WEDNESDAY JANUARY TENTH
APPROXIMATELY A ONE FORTY ONE.
PM.
ONE THING EACH AND EVERYONE OF
YOU.
COLLEAGUES FOR.
COMING ON TIME HERE TODAY WITH
ESTABLISH A QUORUM SO TO MOVE
FORWARD WITH TODAY'S HEARING
MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL SENATORS ATKINS ATKINS HERE
BERRYHILL BERRYHILL HERE LEYVA.
LEYVA HERE CANNELLA HERE
CANNELLA HERE DAILY ON.
HERE LEN HERE THAT TESSA THANK
YOU MADAM SECRETARY WE'VE
ESTABLISHED A QUORUM.
COLLEAGUES.
LET'S GO TO THE AGENDA ITEMS
THAT ARE BEFORE US WE'RE GOING
TO GO.
INTAKE FILES ITEM NUMBER TWO.
THREE.
SIX SEVEN EIGHT
TWO THREE SIX SEVEN EIGHT PAGAN
MOTION.
WHERE MOTION MADE BY MISS LEYVA
AMEND SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL SENATORS ATKINS ATKINS AYE
BERRYHILL? BERRYHILL AYE LEYVA.
LEYVA AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE
DELEON ON DAILY ON AYE AS A
FIGURE WHICH.
NOW COLLEAGUES THAT THAT MOTION
DOES PASS WE HAVE TO
APPOINTMENTS THAT ARE BEFORE US
TODAY.
.
WE HAVE MISTER MICHAEL ROTH
WHO'S COMMISSIONER OF THE BOARD
OF PAROLE AS WELL AS PAULA LA
BREA HOPE I'M PRONOUNCING
CORRECTLY DELIVERY LIBERTY
LIBERTY.
THE CALIFORNIA GAMBLING AT.
CONTROL COMMISSION WHEN WE BRING
UP MR ROUGH THAT IS BEFORE US
MISS ROUGH.
NO.
WELCOME.
ONE SHOE.
INTRODUCE YOURSELF GIVE US A
SHORT TO A SYNOPSIS OF.
YOU BY YOU AND THEN WE'LL GO TO
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS.
OKAY GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE MY NAME
IS MICHAEL ROUGH AND I AM HERE
SEEKING YOUR APPROVAL TO
CONTINUE MY PUBLIC SERVICE.
AS A MEMBER OF THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARING.
MY SERVICE TO COUNTRY AND THE
PUBLIC HAVE SPANNED PROXY THIRTY
FOUR YEARS.
I WAS TRULY AUTHOR WHEN GOVERNOR
BROWN APPOINTED ME AS
COMMISSIONER FOR BORDER PEROT.
I FELIZ ONE OF THE MOST
REWARDING JOBS I'VE EVER HAD.
IS A PERSONAL FULFILMENT FOR ME
IN A WAY TO CONTINUE SERVING THE
PUBLIC.
I APPROACH EVERY CASE WITH
UNDERSTANDING MY DECISIONS WILL
IMPACT THE INMATES AND THE
INMATES FAMILIES AS WELL THE
VICTIMS OF THE VICTIM'S FAMILY.
AND THE PUBLIC.
I HAVE EMPTIVELY AND COMPASSION
FOR THE VICTIMS AND THE VICTIMS'
FAMILY AND I TRIED PROVIDE
OPPORTUNITY AND HOPE.
FOR THOSE OF REHABILITATING
DESERVE AN OPPORTUNITY RUNNER
REITERATE INTO THE COMMUNITY.
I AM HONORED TO SPEAK WITH ALL
OF YOU TODAY AND I LOOK FORWARD
TO ANSWERING YOUR QUESTIONS.
SHAMUS RUFFLED WE OPENED UP TO A
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS FROM THE
MEMBERS.
.
MISLIM.
THANK YOU MR PRETEND GOOD
AFTERNOON MISTER RUFF I ENJOYED
MEETING WITH YOU YESTERDAY AND I
WILL THANK YOU PUBLICLY AS I DID
PRIVATELY FOR YOUR SERVICE I
THINK THAT THE JOB THAT YOU DO
IS VERY VERY DIFFICULT BUT VERY
MEANINGFUL. R. AND HELPFUL TO
SOCIETY AT LARGE HAS HAD A
COUPLE QUESTIONS.
