SECTOR.
THESE.
ALAN. ANDERSON ATKINS BATES
BELL.
BERRYHILL. BRADFORD. CANNELLA.
DELEON DOT.
FULLER. GAINES.
GALGIANI GLAZER HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG HE'LL.
HUESO JACKSON LADA.
LEYVA MCGUIRE MENDOZA. MITCHELL
MONNING. MORLOCK.
RAIL.
NEWMAN.
WHEN.
NIELSEN PAN.
PORTANTINO ROTH.
SKINNER
STERN.
STONE.
BIDAK Y. KATHY WIENER WILK.
WONDERFUL MCCORMACK'S PRESENT.
WHAT THE MEMBERS AND OUR GUEST
BEYOND THE RAIL AND IN THE
GALLERY PLEASE RISE?
WE'LL BE LEAD IN PRAYER THIS
AFTERNOON BAR CHAPLAIN.
SISTER MICHELLE GORMAN.
AFTER WHICH PLEASE REMAIN
STANDING WOULD BE LED IN THE
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE
FLAG.
BY SENATOR HILL.
LET A CENTER OURSELVES IN GOD'S
PRESENCE.
GOD IF THE PAST PRESENT AND
FUTURE.
YOU HAVE TOLD US THROUGH OUR
SCRIPTURES.
BUT YOU HAVE CALLED US BY OUR
NAME.
YOU HOLD OUR TEARS AND A FLASK.
AND THAT OUR LIVES ARE WORTH
MORE THAN MANY SPARROWS.
GRANT US THE GRACE TO VALUE ALL
PERSONS FOR THEIR PRESENCE.
THEIR GIFTS.
THEIR CONTRIBUTIONS
TO THE ONGOING EVOLUTION OF OUR
CIVILIZATIONS.
BANISHED FROM OUR HEARTS FEAR
PREJUDICE ARROGANCE
AND ALL THOSE WOULD PREVENTERS
FROM APPRECIATING THE BEAUTY OF
ALL YOU HAVE CREATORS.
WE ASK THIS IN YOUR NAME AMEN.
STATE SENATOR.
SURE I.
MISSION.
BUSINESSES.
ALRIGHT MEMBERS NOW UNDER.
PRIVILEGES OF THE FLOOR.
SENATOR NIELSEN I BELIEVE YOU
HAVE A INTRODUCTION TO MAKE.
YES PLEASE.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN THE SENATE
TO A. VERY SPECIAL.
OCCASION TODAY FOR ME TO
INTRODUCE TO YOU.
SO TRUE HEROES.
ONE PARTICULAR HERO.
LITTLE TOWN CALLED RANCHO TAME.
OPEN TO HIM THE COUNTY.
AND A LITTLE SCHOOL.
IN THAT COMMUNITY.
THE ONLY ABOUT TEN MILES FROM
OUR. RANCHO.
IN THE COUNTY.
SEVERAL MONTHS AGO.
DISTURBED INDIVIDUAL.
DECIDED HE HAD TO TAKE.
POWER INTO HIS OWN HANDS.
AND DROVE AROUND THAT LITTLE
COMMUNITY.
THE GUN.
SHOOTING PEOPLE.
AND HE HAD PARTICULARLY HAD A
GOAL.
OF KILLING ONE OF THE. CHILDREN
AT THAT SCHOOL.
RATCHET TO HIM ELEMENTARY.
THAT WAS NOVEMBER FOURTEENTH
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
WHEN HE BEGAN HIS.
RAMPAGE.
WAS A HORRIFIC EVENT.
BUT DUE TO THE VIGILANCE.
A HANDFUL OF PEOPLE.
THAT'S SCHOOL.
NO CHILDREN.
OR HER.
THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
NO CHILDREN WHERE LOST NO LIVES
AT ALL LOST.
ON THE CAMPUS.
BECAUSE.
OF ONE PERSON'S.
VIGILANT.
AND VERY WARY EFFORTS.
HER.
THE NAME WAS SARAH LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN.
SARAH LOBBED.
AND I JUST TALKED WITH HER A
LITTLE BIT ABOUT THAT COURAGE IN
THE MOMENT. I'VE KIND OF BEEN
PLACES LIKE THAT MYSELF. AND NOT
SUCH MOMENTS OF A WONDERFUL
PIECE COMES OVER THOUGH YOU'RE
IN THE MIDDLE OF A SUCH A
STRESSFUL. CIRCUMSTANCE.
BUT SHE WAS PEACEFUL AND CLEAR
WHAT SHE HAD TO DO. AND THAT WAS
TO PROTECT.
THOSE CHILDREN.
AND EMPLOYEES OR TO THAT SCHOOL.
SHE TOOK.
DECISIVE ACTION.
FEE ANNOUNCED.
AN IMMEDIATE LOCKDOWN.
IT COMMUNICATED THAT.
SHE DIDN'T WAIT TO CALL NINE ONE
ONE. FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT TO
RESPOND.
THE TICKET SOLELY INTO OUR OWN
HANDS.
AND THERE'S NO DOUBT IN ANYONE'S
MIND.
THAT HER INTERVENTION.
SAVED LIVES
BUT THAT LITTLE SCHOOL.
TODAY SHE'S HERE WHETHER HUSBAND
JAY AND THEIR TWO SONS DYLAN AND
JAMISON.
THOUGH IN THE JAMES CENTER VERY
PRECOCIOUS YOUNG MEN.
I THINK YOU MIGHT SEE ONE I'M
SERVING HERE SUNDAY MAYBE BOTH
OF.
BUT THEY CERTAINLY DO HAVE.
HEROIC MOTHER.
WE HAVE THE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL
HERE WITH US TODAY POWER AND
FILIAL. AND THE SUPERINTENDENT.
READ RECTITUDE FITZPATRICK.
AND THIS IS AN EXAMPLE LADIES
AND GENTLEMEN I ARGUE WISH.
TERRIFYING SITUATION.
OR THE BEST.
IN ALL OF US.
SHOWED FORTH.
AND LIVES WERE SAVED.
PARTICULARLY.
CHILDREN.
THAT RATCHET TO HEMA ELEMENTARY
SCHOOL.
SARAH PLEASE COME UP AND ALLOW
THE SENATE TO RECOGNIZE YOU.
WITH THIS RESOLUTION
.
GALLAGHER SENIOR WORD YOU
MISSED.
THIS PRESIDENT.
ABSOLUTELY ASSEMBLY MY GALLAGHER
PLEASE.
I THINK THAT THE SENATOR.
REALLY SAID IT SO WELL BUT TERM
WE ARE SO APPRECIATIVE OF THAT
PEOPLE LIKE SARAH.
I WORRY DAY AND HELP SUPPORT OUR
YOUNG PEOPLE.
AND WHO MADE.
A COURAGEOUS AND LIFESAVING
DECISION THAT DAY.
.
HER IN HER FELLOW COLLEAGUES AT
THE SCHOOL.
ARE ARE TRULY TO BE COMMENDED.
.
THIS COULD HAVE BEEN A MUCH MORE
DIRE SITUATION. BUT BECAUSE OF
THEIR FAST ACTING.
AND.
AND THE FACT THEY HAVE ACTUALLY
BEEN THEY HAD BEEN TRAINING ON
THIS. I THINK THAT POINTS TO
ANOTHER AND ANOTHER NEED.
I MEAN ARE COMMUNITIES AND THAT
WE NEED TO KEEP OUR. GARCIA WE
CAN KEEP OUR SCHOOLS SAFE.
AND THAT THEY CAN BE. THE
ULTIMATE SOFT TARGET.
AND SO I THINK THERE'S MORE
THAT WE CAN DO AS AS BOTH OF OUR
BODIES. AT TO ENSURE THAT SAFETY
AND WE ARE CERTAINLY THANKFUL.
ADVERSARY AND FOR ALL OF THE THE
THE STAFF MANNER MEMBERS WHO
ACTED SO QUICKLY THAT DAY.
THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GALLAGHER A CONGRATULATIONS TO
SARAH LA BELLE.
OKAY.
MEMBERS MOVING TO PRIVILEGES OF
THE FLOOR IS CENTER WHO WAY SO
AND CENTER MINING HERE OKAY I
BELIEVE YOU HAVE AN INTRODUCTION
TO MAKE.
THANK YOU MISS PRESIDENT.
AS CHAIR OF THE CALIFORNIA LEFT
IN A LEGISLATIVE CAUCUS.
I RISE TO RECOGNIZE A TRAGIC
INCIDENT.
THAT OCCURRED SEVENTY YEARS AGO.
AND TO THANK AN INDIVIDUAL.
WHOSE TIRELESS EFFORTS HAVE LED
TO JUSTICE
ON BEHALF OF THE VICTIMS OF THAT
EVENT.
ON JANUARY TWENTY EIGHTH
NINETEEN FORTY EIGHT.
A GOVERNMENT CHARTERED AIRPLANE
CARRYING TWENTY EIGHT MEXICAN
CITIZENS BACK TO THEIR HOMELAND.
CRASHED IN THE LOS GATOS CANYON.
NEAR THE TOWN OF COALINGA IN
FRESNO COUNTY.
THE MEXICAN PASSENGERS ALONG
WITH THE FOR AMERICAN CREW
MEMBERS WERE INSTANTLY KILLED.
WELL THE NAMES OF THE AMERICAN
CREW MEMBERS WERE IMMEDIATELY
RELEASED.
THE MEXICAN NATIONALS WERE
SIMPLY LISTED AS DEPORTEES.
AND WOULD REMAIN ANONYMOUS
FOR THE NEXT SEVEN DECADES.
THE GOVERNMENT. MADE NO EFFORT.
TO.
RELEASE THEIR IDENTITY. THEY
MADE NO EFFORT.
TO COMMUNICATE THE TRAGIC EVENT.
WITH THEIR FAMILIES.
AND THEY MADE NO EFFORT TO
RELOCATE THE REMAINS OF THESE
VICTIMS.
TWO THEIR THEIR.
NATIVE COUNTRY.
TO ADD INSULT TO INJURY. THE
REMAINS OF THE MEXICAN
PASSENGERS WERE BARE BURIED. IN
A LARGE MASS GRAVE IN FRESNO'S
HOLY CROSS CEMETERY LISTING THEM
ONLY. WITH THE NUMBERS ONE
THROUGH TWENTY EIGHT.
EACH NUMBER FOLLOWED BY TWO HAND
WRITTEN WORDS
MEXICAN NATIONAL.
THIS TRAGIC INCIDENT WAS
MEMORIALIZED IN THE LYRICS BY
FULL. ICON WOODY GUTHRIE.
IN HIS SONG DEPORT T. PLANE
CRASH AT LOS GATOS.
THIS SONG WENT ON TO BE RECORDED
BY SEVERAL OTHER ARTISTS
INCLUDING.
BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN WILLING AND
NELSON AND JOAN BIAS.
AND.
BOB MENTIONED JOAN LATER BUT.
IT WAS NOT UNTIL TWENTY TEN WHEN
AUTHOR TIM HERNANDEZ A SON OF
MIGRANT FARM WORKERS AND A
PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
TEXAS EL PASO. IMPART EMBARKED
ON A SIX YEAR SEARCH TO IDENTIFY
THE VICTIMS.
LOCATE THEIR FAMILIES.
AND WRITE THEIR STORIES IN HIS
BOOK ALL THEY WILL CALL YOU.
I AM HAPPY TO PROVIDE EACH AND
EVERYONE OF YOU A COPY OF THIS
AMAZING ACCOUNT.
AND THIS MAYES IN HISTORY.
PLEASE KNOW. THAT MANY ON THE
PLANE MANY OF THE PLANE CRASH
VICTIMS.
WELCOME TO THE U. S. AS PART OF
THE PLACENTA PROGRAM. WHERE THEY
HELP FILL LARGE LABOR SHORTAGE
RESULT RESULTING FROM WORLD WAR
TWO?
SO WHILE.
AMERICANS WERE OUT.
DEFENDING OUR COUNTRY MANY OF
THESE PROVIDED THE IMPORTANT
ROLE. OF THE FEEDING OUR TROOPS
AND FEEDING EVERYONE HERE AT
HOME AND KEEPING.
OUR AGRICULTURAL ECONOMY
VIBRANT.
THESE INDIVIDUALS.
AND MANY LIKE THEM PLAYED A
SIGNIFICANT PART OF THE WAR
EFFORT.
AND.
WHEN THE WAR WAS OVER. THEY WERE
SIMPLY SHIPPED TO THEIR HOME
COUNTRY.
BUT IN THE CASE OF THESE VICTIMS
THEY NEVER MADE IT HOME.
AND THEIR FAMILIES.
NEVER KNEW.
Y. THEY NEVER CAME BACK HOME.
TIM HERNANDEZ DID THE WORK THAT
THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD HAVE DONE.
BUT SEVENTY YEARS LATER.
AND I'M HONORED TO BE ABLE TO
TAKE A MOMENT TO ACKNOWLEDGE.
THIS TRAGIC EVENT.
AND PROPERLY MEMORIALIZE VICTIMS
ONCE AND FOR ALL.
AND TO LET THEIR FAMILIES NO.
HOW THEY WILL BE REMEMBERED? AS
A VALUED PART OF THE HISTORY OF
OUR STATE.
BEFORE WE THANK THE AUTHOR OF
THE BOOK IN THE FAMILIES OF THE
PLANE CRASH VICTIMS WHICH OF
JOINS US TODAY I WOULD LIKE TO
THANK THE MAJORITY LEADER.
FOR FOR MAKING THIS EVENT
POSSIBLE AND ALSO FOR A PROTON.
FOR MAKING THIS EVENT POSSIBLE
THANK YOU.
I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE OUR OF
MAJORITY LEADER. AND ASK HIM TO
PROPERLY RECOGNIZE
THE PLANE CRASH VICTIMS NOT
REPRESENTED HERE TODAY BY SHERRY
IN THEIR NAMES.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
MEMBERS.
I WOULD ASK
REAR SILENCES WE MEMORIALIZE.
THE THIRTY TWO VICTIMS.
SEVENTY YEARS AGO YESTERDAY ON
THE CRASH AT LOS GATOS CANYON.
MIGUEL NAY GREDDY ALVAREZ.
THOMAS LAVIGNE THEY GARCIA.
SANTIAGO GARCIA ELIZONDO.
ROSARIO IDEA ESTRADA.
BURN A BAY LOPEZ GARCIA.
SALVADOR SANDOVAL. AND THEN
THIS.
SAID ADAM MEDINA LOTTA.
ILIA'S THROUGH HIZO MUSAEUS.
JOSE RODRIGUEZ MUSAEUS.
LOUISE LOPEZ MAY THE INNER.
MANUEL CALDERON MENINO.
LUIS CUEVAS MIRANDA.
MARTINE RASO NO LATERAL. AND.
IF NOT CO PAD IS NAVARRO.
BUT OMAN O. CHORE A CHOI.
APOLONIO BUT I'M IT IS
PLACENCIA.
ALBERTO CARLOS GRAY GHOST.
WHY DO THEY AND LAND THIS
RODRIGUEZ?
MARIA SOMETIMES RODRIGUEZ.
ONE VALENZUELA RELEASED.
WHEN SAYS HELLO FLORES RELEASED.
OPPOSED SAY NO THEY VIA LUNCHES.
HEY STU'S MISTER SANTOS.
ALTHOUGH MARROW MARCUS FLORES.
FRANK ATKINSON PILOT.
BOBBI ATKINSON FLIGHT ATTENDANT.
MARION EWING COPILOT.
FRANK E. CHAFFIN IMMIGRATION
GUARD.
AND NOW I'LL TURN BACK TOWARD
CHAIR.
OF THE LATINO LEGISLATIVE
CAUCUS ON WHO WILL PRESENT THE.
RECOGNITION.
THANK YOU THE MAJORITY LEADER
AND I WOULD LIKE TO PERCENT
RESOLUTION TO MISTER TIM
HERNANDEZ FOR HIS TIRELESS
EFFORTS.
TO HONOR THE PLANE CRASH VICTIMS
BY NAME IN THEM. RESPECTFULLY
MEMORIALIZING THEM AND FOREVER
RESTORING THEIR DIGNITY
.
IF I MAY MISTER PRESIDENT I
WOULD ALSO LIKE TO. PRESENT
ADJOURNED IN MEMORY RESOLUTIONS
TO THE RELATIVES.
AFFORD THE PLANE CRASH VICTIMS
WHETHER REPAIR BY METIS LADA.
BERMAN BUT IT IS GONZALEZ THE
MUST MARKETS BY THE YOUNG.
INFERENCES GOTTEN ON THIS WOULD
ON JAM US THAT ARE HERE WITH US
TODAY
INCLUDE TODAY'S RECOGNITION.
IT'S MY HONOR TO RECOGNIZE JOAN
BAEZ WHO'S WITH US HERE TODAY.
AS MANY OF YOU KNOW.
THE THING THAT KEPT THE MEMORIES
OF THESE VICTIMS ALIVE WAS THE
SONG BY WOODY GUTHRIE. DEPORT
TEENY.
AND JOAN BAEZ POPULARIZE THAT
ALONG WITH PETE SEEGER.
AND IT WAS THROUGH THAT SONG
THAT TIM HERNANDEZ.
WANTED TO KNOW THE FULL STORY.
SO THE FAMILY'S NAMES WOULD HAVE
NEVER BEEN RECOVERED.
THEY ARE NOW MEMORIALIZED AT THE
FRESNO CEMETERY. THE NAMES OF
TWENTY EIGHT.
DEPORTEES IN THE FOUR CREW
MEMBERS ANNA PLEASE JOIN ME IN.
OFFERING A BIG THANK YOU TO JOAN
BAEZ FOR KEEPING THIS LEGACY
ALIVE AND MORE IMPORTANTLY FOR
HER. ACTIVISM HER COMMITMENT TO
PACIFISM INNER CONTINUED WORK TO
BRIDGE HUMANITY ON OUR PLANET.
PLEASE JOIN ME IN THANKING
.
MISSION OF THE PRESIDENT.
ABSOLUTELY.
THANK YOU.
HUGE HONOR FOR ME TO BE HERE
TODAY.
NOT JUST FOR THIS CELEBRATION.
AND THE WORK OF HIM TO FIND.
AFTER SEVENTY YEARS.
THE NAMES OF THE PEOPLE WHO WENT
DOWN WITH THAT.
PLAIN.
I AM SO PLEASED THAT.
IN THAT WAS ALSO INCLUDED.
THE PILOT MCALPINE.
STEWARD STEWARDESS.
.
BECAUSE IT MAKES IT ALL SOMEHOW
RIGHT.
THE WORDS THE SONG I MUST HAVE
SOMETHING ON THE SENATE FLOOR
BUT THEY ARE GOOD BY TO MY QUAN.
GOOD VITAL SALITA O. SMITH'S
AMIGOS HE SIOUXSIE MAHDIA. YOU
WON'T HAVE A NAME WHEN YOU RIDE
THE BIG AIRPLANE ALL THEY WILL
CALL YOU WILL BE DEPORTEES.
AND NOW YOU HAVE NAMES AND YOU
HAVE IS THE SAID YOUR DIGNITY.
AND YOU HAVE.
NEW ALLIANCES WITH PEOPLE HADN'T
EVEN KNOWN EACH OTHER BEFORE SO
IT'S MY ABSOLUTE PLEASURE TO BE
A PART OF THE CITY THANK YOU
SENATOR NIELSEN.
PRESIDENT BY MAY. ON THIS.
ISSUE.
PLEASE.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN THE SENATE.
IF YOU HAVE NOT HEARD IN YOUR
LIVES THE SONG THEY PORTRAY.
PLEASE.
PULL IT UP ON YOUTUBE.
AND LISTEN TO IT.
NONE BETTER SONG THAN BY JOAN
BAEZ MY FAVORITE. FOLKSINGER.
TODAY WITH THOSE AND I
INTRODUCED IN NOW WHO SENATOR
MINING. CENTER HUESO OF
INTRODUCED.
WHAT IT UP LEFT?
BUT THE BEST OF THE BEST.
OF OUR SOCIETY.
OF OUR WORLD POPULATION.
THOSE BRAVE BRAVE MEN AND WOMEN.
FOR DECADES CAME HERE.
MANDATE THE WORK IN MY INDUSTRY.
BRAVE BECAUSE IT'S NOT EASY TO
GET HERE.
BRAVE.
STUDIES HAVE STAYED HERE.
BRAVE.
BECAUSE IT'S VERY HARD WORK.
AT THIS PARTICULAR MOMENT.
I THINK SIGNED A SPOTLIGHT.
ON THOSE.
CAME.
FOR SURVIVOR.
SURVIVAL FOR THEIR FAMILIES IN
MEXICO.
THE PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES
FOR THEIR CHILDREN AND FOR THEIR
GRANDCHILDREN.
TO BE PRODUCTIVE HERE IN THE
UNITED STATES.
IT IS A GREAT HONOR.
AN OVERDUE HONOR
THAT THEY BE RECOGNIZE HERE
TODAY.
THANKS TO EACH OF ALL OF YOU.
AND ALL THOSE WHO PASSED BEFORE.
THEY WILL BE.
AND MY PRAYERS.
THANK YOU SENATOR NELSON.
THANKS THE SENATORS HUESO AND
MOANING IN RECOGNITION OF TIM
HERNANDEZ JOAN BAEZ AND THE
FAMILY OF THE VICTIMS OF
NINETEEN FORTY EIGHT LOS GATOS.
PLANE CRASH
OR IT MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO
SENATOR PORTANTINO WHO WILL MAKE
AN INTRODUCTION.
THANK YOU. MISTER PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS.
.
TODAY THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
COLLEGE LEAGUE IS UP IN THE
CAPITAL. WITH COMMUNITY COLLEGE
SHOW A. BOARD MEMBER STUDENTS.
AND ADMINISTRATORS FROM ALL
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
I HAPPEN TO REPRESENT
SEVERAL OF THE BY MY OPINION
GREATEST COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA OF NOT
THE ENTIRE UNITED STATES. WHICH
INCLUDE PASADENA CITY COLLEGE
GLENDALE A COMMITTEE COLLEGE AND
CITRUS COMMUNITY COLLEGE ARE ALL
IN THE TWENTY FIFTH SENATE
DISTRICT. AND IN THE GALLERY
TODAY IF THEY WOULD STAND. IT'S
MY HONOR TO REPRESENT.
PASADENA CITY COLLEGE STUDENT
TRUSTEE AND BOARD MEMBERS AND
ADMINISTRATORS WE HAVE ADRIN TO
SEE S. WAS THE ASSOCIATE
STUDENTS SUPREME COUNCIL CHIEF
JUSTICE.
WE HAVE FAMILY X. YOM WHO WAS
THE STUDENT TRUSTEE WE HAVE
GABBY WHOA ASSOCIATED STUDENTS
LOBBY COMMITTEE CHAIR. JIM MOSS
STERLING WHO WAS A TRUSTEE RAW
SELVAGE WHO WAS A TRUSTEE AND
LINDA HUANG WHO IS A TRUSTEE SO
WE COULD GIVE THEM A WARM
WELCOME AND THANK YOU FOR HAVING
THEM IN THE CAPITAL TODAY.
WELCOME TO THE STATE CAPITOL.
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO SENATOR
HERTZBERG.
ARE YOU PREPARED TO MAKE AN
INTRODUCTION.
DEMI THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
I WAS INTENDING TO ANNOUNCED A.
THE FOLKS FROM PROCLAIM A
BEAUTIFUL WERE HERE IN
SACRAMENTO TO ADVOCATE THE AT
THE STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNSEL.
FOR.
AN IMPORTANT AWARD THAT THEY'RE
ENGAGED IN UNFORTUNATELY THEY'RE
STILL THERE AT THE STRATEGIC
GROWTH COUNCIL BUT THEY ARE HERE
IN SPIRIT. IN SACRAMENTO SO I
WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE GREAT.
COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION OFA
QUORUM OF BEAUTIFUL VERY
PORTANTINO'S I REPRESENT IN THE
SENATE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MEMBER I CAN SEND HER SPUR.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO SENATOR
MORALE.
YOU HAVE A RESOLUTION TO PRESENT
CENTER MORALE.
.
MISTER PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS
THANK YOU HATE TODAY.
HERE'S A BITTERSWEET DAY IT'S A
BEAUTIFUL DAY IS THE SWEET PART
THE BITTERNESS IS.
WHEN I FIRST GOT ELECTED TO THE
STATE SENATOR.
I GOT.
