU THINK THOSE TWO
01:53:20.160 --> 01:53:24.264 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY WOULD PROVIDE WHAT
01:53:22.529 --> 01:53:25.098 region:rollup2
THESE PEOPLE NEED WHO ARE?
01:53:24.264 --> 01:53:27.668 region:rollup2
SEVERELY.
01:53:25.098 --> 01:53:29.336 region:rollup2
.
01:53:27.668 --> 01:53:31.772 region:rollup2
CHALLENGED IN PHYSICALLY
01:53:29.336 --> 01:53:33.206 region:rollup2
THREATENED WE HAVE A NUMBER HERE
01:53:31.772 --> 01:53:34.808 region:rollup2
OF NINE HUNDRED PEOPLE THERE'S A
01:53:33.206 --> 01:53:36.143 region:rollup2
BAND WE KNOW THIS TO IT'S NOT
01:53:34.808 --> 01:53:38.245 region:rollup2
YOU JUST WALK THE STREETS OF LA
01:53:36.143 --> 01:53:38.779 region:rollup2
OR SAN FRANCISCO ANY BIG CITY
01:53:38.245 --> 01:53:40.013 region:rollup2
YOU SEE A LOT OF HOMELESS
01:53:38.779 --> 01:53:41.615 region:rollup2
PEOPLE.
01:53:40.013 --> 01:53:43.650 region:rollup2
WHO HAVE WHO ARE CLEARLY
01:53:41.615 --> 01:53:44.751 region:rollup2
SUFFERING THROUGH LOTS OF
01:53:43.650 --> 01:53:46.553 region:rollup2
CHALLENGES
01:53:44.751 --> 01:53:48.055 region:rollup2
WHY IS THIS?
01:53:46.553 --> 01:53:49.623 region:rollup2
ABOUT WHY DO YOU THINK I SHOULD
01:53:48.055 --> 01:53:51.291 region:rollup2
SAY AND PERHAPS WILL HAVE OUR
01:53:49.623 --> 01:53:55.062 region:rollup2
NEXT WITNESS PERHAPS ADDRESS
01:53:51.291 --> 01:53:57.798 region:rollup2
THIS. WHY DO YOU FEEL NAM? THAT.
01:53:55.062 --> 01:54:00.834 region:rollup2
THAT.
01:53:57.798 --> 01:54:02.703 region:rollup2
LPS FILE OR LOWERS LAW WOULD
01:54:00.834 --> 01:54:04.738 region:rollup2
ADDRESS THE PROBLEM AND THAT WE
01:54:02.703 --> 01:54:07.641 region:rollup2
DON'T NEED A THIRD SORT OF A
01:54:04.738 --> 01:54:08.608 region:rollup2
THIRD SYSTEM.
01:54:07.641 --> 01:54:10.410 region:rollup2
BUT I'D LIKE TO ASK YOU I DON'T
01:54:08.608 --> 01:54:11.578 region:rollup2
KNOW YOUR NAME I APOLOGIZE.
01:54:10.410 --> 01:54:13.347 region:rollup2
I'M JENNIFER FRIEDMAN BAKA.
01:54:11.578 --> 01:54:14.915 region:rollup2
FROM COALITION ON HOMELESSNESS
01:54:13.347 --> 01:54:16.550 region:rollup2
SOME I HAVE A STATEMENT THAT
01:54:14.915 --> 01:54:19.486 region:rollup2
MIGHT ADDRESS SOME OF THAT FREE
01:54:16.550 --> 01:54:20.253 region:rollup2
ARM. SO. AND I'VE BEEN WORKING
01:54:19.486 --> 01:54:21.154 region:rollup2
IN THIS FIELD FOR ABOUT THIRTY
01:54:20.253 --> 01:54:22.656 region:rollup2
YEARS.
01:54:21.154 --> 01:54:24.458 region:rollup2
I JUST WANT TO START BY
01:54:22.656 --> 01:54:26.059 region:rollup2
ACKNOWLEDGING A SENATOR WINNER
01:54:24.458 --> 01:54:27.294 region:rollup2
STATEMENT THAT WERE NEGLECTING
01:54:26.059 --> 01:54:28.762 region:rollup2
ALL PEOPLE WITH SEVERE MENTAL
01:54:27.294 --> 01:54:32.265 region:rollup2
ILLNESSES AN ADDICTIVE DISORDERS
01:54:28.762 --> 01:54:33.800 region:rollup2
I WISH THIS BILL WOULD SERVE
01:54:32.265 --> 01:54:34.401 region:rollup2
THEM. IT WILL NOT.
01:54:33.800 --> 01:54:34.935 region:rollup2
SOME OF SPENT THE LAST MONTH
01:54:34.401 --> 01:54:36.069 region:rollup2
TALKING TO MENTAL HEALTH
01:54:34.935 --> 01:54:39.206 region:rollup2
PROFESSIONALS.
01:54:36.069 --> 01:54:41.508 region:rollup2
AT THE. GROUND LEVEL.
01:54:39.206 --> 01:54:42.442 region:rollup2
AND HOMELESS PROVIDERS SOME WE
01:54:41.508 --> 01:54:43.543 region:rollup2
SPEND THEIR DAYS OF RATHER
01:54:42.442 --> 01:54:45.178 region:rollup2
SWEATER TEARS WORKING TO ADDRESS
01:54:43.543 --> 01:54:46.179 region:rollup2
THIS ARE. TWENTY EIGHT MEMBER
01:54:45.178 --> 01:54:48.248 region:rollup2
HOMELESS EMERGENCY SERVICE
01:54:46.179 --> 01:54:50.083 region:rollup2
PROVIDERS ASSOCIATION OPPOSE
01:54:48.248 --> 01:54:52.018 region:rollup2
THIS BILL WITHOUT QUESTION. AND
01:54:50.083 --> 01:54:53.253 region:rollup2
THEY KNOW IT WON'T WORK AND WE
01:54:52.018 --> 01:54:54.588 region:rollup2
HAVE ABOUT A THOUSAND PEOPLE ON
01:54:53.253 --> 01:54:55.956 region:rollup2
A WAIT LIST FOR SHELTERS IN SAN
01:54:54.588 --> 01:54:57.124 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO WE HAVE ABOUT EIGHT
01:54:55.956 --> 01:54:58.558 region:rollup2
HUNDRED SUPPORTIVE HOUSING UNITS
01:54:57.124 --> 01:55:00.227 region:rollup2
AT OPEN UP EVERY YEAR.
01:54:58.558 --> 01:55:01.695 region:rollup2
WE HAVE THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS
01:55:00.227 --> 01:55:03.530 region:rollup2
AND THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:55:01.695 --> 01:55:04.831 region:rollup2
TRYING TO GET THOSE SPOTS WE
01:55:03.530 --> 01:55:07.067 region:rollup2
HAVE OUR MENTAL HEALTH DIED
01:55:04.831 --> 01:55:08.602 region:rollup2
SYSTEM IS GREATLY IMPAIRED. OF
01:55:07.067 --> 01:55:10.737 region:rollup2
FOR RESIDENTIAL TREATMENT ONLY
01:55:08.602 --> 01:55:12.806 region:rollup2
THE VERY SLIGHT SLIVER OF PEOPLE
01:55:10.737 --> 01:55:14.541 region:rollup2
GET ACCESS TO THOSE AND
01:55:12.806 --> 01:55:17.244 region:rollup2
COMMUNITY CRISES MOST OF THE
01:55:14.541 --> 01:55:18.211 region:rollup2
TIME PEOPLE ARE TURNED AWAY EVEN
01:55:17.244 --> 01:55:20.013 region:rollup2
OUR OUTPATIENT TREATMENT.
01:55:18.211 --> 01:55:21.948 region:rollup2
PAUSE LONG LONG LONG WAIT LISTS
01:55:20.013 --> 01:55:23.016 region:rollup2
BY FAR THE EASIEST WAY TO ACCESS
01:55:21.948 --> 01:55:24.317 region:rollup2
TREATMENT IS TO GET FIFTY ONE
01:55:23.016 --> 01:55:25.685 region:rollup2
FIFTY EIGHT FOR MOST THAT'S
01:55:24.317 --> 01:55:28.155 region:rollup2
THEIR FIRST INTRODUCTION TO CARE
01:55:25.685 --> 01:55:29.856 region:rollup2
IT'S TRAUMATIZING. AND IT'S ALSO
01:55:28.155 --> 01:55:32.259 region:rollup2
THE MOST EXPENSIVE THE LEAST
01:55:29.856 --> 01:55:33.460 region:rollup2
EFFECTIVE. AUTUMN FOR PEOPLE WHO
01:55:32.259 --> 01:55:34.928 region:rollup2
BECOME HOMELESS THEIR ENTRANCE
01:55:33.460 --> 01:55:36.129 region:rollup2
INTO HOMELESSNESS THEY HAVE NO
01:55:34.928 --> 01:55:37.998 region:rollup2
HIGHER RATES OF MENTAL HEALTH OR
01:55:36.129 --> 01:55:39.032 region:rollup2
ADDICTION DISORDERS ONCE THEY
01:55:37.998 --> 01:55:39.566 region:rollup2
ARE HOMELESS AND FORCED TO
01:55:39.032 --> 01:55:40.634 region:rollup2
REMAIN ON THE STREETS FOR
01:55:39.566 --> 01:55:42.569 region:rollup2
LONGER.
01:55:40.634 --> 01:55:44.004 region:rollup2
THAN THOSE ISSUES THEIR MENTAL
01:55:42.569 --> 01:55:45.105 region:rollup2
HEALTH DISINTEGRATES THERE'D AND
01:55:44.004 --> 01:55:46.940 region:rollup2
ADDICTION DISORDERS GET STRONGER
01:55:45.105 --> 01:55:48.642 region:rollup2
AND NOT ONLY CHANGES ONCE
01:55:46.940 --> 01:55:51.678 region:rollup2
THEY'RE IN HOUSING. FROM OUR
01:55:48.642 --> 01:55:53.447 region:rollup2
ANALYSIS OF THE LANGUAGE
01:55:51.678 --> 01:55:55.682 region:rollup2
AND WE BELIEVE THAT TWENTY ONE
01:55:53.447 --> 01:55:56.683 region:rollup2
HUNDRED PEOPLE IN SAN FRANCISCO
01:55:55.682 --> 01:55:58.318 region:rollup2
OF WHAT WOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR
01:55:56.683 --> 01:56:01.054 region:rollup2
THIS.
01:55:58.318 --> 01:56:03.557 region:rollup2
AND THEY ARE HOMELESS
01:56:01.054 --> 01:56:05.792 region:rollup2
CHECK RIGHT ARM FOR A FRANKLY
01:56:03.557 --> 01:56:07.294 region:rollup2
BIZARRE WAY TO DETERMINE WHETHER
01:56:05.792 --> 01:56:09.763 region:rollup2
OR NOT YOU CAN TAKE AWAY
01:56:07.294 --> 01:56:12.165 region:rollup2
SOMEONE'S. A LIBERTIES ON
01:56:09.763 --> 01:56:14.701 region:rollup2
HOMELESSNESS IS A STATE IT IS
01:56:12.165 --> 01:56:16.102 region:rollup2
NOT A CLINICAL TRAITS.
01:56:14.701 --> 01:56:17.471 region:rollup2
THAT DETERMINES A LACK OF
01:56:16.102 --> 01:56:19.573 region:rollup2
ABILITY TO SELF CARE MAKE
01:56:17.471 --> 01:56:21.208 region:rollup2
DECISIONS FOR YOURSELF ABOUT
01:56:19.573 --> 01:56:22.509 region:rollup2
WENT WHAT SERVICES YOU NEED.
01:56:21.208 --> 01:56:24.244 region:rollup2
THEY WOULD HAVE FREQUENT
01:56:22.509 --> 01:56:25.579 region:rollup2
HOSPITALIZATIONS CHECK HOMELESS
01:56:24.244 --> 01:56:27.614 region:rollup2
PEOPLE GET SICK A LOT THEY LIVE
01:56:25.579 --> 01:56:29.115 region:rollup2
OUTDOORS THEY SUFFER FROM SEVERE
01:56:27.614 --> 01:56:30.484 region:rollup2
SLEEP DEPRIVATION AGAIN NOT A
01:56:29.115 --> 01:56:32.018 region:rollup2
REASON TO TAKE AWAY THEIR.
01:56:30.484 --> 01:56:34.654 region:rollup2
LIBERTIES WE BELIEVE THIS CASTS
01:56:32.018 --> 01:56:36.456 region:rollup2
A VERY DANGEROUSLY LARGE NETS A
01:56:34.654 --> 01:56:37.324 region:rollup2
MOST OF THE FACTORS WERE TALKING
01:56:36.456 --> 01:56:39.359 region:rollup2
ABOUT WOULD BE ADDRESSED BY
01:56:37.324 --> 01:56:40.927 region:rollup2
HOUSING. ON WE HAVE COORDINATED
01:56:39.359 --> 01:56:42.796 region:rollup2
ENTRY IN SAN FRANCISCO LIKE WE
01:56:40.927 --> 01:56:44.731 region:rollup2
DO AROUND THE STATE WHICH MEANS
01:56:42.796 --> 01:56:45.765 region:rollup2
THE MUNICIPALITY DECIDES WHO
01:56:44.731 --> 01:56:48.768 region:rollup2
GETS SUPPORTIVE HOUSING THEY ARE
01:56:45.765 --> 01:56:48.935 region:rollup2
READY PRIORITIZE. PEOPLEWITH A
01:56:48.768 --> 01:56:50.036 region:rollup2
KEY.
01:56:48.935 --> 01:56:50.904 region:rollup2
AND HIGH ACUITY.
01:56:50.036 --> 01:56:52.973 region:rollup2
THE SAME FOLKS WERE TALKING
01:56:50.904 --> 01:56:54.808 region:rollup2
ABOUT THIS BILL GOES THE
01:56:52.973 --> 01:56:56.443 region:rollup2
COMPLETE WRONG DIRECTION I'M
01:56:54.808 --> 01:56:58.211 region:rollup2
CURRENTLY OUR SYSTEMS BROKE.
01:56:56.443 --> 01:56:59.112 region:rollup2
WE HAVE MENTALLY ILL AND
01:56:58.211 --> 01:57:00.347 region:rollup2
ADDICTED HOMELESS PEOPLE CAN IT
01:56:59.112 --> 01:57:01.414 region:rollup2
CAN GET CANNOT GET THE HELP THEY
01:57:00.347 --> 01:57:03.250 region:rollup2
NEED EXCEPT THIS HIGH AND
01:57:01.414 --> 01:57:04.851 region:rollup2
HOSPITAL LEVEL. I'M AND THEN
01:57:03.250 --> 01:57:06.086 region:rollup2
EVENTUALLY THE RELEASED BACK TO
01:57:04.851 --> 01:57:07.754 region:rollup2
THE STREETS.
01:57:06.086 --> 01:57:09.556 region:rollup2
ALCOHOLICS WE ALREADY HAVE THAT
01:57:07.754 --> 01:57:11.825 region:rollup2
RATE WITH A FIFTY TO FIFTY AGAIN
01:57:09.556 --> 01:57:13.460 region:rollup2
IT DOESN'T WORK BECAUSE YOU THEY
01:57:11.825 --> 01:57:15.095 region:rollup2
DON'T MAKE THEIR WAY THROUGH IT.
01:57:13.460 --> 01:57:15.629 region:rollup2
IT IT HASN'T DONE ANYTHING WE
01:57:15.095 --> 01:57:16.897 region:rollup2
ALREADY TRIED THIS AND IT
01:57:15.629 --> 01:57:18.198 region:rollup2
FAILED.
01:57:16.897 --> 01:57:20.333 region:rollup2
.
01:57:18.198 --> 01:57:21.701 region:rollup2
THIS BILL. THERE'S NO COMMITTEE
01:57:20.333 --> 01:57:23.336 region:rollup2
RESIDENTIAL CARE THERE'S NO
01:57:21.701 --> 01:57:27.374 region:rollup2
HOUSING THIS BILL WOULD
01:57:23.336 --> 01:57:29.876 region:rollup2
LITERALLY EXPAND NOT FIX EXPAND
01:57:27.374 --> 01:57:31.811 region:rollup2
THE BROKEN PART OF OUR SYSTEM IT
01:57:29.876 --> 01:57:33.513 region:rollup2
WOULD NOT ADD MORE HOUSING AND
01:57:31.811 --> 01:57:34.014 region:rollup2
IT'S NOT IT'S NOT A SOLUTION.
01:57:33.513 --> 01:57:36.550 region:rollup2
IT'S NOT GOING TO GET US
01:57:34.014 --> 01:57:37.317 region:rollup2
ANYWHERE.
01:57:36.550 --> 01:57:38.852 region:rollup2
THEY FEEL SORRY.
01:57:37.317 --> 01:57:46.326 region:rollup2
OTHER WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
01:57:38.852 --> 01:57:47.327 region:rollup2
PLEASE.
01:57:46.326 --> 01:57:49.563 region:rollup2
JERRY KEVIN BIG AMERICAN CIVIL
01:57:47.327 --> 01:57:51.097 region:rollup2
LIBERTIES UNION OF CALIFORNIA.
01:57:49.563 --> 01:57:52.766 region:rollup2
JUST TAKING US BACK QUICKLY TO
01:57:51.097 --> 01:57:54.367 region:rollup2
BREEZE FIRST PRINCIPLES WE KNOW
01:57:52.766 --> 01:57:56.937 region:rollup2
AS LAWYERS THAT THE GOVERNMENT
01:57:54.367 --> 01:57:58.872 region:rollup2
CANNOT DETAIN AND CONFINE
01:57:56.937 --> 01:58:00.273 region:rollup2
SOMEONE INVOLUNTARILY AGAINST
01:57:58.872 --> 01:58:03.143 region:rollup2
THEIR WILL WITHOUT A COMPELLING
01:58:00.273 --> 01:58:04.578 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENTAL INTEREST. AND LEAST
01:58:03.143 --> 01:58:05.912 region:rollup2
RESTRICTIVE ALTERNATIVES AS THE
01:58:04.578 --> 01:58:07.647 region:rollup2
TESTIMONY HERE MAKES CLEAR WE
01:58:05.912 --> 01:58:09.716 region:rollup2
DON'T HAVE THOSE CONDITIONS IN
01:58:07.647 --> 01:58:11.217 region:rollup2
THAT IN THIS BILL AND WOULD
01:58:09.716 --> 01:58:12.218 region:rollup2
THEREFORE THINK IT'S AND.
01:58:11.217 --> 01:58:12.686 region:rollup2
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:58:12.218 --> 01:58:16.323 region:rollup2
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
01:58:12.686 --> 01:58:18.224 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION.
01:58:16.323 --> 01:58:20.493 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIRMAN MATA TWEENER NO
01:58:18.224 --> 01:58:22.195 region:rollup2
POSITION CATEGORY TRANSMIT ON
01:58:20.493 --> 01:58:24.197 region:rollup2
BEHALF OF THE STATE ASSOCIATION
01:58:22.195 --> 01:58:24.698 region:rollup2
OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS PUBLIC
01:58:24.197 --> 01:58:25.999 region:rollup2
CONSERVATIVES IN PUBLIC
01:58:24.698 --> 01:58:26.433 region:rollup2
GUARDIANS.
01:58:25.999 --> 01:58:28.568 region:rollup2
ARE.
01:58:26.433 --> 01:58:31.271 region:rollup2
MAIN CONCERN IS THE FINANCING
01:58:28.568 --> 01:58:33.173 region:rollup2
PART OF THIS AND WHILE THIS AND
01:58:31.271 --> 01:58:35.375 region:rollup2
I APPRECIATE SENATOR STERN'S
01:58:33.173 --> 01:58:37.777 region:rollup2
COMMENTS WELL THIS PROBABLY CARE
01:58:35.375 --> 01:58:39.813 region:rollup2
MAY BE A LEGITIMATE TOOL TO BE
01:58:37.777 --> 01:58:41.748 region:rollup2
USING. AGAIN WE.
01:58:39.813 --> 01:58:44.784 region:rollup2
HAVE A CAUTIONARY NOTE THAT
01:58:41.748 --> 01:58:46.219 region:rollup2
WE'RE NOT SURE IT WILL REACH THE
01:58:44.784 --> 01:58:47.854 region:rollup2
CONCLUSION EVERYONE HOPES.
01:58:46.219 --> 01:58:50.123 region:rollup2
IF THERE ARE NOT MORE PEOPLE
01:58:47.854 --> 01:58:52.058 region:rollup2
COUNTY EMPLOYEES HIGHER TO
01:58:50.123 --> 01:58:55.095 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY SERVE AS THE PUBLIC
01:58:52.058 --> 01:58:56.730 region:rollup2
CONSERVATOR RIGHT NOW MOST CASES
01:58:55.095 --> 01:58:58.365 region:rollup2
AND MOST COUNTIES THOSE
01:58:56.730 --> 01:58:59.1000 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENTS ARE OVERWHELMED WITH
01:58:58.365 --> 01:59:01.368 region:rollup2
THEIR CURRENT CASELOAD AND IF
01:58:59.1000 --> 01:59:03.503 region:rollup2
YOU'RE GOING TO ADD MORE.
01:59:01.368 --> 01:59:05.271 region:rollup2
CASELOAD WITHOUT DEDICATED
01:59:03.503 --> 01:59:07.607 region:rollup2
FUNDING TO HIRE MORE PUBLIC
01:59:05.271 --> 01:59:09.075 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORS YOU'RE NOT GONNA.
01:59:07.607 --> 01:59:10.777 region:rollup2
HAVE THE THE OUTCOME YOU'RE
01:59:09.075 --> 01:59:12.779 region:rollup2
YOU'RE LOOKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL
01:59:10.777 --> 01:59:15.181 region:rollup2
ONCE THEY ARE CONSERVE IT'S BEEN
01:59:12.779 --> 01:59:17.584 region:rollup2
ALLUDED TO. CURRENTLY RIGHT NOW
01:59:15.181 --> 01:59:19.019 region:rollup2
WE DON'T HAVE THE MENTAL HEALTH
01:59:17.584 --> 01:59:21.554 region:rollup2
FACILITIES TO PLACE THESE
01:59:19.019 --> 01:59:22.722 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS JUST AN EXAMPLE IN
01:59:21.554 --> 01:59:24.924 region:rollup2
YOUR OWN COUNTY.
01:59:22.722 --> 01:59:27.527 region:rollup2
CHAIRWOMAN JACKSON THERE ARE
01:59:24.924 --> 01:59:29.562 region:rollup2
CONSERVING THESE WHO ARE BEING
01:59:27.527 --> 01:59:31.398 region:rollup2
TREATED IN SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY
01:59:29.562 --> 01:59:34.200 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THERE ARE NO BEDS AND SO
01:59:31.398 --> 01:59:35.402 region:rollup2
AGAIN IF YOU PUT MORE PEOPLE
01:59:34.200 --> 01:59:37.203 region:rollup2
INTO THE CONSERVATIVE THE.
01:59:35.402 --> 01:59:38.772 region:rollup2
PROGRAM AND THERE AREN'T THE
01:59:37.203 --> 01:59:42.175 region:rollup2
MENTAL HEALTH FACILITIES TO
01:59:38.772 --> 01:59:43.610 region:rollup2
TREAT THEM AGAIN YOU YOU END UP.
01:59:42.175 --> 01:59:45.545 region:rollup2
SADLY SOME OF THESE PEOPLE AND
01:59:43.610 --> 01:59:47.280 region:rollup2
UP AN EXTENDED STAY HOTEL
01:59:45.545 --> 01:59:49.149 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THERE LITERALLY IS NO
01:59:47.280 --> 01:59:50.617 region:rollup2
PLACE TO PUT ON. AND SO AGAIN
01:59:49.149 --> 01:59:53.853 region:rollup2
WITHOUT THE FUNDING FOR THESE
01:59:50.617 --> 01:59:54.587 region:rollup2
OTHER KEY TOOLS THIS MAY NOT BE
01:59:53.853 --> 01:59:57.223 region:rollup2
THE SOLUTION EVERYONE'S HOPING.
01:59:54.587 --> 02:00:00.160 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
01:59:57.223 --> 02:00:00.360 region:rollup2
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION.
02:00:00.160 --> 02:00:02.362 region:rollup2
RIGHT.
02:00:00.360 --> 02:00:04.798 region:rollup2
.
02:00:02.362 --> 02:00:06.199 region:rollup2
DIDN'T HAVE ANY QUESTIONS I HAVE
02:00:04.798 --> 02:00:07.367 region:rollup2
SEVERAL BUT OUR WINNER LET'S
02:00:06.199 --> 02:00:07.901 region:rollup2
OPEN IT UP TO THE DICE FOR
02:00:07.367 --> 02:00:11.104 region:rollup2
SENATOR MONEY.
02:00:07.901 --> 02:00:12.639 region:rollup2
TO.
02:00:11.104 --> 02:00:13.973 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR I AM.
02:00:12.639 --> 02:00:14.741 region:rollup2
SORRY I MISSED THE FIRST PART OF
02:00:13.973 --> 02:00:16.843 region:rollup2
THE PRESENTATION FROM THE
02:00:14.741 --> 02:00:18.411 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS.
02:00:16.843 --> 02:00:20.013 region:rollup2
I DO HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS OR
02:00:18.411 --> 02:00:21.815 region:rollup2
COMMENTS BUT IT AND WANT TO JUST
02:00:20.013 --> 02:00:23.249 region:rollup2
CLARIFY I'M SORRY MISSED.
02:00:21.815 --> 02:00:24.751 region:rollup2
THE AUTHOR'S ACCEPTED THE
02:00:23.249 --> 02:00:27.053 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS.
02:00:24.751 --> 02:00:28.054 region:rollup2
YES WITH THE PALM OF HIS HAND
02:00:27.053 --> 02:00:29.756 region:rollup2
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
02:00:28.054 --> 02:00:30.557 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE.
02:00:29.756 --> 02:00:33.193 region:rollup2
AND I.
02:00:30.557 --> 02:00:35.295 region:rollup2
TIES THE BILL INVOLVES LEAVING
02:00:33.193 --> 02:00:36.362 region:rollup2
OPEN THE DOOR POTENTIALLY TO ADD
02:00:35.295 --> 02:00:38.098 region:rollup2
ADDITIONAL COUNTIES WE KNOW THAT
02:00:36.362 --> 02:00:41.000 region:rollup2
ORANGE COUNTY HAS EXPRESSED
02:00:38.098 --> 02:00:42.602 region:rollup2
INTEREST OF SAN DIEGO.
02:00:41.000 --> 02:00:44.704 region:rollup2
HAVE HAD SUPPORTING THE BILL
02:00:42.602 --> 02:00:45.872 region:rollup2
THOUGHT SO BUT FORNOW I WILL
02:00:44.704 --> 02:00:47.440 region:rollup2
WORK WITH THE COMMITTEE ON ANY
02:00:45.872 --> 02:00:49.409 region:rollup2
OF THOSE ABOUT ME IF WE FIND
02:00:47.440 --> 02:00:51.744 region:rollup2
THAT SWEET SPOT BECAUSE THAT
02:00:49.409 --> 02:00:52.979 region:rollup2
WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS WE
02:00:51.744 --> 02:00:54.881 region:rollup2
HAVE LPS.
02:00:52.979 --> 02:00:56.649 region:rollup2
WE HAVE LARA SLAW THIS IS A
02:00:54.881 --> 02:00:58.885 region:rollup2
THIRD SYSTEM.
02:00:56.649 --> 02:00:59.853 region:rollup2
IF THERE'S A CHANCE WE CAN TAKE
02:00:58.885 --> 02:01:01.287 region:rollup2
WHAT WE HAVE IN SORT OF LINK THE
02:00:59.853 --> 02:01:04.157 region:rollup2
TWO.
02:01:01.287 --> 02:01:06.126 region:rollup2
THEN I THINK WE HAVE A.
02:01:04.157 --> 02:01:08.228 region:rollup2
WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR AT WHICH
02:01:06.126 --> 02:01:09.896 region:rollup2
POINT WE IT WOULD THEN OPEN UP
02:01:08.228 --> 02:01:11.765 region:rollup2
THAT'S MY UNDERSTANDS WHAT I'M
02:01:09.896 --> 02:01:13.032 region:rollup2
PREPARED TO DO AND IF WE CAN'T?
02:01:11.765 --> 02:01:13.766 region:rollup2
GET THERE WE CAN PULL IT BACK
02:01:13.032 --> 02:01:15.135 region:rollup2
AND WE WERE UNDER TIME
02:01:13.766 --> 02:01:16.202 region:rollup2
CONSTRAINTS HOW COULD YOU DO GO
02:01:15.135 --> 02:01:17.070 region:rollup2
TO PUBLIC SAFETY IF I'M NOT
02:01:16.202 --> 02:01:19.672 region:rollup2
MISTAKEN.
02:01:17.070 --> 02:01:20.707 region:rollup2
BUT THAT THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT
02:01:19.672 --> 02:01:23.143 region:rollup2
ISSUE AS WAS MENTIONED ARE
02:01:20.707 --> 02:01:24.911 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTIONAL CONCERNS HERE.
02:01:23.143 --> 02:01:26.179 region:rollup2
AND SO WE HIT WITH THIS IS A
02:01:24.911 --> 02:01:27.480 region:rollup2
VERY DELICATE BALANCE WE'RE
02:01:26.179 --> 02:01:29.048 region:rollup2
TRYING TO ACHIEVE THANK YOU I
02:01:27.480 --> 02:01:31.618 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THE CLARIFICATION.
02:01:29.048 --> 02:01:34.187 region:rollup2
.
02:01:31.618 --> 02:01:36.156 region:rollup2
THE SEVENTEENTH SENATE DISTRICT.
02:01:34.187 --> 02:01:38.024 region:rollup2
SAN LUIS OBISPO MONTEREY SANTA
02:01:36.156 --> 02:01:40.860 region:rollup2
CRUZ SANTA CLARA.
02:01:38.024 --> 02:01:41.394 region:rollup2
ALSO HAS THE SAME CHALLENGE.
02:01:40.860 --> 02:01:42.929 region:rollup2
THE SAME PROBLEM THE SAME
02:01:41.394 --> 02:01:46.533 region:rollup2
CRISES.
02:01:42.929 --> 02:01:48.935 region:rollup2
.
02:01:46.533 --> 02:01:52.238 region:rollup2
I FIND THE AMENDMENTS IN A PILOT
02:01:48.935 --> 02:01:55.408 region:rollup2
NAM. REASSURING BUT I WOULD LIKE
02:01:52.238 --> 02:01:55.909 region:rollup2
TO JUST HEAR FROM THE OPPONENTS.
02:01:55.408 --> 02:02:01.748 region:rollup2
IS THERE ANY FORMULA OF
02:01:55.909 --> 02:02:02.849 region:rollup2
EXPANDED.
02:02:01.748 --> 02:02:05.084 region:rollup2
MANDATORY.
02:02:02.849 --> 02:02:07.187 region:rollup2
SERVICE.
02:02:05.084 --> 02:02:11.191 region:rollup2
FOR PEOPLE SUFFERING FROM MENTAL
02:02:07.187 --> 02:02:13.159 region:rollup2
ILLNESS THAT YOU WOULD SUPPORT.
02:02:11.191 --> 02:02:15.161 region:rollup2
BEYOND WHAT IS IN THE BILL RIGHT
02:02:13.159 --> 02:02:17.797 region:rollup2
NOW RIGHT OR WERE FORMULATED IN
02:02:15.161 --> 02:02:19.265 region:rollup2
ANOTHER WAY TO GET TO THE ISSUE.
02:02:17.797 --> 02:02:21.935 region:rollup2
I MEAN WE WENT THROUGH THIS WITH
02:02:19.265 --> 02:02:23.303 region:rollup2
LARA IS LAW IN AGAIN THE BALANCE
02:02:21.935 --> 02:02:25.305 region:rollup2
BETWEEN.
02:02:23.303 --> 02:02:27.140 region:rollup2
PRIVACY RIGHTS AND INDIVIDUAL
02:02:25.305 --> 02:02:29.209 region:rollup2
LIBERTY RIGHTS.
02:02:27.140 --> 02:02:31.544 region:rollup2
IN PUBLIC SAFETY AND INDIVIDUAL
02:02:29.209 --> 02:02:33.479 region:rollup2
SAFETY. AND I UNDERSTAND FIFTY
02:02:31.544 --> 02:02:36.082 region:rollup2
ONE FIFTEEN I UNDERSTAND LOWERS
02:02:33.479 --> 02:02:37.684 region:rollup2
LA. BUT.
02:02:36.082 --> 02:02:39.452 region:rollup2
WOULD YOU ACKNOWLEDGE THERE'S A
02:02:37.684 --> 02:02:41.955 region:rollup2
GROWING COMMUNITY OF PEOPLE IN
02:02:39.452 --> 02:02:43.990 region:rollup2
DISTRESS FOR WHOM WE DON'T HAVE.
02:02:41.955 --> 02:02:46.259 region:rollup2
ADEQUATE RESOURCES ADEQUATE
02:02:43.990 --> 02:02:49.162 region:rollup2
SERVICES ADEQUATE HOUSING
02:02:46.259 --> 02:02:50.396 region:rollup2
OPTIONS ADEQUATE.
02:02:49.162 --> 02:02:52.565 region:rollup2
MENTAL HEALTH CARE OPTIONS.
02:02:50.396 --> 02:02:54.400 region:rollup2
ABSOLUTELY WE WOULD AGREE WITH.
02:02:52.565 --> 02:02:56.970 region:rollup2
THAT SENATOR.
02:02:54.400 --> 02:02:58.938 region:rollup2
AND THAT BECOMES THE FAILURE OF
02:02:56.970 --> 02:03:00.473 region:rollup2
FELLING GO OF ENSURING THAT
02:02:58.938 --> 02:03:03.109 region:rollup2
THERE ARE THOSE ADEQUATE
02:03:00.473 --> 02:03:04.878 region:rollup2
RESOURCES AND SO WHEN YOU ASK TO
02:03:03.109 --> 02:03:05.912 region:rollup2
THE AND STEPPING INTO INDIVIDUAL
02:03:04.878 --> 02:03:08.514 region:rollup2
RIGHTS.
02:03:05.912 --> 02:03:10.183 region:rollup2
TO COVER UP FOR THOSE FAILURES
02:03:08.514 --> 02:03:11.551 region:rollup2
THAT'S THE PROBLEM THAT WE SEE.
02:03:10.183 --> 02:03:13.987 region:rollup2
TO THE FIRST PART OF YOUR
02:03:11.551 --> 02:03:16.122 region:rollup2
QUESTION THAT WE DO THINK IT IS
02:03:13.987 --> 02:03:17.857 region:rollup2
CRITICAL AND IN INTERESTINGLY
02:03:16.122 --> 02:03:20.760 region:rollup2
ENOUGH IT WAS AMENDED OUT OF THE
02:03:17.857 --> 02:03:22.195 region:rollup2
BILL. IS THAT THERE SHOULD BE AN
02:03:20.760 --> 02:03:24.530 region:rollup2
INSURANCE.
02:03:22.195 --> 02:03:27.467 region:rollup2
HE DIDN'T IN ANY BILL WHETHER
02:03:24.530 --> 02:03:29.335 region:rollup2
THAT BE AND LPS OR ARE LAWYERS
02:03:27.467 --> 02:03:32.238 region:rollup2
WHO ARE LOOKING BEYOND THIS IS
02:03:29.335 --> 02:03:32.805 region:rollup2
THAT THERE BE A SUPPLY OF
02:03:32.238 --> 02:03:35.575 region:rollup2
SUPPORTIVE HOUSING. WITH IN
02:03:32.805 --> 02:03:37.043 region:rollup2
THAT.
02:03:35.575 --> 02:03:38.344 region:rollup2
THAT WAS EVIDENT SPACE THAT WE
02:03:37.043 --> 02:03:40.914 region:rollup2
KNOW WORKS.
02:03:38.344 --> 02:03:43.216 region:rollup2
AND WE KNOW THERE IS NOT ENOUGH
02:03:40.914 --> 02:03:44.784 region:rollup2
OF THAT WITH A FULL RANGE OF
02:03:43.216 --> 02:03:47.553 region:rollup2
WRAPAROUND SERVICES.
02:03:44.784 --> 02:03:49.956 region:rollup2
AND WE WOULD SUGGEST THAT IF
02:03:47.553 --> 02:03:52.225 region:rollup2
YOU HAVE THAT. MUCH LIKE LAURA'S
02:03:49.956 --> 02:03:54.727 region:rollup2
LAW YOU GET MORE VOLUNTARY.
02:03:52.225 --> 02:03:55.695 region:rollup2
PARTICIPATION IF THERE ARE
02:03:54.727 --> 02:03:57.497 region:rollup2
INDEED THOSE.
02:03:55.695 --> 02:03:59.499 region:rollup2
.
02:03:57.497 --> 02:04:02.035 region:rollup2
AT.
02:03:59.499 --> 02:04:03.169 region:rollup2
HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE.
02:04:02.035 --> 02:04:04.470 region:rollup2
AND THAT'S IS A THINK THE
02:04:03.169 --> 02:04:06.205 region:rollup2
AUTHORS WOULD BE THE FIRST TO
02:04:04.470 --> 02:04:07.840 region:rollup2
ACKNOWLEDGE IN ITS PREY IMPLICIT
02:04:06.205 --> 02:04:09.809 region:rollup2
IN.
02:04:07.840 --> 02:04:12.211 region:rollup2
FOR EXPLICIT IN THE AUTHOR'S
02:04:09.809 --> 02:04:14.447 region:rollup2
PRESENTATION THAT.
02:04:12.211 --> 02:04:16.115 region:rollup2
PROBLEMS ARE SO MULTI FACTORIAL
02:04:14.447 --> 02:04:18.151 region:rollup2
THE SOLUTIONS ARE MULTI
02:04:16.115 --> 02:04:21.354 region:rollup2
FACTORIAL.
02:04:18.151 --> 02:04:23.523 region:rollup2
IN THIS EFFORT TO TRY TO.
02:04:21.354 --> 02:04:25.291 region:rollup2
LET ST STE BEST SENSE PROVIDED
02:04:23.523 --> 02:04:27.727 region:rollup2
TOOL TO PROTECT
02:04:25.291 --> 02:04:29.395 region:rollup2
THE LIVES AND HEALTH OF THOSE WE
02:04:27.727 --> 02:04:30.496 region:rollup2
CARE ABOUT. THEM.
02:04:29.395 --> 02:04:33.333 region:rollup2
WITHOUT HAVING ALL THE
02:04:30.496 --> 02:04:34.667 region:rollup2
WRAPAROUND SUPPORT.
02:04:33.333 --> 02:04:36.669 region:rollup2
I WONDER IF THIS.
02:04:34.667 --> 02:04:39.172 region:rollup2
CREATES.
02:04:36.669 --> 02:04:41.741 region:rollup2
A PATHWAY TO.
02:04:39.172 --> 02:04:42.842 region:rollup2
TO NO WHERE IN LESS IT ALSO
02:04:41.741 --> 02:04:44.811 region:rollup2
SERVES TO STIMULATE.
02:04:42.842 --> 02:04:46.145 region:rollup2
.
02:04:44.811 --> 02:04:47.146 region:rollup2
THE MOBILIZATION OF THOSE
02:04:46.145 --> 02:04:49.182 region:rollup2
RESOURCES WHETHER TO THE
02:04:47.146 --> 02:04:52.418 region:rollup2
COMMUNITY LEVEL THE STATE LEVEL
02:04:49.182 --> 02:04:54.420 region:rollup2
OR WHATEVER. NAM BUT I KNOWN WE.
02:04:52.418 --> 02:04:56.222 region:rollup2
WE'VE GOT A JAMMED AGENDA THIS
02:04:54.420 --> 02:04:58.758 region:rollup2
AFTERNOON NAM I AM GONNA BE
02:04:56.222 --> 02:05:01.160 region:rollup2
SUPPORTIVE TODAY BUT WITH.
02:04:58.758 --> 02:05:03.596 region:rollup2
WITH OF VIGILANCE AS IT MOVES
02:05:01.160 --> 02:05:05.898 region:rollup2
FORWARD I HAVE GREAT RESPECT FOR
02:05:03.596 --> 02:05:08.167 region:rollup2
THE COALITION OF OPPONENTS AND
02:05:05.898 --> 02:05:10.036 region:rollup2
EMBRACE THE PRINCIPLES THAT
02:05:08.167 --> 02:05:12.205 region:rollup2
YOU'VE ADVANCED TODAY. GREAT
02:05:10.036 --> 02:05:12.805 region:rollup2
RESPECT FOR THE AUTHORS SIN AND
02:05:12.205 --> 02:05:13.840 region:rollup2
WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO DO WITH
02:05:12.805 --> 02:05:14.707 region:rollup2
THE.
02:05:13.840 --> 02:05:16.976 region:rollup2
HERCULEAN.
02:05:14.707 --> 02:05:18.745 region:rollup2
CHALLENGE I WILL RESERVE THE
02:05:16.976 --> 02:05:20.146 region:rollup2
RIGHT. ON.
02:05:18.745 --> 02:05:21.614 region:rollup2
SHOULD THIS COME TO US ON THE
02:05:20.146 --> 02:05:23.883 region:rollup2
FLORIDA SCENE.
02:05:21.614 --> 02:05:25.885 region:rollup2
HOW HAVE IT'S BEEN ADAPTED BUT?
02:05:23.883 --> 02:05:27.520 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
02:05:25.885 --> 02:05:29.389 region:rollup2
I APPRECIATE THAT CENTER I THINK
02:05:27.520 --> 02:05:30.990 region:rollup2
WE'RE ALL STILL THIS IS A WORK
02:05:29.389 --> 02:05:32.392 region:rollup2
IN PROGRESS FOR SURE WE HAVE A
02:05:30.990 --> 02:05:33.326 region:rollup2
SENATOR ANDERSON FOLLOWED BY
02:05:32.392 --> 02:05:35.661 region:rollup2
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI.
02:05:33.326 --> 02:05:36.429 region:rollup2
AND.
02:05:35.661 --> 02:05:38.765 region:rollup2
HIM CHAIR AND.
02:05:36.429 --> 02:05:42.235 region:rollup2
HARD TO THE AUTHORS AYE KNOWS
02:05:38.765 --> 02:05:43.703 region:rollup2
THAT SEEM. DE ACE IN SUPPORT.
02:05:42.235 --> 02:05:44.270 region:rollup2
YEAR AND YET THE BILL DOESN'T
02:05:43.703 --> 02:05:45.571 region:rollup2
INCLUDE SAN DIEGO IS PART OF
02:05:44.270 --> 02:05:48.041 region:rollup2
THE.
02:05:45.571 --> 02:05:50.243 region:rollup2
PILOT IN PERHAPS WE COULD
02:05:48.041 --> 02:05:51.978 region:rollup2
INCLUDE THEM. IN I THINK ORANGE
02:05:50.243 --> 02:05:52.812 region:rollup2
COUNTY'S IN THE SAME BOAT.
02:05:51.978 --> 02:05:58.051 region:rollup2
BUT.
02:05:52.812 --> 02:06:00.319 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW WE ARE.
02:05:58.051 --> 02:06:01.988 region:rollup2
WE'RE HAVE SUCH A.
02:06:00.319 --> 02:06:03.790 region:rollup2
DIFFICULTY YOU KNOW WE HAD A
02:06:01.988 --> 02:06:04.724 region:rollup2
HEPATITIS OUTBREAK.
02:06:03.790 --> 02:06:07.060 region:rollup2
WE HAVE PEOPLE DYING THE STREETS
02:06:04.724 --> 02:06:07.293 region:rollup2
LITERALLY.
02:06:07.060 --> 02:06:09.262 region:rollup2
NPR AND.
02:06:07.293 --> 02:06:10.363 region:rollup2
.
02:06:09.262 --> 02:06:12.131 region:rollup2
AND I'M CONCERNED THAT WE THAT
02:06:10.363 --> 02:06:13.866 region:rollup2
WE ARE TREATING.
02:06:12.131 --> 02:06:15.435 region:rollup2
THESE PEOPLE ON THE SCREEN.
02:06:13.866 --> 02:06:17.970 region:rollup2
WITH THE COMPASSION THAT THEY
02:06:15.435 --> 02:06:19.005 region:rollup2
DESERVE. AND THAT WERE HELPING
02:06:17.970 --> 02:06:21.507 region:rollup2
THEM AND.
02:06:19.005 --> 02:06:23.409 region:rollup2
I THINK FOR SOME OF THEM.
02:06:21.507 --> 02:06:24.677 region:rollup2
.
02:06:23.409 --> 02:06:26.813 region:rollup2
MENTAL HEALTH IS SO IS A
02:06:24.677 --> 02:06:29.382 region:rollup2
CHALLENGE. AND I THINK WHAT WE
02:06:26.813 --> 02:06:31.050 region:rollup2
CAN DO TO TO GET RESOURCES TO
02:06:29.382 --> 02:06:33.086 region:rollup2
ALMOST QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
02:06:31.050 --> 02:06:34.687 region:rollup2
AND HELP THEM GET BACK IN TO.
02:06:33.086 --> 02:06:36.355 region:rollup2
.
02:06:34.687 --> 02:06:38.424 region:rollup2
I'M MORE MAINSTREAM AMERICA SO
02:06:36.355 --> 02:06:40.526 region:rollup2
THAT THEY THEY CAN.
02:06:38.424 --> 02:06:41.761 region:rollup2
HOLD DOWN A JOB HOLD DOWN. A
02:06:40.526 --> 02:06:43.529 region:rollup2
PLACE TO LIVE IN IN CARE FOR
02:06:41.761 --> 02:06:45.331 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES.
02:06:43.529 --> 02:06:46.332 region:rollup2
SO I I JUST WANTED TO ADD THAT
02:06:45.331 --> 02:06:47.733 region:rollup2
IF THERE'S ANY WAY THAT WE COULD
02:06:46.332 --> 02:06:49.268 region:rollup2
ADD.
02:06:47.733 --> 02:06:50.036 region:rollup2
SAN DIEGO I KNOW THAT MY
02:06:49.268 --> 02:06:52.605 region:rollup2
DISTRICT ATTORNEY WOULD BE
02:06:50.036 --> 02:06:53.739 region:rollup2
DEEPLY APPRECIATIVE.
02:06:52.605 --> 02:06:55.274 region:rollup2
UNDERSTOOD THAT'S WHERE WE'RE
02:06:53.739 --> 02:06:56.075 region:rollup2
HOPING TO WORKING CREATE
02:06:55.274 --> 02:06:57.777 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT WE FEEL
02:06:56.075 --> 02:06:59.445 region:rollup2
COMFORTABLE COULD EXPAND.
02:06:57.777 --> 02:07:01.614 region:rollup2
.
02:06:59.445 --> 02:07:03.216 region:rollup2
SO FAR I I BELIEVE THE JUDICIAL
02:07:01.614 --> 02:07:04.684 region:rollup2
COUNCIL HERE FROM COULD YOU COME
02:07:03.216 --> 02:07:06.953 region:rollup2
UP I KNOW YOU HAVE NO POSITION
02:07:04.684 --> 02:07:09.589 region:rollup2
ON THIS BUT MAYBE.
02:07:06.953 --> 02:07:11.591 region:rollup2
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. IF YOU
02:07:09.589 --> 02:07:14.560 region:rollup2
DON'T HAVE ANY QUESTIONS FOR
02:07:11.591 --> 02:07:16.562 region:rollup2
THEM I DO HAVE A COUPLE SO. NICE
02:07:14.560 --> 02:07:19.632 region:rollup2
GUY BECAUSE.
02:07:16.562 --> 02:07:21.334 region:rollup2
VOTE FOR FOR TO FOURTEEN GO HIT.
02:07:19.632 --> 02:07:22.502 region:rollup2
GO AHEAD. OCEAN PURCHASE WONDER
02:07:21.334 --> 02:07:23.369 region:rollup2
AS I'M SITTING HERE LISTEN THINK
02:07:22.502 --> 02:07:24.337 region:rollup2
THE STIGMA THAT PEOPLE ARE
02:07:23.369 --> 02:07:26.606 region:rollup2
CONCERNED ON WHY DO WE NEED TO
02:07:24.337 --> 02:07:27.140 region:rollup2
IDENTIFY THE HOMELESSNESS IF
02:07:26.606 --> 02:07:29.542 region:rollup2
YOU'VE GOT.
02:07:27.140 --> 02:07:30.776 region:rollup2
FOR FIFTY ONE FIFTIES OR FIVE
02:07:29.542 --> 02:07:33.146 region:rollup2
ARRESTS WITHIN THE TWELVE LAST
02:07:30.776 --> 02:07:34.580 region:rollup2
TWELVE MONTHS OR FIVE TRIPS THE
02:07:33.146 --> 02:07:36.182 region:rollup2
EMERGENCY A ROOM THAT THE
02:07:34.580 --> 02:07:37.416 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP
02:07:36.182 --> 02:07:39.886 region:rollup2
COULD BE SET UP WHY DO WE HAVE
02:07:37.416 --> 02:07:41.654 region:rollup2
THE. ADDITIONAL HOMELESSNESS.
02:07:39.886 --> 02:07:42.221 region:rollup2
ELEMENT IN THE.
02:07:41.654 --> 02:07:43.890 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP GOT
02:07:42.221 --> 02:07:45.758 region:rollup2
QUALIFICATIONS.
02:07:43.890 --> 02:07:47.426 region:rollup2
SO.
02:07:45.758 --> 02:07:50.296 region:rollup2
BOTH SAN FRANCISCO AND LOS
02:07:47.426 --> 02:07:51.931 region:rollup2
ANGELES ARM HAD INDICATED THAT
02:07:50.296 --> 02:07:52.832 region:rollup2
THERE IS A VERY.
02:07:51.931 --> 02:07:55.868 region:rollup2
STINKS.
02:07:52.832 --> 02:07:58.037 region:rollup2
SMALL A GROUP OF PEOPLE. ARE
02:07:55.868 --> 02:08:00.573 region:rollup2
CHRONICALLY HOMELESS SEVERELY
02:07:58.037 --> 02:08:02.975 region:rollup2
DRUG ADDICTED AND DYING AND EVEN
02:08:00.573 --> 02:08:03.843 region:rollup2
THOUGH ALL OF US I MEAN WE'RE
02:08:02.975 --> 02:08:05.444 region:rollup2
ALL ON THE SAME PAGE WE NEED
02:08:03.843 --> 02:08:07.346 region:rollup2
MORE RESOURCES IN THE MENTAL
02:08:05.444 --> 02:08:09.282 region:rollup2
HEALTH SYSTEM. SUPPORTIVE
02:08:07.346 --> 02:08:11.984 region:rollup2
HOUSING AND SO FORTH.
02:08:09.282 --> 02:08:13.119 region:rollup2
BUT PEOPLE WHO. WERE OUT THERE
02:08:11.984 --> 02:08:15.922 region:rollup2
ARE CITIES ARE STRUGGLING TO
02:08:13.119 --> 02:08:18.991 region:rollup2
EVEN GET INTO THE SERVICES THAT
02:08:15.922 --> 02:08:21.127 region:rollup2
DO EXIST. FIVE AND DIME THEIR
02:08:18.991 --> 02:08:23.129 region:rollup2
GOAL IN THIS BILL WAS TO MAKE IT
02:08:21.127 --> 02:08:23.863 region:rollup2
AS NARROW AS POSSIBLE. THROUGH
02:08:23.129 --> 02:08:25.865 region:rollup2
FOR EXAMPLE SOME PEOPLE SAID
02:08:23.863 --> 02:08:27.833 region:rollup2
DOES CHANGE THE DEFINITION OF
02:08:25.865 --> 02:08:28.334 region:rollup2
CREED DISABILITY IN THE LPS
02:08:27.833 --> 02:08:29.635 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE ASSEMBLY BUILD
02:08:28.334 --> 02:08:31.270 region:rollup2
OUTSIDE.
02:08:29.635 --> 02:08:33.706 region:rollup2
GOT PROTECT CHILI A MUCH BROADER
02:08:31.270 --> 02:08:38.010 region:rollup2
EXPANSION POTENTIALLY BECAUSE IT
02:08:33.706 --> 02:08:38.945 region:rollup2
CAN APPLY LPS COMPLY IN A NUMBER
02:08:38.010 --> 02:08:39.779 region:rollup2
OF CONTACT.
