GOOD MORNING.
GOOD MORNING AND THANK YOU ALL
FOR COMING HERE BECAUSE
SCHEDULES WE ARE JOINED IS WE
WELCOME YOU TO THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SENATE GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE COMMITTEE.
THIS MORNING LADIES GENERALLY
START WITH THE SUBCOMMITTEE WITH
THE MAN THE MYTH THE LEGEND FROM
ORANGE COUNTY JOHN MORLOCK.
WE HAVE SEVERAL MEMBERS WHO ARE
PRESENTING IN COMMITTEE OR
CURRENTLY CHAIRING COMMITTEE
BOTH MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE AS
WELL AS AUTHOR SO WE'RE GONNA.
SAY THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
TODAY IS THAT WE HAVE A LOT OF
MOVING PARTS.
BUT WE HAVE TWELVE BILLS ON
ORDER TODAY THAT NUMBER TEN WILL
BE OUR CONSENT WE WON'T A BE OR
MOVE FORWARD ON CONSENT UNTIL WE.
NOT ADVANCE WITH A FULL
COMMITTEE BUT TO BE A KICK*
OFF WHERE THE GRATEFUL THAT
CENTER MORALE IS HERE HE'S GONNA
BE RESENTING S. B. NINE TWENTY
FOUR.
IT IS YOU KNOW SIT AROUND WE
WON'T BE OR TAKE A VOTE ON IT
BECAUSE WERE SET COMMITTEE BUT
WE WELCOME YOU AND THANK YOU
VERY WORKS IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU.
IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU.
THANK YOU MEMBERS INTO A MUCH.
OKAY SENATE BILL NINE TWENTY
FOUR WOULD PROVIDE A TAX BENEFIT
TO OUR DEDICATED STATE SERVICE
MEMBERS WHO HELPED TO PROTECT
FROM.
AND. OUR STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIS BILL WOULD EXEMPT ALL
INCOME TAX RECEIVED BY THE
NATIONAL GUARD MEMBER.
FROM A STATE INCOME TAX WHEN
THAT INCOME IS DERIVED.
VIA THE EMERGENCY STATE ACTIVE
DUTY STATUS KNOWN AS THE S. A.
D. WHEN CALL IN THE SERVICE.
EDSA DE STATUS THE ACTIVE
MILITIA SERVED AT THE COMMAND OF
THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA ARE PAID BY THE STATE
AND THEIR MISSIONS INCLUDE STATE
EMERGENCY SUCH AS WILDFIRES
FLOODS. EARTHQUAKES AND OTHER
NATURAL DISASTERS WHICH I THINK
ALL OF US SIR.
FOR ME HERE WITH HIM THESE PAST
COUPLE OF MONTHS. AND SO ANYWAY
WHEN A NATIONAL GUARD MEMBERS
SERVES UNDER HE SAID THEIR
INCOME IS FULLY TAX BY THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA IS DESPITE THE
FACT THE SERVICE MEMBERS ARE
PROVIDING. THAT COULD STATE A
CRUCIAL SERVICE CALIFORNIA%
CONTINUES COLLECT TAXES ON THIS
INCOME. HOWEVER ESPY TOOK NINE
NINE TWENTY FOUR WOULD HONOR THE
DEDICATED PUBLIC SERVANTS.
WHO ARE CALLED AWAY FROM THEIR
HOMES AND THEIR FAMILIES IN
RESPONSE
STAY CRISIS LIKE THE WILDFIRES
IN THE FLOODS IN THOSE THAT WE
HAD RECENTLY? BY ATTEMPTING BY
EXEMPTING ALL NATIONAL GUARD
INCOME DERIVED FROM SERVICE
UNDER THIS EMERGENCY STATUS.
EMERGENCY STATUS FROM THE STATE
INCOME TAX THIS BILL WILL
EMPOWER AND REWARD YOUR
SACRIFICE REMEMBER SINCE IT IS
AN EMERGENCY BE FOR A VERY SHORT
PERIOD OF TIME. WHILE THEY'RE
AWAY FROM THEIR FAMILIES AND
THEIR HOMES WITH ME TO ANSWER
ANY EASY QUESTIONS THAT YOU GUYS
HAVE. IS THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
OF THE NATIONAL GUARD
ASSOCIATION A CALIFORNIA MISTER
JAMES LIBBY.
WHAT WE THINK IS SO MUCH BEING
HERE YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES HER
AND WE'RE GRATEFUL UP FOR ALL OF
YOUR WORK?
OLD PETE WHERE THEY CHRIS I
GUESS WHAT WE WANT TO SAY IS IS
ONLY AFFECTS THE A CALIFORNIA
MILITARY VETERANS CLOSED ONE
FORTY THREE.
ANY OTHER WAYS OF PEOPLE ANY OF
THE STATUS OF PEOPLE ARE IN IT
IS NOT AFFECTED BY THIS.
IS SKY AND NOT MY OPINION HARP
IN. OPEN SOURCE.
NOW IT'S TIME THAT THE
CALIFORNIA'S FOLLOWS THE EXAMPLE
SEVERAL OTHER STATES.
NATIONAL GUARD MEMBERS RECEIVE
FEW TAX BENEFITS AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL. IS A SMALL BENEFIT AND
THE LEAST WE CAN DO TO HONOR
THEIR SERVICE WITH S. B..
NIGHT TWO FOUR WE WOULD HONOR
THE DEDICATED PUBLIC SERVANTS
WHO ARE CALL AWAY FROM THEIR
HOMES OUR FAMILIES AND JOBS IN
RESPONSE TO STATE CRISIS. BY
EXEMPTING ALL NATIONAL GUARD
INCOME DERIVED FROM EMERGENCY
STATUS. FROM THE STREET STATE
INCOME TAXES BILL WILL EMPOWER
AND REWARD THEIR SACRIFICES.
MANY QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FACILITY
WARREN HOLE FOR QUESTIONS HERE
FOR JUST A BIT AT WE LEFT ME SIR
TO THE COMMITTEE IF YOU CAN
PLEASE STATE YOUR FIRST AND LAST
NAME.
ALONG WITH A YOU ORGANIZATION.
IF TWO MINUTES SIR.
WHERE'S THAT WE'VE AGREED
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS.
BOB MY CLIENTS THE AMERICAN
LEGION DEPARTMENT CALIFORNIA AND
EVENTS PARTLY CALIFORNIA.
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF COUNTY
VETERANS SERVICE OFFICERS
CALIFORNIA STATE. THAT CAPITAL
MILITARY. ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA.
COUNSEL CHAPTERS ARE ALL PART.
NINE TWENTY FOUR. BIGGEST MUCH
IS REALLY GRATEFUL WOULD LIKELY
BE A TO OPEN UP TO ANY OTHER
INDIVIDUALS WITH LIKE TO BE TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IF
YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
IF YOU COULD PLEASE MAKE YOUR
WAY TO THIS MICROPHONE. PLEASE
STATE YOUR FIRST AND LAST
ORGANIZATION IN YOUR POSITION.
ALL RIGHT WE'RE NOT GONNA OPEN
UP TO THOSE WHO MAY BE SQUISHY.
AND DON'T HAVE A POSITION QUITE
YET OR WHO ARE IN OPPOSITION TO
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
BRING WE BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE BEFORE E. I TURN IT
OVER TO MISTER OR LOCK IT IS
HARD TO MAKE SURE WE HAD A FEW
CALLS INTO THE COMMITTEE OFFICE.
ABOUT A IF THOSE WHO ARE BEING
CALLED UP BY THE PRESIDENT THE
PRESIDENT TRUMP.
WOULD QUALIFY.
IF THEY'RE BEEN DEPLOYED TO THE
BORDER AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT EVERYONE KNOWS THAT HOW THE
INCOME IF I NATIONAL GUARD
MEMBER FROM CALIFORNIA. BY ITS
DEPLOYED TO THE BORDER WOULD BE
EXCLUDED FOR THIS PURPOSE UNDER
NINE TWENTY FOUR.
REASON BEING IS THAT IS A
FEDERAL ORDER.
AND NOT STATE A AS DIRECTED IN
LISTENER MORALES BELTS JUST
WANNA MAKE SURE THAT FOLKS
UNDERSTAND THAT THAT COMPLETELY
SEPARATE BECAUSE IT IS A FEDERAL
ORDER. WITH THAT AND TURNED OVER
CENTER MORE LUCK WITH ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
TEACHER I WERE WAITING ON THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD LISTEN
ANALYSIS OF THE FEDERAL TAX BILL.
THAT WAS APPROVED LAST DECEMBER
AND.
SO MY CONCERN IS IS CONFORMITY
AND.
HOW WE?
YOU KNOW HOW ARE FOR TAX RETURN
LOOK WITH ALL THESE.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN FEDERAL AND
STATE AND.
WHAT KIND OF A?
SHORT WILL BE FOR TAX
PREPARATION PURPOSES ARM.
I JUST SORT OF CURIOUS.
.
MAYBE I SHOULD AT DIRECT THE
QUESTION TO YOU AND THAT IS WHAT
WHAT IS WHAT IS OUR POLICY ON.
ATTEMPTING TO DO. CONFORMITY SO
THEY WERE KIND OF. SIMILAR TO
FEDERAL LAW AS OPPOSED TO HAVING.
TO PRETTY DIFFERENT TAX CODES.
WELL I MEAN AS YOU KNOW WE ARE
KNEE DEEP IN.
CONFORMITY HERE AT THE STATE
AND WE HAVE TO MAKE A ULTIMATE
DECISION IF WE'RE GONNA CONFORM
OR NOT I IN IN YEARS PAST WE
HAVE GONE EITHER WAY SO WE DON'T
HAVE THE AYE CLEAR DIRECTION AT
THIS POINT.
I'M JUST.
ONE BE SENSITIVE THAT I
ABSOLUTELY.
DIANNE FROM FDB WANTS TO COMMENT
DIANNE GUTHRIDGE.
BUT.
JUST TO I KNOW I KNOW ONCE
REPORT COMES OUT THE END OF
APRIL.
YOU AND I ARE GONNA BE
SCRAMBLING RIGHT.
IF TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT
WILL WE DO WE WILL HAVE A VERY
LONG TIME LINE TO PROVIDE THE
TAX BILL.
SO THAT YOU KNOWS AS HAS WERE
WORKING WE SHOULD MAYBE.
KNOW WHAT OUR GUIDELINES ARE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE HAD THE
FAMOUS DIANE FROM FTP HERE.
WITH AS HE LIKES TO MAKE HER
PARENTS AND WE'RE GRATEFUL THAT
SHE'S ALWAYS HEARING COMMITTEE.
DANE IF YOU DON'T MIND.
COMMENTING ON CENTER MORE LOCKS
A QUESTION PLEASE. OKAY WE ARE.
WORKING ON THE CAMPARI PORRIDGE
FOR UNLESS AND WE HAVE BEEN
PUTTING OUT PORTIONS OF IT.
THROUGH WE'VE PUT THE M.
SUBTITLE WELL SUBTITLE B. IN
SUBTITLE C.. SO SO FAR WE'RE
MISSING A WE HAVE NOT PROVIDED
THE INDIVIDUAL INCOME PROVISIONS
AS WELL AS THE FOREIGN INCOME
PROVISIONS.
THOSE WILL BE OUT BY THE
TWENTIETH WE'RE HOPING IT WILL
BE A LITTLE BIT EARLY BUT.
A LITTLE EARLIER THAN THAT BUT
I'M NOT SURE.
WE'RE JUST TYING UP THE VERY YOU
KNOW THE VERY FEW LESS LOOSE
ENDS THAT WE HAVE.
SO WHERE IS YOUR POLICY ON
CONFORMITY.
WELL.
AND WE ALWAYS. PUT IN OUR
ANALYSES THAT IT'S BETTER FOR
THE TAXPAYER AND BETTER FOR THE
ADMINISTRATION TO CONFORM WHERE
WE CAN.
DO YOU THINK YOU.
DIANNE SIR THANK YOU SO MUCH I'M
SURE SEE LATER TODAY OKAY THERE
WE GO THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
THE I APPRECIATED THE CONSUMER
LAVA WE ARE JOINED NOW BY. THE
GREAT TENER FROM THE POINT THAT
WE WELCOME I SAY HERNANDEZ IT'S
GOOD TO SEE SIR.
LOW POINT DAY TYPOLOGY. AYE I
ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT THERE'S A.
AN AMAZING.
TEMPERATURE SHOP THERE SO THEY
WERE GO OPTOMETRIST SHOP GREAT
YEAH IT'S EXACTLY HOW DID HALF
PRICE FOR EVERYBODY HERE TODAY.
TO MAKE IT OUR I THINK THERE YOU
GO I DAY. BOND GIVEN QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS TURNS THE THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
I'M WE ARE GOING TO TAKE A ROLE
BUT BEFORE WE TAKE A ROLL TO BE
ABLE TO GET A QUORUM WE'RE GONNA
AND SENATE OVER TO THE GOOD
SENATOR FOR ANY CLOSING COMMENTS
NO I. I THINK
SIMPLE ONE ON OUR TROOPS THIS IS.
A GOOD THING ESPECIALLY IF NO
IT'S NOT LIKE THEY'RE CALL UP
FOR A WHOLE YEAR IT SAID HE
USUALLY A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME.
SO I WOULDN'T RESPECTFULLY I ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND MISS YOU
SENATOR.
BEFORE WE TAKE A VOTE LET'S A
CALL THE ROLL IN SOME SCORM
WHISTLING.
WELL THAT'S WHAT MY GOSH I
APOLOGIZE WHEN I THINK IN A WE
NEED A FOURTH IT WAS A WISHFUL
THINKING. THAT MR MORALE WE'RE
GONNA HOLD THIS THAT WE DO NOT
HAVE A QUORUM I WAS HOPING THAT
WE'RE GOING TO BE ABLE TO VOTE
AT ON THIS BILL CHAIR WILL BE
SUPPORTING THE HERE TDAY. TO
APPRECIATE THAT BUT WE'LL GET
BACK TO SINCE WE GET A FOURTH-MEMBER SOMEBODY MOVE THE BILL BE
FOR A QUORUM WHAT WE'RE NOT
GONNA MOVE THE BILL UNTIL WE
HAVE A QUORUM SO THANK YOU VERY
MUCH SO MUCH. THANK YOU MISTER
BROWN. AND I DO APOLOGIZE.
THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE AND
GERMAN THINK YOU SO MUCH FOR
YOUR WORK.
LAYS IN GENERAL WE'RE NOW MOVING
ON TO ITEM NUMBER ONE THIS IS S.
B. NINE FOURTEEN SENATOR DODD.
WE WELCOME THE SENATOR DO
APPRECIATE ALL HIS HARD WORK.
THIS IS A FOCUS SEEN ON LOCAL
AGENCY CONTRACTS.
TURNER DOT THE FLOORS YOUR
CERTAINLY WELCOMING COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU.
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS.
TODAY I AM PRESENTING SP NINE
FOURTEEN WHICH WOULD EXPAND THE
AUTHORITY OF COUNTIES.
TO DELIVER PROJECTS USING THE
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER AT RISK OR
SEA MAR. CONTRACTING METHOD.
I SEE MORE CON TRACT.
HE IS A COMPETITIVELY COULD
PROCURE A CONTRACT FOR A PROJECT
THAT GUARANTEES THE COST OF THE
PROJECT. AND FURNISHES
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES
INCLUDING PREPARATION AND
COORDINATION OF BID PACKAGES.
SCHEDULING EVALUATION
PRECONSTRUCTION SERVICES AND
CONSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION.
PROJECTS THAT HAVE MULTIPLE
PHASES LEND THEMSELVES TO THIS
METHOD BECAUSE OF THE DESIGN AND
CONSTRUCTION OF DIFFERENT
ASPECTS OF THE PROJECT. CAN
OCCUR. AT DIFFERENT TIMES.
AUTHORIZING THIS METHOD A
PROCUREMENT WILL PROVIDE
COUNTIES WITH THE NECESSARY TOOL.
TO DELIVER FISCALLY RESPONSIBLE
PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS.
ENSURE A HIGH QUALITY
CONSTRUCTION AT A GUARANTEED
MAXIMUM PRICE.
REDUCE PUBLIC SECTOR LIABILITY
AND IT SURE MORE TIGHTLY
COMPLETION OF PUBLIC WORKS
PROJECTS.
LAST YEAR THE LEGISLATURE
AUTHORIZED SEA MAR TO BE USED
FOR FOUR BUILDING PROJECTS AND
THAT PROPOSAL PASSED UNANIMOUSLY
WITH BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
S. B. UNITED FOURTEEN.
GRANTS COUNTIES THE FLEXIBILITY
TO BUILD PROJECTS THEY NEED IN
THE MOST EFFICIENT MANNER
POSSIBLE WHICH TRANSLATES TO
SAVINGS FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
TAXPAYERS ALIKE. WITH ME TODAY
IS KIANA VALENTINE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES.
HE AND HIS OF SOMEBODY ELSE WITH.
OMG IT'S WORTH SARJANG YOU'RE IN
FRONT OF ME JAMES.
SILSBEE DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
WORKS FOR ORANGE COUNTY.
PLEASE PLEASE REGISTER DODD AND
BEFORE WE GOT MISSED ON TIME IF
YOU DON'T MIND WE'RE ESTABLISH A
QUORUM IS I WAS A LITTLE IT
YOU'D BETTER DO THAT EARLIER I
MISS LANE CHESTER ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE.
MCGUIRE HERE WHERE PRESIDENT.
WHEN.
WHEN PRESIDENT BELL HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ PRESENT HERTZBERG LARA
MORE LOCK RESIDENTS MORE LIKE
PRISON.
I THINK.
I THINK SO MUCH AND I JUST SORT
OF FOLKS KNOW WE DO HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON THIS BILL
UP FOR OUR WITNESSES SO IF YOU
DON'T MIND KEEPING YOUR COMMENTS
AT TWO EIGHTY.
MINIMUM WE DO APPRECIATE MISS
CONTENT YOU'RE HERE IN TO
APPRECIATE CENTER DOT FOR ALL
THIS HARD WORK IS DOWNTOWN
WELCOME. GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE KIANA VALENTINE ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES. AT THE
SENATOR STATED THE PURPOSE OF SP
FOUR NINE FOURTEEN IS TO EXPAND
THE TOOLS COUNTIES HAVE TO PLAN
AND DELIVER INFRASTRUCTURE
PROJECTS.
IN A TIMELY EFFICIENT AND COST
EFFECTIVE MANNER IN ORDER TO BE
BRIEF I WILL AGAIN NOT TO THE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT THAT A. B.
EIGHT FIVE ONE BY CABALLERO
RECEIVE FROM THIS COMMITTEE LAST
YEAR THAT RE AUTHORIZED US FOR
FIVE MORE YEARS. WERE MERELY
SEEKING TO EXPAND IT SO COUNTIES
CAN USE THAT FOR OTHER TYPES OF
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS BEYOND
BUILDINGS FOR INSTANCE FLOOD
CONTROL UTILITY IMPROVEMENTS
EXCEPT FOR AND SO WITH THAT.
IT'LL TURN IT OVER TO SHANE AND.
ASKED RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
BUT THIS MORNING THANK YOU SO
MUCH ABOUT HIM AS A DIRECTOR WE
WELCOME YOU CERTAINLY DO HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
YOU'RE GOOD.
I THINK VERY MUCH.
CHAIRMAN SENATORS
HE SAYS WE DIRECTOR ORANGE
COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS ALSO
PARTICIPATE ACTIVELY IN AMERICAN
PUBLIC WORKS ASSOCIATION SOME
REALLY HERE TO BE A TECHNICAL
RESOURCE FOR YOU IF YOU HAVE
QUESTIONS TODAY OR IN THE FUTURE.
THAT COST PREDICTABILITY THAT
CONSTRUCTION INTEREST BRINGS AND
THE SCHEDULE CONTROLS ALREADY
MENTIONED I'LL JUST MENTION ONE
THING THAT'S VERY NEAR AND DEAR
TO ME AND TRYING TO DELIVER SUCH
SUCCESSFUL PROJECTS.
AND THAT IS EARLY CONTRACTOR
INVOLVEMENT. IN A LOW BID
PROCESS THE CONTRACTORS
PRECLUDED BY LAW FROM
PARTICIPATING IN THE DESIGN
PHASE OF THE PROJECT. SO THAT
THE ONLY TIME THAT THE
CONTRACTOR MEETS THE DESIGN TEAM
IS THE DAY OF THE BED WHEN THEY
AT THEIR ONLY REQUIREMENTS AT
THE LOWEST COST.
THEY MEET TOGETHER WE EXPECT TO
HAVE A SUCCESSFUL PROJECT FROM
THAT POINT. IT'S UNLIKELY THAT
THAT HAPPENS FROM A HIGH CHANCE
PROBABILITY THE CONSTRUCTION
MANAGER RISK PROCESS REQUIRES
THE CONTRACTOR TO BE INVOLVED IN
THE DESIGN PROCESS
TO HELP MAKE CHANGES
AND DO VALUE ENGINEERING AND
PROVIDE ALTERNATIVES IN THE WAY
THAT THE CONTRACTOR ACTUALLY
PROPOSES TO BUILD THE PROJECT.
VERY IMPORTANT AND VERY
IMPORTANT SO WITH THAT THE OTHER
THING THAT THAT CHURCH MAJOR
WRIST OFFERS IS A WAY TO
MINIMIZE RISK.
BY HAVING CONTINUE SEE LINE
ITEMS AND.
.
CRITICS COST LINES TO TO ACHIEVE
THOSE ELEMENTS WITH THAT I'M
HERE TO TECHNICAL RESOURCE
APPRECIATE SENATOR DODD SUPPORT
FOR THE BILL AND YOUR ATTENTION
SMALL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AS YOU
DIRECTOR WE'RE GOING TO ASK ALL
THOSE WHO ARE HERE IN SUPPORT
PLEASE SEE IF FOR SOME LASSEN
ORGANIZATION. JEREMY SMITH HERE
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING AND
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL ALSO
SUPPORT COULD SEE SIR GOOD
MORNING.