CAN YOU DESCRIBE THE
CHARACTERISTICS OF A TYPICAL
INMATE WHO WAS RELEASED UNDER
THE TERMS OF PROP FIFTY SEVEN.
USER IF THERE IS SUCH A THING AS
A TYPICAL.
.
BARS RELEASED IN THEIR PROP
FIFTY SEVEN I'M NOT SURE BECAUSE
MOST OF WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH
THE LIFE FOR HEARINGS.
WE'RE NOT DEALING WITH THAT
ASPECT OF IT.
BACHELORS USED TO DEPUTY
COMMISSIONERS.
STILL OKAY FAIR ENOUGH.
WHAT TRAINING HAVE YOU RECEIVED
TO UNDERSTAND THE SPECIFIC
CHALLENGES OF INMATES WITH
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES IF
ANY TRAIN?
WHEN I WAS THE INITIALLY
APPOINTED.
I WENT THROUGH ABOUT FIVE WEEKS
OF TRAINING A COVERED THE
AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES.
REVIEW IN ADDITION TO THAT PRIOR
TO MY APPOINTMENT WHEN I WAS.
APART DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
I RECEIVED TRAINING. ON AN
ANNUAL BASIS IN REGARDS TO.
.
DEALING WITH INMATES WHO HAVE
DISABILITIES. FOR HEARINGS WE
ADDRESS IT EVERY HEARING WE
DISCUSS.
THE INMATES WOULD CALL THE
EIGHTY A REVIEW WE ASKED THEM IF
THEY HAVE ANY DISABILITY AND WE
ENSURE THAT.
THEY'RE ARE DISABILITIES ARE ARE
TEND TO TO DO ON THE HEARING.
OKAY GREAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NO FOR THE QUESTIONS.
I'M A SLAVE.
.
MR BERRYHILL.
A LOCAL.
BUT. OWE YEAH I DON'T HAVE ANY.
CONCERNS ABOUT THE SENATE
CONFIRMATION AN ALL WE DID DO
SOME HOMEWORK I WASN'T ABLE TO
MEET WITH.
BUT.
WE.
WE DID MAKE SOME CALLS ITS BE A
CERTAIN AMOUNT AND THEY'D LOVE
YOU SO. THAT'S GOOD ENOUGH FOR
ME SO LOBBY SPORTED TODAY AND.
CONGRATULATIONS.
BIGGER MUCH.
.
MISTER MISTER BERRYHILL I'M
CIRCUITS.
VERY NICE TO MEET YOU HI I'M
INTERESTED IN IN HEARING YOUR
COMMENTS AYE YOUR OPENING
COMMENTS. YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE A
LONG HISTORY AT CDC R. AND NOW
YOU'RE STEP INTO THIS ROLE GIVE
ME WHAT DO YOU THINK MAKES IT
YOUR UNIQUE PERSPECTIVE. MOVING
FROM ONE PART OF.
CDC R. AND NOW ON THE ON THE
BOARD. ANY ANYTHING YOU FEEL
LIKE YOU BRING THAT KIND OF SET
YOU ASIDE FROM.
FROM OTHERS THINK THAT.
WE ALL ALL MEMBERS OF THE BOARD
OF A UNIQUE BACKGROUNDS.
MIND.
COMING UP THROUGH THE SYSTEM
STARTING AS A CORRECTION OFFICER
AT SAN QUENTIN AND PROMOTING UP
THROUGH THE RANKS.
TWELVE AND A HALF YEARS OF SAN
QUENTIN WAS PART OF A.
BOOT CAMP PROGRAM AT SAN QUENTIN
WAS A PILOT PROGRAM AND. THAT
WAS SORT OF MY FIRST EXPOSURE TO
REHABLITATION I WOULD SAY
BECAUSE.
WAS A GREAT PROGRAM AND HE
REALLY SAW THE CHANGE.
INMATES WHO CAME IN THROUGH THAT
PROGRAM.
PROMOTED THROUGH THE RANKS.
AND WORKING AT DIFFERENT LEVELS
OF INSTITUTION WITH DIFFERENT
TYPES OF. INMATES AND.
EVERY CUSTODY LEVEL.
GIVE ME THAT EXPERIENCE IN THE
HILL HEARINGS WERE TALKING.
DISCUSSING THEIR POST
CONVICTION FACTORS WITH.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER NAM A
CHIME IN IT'S THE DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER DOESN'T. UNDERSTAND
A PARTICULAR.