02:08:38.945 --> 02:08:41.814 region:rollup2
OUR GOAL HERE WAS TO MAKE THIS
02:08:39.779 --> 02:08:43.282 region:rollup2
BILL AS NARROW AS POSSIBLE TO
02:08:41.814 --> 02:08:44.850 region:rollup2
ADDRESS A VERY SPECIFIC ISSUE
02:08:43.282 --> 02:08:46.118 region:rollup2
THAT HAS BEEN BROUGHT TO US. BY
02:08:44.850 --> 02:08:48.087 region:rollup2
A NUMBER OF OUR LOCAL
02:08:46.118 --> 02:08:50.289 region:rollup2
COMMUNITIES AND THAT'S WHY WE
02:08:48.087 --> 02:08:50.856 region:rollup2
LIMITED IT IN THIS RESPECT ARE
02:08:50.289 --> 02:08:52.158 region:rollup2
THE BILL COULD BE BROUGHT IN
02:08:50.856 --> 02:08:53.426 region:rollup2
NOW.
02:08:52.158 --> 02:08:54.293 region:rollup2
BUT THEN THE CIVIL LIBERTIES
02:08:53.426 --> 02:08:56.562 region:rollup2
ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN IDENTIFIED
02:08:54.293 --> 02:08:59.332 region:rollup2
WOULD BE. EVEN BIGGER SO I CAN
02:08:56.562 --> 02:09:00.199 region:rollup2
GUARANTEE YOU. THAT IF THAT THE
02:08:59.332 --> 02:09:02.301 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHO ARE SAYING ó THIS
02:09:00.199 --> 02:09:03.369 region:rollup2
IS. FOCUSING JUST ON HOMELESS
02:09:02.301 --> 02:09:04.604 region:rollup2
PEOPLE.
02:09:03.369 --> 02:09:06.806 region:rollup2
IT OF WE WERE BROUGHT ANNOUNCE
02:09:04.604 --> 02:09:08.474 region:rollup2
OKAY COMPLIED ANYONE SEEN PEOPLE
02:09:06.806 --> 02:09:09.809 region:rollup2
WOULD BE BOXING ó MY GOD THIS
02:09:08.474 --> 02:09:11.143 region:rollup2
IS AN EVEN BIGGER INFRINGEMENT
02:09:09.809 --> 02:09:11.677 region:rollup2
ON CIVIL LIBERTIES SO WE'RE
02:09:11.143 --> 02:09:15.214 region:rollup2
TRYING TO KEEP A NARROW IN
02:09:11.677 --> 02:09:15.815 region:rollup2
FOCUS.
02:09:15.214 --> 02:09:18.017 region:rollup2
NOT ABOUT BETSY ROSS ENOUGH
02:09:15.815 --> 02:09:20.419 region:rollup2
CENTER OKAY I JUST WHOSE HERE
02:09:18.017 --> 02:09:21.787 region:rollup2
THAT THE FUNDAMENTAL IDEAS THAT
02:09:20.419 --> 02:09:23.522 region:rollup2
THEY'RE UNABLE TO CARE FOR%
02:09:21.787 --> 02:09:24.890 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES AND IF THEY'RE UNABLE
02:09:23.522 --> 02:09:26.492 region:rollup2
TO CARE FOR THEMSELVES AND THEY
02:09:24.890 --> 02:09:28.494 region:rollup2
HAVE ALL THESE TRIPS TO. THE
02:09:26.492 --> 02:09:30.596 region:rollup2
COURT FIFTY ONE FIFTY THAT IT
02:09:28.494 --> 02:09:31.931 region:rollup2
APPEARS FOR THE DETERMINATION OF
02:09:30.596 --> 02:09:34.367 region:rollup2
THE CONSERVATORSHIP SHOULD BE
02:09:31.931 --> 02:09:36.469 region:rollup2
ENOUGH AYE I JUST SEE IT
02:09:34.367 --> 02:09:37.270 region:rollup2
DIFFERENTLY BUT. IT'S IT'S A
02:09:36.469 --> 02:09:38.704 region:rollup2
REAL LIVES TO REASONABLE POINT
02:09:37.270 --> 02:09:41.340 region:rollup2
OF VIEW OF THE PROBLEM I BELIEVE
02:09:38.704 --> 02:09:42.074 region:rollup2
A FIFTY ONE FIFTY IT'S TIME
02:09:41.340 --> 02:09:43.743 region:rollup2
LIMITED.
02:09:42.074 --> 02:09:45.945 region:rollup2
A FIFTY ONE FIFTIES HOLD IS
02:09:43.743 --> 02:09:47.113 region:rollup2
THREE DAYS UP TO FOURTEEN AND
02:09:45.945 --> 02:09:49.115 region:rollup2
THEN MAYBE IF YOU HAVE A GOOD
02:09:47.113 --> 02:09:50.950 region:rollup2
SHOWING A GREAT DISABILITY YOU
02:09:49.115 --> 02:09:52.251 region:rollup2
GET YOUR YEAR. THIRTY OR THIRTY
02:09:50.950 --> 02:09:54.720 region:rollup2
DAYS FRIDAY KEIKO'S
02:09:52.251 --> 02:09:56.022 region:rollup2
INCREMENTALLY BUT LAWRENCE LAW.
02:09:54.720 --> 02:09:57.690 region:rollup2
.
02:09:56.022 --> 02:09:59.125 region:rollup2
DOESN'T DO THAT BECAUSE THAT
02:09:57.690 --> 02:10:00.660 region:rollup2
DOESN'T HAVE THAT STANDARD
02:09:59.125 --> 02:10:02.128 region:rollup2
BECAUSE WE'RE NOT AND KEEP WE'RE
02:10:00.660 --> 02:10:03.896 region:rollup2
NOT PUTTING PEOPLE INTO
02:10:02.128 --> 02:10:05.665 region:rollup2
INVOLUNTARY TREATMENT THAT ITS
02:10:03.896 --> 02:10:06.932 region:rollup2
TREATMENT WITHIN THE COMMUNITY
02:10:05.665 --> 02:10:08.801 region:rollup2
AND THEY'RE NOT.
02:10:06.932 --> 02:10:09.802 region:rollup2
DEPRIVED OF THEIR LIBERTY AND
02:10:08.801 --> 02:10:11.504 region:rollup2
WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO
02:10:09.802 --> 02:10:13.839 region:rollup2
SOMETHING IN BETWEEN.
02:10:11.504 --> 02:10:16.275 region:rollup2
SO I GUESS MY MY POINT WAS IS
02:10:13.839 --> 02:10:17.843 region:rollup2
THAT I'VE GOT PERSON A WHO SPENT
02:10:16.275 --> 02:10:19.745 region:rollup2
FIFTY ONE FIFTY FOUR TIMES A
02:10:17.843 --> 02:10:20.746 region:rollup2
PERSON BE HE'S BEEN FIFTY ONE
02:10:19.745 --> 02:10:22.815 region:rollup2
FIFTY FOUR TIMES BUT THERE
02:10:20.746 --> 02:10:24.250 region:rollup2
HOMELESS. THEY'RE ELIGIBLE THIS
02:10:22.815 --> 02:10:26.686 region:rollup2
OTHER PERSON IS NOT ELIGIBLE
02:10:24.250 --> 02:10:28.554 region:rollup2
FROM CONSERVATORSHIP IT APPEARS
02:10:26.686 --> 02:10:29.455 region:rollup2
THAT THE UNDERLYING.
02:10:28.554 --> 02:10:30.256 region:rollup2
THE SUGGESTION IS THAT THEY'RE
02:10:29.455 --> 02:10:32.058 region:rollup2
UNABLE TO CARE FOR THEMSELVES
02:10:30.256 --> 02:10:33.559 region:rollup2
BUT.
02:10:32.058 --> 02:10:34.927 region:rollup2
I LISTEN TO WHAT THE CHIP
02:10:33.559 --> 02:10:36.028 region:rollup2
JUDICIAL COUNCIL HAS TO SAY.
02:10:34.927 --> 02:10:37.430 region:rollup2
FULLER ACTUALLY THAT'S A GOOD.
02:10:36.028 --> 02:10:38.898 region:rollup2
.
02:10:37.430 --> 02:10:40.266 region:rollup2
IT COULD THE SUPPORTERS THIS
02:10:38.898 --> 02:10:41.367 region:rollup2
RESPOND TO THAT TO ME BECAUSE
02:10:40.266 --> 02:10:42.268 region:rollup2
THEY'RE THAT THE ELEMENT OF
02:10:41.367 --> 02:10:44.303 region:rollup2
HOMELESSNESS.
02:10:42.268 --> 02:10:46.772 region:rollup2
.
02:10:44.303 --> 02:10:48.274 region:rollup2
IT IS IMPLIED THE IMPLICIT THAT
02:10:46.772 --> 02:10:49.642 region:rollup2
THESE ARE THE PEOPLE TRULY CAN'T
02:10:48.274 --> 02:10:51.077 region:rollup2
CARE FOR THEMSELVES BECAUSE ARE
02:10:49.642 --> 02:10:52.244 region:rollup2
HOMELESS AND THAT IS I BELIEVE
02:10:51.077 --> 02:10:53.279 region:rollup2
SOMEONE REFERRED TO IT AS SUCH
02:10:52.244 --> 02:10:55.314 region:rollup2
STATUS.
02:10:53.279 --> 02:10:56.582 region:rollup2
NOT A CONDITION.
02:10:55.314 --> 02:10:57.650 region:rollup2
YEAH WE'RE REALLY DEEPLY
02:10:56.582 --> 02:11:00.352 region:rollup2
CONCERNED WITH HAVING
02:10:57.650 --> 02:11:01.821 region:rollup2
HOMELESSNESS AS A CRITERIA. IN
02:11:00.352 --> 02:11:02.688 region:rollup2
AND OF ITSELF FOR REMOVING CIVIL
02:11:01.821 --> 02:11:04.490 region:rollup2
LIBERTIES.
02:11:02.688 --> 02:11:05.391 region:rollup2
BECAUSE IT'S
02:11:04.490 --> 02:11:06.792 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW IT'S CAUSED BY THE LACK
02:11:05.391 --> 02:11:08.661 region:rollup2
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN ITS
02:11:06.792 --> 02:11:10.563 region:rollup2
CENTER AND AS I AS I DROUGHT AND
02:11:08.661 --> 02:11:12.031 region:rollup2
SO IF YOU'RE. YOU'RE TALKING
02:11:10.563 --> 02:11:13.666 region:rollup2
ABOUT A SYSTEM WHERE YOU GONNA
02:11:12.031 --> 02:11:15.034 region:rollup2
GO THROUGH.
02:11:13.666 --> 02:11:18.537 region:rollup2
THE COURT PROCESS YOU'RE GONNA
02:11:15.034 --> 02:11:20.506 region:rollup2
BE GIVING JURY INSTRUCTIONS ON
02:11:18.537 --> 02:11:22.541 region:rollup2
AND SETTING STANDARDS ARM AND
02:11:20.506 --> 02:11:24.710 region:rollup2
HOUSING STATUS OF DOES NOT
02:11:22.541 --> 02:11:26.345 region:rollup2
RELATED ALL WHATSOEVER TO ONE'S
02:11:24.710 --> 02:11:27.279 region:rollup2
ABILITY TO MAKE A DECISION ABOUT
02:11:26.345 --> 02:11:29.348 region:rollup2
WHETHER. THEY'RE GOING TO
02:11:27.279 --> 02:11:30.983 region:rollup2
VOLUNTARILY ACCEPT TREATMENT OR
02:11:29.348 --> 02:11:32.385 region:rollup2
INVOLUNTARY RIGHT BECAUSE
02:11:30.983 --> 02:11:34.720 region:rollup2
ARGUMENT BEHIND THIS IS THAT.
02:11:32.385 --> 02:11:35.755 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHICH. YOU KNOW WHICH WE
02:11:34.720 --> 02:11:37.523 region:rollup2
DISAGREE WITH WE SEE PEOPLE
02:11:35.755 --> 02:11:38.591 region:rollup2
EVERY DAY TRYING TO GET FIFTY
02:11:37.523 --> 02:11:40.693 region:rollup2
ONE FIFTY THEY LITERALLY GO TO
02:11:38.591 --> 02:11:42.094 region:rollup2
TECH EMERGENCY AND SAY CAN YOU
02:11:40.693 --> 02:11:44.597 region:rollup2
PLEASE FIFTY ONE FIFTY MAKE. OF
02:11:42.094 --> 02:11:45.731 region:rollup2
THEIR LOCKED OUT OF CARE SO ON
02:11:44.597 --> 02:11:47.533 region:rollup2
BUT NONE THE LESS THE IDEA I
02:11:45.731 --> 02:11:49.101 region:rollup2
THINK BEHIND THIS IS THAT YOU
02:11:47.533 --> 02:11:50.636 region:rollup2
HAVE FOLKS WHO WERE IN AND.
02:11:49.101 --> 02:11:52.738 region:rollup2
IN GREAT NEED LET'S SAY SOMEONE
02:11:50.636 --> 02:11:53.472 region:rollup2
WITH AN ADDICTIVE DISORDER AND
02:11:52.738 --> 02:11:56.075 region:rollup2
THEY ARE.
02:11:53.472 --> 02:11:59.512 region:rollup2
DIET REFUSING TREATMENT.
02:11:56.075 --> 02:12:00.179 region:rollup2
AS IF THAT TREATMENT WHEREVER.
02:11:59.512 --> 02:12:01.714 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW PRESENTED TO THEM WHICH
02:12:00.179 --> 02:12:02.181 region:rollup2
IT'S NOT BUT LET'S PRETEND IT
02:12:01.714 --> 02:12:04.383 region:rollup2
WAS.
02:12:02.181 --> 02:12:05.618 region:rollup2
IT AND THEN WE'RE SAYING OKAY
02:12:04.383 --> 02:12:06.752 region:rollup2
BECAUSE YOU DON'T HAVE HOUSING
02:12:05.618 --> 02:12:08.487 region:rollup2
BECAUSE YOU'RE TOO POOR TO
02:12:06.752 --> 02:12:09.722 region:rollup2
AFFORD A PLACE TO LIVE. THAT
02:12:08.487 --> 02:12:11.223 region:rollup2
ITSELF IS A CRITERIA FOR
02:12:09.722 --> 02:12:11.757 region:rollup2
DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT WE'RE
02:12:11.223 --> 02:12:12.892 region:rollup2
GONNA TAKE AWAY YOUR CIVIL
02:12:11.757 --> 02:12:14.794 region:rollup2
LIBERTIES IT'S HIGHLY
02:12:12.892 --> 02:12:17.329 region:rollup2
PROBLEMATIC BECAUSE IT HAS NO
02:12:14.794 --> 02:12:19.498 region:rollup2
CLINICAL OR. JUSTIFICATION
02:12:17.329 --> 02:12:21.434 region:rollup2
BEHIND IT.
02:12:19.498 --> 02:12:22.001 region:rollup2
SO I'M PLEASE GO AND RESPOND TO
02:12:21.434 --> 02:12:23.769 region:rollup2
THAT VERY VERY QUICKLY IF WE
02:12:22.001 --> 02:12:26.305 region:rollup2
SAW.
02:12:23.769 --> 02:12:27.673 region:rollup2
THIS BILL IS NOT ABOUT YOUR TOO
02:12:26.305 --> 02:12:29.175 region:rollup2
POOR FOR A PLACE TO LIVE AND SO
02:12:27.673 --> 02:12:33.445 region:rollup2
WE'RE GONNA CONSERVE YOU THIS IS
02:12:29.175 --> 02:12:35.247 region:rollup2
ABOUT PEOPLE WHO ARE SEVERELY.
02:12:33.445 --> 02:12:37.550 region:rollup2
SICK AND YOU ARE DYING ON OUR
02:12:35.247 --> 02:12:39.185 region:rollup2
STREETS AND AND AND TO AND I
02:12:37.550 --> 02:12:40.186 region:rollup2
KNOW THAT THE RHETORIC ALL WILL
02:12:39.185 --> 02:12:41.420 region:rollup2
ALWAYS COME BACK TO THIS IS JUST
02:12:40.186 --> 02:12:43.055 region:rollup2
A WAY OF ROUNDING UP POOR EOPLE
02:12:41.420 --> 02:12:44.824 region:rollup2
WHO CAN'T AFFORD HOUSING. THAT
02:12:43.055 --> 02:12:45.925 region:rollup2
IS NOT WHAT THE BILL IS ABOUT.
02:12:44.824 --> 02:12:48.928 region:rollup2
IT THAT DOES NOT MEET THE
02:12:45.925 --> 02:12:50.129 region:rollup2
CRITERIA OF THE BILL AND YOU
02:12:48.928 --> 02:12:51.430 region:rollup2
KNOW I THINK IT'S VERY CLEAR
02:12:50.129 --> 02:12:52.932 region:rollup2
WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH
02:12:51.430 --> 02:12:54.533 region:rollup2
AND WE CAN TALK ABOUT HOW THE
02:12:52.932 --> 02:12:55.334 region:rollup2
BILL IS STRUCTURED THE DETAILS
02:12:54.533 --> 02:12:56.902 region:rollup2
OF THE BILL TO MAKE SURE
02:12:55.334 --> 02:12:58.437 region:rollup2
COMPETITION NOT. A FAIR
02:12:56.902 --> 02:13:01.440 region:rollup2
DISCUSSION BUT IT DIED THE LAST
02:12:58.437 --> 02:13:02.808 region:rollup2
COMMENT I JUST I STRONGLY
02:13:01.440 --> 02:13:04.043 region:rollup2
DISAGREE ABOUT WITHOUT.
02:13:02.808 --> 02:13:05.845 region:rollup2
SO PART OF THIS GUY AND I'D LIKE
02:13:04.043 --> 02:13:06.812 region:rollup2
TO ASK THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL THAT
02:13:05.845 --> 02:13:08.781 region:rollup2
WE HAVE TO KEEP INDIA GOING E
02:13:06.812 --> 02:13:10.149 region:rollup2
COULD SPEND A MONTH ON THIS SITE
02:13:08.781 --> 02:13:13.052 region:rollup2
A SUSPECT. BUT.
02:13:10.149 --> 02:13:14.820 region:rollup2
WITH THE LPS SYSTEM WHICH IS
02:13:13.052 --> 02:13:16.455 region:rollup2
THE THE ONE THAT RISES TO
02:13:14.820 --> 02:13:18.958 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTIONAL LEVEL BECAUSE WE
02:13:16.455 --> 02:13:20.392 region:rollup2
ARE DENYING PEOPLE OF THEIR.
02:13:18.958 --> 02:13:21.694 region:rollup2
THEIR LIBERTY. BUT. MY
02:13:20.392 --> 02:13:23.162 region:rollup2
UNDERSTANDING IS A CASE LAW
02:13:21.694 --> 02:13:25.698 region:rollup2
PROVIDES THE QUARTZ WITH THE
02:13:23.162 --> 02:13:27.499 region:rollup2
ABILITY OF A TO CONSIDER
02:13:25.698 --> 02:13:29.001 region:rollup2
PERSON'S PAST HISTORY. A WITH
02:13:27.499 --> 02:13:30.369 region:rollup2
THE LPS SYSTEM IF THAT
02:13:29.001 --> 02:13:32.605 region:rollup2
INFORMATION.
02:13:30.369 --> 02:13:34.273 region:rollup2
OR IS THAT INFORMATION PROVIDED
02:13:32.605 --> 02:13:36.709 region:rollup2
TO THE COURT WHEN THERE'S AN LPS
02:13:34.273 --> 02:13:38.410 region:rollup2
PROCEEDING.
02:13:36.709 --> 02:13:39.678 region:rollup2
BOTTOM. ETCETERA JERRY DIDN'T
02:13:38.410 --> 02:13:40.145 region:rollup2
COME FOR THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL.
02:13:39.678 --> 02:13:40.713 region:rollup2
THEM YOU'RE CORRECT WE
02:13:40.145 --> 02:13:42.214 region:rollup2
DON'T-HAVE A POSITION ON THE
02:13:40.713 --> 02:13:43.616 region:rollup2
BILL
02:13:42.214 --> 02:13:45.050 region:rollup2
THESE ARE POLICY ISSUES OUTSIDE
02:13:43.616 --> 02:13:47.052 region:rollup2
OUR PURVIEW WE WILL BE LOOKING
02:13:45.050 --> 02:13:48.387 region:rollup2
AT THE FISCAL. THE IMPLICATION
02:13:47.052 --> 02:13:49.455 region:rollup2
SHOULD THE BILL MOVE FORWARD BUT
02:13:48.387 --> 02:13:51.757 region:rollup2
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT
02:13:49.455 --> 02:13:53.559 region:rollup2
HISTORICAL COURSE INFORMATION.
02:13:51.757 --> 02:13:55.828 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE PERSON'S CONDITION IS
02:13:53.559 --> 02:13:57.496 region:rollup2
RECOGNIZE BOTH THROUGH STATUTE
02:13:55.828 --> 02:13:58.864 region:rollup2
IN CASE LAW ON THAT SOMETHING
02:13:57.496 --> 02:14:01.767 region:rollup2
THAT'S FROM ROUTINELY PRESENTED.
02:13:58.864 --> 02:14:03.636 region:rollup2
IN LPS CASES.
02:14:01.767 --> 02:14:04.670 region:rollup2
SO IT IS THERE IT IS TO THINK
02:14:03.636 --> 02:14:06.605 region:rollup2
THERE'S A FURTHER NEED FOR
02:14:04.670 --> 02:14:08.107 region:rollup2
EDUCATION OF OUR BENCH OFFICERS.
02:14:06.605 --> 02:14:09.942 region:rollup2
.
02:14:08.107 --> 02:14:11.110 region:rollup2
OF REGARDING THIS SYSTEM I MEAN
02:14:09.942 --> 02:14:11.977 region:rollup2
TO INC YOU'VE HEARD THE
02:14:11.110 --> 02:14:13.812 region:rollup2
TESTIMONY YOU'VE HEARD THE.
02:14:11.977 --> 02:14:16.081 region:rollup2
.
02:14:13.812 --> 02:14:17.850 region:rollup2
THE CONCERNS UNDER THE LPS
02:14:16.081 --> 02:14:20.419 region:rollup2
SYSTEM WHICH IS THE WAY WE CAN
02:14:17.850 --> 02:14:21.720 region:rollup2
BRING THESE PEOPLE IN AND. OF
02:14:20.419 --> 02:14:23.122 region:rollup2
REQUIRED THAT THEY THEY GET
02:14:21.720 --> 02:14:24.690 region:rollup2
TREATMENT
02:14:23.122 --> 02:14:26.492 region:rollup2
BOB YEAH BUT ONLY AFTER THOSE
02:14:24.690 --> 02:14:28.594 region:rollup2
PROTECTIONS ARE MET.
02:14:26.492 --> 02:14:29.962 region:rollup2
HE DO YOU BELIEVE THE LPS SYSTEM
02:14:28.594 --> 02:14:32.298 region:rollup2
AT LEAST AS THE COURTS HAVE
02:14:29.962 --> 02:14:34.633 region:rollup2
IMPLEMENTED IT. UP WOULD BE AN
02:14:32.298 --> 02:14:36.101 region:rollup2
OPTION THAT IS OTHERWISE
02:14:34.633 --> 02:14:37.670 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE.
02:14:36.101 --> 02:14:39.638 region:rollup2
IF THE COURTS TO EITHER
02:14:37.670 --> 02:14:41.140 region:rollup2
EDUCATED ON IT OR DO THEY HAVE
02:14:39.638 --> 02:14:43.242 region:rollup2
THAT INFORMATION TODAY.
02:14:41.140 --> 02:14:44.810 region:rollup2
CONTEND WERE TRUSTS YOU REALLY
02:14:43.242 --> 02:14:46.812 region:rollup2
SERIOUS PROBLEM.
02:14:44.810 --> 02:14:49.848 region:rollup2
WHAT DOES THIS FIT WITHIN OUT
02:14:46.812 --> 02:14:51.517 region:rollup2
THE LPS SYSTEM FROM THE AND?
02:14:49.848 --> 02:14:53.252 region:rollup2
I'VE I'VE NOT HEARD FROM THE
02:14:51.517 --> 02:14:55.454 region:rollup2
PROPONENTS ARE SAN FRANCISCO
02:14:53.252 --> 02:14:56.956 region:rollup2
COUNTY ABOUT. COMPLAINTS ABOUT
02:14:55.454 --> 02:14:58.757 region:rollup2
JUDICIAL OFFICERS IN SAN
02:14:56.956 --> 02:15:00.759 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO.
02:14:58.757 --> 02:15:02.094 region:rollup2
IN PARTICULAR ORDERED MORE
02:15:00.759 --> 02:15:04.863 region:rollup2
GENERALLY ACROSS THE STATE.
02:15:02.094 --> 02:15:07.232 region:rollup2
NOT UNDERSTANDING OR MISS
02:15:04.863 --> 02:15:08.867 region:rollup2
SUPPLYING WHAT THE CURRENT LEGAL
02:15:07.232 --> 02:15:10.302 region:rollup2
STANDARDS ARE IT MAY BE A
02:15:08.867 --> 02:15:11.971 region:rollup2
DIFFERENCE OF OPINION ABOUT.
02:15:10.302 --> 02:15:13.272 region:rollup2
INTERPRETING HOW THE STANDARDS
02:15:11.971 --> 02:15:15.741 region:rollup2
ARE BEING APPLIED ON A CASE BY%
02:15:13.272 --> 02:15:17.509 region:rollup2
CASE BASIS IT'S OFTEN THE CASE.
02:15:15.741 --> 02:15:19.378 region:rollup2
AND LPS ESPECIALLY AFTER A SHORT
02:15:17.509 --> 02:15:21.413 region:rollup2
TERM DETENTION IF TREATMENT IS
02:15:19.378 --> 02:15:22.815 region:rollup2
BEING PROVIDED. THOUGHT THAT THE
02:15:21.413 --> 02:15:24.583 region:rollup2
CONDITION THAT LED TO THE
02:15:22.815 --> 02:15:26.051 region:rollup2
DETENTION HAS AMELIORATED
02:15:24.583 --> 02:15:27.820 region:rollup2
SOMEWHAT IT IS OFTEN THE CASE
02:15:26.051 --> 02:15:29.221 region:rollup2
THAT SOMEONE PRESENT AT THE TIME
02:15:27.820 --> 02:15:30.723 region:rollup2
OF THE HEARING. WHETHER IT'S AT
02:15:29.221 --> 02:15:31.991 region:rollup2
A FIFTY TO FIFTY HEARING OR A
02:15:30.723 --> 02:15:33.759 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP HEARING THERE IN
02:15:31.991 --> 02:15:35.127 region:rollup2
BETTER SHAPE OR THEY HAVE A PLAN
02:15:33.759 --> 02:15:36.395 region:rollup2
FOR THIRD PARTY ASSISTANCE.
02:15:35.127 --> 02:15:37.730 region:rollup2
AND THE LAW REQUIRES THAT YOU
02:15:36.395 --> 02:15:39.665 region:rollup2
LOOK AT WHAT THEIR PRESENT
02:15:37.730 --> 02:15:41.967 region:rollup2
CONDITION IS AT THE TIME.
02:15:39.665 --> 02:15:43.902 region:rollup2
THAT'S ONE QUESTION. THAT I
02:15:41.967 --> 02:15:45.104 region:rollup2
WOULD HAVE IS. THE WHOLE
02:15:43.902 --> 02:15:46.538 region:rollup2
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE WHEN
02:15:45.104 --> 02:15:48.774 region:rollup2
LAURA'S LAW WAS BEING.
02:15:46.538 --> 02:15:49.408 region:rollup2
CONSIDERED BY THIS LEGISLATURE
02:15:48.774 --> 02:15:50.376 region:rollup2
OVER THE SEVERAL YEARS BEFORE IT
02:15:49.408 --> 02:15:52.778 region:rollup2
WAS PASSED
02:15:50.376 --> 02:15:54.213 region:rollup2
WITH I BELIEVE ABOUT THE
02:15:52.778 --> 02:15:56.115 region:rollup2
POPULATION THAT SIMILARLY BEING
02:15:54.213 --> 02:15:56.715 region:rollup2
DESCRIBED. IN SUPPORT OF THE
02:15:56.115 --> 02:15:58.417 region:rollup2
NEED FOR THIS PARTICULAR BILL
02:15:56.715 --> 02:16:00.386 region:rollup2
SO.
02:15:58.417 --> 02:16:01.987 region:rollup2
IT AS FAR AS I'VE HEARD OUR
02:16:00.386 --> 02:16:03.689 region:rollup2
JUDICIAL OFFICERS ARE WELL
02:16:01.987 --> 02:16:05.424 region:rollup2
FAMILIAR WITH THE CRITERIA. OF
02:16:03.689 --> 02:16:06.825 region:rollup2
BOTH SCHEMES AND THEY HAVE A
02:16:05.424 --> 02:16:08.327 region:rollup2
PROBATE INSTITUTE WHERE. THE
02:16:06.825 --> 02:16:09.395 region:rollup2
THAT THE OFFICERS RECEIVE
02:16:08.327 --> 02:16:10.629 region:rollup2
TRAINING ON WHAT THE CURRENT
02:16:09.395 --> 02:16:12.965 region:rollup2
STANDARDS ARE IN THE NEW
02:16:10.629 --> 02:16:14.667 region:rollup2
DEVELOPMENTS IN THE CASE LAW OR.
02:16:12.965 --> 02:16:16.902 region:rollup2
THE LEGISLATIVE CHANGES BUT IT
02:16:14.667 --> 02:16:17.503 region:rollup2
LEAST UNTIL TODAY I HAVE NOT
02:16:16.902 --> 02:16:19.171 region:rollup2
HEARD ANY SPECIFIC COMPLAINTS
02:16:17.503 --> 02:16:21.306 region:rollup2
ABOUT. PROBLEMS WITH INDIVIDUAL
02:16:19.171 --> 02:16:23.175 region:rollup2
CALL SO SO MY LAST QUESTION TWO
02:16:21.306 --> 02:16:24.643 region:rollup2
IS CAN A COURT ORDER UNDER LARA
02:16:23.175 --> 02:16:26.145 region:rollup2
SLAW.
02:16:24.643 --> 02:16:29.014 region:rollup2
CONTAIN THE TREATMENT OPTIONS
02:16:26.145 --> 02:16:31.750 region:rollup2
THAT ARE BEING SOUGHT BY. THE
02:16:29.014 --> 02:16:33.719 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION BROUGHT TODAY AS
02:16:31.750 --> 02:16:35.754 region:rollup2
DISCUSSED BY THE WITNESSES IN
02:16:33.719 --> 02:16:38.290 region:rollup2
YOUR OPINION. AND BEGIN MY
02:16:35.754 --> 02:16:40.025 region:rollup2
UNDERSTANDING GENERALLY IS THAT
02:16:38.290 --> 02:16:41.760 region:rollup2
LAWYERS LAW WAS DESIGNED TO TRY
02:16:40.025 --> 02:16:43.529 region:rollup2
TO ADDRESS THE POPULATION THAT
02:16:41.760 --> 02:16:45.330 region:rollup2
WAS BEING DESCRIBED CYCLES IN
02:16:43.529 --> 02:16:46.365 region:rollup2
AND OUT THAT MAY GET IT TOGETHER
02:16:45.330 --> 02:16:47.733 region:rollup2
ENOUGH AT THE TIME OF THE
02:16:46.365 --> 02:16:49.868 region:rollup2
HEARING TO NOT MEET IN PATIENT
02:16:47.733 --> 02:16:51.637 region:rollup2
CRITERIA BUT. BASED ON THEIR
02:16:49.868 --> 02:16:52.871 region:rollup2
HISTORY OF HISTORICAL COURSE
02:16:51.637 --> 02:16:55.240 region:rollup2
KIND OF INFORMATION THAT'S
02:16:52.871 --> 02:16:56.742 region:rollup2
PRESENTED MAY LOOK MAY LIKELY BE
02:16:55.240 --> 02:16:58.243 region:rollup2
BACK IN THE SYSTEM AND THAT
02:16:56.742 --> 02:16:59.611 region:rollup2
THEIR FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH
02:16:58.243 --> 02:17:01.346 region:rollup2
TREATMENT SO LAURA'S LOT WITH
02:16:59.611 --> 02:17:03.082 region:rollup2
ALL DESIGNED FOR. THAT
02:17:01.346 --> 02:17:05.117 region:rollup2
POPULATION THAT THE HAMMER OVER
02:17:03.082 --> 02:17:06.819 region:rollup2
THAT IN THE FAILURE TO FOLLOW
02:17:05.117 --> 02:17:07.953 region:rollup2
THROUGH WITH THAT TREATMENT. AND
02:17:06.819 --> 02:17:10.656 region:rollup2
IT'S A BROAD BASE OF TREATMENTS
02:17:07.953 --> 02:17:11.824 region:rollup2
THAT MUST BE OFFERED IN ORDER
02:17:10.656 --> 02:17:14.393 region:rollup2
FOR THE COUNTY TO EVEN.
02:17:11.824 --> 02:17:16.028 region:rollup2
OPT INTO THE PROGRAM. M. AGAIN
02:17:14.393 --> 02:17:17.429 region:rollup2
UNLESS I'M MISSING SOMETHING IT
02:17:16.028 --> 02:17:18.964 region:rollup2
WAS DESIGNED FOR ADDRESSING A
02:17:17.429 --> 02:17:20.733 region:rollup2
VERY SIMILAR POPULATION AND WITH
02:17:18.964 --> 02:17:22.301 region:rollup2
THAT SENATOR WIENER WHICH YOU
02:17:20.733 --> 02:17:24.536 region:rollup2
RESPOND TO THAT IN YOUR CLOTHES
02:17:22.301 --> 02:17:25.971 region:rollup2
OUT. AT THIS POINT.
02:17:24.536 --> 02:17:26.572 region:rollup2
WOULD YOU GO HIM CLOSE PLACE
02:17:25.971 --> 02:17:30.209 region:rollup2
OKAY GREAT.
02:17:26.572 --> 02:17:31.276 region:rollup2
FIVE THANK YOU AGAIN AND I I
02:17:30.209 --> 02:17:33.045 region:rollup2
HAD TO REALIZE THAT THE JUICE OF
02:17:31.276 --> 02:17:33.879 region:rollup2
COUNSEL I'D LIKE MEDICINE WAS
02:17:33.045 --> 02:17:35.047 region:rollup2
THAT DON'T HAVE A POSITION ON AT
02:17:33.879 --> 02:17:37.616 region:rollup2
THAT TIME THE LITTLE BIT LIKE A
02:17:35.047 --> 02:17:38.684 region:rollup2
POSITION BUT. I WANT TO JUST
02:17:37.616 --> 02:17:39.551 region:rollup2
RESPOND NO IT.
02:17:38.684 --> 02:17:41.186 region:rollup2
WHATEVER IT IS WOULD YOU RESPOND
02:17:39.551 --> 02:17:42.821 region:rollup2
TO THE CONCERNS BECAUSE THAT'S
02:17:41.186 --> 02:17:44.289 region:rollup2
SORT OF THE GRAVEL MEN OF THE
02:17:42.821 --> 02:17:45.791 region:rollup2
PROBLEM RIGHT HERE DO THAT
02:17:44.289 --> 02:17:47.860 region:rollup2
MANAGER FIRST OF ALL. LOWERS LAW
02:17:45.791 --> 02:17:49.394 region:rollup2
IS NOT NEARLY AS COMPREHENSIVE
02:17:47.860 --> 02:17:50.796 region:rollup2
AS A CONSERVATORSHIP.
02:17:49.394 --> 02:17:53.232 region:rollup2
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE WHO
02:17:50.796 --> 02:17:55.901 region:rollup2
DO SUCH AS A BALLOT MEDICATION.
02:17:53.232 --> 02:17:57.436 region:rollup2
TREATMENT IT'S ALSO ABOUT THE
02:17:55.901 --> 02:17:59.371 region:rollup2
GLOBAL WELL BEING AT A
02:17:57.436 --> 02:18:01.607 region:rollup2
CONSERVATIVE HAS THOSE BROAD
02:17:59.371 --> 02:18:02.674 region:rollup2
TOOLS TO CONSIDER SOMEONE'S
02:18:01.607 --> 02:18:05.110 region:rollup2
OVERALL WELL BEING AND HELP THEM
02:18:02.674 --> 02:18:07.446 region:rollup2
GET HEALTHY SOLARZ LAW NOTHING
02:18:05.110 --> 02:18:08.347 region:rollup2
IS NO OVERLAP. BUT I DON'T THINK
02:18:07.446 --> 02:18:09.815 region:rollup2
IT'S ACCURATE TO SAY THE LORD'S
02:18:08.347 --> 02:18:11.450 region:rollup2
LAW SO IT'S WILL ACHIEVE WHAT
02:18:09.815 --> 02:18:13.552 region:rollup2
WE'RE DOING HERE TONIGHT IT IS A
02:18:11.450 --> 02:18:13.886 region:rollup2
PIECE OF THE PUZZLE. CON IN
02:18:13.552 --> 02:18:15.587 region:rollup2
TERMS.
02:18:13.886 --> 02:18:17.089 region:rollup2
AND I'M TEARS YOU KNOW BECAUSE
02:18:15.587 --> 02:18:19.291 region:rollup2
WHEN WE MET WITH FOLKS FROM SAN
02:18:17.089 --> 02:18:21.393 region:rollup2
FRANCISCO ON THERE ARE JUDGES
02:18:19.291 --> 02:18:23.896 region:rollup2
WHO ARE ABSOLUTELY SAME PERSON
02:18:21.393 --> 02:18:25.964 region:rollup2
LOOKS FINE NOW. NO BASIS TO HOLD
02:18:23.896 --> 02:18:27.266 region:rollup2
THEM AND NOT JUST ACCOUNTS
02:18:25.964 --> 02:18:28.800 region:rollup2
LEADING ADMITTED THAT OCCURRED
02:18:27.266 --> 02:18:29.401 region:rollup2
TO THEIR KNOWLEDGE THAT I CAN BE
02:18:28.800 --> 02:18:31.170 region:rollup2
THE CASE.
02:18:29.401 --> 02:18:33.872 region:rollup2
AND AND WE'RE TRYING TO CLARIFY
02:18:31.170 --> 02:18:37.142 region:rollup2
THE LAW THAT THEY CAN ACTUALLY.
02:18:33.872 --> 02:18:39.945 region:rollup2
CONSIDER OTHER WHAT HAS GONE
02:18:37.142 --> 02:18:41.780 region:rollup2
BEFORE. DONE SO NON COLLEAGUES I
02:18:39.945 --> 02:18:43.048 region:rollup2
KNOW THIS IS A HARD ISSUE AND
02:18:41.780 --> 02:18:44.917 region:rollup2
WHEN THIS BILL WAS FIRST BROUGHT
02:18:43.048 --> 02:18:45.484 region:rollup2
TO ME. I I YOU KNOW YOU GET A
02:18:44.917 --> 02:18:48.053 region:rollup2
BILL LIKE THISTO TAKE A DEEP
02:18:45.484 --> 02:18:48.921 region:rollup2
BREATH. YOU KNOW THAT ANYTIME
02:18:48.053 --> 02:18:50.355 region:rollup2
YOU'RE EXPANDING A
02:18:48.921 --> 02:18:52.157 region:rollup2
CONSERVATORSHIP OR CREATING A
02:18:50.355 --> 02:18:54.026 region:rollup2
NEW CONSUMERS HAVE THERE'S GOING
02:18:52.157 --> 02:18:54.927 region:rollup2
TO BE IT'S GOING TO HARD BILL IS
02:18:54.026 --> 02:18:56.428 region:rollup2
GOING TO BE A LOT OF BACK AND
02:18:54.927 --> 02:18:59.565 region:rollup2
FORTH. A LOT OF.
02:18:56.428 --> 02:19:00.799 region:rollup2
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION FIVE BIG
02:18:59.565 --> 02:19:02.501 region:rollup2
AND THAT'S HOW IT SHOULD BE
02:19:00.799 --> 02:19:03.569 region:rollup2
DELIVER TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE
02:19:02.501 --> 02:19:05.704 region:rollup2
CIVIL LIBERTIES I DON'T TAKE
02:19:03.569 --> 02:19:07.506 region:rollup2
THIS LIGHTLY IT'S A SERIOUS
02:19:05.704 --> 02:19:09.241 region:rollup2
THING TO CONSERVE SOMEONE. UP
02:19:07.506 --> 02:19:11.643 region:rollup2
BUT THE REALITY IS THAT THERE
02:19:09.241 --> 02:19:13.378 region:rollup2
ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE. DYING ON OUR
02:19:11.643 --> 02:19:15.380 region:rollup2
STREETS AND THE CURRENT TOOLS
02:19:13.378 --> 02:19:15.881 region:rollup2
THAT WE HAVE ARE NOT REACHING
02:19:15.380 --> 02:19:19.484 region:rollup2
THEM.
02:19:15.881 --> 02:19:21.920 region:rollup2
AND THIS ADDITIONAL NARROW TOOL.
02:19:19.484 --> 02:19:24.590 region:rollup2
WILL HELP AND WE ARE BEING TOLD
02:19:21.920 --> 02:19:26.358 region:rollup2
THAT. BY OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES
02:19:24.590 --> 02:19:29.061 region:rollup2
ARE SAYING. TOOLS WE HAVE AREN'T
02:19:26.358 --> 02:19:31.063 region:rollup2
ENOUGH WE NEED ANOTHER TOOL. ON
02:19:29.061 --> 02:19:32.531 region:rollup2
OF COURSE IN COMBINATION WITH
02:19:31.063 --> 02:19:39.805 region:rollup2
RESOURCES I SUPPORT THAT A
02:19:32.531 --> 02:19:40.806 region:rollup2
THOUSAND PERCENT AND I
02:19:39.805 --> 02:19:41.740 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AUTO.
02:19:40.806 --> 02:19:43.575 region:rollup2
THANK YOU CENTURY THANK YOU TO
02:19:41.740 --> 02:19:45.744 region:rollup2
ALL OF YOU THIS AGAIN IT'S A
02:19:43.575 --> 02:19:47.279 region:rollup2
VERY CALM I THINK AN ANGUISHING.
02:19:45.744 --> 02:19:48.447 region:rollup2
A SET OF CIRCUMSTANCES AND.
02:19:47.279 --> 02:19:49.281 region:rollup2
WITH THAT WE HAVE A MOTION.
02:19:48.447 --> 02:19:51.116 region:rollup2
WITH DEMANDS TO BE TAKEN IN
02:19:49.281 --> 02:19:53.185 region:rollup2
PUBLIC SAFETY AND I ALSO WANT TO
02:19:51.116 --> 02:19:54.953 region:rollup2
INDICATE IS SENATOR MONNING I'M.
02:19:53.185 --> 02:19:56.722 region:rollup2
HOPING TO HELP
02:19:54.953 --> 02:19:58.490 region:rollup2
GET TO RESOLUTION BUT I DO ALSO
02:19:56.722 --> 02:20:00.659 region:rollup2
RESERVE THE RIGHT AT SOME POINT
02:19:58.490 --> 02:20:02.160 region:rollup2
IF THIS DOES NOT MEET WHAT.
02:20:00.659 --> 02:20:03.896 region:rollup2
I BELIEVE IT NEEDS TO AYE ONE
02:20:02.160 --> 02:20:07.165 region:rollup2
SPORT BUT FOR TODAY PLEASE CALL
02:20:03.896 --> 02:20:10.102 region:rollup2
OUR.
02:20:07.165 --> 02:20:11.169 region:rollup2
IT DIDN'T MOTION.
02:20:10.102 --> 02:20:13.038 region:rollup2
WE NEED A MOTION BIGGEST THANK
02:20:11.169 --> 02:20:15.507 region:rollup2
YOU DID PASSED A PUBLIC SAFETY
02:20:13.038 --> 02:20:16.975 region:rollup2
DO WE HAVE SUCH A MOTION.
02:20:15.507 --> 02:20:18.143 region:rollup2
I'M.
02:20:16.975 --> 02:20:20.279 region:rollup2
SENATOR MORE LIKE MOVES PLEASE
02:20:18.143 --> 02:20:22.414 region:rollup2
CALL THE ROLL.
02:20:20.279 --> 02:20:24.816 region:rollup2
JACKSON AYE JACKSON AYE AND MORE
02:20:22.414 --> 02:20:27.119 region:rollup2
LOCK MORE LUCK AYE ANDERSON.
02:20:24.816 --> 02:20:29.888 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG.
02:20:27.119 --> 02:20:32.324 region:rollup2
MONNING. MONNING AYE STERN
02:20:29.888 --> 02:20:32.991 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE
02:20:32.324 --> 02:20:34.459 region:rollup2
RIGHT THAT HIS FOUR VOTES WILL
02:20:32.991 --> 02:20:35.661 region:rollup2
KEEP THE ROLE OF THANK YOU
02:20:34.459 --> 02:20:37.429 region:rollup2
SENATOR WIENER.
02:20:35.661 --> 02:20:39.398 region:rollup2
AND THANK YOU SENATOR A MITCHELL
02:20:37.429 --> 02:20:42.834 region:rollup2
FOR BEING SO PATIENT.
02:20:39.398 --> 02:20:45.003 region:rollup2
FASCINATING DISCUSSION I'M SURE
02:20:42.834 --> 02:20:49.675 region:rollup2
BOTH AFFIDAVIT I JUST WISH THE
02:20:45.003 --> 02:20:49.841 region:rollup2
ROOM OR NOT SUBZERO.
02:20:49.675 --> 02:20:51.076 region:rollup2
I.
02:20:49.841 --> 02:20:51.710 region:rollup2
FEEL THEIR WAY OF TIPS ABOUT
02:20:51.076 --> 02:20:52.344 region:rollup2
MOST OF THE ROOMS IN THIS
02:20:51.710 --> 02:20:54.046 region:rollup2
BUILDING EFFORT THIS ONE FELT
02:20:52.344 --> 02:20:56.181 region:rollup2
WARMER THAN WHERE WE WERE THIS
02:20:54.046 --> 02:20:58.517 region:rollup2
MORNING SO GO FIGURE I THINK I'M
02:20:56.181 --> 02:21:00.686 region:rollup2
NOW JUST HIM GOT IT. ALRIGHT.
02:20:58.517 --> 02:21:03.322 region:rollup2
SO WE ARE ON FILE ITEM TWELVE
02:21:00.686 --> 02:21:06.792 region:rollup2
THIS IS S. B. THIRTEEN FORTY
02:21:03.322 --> 02:21:08.860 region:rollup2
THREE AND I UNDERSTAND.
02:21:06.792 --> 02:21:10.462 region:rollup2
IT'S. I UNDERSTOOD HIS SENATOR
02:21:08.860 --> 02:21:11.797 region:rollup2
THAT YOU ARE TAKING ALL OF THE
02:21:10.462 --> 02:21:14.099 region:rollup2
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS DETAILED IN
02:21:11.797 --> 02:21:15.867 region:rollup2
THE ANALYSIS.
02:21:14.099 --> 02:21:19.204 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR I AM THINKING THEIR
02:21:15.867 --> 02:21:22.341 region:rollup2
TECHNICAL IN NATURE WE ACCEPT.
02:21:19.204 --> 02:21:23.742 region:rollup2
VERY GOOD.
02:21:22.341 --> 02:21:25.110 region:rollup2
WITH THAT PLEASE PROCEED THANK
02:21:23.742 --> 02:21:26.678 region:rollup2
YOU VERY MUCH I'M PRESENTING
02:21:25.110 --> 02:21:29.081 region:rollup2
CALLING FOR THE BILL THIRTEEN
02:21:26.678 --> 02:21:30.415 region:rollup2
FORTY THREE WHICH TAKES A MODEST
02:21:29.081 --> 02:21:32.718 region:rollup2
STEP TOWARD A MORE EQUITABLE
02:21:30.415 --> 02:21:34.319 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE BY ESTABLISHING A BASE
02:21:32.718 --> 02:21:36.288 region:rollup2
STANDARD REQUIREMENT. THAT ALL
02:21:34.319 --> 02:21:37.789 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES WHO WORK FOR COMPANIES
02:21:36.288 --> 02:21:39.758 region:rollup2
WITH FIVE OR MORE EMPLOYEES
02:21:37.789 --> 02:21:41.193 region:rollup2
RECEIVE INFORMATION TRAINING ON
02:21:39.758 --> 02:21:42.794 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT PREVENTION.
02:21:41.193 --> 02:21:43.762 region:rollup2
SINCE TWO THOUSAND SEVEN
02:21:42.794 --> 02:21:45.163 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS WITH FIFTY OR MORE
02:21:43.762 --> 02:21:46.698 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES THESE HAVE BEEN
02:21:45.163 --> 02:21:48.233 region:rollup2
REQUIRED TO PROVIDE TWO HOURS OF
02:21:46.698 --> 02:21:49.868 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT PREVENTION
02:21:48.233 --> 02:21:52.070 region:rollup2
TRAINING TO ALL SUPERVISORS
02:21:49.868 --> 02:21:54.172 region:rollup2
EVERY TWO YEARS.
02:21:52.070 --> 02:21:56.308 region:rollup2
CURRENT STANDARD. FOR INFORMING
02:21:54.172 --> 02:21:57.509 region:rollup2
NON SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES ABOUT
02:21:56.308 --> 02:21:58.844 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT PREVENTION
02:21:57.509 --> 02:22:00.112 region:rollup2
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES IT
02:21:58.844 --> 02:22:02.547 region:rollup2
THROUGH A POSTER THAT ALL
02:22:00.112 --> 02:22:04.116 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS ARE REQUIRED TO HANG.
02:22:02.547 --> 02:22:06.051 region:rollup2
POLLSTER OUT LIES IN OUTLINES
02:22:04.116 --> 02:22:07.386 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEE RIGHTS
02:22:06.051 --> 02:22:08.653 region:rollup2
THE FILED COMPLAINT AND INCLUDES
02:22:07.386 --> 02:22:09.988 region:rollup2
A TOLL FREE PHONE NUMBER FOR
02:22:08.653 --> 02:22:11.089 region:rollup2
PEOPLE TO CALL TO REGISTER
02:22:09.988 --> 02:22:13.091 region:rollup2
COMPLAINTS OR ASK FOR MORE
02:22:11.089 --> 02:22:14.860 region:rollup2
INFORMATION. BUT THERE IS NO
02:22:13.091 --> 02:22:17.896 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENT TO PROVIDE TRAINING
02:22:14.860 --> 02:22:19.064 region:rollup2
TO NON SUPERVISORY EMPLOYEES.
02:22:17.896 --> 02:22:20.432 region:rollup2
MILLIONS OF CALIFORNIA WORKERS
02:22:19.064 --> 02:22:21.933 region:rollup2
HAD NOT BEEN INFORMED OF THEIR
02:22:20.432 --> 02:22:23.835 region:rollup2
RIGHTS AND PROTECTIONS NOR
02:22:21.933 --> 02:22:25.871 region:rollup2
TRAINED IN HOW TO DETECT WORK
02:22:23.835 --> 02:22:28.073 region:rollup2
INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIORS. ARE HOW
02:22:25.871 --> 02:22:29.574 region:rollup2
TO REPORT THOSE BEHAVIORS.
02:22:28.073 --> 02:22:30.742 region:rollup2
TO THE EEOC EVEN MINIMAL
02:22:29.574 --> 02:22:32.677 region:rollup2
TRAINING CAN INCREASE THE
02:22:30.742 --> 02:22:34.179 region:rollup2
ABILITY OF WORKERS TO UNDERSTAND
02:22:32.677 --> 02:22:36.815 region:rollup2
THE TYPE OF CONDUCT THAT'S
02:22:34.179 --> 02:22:38.884 region:rollup2
CONSIDERED HARASSMENT. AND HINTS
02:22:36.815 --> 02:22:40.819 region:rollup2
UNACCEPTABLE IN THE WORKPLACE.
02:22:38.884 --> 02:22:41.753 region:rollup2
BUT TWO THOUSAND ONE STUDY FOUND
02:22:40.819 --> 02:22:43.288 region:rollup2
THAT EVEN THE THIRTY MINUTE
02:22:41.753 --> 02:22:44.256 region:rollup2
TRAINING SESSION RESULTED IN
02:22:43.288 --> 02:22:46.324 region:rollup2
PARTICIPANTS BE MORE
02:22:44.256 --> 02:22:47.793 region:rollup2
KNOWLEDGEABLE ABOUT SEXUAL
02:22:46.324 --> 02:22:49.027 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AND THOSE WHO WOULD
02:22:47.793 --> 02:22:50.061 region:rollup2
THEN THOSE WHO HAD NOT
02:22:49.027 --> 02:22:51.696 region:rollup2
PARTICIPATED IN ANY TRAINING AT
02:22:50.061 --> 02:22:53.565 region:rollup2
ALL.