MARK TIMMERMAN AS MY CHIEF OF
STAFF AND HE PROMISED TO STAY.
THREE YEARS AND HE ACTUALLY WENT
PAST THREE YEARS WHICH WAS GOOD
FOR ME BUT IT'S THE BITTERNESS
IS I I CERTAINLY HATE TO LOSE
HIM BECAUSE I.
HE HAS KEPT ME FROM WALKING OFF
THE CLIFF A NUMBER OF TIMES ANNA
HE. WILL SOMETIMES YEAH AND HE'S
GOT AS SUCH A GOOD WORKING
KNOWLEDGE OF THIS BILLING
BECAUSE HE'S BEEN HERE FOR SO
MANY YEARS IN FACT LET ME READ A
LITTLE BIT ABOUT. HIS RESUME AND
BY THE WAY WEDNESDAY'S HIS LAST
DAY ARMY AUBRY RETIRED AFTER
THIRTY YEARS.
AND WHEN I FIRST MET MARK HE
WORK FOR ASSEMBLY MAN.
JEFF CORRAL. IS YOU GUYS
REMEMBER HIM BUT ALSO MARK BEGAN
HIS CAREER.
UNDER.
A GOVERNMENT DEUKMEJIAN AS IN A
POINT.
BEING APPOINTED TO THE
APARTMENT TREES AND THEN HE WAS
THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
IN POLICY DIRECTOR FOR THE
REPUBLICAN.
ASSEMBLY CAUCUS HE OFF MARK
ALSO WORKED FOR THE CALIFORNIA.
BUSINESS ROUNDTABLE AS WELL AS
THE CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION THE
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS
ASSOCIATION AND SWALLOWS.
BECOMING A DIRECTOR OF THE
STATE GOVERNMENT FAIRS FOR PGM
AND. MANY OTHER THINGS
LOBBYING ON BEHALF OF SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA EDISON BUT ANYWAY I
THINK THE BEST THING HE DID WAS
WORK FOR SENATOR MIKE MORRELL BE
HONEST WITH YOU.
BUT ANYWAY I'M EXTREMELY
GRATEFUL FOR HIS.
HIS GUIDANCE IN THIS LEADERSHIP
AND.
MARK IS MORE THAN JUST THE
CHIEF OF STAFF FOR ME HE'S
BECOME A GOOD FRIEND. AND.
OUR RELATIONSHIP WILL CONTINUE
BECAUSE.
MARK IS THAT A GOOD MAN AND.
WE WISH HIM WELL AS HE RETIRES
BUT HE IS GOING TO BE MESSED SO
I WOULD JUST LIKE TO HAVE MARKED
COME UP HERE.
.
AND ON BEHALF OF THE.
CALIFORNIA SENATE.
MARK THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THERE'S A LOT AWARE AS IS HERE
BECAUSE YOU'VE DONE A GOOD JOB
SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU CHIEF OF STAFF MARK
CAMERON
.
SENATOR NIELSEN ON THIS ITEM.
YES MISTER PRESIDENT PLEASE.
THIS PERSON LADIES AND GENTLEMEN
THE SENATE IF I MAY ADD MY.
SENTIMENT STILL.
MARK TIM.
MARK IS ONE OF THOSE WERE QUIET.
BEHIND THE SCENES SOULS.
THE BOND IN THE. FABRIC IN THE
METAL.
THEN THE TT LA THE METAL. OF
INSTITUTIONS LIKE THIS.
HE'S THE ONE WHO HAS BEEN AROUND
THROUGH GOOD TIMES AND BAD.
HE'S KNOWN HOW TO NEGOTIATE.
THE VICISSITUDES OF GOVERNMENT.
PROBLEMS IN THE CHALLENGES.
ALWAYS BEING TRUE TO HIMSELF IS
VALUED. AND ALWAYS TO.
TO THE STATE SENATE.
WARRANTY SO AB WORKED.
FOR SO LONG.
HIS ELK.
OFTEN GO UNSUNG OTHER THAN BY
THEIR OWN.
SENATORS.
TO HIRE THEM.
THE STAFFS THAT WORK WITH THEM.
MAYBE THEY'RE KNOWN A LITTLE
BIT.
FURTHER AROUND IN THAT.
BUT MOST OF THE WORLD OUT THERE.
DOES NOT KNOW.
THEIR LABORS AND THEIR
CONTRIBUTIONS
ON BEHALF OF THE PUBLIC.
MARK IS A MAN OF GREAT FORCE
AND.
WELL.
KNOWLEDGE.
PASSION.
AND GOODNESS.
THEN MAY ALL GOODNESS MARK.
SHARE YOUR LIFE.
IN THE YEARS THE LORD YET LEAVES
YOU TO LIVE ON THIS EARTH.
GODSPEED MY FRIEND.
THANK YOU SENATOR NIELSEN.
AND CENTER CANNELLA YOU'RE
ENTERTAINERS PRESIDENT WE HAVE
SOME SPECIAL GUESTS HERE TODAY
WE HAVE THE EIGHTH GRADE CLASS
FROM THE LICO CHRISSY SCHOOL
DISTRICT. ALRIGHT APPEAR WELCOME
TO THE CALIFORNIA STATE SENATE.
GREAT.
THEY CONSIDER CANNELLA SENATOR
ALAN.
OKAY SENATOR HERTZBERG.
LAST NIGHT WE SAW THE GRAMMY
AWARDS TO HONOR.
PEOPLE OF
IN THE MUSICAL WORLD IN AMERICA.
WE SEE IN THE ACADEMY AWARDS TO
HONOR PEOPLE.
IN THE MOTION PICTURE INDUSTRY.
I JUST LEARNED THIS MORNING.
AS I WAS GETTING ON THE AIRPLANE
THAT IS AN ORGANIZATION CALLED
THE INTERNATIONAL OPERATE WARDS.
HELD IN APRIL.
IN LONDON THE LONDON COLISEUM.
AND I WAS LEARNED BECAUSE MY
YOUNG SON WHO YOU'VE ALL HEARD
ABOUT.
CALLED TO TELL ME THAT HE
RECEIVED A NOTIFICATION.
THAT. HE WAS.
NOMINATED.
TO BE.
THE NEWCOMER OF THE YEAR
GLOBALLY IN THE AREA OF OPERA HE
IS THE ONLY COMPOSER ON THE
PLANET.
IN THE NEWCOMER'S CATEGORY
THERE'S A COUPLE OF DIRECTORS.
AND THERE'S A COUPLE OF
CONDUCTORS BUT HE IS THE ONLY
COMPOSER.
AND ALL I CAN SAY COLLEAGUES IS
AS THEY SAY IN THE MOVIES.
THAT'S AS GOOD AS IT GETS THANK
YOU VERY MUCH CREW GRADUATION
SENATOR HERTZBERG
.
ALRIGHT MEMBERS WE CAN NOW MOVE
ON TO.
pBE DEEMED READ MESSAGES FROM
THE
ASSEMBLY. OF MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
MISTER PRESIDENT I'M GRETCHEN
FORMER AUDIBLE BODY THAT THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDED AND ON THE
STATE PASSED AS AMENDED SENATE
BILL FIVE FIFTY EIGHT. I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST OR ABA BY
TWO CONCURRENT SAID AMENDMENTS
HE DOESN'T LISTEN SHE CLICK AT
THE ASSEMBLY.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY ARE
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES WILL BE
DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
ADOPTED.
MOTIONS RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES.
SENATOR GLAZER.
OH WAIT WHAT ONE MOMENT I'M
ISSUES ME.
WITHOUT OBJECTION THE FOLLOWING
BILLS WITH FLOOR AMENDMENTS WILL
BE DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
ADOPTED.
FILE ITEM SEVENTY ONE. BILL
NUMBER EIGHTY FOUR A THREE.
AUTHOR BATES.
SENATE GLAZER. I THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS I'D
LIKE TO REQUEST UNANIMOUS
CONSENT.
THE TAKE UP SENATE BILL FIVE
FIVE EIGHT WITH THAT FOR
CONCURRENCE WITHOUT REFERENCE TO
FILE.
GREAT THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER
THE.
WITHOUT OBJECTION.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FIVE FIFTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR GLAZER AND ACT LIKE TO
TAXATION TO TAKE EFFECT
IMMEDIATELY TAX LEVY.
SENATOR GLAZERS THAT THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS. I SP
FIVE FIVE EIGHT IS A COMPANION
BILL TO AT CA NINE.
THIS IS A THAT A CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENT. THAT WOULD ALLOW A
PROPERTY OWNER TO INSTALL
RAINWATER RECYCLING ON THEIR
PROPERTY WITHOUT A TAX.
THE INCREASE IS MODELED AFTER
THE SOLAR EXCLUSION THAT WE'VE
HAD IN PLACE FOR SOMETIME.
AS CA NINE WAS JUST PASSED OUT
THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR ON A
UNANIMOUS VOTE I THINK IT WAS
SIXTY NINE TO ZERO.
THE AMENDMENTS OUT FIVE FIVE
EIGHT THAT WERE TAKEN IN THE
ASSEMBLY AMONG OTHER THINGS
MAKES THIS MEASURE ELIGIBLE FOR
THE JUNE BALLOT.
THAT'S THE JUNE BALLOT FOR THE
VOTERS TO MAKE A DECISION ABOUT.
A FEW DAYS AGO THE GOVERNOR I
GAVE A STATE OF THE STATE
ADDRESS.
AND AMONG THE MANY THINGS THAT
HE TALKED ABOUT OF IMPORTANCE TO
HIM AND AND OUR STATE. WAS THE
ISSUE OF RAINWATER RECYCLING.
AND THE EFFICIENT AND IMPORTANT
UP WATER CONSERVATION WORK THAT
WE HAVE DONE AND WE NEED TO DO.
SP FIVE FIVE EIGHT ALONG WITH
S. S. C. A. NINE. WILL. DO JUST
THAT I WOULD ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
WE THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZER
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SENIOR HEARING NONE SECRETARY.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
BY BATES
BY BILL. AYE BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
I GAINES AYE AYE GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL.
I HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LARA. AYE LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA. MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE. AYE BIDAK
AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WIENER. AYE WILK.
I THINK TERRY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I.
DELEON.
MENDOZA.
MONNING.
BUT THE CALL.
ALRIGHT MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE
TO.
INTRODUCTION AND FIRST READING
OF BILLS.
FOR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE THIRTY EIGHT
NINE THIRTY NINE NINE FORTY NINE
FORTY ONE AND FORTY TWO NINE
FORTY THREE NINE FORTY FOUR NINE
FORTY FIVE.
AND SENATE BILL NINE FOUR SIX.
THANK YOU NOW MEMBERS.
WILL.
NOW MOVE TO CONSIDERATION THE
DAILY FILE.
SECOND READING FILE.
VICTORY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TWO FIFTEEN.
SENATE RESOLUTION SEVENTY THREE
AND SENATE BILL TWO TWENTY
SEVEN.
THANK YOU KNOW MEMBERS WILL.
MOVE TO GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENTS.
CENTER DALY OWNER CENTER
CANNELLA.
OKAY WILL THEN.
MOVE FORWARD TO SENATE THIRD
READING.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
FILE ISSUES MAY FILE ITEM FORTY
THREE.
SURGERY PLEASE READ.
OF CENTER ANDERSON ARE YOU
PREPARED BRING FORWARD FILE ITEM
FORTY THREE.
A PASS ON FILE OKAY.
OKAY FILE ITEM FORTY FOR SENATOR
BRADFORD ARE YOU PREPARED TO
BRING THIS FORWARD.
OKAY SENATOR.
LAURA YOU PAIRED TO BRING
FORWARD FILE ITEM FORTY FIVE.
VICTORY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SIX NINETY FIVE BY
SENATOR LADA AND ACTUALLY DO
TEACHER CREDENTIALING.
THEY'RE LARA. THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS S. B. SIX
NINETY FIVE QUALIFIES THE
COMMISSION ON TEACHER
CREDENTIALING. CURRENT PRACTICE
OF USING THE SOCIAL SECURITY OR
A FEDERAL INDIVIDUAL TAX
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER OTHERWISE
KNOWN AS AN AYE TEN WHEN
APPLYING FOR A TEACHER TEACHING
CREDENTIAL. AGAIN THIS IS
ALREADY COMMON PRACTICE TO WANT
TO CODIFY THIS AYE STRICTLY
ANSWER AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA.
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
NO ATKINS. AYE BATES.
BY BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA. AYE DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG. AYE HILL. AYE
HUESO.
BY JACKSON PILOTA.
I LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
BY MENDOZA. MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
BY SKINNER. AYE STERN. AYE
STONE.
NO BIDAK.
IOWA COUNTY. BY WIENER. AYE
WILK.
SIX A PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS.
DELEON.
FULLER.
MENDOZA.
MONNING. WILK.
SIR LARA MOVES TO CALL.
WHEN THE LOOK AT FILE ITEM FORTY
SIX FULLER LARA YOU PREPARED
BRING THIS FORWARD.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SIX NINETY ONE BY
SENATOR LOTT ARE AND ACT WILLING
TO EDUCATIONAL EQUITY.
THE LARA THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT MEMBERS S. B. SIX
NINETY ONE WILL INCLUDE
IMMIGRATION STATUS AS A
PROTECTED CLASS WITHIN THE
CALIFORNIA EQUITY AND HIGHER
EDUCATION ACT. INCLUDING
IMMIGRATION STATUS AS A COVERED
BASIS UNDER THE ACT WILL MAKE IT
VERY CLEAR THAT CALIFORNIA'S
CONTINUED COMMITMENT. TO ALL
PEOPLE LOOKING TO FURTHER THEIR
EDUCATION OUR INSTITUTIONS OF
HIGHER LEARNING SHOULD BE AS
INCLUSIVE AS POSSIBLE AND
COMMITTED TO THE EDUCATION OF
OUR PEOPLE. RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTES.
GREAT THANK YOU SIR LARA MEMBERS
ANY DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
NO ATKINS. AYE BATES.
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON. AYE LARA.
AYE LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
MORE LOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
BY NIELSEN.
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
BY STONE.
NO BY JACK.
AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
SICK TO RECALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
DALY ON.
FULLER.
NO.
MENDOZA.
MONNING.
WILK.
SIMILAR MOVES THE CALL.
NUMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO A FILE
ITEM FORTY SEVEN.
SENATOR LARA.
THE.
CENTER LEYVA LEYVA SEES ME.
VICTORY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THREE TWENTY HAULED
BY SENATOR LEYVA AND ACTING TO
PUBLIC HEALTH AND MAKING
PREPARATION THERE FOR.
CENTER LEYVA.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
AFTERNOON MEMBERS S. B. THREE
TWENTY WOULD REQUIRE ALL ON
CAMPUS STUDENT HEALTH CENTERS.
AT PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES TO
PROVIDE MEDICATION FOR EARLY
PREGNANCY TERMINATION FOR THEIR
STUDENTS
LET ME BE CLEAR THIS BILL IS NOT
ABOUT SURGICAL ABORTION.
S. B. THREE TWENTY WOULD
INCREASE ACCESS TO MEDICATION
ABORTION WHICH IS A TWO STEP
PROCESS WERE WOMAN TAKES TWO
SETS OF PILLS OVER THE COURSE OF
TWO DAYS. DURING THE FIRST TEN
WEEKS OF PREGNANCY.
ACCORDING TO THE GUTTMACHER
INSTITUTE SINCE TWO THOUSAND
OVER ONE POINT FIVE MILLION
WOMEN IN THE UNITED STATES HAVE
TERMINATED EARLY PREGNANCIES
THROUGH THE USE OF MEDICATION
ABORTION.
IN TWO THOUSAND FOURTEEN WOMEN
AGED TWENTY TO TWENTY FOUR
ACCOUNTED FOR THIRTY FOUR
PERCENT. OF ABORTIONS THE
LARGEST OF ANY AGE GROUP.
ACCORDING TO A UC SAN FRANCISCO
STUDY ABORTION MEDICATION ONLY
HAS SERIOUS SIDE EFFECTS IN
POINT ZERO THREE PERCENT OF
CASES.
WHICH IS LESS SYMBOL TYLENOL AND
*.
TERMINATION OF A PREGNANCY IS A
CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED RIGHT
AND WOMEN SHOULD BE ABLE TO
ACCESS THAT RIGHT. IN A TIMELY
SAFE AND FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE
WAY. THE SAME UC SAN FRANCISCO
STUDY STUDY FOUND THAT EVERY
MONTH UP TO FIVE HUNDRED IN
NINETEEN STUDENTS AT THE THIRTY
FOUR UC AND CSU CAMPUSES.
THINK MEDICATION ABORTIONS AT
OFF SITE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES.
THESE COLLEGE STUDENTS FACE
NUMEROUS BARRIERS.
WITH SEEKING EARLY TERMINATION
OF A PREGNANCY SUCH AS FINANCIAL
LIMITATIONS AND TRANSPORTATION
ISSUES CURRENTLY FIFTY ONE
PERCENT OF STUDENTS ACROSS THE
UC AND SEE ISSUE SYSTEMS. ARE
LOW INCOME AND TWO THIRDS OF YOU
SEE STUDENTS AND ONE THIRD OF
SEE ISSUE STUDENTS. DO NOT HAVE
ACCESS TO RELIABLE
TRANSPORTATION EVERY STUDENT HAS
TO GO TO AN OFF CAMPUS PROVIDER
THAT DOES NOT ACCEPT THAT THEIR
STUDENT OR OTHER PRIVATE HEALTH
INSURANCE. PAYING FOR MEDICATION
ABORTION MAY BE A SIGNIFICANT
FINANCIAL BURDEN. IN TOTAL
TWENTY TWO UC AND CSU CAMPUSES
OR MORE THAN THIRTY MINUTES AWAY
FROM THE CLOSEST ABORTION
PROVIDER VIA PUBLIC
TRANSPORTATION.
THESE BARRIERS ARE WORSENED
SINCE ONLY FIFTEEN PERCENT OF
THE CLOSEST OFF CAMPUS ABORTION
PROVIDERS ARE OPEN ON WEEKENDS
MEANING THAT STUDENTS HAVE TO
ALTER OR MISS CLASSES EXAMS AND
WORK. TO ASK ACCESS THIS
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT
DENYING COMPREHENSIVE AND
ACCESSIBLE REPRODUCTIVE CARE ON
CAMPUSES INTERFERES WITH THE
WELL BEING ACADEMIC SUCCESS. OF
WOMEN AND DISPROPORTIONATELY
IMPACT STUDENTS OF COLOR AND LOW
INCOME STUDENTS.
I FIRMLY BELIEVE THAT ALL
STUDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO
DECIDE WHAT TO DO WITH THEIR OWN
BODIES AND WIND A FACTOR FAMILY
INTO THEIR LIFE.
AFTER ALL. WOMEN DO NOT LOSE THE
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO IN THE
PREGNANCY SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY
ARE A COLLEGE STUDENT.
NOT ALL STUDENTS TO GET PREGNANT
WILL CHOOSE TO TERMINATE THE
PREGNANCY BUT FOR THOSE WHO DO
SB THREE TWENTY AIMS TO
ELIMINATE THE BARRIERS TO ACCESS
OF CARE.
S. B. THREE TWENTY ALLOWS FOR A
PHASED IN APPROACH TO
IMPLEMENTATION SO THAT EACH
CAMPUS HAS AMPLE TIME TO
EVALUATE ITS NEEDS AND SAFELY
BEGAN PROVIDING THE SERVICE.
THE BILL ALSO CREATES A
MEDICATION IMPLEMENTATION FUND
WITHIN THE TRENT TREASURER'S
OFFICE TO MAKE SURE THE CAMPUSES
HAVE ACCESS TO PRIVATELY FUNDED
GRANTS SO CAMPUSES CAN RECEIVE
ANY NECESSARY TRAINING EQUIPMENT
OR INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDED TO
PROVIDE THIS SERVICE.
BRINGING ACCESS TO MEDICATION
ABORTION TO COLLEGE CAMPUSES IS
CRITICAL SINCE WOMEN MUST ACCESS
THIS CARE WITHIN THE FIRST TEN
WEEKS OF PREGNANCY. THAT MOST
WOMEN DON'T FIND OUT THEY'RE
PREGNANT UNTIL THE FOUR TO FIVE
WEEKS ALONG.
PROVIDING MEDICAL ABORTION ON
CAMPUS WOULD HELP ENSURE THAT
STUDENTS CAN FOCUS ON THEIR
FUTURE. WITHOUT THE ADDED
FINANCIAL AND LOGISTICAL
BARRIERS OF SEEKING REPRODUCTIVE
CARE OFF CAMPUS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LEYVA.
SENATE SENATOR WIENER.
I THANK YOU ARE MISTER PRESIDENT
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
AND I WANT TO THANK. MY
COLLEAGUE FOR BRINGING IT
FORWARD.
AYE I PERSONALLY I IE TRUSTS
WOMEN TO MAKE.
THEIR HEALTHCARE DECISIONS A
PERSONAL DECISIONS FOR WHAT
WORKS FOR THEM I DON'T THINK.
THAT. WE SHOULD BE TELLING THEM
WHAT TO DO AND WE SHOULD BE.
HELPING ENSURE.
THAT WOMEN HAVE ALL OF THE
RESOURCES AND TOOLS.
I THAT THEY NEED OUGHT TO BE
ABLE TO CONTROL THEIR OWN BODIES
IN THEIR OWN LIVES. I'M
PARTICULARLY WITH EVERYTHING
THAT IS HAPPENING. IN THIS
COUNTRY RIGHT NOW WHERE WE HAVE
AN ADMINISTRATION THAT IS MOVING
AGGRESSIVELY.
TO RESTRICT WOMEN'S ACCESS TO
HEALTH CARE.
INCLUDING.
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH OPTIONS BY
AND IN FACT I JUST THIS EVENING
IN THE UNITED STATES SENATE WILL
BE VOTING ON.
AND ABOARD A SIGNIFICANT
RESTRICTION OF ABORTION.
ACCESS REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
ACCESS AYE AYE NOT EVEN WITH AN
EXCEPTION FOR THE HEALTH OF THE
MOTHER.
I THINK CALIFORNIA SHOULD MAKE
CLEAR THAT WE ARE COMMITTED.
TO FULL ACCESS TO REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH SERVICES ALL BE VOTING
AYE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER SENATOR
MORE LOCK.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
.
WE'RE ESTABLISHING A MEDICATION
ABORTION IMPLEMENTATION FUND
WHICH WILL BE ADMINISTERED BY
THE STATE PROBABLY THROUGH THE
STATE COMPTROLLER'S OFFICE.
AND SO I'M WONDERING WHY WE
NEED TO HAVE STATE INVOLVEMENT.
AND STATE BECAUSE
INVOLVING HER WIN A PRIVATE
FOUNDATION CAN DO THIS WITHOUT
STATE INVOLVEMENT OR STATE
EXPENDITURES.
IT'LL COST TWO AND A HALF
MILLION DOLLARS. AND THAT MEANS
THE TAXPAYERS WILL HAVE TO PAY
FOR THAT PROBABLY WOULD TAX.
THAT ARE NO LONGER DEDUCTIBLE.
ON THEIR TAX RETURNS ABOUT THE
DONORS TO THE FUND COULD IT
LEAST GET A CHARITABLE
CONTRIBUTION.
SO.
WE'RE WE'RE FORCING TAXPAYERS
MANY WHO ARE PROBABLY
CONSCIENTIOUSLY OBJECTING.
TO THIS.
TECHNIQUE
AND SO WITH THAT CONCERNED.
WITH SOMETHING THAT MAYBE THE
STATE.
DOESN'T NEED TO BE INVOLVED WITH
HAS A CUSTODIAN OR TRUSTEE.
I I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST A NO
VOTE ON.
SENATE BILL THREE TWO ZERO THANK
YOU MISTER PRESIDENT THANK YOU
SENATOR MORE LOCK SENATOR
SKINNER.
AND THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
I'M STAND IN SUPPORT OF THIS
BILL I DON'T THINK THE AUTHOR
FOR BRINGING IT TO US.
AS A A PERSON KNOWS I WAS PRETTY
SANTA MY GRADUATE DEGREE WHILE I
WAS IN STUDENT.
PURSUING THAT DEGREE.
AND I WAS FORTUNATELY IN A
SITUATION WHERE I KNEW THAT I
WAS GOING TO BE ABLE TO COMPLETE
MY DEGREE.
.