BINGO THE INMATES TALKING ABOUT
THAT ALTHOUGH WHILE HE'S TALKING
ABOUT THIS SO THAT.
EXPERIENCE THAT.
I HAD COMING UP THROUGH THE
RANKS.
IS GIVEN ME.
THE ABILITY TO I GUESS TO
COMMUNICATE ALL OF IT BETTER IN
CERTAIN AREAS.
ANNA AND I AM.
I'M SORT OF A.
IT STUCK OUT TO ME. AS YOU WERE
STARTING OF COURSE ANYBODY WHO
GETS APPOINTED TO A POSITION BY
THE GOVERNOR FEELS HONORED AND.
WHAT AN OPPORTUNITY TO SERVE
BUT YOU HAD A CAREER AND
FINISHED GIVEN THE A HARD NATURE
OF THE WORK IN PUBLIC? SAFETY.
THE FACT THAT YOU ARE JUST.
WHERE HE WAS SO EXCITED TO BE
APPOINTED? EYES STRUCK ME SO.
ARABIC A AFTER A MUCH DESERVED
REST FROM A DIFFICULT JOB IN THE
SYSTEM. TELL ME TELL ME TELL ME
A LITTLE MORE ABOUT WHY YOU.
WELL ARE SO EXCITED TO BE
APPOINTED TO THIS POSITION.
WHEN I RETIRED I RETIRED IN TWO
THOUSAND THIRTEEN THAT TOOK
SEVEN WEEKS OFTEN MY WIFE THAT
YOU DIDN'T REALLY RETIRE.
.
I RETIRED AT THE AGE OF FIFTY
AND I WASN'T READY TO STOP WORK.
I ENJOY MY JOB. WHEN I WAS
DOING IT.
AND.
THIS JOB IN ITSELF.
PUBLIC SERVICE IS SOMETHING
I'VE DONE ALL MY LIFE.
PRIOR TO THAT WHEN I WAS IN THE
MILITARY I ENJOYED THAT I WAS.
INITIALLY THINKING ABOUT MAKING
A CAREER OF THAT BUT.
MY YOU KNOW MY PATH WENT INTO
LAW ENFORCEMENT AND.
IT'S JUST.
THE JOB ITSELF AND EVEN THIS IS
REALLY FULFILLING ITS.
.
SEEN THE THE PROCESS ITSELF
WORK.
SEEN THE CHANGE IN PEOPLE.
.
I WON'T LIE THE THE VICTIMS IS
A.
REALLY BIG.
THING THAT I WASN'T. YOU KNOW
YOU GET THE TRAINING BUT WHEN
YOU ACTUALLY SEE THE.
THE PAIN OF THE FAMILY MEMBERS
IS SOMETHING THAT AFFECTS YOU
KNOW.
BUT BY THAT SAME TOKEN THEN YOU
HAVE THE INMATES IN YOU KNOW
WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT THE
IMAGE THE INMATES TO COME AND
WHO.
NEAR YOU HAVE THE YOU FOR
VENDORS WHO COME IN AND YOU SEE
THAT CHANGE WHERE THE
INDIVIDUAL.
HAS MATURED IN THEIR INVOLVED IN
REHABILITATIVE PROGRAMMING THEN.
YOU SEE THE PERSON WHO WAS THEN.
THE TIME THEY COMMITTED THE
CRIME THE PERSON WHO THEY ARE
NOW IN ITS.
.
ITS GOOD TO SEE THAT IT'S GOOD
TO SEE THAT A PERSON HAS TAKEN
THOSE EFFORTS THOUGH INNKEEPER
ME THE PUBLIC SERVICES IS
SOMETHING I'VE ENJOYED.
WELL LAST QUESTION I HAVE ASKED
PEOPLE WILL FOR HERE. IF YOU
COULD SHARE ANYTHING WITH
LEGISLATORS IS NOT OFTEN. MAYBE
THAT WE SIT.
ABILITY TO INTERACT AS
LEGISLATORS TO
APPROVED BUDGETS AND WHO ARE I
DO BILLS AND LEGISLATION WHAT
WHAT WHAT IF ANYTHING MIGHT BE
THE ONE THING YOU WOULD WANT US
TO REALLY KNOW.
I THINK THAT.
.
MY THIRTY YEARS OF SERVICE I
WHEN I CAME OVER THE BORDER
PRESIDENT I WAS REALLY
IMPRESSED.
WITH THE TEAM WORK AND THE
SUPPORT THAT THE UNIT GETS FROM.