02:22:51.696 --> 02:22:55.600 region:rollup2
ADDITIONALLY NINETY TWO PERCENT
02:22:53.565 --> 02:22:56.735 region:rollup2
OF THE WORKFORCE IS EMPLOYED BY
02:22:55.600 --> 02:22:58.203 region:rollup2
A FIRM WITH FIVE OR MORE
02:22:56.735 --> 02:22:59.905 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES
02:22:58.203 --> 02:23:01.807 region:rollup2
WHILE THIRTY PERCENT OF
02:22:59.905 --> 02:23:03.508 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS HAVE FIVE OR MORE
02:23:01.807 --> 02:23:05.043 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES.
02:23:03.508 --> 02:23:07.012 region:rollup2
THAT TRANSLATES.
02:23:05.043 --> 02:23:08.113 region:rollup2
DID.
02:23:07.012 --> 02:23:09.614 region:rollup2
IT TO THE FACT THAT NEARLY ALL
02:23:08.113 --> 02:23:11.049 region:rollup2
OF CALIFORNIA'S WORKFORCE BUT
02:23:09.614 --> 02:23:12.150 region:rollup2
ONLY A RELATIVELY SMALL AMOUNT
02:23:11.049 --> 02:23:14.052 region:rollup2
OF EMPLOYERS WOULD BE IMPACTED
02:23:12.150 --> 02:23:15.353 region:rollup2
BY THIS BILL.
02:23:14.052 --> 02:23:17.522 region:rollup2
WE'RE SENSITIVE TO THE DELICATE
02:23:15.353 --> 02:23:19.958 region:rollup2
BALANCE BETWEEN BUSINESS COSTS
02:23:17.522 --> 02:23:21.493 region:rollup2
TO EMPLOYERS AND EMPLOYEES
02:23:19.958 --> 02:23:23.028 region:rollup2
SAFETY IN THE WORKPLACE WIFE.
02:23:21.493 --> 02:23:25.163 region:rollup2
WERE WORKING COLLABORATIVELY
02:23:23.028 --> 02:23:26.264 region:rollup2
WITH VESTED INTERESTS TO ENSURE
02:23:25.163 --> 02:23:27.866 region:rollup2
THAT THE VIDEO TRAINING
02:23:26.264 --> 02:23:29.401 region:rollup2
COMPONENT THIS BILL IS BOTH
02:23:27.866 --> 02:23:31.169 region:rollup2
ACCESSIBLE.
02:23:29.401 --> 02:23:32.270 region:rollup2
AND COST EFFICIENT WHILE ALSO
02:23:31.169 --> 02:23:34.239 region:rollup2
DELIVERING THE IMPORTANT
02:23:32.270 --> 02:23:37.109 region:rollup2
INFORMATION THAT EMPLOYEE NEEDS
02:23:34.239 --> 02:23:37.609 region:rollup2
PRIMARILY.
02:23:37.109 --> 02:23:40.779 region:rollup2
INFORMATION THAT SECTOR
02:23:37.609 --> 02:23:41.813 region:rollup2
SPECIFIC.
02:23:40.779 --> 02:23:42.781 region:rollup2
GIVEN THESE WITH ACTORS AN
02:23:41.813 --> 02:23:43.949 region:rollup2
UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE ARE
02:23:42.781 --> 02:23:45.450 region:rollup2
MILLIONS OF WORKERS WHO NEVER
02:23:43.949 --> 02:23:47.219 region:rollup2
RECEIVED ANY EXPLANATION ABOUT
02:23:45.450 --> 02:23:48.587 region:rollup2
THEIR RIGHTS THE TYPES OF
02:23:47.219 --> 02:23:50.088 region:rollup2
BEHAVIORS THEY SHOULD REPORT OR
02:23:48.587 --> 02:23:51.756 region:rollup2
THE PROCEDURES IN PLACE TO
02:23:50.088 --> 02:23:53.391 region:rollup2
REALLY THEIR GRIEVANCES. WE NEED
02:23:51.756 --> 02:23:55.527 region:rollup2
TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE DEVELOP A
02:23:53.391 --> 02:23:57.629 region:rollup2
SYSTEM TO ADDRESS ABUSE OF POWER
02:23:55.527 --> 02:23:59.865 region:rollup2
IN THE WORKPLACE.
02:23:57.629 --> 02:24:01.099 region:rollup2
WITH ME TODAY I'M GLAD TO HAVE
02:23:59.865 --> 02:24:02.701 region:rollup2
JEFF DEFENDER FROM EQUAL RIGHTS
02:24:01.099 --> 02:24:04.603 region:rollup2
ADVOCATES.
02:24:02.701 --> 02:24:06.605 region:rollup2
AND EVAN GOLDBERG REPRESENTING
02:24:04.603 --> 02:24:08.940 region:rollup2
STATE COMPTROLLER BETTY WHO IS
02:24:06.605 --> 02:24:09.975 region:rollup2
SPONSORING THIS LEGISLATION.
02:24:08.940 --> 02:24:11.843 region:rollup2
MUCH TWO MINUTES EACH IF YOU
02:24:09.975 --> 02:24:13.678 region:rollup2
WOULD.
02:24:11.843 --> 02:24:15.013 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON JESSICA CENTER OR
02:24:13.678 --> 02:24:16.414 region:rollup2
LESS COUNSEL FOR WORKPLACE
02:24:15.013 --> 02:24:17.983 region:rollup2
JUSTICE AND PUBLIC POLICY GET
02:24:16.414 --> 02:24:18.850 region:rollup2
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES ARGUE A
02:24:17.983 --> 02:24:19.618 region:rollup2
BRIEF I KNOW WE'VE HAD A LONG
02:24:18.850 --> 02:24:20.685 region:rollup2
DAY.
02:24:19.618 --> 02:24:21.586 region:rollup2
WE.
02:24:20.685 --> 02:24:22.787 region:rollup2
AT THE COURTS ADVOCATES
02:24:21.586 --> 02:24:24.456 region:rollup2
REGULARLY REPRESENT.
02:24:22.787 --> 02:24:25.690 region:rollup2
WORKERS WHO EXPERIENCE SEXUAL
02:24:24.456 --> 02:24:27.058 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT THE WORKPLACE
02:24:25.690 --> 02:24:28.827 region:rollup2
PRIMARILY WOMEN.
02:24:27.058 --> 02:24:30.128 region:rollup2
ANY UC TASK FORCE STUDY FROM
02:24:28.827 --> 02:24:31.897 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIFTEEN FOUND THAT AS
02:24:30.128 --> 02:24:33.732 region:rollup2
MANY AS EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT OF
02:24:31.897 --> 02:24:36.468 region:rollup2
WOMEN SAY THEY EXPERIENCE SEXUAL
02:24:33.732 --> 02:24:37.903 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT HOWEVER CSUS SEVENTY
02:24:36.468 --> 02:24:38.570 region:rollup2
FIVE PERCENT NEVER REPORT THAT.
02:24:37.903 --> 02:24:39.371 region:rollup2
ONE OF THE MAJORITY OF THE ONE
02:24:38.570 --> 02:24:41.072 region:rollup2
OF THE MAJOR BARRIERS THAT
02:24:39.371 --> 02:24:42.874 region:rollup2
PEOPLE FACE IN REPORTING SEXUAL
02:24:41.072 --> 02:24:44.142 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT IS THAT OFTEN PEOPLE
02:24:42.874 --> 02:24:45.644 region:rollup2
DON'T EVEN KNOW THAT WHAT
02:24:44.142 --> 02:24:46.978 region:rollup2
THEY'VE EXPERIENCED CONSTITUTES
02:24:45.644 --> 02:24:48.547 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL BEHAVIOR.
02:24:46.978 --> 02:24:49.981 region:rollup2
AND DON'T KNOW WHERE TO TURN IF
02:24:48.547 --> 02:24:51.583 region:rollup2
THE IF SOMETHING HAS OCCURRED.
02:24:49.981 --> 02:24:53.518 region:rollup2
THIS OCCURS WITH EMPLOYEES OF
02:24:51.583 --> 02:24:55.320 region:rollup2
ALL TYPES ALL TYPES OF JOBS AND
02:24:53.518 --> 02:24:56.121 region:rollup2
ALL WE'D JE REGION WAGE WAGE
02:24:55.320 --> 02:24:57.656 region:rollup2
RATES.
02:24:56.121 --> 02:24:59.824 region:rollup2
HOWEVER LOW INCOME WORKERS IN
02:24:57.656 --> 02:25:00.759 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR ARE OUR SPECIALTY.
02:24:59.824 --> 02:25:02.327 region:rollup2
KIND OF VULNERABLE.
02:25:00.759 --> 02:25:03.995 region:rollup2
AND AND NOT AWARE OF THEIR
02:25:02.327 --> 02:25:04.696 region:rollup2
RIGHTS WHICH INDICATES A NEED
02:25:03.995 --> 02:25:05.997 region:rollup2
FOR HAVING THESE KINDS OF
02:25:04.696 --> 02:25:07.599 region:rollup2
TRAINING REQUIREMENTS THAT APPLY
02:25:05.997 --> 02:25:09.568 region:rollup2
TO ALL EMPLOYEES AND NOT JUST
02:25:07.599 --> 02:25:11.102 region:rollup2
FROM SUPERVISORS WE REGULARLY
02:25:09.568 --> 02:25:12.804 region:rollup2
REPRESENT ON. LE LOW WAGE
02:25:11.102 --> 02:25:14.139 region:rollup2
WORKERS IN INDUSTRIES SUCH AS
02:25:12.804 --> 02:25:15.507 region:rollup2
THE JANITORIAL INDUSTRY
02:25:14.139 --> 02:25:16.942 region:rollup2
FARMWORKER INDUSTRY RESTAURANT
02:25:15.507 --> 02:25:18.677 region:rollup2
INDUSTRY WHERE THERE HIGH
02:25:16.942 --> 02:25:19.945 region:rollup2
INCIDENCE OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT
02:25:18.677 --> 02:25:21.646 region:rollup2
AND OFTEN WOMEN THAT WE SPEAK
02:25:19.945 --> 02:25:23.415 region:rollup2
WITH ARE AWARE THAT WOULD HAPPEN
02:25:21.646 --> 02:25:24.950 region:rollup2
TO THEM IS ILLEGAL. A SERVICE A
02:25:23.415 --> 02:25:26.251 region:rollup2
BILL WHICH WOULD REQUIRE ALL
02:25:24.950 --> 02:25:27.686 region:rollup2
COVERED EMPLOYERS WHO ARE
02:25:26.251 --> 02:25:29.554 region:rollup2
CURRENTLY COVERED BY THE FIA TO
02:25:27.686 --> 02:25:30.722 region:rollup2
PROVIDE TRAINING AND REQUIRE
02:25:29.554 --> 02:25:32.157 region:rollup2
THAT THAT TRAINING BE PROVIDED
02:25:30.722 --> 02:25:33.825 region:rollup2
TO ALL EMPLOYEES NOT JUST
02:25:32.157 --> 02:25:34.926 region:rollup2
SUPERVISORY WILL FILL A REALLY
02:25:33.825 --> 02:25:35.961 region:rollup2
NECESSARY.
02:25:34.926 --> 02:25:37.262 region:rollup2
VOID.
02:25:35.961 --> 02:25:38.797 region:rollup2
AND ENSURING THAT WORKERS HAVE
02:25:37.262 --> 02:25:39.331 region:rollup2
SUFFICIENT INFORMATION ABOUT
02:25:38.797 --> 02:25:41.333 region:rollup2
THEIR RIGHTS.
02:25:39.331 --> 02:25:42.100 region:rollup2
ABOUT WHAT CONSTITUTES SEXUAL
02:25:41.333 --> 02:25:43.602 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AND ABOUT HOW TO
02:25:42.100 --> 02:25:44.936 region:rollup2
REPORT IT AND THAT THEY RECEIVE
02:25:43.602 --> 02:25:46.571 region:rollup2
THAT INFORMATION AND ANYTHING A
02:25:44.936 --> 02:25:48.039 region:rollup2
LANGUAGE THAT THEY UNDERSTAND.
02:25:46.571 --> 02:25:49.474 region:rollup2
LEGAL PROTECTIONS MEAN NOTHING
02:25:48.039 --> 02:25:50.775 region:rollup2
IF WORKERS ARE AWARE OF THEM AND
02:25:49.474 --> 02:25:52.177 region:rollup2
IF THESE LAWS ARE ENFORCED AND
02:25:50.775 --> 02:25:53.345 region:rollup2
SO FOR THESE REASONS WE
02:25:52.177 --> 02:25:54.846 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY RESPECT YOUR AYE AS
02:25:53.345 --> 02:25:56.514 region:rollup2
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
02:25:54.846 --> 02:25:58.149 region:rollup2
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS AFTERNOON
02:25:56.514 --> 02:25:58.917 region:rollup2
MADAM CHAIR AND SENATORS EVAN
02:25:58.149 --> 02:26:00.619 region:rollup2
GOLDBERG WITH STATE COMPTROLLER
02:25:58.917 --> 02:26:01.620 region:rollup2
BRADY IN SUPPORT OF. THE BILL
02:26:00.619 --> 02:26:03.121 region:rollup2
HAPPEN ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU
02:26:01.620 --> 02:26:04.656 region:rollup2
MAY HAVE THANK YOU VERY GOOD
02:26:03.121 --> 02:26:06.758 region:rollup2
THANK YOU. OTHER WITNESSES IN
02:26:04.656 --> 02:26:08.593 region:rollup2
SUPPORT IF YOU'D STEP FORWARD TO
02:26:06.758 --> 02:26:13.031 region:rollup2
THE MIKE AND GIVE YOUR NAME AND
02:26:08.593 --> 02:26:13.665 region:rollup2
AFFILIATION PLEASE. MANDY BENSON
02:26:13.031 --> 02:26:13.932 region:rollup2
WITH WORK EQUITY AND WE SUPPORT
02:26:13.665 --> 02:26:18.436 region:rollup2
THIS BILL
02:26:13.932 --> 02:26:19.704 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
02:26:18.436 --> 02:26:21.139 region:rollup2
WHEN DID HE SETTLED CHAIR OF THE
02:26:19.704 --> 02:26:21.640 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIAN PLUMMET LAWYERS
02:26:21.139 --> 02:26:25.677 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
02:26:21.640 --> 02:26:26.544 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
02:26:25.677 --> 02:26:27.345 region:rollup2
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
02:26:26.544 --> 02:26:28.213 region:rollup2
DILLON GIVENS WITH THE
02:26:27.345 --> 02:26:30.115 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
02:26:28.213 --> 02:26:31.850 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION ALSO REPRESENTING
02:26:30.115 --> 02:26:32.617 region:rollup2
THE ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA
02:26:31.850 --> 02:26:34.386 region:rollup2
HEALTHCARE DISTRICTS AND SEE
02:26:32.617 --> 02:26:36.021 region:rollup2
SACK. AND OUR SUPPORT IF AMENDED
02:26:34.386 --> 02:26:38.623 region:rollup2
POSITION.
02:26:36.021 --> 02:26:39.424 region:rollup2
TO ARE ASSOCIATIONS WHO WOULD
02:26:38.623 --> 02:26:41.593 region:rollup2
SEEK.
02:26:39.424 --> 02:26:43.261 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS TO HAVE PROOF FOR
02:26:41.593 --> 02:26:45.297 region:rollup2
TRAINING COMPLETION.
02:26:43.261 --> 02:26:46.798 region:rollup2
BUT WE ALSO SEEK TO HAVE THE.
02:26:45.297 --> 02:26:48.600 region:rollup2
TRAINING REQUIREMENTS REDUCED
02:26:46.798 --> 02:26:50.602 region:rollup2
DOWN O AN HOUR FOR THOSE%
02:26:48.600 --> 02:26:51.903 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES WHO ARE ARE THERE AND
02:26:50.602 --> 02:26:53.271 region:rollup2
THEY'RE NON SUPERMAJORITY WHICH.
02:26:51.903 --> 02:26:55.006 region:rollup2
.
02:26:53.271 --> 02:26:56.007 region:rollup2
THOSE SORTS SUPERVISORS ALREADY
02:26:55.006 --> 02:26:57.142 region:rollup2
RECEIVED TWO HOURS OF TRAINING.
02:26:56.007 --> 02:26:59.210 region:rollup2
I JUST THINK THAT SINCE THEY
02:26:57.142 --> 02:27:00.345 region:rollup2
HAVE LESS LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
02:26:59.210 --> 02:27:01.546 region:rollup2
THAT THAT TRAINING CAN BE
02:27:00.345 --> 02:27:03.982 region:rollup2
REDUCED OUT OF OUR. WOULD ALSO
02:27:01.546 --> 02:27:05.483 region:rollup2
SEEK A AMENDMENTS TO.
02:27:03.982 --> 02:27:07.052 region:rollup2
.
02:27:05.483 --> 02:27:08.486 region:rollup2
WORK AROUND OUR SEASONAL AND
02:27:07.052 --> 02:27:09.988 region:rollup2
TEMPORARY EMPLOYEES.
02:27:08.486 --> 02:27:12.090 region:rollup2
TOOK KNOWLEDGE THAT YOU KNOW WE
02:27:09.988 --> 02:27:13.391 region:rollup2
MIGHT HAVE LIFEGURDS WHO WERE
02:27:12.090 --> 02:27:14.893 region:rollup2
WORKING PART TIME FOR THREE
02:27:13.391 --> 02:27:16.928 region:rollup2
MONTHS THAT MAYBE A AS SEPARATE
02:27:14.893 --> 02:27:17.862 region:rollup2
TYPE OF TRAINING OR. PRODUCE
02:27:16.928 --> 02:27:18.430 region:rollup2
TRAINING OR SOME TYPE OF
02:27:17.862 --> 02:27:20.632 region:rollup2
EXEMPTION MIGHT.
02:27:18.430 --> 02:27:22.200 region:rollup2
TO BE HELPFUL FOR ME IN THOSE
02:27:20.632 --> 02:27:23.735 region:rollup2
CASES AND AND PRESERVE OUR
02:27:22.200 --> 02:27:26.004 region:rollup2
CURRENT TRAINING PRACTICES FOR
02:27:23.735 --> 02:27:27.672 region:rollup2
THOSE AGENCIES. HAVE FOR THOSE
02:27:26.004 --> 02:27:29.441 region:rollup2
DISTRICTS OR ARE COUNTIES ARE
02:27:27.672 --> 02:27:30.575 region:rollup2
ALREADY PROVIDING TRAINING FOR.
02:27:29.441 --> 02:27:32.477 region:rollup2
NON SUPERVISORY WILL.
02:27:30.575 --> 02:27:34.045 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES AND HAVE A PARTICULAR
02:27:32.477 --> 02:27:36.081 region:rollup2
SCHEDULE ALREADY SET UP. DID
02:27:34.045 --> 02:27:37.482 region:rollup2
THOSE SCHEDULES MIGHT BE ABLE TO
02:27:36.081 --> 02:27:39.317 region:rollup2
GET GRANDFATHERED IN.
02:27:37.482 --> 02:27:42.220 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I'M SURE THE
02:27:39.317 --> 02:27:43.855 region:rollup2
SENATORS TAKEN GOOD NOTES. ON
02:27:42.220 --> 02:27:46.257 region:rollup2
THAT OTHER ANY.
02:27:43.855 --> 02:27:47.058 region:rollup2
LET'S SEE THAT WAS A TWEEN TO
02:27:46.257 --> 02:27:50.628 region:rollup2
HAVE ANY.
02:27:47.058 --> 02:27:51.663 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
02:27:50.628 --> 02:27:57.535 region:rollup2
FEEL FREE TO COME TO THE DESK
02:27:51.663 --> 02:27:59.237 region:rollup2
HERE.
02:27:57.535 --> 02:28:00.839 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON. NEW MADAM CHAIR
02:27:59.237 --> 02:28:02.006 region:rollup2
MEMBERS LOCAL RICE CALIFORNIA
02:28:00.839 --> 02:28:04.409 region:rollup2
MANUFACTURERS AND TECHNOLOGY
02:28:02.006 --> 02:28:05.910 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION WE ALSO WORKED
02:28:04.409 --> 02:28:06.745 region:rollup2
WIENERS WORD JUST LEANING A
02:28:05.910 --> 02:28:09.314 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT WAY.
02:28:06.745 --> 02:28:11.349 region:rollup2
WHERE OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED ADD
02:28:09.314 --> 02:28:13.418 region:rollup2
TO THE BILL TO INCLUDE?
02:28:11.349 --> 02:28:15.620 region:rollup2
SEVERAL ON HAVE THE COMMENTS
02:28:13.418 --> 02:28:18.523 region:rollup2
THAT WERE MADE BY THE WITNESS ON
02:28:15.620 --> 02:28:20.024 region:rollup2
A PREVIOUSLY RELATED TO YOU.
02:28:18.523 --> 02:28:21.392 region:rollup2
ENSURING COMPETENCY AND
02:28:20.024 --> 02:28:23.762 region:rollup2
COMPLETION OR REGARDING THE
02:28:21.392 --> 02:28:26.164 region:rollup2
VIDEO CMPONENT TO MAKE SURE
02:28:23.762 --> 02:28:28.433 region:rollup2
THAT IT'S.
02:28:26.164 --> 02:28:29.868 region:rollup2
TO.
02:28:28.433 --> 02:28:30.935 region:rollup2
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT WOULD HAVE
02:28:29.868 --> 02:28:33.004 region:rollup2
BEEN ALRIGHT I FELT THAT. A
02:28:30.935 --> 02:28:34.572 region:rollup2
RANDOM.
02:28:33.004 --> 02:28:36.207 region:rollup2
BUT IN A MAP HERE BECCHIO.
02:28:34.572 --> 02:28:38.009 region:rollup2
TO ENSURE COMPETENCY IN
02:28:36.207 --> 02:28:40.044 region:rollup2
COMPLETION RELATED TO THE VIDEO.
02:28:38.009 --> 02:28:41.312 region:rollup2
OMPONENT IN THE BILL SO THAT
02:28:40.044 --> 02:28:44.249 region:rollup2
IT IS A TRUE AID.
02:28:41.312 --> 02:28:46.317 region:rollup2
FOR OUR SMALL AND MANUFACTURERS
02:28:44.249 --> 02:28:48.219 region:rollup2
ALSO RELATED TO THAT DIE OUR
02:28:46.317 --> 02:28:50.121 region:rollup2
TIME FRAME THAT IS FOR NON
02:28:48.219 --> 02:28:51.589 region:rollup2
SUPERVISOR ORIEL EMPLOYEES FOR
02:28:50.121 --> 02:28:53.725 region:rollup2
THE REASONS THAT WOULD JUST MAKE
02:28:51.589 --> 02:28:55.593 region:rollup2
MENTION AND THEN WE ALSO HAVE. A
02:28:53.725 --> 02:28:57.662 region:rollup2
LITTLE A CLARIFYING ISSUE FOR
02:28:55.593 --> 02:28:59.864 region:rollup2
SMALL MANUFACTURERS TO ENSURE
02:28:57.662 --> 02:29:00.999 region:rollup2
THAT THEY CAN INCLUDE THIS
02:28:59.864 --> 02:29:02.600 region:rollup2
TRAINING INTO IN THEIR DURING
02:29:00.999 --> 02:29:03.935 region:rollup2
THEIR TRAINING MECHANISMS THAT.
02:29:02.600 --> 02:29:05.370 region:rollup2
THEY ALREADY HAVE IN PLACE TO
02:29:03.935 --> 02:29:06.070 region:rollup2
COVER A VARIETY OF DIFFERENT
02:29:05.370 --> 02:29:08.473 region:rollup2
THINGS THAT ARE ALREADY UNDER
02:29:06.070 --> 02:29:10.041 region:rollup2
LAW SO WE HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH
02:29:08.473 --> 02:29:12.043 region:rollup2
THE AUTHOR WILL CONTINUE TO DO
02:29:10.041 --> 02:29:13.344 region:rollup2
THAT WE HOPE TO BE ABLE TO REACH
02:29:12.043 --> 02:29:15.313 region:rollup2
A RESOLUTION. THANK YOU VERY
02:29:13.344 --> 02:29:19.184 region:rollup2
GOOD THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY
02:29:15.313 --> 02:29:21.352 region:rollup2
WITNESSES AND FULL OPPOSITION.
02:29:19.184 --> 02:29:23.855 region:rollup2
HIDE SEEING NONE. LET'S BRING IT
02:29:21.352 --> 02:29:27.058 region:rollup2
BACK TO THE DYESS ANY QUESTION
02:29:23.855 --> 02:29:28.460 region:rollup2
SENATOR. MONNING.
02:29:27.058 --> 02:29:29.627 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR ONE THINK
02:29:28.460 --> 02:29:30.495 region:rollup2
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
02:29:29.627 --> 02:29:32.130 region:rollup2
FORWARD.
02:29:30.495 --> 02:29:33.164 region:rollup2
ON.
02:29:32.130 --> 02:29:34.699 region:rollup2
I THINK YOU'VE ANSWERED MY
02:29:33.164 --> 02:29:36.167 region:rollup2
QUESTION WE PASSED LEGISLATION
02:29:34.699 --> 02:29:37.802 region:rollup2
LAST YEAR THAT REQUIRES
02:29:36.167 --> 02:29:40.338 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT PREVENTION
02:29:37.802 --> 02:29:41.940 region:rollup2
TRAINING FOR FARMWORKERS SIMPLY
02:29:40.338 --> 02:29:43.274 region:rollup2
BY FARM LABOR CONTRACTORS WITH
02:29:41.940 --> 02:29:46.110 region:rollup2
THIS COVER ALL AGRICULTURAL
02:29:43.274 --> 02:29:49.581 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS.
02:29:46.110 --> 02:29:50.048 region:rollup2
HA AS WRITTEN TODAY YES OUGHT IF
02:29:49.581 --> 02:29:53.017 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE FIVE OR MORE
02:29:50.048 --> 02:29:54.919 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES.
02:29:53.017 --> 02:29:56.688 region:rollup2
END WITH IT COVER.
02:29:54.919 --> 02:29:58.823 region:rollup2
PEOPLE THAT EMPLOYEE JANITORS.
02:29:56.688 --> 02:30:00.658 region:rollup2
YES IF THEY EMPLOY FIVE OR MORE
02:29:58.823 --> 02:30:02.627 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES IN WITH IT COVER
02:30:00.658 --> 02:30:04.562 region:rollup2
PEOPLE THE EMPLOYEE FIVE OR MORE
02:30:02.627 --> 02:30:06.764 region:rollup2
DOMESTIC WORKERS.
02:30:04.562 --> 02:30:08.733 region:rollup2
YES.
02:30:06.764 --> 02:30:10.735 region:rollup2
AND WOOD LIVOR MORE ELITE COVER
02:30:08.733 --> 02:30:11.803 region:rollup2
PEOPLE EMPLOY FIVE OR MORE FAST
02:30:10.735 --> 02:30:14.339 region:rollup2
FOOD WORKERS.
02:30:11.803 --> 02:30:15.807 region:rollup2
INDEED.
02:30:14.339 --> 02:30:18.576 region:rollup2
THANK YOU AND IN LANGUAGE
02:30:15.807 --> 02:30:20.378 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE TO.
02:30:18.576 --> 02:30:22.447 region:rollup2
BEING UNDERSTOOD BY THOSE FIVE
02:30:20.378 --> 02:30:24.282 region:rollup2
OR MORE EMPLOYEES THAT THAT
02:30:22.447 --> 02:30:26.517 region:rollup2
AGAIN IS THE GOAL OF A LANGUAGE
02:30:24.282 --> 02:30:27.952 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE AND SECTOR SPECIFIC
02:30:26.517 --> 02:30:29.487 region:rollup2
ON THAT WE'VE HAD LOTS OF
02:30:27.952 --> 02:30:30.889 region:rollup2
CONVERSATION.
02:30:29.487 --> 02:30:32.957 region:rollup2
AND WE APPRECIATE THAT WILL BE
02:30:30.889 --> 02:30:34.759 region:rollup2
CHALLENGING BUT WE LOOK TO WORK.
02:30:32.957 --> 02:30:36.160 region:rollup2
A CREATE OPPORTUNITIES FOR THOSE
02:30:34.759 --> 02:30:37.929 region:rollup2
WHO.
02:30:36.160 --> 02:30:39.564 region:rollup2
ARE ABLE TO OUR DON'T HAVE THE
02:30:37.929 --> 02:30:41.266 region:rollup2
RESOURCES INTERNALLY TO DEVELOP
02:30:39.564 --> 02:30:42.333 region:rollup2
THE VIDEOS BUT THE FIELD VIDEOS
02:30:41.266 --> 02:30:43.101 region:rollup2
THAT WILL BE A MALE MADE
02:30:42.333 --> 02:30:45.470 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE BY.
02:30:43.101 --> 02:30:47.305 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT EMPLOYMENT HOUSING A
02:30:45.470 --> 02:30:48.273 region:rollup2
MEET ALL THE CRITERIA WE
02:30:47.305 --> 02:30:50.341 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THAT.
02:30:48.273 --> 02:30:52.577 region:rollup2
GONNA BE CHALLENGING BUT THAT
02:30:50.341 --> 02:30:53.678 region:rollup2
ULTIMATELY IS OUR GOAL.
02:30:52.577 --> 02:30:56.247 region:rollup2
I JUST WANT TO KNOW WITH REGARD
02:30:53.678 --> 02:30:57.982 region:rollup2
TO A JANITORIAL WORKERS EXISTING
02:30:56.247 --> 02:30:59.484 region:rollup2
LAUNDER AB NINETEEN SEVENTY
02:30:57.982 --> 02:31:01.719 region:rollup2
EIGHT ACTUALLY CRYING PROVIDES
02:30:59.484 --> 02:31:02.553 region:rollup2
FOR A A A BIT MORE ABOUT THE A
02:31:01.719 --> 02:31:03.121 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT PROGRAM IS ALREADY IN
02:31:02.553 --> 02:31:05.056 region:rollup2
PLACE.
02:31:03.121 --> 02:31:06.424 region:rollup2
FOR INTERACTIVE IN PERSON
02:31:05.056 --> 02:31:08.026 region:rollup2
TRAINING SO I BELIEVE THAT WOULD
02:31:06.424 --> 02:31:10.295 region:rollup2
IN THAT CASE APPLY.
02:31:08.026 --> 02:31:11.930 region:rollup2
EVEN BETTER YET FREE SO THIS TO
02:31:10.295 --> 02:31:14.165 region:rollup2
BE COMPLIMENTARY EXACTLY BUT
02:31:11.930 --> 02:31:15.199 region:rollup2
EVEN BETTER WOULDN'T DISPLACE
02:31:14.165 --> 02:31:17.268 region:rollup2
THAT. GREAT.
02:31:15.199 --> 02:31:18.636 region:rollup2
WITH THOSE CLARIFICATIONS THANK
02:31:17.268 --> 02:31:20.872 region:rollup2
YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THAT WOULD
02:31:18.636 --> 02:31:22.173 region:rollup2
BE HONORED TO MOVE THE BILL AT
02:31:20.872 --> 02:31:23.942 region:rollup2
THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
02:31:22.173 --> 02:31:25.276 region:rollup2
THIS LOOKS LIKE THE APPROPRIATE
02:31:23.942 --> 02:31:27.078 region:rollup2
TIME NO QUESTIONS OVER HERE
02:31:25.276 --> 02:31:28.413 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE
02:31:27.078 --> 02:31:29.681 region:rollup2
MADAM.
02:31:28.413 --> 02:31:31.282 region:rollup2
IT DOES VERY DELIBERATELY AND
02:31:29.681 --> 02:31:33.051 region:rollup2
AND YES WE HAVE HEARD FROM ALL
02:31:31.282 --> 02:31:34.819 region:rollup2
THOSE WHO REPRESENT THEMSELVES
02:31:33.051 --> 02:31:36.154 region:rollup2
TODAY S. TWEENS ARE CONTINUING
02:31:34.819 --> 02:31:37.522 region:rollup2
TO HAVE CONVERSATION WE WERE
02:31:36.154 --> 02:31:39.157 region:rollup2
DOUBLE WERE FOR. BEGAN THE
02:31:37.522 --> 02:31:40.658 region:rollup2
CONVERSATIONS IN LABOR COMMITTEE
02:31:39.157 --> 02:31:41.759 region:rollup2
OUGHT LAST WEEK AND WILL
02:31:40.658 --> 02:31:43.261 region:rollup2
CONTINUE TO.
02:31:41.759 --> 02:31:45.730 region:rollup2
HOPEFULLY BEFORE WE GET.
02:31:43.261 --> 02:31:47.465 region:rollup2
TO A APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
02:31:45.730 --> 02:31:50.168 region:rollup2
AYE AYE TO HAVE MET WITH A
02:31:47.465 --> 02:31:51.202 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF SMALL. THE A A GROUP
02:31:50.168 --> 02:31:52.236 region:rollup2
THAT REPRESENTS A NUMBER OF
02:31:51.202 --> 02:31:54.172 region:rollup2
SMALL MANUFACTURERS.
02:31:52.236 --> 02:31:55.673 region:rollup2
IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA IN MY
02:31:54.172 --> 02:31:57.141 region:rollup2
DISTRICT WHO.
02:31:55.673 --> 02:31:59.177 region:rollup2
I WAS.
02:31:57.141 --> 02:32:01.479 region:rollup2
PLEASED TO HEAR AMMAR ALREADY ON
02:31:59.177 --> 02:32:02.647 region:rollup2
THEIR OWN PROVIDING. A LEVEL OF
02:32:01.479 --> 02:32:05.049 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT TREATY BECAUSE
02:32:02.647 --> 02:32:07.185 region:rollup2
AS EMPLOYERS THEY WANT TO AVOID
02:32:05.049 --> 02:32:08.853 region:rollup2
POTENTIAL LAWSUIT. ON I FOUND IT
02:32:07.185 --> 02:32:10.188 region:rollup2
STRIKING TODAY AS WE TALK ABOUT
02:32:08.853 --> 02:32:12.390 region:rollup2
BALANCING KIND OF BUSINESS
02:32:10.188 --> 02:32:14.492 region:rollup2
INTERESTS WITH. ON THE RIGHTS OF
02:32:12.390 --> 02:32:15.026 region:rollup2
WORKERS TO HEAR ON CNN TODAY
02:32:14.492 --> 02:32:17.428 region:rollup2
THAT.
02:32:15.026 --> 02:32:19.664 region:rollup2
STARBUCKS WILL CLOSE ALL
02:32:17.428 --> 02:32:21.833 region:rollup2
STARBUCKS ACROSS THE COUNTRY MAY
02:32:19.664 --> 02:32:23.201 region:rollup2
TWENTY NINTH FOR A FULL DAY TO
02:32:21.833 --> 02:32:25.003 region:rollup2
ALLOW THEM TO ENGAGE THEIR
02:32:23.201 --> 02:32:26.871 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES IN RACIAL BIAS
02:32:25.003 --> 02:32:28.473 region:rollup2
TRAINING. SO I THINK EMPLOYERS
02:32:26.871 --> 02:32:29.173 region:rollup2
WHEN THEIR BACKS AGAINST THE
02:32:28.473 --> 02:32:31.442 region:rollup2
WALL.
02:32:29.173 --> 02:32:32.243 region:rollup2
THEM AND THEY RECOGNIZE THAT
02:32:31.442 --> 02:32:32.877 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE.
02:32:32.243 --> 02:32:34.679 region:rollup2
A.
02:32:32.877 --> 02:32:36.614 region:rollup2
CORPORATE CULTURE THAT NEEDS
02:32:34.679 --> 02:32:38.549 region:rollup2
SOME ATTENTION THEY STEP UP AND
02:32:36.614 --> 02:32:41.019 region:rollup2
DO THE RIGHT THING. OUT WITHOUT
02:32:38.549 --> 02:32:43.354 region:rollup2
I ASK FOR YOUR ARM AYE VOTE
02:32:41.019 --> 02:32:45.089 region:rollup2
TODAY ON THIS BILL.
02:32:43.354 --> 02:32:47.392 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF. THE
02:32:45.089 --> 02:32:48.493 region:rollup2
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
02:32:47.392 --> 02:32:50.094 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATIONS.
02:32:48.493 --> 02:32:52.430 region:rollup2
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
02:32:50.094 --> 02:32:56.567 region:rollup2
ROLL JACKSON AYE JACKSON AYE
02:32:52.430 --> 02:32:59.237 region:rollup2
MORE LOCK. BLOCK AYE ANDERSON.
02:32:56.567 --> 02:33:01.339 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG. MINING. MINING AYE
02:32:59.237 --> 02:33:03.307 region:rollup2
STERN. WIECKOWSKI. WIECKOWSKI
02:33:01.339 --> 02:33:04.842 region:rollup2
AYE ALRIGHT THAT BILL HAS FOUR
02:33:03.307 --> 02:33:06.044 region:rollup2
VOTES WILL HOLD THE REBEL ROLE
02:33:04.842 --> 02:33:12.717 region:rollup2
OPEN FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS
02:33:06.044 --> 02:33:13.985 region:rollup2
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:33:12.717 --> 02:33:16.521 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT WE HAVE VOTE SENATOR
02:33:13.985 --> 02:33:18.189 region:rollup2
HILL NEXT TO AND THEN I HAVE TWO
02:33:16.521 --> 02:33:20.658 region:rollup2
MATTERS.
02:33:18.189 --> 02:33:22.560 region:rollup2
THE LAST TWO ARE.
02:33:20.658 --> 02:33:24.862 region:rollup2
IT'S BE.
02:33:22.560 --> 02:33:26.230 region:rollup2
TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR AND S. B.
02:33:24.862 --> 02:33:27.699 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN HUNDRED INTO THOSE
02:33:26.230 --> 02:33:28.766 region:rollup2
WITNESSES WHO ARE GOING TO
02:33:27.699 --> 02:33:31.235 region:rollup2
APPEAR IN THOSE PILLS I
02:33:28.766 --> 02:33:33.271 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE YOUR. PATIENCE WE
02:33:31.235 --> 02:33:33.504 region:rollup2
HAVE ONE BILL BEFORE THAT AND
02:33:33.271 --> 02:33:36.107 region:rollup2
THAT IS.
02:33:33.504 --> 02:33:37.508 region:rollup2
SENATOR HILL S. B. ELEVEN
02:33:36.107 --> 02:33:39.677 region:rollup2
EIGHTY SIX GOOD AFTERNOON
02:33:37.508 --> 02:33:40.445 region:rollup2
SENATOR AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
02:33:39.677 --> 02:33:41.145 region:rollup2
AND MEMBERS OF THE FIRST ONE I
02:33:40.445 --> 02:33:42.980 region:rollup2
THINK.
02:33:41.145 --> 02:33:44.115 region:rollup2
VERY MUCH THE CHAIR AND THE
02:33:42.980 --> 02:33:45.883 region:rollup2
STAFF FOR THE WORK ON THIS BILL
02:33:44.115 --> 02:33:47.485 region:rollup2
I JUST I REALLY APPRECIATE THE
02:33:45.883 --> 02:33:48.486 region:rollup2
HARD WORK IN THE COMMITMENT THAT
02:33:47.485 --> 02:33:49.720 region:rollup2
THEY'VE MADE.
02:33:48.486 --> 02:33:51.622 region:rollup2
TO THE EFFORT TO.
02:33:49.720 --> 02:33:52.156 region:rollup2
I'M ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENT
02:33:51.622 --> 02:33:54.292 region:rollup2
SUGGESTED IN THE COMMITTEE
02:33:52.156 --> 02:33:56.027 region:rollup2
ANALYSIS SB ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX IS
02:33:54.292 --> 02:33:58.062 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR TO A BILL
02:33:56.027 --> 02:33:59.530 region:rollup2
THIS COMMITTEE APPROVED LAST
02:33:58.062 --> 02:34:01.099 region:rollup2
YEAR WHICH IS S. B. TWENTY ONE.
02:33:59.530 --> 02:34:03.267 region:rollup2
IT ENSURES THAT STATE LAW KEEPS
02:34:01.099 --> 02:34:04.202 region:rollup2
UP WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT'S RAPID
02:34:03.267 --> 02:34:05.870 region:rollup2
ADOPTION OF SURVEILLANCE
02:34:04.202 --> 02:34:06.771 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES.
02:34:05.870 --> 02:34:08.372 region:rollup2
THE POLICE WANT A SEARCH YOUR
02:34:06.771 --> 02:34:10.074 region:rollup2
PHONE YOUR CAR OR YOUR HOUSE
02:34:08.372 --> 02:34:11.476 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE TO GET A WARRANT.
02:34:10.074 --> 02:34:13.010 region:rollup2
BUT MANY AGENCIES HAVE
02:34:11.476 --> 02:34:14.879 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY THE CONTRACT WHERE
02:34:13.010 --> 02:34:16.447 region:rollup2
YOU GO WHO YOU TALK TO AND WHAT
02:34:14.879 --> 02:34:18.249 region:rollup2
YOU SAY IN PUBLIC PLACES WITHOUT
02:34:16.447 --> 02:34:19.550 region:rollup2
ANY SAFEGUARDS.
02:34:18.249 --> 02:34:20.852 region:rollup2
OVER ONE HUNDRED LAW ENFORCEMENT
02:34:19.550 --> 02:34:22.687 region:rollup2
AGENCIES IN THE STATE ARE
02:34:20.852 --> 02:34:24.322 region:rollup2
THOUGHT TO USE SOME TYPE OF
02:34:22.687 --> 02:34:26.324 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY. AND
02:34:24.322 --> 02:34:27.425 region:rollup2
MANY DEPLOY MULTIPLE KINDS
02:34:26.324 --> 02:34:28.926 region:rollup2
INCLUDING FACIAL RECOGNITION
02:34:27.425 --> 02:34:31.963 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY AND SOFTWARE THAT CAN
02:34:28.926 --> 02:34:33.631 region:rollup2
MONITOR SOCIAL MEDIA WEBSITE.
02:34:31.963 --> 02:34:34.932 region:rollup2
S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX EXPANDS
02:34:33.631 --> 02:34:36.467 region:rollup2
THE TRANSPARENCY REQUIREMENTS
02:34:34.932 --> 02:34:38.469 region:rollup2
ESTABLISH FOR LICENSE PLATE
02:34:36.467 --> 02:34:40.004 region:rollup2
READERS AND CELL PHONE TRACKING
02:34:38.469 --> 02:34:42.173 region:rollup2
DEVICES ESTABLISHED IN TWENTY
02:34:40.004 --> 02:34:43.875 region:rollup2
FIFTEEN TO ALL SURVEILLANCE
02:34:42.173 --> 02:34:45.409 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES USED BY LAW
02:34:43.875 --> 02:34:46.577 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES. WHICH
02:34:45.409 --> 02:34:47.879 region:rollup2
MEANS SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
02:34:46.577 --> 02:34:49.814 region:rollup2
WILL BE SUBJECT TO PUBLIC
02:34:47.879 --> 02:34:51.048 region:rollup2
DISCLOSURE AND LOCAL LEGISLATIVE
02:34:49.814 --> 02:34:52.583 region:rollup2
REVIEW.
02:34:51.048 --> 02:34:54.051 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGIES MUST
02:34:52.583 --> 02:34:55.887 region:rollup2
BE GOVERNED BY A SURVEILLANCE
02:34:54.051 --> 02:34:58.523 region:rollup2
USE POLICY AND LAW ENFORCEMENT
02:34:55.887 --> 02:35:00.391 region:rollup2
AGENCIES MUST PRODUCE BIANNUAL
02:34:58.523 --> 02:35:02.393 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE REPORT. THE BILL
02:35:00.391 --> 02:35:04.162 region:rollup2
PROVIDES AN EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCE
02:35:02.393 --> 02:35:05.696 region:rollup2
PROVISION TO LAW ENFORCEMENT TO
02:35:04.162 --> 02:35:07.331 region:rollup2
ALLOW THEM TO USE UNAPPROVED
02:35:05.696 --> 02:35:08.833 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE DEVICES IN
02:35:07.331 --> 02:35:10.201 region:rollup2
EMERGENCY SITUATIONS.
02:35:08.833 --> 02:35:12.136 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT GROUPS WILL
02:35:10.201 --> 02:35:13.604 region:rollup2
ARGUE THAT CREATING TRANSPARENCY
02:35:12.136 --> 02:35:15.373 region:rollup2
PROVIDES A SURVEILLANCE ROAD MAP
02:35:13.604 --> 02:35:16.941 region:rollup2
TO CRIMINALS.
02:35:15.373 --> 02:35:18.342 region:rollup2
THIS IS NOT THE CASE
02:35:16.941 --> 02:35:19.844 region:rollup2
THE MERE KNOWLEDGE OF A POLICE
02:35:18.342 --> 02:35:21.813 region:rollup2
TACTIC DOES NOT RENDER IT
02:35:19.844 --> 02:35:23.548 region:rollup2
USELESS THERE ARE ALREADY LAWS
02:35:21.813 --> 02:35:25.883 region:rollup2
MANDATING THE DISCLOSURE OF WIRE
02:35:23.548 --> 02:35:27.185 region:rollup2
TAPS. AND LICENSE PLATE READERS
02:35:25.883 --> 02:35:28.653 region:rollup2
THAT BOTH TECHNOLOGY STILL HELP
02:35:27.185 --> 02:35:29.954 region:rollup2
CATCH CRIMINALS.
02:35:28.653 --> 02:35:31.122 region:rollup2
SOME CONCERNS MAY ALSO BE
02:35:29.954 --> 02:35:32.123 region:rollup2
EXPRESSED BY THE BREADTH OF
02:35:31.122 --> 02:35:34.158 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGIES
02:35:32.123 --> 02:35:35.059 region:rollup2
COVERED BY THE BILL.
02:35:34.158 --> 02:35:36.961 region:rollup2
S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX
02:35:35.059 --> 02:35:38.696 region:rollup2
RECOGNIZES THE WIDE AN EVER
02:35:36.961 --> 02:35:40.898 region:rollup2
CHANGING ARRAY OF SURVEILLANCE
02:35:38.696 --> 02:35:42.700 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES AT THE DISPOSAL OF
02:35:40.898 --> 02:35:44.435 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT. NOW IN IN THE
02:35:42.700 --> 02:35:46.204 region:rollup2
FUTURE. THE GOAL IS TO BE
02:35:44.435 --> 02:35:48.406 region:rollup2
SPECIFIC ENOUGH TO CAPTURE THE
02:35:46.204 --> 02:35:50.608 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE SURVEILLANCE DEVICES
02:35:48.406 --> 02:35:52.043 region:rollup2
BUT NOT OVERLY PRESCRIPTIVE SO
02:35:50.608 --> 02:35:53.744 region:rollup2
THAT WE WOULD HAVE TO RUN A BILL
02:35:52.043 --> 02:35:55.012 region:rollup2
EACH TIME A NEW TECHNOLOGY IS
02:35:53.744 --> 02:35:56.280 region:rollup2
INVENTED.
02:35:55.012 --> 02:35:57.748 region:rollup2
IN CLOSING I'D LIKE TO MAKE ONE
02:35:56.280 --> 02:35:59.383 region:rollup2
THING VERY CLEAR.
02:35:57.748 --> 02:36:00.718 region:rollup2
THIS BILL DOES NOT PROHIBIT LAW
02:35:59.383 --> 02:36:01.719 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT FROM USING
02:36:00.718 --> 02:36:03.387 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY TO FIGHT
02:36:01.719 --> 02:36:05.056 region:rollup2
CRIME.
02:36:03.387 --> 02:36:06.991 region:rollup2
I SUPPORT USING TECHNOLOGY TO
02:36:05.056 --> 02:36:08.860 region:rollup2
INCREASE PUBLIC SAFETY BUT WE
02:36:06.991 --> 02:36:11.195 region:rollup2
NEED TO SAFEGUARD BASIC CIVIL
02:36:08.860 --> 02:36:12.863 region:rollup2
LIBERTIES FROM POTENTIAL ABUSES.
02:36:11.195 --> 02:36:14.799 region:rollup2
WE LIVE IN A NATION OF LAWS AND
02:36:12.863 --> 02:36:16.067 region:rollup2
A NATION FOUNDED ON DEMOCRATIC
02:36:14.799 --> 02:36:17.468 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABILITY AND IS THOMAS
02:36:16.067 --> 02:36:19.370 region:rollup2
PAINE ONCE SAID.
02:36:17.468 --> 02:36:21.439 region:rollup2
A BODY OF MEN HOLDING THEMSELVES
02:36:19.370 --> 02:36:24.242 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABLE TO NOBODY OUGHT NOT
02:36:21.439 --> 02:36:25.309 region:rollup2
TO BE TRUSTED BY ANYBODY.
02:36:24.242 --> 02:36:27.245 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MEMBERS APPRECIATE
02:36:25.309 --> 02:36:28.679 region:rollup2
YOUR. INDULGENCE THANK YOU
02:36:27.245 --> 02:36:30.781 region:rollup2
SENATOR HILL AND SOMEDAY WE WILL
02:36:28.679 --> 02:36:32.383 region:rollup2
AMEND THAT STATEMENT TO INCLUDE
02:36:30.781 --> 02:36:33.985 region:rollup2
WOMEN AS WELL BUT. THE POINT IS
02:36:32.383 --> 02:36:35.953 region:rollup2
WELL MADE.
02:36:33.985 --> 02:36:36.420 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT TWO
02:36:35.953 --> 02:36:40.124 region:rollup2
MINUTES EACH POLICE TO
02:36:36.420 --> 02:36:41.759 region:rollup2
WITNESSES.
02:36:40.124 --> 02:36:43.628 region:rollup2
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND GOOD
02:36:41.759 --> 02:36:44.729 region:rollup2
AFTERNOON COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
02:36:43.628 --> 02:36:45.830 region:rollup2
YOU NEED TO SEE US AND I'M WITH
02:36:44.729 --> 02:36:46.898 region:rollup2
THE COUNCIL ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC
02:36:45.830 --> 02:36:48.466 region:rollup2
RELATIONS WE ARE THAN IT
02:36:46.898 --> 02:36:50.501 region:rollup2
NATION'S LARGEST MUSLIM CIVIL
02:36:48.466 --> 02:36:52.270 region:rollup2
RIGHTS GROUP. CARE CALIFORNIA
02:36:50.501 --> 02:36:54.205 region:rollup2
URGES THE COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT
02:36:52.270 --> 02:36:55.940 region:rollup2
SB ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX MUSLIM
02:36:54.205 --> 02:36:57.775 region:rollup2
AMERICANS IMMIGRANTS AND PEOPLE
02:36:55.940 --> 02:36:58.609 region:rollup2
OF COLOR ARE FREQUENTLY CAUGHT
02:36:57.775 --> 02:36:59.977 region:rollup2
IN THE NET OF WARRANTLESS
02:36:58.609 --> 02:37:01.646 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE. LEADING TO
02:36:59.977 --> 02:37:02.813 region:rollup2
PLACEMENT IN DATA BASES THAT MAY
02:37:01.646 --> 02:37:04.649 region:rollup2
BE ACCESSIBLE TO THE FEDERAL
02:37:02.813 --> 02:37:05.983 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENT INCLUDING IMMIGRATION
02:37:04.649 --> 02:37:07.551 region:rollup2
AUTHORITIES.
02:37:05.983 --> 02:37:08.953 region:rollup2
THE SECRET AND UNACCOUNTABLE USE
02:37:07.551 --> 02:37:10.922 region:rollup2
OF SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY IS A
02:37:08.953 --> 02:37:12.556 region:rollup2
WIDESPREAD PROBLEM IN CALIFORNIA
02:37:10.922 --> 02:37:13.991 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES ARE
02:37:12.556 --> 02:37:16.494 region:rollup2
USING TECHNOLOGIES DESK OUR
02:37:13.991 --> 02:37:17.595 region:rollup2
SOCIAL MEDIA SCANNED FACES.
02:37:16.494 --> 02:37:19.096 region:rollup2
AND EYES AND RECORD THE
02:37:17.595 --> 02:37:20.331 region:rollup2
LOCATIONS OF DRIVERS FREQUENTLY
02:37:19.096 --> 02:37:22.133 region:rollup2
WITHOUT PUBLIC KNOWLEDGE OR
02:37:20.331 --> 02:37:24.835 region:rollup2
WRITTEN RULES FOR TO PREVENT
02:37:22.133 --> 02:37:26.637 region:rollup2
ABUSE. S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX
02:37:24.835 --> 02:37:28.372 region:rollup2
HELP COUNTER THIS TREND.