NICOLE ORNAMENT ON BEHALF OF THE
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS AND SAN BERNARDINO
COUNTY PART OF SUPERVISORS AND
SUPPORT THANK YOU SO MUCH.
MISTER CHAIRMAN VIRTUAL
ENFORCEABLE AT THE URBAN
COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT
GOOD TO SEE YOU. ANYONE ELSE IN
SUPPORT IF YOU TO PLEASE COME
FOR THIS TIME.
WE NOW ELCOME INDIVIDUALS WHO
ARE STILL THINKING ABOUT IT OR
WHO ARE OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE AS WE HAVE SOME
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE VERY
FAMILIAR WITH THE ORANGE COUNTY
BOARD SUPERVISORS WOULD LIKE TO
BE ABLE TO SEE IF EITHER OF THEM
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
ALRIGHT HAY THERE WE GO.
STACEY THERE WATCH OUT I I
THOUGHT THE A.
ALRIGHT WE DO HAVE A MOTION ON
THE FLOOR. ANY FINAL QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
WOULD LIKELY TO SEE IF MR DOT
LIKE TO HAVE A CLOSE BY FOR ASK
FOR A VOTE YOU WANT TO SAY THANK
YOU TO THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
NAPA COUNTY FOR ALL HIS HARD
WORK ON THIS AND TAKE YOU TO OF
BOTH YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. THE
SAME CHESTER ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE CHOIR BY WIRE IRWIN.
NGUYEN AYE BELL HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. LARA
MORLOCK.
WHEN I GOT. THE CURRENTLY ENJOYS
A FOUR ZERO VOTE OR GIVE THE
ROLE OPEN IS CENTER HERTZBERG
WILL BE HERE AND JUST FYI TO THE
COMMITTEE CENTER LARA WILL NOT
BE WITH US TODAY. THREE KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN THANK YOU SO MUCH
MISTER DODD THANK YOU TO OUR
WITNESSES.
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA BE DOING A
LITTLE BIT OF HOUSEKEEPING HERE
IF IT WORKS FOR THE COMMITTEE
WITH THAT TO BE A TACKLE OUR
CONSENT CALENDAR. ABOUT WHICH IT
CONSISTS OF ONE ITEM THAT'S ITEM
NUMBER TEN ON YOUR AGENDA.
MISTER HERNANDEZ IS BILL IN
THAT WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE TO
JUMP BACK TO S. B. NINE TWENTY
FOUR NUMBER TWO ON YOUR JIM
DEATH FIVE TO BE ABLE TO BUT
TAKE A VOTE ON THAT. BUT THE
CONSENT.
S. B. THIRTEEN TWENTY THREE
THIS IS A DO PASSED TO THE FLOOR
AYE IS THERE A MOTION TO PASS
THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY MISTER MOORE
LOCKET DO PASSED TO THE FLOOR
MISLED JUST ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE WIRE. BY WIRE PRESS AYE.
WIN. WIN I'D BILL.
HERNANDEZ OCCURRED AT THE SIGN
HERTZBERG. LARA MORE. WE'RE NOT
GUY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE HAVE JUST
ONE QUICK ITEM I WAS HE TOOK ONE
LAST VOTE AND WE NEED TO GET THE
CHAIR OF EDUCATION ADHERE BACK
TO HIS COMMITTEE. WE DO HAVE
ITEM NUMBER TWO IT'S BEEN NINE
TWENTY FOUR THIS IS A DO PASSED
THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON VETERANS
AFFAIRS IS THERE A MOTION TO
APPROVE.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
HERNANDEZ ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE
MISS LANE CHESTER.
MCGUIRE BY WHY I WIN WITH AYE
BELL HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG LARA MORE LOCK.
ONE GUY FORCES MOVE FORWARD ZERO
ORGAN KEEP THAT ROLE OPEN THANK
YOU SO MUCH WE'RE NOW CAN BE
MOVING ON TO MISTER ALLEN SP
NINE SIXTY THREE THIS IS.
RELATED TO WATER REPLACEMENT
DISTRICTS WOULD BE* ALL THIS
WORK ON THIS.
IN IN MISTER ALLEN JUST WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT YOU ARE
COMFORTABLE WITH TAKING THE
AMENDMENTS AS RECOMMENDED YES
YES I AM.
AND LET ME.
BEGIN BY THINKING THIS COMMITTEE
FOR ITS CHARACTER SLEEP BOSS
THOUGHTFUL ANALYSIS IN BY
AGREEING TO THE SUGGESTED
AMENDMENT.
IN COMMENTS THREE THAT THE WATER
PLEASURE TO SORT OF SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA BE REQUIRED TO SUBMIT
AN INDEPENDENT AUDITED FINANCIAL
STATEMENT. ANNUALLY TO THE
GOVERNOR AND APPROPRIATE
COMMITTEES OF THE LEGISLATURE
INCLUDING THAT THE SENATE
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE COMMITTEE.
IN ANY SALINAS AROUND YOU A
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. THAT SO WHY
WE WELCOME I YOUR HIGH IN LA IN
DEPTH TESTIMONY.
WE WOULD ALSO WELCOME A
TRUNCATED VERSION OKAY WHILE
I'LL ASK FOR NAY VOTE I AM
SHARING COMMITTEE AS WELL AS WE
SPEAK SO. I'M NOT HAVING AS
BILLS QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE DO HAVE A
MOTION ON THE FLOOR BY THE VICE
TESTIMONY SIR.
BOB READ WITH THREE GOVERNMENT
RELATIONS ON BEHALF OF THE WATER
REPLENISHMENT DISK OF SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA AVAILABLE ANSWER
QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE TODAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND IN TRULY
DO APPRECIATE CENTER SOUNDS HARD
WORK ON THIS BILL.
INCREASE YOU WORKING WITH US
THAT'S WE ARE OPEN IT UP FOR ANY
INDIVIDUAL WHO LIKED WERE
SPEAKING SUPPORT IF YOU COULD
PLEASE COME FOR TO THE
MICROPHONE AT THIS TIME WE
WELCOME.
ANYONE WHO IS STILL THINKING
ABOUT THIS BILL OR.
WHO IS IN OPPOSITION TO PLEASE
COME FORWARD?
BERMAN RAIN BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE WE DO HAVE A MOTION.
BY OUR VICE CHAIR THIS IS A DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO.
APPROPRIATIONS.
BUT I WANT SEATS OR ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS BEFORE WE
ACTUALLY GO TO THE VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AS LANCHESTER
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE REQUIRE.
I HOPE YOU
I
MCGUIRE AYE WIN. WIN AYE BELL.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG LARA.
LARA GUY. BETTER THIS IT'S LIKE
A BIPARTISAN HUG ITS IS AMAZING
THANK YOU SO MUCH MISTER AL GOOD
TO SEE YOU AND GOOD LUCK IN
EDUCATION.
ALRIGHT I DIEM.
ALRIGHT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
SO WHAT IS A JAM THIS IS THE
TIME.
WHERE THE VICE CHAIRED SO THE
VICE CHAIR STARTED TRADITION I
THINK GOD A YEAR AGO AT MY CRACK
MAN VICE CHAIR?
OKAY COMPLETE.
SO ANYTIME THAT WE'RE.
WE'RE WAITING FOR AN AUTHOR.
I DO BELIEVE THAT.
IT'S BECOME A TRADITION THAT.
DO A LITTLE.
LITTLE DITTY.
MERRY.
I THINK THE ONLY ONE THAT HAS
NOT IS A VICE CHAIR.
YOU KNOW YOU'RE.
YOU HAVE DONE THAT BEFORE YEAH
SO IS SENATOR BAIL.
I THINK IT'S A MORE LOCKETS
CLOGS ON.
A AND.
.
THE BILL WE WILL WIN THE GIG BAG.
DANCING A LITTLE DANCE.
WELL YOU KNOW. IT'S SO I THINK
I'M I THINK CENTER BELL DID
SPRINKLER.
WAY WHICH WAS VERY IMPRESSIVE.
YEAH HE DID THAT WAS.
.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE HECK THAT
IS IS IT BECAUSE OF ALL THE CAN
IS YOU GIVE THE ABSOLUTELY.
EXACTLY YEAH EXACTLY LOCAL WITH.
YEAH KNOW EVERY GO AND IF YOU
NEED.
SO WE'RE GONNA WAIT.
FOR THE VICE YOU DECIDE.
THAT WHICH WHAT SHE'D LIKE YOU
TO DO AND I THINK AT THIS POINT
IN TIME I THINK SHE'S READY TO
CUSS SO WE'RE GONNA.
JUST TURN IT BACK OVER WE'RE
GONNA ASK FOR EVER HEY THERE YOU
GO OVER GAS FOR EVERYONE'S
PATIENCE AT THE SERGEANTS ARE
CALLING OFFICES RIGHT NOW TO BE
ABLE TO GET AS AN AUTHOR AND WE
DO APPRECIATE YOUR PATIENCE WE
BACK WITH YOU HERE. MOMENTARILY
THANKS FOR HANGING WITH US
WITH.
PARIS.
PADDLING
.
BERNIE.
NQUIRE.
CLICK HERE WE WELCOME YOU BACK
TO THE GOVERNOR'S FINANCE
COMMITTEE. ARTISTS WORKING
SENATOR IN THE INLAND EMPIRE IS
HERE BECAUSE SHE IS WEARING IN
FORWARD.
SP ELEVEN THIRTY CENTER LEYVA
BY RELATING TO PROPERTY TAX
POSTPONE IT A WOMAN IN MENUS ON
MANUFACTURED HOMES
SENATOR YOU DO HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON THIS BILL. HOT SO WE
WELCOME YOU TO PROVIDE YOUR IN
DEPTH TESTIMONY. OR.
WE ALSO WELCOME.
IT.
A TRUNCATED VERSION ALONG WITH
YOUR WITNESS IS AND AGAIN YOUR
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT WE DO WELCOME
YOU TO THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU
FROM YOUR WORK MISTER CHAIR I
APPRECIATE THOSE.
WORDS OF WISDOM FROM YOU SO I
WILL TO SAY THANK YOU FOR HAVING
ME A GOOD MORNING TO ALL OF THE
MEMBERS.
S. B. ELEVEN THIRTY WOULD
SIMPLY REINSTATE OBILE HOME
OWNERS AS ELIGIBLE PARTICIPANTS
IN CALIFORNIA'S PROPERTY TAX
POSTPONEMENT PROGRAM. AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU SO MUCH CENTER LATER
WE WELCOME YOUR COMMENTS IN
AGAIN YOU DO HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT IF YOU COULD PLEASE SEE
YOUR FIRST AND LAST ORGANIZATION.
CHART THIS CASE HE O'CONNOR I AM
LEDGE DIRECTOR FOR BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION VICE CHAIR FIONA MA
WHERE PROUD SPONSORS OF THIS
BILL THANK THE CENTER FOR BRING
IT FORWARD THINK THE
COMPTROLLER'S OFFICE FOR WORKING
WITH US TO GET TO THIS UNIQUE.
FACTS OF THIS PROBLEM AND
APPRECIATE ALL YOUR SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
BUT SURELY THAT SORT OF CONFIRM
YOUR GONNA BE TAKING THE
TECHNICAL MEANS AYE AS LIST UP
SALUTE THANK YOU SO MUCH AND I
THE I WOULD LIKE TO BE TO COME
ON HIS CO AUTHOR THIS BILLS WELL
WOULD LOVE TO HAVE YOU THINK YOU
THINK YOU SO MUCH. WE'D LIKE TO
BE ABLE TO OPEN IT UP FOR ANY
INDIVIDUAL WOULD LIKE TO GET TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF IT
PLESIOSAURUS AN ORGANIZATION.
BENJAMIN PALMER BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURED HOUSING
INSTITUTE AND SUPPORT BECAUSE
SEEMS PALMER THANK YOU ANYONE
ELSE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT PLEASE COMPORT THIS TIME.
ANY INDIVIDUAL WHO MAY BE
SQUISHY ON THIS BILL OR WHO IS
OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
WE'RE GONNA BRING BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE TO BETTER SEE IF WE
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS COMMENTS OR A
MOTION.
I CENTER MORE LUCK PLEASE BRUCE
REVIEW OF THE ASSOCIATION OF OUR
COUNTY.
ASSESSOR STANDS. AND MAYBE THE
TREASURE TAX COLLECTORS DO THEY
HAVE A POSITION I.
WE HAVE NOT SEEN A POSITION AYE
AYE BUT OTHER ME SEE WHAT THE
AUTHOR I DO NOT KNOW. THEY HAVE
NOT WEIGHED IN TO MY KNOWLEDGE.
AND THEY HAVE NOT A WAITING WITH
THE COMMITTEE.
I THINK SO MUCH.
SO LADIES AND GENTLEMEN THE
COMMITTEE WE DO HAVE A BILL ON
THE FLOOR IS THERE ANYONE LIKE
TO BE ABLE TO MAKE A MOTION THIS
IS A DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
HOW ABOUT HER?
YES I MOVE THE BILL PASSED WE DO
HAVE A MOTION BY US HERNANDEZ
ANY CLOSING COMMENTS MISS LEYVA.
I WOULD JUST SAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE CENTER REQUIRE WERE HAPPY
TO HAVE YOU ON AS A CO AUTHOR
AND AS YOU HAVE FIVE HUNDRED
THIRTY FIVE MOBILE HOME PARKS.
IN YOUR DISTRICT BUT YOU
PROBABLY ALREADY KNEW THAT
NOTHING TO SEMI CENTER LEYVA.
I RECALL VOTE PLEASE MISS THING
JESTER Y. HIGH WHERE I WOULD.
WHEN I BELT. FERNANDES.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
LARA MORLOCK.
OR NOT GOOD FOR TO DO THAT
ANOTHER BIPARTISAN GROUP BUT
THIS IS AMAZING THANK YOU SO
MUCH SIMILAR THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING HERE THANK YOU.
GOOD.
GOOD MORNING AGAIN MISTER CHAIR
AND MEMBERS I AM HAPPY TO
PRESENT S. B. ELEVEN FORTY FIVE
I WOULD FIRST LIKE TO ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS CLARIFYING
THE BOND FUNDS CANNOT BE USED
FOR MAINTENANCE.
THANK YOU TO THE CHAIR COMMITTEE
FOR YOUR WORK ON THIS BILL.
ELEVEN EIGHT FORTY FIVE
AUTHORIZES AUTHORIZES ENHANCED
INFRASTRUCTURE FINANCING
DISTRICTS OR E. I. F. DIS TO DO
MAINTENANCE OF THE FACILITIES
THEY WOULD BUILD.
THE IDEA OF THESE ARE IMPORTANT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT FINANCE
TOOL FOR LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO
MOVE COMMUNITY PROJECTS FORWARD.
CITIES AND COUNTIES CAN CREATE
THE AYE OF DEE'S TO PAY FOR
WATER SYSTEMS CHILDCARE
FACILITIES PARKS AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AMONG OTHER ITEMS. THERE
ARE CURRENTLY OVER TWENTY FIVE
III OF DIS ACROSS THE STATE THAT
ARE EITHER APPROVED OR IN THE
STUDY PHASE. LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
ARE CONSIDERING ESTABLISHING IN
THE I FD ARE FACING THE CURRENT
LIMITATION ON MAINTAINING THE
PROJECTS THAT WOULD BE BUILT. AS
YOU KNOW LONG TERM MAINTENANCE
COSTS ARE OFTEN TIMES OVERLOOKED
IN THESE TYPES OF DEVELOPMENT
PROJECTS. PRESENTLY I OF
DIS CANNOT PAY FOR MAINTENANCE
ROUTINE REPAIRS OR OPERATIONS
THE SITUATIONS PROBLEMATIC SINCE
MANY COMMUNITIES WILL NEED FUNDS
FROM THESE DISTRICTS TO MAINTAIN
STRUCTURES OVER TIME.
S. B. ELEVEN FORTY FIVE ALLOWS
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO PROACTIVELY
BOOK BUDGET MAINTENANCE COSTS
FROM THE E. IFT REVENUES RATHER
THAN RELY HUMBOLDT HOLD GENERAL
FUNDS.
THIS BILL DOES NOT ASK FOR NEW
FUNDS TAXES OR FEES IT WILL
HOWEVER ALLOWED EAI OF DIS TO
MAINTAIN FACILITIES PROPERLY I'M
PROTECT LOCAL TAXPAYER
INVESTMENTS LONG TERM. WITH ME
TODAY IS AARON WORRELL WHOSE
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND HOUSING
DIRECTOR FOR THE CITY OF WEST
SACRAMENTO. AND IS REPRESENTING
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
LOCAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND
RESPECTFUL AS FOR AN AYE VOTE SO
MUCH SENATOR AIRONET WE ASK THAT.
TWO MINUTES WE WELCOME YOU AND
THANK YOU VERY ONE SIR.
OUR THEY CATCH MISTER SHARON
SENATORS AGAIN MY NAME'S THEIR
LOYALTY WAS SACRAMENTO BUT I'M
HERE TO REPRESENT OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION LOOK LIKE
ON DEVELOPMENT AS A BOARD MEMBER.
HOW WE ALSO ARE IN THE ROLE OF?
TRYING TO OFFER A TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE TO OUR MEMBERS MANY
OF WHOM ARE LOOKING AT THE ID'S
AS A A WAY TO HELP FINANCE
INFRASTRUCTURE IN ADVANCE
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT.
AS WAS ALREADY STATED OF AS
WERE ONE OF THREE CITIES IN THE
STATE THAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED A
DISTRICT IN OPERATION SO
SPEAKING FROM A PRACTICAL
STANDPOINT WE'VE RUN INTO THIS
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUE OF WHAT
WE'RE. NOW HAVE A POWERFUL TOOL
FOR FINANCING NEW IMPROVEMENTS
BUT AS YOU KNOW A LOT OF YOU
HAVE BACKGROUND LOCAL GOVERNMENT.
THE THE ISSUE OF MAINTENANCE
OFTEN COMES UP WHERE IT'S IT'S
VERY DIFFICULT TO BUDGET MONEY
EVERY YEAR.
TO MAINTAINING SOMETHING LIKE A
BRIDGE AND WE ACTUALLY HAVE THAT
EXAMPLE IN OUR CITY WERE
BUILDING A BRIDGE THE CITY OF US
SACRAMENTO.
WILL INCUR ABOUT PRETTY LARGE
MAINTENANCE COSTS TO THE IDEA.
IS AN OPTION TO FINANCE THAT.
PROJECT BUT ALSO WITH THE
CHANGES THAT THIS BILL WILL
BRING ABOUT WE WOULD WE WOULD BE
ABLE TO PLEDGE STE SAY TO A LONG
TERM MAINTENANCE AGREEMENT WITH
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO. MONEY THROUGH THE
DISTRICT THAT WOULD HELP
MAINTAIN THAT FACILITY AND THAT
COULD BE USED ON A LOT OF OTHER
EXAMPLES ALL DISEASE LIKE A
WATER INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECT FOR
EXAMPLE. OF THE COULD HAVE
MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS HELPING
TO FINANCE IT THEY COULD ALSO
PLEDGE MONEY TOWARDS A SALE
WATER DISTRICT TO PASS A LONG
TERM MEASURE MAINTAIN THAT
FACILITY AS WELL.
SO.
THAT'S.
BUILT THOSE OF A AS SORTS OF
EXAMPLES THAT THAT WE WOULD PUT
FORTH AS A PRACTICAL
IMPLEMENTATION FOR THIS MEASURE.
.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
I'M HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
ABOUT THE BILL HE MIGHT HAVE.
THANK YOU AND THANK YOU SO MUCH
THANKS MAKE THE DRIVE INTO THAT
WOULD LIKE THAT A WELCOME IN
INDIVIDUAL WOULD LIKE YOU TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
QUICKLY SEE YOUR FIRST LAST
ORGANIZATION WE WALK ME SIR. YES
GONNA MISS CHAIR MEMBERS JASON
RHYME BILLY CALIFORNIA CITIES.
WE ARE SUPPORTERS MEASURES WILL
BE TO SEE JASON THANK YOU GOOD
MORNING.
THE MORNINGS ARE MEMBERS AREN'T
ABLE ANTI REPRESENT AMERICAN
PLANNING ASSOCIATION SUPPORT
THANKS FOR BEING HERE OR IN. THE
MORNING FISH CHAIR MEMBERS
MATTHEW HARD WITH THE CALIFORNIA
BUSINESS PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION
HERE IN SUPPORT THINKING BIGGEST
MUCH MATTHEW.
ANYONE ELSE LIKE TO BE TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OF IT PLEASE
COMPORTED MICRON DESTROYING.
ALRIGHT WE WELCOME ANY
INDIVIDUAL WHO WOULD LIKE TO
SPEAK AS AN OPPOSE POSITION TO
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
THAT'S BRING TO THE COMMITTEE
FOR ANY DISCUSSION THAT'S GO TO
CENTER MORE LUCK PLEASE.
TERRACE OF SORT OF HOPING THAT
SENATOR BELL WOULD BE HERE SINCE
HE WAS.
VETERANS POSSIBLE AND.
CREATING THIS THIS INSTRUMENT SO.
THIS CENTURY HER MAKING THIS
MODIFICATION WHAT OTHER
MODIFICATIONS DO WE NEED TO LOOK
AT IN THE FUTURE.