TAKING CARE OF THE COMMISSIONERS
AND THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONERS TO.
THE WHOLE BUILDING THIS
DEDICATED TO MAKING SURE THESE
HEARINGS GO.
SO. MORE WOULDN'T A.
APPRECIATION FOR THE PROCESS
ITSELF. AND NOT ONLY THE THEM
BORDER PRISONS BUT ALSO THE
INSTITUTIONS.
DO A GREAT JOB AND WE GET THOSE
INSTITUTION MAKE SURE IT WOULD
TAKE CARE OF.
THANK YOU THANK YOU MISTER BUT
YOU THINK YOU MUCH OF A SENATE
ATKINS A MISTER VICE CHAIR.
EXIT.
BEFORE GOING TO THAT MR VICE
CHAIR I'M I APOLOGIZE MISS
ROUGH.
I NEVER ASKED IF YOU FACT HAD AN
THE LOVED ONES OR FRIENDS THAT
YOU WANTED TO INTRODUCE NOT.
HERE TODAY UNITE HERE TODAY
OKAY.
BUT YOU CAN TO DO SEVEN SPIRITS
AYE I DO SO YOU HAVE THE
CREDIBLE FAMOUS NAY THE METAL
BETTY SABLE HOUSE YOU KNOW.
USING MEANS OF FOR A NOMINATION
THESE OTHER POWERFUL NOMINATION
ARE IN TROUBLE THEY BRING IN THE
HEAVY WEIGHT IN THAT THE SALE
HOUSE IN THE WHO.
IF GET. SO. IT'S VICE CHAIR WELL
JUST GONNA SAY WE JUST MET A FEW
MINUTES AGO IN THIS ROUGH
ANSWERED ALL MY QUESTIONS HAVE
NO DIESEL QUESTION BETTER AS I
DON'T HINK THERE'S ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS OF COMMENTARIES FOR
THE MEMBERS WHAT WE GO TO THOSE
WHO SUPPORTED TODAY'S NOMINATION
DOES UNSUPPORTED DAYS.
NOMINATION
PLEASE COME UP AS TO BE AS
SUCCINCT AS POSSIBLE FOR THOSE
WHO IN SUPPORT OF TODAY'S
NOMINATIONS FOR MICHAEL. ROUGH.
I THINK MISTERCHAIRMAN MY NAME
IS BERNICE NELSON SLOAN I'M THE
DIRECTOR OF LIFE SUPPORT
ALLIANCE. WERE A PRISONER
ADVOCACY LIFER ADVOCACY
ORGANIZATION. REACHING A
DECISION ON SUPPORTING OR
OPPOSING COMMISSIONERS
CONFIRMATION TO THE BOARD WE
GATHER INFORMATION MANY SOURCES
OFTEN INCLUDING OBSERVING
HEARINGS. AND ALWAYS REVIEWING
TRANSCRIPTS AND SOLICITING
COMMENTS ATTORNEYS AND INMATES
WHO APPEARED BEFORE THE NOMINEE.
MR REPS CASE SO THAT WE ARE NOT
ABLE TO ATTEND HIS HEARINGS THE
INFORMATION GLEANED FROM OTHER
SOURCES HAS BEEN VERY POSITIVE
AND SUPPORTIVE. THE COMMENTS WE
HEARD WERE MOST OFTEN. ABOUT
COMMISSIONER ROUGH IS AT HIS
VERY CONSIDERATE TREATS ALL
PARTIES PROFESSIONALLY AND WITH
COURTESY.
CHARACTERISTICS WHICH WE CONCUR
WITH FROM READING THE
TRANSCRIPTS WE HAVE ALSO NOTED
MISTER REPP DOESN'T SPEAK OFTEN
IN THE BOARD OF PAROLE HEARINGS.
BUSINESS MEETINGS BUT WHEN HE
DOES HIS QUESTIONS WHEN ASKED
ARE ON POINT AND VERY PURPOSEFUL
WE HAVE A PLEASE TO SUPPORT HIS
NOMINATION TODAY THANK YOU.
ARE ANY OF THE FOLKS WHO
SUPPORTED SAYS. SCENE AND THOSE
IN OPPOSITION.
TODAY'S A NOMINEE AND THE FOLKS
OPPOSITION I'M SEEING NONE I
DON'T THINK THERE'S ANY FOR THE
QUESTIONS OF.