02:37:26.637 --> 02:37:29.607 region:rollup2
IT PROVIDES BASIC MECHANISMS OF
02:37:28.372 --> 02:37:30.675 region:rollup2
TRANSPARENCY AND OVERSIGHT THAT
02:37:29.607 --> 02:37:32.109 region:rollup2
ALLOW CALIFORNIANS TO HAVE A
02:37:30.675 --> 02:37:33.678 region:rollup2
VOICE.
02:37:32.109 --> 02:37:35.346 region:rollup2
IN SURVEILLANCE DECISIONS A
02:37:33.678 --> 02:37:36.914 region:rollup2
IMPACT THEIR DAILY LIVES THE
02:37:35.346 --> 02:37:38.349 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATORY COLLECTION AND
02:37:36.914 --> 02:37:39.650 region:rollup2
USE OF SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
02:37:38.349 --> 02:37:41.118 region:rollup2
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTS
02:37:39.650 --> 02:37:42.953 region:rollup2
MINORITY AND IMMIGRANT
02:37:41.118 --> 02:37:45.122 region:rollup2
POPULATIONS HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
02:37:42.953 --> 02:37:47.058 region:rollup2
JUST A FEW EXAMPLES OVER TWO
02:37:45.122 --> 02:37:48.526 region:rollup2
DOZEN CALIFORNIA LAW ENFORCEMENT
02:37:47.058 --> 02:37:49.860 region:rollup2
AGENCIES INCLUDING SHARE SAN
02:37:48.526 --> 02:37:51.295 region:rollup2
DIEGO'S ACROSS THE STATE HAVE
02:37:49.860 --> 02:37:53.631 region:rollup2
PURCHASED SOCIAL MEDIA
02:37:51.295 --> 02:37:54.732 region:rollup2
MONITORING SOFTWARE. MARKETED AS
02:37:53.631 --> 02:37:56.867 region:rollup2
A TOOL FOR SURVEILLING BLACK
02:37:54.732 --> 02:37:58.135 region:rollup2
LIVES MATTER AND OTHER PEACEFUL
02:37:56.867 --> 02:37:59.770 region:rollup2
ACTIVISTS ALL WITHOUT PUBLIC
02:37:58.135 --> 02:38:01.672 region:rollup2
PROCESS.
02:37:59.770 --> 02:38:04.041 region:rollup2
COMPTON RESIDENTS WERE OUTRAGED
02:38:01.672 --> 02:38:05.776 region:rollup2
TO LEARN THAT LA SHOULD THE LA
02:38:04.041 --> 02:38:07.678 region:rollup2
SHARE OF AND.
02:38:05.776 --> 02:38:09.046 region:rollup2
DID THE LA SHOW IF I CONDUCTED
02:38:07.678 --> 02:38:10.614 region:rollup2
SECRETIVE AERIAL SURVEILLANCE
02:38:09.046 --> 02:38:12.049 region:rollup2
WITH HIGH POWERED CAMERAS
02:38:10.614 --> 02:38:13.184 region:rollup2
WITHOUT NOTICE TO THE CITY'S
02:38:12.049 --> 02:38:14.652 region:rollup2
NINETY THOUSAND RESIDENTS
02:38:13.184 --> 02:38:16.053 region:rollup2
RAISING CONCERNS ABOUT
02:38:14.652 --> 02:38:17.955 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATORY SURVEILLANCE.
02:38:16.053 --> 02:38:19.523 region:rollup2
THE SAN DIEGO AND CHULA VISTA
02:38:17.955 --> 02:38:20.858 region:rollup2
POLICE DEPARTMENT HAVE USE
02:38:19.523 --> 02:38:22.460 region:rollup2
MOBILE FACIAL RECOGNITION
02:38:20.858 --> 02:38:23.894 region:rollup2
DEVICES SINCE AT LEAST TWO
02:38:22.460 --> 02:38:25.930 region:rollup2
THOUSAND ELEVEN TO SCAN IN
02:38:23.894 --> 02:38:27.398 region:rollup2
RECORD THE BIOMETRIC SIGNATURES
02:38:25.930 --> 02:38:29.100 region:rollup2
OF THOUSANDS OF RESIDENTS NOT
02:38:27.398 --> 02:38:30.301 region:rollup2
CONVICTED OF A CRIME.
02:38:29.100 --> 02:38:31.635 region:rollup2
THE SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGIES
02:38:30.301 --> 02:38:33.637 region:rollup2
ARE FREQUENTLY PURCHASED WITH
02:38:31.635 --> 02:38:34.905 region:rollup2
FEDERAL GRANTS YET IT IS THE
02:38:33.637 --> 02:38:36.807 region:rollup2
LOCAL COMMUNITIES WHO ARE
02:38:34.905 --> 02:38:38.309 region:rollup2
BURDENED WITH THE REAL HUMAN AND
02:38:36.807 --> 02:38:41.112 region:rollup2
FINANCIAL COSTS. WHEN THESE
02:38:38.309 --> 02:38:42.813 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES ARE MISUSED S. B.
02:38:41.112 --> 02:38:44.148 region:rollup2
ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX IS NEEDED TO
02:38:42.813 --> 02:38:45.983 region:rollup2
ADDRESS THESE IMPACTS AND ENSURE
02:38:44.148 --> 02:38:47.385 region:rollup2
DIVERSE CALIFORNIANS ARE PART OF
02:38:45.983 --> 02:38:49.053 region:rollup2
THE CONVERSATION AND IMPORTANT
02:38:47.385 --> 02:38:50.354 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE DECISIONS. ALL
02:38:49.053 --> 02:38:52.289 region:rollup2
LOCAL COMMUNITIES NOT JUSTCITY
02:38:50.354 --> 02:38:53.791 region:rollup2
RESIDENTS DESERVE TO BE IN
02:38:52.289 --> 02:38:54.759 region:rollup2
CONTROL OF DECISIONS.
02:38:53.791 --> 02:38:56.093 region:rollup2
ABOUT INVASIVE SURVEILLANCE
02:38:54.759 --> 02:38:57.328 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES ACQUIRED BY LAW
02:38:56.093 --> 02:38:58.796 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES CARE
02:38:57.328 --> 02:39:00.264 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA URGES THE COMMITTEE
02:38:58.796 --> 02:39:01.565 region:rollup2
TO SUPPORT SB ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX
02:39:00.264 --> 02:39:02.900 region:rollup2
WITH THE RECOMMENDED AMENDMENTS
02:39:01.565 --> 02:39:04.635 region:rollup2
BY THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU THANK
02:39:02.900 --> 02:39:06.103 region:rollup2
YOU VERY MUCH NEXT WITNESS TWO
02:39:04.635 --> 02:39:08.606 region:rollup2
MINUTES PLEASE LESS OBVIOUS FAST
02:39:06.103 --> 02:39:10.641 region:rollup2
AS I CAN. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
02:39:08.606 --> 02:39:11.909 region:rollup2
CAN MEMBERS MY NAME IS TRACY
02:39:10.641 --> 02:39:13.677 region:rollup2
CRUCIBLE ECONOMIC OAKLAND
02:39:11.909 --> 02:39:15.913 region:rollup2
PRIVACY A CITIZENS COALITION
02:39:13.677 --> 02:39:17.248 region:rollup2
THAT THE DEFENSE PRIVACY RIGHTS.
02:39:15.913 --> 02:39:19.617 region:rollup2
AND HAS BEEN IMPLEMENTING
02:39:17.248 --> 02:39:20.584 region:rollup2
SIMILAR LEGISLATION TO SENATE
02:39:19.617 --> 02:39:23.320 region:rollup2
BILL.
02:39:20.584 --> 02:39:24.655 region:rollup2
ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX IN SEVERAL.
02:39:23.320 --> 02:39:26.590 region:rollup2
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CITIES AND
02:39:24.655 --> 02:39:27.658 region:rollup2
COUNTIES
02:39:26.590 --> 02:39:29.460 region:rollup2
THE BILL IS IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT
02:39:27.658 --> 02:39:31.762 region:rollup2
DOESN'T FOCUS ON ONE OR TWO.
02:39:29.460 --> 02:39:32.997 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR. ARE TYPES OF
02:39:31.762 --> 02:39:34.331 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE EQUIPMENT OR
02:39:32.997 --> 02:39:36.534 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY THAT SEEKS TO INSTALL
02:39:34.331 --> 02:39:38.169 region:rollup2
ON OVERSIGHT FRAMEWORK FOR ALL
02:39:36.534 --> 02:39:40.504 region:rollup2
OF THEM INCLUDING THOSE.
02:39:38.169 --> 02:39:42.506 region:rollup2
THAT WE KNOW ABOUT NOW AND THOSE
02:39:40.504 --> 02:39:44.041 region:rollup2
THAT ARE STILL TO COME. DOES NOT
02:39:42.506 --> 02:39:46.610 region:rollup2
PROHIBIT OR BANNED THE USE OF
02:39:44.041 --> 02:39:48.212 region:rollup2
ANY SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY OR
02:39:46.610 --> 02:39:50.614 region:rollup2
AUTHOR I THINK PREVENT MATTER
02:39:48.212 --> 02:39:52.216 region:rollup2
IT'S ABOUT LOCAL CONTROL IT'S
02:39:50.614 --> 02:39:54.418 region:rollup2
ABOUT.
02:39:52.216 --> 02:39:58.155 region:rollup2
POWERING LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
02:39:54.418 --> 02:40:00.224 region:rollup2
SIT DOWN. LOCAL. RESIDENTS AND
02:39:58.155 --> 02:40:03.127 region:rollup2
FIGURE OUT THE PROPER BALANCE
02:40:00.224 --> 02:40:04.295 region:rollup2
BETWEEN SAFETY AND SECURITY. AND
02:40:03.127 --> 02:40:08.566 region:rollup2
CIVIL RIGHTS AND.
02:40:04.295 --> 02:40:12.036 region:rollup2
AND LIBERTIES.
02:40:08.566 --> 02:40:14.472 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE.
02:40:12.036 --> 02:40:17.141 region:rollup2
COMMITMENT COMMANDMENTS WE WERE
02:40:14.472 --> 02:40:19.310 region:rollup2
LOOKING EARLIER ADD ACR.
02:40:17.141 --> 02:40:21.212 region:rollup2
EQUITY PROBLEM SCORES OF
02:40:19.310 --> 02:40:22.613 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS LIVE IN
02:40:21.212 --> 02:40:24.281 region:rollup2
UNINCORPORATED AREAS OF THE
02:40:22.613 --> 02:40:26.917 region:rollup2
STATE.
02:40:24.281 --> 02:40:29.487 region:rollup2
WAR I'M IN AREAS WHERE LAW
02:40:26.917 --> 02:40:31.489 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT IS OUTSOURCE IT CUTE
02:40:29.487 --> 02:40:33.157 region:rollup2
CUTE.
02:40:31.489 --> 02:40:34.391 region:rollup2
CHU CHU TO THE SHERIFF'S SAN
02:40:33.157 --> 02:40:36.127 region:rollup2
WERE BASICALLY EXEMPTED.
02:40:34.391 --> 02:40:37.595 region:rollup2
FROM THIS BILL AND IT'S
02:40:36.127 --> 02:40:40.364 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT THAT CIVIL RIGHTS NOT
02:40:37.595 --> 02:40:41.532 region:rollup2
BE DEPENDENT ON.
02:40:40.364 --> 02:40:43.467 region:rollup2
WHERE WE LIVE IN THE STATE OF
02:40:41.532 --> 02:40:45.603 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA?
02:40:43.467 --> 02:40:48.172 region:rollup2
THE FUNCTIONS IN THIS BILL WHICH
02:40:45.603 --> 02:40:49.840 region:rollup2
INCLUDE ITEM ACQUISITION OF
02:40:48.172 --> 02:40:53.744 region:rollup2
EQUIPMENT.
02:40:49.840 --> 02:40:55.179 region:rollup2
POLICY OVERSIGHT AND REPORTING
02:40:53.744 --> 02:40:57.148 region:rollup2
AND AUDITING ARE NOT.
02:40:55.179 --> 02:40:59.917 region:rollup2
INVESTIGATIVE.
02:40:57.148 --> 02:41:02.253 region:rollup2
FUNCTIONS THEY ARE NOT SPECIFIC
02:40:59.917 --> 02:41:04.388 region:rollup2
CUED THE DETAILS OF ANY
02:41:02.253 --> 02:41:05.422 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR CASE. SO IT IS
02:41:04.388 --> 02:41:07.858 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT WILL ONLY BRING UP
02:41:05.422 --> 02:41:08.359 region:rollup2
THINGS LIKE STATE CODE TWO FIVE
02:41:07.858 --> 02:41:10.427 region:rollup2
THREE OH THREE IT'S NOT
02:41:08.359 --> 02:41:12.229 region:rollup2
RELEVANT.
02:41:10.427 --> 02:41:14.265 region:rollup2
TO TO THE FUNCTIONS THAT ARE
02:41:12.229 --> 02:41:16.934 region:rollup2
BEING.
02:41:14.265 --> 02:41:18.502 region:rollup2
ASSIGNED TO.
02:41:16.934 --> 02:41:21.105 region:rollup2
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
02:41:18.502 --> 02:41:23.674 region:rollup2
OUR EARLY.
02:41:21.105 --> 02:41:26.377 region:rollup2
ADOPTER OF LEGISLATION LIKE THIS
02:41:23.674 --> 02:41:29.513 region:rollup2
LOCALLY SANTA CLARA COUNTY
02:41:26.377 --> 02:41:31.582 region:rollup2
PRODOXIDAE IN JUNE OF TWENTY
02:41:29.513 --> 02:41:32.149 region:rollup2
SIXTEEN AND TO DATE THERE HAS
02:41:31.582 --> 02:41:35.119 region:rollup2
BEEN NO LEGAL CHALLENGE YOU
02:41:32.149 --> 02:41:37.855 region:rollup2
KNOW.
02:41:35.119 --> 02:41:38.556 region:rollup2
LITIGATION. AND THE SANTA CLARA
02:41:37.855 --> 02:41:40.124 region:rollup2
COUNTY SHERIFF IS IN FULL
02:41:38.556 --> 02:41:41.992 region:rollup2
COMPLIANCE
02:41:40.124 --> 02:41:43.327 region:rollup2
WITH THE WORD AND SO WE KNOW
02:41:41.992 --> 02:41:44.795 region:rollup2
THAT IT WORKS NAY CAN'T WE.
02:41:43.327 --> 02:41:47.064 region:rollup2
CAN'T WE KNOW THAT IT WORKS ON
02:41:44.795 --> 02:41:48.732 region:rollup2
THE GROUND SIR THANK YOU AMADOR
02:41:47.064 --> 02:41:50.568 region:rollup2
IMAGE CREE THANK YOU OTHER
02:41:48.732 --> 02:41:52.069 region:rollup2
WITNESSES SINCE POURED NAME AND
02:41:50.568 --> 02:41:53.404 region:rollup2
AFFILIATION PLEASE PATTERN
02:41:52.069 --> 02:41:54.638 region:rollup2
MEMBERS KEVIN BACON FAT AMERICAN
02:41:53.404 --> 02:41:56.006 region:rollup2
CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION WITH
02:41:54.638 --> 02:41:56.707 region:rollup2
APPRECIATION FOR THE COMMITTEE
02:41:56.006 --> 02:42:00.077 region:rollup2
AND THE AUTHOR FATIGUE MUCH
02:41:56.707 --> 02:42:01.011 region:rollup2
NEEDED AMENDMENTS THANK YOU VERY
02:42:00.077 --> 02:42:03.547 region:rollup2
MUCH OTHER. WITNESSES AND SPORT.
02:42:01.011 --> 02:42:05.950 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
02:42:03.547 --> 02:42:06.717 region:rollup2
TWO PEOPLE PLEASE.
02:42:05.950 --> 02:42:08.719 region:rollup2
AND WHILE WE'RE GOING TO ASK YOU
02:42:06.717 --> 02:42:10.788 region:rollup2
TO. VACATE THE FRONT DESK THERE
02:42:08.719 --> 02:42:15.893 region:rollup2
IS THOSE.
02:42:10.788 --> 02:42:16.760 region:rollup2
FAR THE OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
02:42:15.893 --> 02:42:19.163 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON TWO MINUTES EACH
02:42:16.760 --> 02:42:20.364 region:rollup2
PLACE.
02:42:19.163 --> 02:42:21.899 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
02:42:20.364 --> 02:42:23.300 region:rollup2
MEMBERS WHO SHALL MUCH ARE ON
02:42:21.899 --> 02:42:24.635 region:rollup2
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
02:42:23.300 --> 02:42:25.135 region:rollup2
SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION WE MUST
02:42:24.635 --> 02:42:26.870 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE THIS
02:42:25.135 --> 02:42:28.272 region:rollup2
MEASURE.
02:42:26.870 --> 02:42:30.074 region:rollup2
AND WE BELIEVE THAT THE RISK
02:42:28.272 --> 02:42:31.875 region:rollup2
INVOLVED IN PUBLICIZING GAS
02:42:30.074 --> 02:42:34.111 region:rollup2
SENSITIVE INFORMATION DORIS ANY
02:42:31.875 --> 02:42:35.846 region:rollup2
PERCEIVED BENEFIT EMANATING FROM
02:42:34.111 --> 02:42:38.449 region:rollup2
THE DESIRE TO INFORM THE PUBLIC
02:42:35.846 --> 02:42:39.583 region:rollup2
ABOUT HOW LONG FORSMAN OPERATES.
02:42:38.449 --> 02:42:42.119 region:rollup2
AS IT RELATES TO LONG FORCE
02:42:39.583 --> 02:42:43.621 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL SURVEILLANCE TECHNIQUES
02:42:42.119 --> 02:42:45.122 region:rollup2
A WERE ALSO CONCERNED ABOUT THE
02:42:43.621 --> 02:42:46.724 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENT THAT SHERIFF'S HOLD
02:42:45.122 --> 02:42:48.225 region:rollup2
A PUBLIC HEARING UNDER
02:42:46.724 --> 02:42:50.027 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE POLICIES AND
02:42:48.225 --> 02:42:52.062 region:rollup2
CONDUCT REGULAR REPORTING ON THE
02:42:50.027 --> 02:42:53.597 region:rollup2
USE OF SURVEILLANCE. AGAIN THIS
02:42:52.062 --> 02:42:56.100 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR FUNCTION IS VERY
02:42:53.597 --> 02:42:57.167 region:rollup2
SENSITIVE AND THESE BURDEN SOME
02:42:56.100 --> 02:42:59.236 region:rollup2
HEARING AND REPORTING
02:42:57.167 --> 02:43:01.171 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS WILL ONLY SERVE AS
02:42:59.236 --> 02:43:02.506 region:rollup2
COSTLY UNFUNDED MANDATES THAT
02:43:01.171 --> 02:43:04.875 region:rollup2
COULD POTENTIALLY JEOPARDIZE
02:43:02.506 --> 02:43:06.010 region:rollup2
OFFICER SAFETY. ALSO AS FAR AS
02:43:04.875 --> 02:43:08.612 region:rollup2
LOCAL GOVERNMENT IS CONCERNED
02:43:06.010 --> 02:43:10.347 region:rollup2
LOCAL CONTROL I'M CURRENTLY ANY
02:43:08.612 --> 02:43:12.483 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY SHOULD
02:43:10.347 --> 02:43:14.251 region:rollup2
DAY A DESIRE DE ARE THEY CAN'T
02:43:12.483 --> 02:43:14.518 region:rollup2
PUT THEIR SURVEILLANCE POLICY.
02:43:14.251 --> 02:43:16.820 region:rollup2
ON.
02:43:14.518 --> 02:43:18.522 region:rollup2
ON THEIR WEBSITE AND SHARE THAT
02:43:16.820 --> 02:43:19.923 region:rollup2
INFORMATION WITH THE PUBLIC IF
02:43:18.522 --> 02:43:21.125 region:rollup2
THAT'S WHAT THEY DESIRE TO DO.
02:43:19.923 --> 02:43:24.995 region:rollup2
AND FORTIES REASONS WOULD
02:43:21.125 --> 02:43:25.629 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY I REQUEST THAT YOU
02:43:24.995 --> 02:43:26.196 region:rollup2
VOTE NO I JUST LEGISLATION THANK
02:43:25.629 --> 02:43:27.831 region:rollup2
YOU.
02:43:26.196 --> 02:43:28.932 region:rollup2
VERY MUCH NEXT WITNESS PLEASE
02:43:27.831 --> 02:43:29.700 region:rollup2
SHARE MEMBERS JONATHAN FILM OF
02:43:28.932 --> 02:43:33.337 region:rollup2
THE CALIFORNIA POLICE CHIEFS
02:43:29.700 --> 02:43:34.872 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION.
02:43:33.337 --> 02:43:36.373 region:rollup2
LIKE THE MY COLLEAGUES SAID IN
02:43:34.872 --> 02:43:37.241 region:rollup2
IS THE WITNESS BEFORE SAID LOCAL
02:43:36.373 --> 02:43:37.808 region:rollup2
GOVERNMENTS CAN ALREADY
02:43:37.241 --> 02:43:39.710 region:rollup2
ADDRESSES IF THEY'VE CHAIRED
02:43:37.808 --> 02:43:41.412 region:rollup2
GUY.
02:43:39.710 --> 02:43:42.513 region:rollup2
CARE TO DO SO THEY CAN ADOPT
02:43:41.412 --> 02:43:43.847 region:rollup2
ORDINANCE IS TO PLACE
02:43:42.513 --> 02:43:45.015 region:rollup2
RESTRICTIONS ON USE OF
02:43:43.847 --> 02:43:46.517 region:rollup2
SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
02:43:45.015 --> 02:43:47.718 region:rollup2
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.
02:43:46.517 --> 02:43:49.920 region:rollup2
IT'S BEEN DONE IN PLACES IT CAN
02:43:47.718 --> 02:43:51.588 region:rollup2
BE DONE NOW WITH THIS BILL DOES
02:43:49.920 --> 02:43:53.057 region:rollup2
IS SAID. BURDENSOME CUMBERSOME
02:43:51.588 --> 02:43:54.825 region:rollup2
RESTRICTIONS
02:43:53.057 --> 02:43:56.827 region:rollup2
REPORTING MANDATES REQUIREMENTS
02:43:54.825 --> 02:43:58.128 region:rollup2
FOR DOING SO THAT A LOT OF OUR
02:43:56.827 --> 02:43:59.563 region:rollup2
SMALLER AGENCIES ARE GOING TO BE
02:43:58.128 --> 02:44:00.731 region:rollup2
ABLE TO KEEP UP WITH. I MEAN
02:43:59.563 --> 02:44:02.166 region:rollup2
I'VE GOT CHIEF SCENARIOS WITH
02:44:00.731 --> 02:44:02.766 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIVE SWORN OFFICERS
02:44:02.166 --> 02:44:07.337 region:rollup2
FIFTEEN SWORN SINGLE TIME THAT
02:44:02.766 --> 02:44:09.640 region:rollup2
THEY ACQUIRE
02:44:07.337 --> 02:44:11.108 region:rollup2
NEW TECHNOLOGY. A MAN THE USE OF
02:44:09.640 --> 02:44:12.343 region:rollup2
THEIR EXISTING TECHNOLOGY
02:44:11.108 --> 02:44:13.844 region:rollup2
THEY'VE GOT A REPORT OUT ON
02:44:12.343 --> 02:44:16.080 region:rollup2
EVERYONE THAT USES IT HOW IT'S
02:44:13.844 --> 02:44:17.181 region:rollup2
BEING USED HOW THEIR ENSURING
02:44:16.080 --> 02:44:18.282 region:rollup2
THAT ITS MEETING ALL THE PULSE
02:44:17.181 --> 02:44:19.483 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS I MEAN IT'S A LIST
02:44:18.282 --> 02:44:22.319 region:rollup2
OF THINGS IN THIS BILL. THAT
02:44:19.483 --> 02:44:23.854 region:rollup2
THEY CANNOT KEEP UP WITH. AND
02:44:22.319 --> 02:44:25.489 region:rollup2
THEY DAVE TOLD ME FLAT OUT WHICH
02:44:23.854 --> 02:44:27.558 region:rollup2
IS NOT GONNA BUY THIS TECHNOLOGY
02:44:25.489 --> 02:44:29.226 region:rollup2
THEN WHEN WE CAN'T. WE CAN MEET
02:44:27.558 --> 02:44:30.728 region:rollup2
THE THE BURDENS THAT THIS BILL
02:44:29.226 --> 02:44:32.129 region:rollup2
SETS.
02:44:30.728 --> 02:44:33.464 region:rollup2
ONCE WE WON'T BUY AND THAT YOU
02:44:32.129 --> 02:44:34.631 region:rollup2
KNOW WE TALK ABOUT PRACTICALLY
02:44:33.464 --> 02:44:35.599 region:rollup2
THE IMPLICATIONS OF THIS BILL
02:44:34.631 --> 02:44:37.201 region:rollup2
AND OF THE AUTHOR SAID NOTHING
02:44:35.599 --> 02:44:39.603 region:rollup2
IN THIS LEGISLATION. PRECLUDES
02:44:37.201 --> 02:44:40.204 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT FROM ACQUIRING
02:44:39.603 --> 02:44:40.537 region:rollup2
THE TECHNOLOGY BUT EFFECTIVELY
02:44:40.204 --> 02:44:42.840 region:rollup2
DOES.
02:44:40.537 --> 02:44:44.708 region:rollup2
.
02:44:42.840 --> 02:44:46.510 region:rollup2
WANT ANY AND I UNDERSTAND YOU
02:44:44.708 --> 02:44:47.845 region:rollup2
KNOW. FOLKS DON'T THAT THERE'S
02:44:46.510 --> 02:44:49.246 region:rollup2
NO REQUIREMENT INVESTED DIVULGE
02:44:47.845 --> 02:44:51.215 region:rollup2
OUR.
02:44:49.246 --> 02:44:52.349 region:rollup2
TACTICS WITH THAT IS A CONCERN
02:44:51.215 --> 02:44:54.618 region:rollup2
THAT WE HAVE AN OPEN PUBLIC
02:44:52.349 --> 02:44:56.820 region:rollup2
HEARING AND I TOLD THE SENATORS
02:44:54.618 --> 02:44:58.589 region:rollup2
AUTHOR AT THE START OF LAST YEAR
02:44:56.820 --> 02:45:00.891 region:rollup2
ONES BUT. BILL CAME UP.
02:44:58.589 --> 02:45:01.992 region:rollup2
THAT THAT'S A NON STARTER FOR US
02:45:00.891 --> 02:45:03.494 region:rollup2
IF YOU'RE WILLING TO TAKE A
02:45:01.992 --> 02:45:05.195 region:rollup2
PIECE OUT YOU KNOW THERE IS OF
02:45:03.494 --> 02:45:06.497 region:rollup2
COURSE LAW ENFORCEMENT IS ALWAYS
02:45:05.195 --> 02:45:08.532 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW LOOKING TO ENGAGE THE
02:45:06.497 --> 02:45:09.833 region:rollup2
PUBLIC IN AND TALK WITH OUR CITY
02:45:08.532 --> 02:45:13.303 region:rollup2
COUNCILS ABOUT WHAT WE'RE DOING.
02:45:09.833 --> 02:45:14.638 region:rollup2
IS IT IS A WAY TO INCLUDE THAT.
02:45:13.303 --> 02:45:16.807 region:rollup2
PROVISION ON THAT AROUND. A
02:45:14.638 --> 02:45:18.175 region:rollup2
LOCAL GOVERNMENT CONTROL OF THIS
02:45:16.807 --> 02:45:19.576 region:rollup2
OF OUR AGREE ACQUISITION AND USE
02:45:18.175 --> 02:45:21.145 region:rollup2
THE TECHNOLOGY.
02:45:19.576 --> 02:45:22.546 region:rollup2
WITHOUT A PUBLIC HEARING AND IF
02:45:21.145 --> 02:45:23.580 region:rollup2
WE ARE WILLING TO GET PAST THAT
02:45:22.546 --> 02:45:24.915 region:rollup2
THERE'S ROOM FOR US TO TALK
02:45:23.580 --> 02:45:26.350 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE REST OF THE CONCERNS
02:45:24.915 --> 02:45:28.552 region:rollup2
WE HAVE WITH THE BURDENSOME
02:45:26.350 --> 02:45:30.020 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS IN THE BILL.
02:45:28.552 --> 02:45:32.356 region:rollup2
LASTLY I WANT TO TALK ABOUT.
02:45:30.020 --> 02:45:33.690 region:rollup2
THE EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCES
02:45:32.356 --> 02:45:35.526 region:rollup2
EXEMPTION THAT THEY HAVE IN THE
02:45:33.690 --> 02:45:37.194 region:rollup2
BILL THAT PRACTICALLY DOESN'T DO
02:45:35.526 --> 02:45:39.129 region:rollup2
ANYTHING FOR US THE WAY IT'S SET
02:45:37.194 --> 02:45:40.664 region:rollup2
UP. AYE YOU CAN USE THE
02:45:39.129 --> 02:45:41.698 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY ONLY FOR THE SOLE
02:45:40.664 --> 02:45:43.367 region:rollup2
PURPOSE OF THAT EXIGENT
02:45:41.698 --> 02:45:45.969 region:rollup2
CIRCUMSTANCE WHICHEVER IS
02:45:43.367 --> 02:45:47.905 region:rollup2
DEFINED BY I DON'T KNOW WHO. I.
02:45:45.969 --> 02:45:49.273 region:rollup2
IF YOU CAN'T STORE DATA OR USE
02:45:47.905 --> 02:45:50.240 region:rollup2
THE TECHNOLOGY FOR ANYTHING
02:45:49.273 --> 02:45:51.275 region:rollup2
UNRELATED TO THAT EXHAUSTION
02:45:50.240 --> 02:45:52.810 region:rollup2
CIRCUMSTANCE OF YOU'RE GOING
02:45:51.275 --> 02:45:54.144 region:rollup2
AFTER KIDNAPPED.
02:45:52.810 --> 02:45:56.079 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW KIDNAPPING SUSPECT AND
02:45:54.144 --> 02:45:57.347 region:rollup2
YOU FIND EVIDENCE OF A MURDER OR
02:45:56.079 --> 02:45:59.016 region:rollup2
SOMETHING ELSE YOU KNOW YOU YOU
02:45:57.347 --> 02:46:00.050 region:rollup2
CAN'T USE THAT DATA YOU CAN'T
02:45:59.016 --> 02:46:01.518 region:rollup2
SAVE THE DATA THAT DATA HAS TO
02:46:00.050 --> 02:46:03.854 region:rollup2
BE JETTISONED.
02:46:01.518 --> 02:46:05.022 region:rollup2
THE TECHNOLOGY TWO CHOIR FOR
02:46:03.854 --> 02:46:06.857 region:rollup2
THAT EXHAUSTION CIRCUMSTANCE HAS
02:46:05.022 --> 02:46:08.625 region:rollup2
TO BE RETURNED WITHIN SEVEN DAYS
02:46:06.857 --> 02:46:11.261 region:rollup2
OR THE END OF THE CIRCUMSTANCE.
02:46:08.625 --> 02:46:12.162 region:rollup2
WHICH IS NOW DEFINED BY AGAIN I
02:46:11.261 --> 02:46:13.831 region:rollup2
GUESS THE LAW ENFORCEMENT OR OR
02:46:12.162 --> 02:46:16.200 region:rollup2
WHOEVER ELSE.
02:46:13.831 --> 02:46:17.534 region:rollup2
UNLESS APPROVED BY THE
02:46:16.200 --> 02:46:18.469 region:rollup2
GOVERNING BOARD OR GRANT AN
02:46:17.534 --> 02:46:19.803 region:rollup2
EXTENSION IN THOSE TIME LINES
02:46:18.469 --> 02:46:21.171 region:rollup2
DON'T.
02:46:19.803 --> 02:46:21.705 region:rollup2
MATCH UP FOR A LOT OF THE
02:46:21.171 --> 02:46:23.307 region:rollup2
PROCESS THAT WE HAVE TO GO
02:46:21.705 --> 02:46:23.874 region:rollup2
THROUGH.
02:46:23.307 --> 02:46:25.142 region:rollup2
TO GET THIS APPROVED IN THE
02:46:23.874 --> 02:46:26.810 region:rollup2
FIRST PLACE.
02:46:25.142 --> 02:46:28.011 region:rollup2
SO YOU KNOW PRACTICALLY THERE'S
02:46:26.810 --> 02:46:29.713 region:rollup2
THERE'S A LOT OF CONCERNS THAT
02:46:28.011 --> 02:46:31.348 region:rollup2
JUST DON'T MAKE THIS WORKABLE.
02:46:29.713 --> 02:46:32.716 region:rollup2
I THERE'S ROOM FOR US TO DISCUSS
02:46:31.348 --> 02:46:34.651 region:rollup2
IT BUT YOU KNOW AGAIN THE
02:46:32.716 --> 02:46:36.587 region:rollup2
PHILOSOPHICAL OPPOSITION TO THE
02:46:34.651 --> 02:46:37.688 region:rollup2
PUBLIC HEARING. IS KIND OF AN
02:46:36.587 --> 02:46:38.422 region:rollup2
IMPEDIMENT FOR US HAVING ANY OF
02:46:37.688 --> 02:46:40.324 region:rollup2
THOSE CONVERSATIONS LIKE THE
02:46:38.422 --> 02:46:40.924 region:rollup2
OTHER POINTS WE HAVE.
02:46:40.324 --> 02:46:42.326 region:rollup2
CONSERVE SHADED OR APPRECIATE
02:46:40.924 --> 02:46:44.161 region:rollup2
YOUR TESTIMONY.
02:46:42.326 --> 02:46:45.062 region:rollup2
OTHER WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION IF
02:46:44.161 --> 02:46:50.167 region:rollup2
YOU'D COME TO THE MIKE GIVE YOUR
02:46:45.062 --> 02:46:51.568 region:rollup2
NAME AND AFFILIATION PLEASE.
02:46:50.167 --> 02:46:52.669 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON CENTER RANGE FROM
02:46:51.568 --> 02:46:54.271 region:rollup2
OF THE RIVERSIDE SHERIFF'S
02:46:52.669 --> 02:46:56.006 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION OF FOR THE.
02:46:54.271 --> 02:46:57.708 region:rollup2
REASONS STATED OR POST WELL
02:46:56.006 --> 02:46:59.276 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
02:46:57.708 --> 02:47:01.178 region:rollup2
PAN BRENDAN UP OPPOSE ON BEHALF
02:46:59.276 --> 02:47:01.678 region:rollup2
OF SHARE FEW MCDONNELL LOS
02:47:01.178 --> 02:47:04.214 region:rollup2
ANGELES COUNTY SHERIFF'S
02:47:01.678 --> 02:47:05.048 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT THANK YOU SIR.
02:47:04.214 --> 02:47:05.649 region:rollup2
ABOUT AND CHECK MEMBERS NOT
02:47:05.048 --> 02:47:06.850 region:rollup2
CYBERLINK ON BEHALF OF THE
02:47:05.649 --> 02:47:08.852 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION FOR LOS ANGELES
02:47:06.850 --> 02:47:10.153 region:rollup2
DEPUTY SHERIFF THE LOS ANGELES
02:47:08.852 --> 02:47:11.622 region:rollup2
POLICE PROTECTIVELY THANK YOU.
02:47:10.153 --> 02:47:12.990 region:rollup2
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
02:47:11.622 --> 02:47:14.191 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION ARE ABLE TO BRING IT
02:47:12.990 --> 02:47:15.659 region:rollup2
BACK TO THE FLOOR.
02:47:14.191 --> 02:47:17.861 region:rollup2
.
02:47:15.659 --> 02:47:19.630 region:rollup2
THE THE ONE AREA OF THE THE
02:47:17.861 --> 02:47:21.131 region:rollup2
SENATOR HILL THAT IS OF CONCERN
02:47:19.630 --> 02:47:23.433 region:rollup2
TO ME I THINK.
02:47:21.131 --> 02:47:24.568 region:rollup2
.
02:47:23.433 --> 02:47:25.969 region:rollup2
TO SAY THAT THEY'RE GOING TO USE
02:47:24.568 --> 02:47:27.738 region:rollup2
IT FOR LAWFUL TECHNIQUES
02:47:25.969 --> 02:47:29.506 region:rollup2
BASICALLY ALSO GIVES.
02:47:27.738 --> 02:47:31.808 region:rollup2
LAW ENFORCEMENT THE.
02:47:29.506 --> 02:47:33.243 region:rollup2
THE FULL POWER TO DETERMINE WHAT
02:47:31.808 --> 02:47:35.445 region:rollup2
IS AND ISN'T LAWFUL AND I THINK
02:47:33.243 --> 02:47:37.080 region:rollup2
AS WE WERE DISCUSSING TODAY AND.
02:47:35.445 --> 02:47:38.315 region:rollup2
PUBLIC SAFETY AND I THINK
02:47:37.080 --> 02:47:39.683 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT WE.
02:47:38.315 --> 02:47:41.585 region:rollup2
GOING FORWARD I THINK ARE ALL
02:47:39.683 --> 02:47:43.120 region:rollup2
REALIZING IS THAT PRIVACY IS AT
02:47:41.585 --> 02:47:46.623 region:rollup2
RISK.
02:47:43.120 --> 02:47:48.358 region:rollup2
THE PUBLIC'S CONFIDENCE IN OF
02:47:46.623 --> 02:47:50.427 region:rollup2
SOME OF OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT IS
02:47:48.358 --> 02:47:53.664 region:rollup2
ALSO RIGHT NOW.
02:47:50.427 --> 02:47:55.232 region:rollup2
CARE AND IT IN QUESTION AND TO
02:47:53.664 --> 02:47:58.936 region:rollup2
ADD BOTH TOGETHER I THINK IT IS
02:47:55.232 --> 02:48:02.372 region:rollup2
A OF. A POTENTIALLY TOXIC STEW.
02:47:58.936 --> 02:48:03.807 region:rollup2
OF FARM POSSIBLE ABUSE SO I I
02:48:02.372 --> 02:48:06.109 region:rollup2
HAVE WORKED CLOSELY WITH THE%
02:48:03.807 --> 02:48:07.344 region:rollup2
SENATOR HILL AND. I'M A PRIVACY
02:48:06.109 --> 02:48:09.980 region:rollup2
BUFF MYSELF I THINK WE'RE ALL
02:48:07.344 --> 02:48:11.615 region:rollup2
ENTITLED TO IT BUT I ALSO FEEL
02:48:09.980 --> 02:48:14.184 region:rollup2
VERY STRONGLY THAT WE NEED TO.
02:48:11.615 --> 02:48:16.186 region:rollup2
PROVIDE OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT WITH
02:48:14.184 --> 02:48:19.022 region:rollup2
THE TEETH TECHNIQUES THAT THEY.
02:48:16.186 --> 02:48:20.991 region:rollup2
NEED TO BE ALE TO ADDRESS A A
02:48:19.022 --> 02:48:22.993 region:rollup2
CRIME IN A REASONABLE FASHION
02:48:20.991 --> 02:48:25.862 region:rollup2
AND SO WHAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT
02:48:22.993 --> 02:48:27.798 region:rollup2
IS THE EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCES.
02:48:25.862 --> 02:48:28.932 region:rollup2
BECAUSE STATEMENT NOW EXIGENT
02:48:27.798 --> 02:48:31.535 region:rollup2
CIRCUMSTANCES ARE WELL
02:48:28.932 --> 02:48:34.438 region:rollup2
ESTABLISHED IN IN LAW.
02:48:31.535 --> 02:48:36.073 region:rollup2
O. USUALLY WHERE YOU DON'T HAVE
02:48:34.438 --> 02:48:37.941 region:rollup2
THE TIME TO GET A WARRANT YOU
02:48:36.073 --> 02:48:39.276 region:rollup2
ARE IN HOT PURSUIT THERE ARE A
02:48:37.941 --> 02:48:41.979 region:rollup2
WHOLE VARIETY OF.
02:48:39.276 --> 02:48:44.548 region:rollup2
LEGALLY IDENTIFIED EXIGENT
02:48:41.979 --> 02:48:45.816 region:rollup2
CIRCUMSTANCES BUT.
02:48:44.548 --> 02:48:47.150 region:rollup2
.
02:48:45.816 --> 02:48:50.253 region:rollup2
MY CONCERN IS THAT.
02:48:47.150 --> 02:48:53.156 region:rollup2
THE IF IN THE COURSE OF.
02:48:50.253 --> 02:48:54.825 region:rollup2
THAT THAT WE FIND. THAT WE
02:48:53.156 --> 02:48:56.627 region:rollup2
HAVEN'T WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT
02:48:54.825 --> 02:48:57.961 region:rollup2
HASN'T EXACTLY IDENTIFIED THE
02:48:56.627 --> 02:48:58.929 region:rollup2
CRIME THAT THEY'RE GOING AFTER
02:48:57.961 --> 02:49:00.564 region:rollup2
WHAT THEY DISCOVERED TO
02:48:58.929 --> 02:49:03.133 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT CRIME.
02:49:00.564 --> 02:49:04.768 region:rollup2
IT COULD YOU RESPOND TO THAT.
02:49:03.133 --> 02:49:07.037 region:rollup2
A WOULD YOU BE.
02:49:04.768 --> 02:49:09.506 region:rollup2
WILLING SENATOR TO TAKE AN
02:49:07.037 --> 02:49:11.174 region:rollup2
AMENDMENT THAT THAT RECOGNIZES
02:49:09.506 --> 02:49:12.209 region:rollup2
THAT PERHAPS
02:49:11.174 --> 02:49:13.543 region:rollup2
I MEAN IF IT'S JUST WERE OUT
02:49:12.209 --> 02:49:15.612 region:rollup2
THERE WERE JUST LOOKING AROUND
02:49:13.543 --> 02:49:17.247 region:rollup2
TO SEE. WHO IS?
02:49:15.612 --> 02:49:18.548 region:rollup2
DRIVING DOWN A PARTICULAR
02:49:17.247 --> 02:49:19.983 region:rollup2
STREET IN A NEIGHBORHOOD THAT
02:49:18.548 --> 02:49:21.818 region:rollup2
WERE A LITTLE CONCERNED ABOUT I
02:49:19.983 --> 02:49:23.086 region:rollup2
THINK THAT'S THE KIND OF THING
02:49:21.818 --> 02:49:24.588 region:rollup2
WE'RE TALKING BY THAT.
02:49:23.086 --> 02:49:27.391 region:rollup2
ANY OF US WOULD FEEL A SORT OF A
02:49:24.588 --> 02:49:28.859 region:rollup2
AND ABUSE OR AN EXTENSION OF
02:49:27.391 --> 02:49:29.826 region:rollup2
POLICE POWERS BEYOND WHAT'S
02:49:28.859 --> 02:49:32.663 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATE.
02:49:29.826 --> 02:49:35.365 region:rollup2
BUT IN AN EXIGENCY COME STANCE.
02:49:32.663 --> 02:49:36.900 region:rollup2
WHERE YOU'RE NOT QUITE SURE
02:49:35.365 --> 02:49:38.735 region:rollup2
WHAT YOU'RE GOING AFTER BUT YOU
02:49:36.900 --> 02:49:40.971 region:rollup2
KNOW THAT IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S
02:49:38.735 --> 02:49:41.805 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL? A WOULD YOU RESPOND TO
02:49:40.971 --> 02:49:44.141 region:rollup2
HAVE ACTUALLY MINIATURE AND AND
02:49:41.805 --> 02:49:44.741 region:rollup2
I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS OF THE
02:49:44.141 --> 02:49:45.308 region:rollup2
OF THE POLICE CHIEF BECAUSE I
02:49:44.741 --> 02:49:48.345 region:rollup2
THINK.
02:49:45.308 --> 02:49:50.347 region:rollup2
WHAT WE'VE WHEN WE MET WITH THE
02:49:48.345 --> 02:49:50.981 region:rollup2
LOCAL POLICE CHIEF SHOULD OF
02:49:50.347 --> 02:49:52.482 region:rollup2
WENT IN?
02:49:50.981 --> 02:49:54.251 region:rollup2
IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS
02:49:52.482 --> 02:49:54.918 region:rollup2
OF A RAISE THAT ISSUE AS WELL
02:49:54.251 --> 02:49:56.286 region:rollup2
AND I THINK THERE'S SOME
02:49:54.918 --> 02:49:57.621 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITIES THERE TO ALLOW FOR
02:49:56.286 --> 02:49:59.356 region:rollup2
CIVIC.
02:49:57.621 --> 02:50:00.857 region:rollup2
SOME ARE SOME EXPANSION OF OF
02:49:59.356 --> 02:50:03.560 region:rollup2
THAT WITH AN EXOGENOUS SPECIALLY
02:50:00.857 --> 02:50:06.129 region:rollup2
IF YOU'RE USING THE TECHNOLOGY
02:50:03.560 --> 02:50:08.398 region:rollup2
AND YOU HAVE TO. GO ONE.
02:50:06.129 --> 02:50:10.500 region:rollup2
IF THE RETURN OF RIGHT OF WAY
02:50:08.398 --> 02:50:12.102 region:rollup2
YOU CAN'T CONTINUE TO THE USE OF
02:50:10.500 --> 02:50:13.437 region:rollup2
IT I MEAN I I GUESS WE'RE TRYING
02:50:12.102 --> 02:50:15.405 region:rollup2
TO PREVENT ALL OF THE ABUSES THE
02:50:13.437 --> 02:50:17.574 region:rollup2
ABUSES WHERE SOMEONE WOULD TAKE
02:50:15.405 --> 02:50:18.942 region:rollup2
THE TECHNOLOGY USE OF TECHNOLOGY
02:50:17.574 --> 02:50:20.343 region:rollup2
KEEP THE TECHNOLOGY AND THEN.
02:50:18.942 --> 02:50:22.079 region:rollup2
CONTINUE TO APPLY IT WITH WITHIN
02:50:20.343 --> 02:50:23.447 region:rollup2
THEIR DEPARTMENT AND AND NOT
02:50:22.079 --> 02:50:26.416 region:rollup2
HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE NORMAL
02:50:23.447 --> 02:50:28.318 region:rollup2
PROCESS OF. OF OF A PUBLIC.
02:50:26.416 --> 02:50:30.187 region:rollup2
DISCUSSION WITH THE OF THE
02:50:28.318 --> 02:50:31.621 region:rollup2
CONSTITUENTS IN THE CITIZENS OF
02:50:30.187 --> 02:50:33.123 region:rollup2
THAT AREA SO I THINK THERE ARE A
02:50:31.621 --> 02:50:34.958 region:rollup2
LOT OF OPPORTUNITIES TO BROADEN
02:50:33.123 --> 02:50:36.593 region:rollup2
THAT IT TO ALLOW FOR. LAW
02:50:34.958 --> 02:50:38.128 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT TO DO WHAT I THINK
02:50:36.593 --> 02:50:39.996 region:rollup2
THEY NEED TO DO WITH THOSE.
02:50:38.128 --> 02:50:41.131 region:rollup2
EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCES FOR THAT
02:50:39.996 --> 02:50:42.899 region:rollup2
THE SMALLER DISTRICTS ESPECIALLY
02:50:41.131 --> 02:50:44.201 region:rollup2
SMALL DEPARTMENTS WON'T HAVE TO
02:50:42.899 --> 02:50:45.335 region:rollup2
STRUGGLE WITH THAT AND HAVE THE
02:50:44.201 --> 02:50:46.937 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO USE THE
02:50:45.335 --> 02:50:48.472 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY WHEN NEEDED.
02:50:46.937 --> 02:50:49.339 region:rollup2
IT IS A BALANCE IT IS A BALLOTS
02:50:48.472 --> 02:50:50.807 region:rollup2
AND I THINK WE CAN GET THERE
02:50:49.339 --> 02:50:54.778 region:rollup2
WITH THIS I APPRECIATE THE WORK
02:50:50.807 --> 02:50:56.413 region:rollup2
YOU'VE DONE ON THAT AND AND SO.
02:50:54.778 --> 02:50:58.148 region:rollup2
IT ANY OTHER SENATOR MORE LOCK
02:50:56.413 --> 02:50:59.349 region:rollup2
IN THAT WILL ENTERTAIN A MOTION.
02:50:58.148 --> 02:51:00.050 region:rollup2
THANK YOU THANK SENATOR HILL
02:50:59.349 --> 02:51:02.152 region:rollup2
THIS.
02:51:00.050 --> 02:51:04.221 region:rollup2
WRITTEN SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY
02:51:02.152 --> 02:51:06.189 region:rollup2
ROOF USED REPORT.
02:51:04.221 --> 02:51:08.258 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD BE.
02:51:06.189 --> 02:51:09.626 region:rollup2
REQUIRED.
02:51:08.258 --> 02:51:11.394 region:rollup2
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU THINK THAT
02:51:09.626 --> 02:51:13.330 region:rollup2
WOULD TAKE? STATE PUBLIC SAFETY
02:51:11.394 --> 02:51:14.364 region:rollup2
OFFICIAL TO PREPARE.
02:51:13.330 --> 02:51:15.999 region:rollup2
WELL I DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH THEY
02:51:14.364 --> 02:51:17.968 region:rollup2
WOULD USE THE TECHNOLOGY.
02:51:15.999 --> 02:51:19.436 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD DETERMINE THE AMOUNT
02:51:17.968 --> 02:51:21.138 region:rollup2
OF TIME THAT THEY USED IT IF
02:51:19.436 --> 02:51:22.906 region:rollup2
IT'S A. A PIECE OF TECHNOLOGY
02:51:21.138 --> 02:51:24.441 region:rollup2
THAT THEY IF IT'S A LICENSE
02:51:22.906 --> 02:51:25.742 region:rollup2
PLATE READER WHICH IS NOW IN
02:51:24.441 --> 02:51:27.110 region:rollup2
EFFECT IN THAT IS LAW TODAY
02:51:25.742 --> 02:51:29.579 region:rollup2
AFTER THEY USE LICENSE PLATE
02:51:27.110 --> 02:51:32.082 region:rollup2
READERS QUITE. FREQUENTLY A AND
02:51:29.579 --> 02:51:33.483 region:rollup2
OFTEN IN THEIR COMMUNITIES OF
02:51:32.082 --> 02:51:35.719 region:rollup2
THEIR THEIR WORK THAT THAT IS.
02:51:33.483 --> 02:51:37.921 region:rollup2
THAT IS WORKING TODAY IN THOSE
02:51:35.719 --> 02:51:39.856 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENTS AS WELL AS FOR
02:51:37.921 --> 02:51:41.158 region:rollup2
CELLULAR INTERCEPTED VICES
02:51:39.856 --> 02:51:43.593 region:rollup2
THEY'RE USING THOSE TECHNOLOGIES
02:51:41.158 --> 02:51:45.695 region:rollup2
TODAY. WITHOUT COMPLAINT WHEN
02:51:43.593 --> 02:51:47.764 region:rollup2
THE THE THE LEGISLATION WAS
02:51:45.695 --> 02:51:49.599 region:rollup2
ADOPTED OR OUR COMPLAINT
02:51:47.764 --> 02:51:51.234 region:rollup2
REGARDING THE TIME INVOLVED IN
02:51:49.599 --> 02:51:52.869 region:rollup2
THIS OR THE FACT THAT SMALL
02:51:51.234 --> 02:51:55.272 region:rollup2
CITIES WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO
02:51:52.869 --> 02:51:56.940 region:rollup2
ACQUIRE. THAT EQUIPMENT NONE OF
02:51:55.272 --> 02:51:58.675 region:rollup2
THAT CONVERSATION NONE OF THOSE
02:51:56.940 --> 02:52:00.610 region:rollup2
ISSUES WERE RAISED THE FACT THAT
02:51:58.675 --> 02:52:03.213 region:rollup2
THIS WOULD BE TELLING THE THE
02:52:00.610 --> 02:52:04.481 region:rollup2
BAD GUY WHAT TECHNOLOGY HAD NONE
02:52:03.213 --> 02:52:06.783 region:rollup2
OF THOSE ISSUES WERE RAISED WHEN
02:52:04.481 --> 02:52:08.218 region:rollup2
THOSE. WHEN THOSE. TECHNOLOGIES
02:52:06.783 --> 02:52:09.619 region:rollup2
WERE BROUGHT FORWARD NOW WHEN WE
02:52:08.218 --> 02:52:11.822 region:rollup2
WANT TO INCLUDE OTHER
02:52:09.619 --> 02:52:13.123 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGIES ALL OF A SUDDEN
02:52:11.822 --> 02:52:14.391 region:rollup2
THAT DISCLOSURE IS BECOMING A
02:52:13.123 --> 02:52:16.226 region:rollup2
PROBLEM I DON'T KNOW THE TIME
02:52:14.391 --> 02:52:17.661 region:rollup2
THAT WOULD BE INVOLVED. BUT I DO
02:52:16.226 --> 02:52:18.828 region:rollup2
THINK IT'S AN APPROPRIATE AMOUNT
02:52:17.661 --> 02:52:20.463 region:rollup2
OF TIME WHEN YOU WHEN YOU FIND
02:52:18.828 --> 02:52:22.365 region:rollup2
TRIED TO DETERMINE THE PUBLIC
02:52:20.463 --> 02:52:23.867 region:rollup2
HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW. THE AMOUNT
02:52:22.365 --> 02:52:25.368 region:rollup2
THAT THE THE EQUIPMENT ISSUES
02:52:23.867 --> 02:52:27.237 region:rollup2
HOW IT'S BEING USED IN TERMS OF
02:52:25.368 --> 02:52:29.139 region:rollup2
WHO WHO HAS ACCESS TO THAT
02:52:27.237 --> 02:52:31.508 region:rollup2
INFORMATION THAT'S BEING NOT
02:52:29.139 --> 02:52:33.210 region:rollup2
BEING COLLECTED. UNITS GETS PUT
02:52:31.508 --> 02:52:34.177 region:rollup2
ON THE WEBSITE.