THE MOST OF MY REQUIREMENTS WERE
COMPLETED AND SO MY HAVING MY
DAUGHTER AT THAT TIME WAS NOT
GOING TO HAVE A SIGNIFICANT
INTERFERENCE MY STUDIES.
HAD I.
GOTTEN PREGNANT EITHER DURING MY
UNDERGRAD CAREER OR AT THE
BEGINNING OF MY GRADUATE SCHOOL
CAREER.
I WOULD NOT HAVE FACED A
SIMILAR.
CIRCUMSTANCE AND WOULD HAVE BEEN
HAVING TO MAKE A VERY DIFFICULT
DECISION BECAUSE IT IS VERY
HARD.
CHIU ESPECIALLY MOST PEOPLE
UNDER GRAD STUDENTS DON'T HAVE
THE MEANS
TO PAY FOR CHILDCARE FOR EXAMPLE
ESPECIALLY INFANT CARE.
AND TO TAKE TWO OR THREE YEARS
OUT OF YOUR.
STUDIES
TO DEAL WITH THE EXPENSES OF
YOUR. BABY AND THEN TO TRY TO
RETURN MOST OF THAT TIME WHERE
YOU WOULDN'T HAVE HAD. REALLY
GOOD FOR.
SOURCE OF INCOME AND CERTAINLY
AS A STUDENT YOU DON'T.
AND THEN HOW THEN IS YOUR CHILD
SUPPORTED.
I THINK THAT JUST FROM A
PRCTICAL POINT OF VIEW IT'S
IMPORTANT FOR US TO REALIZE THE
KINDS OF THINGS WOMEN ARE FACING
WHEN THEY HAVE TO MAKE THESE
CHOICES.
AND SINCE THIS IS A.
PRESCRIPTION FOR A MEDICINE THAT
IS AVAILABLE.
AND ARE OUR MOST OF OUR CAMPUSES
PROVIDE HEALTH CARE THEY SHOULD
PROVIDE THAT FULL ARRAY OF
HEALTH CARE IN REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CARE AND I THINK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR BRINGING IT I SUPPORT
THE BILL.
THANK YOU SENATOR SKINNER ANY
FURTHER DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE CENTER LABOR WHICH
LIKE THE CLOTHES THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
ALRIGHT SICK TRADE CALL THE ROLL
BALANCE.
I ANDERSON. NO.
ATKINS.
BY BATES.
NO. BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD. AYE CANNELLA.
NO DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL.
BY HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
ISLA. AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE. AYE
MENDOZA MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
MORE LOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN. AYE PORTANTINO. AYE
ROTH.
I SKINNER. AYE STERN.
BY STONE.
NOVI DAK. KNOW WHAT COUNTY.
I WINNER.
BUT I WILK NO. SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS DELEON.
MENDOZA. MONNING. NEWMAN.
SENATOR LEYVA MOVES TO CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM.
FORTY EIGHT.
CENTER MCGUIRE VICTORY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN FIFTY NINE
LESSEN REQUIRE AND EXPLAIN TO
ELECTIONS.
THEN REQUIRED.
THANK YOU SO MUCH MISTER
PRESIDENT AND HAVING MONEY TO
YOU.
MEMBERS A STRONG DEMOCRACY
DEPENDS ON A VOTERS BELIEVE THAT
THERE BALLOT COUNTS.
HOWEVER HOWEVER IN CALIFORNIA
ACCORDING TO SECRETARY STATES
OFFICE.
OVER TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND
RESIDENTS HAD THE WORLD ROCKED.
WHEN THEY'RE BALLOT WAS THROWN
AWAY NOT COUNTED IN THE NOVEMBER
GENERAL ELECTION
BECAUSE OF THE MISMATCH IN
SIGNATURE. TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND
VOTES.
AND WHILE CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY
ALLOWS EIGHT DAYS TO CORRECT A
BALLOT WITHOUT A SIGNATURE.
THERE IS NO GUARANTEE THAT IT
COUNTY GIVES A VOTER IN
OPPORTUNITY TO CORRECT AND
MISMATCHING SIGNATURE.
IN FACT TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND
VOTERS HAD THEIR BALLOTS THOMAS
BECAUSE THE WERE NOTIFIED OF
DISCREPANCY IN THEIR SIGNATURE.
S. B. SEVEN FIFTY NINE WILL
ESTABLISH A PROCESS FOR LOCAL
ELECTION OFFICIALS DID NOTIFY
VOTERS WIN THEIR VOTE BY MAIL
BALLOTS SIGNATURE MISMATCH IS
THE ONE ON FILE.
IT WILL ALSO GUARANTEE THOSE
VOTERS AN OPPORTUNITY TO CORRECT
THE MISMATCH SO THEIR VOTES CAN
BE COUNTED.
AS THE USE OF VOTE BY MAIL
BALLOTS INCREASING CALIFORNIA WE
CANNOT IGNORE THIS ISSUE ANY
LONGER. TODAY OVER HALF
HALF OF ALL CALIFORNIANS VOTE BY
MAIL IN SOME COUNTIES LIKE
PLUMAS. NOT CONDUCT THEIR ENTIRE
ELECTIONS BY MAIL IT'S UP TO US.
TO KEEP DEMOCRACY STRONG IN
PASSED S. B. SEVEN FIFTY NINE
MEMBERS I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOU TO JOIN SECTORS STATE
PADILLA. IN ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER MCGUIRE MEMBERS
A DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
BY.
ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
BY BATES.
NOBEL. AYE BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD. AYE CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG. AYE HILL.
I WAS SO.
I JACKSON.
BY LATA. AYE LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE
AYE MENDOZA. MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN. AYE STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO. BY CASKEY. AYE WIENER. AYE
WILK.
NO.
THICK DIAPERS COLLAPSE OF
MEMBERS DALY OWN. MENDOZA MONEY.
SENATE MCGUIRE MOVES THE CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FORTY NINE SENATOR
PORTANTINO.
VICTORY PLEASE READ SENATE BILL
THREE NINETY NINE BY SENATOR
PORTANTINO ANAK CLING TO
HEALTHCARE COVERAGE RATE SENATOR
PORTANTINO. THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT AND NINE MEMBERS TODAY
I AM PRESENTING SP THREE NINE
NINE. WHICH WILL ELIMINATE
SIGNIFICANT ARTIFICIAL BARRIERS
IMPOSED BY HEALTH PLANS THAT ARE
PREVENTING FAMILIES FROM
ACCESSING BEHAVIOR HELP
TREATMENT FOR CALIFORNIANS WITH
AUTISM. THE BILL ALSO CODIFIES
THE REQUIREMENTS FOR QUALIFIED
AUTISM SERVICE PROFESSIONAL AND
PARA PROFESSIONAL TO ENSURE
HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE.
STATISTICS TELL US THAT ONE IN
SIXTY EIGHT CHILDREN BORN TODAY
ARE DIAGNOSED WITH AUTISM EARLY
INTERVENTION IS THE KEY TO
HELPING THESE CHILDREN LIVE UP
TO THEIR POTENTIAL. AND HEALTH
INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH TREATMENT IS A
CRITICAL COMPONENT. NOT ALL
CHILDREN WITH AUTISM ARE THE
SAME THEY RESPOND TO TREATMENT
DIFFERENTLY CHILDREN NEED
TREATMENT TAILORED TO THEIR
INDIVIDUAL NEEDS PRESCRIBED BY
THEIR PHYSICIAN OR PSYCHOLOGIST.
WHO KNOWS THEM BASS NOT A ONE
SIZE FITS ALL TREATMENT THAT MAY
NOT FIT?
SEVEN YEARS AGO.
FOR S. B. NINE FORTY SIX PASSED
THE LEGISLATURE TO PROVIDE
HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR
CALIFORNIANS WITH AUTISM.
IT HAS BEEN VERY SUCCESSFUL FOR
MANY CALIFORNIANS BUT MANY
OTHERS HAVE BEEN PREVENTED FROM
RECEIVING ITS BENEFIT. BECAUSE
OF ARTIFICIAL BARRIERS NOT EVERY
CHILD IS RECEIVING COVERAGE FOR
THE TREATMENT THEIR HEALTHCARE
PROVIDER PRESCRIBES THOUSANDS OF
CALIFORNIANS ARE BEING DENIED
COVERAGE FOR MEDICALLY
NECESSARY.
PHYSICIAN PRESCRIBED EVIDENCE
BASED CARE. THIS IS COVERAGE
THEY OR THEIR EMPLOYERS HAVE
ALREADY PAID FOR IN TOO MANY
CASES THE PARENTS.
FOR THE STATE ARE LEFT TO COVER
THE COSTS IN THIS CRITICAL CARE
SP THREE NINE NINE SEEKS TO
CORRECT THE DRAFTING ERRORS IN
S. B. NINE FORTY SIX.
THE MAKE SURE EVERY PERSON WITH
AUTISM HAS HEALTH COVERAGE FOR
THEIR MEDICALLY PRESCRIBED
TREATMENT AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PORTANTINO
MEMBERS ANY FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
NO ATKINS.
BY BATES.
NOBEL.
I.
BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
ISLETA.
I LABOR.
I MCGUIRE.
I MONNING.
MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN. AYE STONE.
BUT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
BY WIENER. AYE WILK.
SURGERY PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
FULLER.
NO.
MENDOZA.
MONNING NO.
NIELSEN.
STONE.
WILK.
CENTER PORTANTINO MOVES THE
CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO.
FILE ITEM FIFTY.
SENATE CANNELLA VICTORY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN A SEVEN BY
SENATOR CANNELLA ENACT GOING TO
MEDI CAL.
THINGS PRESIDENT. A S. B. SEVEN
OH SEVEN CREATES ELEVEN MEMBER
ADVISORY GROUP TO OVERSEE DE
KALB POLICIES AND PRIORITIES.
AS THE MEMBER OF THE JOINT
LEGISLATIVE AUDIT COMMITTEE IN
THE LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION
I'VE HEARD MANY ACCOUNTS AT
DINNER CAL RULES AND PROCESSES
ARE OFTEN HARMFUL TO
BENEFICIARIES.
THE TWO THOUSAND FOURTEEN STATE
AUDITOR AUDIT INTO THE ON
SIXTEEN LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION
REPORT FOUND THAT FEWER THAN
HALF. OF THE BENEFICIARIES USED
IN A CALENDAR YEAR.
IN RESPONSE TO RECOMMENDATIONS
BY LITTLE WHO WERE COMMISSION
REPORT I INTRODUCED SP TEN
NINETY EIGHT TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN. WHICH WOULD HAVE
CREATED THE DATA CAL ADVISORY
GROUP. THAT BILL WAS UNANIMOUS
ON THE SENATE FLOOR BEFORE IT
WAS AMENDED IN THE ASSEMBLY.
TO REQUIRE D. H. CS TO REPORT TO
THE LEGISLATURE BY OCTOBER FIRST
OF TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN ON
PROGRESS TOWARDS THE GOAL OF
RAISING THE UTILIZATION RATE TO
SIXTY PERCENT. HAD TO IDENTIFY A
DATE BY WELL BY WHICH IT
PROJECTS THAT THIS RATE WILL BE
MET.
I'M CONCERNED THAT DE CSS FAILED
TO COMPLY WITH STATE LA HAS
ESTABLISHED UNDER SP TEN NINETY
EIGHT.
I REPRESENT COUNTIES WITH HIGH
POPULATIONS OF CHILD
BENEFICIARIES WERE THEY THERE
AREN'T ENOUGH DENTISTS.
THE IMPACT OF THIS PROGRAM MY
CONSTITUENTS LEADS TO EMERGENCY
EXPENSE OF EMERGENCY ROOM VISITS
MISS SCHOOL DAYS AND LOST JOB
OPPORTUNITIES.
THIS ADVISORY GROUP IS AN
IMPORTANT STEP TO ENSURING THAT
DAC ES AND PROVIDERS WORK
TOGETHER FOR DENTAL HEALTH FOR
THEIR BENEFICIARIES ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR CANNELLA
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
I BATES.
BY BILL. AYE BERRYHILL.
BY BRADFORD. AYE CANNELLA AYE
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER. AYE GAINES AYE AYE
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
BY LARA. AYE LEYVA.
BY MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
MONNING.
I'M MORE LIKE.
MORRELL.
BY NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH. AYE SKINNER. AYE STERN
AYE STONE.
I'VE IDEC. AYE WIECKOWSKI. AYE
WIENER.
I WILK.
I. SURGERY PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS DELEON. MENDOZA
MITCHELL.
AYE.
MORE LOCK.
I. NIELSEN.
OKAY.
CENTER CANNELLA MOVES CALL.
THE PERSONNEL MOVED TO FILE ITEM
FIFTY ONCE SENATOR WHY CASKEY
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ONE SIXTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR WHITE HOUSE KEY AND
EXPLAIN TO RECYCLING RATE CENTER
MY COUNTY MISTER PRESIDENT
MEMBERS BAD SENATE BILL ONE
SIXTY EIGHT MAY HAVE GONE. FROM
ONE THE MOST COMPLEX MATTERS ONE
OF THE MOST SIMPLE MATTERS LAST
YEAR THE GOVERNOR CONVENED A
SERIOUS STAKEHOLDER HEARINGS ON
THE RECYCLING PROGRAM THE
LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S OFFICE.
ISSUED A DETAILED REPORT ON THE
PROGRAM CAL RECYCLE A ISSUED ITS
WHITE PAPER ON THE PROGRAM AND
THE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
COMMITTEE HELD A HEARING TODAY
I'M. BEFORE YOU ONE TWO SMALL
MATTERS UP BUT NEVER LESS
IMPORTANT COMPONENTS THAT CAME
OUT OF THESE SERIES OF HEARINGS
AND THAT MEETING SET UP HAVE
OCCURRED OVER THE YEARS.
FIRST SB ONE SIXTY DIRECTS CAL
RECYCLE TO ESTABLISH MINIMUM
CONTENT STANDARDS FOR ALL
BEVERAGE CONTAINERS THIS WILL
PRODUCE ECONOMIC AS WELL OPEN AS
ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS OUT FOR
CALIFORNIA. ECONOMIC BENEFIT IS
CREATING MARKETS FOR RECYCLING
MATERIALS RIGHT HERE IN
CALIFORNIA.
THE OVERSEAS MARKET
PARTICULARLY HERE IN CHINA ARE
NOW CLOSE TO MANY OF THE THE
RECYCLED MATERIAL THAT WE USE TO
SHIP OVER THERE.
BUT IT'S GOING TO GENERATE
ECONOMIC BENEFIT ENVIRONMENTAL
BENEFITS BY REDUCING GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSIONS.
BY UTILIZING RECYCLED MATERIAL
FOR EXAMPLE INCREASING THE USE
OF RECYCLED A CONTENT IN PLASTIC
BOTTLES BY TWENTY THREE PERCENT
CAN REDUCE THE RESULTING
GREENHOUSE GASES BY TEN PERCENT.
SECOND SP ONE SIXTY DIRECTS CAO
RECYCLE TO PROVIDE A REPORT ON
THE VIABILITY OF ESTABLISHING AN
EXTENDED PRODUCER RESPONSIBILITY
COMPONENT ARE IN THE BOTTLE BILL
PROGRAM. I UNDERSTAND LAST YEAR
WHEN WE VOTED ON THIS THAT. GOT
PEOPLE'S.
CONCERN TO THIS REPORT A MAY
PRODUCE GOOD IDEAS IT MAY NOT
PRODUCE GOOD IDEAS MCALARY SPIKE
RECYCLE IS NEVER LOOKED AT A. EP
ARE IN THE BOTTLE BILL PROGRAM
LIKE THE THEY'VE LOOKED AT IT
AND OTHER PROGRAMS THEY RAN LIKE
CARPETING AND AND MATTRESSES
SOME. TODAY'S BILL. HAD A LONG
LIST OF OPPOSITION BUT TODAY
ENJOYS A LIST OF PRIVATE SECTOR
AND NONPROFIT A SUPPORTERS OF
THE BILL SOME OF THE OPPOSITION
HAS BEEN REMOVED. IN SOME OF IT
HAS NOT BEEN REMOVED FROM THE
INITIAL. AYE ITERATION OF THE
BILL WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY
URGE AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR Y. KOWSKI.
DEBATE OR DISCUSSION SENATOR
STONE. FIGURE MISTER. OF
PRESIDENT I ICE I RISE IN
SUPPORT OF SB ONE SIXTEEN PROUD
TO SERVE AS A VICE CHAIR WITH
THE THE GREAT SENATOR FROM
ALAMEDA THAT.
WE STRUGGLED LAST YEAR ON
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY TO COME UP
WITH.
A SOLUTION TO MAKE CAO RECYCLE
A MORE VIABLE AND TO GET SOME OF
THESE RECYCLING CENTERS THAT
HAVE CLOSED DOWN IN MANY GROCERY
STORE LOCATIONS THROUGHOUT THE
STATE LEAVING NO PLACE FOR
PEOPLE TO WILL TAKE A RECITAL
RECYCLED PLASTIC AND GLASS.
AND. THERE WAS EVEN AN IMPACT ON
THE USE OF THE STORES IF YOU DID
HAVE A CERTAIN.
NUMBER OF RECYCLING CENTERS
WITHIN A CERTAIN RADIUS OF THE
STORES THEY WERE GETTING FIND
EVERY SINGLE DAY AND STILL DO
EVEN TODAY.
SO THERE WAS A LOT OF SPECIAL
INTERESTS THAT.
FELT THAT THEY NEED TO GET
INVOLVED IN THIS.
SOLUTION AND.
I HAVE TO APPLAUD THE THE
CHAIRMAN FOR WORKING WITH ALL
THE AFFECTED PARTIES AND ALL TEH
THIS BILL LIVES TURNED OUT TO BE
A MUCH BETTER FORM THAN IT WAS.
LAST YEAR AND AS AMENDED I'M I'M
PROUD TO OFFER UP TO BE A CO
AUTHOR OF THIS BILL AS THE VICE
CHAIRMAN MARBLE QUALITY. AND WE
WE NEED THIS BILL TO CONTINUING
THE STRONG RECYCLING EFFORS
THAT WE HAVE BEEN IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA HISTORICALLY AND
TAKING A LOT OF PLASTICS AND
GLASS AND. AND TAKING THEM.
OUT OF OUR OUR LANDFILLS BUT
AGAIN THIS WILL STOP A LOT OF.
RECYCLING BUSINESS FROM GOING
OUT OF BUSINESS AND HOPEFULLY
BRINGING MANY THEM BACK TO MAKE
IT MORE CONVENIENT. FOR MANY OF
OUR OUR PATRONS TO CONTINUE OUR
LEAD HIM IN THIS IN THE UNITED
STATES AND AND GETTING A LOT OF
THESE RECYCLABLES OUT OF OUR OUR
LANDFILLS. SO IT'S GOING TO
CREATE MORE JOBS BY THE OPENING
THESE RECYCLING CENTERS ARE MORE
POORLY IT'S GOING TO IMPROVE OUR
ENVIRONMENT FOR THOSE REASONS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK. FOR ALL OF OUR
AYE VOTES TO MAKE THIS A
BIPARTISAN YES.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE.
MEMBERS A FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
THING NONE SENATOR WHITE HOUSE
HE WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE. I WOULD
URGE AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
HI ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS. AYE BATES.
I BILL. AYE BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG. AYE HILL AYE
HUESO. AYE JACKSON.
ISLETA BY LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I MORE LUCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
BY ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
PI BIDAK. NO WHITE HOUSE HE. AYE
WINNER.
I WILK.
VICTORY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
FULLER.
GAINES AYE. AYE.
GLAZER.
MCGUIRE AYE.
MENDOZA MORLOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
WILK.
SENATOR MURKOWSKI MOVES THE
COFFEE.
MEMBERS WILL MOVE TO OF FILE
ITEM FIFTY TWO.
SENATOR ROTH SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTY EIGHT
PASSENGER. AND ACKLAND COURTS.
SO THE ROTH THANK YOU MISTER
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES THIS IS
PART OF MY.
MULTI YEAR CRUSADE TO ED JUDGES
TO THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
JUDICIAL SYSTEM.
IN THIS CASE SENATE BILL THIRTY
EIGHT IS AMENDED AUTHORIZES ONE
ADDITIONAL JUSTICE TO BE
APPOINTED TO THIS.
SECOND DIVISION OF THE FOURTH
APPELLATE DISTRICT IN
CALIFORNIA.
THE SECOND DIVISION OF THIS
APPELLATE DISTRICT IS THE MOST
IMPACTED APPEALS COURT IN THE
STATE.
THE DISTRICT CONSISTENTLY
RECEIVES OVER FIVE THOUSAND
FILINGS PER YEAR SECOND ONLY. TO
LOS ANGELES COUNTY SECOND
DISTRICT HOWEVER WITH FAR FEWER
JUSTICES.
TO HEAR THE CASES.
RAPID POPULATION GROWTH IN
RECENT YEARS IN INLAND SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA SPECIFICALLY
RIVERSIDE AND SAN BERNARDINO
COUNTIES. IS LARGELY FUELING
THIS NEED.
AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW BECAUSE
YOU'VE HEARD ME TALK ABOUT IT
BEFORE THESE TWO COUNTIES
ACCOUNT FOR OVER. ONE HALF OF
THE STATE WIDE NEED FOR JUDGES.
IN ADDITION TO THIS NEED FOR
TRIAL JUDGES.
THE APPELLATE JUSTICES FEEL THE
SAME PRESSURES AND FREQUENTLY
RESORT TO TRANSFERRING APPELLATE
CASES TO OTHER DISTRICTS IN
ORDER TO MEET CASE DEADLINES.
TO THE COURTHOUSE CLOSURES THE
PEOPLE IN RIVERSIDE ASSEMBLY NO
COUNTIES MUST OFTEN TRAVEL GREAT
DISTANCES.
TO REACH A COUNTY COURTHOUSE.
BUT DUE TO THE UNIQUE NATURE OF
THE APPEALS COURT AND IMPACTION
IN ORDER TO APPEAL A DECISION
SOME OF THESE LITIGANTS MUST
THEN TRAVEL EVEN FURTHER.
TO REACH A COURT AN APPELLATE
COURT IN A DISTANT COUNTY IN
ORDER TO HAVE THEIR APPEAL
HEARD.
UNFORTUNATELY THIS BILL DOES NOT
INCLUDE FUNDING.
BUT BY NOW AUTHORIZING AN
ADDITIONAL JUSTICE IN THIS
DIVISION AND BY ULTIMATELY
FUNDING THE POSITION. WE CAN PUT
A BANDAID ON THIS HEMORRHAGE.
AND ALLOW OUR COURTS OF APPEAL
TO DEAL WITH FRANKLY WHAT IS HAS
BECOMING CONTINUES TO BE. A
CRUSHING WORKLOAD I WOULD ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ROTH MEMBERS A
DEBATER DISCUSSION CENTER STONE.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT I WON
APPLAUD MY COLLEAGUE FROM
RIVERSIDE COUNTY FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD WE ALL KNOW THAT.
JUSTICE.
DELAYED IS JUSTICE DENIED.
AND WE IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY AND
CERTAINLY SAN BENITO COUNTY IF
YOU LOOK AT THE NUMBER OF
APPELLATE JUDGES.
BASED ON THE POPULATION
COMPARED TO OTHER AREAS OF THE
STATE INCLUDING OUR SUPERIOR
COURT JUDGES WE FALL WAY BEHIND.
AND SO IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
JUSTICE WE NEED AT THE
APPROPRIATE NUMBER JUDGES TO
RENDER THESE DECISIONS THAT I
URGE AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE ANY.
FURTHER DEBATE OR DISCUSSION
MEMBERS.
SEEING NONE SAID THE ROTH WHICH
ELECT THE CLOSE.
THANK YOU AS PRESIDENT JUST
RESPECTFULLY AS FOR THAT I VOTE.
WONDERFUL ALRIGHT SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON. AYE ATKINS.
BY BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA. AYE DELEON. DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON AYE LARA.
BY LABOR.
I MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL. AYE MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL.
I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE.
I'VE BIDAK AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE
WIENER.
I WILK.
I. SURGERY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS DAILY ON.
MENDOZA. NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
SENATOR ROTH MOVES THE CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM.