A COMMITTEES FOR THE MEMBERS
THEMSELVES CAN I GET A MOTION.
FOR MR ROUGH TO GET A MOTION
FROM SWIFT MOTION MADE MEMBERS
HAVE A MAP SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE.
SENATORS ATKINS ATKINS AYE
BERRYHILL BERRYHILL AYE LEYVA
LEYVA AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE
DELEON DELEON AYE THIS ROPE
CONGRATULATIONS.
OKAY ARE A LAST NOMINEE HERE
TODAY IS MISS PALA DELIVERY A
MEMBER THEY CALIFORNIA GAMBLING
A CONTROL COMMISSION WELCOME.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND AS IS
STATED A FEW MOMENTS AGO WITH
MISTER RUFF.
PLEASE GIVE US A SYNOPSIS OF
YOUR PERSON.
AND THEY WILL GO TO QUESTIONS
OF COMMENTARIES BUT BEFORE WE DO
THAT THAT THERE ANY.
FAMILY FRIENDS LOVED ONES THAT
LIKE TO PRODUCE
BUT TODAY PLEASE SO.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR YES
ACTUALLY I DO HAVE WITH ME TODAY
MY HUSBAND TIMOTHY NICHOLS WAS
BEHIND ME AS WELL AS THREE OF MY
SEVEN SIBLINGS.
JOHN THE BREANNA PAM AMERICA
SENATE PATRICIA CALLAWAY AND A
DIFFERENT STANCE THEM SO ARE ALL
HERE WITH ME ON AND IN THE EVEN
THAT YOU DON'T KNOW OR HAVEN'T
HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO MEET HER.
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
GAMING CONTROL COMMISSION STACEY
LUNA BAXTER IS HERE AS WELL.
OKAY WELCOME.
OKAY.
PLEASE PROCEED.
A THANK YOU OUT MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE ASKED AND MISTER CHAIR
I AM HONORED TO BE HERE BEFORE
YOU.
AND THANK YOU AND YOUR STAFF
FOR YOUR CAREFUL CONSIDERATION
OF MY APPLICATION ON FOR THIS
POSITION I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO
THANK THE GOVERNOR.
AND HIS STAFF FOR THIS
APPOINTMENT AND FOR TRUSTING ME
WITH THIS REALLY IMPORTANT.
DUTY AYE THE STAFF AT THE
GAMING CONTROL COMMISSION I AND
MY COLLEAGUES.
EMBRACED ME OFF FROM THE MOMENT
THAT I WALKED INTO THE OFFICE
AND I CERTAINLY APPRECIATE THAT
AND ON THEIR SUPPORT OF ME. ON
DURING THIS TIME.
I AM TRULY ENJOYING THIS JOB I
HAVE BEEN NOW DOING IT FOR
AWHILE. FOR ME ARE NOT ONLY IS
THIS A FASCINATING INDUSTRY BUT
THIS IS ALSO A PLACE WHERE MUCH
OF MY BACKGROUND IN TERMS OF
ACADEMIC TRAINING. AND IN TERMS
OF EMPLOYMENT CHYNA COME
TOGETHER ON TO HELP ME BE ABLE
TO PERFORM THE DUTIES THAT NEED
TO BE PERFORMED MAKE THE
DECISIONS THAT ARE NECESSARY TO
BE MADE. AND.
SERVE OF THE PUBLIC.
US SO ITEM I AM I AM VERY
GRATEFUL TO BE HERE.
SOME OF MY MAIN GOALS INITIALLY
I'M AND ON A BROADER LEVEL ARE
TO OF COURSE MAINTAIN THE
INTEGRITY OF THE INDUSTRY ON
THAT INVOLVES A CONSUMER
PROTECTION.
I'D ALSO LIKE TO CONTINUE ON
THE PATH THAT ARE CHAIR HAS SET
ON TO BUILD RELATIONS WITH THE
BUREAU AND WITH OUR
STAKEHOLDERS.
ON CONTINUING OUT REACH WITH
THEM AND EDUCATION. ARE TWO.
NOT WITH THE STAKE HOLDERS BUT
ALSO THEIR EMPLOYEES ARE SO THAT
THEY ARE CLEAR ON WHAT THE
COMMISSION DOES AND WE CONSERVE
THEM ARM. AS BEST WE CAN THAT A
PATH TO TAKE ANY QUESTIONS THANK
YOU.
MUCH.