THE QUESTION THAT WE HAVE ABOUT
AS AN SPEAKING FROM CAL AND BOTH
FROM OUR EXPERIENCE IN WAS
SACRAMENTO THERE IS A LAUNDRY
LIST OF OTHER THINGS THAT WE
WOULD LIKE TO BRING UP WE ARE
WORKING ON. A PLAN FOR THAT I
THINK TIMING IS IS SORT OF A
QUESTION WITH.
THAT THE CURRY MINISTRATION
MCCARTY OF OUR MEN LIKE A LOT OF
TALK ABOUT TAX INCREMENTAL BUT
WE DO HAVE A LOT OF OTHER.
PRACTICAL ISSUES WITH THE ID'S
THAT.
.
WE'RE WE'RE ACTUALLY PLANNING TO
RUN MORE LEGISLATION TO TAKE
PUBLICLY NEXT YEAR A WE ALSO
HAVE A COUPLE OF ON THE BUS
CHANGES THAT ARE THAT ARE IN THE
COMMITTEES.
ON THE BUS BILL.
THAT WOULD ADDRESS I'D JUST
SOME OF THE PRACTICAL ISSUES
ABOUT NOTIFICATION.
BUT BUT YES THERE ARE THERE ARE
A LOT OF OTHER THINGS NOT TO GET
TOO SPECIFIC BUT WE WILL BE BACK
WITHOUT ADDITIONAL IMPROVEMENTS.
THIS IS ONE WE THINK THAT COULD
BE SUPPORTED THIS YEAR AND
REALLY APPLY RIGHT NOW THAT
COULD HAVE A MEANINGFUL IMPACT
ON. OF THE DISTRICTS THAT ARE IN
PLACE.
RIGHT NOW.
AND SO IT'S HARD OTHER MODEL IN
ANOTHER STATE OF THIS. VEHICLE.
OTHER BUT ON THE MAIN ISSUE IN
PARTICULAR OR JUST ON TAX
INCREMENT HOLD THE HOPE THE
OTHER E. I. F. YES SO TAX
OCCURRENCE ACTUALLY VERY COMMON
TOOL.
IN IN OTHER STATES.
WE WHEN WE USED EVERY
DEVELOPING A SEIZE THAT WAS THE
COMMON TO A TOOL WE HADN'T
CALIFORNIA'S ANOTHER SEVERAL
DIFFERENT OPTIONS FOR.
THE USE OF TAX INCREMENT
FINANCING IN CALIFORNIA.
THE ID'S IN PARTICULAR ARE ARE
RELEASED FROM CALLOUSED AND
POINT AND AND FROM OUR CITIES OF
PERSPECTIVE THE MOST FLEXIBLE
MOST USEFUL OF THE OPTIONS THAT
ARE CURRENTLY AVAILABLE. IT'S
IT'S IN PERFECT RIGHT NOW BUT.
BUT THIS CHANGE IN IN THE OTHER
SIDE.
WHAT WILL BOOK WE GETTING INTO
LATER?
WOULD WOULD MAKE A LOT MORE
FLEXIBLE IMPROVE THE THE UTILITY
OF OF THE TOOL. FOR THERE'S
LEAST A BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICE
SOMEWHERE IN THE COUNTRY WE GET
MODELER.
DUPLICATE HERE.
I THINK THERE'S LOTS OF GOOD
EXAMPLES AND I THINK WHAT WHAT
BUT WHAT I WOULD ADVISE WE'RE
TRYING TO DO IS AN ORGANIZATION
IS TO TAKE ELEMENTS OF EACH ONE
OF THOSE AND BUILD SOMETHING
THAT CAN BE.
SUSTAINABLE IN IN WORKABLE FOR
A CITIES NO MATTER THE SIZE OR
CIRCUMSTANCE AND I THINK THE
IDEAS OF THE BEST TOOL WE HAVE
TO GET TO THAT RIGHT NOW. UP
THERE THAT LIKE I SAI THERE ARE
LOTS OF OTHER IDEAS OF KIND OF
GOING THROUGH RIGHT NOW AND.
THAT THERE'S A LOT OF WORK OVER
THE NEXT FEW YEARS TO.
THE BILL THAT THE OVERALL
PROGRAM.
AT YOU THANK YOU MATURE THINK
YOU SO MUCH FOR CENTER.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
FROM THE MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE.
LIKE TO BE TO SEE BEFORE WE GOT
A CLOSE COMMENTS HAVE WE DO HAVE
A MOTION ON THE FLOOR.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
HERNANDEZ IN THIS IS A DO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR CENTER
LEYVA CLOSING COMES POLICE
SUSPECT LESSON ABOUT. SENATE
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR WORK
ON THIS AND THINK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING WITH US TODAY WE DO.
DO PASS AS AMENDED MOTION ON.
TO THE FLOOR INSANE JUST A ROLL
CALL VOTE PLEASE CHOIR AYE FLY
AYE NGUYEN.
WHEN I BELL HERNANDEZ RENOWNED
DECIDE HERTZBERG LARA MORLOCK.
WHEN I GOT FORCING LOOK AT THAT
BIPARTISAN.
FANTASTIC SURLY MISTER CHAIR
THANK YOU MEMBERS THANK YOU SO
MUCH THANK YOU BOTH FOR BEING
HERE FOR ALL YOUR WORK.
WE ARE NOW WELCOMING.
YOU HAVE HEARD THE NOTORIOUS.
PART B. J. WE ARENT DOING H. PJ
COMING AND WATCH OUT. BY HANNAH
BETH JACKSON THE GREAT SENATOR
FROM SANTA BARBARA COUNTIES HERE
TO BE AT A PRISON SP TEN THIRTY
FIVE AND A VERY. IMPORTANT BILL
THAT WE WELCOME HER IN THANK YOU
FOR ALL OF YOUR WORK LIAM. THANK
YOU ALWAYS SO HONORED TO BE
INCLUDED IN THE SAME SENTENCE
WITH THE GREAT RPG.
.
AND THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS BILL.
THAT SPECIFIES AN UPDATE
SCHEDULE FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
TO ADDRESS CLIMATE ADAPTATION
AND RESILIENCY IN THEIR GENERAL
PLAN.
BEFORE GOING ANY FURTHER I
APPRECIATE THE GOOD WORK OF THE
COMMITTEE AND.
WILL ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS AS
DETAILED IN THE ANALYSIS TO
PROVIDE. LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WITH
FLEXIBILITY TO DECIDE WHEN TO
MAKE THE UPDATES REQUIRED BY THE
BILL. WHILE STILL ENSURING THAT
READ REGULAR UPDATES TO IN FACT
OCCUR IN A TIMELY MANNER. AND.
TO MAKE SURE THAT THE LOW OUR
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ALSO ADDRESS A
RELATED SUBJECT MATTER SUCH AS
HAZARD MITIGATION. AND.
OR HOUSING SO THAT CLIMATE
POLICY MAY INDEED BE
INCORPORATED WITH OTHER ELEMENTS
OF THE GENERAL PLAN. A DIRECTLY
IMPACTED BY OUR EVER CHANGING
CLIMATE.
AND I WANT TO AGAIN THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR ITS GOOD WORK.
.
AS I MENTIONED THE BILL
SPECIFIES AN UPDATE SCHEDULED
THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS MUST
FOLLOW WHEN REVISING THEIR
SAFETY ELEMENT FOR CLIMATE
ADAPTATION AND RESILIENCY
STRATEGIES.
US FOR A A REQUIREMENT THAT WAS
ESTABLISHED IN TWENTY FIFTEEN
WITH MY THEN S. B. THREE SEVENTY
NINE.
WHICH DIRECTED LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
TO CONSIDER CLIMATE IMPACTS WHEN
AMENDING GENERAL PLANS TO
ADDRESS IMPACTS FROM SUCH THINGS
AS FIRES. AND FLOODS AND EVEN.
DEBRIS FLOWS.
FIRE IN THE FLOOD RISKS WERE
INCLUDED IN THE GENERAL PLAN IN
RESPONSE TO CATASTROPHIC
WILDFIRES AND FLOODING THAT. AT
THE TIME BACK IN TWENTY FIFEEN
WISHING IS RATHER UNUSUAL BUT
INCREASINGLY FREQUENT EVENTS WE
NOW KNOW OF COURSE THAT.
THESE EVENTS ARE MORE THE NEW
NORMAL UNFORTUNATELY AND I KNOW
THE CHAIR EXPERIENCED A RAGING
WILDFIRE FIRES IN THE IMPACT ON
HIS DISTRICT.
AND.
JUST A FEW MONTHS LATER. IN
DECEMBER MY DISTRICT A RECENTLY
EXPERIENCED THE LARGEST WILDFIRE
IN OUR STATE'S HISTORY. AND
FOLLOWED BY CATASTROPHIC DEBRIS
FLOW THAT.
KILLED TWENTY THREE PEOPLE
CAUSING ADDITIONAL ENORMOUS
DAMAGE AS WELL.
SO WHAT WE KNOW NOW EVEN MORE
CLEARLY IS THAT THESE EVENTS ARE
INEXTRICABLY LINKED TO RAPID
CLIMATE CHANGE AND THE EFFECTS
OF A CHANGING CLIMATE ARE
SEVERAL.
FROM RISING SEA LEVELS TO
WORSENING AIR QUALITY TO DAMAGED
INFRASTRUCTURE AND TO OF COURSE.
INTENSIFYING NATURAL DISASTERS
AND I KNOW THAT JUST THE
RECENTLY WE WERE ADVISED THAT
THIS YEAR'S HURRICANE SEASON
FORTUNATELY WE ARE. ON THE OTHER
COAST AND HOPEFULLY WON'T HAVE
TOO MANY OF THEM BUT FOR OUR
FRIENDS AND COLLEAGUES AND
COUNTRYMEN. AYE IN THE EAST
COAST OR EXPECTING AMONG THE
WORST HURRICANE SEASON THEY'VE
EVER RECORDED ALL THAT DO OF
COURSE TO THE IMPACTS OF CLIMATE
CHANGE.
SO WE HAVE TO BE SURE THAT OUR
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE SERIOUSLY
THOUGHT. COMPREHENSIVELY AND
REGULARLY ADDRESSING CLIMATE
CHANGE IN THEIR GENERAL PLANTS.
THIS BILL ENSURES THIS WHILE AT
THE SAME TIME PROVIDING LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS WITH THE APPROPRIATE
FLEXIBILITY.
A TIME THOSE UPDATES.
AS THE CHAIR MENTION THIS
REALLY IS A VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE
SOMETHING THAT TEN YEARS AGO WE
REALLY DIDN'T NECESSARILY THINK
ABOUT. BUT WHICH NOW IS.
BASICALLY OF A MATTER OF LIFE
AND DEATH FOR SO MANY OF OUR
CONSTITUENTS SO WITH THAT I'D
LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE CARE
MORTENSEN FROM THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES.
KYLE JONES WHO'S HERE FROM THE
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA
CLUB WHO ARE AVAILABLE. WITH ANY
OF THE TECHNICAL BURKE AND WERE
ANSWERS TO ANY TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE BEEN I
THANK YOU FOR YOUR. INDULGENCE
CARRIER SYSTEMS AND FOR THE GOOD
WORK OF THE COMMITTEE AND WOULD
ASK FOR YOUR IPHONE. NOTHING
GETS MUCH VENOM SENATOR WE'RE
GRATEFUL FOR YOUR WORK TRULY ON
THIS IMPORTANT BILL FACE IN THIS
NEW NORMAL AND.
GOOD CENTER FROM SANTA BARBARA
HAS HAD DE HELD INTO THE YEAR IN
INTO.
HERE IN TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN
JUST ALSO WANTED KNOWLEDGE ALL
OF YOUR WORK AND EFFORT. ON
BEHALF OF THE RESIDENTS HERE
DISTRICTS SO THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE'D LIKE TO BE A TO OPEN IT UP
FOR.
WITNESSES TESTIMONY WE
TYPICALLY DO TWO INDIVIDUALS
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE SO.
WE ASK THAT YOU PLEASE KEEP
YOUR COMMENTS IN NO MORE THAN
TWO MINUTES AND THEN IF YOU
COULD SEE YOUR FIRST AND LAST AS
WELL AS. I YOUR ORGANIZATION WE
WELCOME IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU.
GREAT THANK YOU CAREMARK'S AND
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES I
WOULD LIKE TO FIRST THANK THE
AUTHOR OF FOR THIS BILL AND HER
WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH US.
AT C. SACK OBVIOUSLY AFTER THIS
PAST FIRE SEASON AND REALLY THE
ON SET OF MORE CLIMATE. USE.
NATURAL DISASTERS WE ARE
LOOKING AT HOW WE CAN DO THINGS
DIFFERENTLY AND I I DO THINK
THIS IS A A GOOD FIRST UP IN
THAT IN THAT DIRECTION INCLUDING
THIS IMPORTANT INFORMATION. IN
OUR CRITICAL PLANNING DOCUMENTS
OUT THE LOCAL LEVEL AND THE
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS WOULD A LINE
ON THIS INFORMATION AND WITH THE
TIMING OF OTHER.
ELEMENTS WITHIN THE GENERAL
PLAN INCLUDING THE HOUSING
ELEMENT WHERE THE HAZARD
MITIGATION.
PLAN WHICH IS ON A FIVE YEAR
CYCLE SO WE APPRECIATE THAT
FLEXIBILITY THINK IT'S A
FANTASTIC DEL AND HAPPY TO
SUPPORT. BECAUSE MEASURES
MORTENSEN AND YOU ALSO
ACKNOWLEDGE THE SEX WORKER OVER
THE PAST MANY MONTHS SINCE
OCTOBER IN THE NORTH BAY AS WELL
AS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SO
THANK YOU.
PLEASE WELCOME GOOD THINGS THERE
ARE THE COMMITTEE I CAO JOINS US
HERE CALL CALIFORNIA AND ALSO TO
REGISTER SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIA LEGAL CONSERVATION
VOTERS THIS MORNING.
AND WANT TO THANK EVERYBODY FOR
WORKING TOGETHER ON THIS VERY
IMPORTANT BELL I THINK REGULAR
UPDATES ON CLIMATE. ADAPTATION
RESILIENCY ARE VERY IMPORTANT I
THINK EIGHT YEARS AGO WE DIDN'T
HAVE THE WORST DROUGHT WE'VE
EVER HAD IN OUR HISTORY WE
DIDN'T KNOW THE EXTENT TO WHICH
FIVE WILDFIRES COULD REACH. INTO
URBAN AREAS AND I THINK AS THIS
AREA IS A GOOD AREA WITH STOP A
LOT OF SCIENCE COMING OUT
REGULARLY OUT RECENTLY THEY
MENTIONED THAT THEIR REVISING
HOW.
SEA LEVEL RISE WILL IMPACT THE
BACK AYE IT'S MORE IMPORTANT
THAT WE TAKE REGULAR UPDATE
UPDATED LOOKS AT AT THIS DATA
AND SO WE ARE DRIVE OUT TODAY
THANK YOU THANK YOU MISTER JONES
GOOD MORNING. RAIN AGAIN A LARGE
EVELYN TEGAN REPRESENT AMERICAN
PLANNING ASSOCIATION AND JUST
VERY PLEASED TO BE HERE IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL AND REALLY
APPRECIATEI'M WORKING WITH THE
AUTHOR AND YOUR STAFF. AND TO
MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S THAT
FLEXIBILITY WHILE STILL
CERTAINLY REACHING THE GOALS OF
THE BILL THANK YOU THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
TO APPRECIATE YOUR COMMENTS
THAT'S OPEN UP FOR ANY OTHER
INDIVIDUAL WOULD LIKELY TO COME
FORWARD AND SPEAK ON BEHALF OF
THIS BILL WE WELCOME YOU IF YOU
COULD PLEASE STATE YOUR FIRST
AND LAST ORGANIZATION.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING SIR. THANK YOU SO
MUCH SIR.
I'M KID SURE I MEAN IF THE
LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMISSION WE
WANT TO EXPRESS OUR SUPPORT AS
WELL FOR THE BILL. WE BELIEVE
THAT REGULAR UPDATES FOR ALL THE
REASONS THAT WERE OUTLINED A
REALLY CRITICAL TO RESPOND TO
EMERGING ISSUES ALSO TO MAKE
SURE THAT THE PLANS AND POLICIES
REFLECT THE LATEST SCIENCE AND
THE SOLUTIONS THAT WILL HELP ALL
OF OUR COMMUNITIES MOVE FORWARD.
THANK YOU THANKS FOR BEING HERE
TODAY.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
WE'RE NOT GONNA WELCOME ANYONE
WHO'S OPPOSE HER STILL THINKING
ABOUT IT.
ANYONE IS OPPOSED.
IT'S PRETTY BACK TO COMMITTEE
FOR QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
COMMITTEE.
ALRIGHT.
WE DO NOT SEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS I.
BEFORE WE TURN IT BACK OVER TO
SENATOR FOR CLOSING COMMENTS
WOULD LIKELY TO SEE IF THERE'S
AN INDIVIDUALLIKE THAT OFFER A
MOTION WHICH IS A TO DO PASS AS
AMENDED. TO ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY.
KLAY THE LOTION BY SENATOR
HERNANDEZ
SENATE JACKSON CLOSING COMMENTS
PLEASE OF VERY BRIEFLY.
.
YOU KNOW AS WE SEE THESE
INCIDENTS OCCURRING IN THE
SCIENCE GETTING BETTER AND
BETTER.
IT'S MY HOPE THAT THIS
BECOMES A TOP PRIORITY FOR OUR
LOCAL COMMUNITIES HAVING
EXPERIENCED A DEADLY. VAN SAYS I
KNOW THE SENATOR THE CHAIR HAS.
THIS DOES BECOME A MATTER OF
LIFE AND DEATH IN SOMETHING WE
HAVE TO TAKE A.
VERY SERIOUSLY GOING FORWARDS
WITH THAT I WOULD ASK YOUR
IPHONE. SO JACKSON THANK YOU SO
MUCH WE DO HAVE A MOTION BY
SATURN AND IS ON THE FLOOR DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY MISCELLANEOUS ROLL CALL
VOTE PLEASE CHOIR AYE SWEAR I
WIN. WIN AYE BELL HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG LARA
MORLOCK.
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE ZERO
VOTE WE'RE GOING TO BE ABLE TO
KEEP THA OPEN THAT WE ARE
MISSING TO MISTER LAWRENCE ON
COMMITTEE TODAY SO THANK YOU SO
MUCH THANK YOU SENATOR MY HAND
THANK YOU MEMBERS LIKE YOU
CENTER.
MEMBERS ARE NOW WILL JUMP IN AND
I APPRECIATE EVERYONE'S PATIENCE
IS WERE JUMPER ON THE AGENDA A
BIT. WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
S. B. TWELVE THIRTEEN THIS IS
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN ON OUR
CALENDAR TODAY.
RELATING TO PERSONAL INCOME
TAXES FOCUS ON HOW SOLELY
DEPENDENT CARE.
WE WELCOME THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
SAN DIEGO HERE TODAY.
WE HAVE MISTER ANDERSON.
SAN DIEGO IN MANY OTHER AREAS
AROUND.
GREAT SITTING COUNT.
THE CHANGE IN THE FLOORS OR
SUBMIT A PRESENT ON S. B. TWELVE
THIRTEEN. MISTER CHAIR I WANT TO
THANK YOU THIS I THINK THIS
FIRST I PRESENTED YOUR COMMITTEE
AND I'M CITING GET HERE SOONER
THOU GOOD SIR.
.
SADLY FOR MANY CALIFORNIA
FAMILIES IT'S GETTING HARDER AND
HARDER TO MAKE ENDS MEET.
RESULTING IN MILLIONS
CALIFORNIA'S CHILDREN GOING
WITHOUT FOOD WITHOUT CLOTHING IN
WITHOUT CHILD CARE.
THIS MEASURE SEEKS TO HELP THOSE
FAMILIES WHO HAVE GONE EITHER
UNSERVED BY GOVERNMENT PROGRAMS
OR DON'T QUALIFY FOR ASSISTANCE.
TODAY.
BUT THESE FAMILIES NONETHELESS
ARE EXPERIENCING INCREASED
HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION COSTS
YOU KNOW THE COST OF LIVING.
AND STAGNANT WAGES.
S. B. TWELVE THIRTEEN INCREASES
THE CHILD CARE. TAX CREDIT IN
MAKES IT REFUNDABLE.
FAMILIES ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
SUBSIDIZED CHILDCARE ONLY IF
THEIR INCOME FALLS. BELOW
SEVENTY PERCENT OF THE STATE
MEDIAN INCOME.
IN TWENTY SIXTEEN THAT WAS FIFTY
FOUR THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED
DOLLARS.
ACCORDING TO ANALYSIS.
BY THE END THE ADVANCEMENT
PROJECT CALIFORNIA REGARDING
INFANT AND TODDLER CARE IN LOS
ANGELES COUNTY.
FIFTY ONE PERCENT OF THE BABIES
AND TODDLERS WERE ELIGIBLE FOR
STATE SUBSIDIZED CHILD PROGRAMS
BUT ONLY SIX PERCENT OF THESE
CHILDREN WERE SERVED.
THIS BILL WOULD HELP THE OVER
NINETY PERCENT OF ELIGIBLE
RECIPIENTS
WHO ARE NOT SERVED IN
CALIFORNIA'S SHRINKING MIDDLE
CLASS.
LARA WHO FACE THE PRESSURES OF
INCREASED COST OF LIVING
COMBINED WITH STAGNANT WAGES.
WITHOUT THE HELP PROVIDED WITH
THIS CREDIT MANY OF THOSE
PARENTS WILL STOP HAVE TO
CONTINUE TO WORK AROUND THEIR
CHILDREN SCHEDULE. RESULTING IN
LAW LOW PAYING PART TIME JOBS.
MAKING THE DEPENDENT CHILD.
EXCUSE ME DEPENDENT CARE CREDIT.