FIFTY THREE SENATOR PORTANTINO
SECRETARY. PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOUR FIFTY NINE BY
SENATOR PORTANTINO AND THAT KIND
OF FIREARMS
CENTER PORTANTINO. THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT AND SENATORS
TODAY I'M PRESENTING SP FOUR
FIFTY NINE WHICH WOULD REQUIRE
THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO
CONDUCT INSPECTIONS OF LICENSED
FIREARMS DEALERS. AT LEAST EVERY
THREE YEARS THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE FIREARMS TO FIDGET
DIVISION INSPECTION PROGRAM IS
REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN A
CENTRALIZED LISTA FIREARMS
DEALERS. EXISTING LAW AUTHORIZES
THE DEPARTMENT TO INSPECT
DEALERS TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE
WITH OTHER SPECIFIED PROVISIONS
OF FIREARMS LAWS AND TWO
ASSASSIN ANNUAL FEE TO COVER THE
REASONABLE COSTS. OF MAINTAINING
THE DEALER LISTING CONDUCTING
INSPECTIONS UNDER CURRENT LAW
HOWEVER THERE IS NO TIME FRAME
ESTABLISH FOR WHEN THE
DEPARTMENT SHOULD INSPECT
FIREARMS DEALER BUSINESSES. BY
ADOPTING A TIME FRAME OF AT
LEAST EVERY THREE YEARS ENSURES
COMPLIANCE WITH ALL FIREARM LAWS
AND REGULATIONS.
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PORTANTINO
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SENATOR STONE.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT.
HAS A.
ARTICULATED IN THE PUBLIC
SAFETY COMMITTEE THAT THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE HAS THE
RIGHT TO GO IN AND DO THREE OR
MORE INSPECTIONS RIGHT NOW.
IN MY MANDATING THAT.
THEY HAVE TO BE MANDATORILY
THREE INSPECTIONS EVERY FIREARM
DEALER IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. WOULD BASICALLY.
TAKE WITHOUT CONTROL OF THE
AGENCY THAT.
MAY WANT TO. EMPHASIZE. DEALERS
THAT HAVE A HISTORY OF OF NOT
FOLLOWING THE LAWS
SO I THINK THIS IS GOING TO WORK
TO THE REVERSE I THINK IT'S
GOING TO ELECT.
EIGHTY FAR ARMS DEALERS ARE NOT
COMPLYING WITH THE LAW.
MORE OF AN OPPORTUNITY TO
CONTINUE THEIR DASTARDLY DEEDS
IF YOU WILL. AND IT'S GOING TO
REQUIRE THEM TO GO INTO LAW
BITING FIREARM DEALERS AND NEVER
HAD A PROBLEM BEING IN BUSINESS
FOR TWENTY OR THIRTY YEARS AWAY
SING THOSE RESOURCES.
WITHOUT ANY COMPLAINTS OF ANY
IMPROPRIETY FOR THOSE FIREARM
DEALERS AGAIN THIS IS JUST
ANOTHER. ANOTHER ATTACK ON
SECOND AMENDMENT RIGHTS IN A
VERY INDIRECT WAY BUT IT IS A IT
IS A DIRECT ASSAULT AND FOR
THOSE REASONS I URGE A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE SENATOR
ANDERSON.
MEMBERS I UP YOU'VE HEARD ME
SPEAK BEFORE ABOUT THE DOJ.
AND.
THE GROSS MISMANAGEMENT THAT
THEY HAVE WORKED ON OVER THE
LAST.
FIVE YEARS WITH PROHIBITED
PEOPLE. AND THAT THOSE NUMBERS
OF PEOPLE THAT COULD NOT BE
OWNING A WEAPON WALKING OUR
STREETS.
I IN POSSESSION OF THOSE WEAPONS
WHEN THEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN
REMOVED EARLY ON.
BUT THE DOJ'S KIND TURN THE
CORNER IN OVER THE LAST YEAR
WE'VE SEEN.
MARKED IMPROVEMENT AND HOW
THEY'RE MINISTRY NESS AND I GET
THAT YOU DON'T TRUST THE DOJ AND
THAT'S WHY YOU WANT TO.
FORCE THEM TO DO THESE THINGS
BECAUSE YOU DON'T TRUST THAT
THEIR OPINION.
IS CAPABLE OF DISCERNING THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SOMEBODY
WHOSE IN VIOLATION IN SOMEBODY
WHO IS NOT A PROBLEM CHU I MEAN
SOMEBODY WHO IS A PROBLEM CHILD
FOR SOMEONE WHO IS IN A PROBLEM
CHILD.
BUT I DON'T THINK THAT WE NEED
TO.
INTERVENE AT THIS TIME BECAUSE
I THINK THEY DO IT DOJ'S DOING A
BETTER JOB.
YEAH IN MINISTERING THIS PROGRAM
SO FOR THAT REASON I URGE A NO
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON
MEMBERS ANY FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SENATOR PORTANTINO
WHICH LIKE THE CLOTHES I WOULD.
MISTER PRESIDENT I. RISE TO.
A SAY THAT WE ARE WORKING
CLOSELY WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
THIS BILL.
AND I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT.
MY GENTLE COLLEAGUES FROM A TO
MACULA MENTIONED.
MANDATING THREE INSPECTIONS
WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT.
MANDATES THAT AN INSPECTION
MUST TAKE PLACE IN A THREE YEAR
PERIOD NOT THREE INSPECTIONS BUT
EVERY DEALER MUST BE INSPECTED
AT LEAST ONCE.
IN A THREE YEAR PERIOD THAT'S A
THAT'S A SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE.
AND AGAIN WE PRIDE OURSELVES ON
HAVING STRICT.
GUN REGULATIONS IN THIS THIS
WONDERFUL STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AND WE SHOULD HAVE A DEPARTMENT
THAT MAKE SURE THERE IN FORCE
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR
PORTANTINO SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL. AYE BERRYHILL.
NO BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
NO DAILY ON.
I DOT.
I FULLER. KNOW GAINES. NO
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON
ISLA.
I LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
I MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NO.
NGUYEN.
NO NO SON.
PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
HI ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE.
NO BIDAK NO WIECKOWSKI.
WINNER.
BY WILK.
NO.
THE TYPICAL ABSENT MEMBERS
MENDOZA. NIELSEN.
WHAT COUNTY?
CENTER PORTANTINO MOUSA CALL.
MEMBERS ARE NOW GOING TO MOVE
TO FILE ITEM.
SHE IS ME WE'RE GONNA MOVE TO
PROTEST DAY THEY OWN PRIVILEGES
OF THE FLOOR.
THANK YOU MUCH OF MISTER
PRESIDENT.
COLLEAGUES.
I HAD THIS.
THE DISTINCTION THE HONOR TO
REPRESENT A TWO GENTLEMEN WHO
COME.
FAR AWAY.
FROM THE OTHER SIDE OF THE LAND
TO GOSHENBUT THEY'RE BOTH
LOCATED HERE IN OUR GREAT STATE
OF CALIFORNIA IN SAN FRANCISCO
TO BE IN PARTICULAR. I HAVE THE
DISTINCT HONOR PLEASURE TO
INTRODUCE
THE AUDIBLE COUNSEL GENERAL OF
THE GRADES.
NATION OF IRELAND WHO'S WITH US
TODAY MISTER ROBERTS O'DRISCOLL
AS WELL AS THE VICE CONSUL
MISTER JOHN CALLAHAN. THEY'RE
BOTH A HERE IN REPRESENTATION OF
THEIR A GREAT PRIME MINISTER.
THAT IS LEO BUT REDEKER VOTER
RAPTURE.
IT LEE OVERRIDE OCCURRED THE
NATIONAL MINISTER OF IRELAND IS
THE FIRST OF MANY.
HE IS THE FIRST PRIMARY IRISH
PRIME MINISTER TO BE LGBT OPENLY
GAY. HE'S A FIRST OF.
IRISH PRIME MINISTER TO BE A
PERSON OF COLOR HE'S A FIRST
IRISH.
PRIME MINISTER TO BE THE SON OF
IMMIGRANTS
SO THIS IS.
AN INCREDIBLE FEAT THE OF HIGH
CLEARLY AHEAD OF US
YOU KNOW WHEN IT COMES TO THE
COMPARISON OF LAW BORROW
POLITICAL HIGHER KEY. BUT THAT
THEY ARE HERE TO VISIT MANY THAT
COLLEAGUES HERE AS YOU CAN TELL
WE HAVE A LOT OF THE IRISH
AMERICANS POLITICIANS HERE AS
WELL AS. AND I AM PROUD TO BE
FROM A LONG LEAN ASIA PROBABLY
NICHE OF IRISH AMERICANS IN MY
FAMILY HAS MY NAME KEVIN. YEAH
ó DELEON.
SO WITH THAT LET'S GO FOR THE ON
ALL COUNSEL GENERAL ROBERT
O'DRISCOLL.
WELCOME
TO FILE ITEM FIFTY FOUR. CENTER
MORLOCK. VICTORY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SIX FIFTY SIX BY
SENATOR MORE LOCKED AND ACTING
TO JUDGES RETIREMENT MAKING
APPROPRIATION THERE FOR.
HE WAS IN RESIDENCE AT
COLLEAGUES IN NINETEEN NINETY
FOUR SECOND TIER WAS
ESTABLISHED.
FOR THE PENSION PLAN FOR JUDGES
IT'S A KNOWN AS J. R. S. TO. IT
IS A HYBRID IT'S PARTLY DEFINED
CONTRIBUTION PARTLY DEFINED
BENEFIT. AND IT HAS COMPONENTS
THAT.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT IT IN HINDSIGHT
LOOKS LIKE A A PLAN THAT WAS
CREATED BY A COMMITTEE.
THE NET RESULT IS THE JUDICIAL
BRANCH IS THE ONLY PUBLIC
EMPLOYEE GROUP NOT IN A BONAFIDE
DEFINED BENEFIT PENSION PLAN.
YEAH. A LONG TIME DEFINED
BENEFIT PENSION PLAN. REFORMERS
WHAT I'VE BEEN AND SO I WANT TO.
ADDRESS TWO MAJOR ISSUES THE
FIRST IS THE PRINCIPLE OF NO
BETTER NO WORSE. THE STATES
SUPERIOR COURT JUDGES CANNOT
OBTAIN THE DEFINED BENEFIT.
UNLESS THEY HAVE WORKED TWENTY
YEARS AND REACH AGE SIXTY FIVE.
THOSE. THOSE STARTING BEFORE THE
AGE OF FORTY FIVE MUST RESPECT
FOR LAWYERS THIS WOMAN IF WE
COULD PLEASE SHOW RESPECT THE
CENTER MORE LUCK AS HE PRESENTS
HIS BILL.
PLEASE CONTINUE.
THOSE APPOINTED AFTER AGE FORTY
FIVE LET'S WORK PAST SIXTY FIVE
OR THE AGE OF SEVENTY. DOES NOT
MEETING THESE PECULIAR
REQUIREMENTS WILL RECEIVE THEIR
CONTRIBUTIONS PLUS INTEREST PLUS
A STATEMENT AT TEN PERCENT
MATCH.
THEREFORE IF A JUDGE HAS HEALTH
CONCERNS. IF A JUDGE IS NOT
REELECTED EVERY SIX YEARS. IF
THIS. JUDGE NEEDS TO LEAVE THE
BENCH IN ORDER TO ASSIST THAT
AILING SPOUSE.
THEN THAT FAMILY HAS SOME MAJOR
DECISIONS TO MAKE ALSO IF THE
JUDGE PASSES AWAY BEFORE MEETING
THESE REQUIREMENTS.
THERE IS A A DIRECTOR.
YOU KNOW RESULT TO THE SURVIVING
SPOUSE FELL ONE BEGS THE
QUESTION DOES A JUDGE WHO'S
FIGHTING CANCER.
TAKING CHEMO SO SHOW UP OR TRY
TO SHOW UP. TO WORK TO REACH
TWENTY YEARS OR TO REACH AGE.
THIS IS NOT A PROPERLY
INCENTIVIZE SYSTEM COLLEAGUES
AND IF THE QUALITY IS OUR BUZZ
WORD HERE THAT SOMETHING MUST BE
DONE. THE SECOND CONCERN FOR THE
CPAC OF P. IS COST.
I AM OF THE OPINION THAT OUR
VOTERS DO NOT WANT ANOTHER
LAYER.
TO THE STATE'S EXISTING PENSION
CRISIS. THE ACTUARIES HAVE
REVIEWED AS BE SIX FIFTY SIX A
SIMPLE MODIFICATION WHICH IS TO
ALLOW A DEFERRAL. IF YOU'RE IF
YOU'VE WORKED TWENTY YEARS BUT
ARE ONLY SIXTY YOU CAN WAIT
UNTIL SIXTY FIVE TO RECEIVE THE
DEFINED BENEFIT.
THIS COMES AT A COST ACCORDING
TO CALPERS ACTUARIES IT'S TWENTY
ONE MILLION DOLLARS. THIS IS NOT
A MASSIVE AMOUNT BUT MY GOAL IS
TO PRESENT A BILL THAT IS CASH
NEUTRAL. ACCORDINGLY ARRANGEMENT
MUST BE WORKED OUT WITH THE J.
ARRESTS PARTICIPANTS SOME
SIXTEEN HUNDRED AND FIFTY SIX.
TO ACHIEVE COST NEUTRALITY. THE
J. ARREST JUDGES.
TO JUDGE ISSUES WE ARE WILLING
TO STEP UP TO THE TABLE AND WILL
CONFER AS THIS BILL MOVES
FORWARD TO THE ASSEMBLY PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT AND SOCIAL
SECURITY COMMITTEE. IT COULD
MEAN AN INCREASE TO
CONTRIBUTIONS OR A MODIFICATION
TO BENEFITS. WE WILL WORK. WITH
THE ACTUARIES TO FIND THE SWEET
SPOT.
COLLEAGUES MY REQUEST IS THAT
YOU VOTE FOR SP SIX FIVE SIX TO
MOVE IT FORWARD. APPROPRIATE IN
FAIR AMENDMENTS. I HAVE ALREADY
RECEIVED NEARLY FIVE HUNDRED
SIGNATURES IN SUPPORT OF SB SIX
FIVE SIX BY IMPACTED JUDGES.
JUDGE LANCE ITO WHO'S RETIRED
AND A J. ARREST ONE PARTICIPANT.
CAME TO THE CAPITOL TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL IN
COMMITTEE. WERE RECEIVED NO
OPPOSITION. I'M ALSO HONORED TO
HAVE SENATOR RICARDO LARA. AS A
CO AUTHOR.
I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I
VOTE FOR SP SIX FIFTY SIX.
THANK YOU SIR MORE LOCKS AND
LAURA THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
I'M OUR PRODUCTS THAT AS A JOINT
AUTHOR OF SP SIX FIFTY SIX.
REALLY IS AN ACCESS TO JUSTICE
ENSURING THAT. OUR JUDGES ARE
ABLE TO SERVE WE'VE BEEN HEARING
STORY AFTER STORY OF JUDGES
HAVING TO COME BACK.
FOR A COUPLE DAYS AND THEN MOVE
AND HAVING TO LEAVE BECAUSE OF
AN ILLNESS FOR MONTHS ON END
WHICH AGAIN CREATES THAT BACKLOG
OF CASES. THIS IS A FAIR THING
WE'RE GONNA WORK WITH.
CENTER MORLOCK TO SURE THAT WE
RENDER THE ISSUE OF.
ANY IMPACT TO THE GENERAL FUND
SO I WOULD ASK THAT WE KEEP THIS
BILL MOVING AS WE CONTINUE WORK
ON THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE
GREAT THANK YOU SIR LAURA
MEMBERS ANY FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SINGH NANDA SAID ARE MORE LIKE
WHAT YOU LIKE THE CLOTHES I
RESPECTFULLY A REQUEST AND I
BOTH THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
RIGHT THANK YOU. MORLOCKS
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALAN.
I ANDERSON BY ATKINS. I BATES.
BY BILL.
HE'LL.
I BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DAILY ON.
I DOT.
BYE FULLER.
GAINES. I I GOT JOHNNY.
I GLASER BY HERNANDEZ BY
HERZBERG.
HILL. HIGHWAY SO. BY JACKSON.
LOTTE. I.
LABOR.
I AM ACQUIRE. BY MENDOZA
MITCHELL. BY MORNING.
MORE LARK. I'M REAL.
NEWMAN.
OUR BY WIN. BY NELSON.
I PAN.
I PATINO. FIREARMS.
BY SKINNER.
BY STERN. BY STONE. FIVE IDEC.
CASKEY BY WINNER. BY WILKE.
I.
COLLAPSE OF MEMBERS BRADFORD.
HI FULLER.
I HURTS WORK.
JACKSON.
MENDOZA.
WANTING.
MERRELL.
I.
THEY'RE MORE LIKE MOVES THE
CALL.
MEMBERS JUST FOR A MOMENT UNDER
PRIVILEGES OF THE FLOOR US
SENATOR WHEN.
MISTER PRESIDENT I JUST WANNA
WELCOME AND.
WANT TO INTRODUCE MY MAYOR FOR
THE CITY OF ANAHEIM WHICH IS THE
HOME TO THE HAPPY A CITY AND THE
HAPPIEST DISTRICT DISNEYLAND.
MAYOR TOM TATE IS HERE TODAY.
TOM WELCOME TO THE SENATE.
THANK YOU.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY FIVE SENATOR GLAZER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. THE
NOVELS SEVEN FIFTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR GLASER AND ACTING TO
CRIMES. CENTER GLAZER THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS I SP
SEVEN FIVE SEVEN DOES TWO THINGS
REGARDING THIS SEXUAL
EXPLOITATION OF MINORS. ONE IT
WOULD REQUIRE PEOPLE CONVICTED
OF SOLICITING OR ENGAGING. IN
PROSTITUTION WITH A MINOR TO
PROVIDE. THE DNA SAMPLE FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT IDENTIFICATION
ANALYSIS.
AND THE SECOND THING I WOULD DO
WOULD BE THAT. WHEN THE NEW
TIERED REGISTRY TAKES EFFECT IN
TWO THOUSAND TWENTY ONE THIS
BILL WOULD ALSO REQUIRE THOSE
WHO ARE CONVICTED. TO REGISTER
AS A SEX OFFENDER FOR TEN YEARS
WHICH IS THE LOWEST. AMENDMENTS
TAKEN IN SENATE APPROPRIATIONS.
ALLOWS THOSE WHO ARE CONVICTED
TO AVOID REGISTERING AS A SEX
OFFENDER. IF THEY HAD REASON TO
BELIEVE THE VICTIM WAS NOT A
MINOR. WERE MISLED ABOUT THE
VICTIM'S AGE OR LESS THAN THREE
YEARS OLDER THAN THE VICTIM. AT
THE TIME OF THE SOLICITATION.
IN A STUDY CONDUCTED BY THE
OAKLAND SPECIAL VICTIMS UNIT.
IT WAS FOUND THAT EIGHTY FIVE
PERCENT OF THE UNSOLVED MURDERS
EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT OF THE
UNSOLVED MURDERS IN THE CITY.
INVOLVED A PROSTITUTE.
FURTHER IN OAKLAND AS WELL TWO
HUNDRED AND SIXTY MINERS WERE
RESCUED FROM PROSTITUTION IN TWO
THOUSAND FOURTEEN AND FIFTEEN
ALONE. TWO HUNDRED AND SIXTEEN
MINERS RESCUED FROM
PROSTITUTION.
AND THIS IS NOT A PARTICULAR
PROBLEM JUST IN OAKLAND. HOWEVER
OF ALL THE PEOPLE ARRESTED FOR
SOLICITING A PROSTITUTE IN
OAKLAND TWO THIRDS REPORT FROM
OUTSIDE THE AREA.
WITH NO MAJOR METRO AREA
UNTOUCHED BY HUMAN TRAFFICKING A
STATEWIDE RESPONSE IS REQUIRED
TO MAKE SURE WE ADDRESS THOSE
THAT PERPETUATE THE SYSTEM. OF
SEXUAL EXPLOITATION I
RESPECTFULLY ASK THE ARRIVAL OF.
THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZER MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE VICTORY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL. ALAN.
I ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES I BILL. HIGHBURY HILL.
BY BRADFORD I CAN TELL A.
IDEALLY OWN. IDOT.
I FULLER. I GAINS BY I GOT
JOHNNY. I GLAZER. I HERNANDEZ BY
HERZBERG.
HILL I WITH SOME. HIGH JACKSON.
ISLA.
LEVER. I'M ACQUIRE.
I MENDOZA. MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I AM MORE LOCK I'M REAL. BY
NEWMAN.
I WIN.
BY NELSON.
IBM. HARDWARE TO DO YOU KNOW.
ARE ROUGH. BY SKINNER.
I STERN. I STONE.
I BY BACK. KELSEY.
I WINNER.
I WILL.
I THINK THREE PLEASE CALL THAT
SOME MEMBERS ANDERSON. HIGH.
BURKE.
LOTTE.
I. MEAN DOESN'T.
THIRD PLACE REMOVES THE CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY SIX SENATOR WINNER.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ THE NOVEL
SEVEN SIXTY BY SENATOR WINNER
AND EQUITY TRANSPORTATION.
AND A REMINDER THAT GIVE US
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES IS STILL
REQUIRES CALTRANS TO CONSIDER
NATIONAL BEST PRACTICES IN
DEVELOPING COMPLETE STREETS
GUIDELINES. THE SET OF
GUIDELINES RECOMMENDED AN SP
SEVEN SIXTY WAS DEVELOPED BY
DOCTOR THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
OF CITY TRANSPORTATION
OFFICIALS.
WHICH IS A CONSORTIUM OF LOCAL
TRANSPORTATION.
AGENCIES FROM A DIVERSE SET OF
COMMUNITIES AROUND THE COUNTRY.
BY THE CONCEPT OF COMPLETE
STREETS INCLUDES PEOPLE WHO
DRIVE BUT ALSO PEOPLE WHO WERE
WALKING RIDING BIKES OR USING
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION.
NO CAL TRANS SPENDS BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS PER YEAR ON ROAD
MAINTENANCE AND REHABILITATION
OF THE AGENCY.
OFTEN DOES NOT TAKE THE
OPPORTUNITY.
TO ADD COMPLETE STREETS
FEATURES WHETHER BIKE LANES ARE
PEDESTRIAN FACILITIES OR TRANS
AND PREVENTS OUT WHEN THEY
REBUILT SAY HIGHWAYS THAT ALSO
RUN THROUGH COMMUNITIES AND A
NEW LOOK AND FEEL. LIKE CITY
STREETS EVEN THOUGH THE
TECHNICALLY STATE HIGHWAYS. A
FEW YEARS AGO CALTRANS ADOPTED A
DEPARTMENT POLICY TO PRIORITIZE
COMPLETE STREETS IN THEIR
PROJECTS. BUT IT HAS NOT YET
BEEN IMPLEMENTED. I WANT TO
STRESS THAT THIS BILL WILL NOT
AFFECT IN ANY WAY ANY ROAD
PROJECTS THAT OR WILL BE IN
DEVELOPMENT AS A RESULT OF SP
ONE. COLLEAGUES I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR A VOTE. THEY CONSIDER
WINNER MEMBERS ANY FURTHER
DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALAN. ANDERSON.
BY ADKINS BY BATES.
NO BELL.
HI BERRY HILL.
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
DAILY ON.
I DOT. FIVE FULLER. NO GAINS.
NO NO YEAH JOHNNY. BY GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ I HURTS FOR. HIGH
HEEL I WISH SO. BY JACKSON BY
LOTTE. I LABOR BY REQUIRE I MEAN
DOES A. MITCHELL.
BY MORNING. BY MORE LOCK.
MORALE.
NO.
NEWMAN. I WIN.
NELSON.
NO.
AND.
BY FOURTEEN NOW.
BY.
ROTH.
BY SKINNER.
BY STERN BY STONE.
NO BIDAK KNOW WHY CASKEY.
HI WINNER. I WILL.
I THINK THEY PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS. HILL.
BRADFORD. I CAN NEVER.
MENDOZA MORLOCK. BY.
WHEN.
BY.
I WAS THIRTEEN NO SEVEN MEASURE
PASSES.
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS.
FREE TO MOVE NOW TO FILE ITEM
FIFTY SEVEN.
SENATOR WAY SO. SECRETARY PLEASE
READ. SAID ABOUT SIX THIRTY FIVE
A SENATOR WITH SO AN ACTING TO
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT CENTER WAY
SO. THANK YOU THIS PRESIDENT
MEMBERS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SHOULD DO EVERYTHING IT CAN TO
PROVIDE. A QUALITY HOME. FOR
PEOPLE RAISE OUR FAMILIES
QUALITIES EDUCATION FOR
EVERYONE'S CHILDREN.