SABRI OF QUESTIONS ARE
COMMUTERS MISS AFGHANS.
YOU COULD OKAY.
MISTER BERRYHILL.
THANK YOU AND WELCOME THANK YOU.
I REGISTER JUST ONE QUESTION ON
RENEWAL OF CARD CLUBS.
AND LOCAL COMMUNITY COMMUNITIES.
I'VE GOT A NUMBER OF THEM IN MY
DISTRICT AND DOES SO YOU GOT
JUST A COUPLE QUESTIONS FOR THE.
AS I UNDERSTAND CORRECTLY.
ON REVIEW AND A RENEWAL
APPLICATION FOR A CARD CLUB YOU
GOOD INFORMATION ON ANY CRIMINAL
ACTIVITIES IT MAY. HAVE TAKEN
PLACE AT THE CLUB OR HUNTS
PARKING LOT. IS THAT CORRECT
THAT'S TRUE.
SO.
BILL YOUR. YES THAT'S TRUE SO WE
WILL GET BOMB BY A PACKAGE OF
INFORMATION ON BASED ON
INVESTIGATION FROM THE BUREAU.
ON WITH THESE RENEWAL
APPLICATIONS COMBAT WITH INITIAL
APPLICATIONS COME UP.
AND.
WE WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
REVIEW IF THERE HAS BEEN
ACTIVITY CRIMINAL ACTIVITY IN
THE CARD ROOM AND EXTENDING INTO
THE PARKING LOT WILL GIVE US AN
OPPORTUNITY TO SEE IF THERE'S
BEEN A DECREASE IN THAT OR
PERHAPS AN INCREASE SO THAT WE
CAN FIGURE OUT IF THERE'S.
SOME KIND OF CONDITION OR
CONVERSATION WE NEED TO HAVE TO
UP SORT OF GET THAT IN TOM.
TO MAKE THAT RIGHT.
JULIA WHAT WHAT WOULD STILL BE
APPALLED SERIES FOR NOT
INCLUDING THIS ADDITIONAL
CRIMINAL OR CRIMINAL ADDITIONAL
CRIMINAL ACTIVITY INFORMATION.
AND THE OJ REPORT FOR MAKING A
PART OF THE RENEWAL APPLICATIONS
AND OTHER WORDS.
DO YOU AND DO YOU INCLUDE ALL
THE CRIMINAL ACTIVITY IN THE
AREA ARE JUST AT THE CARD CLUB
ITSELF.
JUST OF THE CAR CLUB ITSELF IN
IN THE PARKING LOT WE DON'T
EXTENDED TO OTHER AREAS.
WHILE OTHER WAY WHAT DON'T YOU
LE.
INCLUDED.
IT WELL.
IT WOOD AT WHAT POINT YOU KNOW
WHERE WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE
BOUNDARY I MEAN IT TO WHAT
EXTENT IS THE CAR CLUB
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE OTHER
ACTIVITIES THAT ARE TAKING PLACE
WITHIN THE.
SO I I WOULD PRESUME THAT WAS
THE IMPETUS FOR WHERE THE
BOUNDARIES WERE SET RIGHT OUT
RIGHT SO.
THEY ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT
TAKES PLACE WITHIN THEIR AND THE
CARD ROOMS AND ON THE PREMISES
PROMISES THAT THEY LEASE.
IS WHAT THEY'RE RESPONSIBLE FOR.
GREAT THANK YOU DEBTS IN THE
TOILET RETHINKING MUCH I'M SUPER
HELL.
.
MISLIM.
OKAY MISLABELLED IS FINE AS WELL
TO.
OR VICE SHARE HAS STEPPED OUT TO
GO PRISON A BILL SO.
WE WILL SEE
IT'S HERE WITH IN THE LOT AMOUNT
OF TIME TO ASK ANY QUESTIONS ARE
PROPS AS A COMMENTARY R. TO SUE
WHEN WE GO TO THOSE WHO IN
SUPPORT.
OF TODAY'S NOMINEE THOSE ONE
SUPPORT TO A SEVENTY MISS
PAULA LIBERTY.
THIS BOOK A MEMBERS.
A I'M HERE MY PERSONAL CAPACITY
A HAPPY NEW YEAR. AM I IN WHEN.
MISLED REWORKED FOR TRIPLE A I
WORKED WITH HER THE BETTER PART
OF A DECADE WANT YOU STATE YOUR
NAME PLEASE MY COMMUTES AND
SORRY. I I MADE AN ASSUMPTION
THAT'S LIKE BECAUSE SHE WAS
CONNECTED AND. AND THE ICE CREAM
AND THE ASK ANOTHER THE SOUR.