02:52:33.210 --> 02:52:35.979 region:rollup2
AND THOUGHT IT REASON I ASKED
02:52:34.177 --> 02:52:36.947 region:rollup2
ABOUT THE TIME COMPONENT IS. I'M
02:52:35.979 --> 02:52:37.914 region:rollup2
I'M DEALING WITH CITIES THAT
02:52:36.947 --> 02:52:38.882 region:rollup2
HAVE CUT THEIR POLICE
02:52:37.914 --> 02:52:39.916 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENTS BY TWENTY FIVE
02:52:38.882 --> 02:52:44.754 region:rollup2
PERCENT.
02:52:39.916 --> 02:52:44.754 region:rollup2
SO THERE'S A LOT MORE WORK BEING
02:52:44.821 --> 02:52:47.657 region:rollup2
I'M NOT ABLE TO GET THE COSTS
02:52:46.389 --> 02:52:49.125 region:rollup2
ARE JUST LOOKING AT HOW THEY.
02:52:47.657 --> 02:52:50.727 region:rollup2
FIT ALL THAT AND TO HAVE ANOTHER
02:52:49.125 --> 02:52:52.295 region:rollup2
MANDATE.
02:52:50.727 --> 02:52:53.997 region:rollup2
SO THAT'S WHERE I'M.
02:52:52.295 --> 02:52:55.065 region:rollup2
THAT'S WHY I ASKED THE QUESTION
02:52:53.997 --> 02:52:56.1000 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW I UNDERSTAND IT AND
02:52:55.065 --> 02:52:58.501 region:rollup2
THEY ARE DOING IT WITH THE.
02:52:56.1000 --> 02:52:59.769 region:rollup2
THE OTHER TECHNOLOGIES THAT WE
02:52:58.501 --> 02:53:01.905 region:rollup2
HAVE THE BACKING OF GIVE BUT I
02:52:59.769 --> 02:53:03.773 region:rollup2
THINK IF IF IT'S PART OF A LOG
02:53:01.905 --> 02:53:06.376 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW IS THEY GO OUT DURING
02:53:03.773 --> 02:53:07.444 region:rollup2
THE DAY THEY TAKE FIREARMS WITH
02:53:06.376 --> 02:53:08.578 region:rollup2
THEM THEY HAVE TO LOG THE MEN
02:53:07.444 --> 02:53:09.679 region:rollup2
LOG IN MY. I THINK THAT THE IT
02:53:08.578 --> 02:53:12.482 region:rollup2
WOULD ASSUME THAT THEY COULD DO
02:53:09.679 --> 02:53:13.617 region:rollup2
THAT IF THEY WERE USING VARIOUS
02:53:12.482 --> 02:53:15.785 region:rollup2
TYPES OF TECHNOLOGY.
02:53:13.617 --> 02:53:17.454 region:rollup2
SO I THINK THE PUBLIC INTEREST
02:53:15.785 --> 02:53:19.256 region:rollup2
IN PROTECTING OUR PRIVACY RIGHTS
02:53:17.454 --> 02:53:21.491 region:rollup2
TO MAKING SURE THAT.
02:53:19.256 --> 02:53:23.593 region:rollup2
OF LAW ENFORCEMENT IS DOING ITS
02:53:21.491 --> 02:53:25.328 region:rollup2
JOB IN IN A WAY THAT HAS THE
02:53:23.593 --> 02:53:26.830 region:rollup2
PUBLIC CONFIDENCE IN THAT WORK
02:53:25.328 --> 02:53:29.266 region:rollup2
ETHIC IS PART OF WHAT THIS IS
02:53:26.830 --> 02:53:30.033 region:rollup2
AND SO. WITH THAT SENATOR FEED
02:53:29.266 --> 02:53:30.233 region:rollup2
LIKE TO BRIEFLY ADDRESS RIVALS
02:53:30.033 --> 02:53:32.802 region:rollup2
THINK
02:53:30.233 --> 02:53:34.337 region:rollup2
FOR GOOD.
02:53:32.802 --> 02:53:35.405 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS
02:53:34.337 --> 02:53:38.174 region:rollup2
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS IS OUR
02:53:35.405 --> 02:53:39.309 region:rollup2
MOTION.
02:53:38.174 --> 02:53:41.278 region:rollup2
BROUGH BY SENATOR MONNING.
02:53:39.309 --> 02:53:42.913 region:rollup2
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:53:41.278 --> 02:53:44.547 region:rollup2
JACKSON AYE JACKSON AYE MORE
02:53:42.913 --> 02:53:45.515 region:rollup2
LOCK.
02:53:44.547 --> 02:53:46.616 region:rollup2
MORE LIKE NEW ANDERSON.
02:53:45.515 --> 02:53:48.418 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG.
02:53:46.616 --> 02:53:51.187 region:rollup2
MONNING.
02:53:48.418 --> 02:53:53.556 region:rollup2
I MONEY I STERN.
02:53:51.187 --> 02:53:55.225 region:rollup2
WIECKOWSKI. WIECKOWSKI AYE RIGHT
02:53:53.556 --> 02:53:58.128 region:rollup2
HIT THE OF THREE VOTES WILL PUT
02:53:55.225 --> 02:53:58.928 region:rollup2
THAT MATTER ON CALL.
02:53:58.128 --> 02:54:00.864 region:rollup2
YOU'RE THINK YOU'VE EVER TRIED
02:53:58.928 --> 02:54:03.767 region:rollup2
TO HAVE A TO MORE ITEMS THEY ARE
02:54:00.864 --> 02:54:04.734 region:rollup2
BOTH SO. MY BILLS AND I WILL.
02:54:03.767 --> 02:54:07.337 region:rollup2
HAND THE GAVEL OVER TO MY.
02:54:04.734 --> 02:54:09.472 region:rollup2
VICE CHAIR.
02:54:07.337 --> 02:54:11.274 region:rollup2
PENSION POPE.
02:54:09.472 --> 02:54:14.444 region:rollup2
AND WE'LL START.
02:54:11.274 --> 02:54:30.794 region:rollup2
LET'S START WITH FILE ITEM. NINE
02:54:14.444 --> 02:54:30.794 region:rollup2
SP TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR
02:54:44.007 --> 02:54:46.242 region:rollup2
.
02:54:44.140 --> 02:54:49.846 region:rollup2
WELCOME SENATOR JACKSON YOU HAVE
02:54:46.242 --> 02:54:52.015 region:rollup2
THE FLOOR. NICE TO BE HERE.
02:54:49.846 --> 02:54:53.416 region:rollup2
THAT AFTERNOON MISTER VICE IT IS
02:54:52.015 --> 02:54:55.485 region:rollup2
STILL AFTERNOON GOOD AFTERNOON
02:54:53.416 --> 02:54:57.954 region:rollup2
MR VICE CHAIR MEMBERS. OF I AM I
02:54:55.485 --> 02:55:00.256 region:rollup2
HERE TO PERCENT SP TWELVE EIGHTY
02:54:57.954 --> 02:55:02.292 region:rollup2
FOUR THIS IS A BILL. TO FIGHT
02:55:00.256 --> 02:55:04.060 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION WOULD DATA.
02:55:02.292 --> 02:55:05.362 region:rollup2
WITH INFORMATION.
02:55:04.060 --> 02:55:07.063 region:rollup2
BECAUSE WHEN IT COMES TO PAY
02:55:05.362 --> 02:55:10.500 region:rollup2
EQUITY FOR WOMEN AND MINORITIES
02:55:07.063 --> 02:55:11.701 region:rollup2
WE CAN'T FIX WHAT WE DON'T KNOW.
02:55:10.500 --> 02:55:14.070 region:rollup2
AS NOTED IN THE COMMITTEE
02:55:11.701 --> 02:55:15.472 region:rollup2
ANALYSIS I AM TAKING A NUMBER OF
02:55:14.070 --> 02:55:17.507 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS TO THIS BILL.
02:55:15.472 --> 02:55:19.409 region:rollup2
WHICH ADDRESS CONCERNS RAISED BY
02:55:17.507 --> 02:55:19.943 region:rollup2
THE ANALYSIS AND THE OPPOSITION
02:55:19.409 --> 02:55:21.911 region:rollup2
AND I THINK MOVE THE BILL
02:55:19.943 --> 02:55:23.646 region:rollup2
CLOSER.
02:55:21.911 --> 02:55:25.215 region:rollup2
TO ITS INTENDED GOAL.
02:55:23.646 --> 02:55:28.318 region:rollup2
I BELIEVE THESE AMENDMENTS MAKE
02:55:25.215 --> 02:55:30.920 region:rollup2
IT CLEAR. THAT I AM.
02:55:28.318 --> 02:55:33.623 region:rollup2
SERIOUS ABOUT THIS BILL NOT
02:55:30.920 --> 02:55:35.625 region:rollup2
BEING ABOUT PUBLIC SHAMING OF
02:55:33.623 --> 02:55:37.560 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS THIS IS A COMPLAINT I
02:55:35.625 --> 02:55:39.929 region:rollup2
HAVE HEARD. I THINK IT'S A
02:55:37.560 --> 02:55:41.398 region:rollup2
LEFTOVER FROM THE MEASURE BY
02:55:39.929 --> 02:55:42.766 region:rollup2
ANOTHER BILL IN ANOTHER
02:55:41.398 --> 02:55:43.633 region:rollup2
COLLEAGUE LAST YEAR THERE WAS
02:55:42.766 --> 02:55:45.568 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY.
02:55:43.633 --> 02:55:48.204 region:rollup2
I THINK INTENDED TO PUBLICLY
02:55:45.568 --> 02:55:52.008 region:rollup2
SHAME THAT IS NOT MY GOAL HERE.
02:55:48.204 --> 02:55:53.576 region:rollup2
IT IS NOT MY GOAL IN TRYING TO
02:55:52.008 --> 02:55:55.311 region:rollup2
ADDRESS THIS SERIOUS PROBLEM. A
02:55:53.576 --> 02:55:56.846 region:rollup2
PAY DISPARITY I BELIEVE THERE
02:55:55.311 --> 02:55:58.148 region:rollup2
ARE WAYS THAT WE CAN DO IT
02:55:56.846 --> 02:55:59.282 region:rollup2
COLLABORATIVELY AND I.
02:55:58.148 --> 02:56:01.284 region:rollup2
AND VERY PROUD THAT WHEN IT
02:55:59.282 --> 02:56:04.087 region:rollup2
COMES TO THE EQUAL PAY BILL THAT
02:56:01.284 --> 02:56:06.489 region:rollup2
WE PASSED IN TWENTY. OF FIFTEEN
02:56:04.087 --> 02:56:08.258 region:rollup2
A WE HAVE WORKED COLLABORATIVELY
02:56:06.489 --> 02:56:11.561 region:rollup2
WITH ALL THE STAKEHOLDERS TO
02:56:08.258 --> 02:56:14.364 region:rollup2
DEVELOP A REGULATIONS AND.
02:56:11.561 --> 02:56:16.433 region:rollup2
CRITERIA. THAT ARE HOPEFULLY
02:56:14.364 --> 02:56:17.534 region:rollup2
GOING TO GET US TO THE GOAL THAT
02:56:16.433 --> 02:56:19.302 region:rollup2
ARE COLLABORATIVE THAT A
02:56:17.534 --> 02:56:21.304 region:rollup2
COOPERATIVE AND THAT ARE
02:56:19.302 --> 02:56:23.073 region:rollup2
DESIGNED TO. BRING ALL THE
02:56:21.304 --> 02:56:24.774 region:rollup2
PARTIES TOGETHER IN A POSITIVE
02:56:23.073 --> 02:56:26.176 region:rollup2
FASHION AND THAT'S WHAT I AM
02:56:24.774 --> 02:56:27.210 region:rollup2
HOPING TO DO WITH THIS BILL AS
02:56:26.176 --> 02:56:29.245 region:rollup2
WELL.
02:56:27.210 --> 02:56:31.648 region:rollup2
SO THIS BILL OF THE AMENDMENTS.
02:56:29.245 --> 02:56:33.583 region:rollup2
CLARIFY THAT THIS BILL APPLIES
02:56:31.648 --> 02:56:36.186 region:rollup2
TO EMPLOYERS WITH A HUNDRED OR
02:56:33.583 --> 02:56:37.787 region:rollup2
MORE EMPLOYEES NOT JUST THOSE
02:56:36.186 --> 02:56:40.123 region:rollup2
INCORPORATED IN CALIFORNIA.
02:56:37.787 --> 02:56:41.724 region:rollup2
WE KNOW THAT MANY IF NOT MOST OF
02:56:40.123 --> 02:56:42.225 region:rollup2
THE CORPORATIONS IN CALIFORNIA
02:56:41.724 --> 02:56:44.394 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY INCORPORATE IN
02:56:42.225 --> 02:56:46.763 region:rollup2
DELAWARE.
02:56:44.394 --> 02:56:48.998 region:rollup2
BECAUSE DELAWARE HAS ALWAYS BEEN
02:56:46.763 --> 02:56:50.834 region:rollup2
A BUSINESS FRIENDLY EXTREMELY
02:56:48.998 --> 02:56:52.302 region:rollup2
BUSINESS FRIENDLY.
02:56:50.834 --> 02:56:54.537 region:rollup2
CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS SO OUR
02:56:52.302 --> 02:56:56.639 region:rollup2
GOAL IS IN A PLACE WHERE THERE
02:56:54.537 --> 02:56:58.208 region:rollup2
ARE. A BUSINESS WHO IN
02:56:56.639 --> 02:57:00.443 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA WITH A HUNDRED. OR
02:56:58.208 --> 02:57:02.545 region:rollup2
MORE EMPLOYEES THAT THAT WILL
02:57:00.443 --> 02:57:04.080 region:rollup2
COVER THEM AS WELL. THE
02:57:02.545 --> 02:57:05.148 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS ALSO NARROW THE
02:57:04.080 --> 02:57:07.684 region:rollup2
ENTITIES THAT RECEIVE THIS
02:57:05.148 --> 02:57:08.585 region:rollup2
CONFIDENTIAL PAY DATA. TO BE THE
02:57:07.684 --> 02:57:10.487 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL%
02:57:08.585 --> 02:57:12.222 region:rollup2
RELATIONS AND THE DEPARTMENT OF
02:57:10.487 --> 02:57:14.557 region:rollup2
FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING. AS
02:57:12.222 --> 02:57:15.592 region:rollup2
THESE ARE OUR ENFORCEMENT
02:57:14.557 --> 02:57:16.893 region:rollup2
AGENCIES.
02:57:15.592 --> 02:57:18.595 region:rollup2
THE AMENDMENTS ALSO ENSURE THE
02:57:16.893 --> 02:57:21.397 region:rollup2
DATA THAT INCLUDES EMPLOYER
02:57:18.595 --> 02:57:23.399 region:rollup2
SPECIFIC INFORMATION REMAINS
02:57:21.397 --> 02:57:25.568 region:rollup2
CONFIDENTIAL AND IS NOT SUBJECT
02:57:23.399 --> 02:57:27.470 region:rollup2
TO DISCLOSURE. THROUGH A PUBLIC
02:57:25.568 --> 02:57:30.540 region:rollup2
RECORDS ACT REQUEST THE
02:57:27.470 --> 02:57:32.809 region:rollup2
AGGREGATE DATA WHICH IS.
02:57:30.540 --> 02:57:34.544 region:rollup2
DIDN'T NOT SPECIFIC TO ANY
02:57:32.809 --> 02:57:36.713 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL.
02:57:34.544 --> 02:57:38.148 region:rollup2
AGGREGATE GATHER WHAT DATA
02:57:36.713 --> 02:57:39.849 region:rollup2
WOULD BE AVAILABLE PUBLICLY IT
02:57:38.148 --> 02:57:41.985 region:rollup2
CLARIFIES THAT EMPLOYERS NEED
02:57:39.849 --> 02:57:43.586 region:rollup2
NOT PROVIDE SPECIFIC PAY DATA
02:57:41.985 --> 02:57:46.422 region:rollup2
FOR EACH EMPLOYEE BUT ARE TO USE
02:57:43.586 --> 02:57:48.258 region:rollup2
AN INDIVIDUAL'S W. TO USE. AS
02:57:46.422 --> 02:57:50.126 region:rollup2
THE BASIS FOR DETERMINING WHAT
02:57:48.258 --> 02:57:53.329 region:rollup2
PAY BAND AN INDIVIDUAL FALLS
02:57:50.126 --> 02:57:55.999 region:rollup2
INTO AGAIN. NOT FOCUSING ON THE
02:57:53.329 --> 02:57:57.600 region:rollup2
GRANULAR AND SPECIFIC BUT TO GET
02:57:55.999 --> 02:58:00.570 region:rollup2
A IF YOU WILL THIRTY THOUSAND
02:57:57.600 --> 02:58:01.871 region:rollup2
FOOT VIEW OF HOW COMPANIES ARE
02:58:00.570 --> 02:58:04.874 region:rollup2
OPERATING.
02:58:01.871 --> 02:58:06.109 region:rollup2
AS. YOU MAY KNOW EQUAL PAY IS AN
02:58:04.874 --> 02:58:07.410 region:rollup2
ISSUE GO NEAR AND DEAR TO MY
02:58:06.109 --> 02:58:08.811 region:rollup2
HEART.
02:58:07.410 --> 02:58:10.246 region:rollup2
IN CALIFORNIA I AM PROUD THAT
02:58:08.811 --> 02:58:11.714 region:rollup2
WE'VE MADE GREAT STRIDES IN
02:58:10.246 --> 02:58:13.683 region:rollup2
ADDRESSING THE DISPARITY IN
02:58:11.714 --> 02:58:14.884 region:rollup2
EQUAL PAY. INCLUDING THE
02:58:13.683 --> 02:58:16.953 region:rollup2
ENACTMENT OF.
02:58:14.884 --> 02:58:19.255 region:rollup2
MY BILL THE CALIFORNIA FAIR PAY
02:58:16.953 --> 02:58:21.157 region:rollup2
ACT BECAME OPERATIVE IN TWENTY
02:58:19.255 --> 02:58:22.025 region:rollup2
SIXTEEN. AND I'D LIKE TO
02:58:21.157 --> 02:58:23.493 region:rollup2
INDICATE THAT AS A RESULT OF
02:58:22.025 --> 02:58:25.762 region:rollup2
THAT LEGISLATION THERE ARE NOW
02:58:23.493 --> 02:58:26.863 region:rollup2
FORTY ONE OTHER STATES THAT ARE
02:58:25.762 --> 02:58:29.265 region:rollup2
FOLLOWING SUIT IN USING THAT
02:58:26.863 --> 02:58:30.900 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION AS A TEMPLATE.
02:58:29.265 --> 02:58:33.603 region:rollup2
SO WE ARE MOVING FORWARD IN THAT
02:58:30.900 --> 02:58:35.471 region:rollup2
AREA BUT WE AREN'T THERE YET IN
02:58:33.603 --> 02:58:37.707 region:rollup2
THE SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGE WITH
02:58:35.471 --> 02:58:39.809 region:rollup2
ON EQUAL PAY IS THAT IT'S SO
02:58:37.707 --> 02:58:42.245 region:rollup2
OFTEN HIDDEN. NACHOS TO
02:58:39.809 --> 02:58:44.047 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES BUT OFTEN EVEN TO
02:58:42.245 --> 02:58:45.548 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS THEMSELVES
02:58:44.047 --> 02:58:47.817 region:rollup2
AND WHILE PAYING THEIR EQUITY
02:58:45.548 --> 02:58:49.852 region:rollup2
AND PAY INEQUALITY CONTINUES
02:58:47.817 --> 02:58:53.356 region:rollup2
MOST EMPLOYERS I BELIEVE DON'T
02:58:49.852 --> 02:58:55.992 region:rollup2
INTEND. TO SHORT A CHANGE THEIR
02:58:53.356 --> 02:58:58.494 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES BUT. THERE IS A LOT OF
02:58:55.992 --> 02:59:00.496 region:rollup2
IMPLICIT BIAS AND SO WE HAVE
02:58:58.494 --> 02:59:01.631 region:rollup2
MUCH WORK TO BE DONE. AND
02:59:00.496 --> 02:59:03.833 region:rollup2
RECOGNIZING THE PAY
02:59:01.631 --> 02:59:05.501 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION IS HARD TO DETECT
02:59:03.833 --> 02:59:07.203 region:rollup2
AN ADDRESS.
02:59:05.501 --> 02:59:09.339 region:rollup2
THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION.
02:59:07.203 --> 02:59:11.140 region:rollup2
IT DURING IT'S THE IT'S THE
02:59:09.339 --> 02:59:13.676 region:rollup2
IT'S TENURE ANNOUNCED A PROPOSED
02:59:11.140 --> 02:59:15.011 region:rollup2
REVISION TO A DEMOGRAPHIC REPORT
02:59:13.676 --> 02:59:17.947 region:rollup2
THAT LARGE EMPLOYERS HAVE BEEN
02:59:15.011 --> 02:59:20.016 region:rollup2
SUBMITTING. FOR OVER FIFTY YEARS
02:59:17.947 --> 02:59:21.284 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYER INFORMATION REPORT
02:59:20.016 --> 02:59:22.552 region:rollup2
OTHERWISE KNOWN AS THE E. E. O.
02:59:21.284 --> 02:59:24.487 region:rollup2
ONE.
02:59:22.552 --> 02:59:26.022 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT ALL EMPLOYERS ARE
02:59:24.487 --> 02:59:27.657 region:rollup2
A LARGE EMPLOYERS HAVE BEEN
02:59:26.022 --> 02:59:29.125 region:rollup2
REQUIRED TO SUBMIT FOR A LENGTHY
02:59:27.657 --> 02:59:31.027 region:rollup2
PERIOD OF TIME.
02:59:29.125 --> 02:59:32.595 region:rollup2
TO ADD
02:59:31.027 --> 02:59:34.430 region:rollup2
INCLUDE REPORTING A PAY DATA BY
02:59:32.595 --> 02:59:36.165 region:rollup2
RACE AND GENDER.
02:59:34.430 --> 02:59:38.635 region:rollup2
THIS WAS TO BEGIN IN TWENTY
02:59:36.165 --> 02:59:40.169 region:rollup2
EIGHTEEN THIS IS A PROCESS THAT
02:59:38.635 --> 02:59:42.071 region:rollup2
THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION HAD
02:59:40.169 --> 02:59:43.373 region:rollup2
BEEN WORKING ON FOR A NUMBER OF
02:59:42.071 --> 02:59:45.708 region:rollup2
YEARS BRINGING ALL THE
02:59:43.373 --> 02:59:47.176 region:rollup2
STAKEHOLDERS TOGETHER. IN ITS
02:59:45.708 --> 02:59:49.379 region:rollup2
TRADITIONAL THOUGHTFUL.
02:59:47.176 --> 02:59:50.813 region:rollup2
AND OF A COLLABORATIVE EFFORT
02:59:49.379 --> 02:59:53.249 region:rollup2
BUT IN AUGUST TO TWENTY
02:59:50.813 --> 02:59:54.317 region:rollup2
SEVENTEEN NOT SURPRISINGLY GIVEN
02:59:53.249 --> 02:59:54.984 region:rollup2
THE DIFFERENCES IN THE
02:59:54.317 --> 02:59:56.919 region:rollup2
APPROACHES OF THE TWO
02:59:54.984 --> 02:59:58.388 region:rollup2
ADMINISTRATIONS. THE TRUMP
02:59:56.919 --> 02:59:59.555 region:rollup2
ADMINISTRATION PUT A HALT TO
02:59:58.388 --> 03:00:02.291 region:rollup2
THIS NEW RULE.
02:59:59.555 --> 03:00:04.060 region:rollup2
DEALING A BLOW TO THE FIGHT FOR
03:00:02.291 --> 03:00:06.596 region:rollup2
EQUAL PAY.
03:00:04.060 --> 03:00:08.364 region:rollup2
SO S. B. TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR
03:00:06.596 --> 03:00:10.500 region:rollup2
GAMES TO ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIA
03:00:08.364 --> 03:00:12.268 region:rollup2
COLLECTS THIS IMPORTANT PAY DATA
03:00:10.500 --> 03:00:13.436 region:rollup2
THAT EMPLOYERS WERE POOREST OF
03:00:12.268 --> 03:00:15.171 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY PREPARED TO START
03:00:13.436 --> 03:00:16.706 region:rollup2
REPORTING.
03:00:15.171 --> 03:00:19.042 region:rollup2
AND TO DO THIS EVEN IF THE
03:00:16.706 --> 03:00:21.044 region:rollup2
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT DOES NOT.
03:00:19.042 --> 03:00:22.945 region:rollup2
MODELED AGAIN AFTER THIS SET UP
03:00:21.044 --> 03:00:24.714 region:rollup2
OBAMA ADMINISTRATION ORDER THIS
03:00:22.945 --> 03:00:25.715 region:rollup2
BIT OF A BILL WILL REQUIRE
03:00:24.714 --> 03:00:27.417 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS WITH A HUNDRED
03:00:25.715 --> 03:00:30.286 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES OR MORE TO SUBMIT A
03:00:27.417 --> 03:00:31.688 region:rollup2
PAID DATA REPORT ANNUALLY.
03:00:30.286 --> 03:00:33.289 region:rollup2
TWO THE DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL
03:00:31.688 --> 03:00:35.124 region:rollup2
RELATIONS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF
03:00:33.289 --> 03:00:37.093 region:rollup2
FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING.
03:00:35.124 --> 03:00:39.729 region:rollup2
WHICH OUTLINES THE COMPENSATION
03:00:37.093 --> 03:00:42.265 region:rollup2
IN HOURS WORKED OF EMPLOYEES BY
03:00:39.729 --> 03:00:43.933 region:rollup2
GENDER. RACE ETHNICITY AND JOB
03:00:42.265 --> 03:00:46.102 region:rollup2
CATEGORY BILL THE GOAL IS TWO
03:00:43.933 --> 03:00:48.638 region:rollup2
FOLD TO ENCOURAGE EMPLOYERS TO
03:00:46.102 --> 03:00:50.340 region:rollup2
ANALYZE THEIR OWN PAY PRACTICES
03:00:48.638 --> 03:00:52.141 region:rollup2
AND ALLOW FR SELF CORRECTION.
03:00:50.340 --> 03:00:54.977 region:rollup2
THAT IS THE BEST OF ALL POSSIBLE
03:00:52.141 --> 03:00:56.379 region:rollup2
WORLDS AND TO TO ALLOW THE
03:00:54.977 --> 03:00:58.548 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL
03:00:56.379 --> 03:01:00.650 region:rollup2
RELATIONS AND DE FE H. ACCESS TO
03:00:58.548 --> 03:01:02.418 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT DATA. THAT ALLOWS THEM
03:01:00.650 --> 03:01:04.987 region:rollup2
TO SEE PATTERNS OF WAGE
03:01:02.418 --> 03:01:07.023 region:rollup2
DISPARITIES AND IF THEY NOTICED
03:01:04.987 --> 03:01:08.791 region:rollup2
DEVIATIONS WORE OUT LIARS IT
03:01:07.023 --> 03:01:11.461 region:rollup2
GIVES THEM THE ABILITY TO
03:01:08.791 --> 03:01:12.995 region:rollup2
INVESTIGATE THREATS OF FURTHER.
03:01:11.461 --> 03:01:14.497 region:rollup2
SO I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT BASED
03:01:12.995 --> 03:01:15.765 region:rollup2
UPON SOME OF THE INFORMATION OUT
03:01:14.497 --> 03:01:17.400 region:rollup2
THERE TO NOTE AGAIN WHAT THIS
03:01:15.765 --> 03:01:19.335 region:rollup2
BILL IS NOT.
03:01:17.400 --> 03:01:20.636 region:rollup2
THIS BILL IS NOT ABOUT PUBLIC
03:01:19.335 --> 03:01:23.039 region:rollup2
SHAMING IT WILL NOT EXPOSE
03:01:20.636 --> 03:01:25.508 region:rollup2
INFORMATION THAT IS IDENTIFIABLE
03:01:23.039 --> 03:01:27.043 region:rollup2
BY BUSINESS TO THE PUBLIC NOR
03:01:25.508 --> 03:01:29.112 region:rollup2
WILL IT EXPOSED EMPLOYEES
03:01:27.043 --> 03:01:31.080 region:rollup2
PRIVATE FINANCIAL INFORMATION TO
03:01:29.112 --> 03:01:33.850 region:rollup2
THE PUBLIC. THE DATA WILL
03:01:31.080 --> 03:01:35.752 region:rollup2
PROVIDE A BIRDS EYE VIEW ON PAY
03:01:33.850 --> 03:01:37.720 region:rollup2
DISPARITIES AND OCCUPATIONAL
03:01:35.752 --> 03:01:39.522 region:rollup2
SEGREGATION.
03:01:37.720 --> 03:01:42.258 region:rollup2
A BIRDS EYE THIS LEVEL BUT IT
03:01:39.522 --> 03:01:44.026 region:rollup2
DOESN INTEND TO DO IT IN A.
03:01:42.258 --> 03:01:45.862 region:rollup2
GRANULAR LEVEL THE INFORMATION
03:01:44.026 --> 03:01:47.697 region:rollup2
IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED TO
03:01:45.862 --> 03:01:50.500 region:rollup2
ENFORCE THE CALIFORNIA FAIR PAY
03:01:47.697 --> 03:01:53.035 region:rollup2
ACT IT IS AN INVESTIGATORY TOOL.
03:01:50.500 --> 03:01:55.071 region:rollup2
TO HELP COMPANIES AND THE
03:01:53.035 --> 03:01:58.040 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY SHED LIGHT ON
03:01:55.071 --> 03:02:00.710 region:rollup2
TRENDS AND PROVIDE CLUES ABOUT
03:01:58.040 --> 03:02:01.978 region:rollup2
DISPARITIES IN PAY TODAY.
03:02:00.710 --> 03:02:03.780 region:rollup2
I'M PLEASED TO HAVE WITH ME
03:02:01.978 --> 03:02:05.448 region:rollup2
JESSICA STANDARD. OF EQUAL
03:02:03.780 --> 03:02:06.849 region:rollup2
RIGHTS ADVOCATES A SPONSOR OF
03:02:05.448 --> 03:02:08.184 region:rollup2
THE BILL.
03:02:06.849 --> 03:02:10.553 region:rollup2
AND SHANNON SMITH PROBABLY WITH
03:02:08.184 --> 03:02:12.722 region:rollup2
A A UW ALSO ONE OF THE BILL'S
03:02:10.553 --> 03:02:14.190 region:rollup2
SPONSORS HERE TO SPEAK IN
03:02:12.722 --> 03:02:15.691 region:rollup2
SUPPORT OF THE MEASURE AND WITH
03:02:14.190 --> 03:02:19.495 region:rollup2
THAT I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:02:15.691 --> 03:02:20.062 region:rollup2
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
03:02:19.495 --> 03:02:21.798 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON SHANNON SMITH
03:02:20.062 --> 03:02:23.266 region:rollup2
CROWLEY AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF
03:02:21.798 --> 03:02:24.634 region:rollup2
UNIVERSITY WOMEN ALL KEEP MY
03:02:23.266 --> 03:02:25.334 region:rollup2
COMMENTS BRIEF THERE'S NOT A
03:02:24.634 --> 03:02:26.936 region:rollup2
WHOLE LOT TO AND.
03:02:25.334 --> 03:02:28.671 region:rollup2
AFTER SENATOR JACKSON'S
03:02:26.936 --> 03:02:30.206 region:rollup2
COMMENTS BUT JUST REALLY WANTED
03:02:28.671 --> 03:02:31.541 region:rollup2
TO FOCUS ON THE NEED FOR THE
03:02:30.206 --> 03:02:32.708 region:rollup2
BILL ABOUT THE PERSISTENCE OF
03:02:31.541 --> 03:02:33.609 region:rollup2
THE PAY GAP.
03:02:32.708 --> 03:02:35.578 region:rollup2
AND I KNOW THAT YOU'VE HEARD A
03:02:33.609 --> 03:02:36.913 region:rollup2
LOT IN THE LAST FOUR YEARS ABOUT
03:02:35.578 --> 03:02:37.513 region:rollup2
THE DIFFERENT BILLS THAT WE'VE
03:02:36.913 --> 03:02:40.383 region:rollup2
HAD BUT WE ACTUALLY HOUSE NEW
03:02:37.513 --> 03:02:41.551 region:rollup2
DATA.
03:02:40.383 --> 03:02:43.586 region:rollup2
TOMMY GARDENS IN NOTHING THE
03:02:41.551 --> 03:02:44.420 region:rollup2
SENATE LABOR COMMITTEE WE'VE
03:02:43.586 --> 03:02:45.755 region:rollup2
BEEN SAYING.
03:02:44.420 --> 03:02:49.125 region:rollup2
THAT IT WAS TWO THOUSAND
03:02:45.755 --> 03:02:49.792 region:rollup2
FIFTEEN NINE BEFORE THE CAP WAS
03:02:49.125 --> 03:02:51.327 region:rollup2
GOING TO CLOSE HAVING FEMALE SO
03:02:49.792 --> 03:02:52.428 region:rollup2
SHE'S. A DIFFERENT ORGANIZATIONS
03:02:51.327 --> 03:02:53.296 region:rollup2
NUMBER WAS TWO THOUSAND FIFTY
03:02:52.428 --> 03:02:54.497 region:rollup2
EIGHT.
03:02:53.296 --> 03:02:56.899 region:rollup2
BUT BASED ON THE TRAIN FROM TWO
03:02:54.497 --> 03:02:57.800 region:rollup2
THOUSAND ONCE TWO THOUSAND
03:02:56.899 --> 03:02:59.235 region:rollup2
FIFTEEN.
03:02:57.800 --> 03:03:01.737 region:rollup2
IT'S TWO THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED
03:02:59.235 --> 03:03:04.106 region:rollup2
AND NINETEEN NOW.
03:03:01.737 --> 03:03:06.876 region:rollup2
IS THE PROJECT PROJECTED DATE.
03:03:04.106 --> 03:03:08.778 region:rollup2
THAT'S A HUNDRED THEM ONE YEARS.
03:03:06.876 --> 03:03:10.012 region:rollup2
FIFTEEN YEARS FURTHER THE WELL
03:03:08.778 --> 03:03:11.614 region:rollup2
WE'VE MADE GREAT STRIDES IN
03:03:10.012 --> 03:03:14.050 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA AND SOME OF THE DATA
03:03:11.614 --> 03:03:14.650 region:rollup2
MEAN ON MAY BE CHANGING BECAUSE
03:03:14.050 --> 03:03:15.751 region:rollup2
OF BECAUSE OF THE BILL'S WE'VE
03:03:14.650 --> 03:03:16.719 region:rollup2
DONE.
03:03:15.751 --> 03:03:19.055 region:rollup2
IT'S STILL WE NEED TO DO
03:03:16.719 --> 03:03:21.958 region:rollup2
SIGNIFICANT.
03:03:19.055 --> 03:03:23.426 region:rollup2
EFFORTS IN THIS AREA AND I HIT
03:03:21.958 --> 03:03:24.594 region:rollup2
RENTS JUST TODAY BUT SOME USING
03:03:23.426 --> 03:03:25.461 region:rollup2
WELL IT'S ACTUALLY NOT A GENDER
03:03:24.594 --> 03:03:27.763 region:rollup2
PAY GAP.
03:03:25.461 --> 03:03:29.298 region:rollup2
IT'S A CHASM.
03:03:27.763 --> 03:03:31.300 region:rollup2
DENNIS AT ALL CATEGORIES EVEN
03:03:29.298 --> 03:03:33.169 region:rollup2
FOR PROFESSIONAL WOMEN AT THE
03:03:31.300 --> 03:03:35.471 region:rollup2
NINETY NINTH PERCENTILE.
03:03:33.169 --> 03:03:38.140 region:rollup2
PROFESSIONAL WOMEN MAKE HALF OF
03:03:35.471 --> 03:03:40.076 region:rollup2
WHAT MEN MAKE. EVEN IN IN.
03:03:38.140 --> 03:03:42.378 region:rollup2
MEDICINE.
03:03:40.076 --> 03:03:44.780 region:rollup2
CLUB OBGYN SPILL OVER CHILEANS
03:03:42.378 --> 03:03:46.916 region:rollup2
MAKE MORE MALE NURSES MAKE MORE
03:03:44.780 --> 03:03:48.284 region:rollup2
IS ACROSS THE BOARD.
03:03:46.916 --> 03:03:50.353 region:rollup2
EIGHTEEN W. AGREEMENTS WITH
03:03:48.284 --> 03:03:52.688 region:rollup2
SENATOR JACKSON A LOT OF THIS IS
03:03:50.353 --> 03:03:54.457 region:rollup2
NOT INTENTIONAL.
03:03:52.688 --> 03:03:56.359 region:rollup2
BUT IT'S WE ACTUALLY HAVE DONE
03:03:54.457 --> 03:03:58.494 region:rollup2
IT SAYS THAT ONLY ABOUT SIX TO
03:03:56.359 --> 03:03:59.795 region:rollup2
TWELVE PERCENT OF THE OF THE.
03:03:58.494 --> 03:04:01.097 region:rollup2
PINK OUT CAN BE DISARM.
03:03:59.795 --> 03:04:03.266 region:rollup2
EXPLAINED BY BIAS OR
03:04:01.097 --> 03:04:04.433 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION AND REALLY THE
03:04:03.266 --> 03:04:05.868 region:rollup2
REST OF IT IS.
03:04:04.433 --> 03:04:08.638 region:rollup2
JUST WERE PERPETUATING THE
03:04:05.868 --> 03:04:10.239 region:rollup2
STATUS QUO. WE DON'T LOOK AS WE
03:04:08.638 --> 03:04:11.674 region:rollup2
NEED TAKE A STEP BACK AND GET
03:04:10.239 --> 03:04:13.843 region:rollup2
THE STUFF OUT THERE.
03:04:11.674 --> 03:04:14.777 region:rollup2
AND SO THE PEOPLE CAN LOOK AT
03:04:13.843 --> 03:04:16.145 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES AND MANY
03:04:14.777 --> 03:04:18.314 region:rollup2
ORGANIZATIONS ARE MAKING THE
03:04:16.145 --> 03:04:21.584 region:rollup2
CHANGES THEMSELVES. SO.
03:04:18.314 --> 03:04:22.184 region:rollup2
THAT WE SUPPORT THIS EFFORT AND
03:04:21.584 --> 03:04:24.887 region:rollup2
WE ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
03:04:22.184 --> 03:04:26.589 region:rollup2
CHIU.
03:04:24.887 --> 03:04:28.090 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MR VICE CHAIR
03:04:26.589 --> 03:04:29.258 region:rollup2
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
03:04:28.090 --> 03:04:30.293 region:rollup2
ARMENIANS JESSICA STANDER I'M
03:04:29.258 --> 03:04:31.294 region:rollup2
SENIOR COUNSEL FOR PLEASE
03:04:30.293 --> 03:04:32.428 region:rollup2
JUSTICE AND PUBLIC POLICY PEOPLE
03:04:31.294 --> 03:04:33.596 region:rollup2
RIGHTS ADVOCATES WHO WORK TO
03:04:32.428 --> 03:04:35.231 region:rollup2
REMOVE BARRIERS TO EQUAL
03:04:33.596 --> 03:04:36.666 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY AND TREATMENT IN THE
03:04:35.231 --> 03:04:37.967 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE. HOW MORE PROUD
03:04:36.666 --> 03:04:39.835 region:rollup2
SPONSOR OF THIS BILL?
03:04:37.967 --> 03:04:40.803 region:rollup2
I ALSO KEEP MY COMMENTS BRIEF
03:04:39.835 --> 03:04:42.238 region:rollup2
BECAUSE OF SENATOR JACKSON'S
03:04:40.803 --> 03:04:43.172 region:rollup2
VERY THOROUGH PRESENTATION BUT
03:04:42.238 --> 03:04:44.373 region:rollup2
REALLY QUICKLY I THINK IT'S
03:04:43.172 --> 03:04:46.142 region:rollup2
IMPORTANT TALK ABOUT WHY THIS
03:04:44.373 --> 03:04:48.444 region:rollup2
BILL MATTERS Y. THE DATA THAT WE
03:04:46.142 --> 03:04:49.178 region:rollup2
WILL GET FROM THIS BILL.
03:04:48.444 --> 03:04:50.546 region:rollup2
PATTERSON IS IMPORTANT
03:04:49.178 --> 03:04:51.847 region:rollup2
THE BILL WOULD ADDRESS TWO MAJOR
03:04:50.546 --> 03:04:53.716 region:rollup2
OBSTACLES TO CLOSING THIS GENDER
03:04:51.847 --> 03:04:55.184 region:rollup2
AND RACE WAGE GAP WE ALL KNOW
03:04:53.716 --> 03:04:56.986 region:rollup2
HOW PERVASIVE IT IS AN EFFECTIVE
03:04:55.184 --> 03:04:58.521 region:rollup2
TAKES NOT ONLY ON WOMEN BUT ON
03:04:56.986 --> 03:04:59.956 region:rollup2
FAMILIES GIVEN HOW OFTEN WOMEN
03:04:58.521 --> 03:05:01.824 region:rollup2
ARE. PRIMARY OR CO PRIMARY
03:04:59.956 --> 03:05:03.426 region:rollup2
BREADWINNERS IN THEIR FAMILIES.
03:05:01.824 --> 03:05:04.927 region:rollup2
BUT IT'S A IT'S IT'S A STUBBORN
03:05:03.426 --> 03:05:06.128 region:rollup2
GAP IT'S NOT CLOSING AND THE
03:05:04.927 --> 03:05:06.662 region:rollup2
RATE AT WHICH IS CLOSING
03:05:06.128 --> 03:05:07.530 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY SLOWING AS YOU'VE
03:05:06.662 --> 03:05:08.898 region:rollup2
HEARD.
03:05:07.530 --> 03:05:10.600 region:rollup2
AND THERE'S MANY CONTRIBUTORS
03:05:08.898 --> 03:05:11.934 region:rollup2
TO THE GAP AND THAT REQUIRES A
03:05:10.600 --> 03:05:13.336 region:rollup2
KIND OF VERY APPROACH TO
03:05:11.934 --> 03:05:14.971 region:rollup2
ADDRESSING THE CONTRIBUTORS TO
03:05:13.336 --> 03:05:17.006 region:rollup2
THE TO THIS RACE RACIAL AND
03:05:14.971 --> 03:05:18.040 region:rollup2
GENDER WAGE GAP. ARMS OF THE TWO
03:05:17.006 --> 03:05:18.507 region:rollup2
THAT THIS BILL REALLY DEALS WITH
03:05:18.040 --> 03:05:21.210 region:rollup2
OUR.
03:05:18.507 --> 03:05:22.411 region:rollup2
OCCUPATIONAL SEGREGATION THAT
03:05:21.210 --> 03:05:24.113 region:rollup2
WOMEN AND MINORITIES ARE OFTEN
03:05:22.411 --> 03:05:26.315 region:rollup2
FALL INTO LOWER PAID.
03:05:24.113 --> 03:05:27.617 region:rollup2
OCCUPATIONS AND ALSO INTO LOWER
03:05:26.315 --> 03:05:29.819 region:rollup2
PAID POSITION WITHIN A COMPANY.
03:05:27.617 --> 03:05:31.053 region:rollup2
AND ALSO THE FACT THAT I MANY
03:05:29.819 --> 03:05:32.722 region:rollup2
PEOPLE INCLUDING EMPLOYERS
03:05:31.053 --> 03:05:34.590 region:rollup2
THEMSELVES ARE OFTEN UNAWARE OF
03:05:32.722 --> 03:05:36.726 region:rollup2
PAY DISPARITIES AND THIS TYPE OF
03:05:34.590 --> 03:05:38.094 region:rollup2
OCCUPATIONAL SEGREGATION.
03:05:36.726 --> 03:05:39.228 region:rollup2
.
03:05:38.094 --> 03:05:40.296 region:rollup2
THE WHEN EMPLOYERS ARE UNAWARE
03:05:39.228 --> 03:05:41.597 region:rollup2
OF THESE DISPARITIES THEY DON'T
03:05:40.296 --> 03:05:43.165 region:rollup2
KNOW WHAT THEY CAN FIX SO
03:05:41.597 --> 03:05:44.100 region:rollup2
REQUIRING PAY DATA COLLECTION
03:05:43.165 --> 03:05:45.801 region:rollup2
PROVIDES EMPLOYERS OF THE
03:05:44.100 --> 03:05:47.637 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO DO THIS INTERNAL
03:05:45.801 --> 03:05:48.871 region:rollup2
LOOKING AND THEN TO DIVE DEEPER
03:05:47.637 --> 03:05:50.239 region:rollup2
IN WHEN THEY NOTICED THERE IS A
03:05:48.871 --> 03:05:51.507 region:rollup2
PAY DISPARITY. THAT DOESN'T
03:05:50.239 --> 03:05:53.142 region:rollup2
NECESSARILY MEAN THERE'S A
03:05:51.507 --> 03:05:54.176 region:rollup2
VIOLATION OF AN EQUAL PAY LAW
03:05:53.142 --> 03:05:55.778 region:rollup2
BUT A KIND OF INSTANT
03:05:54.176 --> 03:05:56.879 region:rollup2
INCENTIVIZE THEM TO LOOK DEEPER
03:05:55.778 --> 03:05:58.514 region:rollup2
AND IF THEY DETERMINE THAT THERE
03:05:56.879 --> 03:06:00.149 region:rollup2
IS NO JUSTIFICATION AT AN
03:05:58.514 --> 03:06:01.584 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUAL LEVEL. THEY CAN THEN
03:06:00.149 --> 03:06:02.485 region:rollup2
RECTIFY THAT COMMENT ALSO IF
03:06:01.584 --> 03:06:03.619 region:rollup2
THEY DETERMINE THERE ARE
03:06:02.485 --> 03:06:05.187 region:rollup2
PATTERNS THAT THEY MIGHT NOT
03:06:03.619 --> 03:06:06.822 region:rollup2
HAVE BEEN AWARE OF WITH WOMEN
03:06:05.187 --> 03:06:08.391 region:rollup2
AND PEOPLE OF COLOR CONCENTRATED
03:06:06.822 --> 03:06:09.759 region:rollup2
INTO THESE LOWER PAID POSITIONS
03:06:08.391 --> 03:06:11.193 region:rollup2
OF THEIR COMPANIES. THAT CAN
03:06:09.759 --> 03:06:12.795 region:rollup2
THEN SPUR THEM TO TAKE TO MAKE
03:06:11.193 --> 03:06:14.430 region:rollup2
CHANGES WITHIN THEIR HIRING AND
03:06:12.795 --> 03:06:15.865 region:rollup2
PROMOTION PRACTICES TO TRY TO.
03:06:14.430 --> 03:06:17.433 region:rollup2
ADDRESS THESE PROACTIVELY.
03:06:15.865 --> 03:06:19.101 region:rollup2
WE'VE HEARD OF MANY LARGE
03:06:17.433 --> 03:06:20.136 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER VOLUNTARILY DOING THIS
03:06:19.101 --> 03:06:22.438 region:rollup2
I'M JUST TO NAME A FEW SALES
03:06:20.136 --> 03:06:23.372 region:rollup2
FORCE DELTA AND STARBUCKS ABOUT
03:06:22.438 --> 03:06:24.974 region:rollup2
PUBLICLY ANNOUNCE THAT THEY'VE
03:06:23.372 --> 03:06:26.275 region:rollup2
DONE THESE TYPES OF. INTERNAL
03:06:24.974 --> 03:06:27.309 region:rollup2
PAY AUDITS AND THEY HAVE AND NOT
03:06:26.275 --> 03:06:28.611 region:rollup2
SURPRISINGLY.
03:06:27.309 --> 03:06:30.813 region:rollup2
UNCOVERED THE STEPS OF
03:06:28.611 --> 03:06:32.014 region:rollup2
DISPARITIES AND CAUSED IN IN IN
03:06:30.813 --> 03:06:34.016 region:rollup2
ALMOST ALL THOSE CASES.
03:06:32.014 --> 03:06:34.884 region:rollup2
THE EMPLOYERS THAT TO MAKE PAGE
03:06:34.016 --> 03:06:37.219 region:rollup2
CHANGES CHANGES THEIR BASE
03:06:34.884 --> 03:06:37.753 region:rollup2
SYSTEMS TO BRING A WORKERS UP TO
03:06:37.219 --> 03:06:39.255 region:rollup2
PARITY.
03:06:37.753 --> 03:06:40.823 region:rollup2
AND ALSO TO CHANGE THEIR HIRING
03:06:39.255 --> 03:06:42.058 region:rollup2
PRACTICES TO ENSURE EQUAL
03:06:40.823 --> 03:06:43.826 region:rollup2
REPRESENTATION OF WOMEN AND
03:06:42.058 --> 03:06:45.828 region:rollup2
PEOPLEOF COLOR IN ALL ROUNDS
03:06:43.826 --> 03:06:46.796 region:rollup2
AND ALL PAY SCALES. AND I WOULD
03:06:45.828 --> 03:06:48.731 region:rollup2
JUST ADD THAT IN ADDITION TO
03:06:46.796 --> 03:06:50.533 region:rollup2
THIS ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES NOW
03:06:48.731 --> 03:06:52.768 region:rollup2
WILL HAVE MORE EFFECTIVE A USE
03:06:50.533 --> 03:06:54.203 region:rollup2
OF THEIR. RESOURCES
03:06:52.768 --> 03:06:55.271 region:rollup2
INVESTIGATORY DRIVE AND I'LL
03:06:54.203 --> 03:06:59.075 region:rollup2
LEAVE IT AT THAT I'M HAPPY TO
03:06:55.271 --> 03:06:59.675 region:rollup2
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AND I
03:06:59.075 --> 03:07:00.876 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
03:06:59.675 --> 03:07:01.811 region:rollup2
VOTE.
03:07:00.876 --> 03:07:03.446 region:rollup2
STANDARD DO I HAVE ANY OTHER
03:07:01.811 --> 03:07:04.547 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
03:07:03.446 --> 03:07:05.414 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY CLEAR SHE ARE
03:07:04.547 --> 03:07:06.015 region:rollup2
WITH THE CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT
03:07:05.414 --> 03:07:09.418 region:rollup2
LAWYERS ASSOCIATION IN STRONG
03:07:06.015 --> 03:07:10.519 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:07:09.418 --> 03:07:11.687 region:rollup2
JERRY MEMBERS KEVIN BAKER FOR
03:07:10.519 --> 03:07:12.254 region:rollup2
THE MARKETS OF LIBERTIES UNION
03:07:11.687 --> 03:07:15.391 region:rollup2
OF CALIFORNIA ALSO INSTRUCTS
03:07:12.254 --> 03:07:17.259 region:rollup2
PARK.
03:07:15.391 --> 03:07:19.729 region:rollup2
WHEN A LOT OF US ARE YOU
03:07:17.259 --> 03:07:20.996 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ALSO IN SUPPORT.
03:07:19.729 --> 03:07:21.831 region:rollup2
GETTING GARY FROM LEGALLY
03:07:20.996 --> 03:07:22.398 region:rollup2
NETWORK CONCERNS FOR.