REFUNDABLE REMOVES BARRIERS FOR
FAMILIES AND EMPOWERS THEM WITH
THE RESOURCES SUFFICIENT TO
SECURE QUALITY CHILDCARE WHICH
IN TURN ALLOWS THEM TO PURSUE
TRADITIONAL HIGHER PAYING JOBS.
SP TWELVE THIRTEEN WILL RESTORE
HOPE AND FINALLY LEFT.
RESTORE HOPE BY FINALLY LIFTING
THEIR ENTIRE FAMILY OUT OF THE
DAILY HARDSHIPS THEY HAVE BECOME
A WAY OF LIFE FOR FAR TOO MANY
LOW AND MIDDLE INCOME
CALIFORNIANS.
WITH ME TODAY CYNTHIA BRIDGES A
SENIOR ADVISER TO BOARD MEMBER
DRONE HORTON WHOSE TO SPONSOR OF
THE BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH MISTER
ANDERSON WAS BRIDGES WE WELCOME
YOU ON BEHALF OF THE GOOD MEMBER
AT YOU'VE TWO MINUTES MA'AM AND
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR ALL THE
WORK ON THE AT THE RESIDENCE
CALIFORNIA.
GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE.
AS THOSE SENATOR OUT ANDERSON
DID STATE CHILDCARE IS ONE OF
THE LARGEST COSTS THAT MOST LOW
INCOME AND MIDDLE INCOME.
FAMILIES.
INCUR.
.
THE CURRENT CREDIT AMOUNT IS
INSUFFICIENT CONSIDERING THE
INCREASED.
COST OF LIVING THAT
CALIFORNIANS FACE TODAY. AND.
WE ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS
PARTICULAR PROPOSAL.
YOU SO MUCH MA'AM WE WOULD LIKE
TO BE TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
OUT HERE IN THE AUDIENCE TODAY
THAT WOULD LIKE TO GO TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL. IF YOU
ARE INCLINED TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD TO THE MICROPHONE STATE
FIRST LASSEN ORGANIZATION.
DO WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE WHO WOULD
LIKELY TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF
THE BILL OR IF YOU'RE STILL
THINKING ABOUT IT WE WELCOME YOU
TO.
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT BACK TO
THIS COMMITTEE TO BETTER SEE
PLAYED ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
SIMILAR.
I'M I'M JUST CURIOUS SENATOR
ANDERSON HOW DOES THIS CREDIT
INTERFACE WITH THE EARNED INCOME
TAX. CREDIT.
I'M TO DEFER TO CYNTHIA SHE'S
THE EXPERT IN THIS FIELD YEAH
AND. THAT THE IF YOU DON'T MIND.
AND CERTAINLY THIS IS A SEPARATE
STANDALONE CREDIT.
IT IN ADDITION TO THE AIR AND
INCOME TAX CREDIT.
SO THEN WHAT IS THE WHAT IS THE
MAXIMUM AMOUNT THAT SOMEONE
MAKING FIFTY FOUR THOUSAND
TAXABLE INCOME.
WOULD RECEIVE THEM WELLOF THE
CREDIT IS A CURRENTLY
EXTRAPOLATION AT.
FIFTY. IT'S.
.
IT'S BASED ON THE. CHILDCARE
COST.
THAT ARE INCURRED. AND THE
PERCENTAGE IS.
APPLIED
TOWARDS THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS
FOR AN INDIVIDUAL.
WITH CHILDREN.
WITH ONE CHILD OR SIX THOUSAND
DOLLARS FOR AN INDIVIDUAL OR
FAMILY WITH TWO OR MORE CHILDREN.
AND WHATEVER THE COST IT I MEAN
THAT'S THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT THAT
CAN BE.
.
APPLIED WITH REGARD TO EXPENSES
INCURRED YOU TAKE THE EXPENSES
INCURRED UP TO THOSE AMOUNTS AND
THEN YOU APPLY THE PERCENTAGE TO
THAT AMOUNT.
THE ALLOWABLE PERCENTAGE WHICH
CURRENTLY IS FIFTY PERCENT FOR
THOSE THAT ARE EARNING LESS THAN
FORTY THOUSAND DOLLARS. THIRTY
FOUR PERCENT FOR THOSE THAT ARE
EARNING BETWEEN FORTY THOUSAND
AND SEVENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS AND
THEN SEVENTY THOUSAND TO ONE
HUNDRED THOUSAND.
DOLLARS.
SO I HOPE USUALLY YOU GET A
CREDIT AND IT'S.
NOT REFUNDABLE IT SHOULD STOP
STATURE IT JUST UPSETS YOUR A.
TAX LIABILITY YOUR WERE ACTUALLY
KINDA GIVING MONEY.
BUT TRYING TO. THE HOUSE SENATOR
ANDERSON YOU KNOW I I EVEN VOTED
AGAINST THE EARNED INCOME TAX
CREDIT THAT UP BECAUSE I MEAN
SORT OF BUT.
I I'M JUST WORRIED ABOUT THE
STATE IN ITS REVENUE SOME TRYING
TO AS AS A FORMER TAX PREPARER
TRYING TO.
VISUALIZE WHAT HAPPENS BUT ALSO
SOME ITS FUTURE ABOUT THE BUDGET
I.
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT I I JUST
TWO SUCH BIG BILLS ON THE
HORIZON. FOR THIS STATE WITH ITS
UNFUNDED LIABILITIES THAT I'M
TRYNA.
FIGURE OUT HOW I HELP. IN THE
WHOLE EQUATION SO THAT'S WHERE
I'M AT EVERY WHAT TROUBLE I HAVE
AN ARGUMENT FOR YOU THAT.
AS A LITTLE BIT OFF THE BEATEN
PATH.
BUT WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE
CHILDCARE OR DEPENDABLE
CHILDCARE AND YOU HAVE TO WORK
AROUND YOUR CHILDREN SCHEDULE.
YOU'RE LIMITED TO WHERE YOU CAN
BE EMPLOYED.
AND THAT MEANS.
LOW PAYING WAGES THAT MEANS OUR
TIME TO APPRECIATE ALL THAT IS
I'M JUST WANTING IT WELL GOING
TO GIVE IT WELL IF WE MOVE
PEOPLE TO HIRE. IF WE'RE ABLE TO
ASSIST PEOPLE TO HIGHER WAGES.
THE TAX STRUCTURE CHANGES.
AND WE ALREADY HAVE PROGRAMS IN
PLACE THAT WE ARE PAYING FOR.
THEY'RE NOT DELIVERING WHEN YOU
THINK IN TERMS OF WHAT'S GOING
ON WITH LOS ANGELES AND ONLY SIX
PROTECT SIX PERCENT OF THE
CHILDREN.
WHO QUALIFIER OR PARTICIPATE IN
THAT PROGRAM?
TO FILL PROGRAM.
AND WHAT THIS DOES IS IT
EMPOWERS THE FAMILIES BY NOT
GOING THROUGH A HUGE BUREAUCRACY
WITH THAT THEY CAN'T. FIGURE OUT
HOW TO NAVIGATE BUT ACTUALLY
GETS THE RESOURCES IT WAS IN A
VERY EFFICIENT WAY. THAT WOULD
LEAD TO HIGHER PAYING WAGES
WHICH BENEFITS EVERYONE.
IT GETS SO THAT WOULD BE HOW WE
WOULD GET THE REVENUES TO OFFSET.
OKAY.
THAT'S GETS AN ANSWER THANK YOU
THANK YOU MISTER.
THANK YOU SO MUCH IVON QUICK
QUESTIONS IS WELL SOMEONE
SOMEWHERE DOWN THE LINE ON THE
BUT.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE
COMMITTEE.
SO A TRANSFORMER TIME SO I THINK
WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT SERVE
FISCAL YEAR BAD. THE ESTIMATE IS
ABOUT SIXTY MILLION EIGHTEEN
NINETEEN HUNDRED MILLION FOR
NINETEEN TWENTY.
AND A HUNDRED MILLION FOR
TWENTY TWENTY ONE AND AS WE
CONTINUE GO DOWN SO.
GO DOWN THE LINE REGARDS AT.
THE COUNTER IN YEARS.
TO TALK ABOUT THAT A BIT ITS
DEBTS
SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT OBVIOUSLY
VERY IMPORTANT BUT NEEDING TO BE
UNDER DEVELOPED SO WHAT WE DO IF
WE HAVE MONEY ALLOCATED.
FOR PROGRAMS ARE NOT WORKING I
MEAN RIGHT NOW WE IF ONLY SIX
PERCENT OF THE QUALIFY CHILDREN
ARE PARTICIPATING RECEIVING
THOSE BENEFITS.
WE SHOULD BE LOOKING AT
EFFECTIVENESS BEFORE WE CAN WE
CAN PROMISE THE WORLD. ANYTHING
WE WANT BUT WE NEVER INTEND AND
DELIVERING ON THOSE PROMISES
THOUGH FAILED FALSE PROMISES
SPECIFICALLY THOUGH WHAT I'M
LOOKING FOR IS JUST. THAT SO
WE'RE LOOKING AT A HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLAR INVESTMENT.
ON GOING FROM ABOUT TWENTY
NINETEEN TWENTY TWENTY RUN WHAT
WE HAVE THIS SO I'M JUST I KNOW
YOU'RE SAYING THAT THERE ARE
SOME I HANG ON ONE SECOND I'M
NOT DONE SO I AND IF THERE ARE
PROGRAMS THAT ARE WORKING I GET
IT THERE'S ALWAYS. THAT WE CAN
LOOK AT EFFICIENCIES AND WE CAN
LOOK IMPROVEMENTS I'M JUST
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT.
JUST IN THE ON GOING COSTS AND
HOW YOU SEE. WHAT WHAT THE
STATION DUE TO BE A TO PAY FOR
PARTICULARLY HEADER AB IN ARAB
RECESSION IN THIS IS AN
IMPORTANT ISSUE RIGHT I DON'T
WANNA? I WANNA MAKE THAT CLEAR.
BUT I'M GONNA DEFERRED TO
CYNTHIA COULD USE THE EXPERT BUT
I WOULD SAY BEFORE I DIFFER.
THEY HAD TO.
MANY OF THESE QUESTIONS WILL BE
ANSWERING AND APPROPRIATIONS
EFFORT IF IT WOULD HARDLY GET
THROUGH THIS POLICY COMMITTEE.
SEC IF YOU WOULD MIND SPEAKING
TO THAT.
CERTAINLY.
.
ONE OF THE.
SUGGESTIONS THAT MEMBER HORTON
HAS IS TO.
UTILIZE SOME OF THE.
OR ACTUALLY SAVED YOU SOME OF
THE UNDER UTILIZED.
ALLOCATIONS THAT ARE APPLIED TO
OTHER TAX EXPENDITURES FOR
EXAMPLE THE RESEARCH AND
DEVELOPMENT CREDIT.
IS UNDER UTILIZED BY ABOUT IF I
MAKE IT ABSOLUTELY.
.
ABOUT.
THIRTY THOUSAND OF THREE
HUNDRED THOUSAND I'M SORRY THREE
HUNDRED. MILLION DOLLARS.
.
AND THERE ARE A COUPLE OF OTHER
TAX EXPENDITURES THAT ARE
ALLOCATED BUT.
OR WHEN CLAIMS ARE
SUBSTANTIALLY LESS THAN THAT
AMOUNT SO THOSE MIGHT BE OTHER
OPTIONS TO CONSIDER.
FOR COVERING THE COST
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS PARTICULAR
PROPOSAL.
OKAY.
LOOK I THINK THAT I. THIS
COMMITTEES FOCUS ON POLICY. UP
IN THERE BUT THE REASON I BRING
THIS UP IS I THINK THERE'S BEEN
A HISTORY WE'VE HAD. A. B..
TO THIRTY THAT WAS HELD IN
ASSEMBLY PROCS WE HAD AB TWENTY
SIX SEVENTY SIX.
IN REGARDS TO A CREDIT.
HELD.
WE HAD.
SP TWO SIXTY EIGHT ONLY REASON
I BRING THAT UP IS
WHILE THIS IS A VERY WORTHY AND
IMPORTANT POLICY ISSUE.
.
IT HAS NOT HAD.
SUCCESS IN REGARDS TO GETTING
THROUGH THE PREPARATION SIDE IN
AGAIN AS THE.
GOOD CENTERED SAID THAT'S THAT
WERE THERE FOCUS WILL BE ABSENT
OWES IS AN IMPORTANT ISSUE TO
THE SENATOR.
AND WANTING TO BE OF THE MOVIES
TODAY I JUST HAVE SOME CONCERN.
AGAIN ON HOW THIS IS GOING TO BE
REMOVED AS WE'VE SEEN AYE AYE
HISTORY OF IT PUBLIC SUPPORT IN
HERE TODAY SENATOR BUT I I THINK
THAT IS A IT'S A REAL QUESTION
THAT'S GOING TO NEED TO BE
ANSWERED. AS WE GO DOWN THE LINE
MISTER CHAIR I GREW WITH YOU
WHOLE HEARTEDLY I WOULD SUBMIT
TO YOU THOUGH.
IF WE LOOK IN THE BROADER JUST
PLENTY OF PLACES TO FIND AND I I
DON'T WANT TO LIMIT BY SATAN IT
CAN ONLY BE FUNDED THIS WAY. BUT
WE LOOKED IN THE BROADER STROKES.
OVER THE LAST SEVEN YEARS WE'VE
HAD A SIXTY FIVE PERCENT
INCREASE IN REVENUE TO THE STATE.
WE HAVE NOT BUILD ROADS WITH THE
MONEY WE HAVEN'T FULLY RESTORED
THE MONEY WE OWE TO. TO
EDUCATION
CERTAINLY.
WE CAN TAKE CARE OF CHILD CARE
WITH THAT INCREASE IN REVENUE
AND WE KNOW THAT THAT REVENUES
ONLY GOING TO INCREASE MORE THIS
YEAR.
SO INSTEAD OF BUTTERFLY
FESTIVALS IN CERTAIN SENATORS
DISTRICTS PERHAPS AWARE AND I'M
NOT REFERRING TO YOUR DISTRICT.
BUT WE DID WE PASSED A MONARCH
BUTTERFLY FESTIVAL LAST YEAR.
AND I THINK IT'S I THINK IT'S A
GREAT BUT MONARCH BUTTERFLIES
ARE NOT.
I IN DANGER TO IT WAS A MILLION
DOLLARS.
IF WE WILL LOOK AT THOSE
PROGRAMS AND SAD. CHILDREN'S
WELFARE.
FOR MONARCH BUTTERFLIES I THINK
THE MAJORITY OF OUR FLOOR
OVERWHELMINGLY.
WOULD BE IN SUPPORT OF OUR CHILL
CALIFORNIA'S CHILDREN ENSURING
THAT THEY HAVE FOOD THEY HAVE
CLOTHES AND THEY HAVE CARE.
AND IF I MAY ALSO INTERJECT A
ANOTHER CORNERSTONE OF.
IMPORTANT IS JOBS
CREATION OF JOBS AND I THINK HE
SEES THIS PROPOSAL AS ONE WAY OF
ALSO ENSURING THAT.
MANY CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS ARE
ABLE TO.
SEEK BETTER JOBS BETTER PAYING
JOBS AND TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY
DO THEY HAVE MORE.
DISCRETIONARY INCOME WHICH ALSO
SUFFERS A CONSUMER SPENDING AND
ULTIMATELY INCREASES TAX
REVENUES.
THANKYOU SO MUCH.
SO WE HAVE THE MONARCH
BUTTERFLY FESTIVAL WHICH I HAD
NOT BEEN TO.
AND NOW WE HAVE NINETY NINE
MILLION DOLLARS MORE TO GO.
THAT SAID AGAIN WE ARE FOCUSED
ON THE POLICY IN THIS COMMITTEE
UNDERTAKE THAT SERVES OUR
CLOSING. ARGUMENT THANK YOU FOR
FOR.
ALLOWING US TO PRESENT TODAY
AND I THINK YOU FOR YOUR
KINDNESS NO THANK YOU SO MUCH
AND THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING
HERE AS WELL APPRECIATE BOTH
YOUR HARD WORK. WE ARE LOOKING
FOR A WE HAVE A MOTION BY THE
VICE CHAIR THIS IS A DO PASSED
TO APPROPRIATIONS.
A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE MISSING
GESTURE CHOIR AYE WHERE I'M A
WIN. WIN AYE BELL FERNANDES
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG LARA
MORLOCK.
WE CURRENTLY HAVE A THREE ZERO
AND KEEP THE ROLE OPENED.
WILL NEED WE HAD AT LEAST ONE
MORE VOTE TO IT IN CENTER LARA
IS NOT HERE TODAY SO TO AND I IF
IT FAILS. RECONSIDERATION COURSE
ABSOLUTELY GREAT MONEY SO MUCH
THANK YOU THANK YOU SENATOR.
FIGURE.
ALRIGHT.
SHOULD WE HAVE BEEN INFORMED BY
SENATOR GLAZERS OFFICE THAT HE
IS GOING TO BE PULLING ITEM
NUMBER EIGHT S. B. TWELVE TWENTY
FIVE TODAY.
A AND IS LOOKING TO PUT THAT ON
FOR IT NEXT WEEK BUT WE DO WANT
YOU KNOW THAT CENTER GLAZIER THE
AUTHOR IS PERSONALLY PULLING. SP
TWELVE TWENTY FIVE TODAY THEY
WILL BE LOOKING. TO PUT THAT
BACK ON NEXT WEEK.
IF WE GO.
WE ARE NOW GONNA BE MOVING ON TO
ITEM NUMBER NINE ON OUR CALENDAR
TODAY THAT'S S. B. THIRTEEN OF
THREE SENATOR PAN.
WE WELCOME THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
SACRAMENTO HERE TODAY.
THE SENATOR IS WEARING MANY HATS
AS HE'S ALSO CHAIRING A
COMMITTEE.
SO I AND I NEED TO SEE HIM
SHORTLY.
COMING UP AS WELL.
SO THIS IS FOCUSING ON.
CORNER'S OFFICE IN SOME VERY
SPECIFIC COUNTIES.
IN FOCUSING ON THE COUNTY
OFFICE OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER.
CENTER PAN AT THE FLOOR IS YOURS
SIR.
OKAY THANK THANK YOU. SIR CHAIR
CENTERS I DO HAVE A WITNESS
WHO'S ON THE HOT LITTLE THE ON
THE WAY SO I APPRECIATE YOUR
INDULGENCE BATTLED BEGIN MY.
OPENING TESTIMONY HERE. SO
THANK YOU AT FIRST I WANT TO SEE
BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND THINKING I WANT
THANKS YOU SO MUCH. AS THEIR
CARE CHAIR AND THE STAFF FOR
WORKING WITH ME ON ON THE SPELL.
S. B. THIRTY NO THREE WILL
REQUIRE AND MEDICAL EXAMINER'S
OFFICE TO BE ESTABLISHED IN LIEU
OF A SHARE OF CORNER IN NINE
CHARTER COUNTIES WITH A
POPULATION OF FIVE HUNDRED
THOUSAND OR MORE.
ACROSS OUR GREAT COUNTRY THE
MEDICAL EXAMINER MODEL IS THE
QUALITY STANDARD AND.
WHERE IN THIS MODEL THE
FORENSIC PATHOLOGISTS IS
ACTUALLY IN CHARGE OF THE
AUTOPSY AND THE SUBSEQUENT
REPORT? HOWEVER CALIFORNIA IS
ONE OF THE LAST STATES TO
MAINTAIN THE SHERIFF CORNER
MODEL TO INVESTIGATE SUSPICIOUS
DEATHS.
IN THIS MODEL AND ELECTED LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL THE SHARE
IS CHARGED WITH OVERSEEING ARE
THE AUTOPSIES AND INVESTIGATE
SUSPICIOUS DEATHS INCLUDING.
INCLUDING THOSE THAT MAY INVOLVE
A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER EVEN
IN YOUR OWN. DEPARTMENT.
CURRENTLY THE MAJORITY OF
CALIFORNIA COUNTIES DO OPERATE
SHERIFF CORNER MODEL WHERE BY
THE SHERIFF.
IS RESPONSIBLE SO ALTHOUGH IN
THOSE COUNTIES A LICENSED
PHYSICIAN WHO IS A UP
PROFESSIONALS A FORENSIC
PATHOLOGIST TO CONDUCT THE
AUTOPSY DID THE TERMINATION OF
THE MANNER OF DEATH WHETHER THIS
IS AN ACCIDENT HOMICIDE. AFTER
BECAUSE STILL REMAINS VESTED IN
THE SHERIFF.
THIS MEANS THAT IN UNDER A CHEF
QUORUM MODEL.
THIS ELECTED LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICER WHO DOESN'T HAVE MEDICAL
BACKGROUND CAN OVERRULE THE
FINDINGS OF A BOARD CERTIFIED
FORENSIC PATHOLOGIST AS IT
PERTAINS TO THE MANNER OF DEATH
DETERMINATION.
S. B. THIRTY NO THREE IS A
RESPONSE TO ALLEGATIONS OF
IMPROPER INFLUENCE INTO THE
MEDICAL DETERMINATION OF
POSITIONS CONDUCTING AUTOPSIES.
IN SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY AND WE'VE
HEARD ALSO FROM SOME OTHER
COUNTIES AS WELL. IN THIS SKIN
SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY TO FOR A
QUALIFIED FORENSIC PATHOLOGIST
RESIGNED IN LATE TWENTY NINTH
SEVENTEEN AND IF YOU'RE ON PLAY
OF A CHAIR OF COURSE THAT'S
RESULT YOU'RE ONLY.
RECOURSE ALLEGING THAT THE
SHARE PRESSURED THEM INTO
CHANGING THE FINDINGS AND
REPORTS OUTLINED THE CAUSE AND
MANNER OF DEATH OF INDIVIDUALS
INVOLVED IN OFFICER RELATED
DEATHS.