AND YOGURT NO FORGET THAT.
I WORKED FOR THE BETTER PART OF
A DECADE HIGH LEVEL OF
COMPETENCE HIGH LEVEL OF
INTEGRITY THE STATE IS LUCKY TO
HAVE HER.
THANK YOU MUCH MISCONDUCT
SOMETIME NEXT. IT AFTERNOON
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS PHYLLIS
MARSHALL I'VE KNOWN ON THIS
DEBRIS FOR OVER THIRTY YEARS WE
WERE. CLASSMATES AT HASTINGS
COLLEGE OF THE LAW WE WORK
TOGETHER AS A LEADERS OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF BLACK
LAWYERS I HAVE WORKED WITH HER
PROFESSIONALLY. ARCHIE EXEMPLIFY
EXEMPLIFIES A HIGH LEVEL OF
INTEGRITY AND EVERYTHING THAT
SHE DOES ARE WAS VERY PLEASED
WITH THE GOVERNOR APPOINTED HER
TO NOT ONLY THIS POSITION BUT.
CHIEF COUNSEL FOR THE CALIFORNIA
LOTTERY COMMISSION ASHI ONLY
SERVE THERE FOR ABOUT A YEAR
AFTER WHICH TIME SHE WAS
ELEVATED TO ACTING DIRECTOR OF
THE CALIFORNIA STATE LOTTERY.
DURING THAT TENURE SHE IMPLEMENT
PROGRAMS THAT INCREASE REVENUE
FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ARM
I JUST URGE THIS OUR COMMITTEE
TO CONFIRM HER APPOINTMENT. I
THINK SHE SERVES AS A ROLE MODEL
TO SO MANY WOMEN PARTICULARLY
WOMEN OF COLOR ARE FUNCTIONING
IN A POSITION THAT IS NOT
TRADITIONALLY HELD BY WOMEN.
THANK YOU ABSOLUTE THANK YOU
MUCH I MISS MARSHALL NEXT
WITNESS IN SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS NATE
VOLUMES ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF
THE BUREAU GAMMA CONTROL
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE.
HERE IN SUPPORT OF COMMISSION OF
THE BREED WOULD HAVE THE
OPPORTUNITY WORK WITH HER AND
WE'RE AND PULLS BORDER FOR
CONFIRMATION THANK THANK YOU
MUCH THANK YOU MUCH A NEXT
WITNESS LAST WITNESS IN SUPPORT.
AFTER DANIEL ON TOMORROW
ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF THE BUREAU
OF GAMING CONTROL ECHO MY
COLLEAGUES COMMENTS WERE IN
SUPPORT OF A MISSILE BE THE
POINT. THANK YOU MUCH ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF TODAY'S
ARMY MISS LIBERTY.
ANY OTHER FOLKS TO SUPPORT SEEN
AND THOSE IN OPPOSITION.
MANY FOLKS IN OPPOSITION TO
TODAY'S.
NOMINEE ALSO SAYING NINE.
OF THERE'S NO OF FURTHER
QUESTIONS OF COMMENTARIES FOR
THE MEMBERS
THING AND GO GET A MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION IT'S AND BY
MISS.
ATKINS OP PRO TEM DESIGNEES. OF
MATURITY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SENATORS ATKINS AYE ATKINS AYE
BERRYHILL BERRYHILL AYE LEYVA.
LEYVA AYE CANNELLA DELI OWNED BY
LEN. SABRI CONGRATULATIONS YOU
PASS ON AFFORDABLE WILL BE TO
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN SO MISTER OF
VICE CHAIR CAN ADD ON SO CAN BE
A FIVE ZERO CONGRATULATIONS
THANK YOU
.
COLLEAGUES I JUST SAW AN FYI OF
FILE ITEMS NUMBER FOUR AND FIVE
ON THE AGENDA HAD BEEN PULLED.
JUST FOR TODAY.
WILL BE REVISITED.
SOMETIME NEXT WEEK. UP WITH
THAT.
WE'RE GOING TO ADJOURN.
TODAY'S.
MEETING WILL GO TO AN EXECUTIVE
SESSION SO ASKED.
PLEASE LEAVE.
TODAY'S RULES COMMITTEE IS A
CHAIR