03:07:21.831 --> 03:07:36.245 region:rollup2
DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES IN
03:07:22.398 --> 03:07:37.213 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION.
03:07:36.245 --> 03:07:38.147 region:rollup2
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME FLOOR
03:07:37.213 --> 03:07:39.215 region:rollup2
CURTIS NAME HERE ON BEHALF THE
03:07:38.147 --> 03:07:40.349 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
03:07:39.215 --> 03:07:41.984 region:rollup2
THANK YOU AGAIN FOR THE
03:07:40.349 --> 03:07:43.786 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY TODAY WE
03:07:41.984 --> 03:07:44.487 region:rollup2
ARE HERE IN OPPOSITION TO SB
03:07:43.786 --> 03:07:46.322 region:rollup2
TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR WE DO
03:07:44.487 --> 03:07:47.189 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE. SENATOR JACKSON
03:07:46.322 --> 03:07:49.225 region:rollup2
THEIR WILLINGNESS TO TAKE SOME
03:07:47.189 --> 03:07:50.826 region:rollup2
OF THE AND SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
03:07:49.225 --> 03:07:52.161 region:rollup2
AND WE JUST WANT TO BE SURE THAT
03:07:50.826 --> 03:07:53.596 region:rollup2
THOSE AMENDMENTS FALL IN LINE
03:07:52.161 --> 03:07:54.730 region:rollup2
WITH THE STRICT PARAMETERS
03:07:53.596 --> 03:07:55.531 region:rollup2
IMPOSED BY THE OBAMA
03:07:54.730 --> 03:07:57.600 region:rollup2
ADMINISTRATION WITH THE
03:07:55.531 --> 03:07:59.568 region:rollup2
ORIGINALLY EO ONE. REQUIREMENTS
03:07:57.600 --> 03:08:00.836 region:rollup2
AND ADDITIONALLY ARE CONCERNED
03:07:59.568 --> 03:08:02.371 region:rollup2
STILL IS THE UNDERLYING
03:08:00.836 --> 03:08:03.038 region:rollup2
ADDITIONAL REPORTING THAT'S
03:08:02.371 --> 03:08:04.874 region:rollup2
GOING TO BE REQUIRED BY
03:08:03.038 --> 03:08:06.408 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS THAT ACTUALLY DOESN'T
03:08:04.874 --> 03:08:07.943 region:rollup2
COMPARE SIMPLY APPLES TO APPLES.
03:08:06.408 --> 03:08:10.045 region:rollup2
AND THE ESSENCE OF THE FAIR PAY
03:08:07.943 --> 03:08:11.680 region:rollup2
ACT WAS TO HAVE SUBSTANTIALLY
03:08:10.045 --> 03:08:13.382 region:rollup2
SIMILAR TO HAVE AND. THE
03:08:11.680 --> 03:08:15.384 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR POSITIONS
03:08:13.382 --> 03:08:16.685 region:rollup2
COMPARED AND THAT ALLOWS FOR
03:08:15.384 --> 03:08:18.487 region:rollup2
BONA FIDE FACTORS TO BE IN
03:08:16.685 --> 03:08:19.855 region:rollup2
CONSIDERATION HOWEVER THIS
03:08:18.487 --> 03:08:20.990 region:rollup2
REPORTING I'M WILL NOT SHOW THAT
03:08:19.855 --> 03:08:22.658 region:rollup2
THIS REPORTING WILL SHOW
03:08:20.990 --> 03:08:24.360 region:rollup2
EVERYBODY UNDER ONE SPECIFIC
03:08:22.658 --> 03:08:25.427 region:rollup2
TITLE. FOR EXAMPLE IF YOU TAKE
03:08:24.360 --> 03:08:26.662 region:rollup2
ALL OF YOUR STAFFERS ONE HAS
03:08:25.427 --> 03:08:28.030 region:rollup2
BEEN HERE FOR THIRTY YEARS ONE
03:08:26.662 --> 03:08:29.365 region:rollup2
HAS BEEN HERE FOR TWO WEEKS YOU
03:08:28.030 --> 03:08:30.132 region:rollup2
PUT THOSE TO YOU UPON TOGETHER
03:08:29.365 --> 03:08:31.901 region:rollup2
THERE'S GOING TO BE WAGE
03:08:30.132 --> 03:08:34.003 region:rollup2
DISPARITY NOT ALWAYS DISPARITIES
03:08:31.901 --> 03:08:35.237 region:rollup2
UNLAWFUL. WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT
03:08:34.003 --> 03:08:36.772 region:rollup2
THERE SHOULD BE UNLAWFUL WAGE
03:08:35.237 --> 03:08:37.706 region:rollup2
DISPARITY BY ANY MEANS WE
03:08:36.772 --> 03:08:39.441 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY SUPPORTED THE FAIR PAY
03:08:37.706 --> 03:08:40.776 region:rollup2
ACT HOWEVER OUR CONCERN IS IS
03:08:39.441 --> 03:08:42.378 region:rollup2
THAT THIS WILL BE A REQUIRED
03:08:40.776 --> 03:08:43.212 region:rollup2
REPORTING THAT WON'T ALLOW
03:08:42.378 --> 03:08:44.814 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS. TO ACTUALLY THAT
03:08:43.212 --> 03:08:46.382 region:rollup2
WON'T SHOW WHAT YOU'RE ACTUALLY
03:08:44.814 --> 03:08:47.149 region:rollup2
LOOKING FOR A MINUTE ALTERNATIVE
03:08:46.382 --> 03:08:48.984 region:rollup2
I THINK THERE SHOULD BE AN
03:08:47.149 --> 03:08:50.419 region:rollup2
INCENTIVE FOR EMPLOYERS TO
03:08:48.984 --> 03:08:52.288 region:rollup2
CONDUCT FOR PACKED AUDITS RATHER
03:08:50.419 --> 03:08:53.589 region:rollup2
THAN REQUIRING REPORTING THAT
03:08:52.288 --> 03:08:56.826 region:rollup2
WON'T SHOW WITH MISS IT WHAT DAY
03:08:53.589 --> 03:08:57.293 region:rollup2
AND WHAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR.
03:08:56.826 --> 03:08:58.360 region:rollup2
BIGGER SO MUCH FOR THE
03:08:57.293 --> 03:08:59.128 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY.
03:08:58.360 --> 03:08:59.895 region:rollup2
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS
03:08:59.128 --> 03:09:01.297 region:rollup2
MIKE BELOVED FOR THE CALIFORNIA
03:08:59.895 --> 03:09:02.665 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT LAW CUNSEL. I DON'T
03:09:01.297 --> 03:09:04.366 region:rollup2
KNOW IF ANY OF YOU HAD A CHANCE
03:09:02.665 --> 03:09:06.602 region:rollup2
TO SEE SIXTY MINUTES THE OTHER
03:09:04.366 --> 03:09:08.704 region:rollup2
DAY BUT IT HAD A SEGMENT ABOUT
03:09:06.602 --> 03:09:11.907 region:rollup2
SALES FORCE AND THE DIFFICULTY
03:09:08.704 --> 03:09:12.074 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE ROOTING OUT. OF EQUAL
03:09:11.907 --> 03:09:13.776 region:rollup2
PAY.
03:09:12.074 --> 03:09:15.544 region:rollup2
.
03:09:13.776 --> 03:09:17.246 region:rollup2
EQUITY. IT WAS IT BUT IT WAS
03:09:15.544 --> 03:09:19.048 region:rollup2
HARD IT WAS REALLY HARD TAKES A
03:09:17.246 --> 03:09:21.851 region:rollup2
LONG TIME OUR COMPANIES ARE
03:09:19.048 --> 03:09:23.652 region:rollup2
DOING THESE SELF AUDITS NOW. AND
03:09:21.851 --> 03:09:25.821 region:rollup2
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT AND AND THE
03:09:23.652 --> 03:09:27.423 region:rollup2
LAW REQUIRES AN ABILITY TO CUT
03:09:25.821 --> 03:09:30.426 region:rollup2
DISCERN EVEN THE SMALLEST
03:09:27.423 --> 03:09:31.694 region:rollup2
DISTINCTIONS AND FIX SOME OF TWO
03:09:30.426 --> 03:09:33.696 region:rollup2
EVEN IF STATISTICALLY
03:09:31.694 --> 03:09:36.031 region:rollup2
INSIGNIFICANT ANY. DIFFERENCE
03:09:33.696 --> 03:09:37.433 region:rollup2
THAT CANNOT BE EXPLAINED BY
03:09:36.031 --> 03:09:38.834 region:rollup2
OTHER REASONS MUST BE CORRECTED
03:09:37.433 --> 03:09:41.036 region:rollup2
AT OUR COMPANIES ARE GOING
03:09:38.834 --> 03:09:43.172 region:rollup2
THROUGH THAT. SO NOW WE LAYER ON
03:09:41.036 --> 03:09:45.474 region:rollup2
TOP OF THIS ON TOP OF THE EQUAL
03:09:43.172 --> 03:09:47.209 region:rollup2
PAY ACT WHICH WE SUPPORTED AND
03:09:45.474 --> 03:09:48.677 region:rollup2
WE ARE WORKING TO IMPLEMENT.
03:09:47.209 --> 03:09:51.714 region:rollup2
THAT NOW THIS.
03:09:48.677 --> 03:09:53.182 region:rollup2
THIS NEW A REPORTING
03:09:51.714 --> 03:09:54.183 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENT ACCORDING TO
03:09:53.182 --> 03:09:56.018 region:rollup2
CATEGORIES AND.
03:09:54.183 --> 03:09:57.519 region:rollup2
SENATOR JACKSON'S ABSOLUTELY
03:09:56.018 --> 03:09:59.054 region:rollup2
RIGHT THE STAKEHOLDERS DID WORK
03:09:57.519 --> 03:10:00.422 region:rollup2
WITH THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION TO
03:09:59.054 --> 03:10:01.690 region:rollup2
TRY TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO MAKE
03:10:00.422 --> 03:10:03.959 region:rollup2
THAT WORK.
03:10:01.690 --> 03:10:05.294 region:rollup2
I THOUGHT THE ANALYSIS OF MR
03:10:03.959 --> 03:10:07.930 region:rollup2
GRIFFITHS DID WAS WAS REALLY
03:10:05.294 --> 03:10:09.131 region:rollup2
GOOD AND THOUGHTFUL AND COMPLETE
03:10:07.930 --> 03:10:11.300 region:rollup2
HE TAUGHT BUT IT IT RAISES AN
03:10:09.131 --> 03:10:13.636 region:rollup2
AMBIGUITY ABOUT THE PURPOSE TO
03:10:11.300 --> 03:10:14.837 region:rollup2
WHICH THIS INFORMATION IS BEING
03:10:13.636 --> 03:10:16.805 region:rollup2
COMPILED AND SEND IT.
03:10:14.837 --> 03:10:18.807 region:rollup2
ON PAGE TWO OF THE ANALYSIS IT
03:10:16.805 --> 03:10:20.976 region:rollup2
SAYS THE RESULTING AGGREGATE
03:10:18.807 --> 03:10:23.913 region:rollup2
DATA WOULD ENABLE THE STATE TO
03:10:20.976 --> 03:10:26.148 region:rollup2
MONITOR OVERALL PROGRESS OR LACK
03:10:23.913 --> 03:10:27.916 region:rollup2
THEREOF. TOWARD ACHIEVING PAY
03:10:26.148 --> 03:10:30.286 region:rollup2
EQUITY AND IT TALKED ABOUT THE
03:10:27.916 --> 03:10:32.521 region:rollup2
OBAMA ADMINISTRATION USING
03:10:30.286 --> 03:10:33.355 region:rollup2
AGGREGATE DATA. BUT IT'S UNCLEAR
03:10:32.521 --> 03:10:36.358 region:rollup2
TO US.
03:10:33.355 --> 03:10:37.760 region:rollup2
UNDER THE AMENDMENTS THAT ARE
03:10:36.358 --> 03:10:40.362 region:rollup2
BEING DISCUSSED IF THIS IS
03:10:37.760 --> 03:10:42.765 region:rollup2
SPECIFIC INFORMATION GIVING DE
03:10:40.362 --> 03:10:44.733 region:rollup2
L. AT SEA SPECIFIC AUTHORITY TO
03:10:42.765 --> 03:10:46.902 region:rollup2
RETURN AN ENFORCEMENT ACTION
03:10:44.733 --> 03:10:49.805 region:rollup2
AGAINST AN EMPLOYER. OBVIOUSLY
03:10:46.902 --> 03:10:51.874 region:rollup2
WE ARE MORE INTERESTED IN THE
03:10:49.805 --> 03:10:53.642 region:rollup2
OBAMA OUT WHAT WE THINK IS THE
03:10:51.874 --> 03:10:55.177 region:rollup2
OBAMA APPROACH.
03:10:53.642 --> 03:10:57.646 region:rollup2
YEAH WHICH WAS AGGREGATE AND
03:10:55.177 --> 03:11:00.349 region:rollup2
CONFIDENTIAL.
03:10:57.646 --> 03:11:02.351 region:rollup2
AND WHAT LOOKS LIKE I MORE
03:11:00.349 --> 03:11:04.720 region:rollup2
ENFORCEMENT ORIENTED APPROACH
03:11:02.351 --> 03:11:07.056 region:rollup2
HERE BUT OUR EMPLOYERS ARE
03:11:04.720 --> 03:11:08.657 region:rollup2
WORKING HARD ON THE SELF AUDITS
03:11:07.056 --> 03:11:10.526 region:rollup2
WE WOULD LIKE TO ADD GET AN
03:11:08.657 --> 03:11:11.794 region:rollup2
ANSWER TO OUR QUESTION AND WE
03:11:10.526 --> 03:11:12.995 region:rollup2
WILL KEEP WORKING WITH SENATOR
03:11:11.794 --> 03:11:14.463 region:rollup2
JACKSON BECAUSE WE ALL BELIEVE
03:11:12.995 --> 03:11:15.965 region:rollup2
IN PAY EQUITY.
03:11:14.463 --> 03:11:18.534 region:rollup2
THANK YOU ARE THERE ANY OTHER
03:11:15.965 --> 03:11:19.435 region:rollup2
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
03:11:18.534 --> 03:11:23.972 region:rollup2
THE BOOK AND PLEASE FEEL FREE TO
03:11:19.435 --> 03:11:25.040 region:rollup2
USE THE MICROPHONE.
03:11:23.972 --> 03:11:25.874 region:rollup2
MEMBERS TRUST ABOUT THE ABOUT
03:11:25.040 --> 03:11:28.978 region:rollup2
THE PERSONAL INSURANCE
03:11:25.874 --> 03:11:30.412 region:rollup2
FEDERATION OPPOSITION.
03:11:28.978 --> 03:11:31.580 region:rollup2
KEVIN ANDERSON ON BEHALF OF THE
03:11:30.412 --> 03:11:36.318 region:rollup2
RETAIL INDUSTRY LEADERS
03:11:31.580 --> 03:11:37.653 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION.
03:11:36.318 --> 03:11:39.188 region:rollup2
BRIAN LITTLE CALIFORNIA FARM
03:11:37.653 --> 03:11:41.390 region:rollup2
BUREAU FEDERATION OPPOSITION FOR
03:11:39.188 --> 03:11:41.957 region:rollup2
THE REASONS ARTICULATED
03:11:41.390 --> 03:11:45.761 region:rollup2
PREVIOUSLY BY MY COLLEAGUES
03:11:41.957 --> 03:11:47.196 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
03:11:45.761 --> 03:11:49.098 region:rollup2
AND THE CALL RISE CALIFORNIA
03:11:47.196 --> 03:11:53.869 region:rollup2
MANUFACTURES AND TECHNOLOGY
03:11:49.098 --> 03:11:55.170 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION ALSO HAS.
03:11:53.869 --> 03:11:56.071 region:rollup2
JOHN LEWIS OF THE NATIONAL
03:11:55.170 --> 03:11:57.206 region:rollup2
FEDERATION OF INDEPENDENT
03:11:56.071 --> 03:11:58.507 region:rollup2
BUSINESS REPRESENTING OVER
03:11:57.206 --> 03:11:59.074 region:rollup2
TWENTY THOUSAND SMALL BUSINESS
03:11:58.507 --> 03:12:02.745 region:rollup2
OWNERS ACROSS THE STATE ALSO
03:11:59.074 --> 03:12:04.013 region:rollup2
POST.
03:12:02.745 --> 03:12:04.947 region:rollup2
WHEN KATIE HANSON CALIFORNIA
03:12:04.013 --> 03:12:07.082 region:rollup2
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION WERE HERE
03:12:04.947 --> 03:12:08.217 region:rollup2
IN OPPOSITION.
03:12:07.082 --> 03:12:10.052 region:rollup2
THANK YOU DO I HAVE ANY
03:12:08.217 --> 03:12:11.320 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS FOR MY COLLEAGUES WILL
03:12:10.052 --> 03:12:12.688 region:rollup2
START WITH SENATOR WIECKOWSKI.
03:12:11.320 --> 03:12:14.256 region:rollup2
MISTER CHAIR CAN WE GET A
03:12:12.688 --> 03:12:16.492 region:rollup2
CLARIFICATION OF THE A BOMB
03:12:14.256 --> 03:12:17.960 region:rollup2
APPROACH IN THE JACKSON APPROACH
03:12:16.492 --> 03:12:19.428 region:rollup2
IF THERE'S A DISTINCTION TO BE
03:12:17.960 --> 03:12:20.429 region:rollup2
MADE. THERE REALLY ISN'T A
03:12:19.428 --> 03:12:22.498 region:rollup2
DISTINCTION.
03:12:20.429 --> 03:12:24.666 region:rollup2
AND WHAT WE'VE DONE IS FEES
03:12:22.498 --> 03:12:27.870 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS BRING IT. JUST ABOUT
03:12:24.666 --> 03:12:29.605 region:rollup2
IN LINE OF TO THE EXTENT THAT.
03:12:27.870 --> 03:12:31.240 region:rollup2
ONE DEALS WITH THE FEDERAL WE
03:12:29.605 --> 03:12:32.341 region:rollup2
DEAL WITH THE STATE SO WE LOOK
03:12:31.240 --> 03:12:34.176 region:rollup2
TO THE DEPARTMENT OF FAIR
03:12:32.341 --> 03:12:35.878 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT HOUSING DEPARTMENT OF
03:12:34.176 --> 03:12:38.680 region:rollup2
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS.
03:12:35.878 --> 03:12:40.382 region:rollup2
WE HAVE A ADDRESS THE THE ISSUE
03:12:38.680 --> 03:12:42.885 region:rollup2
IT IS AGGREGATE WHICH MEANS IT'S
03:12:40.382 --> 03:12:45.320 region:rollup2
NONSPECIFIC ANONYMOUS IF YOU
03:12:42.885 --> 03:12:47.456 region:rollup2
WILL IN BIG BANDS.
03:12:45.320 --> 03:12:49.358 region:rollup2
SO THAT IF THERE ARE
03:12:47.456 --> 03:12:50.692 region:rollup2
DIFFERENCES FOR REASONS THAT ARE
03:12:49.358 --> 03:12:52.561 region:rollup2
CLEARLY.
03:12:50.692 --> 03:12:55.364 region:rollup2
ACCEPTABLE THAT THERE'S AN
03:12:52.561 --> 03:12:57.099 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY TO IDENTIFY.
03:12:55.364 --> 03:12:58.133 region:rollup2
YOU HAVE SOMEONE IS WORK FOR
03:12:57.099 --> 03:13:00.035 region:rollup2
COMPANY THIRTY YEARS LET'S SAY
03:12:58.133 --> 03:13:01.403 region:rollup2
NINETY PERCENT HAVE BEEN THERE
03:13:00.035 --> 03:13:02.971 region:rollup2
FOR THIRTY YEARS AND THAT'S THE
03:13:01.403 --> 03:13:04.506 region:rollup2
REASON THAT THE THE PAY OF A PAY
03:13:02.971 --> 03:13:07.943 region:rollup2
DIFFERENTIAL.
03:13:04.506 --> 03:13:10.379 region:rollup2
THAT AGAIN IS SO.
03:13:07.943 --> 03:13:11.647 region:rollup2
AND ATTEMPTED TO CREATE A SORT
03:13:10.379 --> 03:13:12.848 region:rollup2
OF THAT GENERAL.
03:13:11.647 --> 03:13:15.050 region:rollup2
.
03:13:12.848 --> 03:13:16.985 region:rollup2
TOP DOWN VIEW IF YOU WILL THE
03:13:15.050 --> 03:13:18.454 region:rollup2
THIRTY THOUSAND FOOT VIEW AND TO
03:13:16.985 --> 03:13:20.923 region:rollup2
MAKE IT CONFIDENTIAL.
03:13:18.454 --> 03:13:22.291 region:rollup2
WE HAVE ALSO REMOVED.
03:13:20.923 --> 03:13:25.494 region:rollup2
SECRETARY STATE.
03:13:22.291 --> 03:13:28.430 region:rollup2
NOW THIS IS GOING ON A WEBSITE.
03:13:25.494 --> 03:13:31.700 region:rollup2
SO WE ARE PARALLELING I THINK.
03:13:28.430 --> 03:13:33.302 region:rollup2
AND. THE PRETTY MUCH.
03:13:31.700 --> 03:13:34.937 region:rollup2
IN SPIRIT AS WELL AS HE AND.
03:13:33.302 --> 03:13:35.504 region:rollup2
DESIGN.
03:13:34.937 --> 03:13:38.607 region:rollup2
WITH THE.
03:13:35.504 --> 03:13:40.442 region:rollup2
WITH THE OBAMA EFFORT. WILL
03:13:38.607 --> 03:13:41.543 region:rollup2
THAT'S BASICALLY THIS IT TAKES
03:13:40.442 --> 03:13:43.779 region:rollup2
THAT AND OVERLAYS WITH
03:13:41.543 --> 03:13:45.881 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA DATA HARMONIZATION
03:13:43.779 --> 03:13:46.381 region:rollup2
NAM PREPARE TO MOVE THE BILL.
03:13:45.881 --> 03:13:48.584 region:rollup2
WE HAVE A MOTION SENATOR
03:13:46.381 --> 03:13:49.651 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG.
03:13:48.584 --> 03:13:50.385 region:rollup2
YEAH YOU KNOW THAT THAT THE
03:13:49.651 --> 03:13:52.221 region:rollup2
THING IN THE OTHER NIGHT
03:13:50.385 --> 03:13:53.088 region:rollup2
ADDITION SEE FOR THE SALES FORCE
03:13:52.221 --> 03:13:55.324 region:rollup2
HOUSE UP PIECE OF AT NIGHT
03:13:53.088 --> 03:13:57.326 region:rollup2
INCIDENT BASING THE PROMISE WAS
03:13:55.324 --> 03:13:59.361 region:rollup2
NOT HEARTLESS BUT.
03:13:57.326 --> 03:14:00.896 region:rollup2
THAT WAS HIS MIKE MARC BENIOFF
03:13:59.361 --> 03:14:01.663 region:rollup2
WAS IN THE GENTLEMAN'S CEO HE
03:14:00.896 --> 03:14:02.598 region:rollup2
DIDN'T VEN KNOW WE HAD THE
03:14:01.663 --> 03:14:03.198 region:rollup2
PROBLEMS RIGHT THE WORD SO I
03:14:02.598 --> 03:14:03.799 region:rollup2
THINK WHAT'S HAPPENED IS TWO
03:14:03.198 --> 03:14:05.634 region:rollup2
SIDES THIS IS THE GOVERNMENT
03:14:03.799 --> 03:14:06.535 region:rollup2
SIDE AND THEN THERE'S ALSO THE
03:14:05.634 --> 03:14:07.069 region:rollup2
PRIVATE SIDE.
03:14:06.535 --> 03:14:09.037 region:rollup2
WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN WITH
03:14:07.069 --> 03:14:11.006 region:rollup2
COMPANIES WHEN THEY'RE REQUIRED
03:14:09.037 --> 03:14:11.907 region:rollup2
TO DO THIS DIAGNOSTIC WHICH DID.
03:14:11.006 --> 03:14:12.674 region:rollup2
NOT DOING BECAUSE THEY'RE
03:14:11.907 --> 03:14:14.209 region:rollup2
INVOLVED THIS STUFF THEY'RE
03:14:12.674 --> 03:14:15.611 region:rollup2
GONNA REALIZE PATTERNS AND
03:14:14.209 --> 03:14:17.846 region:rollup2
YOU'RE GONNA SEE SELF HELP.
03:14:15.611 --> 03:14:18.780 region:rollup2
I THINK IN THE PROCESS JUST
03:14:17.846 --> 03:14:19.381 region:rollup2
BECAUSE YOU'RE THE ONLY GUY THAT
03:14:18.780 --> 03:14:21.116 region:rollup2
I DIDN'T REALIZE IT HAD THESE
03:14:19.381 --> 03:14:21.984 region:rollup2
PATTERNS IN THIS PROCESS AND
03:14:21.116 --> 03:14:23.285 region:rollup2
THEY'RE GONNA KNOW WHAT ARE SOME
03:14:21.984 --> 03:14:24.920 region:rollup2
WAS THERE FOR TWO MONTHS OR
03:14:23.285 --> 03:14:26.388 region:rollup2
TWENTY YEAR IT'S WHATEVER. AND
03:14:24.920 --> 03:14:28.023 region:rollup2
SO WHAT IT DOES IT DID FORCES
03:14:26.388 --> 03:14:29.825 region:rollup2
THAT DIAGNOSTICS OF THAT REASON
03:14:28.023 --> 03:14:32.194 region:rollup2
THESE GOOD IDEA. AND THAT'S PART
03:14:29.825 --> 03:14:33.428 region:rollup2
OF THAT IF WE CAN GET COMPANIES
03:14:32.194 --> 03:14:34.496 region:rollup2
TO LOOK IN THE MIRROR THAT'S
03:14:33.428 --> 03:14:36.031 region:rollup2
RIGHT GOAL LOOK IN THE MIRROR
03:14:34.496 --> 03:14:38.133 region:rollup2
SEE WHAT YOU'RE DOING. WHEN YOU
03:14:36.031 --> 03:14:39.635 region:rollup2
DO WHEN IT ONE OF THE STATISTICS
03:14:38.133 --> 03:14:41.236 region:rollup2
THAT IS STAGGERING TO ME ON
03:14:39.635 --> 03:14:44.506 region:rollup2
PEOPLE PAY. YOU KNOW THE NURSING
03:14:41.236 --> 03:14:45.774 region:rollup2
PROFESSION IS NINETY NINETY FIVE
03:14:44.506 --> 03:14:46.975 region:rollup2
PERCENT FEMALE.
03:14:45.774 --> 03:14:47.543 region:rollup2
AND YET IN THE STUDY THAT WOULD
03:14:46.975 --> 03:14:48.176 region:rollup2
COME OUT IN THE NEW ENGLAND
03:14:47.543 --> 03:14:49.845 region:rollup2
JOURNAL OF MEDICINE IN TWENTY
03:14:48.176 --> 03:14:51.446 region:rollup2
FOURTEEN. TO TWENTY FIFTEEN.
03:14:49.845 --> 03:14:53.615 region:rollup2
.
03:14:51.446 --> 03:14:55.417 region:rollup2
MALE NURSES ARE PAID ON AVERAGE
03:14:53.615 --> 03:14:58.320 region:rollup2
FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS MORE PER
03:14:55.417 --> 03:14:59.521 region:rollup2
MONTH THAN FEMALE NURSES.
03:14:58.320 --> 03:15:01.356 region:rollup2
I'M ME WHO KNOW WHAT I THE
03:14:59.521 --> 03:15:02.891 region:rollup2
CHURCH SHOPPING AND SO THE HOPE
03:15:01.356 --> 03:15:03.458 region:rollup2
IS THAT IF A HOSPITAL FINDS
03:15:02.891 --> 03:15:05.294 region:rollup2
ITSELF IN THAT CIRCUMSTANCE
03:15:03.458 --> 03:15:06.995 region:rollup2
THAT.
03:15:05.294 --> 03:15:08.597 region:rollup2
THEY ASK THEMSELVES WHY WE WHY
03:15:06.995 --> 03:15:11.400 region:rollup2
IT WHY IS THAT AND.
03:15:08.597 --> 03:15:12.634 region:rollup2
THAT IS SOME IMPLICIT BIAS THAT
03:15:11.400 --> 03:15:14.469 region:rollup2
THEN THESE ARE THINGS THAT WE
03:15:12.634 --> 03:15:17.005 region:rollup2
JUST HAVE TO AGAIN LOOK IN THE
03:15:14.469 --> 03:15:18.640 region:rollup2
MIRROR AND REALIZE. THAT WE ALL
03:15:17.005 --> 03:15:20.175 region:rollup2
HAVE THE BIASES.
03:15:18.640 --> 03:15:22.611 region:rollup2
I AND I DON'T THINK THEY'RE
03:15:20.175 --> 03:15:24.246 region:rollup2
NECESSARILY INTENTIONAL OR
03:15:22.611 --> 03:15:26.815 region:rollup2
VICIOUS BUT I THINK THAT THEY
03:15:24.246 --> 03:15:28.016 region:rollup2
HAVE REALLY IMPROVED IMPEDED
03:15:26.815 --> 03:15:29.585 region:rollup2
WOMEN'S ABILITY TO.
03:15:28.016 --> 03:15:30.852 region:rollup2
PD COOLEY IN THE WORKPLACE AND
03:15:29.585 --> 03:15:32.854 region:rollup2
TO BE PAID FAIRLY AND THAT'S THE
03:15:30.852 --> 03:15:34.022 region:rollup2
REASON FOR THIS BILL.
03:15:32.854 --> 03:15:36.391 region:rollup2
WAS THAT YOUR AND THAT WAS MY
03:15:34.022 --> 03:15:38.460 region:rollup2
CLOSE GREAT THEN ONE OF THE.
03:15:36.391 --> 03:15:40.963 region:rollup2
WE HAVE A MOTION NO MORE NO FOR
03:15:38.460 --> 03:15:42.764 region:rollup2
THE QUICK.
03:15:40.963 --> 03:15:43.966 region:rollup2
ASIA*. GOING TO PROPOSE
03:15:42.764 --> 03:15:44.900 region:rollup2
INSTEAD OF LADY LIBERTY HIGH
03:15:43.966 --> 03:15:47.035 region:rollup2
NOTE CENTER JACKSON LIKES TO
03:15:44.900 --> 03:15:49.037 region:rollup2
QUOTE LADY EQUALITY MAY BE
03:15:47.035 --> 03:15:50.739 region:rollup2
BETTER TITLE FOR YOU APPRECIATE
03:15:49.037 --> 03:15:51.540 region:rollup2
BRINGING THIS FORWARD HOPEFULLY
03:15:50.739 --> 03:15:52.908 region:rollup2
GET THIS THING.
03:15:51.540 --> 03:15:55.277 region:rollup2
THROUGH THIS YEAR BUT. THIS
03:15:52.908 --> 03:15:56.678 region:rollup2
QUESTION ABOUT.
03:15:55.277 --> 03:15:59.381 region:rollup2
THE ACTUAL WHAT LIKE WHAT
03:15:56.678 --> 03:16:00.749 region:rollup2
TRIGGERS THE THE LIABILITY HERE
03:15:59.381 --> 03:16:02.251 region:rollup2
AND THE THIS OF STANGEL A
03:16:00.749 --> 03:16:04.920 region:rollup2
SIMILAR POSITIONS THAT WON'T BE
03:16:02.251 --> 03:16:06.588 region:rollup2
IN THE REPORT ITSELF
03:16:04.920 --> 03:16:08.590 region:rollup2
THAT'S NOT WHAT WOULD TRIGGER.
03:16:06.588 --> 03:16:10.359 region:rollup2
WHO A VIOLATION THAT WOULD SORT
03:16:08.590 --> 03:16:11.460 region:rollup2
OF THE AGGREGATE DATA IS WHAT
03:16:10.359 --> 03:16:12.961 region:rollup2
WOULDWOULD TREAT A VIOLATION OF
03:16:11.460 --> 03:16:14.463 region:rollup2
THE FAILURE TO ACCURATELY REPORT
03:16:12.961 --> 03:16:16.331 region:rollup2
THE AGGREGATE DATA AND THAT
03:16:14.463 --> 03:16:17.599 region:rollup2
WOULD TRIGGER THE VIOLATION? BUT
03:16:16.331 --> 03:16:19.968 region:rollup2
THEN THEY'D HAVE TO DRILL DOWN
03:16:17.599 --> 03:16:21.169 region:rollup2
DEEPER TO FIGURE OUT THIS IS TO
03:16:19.968 --> 03:16:23.672 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR.
03:16:21.169 --> 03:16:24.706 region:rollup2
POSITIONS IN A LEGAL PROCEEDING
03:16:23.672 --> 03:16:26.208 region:rollup2
I JUST WALK ME THROUGH IT
03:16:24.706 --> 03:16:27.743 region:rollup2
BECAUSE I'M SURE I'M CONFUSED
03:16:26.208 --> 03:16:28.944 region:rollup2
BUT I JUST DID. THE CHAMBERS
03:16:27.743 --> 03:16:30.879 region:rollup2
CONCERNS ABOUT THOSE SORT OF
03:16:28.944 --> 03:16:33.949 region:rollup2
SIMILAR LEAST.
03:16:30.879 --> 03:16:35.851 region:rollup2
TITLE SAME SAME BUT EXPERIENCE.
03:16:33.949 --> 03:16:36.852 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW EDUCATION THOSE KINDS
03:16:35.851 --> 03:16:38.287 region:rollup2
OF THINGS DIFFERING SO HOW DOES
03:16:36.852 --> 03:16:40.055 region:rollup2
THAT WORK SOURCE OF THE DATA
03:16:38.287 --> 03:16:41.790 region:rollup2
WOULDN'T TRIGGER A VIOLATION OF
03:16:40.055 --> 03:16:42.924 region:rollup2
ANYTHING THAT THE DATA YOU KNOW
03:16:41.790 --> 03:16:44.760 region:rollup2
UNDER THE FAIR PLAY ACT IF YOU A
03:16:42.924 --> 03:16:46.028 region:rollup2
MAN AND A WOMAN AND.
03:16:44.760 --> 03:16:46.895 region:rollup2
LET'S A WOMAN'S EARNING LESS FOR
03:16:46.028 --> 03:16:48.096 region:rollup2
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR WORK AND
03:16:46.895 --> 03:16:49.698 region:rollup2
THERE'S NO BONA FIDE
03:16:48.096 --> 03:16:51.533 region:rollup2
JUSTIFICATION BONAFIDE FACTOR TO
03:16:49.698 --> 03:16:52.868 region:rollup2
JUSTIFY RECEIVING LESS PAY FOR
03:16:51.533 --> 03:16:54.603 region:rollup2
EQUAL WORK THAT COULD BE A
03:16:52.868 --> 03:16:56.104 region:rollup2
VIOLATION OF THE ACT. THIS
03:16:54.603 --> 03:16:57.506 region:rollup2
AGGREGATE DATA IS AN INDIVIDUAL
03:16:56.104 --> 03:16:59.341 region:rollup2
BY EMPLOYEES SO WHAT IT DOES IS
03:16:57.506 --> 03:17:00.742 region:rollup2
IT SHOWS HOW MANY EMPLOYEES ARE
03:16:59.341 --> 03:17:01.843 region:rollup2
IN EACH OF THESE BODIES SEVERAL
03:17:00.742 --> 03:17:03.512 region:rollup2
JOB CATEGORIES.
03:17:01.843 --> 03:17:05.113 region:rollup2
AND THEN THAT'S BROKEN DOWN BY
03:17:03.512 --> 03:17:06.815 region:rollup2
RACE GENDER ETHNICITY AND HOW
03:17:05.113 --> 03:17:08.183 region:rollup2
MANY EMPLOYEES ARE IN A SEVERAL
03:17:06.815 --> 03:17:10.485 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT KINDS OF PAY BANDS OR
03:17:08.183 --> 03:17:11.753 region:rollup2
PAY RANGES BROKEN DOWN BY SEX
03:17:10.485 --> 03:17:13.855 region:rollup2
RACE AND ETHNICITY SUCH
03:17:11.753 --> 03:17:14.489 region:rollup2
AGGREGATE IT'S NOT INDIVIDUAL.
03:17:13.855 --> 03:17:16.425 region:rollup2
AND REALLY WHAT IT IS INTENDED
03:17:14.489 --> 03:17:18.260 region:rollup2
TO DO IT'S PROMPTED EMPLOYER TO
03:17:16.425 --> 03:17:20.095 region:rollup2
SAY HEY AS I'M CENTER HERTZBERG
03:17:18.260 --> 03:17:21.697 region:rollup2
MENTION EMPLOYERS ARE OFTEN
03:17:20.095 --> 03:17:22.964 region:rollup2
AREN'T EVEN AWARE THAT THERE
03:17:21.697 --> 03:17:24.599 region:rollup2
MEET MAYBE THESE FIVE FOCUSED A
03:17:22.964 --> 03:17:26.902 region:rollup2
KIND OF CONCENTRATION OF WOMEN
03:17:24.599 --> 03:17:28.136 region:rollup2
OR MINORITIES. IN LOWER PAID UP
03:17:26.902 --> 03:17:29.838 region:rollup2
POSITIONS OR LOWER PAID YOU KNOW
03:17:28.136 --> 03:17:31.239 region:rollup2
PAY BANDS OUGHT TO LOOK A LITTLE
03:17:29.838 --> 03:17:32.607 region:rollup2
DEEPER AND SAY HEY SHOULD WE
03:17:31.239 --> 03:17:34.343 region:rollup2
CHANGE OUR HIRING AND PROMOTION
03:17:32.607 --> 03:17:36.211 region:rollup2
OF POLICIES TO TRY TO GET BETTER
03:17:34.343 --> 03:17:37.279 region:rollup2
REPRESENTATION ACROSS THE BOARD.
03:17:36.211 --> 03:17:39.681 region:rollup2
AND THEN IF WITHIN A CERTAIN JOB
03:17:37.279 --> 03:17:41.616 region:rollup2
CATEGORY THE SEED DISPARITIES ON
03:17:39.681 --> 03:17:42.184 region:rollup2
THIS AGGREGATE BASIS IT'S A
03:17:41.616 --> 03:17:43.352 region:rollup2
TRIGGER THEM TO LOOK A BIT
03:17:42.184 --> 03:17:44.519 region:rollup2
DEEPER AND SAY. IS THIS
03:17:43.352 --> 03:17:46.722 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THAT AT AN INDIVIDUAL
03:17:44.519 --> 03:17:48.390 region:rollup2
LEVEL WE AS EMPLOYERS DETERMINE
03:17:46.722 --> 03:17:49.591 region:rollup2
THAT MAY BE AN INDIVIDUAL.
03:17:48.390 --> 03:17:51.126 region:rollup2
DIFFERENCE OUT THE NEEDS WE
03:17:49.591 --> 03:17:52.494 region:rollup2
RECTIFY THAT IS NOT JUSTIFIED
03:17:51.126 --> 03:17:54.429 region:rollup2
BUT THE MOVE DATA GOING TO THE
03:17:52.494 --> 03:17:56.198 region:rollup2
AGENCY WOULD BE THIS AGGREGATE
03:17:54.429 --> 03:17:57.532 region:rollup2
DATA NOT AND ANYTHING THAT WOULD
03:17:56.198 --> 03:17:59.534 region:rollup2
TRIGGER A VIOLATION OF THE ACT
03:17:57.532 --> 03:18:01.069 region:rollup2
THAT DATA WON'T INCLUDE EXPIRY
03:17:59.534 --> 03:18:02.337 region:rollup2
THAT YEARS OF EXPERIENCE HOW
03:18:01.069 --> 03:18:03.372 region:rollup2
MANY YEARS YOU'VE WORKED THERE
03:18:02.337 --> 03:18:05.440 region:rollup2
THINGS LIKE. THAT NOW BECAUSE
03:18:03.372 --> 03:18:07.042 region:rollup2
IT'S BY GROUP IT WOULD BE BY
03:18:05.440 --> 03:18:09.344 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES BY JOB
03:18:07.042 --> 03:18:12.514 region:rollup2
CATEGORY BY PAY BAND AND EACH OF
03:18:09.344 --> 03:18:13.348 region:rollup2
THOSE BROKEN DOWN BY RACE GENDER
03:18:12.514 --> 03:18:14.716 region:rollup2
ETHNICITY.
03:18:13.348 --> 03:18:15.217 region:rollup2
SO FOR SO AS A PRACTICAL MATTER
03:18:14.716 --> 03:18:16.218 region:rollup2
LET'S SAY THE STARTED.
03:18:15.217 --> 03:18:18.420 region:rollup2
IT NEXT YEAR
03:18:16.218 --> 03:18:19.888 region:rollup2
AND COMPANIES STARTED DOING THIS
03:18:18.420 --> 03:18:21.723 region:rollup2
AND THAT THE INFORMATION HAS TO
03:18:19.888 --> 03:18:23.525 region:rollup2
BE REPORTED TO LET'S IDEA FEE
03:18:21.723 --> 03:18:25.994 region:rollup2
AGE. AND OVER THE COURSE OF FIVE
03:18:23.525 --> 03:18:28.563 region:rollup2
YEARS YOU START SEEING THE THE
03:18:25.994 --> 03:18:31.032 region:rollup2
THE THE. A CONSTITUTION OF THE
03:18:28.563 --> 03:18:32.467 region:rollup2
HIGHER LEVEL PEOPLE ARE GOING UP
03:18:31.032 --> 03:18:34.002 region:rollup2
MORE WOMEN MORE MINORITIES
03:18:32.467 --> 03:18:35.437 region:rollup2
YOU SEE A TREND WHERE THEY'RE
03:18:34.002 --> 03:18:37.906 region:rollup2
MAKING IMPROVEMENTS ON THEIR
03:18:35.437 --> 03:18:39.975 region:rollup2
EXISTING SYSTEM. IF THERE'S A IF
03:18:37.906 --> 03:18:41.543 region:rollup2
IT'S GOING DOWN FOR EXAMPLE AT
03:18:39.975 --> 03:18:42.611 region:rollup2
THE END OF THREE FOUR FIVE YEARS
03:18:41.543 --> 03:18:44.446 region:rollup2
DEPARTMENT OF FAIR EMPLOYMENT
03:18:42.611 --> 03:18:45.447 region:rollup2
HOUSING WOULD HAVE THE ABILITY
03:18:44.446 --> 03:18:47.382 region:rollup2
TO GOAL NGUYEN AND TO
03:18:45.447 --> 03:18:49.618 region:rollup2
INVESTIGATE WIERD THINGS GETTING
03:18:47.382 --> 03:18:50.786 region:rollup2
WORSE. RATHER THAN BETTER SO IT
03:18:49.618 --> 03:18:53.655 region:rollup2
DOESN'T TRIGGER ANY KIND
03:18:50.786 --> 03:18:55.624 region:rollup2
LITIGATION WHAT IT DOES IS IT IT
03:18:53.655 --> 03:18:58.426 region:rollup2
IT WILL PROVIDE INFORMATION ON
03:18:55.624 --> 03:19:01.096 region:rollup2
SORT OF ALL. A BROAD SCALE OF
03:18:58.426 --> 03:19:03.598 region:rollup2
HOW COMPANIES ARE PERFORMING
03:19:01.096 --> 03:19:05.867 region:rollup2
WITH RESPECT TO THE ISSUE OF
03:19:03.598 --> 03:19:07.068 region:rollup2
DISPARITY.
03:19:05.867 --> 03:19:07.736 region:rollup2
THAT'S BASICALLY IT ONE OF
03:19:07.068 --> 03:19:09.004 region:rollup2
THINGS CHAIRMAN JUST VERY
03:19:07.736 --> 03:19:10.572 region:rollup2
QUICKLY BECAUSE I I LOVE THIS
03:19:09.004 --> 03:19:12.274 region:rollup2
KIND OF STUFF BECAUSE WHAT
03:19:10.572 --> 03:19:13.675 region:rollup2
HAPPENS IS IT HAS A SHORT AND
03:19:12.274 --> 03:19:15.443 region:rollup2
NARROWLY BROUGHT AFFECT.
03:19:13.675 --> 03:19:17.045 region:rollup2
THE LEAST AMOUNT OF ENERGY
03:19:15.443 --> 03:19:19.481 region:rollup2
INFORMING PEOPLE THE ABILITY TO
03:19:17.045 --> 03:19:20.882 region:rollup2
SELF CORRECT WITHOUT HAVING A
03:19:19.481 --> 03:19:21.516 region:rollup2
BIG GOVERNMENT PROGRAM I KNOW WE
03:19:20.882 --> 03:19:23.618 region:rollup2
HAD THOSE DISCUSSIONS YESTERDAY
03:19:21.516 --> 03:19:24.553 region:rollup2
TIME TO DO SOME AND YOU GET THE
03:19:23.618 --> 03:19:25.854 region:rollup2
RESULT THAT WE'RE TRYING TO
03:19:24.553 --> 03:19:27.322 region:rollup2
ACHIEVE FROM A GOVERNMENTAL
03:19:25.854 --> 03:19:29.157 region:rollup2
PUBLIC POLICY PERSPECTIVE I
03:19:27.322 --> 03:19:30.659 region:rollup2
THINK ABOUT THIS LOTS A. TIMES
03:19:29.157 --> 03:19:31.893 region:rollup2
IN TERMS OF CONSTRUCT OF LAWS
03:19:30.659 --> 03:19:33.428 region:rollup2
HOW DO YOU GET THE MOST AMOUNT
03:19:31.893 --> 03:19:35.964 region:rollup2
OF LEVERAGE FOR THE OUTCOME YOU
03:19:33.428 --> 03:19:37.999 region:rollup2
WANT. FOR THE LEAST AMOUNT TO
03:19:35.964 --> 03:19:40.535 region:rollup2
COST THE LEAST AMOUNT OF.
03:19:37.999 --> 03:19:42.237 region:rollup2
IT MISTAKES OR OVER REACHING OR
03:19:40.535 --> 03:19:43.939 region:rollup2
WHATEVER ELSE THE CASE MAY BE
03:19:42.237 --> 03:19:45.774 region:rollup2
THIS IS A PERFECT EXAMPLE IN MY
03:19:43.939 --> 03:19:48.343 region:rollup2
JUDGMENT. OF HOW TO ACCOMPLISH
03:19:45.774 --> 03:19:49.511 region:rollup2
THAT NIGHT THANK YOU AND IF IT
03:19:48.343 --> 03:19:51.313 region:rollup2
WAS RD MOVE IT MOVE IT AGAIN.
03:19:49.511 --> 03:19:53.048 region:rollup2
I WOULD JUST ADD THE VOC ADOPTED
03:19:51.313 --> 03:19:54.549 region:rollup2
THIS E. O. ONE REVISED FORM ON
03:19:53.048 --> 03:19:56.051 region:rollup2
WHICH THIS BILL IS BASED AFTER A
03:19:54.549 --> 03:19:58.119 region:rollup2
VERY THOROUGH INVESTIGATION
03:19:56.051 --> 03:20:00.322 region:rollup2
FOCUSED ON BURDEN ON EMPLOYER.
03:19:58.119 --> 03:20:02.057 region:rollup2
CONFIDENTIALITY AND UTILITY OF
03:20:00.322 --> 03:20:03.825 region:rollup2
DATA AND CONCLUDED AFTER THIS
03:20:02.057 --> 03:20:05.126 region:rollup2
VERY RIGOROUS PROCESS THAT WOULD
03:20:03.825 --> 03:20:06.361 region:rollup2
NOT IMPOSE IT WOULD NONE UNDUE
03:20:05.126 --> 03:20:08.063 region:rollup2
BURDEN ON EMPLOYERS WILL BE A
03:20:06.361 --> 03:20:09.464 region:rollup2
MINIMAL COST AND BENEFICIAL FOR
03:20:08.063 --> 03:20:11.633 region:rollup2
THE REASONS WE TALKED ABOUT.
03:20:09.464 --> 03:20:13.168 region:rollup2
SO IF WE REALLY NEEDED TO HAVE
03:20:11.633 --> 03:20:15.804 region:rollup2
TO HIRE DRIVE VOTE. BUT HAVE TO
03:20:13.168 --> 03:20:17.005 region:rollup2
MOTIONS TO US SUPPORT AND I I
03:20:15.804 --> 03:20:19.908 region:rollup2
HAVE NOT HEARD FROM SENATOR
03:20:17.005 --> 03:20:22.310 region:rollup2
MINING SO PLEASE.
03:20:19.908 --> 03:20:22.878 region:rollup2
A HOMEMADE. MARKET AT THREE
03:20:22.310 --> 03:20:24.412 region:rollup2
MOTION.
03:20:22.878 --> 03:20:25.547 region:rollup2
EVEN
03:20:24.412 --> 03:20:27.015 region:rollup2
THUNDERSTONE WOULD YOU LIKE FOR
03:20:25.547 --> 03:20:29.084 region:rollup2
A CASE OF WORLD GOOD AND WE GOT
03:20:27.015 --> 03:20:30.185 region:rollup2
A CLOSE A MADAM CLERK WENCH TAKE
03:20:29.084 --> 03:20:30.752 region:rollup2
THE ROLE.
03:20:30.185 --> 03:20:31.820 region:rollup2
THE MOTION IS DEEP PASSES
03:20:30.752 --> 03:20:34.289 region:rollup2
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
03:20:31.820 --> 03:20:36.791 region:rollup2
JACKSON HIGH JACKSON AYE MORE
03:20:34.289 --> 03:20:37.292 region:rollup2
LOCK. MORE LIKE NO ANDERSON.
03:20:36.791 --> 03:20:39.661 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG I AM
03:20:37.292 --> 03:20:41.396 region:rollup2
MONNING.
03:20:39.661 --> 03:20:43.698 region:rollup2
MONNING AYE STERN.
03:20:41.396 --> 03:20:45.767 region:rollup2
STERN AYE WIECKOWSKI. WIECKOWSKI
03:20:43.698 --> 03:20:47.602 region:rollup2
AYE. FOR FIVE ONE.
03:20:45.767 --> 03:20:49.170 region:rollup2
THEN WILL HOLD OPEN THE ROLE
03:20:47.602 --> 03:20:50.505 region:rollup2
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR NOW HAVE
03:20:49.170 --> 03:20:52.207 region:rollup2
SHARED S. B. THIRTEEN HUNDRED
03:20:50.505 --> 03:20:52.807 region:rollup2
VERY GOOD.
03:20:52.207 --> 03:20:53.942 region:rollup2
FIGHT THE LAST BILL OF THE DAY
03:20:52.807 --> 03:20:57.078 region:rollup2
HE.
03:20:53.942 --> 03:20:58.346 region:rollup2
IS S. B. THIRTEEN HUNDRED.
03:20:57.078 --> 03:21:00.782 region:rollup2
THIS IS A.
03:20:58.346 --> 03:21:03.184 region:rollup2
FAIRLY COMPREHENSIVE BILL ON
03:21:00.782 --> 03:21:04.953 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND PREVENTION
03:21:03.184 --> 03:21:06.721 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABILITY.
03:21:04.953 --> 03:21:08.657 region:rollup2
FIRST I WANT TO THANK STAFF.
03:21:06.721 --> 03:21:11.026 region:rollup2
TIM GRIFFITHS.
03:21:08.657 --> 03:21:13.295 region:rollup2
WITH THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS
03:21:11.026 --> 03:21:15.530 region:rollup2
WHICH IF YOU READ THOROUGHLY.
03:21:13.295 --> 03:21:16.831 region:rollup2
SHOULD RESULT IN CONTINUING
03:21:15.530 --> 03:21:18.733 region:rollup2
LEGAL EDUCATION CREDITS FOR ALL
03:21:16.831 --> 03:21:20.468 region:rollup2
OF US.
03:21:18.733 --> 03:21:22.103 region:rollup2
FOR THSE OF US WHO ACTUALLY
03:21:20.468 --> 03:21:24.606 region:rollup2
NONE OF US NEED THE MORE WE HEAR
03:21:22.103 --> 03:21:26.207 region:rollup2
BUT PERHAPS CAN EXTEND THEM. AT
03:21:24.606 --> 03:21:26.374 region:rollup2
THE END OF OUR TEN YEARS HERE
03:21:26.207 --> 03:21:28.143 region:rollup2
BUT.
03:21:26.374 --> 03:21:31.513 region:rollup2
.
03:21:28.143 --> 03:21:34.182 region:rollup2
I CONDUCTED A COUPLE HEARINGS.