AND OF COURSE A LIVING WAGE JOBS
FOR. EVERYONE THE SIX TO WORK.
TODAY I'M PROUD TO PRESENT SP
SIX THIRTY FIVE WHICH WOULD.
TARGET THE EXISTING STATE
RESOURCES TO DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES WHICH HAVE BEEN
DECLARED PROMISED SOMEONE'S.
OFTENTIMES AND DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES ARE THOSE THAT.
POSSESS.
YOU KNOW THE THE. POOREST
PERFORMING SCHOOLS. THEY POSSESS
OF.
HOMES THAT ARE NOT. YOU KNOW UP
TO CODE OFTEN. THEY POSSESS OF
NEIGHBORHOODS THAT HAVE. UP.
LOCAL. LOW OF.
TAX TAX RATE IN OTHER WORDS THEY
HAVE A. WHAT YOU CALL OF NOT
NOT?
LOW WHAT HE CONTACTS OWNS THE
WHEN THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH
REVENUE SO TOO TO FIND THE
SERVICES THEY NEED.
BUT IN IN THESE AREAS. OF THE A
NEW PROGRAM WAS CREATED CALLED
PROMISE ZONES ENDEAVORS TO UP.
PROVIDE ALL THE SHORTFALLS ARE
FULL OF THEIR FOUND IN THESE.
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES
PROMISE ZONES ARE DEFINED AS
HIGH POVERTY COMMUNITIES AND
SELECT URBAN RURAL AND TRIBAL
COMMUNITIES. WHERE THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT PARTNER STRATEGICALLY
LOCAL LEADERS TO INCREASE
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY AND JOB
GROWTH?
IMPROVE EDUCATIONAL
OPPORTUNITIES AND ENHANCE THE
PUBLIC HEALTH OUTCOMES.
BECAUSE NORMALLY THESE AREAS
HAVE A LACK OF OF RESOURCES. TO
PROPERLY FUND THE SCHOOLS TO
PROPERLY FUND US SERVICES. OFTEN
THEY ARE FOUND UNABLE TO PROVIDE
THE MOST ESSENTIAL SERVICES TO
THE PEOPLE THAT NEED IT MOST.
THAT THENCEFORTH WE WE GET
CAUGHT IN IN AREAS THAT HAVE NOT
ONLY A HIGH POVERTY BUT HIGH
CRIME RATES AS RESULT.
SINCE THE PROMISE. ZONES
INITIATIVE INCEPTION IN TWENTY
FOURTEEN FOR CALIFORNIA
GEOGRAPHIC REGIONS HAVE BEEN
OFFICIALLY SELECTED. BY HUD AS
PROMISED SUMS AND SIXTEEN
ADDITIONAL COMMUNITIES HAVE
APPLIED THIS BILL WOULD EXTEND
US.
SPECIFIC STATE BENEFITS AND TAX
INCENTIVES TO ALL SIXTEEN OF
THOSE AREAS THAT EXTEND
STATEWIDE. LITTLE MAKE USE OF
EXISTING PROGRAMS.
BY AUTHORIZING STATE
DEPARTMENTS TO DEVELOP
APPROPRIATE PROGRAM GUIDELINES
TO ASSIST. AREAS OF THE STATE
WHICH I'VE ALREADY BEEN
IDENTIFIED AS NEEDING FOCUSED
ATTENTION. AMENDMENTS TAKEN
SENATE AT A SUNSET DATE TO THE
BILL THAT'S A SIGNIFICANT
FEDERAL.
THAT'S.
UP.
THAT WORKS WITH FEDERAL LAW
THAT'S CONSISTENT WITH FEDERAL
LAW. AND THAT.
.
THAT PREFERENTIAL CONSIDERATION
TO LOCAL ENTITIES THAT HAVE
APPLIED TO BE A PROMISE ON
PROGRAM.
WILL ALSO RECEIVE BENEFIT FROM
THIS THIS BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION
AND AND HAS RECEIVED BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT A POLICY COMMITTEE. FOR
THOSE RISKS REASONS ARE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SIR WEI SO CALL NOW
MOVING TO DEBATE DISCUSSION
CENTER MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT I
JUST WANT TO.
.
PRICE ON THE PRINCIPLE OF NO
BETTER NO WORSE.
TAX INCENTIVES TAX INCENTIVES
SHOULD BE ACROSS THE BOARD.
AND.
AFTER BEING HERE FOR THIS PARTY
TIME I SEE THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE
OF. BUSINESS AND ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT ALSO KNOWN AS KOBE
IS AS ALMOST A NECESSARY. IT IS
AVOIDED BY MANY BUSINESS OWNERS.
CONSEQUENTLY. I OPPOSE CREATING
ANOTHER POSITION AND THE TITLE
OF PROMISE OWN COORDINATOR. OUR
TOTAL RESPECT THE AUTHOR'S
INTENT. BEDS WHY WHY WHITE WHITE
WHITE WHITE WASH A HOAX
CALIFORNIA IS NOT BUSINESS
FRIENDLY AND GO VISIT AS WINDOW
DRESSING WE NEED TO FIX THIS
DEPARTMENT MISTER PRESIDENT.
LET'S GIVE ALL COMERS IN ALL
AREAS THE SAME SPORTING CHANCE I
RECOMMEND A NO VOTE ON SP SIX
THIRTY FIVE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MOORE LOCK US
CENTER FULLER.
MEMBERS THE REPUBLICAN DIGESTS
SHOWS THAT I VOTED NO ON THIS.
IN COMMITTEE. BUT I HAVE WORKED
WITH THE AUTHOR AND HE HAS DONE.
ABSOLVE MY CONCERNS BY THE
AMENDMENTS SUSPICIOUS SUNSET
DATE AND SOME BROADER
DEFINITIONS. OF THAT I THINK
MAKE THIS A MUCH BROADER BILL
AND I THANK YOU FOR THAT SO I'LL
BE VOTING YES TODAY.
ACCUSER FULLER MEMBERS ANY
FURTHER DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SENATOR ANDERSON.
SANDERS. HIGH IT'S NOT OFTEN
DONE THIS FLOOR.
I HEAR IT'S WORKING WITH THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ON AN ISSUE.
ONE OUT OF FIVE CALIFORNIANS
LIVES AT OR BELOW THE POVERTY
LINE.
WE HAVE THE GREATEST AMOUNT OF
POVERTY AND ALL OF THE UNITED
STATES AND I'M GLAD TO THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT IS PUTTING A
FOCUS ON CALIFORNIA TO HELP LIFT
PEOPLE OUT OF POVERTY. SO TO
REACHING OUT TO THEIR HAND IN
CLASS IN THEIR HAND WHEN THEY
OFFER AN OLIVE BANCH TO US IS A
SMART THING.
AND I ALSO. AGREE WITH MY
COLLEAGUE FROM ORANGE COUNTY.
WE SHOULD JUST BE FOCUSED ON
CERTAIN REGIONS WE SHOULD BE
FOCUSED ON ALL OF CALIFORNIA.
EVERYBODY IN CALIFORNIA DESERVES
THESE TAX BREAKS THEY DESERVE
ALL THESE BENEFITS.
BUT I'M GOING TO TAKE BABY STEPS
FIRST TABI SUPPORTING THE BILL
TODAY. BECAUSE I THINK THAT
ANYTIME THAT WE CAN ENCOURAGE
CALIFORNIA WORKING WITH THE
TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IT'S A GOOD
THING ARCH AN EYEBROW.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON OF
MEMBERS A FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE CENTER AWAY SO YOU
MAY CALL CLOSE.
THANK YOU AND AND I'M IT'S NOT
MY PLACE TO TELL OTHER PEOPLE
YOU KNOW WHAT TO STAND FOR WHAT
TO BELIEVE IN OR EVEN WHAT TO
SAY BUT. YOU KNOW I I WANTED I
DO WANT TO REMIND THEM THAT
CALIFORNIA IS THE LARGEST
ECONOMY. IN THE COUNTRY THAT IT
IS THE MOST PROPER US PER STATE.
AND WHEN IT COMES TO START UP
CAPITAL SEVENTY PERCENT OF ALL
THE SOCKS START UP CAPITAL IN
THE COUNTRY IS INVESTED IN
CALIFORNIA.
BUT CALIFORNIA HAS.
A LARGE SYSTEM. OF DISCREPANCY
OR DISPARITY. VERY LARGE
DISPARITY BETWEEN. YOU KNOW THE
RICHEST AND THE POOREST AND AND
WE HAVE SOME EXTREMELY
PROSPEROUS COMMUNITIES. AND AND
SOME THAT ARE NOT AND AND THIS
IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO
FOCUS. LIMITED RESOURCES ON
HELPING STRENGTHEN THOSE ARE
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND
PROVIDE. IN THEM JUST A FRACTION
OF JUST. SOME SOME OF WHICH
OTHER COMMUNITIES ARE.
ARE ARE VERY RICH AND. JUST UP
QUALITY HOUSING QUALITY JOBS
QUALITY EDUCATION.
THESE ARE THINGS THAT WE CAN
HELP PROVIDE INDECENT
DISADVANTAGE AREAS AND AND WHILE
THIS BUT I DON'T PURPORT TO SAY
THAT THIS BILL IS GOING TO SOLVE
EVERY PROBLEM. THIS BILL WILL
WILL WILL PROVIDE AN INJECTION
OF RESOURCES. IN THIS COMMUNITY
THAT ARE DESPERATELY NEEDED AND
OB I LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
WITH US THE WRISTS LEGISLATORS
HERE TO BRING UP. A BREAK FOR
STRATEGIES WILL HELP ACCOMPLISH
THAT THIS THIS BILL.
MAKES AN EFFORT TO WORK WITH
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. TO TO
BRING IN SOME OF THOSE FEDERAL
DOLLARS THAT ORIGINATE IN
CALIFORNIA THIS IS NOT. MONEY
THAT'S COMING FROM THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT IT COMES FROM
CALIFORNIA TO THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT WE'RE JUST ASKING TO
COME BACK TO OUR STATE. WHICH
GENERATED TO VESTED IN AREAS
THAT ARE DESPERATELY NEED OF
ATTENTION THANK YOU. GREAT THANK
THANK YOU SIR WAY SO. SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALAN.
ANDERSON. HIGH I ATKINS. FIVE
EIGHT.
FELL. ILL. I BRADFORD I CAN TELL
A.
DE LEON. I DIED. I FULLER. BUY
GAMES I GOT JOHNNY. I GLAZER. I
HERNANDEZ PIRATES WERE. I HILL
HIGHWAY SO.
I JACKSON. ISLA. BY LABOR.
I AM A CHOIR. SIMON DOESN'T
MITCHELL.
BY MORNING. ARE MORE LOCK.
NO MORALE.
NEWMAN.
FIVE WHEN.
NELSON.
AND. I PUT IT TO YOU KNOW. I
ROCKED. BY SKINNER. BY STERN. BY
STONE.
BUT ASK.
BY KATHY.
I WINNER. BY WILT. HIGH.
THERE WERE SOME MOVES THE CALL.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY EIGHT SENATOR LARA.
SECRETARY.
PLEASE READ. IN ABOUT ONE EIGHTY
THREE BY SENATOR LOTT A AN ACT
GOING TO STATE BUILDINGS.
THE REAL ARE.
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS.
COLLEAGUES ARE REPUBLICAN
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT CHIEF
JUSTICE CANTO CIRCLE HE RECENTLY
ASKED THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO
CEASE TALKING UNDOCUMENTED
CALIFORNIA RESIDENCY RECORDS.
AND SAID THAT THE PRESENCE OF
ICE AGENTS HAS A CHILLING EFFECT
ON DOCUMENTED AND UNDOCUMENTED
IMMIGRANTS ALIKE.
SP ONE EIGHTY THREE WILL
PROHIBIT IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS
ENFORCEMENT AGENTS OR ICE FROM
ENTERING STATE BUILDINGS. TO
PERFORM SURVEILLANCE EFFECTUATE
AN ARREST OR QUESTION THE VIGIL
UNLESS THEY POSSESS A VALID
FEDERAL WARRANT TO DO SO. FLOOR
AMENDMENTS CLARIFY THAT
ACTIVITIES BY AN AGENT IN
POSSESSION OF THE WARRANT ARE
LIMITED TO THE INDIVIDUAL IS
SUBJECT OF SUCH WARRANT. CHANGES
TO OUR IMMIGRATION POLICIES AND
ENFORCEMENT AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL
HAVE MADE IT IMPERATIVE TO
PROTECT OUR STUDENTS AND WORKERS
FROM INTIMIDATION. OR REDUCE
ACCESS TO RESOURCES AND
ACTIVITIES OF DAILY LIFE THEY
HAVE BEEN THERE HAVE BEEN A
NUMBER OF INSTANCES. OF PEOPLE
BEING ARRESTED BY ICE AGENTS AT
COURTHOUSES AND ACROSS THE
NATION.
HARD WORKING IMMIGRANTS WHO ARE
DROPPING THEIR KIDS OFF AT
SCHOOL WERE SERVING AS WITNESSES
ARE EVEN PAYING FINES AT THE
COURTHOUSE SHOULD NOT BE
TARGETED FOR UNLAWFUL ARREST. BY
ICE THE BILL WILL PROTECT THE
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN IMMIGRANTS
NON IMMIGRANTS AND LAW
ENFORCEMENT. IT CONTINUES TO
FOSTER A SAFE ENVIRONMENT WHERE
PEOPLE CAN CONDUCT BUSINESS AT
VARIOUS ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES
AND REPORT FOR COURT DATES.
PARENTS CAN PICK UP THE CHILDREN
FROM SCHOOL AND STUDENTS CAN
ATTEND CLASSES WITHOUT FEAR OF
BEING TARGETED BY FEDERAL AGENTS
BASED ON THEIR IMMIGRATION
STATUS I STRICTLY ASKED FOR A
VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR LAURA
SENATOR ANDERSON.
MEMBER SORRY.
AND SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT SAFETY
I WAS CONCERNED THAT WE HAVE
STATE EMPLOYEES THAT POTENTIALLY
WOULD BE VIOLATING FEDERAL LAW.
I'M WORRIED THAT THE
INFLAMMATION THIS IMPLEMENTATION
OF THIS BILL. IS PROBLEMATIC.
AND IF WE WERE TO ASK OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT OUR COURT BAILIFFS
INTERVENE. INSIDE. THE FEDS FOR
VIOLATING IT.
I'M NOT SURE THAT THAT WOULD
HOLD UP.
BUT THEY IN TURN. COULD BE
ARRESTED FOR INTERFERING WITH
FEDERAL OFFICER. I THINK THAT
THIS BILL WHILE WELL INTENDED
NEEDS MORE VETTING. BECAUSE I
THINK IT'S A TERRIBLE SITUATION
TO HAVE OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT THE
PEOPLE THAT PROTECT US.
IN JEOPARDY WITH THE FEDERAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT. AGENCIES SO AT THIS
TIME ORIGINAL VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ENTERS CENTER
ANDERSON MEMBERS ANY FURTHER
DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE A CENTER LAR WHICH
LIKE THE CLOSE THANK YOU BY
MEMBERS AGAIN THIS BILL MAKE
SURE THAT ICE AGENTS ARE
PRESENTING WARRANTS TO
INDIVIDUALS. BEFORE MAKING AN
ARREST THIS IS DONE TO MAKE SURE
THAT THE INDIVIDUAL SUBJECT OF
THE ARREST KNOWS THAT THEY
SHOULD BE ASKING FOR A WARRANT.
FROM THESE AGENTS THIS BOOK DOES
I. THIS BILL ISN'T REQUIRING
ANYONE TO INTERFERE WITH THE
FEDERAL AGENT TRYING TO MAKE AN
ARREST RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A
VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR LAURA
SIX KATE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALAN.
ANDERSON.
NO NO ATKINS. I BATES.
BELL.
I FEEL.
BRADFORD. I CAN EITHER. IDEALLY
OWNED. BY DOT. I. FULLER. NO
GAINS. NO GOD JOHNNY.
I GLAZER. I HERNANDEZ I HURTS
BERG. I HILL I WAS SO.
I JACKSON.
I LOTTA. BY LABOR. I'M ACQUIRE
TIME AND DOESN'T. MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
MORE LOCK. NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I WIN.
NELSON.
PAN. HYPER TO DO NOW.
BY ROB.
I SKINNER. BY STERN.
I STONE. NO FIGHT BACK.
I LIKE HEALTHY BY WINNER.
I WILL.
LAURA MOVES THE CALL NUMBERS
WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE ITEM FIFTY
NINE.
SENATOR MORLOCK.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL SIX EIGHTY EIGHT PERCENT OR
MORE LOCK AND ACTING TO MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES. CENTER MAROC
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
SENATE BILL SIX EIGHTY EIGHT IS
MINISTERIAL IN NATURE AND
IMPROVED REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
FOR A CRITICAL REVENUE SOURCE.
THE MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES ACT
IMPLEMENTED UNDER PROPOSITION
SIXTY THREE IN. THE YEAR TWO
THOUSAND FOUR. IT PROVIDES TWO
COMPONENTS FOLLOW GENERALLY
ACCEPTED ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES
AND POST THE REPORT ON THE
COUNTY'S WEBSITE. IN A TIMELY
MANNER JUST LIKE. THEY DO WITH
THEIR ANNUAL KAFIRS. SP SIX
EIGHTY EIGHT IS SUPPORTED BY THE
COUNTY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA. IN SB SIX EIGHTY SIX
EIGHTY EIGHT HAS RECEIVED NO
OPPOSITION AND I ENCOURAGE AND
I'VE A.
GREAT THANK YOU CENTER MORLOCK
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALAN. I I I ANDERSON. ATKINS. BY
BATES. I BILL. I BERRYHILL. FIVE
BRADFORD. I CAN TELL A. HIGH
DAILY ON.
I DOT.
I FULLER.
I GAMES. I GOT JOHNNY.
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
I HEARD SPURRED. BY HILL HIGHWAY
SO.
I JACKSON. BY LOTTE.
AND. BY LABOR.
I AM A CHOIR. MY MENDOZA
ITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I AM MORE LOCKED BY MERRELL.
I KNEW WHEN. I WIN.
NELSON.
PAN.
I PATINO. I ROCK.
I SKINNER BY STERN. BY STONE.
FIVE I'D ACT.
I WORK OUT SEE. BY WINNER. I
WILL.
OKAY THERE WERE LOCKED MOVES THE
CALL MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO
FILE ITEM SIXTY.
PRO TEM DAILY OWN.
LIKE TO BRING THIS MEASURE
FORWARD SECRETARY PLEASE READ
CINEMA FOR SIXTY BY SENATOR
DAILY OWNED AND EXPLAIN TO THE
INTERNET.
YOU'RE MUCH OF THIS PRESENT OUR
COLLEAGUES THAT IN TODAY'S WORLD
OPEN ACCESS TO THE INTERNET IS
CRITICAL TO FREE EXPRESSION FREE
SPEECH AS WELL AS DEMOCRACY.
AMERICANS OF EVERY INCOME LEVEL
OF POLITICAL PROS THAT BRIEF
CLICK PERSUASION DEPEND ON THE
INTERNET. THAT'S WHY THE FEDERAL
COMMUNICATION COMMISSION THE
FCC'S PARTISAN DECISION LAST
MONTH TO REPEAL NET NEUTRALITY
RULES. IS SO DANGEROUS THE FCC'S
ACTION DIRECTLY CONTRADICTS THE
WILL OF THE VAST MAJORITY OF
AMERICANS. GIVES INTERNET
SERVICE PROVIDERS UNFETTERED
POWER TO SABOTAGE THE
COMPETITION BY POTENTIALLY
THROTTLING THE INTERNET SPEEDS
FOR COMPETING CONTACT. THE FCC
ACTION LETS COMPANIES PAY FOR
PRIOR TO THE GAME AND UNFAIR
ADVANTAGE IN THE RACE FOR TIME
TENSION. AS WELL AS OUR BUSINESS
THAT'S WHY THIS MEASURE IT IS SO
IMPORTANT AS WELL AS OTHER
MEASURES IN THE FUTURE BECOMING
FROM THIS HOUSE. SP FOUR SIXTY
PREVENTS EYES PEAS FROM USING
DECEPTIVE DISCRIMINATORY OR ANTI
COMPETITIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES
RELATED SPECIFICALLY TO THE
INTERNET. SERVES THE HEART OF
THE FCC'S NET NEUTRALITY RULES
OF FOR HIS ISPS FROM BLOCKING
CRAWLING. OR PAID FOR PRIVATIZED
PRIVATIZATION. BECAUSE CONSUMERS
GREATER TRANSPARENCY ABOUT THE
SERVICES WE ALL DEPEND ON AN
EVERYDAY LIFE BELL LET ME BE
VERY CLEAR FOR SIXTY DOESN'T
CREATE ANY NEW RATHER TOWARD
DEMOCRACY. INSTEAD OF SIMPLY
MAKES NET NEUTRALITY VIOLATIONS
SUBJECT TO A FORSMAN UNDER THE
CONSUMER PROTECTION AND UNFAIR
BUSINESS PRACTICE LOSS. IT ALSO
PROHIBITS STATE AGENCIES FROM
CONTRACTING WITH EYES PEAS
UNLESS THEY'RE SPEED. CAN
CERTIFY UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY
THAT THEIR BODY BY NET
NEUTRALITY RULES WITHOUT SP FOUR
SIXTY THERE'S NOTHING TO STOP
THE COMPANIES THAT ALREADY
MONOPOLIZE INTERNET FROM
BLOCKING WEBSITE OR PERMISSION
ALL TOGETHER. LET ME BE VERY
CLEAR SP FOR SUCCESS FOR SIXTY
AND NOT A TROLLEY ON IS NOT A
RED STATE OR BLUE STATE IDEA.
STATES LIKE MONTANA BOTH
DEMOCRATS AS WELL AS
REPUBLICANS.
NET NEUTRALITY IS FUNDAMENTALLY
AN ISSUE OF FREE SPEECH AND FREE
EXPRESSION.
IT'S ABOUT WHO HAS ACCESS TO
WHICH IDEAS WHO GETS ASIDE WHICH
INFORMATION YOU SEE HOW FASTER
INTERNET WORKS SO I THINK WE CAN
ALL AGREE. THAT NO COMPANY
SHOULD GET TO DECIDE HOW YOU USE
INTERNET.
NEWCOMERS SHOULD HAVE THE POWER
TO SLOW DOWN YOUR CONNECTION NO
COMPANY SHOULD BE ABLE TO HOLD
YOUR IDEAS HOSTAGE OR DEMAND. A
RANSOM TO ACCESS YOUR FAVORITE
STREAMING SERVICE FOR WEBSITE.
S. BEFORE SIXTEENTH OF CLEAR
REASONABLE STANDARDS FOR
INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDERS. AND
OFFERS MRS ARE PROTECTION FOR
BOTH ONLINE BUSINESSES AND
CONSUMERS
WE ALSO WILL HAVE UP FURTHER
LEGISLATION.
COMING FROM THIS BODY OF FROM
OUR A CENTER FROM SAN FRANCISCO
OF WHO FROM THE VERY BEGINNING
WAS ON THIS ISSUE A WITHOUT
OBVIOUS PRESIDENT OR CERTAINLY
ASK FOR A BI PARTISAN AYE VOTE.
GREAT THANK YOU PRO TEM THE
DAILY OWN NOW UNDER DEBATE AND
DISCUSSION SENATOR STONE THIS IN
THAT YOU AYE MISTER PRESIDENT I
RESPECTFULLY RISE IN OPPOSITION
TO SP FOUR SIXTY IS ONE THAT OF
REALLY BELIEVES WE SHOULD HAVE
AN OPEN AND FREE INTERNET.
WITHOUT MUCH GOVERNMENTAL
INTERFERENCE.
THE RESTORING THE INTERNET
FREEDOM ORDER ARE RESTORED LIGHT
TOUCH REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
CONSISTENT WITH THE
TELECOMMUNICATIONS ACT OF
NINETEEN NINETY SIX.
RECENT MIS CHARACTERIZATIONS
FOR POLITICAL GAIN OF THE ORDER
DOES NOT AND THE OPEN INTERNET.
AND WILL NOT UNDERMINE NET
NEUTRALITY AS IS ALLEGED.
THIS IS INCONSISTENT WITH THE
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK WHICH
GOVERNS INTERNET SERVICE
PROVIDERS.