THE POSITIONS ALSO ALLEGE THAT
CRITICAL INFORMATION WITH SOME
WAS WITHHELD. FOR THE PURPOSE OF
FRUSTRATING THEIR ABILITY TO
ACTUALLY DETERMINE THE TYPE IN
MANNER OF THE INDIVIDUALS THAT.
NOW ENSURING THAT AUTOPSIES ARE
DONE IN AND ETHICAL EQUITABLE
MANNER AND ALSO AN OBJECTIVE
MANNER IS ESSENTIAL TO ASSURING
CONFIDENCE IN A CRIMINAL JUSTICE
SYSTEMS. THESE AUTOPSIES ARE
OFTEN THE BASIS FOR CRIMINAL
CHARGES AND IT'S IMPERATIVE THAT
THE PUBLIC.
GAINES ENOUGH SURFACTANT TERMINE
FALLEN DELIVER JUSTICE
MISSION A CLINICAL
DETERMINATIONS MADE BY
PHYSICIANS MUST BE FREE FROM
UNDUE INFLUENCES FROM POLITICAL
OFFICIALS.
THE PROFESSIONALS RESPONSIBLE
FOR THE AUTOPSY IN THE AUTOPSY
REPORT. SHOULD NOT BE CONSIDERED
PART OF THE PROSECUTION OR
DEFENSE BUT SHOULD BE AN OBJECT.
OBJECTIVE FINDER OF THE FACTS.
S. B. THIRTY NO THREE IS A VITAL
BILL THAT SAFEGUARDS OUR
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM BY
INSULATING THE FOOD
PROFESSIONALS THE POSITIONS FROM
UNDUE PRESSURE INTRUSION BY
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE NO MEDICAL
TRAINING WHO MAY HAVE A
PERCEIVED. IF NOT REAL CONFLICT
OF INTEREST
SO I'M PROUD TODAY TO HAVE.
DOCTOR MALLU WITH THE UNION
MECHANIZATION DENTISTS OUT WHO
ALSO WAS THE FORMER.
FORENSIC PATHOLOGISTS AND WE CAN
COUNTY HERE TO TESTIFY AND SEWER
THOMPSON FOR THE CALIFORNIA
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION ANSWER ANY
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS.
BUT THE EXTRA SEGMENT WITH
BRANDY AND YES.
LA DOCTOR BUS IS WELL FOR YOU
EIGHTY SO. THAT COME OUT OF. THE
ARCHITECT THANK YOU SO MUCH IN
JUST A IS I THINK WE WENT OVER
THE BRIEF WE TYPICALLY HAVE TWO
PRIMARY WITNESSES IN THE
COMMITTEE BUT LEVEL.
.
IT'S AND STUFF ALL THROUGH THE
YEAR WE WELCOME AND YOU'RE GOING
TO ASK YOU TO PLEASE KEEP.
YOUR TESTIMONY DEBATE TO TWO
MINUTES PLEASE AND IF YOU COULD
PLEASE A STATE YOUR FIRST AND
LAST.
OKAY DOT DOCTOR STUART BUT CITY
ON THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNION OF
AMERICAN PHYSICIANS AND DENTISTS
AND FAMILY PHYSICIAN ARE DONE MY
PERSONAL EXPERIENCE WITH THAT
SEARCH OF EGGS VERY.
SIMPLE IN SUBURBAN.
BUT WHEN YOU GET DOWN THE
COMPLEX CASES OF UNEXPECTED IN
VIOLENT DEATHS WE DEPEND ON
EXPERT DEATH INVESTIGATION.
THAT WE'RE HERE TO SUPPORT AS
DOCTOR PANTS AT S. B. THIRTEEN
OH THREE.
MOST OF THE COUNTIES AS YOU
MENTION OUR STATE OF ALLOW FOR
UNQUOTE ON.
QUALIFIED.
Y..
OR.
NON DEGREED.
OF PERSONNEL TO DO THESE MEDICAL
INVESTIGATIONS.
THIS CAME TO PASS FROM OVER THE
LAST SEVERAL DECADES IN FACT THE
CORNER SYSTEM GOES BACK TO
ENGLAND. THE PROBLEM IS THAT
PEOPLE IN CHARGE THE CARS IN
CHARGE OF THE DESTINY. OF
DETERMINATIONS AND MANNER OF
DEATH.
I HAVE CONFLICTS OF INTEREST IN
SAMBORTO DO YOU KNOW WE HAD OUR
MONEY BY MEMBERS CALLED ME UP
THEY FOUND A.
THIRTY FOUR YEAR OLD FACE DOWN
IN A THIRTY GALLON GARBAGE CAN
AND SUBVERSION THIRTEEN INCHES
OF WATER WITH A BAG OVER HIS
HEAD THAT WAS. DETERMINED.
UNDETERMINED CAUSE OF DEATH.
WHO IS PRESSURE FROM THE HOME
FROM THE CORNERS?
SO THAT.
.
HAD A BIG IMPACT ON THE FAMILY
AS FAR AS.
INSURANCE ENCLOSURE.
MOST OF THESE CASES HAVE THESE
OF OF THE FACTS NOT ONLY IN
SOCIETY FOR LEARNING ABOUT
COMMUNICABLE DISEASES.
BUT ALSO IN THE FAMILIES.
MEDICAL EXAMINER IN ON ANOTHER
COUNTY NORTHERN CALIFORNIA TO
WITNESS DROWNING WAS
INACCURATELY REPORTED BY THE
CONTRACTED A PATHOLOGIST.
WE NEEDED A FORENSIC PATHOLOGIST
COME IN TO GIVE THE CORRECT
DIAGNOSIS OF DROWNING THERE I
COULD GO ON WHAT SEVERAL
EXAMPLES IN DIFFERENT COUNTIES.
BUT IT IS A WIDESPREAD PROBLEM
BEYOND SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY. AND
THE SOLUTIONS AS WE MENTIONED
WERE TO ALLOW AN INDEPENDENT
ARBITER A JUDGE A FORENSIC
PATHOLOGIST.
TO MAKE A FEW A TO BE THE
CAPTAIN OF THE TEAM SO TO SPEAK
SO THE COUNTIES WITH HALF A
MILLION PEOPLE. TEN OR TWELVE
AND CALIFORNIA WILL HAVE THIS
MANDATE OF A MEDICAL EXAMINER
DISCRETIONARY FOR THE OTHER
COUNTIES.
BUT EACH GROUP OF PROFESSIONALS
DO WHAT THEY DO BEST MEDICAL
EXAMINERS BECAUSE A MATTER OF
DEATH IF THERE'S AHOMICIDE
POLICE INVESTIGATE IF HIS ARREST
A PROSECUTOR.
THANK YOU SO MUCH ADDRESS HE
GRATEFUL YOU'RE HERE WE'RE GONNA
NOW TURNED TO DOCTOR MALL LOUIS
LEFT ME SIR YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES.
THAT'S LIKE STOP BOB DOCTOR
BENETTON MY LITTLE I HAVE A FIVE
BOARD CERTIFICATIONS AND MAD AS
SAYING THUY. DOT TOP SCIENCE ON
OR WE DID CREATES ON DATA LOST
YEAH I RECEIVED. THE
DISTINGUISHED SERVICE AWARD
WHICH IS THE HIGHEST OUT WHAT
ANY PHYSICIAN CALMLY SIPPING THE
UNITED STATES. FOUGHT TO WALK I
HAVE DONE FOR PATIENT SAFETY.
BOTTOM SOUGHT TO TELL IT TO
GARY BASED ON MY SCIENTIFIC
EXPERIENCE. DOT THE STATE OF CA.
CALIFORNIA ALL GO THE EXTRA MOST
PROGRESSIVE STATE.
MOST DOG FOUND STATE WITH THE
LARGEST ECONOMY.
CALIFORNIA HAS THE MOST BOX WHAT.
SYSTEM MEAN DEATH INVESTIGATION.
IS THE MOST BACKWARD STATE.
AND FIND SIX SCIENCE ON IN
FORENSIC MEDICINE.
IT WILL BE A STATE OF ALABAMA
THE STATE OF MISSISSIPPI IS MORE
OUT FONT DONE THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. WHEN IT COMES TO
FIND SICK MADISON.
IN NINETEEN TWENTY EIGHT AND I
HAVE THE PAPER HERE BIG NATIONAL
ACADEMIES OF SCIENCE IN JUNIOR
RENOWNED MEDICINE IN NINETEEN
TWENTY EIGHT.
OVER FIFTY YEARS BEFORE I WAS
BORN STATE TO IT.
BUDDY SHERIFF CORONER SYSTEM
DOES NOT NO LONGER SERVES THE
INTEREST OF THE PUBLIC.
IT. PUBLIC TRUST.
HONDA PUBLIC CONFIDENCE.
IN NINETEEN FIFTY FULL.
THE.
NATIONAL CONFERENCE OF
COMMISSIONERS ON UNIFORM STATE
LAWS
REPEAT TED WHAT WAS REPEAT WHAT
WAS SAID IN NINETEEN TWENTY
EIGHT.
IN TWO THOUSAND AND NINE NOW THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE OF THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. STATE
HAD DIED IT WAS HIGH TIME WE GOT
A LEAD ON THE SHOP IF GOV ON A
SYSTEM. THAT IS THE COLONIAL
SYSTEM WE EVEN HAD WE TED PUBLIC
KINGS OF ENGLAND. AYE NOW PEOPLE
HAVE SAID. THAT A MEDICAL
EXAMINER SYSTEM WHICH WAS
CREATED IN THE UNITED STATES.
IS MY EXPENSIVE DOWN TO SHARIF
COHEN A SYSTEM. DOT IS NOT TRUE.
THAT IS COMPLETELY FAULTS WE
NEED TO BASE PUBLIC POLICY ON
EVIDENCE
I'M PUBLISHED SCIENTIFIC
EVIDENCE.
ON IN MY WE SUCH DIDN'T NATIONAL
INSTITUTE OF JUSTICE.
ALL THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE OF
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
IN TWENTY THIRTEEN. DID ON
EXTENSIVE ANALYSIS
I'M PUBLISHED A PAPER. ON HOW BE
PEOPLE HERE.
THAT SAVES.
WELL AS LONG DOES ANY CATCHMENT
BELIEVE YOUR HOUSE A POPULATION
OF FIVE PHONE THAT POWERS SO NO
MORE.
TACTIC BACK CAPITO EXPENDITURE
MAY TWELFTH WE DAHLE LOS SOMEONE
YOU FIVE CENTS.
GOT IT IS NO MORE EXPENSIVE
DONNA SHOW ME OF COHEN A SYSTEM.
IM DOT DEVELOP BOOK TANGIBLE AND
INTANGIBLE COSTS.
DETACHABLE COST TWELVE HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS BUT WHAT ABOUT
THE INTANGIBLE COSTS OF PUBLIC
TRUST.
PUBLIC CONFIDENCE.
REPUBLICAN TRUST MILO WE'RE
GONNA HAVE YOU.
CONCLUDING ABOUT THIRTY SECONDS
AND I ASSURE YOU WERE TO HAVE
YOU BACK UP TO ANSWER QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS TO PLEASE SIR YES
PLEASE I LOW POINT AIDS WE
ALWAYS TALK ABOUT. CRIMES CRIMES.
SIXTY TO SEVENTY PERCENT OF
CASES HANDLED BY A CO KNOWS
OFFICE PASSED STRICTLY MEDICAL
CASES
DOT INVOLVES HOT CALL MEDICAL
EXPERTISE OR KNOWLEDGE.
I MY FEAR ARE LOGGED ITS STATE
SO MUCH
BUT ARE STATES LIKE MARYLAND NEW
YORK I'M OPENING TO TWENTY FIRST
CENTURY FORENSIC PATHOLOGY. WHEN
I'M TALKING ABOUT MORE LEGAL LAW
AUTOPSY METABOLIC AUTOPSIES
GENETIC AUTOPSY.
WOODY CHO INSTEAD WE HAVE SHALL
BE OF CORONA I GOVERNMENT T. YOU
WHO IS TALKING ABOUT. IN THE
PAST ONE HUNDRED YEARS I'VE
RESEARCH LAST NIGHT.
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER NOT BE
OBVIOUS CITY OF NEW YORK. HOUSE
PUBLISHED ABOUT ONE THOUSAND
PAPERS TO ADVANCE MEDICAL
SCIENCE.
NEW QUESTION I HOP BECAUSE
SOMEBODY SHOWN ME AND THE
MEDICAL SCIENTIFIC PAPER.
PUBLISHED BY A SHERIFF COLONIAL
INDIA STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN THE
PAST ONE HUNDRED YEARS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH THROWING AGAIN
WILL HAVE YOU BACK UP FOR
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
COMMITTEE AS WELL BE* YOU
BEING HERE TODAY.
BURGER MISTER THOMPSON.
MISS THAT MISS JOHNSON WERE
RUNNING A LITTLE BE HIGH I JUST
I'M HERE FOR TECHNICAL QUESTIONS
YOU ALL MY TIME TO THAT FROM ALL
OF THE NO THANK YOU SO MUCH YOU
APPRECIATE THAT. WE KNOW WOULD
LIKE TO GET A WELCOME
INDIVIDUALS WHO DECADE COMPORTED
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IF
YOU COULD PLEASE STATE YOUR
FIRST AND LAST NAME. ARE ALONG
WITH ORGANIZATION WE WELCOME YOU
TO COMMITTEE.
COULD YOU SEE SIR.
THE CITY IS WHAT MUST CHAIR HA
MISTER MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE
PRIDE HOUSE AND ON BEHALF OF THE
AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE
COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES
ALSO SUPPORT THINKING SO MUCH.
BUT MORE INJURED MEMBERS BOB
ACKERMAN TO HAVE THE CALIFORNIA
STUDY PATHOLOGISTS IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH GOOD MORNING
THE CHAIR MEMBERS JEAN HER
SEARCH HIM BEHALF OF THE SANTA
CLARA COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS IN SUPPORT THINK YOU
VERY MUCH.
WE LIKE REALLY DO ONE LAST CALL
TO BE DISCIPLINED ANYONE ELSE
WHO IS IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
TO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
BUT WE'RE NOT GONNA GO TO THOSE
WHO ARE OPPOSED SUBURBAN ASK
EACH OF OUR WITNESSES TO BE ABLE
TO AYE IF YOU KNOW MY GIVE OF
YOUR CHAIRS A TEMPORARILY WE'RE
NOT GONNA. WELCOME OUR PRIMARY
WITNESSES.
WHO ARE OPPOSED JUST TO MAKE
SURE THAT WE ARE FAIR AND
EQUITABLE WE?
ARE GOING TO GIVE SOME EXTRA
TIME BUT TO THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED TO IT EQUAL TIME FOR
EACH SIDE.
BUT AND WE WELCOME BOTH YOU THAT
TO THE COMMITTEE WHO WOULD LIKE
TO BE TO KICK US OFF AND ARE IN
IF YOU COULD JUST PLEASE STATE
YOUR FIRST AND LAST ORGANIZATION
AGAIN. WOULD GIVE A LITTLE BIT
EXTRA TIME AS WE GIVE EXTRA TIME
I TO THOSE WHO AND SUPPORTS WE
WELCOME YOU. HERE. JESSICA DEVIN
TEN THE ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
COUNTIES. IN OPPOSITION TO THE
LEGISLATION.
COUNTIES CURRENTLY HAVE THE
ABILITY TO CREATE AN OFFICE OF
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER GIPSON
RANDY POLET UP EVEN A LITTLE
TIGHTER I APOLOGIZE THANK YOU SO
MUCH FOR TAKING A RELIGIOUS.
SPECIFICALLY GOVERNMENT CODE
SECTION TWENTY FOUR ZERO TEN
PROVIDES A BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
WITH THE AUTHORITY TO ABOLISH BY
ORDINANCE. THE OFFICE OF THE
CORONER AND PROVIDE INSTEAD FOR
THE OFFICE OF THE EXAMINER.
COUNTIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
HAVE CONSIDERED THAT WHAT MODEL
BEST SERVE THE PEOPLE OF THEIR
COMMUNITIES. WE HAVE ACTUALLY
HAD COUNTIES EXERCISE ITS
AUTHORITY COUNTIES LIKE SAN
DIEGO LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO
VENTURA.
AND MOST RECENTLY SANTA CLARA.
WE ALSO KNOW THAT WE HAVE
COUNTIES CURRENT BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS CURRENTLY
CONSIDERING IF THEY SHOULD MOVE
TO THE OFFICE OF THE MEDICAL
EXAMINER MODEL.
COUNTY'S LIKE CINEMA AND SAN
JOAQUIN COUNTY.
THIS IS NOT A NEW ISSUE FOR THE
COUNTIES AND THE ARGUMENTS MADE
HERE TODAY IN SUPPORT OF THE
LEGISLATION CERTAINLY MERIT
CONSIDERATION. BUT THAT
CONSIDERATION SHOULD BE MADE ON
THE COUNTY LEVEL BY THE
INDIVIDUAL COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS. THE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS ARE IN THE BEST
POSITION TO UNDERSTAND THE
FISCAL IMPACTS.
THAT SUCH A MOVE WILL HAVE ON
THEIR COMMUNITIES FOR EXAMPLE
SANTA CLARA DID IS THE MOST
RECENT COUNTY TO MOVE OVER. AT
COST FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND FIRST
YEAR TO GET THE.
TO GET THE OFFICE STARTED AN
ONGOING PERSONNEL COSTS OF
ROUGHLY EIGHT HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
SO IN CLOSING THE COUNT AND THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
COUNTIES BELIEVES THAT THIS BILL
UNNECESSARILY REMOVE THE
COUNTIES LOCAL CONTROL TO DECIDE
HOW TO ORGANIZE OUR OPERATIONS.
TO BEST SERVE THEIR COMMUNITIES
BOTH ADMINISTRATIVELY AND
FISCALLY.
WE GET SO MUCH IN IF YOU HAVE
ANY OTHER ITEMS.
ACTUALLY SHERIFF'S WE WELCOME
INITIAL COMMENTS HAVE SOME SHORT
TIME WE WERE CONCERNED GET GOOD
MORNING GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIR MEMBERS CORSO'S ALONE HERE
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION.
REGRETTABLY IN HERE IN
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL FIRST.
LIKE TO THANK THE COMMITTEE.
STAFF MEMBER STAFF.
YOURSELF AND ALL THE MEMBERS
FOR REALLY TAKING ON THIS ISSUE
TO DIFFICULT ISSUE.
IT IS IT IS CERTAINLY A A
COMPLICATED ISSUE AND WE
APPRECIATE IT BRINGS ATTENTION
TO IT FIRST AND FOREMOST. I I'D
ALSO LIKE TO INCORPORATE BY
REFERENCE.
THE REMARKS IN THIS DIMENSION
DE REGARDING.
THE CONCERNS RAISED.
THAT THIS JUST REPRESENTS A
COSTLY MANDATE FOR SIX COUNTIES
CURRENTLY AYE AS AND I
CONTEMPLATED ESPECIALLY IN THE
CONTEXT THE COUNTY'S AGAIN
ALREADY HAVE CLEARLY ENUNCIATED
AUTHORITY TO DO EXACTLY WHAT
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE SO WE
ARE IN FACT TELLING COUNTIES.
THAT YOU HAVE THIS AUTHORITY
RIGHT NOW YOU MUST IMPLEMENT
THIS THIS CHANGE. WE WOULD POINT
TO THE FACT THAT SHARE OF CORNER
SYSTEM PROVIDES FOR A PHYSICIAN
WHO DOES THE AUTOPSY AND
DETERMINES THE CAUSE OF DEATH IN
EVERY CASE.
YOU SAY THAT AGAIN. IN EVERY
CASE A PHYSICIAN CONDUCTS THE
AUTOPSY AND DETERMINES THE CAUSE
OF DEATH THIS NOTION THAT.
BECAUSE THE SHERIFF CORNER IS
NOT A PHYSICIAN. IT IS NOT
REALLY RELEVANT TO THIS
DISCUSSION BECAUSE A PHYSICIAN A
TRAINED PHYSICIAN A FORENSIC
PATHOLOGIST.
A PHYSICIAN DOES THE AUTOPSY IN
EVERY SINGLE CASE THAT'S BEEN
PRACTICE FOR YEARS AND THAT WAS.
REAFFIRMED BY S. B. ELEVEN
EIGHTY NINE TWO YEARS AGO.
THE CORNER DETERMINES THE
MANNER OF DEATH HOWEVER AS ONE
OF THE WITNESSES POINTED OUT.
ACCIDENTAL HOMICIDE SUICIDE
NATURAL AN UNDETERMINED DOES A
FIVE POSSIBLE CHOICES.
THAT'S A DETERMINATION THAT'S
MADE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE
TOTALITY OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF
TRAINED INVESTIGATORS LOOK AT
THE CRIME SCENE LOOK AT THE
ISSUE WHERE THE PERSON HAS
EXPIRED IF IT'S NOT A CRIME
SCENE.
AND THEY MAKE DETERMINATIONS AND
CONSIDERATIONS BASED ON THE
CIRCUMSTANCES INVOLVING THE
DEATH THAT EXTEND BEYOND THE
PURELY MEDICAL DETERMINATION A
PERSON MAY HAVE A GUNSHOT WOUND
IN THAT BE ME READILY APPARENT
TO YOU OR ME OR TO A DOCTOR A
CORNER.