03:21:31.513 --> 03:21:35.717 region:rollup2
IN MY IN. MY CAPACITY AS CHAIR
03:21:34.182 --> 03:21:38.286 region:rollup2
OF THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON WOMEN
03:21:35.717 --> 03:21:39.921 region:rollup2
WORK AND FAMILY AND ALSO THE
03:21:38.286 --> 03:21:42.824 region:rollup2
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
03:21:39.921 --> 03:21:44.459 region:rollup2
ON ADDRESSING THE CONCERNS THAT
03:21:42.824 --> 03:21:46.761 region:rollup2
CAME TO LIGHT YET AGAIN I WOULD
03:21:44.459 --> 03:21:48.663 region:rollup2
SAY BY THE MEAT TO MOVEMENT.
03:21:46.761 --> 03:21:50.398 region:rollup2
CAME TO LIGHT YET AGAIN BECAUSE
03:21:48.663 --> 03:21:52.033 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIVE YEARS AGO THESE WERE
03:21:50.398 --> 03:21:54.402 region:rollup2
ISSUES THAT CAME TO LIGHT VERY
03:21:52.033 --> 03:21:56.538 region:rollup2
PUBLICLY WITH THE ANITA HILL.
03:21:54.402 --> 03:21:58.606 region:rollup2
DIE HEARINGS WITH OF THE
03:21:56.538 --> 03:22:00.175 region:rollup2
CLARENCE THOMAS'S CONFIRMATION
03:21:58.606 --> 03:22:01.776 region:rollup2
FOR THE UNITED STATES SUPREME
03:22:00.175 --> 03:22:04.879 region:rollup2
COURT. AND.
03:22:01.776 --> 03:22:07.649 region:rollup2
TWENTY FIVE YEARS LATER IN THE.
03:22:04.879 --> 03:22:09.217 region:rollup2
ISSUE HAS YET A HAS AGAIN RISEN
03:22:07.649 --> 03:22:11.920 region:rollup2
AND THIS TIME I THINK.
03:22:09.217 --> 03:22:13.154 region:rollup2
EXPLODED IN PART BY GIVEN THE
03:22:11.920 --> 03:22:15.523 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF WOMEN OR STEPPED
03:22:13.154 --> 03:22:17.192 region:rollup2
FORWARD GIVEN SOCIAL MEDIA AND
03:22:15.523 --> 03:22:17.993 region:rollup2
THE FACT THAT WE HAVE HEARD
03:22:17.192 --> 03:22:19.761 region:rollup2
HUNDREDS.
03:22:17.993 --> 03:22:21.796 region:rollup2
IF NOT THOUSANDS OF BRAVE WOMEN
03:22:19.761 --> 03:22:23.765 region:rollup2
COME FORWARD BUT TO EXPOSE THE
03:22:21.796 --> 03:22:25.333 region:rollup2
PREVALENCE OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT
03:22:23.765 --> 03:22:28.203 region:rollup2
IN THE WORKPLACE AND IN
03:22:25.333 --> 03:22:29.237 region:rollup2
INDUSTRIES. ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
03:22:28.203 --> 03:22:30.839 region:rollup2
WE'VE SEEN.
03:22:29.237 --> 03:22:32.774 region:rollup2
PERPETRATORS BEING HELD
03:22:30.839 --> 03:22:34.909 region:rollup2
ACCOUNTABLE FINALLY. OF SOME BIG
03:22:32.774 --> 03:22:35.377 region:rollup2
NAMES IN ALL VARIOUS INDUSTRIES
03:22:34.909 --> 03:22:37.612 region:rollup2
WHO HAVE BEEN SEXUALLY
03:22:35.377 --> 03:22:40.315 region:rollup2
HARASSING.
03:22:37.612 --> 03:22:41.716 region:rollup2
DID TO WOMEN FOR DECADES AND
03:22:40.315 --> 03:22:43.718 region:rollup2
WE'VE LEARNED HOW DEVASTATING
03:22:41.716 --> 03:22:45.553 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT IS TO WOMEN
03:22:43.718 --> 03:22:47.088 region:rollup2
AND TO SUMMON.
03:22:45.553 --> 03:22:49.657 region:rollup2
BOB HOW THEIR CAREERS XIN THEIR
03:22:47.088 --> 03:22:51.159 region:rollup2
EMOTIONAL WELL BEING HAS BEEN SO
03:22:49.657 --> 03:22:53.028 region:rollup2
SEVERELY IMPACTED BY THIS
03:22:51.159 --> 03:22:54.129 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR.
03:22:53.028 --> 03:22:55.697 region:rollup2
AND WE'VE ALSO LEARNED HOW
03:22:54.129 --> 03:22:57.265 region:rollup2
CHALLENGING IT IS TO PREVENT AND
03:22:55.697 --> 03:22:59.034 region:rollup2
STOP IT.
03:22:57.265 --> 03:23:00.668 region:rollup2
BECAUSE SEXUAL HARASSMENT IS
03:22:59.034 --> 03:23:02.704 region:rollup2
ABOUT MORE THAN PERPETRATORS WHO
03:23:00.668 --> 03:23:04.539 region:rollup2
SHOULD KNOW BETTER. IT'S ALSO
03:23:02.704 --> 03:23:06.808 region:rollup2
ABOUT ENSURING THAT OUR LAWS OUR
03:23:04.539 --> 03:23:09.277 region:rollup2
JUSTICE SYSTEM AND OUR WORKPLACE
03:23:06.808 --> 03:23:10.979 region:rollup2
CULTURES ARE WORKING TO ENSURE.
03:23:09.277 --> 03:23:13.782 region:rollup2
THAT WOMEN TRULY HAVE EQUAL
03:23:10.979 --> 03:23:15.650 region:rollup2
OPPORTUNITY IN THE WORKPLACE.
03:23:13.782 --> 03:23:17.819 region:rollup2
THIS IS ULTIMATELY A CIVIL
03:23:15.650 --> 03:23:19.521 region:rollup2
RIGHTS ISSUE.
03:23:17.819 --> 03:23:22.123 region:rollup2
IT'S ABOUT ECONOMICS BUT IT'S
03:23:19.521 --> 03:23:23.458 region:rollup2
ALSO ABOUT CIVIL RIGHTS.
03:23:22.123 --> 03:23:25.193 region:rollup2
AND AGAIN AFTER HOLDING THESE
03:23:23.458 --> 03:23:27.629 region:rollup2
TWO HEARINGS TO BECAME CLEAR TO
03:23:25.193 --> 03:23:29.731 region:rollup2
ME THAT THERE ARE LARGE GAPS MY.
03:23:27.629 --> 03:23:31.299 region:rollup2
SOME MIGHT EVEN SAY CHASMS
03:23:29.731 --> 03:23:32.734 region:rollup2
BETWEEN THE PROTECTIONS THAT
03:23:31.299 --> 03:23:34.335 region:rollup2
MANY OF US THINK SHOULD BE IN
03:23:32.734 --> 03:23:36.204 region:rollup2
PLACE FOR SEXUAL HARASSMENT
03:23:34.335 --> 03:23:38.406 region:rollup2
VICTIMS. AND THE ACTUAL
03:23:36.204 --> 03:23:40.508 region:rollup2
PROTECTIONS OF THE LAW CURRENTLY
03:23:38.406 --> 03:23:42.444 region:rollup2
DOES PROVIDE. SO S. B. THIRTEEN
03:23:40.508 --> 03:23:43.578 region:rollup2
HUNDRED.
03:23:42.444 --> 03:23:45.246 region:rollup2
CAME OUT OF THOSE HEARINGS AND
03:23:43.578 --> 03:23:47.615 region:rollup2
IS AN EFFORT TO STRENGTHEN OUR
03:23:45.246 --> 03:23:49.417 region:rollup2
LEGAL PROTECTIONS IN A NUMBER OF
03:23:47.615 --> 03:23:51.453 region:rollup2
KEY AREAS SO IF YOU'LL BEAR WITH
03:23:49.417 --> 03:23:52.887 region:rollup2
ME AS I WORK THROUGH. THEM FOUR
03:23:51.453 --> 03:23:53.321 region:rollup2
MAIN SECTIONS OF THE LOOT
03:23:52.887 --> 03:23:56.191 region:rollup2
LITIGATION EXCUSE ME
03:23:53.321 --> 03:23:56.958 region:rollup2
LEGISLATION.
03:23:56.191 --> 03:23:57.659 region:rollup2
AND THERE WILL BE SOME
03:23:56.958 --> 03:24:00.562 region:rollup2
LITIGATION.
03:23:57.659 --> 03:24:03.331 region:rollup2
THEN AND THERE WILL HAVE TO BE.
03:24:00.562 --> 03:24:04.632 region:rollup2
THE TWO SO THAT WE CAN TRY TO
03:24:03.331 --> 03:24:08.336 region:rollup2
MAKE CHANGES IN THE WORK FORCE.
03:24:04.632 --> 03:24:09.738 region:rollup2
SO THIS BILL. PROVIDES GUIDANCE
03:24:08.336 --> 03:24:11.940 region:rollup2
TO THE COURTS WHEN WE DO HAVE
03:24:09.738 --> 03:24:14.542 region:rollup2
LITIGATION ON THE SEVERE AND
03:24:11.940 --> 03:24:16.978 region:rollup2
PERVASIVE LEGAL STANDARD THAT WE
03:24:14.542 --> 03:24:19.013 region:rollup2
USE IN CALIFORNIA. WHAT WE MIGHT
03:24:16.978 --> 03:24:20.982 region:rollup2
CASUALLY LABEL SEXUAL HARASSMENT
03:24:19.013 --> 03:24:22.650 region:rollup2
IN EVERYDAY LIFE IS A FAR
03:24:20.982 --> 03:24:25.120 region:rollup2
DIFFERENT DEFINITION THAN THE
03:24:22.650 --> 03:24:27.989 region:rollup2
NARROW IMPRECISE LEGAL
03:24:25.120 --> 03:24:29.390 region:rollup2
DEFINITION OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT
03:24:27.989 --> 03:24:31.726 region:rollup2
AVAILABLE IN LITIGATION? AND
03:24:29.390 --> 03:24:33.228 region:rollup2
ACCORDING TO THAT LEGAL STANDARD
03:24:31.726 --> 03:24:34.395 region:rollup2
THE CONDUCT TESTS TO BE
03:24:33.228 --> 03:24:36.364 region:rollup2
UNWELCOME.
03:24:34.395 --> 03:24:38.099 region:rollup2
IT HAS TO BE DISCRIMINATORY
03:24:36.364 --> 03:24:40.335 region:rollup2
MEANING THAT IT IS BASED THAT
03:24:38.099 --> 03:24:43.171 region:rollup2
THE BEHAVIOR IS BASED ON A
03:24:40.335 --> 03:24:45.707 region:rollup2
PRETTY A PROTECTED CLASS WHOARE
03:24:43.171 --> 03:24:47.642 region:rollup2
OTHERWISE. WOULD NOT BE OF THE
03:24:45.707 --> 03:24:49.010 region:rollup2
VICTIM OF THIS BEHAVIOR AND IT
03:24:47.642 --> 03:24:51.646 region:rollup2
HAS TO MEET THE LEVEL OF
03:24:49.010 --> 03:24:53.681 region:rollup2
BECOMING SEVERE. OR PERVASIVE
03:24:51.646 --> 03:24:56.684 region:rollup2
AND IT'S A HIGH BAR.
03:24:53.681 --> 03:24:58.720 region:rollup2
AND FRANKLY. BUT IT HAS NOT ONLY
03:24:56.684 --> 03:25:00.155 region:rollup2
SERVE VICTIMS WELL. MOST OF US
03:24:58.720 --> 03:25:01.723 region:rollup2
WOULD THINK THAT FOR EXAMPLE
03:25:00.155 --> 03:25:03.491 region:rollup2
HAVING OUR BREAST GRAB BY A CO
03:25:01.723 --> 03:25:05.059 region:rollup2
WORKER WHILE REPORTING TO A NINE
03:25:03.491 --> 03:25:07.061 region:rollup2
ONE ONE CALL WOULD INDEED
03:25:05.059 --> 03:25:09.297 region:rollup2
CONSTITUTE SEXUAL HARASSMENT BUT
03:25:07.061 --> 03:25:11.800 region:rollup2
IN FACT. THE COURT FOUND IN
03:25:09.297 --> 03:25:13.768 region:rollup2
BROOKS VERSUS CITY OF SAN MATEO
03:25:11.800 --> 03:25:16.538 region:rollup2
THAT THAT CONDUCT IN DID DID NOT
03:25:13.768 --> 03:25:19.107 region:rollup2
IN FACT RISE TO THE LEVEL OF
03:25:16.538 --> 03:25:20.575 region:rollup2
SEVERE OR PERVASIVE. NOW SO I S.
03:25:19.107 --> 03:25:23.144 region:rollup2
B. THIRTEEN HUNDRED PRESERVES
03:25:20.575 --> 03:25:25.213 region:rollup2
THE LEGAL STANDARD IN PLACE.
03:25:23.144 --> 03:25:27.415 region:rollup2
BUT IT PROVIDES KEY GUIDANCE TO
03:25:25.213 --> 03:25:29.350 region:rollup2
THE COURTS ENCOURAGING THEM TO
03:25:27.415 --> 03:25:31.386 region:rollup2
APPLY THE LAW THROUGH THE LENS
03:25:29.350 --> 03:25:33.755 region:rollup2
OF THIS QUESTION.
03:25:31.386 --> 03:25:35.557 region:rollup2
DID IT FUNDAMENTALLY DEPRIVE
03:25:33.755 --> 03:25:38.426 region:rollup2
SOMEONE OF AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY
03:25:35.557 --> 03:25:40.161 region:rollup2
TO SUCCEED.
03:25:38.426 --> 03:25:42.130 region:rollup2
TWO ITS STRENGTH OR SOME BUT
03:25:40.161 --> 03:25:44.799 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER ACCOUNTABILITY BECAUSE
03:25:42.130 --> 03:25:46.534 region:rollup2
EXISTING LAW ALREADY REQUIRES.
03:25:44.799 --> 03:25:48.436 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS TO TAKE ALL REASONABLE
03:25:46.534 --> 03:25:49.837 region:rollup2
STEPS NECESSARY TO PREVENT
03:25:48.436 --> 03:25:51.606 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION FROM OCCURRING
03:25:49.837 --> 03:25:53.408 region:rollup2
MOST PEOPLE WOULD EXPECT
03:25:51.606 --> 03:25:55.543 region:rollup2
IMPLORED INTERVENED. WHEN THEY
03:25:53.408 --> 03:25:57.445 region:rollup2
LEARN AN EMPLOYEE IS SAYING ON
03:25:55.543 --> 03:25:59.314 region:rollup2
WELCOME SEXUALLY SUGGESTIVE
03:25:57.445 --> 03:26:01.416 region:rollup2
THINGS FOR EXAMPLE TO A CO
03:25:59.314 --> 03:26:02.617 region:rollup2
WORKER OR. BEHAVING IN THE
03:26:01.416 --> 03:26:04.552 region:rollup2
MANNER I CHEST DESCRIBED
03:26:02.617 --> 03:26:06.120 region:rollup2
PREVIOUSLY BUT IT LOGICALLY
03:26:04.552 --> 03:26:07.655 region:rollup2
UNDER CURRENT LAW.
03:26:06.120 --> 03:26:09.891 region:rollup2
AND THIS IS ILLOGICAL IT
03:26:07.655 --> 03:26:12.360 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS DUTY TO PREVENT
03:26:09.891 --> 03:26:13.928 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT ONLY KICKS IN ONCE
03:26:12.360 --> 03:26:15.964 region:rollup2
THE HARASSING CONDUCT HAS
03:26:13.928 --> 03:26:17.899 region:rollup2
REACHED THE SEVERE AND PERVASIVE
03:26:15.964 --> 03:26:19.667 region:rollup2
STANDARD.
03:26:17.899 --> 03:26:22.637 region:rollup2
SO EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN THERE
03:26:19.667 --> 03:26:25.073 region:rollup2
IS NO REQUIREMENT THAT EMPLOYERS
03:26:22.637 --> 03:26:27.075 region:rollup2
STEP IN AND DO SOMETHING.
03:26:25.073 --> 03:26:30.378 region:rollup2
WHICH IS.
03:26:27.075 --> 03:26:32.447 region:rollup2
A CONCERN BECAUSE ONLY UNTIL AN
03:26:30.378 --> 03:26:34.048 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER HAS A VERY SIGNIFICANT
03:26:32.447 --> 03:26:36.784 region:rollup2
PROBLEM TO DEAL WITH DO THEY
03:26:34.048 --> 03:26:38.486 region:rollup2
HAVE A LEGAL DUTY.
03:26:36.784 --> 03:26:41.389 region:rollup2
BY STRENGTHENING THIS FAILURE TO
03:26:38.486 --> 03:26:42.824 region:rollup2
PREVENT PORTION OF THE BILL. S.
03:26:41.389 --> 03:26:44.392 region:rollup2
B. THIRTEEN HUNDRED FIRMS HAD
03:26:42.824 --> 03:26:46.294 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS JUST CAN'T SIMPLY SIT
03:26:44.392 --> 03:26:47.896 region:rollup2
ON THEIR HANDS WHEN THEY LEARN
03:26:46.294 --> 03:26:49.230 region:rollup2
OF UNWELCOME AND DISCRIMINATORY
03:26:47.896 --> 03:26:51.499 region:rollup2
CONDUCT THEY MUST TAKE
03:26:49.230 --> 03:26:53.601 region:rollup2
REASONABLE STEPS TO RESPOND.
03:26:51.499 --> 03:26:54.736 region:rollup2
THAT COULD INCLUDE THINGS LIKE
03:26:53.601 --> 03:26:56.070 region:rollup2
SIMPLY TALKING TO AN EMPLOYEE
03:26:54.736 --> 03:26:58.039 region:rollup2
WERE SENDING THEM AN EMAIL
03:26:56.070 --> 03:27:00.475 region:rollup2
REMINDING THEM OF THE COMPANY
03:26:58.039 --> 03:27:02.010 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT POLICIES WE
03:27:00.475 --> 03:27:04.045 region:rollup2
KNOW THAT MANY EMPLOYERS THROUGH
03:27:02.010 --> 03:27:06.581 region:rollup2
THEIR ZERO TOLERANCE POLICIES.
03:27:04.045 --> 03:27:08.116 region:rollup2
ARE ALREADY RESPONSIVE TO
03:27:06.581 --> 03:27:10.852 region:rollup2
HARASSING CONDUCT IN THIS WAY.
03:27:08.116 --> 03:27:12.787 region:rollup2
BUT THIS BRINGS OUR LAWS IN LINE
03:27:10.852 --> 03:27:14.355 region:rollup2
WITH THOSE BEST PRACTICES. THIRD
03:27:12.787 --> 03:27:16.591 region:rollup2
IT STRENGTHENS TRAINING
03:27:14.355 --> 03:27:18.826 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS NOW.
03:27:16.591 --> 03:27:21.129 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT TRAINING
03:27:18.826 --> 03:27:22.897 region:rollup2
REQUIREMENTS REQUIRE A TRAINING
03:27:21.129 --> 03:27:23.231 region:rollup2
FOR SUPERVISORIAL.
03:27:22.897 --> 03:27:26.634 region:rollup2
A.
03:27:23.231 --> 03:27:29.170 region:rollup2
STAFF THIS BILL WILL REQUIRE
03:27:26.634 --> 03:27:32.106 region:rollup2
THAT IT PROVIDE FOR.
03:27:29.170 --> 03:27:33.474 region:rollup2
COMPANIES O. WITH FIVE OR MORE
03:27:32.106 --> 03:27:35.076 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES.
03:27:33.474 --> 03:27:36.811 region:rollup2
AND IT INCLUDES SUPERVISORS AND
03:27:35.076 --> 03:27:38.546 region:rollup2
CO WORKERS
03:27:36.811 --> 03:27:40.248 region:rollup2
AND THAT INCLUDES BYSTANDER
03:27:38.546 --> 03:27:42.517 region:rollup2
INTERVENTION TRAINING WHICH ARE
03:27:40.248 --> 03:27:44.152 region:rollup2
TECHNIQUES FOR DE ESCALATION.
03:27:42.517 --> 03:27:46.521 region:rollup2
AND DISTRACTION WHICH NOT ONLY
03:27:44.152 --> 03:27:48.456 region:rollup2
DISRUPT BEHAVIOR THIS NEGATIVE
03:27:46.521 --> 03:27:50.992 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR BUT CREATE A SENSE OF
03:27:48.456 --> 03:27:52.694 region:rollup2
SHARED RESPONSIBILITY TO STOP
03:27:50.992 --> 03:27:54.395 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT. AND IT
03:27:52.694 --> 03:27:55.897 region:rollup2
RECENTLY MET WITH SOME TRADE
03:27:54.395 --> 03:27:57.765 region:rollup2
WOMAN.
03:27:55.897 --> 03:27:59.200 region:rollup2
AND LEARNED A AYE EXCUSE ME I
03:27:57.765 --> 03:28:01.436 region:rollup2
RECENTLY MET WITH SOME TRAITS
03:27:59.200 --> 03:28:03.438 region:rollup2
WOMEN. AND LEARNED OF A UNION
03:28:01.436 --> 03:28:05.606 region:rollup2
CURRICULUM THAT THEY CALL BE
03:28:03.438 --> 03:28:07.108 region:rollup2
THAT ONE GUY.
03:28:05.606 --> 03:28:08.810 region:rollup2
WHICH IS ALONG THESE VERY
03:28:07.108 --> 03:28:11.746 region:rollup2
SIMILAR LINES.
03:28:08.810 --> 03:28:14.015 region:rollup2
ADDING ENCOURAGING COLLEAGUES TO
03:28:11.746 --> 03:28:15.917 region:rollup2
BE PART OF THE SOLUTION TO THIS
03:28:14.015 --> 03:28:17.485 region:rollup2
PROBLEM. AND AGAIN WE DIDN'T IN
03:28:15.917 --> 03:28:19.387 region:rollup2
THESE HEARINGS WE LEARNED ABOUT
03:28:17.485 --> 03:28:20.988 region:rollup2
THE EFFICACY OF BYSTANDER
03:28:19.387 --> 03:28:23.591 region:rollup2
INTERVENTION TRAINING.
03:28:20.988 --> 03:28:25.893 region:rollup2
NOW IT DOES NOT. REQUIRE A
03:28:23.591 --> 03:28:27.628 region:rollup2
BYSTANDER TO TAKE ANY ACTION
03:28:25.893 --> 03:28:29.330 region:rollup2
THERE'S NO LIABILITY IF A BY
03:28:27.628 --> 03:28:30.798 region:rollup2
STANDARD DOES NOT BUT WHAT IT
03:28:29.330 --> 03:28:32.333 region:rollup2
DOES IS GIVE THAT BYSTANDER THE
03:28:30.798 --> 03:28:34.602 region:rollup2
TOOLS.
03:28:32.333 --> 03:28:36.671 region:rollup2
SO THAT IF THEY DO WANT TO ENTER
03:28:34.602 --> 03:28:39.540 region:rollup2
INTERVENE THAT THEY HAVE AN
03:28:36.671 --> 03:28:41.342 region:rollup2
ABILITY TO DO SO. IN A CONFIDENT
03:28:39.540 --> 03:28:43.044 region:rollup2
AND EMPOWERING WAY.
03:28:41.342 --> 03:28:44.779 region:rollup2
AND FOURTH THIS CLOSES LEGAL
03:28:43.044 --> 03:28:46.447 region:rollup2
LOOPHOLES.
03:28:44.779 --> 03:28:48.883 region:rollup2
THE LEGAL LOOPHOLES PROHIBITING
03:28:46.447 --> 03:28:50.885 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS FROM REQUIRING WORKERS
03:28:48.883 --> 03:28:53.821 region:rollup2
TO SIGN AWAY THEIR ABILITY TO
03:28:50.885 --> 03:28:55.757 region:rollup2
SPEAK OUT OR THEIR RIGHT TO FILE
03:28:53.821 --> 03:28:58.359 region:rollup2
A CLAIM AGAINST AN EMPLOYER. AS
03:28:55.757 --> 03:29:00.128 region:rollup2
A CONDITION OF EMPLOYMENT OR
03:28:58.359 --> 03:29:02.363 region:rollup2
CONTINUED EMPLOYMENT.
03:29:00.128 --> 03:29:04.565 region:rollup2
FOR FOR A WAGER BONUS INCREASE
03:29:02.363 --> 03:29:06.834 region:rollup2
WHAT'S OFTEN REFERRED TO AS NON
03:29:04.565 --> 03:29:09.370 region:rollup2
DISPARAGEMENT AGREEMENTS OR.
03:29:06.834 --> 03:29:11.105 region:rollup2
SNEAKY RELEASES THIS BILL HAS A
03:29:09.370 --> 03:29:13.207 region:rollup2
NUMBER OF COMPONENTS BUT
03:29:11.105 --> 03:29:14.776 region:rollup2
COLLECTIVELY IT SEEKS TO PROVIDE
03:29:13.207 --> 03:29:15.710 region:rollup2
MANY OF THE PROTECTION SAID I
03:29:14.776 --> 03:29:17.979 region:rollup2
THINK.
03:29:15.710 --> 03:29:21.049 region:rollup2
MOST OF US ASSUME AND EXPECT
03:29:17.979 --> 03:29:23.217 region:rollup2
FROM OUR LAWS AND AS FAR AS THE.
03:29:21.049 --> 03:29:24.385 region:rollup2
SNEAKY RELEASE OR THE DISK NON
03:29:23.217 --> 03:29:26.721 region:rollup2
DISPARAGEMENT AGREEMENT ARE
03:29:24.385 --> 03:29:28.790 region:rollup2
WHICH JUST CITE. THE CASE OF
03:29:26.721 --> 03:29:29.991 region:rollup2
ARMS.
03:29:28.790 --> 03:29:32.994 region:rollup2
A WARNING STICKER INSISTING MORE
03:29:29.991 --> 03:29:34.195 region:rollup2
INTERESTING.
03:29:32.994 --> 03:29:35.863 region:rollup2
WHO'S. CONTROLLING HER REAL HARM
03:29:34.195 --> 03:29:37.131 region:rollup2
HARVEY WEINSTEIN SAY I WANT TO
03:29:35.863 --> 03:29:39.167 region:rollup2
FORGET THIS.
03:29:37.131 --> 03:29:39.667 region:rollup2
NAME THIS PERSON.
03:29:39.167 --> 03:29:42.603 region:rollup2
BUT IN HIS COMPANIES FOR
03:29:39.667 --> 03:29:44.405 region:rollup2
DECADES.
03:29:42.603 --> 03:29:45.907 region:rollup2
PEOPLE WHO WENT TO WORK FOR HIS
03:29:44.405 --> 03:29:47.875 region:rollup2
COMPANIES EITHER MIRAMAX FOR THE
03:29:45.907 --> 03:29:50.745 region:rollup2
WEINSTEIN COMPANY'S HAD TO SIGN
03:29:47.875 --> 03:29:52.747 region:rollup2
A NON DISPARAGEMENT AGREEMENT AS
03:29:50.745 --> 03:29:54.348 region:rollup2
A CONDITION OF EMPLOYMENT.
03:29:52.747 --> 03:29:56.551 region:rollup2
BEFORE THEY EVEN GOT WALKED IN
03:29:54.348 --> 03:29:58.052 region:rollup2
THE DOOR THEY HAD TO AGREE TO
03:29:56.551 --> 03:30:00.455 region:rollup2
SILENCE
03:29:58.052 --> 03:30:03.291 region:rollup2
WHICH FRANKLY HAS BEEN THE
03:30:00.455 --> 03:30:04.692 region:rollup2
SOURCE OF PERPETUATING THIS KIND
03:30:03.291 --> 03:30:06.561 region:rollup2
OF BEHAVIOR. FOR WILL OF THE
03:30:04.692 --> 03:30:09.063 region:rollup2
VARIETY OF INDUSTRIES FOR
03:30:06.561 --> 03:30:11.999 region:rollup2
DECADES AND IT MUST STOP. SO
03:30:09.063 --> 03:30:14.469 region:rollup2
WITH THAT I HAVE WITH ME TODAY.
03:30:11.999 --> 03:30:15.503 region:rollup2
ARUSHA A BETA.
03:30:14.469 --> 03:30:17.138 region:rollup2
TONI.
03:30:15.503 --> 03:30:19.040 region:rollup2
ENTER MARINO.
03:30:17.138 --> 03:30:20.942 region:rollup2
GYMBOREE EXCUSE ME WITH TONY
03:30:19.040 --> 03:30:23.111 region:rollup2
CHAIR THAT I HAVE IT RIGHT
03:30:20.942 --> 03:30:24.612 region:rollup2
ARMENIA KALRA MIA I AM SO SORRY.
03:30:23.111 --> 03:30:28.416 region:rollup2
I AND YOU HAVE TESTIFIED BEFORE
03:30:24.612 --> 03:30:30.284 region:rollup2
ME BEFORE AND SO I APOLOGIZE.
03:30:28.416 --> 03:30:31.853 region:rollup2
HAVE WITH HER LAW PROFESSIONAL
03:30:30.284 --> 03:30:34.155 region:rollup2
LAW CORPORATION TO SPEAK IN
03:30:31.853 --> 03:30:36.257 region:rollup2
SUPPORT OF THESE BILLS AND.
03:30:34.155 --> 03:30:37.725 region:rollup2
THERE ARE IN PARTICULAR OUR TO
03:30:36.257 --> 03:30:39.527 region:rollup2
THE ISSUE OF SOME THE SNEAKY
03:30:37.725 --> 03:30:40.695 region:rollup2
RELEASE AND NON DISPARAGEMENT
03:30:39.527 --> 03:30:42.597 region:rollup2
AGREEMENTS WHICH.
03:30:40.695 --> 03:30:44.732 region:rollup2
CAN SEEM SOMEWHAT ABSTRACT BUT
03:30:42.597 --> 03:30:47.001 region:rollup2
THEY HAVE BEEN A VERY MUCH A
03:30:44.732 --> 03:30:48.669 region:rollup2
SOURCE OF PERPETUATING THIS
03:30:47.001 --> 03:30:50.071 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR AND WE'VE GOT TO PUT AN
03:30:48.669 --> 03:30:52.406 region:rollup2
END TO IT SO WITH THAT I WOULD
03:30:50.071 --> 03:30:52.707 region:rollup2
ASK YOU RIGHT VOTE.
03:30:52.406 --> 03:30:54.575 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
03:30:52.707 --> 03:30:56.844 region:rollup2
THINKING IT THANK YOU SENATOR
03:30:54.575 --> 03:30:58.913 region:rollup2
JACKSON AND I GOOD AFTERNOON
03:30:56.844 --> 03:31:00.448 region:rollup2
MEMBERS ON TONY ARMY I'M PAST
03:30:58.913 --> 03:31:01.782 region:rollup2
CHAIR AND CURRENT MEMBER OF THE
03:31:00.448 --> 03:31:03.784 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS
03:31:01.782 --> 03:31:06.053 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION. AND WE'RE HERE
03:31:03.784 --> 03:31:07.555 region:rollup2
TODAY TO TALK ABOUT AN ASPECT OF
03:31:06.053 --> 03:31:09.857 region:rollup2
THIS BILL.
03:31:07.555 --> 03:31:11.425 region:rollup2
REGARDING THE WHAT IS TERMED
03:31:09.857 --> 03:31:14.128 region:rollup2
SNEAKY RELEASES AND NON
03:31:11.425 --> 03:31:16.964 region:rollup2
DISPARAGEMENT ON THIS IS A
03:31:14.128 --> 03:31:18.533 region:rollup2
MATTER THAT. OF MY CLIENT HERE
03:31:16.964 --> 03:31:20.134 region:rollup2
OF MARIA SAY IS HERE TO TALK
03:31:18.533 --> 03:31:22.003 region:rollup2
ABOUT HER REAL LIFE EXPERIENCE
03:31:20.134 --> 03:31:24.906 region:rollup2
AS TO WHAT HAPPENED TO HER WHEN
03:31:22.003 --> 03:31:25.606 region:rollup2
SHE WAS DEPLOYED. AT A LARGE
03:31:24.906 --> 03:31:28.075 region:rollup2
COMPANY THAT EMPLOYED.
03:31:25.606 --> 03:31:30.011 region:rollup2
THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIA WORKERS
03:31:28.075 --> 03:31:32.180 region:rollup2
IN WHICH THEY WERE REQUIRED TO
03:31:30.011 --> 03:31:34.248 region:rollup2
NOT ONLY SIGN. UP.
03:31:32.180 --> 03:31:35.883 region:rollup2
PROVISIONS THAT PREVENTED THEM
03:31:34.248 --> 03:31:37.685 region:rollup2
FROM TALKING BADLY AND
03:31:35.883 --> 03:31:39.487 region:rollup2
DISPARAGINGLY ABOUT THE EMPLOYER
03:31:37.685 --> 03:31:40.988 region:rollup2
AND THEIR SUPERVISORS AND ANYONE
03:31:39.487 --> 03:31:43.191 region:rollup2
THAT THE COMPANY.
03:31:40.988 --> 03:31:45.126 region:rollup2
BUT ALSO TO SIGN DOCUMENTS AND
03:31:43.191 --> 03:31:47.094 region:rollup2
CONNECTIONS WITH BONUSES AND PAY
03:31:45.126 --> 03:31:49.564 region:rollup2
RAISES AND ANY KIND OF
03:31:47.094 --> 03:31:51.365 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT STATUS CHANGE IN
03:31:49.564 --> 03:31:53.167 region:rollup2
WHICH THEY WOULD HAVE TO SIGN AN
03:31:51.365 --> 03:31:54.569 region:rollup2
AGREEMENT OR SIGNED A RELEASE
03:31:53.167 --> 03:31:56.771 region:rollup2
THAT'S BAD THAT ALL THEIR CIVIL
03:31:54.569 --> 03:31:57.271 region:rollup2
RIGHTS CLAIMS. AND EVEN THEIR
03:31:56.771 --> 03:31:57.905 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT CLAIMS
03:31:57.271 --> 03:32:00.808 region:rollup2
WERE-WAVES SO THAT THEY CAN GET
03:31:57.905 --> 03:32:02.643 region:rollup2
THEIR
03:32:00.808 --> 03:32:03.945 region:rollup2
LITTLE BONUS ARE THERE LOOKED
03:32:02.643 --> 03:32:05.813 region:rollup2
OVER THEIR SLIGHT PAY RAISE.
03:32:03.945 --> 03:32:08.449 region:rollup2
AND SO IN THIS MATTER WIN THIS
03:32:05.813 --> 03:32:11.352 region:rollup2
CASE WAS BROUGHT TO LITIGATION.
03:32:08.449 --> 03:32:13.220 region:rollup2
WE REPRESENTED FOR EMPLOYEES
03:32:11.352 --> 03:32:14.822 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY FIVE WOMEN WHO WERE
03:32:13.220 --> 03:32:16.557 region:rollup2
SEXUALLY HARASSED.
03:32:14.822 --> 03:32:18.859 region:rollup2
AGREE JUST ACTS OF SEXUAL
03:32:16.557 --> 03:32:20.761 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT. BUT THESE RELEASES
03:32:18.859 --> 03:32:22.296 region:rollup2
WERE SET FORTH IN BROUGHT FORTH
03:32:20.761 --> 03:32:23.864 region:rollup2
AND ALL THESE HARASSMENT CLAIMS
03:32:22.296 --> 03:32:25.266 region:rollup2
WERE DISMISSED.
03:32:23.864 --> 03:32:26.667 region:rollup2
BECAUSE EMPLOYEES DID NOT KNOW
03:32:25.266 --> 03:32:28.603 region:rollup2
WHAT THEY WERE SIGNING AND THEY
03:32:26.667 --> 03:32:30.438 region:rollup2
WERE PUT IN THE CONTEXT OF
03:32:28.603 --> 03:32:33.374 region:rollup2
BONUSES AND RELEASES. BONUSES
03:32:30.438 --> 03:32:35.176 region:rollup2
AND AND PAY RAISES AND THEY HAVE
03:32:33.374 --> 03:32:35.376 region:rollup2
TO SIGN THOSE IN ORDER TO GET
03:32:35.176 --> 03:32:36.844 region:rollup2
THAT.
03:32:35.376 --> 03:32:38.079 region:rollup2
.
03:32:36.844 --> 03:32:39.247 region:rollup2
WE HAVE MORRISSEY HERE IS GOING
03:32:38.079 --> 03:32:40.548 region:rollup2
TO TALK ABOUT HER REAL LIFE
03:32:39.247 --> 03:32:42.249 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCE AND WHAT SHE WENT
03:32:40.548 --> 03:32:44.085 region:rollup2
THROUGH AFTER FOUR YEARS OF
03:32:42.249 --> 03:32:46.787 region:rollup2
LITIGATION. AND.
03:32:44.085 --> 03:32:49.690 region:rollup2
WE'RE HERE TODAY TO HOPEFULLY.
03:32:46.787 --> 03:32:51.993 region:rollup2
MAKE SURE THAT THIS TYPE OF.
03:32:49.690 --> 03:32:54.528 region:rollup2
TACTICS BY THAT BY BIG DEFENSE
03:32:51.993 --> 03:32:56.497 region:rollup2
AND EMPLOYERS WILL NOT CONTINUE.
03:32:54.528 --> 03:32:57.732 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
03:32:56.497 --> 03:32:59.066 region:rollup2
OKAY I'D LIKE TO START OUT BY
03:32:57.732 --> 03:33:00.901 region:rollup2
SAYING THANK YOU I KNOW IT'S
03:32:59.066 --> 03:33:02.203 region:rollup2
TIME TO GO SO THANK YOU FOR
03:33:00.901 --> 03:33:04.105 region:rollup2
STICKING AROUND IN WAITING FOR.
03:33:02.203 --> 03:33:05.740 region:rollup2
US THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT TO ME
03:33:04.105 --> 03:33:08.109 region:rollup2
AND I LIKE TO THINK SENATOR
03:33:05.740 --> 03:33:09.644 region:rollup2
JACKSON TONY AND A LOT OF THE
03:33:08.109 --> 03:33:10.945 region:rollup2
WOMEN SITTING BEHIND ME. WHO
03:33:09.644 --> 03:33:12.980 region:rollup2
HAVE RESTORED MY FAITH IN OUR
03:33:10.945 --> 03:33:14.715 region:rollup2
JUDICIAL SYSTEM IT'S REALLY
03:33:12.980 --> 03:33:16.017 region:rollup2
REFRESHING TO BE HERE TODAY AND
03:33:14.715 --> 03:33:19.053 region:rollup2
IT MEANS A LOT?
03:33:16.017 --> 03:33:21.055 region:rollup2
I'M SPEAKING IN FAVOR OF THIS
03:33:19.053 --> 03:33:22.256 region:rollup2
BILL IT DOESN'T IT DOESN'T
03:33:21.055 --> 03:33:23.758 region:rollup2
REALLY BENEFIT ME PERSONALLY TO
03:33:22.256 --> 03:33:26.160 region:rollup2
BE HERE.
03:33:23.758 --> 03:33:27.428 region:rollup2
AT THIS POINT. I WISH IT WOULD
03:33:26.160 --> 03:33:28.629 region:rollup2
HAVE BEEN PASSED A FEW YEARS AGO
03:33:27.428 --> 03:33:29.697 region:rollup2
WHEN I WAS HERE MAYBE SOME OF
03:33:28.629 --> 03:33:30.831 region:rollup2
YOU REMEMBER ME.
03:33:29.697 --> 03:33:32.767 region:rollup2
BUT IT.
03:33:30.831 --> 03:33:36.037 region:rollup2
.
03:33:32.767 --> 03:33:38.706 region:rollup2
IT'S IMPORTANT A IT REALLY.
03:33:36.037 --> 03:33:40.007 region:rollup2
WHERE DID KIND OF PATCH OF? A
03:33:38.706 --> 03:33:41.542 region:rollup2
LOOPHOLE IN THE LAW THAT HAS
03:33:40.007 --> 03:33:43.878 region:rollup2
BEEN EXPLOITED I DON'T KNOW BY
03:33:41.542 --> 03:33:46.280 region:rollup2
HOW MANY. I ONLY KNOW OF ONE
03:33:43.878 --> 03:33:48.683 region:rollup2
INSTANCE BUT IT WAS A BIG
03:33:46.280 --> 03:33:50.217 region:rollup2
COMPANY AND IT'S. FRANKLY VERY
03:33:48.683 --> 03:33:51.886 region:rollup2
FRIGHTENING THAT THAT OCCURRED.
03:33:50.217 --> 03:33:52.987 region:rollup2
I WOULD LOVE TO TELL YOU MY
03:33:51.886 --> 03:33:54.155 region:rollup2
STORY WOULD LOVE TO TELL YOU THE
03:33:52.987 --> 03:33:55.956 region:rollup2
DETAILS OF WHAT HAPPENED TO ME
03:33:54.155 --> 03:33:57.391 region:rollup2
AT THAT COMPANY. BUT I'M NOT AT
03:33:55.956 --> 03:33:59.393 region:rollup2
LIBERTY TO DO SO.
03:33:57.391 --> 03:34:02.229 region:rollup2
I DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT.
03:33:59.393 --> 03:34:05.232 region:rollup2
AND I WISH THAT I DID.
03:34:02.229 --> 03:34:05.433 region:rollup2
BECAUSE IT'S VERY MUCH MY STORY.
03:34:05.232 --> 03:34:07.735 region:rollup2
AND.
03:34:05.433 --> 03:34:09.737 region:rollup2
IT.
03:34:07.735 --> 03:34:11.672 region:rollup2
IT'S IT'S REALLY.
03:34:09.737 --> 03:34:13.507 region:rollup2
IRRELEVANT HOW LONG IT WENT ON
03:34:11.672 --> 03:34:15.609 region:rollup2
BUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT.
03:34:13.507 --> 03:34:17.845 region:rollup2
MY ENTIRE EMPLOYMENT LASTED
03:34:15.609 --> 03:34:20.881 region:rollup2
FOUR MONTHS HAD THIS COMPANY I
03:34:17.845 --> 03:34:22.450 region:rollup2
QUIT. IT WAS AWFUL IT WAS
03:34:20.881 --> 03:34:24.852 region:rollup2
ABSOLUTELY EARTH SHATTERING WE
03:34:22.450 --> 03:34:26.721 region:rollup2
EAT DE HUMANIZING. TO BE
03:34:24.852 --> 03:34:28.789 region:rollup2
EMPLOYED AT THIS COMPANY IT HAS
03:34:26.721 --> 03:34:30.091 region:rollup2
TAKEN ME CLOSE TO EIGHT YEARS OF
03:34:28.789 --> 03:34:33.260 region:rollup2
UNRAVELING.
03:34:30.091 --> 03:34:34.362 region:rollup2
TO UNDO AND AND REFLECT ON ALL
03:34:33.260 --> 03:34:36.497 region:rollup2
THE THINGS THAT THIS MAN WAS
03:34:34.362 --> 03:34:38.199 region:rollup2
ALLOWED TO TAKE FROM ME.
03:34:36.497 --> 03:34:41.202 region:rollup2
WHAT REALLY PISSES ME OFF IS
03:34:38.199 --> 03:34:43.804 region:rollup2
THAT HE TOOK MY VOICE?
03:34:41.202 --> 03:34:46.273 region:rollup2
I DON'T THINK THAT CALIFORNIANS
03:34:43.804 --> 03:34:46.807 region:rollup2
IT SHOULD BE SUBJECTED TO THIS
03:34:46.273 --> 03:34:55.382 region:rollup2
KIND OF A LOOPHOLE. IT'S A
03:34:46.807 --> 03:34:55.583 region:rollup2
SMALL.
03:34:55.382 --> 03:34:58.219 region:rollup2
I A.
03:34:55.583 --> 03:34:59.453 region:rollup2
I DON'T KNOW WHY.
03:34:58.219 --> 03:35:00.721 region:rollup2
I'M JUST A PERSON RAIN I'M NOT A
03:34:59.453 --> 03:35:02.189 region:rollup2
LAWYER.
03:35:00.721 --> 03:35:03.657 region:rollup2
THE I AND THESE RELEASES HAVE
03:35:02.189 --> 03:35:05.059 region:rollup2
BEEN ENFORCED IT COST ME MANY
03:35:03.657 --> 03:35:07.094 region:rollup2
YEARS OF LITIGATION TO GET THEM
03:35:05.059 --> 03:35:09.130 region:rollup2
STRUCK DOWN IN MY CASE.
03:35:07.094 --> 03:35:10.865 region:rollup2
AND I I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THIS
03:35:09.130 --> 03:35:12.399 region:rollup2
BILL PASSED I THINK IT'S A
03:35:10.865 --> 03:35:13.934 region:rollup2
BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF LEGISLATION.
03:35:12.399 --> 03:35:15.870 region:rollup2
I'M I'M ASKING YOU TO PROTECT
03:35:13.934 --> 03:35:17.605 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIANS AT WORK.
03:35:15.870 --> 03:35:18.773 region:rollup2
THANK YOU.
03:35:17.605 --> 03:35:23.611 region:rollup2
ARE THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
03:35:18.773 --> 03:35:24.311 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:35:23.611 --> 03:35:25.513 region:rollup2
PRETTY CLEAR CHARLOTTE THE
03:35:24.311 --> 03:35:27.148 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA PLANET LAWYERS
03:35:25.513 --> 03:35:29.083 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION IN STRONG SUPPORT
03:35:27.148 --> 03:35:30.518 region:rollup2
KNOWING JUST A PERSON. EXIST
03:35:29.083 --> 03:35:32.353 region:rollup2
UNDER EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES AND
03:35:30.518 --> 03:35:32.920 region:rollup2
THE STRONGER CALIFORNIA
03:35:32.353 --> 03:35:37.458 region:rollup2
ADVOCATES NETWORK IN STRONG
03:35:32.920 --> 03:35:38.125 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:35:37.458 --> 03:35:39.026 region:rollup2
SHE AN INCIDENT GROWING AMERICAN
03:35:38.125 --> 03:35:43.063 region:rollup2
ASSOCIATION OF UNIVERSITY WOMEN
03:35:39.026 --> 03:35:44.131 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
03:35:43.063 --> 03:35:45.866 region:rollup2
GETTING GARY LEGALLY THAT WHERE
03:35:44.131 --> 03:35:47.201 region:rollup2
CONCERNS FOR IT.
03:35:45.866 --> 03:35:48.435 region:rollup2
MANDY BENSON WITH WORK EQUITY
03:35:47.201 --> 03:35:50.604 region:rollup2
AND MJ BENSON CONSULTING AND
03:35:48.435 --> 03:35:51.972 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:35:50.604 --> 03:35:54.975 region:rollup2
BRITNEY MCCARTHY WITH WORK
03:35:51.972 --> 03:35:56.210 region:rollup2
EQUITY AND STRONG SUPPORT.
03:35:54.975 --> 03:35:57.812 region:rollup2
ANY NICOSIA'S OF THE COUNCIL ON
03:35:56.210 --> 03:36:01.348 region:rollup2
AMERICAN ISLAMIC RELATIONS
03:35:57.812 --> 03:36:01.882 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIANS STRONG SUPPORT.
03:36:01.348 --> 03:36:04.251 region:rollup2
NIKITA RACE I'M IN STRONG
03:36:01.882 --> 03:36:05.486 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:36:04.251 --> 03:36:08.722 region:rollup2
PAMELA LOPEZ WITH WORK EQUITY IN
03:36:05.486 --> 03:36:09.890 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:36:08.722 --> 03:36:11.492 region:rollup2
JURY MEMBERS KEVINBIG AMERICAN
03:36:09.890 --> 03:36:11.992 region:rollup2
CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION A
03:36:11.492 --> 03:36:13.994 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ALSO INSTRUCT
03:36:11.992 --> 03:36:15.162 region:rollup2
SUPPORT.
03:36:13.994 --> 03:36:20.134 region:rollup2
WE'RE NAY MARROW HERE YOU
03:36:15.162 --> 03:36:21.502 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA ALSO IN SUPPORT.
03:36:20.134 --> 03:36:25.639 region:rollup2
PARADE DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES
03:36:21.502 --> 03:36:29.610 region:rollup2
IN OPPOSITION.
03:36:25.639 --> 03:36:32.580 region:rollup2
HE'S STILL HERE.
03:36:29.610 --> 03:36:34.715 region:rollup2
WE'LL GET.
03:36:32.580 --> 03:36:35.983 region:rollup2
HELLO. PACKING AND MARK CURTIS
03:36:34.715 --> 03:36:37.051 region:rollup2
WITH CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
03:36:35.983 --> 03:36:38.986 region:rollup2
COMMERCE WE ARE HERE IN
03:36:37.051 --> 03:36:40.187 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION TO SB AND THIRTEEN
03:36:38.986 --> 03:36:40.788 region:rollup2
HUNDRED AND AGAIN THIS THAT HAS
03:36:40.187 --> 03:36:42.489 region:rollup2
BEEN LABELED A JOB KILLER FOR
03:36:40.788 --> 03:36:45.059 region:rollup2
US.
03:36:42.489 --> 03:36:45.693 region:rollup2
OTHER SEEMS TO BE SOME CONFUSION
03:36:45.059 --> 03:36:47.595 region:rollup2
AROUND THE CURRENT STATE OF THE
03:36:45.693 --> 03:36:49.163 region:rollup2
LAW. AND THE PLAYERS ACTUALLY DO
03:36:47.595 --> 03:36:49.897 region:rollup2
HAVE AN AFFIRMATIVE DUTY TO
03:36:49.163 --> 03:36:51.599 region:rollup2
PREVENT HARASSMENT AND
03:36:49.897 --> 03:36:53.534 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION THEY'RE REQUIRED
03:36:51.599 --> 03:36:54.602 region:rollup2
TO ACT AS SOON AS A COMPLAINT IS
03:36:53.534 --> 03:36:55.970 region:rollup2
MADE AND THEY ARE REQUIRED TO
03:36:54.602 --> 03:36:58.439 region:rollup2
HAVE. PROVISIONS IN THEIR
03:36:55.970 --> 03:37:00.074 region:rollup2
POLICIES AND HAVE THEM STEPS PUT
03:36:58.439 --> 03:37:01.442 region:rollup2
IN PLACE REGARDING PREVENTION OF
03:37:00.074 --> 03:37:03.377 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT AND DISCRIMINATION
03:37:01.442 --> 03:37:04.411 region:rollup2
NYDIA PH HAS POLICE POWERS
03:37:03.377 --> 03:37:06.447 region:rollup2
AROUND PREVENTION AND OF
03:37:04.411 --> 03:37:08.716 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT DISCRIMINATION AND
03:37:06.447 --> 03:37:10.451 region:rollup2
THEY CAN AND ENFORCE REGULATIONS
03:37:08.716 --> 03:37:12.486 region:rollup2
SEEKING NON MONETARY RELIEF. AND
03:37:10.451 --> 03:37:13.387 region:rollup2
OR IF AN EMPLOYER IS NOT TO AND
03:37:12.486 --> 03:37:14.822 region:rollup2
PREVENTING HARASSMENT AND
03:37:13.387 --> 03:37:16.891 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION SO THIS CAN BE
03:37:14.822 --> 03:37:17.458 region:rollup2
ANY NON MONETARY AND INCLUDING
03:37:16.891 --> 03:37:19.960 region:rollup2
INJUNCTIONS. AND ALSO DURING
03:37:17.458 --> 03:37:21.295 region:rollup2
OUR.