NOW I KNOW WE HAVE A LOT OF
ATTORNEYS THAT ARE ON THE FLOOR
HERE TODAY AND I KNOW THAT A LOT
OF THE ATTORNEYS THAT ARE HERE
TODAY GRADUATED FROM VERY GOOD
LAW SCHOOLS.
AND I KNOW THAT MOST OF YOUR
THINKING IN YOUR HEAD THAT HIS
IS A PREEMPTION BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
BUT I UNDERSTAND THAT THERE IS
SOME POLITICAL PRESSURE THAT YOU
MAY WANT TO.
SUPPORT THIS BILL TODAY BUT THE
BOTTOM LINE FROM A NON LEGAL
EXPERTS IS THAT THIS IS A
FEDERALLY. PREEMPTED AND THIS IS
GOING TO I BELIEVE CAUSE HARM TO
THE CUSTOMER'S EXPERIENCE MAY
LEAD TO COSTLY. AND ZERO
BENEFITS
FOR BROADBAND CUSTOMERS
CERTAINLY IS GOING TO DECREASE
INVESTMENT.
FOR INTERNET DEVELOPMENT IN
BROADBAND CUSTOMERS AND ACTUALLY
STIFLE.
OR DELAY INVESTMENT FOR INTERNET
DEVELOPMENT INNOVATIONS WE SEEK
TO HAVE A FIVE G. NETWORK HERE.
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WHICH
LIKES TO LEAD THE NATION AND AND
TECHNOLOGY.
THIS BILL IS NOTHING MORE.
THEN A POLITICAL VEHICLE TO
SENSATIONALIZE A PRESIDENTIAL
ORDER OF THE WILL DO NOTHING BUT
CONFUSE CONSUMERS. POTENTIALLY
INCREASE IN THE COST OF
INTERNET.
SUBSCRIPTIONS AND STIFLE
INVESTMENT IN BROADBAND DELIVERY
WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT WE NEED
MORE OF. LET'S KEEP THE POLITICS
ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL. OFF THE
SENATE FLOOR AND NOT PANDERING
HERE.
AND LET'S STAND TOGETHER.
AND ENSURE THAT WE DON'T.
ENACT LAWS HAS JUST BEEN
ENCOURAGE LAWSUITS DECREASE
INVESTMENTS ABROAD BRAND AND
INCREASED COSTS FOR OUR
CONSUMERS.
AGAIN PREEMPTION BY FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT FOR THOSE REASONS YOU
SHOULD OPPOSE SB FOUR SIXTY.
THANK YOU SENATOR STONE CENTER
WIENER.
I THINK YOU MISTER PRESIDENTE
COLLEAGUES I RISE IN SUPPORT OF
SB FOUR SIXTY AND IN SUPPORT. OF
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA OF
ENSURING THAT WE HAVE NET
NEUTRALITY IN A FREE AND OPEN
INTERNET.
IN THIS STATE ODD THIS IS A
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT ISSUE. IV
INTERNET.
ACCESS TO THE INTERNET IN TWO
THOUSAND A TEAM IS AT THE HEART.
OF SO MUCH THAT HAPPENS IN THIS
COUNTRY IT IS AT THE HEART OF
OUR DEMOCRACY.
I IS AT THE HEART OF HELL
BUSINESS IS TRANSACTED IN THIS
COUNTRY WHETHER YOU ARE ONE OF
THE WALMARTS AND TARGETS OF THE
WORLD OR WHETHER YOU ARE A MOM
AND POP BRICK AND MORTAR
RETAILERS STRUGGLING AS NINETY
BRICK AND MORTAR RETAILERS
STRUGGLE THESE DAYS. AND MAKING
ENDS MEET BY SELLING ONLINE.
IT IS ESSENTIAL OFF FOR OUR
START UP INNOVATORS THE NEXT
WAVE OF COMPANIES THAT MAY AT
SOME POINT BECOME A GROUP OR AND
I'M IS ON BETTER SMALL RIGHT
NOW.
AND ARE ABLE TO SURVIVE ONLY
BECAUSE THEY HAVE GOT ACCESS TO
THE INTERNET.
BY AND. IT'S TO ALLOW A COMPANY
AN INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER THE
PREROGATIVE TO DECIDE ON THEIR
OWN IF THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE A
FAST LANE. AND THE SLOW LANE IF
THEY'RE GOING TO THROTTLE THE
WEBSITE WERE SPEED UP OR SLOW
DOWN A WEBSITE DEPENDING ON WHO
PAYS MONEY.
THAT HIGHS NOT ACCEPTABLE.
PEOPLE SHOULD BE ABLE TO DECIDE
FOR THEMSELVES.
WHAT WEBSITE SAY ACCESS?
AND NOT HAVE DIED DECISION MADE
FOR THEM BY A BROAD BAND OF
PROVIDER DEPENDING ON WHO PAYS
MORE OR LESS MONEY.
AND SO IDEALLY AND I THINK WE'RE
ALL IN AGREEMENT HERE
REPUBLICANS DEMOCRATS EVERYONE
AYE DELETES THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT WOULD DO ITS JOB AND
PROTECT CONSUMERS. AND ADOPT NET
NEUTRALITY FOR FREE AND OPEN
INTERNET.
UNFORTUNATELY OUR FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
AND SPECIFICALLY THE FCC. HAS
ABDICATED ITS RESPONSIBILITY TO
PROTECT THE INTERNET. AND SO WE
NOW OR FORCED TO STEP IN AND I
UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE SOME
WHO DON'T WANT TO SEE A STATE BY
STATE APPROACH. WHILE THE
SOLUTION TO THAT IS FOR THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO STEP UP.
AND REVERSE THE REPEAL ANOTHER
CHILD TO ADOPT NET NEUTRALITY AS
A UNIFORM FEDERAL STANDARD BOB
BUT UNTIL THAT HAPPENS WE MUST
ACT. BY AND SO I WANT TO THANK
THE PRO TEM FOR HIS
COLLABORATION WITH ME IN MY
OFFICE WE HAVE A SEPARATE BILL
SP A TWENTY TWO WE'RE GONNA
CONTINUE TO WORK AND COLLABORATE
TOGETHER. TO PROTECT A FREE AND
OPEN INTERNET IN CALIFORNIA AND
TO PROTECT CONSUMERS AND
BUSINESSES I REQUEST AN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER CENTER
MORALE S..
MR PRESIDENT THANK YOU AND
MEMBERS.
INTO THIS BILL I AM CONCERNED
LIKE A NUMBER BILLS I'VE SEEN
OUR.
THAT HAVE COME.
THROUGH THE SENATE WHERE IT SAYS
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES DOWN THE
LINES THAT CONCERNS ME. YOU KNOW
I HAVE MY STAFF LOOK UP TODAY.
HOW MANY CALLS IN THE DISTRICT?
AS WELL AS UP HERE AT THE
CAPITOL THAT WE'VE GOTTEN ON
THIS BILL PRIOR TO THIS BECOMING
A BILL SO THERE'S NO NEED AYE
AND THE ELITES THAT MY DISTRICT
NOT ONE CALL OVER THE PAST YEAR.
NOW SENSE THIS BILLS COME UP
WE'VE HAD A HANDFUL OF FORM
LETTERS IT WAS THE SAME LETTER
COME THROUGH SO. IT'S CERTAINLY
NOT A BILL THAT THE PEOPLE ARE
ASKING FOR. ON AND SO FOR THAT
REASON I THINK IT'S A.
NOT PRUDENCE BECAUSE OF SENATE
BECAUSE A LOT OF CHALLENGES WITH
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AS WELL AS
THE OTHER FORTY NINE STATES.
AND AGAIN THAT SAYING I THINK IT
IT GOES ISN'T SO SOLUTION
LOOKING FOR A PROBLEM SO. ON
ALBEIT NO VOTE THANK YOU FOR
LISTENING EARLY SOME AVIA FOR
LISTENING MAKE IT.
THANK YOU SENATOR MORALE SENATOR
OFF.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES YOU KNOW NET
NEUTRALITY.
LIKE.
SOME OF YOU I DID NOT HAVE THE
LUXURY OF HEARING THIS MEASURE
IN THE TWO COMMITTEES.
BUT HEARD OVER THE PAST.
COUPLE WEEKS OR SO.
SO I SPENT THE WEEKEND TRYING TO
GET UP TO SPEED AND WITH THIS
EMERGENCY BILL.
ON WHAT CAN CERTAINLY BE MADE
INTO A VERY COMPLICATED ISSUE
TERMS LIKE I. S. P.'S BLOCKING
THROTTLING.
PAID FOR PRIORITIZING AND THE
LIKE.
AND AS I READ AND CONTINUED TO
READ THE ARTICLES AND.
SCHOLARLY MATERIAL ON THIS. NET
NEUTRALITY ISSUE.
I THOUGHT WILL WHO DOESN'T
SUPPORT A FULLY OPEN INTERNET
WITH.
PROTECTIONS YOU KNOW I CERTAINLY
DO.
FRANKLY IT'S ESSENTIAL TO OUR
ECONOMY AND BECOMING EVER MORE
SO EACH AND EVERY DAY THAT WE
SIT HERE AND THERE WE SIT IN OUR
DISTRICTS.
BUT WHAT MY REVIEW REFLECTED.
IT CAUSED ME SOME CONCERN ABOUT
THIS BILL.
WHAT I LEARNED IS THAT FOR ABOUT
TWENTY YEARS BETWEEN NINETEEN
NINETY SIX IN TWO THOUSAND AND
FIFTEEN THE FEDERAL TRADE
COMMISSION?
REGULATED THESE INFORMATION
SYSTEMS AND IN FACT INSURED. AN
OPEN INTERNET WITH PROTECTIONS.
AND FOR ABOUT TWO YEARS FROM TWO
THOUSAND FIFTEEN SIXTEEN AND
SEVENTEEN.
THE FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMISSION STEPPED IN AND ADDED
SOME REGULATIONS TO THE MIX NOW
THOSE REGULATIONS HAVE GONE
AWAY.
BUT THAT AT NO TIME.
DURING THIS TWENTY YEAR TWENTY
TWO YEAR PERIOD.
WAS THERE ANY INCIDENTS
CERTAINLY ANY SIGNIFICANT ANSWER
AND INVOLVING BLOCKING OR
THROTTLING HER PAY FOR
PRIORITIZATION OR ANY OF THE
THINGS THAT WE.
SEEM TO BE FEARING.
TODAY NOW OF THE. FCC
REGULATIONS ARE GONE HOPEFULLY
TEMPORARILY FOR THOSE WHO.
I BELIEVE THAT THEY SHOULD BE
CONTROLLED IN THAT FASHION BUT
THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
LAST TIME I CHECKED.
IS STILL IN BUSINESS.
AND IT STILL IN BUSINESS TO.
IN FORCING CURB UNFAIR TRADE
PRACTICES ANTI COMPETITIVE
ACTIVITY ALL OF THE THINGS.
THEY WERE TALKING ABOUT.
WELL WITH REGARD.
TO THIS LEGISLATION JUST AS IT
HAS DONE SO. FOR WELL OVER
TWENTY YEARS PLUS IN THIS FIELD
AND LONGER.
IN OTHERS AND SO IF THE FEDERAL
TRADE COMMISSION IS NOT UP TO
THE.
TASK.
THEN I'LL BE THE FIRST PROPOSE A
FIX.
SO HAVING SAID ALL THAT WHY THIS
BILL.
WHY CREATE A NEW SERIES?
OF LAWSUITS TO BE HEARD ON A
FEDERAL ISSUE.
IN ARE OVERCROWDED TRIAL COURTS.
WHY AUTHORIZED OR FIFTY EIGHT
COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S?
AND OUR FOUR HUNDRED PLUS CITY
ATTORNEYS.
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO
FILE INDIVIDUALIZED ACTIONS.
IN LOCAL SUPERIOR COURTS.
TO SET POTENTIALLY CONFLICTING
POLICIES
ON WHAT WE THINK IS A VERY
IMPORTANT ISSUE UP AND DOWN THIS
STATE.
TO BE RESOLVED BY WHO.
AND WHY TOSS THIS VERY VERY
COMPLICATED. LEGAL ISSUE. TO A
STATE COURT SYSTEM THAT IS UNDER
FUNDED BY WELL OVER. ONE HALF OF
A BILLION DOLLARS.
BUT SYSTEM THAT IS NOT ADDED A
TRIAL COURT JUDGE IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. SINCE TWO
THOUSAND AND SIX AS YOU'VE HEARD
ME SPEAK OF BEFORE.
AND A SYSTEM THAT IS CURRENTLY
SHORT HUNDREDS OF JUDGES.
UP AND DOWN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
SO.
I'M NOT PREPARED TO DO SO TODAY.
NO I WILL FIGHT FOR AN OPEN
INTERNET AND I WILL FIGHT FOR AN
OPEN OPEN INTERNET. WITH
PROTECTIONS.
AND IF THERE TURNS OUT TO BE A
PROBLEM WITH THE FEDERAL TRADE
COMMISSION'S ENFORCEMENT ACTION.
AND IF IN FACT THERE'S A PROBLEM
IN THE FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMISSION DOES A STEP UP TO THE
PLATE. THEN I'LL BE THE FIRST
ONE TO STAND ON THIS FLOOR AND
ADVOCATE FOR ACTION BUT I
CANNOT.
THROW A VERY COMPLICATED ISSUE
TO OUR CALIFORNIA STATE COURTS
UNDER FUNDED UNDERMANNED.
AND ILL EQUIPPED TO DEAL WITH
IT.
JUST BECAUSE WILL LET THE COURTS
SORTED OUT SO UNFORTUNATELY.
I AM FORCED TO CASTING A VOTE ON
THIS BILL TODAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR ROTH SENATOR
JACKSON'S.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES I WISH THAT MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE FROM RIVERSIDE WORK. A
A MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE THAT.
WENT THROUGH THIS BILL A TWENTY
TWO PAGE ANALYSIS.
I THINK HE'S MADE A GREAT CASE
FOR WHY WE NEED MORE JUDGES.
A BUT A. NOT QUITE THE CASE ON
THE ISSUE AND IN PART BECAUSE IT
IS COMPLICATED IN. TWENTY TWO
PAGES IS ONE OF THE LONGER
ANALYSES WE'VE HAD IN THE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE IN QUITE
SOME TIME SO. I CONCEDE THAT IT
IS A YEAR A SOMEWHAT COMPLICATED
ISSUE IT'S BEEN REDUCED TO OF
THROWING POLITICAL STONE'S BY.
OF SOME OF MY GOOD COLLEAGUES ON
THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE BUT.
WE ARE NOT HERE TO THROW
POLITICAL STONE'S WE ARE HERE TO
PROTECT
CALIFORNIA'S.
VALUES AND THAT IS WHAT THIS
MEASURE ATTEMPTS TO DO NET
NEUTRALITY IS VITAL TO
MAINTAINING. THE OPEN NATURE OF
THE INTERNET.
AND TO DRIVE INNOVATION.
AND.
WHILE FOR THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS
OF THE INTERNET HAS WORKED AND
FUNCTIONED IN AN OPEN WAY AND
WE'RE ALL VERY PLEASED TO KNOW
THAT. BUT THERE HAVE BEEN CASES.
.
THAT.
HAVE EXISTED THERE ARE ACTUALLY
LOCATED AND IDENTIFIED ON PAGES
TWO OF THREE AND THREE OF THE
TWENTY TWO PAGE ANALYSIS THAT.
OF THE COMMITTEE.
THAT WENT THROUGH IN
CONSIDERING THIS BILL WHEN IT
WAS HEARD BEFORE US LAST WEEK.
ARE THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF
CASES A NUMBER OF INSTANCES
WHERE WE HAVE HAD THE COURTS
HAVE HAD TO TAKE STEPS.
TO A CHANGE BEHAVIOR THAT WAS
ATTEMPTING TO PRIORITIZE AND TO
CREATE A LESS THAN DEMOCRATIC
INTERNET.
WERE DIFFERENT COMPANIES NOW
RECOGNIZING AND AND AGAIN AS WE
BECOME MORE SOPHISTICATED
REALIZING HOW THEY COULD
MONETIZE
THIS INSTRUMENT OF DEMOCRACY IN
A WAY THAT WOULD IMPEDE ITS
ACCESS BY ALL. PEOPLE IN THIS
COUNTRY.
AND SO. IT WAS THE OBAMA
ADMINISTRATION NO THAT'S A A
KIND OF A DIRTY WORD BY SOME OF
MY COLLEAGUES ON THE OTHER SIDE
THE AISLE BUT TOOK SIX YEARS.
TO STUDY AND DEVELOP THE RULES
THAT WERE PUT INTO PLACE IN
TWENTY FIFTEEN THAT THIS
ADMINISTRATION COMMITTED TO
UNDER OVERTURNING AND
UNDERMINING EVERY EFFORT THAT
WAS MADE DURING THE OBAMA ERA.
WITHOUT ANY CONSIDERATION WITH
TROOP.
AFTER SIX YEARS OF HARD WORK TO
TRY TO PROTECT.
INTERNET NEUTRALITY NOW.
WE KNOW IT IS FUNDAMENTALLY
ABOUT DEMOCRACY END AND I
APPRECIATE THAT.
MY GOOD COLLEAGUE FROM TEMECULA
ACKNOWLEDGES THAT HE'S NOT A
LEGAL EXPERT.
AND I WOULD SUGGEST I
ACKNOWLEDGE I AM NOT AN
APOTHECARY AND SO I DON'T TRY
TO.
DISSECT VARIOUS FORMULARIES
THAT ARE USED AYE IN THAT WORLD
UP BUT I WILL TELL YOU THAT THE
ARGUMENT ABOUT FEDERAL
PREEMPTION. THAT WILL BE AND IN
FACT HAS BEEN RAISED BY NO FEWER
THAN TWENTY ONE STATES.
TWENTY ONE OTHER STATES ARE
CHALLENGING WHAT THE STE FTC HAS
DONE.
AND SOME OF THEM AS OUR PRO TEM
MENTIONED ARE NOT STATES THAT
CAME OUT IN THE BLUE COLUMN IN
THE LAST ELECTION.
FACT I BELIEVE THERE ARE THREE
STATES
OF THAT NUMBER THAT ARE RED
STATES
BECAUSE THIS IS ABOUT THE MARK
PRISSY THIS IS ABOUT OPEN ACCESS
THIS IS ABOUT THE FACT THAT THE
FTC. IN THE OPINIONS OF TWENTY
ONE OTHER STATES.
HAS EITHER NOT DONE ITS JOB OR
HAS SUCCEEDED ITS BOUNDARIES
AND THE LAWSUITS THAT WILL BE
EMANATING. AND I WISH WE DIDN'T
HAVE TO GO THERE BUT IF WE
CANNOT GET THE FEDERAL
ADMINISTRATION TO PROTECT A VERY
VERY IMPORTANT DEMOCRATIC THE
INSTITUTION WHICH THE INTERNET
ACTUALLY HAS BECOME. THEN THERE
WILL BE LAWSUITS
BUT. VERA PREVENT OF FEDERAL
PROOF PREEMPTION I THINK YOU ARE
IS IS ARGUABLE. OR MISPLACED AT
THE LEAST.
SO WHAT BASICALLY WE HAVE HERE
IS AN ARGUMENT THAT THE FTC BY
DOING WHAT IT IS DONE HAS
SUCCEEDED ITS AUTHORITY. THAT'S
NOT A FEDERAL PREEMPTION ISSUE.
AND THAT'S THE ISSUE THE TWENTY
ONE OTHER STATES WANT TO BRING
FORWARD. AS WE ATTEMPT TO
MAINTAIN AN OPEN INTERNET SO
THAT YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE RICHER
IN ORDER TO ACCESS IT SO WE
DON'T HAVE SENSORS DECIDING WHAT
WE CAN. AND CANNOT HEAR.
SO I RESPECTFULLY SUGGEST.
DAD WE PERMIT THIS MEASURE TO
MOVE FORWARD OF WE.
HAD A FULL IN ROBUST DISCUSSION
ABOUT IT IN THE SENATE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE.
IT IS.
THE EXPECTATION AND COMMITMENTS
MADE BY THE AUTHOR AND THOSE IN
THIS BUILDING WHO ACTUALLY KNOW
WHAT NET NEUTRALITY IS AND I
WOULD LIKE TO SUGGEST. A TO MY
COLLEAGUE DATA WE HAVE RECEIVED
HUNDREDS OF CALLS ON THIS ISSUE
PERHAPS EVEN MORE THAN THAT FROM
PEOPLE WHO WANTS TO UNDERSTAND
WHAT IS GOING ON HERE RECOGNIZE
AND FEAR WHAT THIS WILL DO TO
DEMOCRACY. SO WITH THAT I WOULD
URGE AN AYE VOTE ON THIS MEASURE
I ALWAYS APPRECIATE TO A
POLITICAL TALKING POINTS BUT IN
THIS CASE. THIS IS A MEASURE
THAT WE MUST CONSIDER WE MUST
MOVE ALONG WITH TWENTY ONE OTHER
STATES TO MAINTAIN THE INTEGRITY
OF OUR DEMOCRACY AND OUR
INTERNET ACCESS.
THANK YOU SENATOR JACKSON CENTER
BATES THEM FOLLOWED BY SENATOR
STERN.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENTE IVAN
THERE BEEN THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF
DISCUSSION PRO AND CON ON THE
VALUE OF THIS BILL ON IN TERMS
OF. THE SURVIVAL AND THE
EXPANSION OF THE INTERNET I
THINK YOU KNOW I'M I'M LEANING
ON. OPPOSITION BUT IN PARTICULAR
IT SEEMS TO HAVE SKIPPED A STEP
AS WE SEE IT TODAY AFTER IT LEFT
AND I SPEAK AS VICE CHAIR OF THE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. AFTER
THE BILL LEFT THE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS WERE ADDED
RELATED TO INCLUDING NET
NEUTRALITY PROVISION IN
CONTRACTS WHICH COULD ALSO LIMIT
THE NUMBER OF BUSINESSES VYING
FOR CERTAIN STATE CONTRACTS
ULTIMATELY LIMITING COMPETITION.
AND PUSHING UP PRICES THAT'S A
SIGNIFICANT FISCAL IMPACT THAT I
BELIEVE ARE THE EXPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE SHOULD HAVE CONSIDERED
THE IMPACT OF THOSE AMENDMENTS
AND SHOULD HAVE HEARD THIS BILL.
PA AND IN ITS IMPACT THE
DEPARTMENTS AND AGENCIES THAT
AND NOW WILL AFFECT. BY IT IS
MOVING ON I'M ASSUMING THEY'RE
PROBABLY VOTES HERE TO MOVE THAT
ONTO ASSEMBLY THAT I DISLIKE IT
ON THE RECORD THAT THAT REALLY
NEEDS TO BE EVALUATED BEFORE IT
MOVES ANY FARTHER. I INSURANCE
OF ITS PROGRESS THROUGH OUT THE
LEGISLATIVE BODIES SO I WOULD
JOB ASK FOR A NO VOTE.
AT THIS POINT TIME A RE
REFERRAL TO APPROPRIATIONS OF
THAT WAS IN ORDER.
THAT ESSENTIALLY ENSURING THAT
THAT HAPPENS AS IT MAKES ITS WAY
OUT THROUGH THE PROCESS THANK
YOU FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TRIED IT
OUT
KNOWN FORTUNATELY. WE'VE BEEN
PUT IN A POSITION BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
AND BY THE F. C. C.'S WRONG
HEADED ACTIONS
TO BE FORCED.
AS ONE ENTITY WITHOUT. PURVIEW
OVER INTERSTATE COMMERCE AND ALL
THE NUANCES TO CONTRACTING THE
GO ON IN THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS
SPACE TO INSERT OURSELVES HERE.
SITS WITH SOME RELUCTANCE THAT
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THS BILL
BECAUSE I DON'T. I DON'T THINK
WE SHOULD BE PUT IN THIS
SITUATION THE FIRST PLACE.
AND I THINK THAT SOME OF THE
CHALLENGES THAT HAVE BEEN
ARTICULATED. BY OPPOSITION ARE
NECESSARILY PARTISAN IN NATURE.
THEY HAVE TO DO WITH THE THE
MECHANICS.
AND I HOPE AND I'M CONFIDENT
BASED ON WHAT THE AUTHOR IS IS
TOLD OUR COMMITTEES.