BUT YOU AN I PROBABLY ARE GOING
TO BE ABLE TO TELL WHETHER THAT
WAS AN ACCIDENT OR A HOMICIDE OR
SUICIDE. OR ANA A AN
UNDETERMINED MAYBE THE GUN
DROPPED MAYBE I POINTED AT YOU
MAYBE YOU POINTED AT ME. THERE
ARE MANY DIFFERENT SCENARIOS AND
THAT'S WHY THIS SYSTEM WE
BELIEVE WORKS APPROPRIATELY BUT
DOCTOR DETERMINES THE CAUSE OF
DEATH A MEDICAL REASON FOR THE
EXPIRATION OF THE BODY. AND THE
CORNER DETERMINES THE MANNER OF
DEATH IT'S A DETERMINATION MADE
IN CONCERT. DOCTOR MAKES HIS OR
HER FINDINGS THE CORNER MAKES-HIS OR HER FINDINGS AND THEN
MARRY THOSE TOGETHER.
PHYSICIANS HAVE BEEN SEEKING
AUTHORITY TO DETERMINE MANNER OF
DEATH FOR SOMETIME THAT WAS PART
OF S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY NINE IT
WAS ULTIMATELY AMENDED OUT. THE
LEGISLATURE DID NOT APPROVE THAT
CHANGE WHEN THEY SOUGHT TO YEARS
AGO.
WE ALSO POINT TO LONG STANDING
SHORTAGE OF FORENSIC
PATHOLOGISTS WHICH WOULD BE
EXACERBATED BY THIS BILL OUR
RESEARCH INDICATES ONLY ABOUT
FIVE HUNDRED FORENSIC
PATHOLOGISTS ARE PRACTICING
NATIONWIDE.
NOT ONLY WILL THIS MAKE IT
HARDER TO HIRE FORENSIC
PATHOLOGISTS A CONTRACT FOR HIS
OR HER SERVICES. IT WILL AFFECT
SMALL OFTEN RURAL COUNTIES WHO
CONTRACT WITH OTHER COUNTIES TO
PROVIDE PATHOLOGY SERVICES.
THE OUTCOME OF THIS BILL WILL
MAKE IT LESS LIKELY THAT THEY'LL
BE ABLE TO CONTRACT WITH
PATHOLOGISTS OR MEDICAL EXAMINER
MODEL.
THE URBAN CONCERNS ABOUT
CONFLICT JUST LIKE LAW
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES HAVE
PROTOCOLS TO HAVE ANOTHER AGENCY
INVESTIGATING OFFICER INVOLVED
SHOOTING ON OFFICE INVOLVED
DEATH. SHIRTS OFTEN HAVE
PROTOCOLS TO HAND OFF CORNER
CASES ON OFFICER INVOLVED DOUBTS
WHEN INVOLVES AN OFFICER FROM
THEIR COUNTY.
BUT WE APPRECIATE THE
COMMITTEE'S CONSIDERATION AND
URGE YOU TO ALLOW COUNTIES TO
MAKE THIS IMPORTANT
DETERMINATION. WITH THE
AUTHORITY THEY CURRENTLY POSSESS
TODAY PICTURE.
IT'S MUCH RECESS OR YOU KNOW IF
THERE'S ANY OTHER ITEMS YOU'D
LIKE TO GET AT IS WHAT THE
EXTENT.
ANY OTHER ITEMS YOU'D LIKE TO BE
OUT AT THAT YOU MAY THINK THIS
IS A FANTASTIC COMMITTEE TRACK
FREE TIME AHEAD OF.
I KEEP ON GOING THERE HOW MUCH
TIME DO I HAVE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE NOW WOULD
LIKE TO BE ABLE TO OPEN UP FOR
THOSE WHO ARE OPPOSED OR STILL
THINKING ABOUT IT PLEASE SEE
YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME AS WELL
AS ORGANIZATION WE WELCOME YOU.
THING CENTER.
RANKS AMONG THE RIVERSIDE
SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION IF THERE'S
CHI HAVE A LIKE A MINUTE TO. AN
ABSOLUTE MINT. A MISSTEP A SLING.
DE STATEWIDE CLUB BASED ONLY ALL
ALLEGATIONS. AND ONE OF THE
COUNTIES HUNDREDS OF MILES AWAY
AS FROM MARS DOES NOT APPEAR TO
WARRANT THE DISMANTLING OF OUR
PUBLIC SAFETY DEPARTMENT
RIVERSIDE SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION.
VIEWS S. B. THIRTEEN OF THREE AS
BEING AKIN TO THE OLD SAYING
ABOUT THROWING THE BABY OUT WITH
THE BATH WATER. S. B. THIRTEEN
OF THREE WILL UNILATERALLY
IMPOSE CHANGES IN TERMS AND
CONDITIONS ARE MO YOU.
BY REMOVING DEPUTY CORNERS FROM
OUR BARGAINING UNIT.
THESE DEDICATED MEN WOMEN ENTER
THEIR CHOSEN PROFESSION HAVE
PROMISED THEIR PENSION AND HAVE
BEEN PROMISE ARE PENSION UPON
RETIREMENT SB THIRTY NO THREE
WILL ELIMINATE THE EMPLOYMENT.
OF THE DEPUTY CORONERS.
RESULTING IN REDUCED RETIREMENT
BENEFITS.
IN VIOLATION OF THE AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE EMPLOYER THE COUNTY
SHERIFF AND THE RECOGNIZE
BARGAINING REPRESENTATIVE.
A.
GARCIA REMAINS.
.
DEFINITELY AND STRONGLY OPPOSED
TO THIRTEEN OF THREE AND WE
WOULD ASK FOR THE BILL TO BE
HELD IN COMMITTEE THANK YOU
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
PP SO YOUR FIRST LASSEN ALONG
WITH YOUR ORGANIZATION AND.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS WHO SHALL MUCH ROOM YOU
HAVE TO CALIFORNIA STATE CORNERS
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION THANK
YOU.
GOOD MORNING.
MISTER CHAIRMAN VIRTUALLY
DIVORCE ON BEHALF THE URBAN
COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA IN
OPPOSITION.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING ADVISERS IN OPPOSITION TO THE
KICK YOU
THE CEILING.
IF ANYONE ELSE LIKE TO BE A
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OR WHO HAVE
CONCERNS WITH THE BILL.
ALRIGHT WHATEVER BRING IT BACK
TO COMMITTEE WE WELCOME SIR
THOMPSON MISTER BESSEY THAT TO
BE OVERTURNED COMMITTEE WITH THE.
WITH CHAIRS ARE OR YOU CAN JUST
HANG THERE IS WELL.
AND WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO BOTH DO
YOU TO PLEASE IF YOU DON'T MIND
JUST TO STAY AND HANG WITH US A
IN CASE YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS
AS WELL.
A BUT WE'D LIKE TO BE TO SEE IF
WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS OF THAT AS A GOOD
SENATOR PLEASE SATURN AND ITS.
THINGS CHAIR MEMBERS.
CENTER LIKE TO KIND OF FOLLOW
UP ON.
YOUR COMMENT IN YOUR OPENING
STATEMENT ABOUT OVERRULING
FINDINGS OF CAN YOU TELL ME DO
YOU HAVE LIKE A. CALM THE NUMBER
IN IN THE IN SPECIFIC CASES
WITHIN CITY CALIFORNIA THAT.
HARM THERE'D BEEN.
FINDINGS OF BEEN OVERRULED BY
THE SHERIFF OVER THE FORENSIC
PATHOLOGIST.
SPECIFIC SO I LOVE THAT BY
SAYING THAT.
THAT MADE THESE FORENSIC
PATHOLOGISTS ARE EMPLOYEES SO.
THEY YELL LET'S
OFTENTIMES IT'S HARD TO HAVE
NAMES MAKE PUBLIC STATEMENTS
BECAUSE THEY SIMPLY DON'T GET
BLACKBALLED AND.
AT AT AND BASICALLY TO HAVE A
CAREER AT HERE AND IN CALIFORNIA
BECAUSE WE HAVE SO BASICALLY IF
YOU GO IN THE FIVE ONE SHARE OF
CORNER YOU PROBABLY DON'T GO
BEHIND BY ANOTHER ONE BUT. AFTER
MOLLY CAN SHARE WITH YOU HIS
EXPERIENCES THAT HE SAW IN SAN
JOAQUIN COUNTY WHERE THIS VERY
PROBLEM HAPPENED. YET DE MINING
BEFORE YOU. PROCEED I'D LIKE TO
JUST.
COMPLEMENT YOU TALKED A MILE OF
NUMBER ONE FOR THE WORK THAT
YOU'VE DONE WITH THE.
DRAMATIC BRAIN INJURY ESPECIALLY
IN PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL PLAYERS
IT'S COMMENDABLE AND I JUST
WANTED TO SAY THAT BUT HAVE YOU
CAN PROCEED AND TELL ME SOME OF
YOUR EXPERIENCES YET SO I WILL
YOU KNOW LIKE SENATE UPON SAT.
I WOULD A BOOK LAST YEAR OF
COLLEGE TRUTH DOESN'T HAVE A
SITE.
I BELIEVE WE MUST SPEAK DAY TRIP
YOU SHOULDN'T BE AFRAID I'M A
CHRISTIAN.
SOB BELIEVE LOAD GOD ALMIGHTY
WOULD GIVE ME THE STRENGTH AND
POWER TO BE WHO I WAS CREATED TO
BE A HAVE TO SPEAK THE TRUTH.
I WAS WORKING IN SAN JOAQUIN
COUNTY FOR TEN YEARS.
DE LAS CHEER THE DOCTOR UP
PASSING JOINT ME.
AND WHEN WE HAVE RESIGNED WE
WOULD ABOT ONE HUNDRED PAGES OF
MAMMAL YES.
CITING EXAMPLES.
IRAQ WILL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE
THAT WAS A CASE I DID I REQUEST
THAT FAR FROM AND SICK ENTREPOT
LOGICAL ANALYSIS.
A CALL VOTE NO SERGEANT WILL
VOTE RULED TO ME.
AND SAID THEY WERE NOT GOING TO
DO WOULD BE ANTHROPOLOGICAL
ANALYSIS.
THAT WAS.
A POLICE SHOOTING.
DIED WAS UNTIL JUST HOMICIDE TAX
FIXATION.
BUT SHALL WE VOLVO HOLD ME I
MADE IT I'M ACCIDENT.
THAT WAS A KIDS KNOCKED OPOSSUM
DATE A WOMAN WHO I MEAN TO
SOMEBODY WE TAKE OUT WEAPONIZED
A CAR.
THEY SHALL BE PERMITTED ON
ACCIDENT.
BY LITO WENT BEHIND US MONEY IT
WAS MADE PUBLIC TO CHANGE IT.
BIG CUTS OF MY EXPERTISE.
FORENSIC PATHOLOGIST CERTAINLY
CASES FROM ALL ACROSS THE STATE.
THERE HAVE BEEN CASES I WOULDN'T
MENTION NAMES WHERE DIFFERENT OF
FACE SHERIFF.
AT A DIFFERENT OF A SHOW IT'S ON
COMEY THAT SUICIDE BY DRUG
OVERDOSE.
AND THE SHERIFF BONTA DIPUTADO
LODGES NOT TO PERFORMED
TOXICOLOGICAL ANALYSIS.
DOCTOR POSTERN WAS REQUESTED FOR
MEDICAL RECORDS TO EVOLVE LATER
CASES. BONTA SERGEANT CAN TO
* ON SAID NO.
DIE YOU ARE ALL DOING MANY
MEDICAL RECORDS.
AND SON HAWKING COLONY I HAVE
REQUEST THAT TEST ANALYSIS
BECAUSE THIS IS NOT A TWENTY
FIVE SANCTUARY. I* LAUDE DO
MAGIC TO DETERMINE CAUSE SUBJECT.
IODISED IS WEB BEGINNING TO DO
MONTHLY COLA ANALYSIS.
I NEED A POLITICAL ANALYSIS TO
BE DONE I WAS TOLD NO. DOUBT I'M
ONLY ALLOWED TO DO FIGHT FOR A
YEAR.
TELL US ANOTHER CAKES I DID TO
BRAIN EXAMINATION ON THE SPINAL
CORD EXAMINATION FOR CRYING OUT
LOUD ON ONE OF THE LEADING NEW A
PATHOLOGIST IN THE COUNTRY.
I EXAMINED IT ON DETERMINING DOT
DISTINCTIVE VIGIL DIED FOLLOWING
TRY MOCKING GETTING JOEY TO HIS
SPINAL CORD WHILE HE WAS BEING
ARRESTED.
THE SHERIFF CALLED ME TO HIS
OFFICE.
I'M SAT AND OUTPUT BY BUT TO.
GOT HIM IF YOU DO MEDICAL
RECORDS
THAT THE CT SCOTT. AND MRI SCOTT
DID NOT SHOW ANY TRAUMA DEATH
FOR I WAS WRONG.
AND I LOOKED AMENDED ARE.
LUCKILY I SPEAK DETROIT I
BELIEVE IN THE SPIRIT OF GOD IN
ME. ASIDE SO.
I DON'T TELL YOU WHAT TO DO
MASSIVE GOVERNMENT.
PLEASE DON'T YOU EVO.
QUESTION MY JUDGEMENT.
AND HE GOT UPSET.
YES SO MANY EXAMPLES.
SO MANY THAT LAST ONE WAS JUST
LAST WEEK ON STEFAN CLOCK.
BASRA SPEAKING NON I HAVE ABOUT
THIRTY CASES ON MY DESK A LOT
CLOSER TO SPIT.
WHERE FAMILY SCOTT NOW SEND IN
REPORTS WHAT TEAM IS SECOND
OPINIONS DOT DOT DOT TRUST ME
SHERIFF COHEN A SYSTEM? ANY
LONGER.
BONNIE ACCOMPLICE IT PRICE
TOGGLED PUBLIC.
BOB PUBLIC CONFIDENCE.
UP PUBLIC INTEREST DOES NOT
PRICE STOCK.
PUBLIC TRUST IS INVALUABLE.
I WE WAITING TO LEAD TO A
BOILING POINT.
DO YOU KNOW WHY TO WAS NO
VIOLENCE IN SACRAMENTO BODY
STEFAN CLOCK CASE.
THE COLLEGE OF AMERICAN
PATHOLOGISTS STATES BUT AFTER
MARKUPS.
YOU MUST MAKE GIVE RESULTS
AVAILABLE WITHIN FORTY EIGHT
HOURS.
BUT ALMOST TWO WEEKS AFTER THE
TOUGH STUFF ON CLOCK AUTOPSY
THERE WAS NO FIND IS MADE OUT TO
THE PUBLIC.
BUT WHEN HAVE FINALLY CAME TO ME
TO DO A SECOND AUTOPSY I SET TO
THE LAWYERS LOOK.
WE MUST GO OUT IMMEDIATELY BUT
IDEA STANDARDS OF PRACTICE OF
MEDICINE.
THE MAKERS OF VALUABLE TO DO
PUBLIC EMPOWER WHAT THE PUBLIC.
I WHEN I HEAR PEOPLE IT SAID
THIS IS A BOB MONO OF DEBT NO
IT'S NOT.
IS ARNOLD BY SIMPLY FREAKISH
OLYMPIC COMPLEX ISSUE.
IT'S NOT ABOUT MONO DECK BUT I
FIND IT FUNNY.
WE HAVE THE MEDICAL BOARD OF
CALIFORNIA.
DODD SUPERVISES DOCTORS. WHAT
BECAUSE A NON FEELS LEASH AND BE
GOT TO DO TELL ME WHAT IS A
MEDICAL PUSHED CBO ON NOT?
IT WAS A BILL PASSED LAST YEAR
DOT DETERMINES THE UC TOPS IS
THE MEDICAL*.
I WANT SOMETHING IS A MEDICAL
PROCEDURE NOT PHYSICIANS SHOULD
NOT MAKE DECISIONS ARE JUDGMENTS
TO MEDICAL DECISIONS.
I FEEL REALLY THE SIMPLEST IN
OUR COULD DO IS TO LEAVE
CALIFORNIA.
BUT IT'S IT'S ABOUT OUR CHILDREN
DOES IS NOT DABABNEH MY NOT OF
DEBT.
THIS IS ABOUT.
PUBLIC TRUST PUBLIC CONFIDENCE
ON PUBLIC INTEGRITY.
THE AUTOPSIES NO LONGER WHAT WE
DID LAST YEAR.
THE LEAP.
IF I HAD BEEN IN CALIFORNIA I
WOULD NOT HAVE DISCOVERED CT.
BECAUSE OF THE ENVIRONMENT I
SHOULDN'T BE WALKING IN THE LAW
ENFORCEMENT ENVIRONMENT.
AND IF YOU WATCH MY START.
WELL I DID MIKE WEBSTER AUTOPSY
I WENT TO MY BOSS WHO WAS A
DOCTOR.
I SPOKE TO HIM DOCTOR TO DOCTOR.
I DO SO TO ME BENNETT WHY NOT
EXAMINE DISPLAY.
WHAT'S NOW VIOLENCE WE KNOW TO
DATE HOW DO WEST NILE VIRUS
INFECTS THE HUMAN BANG.
BECAUSE OF I'M NOT TOUCH ID TO
GET ON THE DOCTOR SHE WEPT.
SO WHAT WE HOLDING CALIFORNIA
BACK JUST BECAUSE OF POLITICS.
ACKERMAN I'M NOT A POLITICIAN
THAT HAVE YOU I'D CONCLUDE
INVENT THIRTY SECONDS IN EXAM
ONE WHICH WE ASK THE QUESTIONS
OF
SO PLEASE CONCLUDE MY THIRTY SET.
SO I COLLIDED BOOK ON EXAMPLE
EXAMPLES EXAMPLES DOES IT GET
SOME INVOLVED WITH NOT KNOWING
SOME BIT MEDINA. AND I'LL BE
SPECIFIC BECAUSE A JUDGE ABOVE
RULED TO TRY. IT CHAU DOUBLE HOW
THAT'LL JUST MACABRE BULLY DE
SADE.
I'M NOT THOUGHT SHE WAS DONE.
THEY DID LOW BUT NOT TO DO ANY
GENETIC PROFILING.
AND IT CHAD TO WAS TRAGICALLY
HOMICIDE.
I SHE WAS SENT TO US BY THE JURY.
TO LIKE.
BUT I DON'T THINK YOU'D BE
EVIDENCE I'M JUST LAST MONTH
SAID NO DOUBLES INSUFFICIENT
EVIDENCE ON THIS WEB IS THE
GENETIC PROFILE.
SO YOU ARE CONSEQUENCES AYE WE
ALMOST STOP IF YOU PICK IT
WOULDN'T GET TO YOU IS ALL A
MATTER OF TIME.
BY LAST NIGHT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH LET ME.
AGAIN JUST FOLLOW UP IN A
NUMBER ONE. I REALLY REALLY
APPRECIATE YOUR PASSION AND THE
ME RESTATE AGAIN THE WORK YOU'VE
DONE WITH CTA AND IT'S MY
UNDERSTANDING WITH MIKE WEBSTER
I THINK YOU EVEN PAID FOR SOME
OF THAT PATHOLOGY REPORTS OF
YOUR OWN MONEY. IF I'M NOT
MISTAKEN AND I JUST.
JUST AND WAIT. BUT I I GUESS THE
QUESTION I'M ASKING IS HERE'S MY
CONCERN ABOUT THE MEDICAL
JUDGEMENT HAVE A PROFESSIONAL
AND I UNDERSTAND THERE'S THE
ECONOMIC PART OF IT WITH REGARD
TO THE COUNTIES AND THIS AND
THAT THEY HAVE TO TAKE THAT INTO
CONSIDERATION.
MY CONCERN IS THE OVER RULING OF
MEDICAL JUDGMENT THAT A
PROFESSIONAL HAS THRESHING WHEN
IT COMES TO THE FINDINGS. IN THE
FOR THE PATHOLOGICAL FINDINGS OF
A SOMEBODY WHO IS DECEASED AND
YES GETTING INTO THE SOCIAL
ASPECTS OF IT WHAT'S GOING ON
TODAY IN THIS COUNTRY. TETRA.
SO IT I GUESS IS VERY SIMPLY
I'M YOU ANSWER MY QUESTION THAT.
YOUR OPPOSE ANY KIND OF
OVERRIDING TO THE MEDICAL-JUDGMENT THAT'S PUT ON A
FORENSIC PATHOLOGISTS CORRECT
I'LL ACTUALLY DO LAW OF THE LAND
MEDICAL BUT UP OF MEDICAL BUT OF
THE STATE.
CLEARLY STATES THAT THERE SHOULD
NOT BE ANY SUBTLY INFLUENCE
PERCEIVED ALL VIEW.
ALL CONTROL OF THE JUDGMENT OF
THE PHYSICIAN.
AGAIN AND AND I THINK THE THINGS
THAT WE HAVE TO BOUNCE WITH IS
YOU KNOW. UNDERSTANDING THE
CONCERNS ABOUT THE OPPOSITION
LOCAL CONTROL I UNDERSTAND THAT
THE COUNTIES CURRENTLY HAVE THAT
BUT AT WHAT POINT DO WE AS
POLICY MAKERS HAVE TO MAKE THAT
DECISION WHAT'S IN THE BEST
INTEREST FOR EVERYBODY WITHIN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND HOW
DO WE MAKE THOSE DECISIONS AND
THAT'S WHY WE'RE HAVING THIS
HEARING I DON'T THINK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR YOUR. FOR YOUR TIME.
THANK YOU SIR THAT THANK YOU SO
MUCH AS INTERNET IT'S AT DON'T
KNOW IF EITHER ONE OF YOU WANT
TO BE TO CHIME IN ON THIS BEFORE
WE GO TO CENTER MORE LOCK.
JUST VERY BRIEFLY MISTER CHAIR
PLEASE. AYE I WOULD JUST RE
INSTATEMENT NOW IN ADDITIONAL
DOCTOR MODE YOU SAID ABOUT THE
MEDICAL BOARD GOVERNING WHO CAN
PRACTICE MEDICINE. SNOW SHARE OF
CORNER THINKS HERE SHE IS A
DOCTOR WORK IN PRACTICE MEDICINE.