03:37:19.960 --> 03:37:22.329 region:rollup2
BUT DURING THE AND HEARINGS OUR
03:37:21.295 --> 03:37:24.265 region:rollup2
UNDERSTANDING WAS THAT THE
03:37:22.329 --> 03:37:24.999 region:rollup2
DETERMINATION WAS TO NOT LOWER
03:37:24.265 --> 03:37:26.800 region:rollup2
THE SEVERE AND PERVASIVE
03:37:24.999 --> 03:37:28.168 region:rollup2
STANDARD WHAT THIRTEEN HUNDRED
03:37:26.800 --> 03:37:29.136 region:rollup2
DOES IT'S ACTUALLY A SKIRT
03:37:28.168 --> 03:37:30.638 region:rollup2
AROUND THE SEVERE PERVASIVE
03:37:29.136 --> 03:37:31.839 region:rollup2
STANDARD. BECAUSE WHY WOULD
03:37:30.638 --> 03:37:33.140 region:rollup2
ANYONE ACTUALLY SUPER HARASSMENT
03:37:31.839 --> 03:37:34.608 region:rollup2
OR DISCRIMINATION WHEN ALL THEY
03:37:33.140 --> 03:37:35.743 region:rollup2
HAVE TO SUE FOR NOW IS FAILURE
03:37:34.608 --> 03:37:37.211 region:rollup2
TO PREVENT HARASSMENT OR
03:37:35.743 --> 03:37:38.178 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION ESPECIALLY WITH
03:37:37.211 --> 03:37:39.580 region:rollup2
THE LANGUAGE OF S. B. IT
03:37:38.178 --> 03:37:41.048 region:rollup2
THIRTEEN HUNDRED. THAT ONLY
03:37:39.580 --> 03:37:43.050 region:rollup2
ALLOWS FOR IF AND WHEN LANGUAGE
03:37:41.048 --> 03:37:44.385 region:rollup2
IF IT CONTINUES THEN IT WOULD BE
03:37:43.050 --> 03:37:45.819 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT DISCRIMINATION BUT NO
03:37:44.385 --> 03:37:47.988 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT OR DISCRIMINATION
03:37:45.819 --> 03:37:49.623 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY HAS TO BE PROVEN. SO AT
03:37:47.988 --> 03:37:50.758 region:rollup2
UNDER THIS BILL ANYONE CONSUMER
03:37:49.623 --> 03:37:52.092 region:rollup2
DOESN'T HAVE TO BE AN EMPLOYEE
03:37:50.758 --> 03:37:53.093 region:rollup2
IT CAN BE ANYONE IF THEY SEE
03:37:52.092 --> 03:37:54.528 region:rollup2
SOMETHING THEY DON'T LIKE THEY
03:37:53.093 --> 03:37:55.763 region:rollup2
CAN TELL IT TO THEIR EMPLOYER.
03:37:54.528 --> 03:37:57.398 region:rollup2
AND THEN THE EMPLOYER OR THEY
03:37:55.763 --> 03:37:58.899 region:rollup2
CAN TELL TO THE EMPLOYER NOT
03:37:57.398 --> 03:38:00.401 region:rollup2
THEIR EMPLOYER TO THE EMPLOYER
03:37:58.899 --> 03:38:01.535 region:rollup2
AND LET THEM KNOW THAT IT WAS
03:38:00.401 --> 03:38:02.336 region:rollup2
UNWELCOME TO THAT DOESN'T MEAN
03:38:01.535 --> 03:38:04.138 region:rollup2
THAT THE HARASSMENT HAS TO
03:38:02.336 --> 03:38:05.439 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY BE HAPPENING TO ANYONE
03:38:04.138 --> 03:38:07.041 region:rollup2
ELSE. RESEMBLED YOU SAW SOMEONE
03:38:05.439 --> 03:38:07.975 region:rollup2
GROUP SOMEONE ELSE YOU DIDN'T
03:38:07.041 --> 03:38:09.343 region:rollup2
KNOW THAT THEY WERE IN A
03:38:07.975 --> 03:38:11.378 region:rollup2
CONSENSUAL RELATIONSHIP PER
03:38:09.343 --> 03:38:12.913 region:rollup2
THAT'S PLAIN LANGUAGE OF THE
03:38:11.378 --> 03:38:13.681 region:rollup2
STATUTE ARE I MEAN OF THIS BILL
03:38:12.913 --> 03:38:14.949 region:rollup2
THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO FILE A
03:38:13.681 --> 03:38:15.783 region:rollup2
LAWSUIT IS BY NOTIFYING THE
03:38:14.949 --> 03:38:17.217 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER THAT IT WAS UNWELCOME
03:38:15.783 --> 03:38:18.586 region:rollup2
TO THEM REGARDLESS OF. THE
03:38:17.217 --> 03:38:20.187 region:rollup2
CONSENSUAL RELATIONSHIP DOES TO
03:38:18.586 --> 03:38:21.288 region:rollup2
KEEP INDIVIDUALS WERE AND AND
03:38:20.187 --> 03:38:22.423 region:rollup2
THIS WOULD CREATE A CRUSHING
03:38:21.288 --> 03:38:23.757 region:rollup2
AMOUNT OF LITIGATION THE COURTS
03:38:22.423 --> 03:38:24.625 region:rollup2
SHOULD NOT BE THE HUMAN
03:38:23.757 --> 03:38:26.460 region:rollup2
RESOURCES DEPARTMENT FOR THE
03:38:24.625 --> 03:38:27.728 region:rollup2
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THAT IS
03:38:26.460 --> 03:38:28.629 region:rollup2
WHAT HUMAN RESOURCES ARE FOR
03:38:27.728 --> 03:38:29.830 region:rollup2
THESE COMPLAINT SHOULD BE GOING
03:38:28.629 --> 03:38:33.100 region:rollup2
TO THE EMPLOYER THEY SHOULD BE
03:38:29.830 --> 03:38:34.268 region:rollup2
FOLLOWING THEIR DUTIES UNDER THE
03:38:33.100 --> 03:38:34.735 region:rollup2
LAW REGARDING HER AND PER
03:38:34.268 --> 03:38:35.269 region:rollup2
ENGINE OF PRESENT AND
03:38:34.735 --> 03:38:36.470 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION AND WHEN IT
03:38:35.269 --> 03:38:37.237 region:rollup2
REACHES A SEVERE AND PERVASIVE
03:38:36.470 --> 03:38:38.372 region:rollup2
STANDARD YES THE COURTS ACTUALLY
03:38:37.237 --> 03:38:39.106 region:rollup2
USE SHOULD STEP IN WE. DO NOT
03:38:38.372 --> 03:38:40.841 region:rollup2
CONDONE HARASSMENT
03:38:39.106 --> 03:38:41.909 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION BUT THE WAY THAT
03:38:40.841 --> 03:38:43.077 region:rollup2
THIS IS DRAFTED IT WILL CREATE A
03:38:41.909 --> 03:38:44.278 region:rollup2
CRUSHING MEN OF LITIGATION FOR
03:38:43.077 --> 03:38:44.878 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
03:38:44.278 --> 03:38:54.421 region:rollup2
THE OPPORTUNITY TODAY AND FOR
03:38:44.878 --> 03:38:56.390 region:rollup2
THE TIME OUTSIDE. IT IS OF
03:38:54.421 --> 03:38:57.124 region:rollup2
EVERYBODY'S BEEN DOING GREAT
03:38:56.390 --> 03:38:59.226 region:rollup2
THEY'RE ALL STAYING AT TWO
03:38:57.124 --> 03:39:00.561 region:rollup2
MINUTES I APPRECIATED THE VERY
03:38:59.226 --> 03:39:01.829 region:rollup2
QUICK WELL IF I COULD JUST ADD
03:39:00.561 --> 03:39:02.796 region:rollup2
TO MISS CURTIS'S COMMENTS MISTER
03:39:01.829 --> 03:39:06.533 region:rollup2
CHAIR I IF YOU. LOOK AT SECTION
03:39:02.796 --> 03:39:07.635 region:rollup2
TWO OF THE BILL SUBDIVISION QUE.
03:39:06.533 --> 03:39:09.103 region:rollup2
THE BILL IN ITS INITIAL FORM
03:39:07.635 --> 03:39:10.104 region:rollup2
ADDED THE SECOND SENTENCE THE
03:39:09.103 --> 03:39:10.671 region:rollup2
FIRST SENTENCES EXISTING LAW.
03:39:10.104 --> 03:39:11.872 region:rollup2
AND THEN THE MOST RECENT
03:39:10.671 --> 03:39:13.007 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS ADD THE THIRD
03:39:11.872 --> 03:39:14.274 region:rollup2
SENTENCE AND IF I COULD JUST.
03:39:13.007 --> 03:39:17.044 region:rollup2
GUIDE YOU TO IT.
03:39:14.274 --> 03:39:17.611 region:rollup2
CENTER JACKSON INDICATED THAT.
03:39:17.044 --> 03:39:19.146 region:rollup2
THE FIRST.
03:39:17.611 --> 03:39:20.914 region:rollup2
MAIN SECTION OF THIS BILL IS T
03:39:19.146 --> 03:39:22.649 region:rollup2
PROVIDE GUIDANCE TO THE COURTS
03:39:20.914 --> 03:39:24.685 region:rollup2
AND I'M GONNA. RESPECTFULLY
03:39:22.649 --> 03:39:27.321 region:rollup2
SUBMIT THAT BUT I THINK THAT
03:39:24.685 --> 03:39:29.123 region:rollup2
THERE'S A LOT OF AMBIGUITY IN
03:39:27.321 --> 03:39:30.324 region:rollup2
AND. FORGOTTEN SAID AND HERE'S
03:39:29.123 --> 03:39:31.792 region:rollup2
WHY. IF YOU READ THE SECOND
03:39:30.324 --> 03:39:33.460 region:rollup2
SENTENCE IT SAYS THE PLAINTIFF
03:39:31.792 --> 03:39:35.362 region:rollup2
IN AN ACTION ALLEGING UNLAWFUL
03:39:33.460 --> 03:39:36.830 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT PRACTICE IS NOT
03:39:35.362 --> 03:39:38.866 region:rollup2
REQUIRED TO PROVE THAT THE
03:39:36.830 --> 03:39:40.067 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF IN DIRT AND THEY'VE
03:39:38.866 --> 03:39:40.467 region:rollup2
STRUCK SEXUAL SO IT'S ONLY IT'S
03:39:40.067 --> 03:39:42.603 region:rollup2
ALL HARASSMENT OR
03:39:40.467 --> 03:39:43.470 region:rollup2
DISCRIMINATION.
03:39:42.603 --> 03:39:44.638 region:rollup2
SO IN THE FOR THE SECOND SENSE
03:39:43.470 --> 03:39:45.939 region:rollup2
WITH THE FIRST ONE ADDED BY THIS
03:39:44.638 --> 03:39:48.475 region:rollup2
BILL.
03:39:45.939 --> 03:39:49.576 region:rollup2
REQUIRES NO SHOWING OF HARM TO
03:39:48.475 --> 03:39:51.378 region:rollup2
THE INDIVIDUAL IS MISS CURTIS
03:39:49.576 --> 03:39:53.580 region:rollup2
INDICATED.
03:39:51.378 --> 03:39:54.782 region:rollup2
IN THE THIRD SENTENCE IT SAYS IT
03:39:53.580 --> 03:39:56.283 region:rollup2
SHALL SUFFICE TO THE FOR THE
03:39:54.782 --> 03:39:57.618 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF TO SHOW THAT THE
03:39:56.283 --> 03:40:00.854 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER KNEW THAT THE CONDUCT
03:39:57.618 --> 03:40:02.723 region:rollup2
WAS UNWELCOME TO THE PLAINTIFF.
03:40:00.854 --> 03:40:04.324 region:rollup2
SO THAT THIRD SENTENCE BEING
03:40:02.723 --> 03:40:05.125 region:rollup2
ADDED BY THE MOST RECENT AMENDED
03:40:04.324 --> 03:40:06.927 region:rollup2
VERSION.
03:40:05.125 --> 03:40:07.995 region:rollup2
SEEMS TO SAY THAT WELL NOW
03:40:06.927 --> 03:40:09.163 region:rollup2
YOU'VE GOT TO SHOW THAT IT WAS
03:40:07.995 --> 03:40:10.798 region:rollup2
ON WELCOME TO THAT INDIVIDUAL
03:40:09.163 --> 03:40:12.833 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF.
03:40:10.798 --> 03:40:15.903 region:rollup2
BUT AGAIN HAS THAT INDIVIDUAL
03:40:12.833 --> 03:40:17.237 region:rollup2
ACTUALLY BEEN IN SOME WAY.
03:40:15.903 --> 03:40:18.872 region:rollup2
HARASSED OR DISCRIMINATED
03:40:17.237 --> 03:40:20.674 region:rollup2
AGAINST.
03:40:18.872 --> 03:40:23.143 region:rollup2
OKAY SO I I THINK THERE'S PURE
03:40:20.674 --> 03:40:24.278 region:rollup2
LACK OF GUIDANCE TO THE COURTS
03:40:23.143 --> 03:40:26.013 region:rollup2
AND THERE'S A GREAT AMBIGUITY
03:40:24.278 --> 03:40:27.948 region:rollup2
BECAUSE THE FIRST.
03:40:26.013 --> 03:40:29.216 region:rollup2
ADDITION SAYS YOU DON'T HAVE TO
03:40:27.948 --> 03:40:30.751 region:rollup2
SHOW THAT YOU ENTERED ANY
03:40:29.216 --> 03:40:32.319 region:rollup2
HARASSMENT OR DISCRIMINATION.
03:40:30.751 --> 03:40:33.554 region:rollup2
BUT THEN IT SAYS THAT YOU HAD TO
03:40:32.319 --> 03:40:35.089 region:rollup2
SHOW WAS ON WELCOME TO THE
03:40:33.554 --> 03:40:37.024 region:rollup2
PLAINTIFF I DON'T KNOW HOW
03:40:35.089 --> 03:40:38.325 region:rollup2
THAT'S PROVIDING GUIDANCE. BUT
03:40:37.024 --> 03:40:40.060 region:rollup2
TO THE COURT WHETHER YOU'RE
03:40:38.325 --> 03:40:41.729 region:rollup2
CRITICAL OF THE SEVERE OR
03:40:40.060 --> 03:40:43.163 region:rollup2
PERVASIVE STANDARD THAT HAS BEEN
03:40:41.729 --> 03:40:44.264 region:rollup2
UTILIZED.
03:40:43.163 --> 03:40:45.365 region:rollup2
THE OTHER THING IS THAT IN
03:40:44.264 --> 03:40:47.768 region:rollup2
SECTION FOUR I THINK WE
03:40:45.365 --> 03:40:49.570 region:rollup2
RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH.
03:40:47.768 --> 03:40:51.538 region:rollup2
THE PROPONENTS WE THINK THAT.
03:40:49.570 --> 03:40:53.240 region:rollup2
.
03:40:51.538 --> 03:40:55.242 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW DISPARAGEMENT CLAUSES
03:40:53.240 --> 03:40:57.444 region:rollup2
ARE GOING TO HAVE AN ADVERSE
03:40:55.242 --> 03:40:58.445 region:rollup2
IMPACT ON POTENTIAL SETTLEMENTS
03:40:57.444 --> 03:40:59.680 region:rollup2
AND WE THINK THAT THERE'S AS
03:40:58.445 --> 03:41:01.682 region:rollup2
WE'VE REYES WAS CENTER JACKSON
03:40:59.680 --> 03:41:03.317 region:rollup2
AND HER STAFF. A CONCERNED ABOUT
03:41:01.682 --> 03:41:04.384 region:rollup2
BUSINESSES THAT ENGAGE IN SELF
03:41:03.317 --> 03:41:05.686 region:rollup2
AUDITS.
03:41:04.384 --> 03:41:07.788 region:rollup2
AND YESTERDAY WE HAD.
03:41:05.686 --> 03:41:08.989 region:rollup2
CONTINUE DISCUSSIONS AND WE DO
03:41:07.788 --> 03:41:11.091 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE THE TIME THAT CENTER
03:41:08.989 --> 03:41:13.594 region:rollup2
JACKSON AND HER STAFF AND
03:41:11.091 --> 03:41:14.728 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE COUNCILMAN.
03:41:13.594 --> 03:41:15.963 region:rollup2
BLESS YOU SENATOR I HAVE
03:41:14.728 --> 03:41:18.031 region:rollup2
PROVIDED TO US THE LASSES IN
03:41:15.963 --> 03:41:19.666 region:rollup2
SECTION FIVE IN SUBDIVISION
03:41:18.031 --> 03:41:20.934 region:rollup2
INCLUSION.
03:41:19.666 --> 03:41:23.036 region:rollup2
VERY QUICK CONCLUSION WE HAVE
03:41:20.934 --> 03:41:24.571 region:rollup2
CONCERNS ABOUT THE EXCEPTION THE
03:41:23.036 --> 03:41:26.573 region:rollup2
NOTWITHSTANDING SECTION NINE
03:41:24.571 --> 03:41:28.075 region:rollup2
NINE NEED OF THE CIVIL CODE AND
03:41:26.573 --> 03:41:30.177 region:rollup2
IMPOSING THE VERY STRONG HOW
03:41:28.075 --> 03:41:31.779 region:rollup2
HEAVY. STANDARD ON THE AWARD OF
03:41:30.177 --> 03:41:33.680 region:rollup2
ATTORNEY'S FEES TO DEFENDANTS IN
03:41:31.779 --> 03:41:37.050 region:rollup2
THESE ACTIONS
03:41:33.680 --> 03:41:37.584 region:rollup2
I GARY MUCH.
03:41:37.050 --> 03:41:41.155 region:rollup2
WE HAVE OTHER WITNESSES IN
03:41:37.584 --> 03:41:42.890 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION.
03:41:41.155 --> 03:41:44.791 region:rollup2
FRIDAY.
03:41:42.890 --> 03:41:45.492 region:rollup2
SO ONCE AGAIN NICOLE RICE
03:41:44.791 --> 03:41:47.794 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURES A
03:41:45.492 --> 03:41:49.263 region:rollup2
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION WE ARE IN
03:41:47.794 --> 03:41:51.832 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL FOR THE
03:41:49.263 --> 03:41:54.067 region:rollup2
REASONS STATED. BUT WE HAVE ALSO
03:41:51.832 --> 03:41:55.736 region:rollup2
AND RAISED AN ADDITIONAL POINT
03:41:54.067 --> 03:41:56.904 region:rollup2
THAT I JUST LIKE TO BRIEFLY I'M
03:41:55.736 --> 03:42:00.474 region:rollup2
PUT BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ABOUT
03:41:56.904 --> 03:42:01.675 region:rollup2
THIRTY SECONDS THIRTY SECONDS
03:42:00.474 --> 03:42:02.709 region:rollup2
HEARING THOUGH. OKAY.
03:42:01.675 --> 03:42:04.778 region:rollup2
SO ARE ISSUE HAS TO DO WITH THE
03:42:02.709 --> 03:42:06.980 region:rollup2
BYSTANDER INTERVENTION TRAINING
03:42:04.778 --> 03:42:09.483 region:rollup2
AND HOW CREATING A SEPARATE
03:42:06.980 --> 03:42:11.318 region:rollup2
INDEPENDENT TRAINING REQUIREMENT
03:42:09.483 --> 03:42:13.020 region:rollup2
WILL EXTEND LIABILITY TO
03:42:11.318 --> 03:42:14.655 region:rollup2
EMPLOYERS AND AND SPECIFICALLY
03:42:13.020 --> 03:42:15.789 region:rollup2
IN OUR CASE IN MANUFACTURING. WE
03:42:14.655 --> 03:42:18.392 region:rollup2
THINK THAT IT'S AN APPROPRIATE
03:42:15.789 --> 03:42:19.760 region:rollup2
ROLE FOR THE EMPLOYER TO INFORM
03:42:18.392 --> 03:42:21.662 region:rollup2
THEIR EMPLOYEES ON HOW TO
03:42:19.760 --> 03:42:22.396 region:rollup2
IDENTIFY SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND
03:42:21.662 --> 03:42:24.398 region:rollup2
OTHER GRASSROOTS IN THE
03:42:22.396 --> 03:42:26.600 region:rollup2
WORKPLACE. AND ALSO TO GIVE THEM
03:42:24.398 --> 03:42:28.635 region:rollup2
INFORMATION RELATED TO REPORTING
03:42:26.600 --> 03:42:30.771 region:rollup2
THAT ACTIVITY UP THROUGH A SOUP
03:42:28.635 --> 03:42:33.841 region:rollup2
OF HIS ORIEL TRAIN. HOWEVER WE
03:42:30.771 --> 03:42:35.542 region:rollup2
DON'T AGREE WITH.
03:42:33.841 --> 03:42:38.312 region:rollup2
WHO MOTIVATING AND ENCOURAGING
03:42:35.542 --> 03:42:39.947 region:rollup2
INDIVIDUALS TO ENGAGE IN THESE
03:42:38.312 --> 03:42:41.715 region:rollup2
POTENTIALLY HOSTILE SITUATIONS
03:42:39.947 --> 03:42:42.549 region:rollup2
BECAUSE WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT
03:42:41.715 --> 03:42:44.618 region:rollup2
THE LIE BELIEVE THAT COULD
03:42:42.549 --> 03:42:46.553 region:rollup2
EXTEND NOT ONLY TO THE EMPLOYER
03:42:44.618 --> 03:42:48.322 region:rollup2
BUT ALSO TO THE EMPLOYEES? AND
03:42:46.553 --> 03:42:50.691 region:rollup2
CO WORKERS THAT THEY'VE COME TO
03:42:48.322 --> 03:42:52.159 region:rollup2
THE ADA SO FOR THOSE REASONS WE
03:42:50.691 --> 03:42:54.561 region:rollup2
HAVE ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION THANK
03:42:52.159 --> 03:42:56.630 region:rollup2
YOU.
03:42:54.561 --> 03:42:59.533 region:rollup2
PAGE BACK TO NORMAL A NAME
03:42:56.630 --> 03:43:00.167 region:rollup2
ORGANIZATIONS. JOHN LEWIS THE
03:42:59.533 --> 03:43:00.634 region:rollup2
NATIONAL FEDERATION OF
03:43:00.167 --> 03:43:01.602 region:rollup2
INDEPENDENT BUSINESS
03:43:00.634 --> 03:43:03.303 region:rollup2
REPRESENTING SMALL BUSINESS
03:43:01.602 --> 03:43:04.805 region:rollup2
OWNERS FOR WHOM LITIGATION IS A
03:43:03.303 --> 03:43:08.308 region:rollup2
SERIOUS ISSUE ALSO OPPOSED.
03:43:04.805 --> 03:43:09.176 region:rollup2
THE SEXUAL HARASSMENT.
03:43:08.308 --> 03:43:10.077 region:rollup2
KATIE HANSON OF THE CALIFORNIA
03:43:09.176 --> 03:43:14.748 region:rollup2
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION WERE HERE
03:43:10.077 --> 03:43:15.549 region:rollup2
IN OPPOSITION.
03:43:14.748 --> 03:43:19.586 region:rollup2
BRIAN LITTLE CALIFORNIA FARM
03:43:15.549 --> 03:43:21.054 region:rollup2
BUREAU FEDERATION OPPOSITION.
03:43:19.586 --> 03:43:22.656 region:rollup2
MIKE FOLLOWED FOR THE CALIFORNIA
03:43:21.054 --> 03:43:23.957 region:rollup2
EMPLOYMENT LAW COUNCIL. HAVE
03:43:22.656 --> 03:43:26.360 region:rollup2
ALSO BEEN ASKED TO INDICATE THAT
03:43:23.957 --> 03:43:27.694 region:rollup2
THE CIVIL JUSTICE ASSOCIATION OF
03:43:26.360 --> 03:43:29.096 region:rollup2
CALIFORNIA'S SUPPOSED THANK YOU.
03:43:27.694 --> 03:43:30.430 region:rollup2
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
03:43:29.096 --> 03:43:36.169 region:rollup2
OPPOSITION. COLLEAGUES ANY
03:43:30.430 --> 03:43:37.170 region:rollup2
QUESTIONS.
03:43:36.169 --> 03:43:39.473 region:rollup2
DO I HAVE A MOTION.
03:43:37.170 --> 03:43:41.341 region:rollup2
SOME OF.
03:43:39.473 --> 03:43:43.377 region:rollup2
YOU I HAVE A CLOSING STATEMENT
03:43:41.341 --> 03:43:45.746 region:rollup2
YES FOR A VERY BRIEFLY.
03:43:43.377 --> 03:43:47.080 region:rollup2
.
03:43:45.746 --> 03:43:48.415 region:rollup2
YOU KNOW WE'RE TRYING VERY HARD
03:43:47.080 --> 03:43:50.350 region:rollup2
TO WORK OUT WHAT I THINK ARE
03:43:48.415 --> 03:43:52.953 region:rollup2
FAIR AND REASONABLE CONCERNS BY
03:43:50.350 --> 03:43:54.821 region:rollup2
THE OPPOSITION I WILL CONTINUE.
03:43:52.953 --> 03:43:55.656 region:rollup2
TO DO SO AND.
03:43:54.821 --> 03:43:57.891 region:rollup2
WORKING CLOSELY WITH THE.
03:43:55.656 --> 03:43:59.593 region:rollup2
.
03:43:57.891 --> 03:44:02.262 region:rollup2
SPONSORS OF THE BILL.
03:43:59.593 --> 03:44:04.464 region:rollup2
I. DON'T QUITE UNDERSTAND THIS
03:44:02.262 --> 03:44:06.266 region:rollup2
CONCERN ABOUT THAT YOU DON'T
03:44:04.464 --> 03:44:08.935 region:rollup2
HAVE TO BE A YEAH.
03:44:06.266 --> 03:44:10.470 region:rollup2
A PLAINTIFF TO INACTION.
03:44:08.935 --> 03:44:12.773 region:rollup2
OR THAT SOMEONE TO WHOM THIS
03:44:10.470 --> 03:44:13.006 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR HAS OCCURRED WE'VE GOT
03:44:12.773 --> 03:44:14.474 region:rollup2
IN HERE.
03:44:13.006 --> 03:44:16.176 region:rollup2
.
03:44:14.474 --> 03:44:17.210 region:rollup2
AT THAT THE IT SHALL SUFFICE FOR
03:44:16.176 --> 03:44:19.146 region:rollup2
THE PLAINTIFF TO SHOW THE
03:44:17.210 --> 03:44:20.948 region:rollup2
EMPLOYER KNEW THAT THE CONDUCT
03:44:19.146 --> 03:44:22.582 region:rollup2
WAS UNWELCOME TO THE PLAINTIFF.
03:44:20.948 --> 03:44:24.217 region:rollup2
SO NOT TO SOME THIRD PARTY TO
03:44:22.582 --> 03:44:25.686 region:rollup2
THE PLAINTIFF THAT THE CONDUCT
03:44:24.217 --> 03:44:27.821 region:rollup2
WOULD MEET THE LEGAL STANDARD
03:44:25.686 --> 03:44:29.790 region:rollup2
FOR HARASSMENT OR DISCRIMINATION
03:44:27.821 --> 03:44:32.225 region:rollup2
IF INCREASED AND SEVERITY AND
03:44:29.790 --> 03:44:33.560 region:rollup2
BECAME OR BECAME PERVASIVE. AND
03:44:32.225 --> 03:44:34.861 region:rollup2
THAT THE DEFENDANT FAILED TO
03:44:33.560 --> 03:44:36.563 region:rollup2
TAKE ALL REASONABLE STEPS TO
03:44:34.861 --> 03:44:38.598 region:rollup2
PREVENT THE SAME OR SIMILAR
03:44:36.563 --> 03:44:39.1000 region:rollup2
CONDUCT FROM OCURRING. THOUGH
03:44:38.598 --> 03:44:41.802 region:rollup2
THAT IS AN AMENDMENT WE TOOK SO
03:44:39.1000 --> 03:44:44.671 region:rollup2
I'M ASSUMING THAT CONCERN WAS
03:44:41.802 --> 03:44:46.473 region:rollup2
FOR PRIOR LANGUAGE. BUT THE ONLY
03:44:44.671 --> 03:44:48.976 region:rollup2
SOMEONE WHO IS AN AGGRIEVED
03:44:46.473 --> 03:44:50.644 region:rollup2
PARTY CAN SO THAT'S OF STANDING
03:44:48.976 --> 03:44:51.712 region:rollup2
ISSUE AND AND YOU'VE GOT TO BE
03:44:50.644 --> 03:44:54.314 region:rollup2
HAVE BEEN.
03:44:51.712 --> 03:44:56.083 region:rollup2
THE RECIPIENT OF THE HARASSING
03:44:54.314 --> 03:44:56.850 region:rollup2
BEHAVIOR.
03:44:56.083 --> 03:44:58.552 region:rollup2
THE.
03:44:56.850 --> 03:44:58.719 region:rollup2
LET'S SEE WHAT WAS THE OTHER
03:44:58.552 --> 03:45:01.288 region:rollup2
ONE.
03:44:58.719 --> 03:45:05.058 region:rollup2
.
03:45:01.288 --> 03:45:07.194 region:rollup2
THE SETTLEMENT ISSUE BUT THIS IS
03:45:05.058 --> 03:45:08.295 region:rollup2
NOT A BILL ABOUT.
03:45:07.194 --> 03:45:10.764 region:rollup2
AGREEMENTS XIN SETTLEMENT NON
03:45:08.295 --> 03:45:12.666 region:rollup2
DISCLOSURE AGREEMENTS THIS IS
03:45:10.764 --> 03:45:15.135 region:rollup2
ABOUT DISPARAGEMENT.
03:45:12.666 --> 03:45:16.670 region:rollup2
THIS OCCURS Y. YOU ARE STILL IN
03:45:15.135 --> 03:45:19.106 region:rollup2
EMPLOYEES.
03:45:16.670 --> 03:45:20.741 region:rollup2
SO THE SETTLEMENT ISSUE I THINK
03:45:19.106 --> 03:45:22.542 region:rollup2
SENATOR LEYVA HAS A BILL ON THAT
03:45:20.741 --> 03:45:24.544 region:rollup2
THIS IS ABOUT AND IN THE WHAT
03:45:22.542 --> 03:45:27.681 region:rollup2
THIS WOMAN COULDN'T TALK ABOUT.
03:45:24.544 --> 03:45:29.649 region:rollup2
WAS EXTRAORDINARY HARASSMENT.
03:45:27.681 --> 03:45:31.518 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT THAT SHE
03:45:29.649 --> 03:45:34.021 region:rollup2
INCURRED DURING THE LIMITED FOR
03:45:31.518 --> 03:45:35.856 region:rollup2
MONTHS THAT SHE WAS EMPLOYED BY
03:45:34.021 --> 03:45:37.924 region:rollup2
A SCOUNDREL WHOSE COMPANY IS
03:45:35.856 --> 03:45:40.093 region:rollup2
GONE OUT OF BUSINESS.
03:45:37.924 --> 03:45:42.462 region:rollup2
AFTER FINALLY HIT THIS PATTERN
03:45:40.093 --> 03:45:42.829 region:rollup2
OF BEHAVIOR.
03:45:42.462 --> 03:45:44.564 region:rollup2
THAT.
03:45:42.829 --> 03:45:46.266 region:rollup2
AND SHE CAN APPARENTLY CANNOT
03:45:44.564 --> 03:45:48.468 region:rollup2
DISCUSS IT.
03:45:46.266 --> 03:45:50.470 region:rollup2
IT WILL KEEP THE GENERAL.
03:45:48.468 --> 03:45:52.906 region:rollup2
PARA AND DID THIS IS SORT OF A
03:45:50.470 --> 03:45:54.541 region:rollup2
HARVEY WEINSTEIN TYPE SITUATION.
03:45:52.906 --> 03:45:56.410 region:rollup2
AND THERE ARE SO DARN MANY OF
03:45:54.541 --> 03:45:58.845 region:rollup2
THESE AND ONE YOUNG WOMEN IN
03:45:56.410 --> 03:46:01.581 region:rollup2
PARTICULAR. EIGHTEEN NINETEEN
03:45:58.845 --> 03:46:03.717 region:rollup2
YEARS OLD THEIR FIRST JOBS.
03:46:01.581 --> 03:46:04.351 region:rollup2
ARE WORKING FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE
03:46:03.717 --> 03:46:07.020 region:rollup2
KNOWN.
03:46:04.351 --> 03:46:10.090 region:rollup2
ABUSERS.
03:46:07.020 --> 03:46:12.025 region:rollup2
AND THEY CANNOT TALK ABOUT THIS
03:46:10.090 --> 03:46:16.430 region:rollup2
OR THEY'VE GIVEN UP THEIR RIGHTS
03:46:12.025 --> 03:46:17.964 region:rollup2
IN EXCHANGE FOR A SMALL RAISE
03:46:16.430 --> 03:46:18.865 region:rollup2
OVER A SMALL BONUS IN A PIECE OF
03:46:17.964 --> 03:46:19.366 region:rollup2
PAPER O. SIGN HERE AND THAT'S
03:46:18.865 --> 03:46:21.368 region:rollup2
WHY WE CALL THEM SNEAKY
03:46:19.366 --> 03:46:22.469 region:rollup2
RELEASES.
03:46:21.368 --> 03:46:24.905 region:rollup2
WE GOTTA STOP THE ACT
03:46:22.469 --> 03:46:26.406 region:rollup2
SO THIS IS NOT ABOUT SETTLEMENT
03:46:24.905 --> 03:46:28.341 region:rollup2
AGREEMENTS ASSIST ARE GOING TO
03:46:26.406 --> 03:46:30.444 region:rollup2
IMPEDE ANY OF THIS SIZE. EFFORT
03:46:28.341 --> 03:46:31.845 region:rollup2
TO SETTLE CASES AND I WILL
03:46:30.444 --> 03:46:33.447 region:rollup2
COMMIT I GOTTA I DON'T TOTALLY
03:46:31.845 --> 03:46:35.115 region:rollup2
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE CONCERN WAS
03:46:33.447 --> 03:46:36.583 region:rollup2
I THINK WE'VE ADDRESSED IT BUT
03:46:35.115 --> 03:46:38.051 region:rollup2
I'M CERTAINLY.
03:46:36.583 --> 03:46:40.053 region:rollup2
WILLING IN AND COMMITTED. TO
03:46:38.051 --> 03:46:40.454 region:rollup2
WORKING WITH THE OPPOSITION HERE
03:46:40.053 --> 03:46:42.556 region:rollup2
SO THAT.
03:46:40.454 --> 03:46:44.591 region:rollup2
I DON'T THINK WE'LL EVER GET
03:46:42.556 --> 03:46:46.293 region:rollup2
THEIR SUPPORT BUT I THINK THAT
03:46:44.591 --> 03:46:49.663 region:rollup2
WE CAN MAKE THIS A GOOD BILL TO
03:46:46.293 --> 03:46:51.364 region:rollup2
PROTECT AGAINST THIS. SYSTEMIC
03:46:49.663 --> 03:46:53.033 region:rollup2
SEXUAL HARASSMENT THAT WE ARE
03:46:51.364 --> 03:46:53.633 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCING AND THAT THESE
03:46:53.033 --> 03:46:55.836 region:rollup2
BRAVE WOMEN AND MEN HAVE COME
03:46:53.633 --> 03:46:57.571 region:rollup2
UP.
03:46:55.836 --> 03:46:58.738 region:rollup2
AND TALKED ABOUT IN THEIR LIFE
03:46:57.571 --> 03:47:00.006 region:rollup2
EXPERIENCE WE'VE GOT TO DO
03:46:58.738 --> 03:47:01.608 region:rollup2
BETTER WITH THAT I WOULD ASK FOR
03:47:00.006 --> 03:47:03.677 region:rollup2
YOUR VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR
03:47:01.608 --> 03:47:05.112 region:rollup2
JACKSON I JUST WANT TO MAKE ONE
03:47:03.677 --> 03:47:07.047 region:rollup2
OBSERVATION AND THAT IS THAT I
03:47:05.112 --> 03:47:09.382 region:rollup2
APPRECIATE. THE SPIRIT AND
03:47:07.047 --> 03:47:10.617 region:rollup2
EVERYTHING YOU'RE TRYING TO DO.
03:47:09.382 --> 03:47:11.384 region:rollup2
I JUST FEEL THAT.
03:47:10.617 --> 03:47:13.453 region:rollup2
OF THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY IS
03:47:11.384 --> 03:47:15.088 region:rollup2
STILL THERE STILL A DIVIDE HERE
03:47:13.453 --> 03:47:15.789 region:rollup2
AND I'LL BE VOTING NO JUST LIKE
03:47:15.088 --> 03:47:17.290 region:rollup2
IT DID IN THE LAST BILL FOR THAT
03:47:15.789 --> 03:47:18.758 region:rollup2
PURPOSE. AND IF YOU CAN BRING
03:47:17.290 --> 03:47:19.793 region:rollup2
THIS UP AND AND GET THEIR
03:47:18.758 --> 03:47:21.294 region:rollup2
AGREEMENT EVEN THOUGH YOUR THAT
03:47:19.793 --> 03:47:22.729 region:rollup2
SKEPTICAL YOUR SKEPTICAL ABOUT
03:47:21.294 --> 03:47:23.830 region:rollup2
THAT BUT I I'LL BE THERE THERE
03:47:22.729 --> 03:47:24.998 region:rollup2
THERE.
03:47:23.830 --> 03:47:25.565 region:rollup2
SO DRIVE A MOTION OR TO THE
03:47:24.998 --> 03:47:26.600 region:rollup2
EFFORT.
03:47:25.565 --> 03:47:30.003 region:rollup2
I HAVE.
03:47:26.600 --> 03:47:33.974 region:rollup2
TO MOTIONS.
03:47:30.003 --> 03:47:34.608 region:rollup2
I RIGHT BECAUSE GIVE MOVES.
03:47:33.974 --> 03:47:35.675 region:rollup2
AND MADAM CLERK I WANT TO READ
03:47:34.608 --> 03:47:36.376 region:rollup2
THE ROLE.
03:47:35.675 --> 03:47:38.478 region:rollup2
THE MOTION IS THE PASTOR
03:47:36.376 --> 03:47:40.514 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATIONS JACKSON AYE
03:47:38.478 --> 03:47:41.948 region:rollup2
JACKSON AYE MORE LOCK NO BLOCK
03:47:40.514 --> 03:47:44.484 region:rollup2
NO ANDERSON.
03:47:41.948 --> 03:47:47.053 region:rollup2
ANDERSON NO HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
03:47:44.484 --> 03:47:50.056 region:rollup2
AYE MONNING. MONNING AYE STERN
03:47:47.053 --> 03:47:51.124 region:rollup2
STERN AYE WIECKOWSKI.
03:47:50.056 --> 03:47:53.326 region:rollup2
I WAY BECAUSE HE AYE MOVE THE
03:47:51.124 --> 03:47:55.996 region:rollup2
CONSENT CALENDAR.
03:47:53.326 --> 03:47:57.664 region:rollup2
I THINK WE HAVE A FIVE TWO THAT
03:47:55.996 --> 03:48:00.767 region:rollup2
WE WILL EVEN MOVED TO CALL ON
03:47:57.664 --> 03:48:02.602 region:rollup2
THAT WERE DONE THANK YOU.
03:48:00.767 --> 03:48:03.837 region:rollup2
THEN I WHAT THE CHAIR.
03:48:02.602 --> 03:48:10.443 region:rollup2
AND CALENDAR. AND ALL THE
03:48:03.837 --> 03:48:12.078 region:rollup2
REMAINING.
03:48:10.443 --> 03:48:13.980 region:rollup2
SO TO BE CLEAR ON A FIVE TO VOTE
03:48:12.078 --> 03:48:14.948 region:rollup2
THAT BILL IS SO.
03:48:13.980 --> 03:48:16.616 region:rollup2
LET US GO BACK CALL THE
03:48:14.948 --> 03:48:18.418 region:rollup2
CONCERNED COUNTY WE HAVE A
03:48:16.616 --> 03:48:20.487 region:rollup2
MOTION BY SENATOR WIECKOSKI.
03:48:18.418 --> 03:48:22.722 region:rollup2
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
03:48:20.487 --> 03:48:25.292 region:rollup2
JACKSON HIGH JACKSON I AM MORE
03:48:22.722 --> 03:48:27.794 region:rollup2
LOCK BLACK AYE ANDERSON ANDERSON
03:48:25.292 --> 03:48:30.931 region:rollup2
AYE HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG AYE
03:48:27.794 --> 03:48:32.866 region:rollup2
MONNING. MONNING AYE STERN STERN
03:48:30.931 --> 03:48:34.434 region:rollup2
AYE WIECKOWSKI.
03:48:32.866 --> 03:48:35.468 region:rollup2
BECAUSE HE AYE INCIDENT
03:48:34.434 --> 03:48:36.336 region:rollup2
CALENDARS SHOUTS SHIPMENT IS
03:48:35.468 --> 03:48:37.571 region:rollup2
HERO WE'RE GOING TO GO THROUGH
03:48:36.336 --> 03:48:39.873 region:rollup2
THE ROLE ONE TIME.
03:48:37.571 --> 03:48:42.776 region:rollup2
AND TO OPEN THE ROLE FOR ABSENT
03:48:39.873 --> 03:48:46.546 region:rollup2
MEMBERS ON FILE ITEM.
03:48:42.776 --> 03:48:47.180 region:rollup2
TO AND THE MOTION IS A TO PASS
03:48:46.546 --> 03:48:49.115 region:rollup2
TO.
03:48:47.180 --> 03:48:51.184 region:rollup2
TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING WITH
03:48:49.115 --> 03:48:52.219 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS TO BE TAKEN IN THAT
03:48:51.184 --> 03:48:54.621 region:rollup2
COMMITTEE.
03:48:52.219 --> 03:48:56.256 region:rollup2
THE VOTE COUNT IS THREE ZERO
03:48:54.621 --> 03:48:58.458 region:rollup2
THE CHAIR VOTING AYE PLEASE CALL
03:48:56.256 --> 03:49:00.427 region:rollup2
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:48:58.458 --> 03:49:02.629 region:rollup2
BLOCK. MORE LIKE NO ANDERSON
03:49:00.427 --> 03:49:05.231 region:rollup2
ANDERSON NO HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
03:49:02.629 --> 03:49:08.034 region:rollup2
AYE MONNING. MONNING AYE FIVE TO
03:49:05.231 --> 03:49:10.070 region:rollup2
TO THE BILL IS OUT NEXT IS FILE
03:49:08.034 --> 03:49:11.738 region:rollup2
ITEM FIVE IT'S BE TEN THIRTY
03:49:10.070 --> 03:49:14.207 region:rollup2
EIGHT THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
03:49:11.738 --> 03:49:16.409 region:rollup2
AS AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
03:49:14.207 --> 03:49:18.712 region:rollup2
VOTE COUNT IS THREE TO ZERO THE
03:49:16.409 --> 03:49:20.513 region:rollup2
CHAIR VOTING AYE PLEASE CALL THE
03:49:18.712 --> 03:49:23.483 region:rollup2
ABSENT MEMBERS BUT A LOT. MORE
03:49:20.513 --> 03:49:24.684 region:rollup2
LIKE NO ANDERSON. ANDERSON NO
03:49:23.483 --> 03:49:25.719 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG.
03:49:24.684 --> 03:49:29.689 region:rollup2
MORNING.
03:49:25.719 --> 03:49:32.025 region:rollup2
MONNING I.
03:49:29.689 --> 03:49:34.027 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT THE OF THE BILL SHALL
03:49:32.025 --> 03:49:37.030 region:rollup2
FORWARD TO.
03:49:34.027 --> 03:49:39.566 region:rollup2
NEXT A BILL UP IS FILE ITEM SIX
03:49:37.030 --> 03:49:41.167 region:rollup2
S. B. TEN FORTY FIVE.
03:49:39.566 --> 03:49:43.336 region:rollup2
OF THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
03:49:41.167 --> 03:49:45.438 region:rollup2
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE WITH THE
03:49:43.336 --> 03:49:46.573 region:rollup2
AMENDMENTS TO BE TAKEN THERE.
03:49:45.438 --> 03:49:49.175 region:rollup2
THE VOTE COUNT IS FOUR ZERO THE
03:49:46.573 --> 03:49:51.211 region:rollup2
CHAIR VOTING AYE PLEASE CALL THE
03:49:49.175 --> 03:49:53.179 region:rollup2
ABSENT MEMBERS ANDERSON.
03:49:51.211 --> 03:49:55.015 region:rollup2
ANDERSON NO HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG
03:49:53.179 --> 03:49:56.983 region:rollup2
AYE STERN.
03:49:55.015 --> 03:49:59.285 region:rollup2
STERN AYE ALRIGHT SIX TWO ONE
03:49:56.983 --> 03:50:03.690 region:rollup2
THAT BILL IS OUT NEXT ITEM IS
03:49:59.285 --> 03:50:05.725 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM.
03:50:03.690 --> 03:50:07.427 region:rollup2
EIGHT S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX
03:50:05.725 --> 03:50:09.529 region:rollup2
THE MOTION IS TO PASS IS AMENDED
03:50:07.427 --> 03:50:11.564 region:rollup2
TO APPROPRIATIONS THE VOTE COUNT
03:50:09.529 --> 03:50:12.666 region:rollup2
IS THREE TO ONE THE CHAIR VOTING
03:50:11.564 --> 03:50:14.734 region:rollup2
AYE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
03:50:12.666 --> 03:50:16.736 region:rollup2
MEMBERS. ANDERSON.
03:50:14.734 --> 03:50:18.171 region:rollup2
ANDERSON AYE HERTZBERG.
03:50:16.736 --> 03:50:21.708 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG AYE STERN.
03:50:18.171 --> 03:50:23.209 region:rollup2
STERN I.
03:50:21.708 --> 03:50:25.345 region:rollup2
LET ME SIX.
03:50:23.209 --> 03:50:29.983 region:rollup2
YEAH ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX ARE A BIT
03:50:25.345 --> 03:50:31.751 region:rollup2
WELL.
03:50:29.983 --> 03:50:35.055 region:rollup2
HE IS VICE.
03:50:31.751 --> 03:50:38.892 region:rollup2
SORRY.
03:50:35.055 --> 03:50:42.328 region:rollup2
NO NO NO EARLY ON SORRY INSTEAD
03:50:38.892 --> 03:50:43.730 region:rollup2
IS IF THAT WAS YOU KNOW THIS IS
03:50:42.328 --> 03:50:47.233 region:rollup2
SENATOR HILLSVILLE.
03:50:43.730 --> 03:50:51.104 region:rollup2
HELLO I'M SORRY THIS IS.
03:50:47.233 --> 03:50:54.274 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM DATE.
03:50:51.104 --> 03:50:54.641 region:rollup2
HARD TO KILL ME TOO. WRITERS
03:50:54.274 --> 03:50:57.944 region:rollup2
WILL DISAPPEAR.
03:50:54.641 --> 03:51:00.013 region:rollup2
DID.
03:50:57.944 --> 03:51:02.082 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT SO. TIGHT HEADLINING ACT
03:51:00.013 --> 03:51:02.282 region:rollup2
LET'S SO LET'S EXPUNGE THE ROLE.
03:51:02.082 --> 03:51:03.717 region:rollup2
AND.
03:51:02.282 --> 03:51:04.451 region:rollup2
WE WILL.
03:51:03.717 --> 03:51:06.286 region:rollup2
RE VOTE ON.
03:51:04.451 --> 03:51:07.787 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM EIGHT WITCHES S. B.
03:51:06.286 --> 03:51:08.154 region:rollup2
ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX.
03:51:07.787 --> 03:51:10.223 region:rollup2
AND.
03:51:08.154 --> 03:51:12.525 region:rollup2
BUT SEE WE DON'T HAVE TO HAVE A
03:51:10.223 --> 03:51:14.227 region:rollup2
MOTION TO DO THAT DOING.
03:51:12.525 --> 03:51:15.528 region:rollup2
TO EXPUNGE THE ORANGE PRIVATE
03:51:14.227 --> 03:51:16.496 region:rollup2
RESPOND WELL AS LONG AS IT IS
03:51:15.528 --> 03:51:17.363 region:rollup2
I'M HAPPY TO DO IT ALRIGHT SO
03:51:16.496 --> 03:51:18.565 region:rollup2
WE'LL EXPUNGE THE ROLE.
03:51:17.363 --> 03:51:20.567 region:rollup2
AND CALL.
03:51:18.565 --> 03:51:22.502 region:rollup2
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:51:20.567 --> 03:51:23.503 region:rollup2
ON A FILE ITEM A TWO PASSES
03:51:22.502 --> 03:51:24.003 region:rollup2
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
03:51:23.503 --> 03:51:25.372 region:rollup2
A PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
03:51:24.003 --> 03:51:26.339 region:rollup2
MEMBERS.
03:51:25.372 --> 03:51:29.642 region:rollup2
ANDERSON NO ANDERSON NO.
03:51:26.339 --> 03:51:31.277 region:rollup2
STERN.
03:51:29.642 --> 03:51:33.813 region:rollup2
BY THE VOTE COUNT IS.
03:51:31.277 --> 03:51:35.415 region:rollup2
FOR.
03:51:33.813 --> 03:51:37.517 region:rollup2
FOUR TO ONE AND THAT BILL IS
03:51:35.415 --> 03:51:39.285 region:rollup2
SHAFT.
03:51:37.517 --> 03:51:40.887 region:rollup2
IT SHOULD BE FORTY TO FORTY TWO
03:51:39.285 --> 03:51:44.190 region:rollup2
THAT BILL IS AFTER.
03:51:40.887 --> 03:51:47.327 region:rollup2
SAID.
03:51:44.190 --> 03:51:50.230 region:rollup2
AND WE HAVE.
03:51:47.327 --> 03:51:51.731 region:rollup2
TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR IS OUT.
03:51:50.230 --> 03:51:53.266 region:rollup2
BUT LET'S GO AHEAD AND CALL THE
03:51:51.731 --> 03:51:54.334 region:rollup2
ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:51:53.266 --> 03:51:56.536 region:rollup2
TWELVE EIGHTY FOUR THE VOTE
03:51:54.334 --> 03:51:58.805 region:rollup2
COUNT IS FIVE TWO ONE PLEASE
03:51:56.536 --> 03:52:00.340 region:rollup2
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:51:58.805 --> 03:52:11.417 region:rollup2
ANDERSON. ANDERSON NOW BUT FIVE
03:52:00.340 --> 03:52:12.352 region:rollup2
TO TWO.
03:52:11.417 --> 03:52:13.319 region:rollup2
I THINK WE GOT EVERYBODY ON THAT
03:52:12.352 --> 03:52:14.554 region:rollup2
ONE. GLORY AND SO I BELIEVE
03:52:13.319 --> 03:52:15.722 region:rollup2
WE'VE GOTTEN TAKING CARE OF ALL
03:52:14.554 --> 03:52:18.358 region:rollup2
OF THE MEASURES.
03:52:15.722 --> 03:52:19.959 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM TWELVE EXCUSE ME
03:52:18.358 --> 03:52:21.594 region:rollup2
FILE ITEM TWELVE S. B. THIRTEEN
03:52:19.959 --> 03:52:22.896 region:rollup2
FORTY THREE THE MOTION IS TO
03:52:21.594 --> 03:52:24.164 region:rollup2
PASS AS AMENDED TO
03:52:22.896 --> 03:52:26.266 region:rollup2
APPROPRIATIONS VOTE COUNT AS
03:52:24.164 --> 03:52:28.134 region:rollup2
FOUR ZERO.
03:52:26.266 --> 03:52:31.538 region:rollup2
ANDERSON I'M ANDERSON AYE
03:52:28.134 --> 03:52:35.108 region:rollup2
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE STERN.
03:52:31.538 --> 03:52:37.310 region:rollup2
STERN AYE SEVEN SEVEN ZERO THAT
03:52:35.108 --> 03:52:38.778 region:rollup2
BILL IS CHAU REFUSAL AND FILE
03:52:37.310 --> 03:52:40.914 region:rollup2
ITEM THIRTEEN.
03:52:38.778 --> 03:52:42.549 region:rollup2
S. B. THIRTEEN NINETY FOR THE
03:52:40.914 --> 03:52:44.317 region:rollup2
MOTION IS TO PASSED THE PUBLIC
03:52:42.549 --> 03:52:45.652 region:rollup2
SAFETY THE VOTE COUNT IS THREE
03:52:44.317 --> 03:52:46.953 region:rollup2
TO ONE THE CHAIR VOTING AYE
03:52:45.652 --> 03:52:49.122 region:rollup2
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:52:46.953 --> 03:52:50.890 region:rollup2
ANDERSON.
03:52:49.122 --> 03:52:52.025 region:rollup2
ANDERSON NO HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG
03:52:50.890 --> 03:52:53.793 region:rollup2
AYE STERN.
03:52:52.025 --> 03:52:55.962 region:rollup2
STERN I.
03:52:53.793 --> 03:52:59.065 region:rollup2
ALRIGHT FIVE TWO TWO THAT BILL
03:52:55.962 --> 03:53:00.467 region:rollup2
IS OUT.
03:52:59.065 --> 03:53:02.135 region:rollup2
ANYTHING ELSE NO. I BELIEVE THAT
03:53:00.467 --> 03:53:04.137 region:rollup2
TAKES CARE OF IT ALL.
03:53:02.135 --> 03:53:05.305 region:rollup2
WE ARE ADJOURNED THANK YOU THANK
03:53:04.137 --> 03:53:11.978 region:rollup2
YOU MEMBERS THANK YOU STAFF
03:53:05.305 --> 03:53:11.978 region:rollup2
THANK YOU