THAT HE'S COMMITTED TO TO
WORKING THROUGH SOME OF THESE
MECHANICS IN THE ASSEMBLY. AS
THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD TO
ADDRESS SOME OF THE OUTSTANDING
FISCAL QUESTIONS THAT I DO
BELIEVE OUGHT TO BE ANSWERED.
TO ADDRESS THE USE OF SAY THIS
CIVIL LEGAL REMEDIES AS OPPOSED
TO.
A REGULATORY APPROACH SAY UNDER
THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION
WHICH WAS.
A WEEK SURE TO CHANGE COURSE
AFTER UTILITIES COMMITTEE IN
SOME FEEDBACK WAS USHERED I DO
NOT THINK IT ANSWER THOUGH IS TO
JUST SIT ON OUR HANDS AND WAIT
FOR THE FEDS TO DO SOMETHING.
SO I APPLAUD THE AUTHOR IN JUST
PUSHING FORTH SOME ACTION HERE
AND GETTING THE BALL ROLLING
BUT.
WE'VE GOT A LONG WAYS TO GO HERE
SO.
WITH FAT.
I HEARD YOUR SUPPORT FOR ITS
BEFORE SIX.
THANK YOU SENATOR STERN MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE PROTEST DAILY ON
MUCH LIKE THE CLOSE YOU MIGHT
SHUT THE WHICH IS A PRESENT
THING TOO MUCH HER COLLEAGUES
FOR A A GOOD DEBATE ON THIS.
LET ME BE VERY CLEAR ABOUT A
COUPLE THINGS SOME FOLKS MAY NOT
HAVE.
THE OPPORTUNITY TO REALLY A
DIGGING DEEPING GET IN THE WEEDS
OF THE ARCANE COMPLEXITIES OF
THIS MEASURE BECAUSE IT IS
COMPLEX WITHOUT A DOUBT YOU
CAN'T DO IT. A DOING A COURSE OF
A WEEKEND BUT WE HAD TWO VERY
FULL ROBUST OF LINK THE.
HEARINGS ON THIS ISSUE OF
STARTING FROM THE UTILITIES.
COMMISSION A UTILIZATION SAY.
COMMITTEE.
AND COMMUNICATIONS AYE AS WELL
AS THE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AS
WELL OUGHT TO JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE AS WELL WE HAVE MANY
LEGAL EAGLES IN ON I HAVE TO
TELL THE LEGAL EAGLES ON THE
COMMITTEE.
SLOW DOWN A TAD BIT BECAUSE I'M
NOT A LAWYER I DON'T HAVE THE
LUXURY OF BEING ABLE TO SLICE
AND DICE PRECISELY. ALL OF YOUR
LEGAL THEORIES WHAT YOU EDUCATED
ME NONE THE LESS IT WAS VERY
HELPFUL IN EMPOWERING. BUT WE'RE
NEED TO ITS COMMITTEE ONE OF THE
BIGGEST CONCERNS WITHOUT A DOUBT
WAS.
THE P. YOU SEE IN THE THE
HIGHEST FOR HELP SO OPINION
AT THIS MOMENT WHEN IT COMES TO
THE P. UC'S SO.
IN THE INFINITE WISDOM OF
LISTEN TO MY COLLEAGUES WE
REMOVED QC.
FROM THE EQUATION ALTOGETHER
THAT WILL NOT BE FIFTY
INTERPRETATIONS WITH REGARD TO
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS OR.
CITY ATTORNEY'S OPEN ON CITY
CALIFORNIA ABOUT WE ARE STILL
WORKING WITH THIS MEASURE.
BUT BE MY FOR BUT WHAT THE
BECAUSE SOME THE TALKING POINTS
I HEARD OR THE SAME TALKING
POINTS THAT WERE UTILIZED BY THE
SAME FOLKS WHO ACTUALLY WERE
BUSY IN WASHINGTON DC.
UNDERMINING THE FCC THAT NET
NEUTRALITY OBAMA ERA AMERICA
RULES BACK IN TWENTY FIFTEEN.
SO THE VERY SAME ARGUMENTS ARE
BEING UTILIZED BACK THERE ARE
THE ONES BEING UTILIZED HERE AS
WELL BY THE VERY SAME FOLKS WHO
WENT OUT OF THE WAY TO ON. TO
SORT OF.
NOT SORT OF BUT ACTUALLY
CONVINCE IN A PARTISAN FASHION
THE FCC TO OVERTURN DOT NET
NEUTRALITY. OF FOR CALIFORNIANS
AND CALIFORNIA CENTRIC OF FOLKS
WHO CARE ABOUT OUR BUSINESSES
HERE PARTICLE IN THE BAY AREA.
AND SILICON VALLEY THIS IS ABOUT
EGALITARIAN SPACE THIS IS ABOUT
BUT OPEN INTERNET THIS IS ABOUT
DEMOCRACY THE WAY WE COMMUNICATE
WITH FOLKS THE WAY WE ACTUALLY
ENGAGE IN OUR BUSINESS IS SO
MUCH COMMERCE IS DONE. AND
CONDUCTED.
ON OUR A HONOR INTERNET.
AS WELL BUT WE WILL CONTINUE TO
WORK WITH OUR COLLEAGUES AS WELL
AS STAKEHOLDERS AND THOSE WERE
IN OPPOSITION TO THE MEASURE.
WHICH WE HAVE BEEN WORKING AND
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THEM.
THE ISSUE WITH REGARDS TO.
PREEMPTION NOW. IT IS OF. MY
HUMBLE OPINION THAT IT IS THE
CONGRESS UNITED STATES WHO MAKES
THE DECISION ON STATUTORY LOTS
WHEN IT COMES TO PREEMPTION.
THAT IN FACT THE FCC DID DRAFT A
PREEMPTIVE CLAUSE BUT WE DON'T
BELIEVE THAT A REGULATORY BODY
HAS THE LEGAL RIGHTS ACTUALLY
PREEMPT STATES FROM DOING WHAT
THEY WANT TO DO SPECIFICALLY.
THAT'S A JOB THE CONGRESS.
ULTIMATELY WILL MAKE THAT
DECISION IF IN FACT THEY WISH TO
DO SO WITHOUT BEING SAID THAT
DOESN'T MEAN THAT WE SIT ON OUR
HANDS.
AND WE DO NOTHING AT ALL
WHATSOEVER OUR JOB IS TO PROTECT
THE CONSUMER OF CALIFORNIA AND
PROTECT THE BUSINESSES OF
CALIFORNIA. THAT'S OUR ROLE INTO
TO RESPONSIBILITY AND JUST LIKE
WE'VE SEEN IN A WHOLE VARIETY OF
ISSUES WITH ITS THE ENVIRONMENT
WITH ITS CLIMATE CHANGE WITH THE
DREAMERS.
WE HAD TO STAND UP TOGETHER IN
UNISON AND PROTECT THE CONSUMERS
A CALIFORNIA WE CAN MAKE SURE
THEY HAVE FREE ACCESS TO THE
INTERNET. AND NOT.
BE UP TOWARD ANYWAY OF FOR AXIS
OF IDEAS AS WELL AS THE ABILITY
TO PUSH THE PRODUCTS THAT THEY
SELL TO CONSUMERS. SO WITH THAT
MISS PRESENT AS WELL AS MISTER
WHAT MISTER PRESIDENT AS WELL AS
COLLEAGUES I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR A A BIPARTISAN. BY THIS
MEASURE.
THANK YOU PRO TEM DE LEóN.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
I DOT.
FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
HE'LL.
I HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I NADA.
I LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
I.
MONNING.
FIVE MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
NO NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
NO SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO Y. CASKEY.
I WIENER.
I WILK.
NO.
VICTORY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
NO.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DODD I. GALGIANI.
GLAZER.
HERTZBERG. AYE.
MENDOZA.
NEWMAN.
I WAS TWENTY ONE KNOWS TWELVE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS DID I JUST FOR A MOMENT
UNDER PRIVILEGES OF THE FLOOR
SENATOR WIENER I BELIEVE YOU
HAVE AN INTRODUCTION TO MAKE.
YES THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT.
COLLEAGUES I JUST ONE.
BRIEFLY WELCOME TO THE FLOOR.
WE HAVE.
WITH US THE AYE CHANCELLOR OF
SAN FRANCISCO CITY COLLEGE.
RQ ARE COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE
MARK ROCHA AS WELL AS THREE OF
OUR ELECTED COMMUNITY COLLEGE BY
TRUSTEES IN SAN FRANCISCO THE
PRESIDENT. OF THE BOARD OF
TRUSTEES PRESENT DAVA WAS WELL
AS I'VE TRUSTEES FEE OF SELBY
AND ALEX ROUND ALSO IN A WELCOME
YOU.
TO THE SENATE.
PLEASE WELCOME TO THE SENATE.
OR IT MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO
RETURN TO THE FILE FILE ITEM
SIXTY ONE.
SENATOR PORTANTINO.
FILE ITEM SIXTY ONE WHICH LIKE
BRING THAT MEASURE FORWARD.
PAST PASS ON FILE OKAY.
MEMBERS WILL MOVE TO FILE ITEM.
SIXTY TWO SENATOR NEWMAN.
NOT AT HIS DESK.
FILE ITEM.
SIXTY THREE.
SENATOR SKINNER.
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE RESOLUTION SEVENTY SIX BY
SENATOR SKINNER RELATIVE TO
HUMAN TRAFFICKING AWARENESS
MONTH
CENTER SKINNER. THANKS SO MUCH.
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS THE
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS.
.
IS THE SPONSOR OF THIS
RESOLUTION AND I STAND TO
PRESENT IT SR SEVENTY SIX A
DECLARES THE MONTH OF JANUARY
TWENTY EIGHTEEN. HUMAN
TRAFFICKING AWARENESS MONTH.
AND INTERESTINGLY HUMAN
TRAFFICKING IS NOW THE WORLD'S.
FASTEST GROWING CRIMINAL
ENTERPRISE IN IS ESTIMATED AT A
THIRTY FIVE BILLION A YEAR
GLOBAL INDUSTRY.
NOW WE THINK OF IT AS AN
INTERNATIONAL PROBLEM RATHER
THAN A DOMESTIC PROBLEM.
BUT IN FACT THE FBI REPORTS THAT
THERE ARE MORE THAN A HUNDRED
THOUSAND CHILDREN TRAFFICKED
RIGHT HERE IN THE U. S..
IN ANY GIVEN TIME.
AND. THE FBI ALSO TELLS US THAT
THREE OF THE NATION'S HIGHEST
INTENSITY AREAS.
FOR COMMERCIAL SEXUAL
EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN. IS ARE
WRITING CALIFORNIA THE LA
METROPOLITAN AREA. THE SAN
FRANCISCO METROPOLITAN AREA IN
THE SAN DIEGO METROPOLITAN AREA.
SO IT'S NECESSARY FOR US.
TO.
REMAIN CONSTANT.
IN TERMS OF OUR AWARENESS OF
THIS.
AND TO MAKE SURE THAT. AND I NOR
LAW ENFORCEMENT IS WELL AWARE
BUT THAT ALL OF OUR COMMUNITIES
DON'T THINK OF THIS AS JUST AN
INTERNATIONAL PROBLEM. BUT
RATHER SOMETHING THAT AFFECTS
OUR OWN CHILDREN RIGHT HERE AT
HOME.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR SKINNER.
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
ANDERSON.
I ATKINS AYE BATES.
I BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL. AYE BRADFORD. AYE
CANNELLA. AYE DELEON.
I DODD.
AYE FULLER. AYE GAINES AYE AYE
GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ. AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON. AYE LARA. AYE LEYVA.
MY MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
I MONNING OKAY PRIMER LOCK. I'M
A REAL.
BY NEWMAN. AYE NGUYEN.
OKAY GOOD. AYE NIELSEN.
I PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER.
I STERN.
I STONE.
I'VE BIDAK.
I LIKE HEALTHY.
WIENER.
I WILK.
I.
SURGERY PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN. AYE.
BY KATHY I.
I THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
RESOLUTION IS ADOPTED.
YEAH MISTER SECRETARY THERE IS A
COMMITTEE REPORT AT THE DESK
PLEASE READ.
MISTER PRESIDENT AS CHAIR OF THE
COMMITTEE APPROPRIATIONS TO
WHICH WAS REFERRED SENATE BILL
FIVE SIXTY ONE.
REPORTS THE SAME BACK THE
RECOMMENDATION THAT THE BILL BE
ORDERED TO SECOND READING
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE TWENTY
EIGHT POINT EIGHT.
BILL HAS ORDERED TO THIRD
READING.
GREAT THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA TAKE AN
OPPORTUNITY NOW TO LIFT THE
CALLS ALL THE VOTES THAT YOU'VE
MADE TODAY. AND WE'RE TO START
WITH SENATE BILL FIVE FIVE
EIGHT.
SECRETARY.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BERRYHILL.
DELEON.
I.
MENDOZA MONEY.
BERRYHILL AYE.
MONNING I.
I THIRTY NINE THOSE ZERO.
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
WITH WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE ITEM
FORTY FIVE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL.
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY OFF.
I.
FULLER.
MENDOZA.
MONNING.
I WILK.
ICE THIRTY NO SEVEN MEASURE
PASSES.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVED TO FILE
ITEM FORTY SIX SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DELEON.
BY.
MENDOZA MINING.
I WILK.
BY.
ICE THIRTY KNOWS NINE MEASURE
PASSES.
WELL NOW MOVED FILE ITEM FORTY
SEVEN SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY OWN.
ME BY MENDOZA MONNING.
I NEWMAN.
ICE TWENTY FIVE KNOWS THIRTEEN
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FORTY EIGHT SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY ALL.
I.
MENDOZA MONEY.
MONNING I.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN THOSE TWELVE.
MEASURE PASSES ON NOW MOVED FILE
ITEM FORTY NINE SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
BY.
MENDOZA MONNING.
I NIELSEN.
NO.
STONE.
WILK.
WILK AYE.
I WAS TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS EIGHT
MEASURE PASSES WILL NOW MOVED TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY. SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY ON.
I.
MENDOZA NIELSEN.
I.
ICE THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO
MEASURE PASSES WILL NOW MOVE TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY ONE SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
CANNELLA.
DELEON.
I FULLER.
GLAZER.
MENDOZA.
MORE LOCK.
NEWMAN.
NIELSEN.
WILK.
NO.
NIELSEN NO.
I WAS TWENTY EIGHT NO SIX
MEASURE PASSES NOW MOVED FILE
ITEM FIFTY TWO SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY OFF.
I.
MENDOZA.
NIELSEN.
I.
I THIRTY NINE THOSE ZERO MEASURE
PASSES WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY THREE SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL ABSENT MEMBERS.
MENDOZA.
NIELSEN.
NO.
WHY CASKEY?
EYES TWENTY FOUR KNOWS FOURTEEN
MEASURE PASSES WILL NOW MOVE THE
FILE ITEM FIFTY FOUR SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
HERTZBERG.
BY. JACKSON.
MENDOZA.
MONNING.
BY.
I THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY FIVE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
HERTZBERG.
I MENDOZA.
ICE THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO
MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM FIFTY SEVEN SEVEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
I.
BATES.
CANNELLA.
MENDOZA MORALE.
NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN
I.
STONE.
BIDAK.
BY THAT I.
YEAH PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
BATES.
CANNELLA.
MENDOZA.
MORRELL.
STONE.
I WAS THIRTY FOUR KNOWS ONE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY
EIGHT SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
ABSENT MEMBERS.
ALLEN.
I.
BATES.
BERRYHILL.
MENDOZA MONNING.
I.
NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NO.
WILK ICE TWENTY EIGHT NO SEVEN
MEASURE PASSES ON THE MOVE TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY NINE SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL ABSENT MEMBERS.
MENDOZA.
NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NGUYEN AYE NIELSEN AYE.
I THIRTY NINE NO ZERO MEASURE
PASSES.
MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING TO THE
CONSENT CALENDAR OTHER ATTY ITEM
SEE LIKE REMOVED FROM THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
SURGERY PLEASE READ THE ITEMS ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
SENATE BILL TWO TWENTY ONE SEVEN
TWENTY FIVE TWENTY TO FIVE
THIRTY TO SEVEN FORTY SIX. SEVEN
SIXTY SIX AND SENATE BILL EIGHT
SIXTEEN.
VICTORY UP PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ON THE FIRST ITEM.
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN. AYE ATKINS.
BY BATES.
BY BILL.
BY BERRYHILL.
DELEON.
I DODD.
I FULLER.
GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LADA.
I LABOR BY MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL.
BUT I NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
AYE NIELSEN. AYE PAN. AYE
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
AYE STERN. AYE STONE.
BIDAK.
AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER.
BY WILK.
WILK I THIRTY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
FULLER AYE. MENDOZA. ROTH.
STONE.
STONE I
SENATOR ROTH WE THINK HE'S.
GONNA BE HERE IN A COUPLE
SECONDS
.
VICTORY PEACEFUL ABSENT MEMBERS
MENDOZA ROUGH. ROTH AYE.
I THIRTY NINE THOSE ZERO THE
CONSENT CALENDAR IS APPROVED
.
MEMBERS ARE NOW IT GONNA MOVE
BACK TO GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENTS
SENATOR CANNELLA.
IT'S FILE ITEM THIRTY EIGHT.
THANK YOU MISS PRESENT THIS IS
FOR ONE PEDRO GAFFNEY MEMBER
ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL
APPEALS BOARD.
A MEMBERS OF THE BOARD REVIEW
THE DECISIONS OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL OR
A. B. C.. WHICH LICENSES AND
REGULATES ALCOHOL MANUFACTURING
DISTRIBUTION AND SALES
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. HOW HE WAS
APPROVED BY UNANIMOUS VOTE IN
THE SENATE RULES COMMITTEE
HEARING ASK FOR A VOTE?
THANK YOU CENTER CANNELLA
MEMBERS ANY DEBATE OR
DISCUSSION.
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NO BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA AYE DELEON.
I.
DODD.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER. AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
I HILL. AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
LOTTE.
I LABOR.
I MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
BY NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
HI. ROTH.
SKINNER.
I STERN. AYE STONE.
BY DAK.
NO I COUNTY.
I WINNER.
I WILK.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS.
JACKSON. I.
MENDOZA.
ROTH.
STONE.
NO.
WILK.
ICE TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS TEN THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED.
UNDER MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS.
SENATOR ALLEN.
THERE MOTIONS RESOLUTIONS.
YES EDITOR ALAN LIKE TO
REQUESTED SB SEVEN A FIVE ITEM
EIGHTY SIX YEAR MOVE FROM
INACTIVE FILE. A DESK WILL NOTE
THANK YOU.
OKAY MEMBERS UNDER MOTIONS AND
RESOLUTIONS SENATOR JACKSON.
BUT IS THIS THE TIME TO ADJOURN
A MEMORY.
YES IT IS THANK YOU.
A THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES YOU KNOW IT WAS OUR.
FIRST SOME OF THOSE OF THE OLDER
GENERATIONS IT WAS REAT TO SEE
JOAN BAEZ HERE. A REMINDING MANY
OF US OF.
WHAT'S SOME OF THE PRIORITIES
WERE BACK IN THAT SO CALLED DAY.
AND.
.
THERE WAS A WAR GOING ON THAT
WAS VERY UNPOPULAR.
THERE WERE PEOPLE WHO WERE
SEEKING PEACE AND JUSTICE AND
SINGING ABOUT IT AND MARCHING
ABOUT IT. AND SO I WANT TO
ADJOURN IN MEMORY OF ONE OF THE
GREAT LEADERS OF THAT ERA AND
BEYOND. OF PAUL BOOTH.
PAUL AND HEATHER BOOTH IF YOU NO
ONE NO YOU WOULD KNOW BOTH. A
WORD EXTRAORDINARY OR WHERE HAVE
BEEN AN EXTRAORDINARY. A LEADERS
IN PROGRESSIVE SOCIAL RIGHTS
ACTIVISM.
PAUL DIED A ON THE SEVENTEENTH
OF THIS MONTH DUE TO
COMPLICATIONS.
ASSOCIATED WITH LEUKEMIA. OF BUT
WAS DOING SO WELL THAT THAT VERY
MORNING.
HEATHER. PROTESTED ALONG WITH A
JEWISH GROUP IN A IN THE HALLS
OF CONGRESS.
IN SUPPORT OF OUR DARKEST
STUDENTS AND WAS ARRESTED.
THAT.
THAT DAY.
OF PROBABLY ANOTHER SISTER WITH
WHITE HAIR BUT.
CONTINUING IN A LEGACY THAT SHE
AND PAUL HAD BEEN INVOLVED IN
SINCE THE SIXTIES WHERE THEY
MET.
ACTUALLY ARE AT A CITY IN.
SOME OF US WHO REMEMBER THE DAYS
OF STADIUMS AND THEY'VE BEEN AND
A STRONG COUPLE. OF ACTIVISTS
EVER SINCE AND UP.
PAUL BEGAN HIS A CAREER IT IT AS
AN ACTIVIST IN THE ANTI VIETNAM
WAR MOVEMENT HE SERVED AS THE
NATIONAL SPOKESMAN. FOR THE
STUDENTS FOR A DEMOCRATIC
SOCIETY HE WAS VIEWED AS ONE OF
THE ONE OF THE MODERATES IN THAT
GROUP. ARE AND ARE URGED A A
MORE RATIONAL PRAGMATIC APPROACH
TO TRYING TO DEAL WITH SOME OF
THE SOCIAL ILLS. IN OUR NATION
AT THAT TIME HE WAS ALSO A A ONE
OF THE ORGANIZERS OF THE FIRST
MAJOR STUDENT ANTI WAR MARCH. ON
WASHINGTON BACK IN NINETEEN
SIXTY FIVE HE LATER BECAME
ENGAGED IN THE IN PUBLIC
EMPLOYEE UNION NOTICE AFFECTS
ME.
THE LARGEST PUBLIC EMPLOYEE
UNION IN THE NATION. AND RETIRED
JUST LAST YEAR AS THE EXECUTIVE
ASSISTANT TO THE UNIONS
PRESIDENT.
HE WAS CONSIDERED ONE OF THE
LABOR MOVEMENT'S KEY STRATEGIST
AND IS CREDITED WITH LEADING
ROLES IN MAJOR ASPECTS OF THE
LABOR MOVEMENT. INCLUDING.
THERE BEING ONE OF THE
ARCHITECTS OF NOT THE ARCHITECT
IN THE NATION'S FIRST LIVING
WAGE CAMPAIGN. HE LOBBIED
AGAINST FORMER PRESIDENT BUSH'S
PROPOSAL TO PRIVATIZE SOCIAL
SECURITY AND WORKED TO EXPAND
SOCIAL BENEFITS FOR WORKING
CLASS FAMILIES.
ISSUES STILL REMAIN RELEVANT
TODAY AS THE VIETNAM WAR IS SEEN
OUR DISTANT REAR VIEW MIRROR.
BUT HE ALSO SHARED HIS WISDOM
AND INSIGHTS BY SERVING AS A
MENTOR TO THE NEXT GENERATION
AND THE CURRENT GENERATION OF
SOCIAL JUSTICE ACTIVISTS HE WAS
CONSIDERED.
AND ORGANIZERS ORGANIZER AND IT
WAS ON MY HONOR AND PRIVILEGE TO
KNOW HIM. TO TALK STRATEGY IN
POLITICS WITH HIM.
TO TALK ABOUT A VISION FOR A
MORE JUST AND BETTER WORLD AND
TO WORK WITH HIM AND HEATHER IN
THAT PURSUIT.
HE IS SURVIVED BY HEATHER HIS
WIFE%
TWO SONGS FIVE GRANDCHILDREN AND
A BROTHER.
AND PLEASE JOIN ME IN SENDING
DEEPEST CONDOLENCES TO HIS
FAMILY. TO A GREAT AMERICAN
SOCIAL JUSTICE LEADER. PAUL
ROBERT BOOTH.
THEY CONSIDER JACKSON OR THOUGHT
AND PRAYERS GO TO PAUL BOOTH IN
THE FAMILY. I WILL NOW MOVE TO
SENATOR MITCHELL.
FOLLOWED BY SENATOR WIENER
SENATOR LEYVA AND CENTER BATES.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
PRESIDENT AND COLLEAGUES.
I STAND HERE TODAY TO ASK THAT
YOU JOIN ME IN THE RESIDENTS OF
THE THIRTY SENATE DISTRICT. ON
IN A JOURNEYING IN MEMORY OF
MARGARET LINGERING. I FIRST MET
MARGARET BECAUSE HER DAUGHTER
DECENT NOT AYE UP WERE.