THE CAUSE OF DEATH IS THE SOLE
DETERMINATION OF THE DOCTOR THE
MANNER OF DEATH IS THE
DETERMINATION OF THE
INVESTIGATOR AGAIN WITH THE
TOTALITY OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES
THAT THE PHYSICIAN MAY NOT HAVE
ACCESS TO INFORMATION ABOUT. SO
I JUST MAKE THAT VERY SPECIFIC
POINT THAT THIS NOTION OF
OVERRULING A CAUSE OF DEATH IS
NOT THE CASE A DOCTOR IN A
CORNER MAY NOT AGREE AND WE
THINK THAT'S VERY RARE. BUT
THEY'RE TWO DIFFERENT
DETERMINATIONS YOU CAN HAVE A
GUNSHOT WOUND AND IT CAN BE IN
MANY DIFFERENT MANNERS OF DEATH.
THOSE DON'T NECESSARILY HAVE TO
SYNC UP WOULD LIKE THEM TO WOULD
LIKE EVERYBODY TO KNOW WHAT
HAPPENED BUT SOMETIMES THERE'S A
DISAGREEMENT AND THAT'S THE
SYSTEM.
THANK YOU AND IF I MIGHT ALSO
ADD A NUMBER OF THE EXAMPLE THAT
WERE GIVEN WERE SAN JOAQUIN
COUNTY AND SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY IS
CURRENTLY EXAMINING IF THEY
SHOULD SET UP AN INDEPENDENT.
OFFICE OF THE MEDICAL EXAMINER.
DOT DOT IS IN OUR COMMITTEE
BOMBING DOT IS NOT SHOULD KNOWS
CASES I'M CITED NOW DID NOT COME
FROM SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY I GIVE
EXAMPLE OF SOME SOME BENEDI NOT.
I HAVE ANOTHER EXAMPLE FROM KENT
COUNTY. BOND I HAVE ANOTHER
EXAMPLE PHONE SO NORMA COUNTY.
SO NO MY COUNTY. ABOUT SIX YEARS
AGO RUBRIC COULD DETERMINE I
JUST WANNA AND AND HAVE YOU TACK
THAT ONTO A A POTENTIAL QUESTION
HERE BUT BEFORE WE GO TO MISTER
MOORE LOCK. CENTER IS ARE THERE
ANY ITEMS.
YOU WOULD LIKE TO CHIME IN ON
SO I I I THINK I THINK THE ISSUE
WHEN THE ISSUES THAT I'M. NOT
AND I CERTAINLY.
THAT THE OPPOSITION.
STATE IT. IS IS THAT WHAT WE'RE
HEARING FROM DOCTOR MAILLOT AND
ALSO FROM OTHER FORENSIC
PATHOLOGISTS NAM.
IS IS THAT WE'RE SEEING. THE.
INTERFERENCE FROM.
THE SHERIFF CORNER SO IT'S NOT
JUST THAT WILSHIRE OF CORNERS
THE TIMING THE MEANS AND THE
POSSESS AND MEDICAL EXAMINER IS
FREE REIN.
THEY'RE ACTUALLY INTERFERING
SAYING YOU CAN'T DO CERTAIN
TASKS DEBT. AND THEIR
PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT SHOULD BE
DONE WHEN I GOT PROVIDE YOU
CERTAIN PIECES OF INFORMATION.
AND AND AND SO.
AND JUST THAT RELATIONSHIP THAT
YOU ARE EMPLOYEES OF THE SHERIFF
CORNER AND SUPPOSE INVOLVES A
DEPUTY SHERIFF.
THAT IS EVEN WHEN THE TERR
CORNER DOESN'T DO ANYTHING.
CREATES THIS
PERCEPTION OF A CONFLICT OF
INTEREST WHICH.
WHICH IS I THINK VERY
PROBLEMATIC SO I SAID BEFORE THE
THE AUTOPSY AND THE MEDICAL
EXAMINER IS NOT SHOULD NOT BE
PART OF THE PROSECUTION OR THE
DEFENSE THEY SHOULD BE THEIR
GOAL SHOULD BE THE OBJECT AND
THE DECK INFORMATION TO THE.
JUDGE AND THE JURY THAT THE A
AND THEN.
THAT INFORMATION'S AVAILABLE
FOR.
THE APPROPRIATE ACTION TO CHIEF
JUSTICE THANK YOU SO MUCH MR
CENTER WHERE TO GO TO A CENTER
MORE LUCK PLEASE IN AGAIN. OF MR
MOLLY CAN TACK THAT WE WOULD ON
SAY ON.
RESPONSE IF HE IF.
CINEMA LOCK HAS BEEN ITEM TO BE
ADDRESSED OF CINEMA LOCK YOU
MISTER CHAIR AND I THANK YOU
DOCTOR BEEN AND ALTHOUGH I. WAS
ARE YOU AREN'T AS PASSIONATE AS
YOU SHOULD BE.
THE THOUSAND NINE THE.
NATIONAL ACADEMIES OF SCIENCE
RECOMMENDED THE SEPARATION OF
CORNERS FROM SHERIFF'S
DEPARTMENT THE NATIONAL REPORT.
AND I WAS SUPERVISOR AT THE TIME
FOR THE COUNTY OF ORANGE AND
pIT INDEPENDENT ANALYSIS BECAUSE
I WANTED TO. TAKE COMPONENTS
FROM THE HEALTH CARE AGENCY FROM
THE CORNER.
FROM THE DNA LABS AND AND AND
AND ESTABLISH AN INDEPENDENT
MEDICAL EXAMINER OFFICE SO
THINNER PAN I MIGHT BE
SUPPORTIVE OF YOUR BILL AND I
KNOW. WHAT'S HAPPENING TO ME BUT
I'M GONNA HAVE TO BREAK FROM MY
FRIENDS AT SEIZE ACT. I THINK
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT.
A DECADE OVERDUE IN CALIFORNIA
SO I I COME WITH THE TRACK
RECORD OF. OF OF HAVING DONE
THIS. I WE GOT BACK A REPORT
THAT IT WOULD COST A MILLION
DOLLARS.
THE SEPARATE.
END ESTABLISHES SEPARATE.
MEDICAL EXAMINER INDEPENDENT
MEDICAL EXAMINER AYE AYE DEBATED
AND CONTESTED IN CHALLENGE THAT
NUMBER BECAUSE I THOUGHT IT WAS
WAY TOO HIGH. BUT AT THE TIME WE
WERE STILL DIGGING OUT OF THE
GREAT RECESSION SO. IT WAS SORT
OF SOMETHING THAT I HAD THAT
KIND OF PUT ON HOLD BECAUSE.
HOW DO YOU CONVINCE FOR OTHER
RELEASE TWO OTHER SUPERVISORS?
THAT THAT THAT THE COST ISN'T
THERE SO I I AM WITH YOU ON ON
THIS CONCEPT. SO MY QUESTIONS
ARE GOING TO BE MORE POLITICAL
BECAUSE.
YOU KNOW IT THE ARGUMENT IS MADE
THAT COUNTIES CAN DO THIS RGHT
NOW WELL I I WILL TELL YOU AS A
FORMER SUPERVISOR. AND A COUNTY
TREASURER FOR FOR NET IT TOOK
COUNTY LIKE TWENTY YEARS. OUT
THERE IS NOT ONE. INDIVIDUAL
MORE.
VISIBLE UNPOPULAR IN THE COUNTY
THEN THE SHERIFF CORNER I MEAN
THAT. THAT IS THE MOST POPULAR
MOST POLITICALLY POWERFUL PERSON
AND TO TRY AND CHANGE THE
PARADIGM TO AN INDEPENDENT
MEDICAL EXAMINER IS NEXT TO
IMPOSSIBLE SO YES YOU HAVE THE
ABILITY TO DO THAT BUT YOU
HAVEN'T SEEN IT. REALLY HAPPENED
BECAUSE IT IS VIRTUALLY.
IMPOSSIBLE TO DO SO NOW YOU'RE
IMPOSING IT WHICH KIND OF GOES
AGAINST MY GRAIN OF OF LOCAL
CONTROL BUT I REALIZED THAT THAT.
THE REALITIES OF IT ALSO SO
YOU'RE SAYING YOU WANT TO
REQUIRE POPULATIONS OF FIVE
HUNDRED THOUSAND OR GREATER. AND
IN THE REPORT GOES INTO GENERAL
OBVERSES CHARTER YADA YADA AND
I'M JUST WONDERING.
WHY THAT THRESHOLD Y. NOT
EVERYBODY WHY NOT NO EXCEPTIONS
WHAT WHERE WHAT IT WHAT'S THE
GOAL HERE? OKAY SO FIRST OF ALL
I THANK YOU SO MUCH JASSIM
LOCKED FOR YOUR CAREFUL
CONSIDERATION THE ISSUE EVEN
BEFORE IS THAT AS A SUPERVISOR
AND COUNTY TREASURER. UP.
FIRST OF ALL THE FIVE HUNDRED
THOUSAND AS YOU HEARD FROM
DOCTOR MULLIS TESTIMONY IS
ACTUALLY BASED ON A STUDY
LOOKING AT WE WE ARE SENSITIVE
TO THE FINANCIAL ISSUES AND I
APPRECIATE THE OPPOSITION BRING
UP THAT SMALLER COUNTIES MAY
HAVE TO HAVE A CONTRACT AND
THEY'RE NOT. THEY'RE NOT
L'ARGENT DEBATE THAT THE VOLUME
OF BUSINESS MEAN OUT OUR
ACTIVITIES MEANS NOT LESLIE
MAKES SENSE ALTHOUGH YOU KNOW
AGAIN WE COULD ARGUE THAT. I
THINK THAT WE WANT TO BE
REASONABLE THAT WE WOULD BE SURE
THAT WE WE SET OF APPROPRIATE
SPECIAL SO THAT'S THE FIVE
HUNDRED THOUSAND.
AND THEN THE SECOND PART YOUR
QUESTION WAS THE YOU HAD YOUR
BIG ARGUMENT ABOUT A TO TALK
ABOUT IS NOT CHARTER ACCIDENT SO
SO BECAUSE THEN THE LEGAL NATURE
CHARTER COUNTIES RELATIONS OF
THE CONSTITUTION AND US PASSING
A LAW. THAT THAT'S. I THINK
THERE'S SOME CONSTITUTIONAL
ISSUES ABOUT US POSING ON THE
CHARTER COUNTIES SO THAT'S.
THAT'S WHY WE DID
THE US ELECTED I CHARTER IS LEFT
IN YOUR BILL WHAT SO BASICALLY
WOULD BE THE CHARTER TERRY
COUNTIES THAT WELL COUNTIES ARE
SMALL AND FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
WHO HAVEN'T DECIDED VOLUNTARILY
DO THAT OR. CHARTER COUNTIES ARE
LARGER AND THEY THEY CAN OF
COURSE THEY SAID. ACT ON THEIR
OWN BUT.
BUT. IT BASICALLY THEY WERE
THERE WOULD BE EXCLUDED IS IN
ROME NOT NON CHARTER COUNTIES OF
RACE COLOR JESSE NINE CHARTER
COUNTIES ARE GREATER FIVE
HUNDRED THOUSAND.
I WOULD SAY THE STATE INTEREST
THAT WAS ASSURING JUSTICE AND
YOU KNOW I CAN CERTAINLY SEE
SOME OF YOUR CONCERNS THAT WE'RE
LEAVING SOME HOLES THEREBY THINK
REASONABLY THAT GIVEN WHAT THE
CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW IS AND
WHAT IS FINANCIALLY. THERE YELL
REASONABLE THAT'S WHAT IF WE PUT
THOSE THINGS INTO THE BILL.
BUT WHAT COUNTIES I CANNOT.
MAY I OUGHT TO GET. REAL QUICK
CONSIDER PAIN IT'S IT'S SIX
COUNTIES COUNTY COUNTY. SO IN
CURRENTLY IN THE BILL. EYES
CENTER OPINION HAS THE COUNTY OF
ORANGE COUNTY OR JUST BEING
AMENDED OUTWHAT.
IN CIGARETTE HAD CENTER PAN.
I.
WHY IT IS ORANGE PHYSICAL THAT
IDEA IF THE CHARTER CHARTER
CHARTER ACCOUNT?
OKAY SO DID SO OUT OF THIS THERE
I HAD TO THERE'S SOMEBODY
MENTIONED IT WAS PULLED OUT SO I
HAS IT.
SENATOR IF I MAY HANG OUR BUDDY
OKAY I'M SORT ONE SECOND. SO.
SIX COUNTIES THIS BILL IS GOING
TO APPLY THE SIX COUNTIES NON
CHARTER GENERAL LAW COUNTIES.
SO.
WERE HAPPY TO BE ABLE TO GO
THROUGH THEM. BUT BECAUSE ORANGE
IS A CHARTER COUNTY SOCCER APPLY.
I THERE WAS THAT.
.
BUT OVERSIGHT INCLUDING ORANGE
THAT IS WHY WE THERE'S GONNA BE
TECH WOMAN TO BETTER TAKE THEM
OUT TO JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT EVERYONE'S ON THE SAME PAGE
ON THAT ONE.
SO.
SURE YET JUST UP PRY
CLARIFICATION ON THAT DATE IS A
CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE OF ONE THAT
WOULD LEAD COUNSEL UP BROUGHT TO
US WE TOOK THEIR LANGUAGE IT
WASN'T REYES TO US UNTIL
WEDNESDAY. THERE SOMETHING
SPECIFIC AS TO ORANGE COUNTY'S
CARTER A CHARTER EXCUSE ME WHERE
THEY. IN THE ABSENCE OF
ESTABLISH OF CORNER OF A GOOD
GENERAL LAW BUT BASICALLY A
STATE LAW CAN'T BE PASSED TO
HAVE ORANGE COUNTY.
IMPOSE A MEDICAL EXAMINER ON
THAT COUNTY SO WE HAD TO EXIT
THE. ELITES HAVE YOU READ THE
CHARTER OF ORANGE COUNTY.
I'VE NOT TAKE YOU LIKE THREE
SECONDS.
I'M SERIOUS DOUG FOR A FOR US
THIS THIS WAS THIS WAS FROM
LEDGE COUNCIL THIS IS BUSINESS.
MANNER. BUT IF YOU HAVE THIS.
EXTRA CHAIR I DON'T HAVE TO.
VIRGO SO JUST BE CLEAR.
THANK YOU SO MUCH REPORT SO IT
SAN JOAQUIN. THE RIVERSIDE.
SAN JOAQUIN HANG ON ONE SECOND
SOMEONE SAN JOAQUIN RIVERSIDE
CONTRA COSTA CURRENCY AND SAW IN
CINEMA IS WHERE I IN IT'S ON
PAGE THREE OF FOUR OF THE IN
HOUSE.
SO MR LOOKED FOR SOURCE.
THANK YOU I FOR THAT NOW I'M
HAVING PROBLEMS WITH THE BILL.
MISSION IS NO IT'S NOT I'M I I'M
A GUY THAT'S NO BETTER NO WORSE
WE WE NEED TO FIX IT EVERYWHERE
SAID JUST PICKING ON SIX OUT OF
FIFTY EIGHT.
SO HOW DO WE.
BUT OF WHAT WE DO WE DO CENTER.
SO I THINK THAT THE TO
CHALLENGES AS YOU'VE HEARD.
Y. IS IS THAT THERE ARE AT
LEAST LEDGE COUNCIL HAS POINTED
OUT THERE'S A CONSTITUTIONAL
ISSUE. I THINK.
DELAYED A FORTUNE DEL WAY TO
ADDRESS THAT WOULD BE TO.
DIRECTLY WOULD BE TO DO
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT OF SOME
SORT BUT I WOULD ALSO POINT OUT
THAT BY MOVING FORWARD AND I
CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND YOUR
DISAPPOINTMENT DATA ORANGE
COUNTY WOULD NOT BE INCLUDING
THIS BILL. I THINK I THINK THAT
AS WE GET MORE COUNTIES TOM OUT
OF THE SHARE OF CORNER SYSTEM IT
MAKES IT CLEAR THIS PASSING THIS
BILL INTO LAW WOULD MAKE IT
CLEAR DEBTS INTENT OF THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. TO.
BASICALLY BRING OUR OFFERINGS
ACT ARE OUR MEDICAL EXAMINER
SYSTEM INTO THE MODERN AGE AND
THAT THAT HOPEFULLY THAT WILL
ALSO HELP COMPEL A THE OTHER
COUNTIES TO LOOK AT THIS AND.
MOVES.
MOVE FORWARD AS WELL. ON THEIR
OWN THE ONES WHO WOULD NOT ABLE
TO COVER IN THIS BILL. IT AND I
WANT TO SPEAK FOR THE SENATE AND
SACRAMENTO AND THERE'S NOTHING
HE CAN DO ABOUT THE
CONSTITUTIONALITY OF THAT ISSUE
RIGHT SO.
CAN'T HOLD THAT AGAINST THEM I
THINK THE OTHER ISSUE IS IS THAT.
WHERE THE OPPOSITION BROUGHT UP
IN IT'S A LEGITIMATE ISSUE A YOU
HAVE FIVE HUNDRED INDIVIDUALS
THAT ARE DOING THIS WORK?
I IN TAT IS WHY THIS COMMITTEE
SUGGESTING.
AN AMENDMENT AN AMENDMENT THAT
WOULD.
DELAY IMPLEMENTATION FOR TWELVE
MONTHS RIGHT UP BECAUSE THERE IS.
THERE ARE CHALLENGES BE NAY OF
SECURE THOSE AYE PROFESSIONALS
WHO WOULD BE ABLE TO DO THIS.
BITS WITH THIS WORK.
AND THAT WHERE AT LEAST IN MY
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE SENATOR
OF LOOKING AT THOSE COUNTIES
THAT HAVE THE POPULATION. HENCE
THE POTENTIAL REVENUE OUGHT TO
BE ABLE TO ADVANCE AN INITIATIVE
LIKE THIS BEGIN I DON'T WANT TO
PUT. ANY WORDS IN THE SINGER'S
MOUTH BUT ON A BELIEVE THAT'S
WAS WHO WHEREYOU'RE LOOKING AT
AS FAR AS THE SCOPE. BUT PLEASE
MR MORLOCK THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR SO THEN.
SENATOR PAN. I'M I'M GONNA HAVE
TROUBLE WITH THIS BILL AS IT IS
BUT I WILL. BE MORE THAN HAPPY
TO COAUTHOR A STATE
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
TO CHANGE THE CONSTITUTION TO
ALLOW FOR THIS TO BE APPLICABLE
TO EVERYBODY BECAUSE I THINK
THIS IS THE RIGHT DIRECTION TO
GO. AND SO THAT'S WERE I AM I
MAD AT THIS POINT MR CHAIRS
THANK YOU THAT THE CHANCE THAT I
WOULD HAVE.
IS THAT'S NOT THE ISSUE AT HAND
RIGHT SO I'M.
IT.
ONLY TO SAY HEY I'M WILLING TO
HELP OUT BECAUSE I'M MORE
CONCERNED ABOUT THE BIGGER ISSUE
THAN JUST.
DOING NIBBLING.
SO THAT'S OKAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH I THAT WOULD
GO OVER TO THAT QUICKLY DAYS IF
WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS AND THE
DOCTOR I PROMISE TO BE ABLE TO
TIME AND AGAIN WE HAVE ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THIS
COMMITTEE.
I A I PROMISE TO FOR MY.
ABSOLUTELY I PROMISE THAT THE
DOCTOR TO BE ABLE TO HAVE A FEW
WORDS IN A DOCTOR I'M GONNA HAVE
YOU LIMIT THOSE WORDS TO ABOUT
THREE MINUTES. THAT ON AND OFF
FOR THE OPPOSITION FINAL THREE
MINUTES AS WELL AND THEN THEY
WERE GONNA ALLOW THE SENATOR TO
BE ABLE TO HAVE CLOSING COMMENTS
YES.
DR YES PLEASE SENATOR IN
RESPONSE TO YOUR QUESTIONS.
ACTUALLY BE FIVE HUNDRED
THOUSAND AIDS EVERY DAY IN SPACE.
ACTUALLY RECOMMEND THAT. IF YOU
DO THE STATISTICAL PROJECTIONS
IN NINETEEN TWENTY EIGHT. ARE
WHAT DECIDED NINETEEN TWENTY
EIGHT WORDS.
DAY OUT BE GOT UP BY NAVY YEARS
YOU CHANGE DAM. BUNDLED FIERCELY
THE SURROUNDING AREAS WAS SEEDED
DISTINCTION IN THE QUALITY OF
SERVICE PROVIDED.
I WOULD BE AND COVERAGE TO
CHANGE ALL FOR. IT SO THE FIVE
HUNDRED THOUSAND DID NOT WE DID
NOT CREATE IT BATES EVIDENCE
BASED ON WALKED UP BECAUSE BEING
DONE BY THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE. MONEY GAINED A SMALL
ACCOUNT IS BECAUSE THEY JUST
DON'T HAVE BE ADEQUATE TAX BASE
IT WILL BE MADRE DEFEAT CALLED
FOR THE SMALLER COUNTIES TO
IMPLEMENT HIS CHAIN FOR EXAMPLE
COLUSA COUNTIES A POPULATION OF
ABOUT TWENTY POLICY.
SO WHAT DOES SUGGEST THAT IN
NINETEEN TWENTY EIGHT WAS
SMALLER COUNTIES LIKE COLUSA
COUNTY NOW SEND KISSES TO DO
ROUTE FEINSTEIN UP ON THE AVIOS
DOT HOW THE QUALITY BE STOPPED.
WHICH IS THE SAME ALL BILL WE
HAVE BEEN HEALTH CARE YOU HAVE
THE BIG HOSPITALS IN BIG
POPULATION AVIOS ON SMALL
COMMUNITY HOSPITAL. THAT NOW
SEND CASES TO THE BIGGER
HOSPITALS SO WHAT WE ARE
CREATING HERE THIS IS A VERY
INTELLIGENT BICU THAT IS
BEGINNING TO SEEM LATE. MODEL OF
HEALTH CARE ARCHITECTURE IN
AMERICA.