FELLOW ADVOCATES IN THE EARLY
CARE AND EDUCATION ARENA.
WITH THE CALIFORNIA RESOURCE
AND REFERRAL NETWORK.
AND I'M ONE SIGH MET MARGARET I
UNDERSTOOD WHERE DE SADE DOT HER
ADVOCACY CHOPS FROM.
MARGARET PASSED ON THE
THIRTEENTH OF JANUARY I AT THE
AGE OF EIGHTY SEVEN
WELL SHE WAS BORN IN CANTON OHIO
TO MISSIONARY PARENTS.
HE SPENT SEVERAL OF HER
CHILDHOOD YEARS IN CHINA IN
SHANGHAI.
AFTER RETURNING TO THE U. S. THE
FAMILY SETTLED IN CLAREMONT
CALIFORNIA HE MET AND MARRIED
ANI LINGERING IN THEY HAD TWO
CHILDREN MY FRIEND DE SEVENTIES
HIS BROTHER ALLEN.
HE BECAME A NURSE AND WORK OUT
AT A HAWAIIAN PLANTATION.
HOSPITAL FOLLOWED BY A CLINIC
NURSING HOME ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
IF YOU SHARE DOES THE HEALTH
CARE COORDINATOR FOR THE MACKLIN
HEART COMMUNITY RESIDENTS IN THE
LOS ANGELES FOR MANY YEARS.
HE WAS REYES IN THE
CONGREGATIONAL UNITED METHODIST
CHURCHES ON THAT WAS THE SOURCE
OF HER DEEP SPIRITUAL.
CONNECTIONS SHE WAS A WOMAN OF
PRAYER AND SERVICE EMPHASIS AND
SERVICE TO THOSE IN NEED.
HE THEN WITH AN ENTHUSIASTIC
PRESENCE AT MEETINGS IN THE
CULVER CITY COMMUNITY AND
MARCHES SHE WAS COMMITTED TO
DOING THE WORK OF JUSTICE AND
PEACE.
HE ADVOCATED FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
WOMEN'S RIGHTS IMMIGRANT AND
REFUGEE RIGHTS FARM WORKERS AND
THE ENVIRONMENT.
THANKS TO FACEBOOK WE NOW ALL
CAN CONNECT WITH CONSTITUENTS
AND COLLEAGUES.
ON A MORE REGULAR BASIS AND IN
RECENT YEARS
ALL AS MARKET FOUND HERSELF
SLOWING DOWN IN A WHEELCHAIR
MORE. I REALLY ENJOYED SEEING
THE PICTURES OF HER IN HER
WHEELCHAIR ON EVENING STROLLS
AROUND CULVER CITY WITH HER
BLACK LIVES MATTER TEE SHIRT ON.
AND THE ME SAY KYLE A NOTE TO MY
SEAT MATE A MARKET LOOK LIKE YOU
WOULD NOT LIKE ME.
SHEET. YOU OFTEN HEAR THAT THAT
THAT THE TERM THAT SOMEONE HAS
JUST A SMILE THAT LIGHTS UP THE
ROOM AND THAT HAS BECOME KIND OF
A. COMMON THING TO SAY BUT
MARGARET TRULY HEAD.
A SMILE THAT JUST MADE YOU SMILE
WHEN YOU SAW HER.
HE WAS PASSIONATE HE WAS AN
ADVOCATE AN OLD SCHOOL ADVOCATE
WHO PRACTICED WHAT HE PREACHED
EVERYDAY.
HA SHE SURVIVED AGAIN BY HER
DAUGHTER DESA.
AYE AND HER SON ALLAN INTO
BROTHERS
PREDECEASED HER CLVER CITY AND
AND ALL OF THEIR.
ACTIVIST COMMUNITY.
ARE MOURNING HER LOSS BUT ARE
COMMITTING TO CONTINUE THE
EFFORTS THAT MARGARET LINGERING
BROUGHT TO THE CULVER CITY
DEMOCRATS UP IN CULVER CITY
ACTIVISTS ALL ACROSS THE CITY.
AND I THAK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME
TO REMEMBER HER AND A JUROR IN
THIS OP BODY IN HER MEMORY.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL IN
OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO TO
MARKET LINGERING IN THE FAMILY
AND.
ALL THE GREAT.
THING SAID SHE DID NOT CULVER
CITY COMMUNITY.
AND WILL NOW MOVE TO SENATOR
WIENER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
PRESIDENT.
I RISE TO REQUEST THAT THE
SENATE ADJOURNED.
IN MEMORY OF TENNIS SPERONE.
I IT IS WITH GREAT SADNESS.
THAT I I NEED TO RISE TODAY.
BECAUSE AND SPERONE AYE WAS AN
ICON AND A TRAILBLAZER AND SAN
FRANCISCO AND FRANKLY.
AROUND THE WORLD. AYE HE WAS.
THE FATHER.
IN MANY WAYS OF THE MEDICAL
CANNABIS ON MOVEMENT
I PASSED AWAY AT THE AGE OF
SEVENTY ONE.
DENNIS WAS A BUSINESSMAN HE
WASN'T LGBT RIGHTS AND HIV
ACTIVISTS.
I AND ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT
LEADERS.
OF THE CANNABIS LEGALIZATION
MOVEMENT AND OUR COUNTRY.
HE WAS BORN IN THE BRONX IN NEW
YORK IN NINETEEN FORTY SIX I
GREW UP ON LONG ISLAND.
IN NINETEEN SIXTY SIX.
DURING THE VIETNAM WAR.
HE ENLISTED IN THE U. S. AIR
FORCE.
I WAS IN VIETNAM WHERE HE FIRST%
ENCOUNTERED CANNABIS.
AFTER THE WAR ENDED DENNIS MOVE
TO SAN FRANCISCO.
AND BECAME A CENTRAL FIGURE IN
THE LGBT I'M CANNABIS
COMMUNITIES.
IN THE HIT ASK VERY
NEIGHBORHOOD.
AND IN MY OWN NEIGHBORHOOD.
THE CASTRO IN FACT HE LIVED
JUST A FEW BLOCKS FOR ME ON THE
SAME STREET.
AS THE AIDS EPIDEMIC OVER TOOK
SAM FRANCISCO AYE DENNIS
BEFRIENDED MARY JANE RATHBURN.
A HOSPITAL VOLUNTEER AND
WAITRESS.
DENISON MARRY WOULD ME A COPY
FLOOR ON MARKET STREET IN THE
CASTRO. BY AND BEGIN A
CALIFORNIA MOVEMENT THAT WOULD
CHANGE OUR STATE AND OUR
COUNTRY.
DENISON MERRY REALIZED THE
HEALTH BENEFITS OF CANNABIS AND
THEY WOULD BAKE AND DISTRIBUTE
CANNABIS BROWNIES.
FOR AIDS PATIENTS AS IT WOULD
ASSIST THEM WITH SLEEP.
THAT WOULD STOP THE NAUSEA THAT
WAS SO OFTEN CAUSED.
BY HIV MEDICATIONS.
I'D ALSO STIMULATE THEIR
APPETITES SO THAT THEY WOULD BE.
AND STOP LOSING WEIGHT.
IN NINETEEN NINETY DENNIS LOST
HAS PARTNERED JONATHAN WEST TO
AIDS.
DENNIS WOULD LATER SAY. IN MY
PAIN I DECIDED TO LEAVE JOHN IT
THAN A LEGACY OF LOVE.
I MADE A MY MORAL PURSUITS TO
LET EVERYONE KNOW ABOUT
JONATHAN'S LIFE.
HIS DEATH AND HIS USE OF
MARIJUANA AND HOW IT GAVE HIM
DIGNITY AND HIS FINAL DAYS.
THE FOLLOWING YEAR IN NINETEEN
NINETY ONE. THAT IS ORGANIZED
AND PLAYED A KEY ROLE IN PASSING
SAN FRANCISCO'S PROPOSITION P..
A RESOLUTION CALLING ON THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO PERMIT.
MEDICAL CANNABIS.
LATER IN NINETEEN NINETY ONE
DENNIS CO FOUNDED THE SAN
FRANCISCO CANNABIS BUYERS CLUB.
WHICH WAS THE FIRST PUBLIC
CANNABIS DISPENSARY AND OUR
COUNTRY.
IN NINETEEN NINETY SIX DENNIS CO
WROTE PROPOSITION TWO FIFTEEN.
OF THE COMPARISON THE
COMPASSIONATE USE ACT OF
NINETEEN NINETY SIX WHICH DOES
COLLEAGUES AS YOU KNOW.
LEGALIZE MEDICAL CANNABIS IN
CALIFORNIA.
ONE MONTH BEFORE ELECTION DAY.
BY DENNIS WAS ARRESTED AT HIS
SAN FRANCISCO CANNABIS BUYERS
CLUB.
AS YOU NO PROP TWO FIFTEEN
PASSED WITH ALMOST FIFTY SIX
PERCENT OF A BOW.
AND IT HAS SPREAD TO VARIOUS
STATES IN THIS COUNTRY.
SIMPLY PUT THIS GAY HIV
ACTIVISTS
SAN FRANCISCO CHANGE THE WORLD.
LATER IN HIS LIFE DENNIS OWNED
AND OPERATED A TWENTY ACRE
COOPERATIVE CANNABIS FARM IN
LAKE COUNTY.
WITH OVER TWO HUNDRED PATIENTS
AS PART OF A FARM THAT IS FROM
GROW AND GIVE LIVING PLANTS TO
ALL OF THE MEMBERS.
DENNIS PERON WAS NOT IN IT FOR
THE MONEY HE WAS AND IT. FOR THE
PEOPLE.
HE OPPOSED OUR PROPS NINETEEN
SIXTY FOUR WHICH ULTIMATELY
LEGALIZE UNTIL USE OF CANNABIS.
BECAUSE IN HIS VIEW ALL
MARIJUANA WAS MEDICINAL.
NOTICES PASS YEAR DENNIS WAS
RECOGNIZED BY THE SAN FRANCISCO
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS.
WHEN ACCEPTING HIS RECOGNITION
DENNIS SAID QUOTE I CAME TO SAN
FRANCISCO TO FIND LOVE AND TO
CHANGE THE WORLD.
I FOUND LOVE ONLY TO LOSE HIM
THROUGH AIDS.
WE CHANGE THE WORLD THROUGH THE
LEGALIZATION OF MARIJUANA WE
HAVE A KINDER AMERICA.
DENIS IS SURVIVED BY HIS HUSBAND
JOHN ENTWISTLE AND HIS BROTHERS
JEFFREY M. BRIAN.
HE MADE SUCH AN IMPACT ON THE
PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA. AND WE
SEND OUR VERY HEARTFELT
CONDOLENCES TO HIS FAMILY AND
HIS MANY FRIENDS.
BY DENNIS YOU CHANGE THE WORLD
AND COLLEAGUES I HOUSE THAT WE
ADJOURN IN MEMORY OF DENNIS
PERON.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER AND OUR
THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO
DENNIS PERONISTS FAMILY. AND IS
CONTRIBUTIONS TO MEDICAL
CANNABIS LGBT COMMUNITY AND HIV.
AND NOW WE WILL MOVE TO SENATOR
LEYVA.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
MEMBERS AS A VICE CHAIR OF THE
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS I
RISE TODAY TO ADJOURN IN THE
MAIN.
PARKER FREELY.
SEVENTY SIX YEARS AGO IN
NINETEEN FORTY TWO NAOMI PARKER
FREELY POSED FOR A PICTURE WHILE
WORKING IN A FACTORY IN ALAMEDA
CALIFORNIA.
BORN IN TULSA OKLAHOMA SHE WAS
THE THIRD OF EIGHT CHILDREN.
HER FAMILY MOVED WHERE HER
FATHER'S WORK TOOK HIM LIVING IN
NEW YORK MISSOURI TEXAS
WASHINGTON YOU TONGUE CALIFORNIA
WHERE THEY FINALLY SETTLED IN
ALAMEDA. AFTER THE JAPANESE
ATTACK ON PEARL HARBOR THE
TWENTY YEAR OLD NAOMI WOULD TO
WORK AT THE NAVAL AIR STATION IN
ALAMEDA.
SHE WAS ASSIGNED TO THE MACHINE
SHOP WHERE HER DUTIES INCLUDED
DRILLING PATCHING AIRPLANE WINGS
AND RIVETING. IT WAS THERE THAT
AN ACME PHOTOGRAPHER CAPTURED
NAM WE PARKER HER HAIR TIED IN A
BANDANNA FOR SAFETY AT HER
WORKSTATION.
LATER PITTSBURG ARTIST JAY
HOWARD MILLER WOULD RENDER THAT
PHOTOGRAPH IN BOLD GRAPHICS AND
BRIGHT COLORS DEPICTING A YOUNG
WOMAN IN A WORK SHIRT AND A
POLKADOT BANDANNA. FLEXING HER
ARM DECLARING. WE CAN'T DO IT.
DURING THE NINETEEN EIGHTIES A
PHOTO QUICKLY BECAME A FEMINIST
SYMBOL AND THE NAME ROSIE THE
RIVETER WAS APPLIED
RETROSPECTIVELY TO THE WOMAN WHO
PORTRAYED IT.
THAT ICONIC PHOTO OF ROSIE THE
RIVETER IS NAOMI PARKER FREELY.
TODAY ROSIE THE RIVETER
CONTINUES TO BE RECOGNIZED AND
USED TO SHINE A POSITIVE AND
ENCOURAGING LIGHT ON WOMEN IN
THE WORKFORCE. AND A SYMBOL OF
PERSISTENCE DEFIANCE AND
FORTITUDE IN SHORT NEARLY PARKER
FREELY OR ROSIE THE RIVETER HAS
BECOME THE ESSENCE OF FEMALE
EMPOWERMENT.
AFTER THE WAR NAOMI MARRIED HAVE
A FAMILY AND IT WASN'T UNTIL TWO
THOUSAND SIXTEEN THAT MRS
FREHLEY'S CONNECTION TO ROSY
BECAME PUBLIC.
LAST SATURDAY SHE PASSED AWAY AT
THE AGE OF NINETY SIX.
HER SURVIVORS INCLUDE A SON FOUR
STEPSONS TWO STEPDAUGHTERS TWO
SISTERS THREE GRANDCHILDREN
THREE GREAT GRANDCHILDREN AND
MANY STEP GRANDCHILDREN AND STEP
GREAT GRANDCHILDREN.
TODAY THE CALIFORNIA STATE
SENATE STANDS WITH THE FREELY
FAMILY AS THEY MOURN THEIR LOSS
AND FOLLOWING IN NAOMI'S
PASSING.
I HOPE YOU'LL JOIN ME TODAY AND
ADJOURNING IN MEMORY OF NAOMI
FREELY MAMMY PARKER FREHLEY
ROSIE THE RIVETER AND FOR THE
FEW OF US THAT ARE LEFT I SAY WE
FLEX OUR MUSCLES.
FOR NAOMI THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR LEYVA AND OUR
THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO TO NAOMI
PARKER IN THE FAMILY.
AND.
.
THE IMPACT SHE HAD AS ROSIE THE
RIVETER. I WILL NOW MOVE TO
SENATOR BATES.
THANK YOU MISTER OP PRESIDENT I
RISE TO ADJOURN IN MEMORY ON A
TWO DAY OF SENT MANY RESIDENTS
IN THINK CYNTHIA COOPER. A VERY
CLOSE PERSONAL FRIEND OF MINE
WHO PASSED AWAY DURING THE
HOLIDAY SEASON AFTER A VERY
BRIEF ILLNESS. WITH OVER THIRTY
YEARS OF VOLUNTEER WORK SHE LEFT
BEHIND A REMARKABLE LEGACY OF
COMMUNITY SERVICE TAKING
LEADERSHIP ROLES IN
ORGANIZATIONS WHOSE PROGRAMS
FOCUSED ON IMPROVING. THE LIVES
OF CHILDREN AND ANIMALS.
VIDEO IS ONE OF THE FOUNDING
MEMBERS OF THE FRIENDS OF SAN
COMMITTEE ANIMALS. ONE OF THE
LEADING EDGE VOLUNTEER ANIMAL
SHELTERS IN ORANGE COUNTY THAT
SOUGHT TO REPLACE YOUTH
INNOVATION WITH A NO KILL PRO
LIFE SHELTER POLICY. HE PLAYED A
KEY ROLE OF FROM THE
ORGANIZATIONS BEGINNING IN THE
EARLY NINETEEN EIGHTIES. AS A
BOARD MEMBER AND A MAJOR DONOR.
HAS A PASSIONATE ANIMAL
ENTHUSIAST CYNTHIA WORKED WITH
THE ORGANIZATION FOR MANY YEARS.
UNTIL IT MERGED WITH THE ANIMAL
RESCUE FOUNDATION IN TWO
THOUSAND FIVE TO FORM THE
CURRENT VOLUNTEER ORGANIZATION
COVERING SOUTH ORANGE COUNTY. IN
PARTS OTHER PARTS OF ORANGE
COUNTY PET PROJECT FOUNDATION.
SHE CONTINUED VOLUNTEERING WITH
THE FOUNDATION OF SERVE FOR MANY
YEARS. AS THE TREASURER AND A
BOARD MEMBERS SHE WORKED
TIRELESSLY TO ENSURE THAT THE
FOUNDATION. COULD CONTINUE TO
CARE FOR ALL OF THE ANIMALS
HOUSE THAT THE COASTAL ANIMAL
SERVICES AUTHORITY.
THROUGH HER EFFORTS ORANGE
COUNTY IS IN A MUCH BETTER
POSITION TODAY. TOENSURE THAT
MORE ANIMALS HAVE SAFE REFUGE
UNTIL ELEVEN HOME CAN BE FOUND
FOR THEM.
SHE IS DEEPLY MISSED BY HER
FAMILY FRIENDS AND THE SOUTH
ORANGE COUNTY COMMUNITIES THAT
SHE WORK SO CLOSELY WITH.
YESTERDAY OVER ONE HUNDRED
FRIENDS AND FAMILY MEMBERS
ATTENDED A CELEBRATION HER HER
LIFE. HONORING HER CONTRIBUTIONS
AND COMMITMENT TO THE LIVES OF
MANY OF HER BELOVED FRANCE AND
ANIMALS SHE IS SURVIVED BY HER
HUSBAND CRAIG. THREE CHILDREN
AND FOUR GRANDCHILDREN I ASK
THAT WE SEND THEM OUR
CONDOLENCES AND ADJOURN. IN THE
MEMORY OF CYNTHIA COOPER A
REMARKABLE COMMUNITY VOLUNTEER
WHOSE LIFE WAS ONE OF GREAT
SERVICE TO MANY.
THANK YOU SENATOR BATES OUR
THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO TO
CYNTHIA COOPER AND THE GREAT
THING SAID SHE DID WITH SETH
COMMITTEE ANIMALS AND THE PET
PROJECT FOUNDATION.
.
MEMBERS WILL NOW MOVE AND.
IF THERE IS NO OTHER BUSINESS
SENATOR DE LEóN.
THE DESK IS CLEAR
.
WHEN I CONCLUDED THAT SINCE WE
MEXICO TO GERMANY MEMBERS.
VERY WELL ABOUT TO ATTEND A
WELFARE CASE.
COLLEAGUES I RISE.
TO JOIN IN THE MEMORY OF MRS
DORIS. COCHRAN PHILLIPS
AGREED MATRIARCH OF HER FAMILY A
TRAILBLAZER. AND A TESTAMENT TO
THE AMERICAN DREAM.
MRS PHILLIPS WAS THE GREAT
GRANDDAUGHTER OF SLAVES FROM
MISSISSIPPI.
AND ALABAMA.
HER FAMILY LEFT SOUTH AS PART
THE GREAT MIGRATION AND
ULTIMATELY SETTLED IN OHIO.
MRS PHILLIPS WAS REYES IS A
PREACHER'S DAUGHTER AND WAS
DEEPLY COMMITTED TO HER.
THROUGHOUT HER LIFE.
SHE WENT ON THE GRADUATE FROM
CENTRAL STATE UNIVERSITY IN
SOUTHERN OHIO. A HISTORICALLY
BLACK COLLEGE CREATED UNDER THE
GLASS LAND GRANTS OF EIGHTEEN
NINETY.
CHOOSE A PROUD SISTER OF THE
DELTA SIGMA THETA SORORITY.
AFTER GRADUATING SHE BEGAN HER
CAREER AS A TEACHER AND THE
CLEVELAND PUBLIC SCHOOL SYSTEM.
IN NINETEEN SIXTY FIVE SHE AND.
HER HUSBAND JAMES BUT AT HOME
IN CLEVELAND HEIGHTS
NEIGHBORHOOD.
THEY WERE THE FIRST BLACK
FAMILY.
IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND HER SON
JIMMY WAS THE FIRST BLACK
STUDENT. TO TEN FAIRFAX
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL A SHORT WALK
FROM OUR HOME.
AFTER RETIRING FROM TEACHING MRS
PHILLIPS WENT ON TO BECOME A
SUCCESSFUL REALTOR. AND REAL
ESTATE INVESTOR.
SHE WOULD EVENTUALLY OWN FOUR
PROPERTIES ONE OF WHICH SHE SOLD
AND USED TO PUT HER THREE
CHILDREN.
THROUGH COLLEGE.
HER CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN
GONE ON TO BECOME A NEW YORK
TIMES BESTSELLING AUTHOR. A
CIVIL RIGHTS ATTORNEY.
THE SUCCESSFUL FINANCIAL ADVISER
LOVING PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS
IN THEIR OWN RIGHT CARRYING THE
LEGACY OF MRS DORIS COCHRAN
PHILLIPS FORD. ANOTHER
GENERATION.
IF I MAY I'D LIKE TO RECITE AN
EXCERPT FROM A POEM THAT HAS
CARRIED HER FAMILY FOR THE PAIN
OF HER PASSING.
STILL I RISE BY THE ONE AND ONLY
THE LATE MAYA ANGELOU.
PART OF THE HUTS OF THE HISTORY
SHAME I RISE.
BUT FROM A PASS THAT THROUGH IN
PAY. I RISE.
I'M A BLACK OCEAN.
LEAPING IN WIDE.
WELLING AND SWELLING. I BEAR IN
THE TITLE.
LEAVING BEHIND NIGHTS OF TERROR
AND FEAR. I RISE
INTO DAY BREAK THAT'S
WONDERFULLY WONDERFULLY CLEAR.
I RISE
BRINGING THE GIFTS THAT MY
ANCESTORS GAVE.
I AM THE DREAM AND THE HOPE OF
THE SLAVE.
I RISE BY RISE BY RISE.
IN THE WORDS OF HER SON STEPHEN.
SHE WAS A BLACK WOMAN.
MOVING WITH CONFIDENCE AND
STYLE.
IN A WORLD FILLED WITH RACISM
AND SEXISM SHE LIVED. LIFE LIKE
A BOSS.
COLLEAGUES SEE MRS DOORS COCHRAN
PHILLIPS LEAVES A MOUNTAIN OF
BROKEN GLASS IN HER WAKE.
SHE A TRUE AMERICAN SUCCESS
STORY.
WHO WITNESS AND HELPED TO BRING
ABOUT HIS SORT PROGRESS IN OUR
COUNTRY?
OUR LEGACY IS ONE OF HOPE HER
LEGACY IS ONE OF HOPE.
AND SHE GIVES ME HOPE FOR
FUTURE.
AND OUR NATION.
COLLEAGUES PLEASE JOIN ME IN
ADJOURNING IN THE MEMORY OF THE
GREAT DORIS COCHRAN PHILLIPS
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES.
THANK YOU PRO TEM DE LEóN IN
OUR THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GOODY
DORIS PHILLIPS AND.
THE STRUGGLES THAT SHE WENT
THROUGH.
TO GRADUATE FROM CENTRAL STATE
UNIVERSITY.
AND TO UP BECOME A REAL LEADER
AND THE CENTER CHILDREN THROUGH
SCHOOL.
WHAT A GREAT TRIBUTE THANK YOU
MUCH
PRESIDENT?
COLLEAGUES A WE WILL ADJOURN
WE WILL RECONVENE A TO
MORROW AT TEN AM ON THE SENATE
FLOOR TENTATIVE PICTURE MUCH
GREAT.
THANK YOU PRO TEM DE LEóN THE
SENATE WILL BE ADJOURNED. WE'LL
RECONVENE ON TUESDAY AT TEN AM