GET OUT ON SALE CHRISTIAN.
THANK YOU SO MUCH
IT'S MY SECTOR WOULD YOU LIKE TO
COMMENT ON UNIT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
SO WITH THAT WOULD TURN IT OVER
TO THE OPPOSITION I IN YOUR
THREE MINUTES AND WE'RE GOING TO
TURN IT OVER. TO ADD TO THE GOOD
SENATE FOR ANY CLOSING COMMENTS
AND THEN ALL BE LOOKING FOR
MOTION AFTER SENATOR PAN.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN THANK
YOU FOR YOUR GENEROSITY WITH THE
TIME AND THE WILLINGNESS THE
COMMITTEE TO HEAR THE ISSUES. I
I WOULD JUST POINT OUT A COUPLE
OF THINGS ONE.
EVERYBODY HAS BOSS IN THIS LIFE.
WHETHER IT'S THE YOU SHARE OF
CORNER FOR CONTRACTED OR
COMPLETE PHYSICIAN A MEDICAL
EXAMINER WHILE THE THE TITLE ON
THE DOOR MAY SAY INDEPENDENT
MEDICAL EXAMINER THAT THAT
PERSON GO WORK FOR BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS IN THERE WILL ALWAYS
BE QUESTIONS ABOUT RESOURCES.
AND PROCEDURES AND IF THAT'S
THE CASE THEN YOU KNOW THAT IT'S
A CONVERSATION BETWEEN AGENCIES
ABOUT. WHO'S DETERMINING WHO'S
MAKING DECISIONS ABOUT WHICH
PROCEDURES ARE DONE. THE
INDICATING THAT I SHARE SHOULD
OVERSEE THAT SORT OF DATA DAY
MEDICAL PROCESS.
INDIVIDUALLY BUT AGAIN THERE ARE
QUESTIONS ABOUT RESOURCES TO.
AS WE'VE PREVIOUSLY STATED SAN
JOAQUIN CINEMA COUNTIES.
HAVE ENGAGED IN THIS SORT OF
DEBATE.
SAN JOAQUIN HAS NOT DECIDED YET
AS I UNDERSTAND IT I BELIEVE
SADDAM HAS LOOKED INTO IT AND
HAS DECIDED NOT TO. MAKE THIS
CHANGE THAT WAS MY UNDERSTANDING
OF THE DECISION SO AGAIN THE
PROCESS.
EXISTS AND WORKS NOTWITHSTANDING.
MANY LEGISLATIVE MANDATE.
AND AND FINALLY I WOULD POINT
OUT THAT S. B. ELIMINATING NINE
WHICH IS THE BILL WENT THROUGH A
COUPLE YEARS AGO.
THAT WAS USED TO HIGHLIGHT.
THE TREMENDOUS DEFICIENCIES AS
I WOULD THINK THE PROPONENTS
WOULD SAY IN THE SHARE OF CORNER
MODEL.
DEBT BILL CAME ABOUT BECAUSE OF
AN INCIDENT IN A COUNTY THAT
DOES NOT HAVE A SHARE OF CORNER.
SO THIS NOTION THAT ONLY SURE OF
CORNER OFFICES HAVE ISSUES AND
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER OFFICES.
OPERATE WITHOUT CONCERN BIAS.
ANYTHING LIKE THAT I THINK IS
IS BEYOND.
ACCURATE BECAUSE AGAIN THAT BILL.
CAME FROM A COUNTY THAT HAD A
MEDICAL EXAMINER WHO WAS ACTING
INAPPROPRIATELY AND THERE WAS A
CONCERN THAT NOTHING COULD BE
DONE ABOUT HIS OR HER ACTIONS SO
I WOULD JUST COMMEND THAT TO THE
COMMITTEE'S ATTENTION. THANK YOU
THINK SO MUCH ACCESO.
ALRIGHT I'M GONNA HAVE SOME
CLOSING COMMENTS BEFORE WE LOOK
FOR MOTION.
BUT I THINK IT TURNED OVER TO
MR PAN OUT TO BE OF MAKE ANY
CLOSING COMMENTS. THE KEEPS
CHAIR I THINK.
FIRST OF ALL JUST TO ADDRESS
ONE ISSUE THAT'S BALONEY AND
WISH I WASN'T OFF THEIR.
ACTUALLY.
THAT REGIONAL IMPETUS OF THE
BILL WAS NOT.
THE ISSUE TO HAPPEN MADERA
COUNTY HOWEVER WE RECOGNIZE
THERE'S A PROBLEM THERE FOR AND
OUT TO GET SENATOR.
FROM WHO REPRESENT THE AREA
BROUGHT THAT SORT TO ME SO WE OF
COURSE I WANTED TO INCLUDE THAT
IN THE BILL BECAUSE AFTER ALL I
THINK THE STATE INTEREST IS
ENSURING THAT WE HAVE A. GOOD WE
HAVE JUSTICE AND WE HAVE GOOD
GUY QUALITY JUSTICE OUT TO THE
PEOPLE OF TRUST AND NOT IN THE
SYSTEM THE OTHER ISSUE I DISCUSS
A US ARE MORE LOCK.
APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR AFT SEAT
FORWARD THIS ISSUE I HOPE I THAT
YOU WILL VOTE FOR THIS BILL AND
CERTAINLY I. HAVE BE INTERESTED
IN WORKING WITH YOU IF YOU'D BE
INTERESTED JOINT OFFERING A
FUTURE PLEASE OUT SCOPE OF THIS
BILL I FUTURE PEACE LEGISLATION
TO AND A CA PERHAPS ADDRESSING
ANY CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES I HELP
YOU WITH THAT. WITH STRANGER
SOME OF THE OTHER COUNTIES AS
WELL.
SO AT THAT TIME I RESPECTFULLY
ASK WHEN I BOUGHT IT THANK YOU
SO MUCH MR PAN AND JUST SOME
QUICK QUESTIONS AS I DID NOT SEE
ANY ADDITIONAL A QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
FIRST FALL.
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO MISTER
PAN OUT FOR THE WORK ON THIS AND
I ALSO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO
OF COURSE. I STATE YEARS AS WELL
SEIZE ACT ARE ON THIS ISSUE AND.
I I'D SAY THE VAST MAJORITY TIME.
IS SPECIALIST HE SACCO. WORK
TOGETHER VERY CLOSELY IS REALLY
IMPORTANT IS A FORMER COUNTY
SUPERVISOR AND I HAVE GREAT
RESPECT
IN DO BELIEVE THAT WE NEED TO
AN INDEPENDENT BODY. AT TO BE
ABLE TO RUN THE CORNER SHOP.
BUT I DO BELIEVE THAT AT THIS
POSITION.
WOULD OPERATE.
LIKE ANY OTHER HIGHER LEVEL
MANAGER WITHIN THE COUNTY CINEMA.
AND.
WOULD ALSO BE ABLE TO WORK ON
SECURING THE NECESSARY BUDGET
THAT TO BE ABLE TO OPERATE
EFFECTIVELY.
I THINK THAT THE.
.
THE ISSUE OF POPULATION IS AN
IMPORTANT ONE. ON AND.
WHICH IS WHY.
MISTER PAN IS TRIED TO BE ABLE
TO LIMIT THIS BILL.
TO THOSE COUNTIES THAT HAVE THE
POTENTIAL REVENUE TO AFFORD.
THIS INDEPENDENT POSITION.
THE OTHER ITEM IS AND I DO AGREE
WITH.
THE STATE CHAIRS THERE IS A
SHORTAGE OF.
THESE TYPE OF POSITION
THROUGHOUT THE NATION ON IT'S A
VERY SPECIALIZED POSITION WHICH
IS WHY THIS COMMITTEE IS ALSO
RECOMMENDING A TWELVE MONTH
DELAY IN IMPLEMENTATION. TO
ASSIST THOSE A COUNTIES TO BE
ABLE SECURE THE NECESSARY
PERSONNEL ARE ON BOARD. SO I
AGAIN I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
THAT TO BOTH SIDES AT FOR THE
ROBUST DISCUSSION ABOUT AND WANT
TO SAY THANK YOU TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR THAT. THE
CONVERSATION IN DEBATE A AND
I'LL BE SUPPORTING THIS BILL THE
IS THERE A MOTION AYE IT WHICH
WOULD BE DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
PUBLIC SAFETY. WE HAVE A MOTION
UP BY SENATOR HERTZBERG WILL
CALL VOTE PLEASE MISLAID CHESTER
MCGUIRE AYE. WIRE AYE NGUYEN.
BELL. BILL AYE HERNANDEZ RE
INSIDE HERTZBERG. EYED HERTZBERG
AYE LARA MORLOCK.
HE HAS FOR SALE.
IT CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
VOTE AND WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE
ROLL OPEN FOR THE VICE CHAIR AND
AGAIN WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO
ALL SIDES UP FOR ALL THE WORK IN.
THANK YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU.
WE'RE GONNA BE HANDING OUT OF
THE PATIENTS WERE TODAY.
IN THE PATIENT'S AWARD GOES TO
THE GOOD ASSEMBLY MEMBER FROM
SAN DIEGO HE HAS TO BUILDCENTER
IN FRONT OF THIS COMMITTEE.
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN A. B.
FIFTEEN NINETY SIX WHICH IS
RELATED TO PROPERTY TAXATION.
GOOD HAVE EVERYONE.
BOB WE CAN YOU SAY KEEP IT QUIET
HERE IN THE ROOM AS WE ARE
TRANSITIONING.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
IS A GLORIOUS GOING TO BE A
FOCUS HERE PROBABLY TAXATION
BASE YOUR VALUE TRANSFERS AND
WE'RE GOING TO BE A MOVING
STRAIGHT ONTO A CA TWELVE.
WHICH IS A COMPANY MEASURE THAT
WITH THESE ITEMS ARE TO BE TAKEN
SEPARATELY WE'RE GONNA NEED TO
HAVE SEPARATE MOTIONS IN THIS
COMMITTEE WILL BE TAKING
SEPARATE ACTIONS IS WELL. SO TO
BE A KICK* OFF AN ITEM
NUMBER ELEVEN A. B. FIFTEEN
NINETY SIX THE SIMPLY MEN.
HAS THE FLOOR IN ASSUMING I DO
WANT TO LET YOU KNOW THAT YOU DO
HAVE. THAT BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON
YOUR BILLS BUT WHICH IS ALWAYS
GOOD NEWS.
IN WHICH WE WOULD ALSO REQUEST
A TRUNCATED VERSION OF YOUR
TESTIMONY BY AND WE DO
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME TODAY AND
APOLOGIZE ABOUT KEEPING YOU
DELAYED IN KNOW YOU'RE VERY BUSY
SIR. THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
NO PROBLEM ALL WELL DONE AS
CHAIRMAN. NAVIGATING ALL THAT.
GOOD MORNING AND THANK YOU I
WILL BE BRIEF IT'S COMBINED
PRESENTATION I THINK YOU I'M
CERTAIN ALL OF YOU READ THE DOT
THE BACK UPS.
WE WILL.
I'M HERE TO ACCEPT OTHER
COMMITTEE SUGGESTED TECHNICAL
AMENDMENTS FOR BOTH A CA TWELVE
AND AB FIFTEEN NINETY SIX
APPRECIATE YOUR CHICKENS
CHAIRMAN YOUR STAFF'S GREAT WORK
ON HELPING THIS AND. BEEN TAUGHT
IN THE INDULGENCE OF HEARING THE
OF THESE TWO ITEMS EARLY IN THE
SESSION I'M I WILL GO ANY
FURTHER SIR I KNOW YOU YOU'RE
PRESSED SO THANK YOU AS THE GOOD WORK.
IT'S GOOD TO BE TEXTING EACH
OTHER MAKING SURE WERE ALL GOOD
THAT SIR YOU'RE AT A FASHION IN
A WITH A GREAT IDEA FOR THEM
CHRIS FOR GLOBAL HEALTH DELIVERY
SO SHE'S TO REALTORS IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WOULD LIKE TO
OPEN IT UP FOR ANYONE WHO IS IN
SUPPORT YOU TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD FIRST AND LAST NAME MR SUMMONING CLOSING COMMENTS.
THE FASTER I VOTE THANK YOU SO
MUCH AS FLINCH AS RICARDO PLEASE
REQUIRE I OR A WIN.
BELL.
WELL I HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
MORE LOCK FOR LUCK GUY EMPLOYERS
FOUR ZERO MISTER SOON WE'RE
GONNA KEEP THAT.
ROLE OPEN THIS IS IN A COMPANY
MEASURE A CA TWELVE ITEMS
TWELVE AS WELL.
OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION ON THE
FLOOR.
WE NEED A VERY QUICK
PRESENTATION PLEASE
OF I REFER YOU BACK TO MY
PREVIOUS COMMENTS AND RESPECT WE
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU SO
MUCH. ANY INDIVIDUAL IN SUPPORT
AS WE'VE HEARD FROM BOTH YOU IN
THE OTHER DISH IN ALL A COMMENTS.
PLEASE COME ON PORTS HER.
PERSON LAST ORGANIZATION DANIEL
CITY NO ARCA IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU SO MUCH WE'D LIKE TO BUILD A
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR AYE
HERTZBERG TO BELIEVE.
BUT I WOULD LIKE TO TO SEE IF
WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE WHO WOULD
LIKE TO GO TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL.
OKAY WOULD COME AND GET.
HEY WHAT'S GOING ON.
A.
WE HAVE.
MISTER BOTH IN THE HOUSE THE
VOICE WAS IF WE SHOULD BE SIT
NEXT TO A GUY I USED TO WORK
WITH FOR MANY YEARS YOU SURE YOU
WANT TO SUPPORT THE SAME THING I
JUST WANT YOU TO GIVE YOU FREE
IN FULL INFORMATION FULL
DISCLOSURE.
SENATOR HERTZBERG MISTER CARLYLE
AND I GET ALONG GREAT.
AND HAVE FOR MANY MANY YEARS SO
I'M NOT ALL WORRIED OR FEEL
THREATENED ABOUT HIM IN THE
LEAST LIKE YOU FOR THAT
ENDORSEMENT AIRLOCK ON.
IT WILL FI THANK YOU MEMBERS
THAT GOOD MORNING DAVID WILL FOR
THE HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION.
WERE IN SUPPORT OF THE BELL AND
AGAIN THIS IS A BILL THAT'S SORT
OF A PERSONAL FOR ME.
YOU KNOW AS SOMEONE WHO GREW UP
WITH A DISABILITY.
I CATCH MY BREATH HERE FOR A
MINUTE I YOUR GRAN IN HERE THANK
YOU. COULD.
.
OBVIOUSLY MEMBERS I WAS BORN
WITH A DISABILITY THAT I HAD BUT
YOU KNOW IF YOU HAVE A CHILD IN
A CAR ACCIDENT AND YOU'RE
DEALING WITH A TWO STORY HOME.
YOU KNOW THE PARENTS ARE GONNA
WANT TO MOVE OUT OF THAT HOME
AND TO THE EXTENT.
THESE TWO BILLS FACILITATE PARA
TO GET SCARED ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE. MAKES A MUCH IS WHAT'S
GOOD TO SEE YOU AS ALWAYS ANYONE
ELSE IN SUPPORT.
BUT THEY'VE BEEN TO SEE IF
ANYONE ELSE CRUNCHY.
HERTZBERG THE MOTION IS BE
ADOPTED AS AMENDED TO ELECTIONS
A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS.
.
ALRIGHT WE ARE ON A ROLL LOCAL
THOUGH PLEASE HUSSEIN CHESTER
WICKWIRE TYPE WHERE I WIN.
THEY'LL. BILL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG
WE ARE ALSO GOING TO CALL THE
VICE CHAIR WERE NEED VICE CHAIR
WINDED PLEASE RETURN TO THE
COMMITTEE.
AS WE'RE GOING TO START ADDING
ON.
JOHN.
WE ALL KNOW.
IF.
A LITTLE BIT AMERICA. BECAUSE I
DID IT AND SHE.
RECENTLY
I THINK IF YOU WOULD ALSO.
WHAT ELSE?
NO.
E. WHO WE NEED A FANCIFUL
CONSENT PLAYING DOWN.
HERTZBERG LIVE.
ALRIGHT LADIES AND GENTLEMEN TRY
TO GET YOU OUT OF HERE.
JUST.
AT. SOME HOUSEKEEPING ITEMS
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT S. B. TWELVE
TWENTY FIVE S. B. TWELVE TWENTY
FIVE HAS BEEN PULLED BY SENATOR
GLAZIER WELL I. HERTZBERG HERTZBERG I
SUCCEEDED THAT ENJOYS A SIX YEAR
WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE THE ROLE ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
BUT WE'RE NOW MOVING ON.
YOU ITEM NUMBER ONE.
MISLAID CHESTER IF YOU CAN JUST
LET US KNOW WHO'S MISSING ON
THIS ONE.
OKAY WE'RE LOOKING FOR A BELL
AND HERTZBERG VOTE AT THIS IS S.
B. NINE FOURTEEN CURRENTLY
JOEY'S EIGHT FOUR ZERO BROKAW
BILL PLEASE FELL.
YEAH I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE
SIX THIS IS A SIX
ZERO WE ARE CLOSING THE ROLE ON
I.
WE ARE NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
NUMBER TWO THIS YEAH THIS
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
VOTE MISS LANE CHESTER WHO WE
LOOKING FOR.
BUT LOOKING FOR MR BELL AND MR
HERTZBERG ITEM NUMBER TWO ITS
FEET NINE TWENTY FOUR.
EVERY GO BROKE ALTHOUGH PLEASE
TELL.
BILL AYE HERTZBERG HURTS OR GUY
ZERO THAT IS A SIX ZERO VOTE WE
ARE NOW CLOSING THE ROLE AND
ITEM NUMBER TWO.
WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
NUMBER THREE.
ESPY'S NINE SIXTY THREE
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
BIPARTISAN.
VOTE FOR LOOKING FOR MR BELL
AND MR HERTZBERG ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE.
WELL.
WELL I HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG
AYE SICK BED IS A SIX ZERO WE
ARE CLOSE IN THE ROLE ON ITEM
NUMBER THREE SB NINE SIXTY THREE.
WE'RE NOW MOVING FORWARD ON S.
B. TEN THIRTY FIVE THIS
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A ITEM NUMBER
FOUR SP TEN THIRTY FIVE
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE ZERO
MISLAID CHESTER WE LOOKING FOR.
MISTER HERTZBERG MISTER BELL
WHAT'S BEEN GOING ON ROLL CALL
VOTE PLEASE SELF. BELL AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE THAT
IS A FIVE ZERO WE'RE GONNA CLOSE
TO ROLL ON ITEM NUMBER FOUR IS
BETWEEN THIRTY FIVE. FOR NOW
MOVING ON TO. ITEM NUMBER FIVE
SP ELEVEN THIRTY THIS CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO WE'RE LOOKING
FOR MISTER HERTZBERG AND MISTER
BELL ON THIS VOTE. BROKE
ALTHOUGH PLEASE TELL BELL AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE SIX
BED IS A SIX ZERO FINAL VOTE WE
ARE CLOSING THE ROLE IN ITEM
NUMBER FIVE SP ELEVEN THIRTY
WE'RE NOW MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER
SIX SB ELEVEN FORTY FIVE THIS
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
VOTE. LOOKING FOR MR BELL AND MR
HERTZBERG ROLL CALL PLEASE TELL.
BILL AYE HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE GUIDE BUT IS A SIX
ZERO WERE CLOSE IN THE ROLE ON
ITEM NUMBER SIX.
WE'RE NOW MOVING FORWARD TO S.
B. TWELVE THIRTEEN IS CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A THREE ZERO. AND WERE
LOOKING FOR.
MISTER HERTZBERG AND MISTER
BALLE ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE.
WELL I HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG
AYE.
THAT IF I EASE.
THE FINAL VOTE FIVE ZERO WE'RE
GONNA BE CLOSING THE ROLE ON
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN. WE'RE NOW
MOVING FORWARD WITH.
NUMBER NINE SP THIRTEEN OH
THREE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR
ZERO VOTE. IN THIS IS THAT WE'RE
LOOKING FOR A VOTE. UP FROM.
VICE CHAIR WYNN A ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE WHEN.
THAT WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE THE
ROLE OF THAT IS GOING TO.
BE A FINAL VOTE OF FOUR ZERO
BUT THAT MOTION DOES PASS ON A
FOUR ZERO VOTE. TAKE YOU SO MUCH
OUR FINAL TWO WE HAVE RIGHT NOW.
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN A. B.
FIFTEEN NINETY SIX CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO.
WE.
BUT WE ARE LOOKING FOR MISTER
HERNANDEZ IN VICE CHAIR WYNN
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE AND. WHEN
I HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE FIX
ZERO ON ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN THAT.
THE BILL IS OUT FIFTY SO MUCH.
BY AD THEN VICE CHAIR WHEN WE
HAVE ONE MORE FOR YOU.
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE EIGHTY CA
TWELVE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A.
FIVE ZERO VOTE ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE AND.
WHEN I.
THAT IS THE FINAL SIX ZERO VOTE
ON ITEM NUMBER TWELVE THAT IS
OUT.
WE HAVE A PRETTY HEAVY MEETING
NEXT WEEK ON THE EIGHTEENTH AND
THEN THE TWENTY FIFTH WE'RE
GONNA BE HERE FOR ABOUT TWELVE
HOURS IS SO.
HOPE EVERYONE HAS A GOOD REST
OF THE WEEK AND WE'LL SEE YOU.
ON THE EIGHTEEN THANK YOU SO
MUCH THIS MEETING IS A.